Board Orientation Toolkit Page 1 Board Orientation Toolkit Board orientation is a core competency of the chief paid executive (executive director.) The toolkit provides processes and examples to aid in communicating the role and responsibilities of volunteer leaders. Contents About the Toolkit ............................................................................................................. 3 Governance Definition ................................................................................................. 3 Planning the Orientation .................................................................................................. 3 Orientation Schedule ................................................................................................... 4 Board Roles and Responsibilities.................................................................................... 5 Purpose of a Board ...................................................................................................... 5 The Partnership ........................................................................................................... 6 Board Names ............................................................................................................... 6 Duties........................................................................................................................... 6 Obedience ................................................................................................................ 6 Loyalty ...................................................................................................................... 7 Care .......................................................................................................................... 7 Directors’ Responsibilities ............................................................................................ 7 Leadership Notebook ................................................................................................... 9 Board Commitment ...................................................................................................... 9 Cultural Expectations ................................................................................................. 10 The Budget ................................................................................................................ 10 High Performing Boards ............................................................................................. 10 Underperforming Directors ......................................................................................... 11 Frequently Asked Questions ......................................................................................... 12 How Big Should the Board Be?.................................................................................. 12 How Often do Boards Meet? ...................................................................................... 12 8/25/2013 12:19 PM Tookit Board Orientation 5-27-12.docx
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 1
Board Orientation Toolkit
Board orientation is a core competency of the chief paid executive (executive director.)
The toolkit provides processes and examples to aid in communicating the role and
responsibilities of volunteer leaders.
Contents About the Toolkit ............................................................................................................. 3
Cultural expectations describe board expectations that have developed over time and
are not part of official governing documents.
• Meeting attendance is very important. Please allocate time to attend and be prepared to discuss the business of the organization.
• Each member will be heard; no one will dominate the discussion.
• If you have a conflict and must miss a meeting, please contact staff so that your absence is noted as “excused.”
• To make the most efficient use of your time, the meeting will start on time and be conducted as efficiently as possible.
• Boards/committees will focus on the objectives and strategies assigned to them.
• All members and their opinions are viewed as equal. Decisions are made based on the consensus of the group.
• Members will speak freely and in turn, as recognized by the meeting chair.
• Members will listen carefully to others’ comments.
• Only issues may be discussed, analyzed or critiqued – not members or staff personalities.
• Complaints must be accompanied with solutions.
• Silence equals agreement. The place to comment on the issues is inside the board meeting – not outside in the parking lot or through a barrage of emails after the meeting. Even if you disagree in the board room, outside the meeting the board of directors are a united front publically supporting all decisions of the board.
• The president and/or designated staff are the spokesperson(s) for the organization; nobody has authority to speak for or contract on behalf of the organization without explicit authority.
• The meeting chair has the authority to enforce these rules as well as policies.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 23
Terminology
Note: The terminology is not all encompassing definitions; rather they are merely to
provide broad understanding. Please consult with other references and professionals
It takes a partnership of the chief elected officer (often called chairman or president of
the board) and the chief paid officer (often titled executive director, executive VP,
administrator or president) to lead an exempt, not-for-profit organization. Generally, the
chief elected officer is responsible for advancing the organization while the paid
executive uses the skills of management, board support, programs and services
implementation to carry out the mission and strategic direction.
Duties of the Board
Focus of the Chief Elected
Officer
(Elected President)
Focus of the Chief Paid
Officer
(Paid Executive Director)
1. Determine and Advance the Organization's Mission
A mission statement should
articulate the organization's
purpose for existence and the
stakeholders it serves. It is the
board’s responsibility to create
the mission statement and
review it periodically for validity.
The president's role is to ensure
the mission is advanced. The
mission should influence every
activity, discussion and
assignment. The president will
reference it often, including it in
messages and on agendas, so
that others realize its importance
to the organization and the
community served.
The executive director is also
responsible for advancing the
mission and serving the
members. He or she should
ensure that the mission is
reflected in nearly every
program and project. Staff
members should understand
how the mission affects their
administrative work. The
executive director should
ensure the mission remains in
the forefront of board work.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 34
Duties of the Board
Focus of the Chief Elected
Officer
(Elected President)
Focus of the Chief Paid
Officer
(Paid Executive Director)
2. Select the Executive Director
Boards must reach consensus
on the need for and job
description of the executive
director. The board undertakes
a careful search process to find
the most qualified individual for
the position.
The president’s concern is to fill
the vacant position. The
selection process must be
thorough and fair. The president
will appoint a committee to
oversee the process which can
impact the association’s success
or failure for many years. Once
in place, the president and
executive director work in
unison.
The executive director will carry
out the duties of the position as
described in the governing
documents, culture/precedents
and employment contract. He
or she should make it clear to
the board that the executive
director is responsible for all
aspects of staffing (not a duty
of the board.)
3. Support the Executive Director and Assess Performance
The board should ensure that
the executive director has their
support. The executive director,
in partnership with the entire
board, should decide how and
when performance evaluations
are conducted. Other
performance measures may
include monitoring the budget,
evaluating the board and
agreeing on metrics.
The president is ultimately
responsible for assessing the
executive director’s
performance, and most often
selects a subgroup of the board
to assess performance. The
president will ensure the
integrity and confidentiality of
the process and lead the
conversation about findings and
improvements.
The executive director relies on
the elected president to enforce
board accountability for
governance duties and
commitments of volunteers and
committees. When the board
fulfills its duties, the executive
is able to focus on
administrative and
management duties. The
executive is versed in a variety
of methods to conduct
performance measures.
4. Conduct Organizational Planning
As stewards of an organization,
boards must participate in an
overall planning process and
assist in implementing the
organization’s goals.
The president, with the help of
the executive director, ensures
that the planning process is
organized to achieve the desired
results. The president will help
to determine who should be
included in the planning meeting
(a.k.a. retreat), for example the
entire board, committee chairs,
staff, etc., when and where it will
occur, and if a facilitator will be
needed.
The executive director will
expect the board to set the
direction; and he or she will
determine how to reach the
destination (the strategic plan is
much like a roadmap.) Staff
will manage the action steps,
deadlines and projects that
advance the plan. The
executive director and staff are
involved in planning.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 35
Duties of the Board
Focus of the Chief Elected
Officer
(Elected President)
Focus of the Chief Paid
Officer
(Paid Executive Director)
5. Build and Maintain Resources
One of the board's foremost
responsibilities is to ensure
adequate resources for the
organization to fulfill its mission.
The board should work in
partnership with the executive
officer to assist in developing
the annual budget and ensure
that proper financial controls are
in place. This is important in
order to remain accountable to
members.
The president has overall
responsibility for understanding
and safeguarding the
organizations resources.
Working with the executive
director and officers, he or she
should be fully aware of all
resources. Member and
stakeholders have expectations
that resources will be
safeguarded and used to benefit
the members through programs
and services.
The executive director has a
managerial duty to use
resources most effectively, and
report to the board as additional
resources are needed. Staff
will support the board’s efforts
to generate additional
resources.
6. Resource Management
The board must safeguard its
tax-exempt status and
resources at all times. They
must prevent excess spending,
mismanagement or loss of
resources. Be sure financial
controls exist.
While the president may rely on
consultants (legal, accounting,
insurance) and committees, in
the end he or she is responsible
for the organization. An
understanding of safeguards
such as insurance, audits and
filing requirements is important
to verify that resources are
appropriately managed.
Besides the financial report to
the board, the executive
director monitors projects and
budgets; and safeguards
assets of the organization
through risk management
techniques and reporting
requirements. The executive
director works closely with the
treasurer, finance committee
and accountants.
7. Determine, Monitor and Strengthen Programs and Services
The board's role is to determine
which programs are the most
consistent with an organization's
mission, and to monitor their
effectiveness.
The president ensures that the
mission is carried out through
programs and services. While
not a direct responsibility to
develop or oversee programs, it
is vital to affirm that existing and
new programs add value and
support the mission statement.
The executive director ensures
that programs are managed
and accessible to members.
He or she is responsible for
quality controls and marketing.
The success of programs,
events and sales may be
dependent on staff skillsets.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 36
Duties of the Board
Focus of the Chief Elected
Officer
(Elected President)
Focus of the Chief Paid
Officer
(Paid Executive Director)
8. Promote the Organization
An organization's primary link to
the community (constituents,
members, public and media) is
through the board. Clearly
articulating the organization's
mission, accomplishments and
goals to the public, and
garnering support from
important community members,
are important elements of public
relations outreach.
The president is the official
spokesperson. The
responsibility can be delegated
for specific instances (i.e.
testimony or interviews). The
public perception is that the
president is always representing
the association; be careful not to
confuse personal opinion with
official positions and duties.
While the chief elected officer is
generally viewed as the
spokesperson, the executive
director is frequently the “face
of the organization.” Personal
communication skills are an
asset, as well as the ability to
manage written messages,
graphics, digital
communications, etc. The
executive may promote training
to enhance board
communication skills and
confidence.
9. Ensure Legal and Ethical Integrity and Maintain Accountability
The board is ultimately
responsible for ensuring
adherence to legal standards
and ethical norms. Solid
personnel policies, grievance
procedures and a clear
delegation to the executive
director of hiring and managing
employees are key. The board
must establish policies and
adhere to provisions of the
organization's bylaws and
articles of incorporation.
The president must understand
all applicable laws and
governing documents.
Enforcement of policies may be
a requirement of the president,
for instance ensuring that
directors disclose any conflicts
of interest or avoid violating
antitrust/competition laws.
The executive director
maintains excellence in
management while promoting
ethics (and training) to
volunteers. He or she
manages the governing
documents, policies, insurance
coverages, records and the
required legal filings. The
executive maintains systems
that promote organizational
sustainability.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 37
Duties of the Board
Focus of the Chief Elected
Officer
(Elected President)
Focus of the Chief Paid
Officer
(Paid Executive Director)
10. Recruit New Board Members; Assess Board Performance
All boards have a responsibility
to sustain themselves by
identifying new leaders through
a search and nominating
process. The composition of
the board should reflect the
membership and be a balance
in skills. Boards must orient
new board members to their
responsibilities and the
organization's history, needs
and challenges. By evaluating
their performance, boards can
recognize their strengths and
weaknesses.
The president will usually
appoint a nominating committee
that has responsibility for
identifying board members. He
or she may have authority in the
bylaws to appoint committees.
There should be processes in
place to determine the
qualifications for board service
and to assess strengths and
weaknesses of the board. It is
essential to focus on
sustainability and competency of
the board.
The executive director
facilitates the leadership
nominations and training
processes. He or she
generally remains impartial to
leadership selection. Board
training and support is a core
competency of the executive
director.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 38
Primary Responsibility Chart
Use the chart to ensure understanding of the need for a combination of governance and
management.
Board's
Responsibility
President's
Responsibility
Executive
Director’s
Responsibility
1 Determine the organization's goals X
2 Hire the executive director, lobbyist X
3 Implement programs and procedures X
4 Keep board members informed regarding
organization's operation X
5 Administer all aspects of organization's operation X
6 Hire and supervise office staff and administrative
consultants X
7 Recruit new board members X
8 Orient new board members X
9 Determine agenda for board meetings X
10 Coordinate board operations, promote
accountability X
11 Prepare minutes of board meetings X
(+ secretary)
12 Serve as resource to board X
13 Evaluate organization's results and performance X X X
14 Appoint committees and task forces; oversee
their work X X
15 Monitor trends and members needs X
16
Manage the affairs and assets of the organization
to carry out the policies established by the board
and to achieve the objectives set forth by the
board
X
17 Set goals and advance the mission X
(Note: Answers will differ as organizations are unique in their deployment of duties.)
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 39
Officers and Directors Sample Job Descriptions
Any member in a position of leadership in the organization, holding a position on the
Board of Directors, or serving on the committees, or in chapter leadership, who feels he
or she is unable to support the policies of the association, should tender a resignation
as a volunteer leader. A member of the Board of Directors who misses more than two
consecutive meetings of the board without adequate excuse should have automatically
resigned.
Responsibilities
Office of President
• Call and chair meetings of the Board of Directors (generally 4 to 6 meetings year)
• Represent the organization as a delegate to the national Annual Meeting
• Lead delegation in legislative meetings
• Prepare a President’s Message due approximately 45 days before the month of publication
• Visit local chapter upon invitation/request
• Call and chair meetings of the Executive Committee
• Represent the organization, as necessary, at official functions with private and public organizations
• Testify before state or federal agencies or legislative committees
• Serve as member of the Executive Committee
• Fill vacancies in committees and offices with the approval of the Board
• Serve as an ex-officio member of each committee
Office of President-Elect
• Attend Legislative meetings
• Represent the Association at coalition and key meetings (5-7 meetings/year)
• Serve as member of the Executive Committee
• Attend regular and special meetings of the Board of Directors (approximately 6 per year)
• Represent the organization, as necessary, at official functions with private and public organizations, as assigned
• Participate in leadership training
• Assume the office of President for the remainder of the un-expired term of office in the event of the resignation, death or removal of the President or due to the failure or inability of the President to perform the duties of his office.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 40
Office of Vice President
• Serve as member of the Executive Committee
• Attend regular and special meetings of the Board of Directors (approximately 6 per year)
• Represent the organization, as necessary, at official functions with private and public organizations, as assigned
• Manage special requests and projects as delegated by the President
Office of Secretary/Treasurer
• Serve as recording secretary for executive sessions of the Board
• Serve as member of the Executive Committee
• Attend regular and special meetings of the Board of Directors (approximately 6 per year)
• Represent the organization, as necessary, at official functions with private and public organizations, as assigned
• Review the accounts of the Association on a timely basis, review the status of the financial integrity of the retirement plan and current status of the revocable trust and report to the Board of Directors
• Prepare an annual budget proposal at least 60 days prior to the fiscal year
• Serve as an ex-officio, non-voting member of the Audit Committee
Directors (three year term)
• Attend regular and special meetings of the Board of Directors (approximately 6 per year)
• Represent the organization, as necessary, at official functions with private and public organizations, as assigned
• Serve on committees
• Undertake special assignments made by the board president
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 41
Silence is NOT Governance
You could hear a pin drop after I asked questions of the board of directors. Not a word.
Deafening silence. The directors avoided eye contact --- turning to their executive
director in hopes he would answer for them.
My image of a meeting of the board of directors includes robust discussions and lively
debates. Communication and curiosity is at the heart of good governance.
Directors have a fiduciary duty to fulfill their roles. Officers or
directors, whether inexperienced or seasoned, have accepted
the duty to advance and protect the interests of the members,
mission and organization. Being silent or absent at board
meetings is not acceptable.
Unique Approaches to Governance
Directors sometimes have unique approaches to their roles on the board:
• The Observer – “I think I’ll just study a few meetings before I speak up.” Or, “I don’t
understand governance so I will just observe.” The problem with the observer is that
each and every director has a vote and is expected to participate.
• The Timid Director – He or she feels they have minimal experience and knowledge.
“Others with more experience and the executive officers will probably say what
needs to be said.” The insecure director should acquire the information they need
about the organization, ask plenty of questions, and seek a board-buddy or mentor.
• MIA – “The bylaws said we could have excused absences!” While the bylaws may
allow for an absence, corporate governance requires the presence of directors.
Even in their absence all directors have a liability for the decisions of the board.
Because board seats are accepted voluntarily, there is a presumption that directors
will allocate sufficient time to fulfill their duties.
• Groupthink – A phenomenon occurs within groups where the desire for harmony
overrides the duty to question and debate. Directors think other directors must
agree so they don’t “rock the boat” and go along with it; making poor decisions.
• Rabbit Chaser – This director seldom offers concrete ideas but
frequently starts sentences with, “I just have a question.” In his
A fiduciary duty is a
legal duty to act solely
in another party's
interests, for example
on behalf of members.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 42
or her mind the question must sound “smart.” Then two or three other directors
appear to help by answering the question that often has more to do with history and
little to do with the agenda item.
• Digitally Distracted – This director comes to the meeting but is quickly seen in the
prayer-position typing text messages below the table. Using email and texting
should be discouraged to maintain confidentiality.
• Part of a Crowd – A director may feel they don’t need to be accountable, especially
on a large board. They think, “It’s only a volunteer position.” Some directors don’t
volunteer for anything in hopes others will carry the weight. Accountability should
be emphasized at board orientation and enforced by the chief elected officer.
All directors have a duty to participate in the governance process. The approaches of
simply listening, avoidance or waiting to learn are not appropriate.
# # #
Note: Bob Harris, CAE, provides governance resources at his website:
www.nonprofitcenter.com. Contact him at [email protected] or 850 570 6000.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 43
Board Responsibilities Quiz
1. “Not for profit” is best described as:
a. Board members will not be reimbursed for travel costs. b. A designation by state government. c. A designation by the IRS.
2. A “mission” for an organization refers to:
a. A building from where to defend ones beliefs or territory. b. A project after a keg party, frequently in a fraternity. c. A description of the organization’s purpose.
3. An “Agenda" typically refers to the:
a. Ulterior motives of individual board members. b. Something hidden. c. A written outline of topics, times, and purpose of items to be covered in a Board or
Committee meeting.
4. "Motions" commonly mean:
a. Proposals for action. b. Moves on the dance floor. c. Description by the weatherman relative to a cold
front.
5. A "Second" typically refers to:
a. An understudy in a play. b. A stand in at a duel or gun fight. c. An endorsement of a motion.
6. "Tabling" commonly means:
a. Proposing a topic for discussion. b. Removing a topic from discussion. c. An appetizer table with multiple options.
7. "Minutes" typically refer to:
a. A written record of time, location, participants, and outcomes of motions.
Board Orientation Toolkit Page 44
b. Units of time as in 60 minutes in an hour. c. The chance to keep minutes while losing hours in a poorly planned meeting.
8. The term "Standing" is most often used to describe:
a. Committees identified in the bylaws and whose work is ongoing usually. b. Meetings held in rooms with no chairs to promote efficiency. c. Characterize long lasting differences of opinion.
9. A “Conflict of Interest” can be avoided by:
a. Denying one exists, ignoring the sacred cows and elephants in the room.
b. Refusing to talk about it. c. Proactively disclosing the conflict and/or recusing
oneself from related motions.
10. “Strategic Planning” is best described as:
a. Often yields a document that no one uses or look at – best stored in a notebook on the shelf.
b. Enables a board to look to the future and consider the challenges for the organization and what to do about them.
c. Is a rare event that creates a ton of work for staff.
11. Board members who act with “Care” are most often protected by:
a. Homeowners’ or renters’ insurance. b. Personal health insurance or Obamacare. c. Directors and Officers liability insurance and volunteer immunity.
12. The “Duty of Obedience” refers to:
a. Always agreeing with the Chair or paid staff.
b. Taught in pet training school.
c. Complying with the organization’s governing documents. Board Quiz - Fun 8-13.doc
Note: Bob Harris, CAE provides free governance and management tips and templates at
www.nonprofitcenter.com. The laminated board guide is available to support training
and orientation for $10 each for a minimum of ten. Contact [email protected].