Top Banner
Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed with minimal text
13

Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Dec 19, 2015

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture

Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig

Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman

FSS 2004

Slides designed with minimal text

Page 2: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Introduce classroom environment

Describe study – empirical analysis of lecture archive

Page 3: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Diagram use in the wild

Identify properties of diagrams

Challenges for analysis

Page 4: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Simple example

- Irregular shapes

- Cryptic labels

- Attentional ink

Page 5: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Similar style, different instructor

Page 6: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.
Page 7: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Analyze example with respect to applications

Static summary

Student note taking

Page 8: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Closer look – challenge of identifying structure based on multiple lines

Page 9: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Phasing in diagrams

Page 10: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

More examples of phasing

Page 11: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Locality in diagrams – inconsistent meaning of ink

In discussion some of the ink is ignored

Top arrows: “Not there”

Separate wins indicated together

Page 12: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

Attentional ink issues

Ink that is both iconic and attentional

Challenge of distinguishing attentional (A) from diagrammatic (B)

Ink that changes meaning: check marks next to 1, 2, 3, become Locks

Opportunistic use of ink

Page 13: Understanding Diagrammatic Ink in Lecture Richard Anderson, Ruth Anderson, Crystal Hoyer, Craig Prince, Fred Videon, Steve Wolfman FSS 2004 Slides designed.

For more information

http://www.cs.washington.edu/education/dl/presenter/

Richard Anderson, [email protected]

Ruth Anderson, [email protected]