TESLA (TSLA) TOYOTA (TM)
DOMESTIC ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
GDPPERSONAL INCOME
CPICORE CPI
UNEMPLOYMENT RATEPAYROLL EMPLOYMENT
CREDIT CARD PURCHASESENERGY PRICES
FED FUNDS RATECONSUMER CONFIDENCE
KEY INDICATORS +1.0% Q4 (Second Estimate)+0.5%-0.2% +0.3%4.9% Feb. 2016+259,000(p) Week Ending March 5+5.0%+47%UNCHANGED-5.7% (92)
EQUITIES & ESTIMATES
DJIANASDAQS&P 500
MSCI WORLDMSCI EMERGING MRKTS
WTD RESULTS % ∆
1.30.71.21.21.3
S&P 500 TARGET10 YR. T.BILLWTI CRUDE
GDP ESTIMATES %GLOBAL
USEUROZONE
EMERGING MARKETS
20002.0%$45.00-------3.22.01.54.2
ESTIMATES - ML
INDUSTRY ANALYSISAUTOMOTIVE
“Automotive Industry have been hit hard in recent months, with double-digit declines across the board. While equities in general have fared poorly, automakers
have been sunk by fears of a sales peak in the U.S. and slowing growth in China”
CHALLENGES Missing estimates for growth in China, -23% in industry since November 2015 v. S&P 500
Low fuel prices, new models attracting attention
Average car is 12 years old making an easy replacement, luxury car market provides hefty margins
China sales (Up 6% but below estimates)
GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES
NEAR FUTURE
METRICS TO WATCH
INDUSTRY FORECASTEmployees: total Nonfarm Payrolls v. Industry Sales
Multiple R .790152
R Square 0.6243409
P-value 0.0065286
y = 11.46x - 806233R² = 0.6243
$500,000.00
$550,000.00
$600,000.00
$650,000.00
$700,000.00
$750,000.00
$800,000.00
$850,000.00
$900,000.00
128000 130000 132000 134000 136000 138000 140000 142000 144000
REGRESSION SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression StatisticsMultiple R 0.790152488R Square 0.624340955Adjusted R Square 0.577383574Standard Error 39355.17361Observations 10
ANOVAdf SS MS F Significance F
Regression 1 20593095128 20593095128 13.29590675 0.006528675Residual 8 12390637518 1548829690Total 9 32983732646
Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P-value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 90.0% Upper 90.0%Intercept -806233.3488 427618.884 -1.885401648 0.096103593 -1792324.264 179857.5661 -1601411.205 -11055.49214X Variable 1 11.45958773 3.142751292 3.646355269 0.006528675 4.212390259 18.70678521 5.615490737 17.30368473
COMPANY ANALYSISTESLA – TSLA
TSLA
Growth RatesSales 23.5%Cash Flow NMFEarnings NMFDividends NILBook Value 16.5%
Liquidity/Financial Health
Current Ratio 0.99Quick Ratio 0.49Financial Leverage 7.43Debt/Equity 1.87
ProfitabilityAsset Turnover (Average) 0.58Return on Assets % -12.75Return on Equity % -88.84Return on Invested Capital % -21.59Interest Coverage -6.37
COMPANY ANALYSISTOYOTA - TM
TM
Growth RatesSales 4.5%Cash Flow 11.5%Earnings 22.50%Dividends 18.50%Book Value 4.50%
Liquidity/Financial HealthCurrent Ratio 1.10Quick Ratio 0.79Financial Leverage 2.83Debt/Equity 0.59
ProfitabilityAsset Turnover (Average) 0.60Return on Assets % 4.87Return on Equity % 13.86Return on Invested Capital % 6.17Interest Coverage 85.48
3 Year Valuation ModelTESLA
Tesla
3 Year Valuation Year Dividend Required Return Div PV
1 $- 1.124510000 $-
2 $- 1.26452274 0
Beta 1.30 3 $- 1.421968466 0.000000000
Rm 10.00% EPS*(1+EGR)^2*P/E - -Recent Dividend $-Risk Free Rate 1.83%
Required return 12.451%
DGR 0.00% Intrinsic Price $- Overvalued
EGR 0.00% Market Price $106.60 2/26/16
EPS (1.90)P/E -
Sensitivity AnalysisTesla-Market Cap 18.9($ Bil)
P/E Beta EGR DGR ROR Valuation Market $237.57 3 Year Valuation($4.92)Low 0.00 0.48 16.50% 0.00% 459.32% 141.00 -96.57 136.08Mean 0.00 0.60 16.50% 0.00% 528.74% 369.69 132.12 364.77High 0.00 1.30 16.50% 0.00% 917.70% 231.40 -6.17 226.48
P/E Beta EGR DGR
Valueline (Trailing/Past 10) -- 1.30 16.50%
Valueline (Median/Past5) -- 1.30 16.50%
Valueline (Forward/Est.) -- 1.30 16.50%
Morningstar (Current/1yr Gr) -- 0.48 15.58%
Morningstar (Forward) -- 0.48 15.58
Google Finance -- 0.56 15%
Mergent Online -- 0.48 15.60%
Yahoo Finance (Past) -- 0.48 15%
Yahoo Finance (Forward) -- 0.48 15%
3 Year Valuation ModelTOYOTA
Toyota
3 Year Valuation Year Dividend Required Return Div PV
1 $4.0000 1.095915000 $3.65
2 $5.6169 1.201029687 4.67673702
Beta 0.95 3 $6.6560 1.31622645 5.056900734
Rm 10.00% EPS*(1+EGR)^2*P/E 165.82 125.98
Recent Dividend $4.00
Risk Free Rate 1.83%
Required return 9.592%
DGR 18.50% Intrinsic Price $139.36 Undervalued
EGR 22.50% Market Price $106.60 2/26/16
EPS 13.00
P/E 8.5
Sensitivity AnalysisToyota-Market Cap 168($Bil)
P/E Beta EGR DGR ROR Valuation Market $135.40
3 Year Valuation$132.05
Low 7.60 0.60 7.00% 10.00% 988.60% 118.50 -16.90 -13.55Mean 9.05 0.68 13.00% 8.00% 1090.63% 135.80 0.40 3.75High 17.56 0.95 22.50% 6.00% 1424.70% 178.31 42.91 46.26
P/E Beta EGR DGR
Valueline (Trailing/Past 10) 8.70 0.90 7.00% 3.00%
Valueline (Median/Past5) NMF 0.90 13.00% 6.00%
Valueline (Forward/Est.) 8.50 0.95 22.50% 18.50%Morningstar (Current/1yr Gr) 8.00 0.60 12 3.40%
Morningstar (Forward) 7.60 0.62 13 1.90%
Google Finance 8.8 0.70 13.2 3.40%
Mergent Online 17.56 0.65 13 3.64
Yahoo Finance (Past) 8.2 0.60 8 3
Yahoo Finance (Forward) 7.89 0.61 8 3.05
DIVERSIFICATION
P-VALUE
MULTIPLE R
R SQUARE
BETA
VL-BETA
1.92742E-36
0.8310753
0.424833576
0.873518688
0.95
2.37675E-15
0.33039456
0.234173
.92
1.30