Top Banner
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA STATE OF TEXAS, : : Plaintiff, : vs. : Docket No. CA 11-1303 : UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and : Washington, D.C. ERIC H. HOLDER, in his official : Wednesday, January 25, 2012 capacity as Attorney General of : 9:05 a.m. the United States : Day Seven : Defendants, and : : Wendy Davis, et al., : : Intervenor-Defendants : ---------------------------------x A.M. SESSION TRANSCRIPT OF BENCH TRIAL BEFORE THE HONORABLES ROSEMARY M. COLLYER and BERYL A. HOWELL UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGES APPEARANCES: For the Plaintiff: ADAM K. MORTARA, Esquire REED CLAY, Esquire JOHN M. HUGHES, Esquire ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610 STACEY NAPIER, Esquire ANGELA V. COLMENERO, Esquire MATTHEW H. FREDERICK, Esquire Office of Attorney General of Texas P.O. Box 12548 Austin, TX 78711-2548 Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 1 of 59
59

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

Jun 18, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

STATE OF TEXAS, :

:

Plaintiff, :

vs. : Docket No. CA 11-1303

:

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and : Washington, D.C.

ERIC H. HOLDER, in his official : Wednesday, January 25, 2012

capacity as Attorney General of : 9:05 a.m.

the United States : Day Seven

:

Defendants, and :

:

Wendy Davis, et al., :

:

Intervenor-Defendants :

---------------------------------x

A.M. SESSION

TRANSCRIPT OF BENCH TRIAL

BEFORE THE HONORABLES

ROSEMARY M. COLLYER and BERYL A. HOWELL

UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGES

APPEARANCES:

For the Plaintiff: ADAM K. MORTARA, Esquire

REED CLAY, Esquire

JOHN M. HUGHES, Esquire

ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire

Bartlit Beck Herman

Palenchar & Scott LLP

Courthouse Place

54 West Hubbard Street

Chicago, IL 60610

STACEY NAPIER, Esquire

ANGELA V. COLMENERO, Esquire

MATTHEW H. FREDERICK, Esquire

Office of Attorney General of Texas

P.O. Box 12548

Austin, TX 78711-2548

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 1 of 59

Page 2: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

Appearances continued:

For the Defendants: DANIEL J. FREEMAN, Esquire

TIMOTHY F. MELLETT, Esquire

BRYAN L. SELLS, Esquire

U.S. Department of Justice

950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Washington, DC 20530

For Intervenor JOHN K. TANNER, Esquire

Defendant: 3743 Military Road, NW

Washington, DC 20015

NINA PERALES, Esquire

REBECCA M. COUTO, Esquire

Mexican American Legal

Defense & Educational Fund, Inc.

110 Broadway Suite 300

San Antonio, TX 78205

JOSE GARZA, Esquire

Law Office of Jose Garza

7414 Robin Rest Drive

San Antonio, TX 98209

JOHN M. DEVANEY, Esquire

Perkins Coie LLP

700 Thirteenth Street NW

Suite 600

Washington, DC 20005-3960

JOSEPH GERALD HEBERT, Esquire

J. Gerald Hebert, P.C.

191 Somervelle Street,

Suite 405

Alexandria, VA 22304

CHAD W. DUNN, Esquire

Brazil & Dunn

4201 FM 1960 West

Suite 530

Houston, Texas 77068

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 2 of 59

Page 3: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

3

1

2 Appearances continued:

3 For Movant: LUIS ROBERTO VERA, Jr.

Law Offices of Luis

4 Robertovera, Jr. & Associates

Riverview Towers Building

5 111 Soledad, Suite 1325

San Antonio, TX 78205-2260

6

7 Court Reporter: CRYSTAL M. PILGRIM, RPR

Official Court Reporter

8 United States District Court

District of Columbia

9 333 Constitution Avenue, NW

Washington, DC 20001

10

Proceedings recorded by machine shorthand, transcript produced

11 by computer-aided transcription.

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 3 of 59

Page 4: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

4

1

2 JUDGE COLLYER: Call the case first.

3 THE DEPUTY CLERK: Yes, Your Honor.

4 Civil action 11-303, State of Texas versus United States

5 of America, et al.

6 For the plaintiffs Adam Mortara, Reed Clay, John Hughes,

7 Stacey Napier, Angela Colmenero, Matthew Frederick and Ashley

8 Keller.

9 For the defense, Daniel Friedman, Timothy Mellett, and

10 Bryan Sells.

11 For the Intervenor Defendant, Gerald Hebert, John

12 Devaney, John Tanner, Nina Perales, Luis Vera and Chad Dunn.

13 JUDGE COLLYER: I'm sorry, Mr. Mortara, I made you

14 sit down.

15 What is it, sir?

16 MR. MORTARA: My apologies. I wanted to give you an

17 update on the designation process.

18 We have an issue if the Court decides it would create

19 more or less work. We received a number of designations last

20 night, absolutely a large number.

21 Defendants are designating large portions of transcripts

22 from witnesses who have appeared at trial, including their own

23 witnesses. So for example. The Justice Department they have --

24 JUDGE COLLYER: Fair enough, I understood -- come to

25 the mic please.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 4 of 59

Page 5: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

5

1 MR. MORTARA: The defendants are designating large

2 portions of transcripts from witnesses that have appeared at

3 trial including their own witnesses.

4 So for example, the Justice Department I think has

5 designated Representative Coleman's deposition and there's

6 large portions of designations of their own witnesses.

7 As I understood the federal rules, you can designate the

8 deposition of a witness who is available. So they've been here

9 and testified.

10 JUDGE COLLYER: But everybody has been here and

11 testified minimally. I mean, I thought that -- I don't know

12 what anybody thought -- but I thought we were limiting

13 testimony such as not putting on direct and only cross and

14 stuff like that so that we would hit the highlights for purpose

15 of the trial but that would not preclude additional evidence.

16 Is that not correct? Is that what everybody else

17 thought?

18 MR. GARZA: Yes, Your Honor.

19 MR. HEBERT: Yes.

20 JUDGE COLLYER: Mr. Mortara, I don't want to have I

21 caught unawares again, but I thought that's how we were setting

22 this up.

23 MR. MORTARA: The only thing that is catching us

24 unaware is with the scope of eliminations of the examinations

25 that took place in Court.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 5 of 59

Page 6: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

6

1 But with that understanding we will counter designate

2 the depositions as they're designated and move forward. We

3 understand the scope of the project is very large. But we will

4 endeavor to get it done by Thursday.

5 JUDGE COLLYER: The benefit that you have is that

6 apparently it's all my fault. So when everybody is working

7 hard you can just say oh, that Judge. Make you feel better.

8 MR. MORTARA: We do not say that, Your Honor.

9 JUDGE COLLYER: No, I'm sure you say things that are

10 stronger.

11 MR. MORTARA: We say oh, those defendants and their

12 designations. We will continue to complete the project.

13 We are working back at the office right now. You will

14 see some of my colleagues are not here today, they are working

15 diligently on the counter designation project. In sum, the

16 defendants have designated large portions of transcripts to

17 expert which I understood that some Courts do not like, but

18 given Your Honor's statements --

19 JUDGE COLLYER: The problem that we have and if you

20 guys had to go back and repeat portions of this in San Antonio,

21 the San Antonio Court will find itself with the same problem.

22 That is that the information presented in both courts are

23 relevant to what each of us is dealing with. Therefore, it's

24 hard to say things presented that don't come in here at all. I

25 just don't want to have to read it all. So that's why you need

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 6 of 59

Page 7: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

7

1 to designate.

2 It's also hard given the limited time we've been able to

3 offer for trial and clearly this matter could have taken a

4 month trial if we'd all had a month to give it, you know. In

5 the normal course of trial this would at least be a month trial

6 which you have basically done so far in what, we say four and a

7 half days, how's that. And you've got another day and a half

8 if you're lucky, that's pretty good for a month trial.

9 So I'm going to be pretty generous in what can be

10 designated. I don't want people to over-designate because

11 you're killing us. I mean, we have got to read what you

12 designate and you're killing us. We spend as much time in

13 court as you do and we have other jobs, we're not actually

14 entirely concentrated on this one case, that's really

15 astonishing but it's true. And so it's killing us, but we're

16 going to do the best we can and get it all read and get it all

17 assimilated and get it decided as fast as we can to be of use

18 to all of you and more importantly, the citizens of the State

19 of Texas.

20 MR. MORTARA: Your Honor, we thank you.

21 I would like to just apprise you that the volume of

22 designated material is astounding.

23 JUDGE COLLYER: Well, it has to be less than 18,000

24 pages.

25 MR. MORTARA: For a deposition transcript pages it

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 7 of 59

Page 8: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

8

1 will be in the thousands I'm sure.

2 JUDGE COLLYER: Well, the thousand and 18,000, you

3 know, it is what it is and we will do what we do and we will do

4 the best that we can do just as you are.

5 MR. MORTARA: Thank you, Your Honor.

6 JUDGE COLLYER: That's all that all of us can say.

7 MR. MELLETT: Thank you, Your Honor.

8 JUDGE COLLYER: Okay. Now we're going to go with

9 much greater attention with time today. We wasted a lot of

10 time yesterday in my humble opinion. We're not going to do

11 that today.

12 If anybody starts asking questions and wondering away

13 from anything either Judge Howell or I feels like we need to

14 know, we're going to say stop, go to something else. We don't

15 have time, okay. All right.

16 Ms. Perales, are you up?

17 MS. PERALES: I am, Your Honor.

18 JUDGE COLLYER: Who's on the stand?

19 MS. PERALES: Dr. Alford is on the stand.

20 JUDGE COLLYER: I thought so.

21 Dr. Alford, can you come forward. We'll have you sworn

22 again since it's a new day.

23 We're going to be breaking at ten because I have a

24 criminal matter.

25 I will say that I have witnesses sworn every day in all

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 8 of 59

Page 9: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

9

1 trials not because I question your ability to remember that you

2 swore to tell the truth yesterday, but because in a criminal

3 trial I like to have cooperators sworn every time they stand up

4 to testify. And once you've done that to one witness you

5 really have to do it to all or else you send a signal to the

6 jury. Follow that.

7 You don't do criminal work very often do you?

8 MR. MORTARA: No.

9 JUDGE COLLYER: Go right ahead, Ms. White.

10 PLAINTIFF WITNESS JOHN ALFORD, Ph.D SWORN

11 MS. PERALES: Your Honor, before I resume my

12 questioning of Dr. Alford, I wanted to make one short mention.

13 Yesterday when describing the districts that we thought

14 were important to look at for retrogression, I omitted District

15 117 in the House. It is in my trial brief and we do have

16 evidence on it. I just forgot to mention it yesterday.

17 JUDGE COLLYER: Well, we needed it. We needed more

18 to study, so I'm glad you mentioned it.

19 MS. PERALES: Sorry, Your Honor, it's only one more

20 District.

21 JUDGE COLLYER: Oh, it's only one more.

22 THE WITNESS: And it's in my table.

23 MS. PERALES: It is.

24 JUDGE COLLYER: Go ahead.

25 MS. PERALES: Thank you, Your Honor.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 9 of 59

Page 10: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

10

1 CROSS EXAMINATION (Continued.)

2 BY MS. PERALES:

3 Q. Dr. Alford, I'd like to talk to you for a couple of

4 minutes about the elections that you refer to as the OAG 10 in

5 your analysis and I'm showing on the screen Exhibit 801,

6 Defense Exhibit 801. This is page 9 of your pre-filed direct.

7 Do you recognize this table of the 10 elections used in the

8 index of the Attorney General?

9 A. Yes.

10 Q. And this set of elections was in fact 10 elections, yes?

11 A. Yes.

12 Q. And they span the years, election years 2002 to 2010,

13 correct?

14 A. That's correct.

15 Q. And they do include multiple races for each election year,

16 yes?

17 A. I believe there's just a single race for 2002.

18 Q. And then otherwise, multiple races for each year?

19 A. Otherwise, multiple races for each year.

20 Q. It appears that these are statewide races that go down as

21 low as the Court of Criminal Appeals in Texas, correct?

22 A. That's correct.

23 Q. And if you can let the Court know whether the Court of

24 Criminal Appeals is elected statewide?

25 A. Elected statewide, fairly far down the ballot.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 10 of 59

Page 11: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

11

1 Q. But it's above all of the district races is it?

2 A. It is a statewide race.

3 Q. And you stated earlier in this case that you would prefer

4 to conduct your analysis on more than ten elections if you

5 could. I believe you said that on the stand yesterday, yes?

6 A. Yes.

7 Q. And you don't know how this list of ten elections was

8 selected by the Attorney General's Office, do you?

9 A. You can see something by, I can infer something by looking

10 at it, but I was not involved in the selection, so I don't know

11 what that discussion was.

12 Q. Thank you, I don't want you to infer. I understand that

13 you were not involved in the selection.

14 You agree with me in your deposition that this list is

15 missing a race from 2008, that's a race for Judge of the Court

16 of Criminal Appeals place 4 featuring candidate Molina,

17 correct?

18 A. Yes.

19 Q. Were you aware that this list is also missing a race in

20 2006? It was a Supreme Court race featuring candidate Madina?

21 A. Yes.

22 Q. Are you aware that this list, given the perimeters of this

23 list that it goes back to 2002 under its own criteria is

24 missing three additional races from 2002; two races for Justice

25 of the Supreme Court and one race for the Court of Criminal

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 11 of 59

Page 12: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

12

1 Appeals. Those all featured racially contested?

2 A. I wasn't aware that there were three missing races from

3 2002. I was aware there was one missing, but if you assert

4 that.

5 So again, as I said in looking at the list I'm assuming

6 that this is a list that works from the top of the ballot down,

7 and the race here is discussing below these races on the

8 ballot.

9 Q. But there is Court of Criminal Appeals, these years under

10 this OAG criteria this list would go down as far as the Court

11 of Criminal Appeals and yet it omit 2002 Justice of the Supreme

12 Court with Linda Yanez as a candidate 2002; Justice of the

13 Supreme Court with Margaret Neala as a candidate in 2002.

14 Justice of the Supreme Court with Margaret Neala as a

15 candidate. In 2002 Judge Court of Criminal Appeals with Jala

16 Molina?

17 A. I'm not sure about the meters already split, doesn't have

18 any distinction about 2002. I mean, about the 2002.

19 JUDGE HOWELL: Could I interrupt?

20 Could you have been talking about the placement on the

21 ballot? Would you explain what importance that has in the

22 consideration of the selection of these races?

23 THE WITNESS: Generally, in doing this sort of index

24 you say white races, you typically like races that are higher

25 on the ballot rather than lower.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 12 of 59

Page 13: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

13

1 JUDGE HOWELL: Higher on the ballot for the race you

2 are studying? What do you mean higher, could you explain?

3 THE WITNESS: I'll assume. We do so much of this

4 work that it's obvious to us.

5 JUDGE HOWELL: We need it obviously on the record.

6 THE WITNESS: A race like the governor's race will

7 appear very near the top of the ballot. The governor's race,

8 presidential race, U.S. Senate race, then the ballot order

9 moves down as roughly as the importance of the office moves

10 down and I don't mean to slight the Court, but the Court races

11 are below the race for example, of the railroad commissioner.

12 So the higher a race is on the ballot order, the more

13 likely it is that individuals will make, will both vote in that

14 so there's people don't, often don't vote down ballot. It's

15 very common for people at some point in the ballot as long as

16 Texas' ballot to start making individual decisions and start

17 making party decisions.

18 For that reason, if we were going to select a race 2002,

19 the reason 2002 is in everybody's index if you are going to go

20 back the full decade is that's the highest race on the ballot

21 and the one most likely to have voters actually paying

22 attention to the candidates as opposed to the parties.

23 BY MS. PERALES:

24 Q. Dr. Alford, just so we can be especially clear for the

25 Court. The top race on the ballot in the presidential year

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 13 of 59

Page 14: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

14

1 would be federal race, yes for president and vice-president?

2 A. Yes, so if you are interested in, if you are interested --

3 JUDGE COLLYER: That's okay, yes was the answer.

4 THE WITNESS: Yes.

5 BY MS. PERALES:

6 Q. Thank you, doctor.

7 And then below that would be a federal race for U.S.

8 Congress because everybody lives in a Congressional District,

9 right?

10 A. There's no -- we stopped electing congressman statewide.

11 Q. Right. So what I'm asking about is the ballot order.

12 When the voter in Texas encounters his or her ballot in a

13 presidential year in a general election, we would see

14 president, vice-president, we would also see a race for

15 Congress, yes?

16 A. Right. In some years a Senate race, then a congressional

17 race.

18 JUDGE COLLYER: The federal vacancies come before

19 state vacancies, is that what you're saying?

20 MS. PERALES: Yes, Your Honor.

21 JUDGE COLLYER: So all federal vacancies come before

22 the governor?

23 MS. PERALES: Yes, Your Honor.

24 JUDGE COLLYER: Thank you.

25 BY MS. PERALES:

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 14 of 59

Page 15: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

15

1 Q. Immediately following would be the statewide race in Texas

2 immediately following whatever is up for federal we would see

3 governor, see lieutenant governor and also see statewide races

4 for railroad commissioner and the Supreme Court and the Court

5 of Criminal Appeals, correct?

6 A. Yes.

7 Q. Thank you.

8 Now you agreed with me in your deposition that including

9 all three elections from 2010 that were racially contested, but

10 only including two of the three racially contested in 2008

11 could skew the analysis towards 2010, didn't you?

12 A. Yes.

13 Q. All right. And it's your opinion that, and I'm quoting

14 now, one ought not to narrow an index down any more than you

15 have to and you think all of these indexes are far more narrow

16 than they need to be?

17 A. Yes. Again, my index was 48 elections, ten elections is

18 better than five, but for the purposes of making sure that it

19 didn't matter which index was used and that we used the index

20 that the Department of Justice expert used and the index that

21 the State used these indexes are in there.

22 Q. You testified that the OAG 10 or this 10 election index is

23 not only not your product, but that you haven't spent any time

24 analyzing it and undoubtedly, it could be increased, yes?

25 A. Yes.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 15 of 59

Page 16: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

16

1 Q. You testified that you don't know of any social science

2 justification for choosing the 10 elections in the OAG 10,

3 correct?

4 A. Correct.

5 Q. And you don't know why the Attorney General's Office

6 omitted the 2008 race for the Court of Criminal Appeals in its

7 index, correct?

8 A. Correct.

9 Q. And you also don't know why the Attorney General's Office

10 omitted the 2006 race that we mentioned or the three 2002

11 races, correct, within your personal knowledge?

12 A. Correct.

13 Q. Given that you didn't choose these ten elections you can't

14 explain why for example, this index doesn't include all 15

15 races that met the criteria you discussed before, racially

16 contested within this time period, Court of Appeals or higher,

17 correct?

18 A. I have always assumed that they wanted to use ten. But I

19 don't know that that was the reason they stopped at ten.

20 JUDGE COLLYER: I already got the answer to that

21 question. Keep moving.

22 MS. PERALES: Thank you, Your Honor.

23 BY MS. PERALES:

24 Q. We talked briefly, Dr. Alford, about your discussion that

25 117 in the House although it was not included in, although it

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 16 of 59

Page 17: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

17

1 decreased in performance I guess is the best way to put it in

2 the State's version of the House plan, you testified that you

3 thought that House District 117 met the Court's bright line

4 criteria for an ability to elect district because it had 60

5 percent citizen voting age population.

6 Do you recall our conversation about that in your

7 deposition?

8 A. Yes.

9 Q. Now if we just used that 60 percent bright line test

10 citizen voting age population you would agree with me wouldn't

11 you that if we just counted those in the benchmark plan and

12 State's plan that they are 25 in the ability to elect in the

13 benchmark and only 21 left an ability to elect in the State's

14 plan, correct?

15 A. So again, we are going back to district county.

16 Q. Uh-hmm?

17 A. And we're putting 117 back in. So that would produce that

18 result.

19 Q. Okay. And you didn't do an analysis to compare the

20 benchmark to the adopted did you to see whether there was a

21 reduction in the number of 60 percent plus HCVAP districts did

22 you?

23 A. I'm sorry, I don't --

24 Q. Do you need me to repeat the question?

25 A. Please.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 17 of 59

Page 18: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

18

1 Q. You didn't do an analysis did you to compare the benchmark

2 to the adopted to see whether there was a reduction in the

3 number of 60 percent plus HCVAP districts, did you?

4 A. No. I took the Court to be setting an upper limit, not an

5 lower limit.

6 Q. You didn't look to see the relative number of districts

7 that have 65 percent or greater Hispanic citizen voting age

8 population to see whether just using that sole criteria the

9 State's plan retrogressed, correct?

10 A. Again, I didn't think the Court was setting the kind of

11 bright line population center that the State attempted to use

12 before. I assumed they were setting an upper limit.

13 Q. Also if we are still district counting, and we are using

14 exogenous elections now instead of a population cut off. And

15 where the cut line would be whether the Hispanic preferred

16 candidate is winning more than half the time, you do agree with

17 me that Dr. Handley's analysis shows that 32 districts in the

18 benchmark and 31 in the adopted, correct?

19 A. I'm not sure about the exact numbers at this point. You

20 know, that's not my approach.

21 I think I made it very clear I don't believe that's either

22 helpful or appropriate.

23 Q. I understand.

24 A. If that's how the numbers add up, then that's how the

25 numbers add up.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 18 of 59

Page 19: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

19

1 Q. We did go over it in your January 11th deposition, Dr.

2 Alford, at pages 121 and 122.

3 Do you recall saying that sounds correct because I think

4 that's basically what I actually say in the text of the report,

5 do you remember that?

6 A. Okay, then I think that's basically correct because

7 according to your research that's what I say in the report.

8 Q. I would like to get to District 117 where you said that --

9 JUDGE COLLYER: Wait. If I understand, what you mean

10 is that it's basically correct to say that if you use the

11 criterion used by Dr. Handley, there would be 32 such districts

12 in the benchmark and 31 in the plan as adopted, but you don't

13 think that's the right analysis?

14 THE WITNESS: This would be so simple if I just

15 thought that was the right analysis. But I think it's not.

16 JUDGE COLLYER: Good. I just want to make sure I got

17 it.

18 Thank you.

19 BY MS. PERALES:

20 Q. Dr. Alford, let us now talk about District 117. After you

21 discussed the fact that Dr. Handley finds one less district in

22 the new plan in the State's plan compared to the benchmark for

23 the Texas House, you said but we should look at District 117

24 because it's over 60 percent HCVAP and under the Court's bright

25 line test, it should be elevated to an ability to elect

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 19 of 59

Page 20: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

20

1 district, do you recall that?

2 A. Yes.

3 Q. That's at page 4 of your pre-filed direct?

4 A. Yes.

5 Q. You and I had a discussion about this and you felt very

6 sure that the Court's bright line test as set out was 60

7 percent?

8 A. Yes.

9 Q. I asked you if the Court's bright line test was in fact 65

10 percent whether District 117 would meet that standard.

11 Do you recall that?

12 A. Yes.

13 Q. And you recall agreeing with me that if the standard is 65

14 percent HCVAP, then your elevation of District 117 is not

15 correct because 117 is below 65 percent HCVAP, yes?

16 A. Yes.

17 MS. PERALES: Your Honor --

18 JUDGE COLLYER: Actually, all that means is that it's

19 not an ability district based on that sole criterion. It

20 doesn't mean it's not an ability district.

21 MS. PERALES: That's correct, Your Honor.

22 JUDGE COLLYER: Okay, I just wanted to make sure.

23 MS. PERALES: We were simply discussing that small

24 portion of his report.

25 Your Honor, in the interest of time, I would like to

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 20 of 59

Page 21: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

21

1 designate as opposed to asking questions of Dr. Alford

2 regarding Congress and the mapping of Congress and the South

3 Texas configuration that his testimony from the Perez trial and

4 we do believe that it is important testimony and what we'd like

5 to do is designate that from the Perez record for the Court

6 instead of questioning Dr. Alford about it.

7 JUDGE COLLYER: That would be fine.

8 MS. PERALES: I pass the witness, Your Honor.

9 MR. DEVANEY: Good morning, Your Honors.

10 JUDGE COLLYER: Good morning.

11 MR. DEVANEY: Good morning, Dr. Alford.

12 JUDGE COLLYER: Could you state your name?

13 MR. DEVANEY: John Devaney, I represent the Gonzalez

14 Intervenors.

15 JUDGE COLLYER: Thank you, sir.

16 CROSS EXAMINATION

17 BY MR. DEVANEY:

18 Q. Dr. Alford, I'm focusing on the congressional plan. You

19 would agree with me that on the benchmark plan Congressional

20 District 25 was a district in which blacks and Hispanics were

21 able to elect the candidates of their choice in general

22 elections, correct?

23 A. Yes.

24 Q. And even though District 25 is an ability district, you

25 did not include it in your statewide functional analysis; is

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 21 of 59

Page 22: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

22

1 that correct?

2 A. Yes.

3 Q. And you agree that plan C 185 eliminates CD 25, correct?

4 A. That is correct.

5 Q. And you also agree that there is indeed racial cohesion

6 between blacks and Hispanics in general elections in

7 Congressional District 25, correct?

8 A. Yes, there is.

9 Q. And I think that you stated in your direct testimony filed

10 last week that in your view there's not racial cohesion in

11 Texas between blacks and Hispanics in primaries; is that a fair

12 summary?

13 A. Yes.

14 By that I mean in Texas as a whole and in any of the

15 individual districts or counties that I looked at in Texas.

16 Q. Very well?

17 A. Or that I've ever seen anyone else look at.

18 Q. Very well.

19 And I want to show you an excerpt from your report. Your

20 report for the record is Exhibit P 175.

21 JUDGE COLLYER: This is his first report?

22 MR. DEVANEY: This is the pre-filed direct testimony

23 that was filed on January 17th.

24 THE WITNESS: I believe this appears as an attachment

25 both to the report that supplemented the direct testimony.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 22 of 59

Page 23: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

23

1 BY MR. DEVANEY:

2 Q. I'll see if I can get this full page in view, it's kind of

3 hard. But in any event, these are the only primaries that you

4 considered for your conclusion that there is not racial

5 cohesion in primaries; is that correct?

6 A. That's correct.

7 Q. These are all statewide primary elections that you've

8 used; is that correct?

9 A. That's correct.

10 Q. By the way, let me back up for a second.

11 CD 25 on the benchmark plan encompasses Travis County; is

12 that correct?

13 A. That's correct.

14 Q. And you didn't conduct any analysis of primaries in Travis

15 County, did you?

16 A. On there, yes, there were analysis of Travis County

17 primaries in the San Antonio case.

18 Q. I know, but in this case you have not presented any

19 analysis of primaries in Travis County; is that right?

20 A. That's correct.

21 Q. And in fact, in offering your opinion that there's not

22 racial cohesion in primaries, you didn't even look at the

23 primaries for Congressional District 25, did you?

24 A. I didn't present the primaries for Congressional 25. I

25 don't know whether I've ever seen analysis of them or not. All

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 23 of 59

Page 24: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

24

1 I can say is that I think I may have at some point.

2 Q. My only question is you didn't perform analysis in this

3 case of the primaries Congressional District 25; is that

4 correct?

5 A. I'm just trying to be careful because I don't want to

6 suggest that I haven't in fact had that analysis before and

7 looked at it. I think that's very possible in the compass of

8 this case that I actually asked for that and had that

9 performed.

10 And I stand by my statement that I've never seen an

11 analysis in which there's cohesion between blacks and Hispanics

12 in the democratic primaries in Texas. So I just don't want to,

13 I want to be straight forward. I'm not certain and I certainly

14 didn't produce it here, but I may very well have seen it.

15 Q. Well, I asked you in your deposition on that wonderful

16 Sunday morning we had a few days ago whether you had conducted

17 an analysis of primaries in Congressional District 25, and you

18 said, this is page 184, lines 17 through 20, I did not look at

19 the primary for Congressional District 25 in this analysis, no.

20 Is that correct?

21 A. Yes. And again, in this analysis I'm not looking at CD

22 25.

23 I thought you asked me a different question whether I had

24 ever done or had that done or seen it.

25 Q. I think we have straightened it out?

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 24 of 59

Page 25: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

25

1 A. Good.

2 Q. Thank you.

3 Am I also right that you only included primaries in your

4 analysis in which minority candidates were elected?

5 A. I did not look at the election of minority candidates.

6 Q. Did you include any primaries in your analysis where

7 Anglos were elected and won the primary?

8 A. I did not look at the elections. I included the primaries

9 based on the primaries as we were dealing with exogenous

10 election analysis. I included the primaries based on the

11 presence of minority candidates and primary, not on the basis

12 of who won the primary.

13 Q. Very well. Once again, looking at table C 2 of your

14 testimony. I'm going to zero in. This won't show the whole

15 page, but it will at least show the heading and percentages I

16 want to ask you about.

17 You'll see the heading says ecological inference estimates

18 of voter cohesion in benchmark Congressional District 25?

19 JUDGE COLLYER: That is not in view.

20 Thank you.

21 MR. DEVANEY: Sorry about that.

22 JUDGE COLLYER: It's okay.

23 BY MR. DEVANEY:

24 Q. Then you list different racial groups with percentages

25 beneath them, correct?

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 25 of 59

Page 26: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

26

1 A. Correct.

2 Q. Those percentages represent your estimate of the

3 percentage of voters in each racial category who voted for the

4 list of candidates in the primary; is that right?

5 A. That's right.

6 Q. I think you may have testified to this, and I apologize if

7 you have. I want to make sure that the record is clear.

8 It is commonly accepted practice of social science analysis

9 of samples to provide a standard error of confidence intervals;

10 is that right?

11 A. Yes.

12 Q. And that's because when you're using a sample instead of

13 the whole universe necessarily there's going to be some margin

14 of error, right?

15 A. Correct.

16 Q. So when we look at TV and watch polling results from

17 elections and forecast of what is going to happen in elections,

18 we always see there's a margin of error of five, six or seven

19 percent or something like that, right?

20 A. Correct.

21 Q. And you have not reported in your analysis of racial

22 cohesion any margin of error or any confidence interval; is

23 that right?

24 A. That's correct.

25 Q. So you are using the example, the sample you always do

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 26 of 59

Page 27: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

27

1 that these are not samples.

2 A. There's a margin of error associated with these estimates

3 because they are ecological estimates. But these are not

4 samples. These are the actual all of the precincts and the

5 primary totaled up.

6 Q. But there is a margin of error, correct, in your estimate?

7 A. Yes, there's a different method, but a different method,

8 but a method for developing a margin of error.

9 Q. It is correct that you have not reported a confidence

10 interval or a margin of error for your analysis; is that right?

11 A. Yes. I had not looked at that carefully and what was

12 actually in the table and what wasn't.

13 So you reminded me in the deposition of that and I went

14 back and looked at the margin of error and they don't change my

15 conclusions at all.

16 Q. But we don't know how much of these percentages you

17 provided actually might vary because you have not provided us

18 with a margin of error or confidence intervals; is that

19 correct?

20 A. Yes and again as I explained to you, if you're concerned

21 with how confident you are about a single result that could be

22 helpful. If you look across a set of eight primaries and you

23 see exactly the same result in every primary, it really doesn't

24 matter what the individual confidence intervals are.

25 The confidence intervals say if this is done randomly then

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 27 of 59

Page 28: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

28

1 we shouldn't look at one result and be too confident. But if

2 you see the same result seven out of eight times, that's really

3 a different confidence interval. Random variation doesn't

4 produce the same result eight out of ten times.

5 You asked me why I was confident without knowing the

6 confidence intervals and that's why because we're not looking

7 at a single. Look at all of the districts, right. It doesn't

8 matter where we go in the State.

9 JUDGE COLLYER: That's fine.

10 BY MR. DEVANEY:

11 Q. You know a lot more about this than I do. I'm trying to

12 simplify it.

13 I see for example 28 percent here, one of your figures that

14 you listed. For all we know that could be 40 percent or it

15 could be 19 percent. We just don't know because you haven't

16 given us a confidence interval, right?

17 A. And the way we --

18 Q. That's all I needed. Thank you.

19 Are you familiar with ACS data?

20 A. Yes.

21 Q. Tell us what ACS data are?

22 A. This is a survey developed by the census to replace the

23 long form in the U.S. census. The long form was last used in

24 2000. So now there's a short form and there is a survey.

25 The survey is done on a continuous basis whereas the long

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 28 of 59

Page 29: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

29

1 form was only done once every ten years like the census itself.

2 Q. And as I understand it a new ACS data has just been

3 released within the last month or two for Texas?

4 A. Yes. I believe in December the 2010 ACS numbers as well

5 as the 2006, 2010 rolling average or center average was

6 released, I'm sorry.

7 Q. The new ACS data show a growth in Hispanic population in

8 Texas; isn't that correct?

9 A. Yes.

10 Q. And in fact, it's a growth of at least tens of thousands

11 of Hispanic citizens and perhaps more than that, correct?

12 A. Well, the Hispanic population is growing throughout the

13 decades. So presumably that would be reflected as we move

14 forward. As we continue to move that number forward.

15 Ultimately the best number for that will be provided when

16 we get the, so the new index is centered on 2008. A year from

17 now we get 2009. A year from then we get 2010 and we'll be

18 ready for a new district.

19 Q. I understand that those new data are not refined to the

20 level that experts in this case have been able to incorporate

21 the data into their conclusions. Right?

22 A. Yes.

23 Q. But when you talk about using a bright line test, isn't it

24 a bit risky to use a bright line test that's based on old data

25 that doesn't reflect perhaps hundreds of thousands of

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 29 of 59

Page 30: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

30

1 additional Hispanics?

2 A. Everybody seems to want me to criticize the Court's choice

3 on bright line test. So I will just say this.

4 Q. It is not a criticism of the Court at all, Dr. Alford.

5 It's just a comment and question about bright line tests and

6 some of the risks inherent in them because of the significant

7 Hispanic growth that's not reflected in the data you are using

8 in your analysis?

9 A. Okay. I as a general rule do not like bright line tests

10 unless they actually mean something.

11 In this case, it doesn't necessarily mean something, and

12 that's the reason why District 117 is in my analysis. District

13 117 is not excluded from my table of the ten districts that at

14 hand here.

15 Q. I'm talking about the Congressional plan, that's all.

16 A. Oh, it's not included in my analysis of the Congressional

17 plan. District 117.

18 MR. DEVANEY: I don't think we are going to reach

19 agreement on this particular issue, so I'll pass the witness

20 and I thank you for your time.

21 THE WITNESS: Thank you.

22 MR. HEBERT: Gerald Hebert for the Davis intervenors,

23 and I just have a few minutes of questions, Your Honors.

24 CROSS EXAMINATION

25 BY MR. HEBERT:

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 30 of 59

Page 31: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

31

1 Q. Dr. Alford, good morning.

2 A. Good morning.

3 Q. You have used the term endogenous and exogenous election,

4 correct?

5 A. Yes.

6 Q. You did examine one -- an endogenous election is an

7 election within the district itself, correct?

8 A. Again, to try to make things as comparable across reports,

9 we are using that terminology, it's a widely used terminology,

10 I think it's an unfortunate one.

11 JUDGE COLLYER: Could you just answer the question?

12 Endogenous means within the district, right? Within the

13 district.

14 Within the district, what are we talking about?

15 THE WITNESS: It does not.

16 JUDGE COLLYER: What does it mean?

17 THE WITNESS: In this case, it means what's often

18 called the election on all fours. It means the actual election

19 in dispute in the case.

20 So endogenous elections say in the Texas House would be

21 an election 4 that for a seat in the Texas House. See the

22 issue of course is that the reconstituted election analysis

23 also those are our elections in the geography's district.

24 JUDGE COLLYER: Yes, I understand that.

25 Did you get an answer?

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 31 of 59

Page 32: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

32

1 MR. HEBERT: Yes, I did I think.

2 BY MR. HEBERT:

3 Q. So an endogenous election with regard to the Senate plan

4 that's at issue here would be elections for Senate District 10,

5 would you agree with that?

6 A. Yes.

7 Q. Okay, that's what I was trying to get at.

8 Now you did examine that endogenous election in Senate

9 District 10 for 2008, correct?

10 A. Correct.

11 Q. And you found consistent with Dr. Lichtman, the expert

12 witness for the Davis intervenors, you found that that election

13 was characterized by extreme racially polarized voting,

14 correct?

15 A. I don't believe I said it was characterized by extreme

16 racially polarized voting. I have seen no racial polorization

17 analysis anywhere else in this case or in San Antonio that ever

18 gets to be as extreme as Dr. Lichtman's analysis. We discussed

19 this before.

20 I'd be happy to comment on what I found in the race but I'm

21 not going to accept Dr. Lichtman's characterizations.

22 Q. I'm going to ask you about yours?

23 A. Thank you.

24 Q. You found that in that election black voters gave 99.6

25 percent of their vote to Senator Davis?

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 32 of 59

Page 33: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

33

1 A. Very cohesive black voting.

2 Q. And Dr. Lichtman found a hundred percent which was four

3 tenths of a point higher than you.

4 You found that Latinos gave 85.3 percent of their votes to

5 Davis, correct?

6 A. Correct.

7 Q. And you found that Anglos gave 25.8 percent of their vote

8 to Davis?

9 A. Correct.

10 Q. And you don't consider that extreme racially polarized

11 voting?

12 A. Again, polorization is a term that indicates that people

13 are polar opposite points. Anglos are voting differently than

14 Hispanics and blacks in that election. There's consequences

15 for the elections, but to characterize 25 percent crossover as

16 extreme polorization I think is inappropriate.

17 Q. But it is white bloc voting against the candidate of

18 choice in minorities; isn't it?

19 A. I'm sorry but to find something is white bloc voting is a

20 legal term, and I have seen core discussion in which they have

21 said surely if there was 25 percent crossover -- this is in the

22 context of coalition districts -- that wouldn't be considered

23 bloc voting, so that's a legal question. I'm just saying it's

24 not extreme polarization.

25 Q. There are also cases aren't there, doctor, that say less

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 33 of 59

Page 34: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

34

1 than that in terms of crossover voting or on rather more than

2 this in crossover voting still constitutes bloc voting?

3 A. Yes. I don't mean to disagree with you because I know we

4 agree about this.

5 It isn't exactly clear what that line is, so is it or is it

6 not bloc voting, that's a legal thing. I just don't think that

7 it's appropriate to characterize 25 percent as extreme

8 polarization because there are other places where we actually

9 have extreme polorization.

10 Q. So can we at least agree that there was racially polarized

11 voting in that election?

12 A. I think it was clearly characterized by a degree of

13 racially polarized voting which I think would make it difficult

14 for minorities to elect in that district under those

15 conditions.

16 JUDGE COLLYER: Wait, wait, wait.

17 It was shown a degree of racially polarized voting that

18 would make it difficult for minorities to elect, but they did.

19 What does your statement mean? It would make it

20 difficult for minorities to elect since they did elect?

21 THE WITNESS: It's an interesting question, isn't it?

22 JUDGE COLLYER: All right, never mind.

23 Go ahead.

24 BY MR. HEBERT:

25 Q. So Dr. Alford, you filed a report in the San Antonio

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 34 of 59

Page 35: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

35

1 litigation in the Senate case, the Section 2 Senate case, Case

2 Number 11-788, correct?

3 A. Correct.

4 Q. You found in that report that Senator Davis in getting 85

5 percent of the Latino vote in 2008 actually got 10 percent more

6 -- well, not really 10 percent -- the prior democratic

7 candidate running against Senator Brimer in 2004 only got 75

8 percent of the Latino vote. So her percentage of the vote was

9 a higher percentage of the Latino vote in 2008.

10 Do you remember finding that in that report?

11 A. I'm sorry?

12 Q. You don't have any reason to disagree with what I'm

13 saying?

14 A. I'll say my recollection was that the major difference in

15 Wendy Davis' election and the previous election was the degree,

16 the deciding factor there was not the degree of change in

17 voting by minorities.

18 It was clear that the deciding factor of what caused that

19 to be a victory was the much higher level of Anglo crossover.

20 The district is a majority Anglo district, something about a 63

21 percent majority Anglo district. In a district like that where

22 the Anglo number is very large and Hispanic number is small, a

23 small change in Hispanic doesn't make that difference.

24 The big change in Wendy Davis' election was that the Anglos

25 crossed over because there were so many more Anglos, she was

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 35 of 59

Page 36: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

36

1 elected on the basis of the Anglo crossover.

2 Q. You actually don't know that though do you? You don't

3 know that she got elected because of the more Anglo vote

4 because you didn't study the percent of voter turn out in the

5 district?

6 A. I did not look at the percent of voter turn out.

7 You asked me what I concluded in my report. I believe

8 that's what I concluded in my report.

9 Q. Right. I'm going to move on. But I think we agree that

10 you did not study the degree to which people turned out to

11 vote.

12 In order to know whether or not she got more white votes

13 than some other candidate, you would have to know what

14 percentage of whites turned out, what percentage of blacks

15 turned out and what percentage of Latinos turned out, correct?

16 A. That would be helpful.

17 Q. Now you have a statement in your pre-filed direct

18 testimony that states and it's in a footnote that Courts have

19 focused on endogenous elections, not reconstituted election

20 results in accessing liability under the Voting Rights Act,

21 correct? It's footnote 4 on page 18 of your report which is

22 Exhibit, Defendant's Exhibit 801.

23 A. So we're talking about Section 2 cases?

24 Q. I'm asking you about the footnote where your cite that

25 endogenous elections are used by Courts that have focused on

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 36 of 59

Page 37: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

37

1 those elections in accessing liability under the Gringles

2 factors?

3 A. Section 2, the Gringles factors.

4 Q. Are you aware of a court that has stated that exogenous

5 elections should be used in Section 5 cases to determine issues

6 of cohesion and bloc voting and ability to elect as opposed to

7 Section 2 cases, you're not aware of any, are you?

8 A. I mean, I just -- when plans are compared to each other as

9 Dr. Davis states, when you are comparing two plans to each

10 other when you are doing Section 5 you use exogenous elections.

11 When you're measuring, you put all of that together. When

12 you are measuring cohesion and polarization if you have an

13 endogenous election you can use endogenous elections. If you

14 are using cross claims you don't have the comparison, so you

15 don't.

16 I'm not arguing that endogenous is in all cases superior or

17 inferior. Endogenous elections might be superior in all cases,

18 but if you don't have endogenous elections to make the

19 comparison, you can't use them.

20 Q. But endogenous elections do reflect the actual voters in

21 the district and how they voted for the district at issue in

22 the case of Senate District 10, isn't that true? Can we agree

23 on that?

24 A. Only, there are two districts at issue. That is something

25 that you keep forgetting. There are two districts that are at

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 37 of 59

Page 38: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

38

1 issue here.

2 There is benchmark 10 and there is adopted 10 and there's

3 no endogenous analysis for adopted 10. The Court's job is to

4 compare, the Justice Department's job is to compare benchmark

5 to endogenous.

6 Endogenous tells us something about benchmark 10 but they

7 just don't provide us a comparison for adopted 10.

8 Q. They tell us whether or not District 10 reflected in 2008

9 that minority voters have the ability to elect their candidate

10 of choice, correct?

11 A. In the benchmark map.

12 Q. Endogenous election allow us to determine that minority

13 voters, black and Latinos elected the candidate of their choice

14 in Senate District 10 in 2008, correct?

15 A. I thought you said 2010. In 2010 they showed the exact

16 opposite as they do in every other election year in decade.

17 But in 2008 for only the endogenous election there is a

18 victory for the democratic candidate and therefore, the

19 candidate of choice of minorities.

20 Q. Now you did not review the intent or motivation behind any

21 of the plans at issue in this case, correct?

22 A. Correct.

23 Q. And you did not study within Senate District 10, you did

24 not conduct an election profile to determine things like the

25 get out the vote effort or building of a black Latino coalition

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 38 of 59

Page 39: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

39

1 or the money spent by the candidates or the issues that were at

2 play in 2008? You didn't study any of that, correct?

3 A. Within --

4 Q. Did you study any of that?

5 A. I didn't study any of it. I have heard lots of discussion

6 of it and I would agree entirely with your position.

7 I think here that this is an example that in the general

8 election this is an effort of where there is a cohesion of

9 democratic voters, Hispanic, black and Anglo to elect a

10 candidate of choice in that district. A candidate of choice,

11 the democrats in the district makes it the candidate of choice

12 given the numbers we talked about blacks and Hispanics.

13 Q. It's also true isn't it that if you take that ability to

14 elect away, that diminishes the voting strengths of blacks and

15 Latinos in that district; isn't that true?

16 A. You know, Gerry, you said that we were going to come to an

17 agreement. You are a pressing man and I couldn't agree with

18 you more, and that's why I think it's so important to count if

19 we could find, for example, if that was an exogenous election

20 so that we can compare it, that would count as a one and a one

21 is not a ten but it's a one and it should count.

22 Q. Thank you and I appreciate that.

23 A district that is drawn as a republican district at the

24 beginning of a decade can over time due to demographic change

25 produce a district in which minority voters can have the

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 39 of 59

Page 40: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

40

1 ability to elect a candidate of their choice, correct?

2 A. Correct and that's I think the 10, District 10 again we

3 can agree, District 10 was drawn with a notion that that was a

4 likely thing that might happen. I think we also agree that

5 what we, what we see by 2008 is some indication that there may

6 have been some progress, but I think we both would agree much

7 less progress either than we would have expected or as a person

8 might would have hoped.

9 Q. I have one final area to question here about, doctor.

10 If we could bring up Defendant's Exhibit 801 which I

11 believe is your pre-filed testimony on page 29. The previous

12 page, I'm sorry if you could page 28. Page 28 of the report

13 and page 29 of the filed document.

14 Thank you.

15 Now this is where your pre-filed report starts with the

16 discussion of the Senate and if we could bring up the first

17 paragraph of the Senate discussion in the text and enlarge that

18 for the witness and the Court.

19 Now you have a sentence in here and it's the first sentence

20 that I want to ask you about. You say that neither the

21 Department of Justice nor its expert Dr. Handley dispute that

22 the adopted Senate plan contains at least as many effective

23 minority districts as the benchmark plan.

24 Do you see that?

25 A. Yes.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 40 of 59

Page 41: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

41

1 Q. Did you write that?

2 A. Yes.

3 Q. This is from your pre-filed direct testimony. Did you,

4 were you the author of that or was that put in by counsel into

5 the report?

6 A. I, I drafted the entire section alone from House on. So I

7 mean, my recollection is that this would be my sentence. It

8 may be that, it may be that later in discussion -- I mean, this

9 is my -- again, all through the report I'm trying as closely as

10 possible to connect this to Dr. Handley's analysis, so I think,

11 I think it's my sentence. It certainly is my belief.

12 Q. Well, this suggests to me that Dr. Handley actually

13 analyzed the Senate plan and concluded that there were as many

14 effective districts in the benchmark plan as in the proposed

15 plan. But in fact, Dr. Handley didn't analyze a single set of

16 elections?

17 A. Maybe it was inartful of me. But I discussed the fact

18 that if we used Dr. Handley's, in the report I discussed the

19 fact that if we used Dr. Handley's methodology there's, just

20 isn't an issue.

21 So okay, I guess she's not, the fact that she's not

22 analyzing this and that her methodology shows clearly that the

23 Senate plan doesn't retrogress suggests to me that she's not

24 disputing.

25 Maybe I should have, maybe I'm over-interpreting the

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 41 of 59

Page 42: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

42

1 silence on the part of the Department of Justice expert, but I

2 thought their job was to dispute things if they thought they

3 retrogressed.

4 Q. But she did not conduct one scintilla of analysis of the

5 Senate plan or at the elections; isn't that true?

6 A. If she did not conduct one scintilla of analysis, then I

7 would have to believe given that she was a Department of

8 Justice expert that that meant that she believed that there was

9 no retrogression.

10 Why else would she not analyze the plan?

11 Q. Well, that's something that we can't speculate about.

12 But my point is and I think I've made it to the Court's

13 satisfaction, that Dr. Handley not only didn't dispute, she

14 never even analyzed is my point.

15 Thank you, doctor.

16 MR. HEBERT: I have no further questions.

17 JUDGE COLLYER: Thank you.

18 Is there anyone else who wishes to cross-examine the

19 witness?

20 Is there any redirect?

21 MR. HUGHES: I think I can get it done before the

22 break, Your Honor.

23 JUDGE COLLYER: All right.

24 I have people beginning to assemble for the next matter.

25 Dah, dah, dah, dah.

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 42 of 59

Page 43: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

43

1 MR. HUGHES: May I take five minutes?

2 JUDGE COLLYER: Yes, but no more.

3 MR. HUGHES: I'm getting faster.

4 JUDGE COLLYER: Good.

5 REDIRECT EXAMINATION

6 BY MR. HUGHES:

7 Q. Professor Alford, good morning?

8 A. Good morning.

9 Q. Given the breath of issues that you've already covered

10 during cross examination I just have one topic.

11 I want to explore with you and I think yesterday during

12 cross examination you were asked some questions about whether

13 you're reaching certain legal conclusions, but what I want to

14 make sure that the record is clear on looking at your table

15 just for the record which table do we have up here on the

16 screen?

17 A. On the screen I believe that's table 3 B.

18 Q. Is this the table that reports the reconstituted election

19 analysis under the three different indexes for the Texas House

20 benchmark enacted plans?

21 A. Yes.

22 Q. And as a political scientist based on the reconstituted

23 election analysis presented here, does the enacted Texas House

24 map increase, decrease, or leave the same the ability of

25 Hispanic voters to elect their candidates of choice?

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 43 of 59

Page 44: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

44

1 A. Major correctly, summarized correctly, across any of these

2 indexes the adopted Texas House plan provides at least as much

3 or more opportunity or -- sorry -- ability to elect statewide

4 in compared to the benchmark and that's true even if we include

5 117.

6 If the Court wants to take 117 out, then it's an increase

7 on every index that is a major, that is the appropriate, it's

8 the appropriate amount of ability to elect in the benchmark and

9 ability to elect in the adopted plan and that ability to elect

10 statewide is either the same or increased under the adopted

11 plan.

12 Q. And have you reached similar conclusions and presented

13 those conclusions in your written testimony concerning the

14 Congress map and the Senate map for Texas?

15 A. It is more strongly true in the Congressional map. So

16 much so in the Congressional map, but if you want to bring 25

17 in, it's still true in the Congressional map, and it is also

18 true in the Senate map, and if you want to bring Senate 10 in

19 it is still true in the Senate map.

20 Q. Thank you, Professor Alford.

21 MR. HUGHES: I have no further questions. Thank you,

22 Your Honor.

23 JUDGE COLLYER: Thank you, sir. You are excused.

24 Thank you, sir.

25 (Witness excused.)

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 44 of 59

Page 45: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

45

1 All right, we'll stand in recess now. You'll stand in

2 recess now, I won't, until 1:30.

3 We're taking early lunch today. We'll be back at 1:30

4 in the courtroom. Okay.

5 You need to clear all tables of all things. You did

6 hear that from Ms. White earlier, right?

7 MR. HEBERT: She probably said it. Some of us were

8 listening and some of us were not as attentive.

9 JUDGE COLLYER: All things must be gone. All, that

10 means no pens, no pencils, no papers, no computers.

11 (Recess at 10:00 a.m.)

12 -o0o-

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 45 of 59

Page 46: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

46

1 I N D E X

2 Direct Cross Redirect Recross

3 On behalf of the Plaintiff:

4 John Alford, Ph.D.

5 By Ms. Perales 10

6 By Mr. Devaney 21

7 By Mr. Hebert 30

8 By Mr. Hughes 43

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 46 of 59

Page 47: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

47

1 CERTIFICATE

2 I certify that the foregoing is a true and correct

3 transcript, to the best of my ability, of the above pages, of

4 the stenographic notes provided to me by the United States

5 District Court, of the proceedings taken on the date and time

6 previously stated in the above matter.

7 I further certify that I am neither counsel for, related

8 to, nor employed by any of the parties to the action in which

9 this hearing was taken, and further that I am not financially

10 nor otherwise interested in the outcome of the action.

11

12 _________________________ _____________________

/s/Crystal M. Pilgrim, RPR Date: January 26, 2012

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 47 of 59

Page 48: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

-------------------------------------x [1] ---------------------------------x [1] ---------------------------------x [1] ---------------------------------x [1] 1/10 1/10 1/10 1/10-o0o [1] -o0o [1] -o0o [1] -o0o [1] 45/12 45/12 45/12 45/12

/////s/Crystal [1] /s/Crystal [1] /s/Crystal [1] /s/Crystal [1] 47/12 47/12 47/12 47/12

111110 [25] 10 [25] 10 [25] 10 [25] 10/4 10/7 10/10 10/4 10/7 10/10 10/4 10/7 10/10 10/4 10/7 10/10 15/22 15/22 16/2 16/2 15/22 15/22 16/2 16/2 15/22 15/22 16/2 16/2 15/22 15/22 16/2 16/2 32/4 32/9 35/5 35/6 37/22 32/4 32/9 35/5 35/6 37/22 32/4 32/9 35/5 35/6 37/22 32/4 32/9 35/5 35/6 37/22 38/2 38/2 38/3 38/6 38/7 38/2 38/2 38/3 38/6 38/7 38/2 38/2 38/3 38/6 38/7 38/2 38/2 38/3 38/6 38/7 38/8 38/14 38/23 40/2 38/8 38/14 38/23 40/2 38/8 38/14 38/23 40/2 38/8 38/14 38/23 40/2 40/2 40/3 44/18 46/5 40/2 40/3 44/18 46/5 40/2 40/3 44/18 46/5 40/2 40/3 44/18 46/510:00 [1] 10:00 [1] 10:00 [1] 10:00 [1] 45/11 45/11 45/11 45/1111-1303 [1] 11-1303 [1] 11-1303 [1] 11-1303 [1] 1/4 1/4 1/4 1/411-303 [1] 11-303 [1] 11-303 [1] 11-303 [1] 4/4 4/4 4/4 4/411-788 [1] 11-788 [1] 11-788 [1] 11-788 [1] 35/2 35/2 35/2 35/2110 [1] 110 [1] 110 [1] 110 [1] 2/10 2/10 2/10 2/10111 [1] 111 [1] 111 [1] 111 [1] 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5117 [15] 117 [15] 117 [15] 117 [15] 9/15 16/25 17/3 9/15 16/25 17/3 9/15 16/25 17/3 9/15 16/25 17/3 17/17 19/8 19/20 19/23 17/17 19/8 19/20 19/23 17/17 19/8 19/20 19/23 17/17 19/8 19/20 19/23 20/10 20/14 20/15 30/12 20/10 20/14 20/15 30/12 20/10 20/14 20/15 30/12 20/10 20/14 20/15 30/12 30/13 30/17 44/5 44/6 30/13 30/17 44/5 44/6 30/13 30/17 44/5 44/6 30/13 30/17 44/5 44/611th [1] 11th [1] 11th [1] 11th [1] 19/1 19/1 19/1 19/1121 [1] 121 [1] 121 [1] 121 [1] 19/2 19/2 19/2 19/2122 [1] 122 [1] 122 [1] 122 [1] 19/2 19/2 19/2 19/212548 [1] 12548 [1] 12548 [1] 12548 [1] 1/25 1/25 1/25 1/251303 [1] 1303 [1] 1303 [1] 1303 [1] 1/4 1/4 1/4 1/41325 [1] 1325 [1] 1325 [1] 1325 [1] 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/515 [1] 15 [1] 15 [1] 15 [1] 16/14 16/14 16/14 16/1417 [1] 17 [1] 17 [1] 17 [1] 24/18 24/18 24/18 24/18175 [1] 175 [1] 175 [1] 175 [1] 22/20 22/20 22/20 22/2017th [1] 17th [1] 17th [1] 17th [1] 22/23 22/23 22/23 22/2318 [1] 18 [1] 18 [1] 18 [1] 36/21 36/21 36/21 36/2118,000 [2] 18,000 [2] 18,000 [2] 18,000 [2] 7/23 8/2 7/23 8/2 7/23 8/2 7/23 8/2184 [1] 184 [1] 184 [1] 184 [1] 24/18 24/18 24/18 24/18185 [1] 185 [1] 185 [1] 185 [1] 22/3 22/3 22/3 22/319 [1] 19 [1] 19 [1] 19 [1] 28/15 28/15 28/15 28/15191 [1] 191 [1] 191 [1] 191 [1] 2/18 2/18 2/18 2/181960 [1] 1960 [1] 1960 [1] 1960 [1] 2/21 2/21 2/21 2/211:30 [2] 1:30 [2] 1:30 [2] 1:30 [2] 45/2 45/3 45/2 45/3 45/2 45/3 45/2 45/3

222220 [1] 20 [1] 20 [1] 20 [1] 24/18 24/18 24/18 24/182000 [1] 2000 [1] 2000 [1] 2000 [1] 28/24 28/24 28/24 28/2420001 [1] 20001 [1] 20001 [1] 20001 [1] 3/9 3/9 3/9 3/920005-3960 [1] 20005-3960 [1] 20005-3960 [1] 20005-3960 [1] 2/16 2/16 2/16 2/1620015 [1] 20015 [1] 20015 [1] 20015 [1] 2/7 2/7 2/7 2/72002 [14] 2002 [14] 2002 [14] 2002 [14] 10/12 10/17 10/12 10/17 10/12 10/17 10/12 10/17 11/23 11/24 12/3 12/11 11/23 11/24 12/3 12/11 11/23 11/24 12/3 12/11 11/23 11/24 12/3 12/11 12/12 12/13 12/15 12/18 12/12 12/13 12/15 12/18 12/12 12/13 12/15 12/18 12/12 12/13 12/15 12/18 12/18 13/18 13/19 16/10 12/18 13/18 13/19 16/10 12/18 13/18 13/19 16/10 12/18 13/18 13/19 16/102004 [1] 2004 [1] 2004 [1] 2004 [1] 35/7 35/7 35/7 35/72006 [3] 2006 [3] 2006 [3] 2006 [3] 11/20 16/10 29/5 11/20 16/10 29/5 11/20 16/10 29/5 11/20 16/10 29/52008 [12] 2008 [12] 2008 [12] 2008 [12] 11/15 15/10 11/15 15/10 11/15 15/10 11/15 15/10 16/6 29/16 32/9 35/5 35/9 16/6 29/16 32/9 35/5 35/9 16/6 29/16 32/9 35/5 35/9 16/6 29/16 32/9 35/5 35/9 38/8 38/14 38/17 39/2 38/8 38/14 38/17 39/2 38/8 38/14 38/17 39/2 38/8 38/14 38/17 39/2 40/5 40/5 40/5 40/52009 [1] 2009 [1] 2009 [1] 2009 [1] 29/17 29/17 29/17 29/172010 [8] 2010 [8] 2010 [8] 2010 [8] 10/12 15/9 15/11 10/12 15/9 15/11 10/12 15/9 15/11 10/12 15/9 15/11 29/4 29/5 29/17 38/15 29/4 29/5 29/17 38/15 29/4 29/5 29/17 38/15 29/4 29/5 29/17 38/15 38/15 38/15 38/15 38/152012 [2] 2012 [2] 2012 [2] 2012 [2] 1/6 47/12 1/6 47/12 1/6 47/12 1/6 47/1220530 [1] 20530 [1] 20530 [1] 20530 [1] 2/5 2/5 2/5 2/521 [2] 21 [2] 21 [2] 21 [2] 17/13 46/6 17/13 46/6 17/13 46/6 17/13 46/622304 [1] 22304 [1] 22304 [1] 22304 [1] 2/19 2/19 2/19 2/192260 [1] 2260 [1] 2260 [1] 2260 [1] 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/525 [18] 25 [18] 25 [18] 25 [18] 1/6 17/12 21/20 1/6 17/12 21/20 1/6 17/12 21/20 1/6 17/12 21/20 21/24 22/3 22/7 23/11 21/24 22/3 22/7 23/11 21/24 22/3 22/7 23/11 21/24 22/3 22/7 23/11

23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 24/19 24/22 25/18 33/15 24/19 24/22 25/18 33/15 24/19 24/22 25/18 33/15 24/19 24/22 25/18 33/15 33/21 34/7 44/16 33/21 34/7 44/16 33/21 34/7 44/16 33/21 34/7 44/1625.8 [1] 25.8 [1] 25.8 [1] 25.8 [1] 33/7 33/7 33/7 33/72548 [1] 2548 [1] 2548 [1] 2548 [1] 1/25 1/25 1/25 1/2526 [1] 26 [1] 26 [1] 26 [1] 47/12 47/12 47/12 47/1228 [3] 28 [3] 28 [3] 28 [3] 28/13 40/12 40/12 28/13 40/12 40/12 28/13 40/12 40/12 28/13 40/12 40/1229 [2] 29 [2] 29 [2] 29 [2] 40/11 40/13 40/11 40/13 40/11 40/13 40/11 40/13

333330 [1] 30 [1] 30 [1] 30 [1] 46/7 46/7 46/7 46/7300 [1] 300 [1] 300 [1] 300 [1] 2/10 2/10 2/10 2/10303 [1] 303 [1] 303 [1] 303 [1] 4/4 4/4 4/4 4/431 [2] 31 [2] 31 [2] 31 [2] 18/18 19/12 18/18 19/12 18/18 19/12 18/18 19/1232 [2] 32 [2] 32 [2] 32 [2] 18/17 19/11 18/17 19/11 18/17 19/11 18/17 19/11333 [1] 333 [1] 333 [1] 333 [1] 3/9 3/9 3/9 3/93743 [1] 3743 [1] 3743 [1] 3743 [1] 2/7 2/7 2/7 2/73960 [1] 3960 [1] 3960 [1] 3960 [1] 2/16 2/16 2/16 2/16

444440 [1] 40 [1] 40 [1] 40 [1] 28/14 28/14 28/14 28/14405 [1] 405 [1] 405 [1] 405 [1] 2/19 2/19 2/19 2/194201 [1] 4201 [1] 4201 [1] 4201 [1] 2/21 2/21 2/21 2/2143 [1] 43 [1] 43 [1] 43 [1] 46/8 46/8 46/8 46/848 [1] 48 [1] 48 [1] 48 [1] 15/17 15/17 15/17 15/17

5555530 [1] 530 [1] 530 [1] 530 [1] 2/22 2/22 2/22 2/2254 [1] 54 [1] 54 [1] 54 [1] 1/20 1/20 1/20 1/20

666660 [6] 60 [6] 60 [6] 60 [6] 17/4 17/9 17/21 17/4 17/9 17/21 17/4 17/9 17/21 17/4 17/9 17/21 18/3 19/24 20/6 18/3 19/24 20/6 18/3 19/24 20/6 18/3 19/24 20/6600 [1] 600 [1] 600 [1] 600 [1] 2/16 2/16 2/16 2/1660610 [1] 60610 [1] 60610 [1] 60610 [1] 1/21 1/21 1/21 1/2163 [1] 63 [1] 63 [1] 63 [1] 35/20 35/20 35/20 35/2065 [4] 65 [4] 65 [4] 65 [4] 18/7 20/9 20/13 18/7 20/9 20/13 18/7 20/9 20/13 18/7 20/9 20/13 20/15 20/15 20/15 20/15

7777700 [1] 700 [1] 700 [1] 700 [1] 2/15 2/15 2/15 2/157414 [1] 7414 [1] 7414 [1] 7414 [1] 2/13 2/13 2/13 2/1375 [1] 75 [1] 75 [1] 75 [1] 35/7 35/7 35/7 35/777068 [1] 77068 [1] 77068 [1] 77068 [1] 2/22 2/22 2/22 2/2278205 [1] 78205 [1] 78205 [1] 78205 [1] 2/11 2/11 2/11 2/1178205-2260 [1] 78205-2260 [1] 78205-2260 [1] 78205-2260 [1] 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/578711-2548 [1] 78711-2548 [1] 78711-2548 [1] 78711-2548 [1] 1/25 1/25 1/25 1/25788 [1] 788 [1] 788 [1] 788 [1] 35/2 35/2 35/2 35/2

8888801 [4] 801 [4] 801 [4] 801 [4] 10/5 10/6 36/22 10/5 10/6 36/22 10/5 10/6 36/22 10/5 10/6 36/22 40/10 40/10 40/10 40/1085 [1] 85 [1] 85 [1] 85 [1] 35/4 35/4 35/4 35/485.3 [1] 85.3 [1] 85.3 [1] 85.3 [1] 33/4 33/4 33/4 33/4

9999950 [1] 950 [1] 950 [1] 950 [1] 2/5 2/5 2/5 2/598209 [1] 98209 [1] 98209 [1] 98209 [1] 2/13 2/13 2/13 2/1399.6 [1] 99.6 [1] 99.6 [1] 99.6 [1] 32/24 32/24 32/24 32/249:05 [1] 9:05 [1] 9:05 [1] 9:05 [1] 1/6 1/6 1/6 1/6

AAAAa.m [3] a.m [3] a.m [3] a.m [3] 1/6 1/12 45/11 1/6 1/12 45/11 1/6 1/12 45/11 1/6 1/12 45/11ability [18] ability [18] ability [18] ability [18] 9/1 17/4 9/1 17/4 9/1 17/4 9/1 17/4 17/12 17/13 19/25 20/19 17/12 17/13 19/25 20/19 17/12 17/13 19/25 20/19 17/12 17/13 19/25 20/19 20/20 21/24 37/6 38/9 20/20 21/24 37/6 38/9 20/20 21/24 37/6 38/9 20/20 21/24 37/6 38/9 39/13 40/1 43/24 44/3 39/13 40/1 43/24 44/3 39/13 40/1 43/24 44/3 39/13 40/1 43/24 44/3 44/8 44/9 44/9 47/3 44/8 44/9 44/9 47/3 44/8 44/9 44/9 47/3 44/8 44/9 44/9 47/3able [3] able [3] able [3] able [3] 7/2 21/21 29/20 7/2 21/21 29/20 7/2 21/21 29/20 7/2 21/21 29/20about [31] about [31] about [31] about [31] 10/4 12/17 10/4 12/17 10/4 12/17 10/4 12/17 12/18 12/18 12/20 14/11 12/18 12/18 12/20 14/11 12/18 12/18 12/20 14/11 12/18 12/18 12/20 14/11 16/24 17/6 18/19 19/20 16/24 17/6 18/19 19/20 16/24 17/6 18/19 19/20 16/24 17/6 18/19 19/20

20/5 21/6 25/16 25/21 20/5 21/6 25/16 25/21 20/5 21/6 25/16 25/21 20/5 21/6 25/16 25/21 27/21 28/11 29/23 30/5 27/21 28/11 29/23 30/5 27/21 28/11 29/23 30/5 27/21 28/11 29/23 30/5 30/15 31/14 32/22 34/4 30/15 31/14 32/22 34/4 30/15 31/14 32/22 34/4 30/15 31/14 32/22 34/4 35/20 36/23 36/24 38/6 35/20 36/23 36/24 38/6 35/20 36/23 36/24 38/6 35/20 36/23 36/24 38/6 39/12 40/9 40/20 42/11 39/12 40/9 40/20 42/11 39/12 40/9 40/20 42/11 39/12 40/9 40/20 42/11 43/12 43/12 43/12 43/12above [3] above [3] above [3] above [3] 11/1 47/3 47/6 11/1 47/3 47/6 11/1 47/3 47/6 11/1 47/3 47/6absolutely [1] absolutely [1] absolutely [1] absolutely [1] 4/20 4/20 4/20 4/20accept [1] accept [1] accept [1] accept [1] 32/21 32/21 32/21 32/21accepted [1] accepted [1] accepted [1] accepted [1] 26/8 26/8 26/8 26/8accessing [2] accessing [2] accessing [2] accessing [2] 36/20 37/1 36/20 37/1 36/20 37/1 36/20 37/1according [1] according [1] according [1] according [1] 19/7 19/7 19/7 19/7across [3] across [3] across [3] across [3] 27/22 31/8 27/22 31/8 27/22 31/8 27/22 31/8 44/1 44/1 44/1 44/1ACS [5] ACS [5] ACS [5] ACS [5] 28/19 28/21 29/2 28/19 28/21 29/2 28/19 28/21 29/2 28/19 28/21 29/2 29/4 29/7 29/4 29/7 29/4 29/7 29/4 29/7Act [1] Act [1] Act [1] Act [1] 36/20 36/20 36/20 36/20action [3] action [3] action [3] action [3] 4/4 47/8 47/10 4/4 47/8 47/10 4/4 47/8 47/10 4/4 47/8 47/10actual [3] actual [3] actual [3] actual [3] 27/4 31/18 27/4 31/18 27/4 31/18 27/4 31/18 37/20 37/20 37/20 37/20actually [12] actually [12] actually [12] actually [12] 7/13 13/21 7/13 13/21 7/13 13/21 7/13 13/21 19/4 20/18 24/8 27/12 19/4 20/18 24/8 27/12 19/4 20/18 24/8 27/12 19/4 20/18 24/8 27/12 27/17 30/10 34/8 35/5 27/17 30/10 34/8 35/5 27/17 30/10 34/8 35/5 27/17 30/10 34/8 35/5 36/2 41/12 36/2 41/12 36/2 41/12 36/2 41/12ADAM [2] ADAM [2] ADAM [2] ADAM [2] 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6add [2] add [2] add [2] add [2] 18/24 18/25 18/24 18/25 18/24 18/25 18/24 18/25additional [3] additional [3] additional [3] additional [3] 5/15 11/24 5/15 11/24 5/15 11/24 5/15 11/24 30/1 30/1 30/1 30/1adopted [11] adopted [11] adopted [11] adopted [11] 17/20 18/2 17/20 18/2 17/20 18/2 17/20 18/2 18/18 19/12 38/2 38/3 18/18 19/12 38/2 38/3 18/18 19/12 38/2 38/3 18/18 19/12 38/2 38/3 38/7 40/22 44/2 44/9 38/7 40/22 44/2 44/9 38/7 40/22 44/2 44/9 38/7 40/22 44/2 44/9 44/10 44/10 44/10 44/10After [1] After [1] After [1] After [1] 19/20 19/20 19/20 19/20again [13] again [13] again [13] again [13] 5/21 8/22 12/5 5/21 8/22 12/5 5/21 8/22 12/5 5/21 8/22 12/5 15/17 17/15 18/10 24/21 15/17 17/15 18/10 24/21 15/17 17/15 18/10 24/21 15/17 17/15 18/10 24/21 25/13 27/20 31/8 33/12 25/13 27/20 31/8 33/12 25/13 27/20 31/8 33/12 25/13 27/20 31/8 33/12 40/2 41/9 40/2 41/9 40/2 41/9 40/2 41/9against [2] against [2] against [2] against [2] 33/17 35/7 33/17 35/7 33/17 35/7 33/17 35/7age [3] age [3] age [3] age [3] 17/5 17/10 18/7 17/5 17/10 18/7 17/5 17/10 18/7 17/5 17/10 18/7ago [1] ago [1] ago [1] ago [1] 24/16 24/16 24/16 24/16agree [16] agree [16] agree [16] agree [16] 11/14 17/10 11/14 17/10 11/14 17/10 11/14 17/10 18/16 21/19 22/3 22/5 18/16 21/19 22/3 22/5 18/16 21/19 22/3 22/5 18/16 21/19 22/3 22/5 32/5 34/4 34/10 36/9 32/5 34/4 34/10 36/9 32/5 34/4 34/10 36/9 32/5 34/4 34/10 36/9 37/22 39/6 39/17 40/3 37/22 39/6 39/17 40/3 37/22 39/6 39/17 40/3 37/22 39/6 39/17 40/3 40/4 40/6 40/4 40/6 40/4 40/6 40/4 40/6agreed [1] agreed [1] agreed [1] agreed [1] 15/8 15/8 15/8 15/8agreeing [1] agreeing [1] agreeing [1] agreeing [1] 20/13 20/13 20/13 20/13agreement [2] agreement [2] agreement [2] agreement [2] 30/19 39/17 30/19 39/17 30/19 39/17 30/19 39/17ahead [3] ahead [3] ahead [3] ahead [3] 9/9 9/24 34/23 9/9 9/24 34/23 9/9 9/24 34/23 9/9 9/24 34/23aided [1] aided [1] aided [1] aided [1] 3/11 3/11 3/11 3/11al [2] al [2] al [2] al [2] 1/9 4/5 1/9 4/5 1/9 4/5 1/9 4/5Alexandria [1] Alexandria [1] Alexandria [1] Alexandria [1] 2/19 2/19 2/19 2/19Alford [19] Alford [19] Alford [19] Alford [19] 8/19 8/21 8/19 8/21 8/19 8/21 8/19 8/21 9/10 9/12 10/3 13/24 9/10 9/12 10/3 13/24 9/10 9/12 10/3 13/24 9/10 9/12 10/3 13/24 16/24 19/2 19/20 21/1 16/24 19/2 19/20 21/1 16/24 19/2 19/20 21/1 16/24 19/2 19/20 21/1 21/6 21/11 21/18 30/4 21/6 21/11 21/18 30/4 21/6 21/11 21/18 30/4 21/6 21/11 21/18 30/4 31/1 34/25 43/7 44/20 31/1 34/25 43/7 44/20 31/1 34/25 43/7 44/20 31/1 34/25 43/7 44/20 46/4 46/4 46/4 46/4all [41] all [41] all [41] all [41] 6/6 6/24 6/25 6/6 6/24 6/25 6/6 6/24 6/25 6/6 6/24 6/25 7/4 7/16 7/16 7/18 8/6 7/4 7/16 7/16 7/18 8/6 7/4 7/16 7/16 7/18 8/6 7/4 7/16 7/16 7/18 8/6 8/6 8/15 8/25 9/5 11/1 8/6 8/15 8/25 9/5 11/1 8/6 8/15 8/25 9/5 11/1 8/6 8/15 8/25 9/5 11/1 12/1 14/21 15/9 15/13 12/1 14/21 15/9 15/13 12/1 14/21 15/9 15/13 12/1 14/21 15/9 15/13 15/15 16/14 20/18 23/7 15/15 16/14 20/18 23/7 15/15 16/14 20/18 23/7 15/15 16/14 20/18 23/7 23/25 27/4 27/15 28/7 23/25 27/4 27/15 28/7 23/25 27/4 27/15 28/7 23/25 27/4 27/15 28/7 28/14 28/18 30/4 30/15 28/14 28/18 30/4 30/15 28/14 28/18 30/4 30/15 28/14 28/18 30/4 30/15 31/18 34/22 37/11 37/16 31/18 34/22 37/11 37/16 31/18 34/22 37/11 37/16 31/18 34/22 37/11 37/16 37/17 41/9 42/23 45/1 37/17 41/9 42/23 45/1 37/17 41/9 42/23 45/1 37/17 41/9 42/23 45/1 45/5 45/5 45/9 45/9 45/5 45/5 45/9 45/9 45/5 45/5 45/9 45/9 45/5 45/5 45/9 45/9allow [1] allow [1] allow [1] allow [1] 38/12 38/12 38/12 38/12alone [1] alone [1] alone [1] alone [1] 41/6 41/6 41/6 41/6already [3] already [3] already [3] already [3] 12/17 16/20 12/17 16/20 12/17 16/20 12/17 16/20

48484848

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 48 of 59

Page 49: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

AAAAalready... [1] already... [1] already... [1] already... [1] 43/9 43/9 43/9 43/9also [13] also [13] also [13] also [13] 7/2 11/19 14/14 7/2 11/19 14/14 7/2 11/19 14/14 7/2 11/19 14/14 15/3 16/9 18/13 22/5 25/3 15/3 16/9 18/13 22/5 25/3 15/3 16/9 18/13 22/5 25/3 15/3 16/9 18/13 22/5 25/3 31/23 33/25 39/13 40/4 31/23 33/25 39/13 40/4 31/23 33/25 39/13 40/4 31/23 33/25 39/13 40/4 44/17 44/17 44/17 44/17although [2] although [2] although [2] although [2] 16/25 16/25 16/25 16/25 16/25 16/25 16/25 16/25always [3] always [3] always [3] always [3] 16/18 26/18 16/18 26/18 16/18 26/18 16/18 26/18 26/25 26/25 26/25 26/25am [4] am [4] am [4] am [4] 8/17 25/3 47/7 8/17 25/3 47/7 8/17 25/3 47/7 8/17 25/3 47/7 47/9 47/9 47/9 47/9AMERICA [2] AMERICA [2] AMERICA [2] AMERICA [2] 1/5 4/5 1/5 4/5 1/5 4/5 1/5 4/5American [1] American [1] American [1] American [1] 2/9 2/9 2/9 2/9amount [1] amount [1] amount [1] amount [1] 44/8 44/8 44/8 44/8analysis [37] analysis [37] analysis [37] analysis [37] 10/5 11/4 10/5 11/4 10/5 11/4 10/5 11/4 15/11 17/19 18/1 18/17 15/11 17/19 18/1 18/17 15/11 17/19 18/1 18/17 15/11 17/19 18/1 18/17 19/13 19/15 21/25 23/14 19/13 19/15 21/25 23/14 19/13 19/15 21/25 23/14 19/13 19/15 21/25 23/14 23/16 23/19 23/25 24/2 23/16 23/19 23/25 24/2 23/16 23/19 23/25 24/2 23/16 23/19 23/25 24/2 24/6 24/11 24/17 24/19 24/6 24/11 24/17 24/19 24/6 24/11 24/17 24/19 24/6 24/11 24/17 24/19 24/21 25/4 25/6 25/10 24/21 25/4 25/6 25/10 24/21 25/4 25/6 25/10 24/21 25/4 25/6 25/10 26/8 26/21 27/10 30/8 26/8 26/21 27/10 30/8 26/8 26/21 27/10 30/8 26/8 26/21 27/10 30/8 30/12 30/16 31/22 32/17 30/12 30/16 31/22 32/17 30/12 30/16 31/22 32/17 30/12 30/16 31/22 32/17 32/18 38/3 41/10 42/4 32/18 38/3 41/10 42/4 32/18 38/3 41/10 42/4 32/18 38/3 41/10 42/4 42/6 43/19 43/23 42/6 43/19 43/23 42/6 43/19 43/23 42/6 43/19 43/23analyze [2] analyze [2] analyze [2] analyze [2] 41/15 42/10 41/15 42/10 41/15 42/10 41/15 42/10analyzed [2] analyzed [2] analyzed [2] analyzed [2] 41/13 42/14 41/13 42/14 41/13 42/14 41/13 42/14analyzing [2] analyzing [2] analyzing [2] analyzing [2] 15/24 41/22 15/24 41/22 15/24 41/22 15/24 41/22ANGELA [2] ANGELA [2] ANGELA [2] ANGELA [2] 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7Anglo [7] Anglo [7] Anglo [7] Anglo [7] 35/19 35/20 35/19 35/20 35/19 35/20 35/19 35/20 35/21 35/22 36/1 36/3 35/21 35/22 36/1 36/3 35/21 35/22 36/1 36/3 35/21 35/22 36/1 36/3 39/9 39/9 39/9 39/9Anglos [5] Anglos [5] Anglos [5] Anglos [5] 25/7 33/7 25/7 33/7 25/7 33/7 25/7 33/7 33/13 35/24 35/25 33/13 35/24 35/25 33/13 35/24 35/25 33/13 35/24 35/25another [1] another [1] another [1] another [1] 7/7 7/7 7/7 7/7answer [4] answer [4] answer [4] answer [4] 14/3 16/20 14/3 16/20 14/3 16/20 14/3 16/20 31/11 31/25 31/11 31/25 31/11 31/25 31/11 31/25Antonio [8] Antonio [8] Antonio [8] Antonio [8] 2/11 2/13 3/5 2/11 2/13 3/5 2/11 2/13 3/5 2/11 2/13 3/5 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 34/25 34/25 34/25 34/25any [20] any [20] any [20] any [20] 12/18 15/14 12/18 15/14 12/18 15/14 12/18 15/14 15/23 16/1 22/14 23/3 15/23 16/1 22/14 23/3 15/23 16/1 22/14 23/3 15/23 16/1 22/14 23/3 23/14 23/18 25/6 26/22 23/14 23/18 25/6 26/22 23/14 23/18 25/6 26/22 23/14 23/18 25/6 26/22 26/22 35/12 37/7 38/20 26/22 35/12 37/7 38/20 26/22 35/12 37/7 38/20 26/22 35/12 37/7 38/20 39/2 39/4 39/5 42/20 44/1 39/2 39/4 39/5 42/20 44/1 39/2 39/4 39/5 42/20 44/1 39/2 39/4 39/5 42/20 44/1 47/8 47/8 47/8 47/8anybody [2] anybody [2] anybody [2] anybody [2] 5/12 8/12 5/12 8/12 5/12 8/12 5/12 8/12anyone [2] anyone [2] anyone [2] anyone [2] 22/17 42/18 22/17 42/18 22/17 42/18 22/17 42/18anything [1] anything [1] anything [1] anything [1] 8/13 8/13 8/13 8/13anywhere [1] anywhere [1] anywhere [1] anywhere [1] 32/17 32/17 32/17 32/17apologies [1] apologies [1] apologies [1] apologies [1] 4/16 4/16 4/16 4/16apologize [1] apologize [1] apologize [1] apologize [1] 26/6 26/6 26/6 26/6apparently [1] apparently [1] apparently [1] apparently [1] 6/6 6/6 6/6 6/6Appeals [10] Appeals [10] Appeals [10] Appeals [10] 10/21 10/24 10/21 10/24 10/21 10/24 10/21 10/24 11/16 12/1 12/9 12/11 11/16 12/1 12/9 12/11 11/16 12/1 12/9 12/11 11/16 12/1 12/9 12/11 12/15 15/5 16/6 16/16 12/15 15/5 16/6 16/16 12/15 15/5 16/6 16/16 12/15 15/5 16/6 16/16appear [1] appear [1] appear [1] appear [1] 13/7 13/7 13/7 13/7APPEARANCES [3] APPEARANCES [3] APPEARANCES [3] APPEARANCES [3] 1/16 2/2 1/16 2/2 1/16 2/2 1/16 2/2 3/2 3/2 3/2 3/2appeared [2] appeared [2] appeared [2] appeared [2] 4/22 5/2 4/22 5/2 4/22 5/2 4/22 5/2appears [2] appears [2] appears [2] appears [2] 10/20 22/24 10/20 22/24 10/20 22/24 10/20 22/24appreciate [1] appreciate [1] appreciate [1] appreciate [1] 39/22 39/22 39/22 39/22apprise [1] apprise [1] apprise [1] apprise [1] 7/21 7/21 7/21 7/21approach [1] approach [1] approach [1] approach [1] 18/20 18/20 18/20 18/20appropriate [4] appropriate [4] appropriate [4] appropriate [4] 18/22 18/22 18/22 18/22 34/7 44/7 44/8 34/7 44/7 44/8 34/7 44/7 44/8 34/7 44/7 44/8are [57] are [57] are [57] are [57] area [1] area [1] area [1] area [1] 40/9 40/9 40/9 40/9aren't [1] aren't [1] aren't [1] aren't [1] 33/25 33/25 33/25 33/25arguing [1] arguing [1] arguing [1] arguing [1] 37/16 37/16 37/16 37/16as [56] as [56] as [56] as [56]

ASHLEY [2] ASHLEY [2] ASHLEY [2] ASHLEY [2] 1/18 4/7 1/18 4/7 1/18 4/7 1/18 4/7ask [3] ask [3] ask [3] ask [3] 25/16 32/22 40/20 25/16 32/22 40/20 25/16 32/22 40/20 25/16 32/22 40/20asked [7] asked [7] asked [7] asked [7] 20/9 24/8 24/15 20/9 24/8 24/15 20/9 24/8 24/15 20/9 24/8 24/15 24/23 28/5 36/7 43/12 24/23 28/5 36/7 43/12 24/23 28/5 36/7 43/12 24/23 28/5 36/7 43/12asking [4] asking [4] asking [4] asking [4] 8/12 14/11 8/12 14/11 8/12 14/11 8/12 14/11 21/1 36/24 21/1 36/24 21/1 36/24 21/1 36/24assemble [1] assemble [1] assemble [1] assemble [1] 42/24 42/24 42/24 42/24assert [1] assert [1] assert [1] assert [1] 12/3 12/3 12/3 12/3assimilated [1] assimilated [1] assimilated [1] assimilated [1] 7/17 7/17 7/17 7/17associated [1] associated [1] associated [1] associated [1] 27/2 27/2 27/2 27/2Associates [1] Associates [1] Associates [1] Associates [1] 3/4 3/4 3/4 3/4assume [1] assume [1] assume [1] assume [1] 13/3 13/3 13/3 13/3assumed [2] assumed [2] assumed [2] assumed [2] 16/18 18/12 16/18 18/12 16/18 18/12 16/18 18/12assuming [1] assuming [1] assuming [1] assuming [1] 12/5 12/5 12/5 12/5astonishing [1] astonishing [1] astonishing [1] astonishing [1] 7/15 7/15 7/15 7/15astounding [1] astounding [1] astounding [1] astounding [1] 7/22 7/22 7/22 7/22attachment [1] attachment [1] attachment [1] attachment [1] 22/24 22/24 22/24 22/24attempted [1] attempted [1] attempted [1] attempted [1] 18/11 18/11 18/11 18/11attention [2] attention [2] attention [2] attention [2] 8/9 13/22 8/9 13/22 8/9 13/22 8/9 13/22attentive [1] attentive [1] attentive [1] attentive [1] 45/8 45/8 45/8 45/8Attorney [6] Attorney [6] Attorney [6] Attorney [6] 1/6 1/24 1/6 1/24 1/6 1/24 1/6 1/24 10/8 11/8 16/5 16/9 10/8 11/8 16/5 16/9 10/8 11/8 16/5 16/9 10/8 11/8 16/5 16/9Austin [1] Austin [1] Austin [1] Austin [1] 1/25 1/25 1/25 1/25author [1] author [1] author [1] author [1] 41/4 41/4 41/4 41/4available [1] available [1] available [1] available [1] 5/8 5/8 5/8 5/8Avenue [2] Avenue [2] Avenue [2] Avenue [2] 2/5 3/9 2/5 3/9 2/5 3/9 2/5 3/9average [2] average [2] average [2] average [2] 29/5 29/5 29/5 29/5 29/5 29/5 29/5 29/5aware [6] aware [6] aware [6] aware [6] 11/19 11/22 11/19 11/22 11/19 11/22 11/19 11/22 12/2 12/3 37/4 37/7 12/2 12/3 37/4 37/7 12/2 12/3 37/4 37/7 12/2 12/3 37/4 37/7away [2] away [2] away [2] away [2] 8/12 39/14 8/12 39/14 8/12 39/14 8/12 39/14

BBBBback [9] back [9] back [9] back [9] 6/13 6/20 11/23 6/13 6/20 11/23 6/13 6/20 11/23 6/13 6/20 11/23 13/20 17/15 17/17 23/10 13/20 17/15 17/17 23/10 13/20 17/15 17/17 23/10 13/20 17/15 17/17 23/10 27/14 45/3 27/14 45/3 27/14 45/3 27/14 45/3ballot [16] ballot [16] ballot [16] ballot [16] 10/25 12/6 10/25 12/6 10/25 12/6 10/25 12/6 12/8 12/21 12/25 13/1 12/8 12/21 12/25 13/1 12/8 12/21 12/25 13/1 12/8 12/21 12/25 13/1 13/7 13/8 13/12 13/14 13/7 13/8 13/12 13/14 13/7 13/8 13/12 13/14 13/7 13/8 13/12 13/14 13/15 13/16 13/20 13/25 13/15 13/16 13/20 13/25 13/15 13/16 13/20 13/25 13/15 13/16 13/20 13/25 14/11 14/12 14/11 14/12 14/11 14/12 14/11 14/12Bartlit [1] Bartlit [1] Bartlit [1] Bartlit [1] 1/19 1/19 1/19 1/19based [5] based [5] based [5] based [5] 20/19 25/9 20/19 25/9 20/19 25/9 20/19 25/9 25/10 29/24 43/22 25/10 29/24 43/22 25/10 29/24 43/22 25/10 29/24 43/22basically [4] basically [4] basically [4] basically [4] 7/6 19/4 7/6 19/4 7/6 19/4 7/6 19/4 19/6 19/10 19/6 19/10 19/6 19/10 19/6 19/10basis [3] basis [3] basis [3] basis [3] 25/11 28/25 25/11 28/25 25/11 28/25 25/11 28/25 36/1 36/1 36/1 36/1be [43] be [43] be [43] be [43] 7/5 7/9 7/9 7/17 7/5 7/9 7/9 7/17 7/5 7/9 7/9 7/17 7/5 7/9 7/9 7/17 7/23 8/1 8/23 13/24 14/1 7/23 8/1 8/23 13/24 14/1 7/23 8/1 8/23 13/24 14/1 7/23 8/1 8/23 13/24 14/1 14/7 15/1 15/16 15/24 14/7 15/1 15/16 15/24 14/7 15/1 15/16 15/24 14/7 15/1 15/16 15/24 18/4 18/15 19/11 19/14 18/4 18/15 19/11 19/14 18/4 18/15 19/11 19/14 18/4 18/15 19/11 19/14 19/25 21/7 24/5 24/13 19/25 21/7 24/5 24/13 19/25 21/7 24/5 24/13 19/25 21/7 24/5 24/13 26/13 27/21 28/1 28/14 26/13 27/21 28/1 28/14 26/13 27/21 28/1 28/14 26/13 27/21 28/1 28/14 28/15 29/13 29/15 29/17 28/15 29/13 29/15 29/17 28/15 29/13 29/15 29/17 28/15 29/13 29/15 29/17 31/20 32/4 32/18 32/20 31/20 32/4 32/18 32/20 31/20 32/4 32/18 32/20 31/20 32/4 32/18 32/20 33/22 35/19 36/16 37/5 33/22 35/19 36/16 37/5 33/22 35/19 36/16 37/5 33/22 35/19 36/16 37/5 37/17 41/7 41/8 41/8 45/3 37/17 41/7 41/8 41/8 45/3 37/17 41/7 41/8 41/8 45/3 37/17 41/7 41/8 41/8 45/3 45/9 45/9 45/9 45/9because [22] because [22] because [22] because [22] 7/10 8/23 7/10 8/23 7/10 8/23 7/10 8/23 9/1 9/2 14/8 17/4 19/3 9/1 9/2 14/8 17/4 19/3 9/1 9/2 14/8 17/4 19/3 9/1 9/2 14/8 17/4 19/3 19/6 19/24 20/15 24/5 19/6 19/24 20/15 24/5 19/6 19/24 20/15 24/5 19/6 19/24 20/15 24/5 26/12 27/3 27/17 28/6 26/12 27/3 27/17 28/6 26/12 27/3 27/17 28/6 26/12 27/3 27/17 28/6 28/15 30/6 34/3 34/8 28/15 30/6 34/3 34/8 28/15 30/6 34/3 34/8 28/15 30/6 34/3 34/8 35/25 36/3 36/4 35/25 36/3 36/4 35/25 36/3 36/4 35/25 36/3 36/4Beck [1] Beck [1] Beck [1] Beck [1] 1/19 1/19 1/19 1/19been [7] been [7] been [7] been [7] 5/8 5/10 7/2 5/8 5/10 7/2 5/8 5/10 7/2 5/8 5/10 7/2 12/20 29/2 29/20 40/6 12/20 29/2 29/20 40/6 12/20 29/2 29/20 40/6 12/20 29/2 29/20 40/6before [9] before [9] before [9] before [9] 1/13 9/11 1/13 9/11 1/13 9/11 1/13 9/11 14/18 14/21 16/15 18/12 14/18 14/21 16/15 18/12 14/18 14/21 16/15 18/12 14/18 14/21 16/15 18/12 24/6 32/19 42/21 24/6 32/19 42/21 24/6 32/19 42/21 24/6 32/19 42/21beginning [2] beginning [2] beginning [2] beginning [2] 39/24 42/24 39/24 42/24 39/24 42/24 39/24 42/24

behalf [1] behalf [1] behalf [1] behalf [1] 46/3 46/3 46/3 46/3behind [1] behind [1] behind [1] behind [1] 38/20 38/20 38/20 38/20belief [1] belief [1] belief [1] belief [1] 41/11 41/11 41/11 41/11believe [11] believe [11] believe [11] believe [11] 10/17 11/5 10/17 11/5 10/17 11/5 10/17 11/5 18/21 21/4 22/24 29/4 18/21 21/4 22/24 29/4 18/21 21/4 22/24 29/4 18/21 21/4 22/24 29/4 32/15 36/7 40/11 42/7 32/15 36/7 40/11 42/7 32/15 36/7 40/11 42/7 32/15 36/7 40/11 42/7 43/17 43/17 43/17 43/17believed [1] believed [1] believed [1] believed [1] 42/8 42/8 42/8 42/8below [4] below [4] below [4] below [4] 12/7 13/11 14/7 12/7 13/11 14/7 12/7 13/11 14/7 12/7 13/11 14/7 20/15 20/15 20/15 20/15BENCH [1] BENCH [1] BENCH [1] BENCH [1] 1/12 1/12 1/12 1/12benchmark [19] benchmark [19] benchmark [19] benchmark [19] 17/11 17/11 17/11 17/11 17/13 17/20 18/1 18/18 17/13 17/20 18/1 18/18 17/13 17/20 18/1 18/18 17/13 17/20 18/1 18/18 19/12 19/22 21/19 23/11 19/12 19/22 21/19 23/11 19/12 19/22 21/19 23/11 19/12 19/22 21/19 23/11 25/18 38/2 38/4 38/6 25/18 38/2 38/4 38/6 25/18 38/2 38/4 38/6 25/18 38/2 38/4 38/6 38/11 40/23 41/14 43/20 38/11 40/23 41/14 43/20 38/11 40/23 41/14 43/20 38/11 40/23 41/14 43/20 44/4 44/8 44/4 44/8 44/4 44/8 44/4 44/8beneath [1] beneath [1] beneath [1] beneath [1] 25/25 25/25 25/25 25/25benefit [1] benefit [1] benefit [1] benefit [1] 6/5 6/5 6/5 6/5BERYL [1] BERYL [1] BERYL [1] BERYL [1] 1/13 1/13 1/13 1/13best [5] best [5] best [5] best [5] 7/16 8/4 17/1 7/16 8/4 17/1 7/16 8/4 17/1 7/16 8/4 17/1 29/15 47/3 29/15 47/3 29/15 47/3 29/15 47/3better [2] better [2] better [2] better [2] 6/7 15/18 6/7 15/18 6/7 15/18 6/7 15/18between [3] between [3] between [3] between [3] 22/6 22/11 22/6 22/11 22/6 22/11 22/6 22/11 24/11 24/11 24/11 24/11big [1] big [1] big [1] big [1] 35/24 35/24 35/24 35/24bit [1] bit [1] bit [1] bit [1] 29/24 29/24 29/24 29/24black [5] black [5] black [5] black [5] 32/24 33/1 32/24 33/1 32/24 33/1 32/24 33/1 38/13 38/25 39/9 38/13 38/25 39/9 38/13 38/25 39/9 38/13 38/25 39/9blacks [8] blacks [8] blacks [8] blacks [8] 21/20 22/6 21/20 22/6 21/20 22/6 21/20 22/6 22/11 24/11 33/14 36/14 22/11 24/11 33/14 36/14 22/11 24/11 33/14 36/14 22/11 24/11 33/14 36/14 39/12 39/14 39/12 39/14 39/12 39/14 39/12 39/14bloc [6] bloc [6] bloc [6] bloc [6] 33/17 33/19 33/17 33/19 33/17 33/19 33/17 33/19 33/23 34/2 34/6 37/6 33/23 34/2 34/6 37/6 33/23 34/2 34/6 37/6 33/23 34/2 34/6 37/6both [4] both [4] both [4] both [4] 6/22 13/13 22/25 6/22 13/13 22/25 6/22 13/13 22/25 6/22 13/13 22/25 40/6 40/6 40/6 40/6Box [1] Box [1] Box [1] Box [1] 1/25 1/25 1/25 1/25Brazil [1] Brazil [1] Brazil [1] Brazil [1] 2/21 2/21 2/21 2/21break [1] break [1] break [1] break [1] 42/22 42/22 42/22 42/22breaking [1] breaking [1] breaking [1] breaking [1] 8/23 8/23 8/23 8/23breath [1] breath [1] breath [1] breath [1] 43/9 43/9 43/9 43/9brief [1] brief [1] brief [1] brief [1] 9/15 9/15 9/15 9/15briefly [1] briefly [1] briefly [1] briefly [1] 16/24 16/24 16/24 16/24bright [11] bright [11] bright [11] bright [11] 17/3 17/9 17/3 17/9 17/3 17/9 17/3 17/9 18/11 19/24 20/6 20/9 18/11 19/24 20/6 20/9 18/11 19/24 20/6 20/9 18/11 19/24 20/6 20/9 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 30/9 30/9 30/9 30/9Brimer [1] Brimer [1] Brimer [1] Brimer [1] 35/7 35/7 35/7 35/7bring [4] bring [4] bring [4] bring [4] 40/10 40/16 40/10 40/16 40/10 40/16 40/10 40/16 44/16 44/18 44/16 44/18 44/16 44/18 44/16 44/18Broadway [1] Broadway [1] Broadway [1] Broadway [1] 2/10 2/10 2/10 2/10BRYAN [2] BRYAN [2] BRYAN [2] BRYAN [2] 2/4 4/10 2/4 4/10 2/4 4/10 2/4 4/10building [2] building [2] building [2] building [2] 3/4 38/25 3/4 38/25 3/4 38/25 3/4 38/25

CCCCCA [1] CA [1] CA [1] CA [1] 1/4 1/4 1/4 1/4Call [1] Call [1] Call [1] Call [1] 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2called [1] called [1] called [1] called [1] 31/18 31/18 31/18 31/18can [22] can [22] can [22] can [22] 5/7 6/7 7/9 7/16 5/7 6/7 7/9 7/16 5/7 6/7 7/9 7/16 5/7 6/7 7/9 7/16 7/17 8/4 8/6 8/21 10/23 7/17 8/4 8/6 8/21 10/23 7/17 8/4 8/6 8/21 10/23 7/17 8/4 8/6 8/21 10/23 11/9 11/9 13/24 23/2 24/1 11/9 11/9 13/24 23/2 24/1 11/9 11/9 13/24 23/2 24/1 11/9 11/9 13/24 23/2 24/1 34/10 37/13 37/22 39/20 34/10 37/13 37/22 39/20 34/10 37/13 37/22 39/20 34/10 37/13 37/22 39/20 39/24 39/25 40/3 42/21 39/24 39/25 40/3 42/21 39/24 39/25 40/3 42/21 39/24 39/25 40/3 42/21can't [3] can't [3] can't [3] can't [3] 16/13 37/19 16/13 37/19 16/13 37/19 16/13 37/19 42/11 42/11 42/11 42/11candidate [17] candidate [17] candidate [17] candidate [17] 11/16 11/16 11/16 11/16 11/20 12/12 12/13 12/15 11/20 12/12 12/13 12/15 11/20 12/12 12/13 12/15 11/20 12/12 12/13 12/15 18/16 33/17 35/7 36/13 18/16 33/17 35/7 36/13 18/16 33/17 35/7 36/13 18/16 33/17 35/7 36/13 38/9 38/13 38/18 38/19 38/9 38/13 38/18 38/19 38/9 38/13 38/18 38/19 38/9 38/13 38/18 38/19 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1candidates [8] candidates [8] candidates [8] candidates [8] 13/22 13/22 13/22 13/22

49494949

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 49 of 59

Page 50: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

CCCCcandidates... [7] candidates... [7] candidates... [7] candidates... [7] 21/21 21/21 21/21 21/21 25/4 25/5 25/11 26/4 39/1 25/4 25/5 25/11 26/4 39/1 25/4 25/5 25/11 26/4 39/1 25/4 25/5 25/11 26/4 39/1 43/25 43/25 43/25 43/25capacity [1] capacity [1] capacity [1] capacity [1] 1/6 1/6 1/6 1/6careful [1] careful [1] careful [1] careful [1] 24/5 24/5 24/5 24/5carefully [1] carefully [1] carefully [1] carefully [1] 27/11 27/11 27/11 27/11case [17] case [17] case [17] case [17] 4/2 7/14 11/3 4/2 7/14 11/3 4/2 7/14 11/3 4/2 7/14 11/3 23/17 23/18 24/3 24/8 23/17 23/18 24/3 24/8 23/17 23/18 24/3 24/8 23/17 23/18 24/3 24/8 29/20 30/11 31/17 31/19 29/20 30/11 31/17 31/19 29/20 30/11 31/17 31/19 29/20 30/11 31/17 31/19 32/17 35/1 35/1 35/1 32/17 35/1 35/1 35/1 32/17 35/1 35/1 35/1 32/17 35/1 35/1 35/1 37/22 38/21 37/22 38/21 37/22 38/21 37/22 38/21cases [6] cases [6] cases [6] cases [6] 33/25 36/23 33/25 36/23 33/25 36/23 33/25 36/23 37/5 37/7 37/16 37/17 37/5 37/7 37/16 37/17 37/5 37/7 37/16 37/17 37/5 37/7 37/16 37/17catching [1] catching [1] catching [1] catching [1] 5/23 5/23 5/23 5/23category [1] category [1] category [1] category [1] 26/3 26/3 26/3 26/3caught [1] caught [1] caught [1] caught [1] 5/21 5/21 5/21 5/21caused [1] caused [1] caused [1] caused [1] 35/18 35/18 35/18 35/18CD [3] CD [3] CD [3] CD [3] 22/3 23/11 24/21 22/3 23/11 24/21 22/3 23/11 24/21 22/3 23/11 24/21census [3] census [3] census [3] census [3] 28/22 28/23 28/22 28/23 28/22 28/23 28/22 28/23 29/1 29/1 29/1 29/1center [2] center [2] center [2] center [2] 18/11 29/5 18/11 29/5 18/11 29/5 18/11 29/5centered [1] centered [1] centered [1] centered [1] 29/16 29/16 29/16 29/16certain [2] certain [2] certain [2] certain [2] 24/13 43/13 24/13 43/13 24/13 43/13 24/13 43/13certainly [2] certainly [2] certainly [2] certainly [2] 24/13 41/11 24/13 41/11 24/13 41/11 24/13 41/11CERTIFICATE [1] CERTIFICATE [1] CERTIFICATE [1] CERTIFICATE [1] 47/1 47/1 47/1 47/1certify [2] certify [2] certify [2] certify [2] 47/2 47/7 47/2 47/7 47/2 47/7 47/2 47/7CHAD [2] CHAD [2] CHAD [2] CHAD [2] 2/20 4/12 2/20 4/12 2/20 4/12 2/20 4/12change [5] change [5] change [5] change [5] 27/14 35/16 27/14 35/16 27/14 35/16 27/14 35/16 35/23 35/24 39/24 35/23 35/24 39/24 35/23 35/24 39/24 35/23 35/24 39/24characterizations [1] characterizations [1] characterizations [1] characterizations [1] 32/21 32/21 32/21 32/21characterize [2] characterize [2] characterize [2] characterize [2] 33/15 33/15 33/15 33/15 34/7 34/7 34/7 34/7characterized [3] characterized [3] characterized [3] characterized [3] 32/13 32/13 32/13 32/13 32/15 34/12 32/15 34/12 32/15 34/12 32/15 34/12Chicago [1] Chicago [1] Chicago [1] Chicago [1] 1/21 1/21 1/21 1/21choice [11] choice [11] choice [11] choice [11] 21/21 30/2 21/21 30/2 21/21 30/2 21/21 30/2 33/18 38/10 38/13 38/19 33/18 38/10 38/13 38/19 33/18 38/10 38/13 38/19 33/18 38/10 38/13 38/19 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1 39/10 39/10 39/11 40/1 43/25 43/25 43/25 43/25choose [1] choose [1] choose [1] choose [1] 16/13 16/13 16/13 16/13choosing [1] choosing [1] choosing [1] choosing [1] 16/2 16/2 16/2 16/2cite [1] cite [1] cite [1] cite [1] 36/24 36/24 36/24 36/24citizen [3] citizen [3] citizen [3] citizen [3] 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 18/7 18/7 18/7 18/7citizens [2] citizens [2] citizens [2] citizens [2] 7/18 29/11 7/18 29/11 7/18 29/11 7/18 29/11Civil [1] Civil [1] Civil [1] Civil [1] 4/4 4/4 4/4 4/4claims [1] claims [1] claims [1] claims [1] 37/14 37/14 37/14 37/14CLAY [2] CLAY [2] CLAY [2] CLAY [2] 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6clear [7] clear [7] clear [7] clear [7] 13/24 18/21 13/24 18/21 13/24 18/21 13/24 18/21 26/7 34/5 35/18 43/14 26/7 34/5 35/18 43/14 26/7 34/5 35/18 43/14 26/7 34/5 35/18 43/14 45/5 45/5 45/5 45/5clearly [3] clearly [3] clearly [3] clearly [3] 7/3 34/12 7/3 34/12 7/3 34/12 7/3 34/12 41/22 41/22 41/22 41/22closely [1] closely [1] closely [1] closely [1] 41/9 41/9 41/9 41/9coalition [2] coalition [2] coalition [2] coalition [2] 33/22 38/25 33/22 38/25 33/22 38/25 33/22 38/25cohesion [10] cohesion [10] cohesion [10] cohesion [10] 22/5 22/10 22/5 22/10 22/5 22/10 22/5 22/10 23/5 23/22 24/11 25/18 23/5 23/22 24/11 25/18 23/5 23/22 24/11 25/18 23/5 23/22 24/11 25/18 26/22 37/6 37/12 39/8 26/22 37/6 37/12 39/8 26/22 37/6 37/12 39/8 26/22 37/6 37/12 39/8cohesive [1] cohesive [1] cohesive [1] cohesive [1] 33/1 33/1 33/1 33/1Coie [1] Coie [1] Coie [1] Coie [1] 2/15 2/15 2/15 2/15Coleman's [1] Coleman's [1] Coleman's [1] Coleman's [1] 5/5 5/5 5/5 5/5colleagues [1] colleagues [1] colleagues [1] colleagues [1] 6/14 6/14 6/14 6/14COLLYER [2] COLLYER [2] COLLYER [2] COLLYER [2] 1/13 4/13 1/13 4/13 1/13 4/13 1/13 4/13COLMENERO [2] COLMENERO [2] COLMENERO [2] COLMENERO [2] 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7COLUMBIA [2] COLUMBIA [2] COLUMBIA [2] COLUMBIA [2] 1/1 3/8 1/1 3/8 1/1 3/8 1/1 3/8come [6] come [6] come [6] come [6] 4/24 6/24 8/21 4/24 6/24 8/21 4/24 6/24 8/21 4/24 6/24 8/21 14/18 14/21 39/16 14/18 14/21 39/16 14/18 14/21 39/16 14/18 14/21 39/16comment [2] comment [2] comment [2] comment [2] 30/5 32/20 30/5 32/20 30/5 32/20 30/5 32/20

commissioner [2] commissioner [2] commissioner [2] commissioner [2] 13/11 13/11 13/11 13/11 15/4 15/4 15/4 15/4common [1] common [1] common [1] common [1] 13/15 13/15 13/15 13/15commonly [1] commonly [1] commonly [1] commonly [1] 26/8 26/8 26/8 26/8comparable [1] comparable [1] comparable [1] comparable [1] 31/8 31/8 31/8 31/8compare [5] compare [5] compare [5] compare [5] 17/19 18/1 17/19 18/1 17/19 18/1 17/19 18/1 38/4 38/4 39/20 38/4 38/4 39/20 38/4 38/4 39/20 38/4 38/4 39/20compared [3] compared [3] compared [3] compared [3] 19/22 37/8 19/22 37/8 19/22 37/8 19/22 37/8 44/4 44/4 44/4 44/4comparing [1] comparing [1] comparing [1] comparing [1] 37/9 37/9 37/9 37/9comparison [3] comparison [3] comparison [3] comparison [3] 37/14 37/14 37/14 37/14 37/19 38/7 37/19 38/7 37/19 38/7 37/19 38/7compass [1] compass [1] compass [1] compass [1] 24/7 24/7 24/7 24/7complete [1] complete [1] complete [1] complete [1] 6/12 6/12 6/12 6/12computer [1] computer [1] computer [1] computer [1] 3/11 3/11 3/11 3/11computer-aided [1] computer-aided [1] computer-aided [1] computer-aided [1] 3/11 3/11 3/11 3/11computers [1] computers [1] computers [1] computers [1] 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10concentrated [1] concentrated [1] concentrated [1] concentrated [1] 7/14 7/14 7/14 7/14concerned [1] concerned [1] concerned [1] concerned [1] 27/20 27/20 27/20 27/20concerning [1] concerning [1] concerning [1] concerning [1] 44/13 44/13 44/13 44/13concluded [3] concluded [3] concluded [3] concluded [3] 36/7 36/8 36/7 36/8 36/7 36/8 36/7 36/8 41/13 41/13 41/13 41/13conclusion [1] conclusion [1] conclusion [1] conclusion [1] 23/4 23/4 23/4 23/4conclusions [5] conclusions [5] conclusions [5] conclusions [5] 27/15 27/15 27/15 27/15 29/21 43/13 44/12 44/13 29/21 43/13 44/12 44/13 29/21 43/13 44/12 44/13 29/21 43/13 44/12 44/13conditions [1] conditions [1] conditions [1] conditions [1] 34/15 34/15 34/15 34/15conduct [5] conduct [5] conduct [5] conduct [5] 11/4 23/14 11/4 23/14 11/4 23/14 11/4 23/14 38/24 42/4 42/6 38/24 42/4 42/6 38/24 42/4 42/6 38/24 42/4 42/6conducted [1] conducted [1] conducted [1] conducted [1] 24/16 24/16 24/16 24/16confidence [9] confidence [9] confidence [9] confidence [9] 26/9 26/22 26/9 26/22 26/9 26/22 26/9 26/22 27/9 27/18 27/24 27/25 27/9 27/18 27/24 27/25 27/9 27/18 27/24 27/25 27/9 27/18 27/24 27/25 28/3 28/6 28/16 28/3 28/6 28/16 28/3 28/6 28/16 28/3 28/6 28/16confident [3] confident [3] confident [3] confident [3] 27/21 28/1 27/21 28/1 27/21 28/1 27/21 28/1 28/5 28/5 28/5 28/5configuration [1] configuration [1] configuration [1] configuration [1] 21/3 21/3 21/3 21/3Congress [5] Congress [5] Congress [5] Congress [5] 14/8 14/15 14/8 14/15 14/8 14/15 14/8 14/15 21/2 21/2 44/14 21/2 21/2 44/14 21/2 21/2 44/14 21/2 21/2 44/14congressional [16] congressional [16] congressional [16] congressional [16] 14/8 14/8 14/8 14/8 14/16 21/18 21/19 22/7 14/16 21/18 21/19 22/7 14/16 21/18 21/19 22/7 14/16 21/18 21/19 22/7 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/17 24/19 25/18 30/15 30/16 24/19 25/18 30/15 30/16 24/19 25/18 30/15 30/16 24/19 25/18 30/15 30/16 44/15 44/16 44/17 44/15 44/16 44/17 44/15 44/16 44/17 44/15 44/16 44/17congressman [1] congressman [1] congressman [1] congressman [1] 14/10 14/10 14/10 14/10connect [1] connect [1] connect [1] connect [1] 41/10 41/10 41/10 41/10consequences [1] consequences [1] consequences [1] consequences [1] 33/14 33/14 33/14 33/14consider [1] consider [1] consider [1] consider [1] 33/10 33/10 33/10 33/10consideration [1] consideration [1] consideration [1] consideration [1] 12/22 12/22 12/22 12/22considered [2] considered [2] considered [2] considered [2] 23/4 33/22 23/4 33/22 23/4 33/22 23/4 33/22consistent [1] consistent [1] consistent [1] consistent [1] 32/11 32/11 32/11 32/11constitutes [1] constitutes [1] constitutes [1] constitutes [1] 34/2 34/2 34/2 34/2Constitution [1] Constitution [1] Constitution [1] Constitution [1] 3/9 3/9 3/9 3/9contains [1] contains [1] contains [1] contains [1] 40/22 40/22 40/22 40/22contested [4] contested [4] contested [4] contested [4] 12/1 15/9 12/1 15/9 12/1 15/9 12/1 15/9 15/10 16/16 15/10 16/16 15/10 16/16 15/10 16/16context [1] context [1] context [1] context [1] 33/22 33/22 33/22 33/22continue [2] continue [2] continue [2] continue [2] 6/12 29/14 6/12 29/14 6/12 29/14 6/12 29/14continued [3] continued [3] continued [3] continued [3] 2/2 3/2 2/2 3/2 2/2 3/2 2/2 3/2 10/1 10/1 10/1 10/1continuous [1] continuous [1] continuous [1] continuous [1] 28/25 28/25 28/25 28/25conversation [1] conversation [1] conversation [1] conversation [1] 17/6 17/6 17/6 17/6cooperators [1] cooperators [1] cooperators [1] cooperators [1] 9/3 9/3 9/3 9/3core [1] core [1] core [1] core [1] 33/20 33/20 33/20 33/20correct [66] correct [66] correct [66] correct [66] correctly [2] correctly [2] correctly [2] correctly [2] 44/1 44/1 44/1 44/1 44/1 44/1 44/1 44/1could [16] could [16] could [16] could [16] 7/3 11/5 12/19 7/3 11/5 12/19 7/3 11/5 12/19 7/3 11/5 12/19 12/20 13/2 15/11 15/24 12/20 13/2 15/11 15/24 12/20 13/2 15/11 15/24 12/20 13/2 15/11 15/24 21/12 27/21 28/14 28/15 21/12 27/21 28/14 28/15 21/12 27/21 28/14 28/15 21/12 27/21 28/14 28/15 31/11 39/19 40/10 40/12 31/11 39/19 40/10 40/12 31/11 39/19 40/10 40/12 31/11 39/19 40/10 40/12 40/16 40/16 40/16 40/16couldn't [1] couldn't [1] couldn't [1] couldn't [1] 39/17 39/17 39/17 39/17counsel [2] counsel [2] counsel [2] counsel [2] 41/4 47/7 41/4 47/7 41/4 47/7 41/4 47/7

count [3] count [3] count [3] count [3] 39/18 39/20 39/18 39/20 39/18 39/20 39/18 39/20 39/21 39/21 39/21 39/21counted [1] counted [1] counted [1] counted [1] 17/11 17/11 17/11 17/11counter [2] counter [2] counter [2] counter [2] 6/1 6/15 6/1 6/15 6/1 6/15 6/1 6/15counties [1] counties [1] counties [1] counties [1] 22/15 22/15 22/15 22/15counting [1] counting [1] counting [1] counting [1] 18/13 18/13 18/13 18/13county [5] county [5] county [5] county [5] 17/15 23/11 17/15 23/11 17/15 23/11 17/15 23/11 23/15 23/16 23/19 23/15 23/16 23/19 23/15 23/16 23/19 23/15 23/16 23/19couple [1] couple [1] couple [1] couple [1] 10/3 10/3 10/3 10/3course [2] course [2] course [2] course [2] 7/5 31/22 7/5 31/22 7/5 31/22 7/5 31/22court [36] court [36] court [36] court [36] 1/1 3/7 3/7 1/1 3/7 3/7 1/1 3/7 3/7 1/1 3/7 3/7 3/8 4/18 5/25 6/21 7/13 3/8 4/18 5/25 6/21 7/13 3/8 4/18 5/25 6/21 7/13 3/8 4/18 5/25 6/21 7/13 10/21 10/23 10/23 11/15 10/21 10/23 10/23 11/15 10/21 10/23 10/23 11/15 10/21 10/23 10/23 11/15 11/20 11/25 11/25 12/9 11/20 11/25 11/25 12/9 11/20 11/25 11/25 12/9 11/20 11/25 11/25 12/9 12/10 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/10 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/10 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/10 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/15 13/10 13/10 13/25 12/15 13/10 13/10 13/25 12/15 13/10 13/10 13/25 12/15 13/10 13/10 13/25 15/4 15/4 16/6 16/16 18/4 15/4 15/4 16/6 16/16 18/4 15/4 15/4 16/6 16/16 18/4 15/4 15/4 16/6 16/16 18/4 18/10 21/5 30/4 37/4 18/10 21/5 30/4 37/4 18/10 21/5 30/4 37/4 18/10 21/5 30/4 37/4 40/18 44/6 47/5 40/18 44/6 47/5 40/18 44/6 47/5 40/18 44/6 47/5Court's [7] Court's [7] Court's [7] Court's [7] 17/3 19/24 17/3 19/24 17/3 19/24 17/3 19/24 20/6 20/9 30/2 38/3 42/12 20/6 20/9 30/2 38/3 42/12 20/6 20/9 30/2 38/3 42/12 20/6 20/9 30/2 38/3 42/12Courthouse [1] Courthouse [1] Courthouse [1] Courthouse [1] 1/20 1/20 1/20 1/20courtroom [1] courtroom [1] courtroom [1] courtroom [1] 45/4 45/4 45/4 45/4courts [4] courts [4] courts [4] courts [4] 6/17 6/22 6/17 6/22 6/17 6/22 6/17 6/22 36/18 36/25 36/18 36/25 36/18 36/25 36/18 36/25COUTO [1] COUTO [1] COUTO [1] COUTO [1] 2/9 2/9 2/9 2/9covered [1] covered [1] covered [1] covered [1] 43/9 43/9 43/9 43/9create [1] create [1] create [1] create [1] 4/18 4/18 4/18 4/18criminal [12] criminal [12] criminal [12] criminal [12] 8/24 9/2 8/24 9/2 8/24 9/2 8/24 9/2 9/7 10/21 10/24 11/16 9/7 10/21 10/24 11/16 9/7 10/21 10/24 11/16 9/7 10/21 10/24 11/16 11/25 12/9 12/11 12/15 11/25 12/9 12/11 12/15 11/25 12/9 12/11 12/15 11/25 12/9 12/11 12/15 15/5 16/6 15/5 16/6 15/5 16/6 15/5 16/6criteria [5] criteria [5] criteria [5] criteria [5] 11/23 12/10 11/23 12/10 11/23 12/10 11/23 12/10 16/15 17/4 18/8 16/15 17/4 18/8 16/15 17/4 18/8 16/15 17/4 18/8criterion [2] criterion [2] criterion [2] criterion [2] 19/11 20/19 19/11 20/19 19/11 20/19 19/11 20/19criticism [1] criticism [1] criticism [1] criticism [1] 30/4 30/4 30/4 30/4criticize [1] criticize [1] criticize [1] criticize [1] 30/2 30/2 30/2 30/2cross [9] cross [9] cross [9] cross [9] 5/13 10/1 21/16 5/13 10/1 21/16 5/13 10/1 21/16 5/13 10/1 21/16 30/24 37/14 42/18 43/10 30/24 37/14 42/18 43/10 30/24 37/14 42/18 43/10 30/24 37/14 42/18 43/10 43/12 46/2 43/12 46/2 43/12 46/2 43/12 46/2cross-examine [1] cross-examine [1] cross-examine [1] cross-examine [1] 42/18 42/18 42/18 42/18crossed [1] crossed [1] crossed [1] crossed [1] 35/25 35/25 35/25 35/25crossover [6] crossover [6] crossover [6] crossover [6] 33/15 33/21 33/15 33/21 33/15 33/21 33/15 33/21 34/1 34/2 35/19 36/1 34/1 34/2 35/19 36/1 34/1 34/2 35/19 36/1 34/1 34/2 35/19 36/1CRYSTAL [2] CRYSTAL [2] CRYSTAL [2] CRYSTAL [2] 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12cut [2] cut [2] cut [2] cut [2] 18/14 18/15 18/14 18/15 18/14 18/15 18/14 18/15

DDDDD.C [1] D.C [1] D.C [1] D.C [1] 1/5 1/5 1/5 1/5dah [4] dah [4] dah [4] dah [4] 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25 42/25DANIEL [2] DANIEL [2] DANIEL [2] DANIEL [2] 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9data [8] data [8] data [8] data [8] 28/19 28/21 29/2 28/19 28/21 29/2 28/19 28/21 29/2 28/19 28/21 29/2 29/7 29/19 29/21 29/24 29/7 29/19 29/21 29/24 29/7 29/19 29/21 29/24 29/7 29/19 29/21 29/24 30/7 30/7 30/7 30/7date [2] date [2] date [2] date [2] 47/5 47/12 47/5 47/12 47/5 47/12 47/5 47/12Davis [8] Davis [8] Davis [8] Davis [8] 1/9 30/22 32/12 1/9 30/22 32/12 1/9 30/22 32/12 1/9 30/22 32/12 32/25 33/5 33/8 35/4 37/9 32/25 33/5 33/8 35/4 37/9 32/25 33/5 33/8 35/4 37/9 32/25 33/5 33/8 35/4 37/9Davis' [2] Davis' [2] Davis' [2] Davis' [2] 35/15 35/24 35/15 35/24 35/15 35/24 35/15 35/24day [4] day [4] day [4] day [4] 1/7 7/7 8/22 8/25 1/7 7/7 8/22 8/25 1/7 7/7 8/22 8/25 1/7 7/7 8/22 8/25days [2] days [2] days [2] days [2] 7/7 24/16 7/7 24/16 7/7 24/16 7/7 24/16DC [4] DC [4] DC [4] DC [4] 2/5 2/7 2/16 3/9 2/5 2/7 2/16 3/9 2/5 2/7 2/16 3/9 2/5 2/7 2/16 3/9dealing [2] dealing [2] dealing [2] dealing [2] 6/23 25/9 6/23 25/9 6/23 25/9 6/23 25/9decade [3] decade [3] decade [3] decade [3] 13/20 38/16 13/20 38/16 13/20 38/16 13/20 38/16 39/24 39/24 39/24 39/24decades [1] decades [1] decades [1] decades [1] 29/13 29/13 29/13 29/13December [1] December [1] December [1] December [1] 29/4 29/4 29/4 29/4decided [1] decided [1] decided [1] decided [1] 7/17 7/17 7/17 7/17decides [1] decides [1] decides [1] decides [1] 4/18 4/18 4/18 4/18deciding [2] deciding [2] deciding [2] deciding [2] 35/16 35/18 35/16 35/18 35/16 35/18 35/16 35/18decisions [2] decisions [2] decisions [2] decisions [2] 13/16 13/17 13/16 13/17 13/16 13/17 13/16 13/17

50505050

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 50 of 59

Page 51: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

DDDDdecrease [1] decrease [1] decrease [1] decrease [1] 43/24 43/24 43/24 43/24decreased [1] decreased [1] decreased [1] decreased [1] 17/1 17/1 17/1 17/1Defendant [2] Defendant [2] Defendant [2] Defendant [2] 2/7 4/11 2/7 4/11 2/7 4/11 2/7 4/11Defendant's [2] Defendant's [2] Defendant's [2] Defendant's [2] 36/22 36/22 36/22 36/22 40/10 40/10 40/10 40/10defendants [7] defendants [7] defendants [7] defendants [7] 1/8 1/10 1/8 1/10 1/8 1/10 1/8 1/10 2/3 4/21 5/1 6/11 6/16 2/3 4/21 5/1 6/11 6/16 2/3 4/21 5/1 6/11 6/16 2/3 4/21 5/1 6/11 6/16defense [3] defense [3] defense [3] defense [3] 2/10 4/9 10/6 2/10 4/9 10/6 2/10 4/9 10/6 2/10 4/9 10/6degree [5] degree [5] degree [5] degree [5] 34/12 34/17 34/12 34/17 34/12 34/17 34/12 34/17 35/15 35/16 36/10 35/15 35/16 36/10 35/15 35/16 36/10 35/15 35/16 36/10democratic [4] democratic [4] democratic [4] democratic [4] 24/12 35/6 24/12 35/6 24/12 35/6 24/12 35/6 38/18 39/9 38/18 39/9 38/18 39/9 38/18 39/9democrats [1] democrats [1] democrats [1] democrats [1] 39/11 39/11 39/11 39/11demographic [1] demographic [1] demographic [1] demographic [1] 39/24 39/24 39/24 39/24Department [7] Department [7] Department [7] Department [7] 2/4 4/23 2/4 4/23 2/4 4/23 2/4 4/23 5/4 15/20 40/21 42/1 42/7 5/4 15/20 40/21 42/1 42/7 5/4 15/20 40/21 42/1 42/7 5/4 15/20 40/21 42/1 42/7Department's [1] Department's [1] Department's [1] Department's [1] 38/4 38/4 38/4 38/4deposition [9] deposition [9] deposition [9] deposition [9] 5/5 5/8 5/5 5/8 5/5 5/8 5/5 5/8 7/25 11/14 15/8 17/7 19/1 7/25 11/14 15/8 17/7 19/1 7/25 11/14 15/8 17/7 19/1 7/25 11/14 15/8 17/7 19/1 24/15 27/13 24/15 27/13 24/15 27/13 24/15 27/13depositions [1] depositions [1] depositions [1] depositions [1] 6/2 6/2 6/2 6/2describing [1] describing [1] describing [1] describing [1] 9/13 9/13 9/13 9/13designate [7] designate [7] designate [7] designate [7] 5/7 6/1 7/1 5/7 6/1 7/1 5/7 6/1 7/1 5/7 6/1 7/1 7/10 7/12 21/1 21/5 7/10 7/12 21/1 21/5 7/10 7/12 21/1 21/5 7/10 7/12 21/1 21/5designated [5] designated [5] designated [5] designated [5] 5/5 6/2 5/5 6/2 5/5 6/2 5/5 6/2 6/16 7/10 7/22 6/16 7/10 7/22 6/16 7/10 7/22 6/16 7/10 7/22designating [2] designating [2] designating [2] designating [2] 4/21 5/1 4/21 5/1 4/21 5/1 4/21 5/1designation [2] designation [2] designation [2] designation [2] 4/17 6/15 4/17 6/15 4/17 6/15 4/17 6/15designations [3] designations [3] designations [3] designations [3] 4/19 5/6 4/19 5/6 4/19 5/6 4/19 5/6 6/12 6/12 6/12 6/12determine [3] determine [3] determine [3] determine [3] 37/5 38/12 37/5 38/12 37/5 38/12 37/5 38/12 38/24 38/24 38/24 38/24DEVANEY [4] DEVANEY [4] DEVANEY [4] DEVANEY [4] 2/14 4/12 2/14 4/12 2/14 4/12 2/14 4/12 21/13 46/6 21/13 46/6 21/13 46/6 21/13 46/6developed [1] developed [1] developed [1] developed [1] 28/22 28/22 28/22 28/22developing [1] developing [1] developing [1] developing [1] 27/8 27/8 27/8 27/8did [29] did [29] did [29] did [29] 17/20 17/21 18/1 17/20 17/21 18/1 17/20 17/21 18/1 17/20 17/21 18/1 18/3 19/1 21/25 23/15 18/3 19/1 21/25 23/15 18/3 19/1 21/25 23/15 18/3 19/1 21/25 23/15 23/23 24/18 25/5 25/6 23/23 24/18 25/5 25/6 23/23 24/18 25/5 25/6 23/23 24/18 25/5 25/6 25/8 31/6 31/25 32/1 32/8 25/8 31/6 31/25 32/1 32/8 25/8 31/6 31/25 32/1 32/8 25/8 31/6 31/25 32/1 32/8 34/18 34/20 36/6 36/10 34/18 34/20 36/6 36/10 34/18 34/20 36/6 36/10 34/18 34/20 36/6 36/10 38/20 38/23 38/23 39/4 38/20 38/23 38/23 39/4 38/20 38/23 38/23 39/4 38/20 38/23 38/23 39/4 41/1 41/3 42/4 42/6 45/5 41/1 41/3 42/4 42/6 45/5 41/1 41/3 42/4 42/6 45/5 41/1 41/3 42/4 42/6 45/5didn't [17] didn't [17] didn't [17] didn't [17] 15/11 15/19 15/11 15/19 15/11 15/19 15/11 15/19 16/13 17/19 18/1 18/6 16/13 17/19 18/1 18/6 16/13 17/19 18/1 18/6 16/13 17/19 18/1 18/6 18/10 23/14 23/22 23/24 18/10 23/14 23/22 23/24 18/10 23/14 23/22 23/24 18/10 23/14 23/22 23/24 24/2 24/14 36/4 39/2 39/5 24/2 24/14 36/4 39/2 39/5 24/2 24/14 36/4 39/2 39/5 24/2 24/14 36/4 39/2 39/5 41/15 42/13 41/15 42/13 41/15 42/13 41/15 42/13difference [2] difference [2] difference [2] difference [2] 35/14 35/14 35/14 35/14 35/23 35/23 35/23 35/23different [6] different [6] different [6] different [6] 24/23 25/24 24/23 25/24 24/23 25/24 24/23 25/24 27/7 27/7 28/3 43/19 27/7 27/7 28/3 43/19 27/7 27/7 28/3 43/19 27/7 27/7 28/3 43/19differently [1] differently [1] differently [1] differently [1] 33/13 33/13 33/13 33/13difficult [3] difficult [3] difficult [3] difficult [3] 34/13 34/18 34/13 34/18 34/13 34/18 34/13 34/18 34/20 34/20 34/20 34/20diligently [1] diligently [1] diligently [1] diligently [1] 6/15 6/15 6/15 6/15diminishes [1] diminishes [1] diminishes [1] diminishes [1] 39/14 39/14 39/14 39/14direct [9] direct [9] direct [9] direct [9] 5/13 10/6 20/3 5/13 10/6 20/3 5/13 10/6 20/3 5/13 10/6 20/3 22/9 22/22 22/25 36/17 22/9 22/22 22/25 36/17 22/9 22/22 22/25 36/17 22/9 22/22 22/25 36/17 41/3 46/2 41/3 46/2 41/3 46/2 41/3 46/2disagree [2] disagree [2] disagree [2] disagree [2] 34/3 35/12 34/3 35/12 34/3 35/12 34/3 35/12discussed [5] discussed [5] discussed [5] discussed [5] 16/15 19/21 16/15 19/21 16/15 19/21 16/15 19/21 32/18 41/17 41/18 32/18 41/17 41/18 32/18 41/17 41/18 32/18 41/17 41/18discussing [2] discussing [2] discussing [2] discussing [2] 12/7 20/23 12/7 20/23 12/7 20/23 12/7 20/23discussion [8] discussion [8] discussion [8] discussion [8] 11/11 11/11 11/11 11/11 16/24 20/5 33/20 39/5 16/24 20/5 33/20 39/5 16/24 20/5 33/20 39/5 16/24 20/5 33/20 39/5 40/16 40/17 41/8 40/16 40/17 41/8 40/16 40/17 41/8 40/16 40/17 41/8dispute [4] dispute [4] dispute [4] dispute [4] 31/19 40/21 31/19 40/21 31/19 40/21 31/19 40/21 42/2 42/13 42/2 42/13 42/2 42/13 42/2 42/13

disputing [1] disputing [1] disputing [1] disputing [1] 41/24 41/24 41/24 41/24distinction [1] distinction [1] distinction [1] distinction [1] 12/18 12/18 12/18 12/18district [64] district [64] district [64] district [64] districts [14] districts [14] districts [14] districts [14] 9/13 17/21 9/13 17/21 9/13 17/21 9/13 17/21 18/3 18/6 18/17 19/11 18/3 18/6 18/17 19/11 18/3 18/6 18/17 19/11 18/3 18/6 18/17 19/11 22/15 28/7 30/13 33/22 22/15 28/7 30/13 33/22 22/15 28/7 30/13 33/22 22/15 28/7 30/13 33/22 37/24 37/25 40/23 41/14 37/24 37/25 40/23 41/14 37/24 37/25 40/23 41/14 37/24 37/25 40/23 41/14do [38] do [38] do [38] do [38] 6/8 6/17 7/13 6/8 6/17 7/13 6/8 6/17 7/13 6/8 6/17 7/13 7/16 8/3 8/3 8/3 8/4 8/10 7/16 8/3 8/3 8/3 8/4 8/10 7/16 8/3 8/3 8/3 8/4 8/10 7/16 8/3 8/3 8/3 8/4 8/10 9/5 9/7 9/7 9/15 10/7 9/5 9/7 9/7 9/15 10/7 9/5 9/7 9/7 9/15 10/7 9/5 9/7 9/7 9/15 10/7 10/15 11/8 13/2 13/3 17/6 10/15 11/8 13/2 13/3 17/6 10/15 11/8 13/2 13/3 17/6 10/15 11/8 13/2 13/3 17/6 17/19 17/24 18/1 18/16 17/19 17/24 18/1 18/16 17/19 17/24 18/1 18/16 17/19 17/24 18/1 18/16 19/3 19/5 20/1 20/11 21/4 19/3 19/5 20/1 20/11 21/4 19/3 19/5 20/1 20/11 21/4 19/3 19/5 20/1 20/11 21/4 21/5 26/25 28/11 30/9 21/5 26/25 28/11 30/9 21/5 26/25 28/11 30/9 21/5 26/25 28/11 30/9 35/10 36/2 37/20 38/16 35/10 36/2 37/20 38/16 35/10 36/2 37/20 38/16 35/10 36/2 37/20 38/16 40/24 43/15 40/24 43/15 40/24 43/15 40/24 43/15Docket [1] Docket [1] Docket [1] Docket [1] 1/4 1/4 1/4 1/4doctor [4] doctor [4] doctor [4] doctor [4] 14/6 33/25 14/6 33/25 14/6 33/25 14/6 33/25 40/9 42/15 40/9 42/15 40/9 42/15 40/9 42/15document [1] document [1] document [1] document [1] 40/13 40/13 40/13 40/13does [4] does [4] does [4] does [4] 31/15 31/16 31/15 31/16 31/15 31/16 31/15 31/16 34/19 43/23 34/19 43/23 34/19 43/23 34/19 43/23doesn't [10] doesn't [10] doesn't [10] doesn't [10] 12/17 16/14 12/17 16/14 12/17 16/14 12/17 16/14 20/20 27/23 28/3 28/7 20/20 27/23 28/3 28/7 20/20 27/23 28/3 28/7 20/20 27/23 28/3 28/7 29/25 30/11 35/23 41/23 29/25 30/11 35/23 41/23 29/25 30/11 35/23 41/23 29/25 30/11 35/23 41/23doing [2] doing [2] doing [2] doing [2] 12/23 37/10 12/23 37/10 12/23 37/10 12/23 37/10don't [38] don't [38] don't [38] don't [38] 5/11 5/20 6/24 5/11 5/20 6/24 5/11 5/20 6/24 5/11 5/20 6/24 6/25 7/10 8/14 9/7 11/7 6/25 7/10 8/14 9/7 11/7 6/25 7/10 8/14 9/7 11/7 6/25 7/10 8/14 9/7 11/7 11/10 11/12 13/10 13/14 11/10 11/12 13/10 13/14 11/10 11/12 13/10 13/14 11/10 11/12 13/10 13/14 13/14 16/1 16/5 16/9 13/14 16/1 16/5 16/9 13/14 16/1 16/5 16/9 13/14 16/1 16/5 16/9 16/19 17/23 18/21 19/12 16/19 17/23 18/21 19/12 16/19 17/23 18/21 19/12 16/19 17/23 18/21 19/12 23/25 24/5 24/12 27/14 23/25 24/5 24/12 27/14 23/25 24/5 24/12 27/14 23/25 24/5 24/12 27/14 27/16 28/15 30/18 32/15 27/16 28/15 30/18 32/15 27/16 28/15 30/18 32/15 27/16 28/15 30/18 32/15 33/10 34/3 34/6 35/12 33/10 34/3 34/6 35/12 33/10 34/3 34/6 35/12 33/10 34/3 34/6 35/12 36/2 36/2 37/14 37/15 36/2 36/2 37/14 37/15 36/2 36/2 37/14 37/15 36/2 36/2 37/14 37/15 37/18 38/7 37/18 38/7 37/18 38/7 37/18 38/7done [9] done [9] done [9] done [9] 6/4 7/6 9/4 6/4 7/6 9/4 6/4 7/6 9/4 6/4 7/6 9/4 24/24 24/24 27/25 28/25 24/24 24/24 27/25 28/25 24/24 24/24 27/25 28/25 24/24 24/24 27/25 28/25 29/1 42/21 29/1 42/21 29/1 42/21 29/1 42/21down [9] down [9] down [9] down [9] 4/14 10/20 10/25 4/14 10/20 10/25 4/14 10/20 10/25 4/14 10/20 10/25 12/6 12/10 13/9 13/10 12/6 12/10 13/9 13/10 12/6 12/10 13/9 13/10 12/6 12/10 13/9 13/10 13/14 15/14 13/14 15/14 13/14 15/14 13/14 15/14Dr [30] Dr [30] Dr [30] Dr [30] 8/19 8/21 9/12 8/19 8/21 9/12 8/19 8/21 9/12 8/19 8/21 9/12 10/3 13/24 16/24 18/17 10/3 13/24 16/24 18/17 10/3 13/24 16/24 18/17 10/3 13/24 16/24 18/17 19/1 19/11 19/20 19/21 19/1 19/11 19/20 19/21 19/1 19/11 19/20 19/21 19/1 19/11 19/20 19/21 21/1 21/6 21/11 21/18 21/1 21/6 21/11 21/18 21/1 21/6 21/11 21/18 21/1 21/6 21/11 21/18 30/4 31/1 32/11 32/18 30/4 31/1 32/11 32/18 30/4 31/1 32/11 32/18 30/4 31/1 32/11 32/18 32/21 33/2 34/25 37/9 32/21 33/2 34/25 37/9 32/21 33/2 34/25 37/9 32/21 33/2 34/25 37/9 40/21 41/10 41/12 41/15 40/21 41/10 41/12 41/15 40/21 41/10 41/12 41/15 40/21 41/10 41/12 41/15 41/18 41/19 42/13 41/18 41/19 42/13 41/18 41/19 42/13 41/18 41/19 42/13drafted [1] drafted [1] drafted [1] drafted [1] 41/6 41/6 41/6 41/6drawn [2] drawn [2] drawn [2] drawn [2] 39/23 40/3 39/23 40/3 39/23 40/3 39/23 40/3Drive [1] Drive [1] Drive [1] Drive [1] 2/13 2/13 2/13 2/13due [1] due [1] due [1] due [1] 39/24 39/24 39/24 39/24DUNN [3] DUNN [3] DUNN [3] DUNN [3] 2/20 2/21 4/12 2/20 2/21 4/12 2/20 2/21 4/12 2/20 2/21 4/12during [2] during [2] during [2] during [2] 43/10 43/11 43/10 43/11 43/10 43/11 43/10 43/11

EEEEeach [7] each [7] each [7] each [7] 6/23 10/15 10/18 6/23 10/15 10/18 6/23 10/15 10/18 6/23 10/15 10/18 10/19 26/3 37/8 37/9 10/19 26/3 37/8 37/9 10/19 26/3 37/8 37/9 10/19 26/3 37/8 37/9earlier [2] earlier [2] earlier [2] earlier [2] 11/3 45/6 11/3 45/6 11/3 45/6 11/3 45/6early [1] early [1] early [1] early [1] 45/3 45/3 45/3 45/3ecological [2] ecological [2] ecological [2] ecological [2] 25/17 27/3 25/17 27/3 25/17 27/3 25/17 27/3Educational [1] Educational [1] Educational [1] Educational [1] 2/10 2/10 2/10 2/10effective [2] effective [2] effective [2] effective [2] 40/22 41/14 40/22 41/14 40/22 41/14 40/22 41/14effort [2] effort [2] effort [2] effort [2] 38/25 39/8 38/25 39/8 38/25 39/8 38/25 39/8eight [3] eight [3] eight [3] eight [3] 27/22 28/2 28/4 27/22 28/2 28/4 27/22 28/2 28/4 27/22 28/2 28/4either [4] either [4] either [4] either [4] 8/13 18/21 8/13 18/21 8/13 18/21 8/13 18/21 40/7 44/10 40/7 44/10 40/7 44/10 40/7 44/10elect [19] elect [19] elect [19] elect [19] 17/4 17/12 17/4 17/12 17/4 17/12 17/4 17/12 17/13 19/25 21/21 34/14 17/13 19/25 21/21 34/14 17/13 19/25 21/21 34/14 17/13 19/25 21/21 34/14

34/18 34/20 34/20 37/6 34/18 34/20 34/20 37/6 34/18 34/20 34/20 37/6 34/18 34/20 34/20 37/6 38/9 39/9 39/14 40/1 38/9 39/9 39/14 40/1 38/9 39/9 39/14 40/1 38/9 39/9 39/14 40/1 43/25 44/3 44/8 44/9 44/9 43/25 44/3 44/8 44/9 44/9 43/25 44/3 44/8 44/9 44/9 43/25 44/3 44/8 44/9 44/9elected [7] elected [7] elected [7] elected [7] 10/24 10/25 10/24 10/25 10/24 10/25 10/24 10/25 25/4 25/7 36/1 36/3 38/13 25/4 25/7 36/1 36/3 38/13 25/4 25/7 36/1 36/3 38/13 25/4 25/7 36/1 36/3 38/13electing [1] electing [1] electing [1] electing [1] 14/10 14/10 14/10 14/10election [32] election [32] election [32] election [32] 10/12 10/15 10/12 10/15 10/12 10/15 10/12 10/15 14/13 15/22 25/5 25/10 14/13 15/22 25/5 25/10 14/13 15/22 25/5 25/10 14/13 15/22 25/5 25/10 31/3 31/6 31/7 31/18 31/3 31/6 31/7 31/18 31/3 31/6 31/7 31/18 31/3 31/6 31/7 31/18 31/18 31/21 31/22 32/3 31/18 31/21 31/22 32/3 31/18 31/21 31/22 32/3 31/18 31/21 31/22 32/3 32/8 32/12 32/24 33/14 32/8 32/12 32/24 33/14 32/8 32/12 32/24 33/14 32/8 32/12 32/24 33/14 34/11 35/15 35/15 35/24 34/11 35/15 35/15 35/24 34/11 35/15 35/15 35/24 34/11 35/15 35/15 35/24 36/19 37/13 38/12 38/16 36/19 37/13 38/12 38/16 36/19 37/13 38/12 38/16 36/19 37/13 38/12 38/16 38/17 38/24 39/8 39/19 38/17 38/24 39/8 39/19 38/17 38/24 39/8 39/19 38/17 38/24 39/8 39/19 43/18 43/23 43/18 43/23 43/18 43/23 43/18 43/23elections [33] elections [33] elections [33] elections [33] 10/4 10/7 10/4 10/7 10/4 10/7 10/4 10/7 10/10 10/10 11/4 11/7 10/10 10/10 11/4 11/7 10/10 10/10 11/4 11/7 10/10 10/10 11/4 11/7 15/9 15/17 15/17 16/2 15/9 15/17 15/17 16/2 15/9 15/17 15/17 16/2 15/9 15/17 15/17 16/2 16/13 18/14 21/22 22/6 16/13 18/14 21/22 22/6 16/13 18/14 21/22 22/6 16/13 18/14 21/22 22/6 23/7 25/8 26/17 26/17 23/7 25/8 26/17 26/17 23/7 25/8 26/17 26/17 23/7 25/8 26/17 26/17 31/20 31/23 32/4 33/15 31/20 31/23 32/4 33/15 31/20 31/23 32/4 33/15 31/20 31/23 32/4 33/15 36/19 36/25 37/1 37/5 36/19 36/25 37/1 37/5 36/19 36/25 37/1 37/5 36/19 36/25 37/1 37/5 37/10 37/13 37/17 37/18 37/10 37/13 37/17 37/18 37/10 37/13 37/17 37/18 37/10 37/13 37/17 37/18 37/20 41/16 42/5 37/20 41/16 42/5 37/20 41/16 42/5 37/20 41/16 42/5elevated [1] elevated [1] elevated [1] elevated [1] 19/25 19/25 19/25 19/25elevation [1] elevation [1] elevation [1] elevation [1] 20/14 20/14 20/14 20/14eliminates [1] eliminates [1] eliminates [1] eliminates [1] 22/3 22/3 22/3 22/3eliminations [1] eliminations [1] eliminations [1] eliminations [1] 5/24 5/24 5/24 5/24else [7] else [7] else [7] else [7] 5/16 8/14 9/5 5/16 8/14 9/5 5/16 8/14 9/5 5/16 8/14 9/5 22/17 32/17 42/10 42/18 22/17 32/17 42/10 42/18 22/17 32/17 42/10 42/18 22/17 32/17 42/10 42/18employed [1] employed [1] employed [1] employed [1] 47/8 47/8 47/8 47/8enacted [2] enacted [2] enacted [2] enacted [2] 43/20 43/23 43/20 43/23 43/20 43/23 43/20 43/23encompasses [1] encompasses [1] encompasses [1] encompasses [1] 23/11 23/11 23/11 23/11encounters [1] encounters [1] encounters [1] encounters [1] 14/12 14/12 14/12 14/12endeavor [1] endeavor [1] endeavor [1] endeavor [1] 6/4 6/4 6/4 6/4endogenous [19] endogenous [19] endogenous [19] endogenous [19] 31/3 31/6 31/3 31/6 31/3 31/6 31/3 31/6 31/12 31/20 32/3 32/8 31/12 31/20 32/3 32/8 31/12 31/20 32/3 32/8 31/12 31/20 32/3 32/8 36/19 36/25 37/13 37/13 36/19 36/25 37/13 37/13 36/19 36/25 37/13 37/13 36/19 36/25 37/13 37/13 37/16 37/17 37/18 37/20 37/16 37/17 37/18 37/20 37/16 37/17 37/18 37/20 37/16 37/17 37/18 37/20 38/3 38/5 38/6 38/12 38/3 38/5 38/6 38/12 38/3 38/5 38/6 38/12 38/3 38/5 38/6 38/12 38/17 38/17 38/17 38/17enlarge [1] enlarge [1] enlarge [1] enlarge [1] 40/17 40/17 40/17 40/17enough [1] enough [1] enough [1] enough [1] 4/24 4/24 4/24 4/24entire [1] entire [1] entire [1] entire [1] 41/6 41/6 41/6 41/6entirely [2] entirely [2] entirely [2] entirely [2] 7/14 39/6 7/14 39/6 7/14 39/6 7/14 39/6ERIC [1] ERIC [1] ERIC [1] ERIC [1] 1/6 1/6 1/6 1/6error [10] error [10] error [10] error [10] 26/9 26/14 26/9 26/14 26/9 26/14 26/9 26/14 26/18 26/22 27/2 27/6 26/18 26/22 27/2 27/6 26/18 26/22 27/2 27/6 26/18 26/22 27/2 27/6 27/8 27/10 27/14 27/18 27/8 27/10 27/14 27/18 27/8 27/10 27/14 27/18 27/8 27/10 27/14 27/18especially [1] especially [1] especially [1] especially [1] 13/24 13/24 13/24 13/24Esquire [17] Esquire [17] Esquire [17] Esquire [17] 1/17 1/17 1/17 1/17 1/17 1/17 1/17 1/17 1/18 1/18 1/23 1/23 1/24 1/18 1/18 1/23 1/23 1/24 1/18 1/18 1/23 1/23 1/24 1/18 1/18 1/23 1/23 1/24 2/3 2/3 2/4 2/6 2/8 2/9 2/3 2/3 2/4 2/6 2/8 2/9 2/3 2/3 2/4 2/6 2/8 2/9 2/3 2/3 2/4 2/6 2/8 2/9 2/12 2/14 2/17 2/20 2/12 2/14 2/17 2/20 2/12 2/14 2/17 2/20 2/12 2/14 2/17 2/20estimate [2] estimate [2] estimate [2] estimate [2] 26/2 27/6 26/2 27/6 26/2 27/6 26/2 27/6estimates [3] estimates [3] estimates [3] estimates [3] 25/17 27/2 25/17 27/2 25/17 27/2 25/17 27/2 27/3 27/3 27/3 27/3et [2] et [2] et [2] et [2] 1/9 4/5 1/9 4/5 1/9 4/5 1/9 4/5even [4] even [4] even [4] even [4] 21/24 23/22 21/24 23/22 21/24 23/22 21/24 23/22 42/14 44/4 42/14 44/4 42/14 44/4 42/14 44/4event [1] event [1] event [1] event [1] 23/3 23/3 23/3 23/3ever [4] ever [4] ever [4] ever [4] 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 24/24 32/17 24/24 32/17 24/24 32/17 24/24 32/17every [6] every [6] every [6] every [6] 8/25 9/3 27/23 8/25 9/3 27/23 8/25 9/3 27/23 8/25 9/3 27/23 29/1 38/16 44/7 29/1 38/16 44/7 29/1 38/16 44/7 29/1 38/16 44/7everybody [5] everybody [5] everybody [5] everybody [5] 5/10 5/16 5/10 5/16 5/10 5/16 5/10 5/16 6/6 14/8 30/2 6/6 14/8 30/2 6/6 14/8 30/2 6/6 14/8 30/2everybody's [1] everybody's [1] everybody's [1] everybody's [1] 13/19 13/19 13/19 13/19evidence [2] evidence [2] evidence [2] evidence [2] 5/15 9/16 5/15 9/16 5/15 9/16 5/15 9/16exact [2] exact [2] exact [2] exact [2] 18/19 38/15 18/19 38/15 18/19 38/15 18/19 38/15exactly [2] exactly [2] exactly [2] exactly [2] 27/23 34/5 27/23 34/5 27/23 34/5 27/23 34/5

51515151

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 51 of 59

Page 52: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

EEEEexamination [6] examination [6] examination [6] examination [6] 10/1 10/1 10/1 10/1 21/16 30/24 43/5 43/10 21/16 30/24 43/5 43/10 21/16 30/24 43/5 43/10 21/16 30/24 43/5 43/10 43/12 43/12 43/12 43/12examinations [1] examinations [1] examinations [1] examinations [1] 5/24 5/24 5/24 5/24examine [3] examine [3] examine [3] examine [3] 31/6 32/8 31/6 32/8 31/6 32/8 31/6 32/8 42/18 42/18 42/18 42/18example [8] example [8] example [8] example [8] 4/23 5/4 4/23 5/4 4/23 5/4 4/23 5/4 13/11 16/14 26/25 28/13 13/11 16/14 26/25 28/13 13/11 16/14 26/25 28/13 13/11 16/14 26/25 28/13 39/7 39/19 39/7 39/19 39/7 39/19 39/7 39/19excerpt [1] excerpt [1] excerpt [1] excerpt [1] 22/19 22/19 22/19 22/19excluded [1] excluded [1] excluded [1] excluded [1] 30/13 30/13 30/13 30/13excused [2] excused [2] excused [2] excused [2] 44/23 44/25 44/23 44/25 44/23 44/25 44/23 44/25Exhibit [6] Exhibit [6] Exhibit [6] Exhibit [6] 10/5 10/6 10/5 10/6 10/5 10/6 10/5 10/6 22/20 36/22 36/22 40/10 22/20 36/22 36/22 40/10 22/20 36/22 36/22 40/10 22/20 36/22 36/22 40/10exogenous [6] exogenous [6] exogenous [6] exogenous [6] 18/14 25/9 18/14 25/9 18/14 25/9 18/14 25/9 31/3 37/4 37/10 39/19 31/3 37/4 37/10 39/19 31/3 37/4 37/10 39/19 31/3 37/4 37/10 39/19expected [1] expected [1] expected [1] expected [1] 40/7 40/7 40/7 40/7expert [6] expert [6] expert [6] expert [6] 6/17 15/20 6/17 15/20 6/17 15/20 6/17 15/20 32/11 40/21 42/1 42/8 32/11 40/21 42/1 42/8 32/11 40/21 42/1 42/8 32/11 40/21 42/1 42/8experts [1] experts [1] experts [1] experts [1] 29/20 29/20 29/20 29/20explain [3] explain [3] explain [3] explain [3] 12/21 13/2 12/21 13/2 12/21 13/2 12/21 13/2 16/14 16/14 16/14 16/14explained [1] explained [1] explained [1] explained [1] 27/20 27/20 27/20 27/20explore [1] explore [1] explore [1] explore [1] 43/11 43/11 43/11 43/11extreme [8] extreme [8] extreme [8] extreme [8] 32/13 32/15 32/13 32/15 32/13 32/15 32/13 32/15 32/18 33/10 33/16 33/24 32/18 33/10 33/16 33/24 32/18 33/10 33/16 33/24 32/18 33/10 33/16 33/24 34/7 34/9 34/7 34/9 34/7 34/9 34/7 34/9

FFFFfact [10] fact [10] fact [10] fact [10] 10/10 19/21 10/10 19/21 10/10 19/21 10/10 19/21 20/9 23/21 24/6 29/10 20/9 23/21 24/6 29/10 20/9 23/21 24/6 29/10 20/9 23/21 24/6 29/10 41/15 41/17 41/19 41/21 41/15 41/17 41/19 41/21 41/15 41/17 41/19 41/21 41/15 41/17 41/19 41/21factor [2] factor [2] factor [2] factor [2] 35/16 35/18 35/16 35/18 35/16 35/18 35/16 35/18factors [2] factors [2] factors [2] factors [2] 37/2 37/3 37/2 37/3 37/2 37/3 37/2 37/3fair [2] fair [2] fair [2] fair [2] 4/24 22/11 4/24 22/11 4/24 22/11 4/24 22/11fairly [1] fairly [1] fairly [1] fairly [1] 10/25 10/25 10/25 10/25familiar [1] familiar [1] familiar [1] familiar [1] 28/19 28/19 28/19 28/19far [4] far [4] far [4] far [4] 7/6 10/25 12/10 7/6 10/25 12/10 7/6 10/25 12/10 7/6 10/25 12/10 15/15 15/15 15/15 15/15fast [1] fast [1] fast [1] fast [1] 7/17 7/17 7/17 7/17faster [1] faster [1] faster [1] faster [1] 43/3 43/3 43/3 43/3fault [1] fault [1] fault [1] fault [1] 6/6 6/6 6/6 6/6featured [1] featured [1] featured [1] featured [1] 12/1 12/1 12/1 12/1featuring [2] featuring [2] featuring [2] featuring [2] 11/16 11/20 11/16 11/20 11/16 11/20 11/16 11/20federal [6] federal [6] federal [6] federal [6] 5/7 14/1 14/7 5/7 14/1 14/7 5/7 14/1 14/7 5/7 14/1 14/7 14/18 14/21 15/2 14/18 14/21 15/2 14/18 14/21 15/2 14/18 14/21 15/2feel [1] feel [1] feel [1] feel [1] 6/7 6/7 6/7 6/7feels [1] feels [1] feels [1] feels [1] 8/13 8/13 8/13 8/13felt [1] felt [1] felt [1] felt [1] 20/5 20/5 20/5 20/5few [2] few [2] few [2] few [2] 24/16 30/23 24/16 30/23 24/16 30/23 24/16 30/23figures [1] figures [1] figures [1] figures [1] 28/13 28/13 28/13 28/13filed [11] filed [11] filed [11] filed [11] 10/6 20/3 22/9 10/6 20/3 22/9 10/6 20/3 22/9 10/6 20/3 22/9 22/22 22/23 34/25 36/17 22/22 22/23 34/25 36/17 22/22 22/23 34/25 36/17 22/22 22/23 34/25 36/17 40/11 40/13 40/15 41/3 40/11 40/13 40/15 41/3 40/11 40/13 40/15 41/3 40/11 40/13 40/15 41/3final [1] final [1] final [1] final [1] 40/9 40/9 40/9 40/9financially [1] financially [1] financially [1] financially [1] 47/9 47/9 47/9 47/9find [3] find [3] find [3] find [3] 6/21 33/19 39/19 6/21 33/19 39/19 6/21 33/19 39/19 6/21 33/19 39/19finding [1] finding [1] finding [1] finding [1] 35/10 35/10 35/10 35/10finds [1] finds [1] finds [1] finds [1] 19/21 19/21 19/21 19/21fine [2] fine [2] fine [2] fine [2] 21/7 28/9 21/7 28/9 21/7 28/9 21/7 28/9first [4] first [4] first [4] first [4] 4/2 22/21 40/16 4/2 22/21 40/16 4/2 22/21 40/16 4/2 22/21 40/16 40/19 40/19 40/19 40/19five [3] five [3] five [3] five [3] 15/18 26/18 43/1 15/18 26/18 43/1 15/18 26/18 43/1 15/18 26/18 43/1FM [1] FM [1] FM [1] FM [1] 2/21 2/21 2/21 2/21focused [2] focused [2] focused [2] focused [2] 36/19 36/25 36/19 36/25 36/19 36/25 36/19 36/25focusing [1] focusing [1] focusing [1] focusing [1] 21/18 21/18 21/18 21/18Follow [1] Follow [1] Follow [1] Follow [1] 9/6 9/6 9/6 9/6following [2] following [2] following [2] following [2] 15/1 15/2 15/1 15/2 15/1 15/2 15/1 15/2footnote [3] footnote [3] footnote [3] footnote [3] 36/18 36/21 36/18 36/21 36/18 36/21 36/18 36/21

36/24 36/24 36/24 36/24forecast [1] forecast [1] forecast [1] forecast [1] 26/17 26/17 26/17 26/17foregoing [1] foregoing [1] foregoing [1] foregoing [1] 47/2 47/2 47/2 47/2forgetting [1] forgetting [1] forgetting [1] forgetting [1] 37/25 37/25 37/25 37/25forgot [1] forgot [1] forgot [1] forgot [1] 9/16 9/16 9/16 9/16form [4] form [4] form [4] form [4] 28/23 28/23 28/23 28/23 28/23 28/23 28/23 28/23 28/24 29/1 28/24 29/1 28/24 29/1 28/24 29/1forward [5] forward [5] forward [5] forward [5] 6/2 8/21 6/2 8/21 6/2 8/21 6/2 8/21 24/13 29/14 29/14 24/13 29/14 29/14 24/13 29/14 29/14 24/13 29/14 29/14found [8] found [8] found [8] found [8] 32/11 32/12 32/11 32/12 32/11 32/12 32/11 32/12 32/20 32/24 33/2 33/4 32/20 32/24 33/2 33/4 32/20 32/24 33/2 33/4 32/20 32/24 33/2 33/4 33/7 35/4 33/7 35/4 33/7 35/4 33/7 35/4four [2] four [2] four [2] four [2] 7/6 33/2 7/6 33/2 7/6 33/2 7/6 33/2fours [1] fours [1] fours [1] fours [1] 31/18 31/18 31/18 31/18FREDERICK [2] FREDERICK [2] FREDERICK [2] FREDERICK [2] 1/24 4/7 1/24 4/7 1/24 4/7 1/24 4/7FREEMAN [1] FREEMAN [1] FREEMAN [1] FREEMAN [1] 2/3 2/3 2/3 2/3Friedman [1] Friedman [1] Friedman [1] Friedman [1] 4/9 4/9 4/9 4/9full [2] full [2] full [2] full [2] 13/20 23/2 13/20 23/2 13/20 23/2 13/20 23/2functional [1] functional [1] functional [1] functional [1] 21/25 21/25 21/25 21/25Fund [1] Fund [1] Fund [1] Fund [1] 2/10 2/10 2/10 2/10further [4] further [4] further [4] further [4] 42/16 44/21 42/16 44/21 42/16 44/21 42/16 44/21 47/7 47/9 47/7 47/9 47/7 47/9 47/7 47/9

GGGGGARZA [2] GARZA [2] GARZA [2] GARZA [2] 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12gave [3] gave [3] gave [3] gave [3] 32/24 33/4 33/7 32/24 33/4 33/7 32/24 33/4 33/7 32/24 33/4 33/7general [8] general [8] general [8] general [8] 1/6 1/24 10/8 1/6 1/24 10/8 1/6 1/24 10/8 1/6 1/24 10/8 14/13 21/21 22/6 30/9 14/13 21/21 22/6 30/9 14/13 21/21 22/6 30/9 14/13 21/21 22/6 30/9 39/7 39/7 39/7 39/7General's [3] General's [3] General's [3] General's [3] 11/8 16/5 11/8 16/5 11/8 16/5 11/8 16/5 16/9 16/9 16/9 16/9Generally [1] Generally [1] Generally [1] Generally [1] 12/23 12/23 12/23 12/23generous [1] generous [1] generous [1] generous [1] 7/9 7/9 7/9 7/9geography's [1] geography's [1] geography's [1] geography's [1] 31/23 31/23 31/23 31/23GERALD [4] GERALD [4] GERALD [4] GERALD [4] 2/17 2/18 4/11 2/17 2/18 4/11 2/17 2/18 4/11 2/17 2/18 4/11 30/22 30/22 30/22 30/22Gerry [1] Gerry [1] Gerry [1] Gerry [1] 39/16 39/16 39/16 39/16get [13] get [13] get [13] get [13] 6/4 7/16 7/16 6/4 7/16 7/16 6/4 7/16 7/16 6/4 7/16 7/16 7/17 19/8 23/2 29/16 7/17 19/8 23/2 29/16 7/17 19/8 23/2 29/16 7/17 19/8 23/2 29/16 29/17 29/17 31/25 32/7 29/17 29/17 31/25 32/7 29/17 29/17 31/25 32/7 29/17 29/17 31/25 32/7 38/25 42/21 38/25 42/21 38/25 42/21 38/25 42/21gets [1] gets [1] gets [1] gets [1] 32/18 32/18 32/18 32/18getting [2] getting [2] getting [2] getting [2] 35/4 43/3 35/4 43/3 35/4 43/3 35/4 43/3give [2] give [2] give [2] give [2] 4/16 7/4 4/16 7/4 4/16 7/4 4/16 7/4given [8] given [8] given [8] given [8] 6/18 7/2 11/22 6/18 7/2 11/22 6/18 7/2 11/22 6/18 7/2 11/22 16/13 28/16 39/12 42/7 16/13 28/16 39/12 42/7 16/13 28/16 39/12 42/7 16/13 28/16 39/12 42/7 43/9 43/9 43/9 43/9glad [1] glad [1] glad [1] glad [1] 9/18 9/18 9/18 9/18go [11] go [11] go [11] go [11] 6/20 8/8 8/14 9/9 6/20 8/8 8/14 9/9 6/20 8/8 8/14 9/9 6/20 8/8 8/14 9/9 9/24 10/20 12/10 13/19 9/24 10/20 12/10 13/19 9/24 10/20 12/10 13/19 9/24 10/20 12/10 13/19 19/1 28/8 34/23 19/1 28/8 34/23 19/1 28/8 34/23 19/1 28/8 34/23goes [1] goes [1] goes [1] goes [1] 11/23 11/23 11/23 11/23going [17] going [17] going [17] going [17] 7/9 7/16 8/8 7/9 7/16 8/8 7/9 7/16 8/8 7/9 7/16 8/8 8/10 8/14 8/23 13/18 8/10 8/14 8/23 13/18 8/10 8/14 8/23 13/18 8/10 8/14 8/23 13/18 13/19 17/15 25/14 26/13 13/19 17/15 25/14 26/13 13/19 17/15 25/14 26/13 13/19 17/15 25/14 26/13 26/17 30/18 32/21 32/22 26/17 30/18 32/21 32/22 26/17 30/18 32/21 32/22 26/17 30/18 32/21 32/22 36/9 39/16 36/9 39/16 36/9 39/16 36/9 39/16gone [1] gone [1] gone [1] gone [1] 45/9 45/9 45/9 45/9Gonzalez [1] Gonzalez [1] Gonzalez [1] Gonzalez [1] 21/13 21/13 21/13 21/13good [11] good [11] good [11] good [11] 7/8 19/16 21/9 7/8 19/16 21/9 7/8 19/16 21/9 7/8 19/16 21/9 21/10 21/11 25/1 31/1 21/10 21/11 25/1 31/1 21/10 21/11 25/1 31/1 21/10 21/11 25/1 31/1 31/2 43/4 43/7 43/8 31/2 43/4 43/7 43/8 31/2 43/4 43/7 43/8 31/2 43/4 43/7 43/8got [8] got [8] got [8] got [8] 7/7 7/11 16/20 7/7 7/11 16/20 7/7 7/11 16/20 7/7 7/11 16/20 19/16 35/5 35/7 36/3 19/16 35/5 35/7 36/3 19/16 35/5 35/7 36/3 19/16 35/5 35/7 36/3 36/12 36/12 36/12 36/12governor [3] governor [3] governor [3] governor [3] 14/22 15/3 14/22 15/3 14/22 15/3 14/22 15/3 15/3 15/3 15/3 15/3governor's [2] governor's [2] governor's [2] governor's [2] 13/6 13/7 13/6 13/7 13/6 13/7 13/6 13/7greater [2] greater [2] greater [2] greater [2] 8/9 18/7 8/9 18/7 8/9 18/7 8/9 18/7Gringles [2] Gringles [2] Gringles [2] Gringles [2] 37/1 37/3 37/1 37/3 37/1 37/3 37/1 37/3groups [1] groups [1] groups [1] groups [1] 25/24 25/24 25/24 25/24

growing [1] growing [1] growing [1] growing [1] 29/12 29/12 29/12 29/12growth [3] growth [3] growth [3] growth [3] 29/7 29/10 29/7 29/10 29/7 29/10 29/7 29/10 30/7 30/7 30/7 30/7guess [2] guess [2] guess [2] guess [2] 17/1 41/21 17/1 41/21 17/1 41/21 17/1 41/21guys [1] guys [1] guys [1] guys [1] 6/20 6/20 6/20 6/20

HHHHhad [11] had [11] had [11] had [11] 6/20 7/4 17/4 6/20 7/4 17/4 6/20 7/4 17/4 6/20 7/4 17/4 20/5 24/6 24/8 24/16 20/5 24/6 24/8 24/16 20/5 24/6 24/8 24/16 20/5 24/6 24/8 24/16 24/16 24/23 24/24 27/11 24/16 24/23 24/24 27/11 24/16 24/23 24/24 27/11 24/16 24/23 24/24 27/11half [3] half [3] half [3] half [3] 7/7 7/7 18/16 7/7 7/7 18/16 7/7 7/7 18/16 7/7 7/7 18/16hand [1] hand [1] hand [1] hand [1] 30/14 30/14 30/14 30/14Handley [6] Handley [6] Handley [6] Handley [6] 19/11 19/21 19/11 19/21 19/11 19/21 19/11 19/21 40/21 41/12 41/15 42/13 40/21 41/12 41/15 42/13 40/21 41/12 41/15 42/13 40/21 41/12 41/15 42/13Handley's [4] Handley's [4] Handley's [4] Handley's [4] 18/17 41/10 18/17 41/10 18/17 41/10 18/17 41/10 41/18 41/19 41/18 41/19 41/18 41/19 41/18 41/19happen [2] happen [2] happen [2] happen [2] 26/17 40/4 26/17 40/4 26/17 40/4 26/17 40/4happy [1] happy [1] happy [1] happy [1] 32/20 32/20 32/20 32/20hard [4] hard [4] hard [4] hard [4] 6/7 6/24 7/2 6/7 6/24 7/2 6/7 6/24 7/2 6/7 6/24 7/2 23/3 23/3 23/3 23/3has [6] has [6] has [6] has [6] 5/4 5/10 7/23 5/4 5/10 7/23 5/4 5/10 7/23 5/4 5/10 7/23 12/21 29/2 37/4 12/21 29/2 37/4 12/21 29/2 37/4 12/21 29/2 37/4have [66] have [66] have [66] have [66] haven't [3] haven't [3] haven't [3] haven't [3] 15/23 24/6 15/23 24/6 15/23 24/6 15/23 24/6 28/15 28/15 28/15 28/15HCVAP [5] HCVAP [5] HCVAP [5] HCVAP [5] 17/21 18/3 17/21 18/3 17/21 18/3 17/21 18/3 19/24 20/14 20/15 19/24 20/14 20/15 19/24 20/14 20/15 19/24 20/14 20/15heading [2] heading [2] heading [2] heading [2] 25/15 25/17 25/15 25/17 25/15 25/17 25/15 25/17hear [1] hear [1] hear [1] hear [1] 45/6 45/6 45/6 45/6heard [1] heard [1] heard [1] heard [1] 39/5 39/5 39/5 39/5hearing [1] hearing [1] hearing [1] hearing [1] 47/9 47/9 47/9 47/9HEBERT [5] HEBERT [5] HEBERT [5] HEBERT [5] 2/17 2/18 4/11 2/17 2/18 4/11 2/17 2/18 4/11 2/17 2/18 4/11 30/22 46/7 30/22 46/7 30/22 46/7 30/22 46/7helpful [3] helpful [3] helpful [3] helpful [3] 18/22 27/22 18/22 27/22 18/22 27/22 18/22 27/22 36/16 36/16 36/16 36/16her [3] her [3] her [3] her [3] 14/12 35/8 41/22 14/12 35/8 41/22 14/12 35/8 41/22 14/12 35/8 41/22here [15] here [15] here [15] here [15] 5/8 5/10 6/14 5/8 5/10 6/14 5/8 5/10 6/14 5/8 5/10 6/14 6/24 12/7 24/14 28/13 6/24 12/7 24/14 28/13 6/24 12/7 24/14 28/13 6/24 12/7 24/14 28/13 30/14 32/4 38/1 39/7 40/9 30/14 32/4 38/1 39/7 40/9 30/14 32/4 38/1 39/7 40/9 30/14 32/4 38/1 39/7 40/9 40/19 43/15 43/23 40/19 43/15 43/23 40/19 43/15 43/23 40/19 43/15 43/23Herman [1] Herman [1] Herman [1] Herman [1] 1/19 1/19 1/19 1/19higher [8] higher [8] higher [8] higher [8] 12/24 13/1 12/24 13/1 12/24 13/1 12/24 13/1 13/2 13/12 16/16 33/3 13/2 13/12 16/16 33/3 13/2 13/12 16/16 33/3 13/2 13/12 16/16 33/3 35/9 35/19 35/9 35/19 35/9 35/19 35/9 35/19highest [1] highest [1] highest [1] highest [1] 13/20 13/20 13/20 13/20highlights [1] highlights [1] highlights [1] highlights [1] 5/14 5/14 5/14 5/14his [5] his [5] his [5] his [5] 1/6 14/12 20/24 1/6 14/12 20/24 1/6 14/12 20/24 1/6 14/12 20/24 21/3 22/21 21/3 22/21 21/3 22/21 21/3 22/21Hispanic [10] Hispanic [10] Hispanic [10] Hispanic [10] 18/7 18/15 18/7 18/15 18/7 18/15 18/7 18/15 29/7 29/11 29/12 30/7 29/7 29/11 29/12 30/7 29/7 29/11 29/12 30/7 29/7 29/11 29/12 30/7 35/22 35/23 39/9 43/25 35/22 35/23 39/9 43/25 35/22 35/23 39/9 43/25 35/22 35/23 39/9 43/25Hispanics [7] Hispanics [7] Hispanics [7] Hispanics [7] 21/20 22/6 21/20 22/6 21/20 22/6 21/20 22/6 22/11 24/11 30/1 33/14 22/11 24/11 30/1 33/14 22/11 24/11 30/1 33/14 22/11 24/11 30/1 33/14 39/12 39/12 39/12 39/12hit [1] hit [1] hit [1] hit [1] 5/14 5/14 5/14 5/14hmm [1] hmm [1] hmm [1] hmm [1] 17/16 17/16 17/16 17/16HOLDER [1] HOLDER [1] HOLDER [1] HOLDER [1] 1/6 1/6 1/6 1/6Honor [19] Honor [19] Honor [19] Honor [19] 4/3 5/18 6/8 4/3 5/18 6/8 4/3 5/18 6/8 4/3 5/18 6/8 7/20 8/5 8/7 8/17 9/11 7/20 8/5 8/7 8/17 9/11 7/20 8/5 8/7 8/17 9/11 7/20 8/5 8/7 8/17 9/11 9/19 9/25 14/20 14/23 9/19 9/25 14/20 14/23 9/19 9/25 14/20 14/23 9/19 9/25 14/20 14/23 16/22 20/17 20/21 20/25 16/22 20/17 20/21 20/25 16/22 20/17 20/21 20/25 16/22 20/17 20/21 20/25 21/8 42/22 44/22 21/8 42/22 44/22 21/8 42/22 44/22 21/8 42/22 44/22Honor's [1] Honor's [1] Honor's [1] Honor's [1] 6/18 6/18 6/18 6/18HONORABLES [1] HONORABLES [1] HONORABLES [1] HONORABLES [1] 1/13 1/13 1/13 1/13Honors [2] Honors [2] Honors [2] Honors [2] 21/9 30/23 21/9 30/23 21/9 30/23 21/9 30/23hoped [1] hoped [1] hoped [1] hoped [1] 40/8 40/8 40/8 40/8House [11] House [11] House [11] House [11] 9/15 16/25 9/15 16/25 9/15 16/25 9/15 16/25 17/2 17/3 19/23 31/20 17/2 17/3 19/23 31/20 17/2 17/3 19/23 31/20 17/2 17/3 19/23 31/20 31/21 41/6 43/19 43/23 31/21 41/6 43/19 43/23 31/21 41/6 43/19 43/23 31/21 41/6 43/19 43/23 44/2 44/2 44/2 44/2Houston [1] Houston [1] Houston [1] Houston [1] 2/22 2/22 2/22 2/22

52525252

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 52 of 59

Page 53: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

HHHHhow [7] how [7] how [7] how [7] 5/21 11/7 18/24 5/21 11/7 18/24 5/21 11/7 18/24 5/21 11/7 18/24 18/24 27/16 27/21 37/21 18/24 27/16 27/21 37/21 18/24 27/16 27/21 37/21 18/24 27/16 27/21 37/21how's [1] how's [1] how's [1] how's [1] 7/7 7/7 7/7 7/7HOWELL [2] HOWELL [2] HOWELL [2] HOWELL [2] 1/13 8/13 1/13 8/13 1/13 8/13 1/13 8/13Hubbard [1] Hubbard [1] Hubbard [1] Hubbard [1] 1/20 1/20 1/20 1/20HUGHES [3] HUGHES [3] HUGHES [3] HUGHES [3] 1/18 4/6 46/8 1/18 4/6 46/8 1/18 4/6 46/8 1/18 4/6 46/8humble [1] humble [1] humble [1] humble [1] 8/10 8/10 8/10 8/10hundred [1] hundred [1] hundred [1] hundred [1] 33/2 33/2 33/2 33/2hundreds [1] hundreds [1] hundreds [1] hundreds [1] 29/25 29/25 29/25 29/25

IIIII'd [2] I'd [2] I'd [2] I'd [2] 10/3 32/20 10/3 32/20 10/3 32/20 10/3 32/20I'll [4] I'll [4] I'll [4] I'll [4] 13/3 23/2 30/19 13/3 23/2 30/19 13/3 23/2 30/19 13/3 23/2 30/19 35/14 35/14 35/14 35/14I'm [33] I'm [33] I'm [33] I'm [33] 4/13 6/9 7/9 8/1 4/13 6/9 7/9 8/1 4/13 6/9 7/9 8/1 4/13 6/9 7/9 8/1 9/18 10/5 12/5 12/17 9/18 10/5 12/5 12/17 9/18 10/5 12/5 12/17 9/18 10/5 12/5 12/17 14/11 15/13 17/23 18/19 14/11 15/13 17/23 18/19 14/11 15/13 17/23 18/19 14/11 15/13 17/23 18/19 21/18 24/5 24/13 24/21 21/18 24/5 24/13 24/21 21/18 24/5 24/13 24/21 21/18 24/5 24/13 24/21 25/14 28/11 29/6 30/15 25/14 28/11 29/6 30/15 25/14 28/11 29/6 30/15 25/14 28/11 29/6 30/15 32/20 32/22 33/19 33/23 32/20 32/22 33/19 33/23 32/20 32/22 33/19 33/23 32/20 32/22 33/19 33/23 35/11 35/12 36/9 36/24 35/11 35/12 36/9 36/24 35/11 35/12 36/9 36/24 35/11 35/12 36/9 36/24 37/16 40/12 41/9 41/25 37/16 40/12 41/9 41/25 37/16 40/12 41/9 41/25 37/16 40/12 41/9 41/25 43/3 43/3 43/3 43/3I've [4] I've [4] I've [4] I've [4] 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 24/10 42/12 24/10 42/12 24/10 42/12 24/10 42/12IL [1] IL [1] IL [1] IL [1] 1/21 1/21 1/21 1/21immediately [2] immediately [2] immediately [2] immediately [2] 15/1 15/2 15/1 15/2 15/1 15/2 15/1 15/2importance [2] importance [2] importance [2] importance [2] 12/21 13/9 12/21 13/9 12/21 13/9 12/21 13/9important [3] important [3] important [3] important [3] 9/14 21/4 9/14 21/4 9/14 21/4 9/14 21/4 39/18 39/18 39/18 39/18importantly [1] importantly [1] importantly [1] importantly [1] 7/18 7/18 7/18 7/18inappropriate [1] inappropriate [1] inappropriate [1] inappropriate [1] 33/16 33/16 33/16 33/16inartful [1] inartful [1] inartful [1] inartful [1] 41/17 41/17 41/17 41/17Inc [1] Inc [1] Inc [1] Inc [1] 2/10 2/10 2/10 2/10include [5] include [5] include [5] include [5] 10/15 16/14 10/15 16/14 10/15 16/14 10/15 16/14 21/25 25/6 44/4 21/25 25/6 44/4 21/25 25/6 44/4 21/25 25/6 44/4included [5] included [5] included [5] included [5] 16/25 25/3 16/25 25/3 16/25 25/3 16/25 25/3 25/8 25/10 30/16 25/8 25/10 30/16 25/8 25/10 30/16 25/8 25/10 30/16including [4] including [4] including [4] including [4] 4/22 5/3 4/22 5/3 4/22 5/3 4/22 5/3 15/8 15/10 15/8 15/10 15/8 15/10 15/8 15/10incorporate [1] incorporate [1] incorporate [1] incorporate [1] 29/20 29/20 29/20 29/20increase [2] increase [2] increase [2] increase [2] 43/24 44/6 43/24 44/6 43/24 44/6 43/24 44/6increased [2] increased [2] increased [2] increased [2] 15/24 44/10 15/24 44/10 15/24 44/10 15/24 44/10indeed [1] indeed [1] indeed [1] indeed [1] 22/5 22/5 22/5 22/5index [13] index [13] index [13] index [13] 10/8 12/23 10/8 12/23 10/8 12/23 10/8 12/23 13/19 15/14 15/17 15/19 13/19 15/14 15/17 15/19 13/19 15/14 15/17 15/19 13/19 15/14 15/17 15/19 15/19 15/20 15/22 16/7 15/19 15/20 15/22 16/7 15/19 15/20 15/22 16/7 15/19 15/20 15/22 16/7 16/14 29/16 44/7 16/14 29/16 44/7 16/14 29/16 44/7 16/14 29/16 44/7indexes [4] indexes [4] indexes [4] indexes [4] 15/15 15/21 15/15 15/21 15/15 15/21 15/15 15/21 43/19 44/2 43/19 44/2 43/19 44/2 43/19 44/2indicates [1] indicates [1] indicates [1] indicates [1] 33/12 33/12 33/12 33/12indication [1] indication [1] indication [1] indication [1] 40/5 40/5 40/5 40/5individual [3] individual [3] individual [3] individual [3] 13/16 13/16 13/16 13/16 22/15 27/24 22/15 27/24 22/15 27/24 22/15 27/24individuals [1] individuals [1] individuals [1] individuals [1] 13/13 13/13 13/13 13/13infer [2] infer [2] infer [2] infer [2] 11/9 11/12 11/9 11/12 11/9 11/12 11/9 11/12inference [1] inference [1] inference [1] inference [1] 25/17 25/17 25/17 25/17inferior [1] inferior [1] inferior [1] inferior [1] 37/17 37/17 37/17 37/17information [1] information [1] information [1] information [1] 6/22 6/22 6/22 6/22inherent [1] inherent [1] inherent [1] inherent [1] 30/6 30/6 30/6 30/6instead [3] instead [3] instead [3] instead [3] 18/14 21/6 18/14 21/6 18/14 21/6 18/14 21/6 26/12 26/12 26/12 26/12intent [1] intent [1] intent [1] intent [1] 38/20 38/20 38/20 38/20interest [1] interest [1] interest [1] interest [1] 20/25 20/25 20/25 20/25interested [3] interested [3] interested [3] interested [3] 14/2 14/2 14/2 14/2 14/2 14/2 14/2 14/2 47/10 47/10 47/10 47/10interesting [1] interesting [1] interesting [1] interesting [1] 34/21 34/21 34/21 34/21interpreting [1] interpreting [1] interpreting [1] interpreting [1] 41/25 41/25 41/25 41/25interrupt [1] interrupt [1] interrupt [1] interrupt [1] 12/19 12/19 12/19 12/19

interval [4] interval [4] interval [4] interval [4] 26/22 27/10 26/22 27/10 26/22 27/10 26/22 27/10 28/3 28/16 28/3 28/16 28/3 28/16 28/3 28/16intervals [5] intervals [5] intervals [5] intervals [5] 26/9 27/18 26/9 27/18 26/9 27/18 26/9 27/18 27/24 27/25 28/6 27/24 27/25 28/6 27/24 27/25 28/6 27/24 27/25 28/6Intervenor [3] Intervenor [3] Intervenor [3] Intervenor [3] 1/10 2/6 1/10 2/6 1/10 2/6 1/10 2/6 4/11 4/11 4/11 4/11Intervenor-Defendants [1] Intervenor-Defendants [1] Intervenor-Defendants [1] Intervenor-Defendants [1] 1/10 1/10 1/10 1/10intervenors [3] intervenors [3] intervenors [3] intervenors [3] 21/14 21/14 21/14 21/14 30/22 32/12 30/22 32/12 30/22 32/12 30/22 32/12involved [2] involved [2] involved [2] involved [2] 11/10 11/13 11/10 11/13 11/10 11/13 11/10 11/13is [131] is [131] is [131] is [131] isn't [10] isn't [10] isn't [10] isn't [10] 29/8 29/23 29/8 29/23 29/8 29/23 29/8 29/23 33/18 34/5 34/21 37/22 33/18 34/5 34/21 37/22 33/18 34/5 34/21 37/22 33/18 34/5 34/21 37/22 39/13 39/15 41/20 42/5 39/13 39/15 41/20 42/5 39/13 39/15 41/20 42/5 39/13 39/15 41/20 42/5issue [9] issue [9] issue [9] issue [9] 4/18 30/19 4/18 30/19 4/18 30/19 4/18 30/19 31/22 32/4 37/21 37/24 31/22 32/4 37/21 37/24 31/22 32/4 37/21 37/24 31/22 32/4 37/21 37/24 38/1 38/21 41/20 38/1 38/21 41/20 38/1 38/21 41/20 38/1 38/21 41/20issues [3] issues [3] issues [3] issues [3] 37/5 39/1 43/9 37/5 39/1 43/9 37/5 39/1 43/9 37/5 39/1 43/9it [93] it [93] it [93] it [93] it's [38] it's [38] it's [38] it's [38] 6/6 6/23 7/2 6/6 6/23 7/2 6/6 6/23 7/2 6/6 6/23 7/2 7/15 7/15 8/22 9/19 9/21 7/15 7/15 8/22 9/19 9/21 7/15 7/15 8/22 9/19 9/21 7/15 7/15 8/22 9/19 9/21 9/22 11/1 13/4 13/14 9/22 11/1 13/4 13/14 9/22 11/1 13/4 13/14 9/22 11/1 13/4 13/14 15/13 19/10 19/15 19/24 15/13 19/10 19/15 19/24 15/13 19/10 19/15 19/24 15/13 19/10 19/15 19/24 20/18 20/20 23/2 25/22 20/18 20/20 23/2 25/22 20/18 20/20 23/2 25/22 20/18 20/20 23/2 25/22 29/10 30/5 30/16 31/9 29/10 30/5 30/16 31/9 29/10 30/5 30/16 31/9 29/10 30/5 30/16 31/9 31/10 33/23 34/7 34/21 31/10 33/23 34/7 34/21 31/10 33/23 34/7 34/21 31/10 33/23 34/7 34/21 36/18 36/21 39/13 39/18 36/18 36/21 39/13 39/18 36/18 36/21 39/13 39/18 36/18 36/21 39/13 39/18 39/21 40/19 41/11 44/6 39/21 40/19 41/11 44/6 39/21 40/19 41/11 44/6 39/21 40/19 41/11 44/6 44/7 44/17 44/7 44/17 44/7 44/17 44/7 44/17its [3] its [3] its [3] its [3] 11/23 16/6 40/21 11/23 16/6 40/21 11/23 16/6 40/21 11/23 16/6 40/21itself [3] itself [3] itself [3] itself [3] 6/21 29/1 31/7 6/21 29/1 31/7 6/21 29/1 31/7 6/21 29/1 31/7

JJJJJala [1] Jala [1] Jala [1] Jala [1] 12/15 12/15 12/15 12/15January [4] January [4] January [4] January [4] 1/6 19/1 1/6 19/1 1/6 19/1 1/6 19/1 22/23 47/12 22/23 47/12 22/23 47/12 22/23 47/12job [3] job [3] job [3] job [3] 38/3 38/4 42/2 38/3 38/4 42/2 38/3 38/4 42/2 38/3 38/4 42/2jobs [1] jobs [1] jobs [1] jobs [1] 7/13 7/13 7/13 7/13JOHN [9] JOHN [9] JOHN [9] JOHN [9] 1/18 2/6 2/14 1/18 2/6 2/14 1/18 2/6 2/14 1/18 2/6 2/14 4/6 4/11 4/12 9/10 21/13 4/6 4/11 4/12 9/10 21/13 4/6 4/11 4/12 9/10 21/13 4/6 4/11 4/12 9/10 21/13 46/4 46/4 46/4 46/4JOSE [2] JOSE [2] JOSE [2] JOSE [2] 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12 2/12JOSEPH [1] JOSEPH [1] JOSEPH [1] JOSEPH [1] 2/17 2/17 2/17 2/17Jr [2] Jr [2] Jr [2] Jr [2] 3/3 3/4 3/3 3/4 3/3 3/4 3/3 3/4JUDGE [5] JUDGE [5] JUDGE [5] JUDGE [5] 4/13 6/7 8/13 4/13 6/7 8/13 4/13 6/7 8/13 4/13 6/7 8/13 11/15 12/15 11/15 12/15 11/15 12/15 11/15 12/15JUDGES [1] JUDGES [1] JUDGES [1] JUDGES [1] 1/14 1/14 1/14 1/14jury [1] jury [1] jury [1] jury [1] 9/6 9/6 9/6 9/6just [28] just [28] just [28] just [28] 6/7 6/25 7/21 6/7 6/25 7/21 6/7 6/25 7/21 6/7 6/25 7/21 8/4 9/16 10/17 13/24 17/9 8/4 9/16 10/17 13/24 17/9 8/4 9/16 10/17 13/24 17/9 8/4 9/16 10/17 13/24 17/9 17/11 18/8 19/14 19/16 17/11 18/8 19/14 19/16 17/11 18/8 19/14 19/16 17/11 18/8 19/14 19/16 20/22 24/5 24/12 28/15 20/22 24/5 24/12 28/15 20/22 24/5 24/12 28/15 20/22 24/5 24/12 28/15 29/2 30/3 30/5 30/23 29/2 30/3 30/5 30/23 29/2 30/3 30/5 30/23 29/2 30/3 30/5 30/23 31/11 33/23 34/6 37/8 31/11 33/23 34/6 37/8 31/11 33/23 34/6 37/8 31/11 33/23 34/6 37/8 38/7 41/19 43/10 43/15 38/7 41/19 43/10 43/15 38/7 41/19 43/10 43/15 38/7 41/19 43/10 43/15Justice [12] Justice [12] Justice [12] Justice [12] 2/4 4/23 5/4 2/4 4/23 5/4 2/4 4/23 5/4 2/4 4/23 5/4 11/24 12/11 12/12 12/14 11/24 12/11 12/12 12/14 11/24 12/11 12/12 12/14 11/24 12/11 12/12 12/14 15/20 38/4 40/21 42/1 15/20 38/4 40/21 42/1 15/20 38/4 40/21 42/1 15/20 38/4 40/21 42/1 42/8 42/8 42/8 42/8justification [1] justification [1] justification [1] justification [1] 16/2 16/2 16/2 16/2

KKKKkeep [2] keep [2] keep [2] keep [2] 16/21 37/25 16/21 37/25 16/21 37/25 16/21 37/25KELLER [2] KELLER [2] KELLER [2] KELLER [2] 1/18 4/8 1/18 4/8 1/18 4/8 1/18 4/8killing [3] killing [3] killing [3] killing [3] 7/11 7/12 7/11 7/12 7/11 7/12 7/11 7/12 7/15 7/15 7/15 7/15kind [2] kind [2] kind [2] kind [2] 18/10 23/2 18/10 23/2 18/10 23/2 18/10 23/2know [24] know [24] know [24] know [24] 5/11 7/4 8/3 5/11 7/4 8/3 5/11 7/4 8/3 5/11 7/4 8/3 8/14 10/23 11/7 11/10 8/14 10/23 11/7 11/10 8/14 10/23 11/7 11/10 8/14 10/23 11/7 11/10 16/1 16/5 16/9 16/19 16/1 16/5 16/9 16/19 16/1 16/5 16/9 16/19 16/1 16/5 16/9 16/19

18/20 23/18 23/25 27/16 18/20 23/18 23/25 27/16 18/20 23/18 23/25 27/16 18/20 23/18 23/25 27/16 28/11 28/14 28/15 34/3 28/11 28/14 28/15 34/3 28/11 28/14 28/15 34/3 28/11 28/14 28/15 34/3 36/2 36/3 36/12 36/13 36/2 36/3 36/12 36/13 36/2 36/3 36/12 36/13 36/2 36/3 36/12 36/13 39/16 39/16 39/16 39/16knowing [1] knowing [1] knowing [1] knowing [1] 28/5 28/5 28/5 28/5knowledge [1] knowledge [1] knowledge [1] knowledge [1] 16/11 16/11 16/11 16/11

LLLLlarge [7] large [7] large [7] large [7] 4/20 4/21 5/1 4/20 4/21 5/1 4/20 4/21 5/1 4/20 4/21 5/1 5/6 6/3 6/16 35/22 5/6 6/3 6/16 35/22 5/6 6/3 6/16 35/22 5/6 6/3 6/16 35/22last [4] last [4] last [4] last [4] 4/19 22/10 28/23 4/19 22/10 28/23 4/19 22/10 28/23 4/19 22/10 28/23 29/3 29/3 29/3 29/3later [1] later [1] later [1] later [1] 41/8 41/8 41/8 41/8Latino [4] Latino [4] Latino [4] Latino [4] 35/5 35/8 35/9 35/5 35/8 35/9 35/5 35/8 35/9 35/5 35/8 35/9 38/25 38/25 38/25 38/25Latinos [4] Latinos [4] Latinos [4] Latinos [4] 33/4 36/15 33/4 36/15 33/4 36/15 33/4 36/15 38/13 39/15 38/13 39/15 38/13 39/15 38/13 39/15Law [2] Law [2] Law [2] Law [2] 2/12 3/3 2/12 3/3 2/12 3/3 2/12 3/3least [6] least [6] least [6] least [6] 7/5 25/15 29/10 7/5 25/15 29/10 7/5 25/15 29/10 7/5 25/15 29/10 34/10 40/22 44/2 34/10 40/22 44/2 34/10 40/22 44/2 34/10 40/22 44/2leave [1] leave [1] leave [1] leave [1] 43/24 43/24 43/24 43/24left [1] left [1] left [1] left [1] 17/13 17/13 17/13 17/13legal [5] legal [5] legal [5] legal [5] 2/9 33/20 33/23 2/9 33/20 33/23 2/9 33/20 33/23 2/9 33/20 33/23 34/6 43/13 34/6 43/13 34/6 43/13 34/6 43/13less [5] less [5] less [5] less [5] 4/19 7/23 19/21 4/19 7/23 19/21 4/19 7/23 19/21 4/19 7/23 19/21 33/25 40/7 33/25 40/7 33/25 40/7 33/25 40/7let [3] let [3] let [3] let [3] 10/23 19/20 23/10 10/23 19/20 23/10 10/23 19/20 23/10 10/23 19/20 23/10level [2] level [2] level [2] level [2] 29/20 35/19 29/20 35/19 29/20 35/19 29/20 35/19liability [2] liability [2] liability [2] liability [2] 36/20 37/1 36/20 37/1 36/20 37/1 36/20 37/1Lichtman [2] Lichtman [2] Lichtman [2] Lichtman [2] 32/11 33/2 32/11 33/2 32/11 33/2 32/11 33/2Lichtman's [2] Lichtman's [2] Lichtman's [2] Lichtman's [2] 32/18 32/18 32/18 32/18 32/21 32/21 32/21 32/21lieutenant [1] lieutenant [1] lieutenant [1] lieutenant [1] 15/3 15/3 15/3 15/3like [16] like [16] like [16] like [16] 5/14 6/17 7/21 5/14 6/17 7/21 5/14 6/17 7/21 5/14 6/17 7/21 8/13 9/3 10/3 12/24 13/6 8/13 9/3 10/3 12/24 13/6 8/13 9/3 10/3 12/24 13/6 8/13 9/3 10/3 12/24 13/6 19/8 20/25 21/4 26/19 19/8 20/25 21/4 26/19 19/8 20/25 21/4 26/19 19/8 20/25 21/4 26/19 29/1 30/9 35/21 38/24 29/1 30/9 35/21 38/24 29/1 30/9 35/21 38/24 29/1 30/9 35/21 38/24likely [3] likely [3] likely [3] likely [3] 13/13 13/21 13/13 13/21 13/13 13/21 13/13 13/21 40/4 40/4 40/4 40/4limit [3] limit [3] limit [3] limit [3] 18/4 18/5 18/12 18/4 18/5 18/12 18/4 18/5 18/12 18/4 18/5 18/12limited [1] limited [1] limited [1] limited [1] 7/2 7/2 7/2 7/2limiting [1] limiting [1] limiting [1] limiting [1] 5/12 5/12 5/12 5/12Linda [1] Linda [1] Linda [1] Linda [1] 12/12 12/12 12/12 12/12line [13] line [13] line [13] line [13] 17/3 17/9 18/11 17/3 17/9 18/11 17/3 17/9 18/11 17/3 17/9 18/11 18/15 19/25 20/6 20/9 18/15 19/25 20/6 20/9 18/15 19/25 20/6 20/9 18/15 19/25 20/6 20/9 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 29/23 29/24 30/3 30/5 30/9 34/5 30/9 34/5 30/9 34/5 30/9 34/5lines [1] lines [1] lines [1] lines [1] 24/18 24/18 24/18 24/18list [10] list [10] list [10] list [10] 11/7 11/14 11/7 11/14 11/7 11/14 11/7 11/14 11/19 11/22 11/23 12/5 11/19 11/22 11/23 12/5 11/19 11/22 11/23 12/5 11/19 11/22 11/23 12/5 12/6 12/10 25/24 26/4 12/6 12/10 25/24 26/4 12/6 12/10 25/24 26/4 12/6 12/10 25/24 26/4listed [1] listed [1] listed [1] listed [1] 28/14 28/14 28/14 28/14listening [1] listening [1] listening [1] listening [1] 45/8 45/8 45/8 45/8litigation [1] litigation [1] litigation [1] litigation [1] 35/1 35/1 35/1 35/1lives [1] lives [1] lives [1] lives [1] 14/8 14/8 14/8 14/8LLP [2] LLP [2] LLP [2] LLP [2] 1/19 2/15 1/19 2/15 1/19 2/15 1/19 2/15long [4] long [4] long [4] long [4] 13/15 28/23 13/15 28/23 13/15 28/23 13/15 28/23 28/23 28/25 28/23 28/25 28/23 28/25 28/23 28/25look [13] look [13] look [13] look [13] 9/14 18/6 19/23 9/14 18/6 19/23 9/14 18/6 19/23 9/14 18/6 19/23 22/17 23/22 24/18 25/5 22/17 23/22 24/18 25/5 22/17 23/22 24/18 25/5 22/17 23/22 24/18 25/5 25/8 26/16 27/22 28/1 25/8 26/16 27/22 28/1 25/8 26/16 27/22 28/1 25/8 26/16 27/22 28/1 28/7 36/6 28/7 36/6 28/7 36/6 28/7 36/6looked [4] looked [4] looked [4] looked [4] 22/15 24/7 22/15 24/7 22/15 24/7 22/15 24/7 27/11 27/14 27/11 27/14 27/11 27/14 27/11 27/14looking [6] looking [6] looking [6] looking [6] 11/9 12/5 11/9 12/5 11/9 12/5 11/9 12/5 24/21 25/13 28/6 43/14 24/21 25/13 28/6 43/14 24/21 25/13 28/6 43/14 24/21 25/13 28/6 43/14lot [2] lot [2] lot [2] lot [2] 8/9 28/11 8/9 28/11 8/9 28/11 8/9 28/11lots [1] lots [1] lots [1] lots [1] 39/5 39/5 39/5 39/5low [1] low [1] low [1] low [1] 10/21 10/21 10/21 10/21lower [2] lower [2] lower [2] lower [2] 12/25 18/5 12/25 18/5 12/25 18/5 12/25 18/5lucky [1] lucky [1] lucky [1] lucky [1] 7/8 7/8 7/8 7/8

53535353

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 53 of 59

Page 54: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

LLLLLUIS [3] LUIS [3] LUIS [3] LUIS [3] 3/3 3/3 4/12 3/3 3/3 4/12 3/3 3/3 4/12 3/3 3/3 4/12lunch [1] lunch [1] lunch [1] lunch [1] 45/3 45/3 45/3 45/3

MMMMmachine [1] machine [1] machine [1] machine [1] 3/10 3/10 3/10 3/10made [3] made [3] made [3] made [3] 4/13 18/21 42/12 4/13 18/21 42/12 4/13 18/21 42/12 4/13 18/21 42/12Madina [1] Madina [1] Madina [1] Madina [1] 11/20 11/20 11/20 11/20major [3] major [3] major [3] major [3] 35/14 44/1 44/7 35/14 44/1 44/7 35/14 44/1 44/7 35/14 44/1 44/7majority [2] majority [2] majority [2] majority [2] 35/20 35/21 35/20 35/21 35/20 35/21 35/20 35/21make [13] make [13] make [13] make [13] 6/7 9/12 13/13 6/7 9/12 13/13 6/7 9/12 13/13 6/7 9/12 13/13 19/16 20/22 26/7 31/8 19/16 20/22 26/7 31/8 19/16 20/22 26/7 31/8 19/16 20/22 26/7 31/8 34/13 34/18 34/19 35/23 34/13 34/18 34/19 35/23 34/13 34/18 34/19 35/23 34/13 34/18 34/19 35/23 37/18 43/14 37/18 43/14 37/18 43/14 37/18 43/14makes [1] makes [1] makes [1] makes [1] 39/11 39/11 39/11 39/11making [3] making [3] making [3] making [3] 13/16 13/17 13/16 13/17 13/16 13/17 13/16 13/17 15/18 15/18 15/18 15/18man [1] man [1] man [1] man [1] 39/17 39/17 39/17 39/17many [3] many [3] many [3] many [3] 35/25 40/22 35/25 40/22 35/25 40/22 35/25 40/22 41/13 41/13 41/13 41/13map [9] map [9] map [9] map [9] 38/11 43/24 44/14 38/11 43/24 44/14 38/11 43/24 44/14 38/11 43/24 44/14 44/14 44/15 44/16 44/17 44/14 44/15 44/16 44/17 44/14 44/15 44/16 44/17 44/14 44/15 44/16 44/17 44/18 44/19 44/18 44/19 44/18 44/19 44/18 44/19mapping [1] mapping [1] mapping [1] mapping [1] 21/2 21/2 21/2 21/2Margaret [2] Margaret [2] Margaret [2] Margaret [2] 12/13 12/14 12/13 12/14 12/13 12/14 12/13 12/14margin [9] margin [9] margin [9] margin [9] 26/13 26/18 26/13 26/18 26/13 26/18 26/13 26/18 26/22 27/2 27/6 27/8 26/22 27/2 27/6 27/8 26/22 27/2 27/6 27/8 26/22 27/2 27/6 27/8 27/10 27/14 27/18 27/10 27/14 27/18 27/10 27/14 27/18 27/10 27/14 27/18material [1] material [1] material [1] material [1] 7/22 7/22 7/22 7/22matter [7] matter [7] matter [7] matter [7] 7/3 8/24 15/19 7/3 8/24 15/19 7/3 8/24 15/19 7/3 8/24 15/19 27/24 28/8 42/24 47/6 27/24 28/8 42/24 47/6 27/24 28/8 42/24 47/6 27/24 28/8 42/24 47/6MATTHEW [2] MATTHEW [2] MATTHEW [2] MATTHEW [2] 1/24 4/7 1/24 4/7 1/24 4/7 1/24 4/7may [7] may [7] may [7] may [7] 24/1 24/14 26/6 24/1 24/14 26/6 24/1 24/14 26/6 24/1 24/14 26/6 40/5 41/8 41/8 43/1 40/5 41/8 41/8 43/1 40/5 41/8 41/8 43/1 40/5 41/8 41/8 43/1maybe [3] maybe [3] maybe [3] maybe [3] 41/17 41/25 41/17 41/25 41/17 41/25 41/17 41/25 41/25 41/25 41/25 41/25me [17] me [17] me [17] me [17] 11/14 15/8 17/10 11/14 15/8 17/10 11/14 15/8 17/10 11/14 15/8 17/10 17/24 18/17 20/13 21/19 17/24 18/17 20/13 21/19 17/24 18/17 20/13 21/19 17/24 18/17 20/13 21/19 23/10 24/23 27/13 28/5 23/10 24/23 27/13 28/5 23/10 24/23 27/13 28/5 23/10 24/23 27/13 28/5 30/2 36/7 41/12 41/17 30/2 36/7 41/12 41/17 30/2 36/7 41/12 41/17 30/2 36/7 41/12 41/17 41/23 47/4 41/23 47/4 41/23 47/4 41/23 47/4mean [16] mean [16] mean [16] mean [16] 5/11 7/11 12/18 5/11 7/11 12/18 5/11 7/11 12/18 5/11 7/11 12/18 13/2 13/10 19/9 20/20 13/2 13/10 19/9 20/20 13/2 13/10 19/9 20/20 13/2 13/10 19/9 20/20 22/14 30/10 30/11 31/16 22/14 30/10 30/11 31/16 22/14 30/10 30/11 31/16 22/14 30/10 30/11 31/16 34/3 34/19 37/8 41/7 41/8 34/3 34/19 37/8 41/7 41/8 34/3 34/19 37/8 41/7 41/8 34/3 34/19 37/8 41/7 41/8means [5] means [5] means [5] means [5] 20/18 31/12 20/18 31/12 20/18 31/12 20/18 31/12 31/17 31/18 45/10 31/17 31/18 45/10 31/17 31/18 45/10 31/17 31/18 45/10meant [1] meant [1] meant [1] meant [1] 42/8 42/8 42/8 42/8measuring [2] measuring [2] measuring [2] measuring [2] 37/11 37/12 37/11 37/12 37/11 37/12 37/11 37/12meet [1] meet [1] meet [1] meet [1] 20/10 20/10 20/10 20/10MELLETT [2] MELLETT [2] MELLETT [2] MELLETT [2] 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9mention [2] mention [2] mention [2] mention [2] 9/12 9/16 9/12 9/16 9/12 9/16 9/12 9/16mentioned [2] mentioned [2] mentioned [2] mentioned [2] 9/18 16/10 9/18 16/10 9/18 16/10 9/18 16/10met [2] met [2] met [2] met [2] 16/15 17/3 16/15 17/3 16/15 17/3 16/15 17/3meters [1] meters [1] meters [1] meters [1] 12/17 12/17 12/17 12/17method [3] method [3] method [3] method [3] 27/7 27/7 27/8 27/7 27/7 27/8 27/7 27/7 27/8 27/7 27/7 27/8methodology [2] methodology [2] methodology [2] methodology [2] 41/19 41/19 41/19 41/19 41/22 41/22 41/22 41/22Mexican [1] Mexican [1] Mexican [1] Mexican [1] 2/9 2/9 2/9 2/9mic [1] mic [1] mic [1] mic [1] 4/25 4/25 4/25 4/25might [4] might [4] might [4] might [4] 27/17 37/17 27/17 37/17 27/17 37/17 27/17 37/17 40/4 40/8 40/4 40/8 40/4 40/8 40/4 40/8Military [1] Military [1] Military [1] Military [1] 2/7 2/7 2/7 2/7mind [1] mind [1] mind [1] mind [1] 34/22 34/22 34/22 34/22minimally [1] minimally [1] minimally [1] minimally [1] 5/11 5/11 5/11 5/11minorities [6] minorities [6] minorities [6] minorities [6] 33/18 33/18 33/18 33/18 34/14 34/18 34/20 35/17 34/14 34/18 34/20 35/17 34/14 34/18 34/20 35/17 34/14 34/18 34/20 35/17 38/19 38/19 38/19 38/19minority [7] minority [7] minority [7] minority [7] 25/4 25/5 25/4 25/5 25/4 25/5 25/4 25/5 25/11 38/9 38/12 39/25 25/11 38/9 38/12 39/25 25/11 38/9 38/12 39/25 25/11 38/9 38/12 39/25

40/23 40/23 40/23 40/23minutes [3] minutes [3] minutes [3] minutes [3] 10/4 30/23 10/4 30/23 10/4 30/23 10/4 30/23 43/1 43/1 43/1 43/1missing [5] missing [5] missing [5] missing [5] 11/15 11/19 11/15 11/19 11/15 11/19 11/15 11/19 11/24 12/2 12/3 11/24 12/2 12/3 11/24 12/2 12/3 11/24 12/2 12/3Molina [2] Molina [2] Molina [2] Molina [2] 11/16 12/16 11/16 12/16 11/16 12/16 11/16 12/16money [1] money [1] money [1] money [1] 39/1 39/1 39/1 39/1month [5] month [5] month [5] month [5] 7/4 7/4 7/5 7/8 7/4 7/4 7/5 7/8 7/4 7/4 7/5 7/8 7/4 7/4 7/5 7/8 29/3 29/3 29/3 29/3more [21] more [21] more [21] more [21] 4/19 7/18 9/17 4/19 7/18 9/17 4/19 7/18 9/17 4/19 7/18 9/17 9/19 9/21 11/4 13/12 9/19 9/21 11/4 13/12 9/19 9/21 11/4 13/12 9/19 9/21 11/4 13/12 15/14 15/15 18/16 28/11 15/14 15/15 18/16 28/11 15/14 15/15 18/16 28/11 15/14 15/15 18/16 28/11 29/11 34/1 35/5 35/25 29/11 34/1 35/5 35/25 29/11 34/1 35/5 35/25 29/11 34/1 35/5 35/25 36/3 36/12 39/18 43/2 36/3 36/12 39/18 43/2 36/3 36/12 39/18 43/2 36/3 36/12 39/18 43/2 44/3 44/15 44/3 44/15 44/3 44/15 44/3 44/15morning [8] morning [8] morning [8] morning [8] 21/9 21/10 21/9 21/10 21/9 21/10 21/9 21/10 21/11 24/16 31/1 31/2 21/11 24/16 31/1 31/2 21/11 24/16 31/1 31/2 21/11 24/16 31/1 31/2 43/7 43/8 43/7 43/8 43/7 43/8 43/7 43/8MORTARA [4] MORTARA [4] MORTARA [4] MORTARA [4] 1/17 4/6 4/13 1/17 4/6 4/13 1/17 4/6 4/13 1/17 4/6 4/13 5/20 5/20 5/20 5/20most [1] most [1] most [1] most [1] 13/21 13/21 13/21 13/21motivation [1] motivation [1] motivation [1] motivation [1] 38/20 38/20 38/20 38/20Movant [1] Movant [1] Movant [1] Movant [1] 3/3 3/3 3/3 3/3move [4] move [4] move [4] move [4] 6/2 29/13 29/14 6/2 29/13 29/14 6/2 29/13 29/14 6/2 29/13 29/14 36/9 36/9 36/9 36/9moves [2] moves [2] moves [2] moves [2] 13/9 13/9 13/9 13/9 13/9 13/9 13/9 13/9moving [1] moving [1] moving [1] moving [1] 16/21 16/21 16/21 16/21Mr [3] Mr [3] Mr [3] Mr [3] 46/6 46/7 46/8 46/6 46/7 46/8 46/6 46/7 46/8 46/6 46/7 46/8Mr. [2] Mr. [2] Mr. [2] Mr. [2] 4/13 5/20 4/13 5/20 4/13 5/20 4/13 5/20Mr. Mortara [2] Mr. Mortara [2] Mr. Mortara [2] Mr. Mortara [2] 4/13 5/20 4/13 5/20 4/13 5/20 4/13 5/20Ms [1] Ms [1] Ms [1] Ms [1] 46/5 46/5 46/5 46/5Ms. [3] Ms. [3] Ms. [3] Ms. [3] 8/16 9/9 45/6 8/16 9/9 45/6 8/16 9/9 45/6 8/16 9/9 45/6Ms. Perales [1] Ms. Perales [1] Ms. Perales [1] Ms. Perales [1] 8/16 8/16 8/16 8/16Ms. White [2] Ms. White [2] Ms. White [2] Ms. White [2] 9/9 45/6 9/9 45/6 9/9 45/6 9/9 45/6much [8] much [8] much [8] much [8] 7/12 8/9 13/3 7/12 8/9 13/3 7/12 8/9 13/3 7/12 8/9 13/3 27/16 35/19 40/6 44/2 27/16 35/19 40/6 44/2 27/16 35/19 40/6 44/2 27/16 35/19 40/6 44/2 44/16 44/16 44/16 44/16multiple [3] multiple [3] multiple [3] multiple [3] 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/19 10/19 10/19 10/19must [1] must [1] must [1] must [1] 45/9 45/9 45/9 45/9my [26] my [26] my [26] my [26] 4/16 6/6 6/14 4/16 6/6 6/14 4/16 6/6 6/14 4/16 6/6 6/14 8/10 9/11 9/15 9/22 15/17 8/10 9/11 9/15 9/22 15/17 8/10 9/11 9/15 9/22 15/17 8/10 9/11 9/15 9/22 15/17 18/20 24/2 24/10 27/14 18/20 24/2 24/10 27/14 18/20 24/2 24/10 27/14 18/20 24/2 24/10 27/14 30/12 30/13 30/16 35/14 30/12 30/13 30/16 35/14 30/12 30/13 30/16 35/14 30/12 30/13 30/16 35/14 36/7 36/8 41/7 41/7 41/9 36/7 36/8 41/7 41/7 41/9 36/7 36/8 41/7 41/7 41/9 36/7 36/8 41/7 41/7 41/9 41/11 41/11 42/12 42/14 41/11 41/11 42/12 42/14 41/11 41/11 42/12 42/14 41/11 41/11 42/12 42/14 47/3 47/3 47/3 47/3

NNNNname [1] name [1] name [1] name [1] 21/12 21/12 21/12 21/12NAPIER [2] NAPIER [2] NAPIER [2] NAPIER [2] 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7narrow [2] narrow [2] narrow [2] narrow [2] 15/14 15/15 15/14 15/15 15/14 15/15 15/14 15/15Neala [2] Neala [2] Neala [2] Neala [2] 12/13 12/14 12/13 12/14 12/13 12/14 12/13 12/14near [1] near [1] near [1] near [1] 13/7 13/7 13/7 13/7necessarily [2] necessarily [2] necessarily [2] necessarily [2] 26/13 26/13 26/13 26/13 30/11 30/11 30/11 30/11need [6] need [6] need [6] need [6] 6/25 8/13 13/5 6/25 8/13 13/5 6/25 8/13 13/5 6/25 8/13 13/5 15/16 17/24 45/5 15/16 17/24 45/5 15/16 17/24 45/5 15/16 17/24 45/5needed [3] needed [3] needed [3] needed [3] 9/17 9/17 9/17 9/17 9/17 9/17 9/17 9/17 28/18 28/18 28/18 28/18neither [2] neither [2] neither [2] neither [2] 40/20 47/7 40/20 47/7 40/20 47/7 40/20 47/7never [3] never [3] never [3] never [3] 24/10 34/22 24/10 34/22 24/10 34/22 24/10 34/22 42/14 42/14 42/14 42/14new [7] new [7] new [7] new [7] 8/22 19/22 29/2 8/22 19/22 29/2 8/22 19/22 29/2 8/22 19/22 29/2 29/7 29/16 29/18 29/19 29/7 29/16 29/18 29/19 29/7 29/16 29/18 29/19 29/7 29/16 29/18 29/19next [1] next [1] next [1] next [1] 42/24 42/24 42/24 42/24night [1] night [1] night [1] night [1] 4/20 4/20 4/20 4/20NINA [2] NINA [2] NINA [2] NINA [2] 2/8 4/12 2/8 4/12 2/8 4/12 2/8 4/12no [16] no [16] no [16] no [16] 1/4 6/9 9/8 14/10 1/4 6/9 9/8 14/10 1/4 6/9 9/8 14/10 1/4 6/9 9/8 14/10 18/4 24/19 32/16 38/3 18/4 24/19 32/16 38/3 18/4 24/19 32/16 38/3 18/4 24/19 32/16 38/3 42/9 42/16 43/2 44/21 42/9 42/16 43/2 44/21 42/9 42/16 43/2 44/21 42/9 42/16 43/2 44/21

45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10normal [1] normal [1] normal [1] normal [1] 7/5 7/5 7/5 7/5not [75] not [75] not [75] not [75] notes [1] notes [1] notes [1] notes [1] 47/4 47/4 47/4 47/4notion [1] notion [1] notion [1] notion [1] 40/3 40/3 40/3 40/3now [16] now [16] now [16] now [16] 6/13 8/8 15/8 6/13 8/8 15/8 6/13 8/8 15/8 6/13 8/8 15/8 15/14 17/9 18/14 19/20 15/14 17/9 18/14 19/20 15/14 17/9 18/14 19/20 15/14 17/9 18/14 19/20 28/24 29/17 32/8 36/17 28/24 29/17 32/8 36/17 28/24 29/17 32/8 36/17 28/24 29/17 32/8 36/17 38/20 40/15 40/19 45/1 38/20 40/15 40/19 45/1 38/20 40/15 40/19 45/1 38/20 40/15 40/19 45/1 45/2 45/2 45/2 45/2number [10] number [10] number [10] number [10] 4/19 4/20 4/19 4/20 4/19 4/20 4/19 4/20 17/21 18/3 18/6 29/14 17/21 18/3 18/6 29/14 17/21 18/3 18/6 29/14 17/21 18/3 18/6 29/14 29/15 35/2 35/22 35/22 29/15 35/2 35/22 35/22 29/15 35/2 35/22 35/22 29/15 35/2 35/22 35/22numbers [5] numbers [5] numbers [5] numbers [5] 18/19 18/24 18/19 18/24 18/19 18/24 18/19 18/24 18/25 29/4 39/12 18/25 29/4 39/12 18/25 29/4 39/12 18/25 29/4 39/12NW [4] NW [4] NW [4] NW [4] 2/5 2/7 2/15 3/9 2/5 2/7 2/15 3/9 2/5 2/7 2/15 3/9 2/5 2/7 2/15 3/9

OOOOo0o [1] o0o [1] o0o [1] o0o [1] 45/12 45/12 45/12 45/12OAG [4] OAG [4] OAG [4] OAG [4] 10/4 12/10 15/22 10/4 12/10 15/22 10/4 12/10 15/22 10/4 12/10 15/22 16/2 16/2 16/2 16/2obvious [1] obvious [1] obvious [1] obvious [1] 13/4 13/4 13/4 13/4obviously [1] obviously [1] obviously [1] obviously [1] 13/5 13/5 13/5 13/5off [1] off [1] off [1] off [1] 18/14 18/14 18/14 18/14offer [1] offer [1] offer [1] offer [1] 7/3 7/3 7/3 7/3offering [1] offering [1] offering [1] offering [1] 23/21 23/21 23/21 23/21office [7] office [7] office [7] office [7] 1/24 2/12 6/13 1/24 2/12 6/13 1/24 2/12 6/13 1/24 2/12 6/13 11/8 13/9 16/5 16/9 11/8 13/9 16/5 16/9 11/8 13/9 16/5 16/9 11/8 13/9 16/5 16/9Offices [1] Offices [1] Offices [1] Offices [1] 3/3 3/3 3/3 3/3official [2] official [2] official [2] official [2] 1/6 3/7 1/6 3/7 1/6 3/7 1/6 3/7often [3] often [3] often [3] often [3] 9/7 13/14 31/17 9/7 13/14 31/17 9/7 13/14 31/17 9/7 13/14 31/17oh [4] oh [4] oh [4] oh [4] 6/7 6/11 9/21 6/7 6/11 9/21 6/7 6/11 9/21 6/7 6/11 9/21 30/16 30/16 30/16 30/16okay [11] okay [11] okay [11] okay [11] 8/8 8/15 14/3 8/8 8/15 14/3 8/8 8/15 14/3 8/8 8/15 14/3 17/19 19/6 20/22 25/22 17/19 19/6 20/22 25/22 17/19 19/6 20/22 25/22 17/19 19/6 20/22 25/22 30/9 32/7 41/21 45/4 30/9 32/7 41/21 45/4 30/9 32/7 41/21 45/4 30/9 32/7 41/21 45/4old [1] old [1] old [1] old [1] 29/24 29/24 29/24 29/24omit [1] omit [1] omit [1] omit [1] 12/11 12/11 12/11 12/11omitted [3] omitted [3] omitted [3] omitted [3] 9/14 16/6 9/14 16/6 9/14 16/6 9/14 16/6 16/10 16/10 16/10 16/10once [3] once [3] once [3] once [3] 9/4 25/13 29/1 9/4 25/13 29/1 9/4 25/13 29/1 9/4 25/13 29/1one [21] one [21] one [21] one [21] 7/14 9/4 9/12 7/14 9/4 9/12 7/14 9/4 9/12 7/14 9/4 9/12 9/19 9/21 11/25 12/3 9/19 9/21 11/25 12/3 9/19 9/21 11/25 12/3 9/19 9/21 11/25 12/3 13/21 15/14 19/21 28/1 13/21 15/14 19/21 28/1 13/21 15/14 19/21 28/1 13/21 15/14 19/21 28/1 28/13 31/6 31/10 39/20 28/13 31/6 31/10 39/20 28/13 31/6 31/10 39/20 28/13 31/6 31/10 39/20 39/20 39/21 40/9 42/4 39/20 39/21 40/9 42/4 39/20 39/21 40/9 42/4 39/20 39/21 40/9 42/4 42/6 43/10 42/6 43/10 42/6 43/10 42/6 43/10only [15] only [15] only [15] only [15] 5/13 5/23 9/19 5/13 5/23 9/19 5/13 5/23 9/19 5/13 5/23 9/19 9/21 15/10 15/23 17/13 9/21 15/10 15/23 17/13 9/21 15/10 15/23 17/13 9/21 15/10 15/23 17/13 23/3 24/2 25/3 29/1 35/7 23/3 24/2 25/3 29/1 35/7 23/3 24/2 25/3 29/1 35/7 23/3 24/2 25/3 29/1 35/7 37/24 38/17 42/13 37/24 38/17 42/13 37/24 38/17 42/13 37/24 38/17 42/13opinion [3] opinion [3] opinion [3] opinion [3] 8/10 15/13 8/10 15/13 8/10 15/13 8/10 15/13 23/21 23/21 23/21 23/21opportunity [1] opportunity [1] opportunity [1] opportunity [1] 44/3 44/3 44/3 44/3opposed [3] opposed [3] opposed [3] opposed [3] 13/22 21/1 13/22 21/1 13/22 21/1 13/22 21/1 37/6 37/6 37/6 37/6opposite [2] opposite [2] opposite [2] opposite [2] 33/13 38/16 33/13 38/16 33/13 38/16 33/13 38/16order [4] order [4] order [4] order [4] 13/8 13/12 13/8 13/12 13/8 13/12 13/8 13/12 14/11 36/12 14/11 36/12 14/11 36/12 14/11 36/12other [6] other [6] other [6] other [6] 7/13 34/8 36/13 7/13 34/8 36/13 7/13 34/8 36/13 7/13 34/8 36/13 37/8 37/10 38/16 37/8 37/10 38/16 37/8 37/10 38/16 37/8 37/10 38/16otherwise [3] otherwise [3] otherwise [3] otherwise [3] 10/18 10/19 10/18 10/19 10/18 10/19 10/18 10/19 47/10 47/10 47/10 47/10ought [1] ought [1] ought [1] ought [1] 15/14 15/14 15/14 15/14our [2] our [2] our [2] our [2] 17/6 31/23 17/6 31/23 17/6 31/23 17/6 31/23out [12] out [12] out [12] out [12] 20/6 24/25 28/2 20/6 24/25 28/2 20/6 24/25 28/2 20/6 24/25 28/2 28/4 36/4 36/6 36/10 28/4 36/4 36/6 36/10 28/4 36/4 36/6 36/10 28/4 36/4 36/6 36/10 36/14 36/15 36/15 38/25 36/14 36/15 36/15 38/25 36/14 36/15 36/15 38/25 36/14 36/15 36/15 38/25 44/6 44/6 44/6 44/6outcome [1] outcome [1] outcome [1] outcome [1] 47/10 47/10 47/10 47/10over [6] over [6] over [6] over [6] 7/10 19/1 19/24 7/10 19/1 19/24 7/10 19/1 19/24 7/10 19/1 19/24

54545454

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 54 of 59

Page 55: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

OOOOover... [3] over... [3] over... [3] over... [3] 35/25 39/24 35/25 39/24 35/25 39/24 35/25 39/24 41/25 41/25 41/25 41/25over-designate [1] over-designate [1] over-designate [1] over-designate [1] 7/10 7/10 7/10 7/10over-interpreting [1] over-interpreting [1] over-interpreting [1] over-interpreting [1] 41/25 41/25 41/25 41/25own [4] own [4] own [4] own [4] 4/22 5/3 5/6 4/22 5/3 5/6 4/22 5/3 5/6 4/22 5/3 5/6 11/23 11/23 11/23 11/23

PPPPP.C [1] P.C [1] P.C [1] P.C [1] 2/18 2/18 2/18 2/18P.O [1] P.O [1] P.O [1] P.O [1] 1/25 1/25 1/25 1/25page [11] page [11] page [11] page [11] 10/6 20/3 23/2 10/6 20/3 23/2 10/6 20/3 23/2 10/6 20/3 23/2 24/18 25/15 36/21 40/11 24/18 25/15 36/21 40/11 24/18 25/15 36/21 40/11 24/18 25/15 36/21 40/11 40/12 40/12 40/12 40/13 40/12 40/12 40/12 40/13 40/12 40/12 40/12 40/13 40/12 40/12 40/12 40/13pages [4] pages [4] pages [4] pages [4] 7/24 7/25 19/2 7/24 7/25 19/2 7/24 7/25 19/2 7/24 7/25 19/2 47/3 47/3 47/3 47/3Palenchar [1] Palenchar [1] Palenchar [1] Palenchar [1] 1/19 1/19 1/19 1/19papers [1] papers [1] papers [1] papers [1] 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10paragraph [1] paragraph [1] paragraph [1] paragraph [1] 40/17 40/17 40/17 40/17part [1] part [1] part [1] part [1] 42/1 42/1 42/1 42/1particular [1] particular [1] particular [1] particular [1] 30/19 30/19 30/19 30/19parties [2] parties [2] parties [2] parties [2] 13/22 47/8 13/22 47/8 13/22 47/8 13/22 47/8party [1] party [1] party [1] party [1] 13/17 13/17 13/17 13/17pass [2] pass [2] pass [2] pass [2] 21/8 30/19 21/8 30/19 21/8 30/19 21/8 30/19paying [1] paying [1] paying [1] paying [1] 13/21 13/21 13/21 13/21pencils [1] pencils [1] pencils [1] pencils [1] 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10Pennsylvania [1] Pennsylvania [1] Pennsylvania [1] Pennsylvania [1] 2/5 2/5 2/5 2/5pens [1] pens [1] pens [1] pens [1] 45/10 45/10 45/10 45/10people [6] people [6] people [6] people [6] 7/10 13/14 7/10 13/14 7/10 13/14 7/10 13/14 13/15 33/12 36/10 42/24 13/15 33/12 36/10 42/24 13/15 33/12 36/10 42/24 13/15 33/12 36/10 42/24PERALES [4] PERALES [4] PERALES [4] PERALES [4] 2/8 4/12 8/16 2/8 4/12 8/16 2/8 4/12 8/16 2/8 4/12 8/16 46/5 46/5 46/5 46/5percent [28] percent [28] percent [28] percent [28] 17/5 17/9 17/5 17/9 17/5 17/9 17/5 17/9 17/21 18/3 18/7 19/24 17/21 18/3 18/7 19/24 17/21 18/3 18/7 19/24 17/21 18/3 18/7 19/24 20/7 20/10 20/14 20/15 20/7 20/10 20/14 20/15 20/7 20/10 20/14 20/15 20/7 20/10 20/14 20/15 26/19 28/13 28/14 28/15 26/19 28/13 28/14 28/15 26/19 28/13 28/14 28/15 26/19 28/13 28/14 28/15 32/25 33/2 33/4 33/7 32/25 33/2 33/4 33/7 32/25 33/2 33/4 33/7 32/25 33/2 33/4 33/7 33/15 33/21 34/7 35/5 33/15 33/21 34/7 35/5 33/15 33/21 34/7 35/5 33/15 33/21 34/7 35/5 35/5 35/6 35/8 35/21 36/4 35/5 35/6 35/8 35/21 36/4 35/5 35/6 35/8 35/21 36/4 35/5 35/6 35/8 35/21 36/4 36/6 36/6 36/6 36/6percentage [6] percentage [6] percentage [6] percentage [6] 26/3 35/8 26/3 35/8 26/3 35/8 26/3 35/8 35/9 36/14 36/14 36/15 35/9 36/14 36/14 36/15 35/9 36/14 36/14 36/15 35/9 36/14 36/14 36/15percentages [4] percentages [4] percentages [4] percentages [4] 25/15 25/15 25/15 25/15 25/24 26/2 27/16 25/24 26/2 27/16 25/24 26/2 27/16 25/24 26/2 27/16Perez [2] Perez [2] Perez [2] Perez [2] 21/3 21/5 21/3 21/5 21/3 21/5 21/3 21/5perform [1] perform [1] perform [1] perform [1] 24/2 24/2 24/2 24/2performance [1] performance [1] performance [1] performance [1] 17/1 17/1 17/1 17/1performed [1] performed [1] performed [1] performed [1] 24/9 24/9 24/9 24/9perhaps [2] perhaps [2] perhaps [2] perhaps [2] 29/11 29/25 29/11 29/25 29/11 29/25 29/11 29/25perimeters [1] perimeters [1] perimeters [1] perimeters [1] 11/22 11/22 11/22 11/22period [1] period [1] period [1] period [1] 16/16 16/16 16/16 16/16Perkins [1] Perkins [1] Perkins [1] Perkins [1] 2/15 2/15 2/15 2/15person [1] person [1] person [1] person [1] 40/7 40/7 40/7 40/7personal [1] personal [1] personal [1] personal [1] 16/11 16/11 16/11 16/11Ph.D [2] Ph.D [2] Ph.D [2] Ph.D [2] 9/10 46/4 9/10 46/4 9/10 46/4 9/10 46/4PILGRIM [2] PILGRIM [2] PILGRIM [2] PILGRIM [2] 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12place [3] place [3] place [3] place [3] 1/20 5/25 11/16 1/20 5/25 11/16 1/20 5/25 11/16 1/20 5/25 11/16placement [1] placement [1] placement [1] placement [1] 12/20 12/20 12/20 12/20places [1] places [1] places [1] places [1] 34/8 34/8 34/8 34/8Plaintiff [4] Plaintiff [4] Plaintiff [4] Plaintiff [4] 1/4 1/17 1/4 1/17 1/4 1/17 1/4 1/17 9/10 46/3 9/10 46/3 9/10 46/3 9/10 46/3plaintiffs [1] plaintiffs [1] plaintiffs [1] plaintiffs [1] 4/6 4/6 4/6 4/6plan [26] plan [26] plan [26] plan [26] 17/2 17/11 17/2 17/11 17/2 17/11 17/2 17/11 17/12 17/14 18/9 19/12 17/12 17/14 18/9 19/12 17/12 17/14 18/9 19/12 17/12 17/14 18/9 19/12 19/22 19/22 21/18 21/19 19/22 19/22 21/18 21/19 19/22 19/22 21/18 21/19 19/22 19/22 21/18 21/19 22/3 23/11 30/15 30/17 22/3 23/11 30/15 30/17 22/3 23/11 30/15 30/17 22/3 23/11 30/15 30/17 32/3 40/22 40/23 41/13 32/3 40/22 40/23 41/13 32/3 40/22 40/23 41/13 32/3 40/22 40/23 41/13 41/14 41/15 41/23 42/5 41/14 41/15 41/23 42/5 41/14 41/15 41/23 42/5 41/14 41/15 41/23 42/5 42/10 44/2 44/9 44/11 42/10 44/2 44/9 44/11 42/10 44/2 44/9 44/11 42/10 44/2 44/9 44/11

plans [4] plans [4] plans [4] plans [4] 37/8 37/9 38/21 37/8 37/9 38/21 37/8 37/9 38/21 37/8 37/9 38/21 43/20 43/20 43/20 43/20play [1] play [1] play [1] play [1] 39/2 39/2 39/2 39/2please [2] please [2] please [2] please [2] 4/25 17/25 4/25 17/25 4/25 17/25 4/25 17/25plus [2] plus [2] plus [2] plus [2] 17/21 18/3 17/21 18/3 17/21 18/3 17/21 18/3point [6] point [6] point [6] point [6] 13/15 18/19 13/15 18/19 13/15 18/19 13/15 18/19 24/1 33/3 42/12 42/14 24/1 33/3 42/12 42/14 24/1 33/3 42/12 42/14 24/1 33/3 42/12 42/14points [1] points [1] points [1] points [1] 33/13 33/13 33/13 33/13polar [1] polar [1] polar [1] polar [1] 33/13 33/13 33/13 33/13polarization [3] polarization [3] polarization [3] polarization [3] 33/24 33/24 33/24 33/24 34/8 37/12 34/8 37/12 34/8 37/12 34/8 37/12polarized [6] polarized [6] polarized [6] polarized [6] 32/13 32/16 32/13 32/16 32/13 32/16 32/13 32/16 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17political [1] political [1] political [1] political [1] 43/22 43/22 43/22 43/22polling [1] polling [1] polling [1] polling [1] 26/16 26/16 26/16 26/16polorization [4] polorization [4] polorization [4] polorization [4] 32/16 32/16 32/16 32/16 33/12 33/16 34/9 33/12 33/16 34/9 33/12 33/16 34/9 33/12 33/16 34/9population [7] population [7] population [7] population [7] 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 18/8 18/11 18/14 29/7 18/8 18/11 18/14 29/7 18/8 18/11 18/14 29/7 18/8 18/11 18/14 29/7 29/12 29/12 29/12 29/12portion [1] portion [1] portion [1] portion [1] 20/24 20/24 20/24 20/24portions [5] portions [5] portions [5] portions [5] 4/21 5/2 5/6 4/21 5/2 5/6 4/21 5/2 5/6 4/21 5/2 5/6 6/16 6/20 6/16 6/20 6/16 6/20 6/16 6/20position [1] position [1] position [1] position [1] 39/6 39/6 39/6 39/6possible [2] possible [2] possible [2] possible [2] 24/7 41/10 24/7 41/10 24/7 41/10 24/7 41/10practice [1] practice [1] practice [1] practice [1] 26/8 26/8 26/8 26/8pre [7] pre [7] pre [7] pre [7] 10/6 20/3 22/22 10/6 20/3 22/22 10/6 20/3 22/22 10/6 20/3 22/22 36/17 40/11 40/15 41/3 36/17 40/11 40/15 41/3 36/17 40/11 40/15 41/3 36/17 40/11 40/15 41/3pre-filed [7] pre-filed [7] pre-filed [7] pre-filed [7] 10/6 20/3 10/6 20/3 10/6 20/3 10/6 20/3 22/22 36/17 40/11 40/15 22/22 36/17 40/11 40/15 22/22 36/17 40/11 40/15 22/22 36/17 40/11 40/15 41/3 41/3 41/3 41/3precincts [1] precincts [1] precincts [1] precincts [1] 27/4 27/4 27/4 27/4preclude [1] preclude [1] preclude [1] preclude [1] 5/15 5/15 5/15 5/15prefer [1] prefer [1] prefer [1] prefer [1] 11/3 11/3 11/3 11/3preferred [1] preferred [1] preferred [1] preferred [1] 18/15 18/15 18/15 18/15presence [1] presence [1] presence [1] presence [1] 25/11 25/11 25/11 25/11present [1] present [1] present [1] present [1] 23/24 23/24 23/24 23/24presented [5] presented [5] presented [5] presented [5] 6/22 6/24 6/22 6/24 6/22 6/24 6/22 6/24 23/18 43/23 44/12 23/18 43/23 44/12 23/18 43/23 44/12 23/18 43/23 44/12president [4] president [4] president [4] president [4] 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/14 14/14 14/14 14/14 14/14 14/14 14/14 14/14presidential [3] presidential [3] presidential [3] presidential [3] 13/8 13/8 13/8 13/8 13/25 14/13 13/25 14/13 13/25 14/13 13/25 14/13pressing [1] pressing [1] pressing [1] pressing [1] 39/17 39/17 39/17 39/17presumably [1] presumably [1] presumably [1] presumably [1] 29/13 29/13 29/13 29/13pretty [2] pretty [2] pretty [2] pretty [2] 7/8 7/9 7/8 7/9 7/8 7/9 7/8 7/9previous [2] previous [2] previous [2] previous [2] 35/15 40/11 35/15 40/11 35/15 40/11 35/15 40/11previously [1] previously [1] previously [1] previously [1] 47/6 47/6 47/6 47/6primaries [18] primaries [18] primaries [18] primaries [18] 22/11 23/3 22/11 23/3 22/11 23/3 22/11 23/3 23/5 23/14 23/17 23/19 23/5 23/14 23/17 23/19 23/5 23/14 23/17 23/19 23/5 23/14 23/17 23/19 23/22 23/23 23/24 24/3 23/22 23/23 23/24 24/3 23/22 23/23 23/24 24/3 23/22 23/23 23/24 24/3 24/12 24/17 25/3 25/6 24/12 24/17 25/3 25/6 24/12 24/17 25/3 25/6 24/12 24/17 25/3 25/6 25/8 25/9 25/10 27/22 25/8 25/9 25/10 27/22 25/8 25/9 25/10 27/22 25/8 25/9 25/10 27/22primary [8] primary [8] primary [8] primary [8] 23/7 24/19 23/7 24/19 23/7 24/19 23/7 24/19 25/7 25/11 25/12 26/4 25/7 25/11 25/12 26/4 25/7 25/11 25/12 26/4 25/7 25/11 25/12 26/4 27/5 27/23 27/5 27/23 27/5 27/23 27/5 27/23prior [1] prior [1] prior [1] prior [1] 35/6 35/6 35/6 35/6probably [1] probably [1] probably [1] probably [1] 45/7 45/7 45/7 45/7problem [2] problem [2] problem [2] problem [2] 6/19 6/21 6/19 6/21 6/19 6/21 6/19 6/21proceedings [2] proceedings [2] proceedings [2] proceedings [2] 3/10 47/5 3/10 47/5 3/10 47/5 3/10 47/5process [1] process [1] process [1] process [1] 4/17 4/17 4/17 4/17produce [4] produce [4] produce [4] produce [4] 17/17 24/14 17/17 24/14 17/17 24/14 17/17 24/14 28/4 39/25 28/4 39/25 28/4 39/25 28/4 39/25produced [1] produced [1] produced [1] produced [1] 3/10 3/10 3/10 3/10product [1] product [1] product [1] product [1] 15/23 15/23 15/23 15/23Professor [2] Professor [2] Professor [2] Professor [2] 43/7 44/20 43/7 44/20 43/7 44/20 43/7 44/20profile [1] profile [1] profile [1] profile [1] 38/24 38/24 38/24 38/24progress [2] progress [2] progress [2] progress [2] 40/6 40/7 40/6 40/7 40/6 40/7 40/6 40/7project [3] project [3] project [3] project [3] 6/3 6/12 6/15 6/3 6/12 6/15 6/3 6/12 6/15 6/3 6/12 6/15proposed [1] proposed [1] proposed [1] proposed [1] 41/14 41/14 41/14 41/14provide [2] provide [2] provide [2] provide [2] 26/9 38/7 26/9 38/7 26/9 38/7 26/9 38/7

provided [4] provided [4] provided [4] provided [4] 27/17 27/17 27/17 27/17 27/17 27/17 27/17 27/17 29/15 47/4 29/15 47/4 29/15 47/4 29/15 47/4provides [1] provides [1] provides [1] provides [1] 44/2 44/2 44/2 44/2purpose [1] purpose [1] purpose [1] purpose [1] 5/14 5/14 5/14 5/14purposes [1] purposes [1] purposes [1] purposes [1] 15/18 15/18 15/18 15/18put [3] put [3] put [3] put [3] 17/1 37/11 41/4 17/1 37/11 41/4 17/1 37/11 41/4 17/1 37/11 41/4putting [2] putting [2] putting [2] putting [2] 5/13 17/17 5/13 17/17 5/13 17/17 5/13 17/17

QQQQquestion [10] question [10] question [10] question [10] 9/1 16/21 9/1 16/21 9/1 16/21 9/1 16/21 17/24 24/2 24/23 30/5 17/24 24/2 24/23 30/5 17/24 24/2 24/23 30/5 17/24 24/2 24/23 30/5 31/11 33/23 34/21 40/9 31/11 33/23 34/21 40/9 31/11 33/23 34/21 40/9 31/11 33/23 34/21 40/9questioning [2] questioning [2] questioning [2] questioning [2] 9/12 21/6 9/12 21/6 9/12 21/6 9/12 21/6questions [6] questions [6] questions [6] questions [6] 8/12 21/1 8/12 21/1 8/12 21/1 8/12 21/1 30/23 42/16 43/12 44/21 30/23 42/16 43/12 44/21 30/23 42/16 43/12 44/21 30/23 42/16 43/12 44/21quoting [1] quoting [1] quoting [1] quoting [1] 15/13 15/13 15/13 15/13

RRRRrace [28] race [28] race [28] race [28] 10/17 11/2 10/17 11/2 10/17 11/2 10/17 11/2 11/15 11/15 11/19 11/20 11/15 11/15 11/19 11/20 11/15 11/15 11/19 11/20 11/15 11/15 11/19 11/20 11/25 12/7 13/1 13/6 13/6 11/25 12/7 13/1 13/6 13/6 11/25 12/7 13/1 13/6 13/6 11/25 12/7 13/1 13/6 13/6 13/7 13/8 13/8 13/11 13/7 13/8 13/8 13/11 13/7 13/8 13/8 13/11 13/7 13/8 13/8 13/11 13/12 13/18 13/20 13/25 13/12 13/18 13/20 13/25 13/12 13/18 13/20 13/25 13/12 13/18 13/20 13/25 14/1 14/7 14/14 14/16 14/1 14/7 14/14 14/16 14/1 14/7 14/14 14/16 14/1 14/7 14/14 14/16 14/17 15/1 16/6 16/10 14/17 15/1 16/6 16/10 14/17 15/1 16/6 16/10 14/17 15/1 16/6 16/10 32/20 32/20 32/20 32/20races [16] races [16] races [16] races [16] 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/19 10/20 11/1 11/24 10/19 10/20 11/1 11/24 10/19 10/20 11/1 11/24 10/19 10/20 11/1 11/24 11/24 12/2 12/7 12/22 11/24 12/2 12/7 12/22 11/24 12/2 12/7 12/22 11/24 12/2 12/7 12/22 12/24 12/24 13/10 15/3 12/24 12/24 13/10 15/3 12/24 12/24 13/10 15/3 12/24 12/24 13/10 15/3 16/11 16/15 16/11 16/15 16/11 16/15 16/11 16/15racial [8] racial [8] racial [8] racial [8] 22/5 22/10 22/5 22/10 22/5 22/10 22/5 22/10 23/4 23/22 25/24 26/3 23/4 23/22 25/24 26/3 23/4 23/22 25/24 26/3 23/4 23/22 25/24 26/3 26/21 32/16 26/21 32/16 26/21 32/16 26/21 32/16racially [10] racially [10] racially [10] racially [10] 12/1 15/9 12/1 15/9 12/1 15/9 12/1 15/9 15/10 16/15 32/13 32/16 15/10 16/15 32/13 32/16 15/10 16/15 32/13 32/16 15/10 16/15 32/13 32/16 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17 33/10 34/10 34/13 34/17railroad [2] railroad [2] railroad [2] railroad [2] 13/11 15/4 13/11 15/4 13/11 15/4 13/11 15/4Random [1] Random [1] Random [1] Random [1] 28/3 28/3 28/3 28/3randomly [1] randomly [1] randomly [1] randomly [1] 27/25 27/25 27/25 27/25rather [2] rather [2] rather [2] rather [2] 12/25 34/1 12/25 34/1 12/25 34/1 12/25 34/1reach [1] reach [1] reach [1] reach [1] 30/18 30/18 30/18 30/18reached [1] reached [1] reached [1] reached [1] 44/12 44/12 44/12 44/12reaching [1] reaching [1] reaching [1] reaching [1] 43/13 43/13 43/13 43/13read [3] read [3] read [3] read [3] 6/25 7/11 7/16 6/25 7/11 7/16 6/25 7/11 7/16 6/25 7/11 7/16ready [1] ready [1] ready [1] ready [1] 29/18 29/18 29/18 29/18really [5] really [5] really [5] really [5] 7/14 9/5 27/23 7/14 9/5 27/23 7/14 9/5 27/23 7/14 9/5 27/23 28/2 35/6 28/2 35/6 28/2 35/6 28/2 35/6reason [5] reason [5] reason [5] reason [5] 13/18 13/19 13/18 13/19 13/18 13/19 13/18 13/19 16/19 30/12 35/12 16/19 30/12 35/12 16/19 30/12 35/12 16/19 30/12 35/12REBECCA [1] REBECCA [1] REBECCA [1] REBECCA [1] 2/9 2/9 2/9 2/9recall [5] recall [5] recall [5] recall [5] 17/6 19/3 20/1 17/6 19/3 20/1 17/6 19/3 20/1 17/6 19/3 20/1 20/11 20/13 20/11 20/13 20/11 20/13 20/11 20/13received [1] received [1] received [1] received [1] 4/19 4/19 4/19 4/19recess [3] recess [3] recess [3] recess [3] 45/1 45/2 45/1 45/2 45/1 45/2 45/1 45/2 45/11 45/11 45/11 45/11recognize [1] recognize [1] recognize [1] recognize [1] 10/7 10/7 10/7 10/7recollection [2] recollection [2] recollection [2] recollection [2] 35/14 35/14 35/14 35/14 41/7 41/7 41/7 41/7reconstituted [4] reconstituted [4] reconstituted [4] reconstituted [4] 31/22 31/22 31/22 31/22 36/19 43/18 43/22 36/19 43/18 43/22 36/19 43/18 43/22 36/19 43/18 43/22record [6] record [6] record [6] record [6] 13/5 21/5 13/5 21/5 13/5 21/5 13/5 21/5 22/20 26/7 43/14 43/15 22/20 26/7 43/14 43/15 22/20 26/7 43/14 43/15 22/20 26/7 43/14 43/15recorded [1] recorded [1] recorded [1] recorded [1] 3/10 3/10 3/10 3/10Recross [1] Recross [1] Recross [1] Recross [1] 46/2 46/2 46/2 46/2redirect [3] redirect [3] redirect [3] redirect [3] 42/20 43/5 42/20 43/5 42/20 43/5 42/20 43/5 46/2 46/2 46/2 46/2reduction [2] reduction [2] reduction [2] reduction [2] 17/21 18/2 17/21 18/2 17/21 18/2 17/21 18/2REED [2] REED [2] REED [2] REED [2] 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6 1/17 4/6refer [1] refer [1] refer [1] refer [1] 10/4 10/4 10/4 10/4refined [1] refined [1] refined [1] refined [1] 29/19 29/19 29/19 29/19

55555555

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 55 of 59

Page 56: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

RRRRreflect [2] reflect [2] reflect [2] reflect [2] 29/25 37/20 29/25 37/20 29/25 37/20 29/25 37/20reflected [3] reflected [3] reflected [3] reflected [3] 29/13 30/7 29/13 30/7 29/13 30/7 29/13 30/7 38/8 38/8 38/8 38/8regard [1] regard [1] regard [1] regard [1] 32/3 32/3 32/3 32/3regarding [1] regarding [1] regarding [1] regarding [1] 21/2 21/2 21/2 21/2related [1] related [1] related [1] related [1] 47/7 47/7 47/7 47/7relative [1] relative [1] relative [1] relative [1] 18/6 18/6 18/6 18/6released [2] released [2] released [2] released [2] 29/3 29/6 29/3 29/6 29/3 29/6 29/3 29/6relevant [1] relevant [1] relevant [1] relevant [1] 6/23 6/23 6/23 6/23remember [3] remember [3] remember [3] remember [3] 9/1 19/5 9/1 19/5 9/1 19/5 9/1 19/5 35/10 35/10 35/10 35/10reminded [1] reminded [1] reminded [1] reminded [1] 27/13 27/13 27/13 27/13repeat [2] repeat [2] repeat [2] repeat [2] 6/20 17/24 6/20 17/24 6/20 17/24 6/20 17/24replace [1] replace [1] replace [1] replace [1] 28/22 28/22 28/22 28/22report [18] report [18] report [18] report [18] 19/4 19/7 19/4 19/7 19/4 19/7 19/4 19/7 20/24 22/19 22/20 22/21 20/24 22/19 22/20 22/21 20/24 22/19 22/20 22/21 20/24 22/19 22/20 22/21 22/25 34/25 35/4 35/10 22/25 34/25 35/4 35/10 22/25 34/25 35/4 35/10 22/25 34/25 35/4 35/10 36/7 36/8 36/21 40/12 36/7 36/8 36/21 40/12 36/7 36/8 36/21 40/12 36/7 36/8 36/21 40/12 40/15 41/5 41/9 41/18 40/15 41/5 41/9 41/18 40/15 41/5 41/9 41/18 40/15 41/5 41/9 41/18reported [2] reported [2] reported [2] reported [2] 26/21 27/9 26/21 27/9 26/21 27/9 26/21 27/9Reporter [2] Reporter [2] Reporter [2] Reporter [2] 3/7 3/7 3/7 3/7 3/7 3/7 3/7 3/7reports [2] reports [2] reports [2] reports [2] 31/8 43/18 31/8 43/18 31/8 43/18 31/8 43/18represent [2] represent [2] represent [2] represent [2] 21/13 26/2 21/13 26/2 21/13 26/2 21/13 26/2Representative [1] Representative [1] Representative [1] Representative [1] 5/5 5/5 5/5 5/5republican [1] republican [1] republican [1] republican [1] 39/23 39/23 39/23 39/23research [1] research [1] research [1] research [1] 19/7 19/7 19/7 19/7Rest [1] Rest [1] Rest [1] Rest [1] 2/13 2/13 2/13 2/13result [6] result [6] result [6] result [6] 17/18 27/21 17/18 27/21 17/18 27/21 17/18 27/21 27/23 28/1 28/2 28/4 27/23 28/1 28/2 28/4 27/23 28/1 28/2 28/4 27/23 28/1 28/2 28/4results [2] results [2] results [2] results [2] 26/16 36/20 26/16 36/20 26/16 36/20 26/16 36/20resume [1] resume [1] resume [1] resume [1] 9/11 9/11 9/11 9/11retrogress [1] retrogress [1] retrogress [1] retrogress [1] 41/23 41/23 41/23 41/23retrogressed [2] retrogressed [2] retrogressed [2] retrogressed [2] 18/9 18/9 18/9 18/9 42/3 42/3 42/3 42/3retrogression [2] retrogression [2] retrogression [2] retrogression [2] 9/14 9/14 9/14 9/14 42/9 42/9 42/9 42/9review [1] review [1] review [1] review [1] 38/20 38/20 38/20 38/20right [27] right [27] right [27] right [27] 6/13 8/15 9/9 6/13 8/15 9/9 6/13 8/15 9/9 6/13 8/15 9/9 14/9 14/11 14/16 15/13 14/9 14/11 14/16 15/13 14/9 14/11 14/16 15/13 14/9 14/11 14/16 15/13 19/13 19/15 23/19 25/3 19/13 19/15 23/19 25/3 19/13 19/15 23/19 25/3 19/13 19/15 23/19 25/3 26/4 26/5 26/10 26/14 26/4 26/5 26/10 26/14 26/4 26/5 26/10 26/14 26/4 26/5 26/10 26/14 26/19 26/23 27/10 28/7 26/19 26/23 27/10 28/7 26/19 26/23 27/10 28/7 26/19 26/23 27/10 28/7 28/16 29/21 31/12 34/22 28/16 29/21 31/12 34/22 28/16 29/21 31/12 34/22 28/16 29/21 31/12 34/22 36/9 42/23 45/1 45/6 36/9 42/23 45/1 45/6 36/9 42/23 45/1 45/6 36/9 42/23 45/1 45/6Rights [1] Rights [1] Rights [1] Rights [1] 36/20 36/20 36/20 36/20risks [1] risks [1] risks [1] risks [1] 30/6 30/6 30/6 30/6risky [1] risky [1] risky [1] risky [1] 29/24 29/24 29/24 29/24Riverview [1] Riverview [1] Riverview [1] Riverview [1] 3/4 3/4 3/4 3/4Road [1] Road [1] Road [1] Road [1] 2/7 2/7 2/7 2/7ROBERTO [1] ROBERTO [1] ROBERTO [1] ROBERTO [1] 3/3 3/3 3/3 3/3Robertovera [1] Robertovera [1] Robertovera [1] Robertovera [1] 3/4 3/4 3/4 3/4Robin [1] Robin [1] Robin [1] Robin [1] 2/13 2/13 2/13 2/13rolling [1] rolling [1] rolling [1] rolling [1] 29/5 29/5 29/5 29/5ROSEMARY [1] ROSEMARY [1] ROSEMARY [1] ROSEMARY [1] 1/13 1/13 1/13 1/13roughly [1] roughly [1] roughly [1] roughly [1] 13/9 13/9 13/9 13/9RPR [2] RPR [2] RPR [2] RPR [2] 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12 3/7 47/12rule [1] rule [1] rule [1] rule [1] 30/9 30/9 30/9 30/9rules [1] rules [1] rules [1] rules [1] 5/7 5/7 5/7 5/7running [1] running [1] running [1] running [1] 35/7 35/7 35/7 35/7

SSSSsaid [10] said [10] said [10] said [10] 11/5 12/5 19/8 11/5 12/5 19/8 11/5 12/5 19/8 11/5 12/5 19/8 19/23 24/18 32/15 33/21 19/23 24/18 32/15 33/21 19/23 24/18 32/15 33/21 19/23 24/18 32/15 33/21 38/15 39/16 45/7 38/15 39/16 45/7 38/15 39/16 45/7 38/15 39/16 45/7same [6] same [6] same [6] same [6] 6/21 27/23 28/2 6/21 27/23 28/2 6/21 27/23 28/2 6/21 27/23 28/2 28/4 43/24 44/10 28/4 43/24 44/10 28/4 43/24 44/10 28/4 43/24 44/10sample [2] sample [2] sample [2] sample [2] 26/12 26/25 26/12 26/25 26/12 26/25 26/12 26/25samples [3] samples [3] samples [3] samples [3] 26/9 27/1 26/9 27/1 26/9 27/1 26/9 27/1 27/4 27/4 27/4 27/4

San [8] San [8] San [8] San [8] 2/11 2/13 3/5 2/11 2/13 3/5 2/11 2/13 3/5 2/11 2/13 3/5 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 6/20 6/21 23/17 32/17 34/25 34/25 34/25 34/25satisfaction [1] satisfaction [1] satisfaction [1] satisfaction [1] 42/13 42/13 42/13 42/13say [20] say [20] say [20] say [20] 6/7 6/8 6/9 6/11 6/7 6/8 6/9 6/11 6/7 6/8 6/9 6/11 6/7 6/8 6/9 6/11 6/24 7/6 8/6 8/14 8/25 6/24 7/6 8/6 8/14 8/25 6/24 7/6 8/6 8/14 8/25 6/24 7/6 8/6 8/14 8/25 12/24 19/4 19/7 19/10 12/24 19/4 19/7 19/10 12/24 19/4 19/7 19/10 12/24 19/4 19/7 19/10 24/1 27/25 30/3 31/20 24/1 27/25 30/3 31/20 24/1 27/25 30/3 31/20 24/1 27/25 30/3 31/20 33/25 35/14 40/20 33/25 35/14 40/20 33/25 35/14 40/20 33/25 35/14 40/20saying [4] saying [4] saying [4] saying [4] 14/19 19/3 14/19 19/3 14/19 19/3 14/19 19/3 33/23 35/13 33/23 35/13 33/23 35/13 33/23 35/13says [1] says [1] says [1] says [1] 25/17 25/17 25/17 25/17science [2] science [2] science [2] science [2] 16/1 26/8 16/1 26/8 16/1 26/8 16/1 26/8scientist [1] scientist [1] scientist [1] scientist [1] 43/22 43/22 43/22 43/22scintilla [2] scintilla [2] scintilla [2] scintilla [2] 42/4 42/6 42/4 42/6 42/4 42/6 42/4 42/6scope [2] scope [2] scope [2] scope [2] 5/24 6/3 5/24 6/3 5/24 6/3 5/24 6/3Scott [1] Scott [1] Scott [1] Scott [1] 1/19 1/19 1/19 1/19screen [3] screen [3] screen [3] screen [3] 10/5 43/16 10/5 43/16 10/5 43/16 10/5 43/16 43/17 43/17 43/17 43/17seat [1] seat [1] seat [1] seat [1] 31/21 31/21 31/21 31/21second [1] second [1] second [1] second [1] 23/10 23/10 23/10 23/10section [7] section [7] section [7] section [7] 35/1 36/23 35/1 36/23 35/1 36/23 35/1 36/23 37/3 37/5 37/7 37/10 41/6 37/3 37/5 37/7 37/10 41/6 37/3 37/5 37/7 37/10 41/6 37/3 37/5 37/7 37/10 41/6see [20] see [20] see [20] see [20] 6/14 11/9 14/13 6/14 11/9 14/13 6/14 11/9 14/13 6/14 11/9 14/13 14/14 15/2 15/3 15/3 14/14 15/2 15/3 15/3 14/14 15/2 15/3 15/3 14/14 15/2 15/3 15/3 17/20 18/2 18/6 18/8 23/2 17/20 18/2 18/6 18/8 23/2 17/20 18/2 18/6 18/8 23/2 17/20 18/2 18/6 18/8 23/2 25/17 26/18 27/23 28/2 25/17 26/18 27/23 28/2 25/17 26/18 27/23 28/2 25/17 26/18 27/23 28/2 28/13 31/21 40/5 40/24 28/13 31/21 40/5 40/24 28/13 31/21 40/5 40/24 28/13 31/21 40/5 40/24seems [1] seems [1] seems [1] seems [1] 30/2 30/2 30/2 30/2seen [7] seen [7] seen [7] seen [7] 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 22/17 23/25 24/10 24/14 24/24 32/16 24/10 24/14 24/24 32/16 24/10 24/14 24/24 32/16 24/10 24/14 24/24 32/16 33/20 33/20 33/20 33/20select [1] select [1] select [1] select [1] 13/18 13/18 13/18 13/18selected [1] selected [1] selected [1] selected [1] 11/8 11/8 11/8 11/8selection [3] selection [3] selection [3] selection [3] 11/10 11/13 11/10 11/13 11/10 11/13 11/10 11/13 12/22 12/22 12/22 12/22SELLS [2] SELLS [2] SELLS [2] SELLS [2] 2/4 4/10 2/4 4/10 2/4 4/10 2/4 4/10Senate [20] Senate [20] Senate [20] Senate [20] 13/8 14/16 13/8 14/16 13/8 14/16 13/8 14/16 32/3 32/4 32/8 35/1 35/1 32/3 32/4 32/8 35/1 35/1 32/3 32/4 32/8 35/1 35/1 32/3 32/4 32/8 35/1 35/1 37/22 38/14 38/23 40/16 37/22 38/14 38/23 40/16 37/22 38/14 38/23 40/16 37/22 38/14 38/23 40/16 40/17 40/22 41/13 41/23 40/17 40/22 41/13 41/23 40/17 40/22 41/13 41/23 40/17 40/22 41/13 41/23 42/5 44/14 44/18 44/18 42/5 44/14 44/18 44/18 42/5 44/14 44/18 44/18 42/5 44/14 44/18 44/18 44/19 44/19 44/19 44/19Senator [3] Senator [3] Senator [3] Senator [3] 32/25 35/4 32/25 35/4 32/25 35/4 32/25 35/4 35/7 35/7 35/7 35/7send [1] send [1] send [1] send [1] 9/5 9/5 9/5 9/5sentence [4] sentence [4] sentence [4] sentence [4] 40/19 40/19 40/19 40/19 40/19 40/19 40/19 40/19 41/7 41/11 41/7 41/11 41/7 41/11 41/7 41/11SESSION [1] SESSION [1] SESSION [1] SESSION [1] 1/12 1/12 1/12 1/12set [4] set [4] set [4] set [4] 10/10 20/6 27/22 10/10 20/6 27/22 10/10 20/6 27/22 10/10 20/6 27/22 41/15 41/15 41/15 41/15setting [4] setting [4] setting [4] setting [4] 5/21 18/4 5/21 18/4 5/21 18/4 5/21 18/4 18/10 18/12 18/10 18/12 18/10 18/12 18/10 18/12seven [3] seven [3] seven [3] seven [3] 1/7 26/18 28/2 1/7 26/18 28/2 1/7 26/18 28/2 1/7 26/18 28/2she [10] she [10] she [10] she [10] 35/25 36/3 36/12 35/25 36/3 36/12 35/25 36/3 36/12 35/25 36/3 36/12 42/4 42/6 42/7 42/8 42/10 42/4 42/6 42/7 42/8 42/10 42/4 42/6 42/7 42/8 42/10 42/4 42/6 42/7 42/8 42/10 42/13 45/7 42/13 45/7 42/13 45/7 42/13 45/7she's [3] she's [3] she's [3] she's [3] 41/21 41/21 41/21 41/21 41/21 41/21 41/21 41/21 41/23 41/23 41/23 41/23short [2] short [2] short [2] short [2] 9/12 28/24 9/12 28/24 9/12 28/24 9/12 28/24shorthand [1] shorthand [1] shorthand [1] shorthand [1] 3/10 3/10 3/10 3/10should [5] should [5] should [5] should [5] 19/23 19/25 19/23 19/25 19/23 19/25 19/23 19/25 37/5 39/21 41/25 37/5 39/21 41/25 37/5 39/21 41/25 37/5 39/21 41/25shouldn't [1] shouldn't [1] shouldn't [1] shouldn't [1] 28/1 28/1 28/1 28/1show [4] show [4] show [4] show [4] 22/19 25/14 22/19 25/14 22/19 25/14 22/19 25/14 25/15 29/7 25/15 29/7 25/15 29/7 25/15 29/7showed [1] showed [1] showed [1] showed [1] 38/15 38/15 38/15 38/15showing [1] showing [1] showing [1] showing [1] 10/5 10/5 10/5 10/5shown [1] shown [1] shown [1] shown [1] 34/17 34/17 34/17 34/17shows [2] shows [2] shows [2] shows [2] 18/17 41/22 18/17 41/22 18/17 41/22 18/17 41/22signal [1] signal [1] signal [1] signal [1] 9/5 9/5 9/5 9/5

significant [1] significant [1] significant [1] significant [1] 30/6 30/6 30/6 30/6silence [1] silence [1] silence [1] silence [1] 42/1 42/1 42/1 42/1similar [1] similar [1] similar [1] similar [1] 44/12 44/12 44/12 44/12simple [1] simple [1] simple [1] simple [1] 19/14 19/14 19/14 19/14simplify [1] simplify [1] simplify [1] simplify [1] 28/12 28/12 28/12 28/12simply [1] simply [1] simply [1] simply [1] 20/23 20/23 20/23 20/23since [2] since [2] since [2] since [2] 8/22 34/20 8/22 34/20 8/22 34/20 8/22 34/20single [4] single [4] single [4] single [4] 10/17 27/21 10/17 27/21 10/17 27/21 10/17 27/21 28/7 41/15 28/7 41/15 28/7 41/15 28/7 41/15sir [4] sir [4] sir [4] sir [4] 4/15 21/15 44/23 4/15 21/15 44/23 4/15 21/15 44/23 4/15 21/15 44/23 44/24 44/24 44/24 44/24sit [1] sit [1] sit [1] sit [1] 4/14 4/14 4/14 4/14six [1] six [1] six [1] six [1] 26/18 26/18 26/18 26/18skew [1] skew [1] skew [1] skew [1] 15/11 15/11 15/11 15/11slight [1] slight [1] slight [1] slight [1] 13/10 13/10 13/10 13/10small [3] small [3] small [3] small [3] 20/23 35/22 20/23 35/22 20/23 35/22 20/23 35/22 35/23 35/23 35/23 35/23so [49] so [49] so [49] so [49] social [2] social [2] social [2] social [2] 16/1 26/8 16/1 26/8 16/1 26/8 16/1 26/8sole [2] sole [2] sole [2] sole [2] 18/8 20/19 18/8 20/19 18/8 20/19 18/8 20/19Soledad [1] Soledad [1] Soledad [1] Soledad [1] 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5some [13] some [13] some [13] some [13] 6/14 6/17 13/15 6/14 6/17 13/15 6/14 6/17 13/15 6/14 6/17 13/15 14/16 24/1 26/13 30/6 14/16 24/1 26/13 30/6 14/16 24/1 26/13 30/6 14/16 24/1 26/13 30/6 36/13 40/5 40/6 43/12 36/13 40/5 40/6 43/12 36/13 40/5 40/6 43/12 36/13 40/5 40/6 43/12 45/7 45/8 45/7 45/8 45/7 45/8 45/7 45/8Somervelle [1] Somervelle [1] Somervelle [1] Somervelle [1] 2/18 2/18 2/18 2/18something [11] something [11] something [11] something [11] 8/14 11/9 8/14 11/9 8/14 11/9 8/14 11/9 11/9 26/19 30/10 30/11 11/9 26/19 30/10 30/11 11/9 26/19 30/10 30/11 11/9 26/19 30/10 30/11 33/19 35/20 37/24 38/6 33/19 35/20 37/24 38/6 33/19 35/20 37/24 38/6 33/19 35/20 37/24 38/6 42/11 42/11 42/11 42/11sorry [9] sorry [9] sorry [9] sorry [9] 4/13 9/19 17/23 4/13 9/19 17/23 4/13 9/19 17/23 4/13 9/19 17/23 25/21 29/6 33/19 35/11 25/21 29/6 33/19 35/11 25/21 29/6 33/19 35/11 25/21 29/6 33/19 35/11 40/12 44/3 40/12 44/3 40/12 44/3 40/12 44/3sort [1] sort [1] sort [1] sort [1] 12/23 12/23 12/23 12/23sounds [1] sounds [1] sounds [1] sounds [1] 19/3 19/3 19/3 19/3South [1] South [1] South [1] South [1] 21/2 21/2 21/2 21/2span [1] span [1] span [1] span [1] 10/12 10/12 10/12 10/12speculate [1] speculate [1] speculate [1] speculate [1] 42/11 42/11 42/11 42/11spend [1] spend [1] spend [1] spend [1] 7/12 7/12 7/12 7/12spent [2] spent [2] spent [2] spent [2] 15/23 39/1 15/23 39/1 15/23 39/1 15/23 39/1split [1] split [1] split [1] split [1] 12/17 12/17 12/17 12/17STACEY [2] STACEY [2] STACEY [2] STACEY [2] 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7 1/23 4/7stand [7] stand [7] stand [7] stand [7] 8/18 8/19 9/3 8/18 8/19 9/3 8/18 8/19 9/3 8/18 8/19 9/3 11/5 24/10 45/1 45/1 11/5 24/10 45/1 45/1 11/5 24/10 45/1 45/1 11/5 24/10 45/1 45/1standard [3] standard [3] standard [3] standard [3] 20/10 20/13 20/10 20/13 20/10 20/13 20/10 20/13 26/9 26/9 26/9 26/9start [2] start [2] start [2] start [2] 13/16 13/16 13/16 13/16 13/16 13/16 13/16 13/16starts [2] starts [2] starts [2] starts [2] 8/12 40/15 8/12 40/15 8/12 40/15 8/12 40/15state [8] state [8] state [8] state [8] 1/3 4/4 7/18 1/3 4/4 7/18 1/3 4/4 7/18 1/3 4/4 7/18 14/19 15/21 18/11 21/12 14/19 15/21 18/11 21/12 14/19 15/21 18/11 21/12 14/19 15/21 18/11 21/12 28/8 28/8 28/8 28/8State's [5] State's [5] State's [5] State's [5] 17/2 17/12 17/2 17/12 17/2 17/12 17/2 17/12 17/13 18/9 19/22 17/13 18/9 19/22 17/13 18/9 19/22 17/13 18/9 19/22stated [4] stated [4] stated [4] stated [4] 11/3 22/9 37/4 11/3 22/9 37/4 11/3 22/9 37/4 11/3 22/9 37/4 47/6 47/6 47/6 47/6statement [3] statement [3] statement [3] statement [3] 24/10 34/19 24/10 34/19 24/10 34/19 24/10 34/19 36/17 36/17 36/17 36/17statements [1] statements [1] statements [1] statements [1] 6/18 6/18 6/18 6/18states [9] states [9] states [9] states [9] 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/14 3/8 4/4 36/18 37/9 1/14 3/8 4/4 36/18 37/9 1/14 3/8 4/4 36/18 37/9 1/14 3/8 4/4 36/18 37/9 47/4 47/4 47/4 47/4statewide [11] statewide [11] statewide [11] statewide [11] 10/20 10/20 10/20 10/20 10/24 10/25 11/2 14/10 10/24 10/25 11/2 14/10 10/24 10/25 11/2 14/10 10/24 10/25 11/2 14/10 15/1 15/3 21/25 23/7 44/3 15/1 15/3 21/25 23/7 44/3 15/1 15/3 21/25 23/7 44/3 15/1 15/3 21/25 23/7 44/3 44/10 44/10 44/10 44/10stenographic [1] stenographic [1] stenographic [1] stenographic [1] 47/4 47/4 47/4 47/4still [4] still [4] still [4] still [4] 18/13 34/2 18/13 34/2 18/13 34/2 18/13 34/2 44/17 44/19 44/17 44/19 44/17 44/19 44/17 44/19stop [1] stop [1] stop [1] stop [1] 8/14 8/14 8/14 8/14stopped [2] stopped [2] stopped [2] stopped [2] 14/10 16/19 14/10 16/19 14/10 16/19 14/10 16/19straight [1] straight [1] straight [1] straight [1] 24/13 24/13 24/13 24/13

56565656

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 56 of 59

Page 57: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

SSSSstraightened [1] straightened [1] straightened [1] straightened [1] 24/25 24/25 24/25 24/25Street [3] Street [3] Street [3] Street [3] 1/20 2/15 2/18 1/20 2/15 2/18 1/20 2/15 2/18 1/20 2/15 2/18strengths [1] strengths [1] strengths [1] strengths [1] 39/14 39/14 39/14 39/14stronger [1] stronger [1] stronger [1] stronger [1] 6/10 6/10 6/10 6/10strongly [1] strongly [1] strongly [1] strongly [1] 44/15 44/15 44/15 44/15study [7] study [7] study [7] study [7] 9/18 36/4 36/10 9/18 36/4 36/10 9/18 36/4 36/10 9/18 36/4 36/10 38/23 39/2 39/4 39/5 38/23 39/2 39/4 39/5 38/23 39/2 39/4 39/5 38/23 39/2 39/4 39/5studying [1] studying [1] studying [1] studying [1] 13/2 13/2 13/2 13/2stuff [1] stuff [1] stuff [1] stuff [1] 5/14 5/14 5/14 5/14such [2] such [2] such [2] such [2] 5/13 19/11 5/13 19/11 5/13 19/11 5/13 19/11suggest [1] suggest [1] suggest [1] suggest [1] 24/6 24/6 24/6 24/6suggests [2] suggests [2] suggests [2] suggests [2] 41/12 41/23 41/12 41/23 41/12 41/23 41/12 41/23Suite [5] Suite [5] Suite [5] Suite [5] 2/10 2/16 2/19 2/10 2/16 2/19 2/10 2/16 2/19 2/10 2/16 2/19 2/22 3/5 2/22 3/5 2/22 3/5 2/22 3/5sum [1] sum [1] sum [1] sum [1] 6/15 6/15 6/15 6/15summarized [1] summarized [1] summarized [1] summarized [1] 44/1 44/1 44/1 44/1summary [1] summary [1] summary [1] summary [1] 22/12 22/12 22/12 22/12Sunday [1] Sunday [1] Sunday [1] Sunday [1] 24/16 24/16 24/16 24/16superior [2] superior [2] superior [2] superior [2] 37/16 37/17 37/16 37/17 37/16 37/17 37/16 37/17supplemented [1] supplemented [1] supplemented [1] supplemented [1] 22/25 22/25 22/25 22/25Supreme [6] Supreme [6] Supreme [6] Supreme [6] 11/20 11/25 11/20 11/25 11/20 11/25 11/20 11/25 12/11 12/13 12/14 15/4 12/11 12/13 12/14 15/4 12/11 12/13 12/14 15/4 12/11 12/13 12/14 15/4sure [10] sure [10] sure [10] sure [10] 6/9 8/1 12/17 6/9 8/1 12/17 6/9 8/1 12/17 6/9 8/1 12/17 15/18 18/19 19/16 20/6 15/18 18/19 19/16 20/6 15/18 18/19 19/16 20/6 15/18 18/19 19/16 20/6 20/22 26/7 43/14 20/22 26/7 43/14 20/22 26/7 43/14 20/22 26/7 43/14surely [1] surely [1] surely [1] surely [1] 33/21 33/21 33/21 33/21survey [3] survey [3] survey [3] survey [3] 28/22 28/24 28/22 28/24 28/22 28/24 28/22 28/24 28/25 28/25 28/25 28/25swore [1] swore [1] swore [1] swore [1] 9/2 9/2 9/2 9/2sworn [4] sworn [4] sworn [4] sworn [4] 8/21 8/25 9/3 8/21 8/25 9/3 8/21 8/25 9/3 8/21 8/25 9/3 9/10 9/10 9/10 9/10

TTTTtable [9] table [9] table [9] table [9] 9/22 10/7 25/13 9/22 10/7 25/13 9/22 10/7 25/13 9/22 10/7 25/13 27/12 30/13 43/14 43/15 27/12 30/13 43/14 43/15 27/12 30/13 43/14 43/15 27/12 30/13 43/14 43/15 43/17 43/18 43/17 43/18 43/17 43/18 43/17 43/18tables [1] tables [1] tables [1] tables [1] 45/5 45/5 45/5 45/5take [3] take [3] take [3] take [3] 39/13 43/1 44/6 39/13 43/1 44/6 39/13 43/1 44/6 39/13 43/1 44/6taken [3] taken [3] taken [3] taken [3] 7/3 47/5 47/9 7/3 47/5 47/9 7/3 47/5 47/9 7/3 47/5 47/9taking [1] taking [1] taking [1] taking [1] 45/3 45/3 45/3 45/3talk [3] talk [3] talk [3] talk [3] 10/3 19/20 29/23 10/3 19/20 29/23 10/3 19/20 29/23 10/3 19/20 29/23talked [2] talked [2] talked [2] talked [2] 16/24 39/12 16/24 39/12 16/24 39/12 16/24 39/12talking [4] talking [4] talking [4] talking [4] 12/20 30/15 12/20 30/15 12/20 30/15 12/20 30/15 31/14 36/23 31/14 36/23 31/14 36/23 31/14 36/23TANNER [2] TANNER [2] TANNER [2] TANNER [2] 2/6 4/12 2/6 4/12 2/6 4/12 2/6 4/12tell [3] tell [3] tell [3] tell [3] 9/2 28/21 38/8 9/2 28/21 38/8 9/2 28/21 38/8 9/2 28/21 38/8tells [1] tells [1] tells [1] tells [1] 38/6 38/6 38/6 38/6ten [11] ten [11] ten [11] ten [11] 8/23 11/4 11/7 8/23 11/4 11/7 8/23 11/4 11/7 8/23 11/4 11/7 15/17 16/13 16/18 16/19 15/17 16/13 16/18 16/19 15/17 16/13 16/18 16/19 15/17 16/13 16/18 16/19 28/4 29/1 30/13 39/21 28/4 29/1 30/13 39/21 28/4 29/1 30/13 39/21 28/4 29/1 30/13 39/21tens [1] tens [1] tens [1] tens [1] 29/10 29/10 29/10 29/10tenths [1] tenths [1] tenths [1] tenths [1] 33/3 33/3 33/3 33/3term [3] term [3] term [3] term [3] 31/3 33/12 33/20 31/3 33/12 33/20 31/3 33/12 33/20 31/3 33/12 33/20terminology [2] terminology [2] terminology [2] terminology [2] 31/9 31/9 31/9 31/9 31/9 31/9 31/9 31/9terms [1] terms [1] terms [1] terms [1] 34/1 34/1 34/1 34/1test [7] test [7] test [7] test [7] 17/9 19/25 20/6 17/9 19/25 20/6 17/9 19/25 20/6 17/9 19/25 20/6 20/9 29/23 29/24 30/3 20/9 29/23 29/24 30/3 20/9 29/23 29/24 30/3 20/9 29/23 29/24 30/3testified [6] testified [6] testified [6] testified [6] 5/9 5/11 5/9 5/11 5/9 5/11 5/9 5/11 15/22 16/1 17/2 26/6 15/22 16/1 17/2 26/6 15/22 16/1 17/2 26/6 15/22 16/1 17/2 26/6testify [1] testify [1] testify [1] testify [1] 9/4 9/4 9/4 9/4testimony [11] testimony [11] testimony [11] testimony [11] 5/13 21/3 5/13 21/3 5/13 21/3 5/13 21/3 21/4 22/9 22/22 22/25 21/4 22/9 22/22 22/25 21/4 22/9 22/22 22/25 21/4 22/9 22/22 22/25 25/14 36/18 40/11 41/3 25/14 36/18 40/11 41/3 25/14 36/18 40/11 41/3 25/14 36/18 40/11 41/3 44/13 44/13 44/13 44/13tests [2] tests [2] tests [2] tests [2] 30/5 30/9 30/5 30/9 30/5 30/9 30/5 30/9TEXAS [22] TEXAS [22] TEXAS [22] TEXAS [22] 1/3 1/24 2/22 1/3 1/24 2/22 1/3 1/24 2/22 1/3 1/24 2/22 4/4 7/19 10/21 14/12 15/1 4/4 7/19 10/21 14/12 15/1 4/4 7/19 10/21 14/12 15/1 4/4 7/19 10/21 14/12 15/1 19/23 21/3 22/11 22/14 19/23 21/3 22/11 22/14 19/23 21/3 22/11 22/14 19/23 21/3 22/11 22/14 22/15 24/12 29/3 29/8 22/15 24/12 29/3 29/8 22/15 24/12 29/3 29/8 22/15 24/12 29/3 29/8

31/20 31/21 43/19 43/23 31/20 31/21 43/19 43/23 31/20 31/21 43/19 43/23 31/20 31/21 43/19 43/23 44/2 44/14 44/2 44/14 44/2 44/14 44/2 44/14Texas' [1] Texas' [1] Texas' [1] Texas' [1] 13/16 13/16 13/16 13/16text [2] text [2] text [2] text [2] 19/4 40/17 19/4 40/17 19/4 40/17 19/4 40/17than [15] than [15] than [15] than [15] 7/23 11/4 12/25 7/23 11/4 12/25 7/23 11/4 12/25 7/23 11/4 12/25 15/14 15/16 15/18 18/16 15/14 15/16 15/18 18/16 15/14 15/16 15/18 18/16 15/14 15/16 15/18 18/16 28/11 29/11 33/3 33/13 28/11 29/11 33/3 33/13 28/11 29/11 33/3 33/13 28/11 29/11 33/3 33/13 34/1 34/1 36/13 40/7 34/1 34/1 36/13 40/7 34/1 34/1 36/13 40/7 34/1 34/1 36/13 40/7thank [25] thank [25] thank [25] thank [25] 7/20 8/5 8/7 7/20 8/5 8/7 7/20 8/5 8/7 7/20 8/5 8/7 9/25 11/12 14/6 14/24 9/25 11/12 14/6 14/24 9/25 11/12 14/6 14/24 9/25 11/12 14/6 14/24 15/7 16/22 19/18 21/15 15/7 16/22 19/18 21/15 15/7 16/22 19/18 21/15 15/7 16/22 19/18 21/15 25/2 25/20 28/18 30/20 25/2 25/20 28/18 30/20 25/2 25/20 28/18 30/20 25/2 25/20 28/18 30/20 30/21 32/23 39/22 40/14 30/21 32/23 39/22 40/14 30/21 32/23 39/22 40/14 30/21 32/23 39/22 40/14 42/15 42/17 44/20 44/21 42/15 42/17 44/20 44/21 42/15 42/17 44/20 44/21 42/15 42/17 44/20 44/21 44/23 44/24 44/23 44/24 44/23 44/24 44/23 44/24that [277] that [277] that [277] that [277] that's [46] that's [46] that's [46] that's [46] 5/21 6/25 7/8 5/21 6/25 7/8 5/21 6/25 7/8 5/21 6/25 7/8 7/14 8/6 10/14 10/22 7/14 8/6 10/14 10/22 7/14 8/6 10/14 10/22 7/14 8/6 10/14 10/22 11/15 13/20 14/3 18/20 11/15 13/20 14/3 18/20 11/15 13/20 14/3 18/20 11/15 13/20 14/3 18/20 18/21 18/24 18/24 19/4 18/21 18/24 18/24 19/4 18/21 18/24 18/24 19/4 18/21 18/24 18/24 19/4 19/6 19/7 19/13 20/3 19/6 19/7 19/13 20/3 19/6 19/7 19/13 20/3 19/6 19/7 19/13 20/3 20/21 23/6 23/9 23/13 20/21 23/6 23/9 23/13 20/21 23/6 23/9 23/13 20/21 23/6 23/9 23/13 23/20 24/7 26/5 26/12 23/20 24/7 26/5 26/12 23/20 24/7 26/5 26/12 23/20 24/7 26/5 26/12 26/24 28/2 28/6 28/9 26/24 28/2 28/6 28/9 26/24 28/2 28/6 28/9 26/24 28/2 28/6 28/9 28/18 29/24 30/7 30/12 28/18 29/24 30/7 30/12 28/18 29/24 30/7 30/12 28/18 29/24 30/7 30/12 30/15 32/4 32/7 33/23 30/15 32/4 32/7 33/23 30/15 32/4 32/7 33/23 30/15 32/4 32/7 33/23 34/6 36/8 39/18 40/2 34/6 36/8 39/18 40/2 34/6 36/8 39/18 40/2 34/6 36/8 39/18 40/2 42/11 43/17 44/4 42/11 43/17 44/4 42/11 43/17 44/4 42/11 43/17 44/4their [14] their [14] their [14] their [14] 4/22 5/3 5/6 4/22 5/3 5/6 4/22 5/3 5/6 4/22 5/3 5/6 6/11 21/21 29/21 32/25 6/11 21/21 29/21 32/25 6/11 21/21 29/21 32/25 6/11 21/21 29/21 32/25 33/4 33/7 38/9 38/13 40/1 33/4 33/7 38/9 38/13 40/1 33/4 33/7 38/9 38/13 40/1 33/4 33/7 38/9 38/13 40/1 42/2 43/25 42/2 43/25 42/2 43/25 42/2 43/25them [4] them [4] them [4] them [4] 23/25 25/25 30/6 23/25 25/25 30/6 23/25 25/25 30/6 23/25 25/25 30/6 37/19 37/19 37/19 37/19then [12] then [12] then [12] then [12] 10/18 13/8 14/7 10/18 13/8 14/7 10/18 13/8 14/7 10/18 13/8 14/7 14/16 18/24 19/6 20/14 14/16 18/24 19/6 20/14 14/16 18/24 19/6 20/14 14/16 18/24 19/6 20/14 25/24 27/25 29/17 42/6 25/24 27/25 29/17 42/6 25/24 27/25 29/17 42/6 25/24 27/25 29/17 42/6 44/6 44/6 44/6 44/6there [32] there [32] there [32] there [32] 12/2 12/3 12/9 12/2 12/3 12/9 12/2 12/3 12/9 12/2 12/3 12/9 15/21 17/20 18/2 19/11 15/21 17/20 18/2 19/11 15/21 17/20 18/2 19/11 15/21 17/20 18/2 19/11 22/5 22/8 23/4 23/16 22/5 22/8 23/4 23/16 22/5 22/8 23/4 23/16 22/5 22/8 23/4 23/16 23/16 27/6 28/24 33/21 23/16 27/6 28/24 33/21 23/16 27/6 28/24 33/21 23/16 27/6 28/24 33/21 33/25 33/25 34/8 34/10 33/25 33/25 34/8 34/10 33/25 33/25 34/8 34/10 33/25 33/25 34/8 34/10 35/16 35/25 37/24 37/25 35/16 35/25 37/24 37/25 35/16 35/25 37/24 37/25 35/16 35/25 37/24 37/25 38/2 38/2 38/17 39/8 40/5 38/2 38/2 38/17 39/8 40/5 38/2 38/2 38/17 39/8 40/5 38/2 38/2 38/17 39/8 40/5 41/13 42/8 42/18 42/20 41/13 42/8 42/18 42/20 41/13 42/8 42/18 42/20 41/13 42/8 42/18 42/20there's [15] there's [15] there's [15] there's [15] 5/5 10/17 5/5 10/17 5/5 10/17 5/5 10/17 13/14 14/10 22/10 23/21 13/14 14/10 22/10 23/21 13/14 14/10 22/10 23/21 13/14 14/10 22/10 23/21 24/11 26/13 26/18 27/2 24/11 26/13 26/18 27/2 24/11 26/13 26/18 27/2 24/11 26/13 26/18 27/2 27/7 28/24 33/14 38/2 27/7 28/24 33/14 38/2 27/7 28/24 33/14 38/2 27/7 28/24 33/14 38/2 41/19 41/19 41/19 41/19therefore [2] therefore [2] therefore [2] therefore [2] 6/23 38/18 6/23 38/18 6/23 38/18 6/23 38/18these [15] these [15] these [15] these [15] 10/20 12/7 10/20 12/7 10/20 12/7 10/20 12/7 12/9 12/22 15/15 15/21 12/9 12/22 15/15 15/21 12/9 12/22 15/15 15/21 12/9 12/22 15/15 15/21 16/13 23/3 23/7 27/1 27/2 16/13 23/3 23/7 27/1 27/2 16/13 23/3 23/7 27/1 27/2 16/13 23/3 23/7 27/1 27/2 27/3 27/4 27/16 44/1 27/3 27/4 27/16 44/1 27/3 27/4 27/16 44/1 27/3 27/4 27/16 44/1they [23] they [23] they [23] they [23] 4/23 6/14 9/3 4/23 6/14 9/3 4/23 6/14 9/3 4/23 6/14 9/3 10/12 10/15 15/16 16/18 10/12 10/15 15/16 16/18 10/12 10/15 15/16 16/18 10/12 10/15 15/16 16/18 16/19 17/12 18/12 27/3 16/19 17/12 18/12 27/3 16/19 17/12 18/12 27/3 16/19 17/12 18/12 27/3 27/14 30/10 33/20 34/18 27/14 30/10 33/20 34/18 27/14 30/10 33/20 34/18 27/14 30/10 33/20 34/18 34/20 37/21 38/6 38/8 34/20 37/21 38/6 38/8 34/20 37/21 38/6 38/8 34/20 37/21 38/6 38/8 38/15 38/16 42/2 42/2 38/15 38/16 42/2 42/2 38/15 38/16 42/2 42/2 38/15 38/16 42/2 42/2they're [1] they're [1] they're [1] they're [1] 6/2 6/2 6/2 6/2they've [1] they've [1] they've [1] they've [1] 5/8 5/8 5/8 5/8thing [3] thing [3] thing [3] thing [3] 5/23 34/6 40/4 5/23 34/6 40/4 5/23 34/6 40/4 5/23 34/6 40/4things [7] things [7] things [7] things [7] 6/9 6/24 31/8 6/9 6/24 31/8 6/9 6/24 31/8 6/9 6/24 31/8 38/24 42/2 45/5 45/9 38/24 42/2 45/5 45/9 38/24 42/2 45/5 45/9 38/24 42/2 45/5 45/9think [31] think [31] think [31] think [31] 5/4 15/15 5/4 15/15 5/4 15/15 5/4 15/15 18/10 18/21 19/3 19/6 18/10 18/21 19/3 19/6 18/10 18/21 19/3 19/6 18/10 18/21 19/3 19/6 19/13 19/15 22/9 24/1 19/13 19/15 22/9 24/1 19/13 19/15 22/9 24/1 19/13 19/15 22/9 24/1 24/7 24/25 26/6 30/18 24/7 24/25 26/6 30/18 24/7 24/25 26/6 30/18 24/7 24/25 26/6 30/18

31/10 32/1 33/16 34/6 31/10 32/1 33/16 34/6 31/10 32/1 33/16 34/6 31/10 32/1 33/16 34/6 34/12 34/13 36/9 39/7 34/12 34/13 36/9 39/7 34/12 34/13 36/9 39/7 34/12 34/13 36/9 39/7 39/18 40/2 40/4 40/6 39/18 40/2 40/4 40/6 39/18 40/2 40/4 40/6 39/18 40/2 40/4 40/6 41/10 41/11 42/12 42/21 41/10 41/11 42/12 42/21 41/10 41/11 42/12 42/21 41/10 41/11 42/12 42/21 43/11 43/11 43/11 43/11Thirteenth [1] Thirteenth [1] Thirteenth [1] Thirteenth [1] 2/15 2/15 2/15 2/15this [62] this [62] this [62] this [62] those [9] those [9] those [9] those [9] 6/11 12/1 17/11 6/11 12/1 17/11 6/11 12/1 17/11 6/11 12/1 17/11 26/2 29/19 31/23 34/14 26/2 29/19 31/23 34/14 26/2 29/19 31/23 34/14 26/2 29/19 31/23 34/14 37/1 44/13 37/1 44/13 37/1 44/13 37/1 44/13though [2] though [2] though [2] though [2] 21/24 36/2 21/24 36/2 21/24 36/2 21/24 36/2thought [13] thought [13] thought [13] thought [13] 5/11 5/12 5/11 5/12 5/11 5/12 5/11 5/12 5/12 5/17 5/21 8/20 9/13 5/12 5/17 5/21 8/20 9/13 5/12 5/17 5/21 8/20 9/13 5/12 5/17 5/21 8/20 9/13 17/3 19/15 24/23 38/15 17/3 19/15 24/23 38/15 17/3 19/15 24/23 38/15 17/3 19/15 24/23 38/15 42/2 42/2 42/2 42/2 42/2 42/2 42/2 42/2thousand [1] thousand [1] thousand [1] thousand [1] 8/2 8/2 8/2 8/2thousands [3] thousands [3] thousands [3] thousands [3] 8/1 29/10 8/1 29/10 8/1 29/10 8/1 29/10 29/25 29/25 29/25 29/25three [6] three [6] three [6] three [6] 11/24 12/2 15/9 11/24 12/2 15/9 11/24 12/2 15/9 11/24 12/2 15/9 15/10 16/10 43/19 15/10 16/10 43/19 15/10 16/10 43/19 15/10 16/10 43/19through [2] through [2] through [2] through [2] 24/18 41/9 24/18 41/9 24/18 41/9 24/18 41/9throughout [1] throughout [1] throughout [1] throughout [1] 29/12 29/12 29/12 29/12Thursday [1] Thursday [1] Thursday [1] Thursday [1] 6/4 6/4 6/4 6/4time [13] time [13] time [13] time [13] 7/2 7/12 8/9 7/2 7/12 8/9 7/2 7/12 8/9 7/2 7/12 8/9 8/10 8/15 9/3 15/23 16/16 8/10 8/15 9/3 15/23 16/16 8/10 8/15 9/3 15/23 16/16 8/10 8/15 9/3 15/23 16/16 18/16 20/25 30/20 39/24 18/16 20/25 30/20 39/24 18/16 20/25 30/20 39/24 18/16 20/25 30/20 39/24 47/5 47/5 47/5 47/5times [2] times [2] times [2] times [2] 28/2 28/4 28/2 28/4 28/2 28/4 28/2 28/4TIMOTHY [2] TIMOTHY [2] TIMOTHY [2] TIMOTHY [2] 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9 2/3 4/9today [4] today [4] today [4] today [4] 6/14 8/9 8/11 6/14 8/9 8/11 6/14 8/9 8/11 6/14 8/9 8/11 45/3 45/3 45/3 45/3together [1] together [1] together [1] together [1] 37/11 37/11 37/11 37/11too [1] too [1] too [1] too [1] 28/1 28/1 28/1 28/1took [2] took [2] took [2] took [2] 5/25 18/4 5/25 18/4 5/25 18/4 5/25 18/4top [3] top [3] top [3] top [3] 12/6 13/7 13/25 12/6 13/7 13/25 12/6 13/7 13/25 12/6 13/7 13/25topic [1] topic [1] topic [1] topic [1] 43/10 43/10 43/10 43/10totaled [1] totaled [1] totaled [1] totaled [1] 27/5 27/5 27/5 27/5towards [1] towards [1] towards [1] towards [1] 15/11 15/11 15/11 15/11Towers [1] Towers [1] Towers [1] Towers [1] 3/4 3/4 3/4 3/4transcript [4] transcript [4] transcript [4] transcript [4] 1/12 3/10 1/12 3/10 1/12 3/10 1/12 3/10 7/25 47/3 7/25 47/3 7/25 47/3 7/25 47/3transcription [1] transcription [1] transcription [1] transcription [1] 3/11 3/11 3/11 3/11transcripts [3] transcripts [3] transcripts [3] transcripts [3] 4/21 5/2 4/21 5/2 4/21 5/2 4/21 5/2 6/16 6/16 6/16 6/16Travis [4] Travis [4] Travis [4] Travis [4] 23/11 23/14 23/11 23/14 23/11 23/14 23/11 23/14 23/16 23/19 23/16 23/19 23/16 23/19 23/16 23/19trial [12] trial [12] trial [12] trial [12] 1/12 4/22 5/3 1/12 4/22 5/3 1/12 4/22 5/3 1/12 4/22 5/3 5/15 7/3 7/4 7/5 7/5 7/8 5/15 7/3 7/4 7/5 7/5 7/8 5/15 7/3 7/4 7/5 7/5 7/8 5/15 7/3 7/4 7/5 7/5 7/8 9/3 9/15 21/3 9/3 9/15 21/3 9/3 9/15 21/3 9/3 9/15 21/3trials [1] trials [1] trials [1] trials [1] 9/1 9/1 9/1 9/1true [11] true [11] true [11] true [11] 7/15 37/22 7/15 37/22 7/15 37/22 7/15 37/22 39/13 39/15 42/5 44/4 39/13 39/15 42/5 44/4 39/13 39/15 42/5 44/4 39/13 39/15 42/5 44/4 44/15 44/17 44/18 44/19 44/15 44/17 44/18 44/19 44/15 44/17 44/18 44/19 44/15 44/17 44/18 44/19 47/2 47/2 47/2 47/2truth [1] truth [1] truth [1] truth [1] 9/2 9/2 9/2 9/2try [1] try [1] try [1] try [1] 31/8 31/8 31/8 31/8trying [4] trying [4] trying [4] trying [4] 24/5 28/11 24/5 28/11 24/5 28/11 24/5 28/11 32/7 41/9 32/7 41/9 32/7 41/9 32/7 41/9turn [2] turn [2] turn [2] turn [2] 36/4 36/6 36/4 36/6 36/4 36/6 36/4 36/6turned [4] turned [4] turned [4] turned [4] 36/10 36/14 36/10 36/14 36/10 36/14 36/10 36/14 36/15 36/15 36/15 36/15 36/15 36/15 36/15 36/15TV [1] TV [1] TV [1] TV [1] 26/16 26/16 26/16 26/16two [6] two [6] two [6] two [6] 11/24 15/10 29/3 11/24 15/10 29/3 11/24 15/10 29/3 11/24 15/10 29/3 37/9 37/24 37/25 37/9 37/24 37/25 37/9 37/24 37/25 37/9 37/24 37/25TX [4] TX [4] TX [4] TX [4] 1/25 2/11 2/13 3/5 1/25 2/11 2/13 3/5 1/25 2/11 2/13 3/5 1/25 2/11 2/13 3/5typically [1] typically [1] typically [1] typically [1] 12/24 12/24 12/24 12/24

UUUUU.S [4] U.S [4] U.S [4] U.S [4] 2/4 13/8 14/7 2/4 13/8 14/7 2/4 13/8 14/7 2/4 13/8 14/7 28/23 28/23 28/23 28/23Uh [1] Uh [1] Uh [1] Uh [1] 17/16 17/16 17/16 17/16

57575757

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 57 of 59

Page 58: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

UUUUUh-hmm [1] Uh-hmm [1] Uh-hmm [1] Uh-hmm [1] 17/16 17/16 17/16 17/16Ultimately [1] Ultimately [1] Ultimately [1] Ultimately [1] 29/15 29/15 29/15 29/15unaware [1] unaware [1] unaware [1] unaware [1] 5/24 5/24 5/24 5/24unawares [1] unawares [1] unawares [1] unawares [1] 5/21 5/21 5/21 5/21under [8] under [8] under [8] under [8] 11/23 12/9 11/23 12/9 11/23 12/9 11/23 12/9 19/24 34/14 36/20 37/1 19/24 34/14 36/20 37/1 19/24 34/14 36/20 37/1 19/24 34/14 36/20 37/1 43/19 44/10 43/19 44/10 43/19 44/10 43/19 44/10understand [7] understand [7] understand [7] understand [7] 6/3 11/12 6/3 11/12 6/3 11/12 6/3 11/12 18/23 19/9 29/2 29/19 18/23 19/9 29/2 29/19 18/23 19/9 29/2 29/19 18/23 19/9 29/2 29/19 31/24 31/24 31/24 31/24understanding [1] understanding [1] understanding [1] understanding [1] 6/1 6/1 6/1 6/1understood [3] understood [3] understood [3] understood [3] 4/24 5/7 4/24 5/7 4/24 5/7 4/24 5/7 6/17 6/17 6/17 6/17undoubtedly [1] undoubtedly [1] undoubtedly [1] undoubtedly [1] 15/24 15/24 15/24 15/24unfortunate [1] unfortunate [1] unfortunate [1] unfortunate [1] 31/10 31/10 31/10 31/10UNITED [7] UNITED [7] UNITED [7] UNITED [7] 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/1 1/5 1/7 1/14 3/8 4/4 47/4 1/14 3/8 4/4 47/4 1/14 3/8 4/4 47/4 1/14 3/8 4/4 47/4universe [1] universe [1] universe [1] universe [1] 26/13 26/13 26/13 26/13unless [1] unless [1] unless [1] unless [1] 30/10 30/10 30/10 30/10until [1] until [1] until [1] until [1] 45/2 45/2 45/2 45/2up [11] up [11] up [11] up [11] 5/22 8/16 9/3 5/22 8/16 9/3 5/22 8/16 9/3 5/22 8/16 9/3 15/2 18/24 18/25 23/10 15/2 18/24 18/25 23/10 15/2 18/24 18/25 23/10 15/2 18/24 18/25 23/10 27/5 40/10 40/16 43/15 27/5 40/10 40/16 43/15 27/5 40/10 40/16 43/15 27/5 40/10 40/16 43/15update [1] update [1] update [1] update [1] 4/17 4/17 4/17 4/17upper [2] upper [2] upper [2] upper [2] 18/4 18/12 18/4 18/12 18/4 18/12 18/4 18/12us [17] us [17] us [17] us [17] 5/23 6/23 7/11 5/23 6/23 7/11 5/23 6/23 7/11 5/23 6/23 7/11 7/12 7/15 8/6 13/4 19/20 7/12 7/15 8/6 13/4 19/20 7/12 7/15 8/6 13/4 19/20 7/12 7/15 8/6 13/4 19/20 27/17 28/16 28/21 38/6 27/17 28/16 28/21 38/6 27/17 28/16 28/21 38/6 27/17 28/16 28/21 38/6 38/7 38/8 38/12 45/7 45/8 38/7 38/8 38/12 45/7 45/8 38/7 38/8 38/12 45/7 45/8 38/7 38/8 38/12 45/7 45/8use [8] use [8] use [8] use [8] 7/17 16/18 18/11 7/17 16/18 18/11 7/17 16/18 18/11 7/17 16/18 18/11 19/10 29/24 37/10 37/13 19/10 29/24 37/10 37/13 19/10 29/24 37/10 37/13 19/10 29/24 37/10 37/13 37/19 37/19 37/19 37/19used [15] used [15] used [15] used [15] 10/7 15/19 10/7 15/19 10/7 15/19 10/7 15/19 15/19 15/20 15/21 17/9 15/19 15/20 15/21 17/9 15/19 15/20 15/21 17/9 15/19 15/20 15/21 17/9 19/11 23/8 28/23 31/3 19/11 23/8 28/23 31/3 19/11 23/8 28/23 31/3 19/11 23/8 28/23 31/3 31/9 36/25 37/5 41/18 31/9 36/25 37/5 41/18 31/9 36/25 37/5 41/18 31/9 36/25 37/5 41/18 41/19 41/19 41/19 41/19using [8] using [8] using [8] using [8] 18/8 18/13 18/8 18/13 18/8 18/13 18/8 18/13 26/12 26/25 29/23 30/7 26/12 26/25 29/23 30/7 26/12 26/25 29/23 30/7 26/12 26/25 29/23 30/7 31/9 37/14 31/9 37/14 31/9 37/14 31/9 37/14

VVVVVA [1] VA [1] VA [1] VA [1] 2/19 2/19 2/19 2/19vacancies [3] vacancies [3] vacancies [3] vacancies [3] 14/18 14/19 14/18 14/19 14/18 14/19 14/18 14/19 14/21 14/21 14/21 14/21variation [1] variation [1] variation [1] variation [1] 28/3 28/3 28/3 28/3vary [1] vary [1] vary [1] vary [1] 27/17 27/17 27/17 27/17VERA [2] VERA [2] VERA [2] VERA [2] 3/3 4/12 3/3 4/12 3/3 4/12 3/3 4/12version [1] version [1] version [1] version [1] 17/2 17/2 17/2 17/2versus [1] versus [1] versus [1] versus [1] 4/4 4/4 4/4 4/4very [13] very [13] very [13] very [13] 6/3 9/7 13/7 6/3 9/7 13/7 6/3 9/7 13/7 6/3 9/7 13/7 13/15 18/21 20/5 22/16 13/15 18/21 20/5 22/16 13/15 18/21 20/5 22/16 13/15 18/21 20/5 22/16 22/18 24/7 24/14 25/13 22/18 24/7 24/14 25/13 22/18 24/7 24/14 25/13 22/18 24/7 24/14 25/13 33/1 35/22 33/1 35/22 33/1 35/22 33/1 35/22vice [2] vice [2] vice [2] vice [2] 14/1 14/14 14/1 14/14 14/1 14/14 14/1 14/14vice-president [2] vice-president [2] vice-president [2] vice-president [2] 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/1 14/14 14/14 14/14 14/14victory [2] victory [2] victory [2] victory [2] 35/19 38/18 35/19 38/18 35/19 38/18 35/19 38/18view [3] view [3] view [3] view [3] 22/10 23/2 25/19 22/10 23/2 25/19 22/10 23/2 25/19 22/10 23/2 25/19volume [1] volume [1] volume [1] volume [1] 7/21 7/21 7/21 7/21vote [11] vote [11] vote [11] vote [11] 13/13 13/14 13/13 13/14 13/13 13/14 13/13 13/14 32/25 33/7 35/5 35/8 35/8 32/25 33/7 35/5 35/8 35/8 32/25 33/7 35/5 35/8 35/8 32/25 33/7 35/5 35/8 35/8 35/9 36/3 36/11 38/25 35/9 36/3 36/11 38/25 35/9 36/3 36/11 38/25 35/9 36/3 36/11 38/25voted [2] voted [2] voted [2] voted [2] 26/3 37/21 26/3 37/21 26/3 37/21 26/3 37/21voter [4] voter [4] voter [4] voter [4] 14/12 25/18 14/12 25/18 14/12 25/18 14/12 25/18 36/4 36/6 36/4 36/6 36/4 36/6 36/4 36/6voters [9] voters [9] voters [9] voters [9] 13/21 26/3 13/21 26/3 13/21 26/3 13/21 26/3 32/24 37/20 38/9 38/13 32/24 37/20 38/9 38/13 32/24 37/20 38/9 38/13 32/24 37/20 38/9 38/13 39/9 39/25 43/25 39/9 39/25 43/25 39/9 39/25 43/25 39/9 39/25 43/25

votes [2] votes [2] votes [2] votes [2] 33/4 36/12 33/4 36/12 33/4 36/12 33/4 36/12voting [22] voting [22] voting [22] voting [22] 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 17/5 17/10 18/7 32/13 32/16 33/1 18/7 32/13 32/16 33/1 18/7 32/13 32/16 33/1 18/7 32/13 32/16 33/1 33/11 33/13 33/17 33/19 33/11 33/13 33/17 33/19 33/11 33/13 33/17 33/19 33/11 33/13 33/17 33/19 33/23 34/1 34/2 34/2 34/6 33/23 34/1 34/2 34/2 34/6 33/23 34/1 34/2 34/2 34/6 33/23 34/1 34/2 34/2 34/6 34/11 34/13 34/17 35/17 34/11 34/13 34/17 35/17 34/11 34/13 34/17 35/17 34/11 34/13 34/17 35/17 36/20 37/6 39/14 36/20 37/6 39/14 36/20 37/6 39/14 36/20 37/6 39/14

WWWWwait [4] wait [4] wait [4] wait [4] 19/9 34/16 34/16 19/9 34/16 34/16 19/9 34/16 34/16 19/9 34/16 34/16 34/16 34/16 34/16 34/16want [17] want [17] want [17] want [17] 5/20 6/25 7/10 5/20 6/25 7/10 5/20 6/25 7/10 5/20 6/25 7/10 11/12 19/16 22/19 24/5 11/12 19/16 22/19 24/5 11/12 19/16 22/19 24/5 11/12 19/16 22/19 24/5 24/12 24/13 25/16 26/7 24/12 24/13 25/16 26/7 24/12 24/13 25/16 26/7 24/12 24/13 25/16 26/7 30/2 40/20 43/11 43/13 30/2 40/20 43/11 43/13 30/2 40/20 43/11 43/13 30/2 40/20 43/11 43/13 44/16 44/18 44/16 44/18 44/16 44/18 44/16 44/18wanted [4] wanted [4] wanted [4] wanted [4] 4/16 9/12 4/16 9/12 4/16 9/12 4/16 9/12 16/18 20/22 16/18 20/22 16/18 20/22 16/18 20/22wants [1] wants [1] wants [1] wants [1] 44/6 44/6 44/6 44/6was [50] was [50] was [50] was [50] Washington [5] Washington [5] Washington [5] Washington [5] 1/5 2/5 1/5 2/5 1/5 2/5 1/5 2/5 2/7 2/16 3/9 2/7 2/16 3/9 2/7 2/16 3/9 2/7 2/16 3/9wasn't [2] wasn't [2] wasn't [2] wasn't [2] 12/2 27/12 12/2 27/12 12/2 27/12 12/2 27/12wasted [1] wasted [1] wasted [1] wasted [1] 8/9 8/9 8/9 8/9watch [1] watch [1] watch [1] watch [1] 26/16 26/16 26/16 26/16way [3] way [3] way [3] way [3] 17/1 23/10 28/17 17/1 23/10 28/17 17/1 23/10 28/17 17/1 23/10 28/17we [93] we [93] we [93] we [93] we'd [2] we'd [2] we'd [2] we'd [2] 7/4 21/4 7/4 21/4 7/4 21/4 7/4 21/4we'll [4] we'll [4] we'll [4] we'll [4] 8/21 29/17 45/1 8/21 29/17 45/1 8/21 29/17 45/1 8/21 29/17 45/1 45/3 45/3 45/3 45/3we're [10] we're [10] we're [10] we're [10] 7/13 7/15 8/8 7/13 7/15 8/8 7/13 7/15 8/8 7/13 7/15 8/8 8/10 8/14 8/23 17/17 28/6 8/10 8/14 8/23 17/17 28/6 8/10 8/14 8/23 17/17 28/6 8/10 8/14 8/23 17/17 28/6 36/23 45/3 36/23 45/3 36/23 45/3 36/23 45/3we've [1] we've [1] we've [1] we've [1] 7/2 7/2 7/2 7/2Wednesday [1] Wednesday [1] Wednesday [1] Wednesday [1] 1/6 1/6 1/6 1/6week [1] week [1] week [1] week [1] 22/10 22/10 22/10 22/10well [13] well [13] well [13] well [13] 7/23 8/2 9/17 7/23 8/2 9/17 7/23 8/2 9/17 7/23 8/2 9/17 22/16 22/18 24/14 24/15 22/16 22/18 24/14 24/15 22/16 22/18 24/14 24/15 22/16 22/18 24/14 24/15 25/13 29/4 29/12 35/6 25/13 29/4 29/12 35/6 25/13 29/4 29/12 35/6 25/13 29/4 29/12 35/6 41/12 42/11 41/12 42/11 41/12 42/11 41/12 42/11Wendy [3] Wendy [3] Wendy [3] Wendy [3] 1/9 35/15 35/24 1/9 35/15 35/24 1/9 35/15 35/24 1/9 35/15 35/24went [1] went [1] went [1] went [1] 27/13 27/13 27/13 27/13were [23] were [23] were [23] were [23] 5/12 5/21 9/14 5/12 5/21 9/14 5/12 5/21 9/14 5/12 5/21 9/14 11/13 11/19 12/2 13/18 11/13 11/19 12/2 13/18 11/13 11/19 12/2 13/18 11/13 11/19 12/2 13/18 15/9 18/12 20/23 21/20 15/9 18/12 20/23 21/20 15/9 18/12 20/23 21/20 15/9 18/12 20/23 21/20 23/16 25/4 25/7 25/9 23/16 25/4 25/7 25/9 23/16 25/4 25/7 25/9 23/16 25/4 25/7 25/9 35/25 39/1 39/16 41/4 35/25 39/1 39/16 41/4 35/25 39/1 39/16 41/4 35/25 39/1 39/16 41/4 41/13 43/12 45/7 45/8 41/13 43/12 45/7 45/8 41/13 43/12 45/7 45/8 41/13 43/12 45/7 45/8West [2] West [2] West [2] West [2] 1/20 2/21 1/20 2/21 1/20 2/21 1/20 2/21what [39] what [39] what [39] what [39] 4/15 5/12 5/16 4/15 5/12 5/16 4/15 5/12 5/16 4/15 5/12 5/16 6/23 7/6 7/9 7/11 8/3 8/3 6/23 7/6 7/9 7/11 8/3 8/3 6/23 7/6 7/9 7/11 8/3 8/3 6/23 7/6 7/9 7/11 8/3 8/3 11/11 12/21 13/2 14/11 11/11 12/21 13/2 14/11 11/11 12/21 13/2 14/11 11/11 12/21 13/2 14/11 14/19 19/4 19/7 19/9 21/4 14/19 19/4 19/7 19/9 21/4 14/19 19/4 19/7 19/9 21/4 14/19 19/4 19/7 19/9 21/4 26/17 27/11 27/12 27/24 26/17 27/11 27/12 27/24 26/17 27/11 27/12 27/24 26/17 27/11 27/12 27/24 28/21 31/14 31/16 32/7 28/21 31/14 31/16 32/7 28/21 31/14 31/16 32/7 28/21 31/14 31/16 32/7 32/20 34/5 34/19 35/12 32/20 34/5 34/19 35/12 32/20 34/5 34/19 35/12 32/20 34/5 34/19 35/12 35/18 36/7 36/8 36/13 35/18 36/7 36/8 36/13 35/18 36/7 36/8 36/13 35/18 36/7 36/8 36/13 36/14 36/15 40/5 40/5 36/14 36/15 40/5 40/5 36/14 36/15 40/5 40/5 36/14 36/15 40/5 40/5 43/13 43/13 43/13 43/13what's [1] what's [1] what's [1] what's [1] 31/17 31/17 31/17 31/17whatever [1] whatever [1] whatever [1] whatever [1] 15/2 15/2 15/2 15/2when [12] when [12] when [12] when [12] 6/6 9/13 14/12 6/6 9/13 14/12 6/6 9/13 14/12 6/6 9/13 14/12 26/12 26/16 29/15 29/23 26/12 26/16 29/15 29/23 26/12 26/16 29/15 29/23 26/12 26/16 29/15 29/23 37/8 37/9 37/10 37/11 37/8 37/9 37/10 37/11 37/8 37/9 37/10 37/11 37/8 37/9 37/10 37/11 37/11 37/11 37/11 37/11where [9] where [9] where [9] where [9] 18/15 19/8 25/6 18/15 19/8 25/6 18/15 19/8 25/6 18/15 19/8 25/6 28/8 34/8 35/21 36/24 28/8 34/8 35/21 36/24 28/8 34/8 35/21 36/24 28/8 34/8 35/21 36/24 39/8 40/15 39/8 40/15 39/8 40/15 39/8 40/15whereas [1] whereas [1] whereas [1] whereas [1] 28/25 28/25 28/25 28/25whether [12] whether [12] whether [12] whether [12] 10/23 17/20 10/23 17/20 10/23 17/20 10/23 17/20 18/2 18/8 18/15 20/10 18/2 18/8 18/15 20/10 18/2 18/8 18/15 20/10 18/2 18/8 18/15 20/10

23/25 24/16 24/23 36/12 23/25 24/16 24/23 36/12 23/25 24/16 24/23 36/12 23/25 24/16 24/23 36/12 38/8 43/12 38/8 43/12 38/8 43/12 38/8 43/12which [15] which [15] which [15] which [15] 6/17 7/6 15/19 6/17 7/6 15/19 6/17 7/6 15/19 6/17 7/6 15/19 21/20 24/11 25/4 33/2 21/20 24/11 25/4 33/2 21/20 24/11 25/4 33/2 21/20 24/11 25/4 33/2 33/20 34/13 36/10 36/21 33/20 34/13 36/10 36/21 33/20 34/13 36/10 36/21 33/20 34/13 36/10 36/21 39/25 40/10 43/15 47/8 39/25 40/10 43/15 47/8 39/25 40/10 43/15 47/8 39/25 40/10 43/15 47/8white [6] white [6] white [6] white [6] 9/9 12/24 33/17 9/9 12/24 33/17 9/9 12/24 33/17 9/9 12/24 33/17 33/19 36/12 45/6 33/19 36/12 45/6 33/19 36/12 45/6 33/19 36/12 45/6whites [1] whites [1] whites [1] whites [1] 36/14 36/14 36/14 36/14who [5] who [5] who [5] who [5] 4/22 5/8 25/12 4/22 5/8 25/12 4/22 5/8 25/12 4/22 5/8 25/12 26/3 42/18 26/3 42/18 26/3 42/18 26/3 42/18Who's [1] Who's [1] Who's [1] Who's [1] 8/18 8/18 8/18 8/18whole [3] whole [3] whole [3] whole [3] 22/14 25/14 22/14 25/14 22/14 25/14 22/14 25/14 26/13 26/13 26/13 26/13why [9] why [9] why [9] why [9] 6/25 16/5 16/9 6/25 16/5 16/9 6/25 16/5 16/9 6/25 16/5 16/9 16/14 28/5 28/6 30/12 16/14 28/5 28/6 30/12 16/14 28/5 28/6 30/12 16/14 28/5 28/6 30/12 39/18 42/10 39/18 42/10 39/18 42/10 39/18 42/10widely [1] widely [1] widely [1] widely [1] 31/9 31/9 31/9 31/9will [15] will [15] will [15] will [15] 6/1 6/3 6/12 6/1 6/3 6/12 6/1 6/3 6/12 6/1 6/3 6/12 6/13 6/21 8/1 8/3 8/3 6/13 6/21 8/1 8/3 8/3 6/13 6/21 8/1 8/3 8/3 6/13 6/21 8/1 8/3 8/3 8/25 13/6 13/13 13/13 8/25 13/6 13/13 13/13 8/25 13/6 13/13 13/13 8/25 13/6 13/13 13/13 25/15 29/15 30/3 25/15 29/15 30/3 25/15 29/15 30/3 25/15 29/15 30/3winning [1] winning [1] winning [1] winning [1] 18/16 18/16 18/16 18/16wishes [1] wishes [1] wishes [1] wishes [1] 42/18 42/18 42/18 42/18within [9] within [9] within [9] within [9] 16/11 16/16 16/11 16/16 16/11 16/16 16/11 16/16 29/3 31/7 31/12 31/12 29/3 31/7 31/12 31/12 29/3 31/7 31/12 31/12 29/3 31/7 31/12 31/12 31/14 38/23 39/3 31/14 38/23 39/3 31/14 38/23 39/3 31/14 38/23 39/3without [1] without [1] without [1] without [1] 28/5 28/5 28/5 28/5witness [9] witness [9] witness [9] witness [9] 5/8 9/4 9/10 5/8 9/4 9/10 5/8 9/4 9/10 5/8 9/4 9/10 21/8 30/19 32/12 40/18 21/8 30/19 32/12 40/18 21/8 30/19 32/12 40/18 21/8 30/19 32/12 40/18 42/19 44/25 42/19 44/25 42/19 44/25 42/19 44/25witnesses [6] witnesses [6] witnesses [6] witnesses [6] 4/22 4/23 4/22 4/23 4/22 4/23 4/22 4/23 5/2 5/3 5/6 8/25 5/2 5/3 5/6 8/25 5/2 5/3 5/6 8/25 5/2 5/3 5/6 8/25won [2] won [2] won [2] won [2] 25/7 25/12 25/7 25/12 25/7 25/12 25/7 25/12won't [2] won't [2] won't [2] won't [2] 25/14 45/2 25/14 45/2 25/14 45/2 25/14 45/2wonderful [1] wonderful [1] wonderful [1] wonderful [1] 24/15 24/15 24/15 24/15wondering [1] wondering [1] wondering [1] wondering [1] 8/12 8/12 8/12 8/12work [3] work [3] work [3] work [3] 4/19 9/7 13/4 4/19 9/7 13/4 4/19 9/7 13/4 4/19 9/7 13/4working [3] working [3] working [3] working [3] 6/6 6/13 6/14 6/6 6/13 6/14 6/6 6/13 6/14 6/6 6/13 6/14works [1] works [1] works [1] works [1] 12/6 12/6 12/6 12/6would [41] would [41] would [41] would [41] 4/18 5/14 5/15 4/18 5/14 5/15 4/18 5/14 5/15 4/18 5/14 5/15 7/5 7/21 11/3 12/10 12/21 7/5 7/21 11/3 12/10 12/21 7/5 7/21 11/3 12/10 12/21 7/5 7/21 11/3 12/10 12/21 14/1 14/7 14/13 14/14 14/1 14/7 14/13 14/14 14/1 14/7 14/13 14/14 14/1 14/7 14/13 14/14 15/1 15/2 17/10 17/17 15/1 15/2 17/10 17/17 15/1 15/2 17/10 17/17 15/1 15/2 17/10 17/17 18/15 19/8 19/11 19/14 18/15 19/8 19/11 19/14 18/15 19/8 19/11 19/14 18/15 19/8 19/11 19/14 20/10 20/25 21/7 21/19 20/10 20/25 21/7 21/19 20/10 20/25 21/7 21/19 20/10 20/25 21/7 21/19 29/13 31/20 32/4 32/5 29/13 31/20 32/4 32/5 29/13 31/20 32/4 32/5 29/13 31/20 32/4 32/5 34/13 34/18 34/19 36/13 34/13 34/18 34/19 36/13 34/13 34/18 34/19 36/13 34/13 34/18 34/19 36/13 36/16 39/6 39/20 40/6 36/16 39/6 39/20 40/6 36/16 39/6 39/20 40/6 36/16 39/6 39/20 40/6 40/7 40/8 41/7 42/7 42/10 40/7 40/8 41/7 42/7 42/10 40/7 40/8 41/7 42/7 42/10 40/7 40/8 41/7 42/7 42/10wouldn't [2] wouldn't [2] wouldn't [2] wouldn't [2] 17/10 33/22 17/10 33/22 17/10 33/22 17/10 33/22write [1] write [1] write [1] write [1] 41/1 41/1 41/1 41/1written [1] written [1] written [1] written [1] 44/13 44/13 44/13 44/13

YYYYYanez [1] Yanez [1] Yanez [1] Yanez [1] 12/12 12/12 12/12 12/12year [8] year [8] year [8] year [8] 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/15 10/18 10/19 13/25 14/13 29/16 10/19 13/25 14/13 29/16 10/19 13/25 14/13 29/16 10/19 13/25 14/13 29/16 29/17 38/16 29/17 38/16 29/17 38/16 29/17 38/16years [5] years [5] years [5] years [5] 10/12 10/12 10/12 10/12 10/12 10/12 10/12 10/12 12/9 14/16 29/1 12/9 14/16 29/1 12/9 14/16 29/1 12/9 14/16 29/1yes [53] yes [53] yes [53] yes [53] yesterday [6] yesterday [6] yesterday [6] yesterday [6] 8/10 9/2 8/10 9/2 8/10 9/2 8/10 9/2 9/13 9/16 11/5 43/11 9/13 9/16 11/5 43/11 9/13 9/16 11/5 43/11 9/13 9/16 11/5 43/11yet [1] yet [1] yet [1] yet [1] 12/11 12/11 12/11 12/11you [234] you [234] you [234] you [234] You'll [2] You'll [2] You'll [2] You'll [2] 25/17 45/1 25/17 45/1 25/17 45/1 25/17 45/1you're [9] you're [9] you're [9] you're [9] 7/8 7/11 7/12 7/8 7/11 7/12 7/8 7/11 7/12 7/8 7/11 7/12 14/19 26/12 27/20 37/7 14/19 26/12 27/20 37/7 14/19 26/12 27/20 37/7 14/19 26/12 27/20 37/7 37/11 43/13 37/11 43/13 37/11 43/13 37/11 43/13you've [4] you've [4] you've [4] you've [4] 7/7 9/4 23/7 7/7 9/4 23/7 7/7 9/4 23/7 7/7 9/4 23/7

58585858

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 58 of 59

Page 59: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF … · ASHLEY C. KELLER, Esquire Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP Courthouse Place 54 West Hubbard Street Chicago, IL 60610

YYYYyou've... [1] you've... [1] you've... [1] you've... [1] 43/9 43/9 43/9 43/9your [66] your [66] your [66] your [66] yours [1] yours [1] yours [1] yours [1] 32/22 32/22 32/22 32/22

ZZZZzero [1] zero [1] zero [1] zero [1] 25/14 25/14 25/14 25/14

59595959

Case 5:11-cv-00360-OLG-JES-XR Document 597-12 Filed 02/02/12 Page 59 of 59