UD Pulau Mas Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership · UD Pulau Mas Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership Summary of improvement developments by UD Pulau Mas (April 2017)

UD Pulau Mas Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership

Summary of improvement developments by UD Pulau Mas (April 2017) – (September 2017)

Munawir and Achmad Mustofa (Capture Fisheries, WWF-Indonesia)

General Information UD Pulau Mas is implementing a responsible fishing practice by having a private supply chain scheme or only buying fish from their members. By this system,

the company has an easier scheme to monitor their total production and control the fishers selling fish to Fish Management Unit. Besideds, UD Pulau plans

to implement a quota system for its fisher members. The preliminary concept proposed by the head of UD Pulau Mas is by considering to number of total

catch in the previous year.

“If a fisher sell his fish to a non-member fisher, automatically he will decrease his own quota,” said Heru Purnomo, the owner of UD Pulau Mas.

Along with WWF-Indonesia, UD Pulau Mas implements the fisheries improvement program by conducting a Better Management Practices (BMP)-grouper

training for one of fisher group assisted by WWF in Wakatobi, South and Eastern Sulawesi Subseascape/SESS. The fisher group is Antapulo which is dominated

by fishers live in Tomia. This group provides 40% of UD Pulau Mas total production in Wakatobi. The training is held on June 206 for its 20 fishers. According

to the result of pre and post-test, the knowledge of them increases 15.61%.

In order to monitor the fishing practice towards the conservation principles in BMP, an assessment of compliance level is conducted to the fishers in ANtapulo

group on February 2017 with the preliminary value (t0) is 71.22%. Based on the assessment, the major aspects needed to be improved are catch result and

fishing vessel data.

Regarding to catch result data, UD Pulau Mas has already implemented a digital base data record using IBM software. However, the fishers need to

independently know the grouper and other catches result as an effort to contribute to the fishery management in Wakatobi. Therefore, after the compliance

assessment, WWF team conducts a training of logbook record to the Antapulo’s fishers. This aims to provide a deeper understanding on catch result and the

fishers are being familiar with the form of data.

Meanwhile, based on the policy stating that all size fishing vessels are obliged to have small pass and fishing vessel permit if the product is exported to the

US and Europe. Based on the observation in the site, all fishing vessel have not been registered to the Fisheries Offices of Wakatobi District. IN the process

of registration, WWF-Indonesia encourages the company and guides the fishers.

Besides those two aspects, the fisher group implements positive activities such as holding group legality, using responsible fishing gear and deciding the

minimum size catch.

Reef fish fishing in Wakatobi, particularky the grouper fishing has shown a decreasing number. For gaining a deeper and a more scientific information, a

historical catch study is conducted by involving all related stakeholders in Wakatobi. The data collection is led by WWF-Indonesia aiming to find out the

historical grouper catch in Wakatobi. The history will be the baseline of grouper harvest strategy document in Wakatobi.

Besides Tomia Island, on June 2017 the WWF in Wakatobi altogether with UD Pulau Mas also implemented fisheries improvement in Wanci Island to two

fisher groups which are Sangeh Kami and Mitra Suni groups, the supplier of D Pulau Mas in Wakatobi District. Throughout the BMP-grouper and snapper to

those two fisher groups coming from Bajo tribe in Mola sub-district, the WWF team informed them about regulation and the responsible fishing practice.

Based on the pre- and post-test in the training, the knowledge of fishers was increasing 15.62%.

Several improvement activities implemented to the two fisher groups are group strengthening and legality to encourage the independency, catch result

record using logbook scheme and updated information about grouper and snapper fishing practice. Based on the observation in the site, the fishing practice

done by members of Mitra Sunu and Sangeh Kami is already implementing the responsible fishing manners using hand line and considering the minimum

catch size instructed by UD Pulau Mas.

The technical assistant is also gained from the Fisheries Office of Wakatobi District from the monthly meeting scheme. The meeting becomes a platform for

fishers to discuss any related activities in grouper snapper fishing practice and a media to share the updated information to government of the current and

future fishing practice.

Membership evaluation details (UD Pulau Mas) based on the implemented Fisheries Improvement Project (FIP):

DETAIL ACTION (for the Seafood Savers member)

OUTPUT AND INDICATOR FOR DETAIL ACTION

(for the Seafood Savers member)

ACTION LEAD & PARTNERS

SEAFOOD SAVERS

stage

EVALUATION RESULT

FOLLOW UP PLAN / DIFFICULTIES

INTER

MED

IATE

AD

VA

NC

E

1.1.1. facilitate the development process of EAFM and or other regulations which promotes sustainable fishery principles

Ministrial decree on EAFM and or other regulations which promotes sustainable Reef fish fisheries is available

SDI, P4KSI, Agency of MAF in Province & District

Fisheries Processing through ecosystem approach in Indonesia had been recognized by government and legalized through Surat Keputusan Dirjen Perikanan Tangkap No. 18/ Kep-DJPT/ 2014* *Download Link : http://infohukum.kkp.go.id/ind ex.php/hukum Government regulated trawl and seine nets through Peraturan Menteri Kelautan dan Perikanan Republik Indonesia Nomor 2/Permen- KP/ 2015 about the prohibition

The company is not directly getting involved in the EAFM activities. However, the company provides data about production in the cage as the research of EAFM assessment. For instance, Takabonerate National Park, Wakatobi National Park and West Manggarai District.

of the use of trawls and seine nets in Wilayah Pengelolaan Perikanan Negara Republik Indonesia* *Download link : http://infohukum.kkp.go.id/ind ex.php/hukum

1.1.2. develop company regulation to support the implementation of EAFM and or other regulations which promotes sustainable fishery principles

the company has a policy on implementation of EAFM and or other regulations related to sustainable fishery principles

Company The Company recorded the catch of fishermen data by using a software developed by IBM and carried out the installation of data collection instruments on the entire cage

The company only bought fish caught by eco-friendly fishing gear (handline)

The company set a minimum size of the catch which is 500 grams

Company had not processed data via IBM

1.2.1 facilitates the Province/District regulation as interpretation of ministerial decree on fishery management plan, which include Harvest Control Rule

Province/District regulation as extention of fishery management plan with harvest strategy is available

SDI, P4KSI, Dinas, PLN, KKJI, PSDP

The Harvest Strategy had not been applied yet because the strategy was still in development stage along with the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries

Along with the LPTK sub-division, WWF-Indonesia develops general guideline of Harvest Strategy for non-tuna fisheries. Currently, it is at training level, the preliminary draft is available and waiting the finalization in 2017.

1.2.2. Company implement measures regulated in Province/District fishery management plan as a patron on the development and implementation in the area. The plan will have harvest control rule with sustainable principles involve e.g. minimum capture size, adjusting the number of effort following the stock carrying capacity

Company become the pioneer to support the development and implementation of Province/District management plan with its harvest control strategy

Company The Harvest Strategy had not been applied yet because the strategy was still in development stage along with the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries

Regarding to the implementation of general guideline of harvest strategy, the company has not complied with the method in the guideline because the guideline has not been socialized. However, the company is actively delegating its representative to join the historical catch training in Wakatobi. Besides, the internal policies about minimum size catch, logbook record and quota scheme plan are based on the harvest strategy general guideline.

1.2.3. facilitate the province/district regulation as an extention of EAFM regulation and or other national regulations which promotes sustainable Reef fish fishery principles

Province/District regulation as extention of EAFM regulation and or other national regulations which promotes sustainable Reef fish fishery principles

SDI, P4KSI, Dinas, PLN, KKJI, PSDP

West Manggarai District uses indicators on EAFM to draft academic paper on which drafting Regional Regulation on Sustainable Fisheries in the territorial waters of West Manggarai. UD Mas has 2 locations cages that run into area waters on the island of Mesa and Sababi island. Ranperda process itself is currently being discussed by the law firm of DPRD West Manggarai District Download Link:

http://bit.ly/1HWO9aH Download Link Ranperda Mabar : http://bit.ly/1ARYi2D Wakatobi District uses indicators on EAFM to draft academic paper on which drafting Regional Regulation on Sustainable Fisheries in the territorial waters of Wakatobi. UD Mas Island has 2 locations cages that go into area waters on the island Tomea and Wangi- Wangi. Ranperda process itself is currently being discussed by the law firm of DPRD Kab. WakatobiDownload Link Naskah Akademis Ranperda Wakatobi : - Download Link Draft Ranperda Wakatobi : http://bit.ly/1DvxRXm East Flores District compiled with the indicator on EAFM academic paper on which the draft Regional Regulation on Sustainable Fisheries in the waters of East Flores Regency. The Ranperda now is being

signed by the Regent and has officially become the decree East Flores District on Sustainable Fisheries Download Link http://bit.ly/1CqDYfT

1.2.4 Company implement measures regulated in Indonesian EAFM guideline and or other national regulations which promotes sustainable Reef fish fishery principles as a patron for the development and implementation of EAFM in Province/District level

Company become the pioneer to support the development and implementation of EAFM regulation and or other regulations which promote sustainable Reef fish fishery principles in Province/District

Company West Manggarai District uses indicators on EAFM to draft academic paper on which drafting Regional Regulation on Sustainable Fisheries in the territorial waters of West Manggarai District. UD Mas had 2 locations cages that went into area waters on the island of Mesa and Sababi Island. Ranperda process itself was currently being discussed by the law firm of DPRD Kab. West Manggarai. Pulau Mas UD actively participates in the provision of data in academic paper. Download Link : http://bit.ly/1HWO9aH Download Link Ranperda Mabar : http://bit.ly/1ARYi2D

The company is not directly getting involved in the EAFM activities. Invitation had been sent, but the company could not attend.

http://bit.ly/1HWO9aH

http://bit.ly/1ARYi2D

1.3.1 Development and adoption of the Reef fish management plan principles in the area

Reef fish management plan is available and adopted

SDI, Agency of MAF in Province & District, Hasanudin University in Makassar

Reef Fish Action Plan document is Available Download link : http://bit.ly/1DvWlA1

Reef Fish Action Plan document is available, the adoption to the fisheries practice is implemented in the FIP corridor with WWF-Indonesia.

1.3.2 Company proactively support and implement the management plan (e.g. Provide letter on on the management plan, proactively attend meetings if required)

Company to be pioneer to support the development and implementation of area based fishery management plan (RPP WPP)

Company Perusahaan terlibat dalam penyusunan RPP oleh Pemerintah yang diadakan pada tanggal 10-12 Maret 2015 di Universitas Terbuka, Tangerang Selatan Link Undangan : http://bit.ly/19v6HDI Dokumentasi :

The Fisheries Management Plan document based on the Fisheries Management Area is being discussed in legal division of the MMAF before being implemented as attachment in the Ministerial Regulation. The main issue found is the lack of quota in the Fisheries Management Plan. In order to solve it, we draft a protocol of fish stock estimation with the National Committee on Fish Stock Assessment.

http://bit.ly/1DvWlA1

http://bit.ly/19v6HDI

WWF-Indonesia get involves In the drafting of Fisheries Management Plan for FMA 713, 714 and 715.

*Download Link: the document has not been finalized, it is still being discussed by the Legal Department of the MMAF

1.4.1 Initiate the workshop on TURF (or other RBM measures) which will also identify the measures needed to develop the mechanism

TURF (or other RBM measures) management to avoid overfishing is adopted

SDI, Agency of MAF in Province & District, Community fishers, NGOs, Hasanudin University in Makassar

TURF mechanism is being developed by WWF team altogether with government for Koon site

1.4.2 Implement TURF (or other RBM measures) to manage the fishery

TURF (or other RBM measures) management to avoid overfishing is implemented

KKJI, Agency of MAF in Province & District, Community fishers, NGOs

TURF mechanism is being developed by WWF team altogether with government for Koon site

1.4.3 Company facilitates the implementation of TURF (or other RBM measures) mechanism

Company to be pioneer on the implementation of TURF (or other RBM measures)

Company Has not been implemented TURF mechanism is being developed by WWF team altogether with government for Koon site

1.5.1 Collect and evaluate the all information needed to develop a new or existing marine no take zone system,

Report available, containing the information on which reefs is supporting the fishery reserves and which reefs do not support the no take zone


Water Conservation Area book published by the directorate KP3K, Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries has provided Download Link : Distribution maps Water Conservation Area in Indonesia available Download Link : Companies establish policies for its members in the form of prohibition to catch in the core zone (TBC)

This stage is still limited to implementing Inventory, “take zone” action has not been taken

1.5.2 Determine no take zone with its regulation to support sustainable fishery

No take zone area and regulation to support sustainable fishery developed


Water Conservation Area book published by the directorate KP3K, Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries has provided Download Link :

Law enforcement is

Distribution maps Water Conservation Area in Indonesia available Download Link : Companies establish policies for its members in the form of prohibition to catch in the core zone (TBC)

1.5.3 Implement the zone delineation result

The new no tak zone implemented and fully functioned


Buku Kawasan Konservasi Water Conservation Area book published by the directorate KP3K, Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries has provided Download Link : Distribution maps Water Conservation Area in Indonesia available Download Link : Companies establish policies for its members in the form of prohibition to catch in the core zone (TBC)

2.1.1 Facilitate the availability of regulation (e.g. ministrial decrees) which promotes sub FKPPS and or national management authority (e.g. task

National Reef fish fishery authority to coordinate the management implementation of area based fishery management plan in district/province level

SDI, Agency of KKP in province and district, NGOs, stakeholders

Has not been implemented

force) to responsible on the Reef fish fishery management

2.1.2 Actively involve industry, research agency, NGOs in meetings related to the fishery decision making

Fishery management authority and area based fishery management plan much credible and supported by all stakeholders



2.1.3 Company proactively supported and involved in the decision making process in national and province/District levels (e.g attending meetings)

Company to be pioneer to support the development and implementation of area based fishery management plan in Indonesia

Company Has not been implemented

2.1.4 Monitor and evaluate the performance of Province/District management authority which conducted by internal and external agencies of MMAF-MAF of Province/District to be responsible on the Reef fish fishery management

Province/District Reef fish fishery management authority is well functioned to implement the management measures in area based fishery management plan



2.2.1 Facilitate the availability of regulation (e.g. ministerial decrees, directorate general decrees) on tasks allocation with specific job description to the right agency to support the fishery management

tasks defined for all stakeholders; Reef fish Fisheries Satker, KKP, DKP Provinsi and District and Community groups

SDI, Agency of KKP in province and district, DKP, community stakeholders, NGOs.


3.1.1 Workshop on stock assessment; including methodology on data collection & analysis, synchronization plan

A clearer role on which agency conduct and the methodology used to do stock assessment

P4KSI, BPPL and Hasanudin University in Makassar

The estimation of stock using the Risk Based Framework has been implemented, report is available. Protocol estimation of the stock is being developed by the National Committee on Fish Stock Assessment

3.1.2 Training on stock assessment, fisheries biology and fishing capacity

The authority on stock assessment have capacity to conduct stock assessment using agreed methodology

P4KSI, BPPL and Hasanudin University in Makassar

Estimation of the stock using the Risk Based Framework has been implemented, report available

3.1.3 Develop company policy to commit on supporting data collection for stock assessment by facilitating research activities and providing access to their production facilities (e.g. Logbook, interview, gonad sampling, etc)

Company to be pioneer on having commitment for data collection support on the stock assessment for Reef fish in Indonesia

Company Implementing Risk Based Framework (PSa/ SICA) : Report is available

3.2.1 Conduct the scientific review on reef fish stock indicators

information on the indicators of reef fish stock status available (e.g. Biological fish information)

P4KSI, BPPL and local universities

A study concerning fisheries stock assessment of coral in five locations in Indonesia altogether wiith the University of Diponegoro Download Link :

Other relevant reseraches

3.3.1 training workshop on risk assessment, include simulation

Fishery managers and researchers understand and have the capacity to conduct the risk assessment

P4KSI, BPPL, DKP, and Hasanudin University in Makassar, NGOs, Community,

Workshop for estimating fish stocks through PSA and SICA have been held in five locations in Indonesia

middlement, processors

3.3.2 undertake the Risk Based Assessment

Information on Risk based assessment conducted to all target species, baitfish and bycatch species available

P4KSI, BPPL, DKP, and Hasanudin University in Makassar, NGOs, Community, middlement, processors

Workshop for estimating fish stocks through PSA and SICA have been held in five locations in Indonesia

3.4.1 Study on LRP for Grouper and Snapper

LRP for grouper and snapper identified and available

P4KSI/BPPL, University in Makassar

In cooperation with Yvone Sadovy to carry out research and studies on the location of cages

The research results are not shared by UD Pulau Ma

3.4.2 Company participated on data collection for stock assessment by facilitating research activities and providing access to their production facilities (e.g. Logbook, interview, gonad sampling, etc)

Company to be pioneer on data collection support on the stock assessment for Reef fish in Indonesia

Company The company participated actively in providing data for stock assessment and status through SICA PSA method implemented by a team of University of Diponegoro

3.5.1 P4KSI and local university will conduct the study on best effort allowed in the fishery and solution for reducing effort

> Report on the study available, providing the information on number of effort allowed to fish within the area and proposed solution to reduce the effort > provide the academic document to propose the effort reduction

DKP Prov & District

Belum dilaksanakan

3.5.2 local government will develop regulation and facilitated the implementation on reducing the effort

Province/District regulation on effort reduction is available and functioned following the scientific recommendation

P4KSI, BPPL, DKP, and Hasanudin University in Makassar, NGOs, Community, middlement, processors


3.5.3 Company participated on implementing the regulation on their supply chain

Company to be pioneer on implementing regulation of effort reduction

Company Menerapkan peraturan pelarangan penggunaan sianida dan kompressor pada beberapa lokasi keramba sesuai dengan peraturan daerah yang ada (ex : Manggarai Barat)

3.6.1 workshop to other stakeholders on data collection

> The data collection methodology of stock assessment is trained to stakeholders > stakeholders committed to assist in data collection

P4KSI, BPPL, SDI, University, industry (direct from haji and buying companies)


3.6.2 Company participated on data collection for stock assessment by facilitating research activities and providing access to their production facilities (e.g. Logbook, interview, gonad sampling, etc)

Company to be pioneer on data collection support on the stock assessment for Reef fish in Indonesia

Company Has not been implemented, the involvement is minimum

3.6.3 P4KSI conduct data analysis and reporting

Report on stock productivity is available

P4KSI Has not been implemented

3.7.1 improve the existing observer/enumerator training module, especially on bycatch data recording (need to be detailed than the current data available)

Training module refined SDI, KKJI, P4KSI, University, PLN, KAPI, Agency of MAF in Province & District


3.7.2 training for observers/enumerator

Observers/enumerator have the capacity to conduct the data collection

P4KSI, BPPL Has not been implemented

3.7.3 Company participated on data collection for stock assessment by facilitating research activities and providing access to observer/enumerator work on their fishing and colecting boats, involving local university and community

Company to be pioneer on data collection support for bycatch through observer/enumerator mechanism

Company Applying the IBM system in cage is done directly by the head of the cage

Sharing data is not available

3.8.1 methodology on habitat monitoring system is identified and training conducted

> monitoring methodology identified > training conducted and human resources to conduct the monitoring available

KKJI, NGO, universities, Agency of MAF in Province & District and buyers/processors


3.8.2 Company participated on data collection for habitat monitoring

Company to be pioneer on data collection for habitat

Company Facilitating a team of researchers from UNDIP at several locations (Togean, Kei, Banggai sea) to carry out stock assessment methods SICA

The report is available

3.8.3 monitoring system conducted annually

annual report on habitat monitoring available and been used as part of reefs management

KKJI, NGO, universities, Agency of MAF in Province & District and buyers/processors

3.9.1 local university conducting the study

report on the effect of bottom longline and handline fisheries to the ecosystem is available

BPPL, Hasanudin University in Makassar

PSA-SICA report on reef fisheries provided

3.10.1 conducting the assessment review

review report available and been used to improve the management and research

Independent reviewer

4.1.1 Facilitate the establishment of PokMasWas, prepared with surveillance and monitoring plan on fishing practices (incl. Institutional and capacity building)

PokMasWas established, trained and functioned

PSDP, Agency of MMAF in province and district / POKMASWAS

KKP through PSDKP have a community watchdog groups are scattered throughout Indonesia. Pokmaswas data is available.

4.1.2 Monitor the performance of PokMasWas as part of management system

6 months regular report on the performance of POKMASWAS available

PSDP, Agency of MMAF in province and district / POKMASWAS

Data has not been obtained

4.1.3 Company develop policy to support the establishment and operation of PokMasWas

Company to be pioneer on the implementation of the POKMASWAS

Company Not yet fully implemented, still a part of the surveillance undertaken by the Government

4.2.1 Facilitate the government on improving the sanctions of regulations, improving the surveillance mechanism, and enforcement to law violations

Regulation is available on ensuring the violations of the law decreased

PSDP/MMAF Legal Department

4.2.2 Socialization of legislation on sanctions for Reef fish fisheries stakeholders

Legislation on sanctions are socialized to stakeholders harvesting at coastal Reef fish fisheries

PSDP/MMAF Legal Department, fishermen

4.2.3 Company develop policy on the implementation of the legislation

Company to be pioneer on the implementation of the legislation

Company Applying some of the rules related to sustainable fisheries in its cages

- Minimum size catch - Selective fishing gear - Prohibition of the use

of cyanide and compressors

4.3.1 Facilitate the training on surveillance to PokMasWas and PSDP in the provincial and districts

POKMASWAS and surveillance officers trained

DKP District, BPPL, WWF and processors

The report is not obtained by MSC

4.3.2 Facilitate the workplan synchronization with other surveillance stakeholders to improve the surveillance and enforcement

Workplan synchronized and support the collaborative surveillance

DKP District, BPPL, WWF and processors, all stakeholders

4.3.3 Training on management measures (e.g. target species, bycatch reduction and consequences of ecosystem interactions) for fishers: - using BMP for sustainable fishing practices - using BMP for increase high fish quality to reduce overfishing - using BMP for bycatch mitigation - traceability record

Fishermen capacity increased on sustainable fishing practices, resulting on: - improvement on sustainable fishing practices - increase high fish quality which led to reduce overfishing - bycatch ETP & juveniles reduced - IUU fishing reduction

Company BMP training has been carried out at several locations cages, for example in Selayar, Tolitoli, Togean

BMP limited print document and is still in the process of revision

4.3.4 Company develop policy on supporting enforcement officers work in the field

Company to be pioneer in supporting the enforcement activities by legal and community entity


4.4.1 Facilitate the collection of report on regulation compliance

Compilation report on regulation compliance across government levels is available

PSDP, Agency of MAF in province and district


4.4.2 Facilitate the report uploading to the MMAF website

6 months regular report available in MMAF website

PSDP, Agency of MAF in province and district

Link to the website : http://djpsdkp.kkp.go.id/

4.4.3 Company develop policy on supporting datac ollectiona dn report preparation on regulation violation

Company to be pioneer on supporting the surveillance for the fishery


http://djpsdkp.kkp.go.id/

been involved in the study on opportunity and challenge of fishery subsidy in Indonesia to support sustainable fishery

study report available PDN, PLN, BBRSE


Involve in the fisheries subsidy study

company to be pioneer in the fisheries subsidy study in Idnonesia

Company Has not been implemented UD Pulau Mas involves in the activities with WWF, particularly if there is visit and transparency in information sharing to all stakeholders.

UD Pulau Mas Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership · UD Pulau Mas Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership Summary of improvement developments by UD Pulau Mas (April 2017)

Documents