UNMESH 2015 Presentation Saikat Halder, Mechanical, IIEST,Shibpur

1

UN

MES

H 20

15

PERFORMANCE OPTIMIZATION OF FORCED DRAFT FAN of UNIT #1 (BBGS)

Project Guide:Mr. Samir BandyopadhyaySenior Manager, Mechanical Maintenance DepartmentBudge Budge Generating StationCESC Limited

Presented By:Saikat Halder, Mechanical Engineering, IIEST, Shibpur

2

UN

MES

H 20

15

Presentation layout

• Introduction• Fans• Air and Flue gas path• Governing Equations• Result and Discussion• Conclusion

3

UN

MES

H 20

15

Introduction

• Forced Draft (FD) fans are used for supplying the combustion air into the furnace of a boiler.

• A good design of fan and its control system increases plant reliability by improving furnace pressure control and airflow control, which is most critical control part of combustion control system.

• In this report, the performance evolution, monitoring and optimization of Forced Draft fan of BBGS unit #1 has represented.

4

UN

MES

H 20

15

Fans• Fans generate a pressure to move air (or gases) against a resistance caused

by ducts, dampers, or other components in a fan system.• Fans fall into two general categories: Centrifugal fan Axial flow fan• System characteristics• Fan characteristics

5

UN

MES

H 20

15

Fan Characteristics Curve

6

UN

MES

H 20

15

Air and Flue Gas path

7

UN

MES

H 20

15

Measurement of various fan parameters

• Pressure of air at the discharge to each FD fan at different load.

• Flow of each FD fan at different load.

• Current requirement (Amps) of each FD fan at different load.

• Inlet damper position of each FD fan at different load.

• The average temperature of the air passing through the FD Fan.

8

UN

MES

H 20

15

Governing equations

• The equation for determining total efficiency is:

• Power input to the motor

• Power input to the shaft

• Air density

( all the equations are taken from the documents of Bureau of

Energy Efficiency)

9

UN

MES

H 20

15

Result

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 2800

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

550

600

650

70%80%

90% 100%

Discharge (mᵌ/sec)

50%

Design Point

Hea

d (m

m o

f WC

)

60%

H-Q Curve of FD Fan-A

10

UN

MES

H 20

15

Result contd.

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 2800

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

550

600

650

Discharge ( mᵌ/sec)

Head

( m

m o

f WC

)

80%90%

100%

60%70%

Design Point

H-Q Curve of FD Fan-B

11

UN

MES

H 20

15

Result contd.• Both fan operation

FD Fan-A

FD Fan-B

• Single fan operation FD Fan-A

Load (MW) Volume Flow Rate (mᵌ/sec) Head (mm of WC) Power (kW) Efficiency (%)

150 (60%) 97.8 256 840.8 29.2

175 (70%) 105.1 255 849.9 30.9

200 (80%) 115.7 274 877.3 35.4

225 (90%) 119.5 288 895.6 37.7

250 (100%) 129.0 303 913.9 40.8

Load (MW) Volume Flow Rate (mᵌ/sec) Head (mm of WC) Power (kW) Efficiency (%)

150 (60%) 113.5 260 831.6 34.8

175 (70%) 121.5 261 859.0 36.2

200 (80%) 136.1 289 886.4 43.5

225 (90%) 143.2 292 913.8 44.9

250 (100%) 143.0 299 913.8 45.9

Load (MW) Volume Flow Rate (mᵌ/sec) Head (mm of WC) Power (kW) Efficiency (%)

125(50%) 165.5 200 1017.9 31.9

12

UN

MES

H 20

15

Result contd.• Design Efficiency of both the fan: 74.53%

• Both fan operating

FD Fan-A 28.3% to 41.9%

FD Fan-B 34. 8% to 47.6%

• Single fan operating (FD Fan-A) 30% to 35%

13

UN

MES

H 20

15

Remedial suggestions

• Design modifications by consulting with the manufacturer or some consulting engineering firms.

• Use of Variable Frequency Drives(VFDs)

• Use of fluid coupling with variable speed

14

UN

MES

H 20

15

Conclusion• The capacity of the FD Fan was considerably higher than required.

• The FD fans operated within a low power output area over a long period of time, thereby increasing power consumption and increasing costs of operating the unit.

• Constant speed of the motor creates inefficient operation.

• Use of dampers to control the air flow is a inefficient manner of flow control.

• Modification in the design of the fan, use of use of Variable Speed Drives (VFDs), use of fluid coupling with variable speed are some corrective measures for improvement.

15

UN

MES

H 20

15

Thank You