8/9/2019 Translate P
1/26
PROPOSAL
DEVELOPMENT OF WORKSHEET BASED ON SCIENCE PROCESS
SKILL X GRADE SMA NEGERI 01 UNGGULAN KAMANRE
LUWU DISTRICT
RAHMAT HIDAYAT EDY
1112040175
PHYSICS DEPARTMENT
MATHEMATIC AND SCIENCE FACULTY
UNIVERSITAS NEGERI MAKASSAR
2014/2015
8/9/2019 Translate P
2/26
TITLE DEVELOPMENT OF WORKSHEET BASED ON SCIENCE
PROCESS SKILL X GRADE SMA NEGERI 01 UNGGULAN
KAMANRE LUWU DISTRICT
I! INTRODUCTION
A! B"#$%&'()*
One of purpose of national development is improve quality of human
resource for national development especially on educational development. It
was stated on fourth paragraph of opening of UUD 1945. he fragment of
fourth paragraph of opening of UUD 1945 is untuk memajukan
kesejahteraan umum, mencerdaskan kehidupan bangsa, dan ikut
melaksanakan ketertiban dunia .
!ualified "uman resource in glo#ali$ation age will #ecome main support
a nation on compete. %elation with it& education sector is one of main sector
to develop human resource qualified human resources. 'ased on Undang(
Undang )o. *+ of *++, contained a#out system of national education& article
1 paragraph 1 stated education is conscious and deli#erate effort to create an
atmosphere of learning and the learning process so that learners are actively
developing the potential for him to have a spiritual quality of religious& self(
control& personality& intelligence& no#le character& and s-ills needed him& the
community& the nation and the tate /0 %2 )DI3'UD %I )o. 5 ahun
*++, 16.
In line with this& government always gives effort to improve quality of
education among others with curriculum improvement& providing quality
#oo-s and increase teacher -nowledge through training and advance studies.
7ll of this is for improve quality of education.
3uri-ulum ing-at atuan 0endidi-an /3 06 is clearly descri#ed that
purpose of physics learning /') 0& *++ 16 is reali$e the #eauty and order of
nature to improve the #eliefs to 7lmighty 8od foster scientific attitude give
the e:perience to #e a#le to propose and test hypotheses through e:periments&
8/9/2019 Translate P
3/26
designed& and constructed e:perimental instruments& collect& process& and
interpret data& prepare reports& and communicate the results of the e:periment
orally and in writing develop the a#ility to thin- of inductive and deductive
analysis using the concepts and principles of physics to e:plain natural events
and resolve pro#lems #oth qualitatively and quantitatively master the
-nowledge& concepts and physical principles and have the s-ills to develop
the -nowledge and attitude of confidence and forming positive attitudes
towards physics with en;oy and reali$e the #eauty of nature and regularity of
#ehavior can e:plain the events of nature and #readth of application of
physics in technology.
tatement #efore is in line with 7rfiah /*+11 ,6 that stated physics
education should give attention to main goals& they are formal goal emphasis
on emphasis on the logical structuring and formation of attitudes and material
goals that emphasi$es the application of physics and physics s-ills. ome
aspects have affect to physics education success in Indonesian& they are
process of physics learning& physics learning device and assessment of
physics less optimal qualified of learning and assessment of learning
outcomes physics. One of pro#lem in physics education is qualified of
learning and teaching process was not optimal.
8/9/2019 Translate P
4/26
8/9/2019 Translate P
5/26
*.
8/9/2019 Translate P
6/26
2eanwhile& if viewed from its format& wor-sheet contain at least eight
components& they are title& #asic competence& deadline& apparatus or material&
short information& wor- procedure& tas- and report.
'ased on its -ind& wor-sheet consists into a several parts& they area. @or-sheet #ased on constructivism and it helps student finds
concept #. @or-sheet helps student apply and integrate many concept that they
-nown #efore.c. @or-sheet has function as learning guided. @or-sheet has function as concept strengthen
e. 0racticum wor-sheet /e:periment wor-sheet67ccording to 0rastowo /*+1, *116& this wor-sheet contains practicum
instruction that separated into separate #oo- and integrates it into #undle of
wor-sheet. o& in this wor-sheet& practicum instruction is one of its content of
wor-sheet. o ma-e it their own& so needed to -now the stages. tages to
ma-e wor-sheet according to DI3)7 in 0rastowo /*+1, *1*6 are
a. Do curriculum analysis #. 7rrange necessary map of student
c. Determine titles of wor-sheetd. 2a-e wor-sheet
tages have to do are
a.
8/9/2019 Translate P
7/26
must #e developed for student as mutual e:perience. 7nyway& understanding
of science concept is not only focus on product only& #ut process how to get
the concept is very important to #uild student?s -nowledge. cience s-ill and
science attitude has important role to get the science concept. tudents can
#uild new idea when they interact with a phenomenon. Idea and -nowledge
formation& student don?t depend on characteristics of o#;ect& #ut depend on
how student understand o#;ect or process the information till get and #uild a
new ideas too.
Definition of process s-ill according to @ahyana /in rianto& *++B A*6 is
s-ills that get from a fundamental mental& physics and social a#ility training
as motor of a#ility to higher level. Improved and trained #asic a#ility will
eventually #ecome a s-ill.
'ased on 0eraturan 2enteri 0endidi-an dan 3e#udayaan
/0 %2 )DI3'UD6 )o. 59 a#out high school curriculum on appendi: III
stated that learning principle #efore #ecome five main learning e:perience&
they are o#servation& as-ing& information collecting& association and
communication. very su#;ect has special characteristic when use learning
approach. cience su#;ect& included physics& more emphasi$es on
implementation of process s-ill. 7spects on scientific approach is integrated
on science process s-ill approach and scientific methods.
7ccording to 2cCollum /*++96 in 0 %2 )DI3'UD no. 59 on *+14 in
, rd appendi:& several aspects must #e noticed in teaching #y using scientific
approach is teacher must give learning that can foster a sense of wonder&
encourage o#servation& push for analysis and require communication.
udarwan /*+1,6 in 0 %2 )DI3'UD no. 59 on *+14 in , rd appendi:
e:plains further that scientific approach in learning involves o#servation&
as-ing question& analy$ing& presenting& concluding and creating aspects for
every o#;ect. 'ased on two opinions #efore& so scientific approach is done
through several steps& they are o#servation& as-ing& collecting information&
associating>interpreting and communicating.
8/9/2019 Translate P
8/26
cience process s-ill is set of s-ill that used #y researchers when do
scientific investigation. rained s-ill is -nown as nature science process s-ill.
American Association for the Advancement of Science /19A+6 in
0 %2 )DI3'UD no. 59 on *+14 in , rd appendi: classified into #asic
process s-ill and integrated process s-ill.
8/9/2019 Translate P
9/26
'ased on e:plaining #efore& it can #e concluded that science process s-ill
is s-ills that used #y student to do scientific activities along teaching and
learning process activities happening.
C! P # W'&$ -- B" -* ') S# -)#- P&'#- S$ ,,
@or-sheet will #e developed #y researchers is physics wor-sheet
orientated on student?s s-ill. In line with e:plaining #efore that wor-sheet is
sheets fill wor- instructions when doing some scientific activities for student&
so physics wor-sheet is sheets fill wor- instructions when doing some
scientific activities on physics su#;ect for student. cience process s-ill is
s-ill that used #y student to do scientific activities along learning and
teaching process happening.
cience process s-ill consists of two s-ills they are #asic process s-ill
and integrated process s-ill. cience process s-ill consists of ten s-ills they
are o#servation s-ill& classification s-ill& interpretation s-ill& prediction s-ill&
as-ing question s-ill& hypothesis formulation s-ill& e:periment planning s-ill&
apparatus and material using s-ill& concept implementation s-ill and
communication s-ill. 7ll of science process s-ill will #e used #y student
when do scientific activities along learning and teaching process happening.
In conclusion& physics wor-sheet #ased on science process s-ill is sheets
fill wor- instruction when do scientific activities on physics su#;ect for
student which sheets ma-ing was oriented on science process s-ill
D! D-3-,'6.-) M'*-, ' W'&$ --
%esearch and development is a relative new concept in education aspect.
cience can #e assumed as a strategy to find out a#stract -nowledge and it
was called theory. @hile& development is organi$ed implementation of
-nowledge to help to solve the pro#lem in society included in education
aspect. 7 interesting question appears for researchers& given current research
and development #ecomes a popular research method and many chosen as
research method for every aspect& included education aspect. %esearch is
collecting& processing& analy$ing& and serving data activity which do
systematically and o#;ectively to solve a pro#lem or want to test a hypothesis
8/9/2019 Translate P
10/26
for develop general principle& while development is process or method which
do to develop something #ecome good and perfect. If research mean and
development mean is related into a unity word& it is research and
development& so it can #e mean as Ecollecting& processing& analy$ing& and
serving data activity which done systematically and o#;ectively and
accompanied with development a product to solve a pro#lem.%esearch and development has goal to produce a new product or
complete an old product and it can #e accounted. 0roduct mustn?t hardware
#ut it can #e invisi#le thing or software. 0roduct /in education aspect6 can #e
a learning model& learning multimedia or learning device& li-e teaching plan&
#oo-& wor-sheet& question and etc or it can #e implementation of learning
theory with com#ine development of learning device. If research and
development has goal to produce product so very clear this product is
researched o#;ect from #eginning till the end& while if do a testing in class& so
student is research su#;ect. o& focus point of research e:actly on research
o#;ect. o when ta-e some decision is not going anywhere #ut stay on
developed product /research o#;ect6.2ain goal from research and development is to develop effective model
or product to fulfill a necessary of definite program on definite instance too.
)e:t& to ma-e product of research and development is still on its goal& so
model and product is testing in real case. 7fter that& it is revised #ased on
discovery from preliminary study and advice from the e:pert. In line #efore&
hiagara;an et. al. present 4D model for a research and development& it is
definition& design& development and dissemination /Upu& *++56.
7ccording to hiagara;an et. al. / rianto& *++A6 development model
consist of four stages& it is definition& design& development dan dissemination&
so this model usually is called as 4D model or adapted into 4(0 model& and it
is pendefenisian& perancangan& pengem#angan dan pendesiminasian.
tages of 4D model e:plain more on #elow
a. Define stagehis stage is analysis of necessary or pro#lem stage. 8oal of this
stage is fi: and define of learning requirement in development of learning
8/9/2019 Translate P
11/26
model or product. In fi: and define learning requirement is started from
goals from #order of developed matter or learning product. #. Design stage
8oal of this stage is to prepare prototype of design model or learning
product.c. Develop stage
8oal of this stage is to produce a revised learning model or product
#ased on advice from the e:pert. his stage is validate the learning model
or product which after designed #y e:perts and revision and testing on
real student.
d. Disseminate stagehis stage is using model or product stage after developing in large
scale. 7nother goal is to test affectivity of model or model using in
learning and teaching process.
8/9/2019 Translate P
12/26
C! D- ) ') ' O6-&" ')", V"& "+,-
o prevent misconception& so research varia#le operationally is defined
into
1. 0hysics wor-sheet #ased on science process s-ill is learning device
in wor-sheet form and it fills information to do scientific activities
#ased on science process s-ill for student.*. Development model to produce physics wor-sheet #ased on science
process s-ill follows development model of device which famous #y
hiagara;an.
,. cience process s-ill is process s-ills that include o#servation&classification& interpreting& predicting& as-ing question& formulating
hypothesis& planning e:periment& using apparatus and material&
implementation concept and communication /ad;usted to matter6.4. 0hysics wor-sheet is valid when data of calculation result of total
average 2 from e:pert and practitioner to physics wor-sheet in valid
categories.5. 0hysics wor-sheet is practice when evaluation from e:pert and
practitioner that physics wor-sheet can #e applied& according too#servation result of learning device accomplished in good or very
good categories.. 0hysics wor-sheet is effective when fulfill , categories of
effectiveness. hese categories are achievement of la# performance
result is minimal B+F student reach minimal A5 of 1++ point
/D 0DI3)7 & *++ 6& student activities along practicum activity
fulfill criteria of time tolerance has #een determine and more than
5+F student give positive response for A+F whole as-ed aspect in
physics wor-sheet.
D! R- -" P&'#-*(&-
Development of physics wor-sheet #ased on science process s-ill refers
to 4D model. his model consists of four stages& they are define& design&
develop& and disseminate or adapted into 40 model& and they are
pendefenisian& perancangan& pengem#angan dan pendiseminasian. %esearcher
chose this model and gives some modification of development to wor-sheet.
8/9/2019 Translate P
13/26
:planation of development of physics wor-sheet is consisted of several
stages& they are
1. Define stage8oal of this stage is to plan physics wor-sheet and it is determining
matter and analy$ing #oundaries of matter of physics wor-sheet that will
#e developed. In this stage& there is literature review and it includes
characteristics review of science process s-ill& reference a#out a good
physics wor-sheet. teps of this stage are curriculum analysis& student
analysis and concept analysis.
a. Curriculum analysisCurriculum analysis has goal to ma-e it in line with current
curriculum with characteristics view of physics wor-sheet. In this
case& characteristics of physics wor-sheet #ased on science process
s-ill will #e lined with demands of -uri-ulum *+1,. %esult of
curriculum analysis is made a view to develop physics wor-sheet
#ased on science process s-ill. #. tudent analysis
tudent analysis is very important on early planning and it is
reviewing a#out characteristics of student which in line with plan
and development of physics wor-sheet. his analysis will #e done
with notice on age and maturity level& a#ility to wor- together and
science process s-ill. In this research& generally& analysis su#;ect is
student of G grade of 27 )egeri +1 Unggulan 3amanre study year
*+14>*+15c. Concept analysis
Concept analysis has goal to identify main concept that will #edeveloped on physics wor-sheet& arrange and specify the concept
systematically and detail and ma-e relation a concept to another
relevant. 2ain concept which identified on physics wor-sheet #ased
on science process s-ill for static fluid matter #ase on -uri-ulum
*+1,.*. Design stage
8oal of this stage is matter preparation that can #e made into a
physics wor-sheet #ased on science process s-ill and format preparation
8/9/2019 Translate P
14/26
of physics wor-sheet that will #e made. 7fter matter and format
preparation so ne:t is physics wor-sheet #ased on science process s-ill
ma-ing that ready to #e developed. In this stage& it is arranging physics
wor-sheet. 7rranging physics wor-sheet #ased on student s-ill #ase on
science process s-ill. 0hysics wor-sheet from this stage is called draft I.,. Develop stage
Develop stage has goal to produce physics wor-sheet #ased on
science process s-ill after revision #ased on e:pert advices. In this stage&
physics wor-sheet from design stage will #e validated #y e:perts. @ith
suggestion and opinion from e:perts& first draft will #e analy$ed andrevised till #ecome second draft. )e:t& second draft will #e revised after
do testing on school. 'y e:perience from physics wor-sheet testing so
second draft will #e analy$ed and revised again till produce third draft
where third draft is physics wor-sheet is ready to use and limited test.4. Disseminate stage
his stage is physics wor-sheet using stage after developed in
limited scale. 8oal of this stage is to test affectivity of physics wor-sheet
when use it on learning and teaching activity& mainly on e:perimentcondition and in this research will end on disseminate stage with limited
test.Development stage of physics wor-sheet can #e figured into
8/9/2019 Translate P
15/26
D- ) ')Curriculum& student and concept analysis
D- %)
8/9/2019 Translate P
16/26
E! I) &(.-) ' R- -"
Instrument of data collection is used to get information a#out
characteristic of physics wor-sheet& activity of student when practicum&
carried out of physics wor-sheet& response of validation result #y e:perts and
response of student to physics wor-sheet. =ater& Instruments will #e used
when do research are validated and revised instrument #y e:perts.
Instruments in this research are validation sheet& o#servation sheet and
questionnaire of student response. :planation of these instruments for
research on following
1. Halidation sheethis instrument is used to validate physics wor-sheet #ased on
science process s-ill. Halidation result from e:perts is suggestions and
opinions from e:perts that will #e used to revise physics wor-sheet.
'eside it& e:perts will fill conclusion column generally a#out physics
wor-sheet which is on very good& good& o- or #ad categories.*. O#servation sheet
O#servation sheets that used on research are o#servation sheet of
student activity and o#servation sheet of wor-sheet accomplished.a. O#servation sheet of student activity
O#servation sheet of student activity is used when do practicum
testing on physics wor-sheet. his o#servation fills assessment
ru#ric of e:periment activity to o#serve science process s-ills of
student along do e:periment or practicum. #. O#servation sheet of wor-sheet accomplished
O#servation sheet of wor-sheet accomplished is used to get data
on real condition a#out developed wor-sheet. Data of wor-sheetaccomplished is get after giving o#servation sheet to o#server when
o#serve accomplished aspect or component of wor-sheet when
teacher does science activity in line with given instruction,. eacher response sheet to physics wor-sheet
7fter using physics wor-sheet is used #y teachers when do limited
testing& so needed to #e -now teacher response to wor-sheet what they
used in learning process too.
8/9/2019 Translate P
17/26
characteristics of wor-sheet& wor-sheet affectivity when used and result
after using wor-sheet to student.4. tudent response sheet to physics wor-sheet
his questionnaire is used to collect data a#out response of student to
practicum activity and developed wor-sheet. tudent gives chec- sign on
given column for every question. !uestionnaire is given to student when
end of practicum.
F! T-# ) 8(- ' *" " ")",
8/9/2019 Translate P
18/26
b. Calculate average of assessment result of e:perts for every
criteria #y this formula
K i= j= 1
n
V ij
n& with
K i average of i th criteriaV ij score of assessment result to i th criteria #y ; th e:pert
n num#er of e:pertc. Calculate average for every aspect #y this formula
Ai= j= 1
n
K ij
n
& with
A i average of i th aspect
K ij average of i th aspect #y ; th criterian num#er of criteria in i th aspect
d. Calculate average of total / X 6 #y this formula
X = j= 1
n
Ai
n& with
X average of total A i average of i th aspect
n num#er of aspecte. Determine category of validation for every criteria
K i or
average of aspect Ai or average of total X with category
of validity has #een determined f. Categories of validity are
,.5 J 2 K 4 very valid*.5 J 2 K , valid1.5 J 2 K * less valid2 K 1.5 not valid /)urdin& *++A 1446
Information2 K i to find validity of criteria2
A i to find validity of aspect2 X to find of every categoryCriteria that used to determining physics wor-sheet has enough
validity coefficient is
X for all of aspect is minimal on valid
categories and all of aspect is minimal on very valid categories. If
not& so need to #e revised #ased on suggestions from e:pert or
8/9/2019 Translate P
19/26
review on lac- aspect. )e:t& it will #e revalidated and then
reanaly$ed till reach score of 2 is minimal on valid categories
%elia#ility of o#servation s-ill of student activity and response sheet
of physics wor-sheet will use formula of percentage of agreements
/8rinnel in 7rdat& *+1+ 496.
R= agreements ( A)disagreements ( D )+agreements ( A)
x 100
@ith
7 num#er of agreement frequency #etween two o#server
D num#er of disagreement frequency #etween two o#server
% coefficient of relia#ility of instrument
Data of percentage of agreements /%6 will #e conversed #y using
criteria& they are
% K *+F very low relia#ility
*+F J % K 4+F low relia#ility
4+F J % K +F standard relia#ility
+F J % K B+F high relia#ility
B+F J % K 1++F very high relia#ility
Criteria of o#servation sheet of student activity are relia#le if its
relia#ility is on high or very high relia#ility /8uilford& 19AB 5A6.
*. Data analysis of practicality of physics wor-sheetData analysis of practicality of physics wor-sheet is supported hy
result of data analysis of wor-sheet accomplished. 0rocess of data
analysis of wor-sheet accomplished is calculate average of o#servation
result from two o#servers for every criteria K i or average for every
aspect A i or average of total
X & and then determine category of
validity for every criteria& validity for every aspect and validity of total
#ased on criteria according to )urdin /*++A 1446& they are1.5 J 2 K * accomplished entirely /get enough6+.5 J 2 K 1.5 partially accomplished /less than enough62 K +.5 not accomplished /not enough6
@ith
8/9/2019 Translate P
20/26
2 A i to find validity for every aspect
2
X to find validity for all of aspectCriteria that used to e:ecute physics wor-sheet has accomplished
coefficient is Ai and X minimal on partially accomplished& it
means physics wor-sheet will not revised )e:t& count relia#ility of wor-sheet assessment #y using percentage
of agreement formula
R= agreements ( A)disagreements ( D )+agreements ( A)
x 100
@ith
7 num#er of agreement frequency #etween two o#server
D num#er of disagreement frequency #etween two o#server
% coefficient of relia#ility of instrument
Data of percentage of agreements /%6 will #e conversed #y using
criteria& they are
% K *+F very low relia#ility
*+F J % K 4+F low relia#ility
4+F J % K +F standard relia#ility
+F J % K B+F high relia#ility
B+F J % K 1++F very high relia#ility
Criteria of o#servation sheet of student activity and response sheet of
physics wor-sheet is relia#le if it relia#ility in high or very high category
/% L +. +6 /8uilford& 19AB 5A6.,. Data analysis of affectivity of wor-sheet
Data analysis of affectivity of wor-sheet is supported #y result of
data analysis from * components of affectivity they are student activity
and achievement of la# performance.
8/9/2019 Translate P
21/26
Indicator of student activity is si$ed with categories on followingB+F ( 1++F high
+F ( A9F normalJ +F low
4. Data analysis of student activity7nalysis of o#servation result of student activity is a#out calculate
using relevant facts.
* Classification
2a-ing notes for every o#servation separately.
8/9/2019 Translate P
22/26
)o. indicators u#(indicators of science process s-ill
3nowing reasons why using apparatus>materials-nowing how to use apparatus>material.
9Conceptimplementation
Using concept that had #een learned in newcondition.
Using concept on new e:perience to e:plain whathappen now
1+ Communication
Changing form of serving Descri#ing empirical data of o#servation s-ill or
o#servation with graphic or ta#le or diagramarranging and delivering report systematicallye:plaining o#servation or e:periment resultreading graphic or ta#le or diagram discussingactivity result a#out a pro#lem or a phenomenon.
/0 %2 )DI3'UD %I )o. 59 on *+14 appendi: , a#out 3(1, in 276
materials 15 minutes 45 seconds9 7pplying concept * minutes seconds
1+ communicating 15 minutes 45 seconds
otal 9+ minutes *A+ seconds
8/9/2019 Translate P
23/26
a. Do recap o#servation result of wor-sheet accomplished for
every aspect #. Calculate average for every o#servation aspect in every meeting
with formula
Ai= j= 1
n
K ij
n@ith
Ai 7verage of i th aspect in practicum K ij ith o#servation result ; th criteria
n num#er of criteria in i th aspect
c. Calculate average of total #y this formula
X = j= 1
n
Ai
n& with
X average of total A i average for i th aspect
n num#er of aspect
d. Determine category of accomplished for every aspect or whole
aspects with comparing average for every aspect or average of
total with determining categoriese. Category of accomplished for every aspect or whole aspect
wor-sheet accomplished according to )urdin /*++A 14461.5 J 2 K * accomplished entirely /get enough6+.5 J 2 K 1.5 partially accomplished /less than enough62 K +.5 not accomplished /not enough6
@ith
2
A i to find validity for every aspect
2 X to find validity for whole aspect. 7nalysis of student response
Data a#out student response is get from questionnaire of student
response to practicum activity and the analy$ed with percentage.
7ctivities that done to data analysis of student response are
a. Calculate num#er of student who give positive response in line
with as-ed aspect and then calculate its percentage. #. Determine category for positive response of student with
compare percentage result with determining criteria.
8/9/2019 Translate P
24/26
c. If analysis result that student response is not positive& so done
revision to developed wor-sheet7nalysis to calculate percentage of num#er of student that gives
response for every as-ed category in questionnaire #y this formula
PRS = A B
100
@ith
0% percentage of num#er of student who give positive response
for every as-ed category.
7 proportion of student that chosen.
' num#er of respondent.
Determine criteria to e:plain that every student who has positive
response to wor-sheet is more than 5+F student give for A+F given
aspect. 0ositive response of student to wor-sheet is achieved if criteria of
positive response to student to wor-sheet are fulfilled.
A.
8/9/2019 Translate P
25/26
REFERENCES
7rdat. *+1+. 0engem#angan perang-at pem#ela;aran #er#asis teori gagne dalamupaya mening-at-an -eterampilan proses sains fisi-a pada peserta didi- -elasG 27 )egeri 1+ 2a-assar. Tesis tida- diter#it-an. 0rogram 0ascasar;anaU)2 2a-assar
7rfiah. *+11. 0engem#angan perang-at pem#ela;aran fisi-a model -ooperatif tipetudent eams 7chievement Division / 7D6 pada siswa -elas G di 27)
1 anete %ilau. Tesis tida- diter#it-an. 0rogram 0ascasar;ana U)22a-assar.
7ri-unto& uharsimi. Dasar Dasar !valuasi "endidikan . Ma-arta 'umi 7-sara
'adan tandar )asional 0endidi-an tahun *++ tentang standar isi untu- se-olahdasar dan se-olah menengah
'org and 8all. 19B9. !ducational #esearch . )ew Nor- 0inancing.
Dimyati dan 2ud;iono. *++9. $elajar dan "embelajaran . Ma-arta %ine-a Cipta
8rinnel& %ichard 2. 19BB. Social %ork and !valuation & rd !dition. Canada
8/9/2019 Translate P
26/26
Rustaman, N.Y. 2005. Strategi Belajar Mengajar Biologi. Malang: UniversitasNegeri Malang.
amsudin& 7.& uhendi& .& fendi& %.& uhandi& 7. *+1*. 0engem#anganE*els dalam -sperimen