TOXIC BOTTLES? CHAPTER 3 INFORMATION LITERACY On the trail of chemicals in our everyday lives.

TOXIC BOTTLES?

CHAPTER 3 INFORMATION LITERACY

On the trail of chemicals in our everyday lives

Do Now

1. 1. Obtain a copy of “But It’s Just a Bottle of Water…”

2. 2. Read Part I.

3. 3. Answer the question on page 2. (please be specific)

4. 4. Share your answer with a neighbor.

5. 5. Share your answer with the class.

3/27/12

Toxins are chemicals that cause direct damage upon exposure.

Toxins fall into two categories, natural and synthetic.

NATURAL TOXINS ARE NOT ALWAYS SAFE.

Arsenic, a basic element, can cause cancer and nervous

system damage in humans.

Synthetic toxins are a problem because many are persistent chemicals—they don’t readily

degrade over time.

According to the EPA:

1,000-2,000 new chemicals enter the market each year

More than 80,000 chemicals are used in the United States

Regulation of toxins begins with risk assessment—a

careful weighing of the risks and benefits associated with any given chemical.

Federal agencies (FDA, EPA) are mandated with protecting us

from harmful chemicals. They can heavily regulate or ban those deemed dangerous.

In 2008, the National Toxicology Program (NTP) analyzed studies

about Bisphenol A, or BPA, which is used in metal food cans and many

plastic products.

NTP stated it had “some concern” about the effects of BPA exposure on brain,

behavior, and prostate glands in fetuses, infants,

and children.

Canada and the European Union had recently banned

the use of BPA in baby bottles and baby food cans.

Most NTP panelists felt the data were too uncertain to

warrant a ban, but they applied the precautionary principle, saying it would

be prudent for industries to look for a BPA replacement.

Toxicologists create a dose-response curve to track the

effects of a dose of a chemical, such as BPA.

Toxicologists use this curve tocalculate the LD50 (lethal dose50%), the dose that would kill

50% of the population.

The lower the LD50, the more toxic the substance. In this example, Substance A is the more toxic

substance.

What is the LD50 of Substance B?a) 10 ppmb) 31ppmc) 17ppmd) 7ppm

Clicker Question

Dose (ppm)

5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Per

cent

age

of te

st p

opul

atio

n k

illed

by

dose

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Substance ASubstance B

Which substance is most toxic?a) Substance

Ab) Substance

Bc) Substances

A & B are equally as toxic

Clicker Question

Dose (ppm)

5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Per

cent

age

of te

st p

opul

atio

n k

illed

by

dose

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Substance ASubstance B

BPA is an endocrine disruptor:It mimics a hormone or preventsa hormone from having an effect

Endocrine disruptors have different effects at low and

high doses, so dose-response curves and LD50s are trickier to

calculate—and a “safe dose” is harder to

determine.

As scientists debated the safety of BPA, and

regulatory agencies struggled, people were left

to decide whether they should purge BPA from their

lives.

We can use critical thinking skillsto analyze reports on potential

toxins and help us determine whatsteps we should take to be safe.

To make decisions, we need toknow whether a chemical hasthe potential to harm us and

how great that harm might be.

First, we need to evaluate thesource of the information about

the chemical.

Next, we need to look for logical fallacies in arguments or claims about the chemical, so we

won’t be misled.

3/27/12

3/27/12

Be skeptical. Require evidencebefore accepting a claim as

reasonable.

Evaluate the evidence:

• Did the researchers look at human populations?

• How relevant are the studies?

• Is the claim from actual scientific studies?

Be open-minded. Identify your own biases or pre-conceived

notions and follow the evidence where it takes you.

Watch out for biases:

• Is the author promoting a specific position?

• Are they financially tied to a specific conclusion?

• Are they trying to support a predetermined conclusion?

There are rarely easy answers and

science is never as straightforward as we would like

it to be.

We are constantly uncovering new information and as our understanding

grows, existing information often becomes obsolete.

Science is incremental: Each study is a piece of the puzzle.

“Sometimes, if there’s enough momentum from the public,

regulatory change will follow. But more often than not, because of

the way the system works, it really has to start with individual

consumers deciding for themselves that they won’t

purchase or use certain items.”

--Sarah Vogel