Top Banner
User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and analysis to augment adaptation planning User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and analysis to augment adaptation planning E.P. Maurer 1 , L.D. Brekke 2 , T. Pruitt 2 , K. White 3 , E. Ochs 3 , P. Duffy 4 , and E.H. Girvetz 5 1 Santa Clara University 2 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation 3 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers 4 Climate Central 5 The Nature Conservancy 90th American Meteorological Society Annual Meeting Joint Session 8 New challenges for applied meteorology and climatology January 21, 2010
20

User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Jul 20, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and analysis to

augment adaptation planning

User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and analysis to

augment adaptation planningE.P. Maurer1, L.D. Brekke2, T. Pruitt2, K. White3, E. Ochs3, P. Duffy4, and E.H. Girvetz5

1Santa Clara University2U.S. Bureau of Reclamation3U.S. Army Corps of Engineers4Climate Central5The Nature Conservancy

90th American Meteorological Society Annual MeetingJoint Session 8

New challenges for applied meteorology and climatologyJanuary 21, 2010

Page 2: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Global Climate is ChangingGlobal Climate is Changing

• Temperatures are increasing globally

• Most recent warming attributed to human-driven GHG emissions

• Some impacts already evident and attributable to warming

Source: U.S. Global Change Research Program (USGCRP)

Page 3: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Projections of Global ChangeProjections of Global Change

• Range of ‘likely warming’ by end of 21st

century variable

• By mid-21st

century most differences smaller

2010

1.8° 3.4° 4.0°2.4° 2.8°

Page 4: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Regional ChangesRegional Changes

• Projected changes non-uniform

• Impacts also non-uniform

Median runoff change, 2041-2060 minus 1901-1970

Greater water scarcityMore wildfiresAccelerating invasive speciesTourism, recreation impactsAgricultural vulnerability

Extreme urban heat eventsWorsening air quality episodes

Ocean fishery migrationIncreased severe flooding events

Source: U.S. Global Change Research Program (USGCRP)

Page 5: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Estimating regional impactsEstimating regional impacts

1. GHG Emissions Scenario

Adapted from Cayan and Knowles, SCRIPPS/USGS, 2003

2. Global Climate Model4. Land surface

(Hydrology) Model

3. “Downscaling”

5. Operations/impacts

Models

Page 6: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

IPCC AR4 GCM SimulationsIPCC AR4 GCM Simulations20th century through 2100 and beyond>20 GCMsMultiple Future Emissions Scenarios

http://www-pcmdi.llnl.gov/

Page 7: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Selecting GCM runs for “Bookend”Studies

Selecting GCM runs for “Bookend”Studies

• Brackets range of uncertainty• Useful where impacts models are

complex• Downscale output from few GCMs

Page 8: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Projected Impacts: Loss of SnowProjected Impacts: Loss of Snow• Snow water in reserve on April 1• Change (Sacramento-San Joaquin basin, 2

GCMs, 2 emissions scenarios):-12% to -42% (for 2035–2064) (up to 1 Lake Shasta)

-32% to -79% (for 2070–2099) (up to 2 Lake Shastas)

Ref: Luers et al., 2006, CEC-500-2006-077 GFDL CM2.1 results

Page 9: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

How many GCMs to select?How many GCMs to select?• Ensemble mean provides better skill• Little advantage to weighting GCMs according to skill• Most important to have “ensembles of runs with enough

realizations to reduce the effects of natural internal climate variability” [Pierce et al., 2009]

Gleckler, Taylor, and Doutriaux, Journal of Geophysical Research (2008) as adapted by B. Santer Brekke et al., 2008

Page 10: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Impact Probabilities for PlanningImpact Probabilities for Planning

Snow

wat

er e

quiv

alen

t on

Apr

il 1,

mm

Point at:120ºW, 38ºN

2/3 chance that loss will be at least 40% by mid century, 70% by end of century

• Combine many future scenarios, models, since we don’t know which path we’ll follow (22 futures here)

• Choose appropriate level of risk

Page 11: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Mass Production of Downscaled Climate Projections

Mass Production of Downscaled Climate Projections

• PCMDI CMIP3 archive of global projections• New archive of 112 downscaled GCM runs• gdo4.ucllnl.org/downscaled_cmip3_projections• Allows quick analysis of multi-model ensembles

Page 12: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Use of U.S. Data ArchiveUse of U.S. Data Archive• Over 500 users downloaded >4 TB of data• From across US and outside• Uses for Research (R), Management & Planning

(MP), Education (E)

Page 13: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Using Archive to Select Specific GCM Runs

Using Archive to Select Specific GCM Runs

Bivariate probability plot shows correlation between ∆T, ∆ P

Identify Change Range: 10 to 90 %-tile ∆T, ∆ P

Select bounds based on:•risk attitude•interest in breadth of changes•number of simulations desired

Brekke et al., 2009

Page 14: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

What is missing from downscaled data archive?

What is missing from downscaled data archive?

Page 15: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Global BCSDGlobal BCSD• Similar to US archive• Allows probabilistic representation of

projections• Captures variability among GCMs• >150 users, >2 TB served• www.engr.scu.edu/~emaurer/global_data/

Source: Girvetz et al, PloS, 2009

A1B Scenario

Page 16: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Most commonly requested itemsMost commonly requested items

Page 17: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Online Analysis and Download withhttp://ClimateWizard.org

Online Analysis and Download withhttp://ClimateWizard.org

Level 1Level 2

Level 3

•Global and US data sets•Country and US state boundaries defined•Spatial and time series analysis•Upload of custom shapefiles

Girvetz et al., PLoS, 2009

Page 18: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Most commonly requested itemsMost commonly requested items

Page 19: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning

Need for enhanced downscalingNeed for enhanced downscaling• Some impacts due to

changes at short time scales

• Heat waves• Flood events• BCSD limited• New daily statistical

downscaling planned for AR5 simulations

Page 20: User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning and ...emaurer/papers/maurer_2010-1-21_ams_final.pdf · 21/01/2010  · User-driven downscaling: advances in data apportioning