UPC2 Trinity Grammar School Heritage Assessment ...

Urban Planning Special Committee Agenda 21/08/17

UPC2 Trinity Grammar School Heritage Assessment - Preliminary consultation outcomes and request for authorisation

Abstract Council’s heritage consultant, Context Pty Ltd (Context), recently completed an assessment of the heritage significance of buildings within the Trinity Grammar School campus at 40 and 41 Charles Street, Kew. The heritage assessment was prompted by a referral from Council’s Statutory Planning Department following the lodgement of a new Development Plan for the School campus. Context identified the following three buildings as individually significant heritage places and recommended them for inclusion in the Heritage Overlay: Henty House (Roxeth)

Merritt House (Molina)

Roberts House (Elsinore) The draft heritage citation recommended that the buildings be protected in the Heritage Overlay within a defined curtilage to ensure that views to the buildings are protected. Context also recommended tree controls for five trees which contribute to the significance of Roberts House. Preliminary consultation on the draft heritage citation was undertaken from 5 June to 30 June 2017. Two (2) submissions were received in response to the assessment, comprising one supporting submission and one partially supporting submission. A summary of the feedback received and officers’ responses to the issues raised is provided in Attachment 1. In response to the feedback received during preliminary consultation, Council’s heritage consultant conducted a further site inspection. Context concluded that the extent of alterations to Merritt House have compromised the building’s heritage significance. As such, Merritt House is no longer recommended for inclusion in the Heritage Overlay. Additionally, the curtilage recommended to the south (side) facade of Roberts House has also been revised from 6m to 5m. The draft heritage citation has been updated accordingly, as provided in Attachment 2. A map of all three buildings originally proposed for the Heritage Overlay can be viewed at Attachment 3. Following preliminary consultation, officers recommend that the Urban Planning Special Committee (UPSC) resolve to: Adopt the updated citation as shown in Attachment 2.

Commence a planning scheme amendment to apply the Heritage Overlay to Henty House and Roberts House, as per the citation in Attachment 2.

City of Boroondara Trinity Grammar School Page 1 of 58


Officers' recommendation That the Urban Planning Special Committee resolve to: 1. Receive and note the feedback received and outcomes of the preliminary

consultation process undertaken on the draft Trinity Grammar School heritage citation.

2. Endorse the officers’ response to the preliminary feedback received and

recommended changes to the draft Trinity Grammar School heritage citation outlined in Attachment 1.

3. Adopt the revised Trinity Grammar School heritage citation contained in

Attachment 2. 4. Write to the Minister for Planning to request authorisation to prepare an

amendment to the Boroondara Planning Scheme in accordance with Section 4B and 8A(4) of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 to include buildings identified in the Trinity Grammar School heritage citation in the Heritage Overlay.

5. Following receipt of authorisation from the Minister for Planning, exhibit the

amendment in accordance with Section 19 of the Planning and Environment Act 1987.

6. Write to the Minister for Planning to request that he prepare, adopt and

approve an amendment to the Boroondara Planning Scheme under Section 20(4) of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 to introduce interim heritage controls to the buildings recommended for inclusion in the Heritage Overlay in the Trinity Grammar School heritage citation.

7. Notwithstanding resolution 6, authorise officers to modify the amendment to

remove properties which have been legally demolished prior to exhibition of the amendment.

8. Authorise the Director City Planning to undertake administrative changes to

the amendment that do not change the intent of the amendment or any changes required under the Minister for Planning’s Authorisation prior to the commencement of exhibition.

Document information



Responsible director: Shiran Wickramasinghe

City Planning ___________________________________________________________________ 1. Purpose

The purpose of this report is to:

Advise the Urban Planning Special Committee (UPSC) of the outcomes of the heritage assessment for Trinity Grammar School.

Provide a summary of the outcomes of preliminary consultation on the draft heritage citation for Trinity Grammar School and officers’ response to the key issues raised, as shown in Attachment 1.

Seek a resolution from the UPSC to request that the Minister for Planning authorise Council to prepare and exhibit Amendment C271 to the Boroondara Planning Scheme to implement the Trinity Grammar School heritage citation, as shown in Attachment 2.

2. Policy implications and relevance to council plan

Council Plan 2013-2017 The assessment, protection and consultation on places of possible heritage significance implements Council's commitment to 'engage with our community in striving for protection and enhancement of the natural and built environment' in order to achieve the objective ‘the character of our neighbourhoods is protected and improved’. (Theme 3, Strategy 10) Public Health and Wellbeing Plan 2013-17 The assessment and protection of places of heritage significance implements Strategic Objective 2 of the Municipal Public Health and Wellbeing Plan 2013-17, to ‘enhance and develop our neighbourhoods to support health and wellbeing’ by including places of heritage significance in the Heritage Overlay. In particular, the inclusion of places of local heritage significance in a Heritage Overlay implements Strategy 2.2 to ‘support practices that assist Council and the community to maintain and enhance our natural environment for future generations’. Heritage Action Plan 2016 The Heritage Action Plan was adopted by Council on 2 May 2016. The Heritage Action Plan establishes the framework to guide Council’s heritage work program as it relates to the identification, protection, management and promotion of Boroondara’s heritage assets. The assessment and protection of places of heritage significance is an ongoing action in the Heritage Action Plan.



Boroondara Planning Scheme The assessment and protection of places of heritage significance is consistent with the objectives of the State Planning Policy Framework (SPPF) and Local Planning Policy Framework (LPPF). In particular, it addresses the following Clauses: Clause 15.03-1 Heritage Conservation which seeks to ‘ensure the

conservation of places of heritage significance’ by identifying, retaining and protecting places with identified heritage significance; and

Clause 21.05 Heritage, Landscapes and Urban Character of the Municipal Strategic Statement which includes the objective ‘to identify and protect all individual places, objects and precincts of cultural heritage, aboriginal, townscape and landscape significance’.

Both the SPPF and LPPF seek to ensure the Heritage Overlay is applied to protect places of heritage significance in the City of Boroondara. Plan Melbourne 2017-2050 The identification, assessment and protection of places of local heritage significance are supported by Outcome 4 of Plan Melbourne which seeks to ensure that ‘Melbourne is a distinctive and liveable city with quality design and amenity’. Direction 4.4 recognises the contribution heritage makes to Melbourne’s distinctiveness and liveability and advocates for the protection of Melbourne’s heritage places. In particular, Policy 4.4.1 recognises the need for ‘continuous identification and review of currently unprotected heritage sites and targeted assessments of heritage sites in areas identified as likely to be subject to substantial change’. The assessment and protection of places of local heritage significance is consistent with these Plan Melbourne directions and initiatives. Planning and Environment Act 1987 The inclusion of places of heritage significance in a Heritage Overlay is consistent with the objectives of planning in Victoria, in particular the objective detailed in Section 4(1) d of the Planning and Environment Act 1987, being: ‘To conserve and enhance those buildings, areas or other places which are of scientific, aesthetic, architectural or historical interest, or otherwise of special cultural value.’ This means that Council has a statutory obligation to continuously identify and protect places of heritage significance through the Heritage Overlay.

3. Background

In August 2016, Trinity Grammar School made an application to Council to approve a new Development Plan for the School (DP16/002). The new Development Plan will provide guidance on the future built form and land use outcomes for the School campus over the next 10 to 15 years.



Following an internal referral from Council’s Statutory Planning Department, the Strategic Planning Department engaged its heritage consultant, Context Pty Ltd (Context), to review the heritage significance of buildings within the Trinity Grammar School campus at 40 and 41 Charles Street, Kew. Heritage assessment Context identified Henty House, Merritt House and Roberts House as individually significant heritage places and recommended their inclusion in a Heritage Overlay within defined curtilages. Context also recommended tree controls for five trees which contribute to the significance of Roberts House. Henty House, Merritt House and Roberts House are nineteenth-century buildings that were incorporated into the Trinity Grammar School campus in the early twentieth century. Henty House, built in 1856, is one of a small number of early Gothic Revival houses to survive in Boroondara. The draft heritage citation proposed curtilages to the Charles Street frontage (west), 3m from the rear facade (north), 5m from the side facade (east) and 10m from the front facade (south). A photo of Henty House can be seen on page 25 of the heritage citation at Attachment 2. Merritt House, built in 1872-73, is a purpose built school building originally constructed for Kew High School. It is a representative example of an austere application of the Italianate architectural style. The draft heritage citation proposed curtilages of 7m from the side facade (west), 3m from the rear facade (north), 10m from the side facade facing Charles Street (east) and 10m from the front facade (south). Photos of Merritt House can be seen on pages 28 and 29 of the heritage citation at Attachment 2. Roberts House, built in 1875, is an Italianate mansion. It retains five mature trees in the front garden, which are contributory to the building’s significance. The draft heritage citation proposed curtilages to the Stanley Street frontage (west), Wellington Street frontage (north), 4m from the rear facade (east) and 6m from the side facade (south). A photo of Roberts House can be seen on page 26 and a map locating the contributory trees can be seen on page 27 of the heritage citation at Attachment 2. A map of all three buildings originally proposed for the Heritage Overlay can be viewed at Attachment 3. Preliminary consultation Officers carried out preliminary consultation on the draft Trinity Grammar School heritage citation between 5 June and 30 June 2017. Two (2) submissions were received; one supporting submission and one partially supporting submission. A summary of the feedback received and officers’ responses to the issues raised during preliminary consultation is provided in Attachment 1 and discussed further below.



4. Outline of key issues/options

Submissions One supporting submission was received in relation to the draft Trinity Grammar School heritage citation. This submission supported the protection of the buildings from demolition and their inclusion in a Heritage Overlay. The second submission received was lodged by Trinity Grammar School and provided partial support for the draft heritage citation. The School provided support for the inclusion of Henty House and Roberts House (including the tree controls) in the Heritage Overlay. However, the School objected to the proposed curtilages for the two buildings. The School contended that the Heritage Overlay should be reduced to align with the building footprints. The School argued that the Development Plan will provide sufficient certainty regarding built form outcomes and that the proposed curtilages are unnecessary and include surrounding non-contributory buildings. Additionally, the School objected to the inclusion of Merritt House in the Heritage Overlay. The School argued that the building has undergone extensive modifications and is not worthy of inclusion in a Heritage Overly. Following a review of this submission, Context conducted a further site inspection. Based on the site inspection, Context concluded that Merritt House is too altered and does not meet the threshold for individual significance. As such, the building does not warrant protection under a Heritage Overlay. Context also concluded that the curtilage to the south of Roberts House could be reduced from 6m to 5m. The reduced curtilage aligns with the proposed footprint of the Junior School, which is shown with a 5m setback from Roberts House in the new Development Plan. No other changes are recommended for the curtilages for Henty House and Roberts House. These curtilages are required to ensure that views to the buildings are protected and the building’s heritage significance is considered when assessing any new development within proximity of the buildings. However, Context recommended that the citation be updated to clarify that portions of non-contributory buildings are within the proposed curtilages and that these buildings do not contribute to the heritage significance of Henty House or Roberts House. This will allow future planning permits to be easily approved where the demolition or alteration of non-contributory fabric is proposed. The Trinity Grammar School heritage citation has been updated accordingly, as shown in Attachment 2. Development Plan The Statutory Planning Department’s assessment of the new Development Plan has taken into consideration the recommendations of the draft Trinity Grammar School heritage citation.



At this stage the proposed Heritage Overlay carries limited weight in the planning permit application assessment process. However, additional consideration has been given to the potential heritage controls, as the Development Plan is a strategic document that envisages the future development of the School over the next 10 to 15 years. The Statutory Planning Department’s recommendation is that the Development Plan be approved subject to conditions. This includes conditions relating to improved built form outcomes for Henty House, Merritt House and Roberts House. Heritage Overlay The Heritage Overlay is the most appropriate planning control in this instance, as it allows Council to identify and protect heritage places of local significance. The Development Plan Overlay (Schedule 2) (DPO2) is not a sufficient planning control for the ongoing management of heritage places. The DPO2 is designed to manage the future development and land use of institutions. Unlike the Heritage Overlay, it does not specifically require the permit applicant or Council to have regard to the heritage significance of a place. In terms of the application of the Heritage Overlay, the use of specific curtilage distances is an established approach, particularly when it is not appropriate to apply the Heritage Overlay to the title boundaries of a property. The Planning Practice Note ‘Applying the Heritage Overlay’ (2012) acknowledges this and states that: ‘In addition to capturing the elements that are significant, it is almost always necessary to include some surrounding land (a “curtilage”) in order to: Retain the setting or context of the significant building, structure, tree or

feature. Regulate development (including subdivision) in close proximity to the

significant building, tree or feature. The recommended Heritage Overlay curtilages for Henty House and Roberts House are required to achieve these outcomes and maintain the heritage significance of the buildings. If a Heritage Overlay is applied as recommended, a planning permit will be required for demolition, alterations and additions and any new buildings. This will require assessment against Clause 22.05 (Heritage Policy) and the Heritage Overlay. Additionally, it is recommended that interim heritage controls are sought from the Minister for Planning to protect the buildings from demolition, whilst Council undertakes the planning scheme amendment to apply the Heritage Overlay on a permanent basis. Recommendation Given the above, officers recommend that the UPSC resolve to: Adopt the updated citation as shown in Attachment 2. Commence a planning scheme amendment to apply the Heritage Overlay

to Henty House and Roberts House, as per the citation in Attachment 2. Seek interim heritage controls for Henty House and Roberts House.



5. Consultation/communication

Officers carried out preliminary consultation on the draft Trinity Grammar School heritage citation between 5 June and 30 June 2017. Affected and surrounding land owners and occupiers were notified by letter at the start of the consultation period. The draft citation was also made available on Council’s website. All parties notified as part of preliminary consultation, and any additional parties who have lodged submissions, have been notified of this UPSC meeting and their opportunity to address the UPSC on the night. If the UPSC resolves to proceed with a planning scheme amendment to implement the recommendations of the Trinity Grammar School heritage citation, further opportunities for consultation will be provided through the exhibition process, as required by Section 19 of the Planning and Environment Act 1987. The outcomes of the exhibition process will also be reported to a future UPSC meeting.

6. Financial and resource implications

The Trinity Grammar School heritage assessment has been funded by the Strategic Planning Department’s operating budget in retaining ongoing heritage consultancy services with Context Pty Ltd. All costs associated with Amendment C271 will continue to be met by the Strategic Planning Department’s operating budget for 2017/18.

7. Governance issues

The officers responsible for this report have no direct or indirect interests requiring disclosure. The implications of this report have been assessed and are not considered likely to breach or infringe upon, the human rights contained in the Victorian Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006.

8. Social and environmental issues

The inclusion of individually significant buildings in the Heritage Overlay will have positive social and environmental effects by contributing to the protection and management of heritage places within the municipality.

Manager: Zoran Jovanovski, Strategic Planning Report officer: Claire Scarlett, Strategic Planner, Strategic Planning


Summary of submissions and officers’ response

Submission No.

Is proposal supported?

Summary of submission Officers’ response to submissionOfficers’recommendation

1 Yes Supports heritage protection of the buildings.

A building permit should be required to protectthe heritage of the area and the School’shistory.

Officers note the comments made in the submission.

If a Heritage Overlay is introduced to the buildings as proposed, a planning permit will be required for demolition and external buildings and works.

No changes recommended. Proceed with amendment.

2 Partly Supports inclusion of Henty House and RobertsHouse in the Heritage Overlay. Also supportstree controls for five trees within the frontage ofRoberts House.

Objects to the curtilages for Henty House andRoberts House. Contends that the extent of theHeritage Overlay should be reduced tosignificant building footprints only.

The curtilages include existing buildings thathave no heritage value. This will create non-essential planning applications.

The Development Plan (DP) provides sufficientcertainty for the built form outcomessurrounding Henty House and Roberts House.The DP includes design features to ensure thatnew development does not detract from theheritage significance of the buildings, assupported by Council’s Statutory Planningheritage advisor.

Objects to the inclusion of Merritt House in theHeritage Overlay as it has undergone extensivedemolition and alterations and does not warrantheritage protection.

Council’s heritage consultant, Context Pty Ltd (Context), has reviewed the submission and conducted a further site inspection.

The following comments are provided:

Merritt House

Based on the site inspection, the building’s level of intactness is less than previously thought. In particular, the opening of the ground floor south wall and entire west wall - hidden in the sports centre - was not known at the time of assessment.

The extent of demolition and alterations has compromised the building’s heritage significance to the point that it falls below the threshold of local significance. Therefore, Merritt House is no longer considered to warrant inclusion in a Heritage Overlay.

Curtilages - Henty House and Roberts House

The VPP Practice Note ‘Applying the Heritage Overlay’ (2012) acknowledges that there may be instances where it is not appropriate to apply theHeritage Overlay to the title boundaries of a property. In these instances, the Practice Note states that curtilages should be provided to: retain the setting or context of the significant building, structure, tree or feature, [and] regulate development (including subdivision) in close proximity to the significant building, tree or feature.

Amend the Trinity Grammar School heritage citation, as shown in Attachment 2, to:

Remove Merritt HouseReduce curtilage to thesouth side of RobertsHouse from 6m to 5mClarify that areas ofnon-contributorybuildings are includedin curtilages.

Proceed with amendment to include Henty House and Roberts House in a Heritage Overlay.

1

Attachment 1

Urban Planning Special Committee Agenda 21/08/17______________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________City of Boroondara Trinity Grammar School Page 9 of 58

Summary of submissions and officers’ response

Curtilages for Henty House and Roberts House are required to achieve these outcomes. The proposed curtilages will ensure that any new development within proximity of the buildings will be assessed with regard to the building’s heritage value and potential impacts on the building’s heritage significance. This cannot be achieved if the Heritage Overlay is applied to the significant building footprints only.

However, Context agrees that the curtilage to the south of Roberts House can be reduced from 6m to 5m. This aligns with the proposed footprint of the Junior School, which is shown with a 5m setback from Roberts House in the new DP.

No other changes are to the other curtilages for Henty House and Roberts House are supported.

Only through inclusion of the buildings and the curtilage areas in a Heritage Overlay will there be a statutory requirement for the consideration of the heritage significance of the buildings and the requirements Clause 22.05 (Heritage Policy). Hence, a Development Plan Overlay alone is not sufficient to protect the heritage significance of Henty House and Roberts House.

However, the citation has been updated to note that portions of non-contributory buildings arelocated within the curtilages and that these buildings do not contribute to the heritage significance of Henty House or Roberts House.

2



TRINITY GRAMMAR SCHOOL

Prepared by: Context Pty Ltd

Address: 40 & 41 Charles Street, Kew

Name: Trinity Grammar School Survey Date: 19 January 2017

Place Type: Community Architect: A. Purchas (Merritt House)

Grading: Significant Builder:

Extent of Overlay: See extent map, below Construction Date: Henty House -1856 & 1863; Merritt House - 1873; Roberts House - 1875

Historical ContextKewTwohree former Kew mansions comprise the heritage place. Jane Carolan summarises the development of Kew’s mansions and villas in her book, For the green and the gold and the mitre: a centenary history of Trinity Grammar School, Kew:

The first residential houses were built in Kew during the 1850s around the area now known as the Kew Junction. Speculation on land purchases increased during the gold rush period, promoting the region's rapid expansion not only as a farming area but as a residential location, a trading place and a stopover for travellers. By 1902 Kew had more than 8,000 residents and 1,500 dwellings. The charm of Kew was its undulating character and the windings of the Yarra River, which formed its northern and western boundaries, and the extensive views it enjoyed in almost every direction…Kew was a suburb of British expatriates who built their homes and gardens to replicate those left behind. Many of the villas and mansions commanding views back over the city were

1

Attachment 2



set in acres of land. Some were named after the birthplace of their owners, such as Henry Henty's ‘Tarring’ named after the village in Sussex where he was born, and Dr Herbert Cowen’s ‘Thornhurst’ after his family home on the Isle of Man and in Bendigo. Manufacturing in Kew was limited to one boot factory and one brick works. The more noxious and unsightly industries were located on the other side of the river in Collingwood. Businesses such as shops, hotels and banks were confined to a strip along High Street and in Cotham and Glenferrie roads (Carolan 2003b:3).

Anglican schools in AustraliaA Church of England (later Anglican Church) clergyman travelled with the First Fleet into Sydney Cove in 1788 as a licensed chaplain to the fleet and to the settlement. The first Church of England building was erected in the new colony in 1793 (AG 2008).

The Church of England was the largest religious denomination in Australia until 1986 when it was overtaken by the Catholic Church. In 1981, the Church of England formally adopted the title ‘Anglican Church of Australia’ (AG 2008).

Today, the Anglican Church of Australia is organised into 23 dioceses. The church has specialist units working in education, health, missionary work, social welfare and communications. Approximately 145 Anglican schools exist throughout Australia, providing education to more than 105,000 children (AG 2008).

Denominational colleges in BoroondaraThe following contextual history, about private education, is cited from the City of Boroondara Thematic Environmental History (Built Heritage, 2012):

[The City of Boroondara] (and notably its eastern half) has become strongly associated with larger church-based colleges that were intended to serve larger catchments across the eastern suburbs, or even the entire metropolitan area. The earliest of these was Xavier College at Kew, which was founded in 1872 by a group of Jesuit priests whose original school, St Patrick's in East Melbourne, was not suitable for boarders. … A decade later, another Roman Catholic order based in the inner city, the Faithful Companions of Jesus, followed the Jesuit lead and proposed to open a private girls' school at Kew. Known as Genazzano College, this developed on a 20-acre site at the corner of Cotham Road and Mont Victor Road, where the foundation stone for a combined convent and school building was laid on 9 March 1890.

The first protestant counterpart was the Methodist Ladies College, also in Kew, which was established on its present site in Barkers Road in 1882. As Vaughan records, this subsequently expanded (through a series of generous bequests by people such as Alfred Nicholas) to the point that it was, at one time, believed to be the largest denominational girls' school in the world. A close rival for that title – later to be described as ‘one of the large girls' schools in the metropolis’ – [was] Fintona Presbyterian Girls' Grammar School. Founded in 1896 by Miss Annie Hughston and her brother, William, this school was originally based in a mansion in Mayston Street, Hawthorn, before moving in 1898 to larger premises at the corner of Burke and Victoria roads, and thence, in 1936, to a larger site at Balwyn, where it remains today.

More modest in scale (at least initially) was the school founded by the local Anglican congregation, Holy Trinity, which commenced in 1903 in the church’s own Parish Hall. Three years later, Trinity Grammar School (as it was known) transferred to a large Victorian mansion, ‘Roxeth’ in Charles Street, Kew, which expanded in 1907 with additional classrooms and a hall. A notable addition to the growing number of denominational colleges in the study area – and one of the first established outside the apparent epicentre of the City of Kew – was Scotch College, a Presbyterian school that opened at Hawthorn in 1916. …

2



The inter-war period saw the ongoing expansion of existing denominational colleges, as well as the appearance of new ones. … All of these denominational colleges have expanded over the decades to include buildings by noted architects. This trend has continued into the post-war period, with such examples Buick Hall at Fintona (John & Phyllis Murphy, 1951), the Assembly Hall (H A & F L Norris, 1957) and Resource Centre (Daryl Jackson, 1973) at MLC, and a string of award-winning buildings at Trinity Grammar School (Crone Ross, 1988-91, 1992 and 1993).

HistoryFoundation and development of Trinity Grammar SchoolTrinity Grammar School, Kew, was founded by members of the Holy Trinity parish on 14 November 1902. Their names were the Venerable Archdeacon Hindley, Vicar of Holy Trinity; the Rev. George Merrick Long, Curate of Holy Trinity; Dr EM Inglis; Dr HO Cowen; Dr W Kent Hughes; and WJ Roberts (Trumble 1987:1).

Trinity Grammar opened on 10 February 1903 as a preparatory school for boys aged between seven and 13 years (Trumble 1987:1). The school commenced operation in the parish hall of Holy Trinity Church with 23 boys enrolled. Edward Taffs was the first headmaster, with GM Long succeeding him in 1904 (TGSK 2017).

Pressure on accommodation increased during 1906, with enrolments reaching 88. The school council began looking for a new site that could accommodate classrooms, a headmaster's residence and playgrounds (Carolan 2003b:76).

Later in 1906, the school purchased a property, ‘Roxeth’ (now Henty House) on the corner of Wellington Street and Charles Street, Kew, a short distance to the south of the Holy Trinity Church. In the same year a new building designed by architect Cecil Gordon McCrae, comprising an assembly hall and two classrooms (named Arnold Hall in 1925), was erected by contractors Swanson Brothers of Melbourne on the new site, and ‘Roxeth’ was converted to a boarding house (Carolan 2003b:79-80,85; Age 9 June 1906:5). The Arnold Hall classroom block, the first Trinity Grammar purpose-built building (see Figure 1), opened in 1907, the year the school moved to the new site. In the same year, Trinity was registered as a public school of the Church of England (TGSK 2017).

Figure 1. Arnold Hall of 1907 – the first purpose-built Trinity Grammar building. Demolished 2015. (Source: Google Streetview, August 2014)

In 1907, timber classrooms from Kew High School were transported to the Trinity Grammar School site for use as an open air gymnasium (Carolan 2003a:26; see Figure 2). In 1908From February 1909 the school leased ‘Molina’ (now Merritt House and previously part of Kew High School), a property in Charles Street. ‘Molina’ had been built

3



in 1872-73 to a design by architect Alfred Purchas, for the secular and private Kew High School. The building served as the headmaster’s residence and boarding accommodation (Trumble 1987:116-17). Kew High School had closed in 1908. In 1909, the school built a science laboratory, designed by architect Cecil Gordon McCrae, on the west side of Arnold Hall (TGSK 2017).

Figure 2. Kew High School with the Kew High School headmaster’s family, 1880s. (Source: Carolan 2003b:26)

Figure 3. View of ‘Molina’, c1890-91, at front. ‘Elsinore’ is visible to the left rear. (Source: KHS)

Formatted: Left

4



Figure 4. Vista of Trinity Grammar School, 1909 – from left to right: Henty House, kitchen, stables, timber open air gymnasium (made from classrooms relocated from Kew High School), science laboratory and Arnold Hall. (Source: Carolan 2003a: 26)

In 1911, GM Long left the school to become Bishop of Bathurst and the Reverend AW Tonge was appointed headmaster. A second classroom building was constructed in front of Arnold Hall in 1915, but has since been demolished. In 1917, Trinity appointed a new headmaster, Frank Shann, who led the school for the next 25 years. Under his tenure, the school grew to a total of 245 boys and other school buildings were erected, including the now demolished War Memorial Library, the junior school classroom building (also known as the Preparatory School, which survives in very altered form) and the ‘Health Pavilion’ – see Figure 4 (TGSK 2017).

In 1924 Shann launched a campaign that he called his `Forward Movement', an ambitious plan designed to expand, develop and reinvigorate the school's facilities Carolan 2003b:254). In 1924 the ‘Molina’ mansion was purchased by the school, as well as the neighbouring mansion, ‘Elsinore’ (see Figure 3). The properties were subsequently renamed in 1925 after men who had contributed significantly to Trinity’s development: ‘Molina’ became Merritt House, ‘Elsinore’ was named Roberts House and ‘Roxeth’ called Henty House, see Figure 4 and Figure 6 (TGSK 2017). At this timesubstantial renovations were made to Merritt House, including the additions of a new sleep out at the north-east corner (open to the elements on two sides), sanitary block and electric light – see Figure 5 (Age 16 December 1925:17). In 1926 a new Junior School was built on the north side of Merritt House, replacing the former Kew High School classrooms (TGSK 2017). Trinity Grammar School grounds from the air in 1928 are depicted in Figure 5.

5



Figure 5. Construction of Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’, rear sleep out, 1926. (Source: Carolan 2003a:153)

Figure 6. Detail from MMBW plan No. 65, 1902. Subject buildings are all shown: ‘Elsinore’ (now Roberts House), ‘Roxeth’ (now Henty House), and ‘Molina’ (now Merritt House). (Source: SLV)

6



Figure 7. Plan of extended school with houses renamed, 1925. Note that North is down. (Source: Carolan 2003b:261)

Figure 8. Showing Trinity Grammar School buildings and two sports grounds in the centre of the photo, 1928. Looking south-east. (Source: Carolan 2003a:301)

7



Figure 9. Pencil, pen and ink drawing of Victorian buildings that comprise Trinity Grammar School: Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’ (right), Roberts House, formerly ‘Elsinore’ (middle) and Henty House, formerly ‘Roxeth’ (left), c1978, by Joy Stewart. (Source: KHS)

Alfred Bright became headmaster upon Frank Shann's death in 1943 (TGSK 2017). The school added a second storey to the Junior School in 1952, and in 1953, the Parents' and Friends' Hall, a multipurpose venue, was built between Merritt House and Xavier College to the south. The Art Building was completed in 1956 and used as a Middle School (TGSK 2017).

On Alfred Bright's retirement, John Leppitt was appointed headmaster. During his time as headmaster, the number of students reached 812. The Robertson Science and Administration Building opened in 1959 and was extended in later years, and in 1961, in order to provide art and music facilities, the Junior School building was extended to almost meet Roberts House. The school population reached 812 in 1962. The Robertson Building was extended along Wellington Street in 1964. In 1968, the four-storey Shann Building was constructed between the Robertson Building and Arnold Hall, in addition to a major sports facility, Cornell Gymnasium (TGSK 2017).

In 1975, the boarding house, which had been run in Merritt House, closed. The War Memorial Library was demolished in 1976 to make way for the three-storey TongeBuilding and Roberts House was converted for Preparatory to Year Three classes in the same year. In 1979 John Leppitt retired and the new headmaster, Don Marles, continued the development of the school with the construction of a new swimming pool in 1980 and, in 1982, the renovation of the original science laboratories housed in the Shann Building, which were renamed the Bright Laboratories. Merritt House, the former boarding house, was converted into a music school in the same year (TGSK 2017).

In 1988 the administration building was redeveloped, and in 1989 another classroom was built, the now demolished Poynter Building. The tuckshop, the original canteen, was closed in 1990, and the cafeteria opened on the ground floor of the Shann Building. In 1991, the school built a dedicated chapel for weekly services. Don Marles retired the

8



same year, replaced by Peter Crawley (TGSK 2017). See Figure 7 for a comparison of Trinity Grammar School in 1992 with the school in the 1920s.

Figure 10. Trinity Grammar School in the 1920s, showing from left to right: Henty House, War Memorial Library (1921), Tonge’s open air gymnasium, Arnold Hall and the sixth-form block (1915); and the same view in 1992. (Source: Carolan 2003a: 27)

In 1999, Richard Tudor was appointed as headmaster and the co-educational Early Learning Centre was opened. In 2000, the school began the construction of the Science and Technology Building to replace the Bright Laboratories, opening in 2003, the year in which Trinity celebrated its centenary year. Enrolments at the school were over 1200 in 2002. In 2003, the school opened a new gymnasium, the Peter McIntyre Sports Centre, to complement the old Cornell Sports Gym (TGSK 2017).

In 2011, the Poynter Building and Technical Centre were demolished to make room for the Richard and Elizabeth Tudor Centre for Contemporary Learning (see Figure 8; TGSK 2017).

9



Figure 11. Plan of existing buildings at Trinity Grammar School by architects Peter Crone and Peter McIntyre, c2010. (Source: Carolan 2003b:XII)

Richard Tudor retired as headmaster in 2013, the same year the Richard and Elizabeth Tudor Centre for Contemporary Living opened. Dr Michael Davies commenced his role as headmaster in 2014 (TGSK 2017).

At the end of 2015 Trinity Grammar undertook two building projects: the demolition of Arnold Hall, to make way for the Centre for Business and Social Enterprise, and the renovation of the Tonge Building.

As noted above, three buildings that pre-date Trinity Grammar have been incorporated into the campus. Their early histories of Henty House and Roberts House are provided below.

Henty House, formerly ‘Roxeth’, 40 Charles Street, KewHenty House, formerly ‘Roxeth’, is a Gothic Revival house, now a part of Trinity Grammar. It was built by 1856 for George Lewis (Argus 29 July 1856:4). George Lewis, who named his residence ‘Roxeth’, was a chemist who worked from premises known as the Medical Hall in Collins Street east, Melbourne. Lewis was also a Kew Borough councillor (South Bourke Standard 27 December 1861:1), chairman of the municipality in 1863 (Barnard 1910:74), and acted in the role of chairman of the Kew Police Court (South Bourke Standard 12 June 1863:4). In 1863, the ‘Roxeth’ property, under the ownership of George Lewis, was rated at a net annual value of £160 (RB 1863).

Because Lewis was leaving Kew, in 1863 he put ‘Roxeth’ up for sale. The sale notice described the property, which included eight acres of land, substantially fenced and partially tile drained, comprising: two acres of garden, planted with fruit trees and vines; two acres of rye grass and clover; two acres of lucerne; and two acres of park land. The house contained eight large rooms, with ‘ample domestic offices for a respectable family’. Additional buildings included a coach house, harness room, two-stall stable, loosebox, piggeries and cowhouse. The ‘beautiful locality’ was home to some of ‘our most wealthy

10



citizens’, including Joseph Mitchell esq., John Halfey esq. JP, and Samuel Finley esq. (Argus 12 September 1863:3).

The brick cottage of some six or eight rooms with broad verandahs running round three sides of it (MS SLV 1934) called ‘Roxeth’ was purchased by James Henty in 1863. He gifted it to his son’s wife, Frances Emma Henty (nee Murphy), daughter of Sir Francis Murphy, as her marriage settlement after she and Herbert James Henty married in 1861 (MS SLV 1934). Herbert and Frances Henty made substantial changes to ‘Roxeth’, including the addition of a two-storey tower, however not all planned additions were carried out (MS SLV 1934). Three out of the four Henty children were born at ‘Roxeth’ in the period 1864-68 (Age 4 October 1864: 4; Argus 31 October 1866:4; Argus 12November 1868:4).

Herbert James Henty (1834-1902), merchant, was the son of James Henty, a member of the Henty family, early white settlers who established whaling and sheep grazing enterprises at Portland Bay in the Port Phillip District in 1834. Married to Charlotte, née Carter, James Henty with his sons Henry, Herbert and Thomas, set up the firm of James Henty & Co., merchants, in Melbourne. Herbert worked in the Bank of Australasia until 1856 when he, with his two brothers, became partners with their father (O'Neill 1972).

Herbert Henty was elected a member of Kew Municipal Council in 1864 and was mayor in 1868-69. He also served on the Melbourne City Council, on the Royal Commission on Education in 1881-82, and as president of the Melbourne Hospital in 1882-84 (O'Neill 1972). Herbert Henty was a churchwarden, vestryman, and lay helper at Holy Trinity Church in Kew for 21 years (Independent 15 August 1902:2).

A notice in 1876 informed the public that Herbert J Henty was returning to England and was therefore selling his household furniture and effects at his residence, ‘Roxeth’, at the corner of Wellington and Charles streets, Kew (Age 17 October 1876:4). It is not known if the family travelled to England, as in 1881 they were still residing at ‘Roxeth’ (Age 7 May 1881:8). A fire occurred at ‘Roxeth’ in 1885, destroying a storeroom and the servants’ ‘compartments’ (Argus 13 April 1885:6). The net annual value of ‘Roxeth’ rose from £250 in 1884 to £300 in 1886, evidencing the rebuilding of the servants’ wing and the addition of a ballroom at this time (RB 1884 & 1886; MS SLV 1934).

Henry Henty went to England and returned in 1884 to find that under his brother Herbert’s management the family business was in difficulties. Although in 1885 the firm was liquidated and reformed with Henry in partnership with Thomas and his uncle Francis, Herbert had signed unrecorded guaranties in the old firm’s name for some £81,000. In November Henry filed a schedule in the Insolvent Court, the firm’s deficit amounting to £149,518 (O'Neill 1972). Much of the ‘Roxeth’ land, comprising mainly paddocks, was sold off in the 1880s (MS SLV 1934).

In 1896 Herbert J Henty moved to Deniliquin where he died on 12 August 1902, survived by a son and a daughter (O'Neill 1972).

By 1895, widow Charlotte Meagher (nee O’Brien) was living at ‘Roxeth’ (Table Talk 4October 1895:16), however the property remained in the ownership of Herbert J Henty and in that year was rated at a net annual value of £180 (RB 1895). In 1898, Charlotte Meagher married Dr Thomas F Bride (Table Talk 25 February 1898:12). Her new husband joined her, and the couple resided at ‘Roxeth’ as lessees. Dr Bride had been formerly married to Mary Clare Newton, who died in 1895, and by whom he had five children (McCallum 1969).

A 1902 plan shows the footprint of ‘Roxeth’ and photographs depict the house itself (see Figure 3, Figure 9 and Figure 11).

11



Figure 12. ‘Roxeth’, 1906. Note the open balcony at the centre. (Source: SLV in Carolan 2003a:77)

Thomas Francis Bride (1849-1927), librarian, was born on 1 October 1849 at Cork, Ireland, son of Henry Nelson Bride and his wife Ellen, née Bourke. In 1870 he enrolled as a law student at the University of Melbourne and after winning scholarships and exhibitions graduated with first-class honours in 1873. Six years later he qualified as doctor of laws, the third Victorian student to do so. Bride served as assistant librarian at the university in 1873-81 (McCallum 1969).

Bride was selected from 37 applicants to be appointed librarian at the Melbourne Public Library in August 1881. Within a few years he had made significant improvements in the administration and working of the institution. During his term as librarian at the Public Library he edited the Letters from Victorian Pioneers, colonial reminiscences collected by Lieutenant-Governor La Trobe, but not published by the library trustees until 1898. In 1895 Bride resigned from the library to become curator of estates of deceased persons. He retired in November 1909 (McCallum 1969).

In addition, Bride unsuccessfully stood for North Melbourne as a Conservative in the Victorian general elections of 1880; in 1885 he was appointed a fellow of the Royal Geographical Society; he was a member of the councils of the University of Melbourne from 1887 and of the Working Men's College for many years. In 1886 he was a member of the Antarctic Exploration Committee and was the chairman of the board appointed by the government in 1896 to investigate the conditions of white and Chinese labour in the furniture trade. Bride founded the Technical Schools Association in Melbourne and was secretary and a writer for the Referendum League (McCallum 1969).

In 1924 Bride made an extended visit to Britain and Europe. Soon after his return to Melbourne he suffered a short illness and died on 7 April 1927 (McCallum 1969).

Henry Henty, Herbert’s elder brother, on behalf of Trinity Grammar School offered to negotiate the purchase price of ‘Roxeth’ with Herbert's two remaining children, Emily and Arthur Henty, who had inherited the house and grounds (four acres), which far exceeded their needs (Carolan 2003b:76,78). In 1906 the school purchased ‘Roxeth’ and its adjacent land and moved to the new site in the same year, with the ‘Roxeth’ residence used as headmaster George Merrick Long’s house. Under the guidance of architect Cecil Gordon McCrae, in 1906 a new building comprising an assembly hall and two classrooms (named Arnold Hall in 1925) was erected by the Swanson Brothers of

12



Melbourne and ‘Roxeth’ was converted to a boarding house (Carolan 2003b:79-80,85; Age 9 June 1906:5).

The first boarders in 1906 lived and dined in ‘Roxeth’ with the Long family. As well as dormitories and a dining room, the building housed common rooms, a prefects’ room and the headmaster’s study (Carolan 2003a:148). Incoming headmaster AW Tonge moved the boarders from ‘Roxeth’ to Trinity Lodge in 1912, and converted the dormitories into a family drawing room and dining room for family use. In 1924, ‘Roxeth’ comprised three parts: a double storey with a tower, a single storey rear wing with a verandah, and separate kitchens and stables (Carolan 2003b:254,258). In 1925 ‘Roxeth’ was renamed Henty House and was back in use as a boarding house after substantial renovations and additions were made to the building, including the addition of an open-air dormitory, theenlargement of the dining room, the addition of a common room and the upgrading of administrative offices (Age 16 December 1925:17; see Figure 10).

Henty House now houses the staff room and other offices at Trinity Grammar School.

Figure 13. Henty House c1926, showing the single-storey rear wing. (Source: Carolan 2003a:150)

13



Figure 14. Henty House, formerly ‘Roxeth’, Trinity Grammar School, 1979, photo by John T Collins. The first-floor balcony has been enclosed. (Source: SLV)

Roberts House, formerly ‘Elsinore’, 41 Charles Street, KewRoberts House, formerly ‘Elsinore’, is a small mansion built in 1875. The land on which ‘Elsinore’ stands measured eight acres in 1863 and was owned by surgeon Edward Barker, at which time no building was in existence (RB 1863). In 1872, Barker owned approximately six acres bound on three sides by Charles Street, Wellington Street and Gellibrand Street; the property was described as ‘land’ only in the rate book of that year (RB 1872; CT:V00472 F377). Later in 1872, Barker subdivided the land into ten allotments, two of which were transferred to the ownership of John Ambrose Kitchen in (CT:V00472 F377).

The Kew Borough rate books and certificate of title show that by 1876, ‘Elsinore’ had been built and was occupied by John Ambrose Kitchen and his wife, Gertrude (nee Walker) Kitchen. John Kitchen was a soap and candle manufacturer (see Figure 13 and Figure 14). ‘Elsinore’, a property of approximately two acres with house, was rated in 1876 at a net annual value of £180 (RB 1876; CT:V1404 F739). A son was born to Kitchen and his wife Gertrude (nee Walker) at ‘Elsinore’ on 10 June 1876 (Argus 13 June 1876:1). From 1878 until 1890, Kitchen’s property at this address was described as ‘house and land’ and ‘land’ (RB). ‘Elsinore’ can be seen in an 1889 photograph of a wedding, likely the marriage of John A Kitchen’s eldest daughter, Elsie, to George Henry Downer, and in a c1890 photograph of Kew (Argus 1 June 1889:1; see Figure 12 and Figure 19).

14



Figure 15. Wedding party at ‘Elsinore’, 1889. (Source: Carolan 2003b:11)

Due to the economic depression of the time, Kitchen took out several mortgages on the ‘Elsinore’ from 1885 until 1892, in which year the Commercial Bank of Australia foreclosed (CT:V1404 F739).

The Australian Dictionary of Biography contains this entry for John Ambrose Kitchen:

John Ambrose Kitchen (1835-1922), businessman, was born in February 1835 at Watlington, Oxfordshire, England... [T]he family migrated to Victoria in 1854…The family began making tallow candles from butchers' scraps in the backyard of their Emerald Hill (South Melbourne) house. Ordered out as an offensive trade, the business removed to Sandridge (Port Melbourne) in 1858.

Fire destroyed the company's premises in 1860, but they were quickly rebuilt and a Melbourne office was opened. In 1870 the Kitchens bought Gossage Bros' soap and candle factory at Footscray, to which they transferred their boiling-down operations. Manufacture of stearine candles commenced in 1871, when the Duffy government increased the protective tariff…By the early 1880s the firm employed some 300 workers in Melbourne. The merger with the Apollo Stearine Candle Co. made it the pre-eminent soap and candle manufacturer in the eastern mainland colonies, with a factory in Brisbane and a half-interest in the Sydney Soap & Candle Co.

Baptised a Wesleyan Methodist, Kitchen joined the Plymouth Brethren in Victoria, but by 1870 belonged to the Church of England. On 3 September 1875 at Kew he marriedwith Congregational forms 21-year-old, Irish-born Gertrude Walker. Having left his Sandridge cottage for Kew in 1868, in 1876 he acquired the mansion ‘Elsinore’. Kitchen also developed an apple orchard at Pakenham from the late 1870s, set up the Melbourne Coffee Taverns Co. with William McLean and (Sir) Matthew Davies in 1878 and co-founded the Royal Bank of Australasia (1888). Financed by the Commercial Bank of Australia, Kitchen speculated in real estate during the 1880s. After the bank crashes…[Kitchen] resigned briefly from the board of J. Kitchen & Sons, and moved to a modest, eight-room villa in East Malvern. All company property was mortgaged

15



when the banks threatened foreclosure, and in 1894 the New Zealand business was sold.

Kitchen's company had expanded to Western Australia and South Australia by 1902, and in 1907 began producing copra oil from a plantation at Milne Bay, Papua. Velvet soap was introduced as a brand name by 1906 and Solvol by 1915. The firm was employing 1000 workers across Australia when it merged with the British firm Lever Bros in 1914; the Australian subsidiary, however, remained under Kitchen family control.

John Ambrose died on 24 May 1922 at Malvern and was buried in Kew cemetery, survived by his wife and their two sons and by three sons and four daughters of his first marriage. Lever had fully acquired the business by 1924; in 1976 John Kitchen & Sons was renamed Unichema, and Lever and Kitchen soaps became Lever Rexona (Veltri 2005).

Figure 16. John Hambleton Kitchen, seated, holding baby Ambrose John Kitchen, John Ambrose Kitchen, standing, with his father John Kitchen seated, c1888. (Source: SLV)

16



Figure 17. J. Kitchen & Sons monthly circular, 1882. (Source: Ballarat Gold Museum)

In 1895, ‘Elsinore’ was advertised as part of a mortgagees’ sale. Described as a ‘family mansion’, it contained ‘large and lofty rooms, with all conveniences, conservatory, fernery, vinery’ and featured outbuildings, including stables and a coach house, as well as an asphalt tennis court. The grounds were ‘well laid out and stocked with choice plants and trees’ (Argus 13 July 1895:2).

‘Elsinore’ was purchased by gentleman Charles Cooper, solicitor Charles Emmerton and Robert Murray Smith (CTV2599 F732). In 1895, Joseph E Pounds lived at ‘Elsinore’;from 1897 contractor Valentine Saddler rented the property, which was rated at a net annual value of £200 (RB). A 1902 Melbourne Metropolitan Board of Works plan shows the footprint of ‘Elsinore’ (see Figure 3).

Valentine John Saddler became the owner of ‘Elsinore’ in 1912 (CTV2599 F732), and lived there with his family until his death there in 1924.

An obituary to Valentine Saddler read:

Mr. Saddler was well known in business and financial circles in Melbourne, and also in the other States, among other institutions with which he was connected being the Colonial Mutual Fire Insurance Co. and the Silverton Tramway Co., of both of which he was chairman. He was also associated as a director with the Dunlop Rubber Co. of Australia since its inception, and with Younghusband Ltd., and with many mining ventures in this and other States. Mr. Saddler was a member of the well known firm of Baxter and Saddler, which in former years built many railways in the various States, Mr. Saddler’s wife and one son predeceased him, and he is survived by a son, Mr. V. J. Saddler, jun., of Melbourne, and a daughter, Miss. S. Hirshfield, of Brisbane (Age 5August 1924:9).

Saddler’s probate described his real estate at his death as approximately two acres on which was erected a ‘two storied brick dwelling and conveniences known as “‘Elsinore’”occupied by deceased at date of death’; the property was valued at £8000 (PROV 1924).

17



As part of his `Forward Movement’ campaign, headmaster Frank Shann initiated the expansion of boarding facilities through the buying and renovation of two properties on the west side of Charles Street: ‘Elsinore’, purchased for £8750 and ‘Molina’ (Carolan2003b:254,258). With the purchase, ‘the whole hill top between Xavier College and Wellington Street’ passed into the possession of Trinity Grammar School, bringing the area of the school to almost ten acres, and plans were made for the construction of sporting facilities and grounds (Age 1 November 1924:24). The purchase of ‘Elsinore’was made possible through finance provided by 23 friends of the school, who agreed to provide money for the purchase of debentures (Argus 1 November 1924).

In 1925 ‘Elsinore’ was renamed Roberts House and substantial renovations and additions were made to the building, including additions of an open-air dormitory, new bathroom facilities and electric light (Age 16 December 1925:17; see Figure 15).

In 1975, the boarding house accommodated in Roberts House closed, and in 1976 it was converted into classrooms for Preparatory to Year Three classes (TGSK 2017). Roberts House in 1978 and 1979 is depicted in Figure 16 and Figure 17.

Figure 18. Roberts House, formerly ‘Elsinore’, with balconies converted into dormitories, 1926. The mature magnolia tree is visible at left, and the semi-mature sycamore tree at right (without foliage). (Source: Carolan 2003: 152)

18



Figure 19. Watercolour of Roberts House, formerly ‘Elsinore’, c1978, by Joy Stewart. (Source: KHS Collection)

Figure 20. Roberts House, formerly ‘Elsinore’, Trinity Grammar School, 1979, photo byJohn T Collins. (Source: SLV)

19



Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’, 41 Charles Street, KewMerritt House, formerly ‘Molina’ was built in 1872-73 for Kew High School.

In 1872, the Rev. Ernest Ingle founded Kew High School and held the first classes in a private home on the northwest corner of Cotham Road and Mary Street, Kew. Because of increasing enrolments, in 1872, a new site for the school was acquired at 7 Charles Street, Kew. A newspaper report noted that:

Since the opening of the [Kew High] school last January, its progress had been such as to encourage hopes of an eventually large and flourishing school at Kew, in view of which result the establishment would be removed to a more suitable position in Charles street, where a house had been built, and a school room would be erected (South Bourke Standard 20 December 1872:3).

In January 1873, architect A Purchas called for tenders for the building of a schoolroom for Kew High School (Argus 4 January 1873: 3). By mid-January 1873, the ‘quite new’ schoolhouse and buildings ‘situated on high and open ground, not to be surpassed for its healthy and commanding position’ were in use by Kew High School (South Bourke Standard 17 January 1873:1). The ‘Molina’ mansion was constructed as part of this 1872-73 building program, as were the classrooms that later became the Junior School classrooms of Trinity Grammar School (Trumble 1987:116-17).

Architect Albert Purchas lived near Kew High School at ‘Fernhill’ in Fitzwilliam Street, Kew (RB 1876). The Encyclopedia of Australian Architecture contains this entry for Purchas:

Albert Purchas (1825-1909) architect, civil engineer and surveyor, was born in Chepstow, England. He migrated to Vic. in 1851 and soon after started a practice that appears to have been primarily architectural…One of his first major commissions was the laying out with botanist Baron Ferdinand von Mueller (1825-96) of the Melbourne General Cemetery (1853) in North Carlton. Purchas attracted a variety of work including several houses, an auction room and a bluestone Mortuary Chapel in the Melbourne Cemetery. He also won second prize in a competition for the Oriental Bank (1856).

In 1856, Purchas joined his brother-in-law Charles R. Swyer (1825-76) in the partnership Purchas & Swyer. They practised until 1862 and during that time designed many buildings, mostly banks in the Renaissance Revival style for the Bank of Australasia across country Victoria and buildings for the Church of England…The remainder of their work was mostly shops and hotels around Melbourne.

Purchas & Swyer disbanded in 1862 when Swyer went to New Zealand and Purchas continued in practice alone for many years, right up until his death in 1909…He ran avery active practice and continued with church and bank work after separating with Swyer…

Apart from his practice, Purchas was a Justice of the Peace and for many years vice-president of the VIA…[and] between about 1873 and 1886 he was the secretary of the Melbourne General Cemetery…chairman of the Cemetery Board at Kew from 1867 to 1909. Purchas married twice, both his wives predeceasing him. From his first marriage came two sons and nine daughters, of which seven daughters predeceased him. One of his sons was Guyon Purchas the architect (Willis and Goad 2012:570).

Because enrolments more than doubled in its first year of operation, Kew High School made plans to extend the schoolroom (South Bourke Standard 19 December 1873:3). Architect A Purchas subsequently called for tenders for additions to Kew High School in

20



1873 (Argus 17 December 1873:3); in 1874 (Argus 14 December 1874:3); and again in 1879 (Argus 27 September 1879:10).

In 1875, after Rev. Ingle died from typhoid fever (Telegraph 28 May 1875:2), John Henning Thompson assumed control of Kew High School as the school’s proprietor and headmaster. Thompson was educated at the Melbourne Grammar School and at the University of Melbourne, where he graduated with a BA in 1864 and MA in 1867, returning to Melbourne Grammar to teach until he became headmaster of Kew High School (UoMA 2011).

JH Thompson used ‘Molina’ as his residence, with the building also providing accommodation for Kew High School boarders – see Figure 18 (Trumble 1987:116-17). In the Kew Borough rate book of 1876, J Henning Thompson is noted as the owner of a ‘new high school’ with the property rated at a net annual value of £200; the property was rated at the same value in 1895 (RB).

Figure 20. Kew High School with Henning family, 1880s. (Source: Carolan 2003b:26)

Figure 19. View of ‘Molina’, c1890-91, at front. ‘Elsinore’ is visible to the left rear. (Source: KHS)

21



‘Molina’ can be seen in a c1890 photograph of Kew (see Figure 19). A 1902 Melbourne Metropolitan Board of Works plan shows the footprint of ‘Molina’ (see Figure 3).

Kew High School closed in 1908. A Kew High School Old Boys association was subsequently formed, which established the John Henning Thompson Cup for cricket to commemorate the service provided by Thompson. Presented at Associated Grammar Schools of Victoria competitions, the Cup is still awarded today (Trumble 1987:116-17). JH Thompson retired to live at South Wandin (Sylvan) and later lived at Hawthorn where he died in 1936 (UoMA 2011).

On 3 October 1908 Trinity Grammar School council offered to lease the Kew High School property from John Henning Thompson for five years, commencing in February 1909, at £120 per year, which was agreed to by Thompson. The contract was for part of Thompson's property, which consisted of 21/2 acres, including the house ‘Molina’ built in 1872, and two separate school buildings added in 1873. All three buildings were of Hawthorn brick and were situated in the centre of the allotment that fronted Charles Street with Stanley Street at the rear. The four-acre paddock on the other side of Stanley Street, owned by Henning Thompson and used by the Kew High School boys for cricket, was subdivided into residential blocks. Architect Cecil Gordon McCrae was employed to renovate the Kew High School schoolroom buildings for junior classes and ‘Molina’ to accommodate 25 boarders and a resident master. The property was renamed Trinity Lodge. (Carolan 2003b:109-11).

A newspaper article of the day described the acquisition:

The movement of a few years back to establish a Church of England public school for eastern suburbs, under the title of Trinity Grammar School, has proved a remarkable success. The new school buildings were opened just two years ago, and twice within the first eighteen months it was found necessary to make fresh additions. In order to provide for further increases, especially in the boarding school, which has been quite full for some time, the council has taken over from Mr. J. Henning Thompson the property formerly known as Kew High School, which immediately adjoins the school property, where a second house for boarders and a preparatory school will be opened for next year (Age 17 December 1908: 6).

As previously mentioned, in 1924, as part of his `Forward Movement’ campaign, headmaster Frank Shann initiated the expansion of boarding facilities through thepurchase and renovation of two properties: ‘Elsinore’ and Trinity Lodge (‘Molina’), the latter bought for £5630 (Carolan 2003b:254; see Figure 20). The purchase was made possible through finance provided by 23 friends of the school, who agreed to provide money for the buying of debentures (Argus 1 November 1924). In 1925 Trinity Lodge was renamed Merritt House and substantial renovations were made to the building, including the additions of a new sleep out (open to the elements on two sides), sanitary block and electric light – see Figure 21 (Age 16 December 1925:17).

22



Figure 20. Preparatory boys and staff at Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’, 1913. (Source: Carolan 2003a: 28)

Figure 21. Construction of Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’, rear sleep out, 1926. (Source: Carolan 2003a:153)

In 1975, the boarding house accommodated in Merritt House closed and the building wasconverted into a music school in 1982 – see Figure 22 (TGSK 2017).

23



Figure 22. South elevation of Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’, Trinity Grammar School, 1979, photo by John T Collins. (Source: SLV)

Description & IntegrityTrinity Grammar School is located in Kew, not far south-east of Kew Junction, in the midst of residential streets but just west of Glenferrie Road. Its central campus area is bounded by Wellington Street, Stanley Street and almost as far east as Gordon Avenue. Charles Street forms a north-south spine through the centre of the campus, making most of the buildings visible from the public domain. Xavier College is located directly south of the west side of the campus, and shares an east-west boundary at the south end of Stanley Street. Built form is grouped along Wellington Street, to the east of Charles Street, and in the southern half of the block between Stanley and Charles streets. The remaining area is taken up with playing fields and other outdoor sporting facilities.

As set out in the place history, there were three large houses already on the site that were acquired by Trinity Grammar in the early years of the 20th century. All three of these houses survive, in somewhat altered form. As also set out in the history, Trinity Grammar erected a number of purpose-built school facilities starting in 1907, but none of these has survived. The only exception is the Preparatory School building of 1926, which has been so extensively extended and remodelled that it is barely recognisable. For this reason, the description will focus on the three two main pre-existing buildings, as well as discussion of the intactness of Merritt House.

24



Figure 21. Henty House, formerly ‘Roxeth’, viewed from the south-west. (Source: Context, 2017)

Henty House, formerly ‘Roxeth’ and built in 1856, stands just south-east of the Charles and Wellington streets corner. Its front façade faces south, but is clearly visible from Charles Street as there is a large clear plaza in front of it. While the houses used to have a sprawling single-storey rear wing, and associated outbuildings, only the main two-storey front volume has been retained. It is Gothic Revival in style. The walls are rendered and the complex gabled roof is clad in slates.

The front (south) façade is symmetrically designed with two parapeted gabled bays. Between them is a lower section with a low balcony to the first floor (infilled with windows), below which is an arcade of two lancet arches supported on a slender cast-iron column. The balcony retains its geometric cast-iron balustrade. Each of the gabled bays has a canted bay with hipped roof to the ground floor, above which is a pair of windows beneath a lancet blind arch. These, and almost all windows of the building, are double-hung sashes with segmentally arched heads - a form typical of the Italianate style. The canted window bays, with their bracketed eaves, are also very Italianate in form. Applied decoration, however, is thoroughly medieval, with cast-cement bosses at the ends of label moulds and a stringcourse beneath the central balcony, blind quatrefoils above the first-floor windows, and impressed trefoils at the ends of the gable parapets.

The west side façade, facing Charles Street, has a different form but consistent details. The front half is articulated by a tall external chimney, and the rear half has a three storey tower which is flush with the façade. There is a window beneath a lancet-arch label mould to the first floor, and a pair of small lancet-arched windows with a continuous label mould are set beneath the bracketed eaves. The tower has a steep medieval flared roof with a louvered vents on each face, bands of scalloped slates, and a cast-iron finial. The north elevation of the tower is similarly expressed.

25



Apart from the demolition of the rear wing, Henty House is largely intact. As noted, the front balcony has been infilled with glazing. Also, the reveals of the windows in the front canted bays have sharp arises, while all other windows have chamfered edges, which is much more common for the 19th century. This suggests re-rendering.

Figure 22. Front façade of Roberts House, formerly ‘Elsinore’. (Source: trinity.vic.edu.au)

Roberts House, former ‘Elsinore’, stands on the north-west corner of Stanley and Wellington streets, set behind a deep front garden containing a number of mature trees, including Magnolia grandiflora (Southern Magnolia), Phoenix canariensis (Canary Island Palm), Brachychiton acerifolius (Illawarra Flame Tree), Platinus occidentalis (Sycamore) and Lophoestemon confertus (Brush Box). Considering their size and species, all of these trees appear to have been planted in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, while it was still a private residence. The Magnolia and the Sycamore are visible in the 1926 photo (see Figure 15). The location of all these trees is shown on the plan, below.

26



Figure 23. Location of contributory trees at Roberts House: 1) Southern Magnolia; 2) Canary Island Palm; 3) Illawarra Flame Tree; 4) Sycamore; and 5) Brush Box.

Roberts House is a two-storey Victorian Italianate mansion-villa with a very wide front façade. Walls are finished in cement render while the complex hipped roof is clad in slate. The façade is divided into two nearly symmetrical halves by a two-storey parapeted entrance tower at the centre. The tower has a buttressed entrance arch at the ground floor leading to the large six-panel front door. Above it is a round-headed window to the first floor and a cornice and pedimented parapet at the top. To either side of the tower is a verandah with cast-iron columns grouped in twos and threes, and curved cast-iron brackets beneath a solid frieze (an original feature, as seen in the 1889 photo). The first-floor balconies have single posts and a solid frieze without brackets. The southern verandah bows outward (curved in plan), while the north side is rectilinear.

Windows beneath the verandah are all rectangular double-hung sashes with louvered shutters to the ground floor (visible in 1889). There is a canted bay window to the north side ground floor, and a very shallow breakfront to the centre of the south side.

Roberts House appears to be largely intact externally, retaining intact rear wings. Comparing its footprint to the 1902 MMBW plan, only the rear wing in the south-east corner has been replaced. Concrete staircases have been added to the south end of the front elevation and the north side elevation, both of which are clearly visible from the public domain. As an aside, the 1902 MMBW plan shows a front verandah only to the south half of the front façade. This appears to be an error, as the historic photo of 1889, shows the verandah across the entire façade, as seen today. The 1926 photo of the building shows that the first-floor balconies were converted to sleep-outs in the 1920s. The photo shows that the cast-iron columns and balustrade remained untouched to the southern part of the verandah, but were replaced by infill walls on the north side. By the

27



1970s, this infill had been removed and the verandah detail reinstated. While there were originally clusters of three posts to the first-floor verandah, they are now single posts. This may be because some of the surviving posts on the south side were used to restore the north side.

Figure 24. Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’, viewed from the south-east. (Source: Context, 2017)

Merritt House, formerly ‘Molina’, is a two-storey bi-chrome brick building in an austere version of the Italianate style. The south-facing front façade is articulated by a shallow breakfront with paired segmentally arched windows at each level. In plan, the building forms a letter ‘T’, with the arms running east-west and the base of the ‘T’ extending northward. The hipped roof is clad in slates. Typical of the Italianate style, the chimneys (of bichrome brick) have decorative cornices at the top, and the eaves are decorated with closely spaces brackets. Around the façade breakfront, windows are single double-hung sashes with bluestone sills, segmentally arched heads and heavy cream brick quoining. The same quoining is used for the corners of the building and the breakfront, and there is also a wide cream-brick beltcourse between the two floors. The front door is expressed similarly to the windows and sits just to the east of the breakfront. The rest of the walls are of brown Hawthorn brick laid in English bond. The same cream brick quoining, beltcourse and paired windows are also seen on the east side elevation.

Merritt House sits within a courtyard at the south-west corner of the school grounds, and is barely visible from the public realm. Its Visibility (and intactness) has also beenseverely impacted by a series of late twentieth-century building campaigns. This is particularly the case of the western third of the building, with alterations including: removal of a large area of ground-floor wall of the south (front) elevation (including two windows); removal of almost the entire two-storey wall of the west elevation; total

28



removal of the single-storey section in the north-west corner, enclosure of the 1925 sleepout above the rear (north) wing; and a number of new window openings to north (rear) elevation ground floor. The western third of the building has also been enclosed within a new sporting facility, which sits just below it eaves. This lack of intactness is considered to seriously compromise Merritt House’s level of significance, as address in the Assessment of Significance section, below.

Figure 25. South-west corner of Merritt House, showing the two-storey opening to the west elevation (left) and ground-floor opening to the south elevation (right). (Source: Context, 2017)extensions to the rear elevations and half of the front façade. It appears that this part of the façade remains intact, and visible within the extension, but it makes it hard to view and understand the building as a whole.

29



Comparative AnalysisEach of the three early buildings that predate the foundation of Trinity GrammarHenty House and Roberts House will be analysed separately in relation to comparable places in Kew and Boroondara more widely, where appropriate.

Henty House (‘Roxeth’) is one of a small number of pre-1870 houses identified in Kew.There is an even smaller handful that survives from the 1850s, but it is not clear how much of the 1856 extent of ‘Roxeth’ survives (following the 1863 expansion by the Hentys and subsequent demolition of the rear wings). It is also one of a small number of early Gothic Revival houses to survive in Boroondara as a whole, most of which are in its earliest suburb: Hawthorn.

Pre-1870s houses that have been identified in Kew are the following:

‘Roseneath’, 62 Peel Street, Kew (HO104) - This brick house was built in stages. In the early 1850s John Ambrose Kitchen (original owner of ‘Elsinore’/Roberts House) had a very simple transverse gabled two-storey house built. In 1885 new owner Edward Dunn had a new single-storey section built at the front. This new section is Gothic Revival in style, with finely detailed bargeboards. It is considered significant, among other reasons, as ‘one of the earliest houses to have been built in the Kew area’ (M Gould, Kew Conservation Study, 1988).

Figure 26. 1850s rear wing at ‘Roseneath’. (Source: Woodards, 2007)

30



Figure 27. Gothic Revival extension to ‘Roseneath’ of 1885. (Source: Woodards, 2007)

‘Studley House’, 2 Nolan Avenue, Kew (VHR H789) - two-storey mansion in a Classical Revival style with columned double-storey verandah, built in 1857 for parliamentarian John Hodgson. It was extended in 1875 remodelled in 1919. Now part of Xavier College.

Figure 28. ‘Studley House’ of 1875. (Source: Heritage Victoria, 2008)

31



‘D’Estaville’, 7 Barry Street, Kew (VHR H201) - bluestone two-storey Classical Revivalhouse of 1859, built for Sir William Stawell, who was an important figure in Victorian politics and public institutions. It was designed by architects Knight and Kerr (architects of the Parliament House).

Figure 29. ‘D’Estaville’ of 1859. (Source: Heritage Victoria, nd)

‘Ivy Grange’, 3 Malmsbury Street, Kew (HO92) - A two-storey, bluestone Gothic Revival mansion. It was built in 1864 and owned by the prominent architect Charles Vickers, at an early stage of Kew's development. It was very sympathetically added to by prominent architects since (Crouch & Wilson in 1877 - including the parapeted Scottish Baronial tower; Reed, Henderson & Smart). The use of basalt combined with cream brick is unusual and enhances the significance.

Figure 331300. ‘Ivy Grange’ of 1864-1885. (Source: Kew Conservation Study, 1992)

32



‘Darley’, 2 Merrion Grove, Kew (HO321) of 1869, a single-storey Italianate villa of the late 1860s, broadly intact to its original form, albeit modified in the Edwardian period. Though now on a much reduced allotment, the house is considered significant as one of a relatively limited number of residences surviving in the Kew area from the period pre-1870.

Figure 332311. ‘Darley’ of 1869. (Source: Lovell Chen, 2005)

‘Mount Ephraim’, 26 Edgecombe Street, Kew (HO297) - This two-storey rendered brick house of c1868-9 is of local historical and architectural significance as one of a relatively limited group of surviving substantial pre-1870s villas and mansion houses in Kew. This is despite alterations including the replacement of the front verandah with a portico (in the 1920s), rear additions, and replacement of the roofing slates.

Figure 333322. ‘Mount Ephraim’ of c1868-9. (Source: Lovell Chen, 2005)

33



For the most part, except for ‘Darley’, the early houses that survive in Kew are the more substantial residences that were built solidly with a high level of architectural pretension for prominent members of the Melbourne community. The same can be said of ‘Roxeth’. Its current appearance dates from the c1863 remodelling by Herbert and Frances Henty in a sophisticated and large-scale rendition of the then-fashionable Gothic Revival.

Among the examples above, there are two homes that share the same Gothic Revival influence: the 1885 wing of ‘Roseneath’ and ‘Ivy Grange’ of 1864-85. The earliest Gothic Revival houses in Boroondara are in Hawthorn, and date from the 1840s and 1850s. Both are of State significance and are included in the Victorian Heritage Register. They are: ‘Invergowie’ of 1846-69, 21 Coppin Grove; and ‘The Hawthorns’ of 1852, 5 Creswick Street. Both are of bluestone with decorative timber fretwork to the gables, and are more informal versions of Gothic than ‘Roxeth’, both in their asymmetric massing and rustic detail.

A closer example to ‘Roxeth’s’ architectural expression, with a formal symmetry and use of parapeted Tudor gables is ‘Avon Court’, 20 Shakespeare Grove, Hawthorn (HO244). It is a two-storey mansion semi-detached pair designed by Crouch & Wilson in 1877. The use of cast-iron ornamented verandahs is typical of the 1870s, as compared to the more restrained and ‘correct’ Gothic influence on ‘Roxeth’s’ entry porch.

Figure 334333. ‘Avon Court’ of 1877. (Source: Heritage Victoria, nd)

Roberts House (‘Elsinore’) of 1875 can be compared to other grand houses of mid and late Victorian period (1870s-1890s). It belongs to the typology of large Italianate houses that eschew strong asymmetry. While the characteristic Italianate parapeted tower is most commonly used off-centre or even on a side elevation for most large Italianate houses, this group uses the tower to define the centre of the composition. To either side is a more-or-less symmetrical composition. This is seen at ‘Elsinore; with the dominant central tower, flanked by two lengths of verandah that are identical in detail but subtly different in plan and with different sized and shaped bay windows beneath them.

Other examples of this typology seen in Kew are:

Villa Alba, 44 Walmer Street (VHR H605), built before 1863 but substantially remodelled and enlarged in 1882-83. It is a two-storeyed residence with rendered masonry walls and

34



a slate roof. The centre of the façade is defined by a projecting three-storey tower with the entrance porch in its base. Unusually, the house has no verandah. It is Italianate in style, but is thought to have a Norman (Romanesque) influence as seen in the use of round-headed arches and the austere tower.

Figure 335344. Villa Alba of c1863 and 1882-83. (Source: Heritage Victoria, 2008)

‘Comaques’, 896 Glenferrie Road, Kew (HO203) - An 1891 two storeyed rendered mansion and is composed and decorated in the Italianate style. It is dominated by a balustraded three storeyed tower over the front entrance that is flanked by two polygonal bay window units. A two storeyed loggia spans down the Wellington Street facade.

Figure 336355. ‘Comaques’ of 1891. (Source: RT Edgar, nd)

‘Inverkelty’, 11 Redmond Street, Kew (HO336) - A two-storey house of 1888. It is a representative example of later nineteenth-century Italianate design as applied to a two-storey suburban villa with tower. It is more asymmetrical than the other examples, with a

35



verandah to one side of the tower and a two-storey bay window to the other. It has been altered in a number of areas, including the rebuilding of the verandah.

Figure 337366. ‘Inverkelty’ of 1888. (Source: Lovell Chen, 2005)

In its intactness, considering the alterations to the verandah, ‘Elsinore’ is closest to ‘Inverkelty’. In its size and architectural expression, it is among the grander houses of the mid-Victorian period in Kew, built before the excesses of the Boom era of the late 1880s and early 1890s.

Merritt House (former ‘Molina’, Kew High School) is a different sort of building, as it was constructed in 1872-73 as part of a school (the schoolmaster’s residence and boarding house). This hybrid use, as well as its early date, is reflected in the restrained, institutional design of its façade.

Early school buildings that survive in Boroondara are provided as examples in the Boroondara Thematic Environmental History (Built Environment, 2012):

36



Former Hawthorn National School (now Hawthorn West Primary School No. 293), Burwood Road (2A Wood Street), Hawthorn (Contributory in HO220). A small portion of the original 1853 bluestone building has been incorporated into a later building.

Figure 3837. ‘Remaining reconstructed wall of Hawthorn West National School 1853’ (Source: L Burchell, SLV)

Former St Joseph's RC School, 102 Power Street/97 Elgin Street, Hawthorn(Significant in HO152). Boroondara's first Catholic parish school of 1857 (transepts added in the 1860s). It is a brick building in the form of an Early English Gothic sacral building, and also served as a Sunday chapel as its original use. It is now incorporated into an aged-care facility.

Figure 3938. Former St Joseph’s School of 1856-1860s. (Source: Hawthorn Heritage Study, 1993)

House (Merritt House), Charles Street, Kew. The former premises of the Kew High School, 1873 to 1908 [(provided in the Thematic Environmental History as an example of a secular private school]).

37



Xavier College (senior campus), Barkers Road, Kew (1872-78) (VHR H893). The first section of Xavier College commenced in December 1872 with the South Wing designed by Kelly, Dennehy and Tappin with a grand Victorian facade. The West Wing was built in 1889 in a Classical design, and Great Hall added in 1890, both extensions to the design of Kelly, Dennehy and Tappin. The South Wing is very long and imposing and a fine cement-rendered two-storeyed structure with cast-iron verandahs set between gabled pavilions.

Figure 4039. Xavier College’s South Wing of 1872. (Source: Heritage Victoria, nd)

Methodist Ladies’ College, Glenferrie Road, Kew (HO150, HO204). The foundation building, known as The Residence/Tiddeman Hall, was built in 1882. It is a two-storeyed cement-rendered building in the Gothic Revival style, designed by architects Crouch & Wilson. It has a commanding design, built symmetrically around the centre tower, and a pavilioned form with projecting gables at each end.

Figure 4140. MLC’s main building of 1882. (Source: Context, 2016)

38



Auburn Primary School, 51 Rathmines Road, Hawthorn East (VHR H1707). Built in 1889-90, it is the earliest surviving state school in Boroondara. It is a polychrome brick building in the Gothic Revival style, considered the finest of its type among Department of Education buildings, with many intact internal features.

Figure 4241. Auburn Primary School of 1889. (Source: Heritage Victoria, 2008)

In conclusion ‘Molina’ is one of the earliest purpose-built school buildings to survive in Boroondara. Among this group it is notably more austere in ornamentation, and smaller than the grand piles erected by wealthy private schools Xavier College and Methodist Ladies’ College. Among these examples, it was the only secular private school.

39



Assessment Against Criteria

Criteria referred to in Practice Note 1: Applying the Heritage Overlay, Department of Planning and Community Development, September 2012, modified for the local context.

CRITERION A: Importance to the course, or pattern, of the City of Boroondara's cultural or natural history (historical significance).

Henty House (‘Roxeth’), Merritt House (‘Molina’) and Roberts House (‘Elsinore’) are of historical significance for their association with Trinity Grammar for around 100 years. Trinity Grammar School was founded in 1902, opened the following year in the Parish Hall of Holy Trinity Church, Kew, at the corner of Pakington and High streets. When the school outgrew these premises, they purchased ‘Roxeth’ in 1906. While some purpose-built school buildings were constructed in these early years (all since demolished), Trinity Grammar also purchased ‘Elsinore’ in 1924. expanded into two other existing buildings: ‘Molina’ (leased from 1908, purchased in 1924) and ‘Elsinore’ (purchased in 1924). Thethree two buildings served the school mainly as boarding facilities, and were renamed in honour of men who contributed significantly to Trinity Grammar’s development.

A third early building, ‘Molina’ a former Kew High School building, was also used by Trinity Grammar from 1909 to the present day.

CRITERION B: Possession of uncommon, rare or endangered aspects of the City of Boroondara's cultural or natural history (rarity).

Henty House (‘Roxeth’), built in 1856 and remodelled and enlarged c1863, is one of a small number of pre-1870 houses identified in Kew. Like most of the other surviving early houses, it is a substantial residence built solidly with the 1860s remodelling exhibiting a high level of architectural pretension for a prominent member of the Melbourne community. It is also one of a small number of early (pre-1870) Gothic Revival houses to survive in Boroondara as a whole.

Merritt House (former ‘Molina’, Kew High School), built in 1872-73, is one a small number of purpose-built school buildings constructed prior to 1890 to survive in Boroondara. Among this number, it is also the only building constructed for a secular private school, while the other earliest examples were for church schools.

CRITERION C: Potential to yield information that will contribute to an understanding of the City of Boroondara's cultural or natural history (research potential).

N/A

CRITERION D: Importance in demonstrating the principal characteristics of a class of cultural or natural places or environments (representativeness).

Merritt House (‘Molina’) is significant as a representative example of an austere, almost institutional, application of the Italianate style, with characteristic features such as a low hipped roof clad in slates, corniced chimneys, bracketed eaves, bichromatic brickwork, segmentally arched openings, and a simple symmetrical façade defined by a central breakfront. Considering the level of demolition to its western third, however, it does not meet the threshold of local significance.

CRITERION E: Importance in exhibiting particular aesthetic characteristics (aesthetic significance).

40



Henty House (‘Roxeth’), as remodelled c1863, is a fine and well-detailed example of the Gothic Revival style. Elements of note include the parapeted front gables with blind lancet arches above the first floor windows, paired lancet arches to the inset porch, a three-storey tower on the west side with a steep medieval flared roof with a louvered vents on each face, bands of scalloped slates, and a cast-iron finial, and applied cast-cement ornament such as bosses at the ends of label moulds and a stringcourse beneath the central balcony, blind quatrefoils above the first-floor windows, and impressed trefoils at the ends of the gable parapets.

Roberts House (‘Elsinore’), of 1875, is an elegant two-storey Italianate mansion with a wide front façade in a largely symmetrical arrangement around a central parapeted tower. The composition at either side of the tower is varied by the different plan forms of the verandahs and bay windows on either side. ‘Elsinore’ is enhanced by the presence of a number of mature specimen trees in the front garden, including a Magnolia grandiflora (Southern Magnolia), Phoenix canariensis (Canary Island Palm), Brachychiton acerifolius (Illawarra Flame Tree), Platinus occidentalis (Sycamore) and Lophoestemon confertus (Brush Box). They illustrate the use of specimen trees and species typically used in residential garden layouts of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century.

CRITERION F: Importance in demonstrating a high degree of creative or technical achievement at a particular period (technical significance).

N/A

CRITERION G: Strong or special association with a particular community or culturalgroup for social, cultural or spiritual reasons. This includes the significance of a place to Indigenous peoples as part of their continuing and developing cultural traditions (social significance).

These three two buildings have a strong association with Trinity Grammar old boys, who have lived in or otherwise used these buildings for around 100 years.

CRITERION H: Special association with the life or works of a person, or group of persons, of importance in the City of Boroondara's history (associative significance).

NA

41



Statement of Significance

What is Significant?The threeTwo nineteenth-century buildings that were incorporated into Trinity Grammar School in the early twentieth century are significant.

The Gothic Revival Henty House (formerly ‘Roxeth’) was first constructed in 1856 for chemist and Kew Borough Councillor George Lewis. It was remodelled c1863 and enlarged for new owners Herbert and Frances Henty. Herbert was a member of the Henry family, who were some of the earliest settlers in the Port Phillip District, and a merchant and banker. It was purchased by Trinity Grammar in 1906 when they moved from their initial lodgings in the Holy Trinity Parish Church.

The bichrome brick Italianate Merritt House (‘Molina’) was built in 1872-73 as part of the secular private school Kew High School. It was designed by architect Alfred Purchase. When the school closed in 1908, it became a boarding house for Trinity Grammar.

The Italianate mansion Roberts House (‘Elsinore’) was built in 1875 for soap and candle manufacturer John Ambrose Kitchen and his family. Kitchen died in 1922, and two years later the house was purchased by Trinity Grammar. The house retains mature trees in the front garden, including a Magnolia grandiflora (Southern Magnolia), Phoenix canariensis (Canary Island Palm), Brachychiton acerifolius (Illawarra Flame Tree), Platinus occidentalis (Sycamore) and Lophoestemon confertus (Brush box), which are contributory to its significance.

Late twentieth-century additions to the threetwo buildings, particularly the rear wing of Henty House, the additions to the front (south), west and north elevations of Merritt House, and the external staircases to Roberts House, are not significant.

How is it significant?Henty House is of local historical, aesthetic, and social significance, and rarity value; and Roberts House is of local historical, aesthetic, and social significance, They are of local historical, architectural, aesthetic, and social significance, and rarity value, all to the City of Boroondara.

Why is it significant? Henty House (‘Roxeth’), Merritt House (‘Molina’) and Roberts House (‘Elsinore’) are of historical significance for their association with Trinity Grammar for over around 100 years. Trinity Grammar School was founded in 1902, opened the following year in the Parish Hall of Holy Trinity Church, Kew, at the corner of Pakington and High streets. When the school outgrew these premises, they purchased ‘Roxeth’ in 1906. While some purpose-built school buildings were constructed in these early years (all since demolished), Trinity Grammar also purchased ‘Elsinore’ in 1924. expanded into two other existing buildings: ‘Molina’ (leased from 1908, purchased in 1924) and ‘Elsinore’ (purchased in 1924). The three two buildings served the school mainly as boarding facilities, and were renamed in honour of men who contributed significantly to Trinity Grammar’s development. (Criterion A)

Henty House (‘Roxeth’), built in 1856 and remodelled and enlarged c1863, is one of a small number of pre-1870 houses identified in Kew. Like most of the other surviving early houses, it is a substantial residence built solidly with the 1860s remodelling exhibiting a high level of architectural pretension for a prominent member of the Melbourne community. It is also one of a small number of early (pre-1870) Gothic Revival houses to survive in Boroondara as a whole.

42



Merritt House (former ‘Molina’, Kew High School), built in 1872-73, is one a small number of purpose-built school buildings constructed prior to 1890 to survive in Boroondara. Among this number, it is also the only building constructed for a secular private school, while the other earliest examples were for church schools. (Criterion B)

Merritt House (‘Molina’) is significant as a representative example of an austere, almost institutional, application of the Italianate architectural style, with characteristic features such as a low hipped roof clad in slates, corniced chimneys, bracketed eaves, bichromatic brickwork, segmentally arched openings, and a simple symmetrical façade defined by a central breakfront. (Criterion D)

Henty House (‘Roxeth’), as remodelled c1863, is a fine and well-detailed example of the Gothic Revival style. Elements of note include the parapeted front gables with blind lancet arches above the first floor windows, paired lancet arches to the inset porch, a three-storey tower on the west side with a steep medieval flared roof with a louvered vents on each face, bands of scalloped slates, and a cast-iron finial, and applied cast-cement ornament such as bosses at the ends of label moulds and a stringcourse beneath the central balcony, blind quatrefoils above the first-floor windows, and impressed trefoils at the ends of the gable parapets.

Roberts House (‘Elsinore’), of 1875, is an elegant two-storey Italianate mansion with a wide front façade in a largely symmetrical arrangement around a central parapeted tower. The composition at either side of the tower is varied by the different plan forms of the verandahs and bay windows on either side. ‘Elsinore’ is enhanced by the presence of a number of mature specimen trees in the front garden, including a Magnolia grandiflora (Southern Magnolia), Phoenix canariensis (Canary Island Palm), Brachychiton acerifolius (Illawarra Flame Tree), Platinus occidentalis (Sycamore) and Lophoestemon confertus (Brush Box). They illustrate the use of specimen trees and species typically used in residential garden layouts of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. (Criterion E)

These three two buildings have a strong association with Trinity Grammar old boys, who have lived in or otherwise used these buildings for around 100 years. (Criterion G)

Grading and Recommendations

Recommended for inclusion in the Schedule to the Heritage Overlay of the Boroondara Planning Scheme as an Individually Significant place.

Recommendations for the Schedule to the Heritage Overlay (Clause 43.01) in the Boroondara Planning Scheme:

It is recommended that the threetwo Significant buildings be protected in defined curtilages that ensure that views to them are protected as well as encompassing trees that contribute to Roberts House’s significance. The following curtilages are recommended, as shown on the map at the start of this citation:

- Henty House - to the west street boundary, 10 metres to the south (front), 3 metres to the north (rear), and 5 metres to the east. This curtilage encompassessmall parts of other school buildings to the north, south and east. These buildings are Non-contributory and their demolition or alteration (apart from their extension) will have no impact on the heritage significance of Henty House.

- Roberts House - to the north and west street boundaries, 4 metres to the east (rear) and 5 metres to the south. This curtilage encompasses part of an addition to the south elevation of the rear wing, which is Non-contributory. Its demolition or alteration (apart from its extension) will have no impact on the heritage significance of Roberts House.

43





External Paint Colours Is a permit required to paint an already painted surface? No

Internal Alteration Controls Is a permit required for internal alterations? No

Tree Controls Is a permit required to remove a tree?

Yes - Southern Magnolia, Canary Island Palm, Illawarra Flame Tree, Sycamore and Brush Box at Roberts House

Victorian Heritage RegisterIs the place included on the Victorian Heritage Register? No

Incorporated Plan Does an Incorporated Plan apply to the site? No

Outbuildings and fences exemptions Are there outbuildings and fences which are not exempt from notice and review?

No

Prohibited uses may be permitted Can a permit be granted to use the place for a use which would otherwise be prohibited?

No

Aboriginal Heritage PlaceIs the place an Aboriginal heritage place which is subject to therequirements of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006?

No

Identified ByP Sanderson, ‘Kew Urban Conservation Study’, 1988.

ReferencesAge, as cited.

Argus, as cited.

Australian Government, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (AG) 2008, About Australia: Religious freedom,https://web.archive.org/web/20100806082535/http://www.dfat.gov.au/facts/religion.html, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Barnard, FGA 1910, Jubilee History of Kew Victoria, Mercury Office, Kew.

Built Heritage Pty Ltd 2012, ‘City of Boroondara Thematic Environmental History’, prepared for the City of Boroondara.

Carolan, Jane 2003a, For the green and the gold and the mitre: a centenary history of Trinity Grammar School, Kew - Vol. 2. And the gold: a pictorial essay of Trinity, 1903-2003, Benchmark Publications, Montrose.

Carolan, Jane 2003b, For the green and the gold and the mitre: a centenary history of Trinity Grammar School, Kew - Vol. 1. For the green: Trinity Grammar School, 1903-2003, Benchmark Publications, Montrose.

Certificates of Title (CT), as cited.

45



City of Kew municipal rate books (RB), as cited.

Collins, John T 1979, ‘Merritt House’ Trinity Grammar School, State Library Victoria (SLV) Pictures Collection, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Collins, John T 1979, ‘Roxeth’ Trinity Grammar School, State Library Victoria (SLV) Pictures Collection, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Collins, John T 1979, Roberts House, State Library Victoria (SLV) Pictures Collection, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Henty, A Frederick 1934, letter to Gertrude Morrissey. MS 1934Box 3709/13 SLV (State Library Victoria) Manuscripts Collection.

Independent, as cited.

J Kitchen and Sons monthly circular 1 April 1882, Gold Museum Ballarat, https://ehive.com/collections/4819/objects/261414/j-kitchen-sons, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Johnstone O'Shannessy & Co. c1888, Kitchen family, State Library Victoria (SLV) Pictures Collection, accessed online 13 February 2017.

McCallum, CA 1969, 'Bride, Thomas Francis (1849–1927)', Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/bride-thomas-francis-3052/text4491, published first in hardcopy 1969, accessed online 10 February 2017.

Melbourne Metropolitan Board of Works (MMBW) Detail Plan, as cited, State Library of Victoria (SLV).

O'Neill, Sally 1972, 'Henty, Herbert James (1834–1902)', Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/henty-herbert-james-3911/text5919, published first in hardcopy 1972, accessed online 10 February 2017.

Public Record Office Victoria (PROV) 1924, Wills, Probate and Administration Records 1841-2013, VPRS28/P3/1504.

Sanderson, Pru Design Pty Ltd 1988, Kew Urban Conservation Study, prepared for the Victorian National Estate Committee and City of Kew.

South Bourke Standard, as cited.

Sands & McDougall directories (S&Mc).Stewart Joy c1978, Watercolour of Roberts House, Kew Historical Society (KHS), https://victoriancollections.net.au/items/57ff68f6d0cdd122b0925872, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Stewart, Joy c1978 Pencil, pen and ink drawing of Victorian buildings that comprise Trinity Grammar School, Kew Historical Society (KHS), https://victoriancollections.net.au/items/5801c769d0cdd103d03c8744, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Table Talk, as cited.

46



Trinity Grammar School, Kew (TGSK) 2017, History of Trinity,http://www.trinity.vic.edu.au/about-trinity/history-of-trinity/, accessed online 10 February2017.

Trumble, Robert 1987, The School on the Hill: A Book of Trinity Grammar School, Kew, Spectrum Publications, Richmond.

University of Melbourne Archives (UoMA) 2011, Thompson, John Henning, accessed online 13 February 2017.

Veltri, Damian 2005, 'Kitchen, John Ambrose (1835–1922)', Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/kitchen-john-ambrose-13027/text23553, published first in hardcopy 2005, accessed online 8 February 2017.

Willis J & Goad P (eds) 2012, The Encyclopedia of Australian architecture, Cambridge University Press, Melbourne.

47



Draft heritage citation Heritage Overlay recommendations prior to preliminary consultation

1

Attachment 3



UPC2 Trinity Grammar School Heritage Assessment ...

Documents