Israeli attacks on Palestinian olive groves kept top secret by state Olive orchards are being destroyed in the West Bank, but defense and media officials have agreed yet again that everything should be done to respect the public's right not to know. By Amira Hass Olive trees damaged in the West Bank village of Jalud. Photo by Guy / Taayush A document obtained by Haaretz details a series of incidents that have been kept confidential. Defense officials are content that the information has been kept secret for so long and that the leak of a few details on social media hasn't caused a fuss. The officials clearly appreciate reporters' responsibility and restraint on the issue - they haven't exploited the right of freedom of information. The following are the incidents in the secret document - all of them in the West Bank in September and October. Sept. 11: 500 trees burned on land belonging to the village of Deir al-Khatab. Sept. 15: 17 olive trees chopped down on land belonging to the village of Kafr Laqif. Sept. 17: 18 olive trees chopped down on land belonging to the village of Kafr Laqif. Sept. 20: 27 olive trees burned in Kafr Qaddum. Sept. 21: 70 trees chopped down in Kafr Qaddum.
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Israeli attacks on Palestinian olive groves kept top secret by state
Olive orchards are being destroyed in the West Bank, but defense and media
officials have agreed yet again that everything should be done to respect
the public's right not to know.
By Amira Hass
Olive trees damaged in the West Bank village of Jalud.Photo by Guy /
Taayush
A document obtained by Haaretz details a series of incidents that have beenkept confidential. Defense officials are content that the information has been
kept secret for so long and that the leak of a few details on social media
hasn't caused a fuss. The officials clearly appreciate reporters' responsibility
and restraint on the issue - they haven't exploited the right of freedom of
information.
The following are the incidents in the secret document - all of them in the
West Bank in September and October.
Sept. 11: 500 trees burned on land belonging to the village of Deir al-Khatab.
Sept. 15: 17 olive trees chopped down on land belonging to the village of Kafr
Laqif.
Sept. 17: 18 olive trees chopped down on land belonging to the village of Kafr
list's last item, the date provided isn't the date on which the attack took
place. It's the date when the vandalism was discovered.
A letter from Rabbis for Human Rights and the Yesh Din human rights group
details these incidents through October 7. The letter was sent on October 9 to
the commanders of the IDF brigades in the West Bank - colonels Avi Balut,Yossi Pinto, Ran Kahane and Yoav Marom - as well as to the legal adviser to
the West Bank division, Doron Ben-Barak. The letter accuses the commanders
of failing to fulfill their obligation to protect the Palestinian farmers and their
property. The IDF Spokesman's Office said it would respond directly to the
letter's authors, not to the media.
Some of the commanders who are due to finish their service soon will have
copied the confidential information into their personal diaries, which must be
full of similar confidential information from previous years. Shortly after they
take off their uniforms, they'll tell the cameras that they always wereconcerned that these unreported attacks would ultimately trigger an
explosion. When they're asked why they didn't say this during their service,
they'll cite the cognitive dissonance between the oath they took as soldiers
and social-historical truth and common sense.
Their oath as soldiers was to protect Jewish citizens of Israel wherever and
whatever the circumstances. Their oath as commanders was also to protect
Israeli soldiers wherever and whatever the circumstances. But social-historical
truth and common sense attest that violence by Jewish Israeli citizens invites a
response and additional violence. Social-historical truth also proves that thosein uniform who dominate a population that did not elect them as their rulers
are violent in their mere presence, even when they aren't killing or injuring,
even when it's only serial armed robbery of land and the protection of
robbers.
In retirement, the army commanders will say that their oath overrode
common sense, requiring them to nullify the Jewish violence with the best
postmodern tools that have been developed in the IDF's consciousness-
engineering laboratories.
Meanwhile, in a secret meeting that might have taken place, defense and
media officials might have agreed that the grove attacks can't be defined as
a quiet - or noisy - escalation because the attacks have been happening for
years at more or less the same frequency and intensity. They might have
agreed that as long as these attacks aren't spoken about on our side, they
don't exist and other events have nothing to do with them. The officials must
have decided that everything should be done to respect the public's desire