Top Banner
TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH TÜV SÜD Automotive Tire Test 2010 Benchmark Test Goodyear Ultragrip 8 205/55 R16 91 H Report No. 76244609 Test Period: December 2010
19

Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

Nov 22, 2014

Download

Automotive

Anton Frolov

Winter tires test made by TUV
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TÜV SÜD Automotive Tire Test 2010

Benchmark Test – Goodyear Ultragrip 8 205/55 R16 91 HReport No. 76244609

Test Period: December 2010

Page 2: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH Page 2

TEST TIRES:

DIMENSION: 205/55 R16 91 H M+S

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

TIRE DETAILS

GOODYEAR

ULTRAGRIP 8

CONTI

WINTERCONTACT TS830MICHELIN

ALPIN A4

Page 3: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH Page 3

SCOPE OF TESTS

Wet Performance

- Braking (ABS, low & high µ)

-Aquaplaning (straight-line & in curve)

- Handling

Dry Performance

- Braking (ABS)

- Handling

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

Snow & Ice Performance

- Braking (ABS)

-Traction (ASR)

- Handling (Snow)

- Lateral grip (Ice)

Page 4: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH Page 4

TEST DETAILS

Test Locations:

- Wet & Dry Performance: Goodyear PG Mireval (F)

- Ice & Snow Performance: Ice Rink Montpellier (F) & Test World Ivalo (Finland)

Acquisition and Evaluation of Results

- All tests were exclusively carried out by TÜV SÜD Automotive personnel

- Snow & ice tests were carried out twice

- Firstly, the performance of each tire is assessed relative to the best tire in each individual test (i.e. the performance of the

best tire ≙ 100%)

- Secondly, the performance of the Goodyear tire is assessed relative to the average performance of the two competitors (i.e. the

average performance of the competitors ≙ 100%)

- The conversion of the results into a percentage value is done in a way that >100% always means better, <100% means worse.

Test Vehicles

- Wet & Dry and Ice (indoor): VW Golf VI 1.4 TSI (160 hp / 118 kW)

- Ice(outdoor) & Snow: VW Golf VI 1.4 TSI (122 hp / 90kW)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

Page 5: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 5

BRAKING ON ICE

- ABS-braking, Test 1: Ice rink, artificial ice, Test 2: Ivalo, natural ice - indoor: 20 to 8 km/h, outdoor 25 to 5 km/h

- Ø Stopping distance of Goodyear Ultragrip 8 (corrected): 10.8m (indoor) , 16.5m (outdoor)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

96%

100%

101%

104%

ICE BRAKING PERFORMANCE (Ø TEST 1&2) (RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 6: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 6

TRACTION ON ICE

- Acceleration ASR, Test 1: Ice rink, artificial ice, Test 2: Ivalo, natural ice - indoor: 8 to 18 km/h, outdoor 10 to 25 km/h

- Ø Time / Acceleration of Goodyear Ultragrip 8: 4.57s / 0.61m/s² (indoor) , 4.74 s / 0.88 m/s² (outdoor)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

93%

100%

102%

107%

ICE TRACTION PERFORMANCE (Ø TEST 1&2) (RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 7: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 7

LATERAL GRIP ON ICE

- ESP off, Test 1: Ice rink, artificial ice, Test 2: Ivalo, natural ice - indoor: R= 9 m, outdoor R=25 m

- Ø Lap Time / Lat. Acceleration Goodyear Ultragrip 8: 19.1s / 0.98m/s² (indoor) , 22.1s / 2.03 m/s² (outdoor)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

94%

100%

101%

106%

LATERAL GRIP ON ICE (Ø TEST 1&2) (RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 8: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 8

BRAKING ON SNOW

- ABS-braking on compressed snow, double test - 50 to 5 km/h

- Ø Stopping distance of Goodyear Ultragrip 8 (corrected): 25.7m (test 1) , 26.7m (test 2)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTER CONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

99%

100%

101%

103%

SNOW BRAKING PERFORMANCE (Ø TEST 1&2) (RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 9: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 9

TRACTION ON SNOW

- ASR acceleration on compressed snow, double test - 10 to 30 km/h

- Ø Time / Acceleration of Goodyear Ultragrip 8: 2.65 s / 2.09 m/s² (test 1) , 2.72 s / 2.04 m /s² (test 2)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

98%

100%

102%

105%

SNOW TRACTION PERFORMANCE (Ø TEST 1&2) (RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 10: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 10

HANDLING ON SNOW

- ESP off (switch) - Subjective assessment & Lap times - Handling track with compressed snow, length 1300m

- Goodyear Ultragrip 8: Ø Speed : ~49.4 (test 1), 49.8 (test 2) km/h Ø Rating (out of max. 10): 8.2 (test 1) / 8.1 (test 2)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

99%

100%

101%

102%

SNOW HANDLING, OVERALL PERFORMANCE (Ø TEST 1&2) (RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 11: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 11

AQUAPLANING STRAIGHT-LINE

- Water depth: ~ 8 mm - Aquaplaning speed at 15% slip difference

- Ø Aquaplaning speed of Goodyear Ultragrip 8: 86.9 km/h

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

100%

100%

100%

101%

AQUAPLANING STRAIGHT-LINE

(RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 12: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 12

AQUAPLANING IN CURVES

- Water depth: ~ 8 mm - R = 100m - Result based on Lateral Acceleration at va, lat -1.5

- Remaining transferable lateral acceleration of Goodyear Ultragrip 8: 3.36 m/s²

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

1,50

2,00

2,50

3,00

3,50

4,00

50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85

Tra

nsf

erab

le

late

ral a

ccel

erat

ion

[m

/s²]

Speed [km/h]

GRAPHS OF LATERAL ACCELERATION

Theoretical Theoretical -1,5m/s² GOODYEAR

CONTI MICHELIN80% 90% 100%

MICHELINALPIN A4

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

GOODYEARULTRAGRIP 8

100%

100%

100%

116%

AQUAPLANING IN CURVE

(RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMP. = 100%)

Page 13: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 13

WET BRAKING high & low µ

- ABS-braking on two wet asphalt surfaces with different grip level - 80 to 20 km/h

- Ø Stopping distance of Goodyear Ultragrip 8 (corrected): 34.6m (high µ) , 40.4m (low µ)

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

98%

100%

102%

104%

99%

100%

101%

102%

WET BRAKING PERFORMANCE (RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)HIGH µ

LOW µ

Page 14: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 14

WET HANDLING

- ESP off (switch) - Subjective assessment & Lap times - Handling track with wet asphalt, length 1700m

- Goodyear Ultragrip 8: Ø Speed : ~82.4 km/h Ø Rating (out of max. 10): 8.3

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

99%

100%

101%

102%

WET HANDLING, OVERALL PERFORMANCE

(RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 15: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 15

DRY BRAKING

- ABS-braking on dry asphalt surface - 100 – 0 km/h

- Ø Stopping distance of Goodyear Ultragrip 8 (corrected): 44.3 m

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

99%

100%

100%

101%

DRY BRAKING PERFORMANCE

(RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 16: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH

TEST RESULTS

Page 16

DRY HANDLING

- ESP off (switch) - Subjective assessment & Lap times - Handling track with dry asphalt, length 3300m

- Goodyear Ultragrip 8: Ø Speed : ~82.4 km/h Ø Rating (out of max. 10): 8.3

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

80% 90% 100%

MICHELIN ALPIN A4

GOODYEAR ULTRAGRIP 8

AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS

CONTI WINTERCONTACT TS830

100%

100%

100%

100%

DRY HANDLING, OVERALL PERFORMANCE

(RELATIVE, AVERAGE OF COMPETITORS = 100%)

Page 17: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH Page 17

SUMMARY OF RESULTS (I)

Balance of Performance

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

Results relative to

the best tire (=100%)

in each test

GOODYEAR

ULTRAGRIP 8

CONTI

WINTERCONTACT

TS830

MICHELIN

ALPIN A4

BRAKING

ON ICE97% 92% 100%

TRACTION

ON ICE96% 87% 100%

LATERAL GRIP

ON ICE95% 89% 100%

BRAKING

ON SNOW100% 96% 98%

TRACTION

ON SNOW100% 93% 97%

HANDLING

ON SNOW100% 97% 99%

AQUAPLANING

STRAIGHT-LINE100% 99% 99%

AQUAPLANING

IN CURVE100% 86% 86%

WET BRAKING,

low µ100% 98% 94%

WET BRAKING,

high µ100% 100% 97%

WET HANDLING 100% 99% 98%

DRY BRAKING 100% 99% 100%

DRY HANDLING 99% 100% 99%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

BRAKING ON ICE

TRACTION ON ICE

LATERAL GRIP ON ICE

BRAKING ON SNOW

TRACTION ON SNOW

HANDLING ON SNOW

AQUAPL.STRAIGHT-LINE

AQUAPL.IN CURVE

WET BRAKING,low µ

WET BRAKING,high µ

WET HANDLING

DRY BRAKING

DRY HANDLING

GOODYEARULTRAGRIP 8

MICHELINALPIN A4

CONTIWINTERCONTACT TS830

Page 18: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH Page 18

SUMMARY OF RESULTS (II)

GY UG8 vs. Competitors

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

Results relative to the

average performance (=100%)

of the two competitors

GOODYEAR

ULTRAGRIP 8

Ø PERFORMANCE

OF COMPETITORS

BRAKING

ON ICE101% 100%

TRACTION

ON ICE102% 100%

LATERAL GRIP

ON ICE101% 100%

BRAKING

ON SNOW103% 100%

TRACTION

ON SNOW105% 100%

HANDLING

ON SNOW102% 100%

AQUAPL.

STRAIGHT-LINE101% 100%

AQUAPL.

IN CURVE116% 100%

WET BRAKING,

low µ104% 100%

WET BRAKING,

high µ102% 100%

WET HANDLING 102% 100%

DRY BRAKING 100% 100%

DRY HANDLING 100% 100%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

110%

BRAKING ON ICE

TRACTION ON ICE

LATERAL GRIP ON ICE

BRAKING ON SNOW

TRACTION ON SNOW

HANDLING ON SNOW

AQUAPL.STRAIGHT-LINE

AQUAPL.IN CURVE

WET BRAKING,low µ

WET BRAKING,high µ

WET HANDLING

DRY BRAKING

DRY HANDLING

GOODYEARULTRAGRIP 8

Ø PERFORMANCE OF COMPETITOR TIRES

Page 19: Tüv süd report UltraGrip8

TÜV SÜD Automotive GmbH Page 19

SUMMARY OF RESULTS (III)

SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS

Benchmark Test M+S – 2010 Report No. 76244609

BRAKING DISTANCES AND REMAINING SPEED

(corrected over the relative pro-/degression of the control or reference tire)

BRAKING SNOWGOODYEAR

ULTRAGRIP 8

AVERAGE OF

COMPETITORS

CONTI

WINTERCONTACT TS830

MICHELIN

ALPIN A4

Corrected distance 50 - 5 km/h (Test 1) 25,71 26,85 27,08 26,62

Remaining Speed (when GY UG 8 is 0) 0,00 10,23 11,25 9,22

Corrected distance 50 - 5 km/h (Test 2) 26,66 27,31 27,66 26,96

Remaining Speed (when GY UG 8 is 0) 0,00 7,38 9,51 5,25

Conclusion 1: The stopping distance of Goodyear UG8 is by average 1 meter shorter than the average stopping distance of the competitors in test.

Conclusion 2: When Goodyear Ultragrip 8 has stopped, the average speed of the competitors is still up to 10 km/h.

BRAKING WET, LOW µGOODYEAR

ULTRAGRIP 8

AVERAGE OF

COMPETITORS

CONTI

WINTERCONTACT TS830

MICHELIN

ALPIN A4

Corrected distance 80 - 20 km/h 40,42 42,02 41,15 42,90

Remaining Speed (when GY UG 8 is 0) 0,00 14,92 10,61 19,23

Conclusion 1: The stopping distance of Goodyear Ultragrip 8 is 1.6 meters shorter than the average stopping distance of the competitors in test.

Conclusion 2: When Goodyear Ultragrip 8 has stopped, the average speed of the competitors is still 15 km/h.

BRAKING WET, HIGH µGOODYEAR

ULTRAGRIP 8

AVERAGE OF

COMPETITORS

CONTI

WINTERCONTACT TS830

MICHELIN

ALPIN A4

Corrected distance 80 - 20 km/h 34,58 35,15 34,75 35,56

Remaining Speed (when GY UG 8 is 0) 0,00 9,38 5,49 13,26

Conclusion 1: The stopping distance of Goodyear Ultragrip 8 is 0.6 meters shorter than the average stopping distance of the competitors in test.

Conclusion 2: When Goodyear Ultragrip 8 has stopped, the average speed of the competitors is still 9 km/h.