Page 1
1
UPCYCLED FASHIONABLE CLOTHING FROM MATERIALS SOURCED FROM
NAIROBI FLEA MARKETS FOR YOUNG WOMEN
(A Survey Research on Nairobi Street style)
BY:
ANYANGO YVETTE ANNE-MARIE
A RESEARCH PAPER SUBMITTED FOR THE FULFILLMENT OF THE
REQUIREMENT FOR THE BACHELOR OF ART IN DESIGN DEGREE TO THE
SCHOOL OF THE ARTS & DESIGN UNIVERSITY OF NAIROBI
Page 2
2
DECLARATION
This Research Project is my original work and has not been submitted for award of a degree at
the University of Nairobi or any other University.
Signed…………………………………..
Date……………………………………….
Anyango Yvette AnneMarie
Reg No. B05/28336/2009
This Research Project has been submitted for examination with my approval as the University
Supervisor
Signed…………………………………
Date…………………………………..
Joan Ogake Mosomi
School of Art and Design
University of Nairobi.
Page 3
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I owe my supervisor Miss Joan Ogake Mosomi special gratitude for her immeasurable support
and guidance. Her supportive and positive criticism that greatly enhanced and enriched this
study through her uncompromising stance on quality and detail. I was greatly motivated.
I sincerely acknowledge the invaluable contribution of Dr. Lilac Osanjo who helped keep the
study in focus and for the direction and advice.
This study would be incomplete without the cooperation of the respondents who voluntarily filled
the questionnaires. My encounter with you, your candid discussion about fashion and style was
an awesome eye-opener. May you all be richly blessed.
The joy and relief of completing this research paper is overwhelming and I owe it all to you,
family, friends and School of Art and Design lecturers.
Page 4
4
DEDICATION
I dedicate this paper to my parents, for the inconclusive support, faith and belief in me, for
getting me this far and to my siblings for their encouragement and constant reminder of how
great I will become.
Page 5
5
ABSTRACT
Fashion is a collective cultural phenomenon generated by the individual but linked to actions of a
very large number of garment designers aiming to create distinctive but similar clothes.
Awareness of what clothes are common, contemporary, appropriate, is a universal part of human
experience, though the sharpness of that awareness differs. The aim of this project paper is to
shed light on sustainable fashion consumption in Kenya by analyzing data from the survey
carried out on Nairobi street style. The main objective of this research project is to investigate
street style of young Nairobi women and to create affordable fashionable collection. The
following is a summary of the collection is about:
The floating woman Spring Summer 2013
This collection is inspired by the art movement abstract expressionism in the 19th century. "A term first
used in connection with Kandinsky in 1919, but more commonly associated with post-war American art
in light view to Jackson Pollock’s gestural paintings, techniques and colours. It was Pollock's legacy to
have developed a style that reflected the aesthetic concerns of his time, yet retained a high level of
individuality. The collection will explore the art of draping and layering of fabrics to create garments.
This collection is an expression of my identity. It’s the freedom to choose what to wear to bring out
attitude. A movement in fashion for the young at heart and are not afraid to try out something new that
will set them apart and be the trendsetters, because they will be the trendsetters. The shape inspiration of
the collection is from abstract paintings: the curves and lines created by brush strokes, movement created
in the paintings and the emotions they evoke. The final pieces are a representation of paintings with form.
This collection is part of the sustainable fashion movement using up-cycling method, extending the
lifecycle of garments and fabrics giving them new life by creating unique and fashionable pieces. This
collection represents identity and individuality. This
collection sets out to bring out confidence, youth urban
flare and to create fluid movements.The fabrics used in
this collection will be chiffon, cotton, jersey, silk and
knit collected from 2nd hand clothing and other fabrics.
This is the range of colours that will be used in this
collection; they are bright, bold, and represent urban
flare.
Page 6
6
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
DEDICATION .............................................................................................................................................. 4
ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................................. 5
1 CHAPTER ONE ................................................................................................................................... 9
1.1 BACKGROUND INFORMATION ............................................................................................. 9
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT ......................................................................................................... 10
1.3 OBJECTIVES ............................................................................................................................. 11
1.4 RESEARCH QUESTIONS ......................................................................................................... 11
1.5 SCOPE ........................................................................................................................................ 12
1.6 JUSTIFICATION ....................................................................................................................... 12
2 CHAPTER TWO ................................................................................................................................ 13
2.1 LITERATURE REVIEW ........................................................................................................... 13
2.2 FAST FASHION ........................................................................................................................ 13
2.3 FAST FASHION BRAND STRATEGIES ................................................................................. 14
2.4 FASHION CONSUMPTION ..................................................................................................... 16
2.4.1 TASTE AND NEED FOR SOCIAL DISTINCTION ........................................................ 18
2.4.2 FASHION WASTE ............................................................................................................. 20
2.5 SECOND HAND CLOTHING ................................................................................................... 21
2.5.1 How the trade operates in Nairobi. ..................................................................................... 23
2.5.2 Who benefits from the second-hand clothing trade ............................................................ 24
2.5.3 Impact on the local textile and clothing production ............................................................ 28
2.5.4 The unsustainable consumption of second-hand garments ................................................. 28
2.6 SUSTAINABLE FASHION ....................................................................................................... 29
2.6.1 UPCYCLING ...................................................................................................................... 30
2.6.2 FASHION DECONSTRUCTION ...................................................................................... 32
2.7 DESIGN EXEMPLARS ............................................................................................................. 36
2.7.1 Jackson Pollock-painter ...................................................................................................... 36
2.7.2 Vivienne Westwood ............................................................................................................ 38
2.7.3 Junky styling ....................................................................................................................... 39
3 CHAPTER THREE ............................................................................................................................ 39
Page 7
7
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................................ 39
3.1 Research Design .......................................................................................................................... 39
3.2 Population of study ..................................................................................................................... 40
3.3 Sample design and sampling design ........................................................................................... 40
3.4 Data Collection ........................................................................................................................... 41
3.5 Data Analysis .............................................................................................................................. 41
4 CHAPTER FOUR ............................................................................................................................... 41
DATA ANALYSIS AND PRESENTATIONS ...................................................................................... 41
4.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 41
4.2 Demographic information ........................................................................................................... 42
4.3 Expenditure on shopping ............................................................................................................ 43
4.4 Limitations of the Survey ............................................................................................................ 48
5 CHAPTER FIVE ................................................................................................................................ 49
FINDINGS, DISCUSSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................... 49
5.1 FINDINGS AND DICUSSIONS ................................................................................................ 49
5.2 RECOMMENDATION .............................................................................................................. 50
5.2.1 Building awareness ............................................................................................................. 50
5.2.2 Engage a willing audience .................................................................................................. 51
5.2.3 Re-evaluating ownership ..................................................................................................... 51
5.2.4 Government Policies ........................................................................................................... 51
5.2.5 Re-opening of closed cotton mills ...................................................................................... 52
5.2.6 Swapping/exchanging clothes ............................................................................................. 52
5.2.7 Up-cycling Fashion ............................................................................................................. 52
5.3 CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................................... 53
BIBLIOGRAPHY ....................................................................................................................................... 54
BOOKS ....................................................................................................................................................... 54
JOURNALS AND PUBLICATIONS ......................................................................................................... 56
Allison Gill article on Deconstruction Fashion ........................................................................................... 56
WEBSITES ................................................................................................................................................. 58
QUESTIONNAIRE .................................................................................................................................... 59
INTERVIEW GUIDE ................................................................................................................................. 60
Page 9
9
1 CHAPTER ONE
1.1 BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Fashion is a collective cultural phenomenon generated by the individual but linked to actions of a
very large number of garment designers aiming to create distinctive but similar clothes.
Awareness of what clothes are common, contemporary, appropriate, is a universal part of human
experience, though the sharpness of that awareness differs. Clothes are individual, but we
perceive styles as collective. We recognize clothes as within a particular contemporary style, or
novel, or outdated, or simply strange – outside the boundaries of any acceptable style.
While fashion has become democratized, so the media and technological developments which
characterize the 21st century have supported fashion becoming a cornerstone of many world
economies. The clothing industry is worth over $1 trillion worldwide and ranked the second
biggest global economic activity for intensity of trade. Yet the pressures of climate change and
ethical concerns about how goods have been produced, coupled with a growing realisation that
consumption dominates too many lives means
“Where did you get that?” This is a question often asked by random people on the streets of
Nairobi. The need to look fashionable and to stand out in a crowd is what the mass population
seek to gain. With Nairobi being the capital city, the amount of exposure to fashion is incredibly
large and is still increasing. People have become more aware of how they look whether casual or
office wear. Haute couture fashion is yet to be explored in Kenya as the fashion industry is still
coming up. The seasonal change in Fashion trends by the western countries have resulted in
consumerism as people want to buy more and more without disposing their old unwanted
clothes.
The mass constantly want to own designer labels or sort after cheaper versions of designer labels.
Emulating western celebrities is something practiced by the western society and Nairobi Kenya
is not an exception. T.V programmes and channels such as Fashion T.V, Style Network, E
Entertainment, Gossip Girls, 90210 are one the biggest influencers. Tips and information about a
celebrity’s style secrets are often being dished out to the public on how to dress like the celebrity.
In this day and age where people are trying to impress others by what they own and how stylish
and fashionable they are will not stop them from purchasing more and more clothes either
Page 10
10
second hand clothing, department stores or stalls. With a huge following on fashion trends, sets
people apart. Articles in the papers being posted about what is in fashion, what to be seen in and
what not to be seen in. People dress up with the chance of being photographed so that their
photos could be posted on social media sites, blogs and occasionally seen in the newspaper pull-
outs.
In the fashion world, it is the luxury fashion brands that set the fashion trends for each season
during the various fashion weeks in cities like Paris, Milan and New York. In the previous
century, haute couture designers like Christian Dior or Valentino used to set the standard for
what colour or cut was fashionable that season through their designs. Today the scenario is
different, because of branding there is as a wider choice and variety in brand and product
offering. However, the top designers within the fashion business are still worshipped like gods.
Through their designs they indirectly dictate the taste of the fashion society, telling the public
what to wear and not to wear. The consumer population waits for these dictations and the fast
fashion brands utilize them to predict what trends to produce. If for example Marc Jacobs, chief
designer of Louis Vuitton decides to show designs only in white for a specific season, then the
world of fashion will adopt and follow. (Okonkwo 2007, p.10)
The increasing supply and demand for fast fashion has created a vicious cycle that is spiralling
out of control, and designers are struggling to keep up. In 2010, renowned British and Turkish-
Cypriot designer Hussein Chalayan bought back his brand from fashion conglomerate PPR in an
attempt to relieve the pressure of constantly creating at ever-faster intervals. “Being in those
houses is like running on a diamond-plated hamster wheel,” he has been quoted as saying. “You
have to go faster and faster and faster, and chances are still very high [that] you will fall off.”
Similarly, designer Tom Ford left Gucci in 2004 and has since relaunched his eponymous brand,
which now shows only two collections per year (BSR, 2012)
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT
―I am against fashion that doesn’t last. I cannot accept that you throw your clothes away
just because it is spring.‖ Coco Chanel
Page 11
11
Kenya is one of the countries that import second hand clothing that are resold in flea markets.
These shipments are old, unwanted and sometimes new clothes that are still in good condition
that are available. As we all know women will always shop, either as a way of therapy (fashion
therapy) or they just need new clothes or there is an event that they need to go to and have
nothing in the closet to much the occasion or an update of their clothes according to the trends
that are in.
Most of the young women we see wear similar clothes; they have no sense of style and
uniqueness that well describes them. There is no individuality when it comes to dressing. They
will buy what they like and continue filling their closets without noticing how much they have
bought in a short time span. Since Kenya is not in the position to resell these items or donate,
where do they go?
Based on the problem statement, the purpose of this study is to create fashionable clothing for
young women in Nairobi the fashion capital of Kenya and to create awareness on sustainable
fashion a subject that has minimal attention pertaining to the environment and is yet to be
explored by designers in Kenya.
1.3 OBJECTIVES
To investigate the fashion sense of young women in Nairobi
To examine the influence of fashion trends on young women in Nairobi
To establish awareness on sustainable fashion consumption
To find out the impact of second hand clothing on its consumers
1.4 RESEARCH QUESTIONS
How are the old unwanted clothes disposed?
Where do women in Nairobi shop?
How much is spent on shopping for clothes in a month.
How frequent does one go shopping.
What is the frequently bought item?
Page 12
12
1.5 SCOPE
This study will be carried out in Nairobi due to its proximity to the researcher. Since Nairobi
is the fashion capital of Kenya, there is readily available information on Nairobi fashion
scene as “Nairobians” are always willing to say something about their street style and the
general outlook of street style in Nairobi.
1.6 JUSTIFICATION
The reason for undertaking this research is to create fashionable and creative wear for the young
women in Nairobi as most people wear the same type of clothing and don’t have a sense of
identity or style. The research also seeks to shed light on the issue of fashion consumption and
sustainable fashion consumption.
Page 13
13
2 CHAPTER TWO
2.1 LITERATURE REVIEW
This review looks at the information on fast fashion and brand strategies, fashion
consumption, fashion waste, sustainable fashion and consumption, second hand clothing
industry in Kenya.
2.2 FAST FASHION
Fast fashion is like fast food it’s cheap, addictive and unsustainable. ‘We now buy 40% of all our
clothes at value retailers, with just 17% of our clothing budget.’ (TNS World panel (2006) -
Fashion Focus issue 29). A Cambridge University study reports that in 2006, people were buying
a third more clothes than they were in 2002. Brands began competing against each other for
market share by introducing more lines per year at lower costs, culminating in a situation where
‘fashion houses now offer up to 18 collections a year’ and the low cost, so called ‘value end’ is
‘booming; doubling in size in just 5 years.‘ This naturally has led to pressure on the supply
chain. “Buyers pressure factories to deliver quality products with ever-shorter lead times. Most
factories just don’t have the tools and expertise to manage this effectively, so they put the
squeeze on the workers. It’s the only margin they have to play with.” (Oxfam report, 2004)
Fast Fashion gathered pace from the end of the 1990’s when brands began to look for new ways
to increase profits. Globalization had grown rapidly in the 80’s and 90’s and paved the way for
value and mid price brands to shift the bulk of their production to the developing world where
labour and overheads cost a fraction of those in Europe. High street brands were coming under
increasing pressure from supermarket chains developing their own lines of low cost clothing.
Initially they sold items like simple T shirts and underwear; however the move of George Davies
from Next to Asda signaled a new era for supermarket clothing and a move into high fashion,
low cost items. Traditionally, most fashion labels have produced two main collections a year,
spring/summer and autumn/winter. However, in order to keep the customer focused on the high
street, High Street brands needed to create some interest within their stores mid season. Certain
companies re-examined their supply chains and developed a system which several other brands
then followed. They segmented their supply chain, keeping basic items manufactured in the far -
east but brought the production of the more high fashion items closer to home. This had several
Page 14
14
benefits. Firstly it decreased their financial outlay on forward orders and also allowed them to
make decisions about the fashion items much later in the season. This added flexibility and
ensured they were able to react to the market quickly and deliver ‘on-trend’ items within their
stores. This model could then be developed through the use of new technological systems which
linked all parts of the supply chain together. This new system allowed for the development of
‘just in time’ manufacturing and has now developed to a stage where they are able to turn a
garment around from drawing to shop floor in just two weeks. Consumers reacted positively to
this trend which in turn has resulted in the widespread speeding up of fashion.
A fast fashion system combines quick response production capabilities with enhanced product
design capabilities to both design “hot” products that capture the latest consumer trends and
exploit minimal production lead times to match supply with uncertain demand. Fast fashion is a
clothing production strategy that emphasizes moving high-end catwalk trends into stores in the
shortest amount of time possible at the cheapest possible price point. It was introduced in 1980s
and ’90s by brands like Zara and Benetton, and gained notoriety over the past decade with stores
like Forever21 and H&M. Now, fast fashion a bona fide juggernaut. H&M—which has over
2,200 stores globally—can design, manufacture, and distribute new products in as little as three
weeks, a timeline that allows the company to remain agile and at the forefront of trends, and to
constantly update its massive inventory. Low-grade fabrics, cheap labor from over-seas, and
flimsy construction allow the company to keep prices bargain-basement low, a key factor in
luring customers back weekly or even daily to check out the always-new inventory. Why pay
$25 at Nordstrom for a T-shirt that’s available at H&M for $4.95?
2.3 FAST FASHION BRAND STRATEGIES
Firms in the fashion apparel industry such as Zara, H&M, and Benetton have increasingly
embraced the philosophy of “fast fashion” retailing (Passariello2008, Rohwedder and Johnson
2008). Generally speaking, a fast fashion system combines at least two components:
1. Short production and distribution lead times, enabling a close matching of supply with
uncertain demand (which we refer to as quick response techniques);
2. Highly fashionable (“trendy”) product design (which we refer to as enhanced design
techniques).
Page 15
15
Short lead times are enabled through a combination of localized production, sophisticated
information systems that facilitate frequent inventory monitoring and replenishment, and
expedited distribution methods. For example, Zara, primarily a European retailer, produces the
majority of its designs in costly European and North African factories (rather than outsourcing to
less expensive Asian facilities), and continuously monitors inventory levels in stores to
effectively match supply and demand (Ghemawat and Nueno 2003, Ferdows et al. 2004). The
second component (trendy product design) is made possible by carefully monitoring consumer
and industry tastes for unexpected fads and reducing design lead times. Benetton, for example,
employs a network of “trend spotters” and designers throughout Europe and Asia, and also pays
close attention to seasonal fashion shows in Europe (Meichtry 2007).
From an operational perspective, quick response strategies have been relatively well studied, and
are known to yield significant value to firms by better matching supply and demand (see, e.g.,
Fisher and Raman 1996, Eppen and Iyer 1997, Caro and Martínez-de-Albéniz 2010, Caro and
Gallien 2010) and by influencing consumer purchasing behavior by reducing the frequency and
severity of season-ending clearance sales (Cachon and Swinney 2009). However, the second
component of fast fashion systems—creating trendy, highly fashionable products—has received
far less attention. Indeed, despite the intense recent interest in lead time reduction, Meichtry
(2007) describes how some firms are attempting to focus on design and develop trendier
products without reducing their production lead times because of the difficulties (both logistical
and cultural) that can accompany drastically redesigning the supply network.
Anna Wintour, the editor-in-chief of American Vogue (Vogue, 2011) has credited Zara for
creating a „seasonless cycle for fashion‟. Zara has with the help of computer technology been
able to spot new trends and produce about ten thousand new products a year, causing the shelf
life of a garment to fall from six months to a couple of weeks. (Thomas 2007, p.316) Zara is also
one of the brands that have made the two seasons, Spring/Summer and Autumn/Winter more
obsolete and the fashion customer is becoming more and more used to this. (Roberts, 2010)
The fast fashion brands have changed customer’s expectations concerning speed and variety and
showing that style is possible at low prices. Even loyal high-end customers have started to mix
their luxury fashion with fast fashion. Attracted by the speed at which new styles are in stores
and the fun of buying 10 cheap knockoffs for the price of one authentic jacket, many wealthy
consumers are becoming loyal to fast fashion as well.‟ (Rohwedder, 2004, p.1)
Page 16
16
2.4 FASHION CONSUMPTION
Fashion consumption is the practice of purchasing and adorning oneself with fashion garments
and it is inextricably linked to all aspects of living in an affluent modern society. The origins of
dress and adornment are debated within fashion literature. There are four key theories are
commonly explored by fashion theorists. These theories are based on whether the need for dress
emerged from the desire for symbolic adornment, protection from the environment, social
modesty or from the desire to be immodest for the purpose of attraction and procreation
There are additional factors increasing the rate and volume of fashion garment consumption.
From the production angle, manufacturing developments within the fashion industry such as
increased production speed and access to cheaper labour have enabled garment prices to drop
and consequently, consumers can afford to buy more garments for their money. They are buying
in binges rather than making more discerning purchasing decisions. This increase in the speed
and volume of production does not equate to an increase in the diversity of fashion garment
styles or the quality of their manufacture.
In the book Waste and Want: A Social History of Trash, Susan Strasser, a professor of history at
the University of Delaware, traces the “progressive obsolescence” of clothing and other
consumer goods to the 1920s. Before then, and especially during World War I, most clothing
was repaired, mended, or tailored to fit other family members, or recycled within the home as
rags or quilts. During the war, clothing manufacturers reduced the varieties, sizes, and colors of
their productions and even urged designers to create styles that would use less fabric and avoid
needless decoration. By the mid-1920s consumerism was back in style. Industrialization grew in
the twentieth century, providing the means of increased production of all consumer goods.
During World War II, consumption rose with increased employment as the United States
mobilized for the war. The production and consumption of many household goods, including
clothing, grew by 10–15% even in the middle of the war and continues to expand to this day.
Industrialization brought consumerism with it as an integral part of the economy. Economic
growth came to depend on continued marketing of new products and disposal of old ones that are
thrown away simply because stylistic norms promote their obsolescence.
Page 17
17
The textile and fashion consumption in the world has been consistently increasing over the years.
According to the World Apparel Fiber Consumption Survey 2005-2008 by Food And
Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and International Cotton Advisory
Committee, “Encompassing an annual average growth of the world gross domestic product
(GDP) of 4.2% during 2000 - 2007, per capita world fiber consumption increased by nearly 35%,
from 8.3 kilograms in 2000 to 11.1 kilograms in 2007. However, the economic stagnation in
developed countries in 2008 resulted in a reduced rate of GDP growth for the world (3%), and a
6.4% contraction in per capita world fiber consumption, to 10.4 kilograms” (Food and
Agricultural Organization, UN, 2011). According to “The Fiber Year 2011”, the annual report of
the Dutch manmade fibre manufacturer Akzo that provides a comprehensive survey on world
textile industries, “The world textile industry in 2010 has experienced the most potent growth in
twenty-five years. Manufacturing volumes of natural and manmade fibers rocketed upwards by
8.6%, or 6.4 million tonnes, at 80.8 million tonnes. This corresponds to an average per capita
consumption of 11.8 kg” (The Fiber Year 2011).
On the contrary, fashion commentators such as L’Oreal Fashion Festival Head Karen Webster,
are lamenting the homogenization of fashion design- where the over-exposed globalised industry
is suffering as copying seemingly supplements innovation (Webster, 2004). Fashion consumers
are now offered limited stylistic choices from what appears to be a plethora of garments and thus
their cravings for distinction are going unsatisfied. Additionally, these cheaply produced
garments are not constructed to last and are deteriorating quickly and necessitating replacement
and thus increasing the rate of consumption (Thomas and van Kopplen, 2002).
The issue of consumption and concomitant discard has been further accentuated by the societal
behavior. With the availability of resources and the dynamics of consumption, the consciousness
to utilize the goods to its full potential is reducing and economic growth came to depend on
continued marketing of new products and disposal of old ones that are thrown away simply
because stylistic norms promote their obsolescence (Claudio, 2007). Globalization has made it
possible to produce clothing at increasingly lower prices, prices so low that many consumers
consider this clothing to be disposable (Claudio, 2007), some call it fast fashion‟, the clothing
equivalent of fast food.
So consumption is not for its own sake, but a vehicle for individuals to discover and display the
characteristics of their personality, taste and individuality. Hamilton, like many economists,
Page 18
18
presented the concept that consumption is a by-product of income generation, believing that
people spend money on goods because they have the means (Hamilton, 2003). Joanne
Finkelstein, in agreement with the social psychologists, believes that the consumption and
adornment of fashion is a process of self actualization (1996). As fashion theorists Joanne Eicher
and Mary Ellen Roach-Higgins explained, the meaning of an identity is social, and relates to an
individual’s social status. The pursuit of fashion becomes the act of reconciling one’s identity in
social terms. Consumption critics Joseph Heath and Andrew Potter elaborated, presenting the
view that people consume either to represent how they are distinctive, or to socially conform
(Heath and Potter, 2005).
Consumers react to changes in fashion, both in clothing and household interior designs.
Seasonal changes in fashion mean that clothes can become outdated very quickly, and this
encourages the replacement and disposal of outdated, yet good quality garments (Katkar &
Bairgadar, 2010). This results in issues of over consumption and disposal of unused clothes
leading to burdening of the resources throughout the world (Hawley, 2008). This presents a
double-edged sword, in that while at the same time it stimulates the economy, it also gives rise to
the increased problem of apparel and textile disposal. Piles of unfashionable, unsuitable clothing,
not yet worn out but no longer wearable are further wasted (Joseph,
2001).
.
2.4.1 TASTE AND NEED FOR SOCIAL DISTINCTION
Arthur Windermere says that one may think about what one wears or one may not. If thinking for
oneself is freedom, then one cannot be free unless one thinks for oneself about what to wear.
Everyone deliberates, but not all deliberation is thinking for oneself. Deliberation is the bare
minimum of choosing. With deliberation one decides upon one course of action or another. But
if the principles from which one deliberates are from someone else, the conclusions one reaches
are not one's own; one's thinking is being done by another.
Consumer researchers have shown considerable interest in values because they are argued to
be an important influence on behaviour. Having more materialistic values has been associated
with using possessions for portraying and managing impressions (Belk 1985). Greater levels of
Page 19
19
materialism seem to be associated with an understanding by individuals that possessions serve as
part of a communication or signal to others informing them of who the individual is and what
they are (Douglas & Isherwood 1979). Materialism may, therefore, represent a key variable in
the development of a consumer’s involvement with products that allow the fulfillment of such
values and assist in portraying acceptable images.
Fashion’s immediate social visibility and largely consumption orientation thus provides a potent
site for exploring the construction of postmodern identity and cultural taste. Traditional
understandings of the use of fashion as a social tool focus heavily on class perspectives. In
Bourdieu’s analysis of taste expression, he argues that cultural taste is a reflection of the
struggles for social recognition or status (Jenkins 1992, p.129). From this perspective, fashion is
consumed as a marker of class status. Traditional understandings of the use of fashion in social
settings have focused heavily on class perspectives. In particular, Pierre Bourdieu’s analysis of
taste expression argued that cultural taste is a reflection of the internal struggle for social
recognition or status (Jenkins 1992, p.129). Status recognition is inextricable woven with style:
one’s social position incorporates dress, speech, outlook and bodily dispositions, in addition to
political entitlement and legal location within that society (Turner 1988). Fashion is employed by
elite social groups, to distinguish themselves from lower classes. Fashion then filters down
through lower classes as they in turn employ their own habitus and attempt to follow the
styling’s of their ‘cultural superiors (Bourdieu 1990). This filtering process within fashion was
also explored by Veblen (1899) who argued that the imitation of higher society was used by
lower classes in order to gain prestige. Bourdieu also
emphasizes that cultural capital maintains the
distinction and inequalities between different classes.
Bourdieu defined the field of fashion as the unequal
distribution of cultural capital between high and low
‘couture houses’, presenting the structural components
of social structure in general. Fashion is then essentially
contradictory, simultaneously providing both social
cohesion and individual expression. (Finkelstein
1996).
[ Marie Antoinette –Painting] source :philosophy of
fashion by Arthur windermere
Page 20
20
People can resist the hegemony of taste and culture, such as through the purchase of vintage
clothing, but is seen by Bourdieu as a functional conflict that only reinforces the structure of
fashion’s reproduction and distinction. A major limitation of this perspective is that both the
groups and specific use of objects remain homogenous throughout all forms of production and
consumption. It is seen, constantly during red carpet shows with people of high class showing of
their clothes and mentioning who the designer is. Successful designers are usually associated
with quality and finesse and most people would sort after this designers for their red carpet looks
rather than play it safe with an upcoming designer.
The selection of clothes is influenced by a variety of conflicting motivations. The force that
drives fashion forward is the desire to be seen both as individual and as a particular kind of
person – especially the desire to be seen as in touch and up-to-date and daring (and thus wearing
what is new). The countervailing desire not to be seen as weird or eccentric is the force that
keeps fashion coherent – as fashion rather than unrestrained variety. For some people, this
expression of attitudes and personality is carefully thought through; for others it consists of
active conformity to or rebellion against the demands of a particular culture; for still others it is
often entirely tacit. While designers have little interest in achieving intellectual coherence in their
designs, they are acutely aware of the impression-creating effects designs will have in
contemporary social environments, and thus how they can be used for social self-expression.
(Claudia Eckert and Martin Stacey)
2.4.2 FASHION WASTE
Fashion waste refers to the inactive garments that are hoarded in wardrobes rather than landfill
(Waste Profile Study of Victorian Landfills 1999). Garments become fashion waste when they
no longer fit, cease to appeal visually and ideologically, or are superseded by a superior version.
Once bought, an estimated 21% of annual clothing purchases stay in the home, increasing the
stocks of clothing and other textiles held by consumers, according to Recycling of Low Grade
Clothing Waste, a September 2006 report by consultant Oakdene Hollins. The report calls this
stockpiling an increase in the “national wardrobe,” which is considered to represent a potentially
large quantity of latent waste that will eventually enter the solid waste stream. According to the
EPA Office of Solid Waste, Americans throw away more than 68 pounds of clothing and textiles
Page 21
21
per person per year, and clothing and other textiles represent about 4% of the municipal solid
waste.
The issue of consumption and concomitant discard has been further accentuated by the societal
behavior. With the availability of resources and the dynamics of consumption, the consciousness
to utilize the goods to its full potential is reducing and economic growth came to depend on
continued marketing of new products and disposal of old ones that are thrown away simply
because stylistic norms promote their obsolescence (Claudio, 2007). Globalization has made it
possible to produce clothing at increasingly lower prices, prices so low that many consumers
consider this clothing to be disposable (Claudio, 2007), some call it, fast fashion‟, the clothing
equivalent of fast food. Seasonal changes in fashion mean that clothes can become outdated very
quickly, and this encourages the replacement and disposal of outdated, yet good quality garments
(Katkar & Bairgadar, 2010).
This results in issues of over consumption and disposal of unused clothes leading to burdening of
the resources throughout the world (Hawley, 2008) resulting in post consumer waste. Post-
consumer waste is defined as any type of garment or household article made from manufactured
textiles that the owner no longer needs and decides to discard (Hawley, 2008). These items are
sometimes given to charities but often are put in trash and end in landfills (Textile Recycling
Fact Sheet).
Post-consumer textiles are often resold via a commodity market (primary consumer) to traders
and then to stall merchants for resale at local markets to other consumers at lower price,
exporting in bulk for sale in other countries that is what we receive in our flea markets in Kenya.
In many countries on the African continent, over 80% of the population dress themselves in
second-hand clothing. Western clothing is very popular and second-hand clothing is often of
better quality than the new clothes offered (Ouvertes Project, 2005).
2.5 SECOND HAND CLOTHING
Cloth and clothing were among the primary historical commodities linking Africa with an
increasingly globalizing economy and gradually altering the subjectivities of the population,
creating consumers. The nineteenth and early twentieth century presence of colonial
administrations and missionaries prompted a profound shift in the clothing worn in communities
throughout the continent - particularly in areas where the predominant coverage came from skin,
hides, and backcloth (Comaroff and Comaroff, 1997). Both voluntary and forced migration
Page 22
22
brought men, in particular, together in urban and other concentrated settlements where new
clothing and the wearing of western fashions became increasingly the norm, particularly in
Southern and East Africa (Hansen, 2000).
The secondhand clothing trade in colonial Africa began in the immediate Post-World War I
period with an influx of surplus military uniforms shipped by used clothing dealers in Europe
and from production areas in the United States (Hansen, 2000:66). The amount of clothing
appearing as cast-off articles increased throughout the industrial states of the North in the
twentieth century with the initial success of Fordist policies and concomitant increases in
disposable income. The countries of sub-Saharan Africa now form the world’s largest
secondhand clothing destination, receiving 30% of total world exports in 2001 with a value of
USD $405 million, up from $117 million in 1990 (United Nations, 1996, 2003). The post-
independence period throughout much of sub-Saharan Africa was characterized by an increased
emphasis on domestic production of textiles and finished apparel for local consumption.
Governments turned to clothing as a visible and potentially lucrative expression of pride and
solidarity in new nations. African print cloth was the focus of campaigns encouraging or
otherwise imposing ‘dress codes’ or national dress, using domestic print cloth from these new
industries.
The importation of secondhand clothing was banned in Kenya, and elsewhere throughout much
of Sub-Saharan Africa, as import substitution policies were adopted to strengthen domestic
manufacture. Despite the ban, secondhand clothing began entering Kenya in the 1970s and 1980s
as a consequence of regional political crises.
The first post-independence shipments of secondhand clothes into Kenya were linked to
geopolitical upheavals in Eastern Africa. Conflict in neighboring Uganda, Sudan, and Ethiopia
resulted in increasing populations of refugees in Kenyan camps. Kenya is one of the largest
importers of second-hand clothing (referred to as ‘mitumba’ meaning ‘onslaught’) in SSA .At
this time, refugees from these countries flocked into Kenya and along with them came charitable
aid in the form of tents, food, medicine and clothing. As more clothing came in through charities
and churches it was also given freely to the urban and rural Kenyan poor who could not afford to
purchase new garments. But, by the mid-1980’s, following high demand for cheap second-hand
clothing, donors revised their distribution policy and started to charge for clothing items. It was
at this point that it became commercialized and accessible to the whole population.Charitable
organizations working with displaced persons were able to import used clothing to serve the
needs of these impoverished communities during this period, with some of the donations
Page 23
23
reportedly finding their way into surrounding villages and later urban areas as commodities for
resale (Kimani, 2002:4).
Protectionist measures implemented after independence to foster domestic industrial growth
were eliminated under trade liberalization policies begun in Kenya in 1991. Previously banned
imports of used clothing were now legally allowed into the country for resale, and at prices far
below that of new, domestically manufactured apparel. The absence of foreign exchange
controls, eliminated restrictions, and reduced tariffs resulted in a rise in value of Kenya’s imports
by nearly half between 1996 and 2000 (McCormick et al., 2002). The garment industry was the
most noticeably affected by the surge in imports, particularly the widespread availability of
secondhand clothing, or mitumba (ibid). Mitumba, literally “bales” in Swahili, denoting the form
in which the secondhand clothing arrives in East African ports, were cheaper than Kenyan
products and rapidly gained favor with consumers (Ongile and McCormick, 1996). This
popularity was achieved despite the stigma of the garments being associated with “dead
Europeans”or “kafa Ulaya” – an earlier term for mitumba.
The increasing volume of used clothes entering Kenya throughout the 1990s corresponded with
the closure of the vast majority of clothing and textile factories creating products for local
consumption in those sub-Saharan African countries which legalized imports. Secondhand
clothing is seen as a primary cause for factory closure. While the importation of mitumba is
viewed as a fundamental contributor to the cessation of domestic textile and apparel manufacture
throughout the 1990s, the rise in the current export apparel market complicates this scenario.
Many of the world’s largest importers of secondhand clothing are also among the top exporters
of textiles and garments, including Pakistan and Hong Kong (Hansen, 2004:4).
2.5.1 How the trade operates in Nairobi.
These are between 60-80 second-hand clothing importers in Kenya. The majority of them are
concentrated close to Mombasa port, at the industrial centres in Nairobi, and around the
periphery of Gikomba market (the largest informal market in Kenya and the biggest second-hand
clothing exchange in East Africa). These importers sell either the whole container, or a large
number of bales (usually the most popular ones that are the ‘fastest movers’), to wholesalers.
They, in turn, sell the bales to other wholesalers or direct to small retailers that trade from
Page 24
24
informal markets in Nairobi. At Gikomba market, there are at least 100-150 wholesalers. They
range from small to very large traders and they supply the majority of bales to the 10 000-15 000
retailers that trade at the market. At around 8am every morning retailers buy approximately 1-3
bales from the wholesale stores. At their market stall, they cut the bales and unpack the different
qualities of clothing by separating them into 3 different piles. 1st camera refers to high quality
clothing that is immediately purchased by a ‘cameraman’ who gets exclusive choice of the best
items. 2nd camera clothing is sold for a lower price.
Once the retailer has made sufficient profit from the bale, the remaining items – the 3rd camera-
are usually ‘cleared’. This means they are sold in bulk to a small retailer who will often purchase
up to 50 low quality garments. The clothes that have been cleared at Gikomba are transported to
smaller markets in Nairobi and surrounding rural areas. At these new markets, once the original
clearer has made their profit on the clothes, someone else will clear form them-and the camera
process starts again (quality declines as the process repeats). Eventually, the final consumer
(often in rural areas) will buy the clothing for a very low price.
2.5.2 Who benefits from the second-hand clothing trade
This section highlights the main beneficiaries of the trade, by tracing the various actions
involved in the supply chain i.e. from commercial importers to the final consumer.
2.5.2.1 Importers
Commercial importers in Kenya undoubtedly provide a lucrative commodity that benefits many
Kenyan people. On average, importers based in Mombasa and Nairobi import 2-4 consignments
per month. Most buyers have a contract with two different suppliers, i.e. one in Europe (for a
high quality product) and one in the US (for al low-cost product). Average profits cited per
month ranged from £800-£4000 depending on the grade, origin and type of clothing sold.
Commercial importers also provide an important source of employment creation. Most
businesses employ between 3-5 local staff, as well as truck drivers, security officers, manual bale
transporters and casual staff to run errands.
2.5.2.2 Wholesalers
Page 25
25
Wholesalers also benefit from the second-hand clothing trade. In general, they make an average
gross profit of Ksh 800-1000 per 45 Kg bale. However, financial gains are dependent on the size
of their business. For example:
• Small wholesalers buy and sell approximately 50-100 bales per week
• Medium sized purchase around 150-300, and
• Large wholesalers buy and sell 400-600 (whole consignments)
2.5.2.3 Market Traders
The following quote is from the Kenyan Department of Trade and Industry: “In terms of the
traders, it is a misconception that they are employed. What are they getting out of it-sitting in the
sun all day? It is disguised unemployment. At the end of the day, there is no dignity in this
work.” In contrast, others estimate that the second-hand clothing trade directly or indirectly
affects 5 million people through employment and income generation. And, when you consider
that the current unemployment rate in Kenya is 40%, the impact of this trade on employment
creation is very substantial.
In Gikomba market, over half of the traders interviewed have previously been unemployed or
recently retrenched. The rest have been in temporary or seasonal jobs (like construction) or
working in low paid service sectors. For these traders, second-hand clothing has provided an
alternative solution by offering them the opportunity to start their own self-employed venture. A
frequent response by traders is:
“I decided to create employment for myself. I sell clothes for my own survival and the survival
of my family”
In comparison to the low wages of unskilled and semi-skilled employees in the formal sector, for
example, factory workers who earn around 4000-7000 Ksh per month, the majority of
secondhand clothes traders relatively earn a much higher income with 10 000-15 000Ksh
recorded as average monthly takings, But this figure accounts for gross takings rather than net
profits and fluctuation demand for clothing results rather than net profits and fluctuation demand
for clothing results in unpredictable daily, weekly and monthly sales. However, even taking this
into account second-hand clothing still represents a productive and lucrative trade especially
when compared to other trades in the informal sector. The trade is also considered a good
training ground for business-in terms of learning marketing skills, direct sales and keeping
financial records. Therefore, even if the trade stopped altogether, informal traders would still
survive by transferring the skills they have learnt to setting up other businesses.
Page 26
26
The second-hand clothing trade has also increased opportunities for women to earn a living.
At Gikomba market, women comprise a large proportion of informal traders, i.e. they make up
about 60% of the trading population. This is mainly because the trade is relatively non-gendered
and accessible to anyone regardless of formal training and access to capital. Women can also sell
second-hand clothing at the same time as attending to many of their domestic responsibilities,
something which is not always possible to balance in formal employment. The majority of
female traders entered the trade:
• To supplement their family income
• Bring money into the household if their parents were unemployed, or
• To become self-reliant by owning their own businesses and working for themselves
These results indicate that the second-hand clothing trade in Kenya has provided an important
opportunity for employment and income generation. Faced by the increasing cost of living,
falling real wages, and rising unemployment, many Kenyans have found an alternative solution,
selling clothing to generate a livelihood or diversify household incomes. It is also clear that
entering the second-hand clothing trade is not just a last resort for the economically desperate
during a period of extreme hardship. Instead, many have pro-actively entered the trade because it
offered a relatively lucrative means of generating an income.
2.5.2.4 Spin off Employment
As well as providing jobs and income to informal traders at Gikomba market, the second-hand
clothing trade also supports a large number of different types of employment: - from, repairing
and ironing (where traders usually have a contract with tailors and ironers to add value to good
quality clothing);
to - bag making (for traders to transport clothing to sell in rural areas);
security (to protect the clothing stored at the market at night and prevent thefts during
the day);
manual bale carriers (who transport bales from warehouses to market stalls)
All these activities take place on a large scale at the market site.
2.5.2.5 Consumers
Page 27
27
Studies have shown that among African countries that are large importers, second-hand clothing
usually accounts for over one –third of all garments purchased, and Kenya is no exception. In
fact, by the mid-1990s, second-hand clothing accounted for 50% of the textile market; locally
produced clothing took 30%; and cheap new imports from the Far East, Europe and the US
comprised 20% of the domestic market.
Considering, over half of Kenya’s 30 million people live below the absolute poverty line, with
56% of the population subsisting on less that US$1 per day, most Kenyans cannot afford to buy
new clothes sold in shops, where prices are comparable to those in Europe or the US. For
example, while a man’s new shirt cost approximately 350-400 Ksh from a formal retail outlet, a
second-hand shirt sold at a flea market can be purchased for 50Ksh. So clearly, at a time when
poverty is increasing in Kenya, second-hand clothing provides a very welcome cheap alternative
to new clothing.
Most importantly, the availability of such cheap clothing has allowed very poor people to clothe
themselves and their families who (in the absence of the trade) could not afford to buy any
clothing at all. The majority of customers that have been interviewed, they were able to combine
their purchases by selecting second-hand clothes for informal occasions and new garments from
retail outlets for formal, ‘special’ occasions; this meant that they could save their limited
resources to finance other basic requirements. Indeed, many Kenyans are only able to maintain a
middle-class façade in the face of falling real incomes by relying on second-hand clothing.
“At Nairobi dinner parties, smartly dressed Kenyan women will discreetly compare their
mitumba purchases in the same way that British women appraise buys from the January sales”.
(Vasager, 2004). The trade also gives customers the opportunity to generate an income by
reselling items of clothing in rural areas. At Gikomba market, nearly half of the customers
interviewed, supplemented their weekly wage by buying clothing in bulk at the weekends to take
back and sell in their hometown.
Finally, the second-hand clothing trade also offers increased consumer choice, regardless of
affordability and consumer income levels, through the provision of a wider and different
selection, quality, and style of clothing in contrast to the expensive and limited choice available
at retail outlets. So, overall, second-hand clothing appeals to low, middle and high-income
earners as well as different ethnic groups.
Page 28
28
2.5.3 Impact on the local textile and clothing production
Much of the existing literature on the second-hand clothing trade has focused on claims by
textile and clothing industries in developing countries, and their associated councils,
Associations and Trade Unions, that the trade has a negative impact on local textile and clothing
production in recipient countries. As a result, the governments of Zimbabwe, Nigeria, Cameroon,
Chad, Tanzania, South Africa and Kenya have all at one time banned or imposed high tariffs on
imports of second-hand clothing.
In Kenya, the general attitude by government officials to the trade was very negative. Typical
comments were “the trade is killing out textile and clothing industry”. A number of other factors
need to be considered include:
• The drought in 1995-7 that hit the cotton sector hard
• The rise of cheap cotton lint producers e.g. Pakistan and India, i.e. Kenyan producers that
provided the domestic and export sector went out of business
• The collapse of the Cotton board of Kenya – this meant that domestic cotton was no longer
subsidized by the government and cotton became far too expensive for manufacturers
• import of very cheap Asian textile products in 1997-98 that textile producers could not compete
with
lack of locally produced synthetic raw material
• Trade liberalisation (the most important factor). In 1990 the economy was opened up to
international competition at a time when Kenyan textiles and clothing were not competitive in
price and quality.
Overall, the decline of textile and clothing companies in African countries is less about
secondhand clothing than about a combination of structural adjustment policies that encourage a
rapid increase in import penetration via trade liberalization without providing incentives to
promote production and employment. Nevertheless, local African markets are still unlikely to
support any considerable growth of the textile and clothing industry unless countries experience
substantial economic growth combined with a more equitable income distribution.
Second hand clothe is the result of the emphasis of the current world on beauty and economy.
Beauty and quality can be borrowed and business cycle can be developed to nowhere and even
recycle it.
2.5.4 The unsustainable consumption of second-hand garments
Page 29
29
It has been proposed that “investing now and storing clothes to age, as one does wine, is advised
as a form of future vintage consumption that validates buying contemporary fashion”(Palmer &
Clark, 2005). Consumers adopting the role of a fashion forecaster can result in overflowing
wardrobes. This advanced consumption encourages the practice of hoarding where garments are
retained with the hope of being popularized by fashions to come. Consumers can become
overzealous and make impulsive purchases because the financial outlay is considered to be
insignificant.
It is difficult for a younger audience experiencing nostalgia for fashions before their time, unless
they are encouraged to feel as though they have missed something important. Brown summarizes
the phenomenon; “with hindsight, we know we missed out on something genuinely inspiring and
progressive and re-edit our histories to include them” (Jones, 2005). It is a form of ‘faux-
nostalgia’ that is also based on the fact that upon reflection, young people identify with certain
eras indicative of certain values that align with their own. As young people do not experience
true nostalgic feelings due to their age, they become highly educated and can enjoy nostalgia
through becoming an informed authority. This younger demographic is choosing to adopt past
fashion at a primarily aesthetic level, but are also appropriating the historical dress within the
contemporary environment.
In addition to the interest of regular consumers, fashionistas, designers and fashion
commentators are embracing vintage styles to inspire a ‘new’ fashion direction or design. This
has imbued the practice of consuming second-hand garments with additional market value
through the inflation of their perceived fashion credibility. The editions of Vogue magazine and
Harpers Bazaar regularly feature vintage pieces within their fashion pictorials.
2.6 SUSTAINABLE FASHION
The Brundtland Report supplied the most common and enduring definition of sustainability as
finding a way to meet the current needs of all people today without compromising the needs of
generations to come. Sustainability expert David Suzuki defined the task of sustainable
development for individuals to be about assessing all kinds of human behaviour with the view to
re-develop those that prohibit the development of a sustainable future (Suzuki & Dressel, 2002).
In terms of sustainable consumption as explored by economist Paddy Dolan, the production
solution is the relatively straight forward task of introducing sustainability regulations regarding
selection of materials and manufacturing processes (Dolan, 2002).
Page 30
30
2.6.1 UPCYCLING
Up-cycling refers to reuse of a garment where its quality remains the same or is increased by the
process, attempting to counter the common problem of recycling practices reducing the quality
of the original materials, as occurs when glass is recycled (adapted from a workshop text for
‘Ever & Again, Rethinking Recycled Textiles: Introduction and Context setting for textile
recycling’, Oct 2005)). Up-cycling confers an environmental benefit by reducing, or at least
delaying, the addition of trash to our landfills. (Andrea Anderson, Holland & Hart 2009)
The process of up-cycling is more than just use old and raw material. By this kind of re-use the
raw material is augmented into an object of higher status than the original object. It is about
upgrading used material and making it more desirable than it was at the start. Reformulate the
basic logic of fashion: making new of the old and create diversity by using unique garments with
using existing design and methods. Every piece that is made according to this method,
regardless of how many versions there may be, is a unique piece, because the materials that are
used in it are unique. (Barbara Vinken)
Broken, damaged and redundant objects can be refashioned and value added through the process
of up-cycling, which in the work from Plunkett and Sales on the use of decorative textile
techniques such as printing and embroidery. As a sustainable strategy for design, up-cycling
provides a designer with the opportunity to reassess the real worth and value of a waste material
through the design and manufacture of new products. Rather than recycling, which can result in
the downgrading of a material up-cycling seeks to further prolong the life and value of a product
and material. (Allison Gwilt, Timo Rissanen 2012)
Murray in the book Zero Waste explains that up-cycling textiles is not merely conserving the
resources that went into the production of a particular materials, but by adding the value
embodied in them by the application of knowledge in the course of their recirculation.(Murray,
2002)
Up-cycling method, or upward re-processing, is defined as bringing waste back into the
consumption chain through design by placing it higher up in the chain than it previously was –
this includes environmental as well as commercial and aesthetical value – while also accounting
Page 31
31
for the product’s future (McDonough and Braungart 2002). Compared To recycling waste
recovery strategies, up-cycling brings about the greatest change with the least amount of energy
use. Via up-cycling, the source material moves from the lowest to the highest level of the
production cycle. By allowing the largest possible amount of textile waste to be given new value,
up-cycling solves the problems associated with fashion textile waste (Reet Aus Trash to Trend
2011).
Up-cycling method also respects the principle of local production. The source material in up-
cycling is usually gathered in the same region where production take place which, in turn, also
contributes to resolving
environmental and social
issues related to the
globalization of the
fashion textile industry
and its reliance on
transportation.
[junky styling] source: www.junkystyling.com
Up-cycling is most efficient if used within the production company itself and under the same
brand, sending all generated waste back to the production process. This entails implementing up-
cycling in the design process of the main product – pre-calculating the textile waste generated
and designing the patterns for side products so that they can be easily made of the textile
leftovers. The availability of waste material in fashion design is essential in implementing up-
cycling, since the design and production process is much determined by the material used. For
the sustainable fashion industry to be cultivated, it is also important to increase the demand for
sustainable fashion. It is therefore essential that sustainable fashion becomes a part of the regular
fashion scene, increasing its supply. In terms of environmental impact as well as economic
Page 32
32
viability and the complexity of the design, up-cycling is most efficient. Implementing a DIY (do
it yourself) approach to up-cycling minimizes the environmental impact of the design and
creation of a garment.
A common phenomenon in fashion over the last 20 years has been the tactic of reusing old
garments into new creations. However, to call the haute couture techniques by for example
Maison Martin Margiela as simply “recycling” would be an understatement. What happens in
this process of reuse is that the raw material is augmented into an object of higher status than its
original incarnation. If these garments are in some way “cycled”, they are “upcycled”. This
concept, initially explored by the Austrian artist group WochenKlausur, is a process of upgrading
used material, making it more desirable than it was at the start. “Upcycling is a procedure akin to
recycling in which waste material and worn out goods are reprocessed directly into new products
without being reduced to raw materials.” (Zinggl: 87)
What this form of recycling is doing to fashion has purposefully been going on in the art world
since Duchamp, and the raw material of used clothes are the objet trouve of fashion. The
“upcycled” haute couture garments are often remade in such way that they leave the consumer
object cycle. Their mundane and ephemeral status enters the timeless state of unique artworks
with very few signs of the zeitgeist manifested into their re-sewn fabric. This process of reuse
reformulates one of the basic logics of fashion; making new of the old and in the procedure get a
singularity of unique garments out of general methods or designs. A kind of shortcut to the
unique object, as the fabric itself is distinctively heterogeneous. This is a fascination of the single
piece, as highlighted by fashion theorist Barbara Vinken, something that traditionally was
exclusively reserved to the artwork. It is the initiation of a fashion based on duration rather than
change. (Vinken: 143) In her book Fashion Zeitgeist she raises the approach on fashion design as
one aspect of what she calls “post-fashion”: Every piece that is made according to this method,
regardless of how many versions there may be, is a unique piece, because the materials that are
used in it are unique.
2.6.2 FASHION DECONSTRUCTION
Flavia Loscialpo in her book “Fashion & philosophical deconstruction” ,“Deconstructionism”
was the brainchild of French philosopher Jacques Derrida who named the process of breaking
Page 33
33
down established forms. The term is normally applied to text but also describes breaking down
conventions and normal boundaries. His idea was to contradict, challenge and destabilize the
universal truth. It’s a fashion item that looks unfinished and the designer is still in the midst of
experimenting with the product. Normally, the fashion item has exposed seams, raw edges,
displacement of certain component and some sort of treatment to make it look distressed.
According to Martin Mcquillan, deconstruction is the rethinking of the conceptual and non-
conceptual foundations of the western tradition. It examines the way in which Western thought is
structured. Jacques Derrida suggested that Western thought is structured in terms of binary
oppositions, the separation of conceptual material such as Man/Woman; Black/White equally.
Deconstruction suggests that opposite concepts are constructions. Yes and no are words that
represent opposing feelings but the words themselves are not opposites. Black and white
represents associations that change from culture to culture. Deconstruction, Mcquillan thinks,
reminds us of the different perceptions of each individual of the world. In an example, the term
‘Here and now’ is never identical to the actual moment in which one was referring to.
Deconstruction fashion is meant to challenge the traditional perception of beauty. In the 1980’s a
generation of independent thinking made an appearance in fashion that incarnated a sort of
‘distress’ in the comparison to fashion at the times. The works resided not only in the undoing of
the structure of a garment but re-thinking the functions and the meaning of the garment itself. It
questioned the relationship between the body and the garment and the concept of ‘body’. As
recalled by fashion experts, 1981 is the year in which both Yamamoto Rei Kawakubo showed for
the first time their collection in Paris. Their appearance forced “the representatives of the world’s
press to examine their consciences”. Rejecting every clichéd notion of what glamour should be,
or the fashionable silhouette should look like, they disclosed in fact a new approach to clothing
in the post-industrial, late 20th century society. Their major contribution consisted, and still
consists, in their endless challenging the relationship between memory and modernity, enduring
and ephemeral. At first, the austere, demure, often second hand look of their creations induced
some journalists to describe it as ‘post-punk’, or ‘grunge’.At the same time, it aims to destabilize
fashion with impeccable garment finishing.
In “Deconstruction Fashion: The Making of Unfinished, Decomposing and Re-Assembled
Clothes,” Alison Gill uses the idea of deconstruction borrowed from Jacques Derrida philosophy.
Gill suggests the fashion style of deconstruction, called “Le Destroy,” by the French, is an
intentional effort at unfinished forms that are coming apart, recycled or transparent. The basis of
Page 34
34
all deconstruction clothing is aestheticized non-functionality that amounts to anti-fashion. Gill
then moves on to relation "deconstructionism" to "Le Destroy," describing the practices of anti-
fashion (which has some deconstruction elements but is far too focused on negative critique of
the industry), recession zeitgeist (which creates a political connection between the instability of
eastern European ideologies and an instability of fashion codes), eco-fashion (which emphasizes
the use of recycled/eroding materials to send a message for more environmentally friendly
textiles), and theoretical fashion (most closely related to deconstructionist fashion in that it links
philosophical ideologies to the practice of fashion). Gill claims that "deconstruction fashion
liberates the garment from functionality by literally undoing," making the reader ponder exactly
what the functionality of fashion is.
She states that deconstruction in fashion is somewhat like an auto-critique of the fashion
system, revealing the draw and attraction of fashion such as the glamour, fantasy and exclusivity
and technical aspects such as form, stitches and fabrication. Deconstruction, in a literal level,
conotates the reversal of construction, thus the unfinished or destroyed look of garments.
Deconstruction was first seen as a rebellion against fashion in the 80s and the acceptance and
movement into the domain of fashion was deemed contradictory and deconstruction was seen as
another superficial trend.
[from left: Karl Lagerfeld,
Dries Van Noten, and Hussein
Chalayan, F 2009]
Gill then goes in depth on the
term "deconstruction" and its
named critique by creator
Jacques Derrida. Derrida
claims that deconstruction
should not be linked to a negative critique (it is not to be called 'destruction') on society, or in
this case the normalized fashion industry, but rather the introduction of a new discourse in the
way we view the working of social codes. This type of thinking may be related to post-
modernism.
Page 35
35
The works of Maison Martin Margiela are indeed classical artworks: exclusive. According to
fashion theorist Alison Gill, Margiela “deconstructs the hierarchical relation that persists
between the exclusivity of designer fashion and everyday clothes.” (Gill: 31) Indeed, Margiela’s
upcycled garments are highly exclusive, fashionable, and pricy; they still represent the top of the
fashion hierarchy, unattainable to most of us. Gill’s assumption that Margiela’s deconstructed
garments somehow should bridge the gap between fashion and the everyday might be true on a
material level, but hardly from a perspective of participation. The upcycling of fashion into art or
the temporal readjustment into postfashion is interesting, but is not the main interest in this
process. Instead, fashions of up-cycling puts a focus on postproduction processes open to people
outside of the fashion system (the once “passive” consumers). With hardly any means of
production to create the new, they can now recreate the old into the new, and still be in fashion.
It enables new interfaces open for fellow amateurs (lovers) and other laymen to share their skills.
Interfaces for new explorations of craftsmanship, outside, but still in relation with, the dictations
of fashion.
Gills’ interpretation of Margiela, she means that the act of unstitching can be defined as “a
practice of ‘undoing’, deconstructionalist fashion liberates the garment from functionality, by
literally undoing it.” (Gill: 35) This notion of liberation is no coincidence. It can trigger us to
further explore the hidden logics of fashion that are at the same time trapped in and performed
through every garment
For deconstruction to take place, the binary must be
reversed, as showing that binary opposition at work
is necessary. Deconstruction is a false opposition
working, however, stopping it would restore the
inequality and there would be no changes towards
the unequal system in the first place. Therefore, it is
necessary to remove the whole system of binary
thinking and binary logic which is the only way the
binary is said to be undone.Comme de Garcons,
2006, the design combines two opposing aesthetics
giving both a presence but denying either totality.
Both aesthetics are in play with one another.
[Rei Kawakubo]
Page 36
36
The general definition of deconstruction as a practice of undoing construction would mean the
liberation of garments from its function, which is not applicable. Gill’s point is that
deconstruction is the dressed down version for its application to fashion and that fashion could
possibly have a prescribed function.
[Comme-de-garcons –Paris Fashion Week-Rei Kawakubo : right]
How can we create practices of
liberation and empowerment with the
tools at hand – with old clothes and
sewing skill? Perhaps this process
opened by up-cycling can make us
also update the world of fashion in
small and beautiful steps, up-
fashioning it with our own
craftsmanship. We can use fashion as
a workshop for collective enablement
where a community shares their
methods and experiences. Liberating a
part of fashion from a phenomenon of
dictations and the anxiety to become a
collective experience of
empowerment through engaged craft.
2.7 DESIGN EXEMPLARS
2.7.1 Jackson Pollock-painter
He is a painter that practiced action painting that was part of the Abstract Expressionism art
movement that was a term first used in connection with Kandinsky in 1919, but more commonly
associated with post-war American art. Robert Coates, an American critic, coined it in 1946,
referring to Gorky, Pollock and de Kooning. All were influenced by Existentialist ideas, which
Page 37
37
emphasized the importance of the act of creating, not of the finished object. With regards to
technique, what is meant is the formal process used in the production of their compositions. The
elements of line, shape, scale, texture, and medium are great examples of what constitute form.
The truth to their principle was determined by how "in the zone" the painter was at the time he or
she was working on the composition. That is, how completely attuned the artist was in the piece
with which they were involved. As well, some Abstract Expressionists painted representational
images. In some cases, an Abstract Expressionist painter would leave the image unfinished.
However, the composition was finished. In regards to Abstract Expressionist techniques, the
creation of patterns and shape, colour, scale, and medium were very important. The work was
less a presentation of colour than a manifestation of spontaneous lines and shape. A
characteristic of many Action Painters was their approach to the canvas. Typically, the paint was
aggressively stroked, poured, splashed, or thrown onto the canvas. The paintings of the Action
painters were not meant to portray objects per se or even specific emotions. Instead they were
meant to touch the observer deep in the subconscious mind, evoking a sense of the primeval and
tapping the collective sense of an archetypal visual language. This was done by the artist painting
"unconsciously," and spontaneously, creating a powerful arena of raw emotion and action, in the
moment. Action painting was clearly influenced by the surrealist.
Their works of art provide a good inspiration for the creation of my prints and the pleasure of
working on a big canvas. The
freedom to express emotions
through art not is restricted.
Their use of colour will help in
choosing the colours for the
2013 women’s collection. The
lines and shapes created in their
painting provide shape
inspiration for the collection to
have a common ground.
[Jackson Pollock- Converge]
photo source: Google images
Page 38
38
2.7.2 Vivienne Westwood
A global icon as well as an iconoclast. In the 1970s, she electrified the fashion world with the
launch of punk and went on to become one of the most inventive and influential designers of
our time. Fashion to her became “a baby I picked up and never put down.” Known best for
her willingness to take risks and to disregard conventions, she also has a profound respect for
the past and such as corsets and crinolines and reinvents them in new ways. Another
hallmark of her ever-evolving work is her use of thoroughly British fabrics such as tartans
and tweeds to create fashion that gently parodies Establishment styles and the royalty.
Regardless of how outrageous or provocative the result may be however, her approach has
always been practical. She is driven by a curiosity about how things work. Vivienne
Westwood revolutionized fashion, and her impact can still be felt. Her clothes are full of
historical references, particularly to the 17th and 18th century, which serve as an
inexhaustible source of inspiration for her. In addition, with her own technique for draping
and pattern cutting, Westwood creates clothes with a characteristic volume.
[Vivienne Westwood- red label collection] photo source : Google images
Page 39
39
2.7.3 Junky styling
Annika Sanders and Kerry Seager established Junky Styling on Brick Lane in London. A
clothing label, shop, and design team, Junky Styling built a reputation over the last ten years, not
only for their tailor-detailed fresh styles, but for also encouraging customers to get involved in
recycling. Junky Styling aims to change the way people consume clothing. Their work consists
of one-off ‘wardrobe surgeries’ for customers as well as an internationally stocked ready-to-wear
collection. The business idea developed from their experimentation with recycling second-hand
clothes into club-wear; being part of the same generation this sounded warmly familiar.
[junky styling-up-cycling] photo source www.junkystyling .com
3 CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Research Design
Page 40
40
The research design is exploratory survey research that is used “to answer questions that have been
raised, to solve problems that have been posed or observed, to assess needs and set goals, to determine
whether or not specific objectives have been met, to establish baselines against which future comparisons
can be made, to analyze trends across time, and generally, to describe what exists, in what amount, and in
what context.” (Isaac & Michael, 1997, p. 136). This study aimed at getting an in-depth study of the street
style fashion based in Nairobi. It therefore fits the descriptive study appropriately. The components of the
Research project included:
i. Investigating the fashion sense and style of young women in Nairobi
ii. Examining the influence of fashion trends on young women in Nairobi and how
they have adapted it into their own style
iii. The impact of second hand clothing on its consumers within Nairobi.
iv. The amount young women in Nairobi spend on shopping and how they dispose of
excess clothing or old clothing.
3.2 Population of study
The population of interest in this study consisted of respondents who are within Nairobi city
between the ages of 18-30. The population was considered because of their exposure to:
fashion and style
Nairobi as the fashion capital of Kenya
the biggest informal market/flea market is in Nairobi [Gikomba Market]
3.3 Sample design and sampling design
The sample size consisted of 40 young women based within Nairobi area. The sample
respondents were randomly selected from a sample frame obtained from the public, flea markets
[toi market], stalls and department stores [Mr.Price] in two localities in Nairobi. The flea markets
were considered because they have the greatest number of shoppers’ everyday compared to stalls
and department stores where they had few shoppers that go into the stalls in a day. Deming
argues that the quality of a study is often better with sampling than with a census. He suggests
that sampling possess the possibility of better interviewing (testing), more thorough investigation
Page 41
41
of missing, wrong, or suspicious information, better supervision and better processing than is
possible with complete coverage.
3.4 Data Collection
Data was collected using a structured questionnaire. The questionnaire were given to respondents
to fill in under close supervision by the researcher who waited to explain to the respondent
questions not well understood and pick up the completed questionnaires [self administered
questionnaires] . The researcher also collected data by sending mails to the respondents via their
personal e-mail accounts that saved the researcher quite a lot of time and helped reach the
respondents even via social media sites.
3.5 Data Analysis
Data was analyzed using descriptive statistics. Mean scores were used to determine the amount
of money spent in a month by the respondents, the frequency of their shopping sprees, which
shopping places have the most number of shoppers and what is the frequently bought items in
their wardrobe. The data collected was presented in tables and pie charts.
4 CHAPTER FOUR
DATA ANALYSIS AND PRESENTATIONS
4.1 Introduction
The study targeted 40 members of the sample that were based within Nairobi area the closest
proximity to the researcher. Questionnaires were given to all members of the sample but only 32
Page 42
42
members responded representing a response rate of 80%. The rule of thumb states that any
sample which is greater or equal to 30 is adequate. In addition, studies never attain 100%
response rate.
4.2 Demographic information
This section shows information on demographic variable of the respondents which is their age
shown by the table below
Table 1: Respondent’ age
The above table shows the age groups that I used in the sample. The most number of people that
I interviewed were between the ages of 22-26 years.
Figure 1: Respondents’ age
Age group frequency percentage
18-22 years 8 25
22-26 years 17 53
26-30 years 7 22
Total 32 100
Page 43
43
4.3 Expenditure on shopping
Table 2: Expenditure on Shopping
Amount frequency Percentage %
500-1000 5 16
1000-2000 8 25
2000-5000 13 41
Over 5000 6 19
Total 32 100%
The table above shows that a higher percentage of young women spend between 2000-5000
shillings on shopping in a month.
18-22 years25%
22-26 years54%
26-30 years21%
figure 1: age group
Page 44
44
Table 3: the most frequently shopped places
Shop Frequency Percentage%
Flea Markets e.g. Gikomba market 18 56
Department stores e.g. Woolworths 4 13
Stalls e.g. Jamia Mall 6 19
Thrift shops e.g. Closet 49 3 9
Online 1 3
Total 32 100%
500-1000 kshs16%
1000-2000 kshs25%
2000-5000kshs40%
over 5000 kshs19%
figure 2:expenditure in kshs per month
Page 45
45
Table 4: Awareness of sustainable fashion
Awareness on sustainable fashion frequency Percentage%
Yes 22 69
No 10 31
Total 32 100%
Table 5: where old unwanted clothes are discarded
flea markets56%
department stores13%
stalls19%
thrift shops9%
online3%
figure 3: Shopping Areas
Yes96%
No4%
figure 4: sustainability awareness
Page 46
46
Frequency Percentage%
Donate 23 72
Burn 1 3
Throw away 3 9
Resell 0 0
Up-cycle 5 16
Total 32 100%
Table 6: those who are aware of Up-cycle
Frequency Percentage%
Yes 19 59
No 13 41
Donate72%
Burn3%
Throw away9%
Resell0%
Up-cycle16%
figure 5: discard of unwanted clothes
Page 47
47
Total 32 100%
Table 7: Those willing to try Up-cycle fashion
Frequency Percentage%
Yes 31 97
No 1 3
Total 32 100%
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Yes No
pe
rce
nta
ge
respondents
figure 6: awareness on up-cycling
Page 48
48
4.4 Limitations of the Survey
The limitations of the study was the small sample size that allowed the researcher to get limited
information and statistics, if the sample was larger the conclusive evidence would have matched
a larger populations, behavioral aspects about fashion and style in general.
Conduction an online survey also had its limitations where respondents did not get back in time
with their questionnaires. A number of them declined to fill in the questionnaire so the researcher
had to work with what she had.
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Yes No
pe
rce
nta
ge
respondents
figure 7: willingness to try up-cycling
Page 49
49
5 CHAPTER FIVE
FINDINGS, DISCUSSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 FINDINGS AND DICUSSIONS
After conducting the survey through interviews and questionnaires it was duly noted that the
pursuit of fashionable dress is motivated primarily by the social desires of the individual. Rather
than consuming fashion garments to appease basic needs. A higher percentage of young women
in Nairobi bought clothes for the sake of being fashionable and in trend without looking at the
bigger picture of why they need the clothes, where they will take the old ones or the room to
accommodate both old and new clothes. The researcher also falls victim to these tendencies. The
typical Nairobi woman will shop till she drops.
While conducting an observation in Nairobi CBD [Central Business Unit] the number of women
sorting through masses of second hand clothing and shoes from hawkers is indeed a great
number. The women are in between the age bracket of 18-30; from students to working class
women all bent down looking for clothes and trying them out in public. With a percentage of
56% it was noted that flea markets are the most visited places for shopping. The respondents said
that the second hand clothing are cheaper, affordable and have a variety of clothing items. Its
clear that second-hand clothing is becoming more desirable for distinction-seeking consumers
who are dissatisfied with the homogenization of new fashion garments in the mass market and
this is leading to its popularization by fashion at the current time.
From the survey the researcher also noted that a small percentage of Nairobi women are
completely unaware of wasteful consumption, if they don’t go shopping its simply because they
don’t have money but as soon as they get some cash a percentage of it will go into buying
clothes and accessories and they term it as “treating” themselves after handworks’ month or day.
Some are impulse shoppers that they buy and buy and forget about some important things that
need to be attended to rather than materialistic things. With the sample of 32 respondents 72 %
of the sample donates their excess clothes to make room for more clothes that they buy with a
frequency of 5 to 10 times in a month.
On analyzing information gathered from the online survey on sustainability and up-cycling
method, 59% of the sample had knowledge concerning sustainability and wasteful consumption.
Page 50
50
[See table 4 and 6]. The rest have no knowledge of how they buy second hand clothing which is
[clothes that have been donated by the West as a way of practicing sustainable fashion
consumption] resold in the flea markets such as Gikomba, Toi and Ngara markets. They are
blindly following trends, all they know is “that dress looks so good on me, I must buy it” or
‘blankets and wine is happening this weekend and I have nothing to make an entrance with”. The
high percentage of the sample on willingness to try out up-cycling gives hope that Nairobi is the
starting point to experiment and have people adopt up-cycling as way of practicing sustainable
fashion
Closet 49 a company in Kenya that started having discovered lack of trendy, affordable,
accessible fashion items online. It is the only company in Kenya that is practicing sustainable
fashion consumption where people resell their own clothes and accessories in closet49 a way of
de-cluttering their wardrobe and earning a few coins when their items are bought by other
people. During my interview with Serah Kinyua a correspondent with Closet49, she shed light on
the sustainability conference dubbed “Fashion Africa 2012” which was a vehicle to create a
social forum that was aimed to raise awareness elevate the perception of fashion design from the
continent and sustainable fashion. The idea for the conference was in conjunction with
Jacqueline Shaw of Africa Fashion Guide and its aim was to create an opportunity to discuss and
promote the full supply chain of African fashion Design, Textiles and Manufacturing and thus
communicate this to a larger global audience through media. They also stock up-coming
designer’s clothes and accessories, a way of promoting the new-comers. Kenya’s very own e-bay
(online shopping site).
5.2 RECOMMENDATION
5.2.1 Building awareness
It is increasingly important that the objectives of sustainability be translated and clarified for a
Kenyan audience. As the globe is warming, it is essential that consumers be made aware of the
need to address all unsustainable behaviours with the view to challenge, re-evaluate and
redevelop in a sustainable way. With regard to fashion consumption, this involves raising
awareness about the ethical and environmental ramifications of new garment production to foster
a willingness to engage in more sustainable consumption.
Page 51
51
5.2.2 Engage a willing audience
The goal for sustainable development in the short term should be to position sustainable
consumption as an ongoing political project (Dolan, 2002). The public needs to be exposed to
and engaged by the political nature of the sustainability debate and consumerism in this way.
Individuals need to be encouraged to respond to their personal politics and feel empowered to
initiate related action. As campaigning is arguably a method of dictating action that captures an
obligatory response. Allowing individuals to test and trial alternative fashion consumption
practices encourages them to make an informed decision about the validity of integrating the
practice into their lifestyles. If an individual decides to adopt a particular sustainable behaviour,
they will do so because it aligns with their values and fits within their lifestyle.
5.2.3 Re-evaluating ownership
According to a recent survey conducted by Cotton Incorporated, approximately 35% of women
clean out their closets and 27% do it twice a year. Rather than throwing out inactive garments or
giving them away, they are simply organizing and consolidating them in order to make room for
new garments to come. Garments are hoarded because they are imbued with the potential to
become useful. Organizing a clothing exchange that is designed to be a catalyst for editing the
fashion waste from wardrobes is a way of re-evaluating ownership of one’s wardrobe. This
process aims to extract surplus clothing while affirming the lasting value of garments kept.
Swapping inactive fashion waste for a new, active wardrobe reduces the need for new clothing
consumption. The aim of sharing goods is to increase the intensity of their use while reducing the
material intensity (Mont, 2004).
5.2.4 Government Policies
The Kenyan government should implement policies that govern the importation from second
hand clothing. In as much it are getting little revenue from it, they should keep in mind about the
local fashion industry that will generate more revenue and boost the Economy just as in the UK
where the fashion industry is the 2nd most earning industry. Second hand clothing will also end
up in our dumping sites e.g. Dandora
Page 52
52
5.2.5 Re-opening of closed cotton mills
The government should re-open the cotton mills in Kenya that were shut down. They created
massive job opportunities for so many Kenyans like cotton farmers, cotton pickers, and cotton
workers to work in the mills and factories, managers, engineers, technologies and so forth.
Kenya was among the leading exporters in Africa for quality cotton, reviving the factories will
boost up the economy. Kenya will then have fewer importation of cheap Asian fabric and
designers will use cotton produced in Kenya hence having Kenyans to purchase their designs
because of the reduced importation of fabric that increases cost of design. Reduction of
importation also means fewer carbon prints.
5.2.6 Swapping/exchanging clothes
The clothing exchange is an ideal transitionary strategy between wasteful consumption and a
sustainable future. It revitalizes the familiar practice of sharing with the new values and ideas of
the sustainability movement. This form of gentle activism empowers the individual because they
test the experience for themselves and make an informed decision about whether to include it in
their lives. As they become acquainted with the practice of sharing clothing, it is anticipated that
they may apply this to other areas of consumption within their life, thus taking a larger stride
towards sustainability
5.2.7 Up-cycling Fashion
This is a way of giving old garments a new look. Instead of going to buy new clothes or just
clothes, people can give a new twist to their old garments, which elongates their cycle buying it
some time for its place in your closet. Taking it to a tailor or a designer benefits all parties
involved, however the designer will have a whole different approach that will make the garment
unique, trendy fashionable according to the client’s needs. Holding events such as “wardrobe
surgery” by junky styling also gives a whole new aspect of up-cycling. Wardrobe surgery is
about inviting people to come with their old garments and showing those different ways and
techniques to up-cycle them. This engages the audience, the more involving they are the more
they get to know about up-cycling and ways of sustainable fashion consumption.
Page 53
53
5.3 CONCLUSION
The research clearly shows how fast fashion has had an impact on the global scene as fast
fashion brand keeps producing more and more cheaper clothes on the western world that
encourages consumerism. This has taken a tall on the environment by letting the fashion waste
pile up at landfills all over the world because they are few designers and organization practicing
sustainability and sustainable consumption. It is however evident that in order to practice
sustainable consumption the fashion waste from the west is being shipped to developing
countries like Kenya as second hand clothing which only minimizes the problem at small
percentage. In as much second hand clothing has provided a cheaper option and job employment
for the poverty stricken, the local fashion industry in Kenya has a slow growth rate due to the
public relying so much on second hand clothing and not giving a chance to the local design
industry. Promoting Kenyan designers is promoting Kenya’s Economy and thus putting Kenya’s
Fashion Industry on the map. This will also create job opportunities for the unemployed youth in
Kenya.
By the end of the project what I hope to achieve is shedding light to the second hand
consumption in Kenya, Nairobi to be specific. Hoping to enlighten and educate the public on
sustainable fashion consumption by using this second hand garments to create a collection that
reflects sustainable fashion that will give insight on how to up-cycle clothes using the philosophy
of fashion deconstruction as stated in this paper. As an up-coming designer it is our duty to come
up with new ways and designs that practice sustainability creatively and getting the public to be
more involved with the movement of eco-fashion. We are the future of sustainable fashion
consumption. It’s our duty to create a safer environment for ourselves and future generations to
come
Page 54
54
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
Allwood, Julian M; Laursen, Søren Ellebaek; Malvido de Rodríguez, Cecilia; Bocken, Nancy M.
P. (2006). Well Dressed? The present and future sustainability of clothing and textiles in the
United Kingdom. Cambridge: University of Cambridge Institute for Manufacturing.
Barthes, R. (1985), The Fashion System, London, Farrar, Straus and Giroux Inc.
Bourdieu, P. (1979). Distinction; A social critique of the judgment of taste. London, Routledge.
Braungart, W. M. D. M. (2002). Cradle to cradle; re-making the way we make things. New York,
North Point Press.
Cachon, G. P., R. Swinney. 2009. Purchasing, pricing, and quick response in the presence of
strategic consumers. Management Sci. 55(3) 497–511.
Caro, F., J. Gallien. 2010. Inventory management of a fast-fashion retail network. Oper. Res.
58(2) 257–273.
Caro, F., V. Martínez-de-Albéniz. 2010. The impact of quick response in inventory-based
competition. Manufacturing Service Oper. Management 12(3) 409–429.
Claudio, L 2007, „Waste couture: environmental impact of the clothing industry‟,
Environmental Health Perspectives, vol. 115, no. 9, pp. A448 - A454, (JSTOR database).
Coase, R. H. 1972. Durability and monopoly. J. Law Econom. 15(1) 143–149.
DEFRA (2009). Maximising Reuse and Recycling of UK Clothing and Textiles EV0421.
Technical Report. Final report for Defra. Oakdene Hollins.
Eppen, G. D., A. V. Iyer. 1997. Improved fashion buying with Bayesian updating. Oper. Res.
45(6) 805–819.
Page 55
55
Farrer, Joan, & Fraser, Kim (2011). Sustainable vs unsustainable.
Fletcher, Kate (2008). Sustainable Fashion and Textiles: Design Journeys. London: Earthscan
Publications
Feitzinger, E., H. Lee. 1997. Mass customization at Hewlett-Packard:
The power of postponement. Harvard Bus. Rev. 75(1) 116–121.
Gupta M C 1995, Environment Management and its impact on the Operations Function,
International Journal of Operations and Production Management 15 (8), pp 34-51.
Gwilt, Alison, & Rissanen, Timo (2011). Shaping Sustainable Fashion: Changing the Way We
Make and Use Clothes. London: Earthscan Publications.
Hansen, K.T. (1994) Dealing with Used Clothing: Salaula and the Construction of Identity in
Zambia’s Third Republic. Public Culture. Vol. 6, pp. 503-523
Hansen, K.T. (1995) Transnational Biographies and Local Meanings: Used Clothing Practices in
Lusaka. Journal of Southern African Studies. Vol.21, No. 1, pp. 131-145
Hansen, K.T. (1999) Second-Hand Clothing Encounters in Zambia. London, The University of
Chicago Press Ltd.
Hansen, K.T. (2000) Salaula: The World of Secondhand Clothing and Zambia. London, The
University of Chicago Press Ltd.
Hawley, JM 2006, „Textile recycling: a system perspective‟ in Y Wang (ed), Recycling of
Textiles, pp.7-24, Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge.
Hawley, JM 2008, „Economic impact of textile recycling', in J Hethron & C Ulasewicz
(eds), pp. 207-232, Sustainable Fashion: Why now? A conversation exploring issues,
practices, and possibilities, Fairchild books Inc, New York.
Page 56
56
Heath, J. P., Andrew (2005). The Rebel Sell; How the counterculture became consumer
culture. Sussex, Capstone Publishing.
Horrocks, A.R. (1996) Recycling Textile and Plastic Waste. Woodhead Publishing Ltd.
McDonough, William, & Braungart, Michael (2002). Cradle to cradle: Remaking the Way We
Make Things. New York: North Point Press.
Johns J, F. T. (2004). SourceAid. Retrieved 02 02, 2012, from http://www.SourceAid.com
Kirkland, R. (1997). http://kirkland.myweb.uga.edu/rk/pdf/guides/WRITING.97.pdf. Retrieved 02
02, 2012, from www. http://kirkland.myweb.uga.edu/rk/pdf/guides/WRITING.97.pdf:
http://kirkland.myweb.uga.edu
Mugenda, O. M. Research Methods: Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches.
Mugenda, O. M. (1999). Research Methods: Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches. Nairobi-
Kenya: Acts Press.
Pecorari, D. (2003). Good and original: Plagiarism and patchwriting in academic second-
language writing. Journal of Second Language Writing , Pages 317–345.
Swales, C., & Feak, J. (March 2005 — Volume 8, Number 4). Academic Writing for Graduate
Students: Essential tasks and skills, Second Edition. The Electronic Journal for English as a
Second Language .
University, T. O. (2009, April 27). types of assingment. Retrieved February 02, 2012, from
http://www.open.ac.uk
JOURNALS AND PUBLICATIONS
Allison Gill article on Deconstruction Fashion
Centre for Sustainable Design – Fashioning the Future 2008
Dolan, P. (2002). The sustainability of sustainable consumption. Journal of Macromarketing
22.No 2 (December 2002): 170-81.
Page 57
57
Food And Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and International Cotton
Advisory Committee, 2011, World Apparel Fiber Consumption Survey 2005-2008.
Jones, D. (2005), In with the old; A sentimental journey, Russh Magazine, Australia, Russh
Magazine and Publications Pty. Ltd. 2005, Issue 4, pp 157-9
Katkar, PM & Bairgadar, SM 2010, Textile waste recycling, Textile Review, pub,
place.http://www.bespokecollections.com/Resources/Textile%20waste%20recycling.pdf
Kenya (1999) National Micro and Small Enterprises Baseline Survey. Central Bureau of
Statistics, International Centre for Economic Growth, and K-Rep Holding Ltd. Government
Printer: Nairobi
Kenya (2000) Second Report on Poverty in Kenya. Volume 1. Ministry of Finance and
Planning. Government Printer: Nairobi
Kirkland, R. (1997). http://kirkland.myweb.uga.edu/rk/pdf/guides/WRITING.97.pdf. Retrieved 02
02, 2012, from www. http://kirkland.myweb.uga.edu/rk/pdf/guides/WRITING.97.pdf:
http://kirkland.myweb.uga.edu
Ouvertes Project, 2005, „Status of the Industry in Europe‟, Textile Reuse and Recycling
Players, viewed 4 March 2011, http://www.textilerecycling. org.uk/ Report_Ouvertes
ProjectJune2005%5B1 % 5D.pdf
Philosophy of Fashion article by Authur Windermere
Reet Aus TRASH TO TREND USING UPCYCLING IN FASHION DESIGN Tallin 2011
Textile Recycling Fact Sheet, Secondary Materials and Recycled Textiles Association
(Bethesda, MD), Council for Textile Recycling, viewed 14 November 2008,
http://www.textilecycle.org
The Fiber Year 2011, Oerlikon Textile Report for Akzo, The Fiber Year GmbH,
Switzerland, viewed 1 May 2011 http://www.oerlikontextile.com/desktopdefault.
Page 58
58
aspx/tabid-1763/
Otunga, R.N., Opata, G and Muyia, F.N. (1998) Socio-Economic Background and Informal
Sector: Business Performance of Women Entrepreneurism Eldoret. Working Paper No. 529,
Institute for Development Studies, University of Nairobi: Kenya
Xaba, J., Horn. P., and Motala, S. (2002) The Informal Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa.
Unpublished Working Paper on the Informal Economy. ILO, Employment Sector: Geneva.
WEBSITES
AGOA, 2004, “Apparel Trade Under AGOA” http://www.agoa. info/index.php?
view=trade_stats&story=apparel_trade&valuation=sme
Export Processing Zones Authority, 2005, Kenya’s Apparel and Textile Industry 2005
http://www.epzakenya.com/news.php?type=press&itemno=45
http://www.divinecaroline.com/37/114456-ready-to-waste-ugly-side-fast-
fashion#ixzz2JZ1f54Qe
http://ezradaniel.me/2012/04/05/deconstruction-fashion-anti-fashion/
Page 59
59
APPENDIX I
QUESTIONNAIRE
The researcher is a 4th year Bachelor of Arts in Design student at the School of Art and Design,
University of Nairobi, seeking to study “Up-cycled Fashionable Clothing From Materials
Sourced From Nairobi Flea Markets For Young Women” . Kindly assist by filling in the
questionnaire. The report will strictly by for scholarly purposes only.
Name:
Age group
[ ] 18-22 [ ] 22-26 [ ] 26-30
Do you consider yourself fashionable
[ ] Yes [ ] No
Do you follow trends
[ ] Yes [ ] No
Where do you shop?
[ ] Flea Markets e.g. Gikomb a [ ] Department Stores e.g. Woolworths, Mr. Price
[ ] Stalls e.g. Jamia Mall [ ] Thrift shops e.g. Closet 49 [ ] Online
How often do you shop in a month
Page 60
60
[ ] Once [ ] 2-4 times [ ] 5-10 times [ ] Over 10times
How much do you spend on shopping in a month
[ ] 500-1000 [ ] 1000-2000 [ ] 2000-5000 [ ] Over 500
What is the frequently bought item in your wardrobe
[ ] blouse/t-shirts/vests [ ] pants/shorts [ ] dresses/skirts [ ] coats/sweaters
Are you aware of sustainable fashion?
[ ] Yes [ ] No
Have you practiced sustainable fashion?
[ ] Yes [ ] No
What do you do with old, unwanted clothes?
[ ] donate [ ] burn [ ] throw away [ ] resell [ ] up-cycle
Do you know about Up-Cycle Fashion?
[ ] Yes [ ] No
Are you willing to try out Up-Cycle Fashion
[ ] Yes [ ] No
Thank you for taking your time to fill in the questionnaire.
APPENDIX II
INTERVIEW GUIDE
The researcher is a 4th year Bachelor of Arts in Design student at the School of Art and Design,
University of Nairobi, seeking to study “Up-cycled Fashionable Clothing From Materials
Sourced From Nairobi Flea Markets For Young Women” . Kindly assist by filling in the
interview guide. The report will strictly by for scholarly purposes only.
Company Name:
What is the idea behind your company?
Where do you source your clothes?
Page 61
61
Which age bracket do you sell to?
What do you do with the items that are not purchased?
A short brief on the sustainable fashion talk that you hosted at Sarakasi Dome.
How did you come up with the idea?
Where did you sort consultations?
Did you achieve what you set out to accomplish?
Will you hold other talks and conferences in the future about
sustainability?
Would you partner up with a designer who practices sustainable fashion?
A short brief on the event you held for people to swap clothes.
Page 62
62
Your say about Kenya’s Fashion Industry
Comment about Nairobi street style, the good or the bad
Thank you for taking your time for the interview