Top Banner
Transportation Cyber Security Edward Fok Federal Highway Administration – Resource Center Operations Technical Service Team [email protected]
52

Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

Jul 19, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Transportation Cyber SecurityEdward FokFederal Highway Administration – Resource CenterOperations Technical Service Team

[email protected]

Page 2: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Age of the Dinosaurs – IR Signal Preemption SystemsAge of the Dodo – Ethernet switches on broadband cable modem2008 - West Coast Toll tag vulnerability discovered2009 – Portable DMS Hack instruction online2010 - Hardcoded backdoor in field hardened Ethernet switch2010 – Unlimited Smart Parking Meters2011 - T3 Webinar on Cyber Security 2011 – Transit system targeted by Hacktivist & PII released2012 - Transit depot and transit vehicle control vulnerability discovered2012 - Contactless Transit pass vulnerability discovered2012 - Licensed public safety radio spectrum (4.9GHz)2012 - Train ticketing Kiosk and control system (Foreign)2012 - TRB Cyber Security Sub-committee formed2013 - Perception of privacy breach (East Coast Toll Tag hacked)2013 – ITE Journal article on Transportation Cyber Security2014 - Cellular connected Center to Field Network2014 - Wireless sensor interconnect2014 - Vendor specific traffic signal features2014 – Creation of FHWA Cyber Security Working Group2015 – ITE Article on Traffic Management Center Cyber Security Issues

Page 3: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

OMG HACKERS ARE EVERYWHERE!!!!3

It’s Hopeless!

Page 4: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 5: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 6: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

What are we trying to protectSafe surface operationEfficient surface mobilityReliable and trusted information to the public

Page 7: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 8: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

EDGE DEVICES

Page 9: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 10: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 11: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 12: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 13: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 14: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 15: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 16: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 17: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 18: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Hacking the Workld’s Traffic Control System

Page 19: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Payment Card Christchurch transport card

• Kiwicon7 – November, 2013• http://youtu.be/gB3EcBp34Xc

MARTA Breeze Card – December 27, 2013• https://www.myfoxatlanta.com

MiFare Ultralight cards continues to be a problem

Page 20: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Hacking Crowd Sourced Traffic DataMarch 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic

information (bh-eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

Page 21: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 22: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

NSA Playbook• Use radio waves to hack air gapped computer• Hack computer using a fake wireless connection• USB thumb drives to open a wireless connection

Page 23: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

CONNECTING EDGE DEVICES – TO EVERYONE ELSE…

Page 24: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Field NetworksWired – Copper, Fiber OpticsWireless• Leased – Cellular• Owned – APCO P25, 4.9GHz, DSRCTopology

Page 25: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 26: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 27: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 28: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 29: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 30: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 31: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

SUN_HACKERDynamic Message Sign HackMultiple States – at least 4 confirmed. There could be othersAttack took place over a 72 hour period (maximum)Twitter Handle: SUN_HACKER

• Claimed credit on both DMS sign and on Twitter• Twitter account originated from the Middle East• User name is an experienced Group 1 attacker

Automated Attack Tool maybe involvedFirst publicized foreign hack into domestic transportation system

Page 32: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 33: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Green Lights ForeverGraduate school class project partnered with Public AgencyPublished in USENIX Technical Proceeding – this is a penetration

test• Exploited vulnerabilities with Center to Field systems• Demonstrated remote control of signal controller• Unable to produce “Bruce Willis” or “The Italian Job” effect –

specifically confirm effectiveness of Conflict Monitor

Mass media did not read the paper – the world did not end

Page 34: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

PSA – ABOUT THEM PASSWORD…

Page 35: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

PIN numbers5 (9.21%) 6 (17.78%) 7 (7.28%)

PSWD PSWD PSWD12345 22.80% 123456 11.68% 1234567 3.44%11111 4.48% 123123 1.37% 7777777 1.72%55555 1.77% 111111 1.30% 1111111 0.64%

http://www.datagenetics.com/blog/september32012/

8 (11.26%) 9 (2.95%) 10 (1.52%)PSWD PSWD PSWD

12345678 11.83% 123456789 35.26% 1234567890 20.43%11111111 1.33% 987654321 3.66% 0123456789 2.32%

88888888 0.96% 123123123 1.59% 0987654321 2.27%

Page 36: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Source: Trustwave2013 Global Security Report

Page 37: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Back office/traffic management center..The chew center of the whole network…

Page 38: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

TransportationManagement CenterGeneral Office

USBCharging

Cable

Internal Network

Smartphones/PMP/USB Drives

Contractor

Office Administrative Network

Wireless Peripherals

Application Servers

Backup

Storage ArrayATIS/511Date Servers

DMS SignTrafficSignal

TrafficSignal

The Internet

Wireless Peripherals

Page 39: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 40: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 41: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

TransportationManagement CenterGeneral Office

USBCharging

Cable

Internal Network

Smartphones/PMP/USB Drives

Contractor

Office Administrative Network

Wireless Peripherals

Application Servers

Backup

Storage ArrayATIS/511Date Servers

DMS SignTrafficSignal

TrafficSignal

The Internet

Wireless Peripherals

Page 42: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

DMZ.

TransportationManagement CenterGeneral Office

Internal Network The Internet

Contractor

Office Administrative Network

Wireless Peripherals

Application Servers

Backup

Storage ArrayATIS/511 Date Servers

4.

1.

DMS SignTrafficSignal

TrafficSignal

IntrusionDetectionSystem

2.

3.

EncryptedConnection

PeripheralsData Diode

Page 43: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

So you engineered a “Perfect System”

Page 44: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Social Engineering• Hacking the human• Example – DEFCON 21 Social Engineering Capturer The Flag:

• Physical Logistics• Contractor information• Staff schedules• IT Equipment and software inventory• Helped to circumvent security to visit rogue website.• Obtained name of real company executive• All of this in about 10 minutes…

Page 45: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Evil…

Page 46: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 47: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

The Future…

Page 48: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Connected Vehicles

Page 49: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Page 50: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

“Look Mom No Hands” – hacker…

Page 51: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

Where to Get HELP!Multi-State Information Sharing & Analysis Center (MS-ISAC)

http://msisac.cisecurity.org

Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT)http://www.cert.orgDocument: Roadmap to Secure Control

Systems in the Transportation SectorVery good source on Insider Threat and

Prevention

Microsoft TechnetISO/IEC 27000Information Security Forum

“Standard of Good Practice”

Industrial Control Systerm-CERT Self Assessment

http://ics-cert.us-cert.gov/Assessments

National Institute of Standards and Technology

http://csrc.nist.gov/index.html

SANS Institutehttp://www.sans.orghttp://ics.sans.org

National Vulnerability Databasehttp://nvd.nist.gov

AntiVirushttp://av-comparatives.org/EICAR virus scanner tester

Page 52: Transportation Cyber Securitysp.scotsem.transportation.org/Documents... · March 12, 2013 Blackhat EU - Messing with Google and Waze traffic information (bh- eu-13-floating-car-data-jeske-wp.pdf)

August 13, 2015

2015 and still going strong!