Page 1
TOBap~ roPBA~ M.C.
K aHa~sy waKTa npHe38a B CCCP BH8HgX aMepHKaHCKHX nO~TM
qeC~X 8eRTe~e~ (KHCCHH8!ep, BSHC, KHpKn8TpHK, BpaYH H 8p.)
r~aBHaH ~e~b npHesAa rpynrrs - B MeHbmeA Mepe 8HanH3 COC
TOHHHH Te~X ~e~ B c~pe COBeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHA.
CTpaTerHqeCKaH OCHOBa - ¢oPMHpOBaHHe "H3 nepBOHCTOqRHKa" B3r~a
Ha nepCneKTHBU paSBHTHH Hame~ CTp8HH C yqeToM BepOffTHOCTH H36pa
HHH B CmA B 1988 ro~ npe3H~eHTa, npe~CT8BRRD~erO c~e~~ee nOKO
~eHHe npaB~e~ SRHT~ CiliA. OTcD8a - HsyqeHHe B03M~HOCTM ROB oro
C08epzaHHR H ~oPM oTHomeHHA C COBeTcKHM CaD30M.
K cepe~He 1980-x rOAoB CT~ OqeBHAeH rpy6H~ npOCqeT aMe
pHKaHCKOa cOBeTO~OrHH, Bcex ee HanpaB~eHH~. ITepe~ H8~anOM TeKY
~ero AeCHTHReTHH rocno~CTBOBaRH ABa "cueHapHH" rpff8Ymero pas
BHTHH CCCP.
ITo nepBOMY - COBeTCKaH SKOHOMHKa no~o~T K rpaHH ~8BHHO
06paSHoro KpHSHca, KOTO~~ npHBe~eT K OTKpHTOMY B~aEeHHD CO
~aHbHoro HeAoBoRbCTB8 (npHwepHO, no "nOHbCKOMY BapM8HTy").
OTK~He Wa3H TaKoro KpHsMca nporH03HpOB8RHCb CTOpOHHKKaMM
STOM KOHUengHM Ha 1983-1984 ro~. MMeHHo Ha STHX 0QeHKaX OCHO
BHBa~aCb, B ~aCTHOCTH, nOnHTHKa a~HHHCTpa~H Pe~raHa cpasy
xe noc~e ee npHxo~a K B~aCTH B RHBape 1981 ro~a.
ITo BTOpOUY - KpH3HC B COBeTCKOM 06~eCTBe He npHMeT OTKpH
THe ¢OPMU, no Kpa~eM Mepe, B Te~eM ~eCHTH~8THH, - Bc~eACTBHe
BHCORoro ypOBHH TepITMMOCTH HaCeneHMH, HCTOpHqeCRHX Tpa~~~,
MO~Horo annapaTa KOHTPO~. O~aKO 3KOHOMMKa COB8TCKoro CO~3a
Page 2
2.
6y~eT paSBMBaTbCR C 3aMe~eHHeM, a rnaBHoe, 6y~eT HapaCTaTb
3KOHOMMQeCROe, Ha~O-TeXHH~eCKoe H COQMa~bHoe OTCTaBaHHe
eeep He TonbRO OT 3ana~a, HO Ta~e H OT COUHaRHCT~~eCKHX
CTpaH BOCTO~O~ EBpOnH, a B ~anbHe~eM - H KHTaR. B pesynb
TaTe eeep r~e-TO sa npe~enaMH 1993-1995 rO~OB YTpaTHT MaTe
pHanb~e nepcneRTHB~ paSBHTHR B Ka~eCTBe MHPOBO~ ~e~aBH H
MopanbHo-nO~THqeCKH~ aBTopHTeT, eGep nepecTaHeT npe~cTaB~b
HS ce6R BoeHHYID, nORHTHqecRYID H co~anbHYD yrposy ~ 3ana~a.
ITo c~eCTBY, HaqHHafl C 1975 ro~a, nocne no~~caHHR Xenb
CHHRCKoro aRTa, Bce BapHaHT~ ~onrOBpeMeHHO~ CTpaTerHH ellA - KaK
COCTaBnRID~He co~e~aHHe O~QManbHOro ~pca a~HHCTpa~~, TaK H
B~HraBIDHeCR B KaqeCTBe anbTepHaTHB eTOMY K,Ypcy, - HCXOAMnH HS
noc~nKH HHCXOAffmero co~anbHO-3KOHOMH~eCKOro paSBHTHR eeGP Ha
~TenbBYD nepcneKTHBY.
B ~aHHOM c~ae TaKO~ no~o~ - He npOCTO KR8CCOBOe HenpHS
HaHHe sa KOMMYHHSMOM 6y~ero. He RBnHIDTCR TaKHe npeAcTaBneHHfl
H O,LUrnWI TOJIbKO "AeJKYPHhIMH" ynp8%HeHHRMH nponaraH,IJ;H. ~aKTH'4eCKHe
o~eH~ 6aSHpOBanHCb Ha ~aHH&X np.y, MHHHcTepcTBa TOprOBRH, aKa~e
MHqeCKHX H ~HaHcoBO-rrpOMHmneHHHX Hccne~OBaTenbCKHX ~eHTpOB,nO~
KpennReMHe HH~opMa~e~ OT npHesxaro~x HS eeep H cTpaH BOCTOqHO~
EBporm 3MHrpaHTOB.
o nocne~HeM MCTO~Ke He06xo~MO CKaSaTb oc060.
Kor~a B Haqane 1970-x rO~OB HS Hame~ cTpaHH nomna 3Ha~Tenb
HaR Bo~a 3MMrpa~H H BHeX8BmMe ~aBaRM BeCbMa HeraTMBHYID xapaKTe
pXCTHKY BHYTpeHHHM npo~eccaM B eeG?, TaKaH HH~opMa~H Ha nepBHX
nopax BOCnpMHMMBE8Cb B GllA co 3Ha~Te~bHHMH orOBopKBMH, ~aEe C
He~OBepMeM. OT 3MMrpah~oB, c06CTBeHHO, HHqerO, KpOMe oTpM~aTe~b
Horo MHeHMR 060 BceM cOBeTcKoM, H He ~anH.
Page 3
3.
Ho Ror~a R KO~Y rrpomnoro AeCflT~neT~fl ~ Ha py6e~e 70-x H
80-x rOAOB O~~ManhHafl CTaT~CT~Ka eccp, HamH ny6naqH~e o~eHR~
cranK, Ha aMepHKaHCKHH B3rnE~, nO~TBepx~aTh HH~OPM~HID SMHrpaH
TOB, TO nocne~eH 3a~KM ~HcnOM 6~no rrpH~aao oco6oe 3Ha~eH~e. ilpo
M30illno KaK 6~ B3aKMOyCHneHHe Tpa~~HOHHoro HeraTHSHoro rrpe~CTaBne
HaR 0 Hame~ cTpaHe H TeKy~ onepaTHBHHX ~aHHgx. PesynhTaToM ~
cranK o~eHK~ BOSMO~OCTe~ HailleH CTPaH~ Ha nepcneKT~BY ~o XXI seRa.
TIOSTOMY nOBopOT B paSBHTHH COBeTCKoro 06meCTBa nocne anpenh
CEoro (1985 r.) ITneHyMa UK npoHsBen s~eKT mOKa H8 aMepHKaHCKyp
nonHTH~eCKyID snHTy.
e06~THfl B eccp rrpe~enhHO B~CBeTHnH cTpaTerKqeCKHe npOMaXH
aMepHKaHCKO~ coseTonorHH H nonHTHKH, nOCKonhKY B TeopeT~eCKKX
peKOMeHA~HflX nocne~ero ~eCRTHneTHR Boo6~e He paCCMaTpHBanaCb
~e KaK ranOTesa, Rax a6CTp8KTH8R B03MO~HOCTh HSMeHeHH~ B eccp.
MMeHao B STOM KOHTeKcTe H cne~eT paCCMaTpHBaTh npa3Be~Ba
TenbHyD" nOnHTKqecKyID MHCC~ yKasaHHoM rpynnH H3 npe~CTaBHTeneH
B~cmero smenOHa nonHTH~eCKOH snHTN. B 06c~~eHKffX, KOTop~e OHH
BenH Me~~ C060H nocne 6ece~ B MocRBe, B~RBKRHCb cne~~He OC
HOBHue HanpaSneHHR.
I. HBnfleTcfl na rrpoHcx0AHmee B eee? nB3pHBOM HAeanH3Ma" HnM
~e GTO npogyMaHHaR H OC03HaHHafl nonHTHKa? Oco6oe SHKMaHHe ~neHa
MH rpynnH y~enRnoCh BHflBneHHID Toro, HacKORhKO rny6oKo BH~T B
CCCP B3aMMOCBR3H Me~~ SKOHOMKqeCKKMK, CO~HanbHUMH H HHHMH ac
neKTaMH npOBo~oro Kypca, KaK O~eHHBaDT CY~OCTb npo6neM K
nepcneKTHBH pa3BHTHR "Ha cT~Kaxn CO~HanbHoro H SKOHOM~eCKoro,
co~~anbHoro H nonHTH~eCKoro, SKOHOMwqeCKoro H BoeHHoro H T.n.
YCnHillaHHOe B MocRBe rrpHBeno ax K B~BO~ 0 TOM, qTO nonHTHKa
nepeCTpOMRH onHpaeTCR Ha npO~MaHHYro KOH~err~MID. fnaEHoe npOTHBO
Page 4
4.
P8~H8 pa3B~THR COB8TCKOrO OO~eCTBa OH~ BOCnpHHHM~T RaK "KOH
~HKT Me~~ TpeOOBaH~RMH SKOHOM~eCROH S~eKTHBHOCT~ ~ 3anpOCaM~
CO~HanhHOH C~epH". Y~acTHHKH rpynn~ OTMeqa~H, qTO, cy~ no npo
m8,DJIIl1M oece,n,aM, B CCCP BM~T H nOHHMaJOT STO npOTHBOpeqI-le CllHTep
COH, BSHC, K~KTIaTpHK, ~OHC, KHCCHH~ep). CH~eHHe OCTPO~ STO
ro npOTI-IBOpeqaH H3MeHHT OO~HR CTpaH~, nOBHCHT ee COQHanhH~~
npeCTmK.
2. HacKo~hKO pea~hH~ n~aHH cOBeTCKoro pyKoBoAcTBa? TO~hKO
O,n,HH H3 yqaCTHHRoB rpynnH - XaHReHA, - o~eHHB~ 3TH n~aHH RaK
"Hepea~bHHe". B TO ~e BpeMR B peaKqHH SToro npo~eCCHOH~bHoro
COBeTo~ora (~HoepanhHoro, no &~epHKaHCKKM KpHTepHflM) OTqeT~HBO
npOCMaTPHBa~OCb CH~bHoe pa3~~eHHe TeM, QTO nporH03H COBeTo~orHH
OKa3anHCb HanpOqb OrrpOKKHyTHMH. OH CaM yqaCTBOBa~ B COCTaB~eHHH
3TIDe rrporH030B.
OCTa~hH@e o~eHHBa~H n~aHH CO~HanbHO-SKOHOMH~eCKoropa3BHTHR
CCCP C pa3HOH ,n,o~e~ ODTHMH3Ma. HH O,ll,HH H3 HIDe He npH3Han B03MO~
HOCTH nO~HOH ocy~ecTBHMOCTH TaKHX n~aHOB. B TO ~e BpeMR B OOmHX
OQeHKax npOH30me~ C,ll,BHr B CTOpOHy OO~bmero OnTKMH3Ma, OO~bmeH
CK~OHHOCTH BepHTb B ycnex HamIDe HaqHHaHHH. Oco6eHHO saMeTHa
TaEaR peaKQHR 6~~a y BSHca H TIHTepcoHa.
3. Xopomo H~H n~oxo ~R CiliA, eC~H CCCP oYAeT pa3BHBaTbcR
no Bocxo8Eme~? TO~bKO XaM~eH,n, B~CKa3~Ba~CR B TOM CMHcne, ~TO yK
pen~eHHe COBeTCKoro COID3a Mo~eT 6~Tb conp~eHO C HapaCTaHHeM npo
oneM ~R CllA, r~aBHHM 06pasOM C TOqKH 3peHHR BHemHeH nO~HTHKH,
B3aHMOOTHomeHHM C 3ana,n,HOH EBponoM. OCT~bHHe CqHTaroT, qTO pa3BH
BaID~HMCR CCCP B OO~bmeM cTeneHH OTBe~aeT HHTepecaM 6e30naCHOCTH
CiliA, ~eM nepcneKTHBa KaKrrx-~H60 nOTpRceHHM B HameM cTpaHe. (~OHC
npRMO 3a.fiB I-m : "lKe,lIaeM ycnexa fl) •
Page 5
5.
HeKOTopHe Y'QaCTH~K~ rpynn~ BHP~an~ OSa60qeHHOCTb no rrOBO~
Toro, 'QTO KOrrn;eHTpa.IJ;IDr ,lJ,Byx cTpaH' Ha COnepHW'tieCTBO .n;pyr C ,npyroM
np~Be,lJ,eT K ~ BSaHMHoMy oCRa6neHHID, a O~OBpeMeHHO TeM CaMHM - K
OTHOCHTenbAOMY YCl1neHHID TpeTbKX CTpaH, npe~,IJ,e Bcero HnOHHR. B 3ToM
CBflSH KHPKnaTp~K w HeKOTop~e ~yrHe B~CKSHBanHCb, HCXO~ I1S BHyT
peHHMX KHTepeCOB CCCP H ernA, B nORbsy cOKpa~eH~R BoeHHHX pacxO,lJ,OB.
4. B KaKO~ Mepe HOBoe nORHTaqeCKOe M@mReHHe cTaRO qaCTbID
BHemHe~ nonHTHKW caMoro COBeTCKoro COIDsa? ~HanaSOH o~eHOK onpe,lJ,e
RHRCR cneAYID~HM 06paSOM. Ha O~OM nORIDce 6~Ra KHpKDaTpHK, KOTopaR
c'QHTaeT, qTO pe'tib H,IJ,eT nHmb 0 RHqHOM cTHRe M.C.rop6a~eBa. ITo ee
o~eHKe, OHa "He O~H~Ra, qTO B CCCP Mo~eT 6HTb CTORb OTKp~TH~ H
,lJ,eMOKpaTHtreCRH HaCTpoeHH~M RH,IJ,ep". qTO ~e KacaeTCR co~ep~aHHR
BHemHe~ nORHTHKH cecp, TO 3~eCb, no ee cnOBa~, "npHCyTCTBYDT RRmb
OT~eRbH~e HOBHe B~~eHHR Ha CTapOM ~OHe".
~yroH BHYTpHrpynnoBo~ nORDC npe~CT8BnRn BSHC. no ero MHeHHO,
B CO,lJ,ep~He BHemHe~ nORMTHKH eGCP ~e BHeceHO MHoro HOBoro, npH
qeM oc06eHHo BaxHO, 'QTO npHHqHrrHaRbH~e 3ReMeHT~ 3Toro HOBoro Ta
KMe, HanpHMep, RaR KOHQen~HR BSaHMOSaBI1CaMOrO Mapa, saKpenneHH B
pemeHHRX XXYil c~es~. H~bSg He BH~eTb H Toro, OTMeqaR OH, qTO
~e~CTBHg COBeTcKoro PYKOBO~CTBa corRacyroTCR C 3TRMH 06~HMW npHH
qHnaMH, pe'tib H~eT He TORbRO 0 nponaraH,IJ,e.
B ~eHTpe ~CKyCCHH 0 AOBOM M~ReHHH Me~,IJ,y y'tiaCTHHKaMH rpynn~
OK8S8RaCb TeMa ~raHHCTaHa.
CTopOHHmm TOM TOtrlm speHMR, trTO "HoBoe MbJIIlReHHe - RmIIb CRO
Ba", npH,IJ,ep~HBaRHCb nos~HH, trTO "CillA HesatreM nOMoraTb CCCP B~
6paTbCR HS AqJrarmCTaHa". B KpaillieM CJIytrae 6bJR O~ BOSMOlKeH "HetfTPa
JIHTeT" CillA no OTHorneHHID K nOJIHTWqeCKoMY yperymrpoBaHmJ B AmraHI1C
TaHe "B OOMeH Ha cOKpa~eHHe BCgqeCKoi1 nOMoU\M CCCP, BKJIlO'QaR 3KOHO
MMqeCKYIO, HMKaparya l! (Xai1JIeH~).
Page 6
6.
B3HC, TapHOB, CBHHr BHCKa3HBanHCb B TOM nRaHe, qTO CiliA He
~3BAeKaIDT ceMqac HMKaKOM peaRbHOH BHro~ H3 BO~HH B ~raH~CTaHe,
HO Bce oORee O~TKMO pHCKyIDT TaM pa3BanOM ITaKHCTaHa H B03MO~
HOCTbro aMep~KaHO-HH~~CKon KOH~POHTaqM~. Yq~T~BaR 3TO, CillA, no
KX MHeHHD, CRe~OBaRO O~ He MemaTb nORHTKqeCKOMY yperYRHpOBaHHD
B ~raHMCTaHe, eCAM CCCP HaM~eT ~OPMYRY TaKoro yperynHPoBaHMR.
5. a rrpe8ilpHRTHRX C COBMeCTH@M Ran~TaROM. K 3TO~ ROHqerrqMH
OHR rrpoRBneH oonbmon HHTepec M C npaKTMqeCKOM CITHTepcoH), H C
H~eonor~ecKoM CKHcc~H~ep) TOqeK 3peHMR. fnaBHHH BOnpOC, KOTOpHM
nOKa OCTaeTCR, no MHeHMID aMep~KaH~eB, oe3 OTBeTa H c~ep~HBaeT
npaRTaqeCKOe ocy~ecTBneHHe TaKMX npoeKTOB: KaR oy~eT pa3pemaTbCR
npOTHBope~Me Me~~ H~eAeHHocTbro 3anaAH~ KaMnaHMM Ha M3BneqeHMe
npHOHnH, Ha cyryoo ~enOBHe KpHTePHH H HeOOXO~MOCTbro nO~HHRTbCR
TpeOOBaHHRM COBeTcKoro co~~anbHoro 3aKOHo~aTenbCTBa. TpeoyroT
pa30RCHeHHM H Bce npaKTHqeCKHe Bonpoc~, rrpe~~e Bcero CBR3aHH~e
C ~OAe~ CMemaHHoro npe~MRTHR Ha BHyTpeHHeM pHHKe CCCP H C no
PR~KOM BHB03a npHoHneH.
6. B qeM 3aKflIDqaeTCR cero8Hfl crnepa OOSHX HHTepecoB CCCP
H CillA? Bce y~acTHHKH rpynrr~ OHRH e~HH B TOM,qTO npHH~KDHanb
HaR c~pa OO~KX HHTepecoB -3TO rrpe~oTBpa~eHHe R~epHoH BOMHH,
C03~aHHe H yKperrneHHe rapaHTHM rrpOT~B ee B03HHKHOBeHHfl.
KaK c~epa pacTy~HX oo~ax HHTepecoB paccMaTpHBanacb yqaCTHHKa
MH rpynnH H 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb ~BYX cTpaH B cOKpa~eHHH BoeHHHX pac
XO~OB. ITHTepcoH nO~qepKHBan, qTO 3a nocne~He 2-3 ro~ B ~enOB~
Kpyrax CiliA cnO~HnaCb cepbe3HaR 03aOOQeHHOCTb rrocne~CTBHRMH pOCTa
BoeHH~ paCXO~OB H CBR3aHHoro C HHMH ~e~~HTa rocy~apcTBeHHoro
Page 7
7.
6D~eTa ellA. CTpax nepe~ ~~KqHTOM B ~e~OBHX Kpyrax OtfeHh 60~hmo~,
OTMetf~ OH, - TeM 60~ee, trTO ere B03~e~CTBHe MoxeT CR83aThCfl
6yKBaJIhHO Ha BceM: BHyTpeHHe~ 1lrn3HH CllIA,HX n03~Mmc B OTHOmeHIDiX
C COlO3HHRaMR, C "TpeThHM MHPQM" H T.,IJ;.
B pe3Y~hTaTe 6ece,n; B MOCRBe rroKo~e6~eHa Bepa B ~elO "M:3MOTaTh
CCCP rOHRO~ BOOPYJKeIm~". YtraCTHHKH rpynITH OTMetIBJIH, trTO rrepe,n.
JI~OM TaKoro CCCP, KaRO~ BhIpHCOBhIB8.eTCfl Ha rrepcrreKTHBy, CillA He
CMOryT ce6e n03BO~HTh qpesMepHHX BoeHHRX pacxo,n.oB (ilHTepcoH, TapHoB,
~OHC, BsHC) , HHat:re HSMOTaIOT CaMHX ce6fl.
B TO ~e BpeMfl HHHX cwep o6max HHTepecoB CCCP H CllA yqacTHHKH
rpynnbI rro c~eCTBY He BH,gHT. BechMa HaCTOpOJKeHHO BOCrrpmrnMaeTCR
~eR rrOJIHoro yHMtITOMeHHfl ~epHHX Boop~eHH~. DPOTHB 3TO~ HAeM TpH
rpynrrbI apryMeHTOB:
- y6e!\,Il;eHHe, tfTO TO~hKO MepHoe 0pyDie COxpaHMO MMp B MHHyB
IIIHe COpoK ~eT, cnoc06Ho COxpaHRTh ero Bnpe,IJ;h;
- orraceHHe, ~o rrpH ~HKB~aqKH ~epHHX BoopyxeHH~ CCCP nO~T
rro,n.aBn~ee rrpeBOCXO,IJ;CTBO B o6~ BoopyxeHHRX;
- eCJIH MbIllineHHe B "~epHbIX" paMKax pasBHTO ,n.ocTaTo~o BbICOKO,
TO ~HKB~aqHR ~epHoro 0P~R B03Bp~aeT BHeillHerrO~TKqeCKOe COSHaHHe
CllA K ypoBHD H rrOHHTHHM 40-50-x rO~OB.
OrraceHHfl rrepcrreKTHBbI yHMtrTO~eHHR ~ep~ Boop~eHH~ HaCTO~bKO
BhlCOKH, trTO, no OTSbIBaM HeKOTOpHX ttJIeHOB rpyn.mr (Mcc~ep, BpayH) ,
CTOpom-rnKi'i KOHTPO~H H8.,ll, BoopyJCeHHHMH B CITIA cetftrac "nonpHTIDCJm" ,
CTpamaCh KaK COBeTCKoro npeBOCXO,IJ;CTBa B 06HtrHHX Boop~eHKRX, TaK H
B03MO~OCTH HeBH,n.aHHO~ rOHKH Boop~eHH~ B 3TO~ c~epe Ha OCHOBe HOBbIX
TeXHo~orH~.
BHBo~ vqaCTHHKOB rpynITbI: gnepHHe Boopy!eHHR HaA0 3Ha~TeJIhHO
COKp~aTh Ha cTa6HnH3Hp~e~ OCHOBe, HO He JIMKBH8HpoBaTh rrOAHOCThD.
Page 8
8.
7. TIepcoeRTKBH cOBeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX oTHomeHH~, oc06eHHO Ha
6~~ee BpeMR. OTO r~aBHoe, ~TO Hccne~OB~OCb K 06c~anocb.
3~ecb yqacTHHR~ rpynnH 6HnH BHCKaSaHH ~Be TOqRH speHHR, cTporo
rOBopR, He rrpoTHBOpeq~e ~pyr ~pyry.
ilepBaE: B npKHqRne eCTb BOSMOXHOCTb ~orOBopHTbCR 0 pasopyxeHHH
B STOT nepHO~, HO TO~bKO eC~H "pa3BH3aTb" pe~RbHBHKCKH~ naKeT. B
STOM c~ae ~orOBopeHHOCTb no PC~ Mo~eT 6HTb ~OCTHrHyTa ~er~e Bcero.
~orOBopeHHOCTb no COH/TIPO T~e He HBnReTCfl HeB03MOXHO~, XOTR ,
nOTpe6yeT 60~bmHX YC~H~.
BTopaH: ~~e ecnM PenraH B OCTaBmHeCfl ~Ba ro~a "rrpoCHeTCH" H
3axOQeT 0 qeM-TO ~orOBopHTbCR, H3 SToro HHQerO He B~eT B C~
paCCTaHOBKH C~ B ~CTPaQHH H B03MOXHOCTe~ ~R Kp~e rrpaBHX
napHpOBaTb TaKHe ~orOBopeHHOCTH YTBe~eHHRMH 0 TOM, QTO OHH 6y~
rrpOTHBOpetrnTb yCTaHOBKaM, O¢~HaJIbHO YJ!e npHHflTID4 ~CTpa.qHe~
paHee.
XapawrepHo, qTO RaR nepByx> , TaR H BTOPYIO O~eHKJI1 BI::.ICKa3bfB8.1IH
O~ H Te ;,;:e ~~a (KHcc~ep, lhHC, BpaYH, TapHOB). fue OHM rro,g
qepKHBanH, 0ARaRO, He06x08KMOCTb B ~OM cnyqae He OTKa3HBaTbCR
OT npOBe~eHHR no OTHomeHHD K CllA "HHTeHCHBHO~ nonHTHKH", KOTOpaR
Y1!.e O~HM CBOIDt !flaKTOM He~TpMH30BID38.JIa 6H yry03Y Kpa~He npaBI::.IX.
A TaKaR yrposa, no 06~en o~eHKe rpynnI::.I, peMbHa, ee MaCillTa6I::.I
HapaCTaDT no Mepe OCnOXHeHHR n03HqHH ~CTPanHH H npH6~~eHRfl
06~eH~HoHanbHHX BH60pOB B 1988 roAY.
II . MO,IW H rrpe,g.nO:IKeHHR
rroe3~Ka B MOCKBy He npHBena, KOHe~o, qneHOB rpyrrrrH K rrepeCMOT
py CBORX 06~ Bsr~~OB - SToro HHKTO H He Mor o~~aTb. OcTaDTCR
rrpe~HMR H OpHHqHOHMbHHe ~eAeB~e yCTaHOBRH. HaM60nee O~TWMO
H3MeHHnOCb O~O - YTBep8~oCb MHeHHe B TOM, ~O B CCCP Bcepbe3
Page 9
9.
HaqaTH H 6ynyT rrpOBOAHTbCH H 8anee TaK~e BHY!peHHHe npeo6pasOBaH~R,
KOTOpHe MOry! nOTpe6oBaTb rny60KHX KoppeKTHpoBOR B aMep~KaHCKHX
rrporH03ax 6YAYmero pa3BHTHE COBeTCKoro 06meCTBa - KoppeKTHpoBOK
nOnMTH~eCKHX, 3KOHOMH~eCKHX. Me;gyHapo8HHX.
rrepeCTpO~Ka He paCCMaTpHBaeTCfi KaK yrpo~aR HHTepeCaM CllA,
r JIaBHhIM 06pasOM, B~HMO, nOTOMy' , qTO ORB BI:llKH,IJ,BJOT, KaK noWT y Hac
~eJIe ~anbme. CoBeTOJIOrH CillA HBHO ~aDTCH H BO BpeMeHH ~H 60JIee
r~6oKoro aHaHH3a B3aHMOCBR3e~ BHYTPeHHe~ H BHeIDHe~ nOJIHTHKH CCCP
Ha nepcrreRTHBY. CYlJ/1 no BceMY, yqacTHHKH rpymrn HMelOT B BH,Dy
BHpa60TaTb KaI\YD-To aJIbTepHaTHBY KYPCY Pe~raHa, HO y6e~HTeJIbHO
rrpe~cTaBHTb ee o6~ecTBeHHoMy MHeHHD, nOJIHTHqeCKO~ SJIHTe CllA OHH
nORa He B COCTORHHH. V~BeCTHaR Heonpe~eJIeHHOCTb nOCJIe npOCqeTOB B
TeOpeTHQeCKKX pa3pa6oTKax H npaKTHQeCKHX ~e~CTBHRX OCTaeTCR.
TeM C~ coxpaHHeTCR 3agaqa HerrpepHBHoro H 3~eKTHBHoro
nOJIHTHqeCKOrO H~a He CllA C ~eJIb~ rrpOTHBo~e~CTBHH KYPCY Pe~raHa
H OKa3aHHfi rro~e~KH TeM CHnaM BHYTpH rocnO~CTB~~ero KnaCca CillA,
KOTopHe BHCTyTIaDT npOTHB 3Toro Kypca.
rrpe~CTaBJlHeTCfi, QTO HaH60JIee 8~eKTHBHHM marOM 3~eCb MOrJIO
6H CTaTb B HHHelliHHX YCJlOBHflX "paCWHypOBaHHe naKeTa", rrpe~o~eHHoro
Ha BCTpeqe B Pe~RbRBHKe, YT0qHeHHe B3aHMOo6ycJIOBJleHHOCTe~ M~
COCTaBJlRD~HMH ero SJIeMeHTaMR. TaKT~qeCKH TaKOe "paCIDHypOBRBaH~e"
MOrJIO 6H 6b1Tb RaK O,II,HOpasOBhTM, BHellIHe o6JIeqeHHHM B KaKyJO-JIH60
")JJ>a.MaTHqeCKyKl" epoPMJT, TaK H 60JIee paCTRHYThIM BO BpeMeHH;
RaK cpasy H rrOJlHOCTb~ OTKpHTHM, ny6JIH~, TaR H COqeT~~
B ce6e OTRpHTHe H ~ITJIOMaTHqeCKHe ~OPMH. HaH60JIee npeATIOqTHTeJIbHa
6bDIa 6hl TPaHCtPoPM~H.fi "naKeTa" B Ko~e~HlO "paMotllioro COrJIameHHR"
THrra ~~HBOCToKcKoro 1974 ro~a.
Page 10
10.
A) ~BH!'\eH}1e "naKeTa" B Pe~KblIBHKe 6WIO TOl:lHHM, rrpaBIDIbHHM
H He06xo,g:m.n:n.<. Hyma 6WIa MO~aH mU1IJ;HaTHBa, KOTOpaH 3a>maTIDIa 6a
06m.ecTBeHHoe MHeHHe, npoBeJIa 6bI CWIbHyJO "pa3Be~KY 60eM" n03MIJ;~
~liCTP~HH, BI:lCBeTIDIa 6I:l 3TH rr03HIl;rm:, CTaJIa 6bl pwraroM ~aBJIeHKH
Ha HIDe. A Y MOIII.HO~ l1HHI.J;HaTHBbI ~oJI'lKHa 6HTb 11 Ha,I\emaH cTpaxoBKa.
fu e 3TH tIJyHKqHH Hama HHHIJ;MaTHBa BbIIIOJIHIDIa C 6JIec KOM :
a) npe~eJIbHO 06HaxeHbl n03~HH Pe~1"a.Ha KaR CTopomrnKa BoeHHO
CIDIOBO~ JImnU1;
6) COR ce~qac BHyTpHnOJIMT~eCKM cJIa6ee B CllA, qeM ~o Pe~Kb1IBH
Ka - He C.nyq~HO YaAH6ep1"ep 11 KpaAHe rrpaBI:le TaR TOporurTClI C peme
HHeM 0 pa3BepTHBaHHH; B KOH1"pecce HaCTpoeHRff Bce 60JIee rrpOTHB
rrOJIHOMaCmTa6HoH COR, B TOM miCJIe H no cPHHaHCOBblM rrpwcrnHaM;
B) BHemHenOJIHTHqeCKH ~MHHMCTPaQKH CJIa6ee:~aH1"eMT'CTaJI
BOSMo~eH TOJIbKO nOCJIe H 6JIa1"o~aplI PeaKblIBHRY, aTO MeCTb PeHraHy
sa PeMKblIBHK (C pa3HHX CTOpOH o,gHOBpeMeHHO):
r) npoHSOmeJI 1"ny60KHH nepeJIOM B 06m.eCTBeHHOM MHeHKH 3an~a
B ~eJIOM, KOTOpHa ce~qac rronyqaeT MHo1"o06pa3HI:le BbIXO~ BO Bce ac
neKTa OTHomeHH~ KaK Me~ BoCTOKOM Ii 3an~OM, TaK H BHyTpH RATa: nepeJIOM TeM 60JIee S~KTHB~, qTO OH HBHJIClI ~JIR 3an~a nOJIHO~
HeO~aHHOCTbJO;
~) BHPa~eH~e B "rraKeTe" ~eH pa60TaroT Ii CeHqaC, cnycTH rrOqTH
nOJIro~a nOCJIe Pe~KbHBHKa, KaK ¢aKTOp M06HJIHS~H BO BceM Mr1pe SJIe
MeHTOB HOB01"O ITOJIHTHqeCR01"O MHmneHHH, rrpoTMBo~eHcTBHH JIHHHH ~
HHCTP~HH Pe'tiraHa. Ho HMeHHO ~e¥1, a He "naKeT" KaK TaKOBoM.
Kopoqe, MbI C03~aJIH Kpa~He B~ M am¢eKTMB~ ITJI?q8apM ~JIlI
HaCTyilJIeHHR Ha PeA1"aHa. Tenepb, He yrryCKaH BpeMeHM, Hsgo e1"o pac
illliPHTb, npeBp~aTb B ilJI~apM HacTynJIeHHH Ha IT03~ HaM60JIee
Page 11
II.
rrpaBHX CRn, aKT~BHHX CTOpOHHHKOB rOHKH Boopy~eHHa B ~e~OM, 06ec
rreqHBaR B03MOEHOCTH gnR COTpYAH~eCTBa 3AeCb C yMepeHHo-ROHCepBa
THBHHME M ~H6ep~bHHMH rpyrrnHpOBKaMH B CllA ~ 3an~0~ EBpone.
06neKTMBHHe B03MO~OCT~ ~ SToro eCTb. rroc~e PeMKbRBMKa
~HCTP~M Pe~raHa nOMTHJIaCb Ha3a,IJ;. 3aJ.urB no C0l1 rr03~ e~e
60Ree BH3HBaIDmy~, qeM Ha CaMOa BCTpeqe, BamKHrToH, cy~ no BceMy,
nHTaeTCH 3apaHee HCKnDqHTb B03MOEHOCTb nO~O~TeRbHHX rrO~BHXeK no
~oMy M3 BOrrpOCOB Hamero "naKeTa", ~8.!te eC~H rry6JrWlHo YTBe~aeT
06paTHoe. OR npeBpan;aeT "rraKeT I1 B TyrrHK.
B BeJIOM ~OMe, rrOXOlKe, r.ny60Ko y6e~eHH, ~o "naKeT" HBJIReTCR
~ Hac rrpe~e~bHO~ rr03HqHe~. OTKJIZKH Ha rroc~e~e.BamM
.BblCTYrr~eHMH nORa3HBaIOT, qTO OT Hac i!,D,~H RaKIDC-TO HOBhIX rrpe,lVIO
lKeH~ H yCTynoK. He rroJIYqHB HX, B BamMHrTOHe ~OJIEHH CeMqaC rro~a
raTb, ~O HOBHe cepbe3BHe rrO~BMEKH B COBeTCKO~ rr03~~ MaJIOBepOHT
RH. "PaCmHypOBbIBaHHe rraKeTa" CTMO 6bI B STHX YC~OBIDDC em.e 0rW1~
aKTOM, ~O Ko~a p8.306~aqa.ICXql1M rrO~~IDiHY~ CY~OCTb rr03HW1H CIIIA rro
BorrpoCaM orpaH~qeHHH H CORp~eHHH BoopyxeH~.
B) He pearMpoBaTb Ha oQepe8HYD y~OBKY CllA HeJIb3H. ~H Hac
"rraKeT" RaR TaKoBoft - He IJ;eJIb, a cpe~CTBO. CoBeTCKaR CTopoHa He
~OJIEHa ~orryCTMTb, qTo6H BamHHrToH CeHJI COMHeHMH B HamKX HaMepe
HHRX, rrepeKJI~aJI Ha CCCP OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a OTCYTCTB~e rrpo~~
~eHHH Ha rreperoBopax, nepeXBaTHBaJI rrO~HT~qeCKyID HH~~aTHBY, P~CYH
06~eCTBeHHOMy MHeH~ID rrepcrreKTHBY "BnO~He pe~bHHX" 5O-rrpo~eHTHHX
COKp~eH~~ ~ rrp.
ReT YBepeHHocT~ B TOM, 'ITO ec~~ MH pa3BffiKeM "rraReT", rnmern
HHH aAMHH~CTPaQMH CllA rro~eT Ha C6aJIaHCHpOBaHHHe ~orOBopeHHOCT~
C HaM~. ~aKT~ CB~eTe~bCTBY~T CKopee a COBepmeHHO ~O~ Te~e~RM
Page 12
12.
B pa3BHTHH nOSKqHH Pe~raHa. Ho CTO~b ~e BepHO 11 ~yroe - B 06cTa
HOBKe saCTOR OTMeqaeTCR pasMHBaHHe ~POHTOB B San~OeBporreaCKOM
06~eCTBeHHOM MHeHHH H OTqaCTH aMepHKaHCKOM, 06e CBep~ep~BH rrpe~
CTaIDT O~HHaROBO Hecnoc06HHMH nOSHTHBHO OT~~KaTbCR Ha qaffHHR MaCC.
B nO~HTHKe BCer~a ~eHHa MaRCHManbHaff cB0608a MaHeBpa. "DaReT"
B HHHemHef:! ero <PoPMe CBHSlffiaeT HaM pyRH. Bpsr.n ~H eCTb OCHOBa.HIDi
o~aTb, qTO Bce 06pasyeTcR CaMO c060~, ~O Pe~raHa oce~T
B Pe~KbRBHKe OR yrryCTRn nyqmHH CBO~ maHC BOaTH B HCTOP~ He RHQe
~eeM, a rocy~apCTBeHHHM ~eHTeneM. ~H SToro Pe~raH 11 He~OCTaTOqHO
yMeH, H C~HIDKOM OppaHHqeH B cB06o~e B~opa.
llpH aHMltI3e Cl1Tya.$U1: c~eAYeT npHHJiTb B paCqeT e~e O~I1H
acrreKT. ITPH HarrHqROM COOTHomeHHH C~ eCC? rrpoT11Bo60pcTByeT C CiliA
He TO~hKO Ha MegyHapO,gHoA apeHe, HO H BHyTpH C8.MHX CInA. KoHetlHO ,
"HylKI-IOro" HaM rrpeSM,D.eHTa MbI He 1136epeM, "HYlmYlO" CCCP nOJIHTHKy
He BHymRM. Ho rrpe~OXpaHHTb ce6R OT xy~ero Mo~ew. CerO~R aTO
SHaQMT: Hap~BaTb ~aBJIeHl1e Ha Pe~raHa H CTO~l1e sa HEM KpyrH.
llp~aHHe COBeTCROMY no~o~ 60JIbme~ rH6KoCTH H ~HHaMHSMa TaKoe
~aBJIeHHe yCRnHT.
B) B HamHX JIM HHTepecax goroBopeHHOCTH no OTAeJIbHUM BOrrpOCaM?
,IIyMaeTcR, ~ MhI HYlKor~a He CTaBMM BOrrpOC TaR: "Bce l1~H FrnQero".
He CTaBHM ero TaR 11 ce~qac: He CBRSHBaeM "naKeT" C RAepHHMM HCTIHTa
HRffMH, XMMKqeCKHMH Boopy~eHHRMH. KaRHe ~orOBopeHHOCTH B npHHQHne
BOSM01KHbl?
I. ~ C o~oBpeMeHHHM pa3rOBoPOM no TaKTHqeCKRM paKeTaM.
~ Hac aTO 6HnO 6H paBHOSHaqHO YCTpaHeH~ OqeHb cepbe3Ho~ yrpo3H.
nO~HRJIO 6H Ham aBTopHTeT B EBpone. B KOHetniOM CqeTe o6~ertlliJIo 6H
~eJIa C MTaeM.
Page 13
13.
ITp06HBaTb coa, ec~ OHa 6y~eT Cos~aHa, paKeTaMH cpe~e~
~anbHocTH B RD60M c~ae BP~ nH rrpH~eTCH. PasBHS~BaHHe "naKeTa"
~e~aeT 3Ty ~oroBopeHHocTb ~OCTKEHMOM, coxpaaeHHe "naKeTa" ee
6noKHpyeT. 3~ecb B~ro~a Pa3BH3~BaHHH HanH~O.
2. 50-rrpoqeHTHoe COKp~eHHe cTpaTerH~ecKHx Boo~e~~, C o~
HOBpeMe~ no~~epKHB~eM H8meH rOTOBHOCTH npHcTynHTb H K nOnHO
MY MepHoMy pB.3oPJ']\emuo. ECJrn 6hl OHO 6blno BOSMO!aiO, BhlI'O~a TaKoro
cOKp~eHHH BO Bcex OTHomeHHRX HeCOMHeHHa: nOXHTHqeCKOM, 3KOHOMH
qeCKOM, MOpaJIbHOM, BoeHHOM. Hap8l1@BaHHe CHB MO;lleT HMeTb ct.niIcn
TOnbKO AnH rrpop~Ba coa, H TO STOT BOrrpOC e~e H§AO BcecTopoHHe
rrpoaaanK3HpOBaTb.
3. 3acny;HBaeT paccMoTpeHHR H cne8YD~aR MOAenb yperynHpOBa
HHH - 50-rrpO~eHTHOe cOKp~eHHe cTpaTerHQeCKHX Boop~eHH~ (peaJIb
HO HanonoBHHy YMeHbmanCR 6~ COCTaB HOCHTeneH H KO~QeCTBO 60esa
PMOB apH OCTaBxeHHK sa R~O~ KS CTOpOH npaBa CaMOM pemaTb, Ka
KOBO 6y~eT COOTHomeHHe MBP, IDIBP, TB), Op,HOBpeMeHHOe COKp~eHKe
Ha 50 npo~eHToB paReT cpe~e~ ~anbHOCTH CCCP H CllA B eBponeMcRoM
SOHe K COKp~eHHe Ha 50 rrpo~eHToB aMepHRaHCKHX cpe~cTB rrepe~OBO
ro 6a3HpOBaHHH. ITPH cornaCHH anA ~eKBaTHO YMeHbmHTb CITE B HrrOHHH
H Im:.Kopee CBeCTH K IOO e,II,Hmr~a.M (no 60eSapMaM) qHC~O PC,.q B ASHK
(cooTBeTcTBeHHo Ha TeppHTopKK CiliA).
ITPH 3TOM ~T~BaeTCH, ~o CiliA CBR3blBaIDT peanK3aqHD Mep no PC~
B EBpone co cTporHM KOHTpOneM. Cne~OBaTenbHO, c06cTBeHHo aMepKRaH
CKaB TeppHTopKH oKasanacb 6~ BHe KOHTponH, a rrpoBepKa B AHrJrnH,
~pr K ~.CTPaHax nOTpe60Bana 6~ cnoXHHX rrpo~e~ cornaCOBaHKR C
H~OHanb~ rrpaBHTenbCTBaMH.
noNJyT Jill CllA Ha TaKHe pemeIDIrr? Y7r.e HCHO, qTO !!pH PenraHe HeT'
B 3THX YC~OBH.ffX Hama rOTOBHOCTb K cornamerrnr> BHe "naKeTa" HMeJIa 6~
Tarrne ,rvIff Hac "rIJIDC~":
Page 14
14.
- 06HaMana 6~ no~~e n03K~H CffiA, CTaHOBH~aCb 6~ MO~
H ~O~rOBpeMeHH&M Cpe~CTBOM H~HWa Ha aMepKKaHQeB, HX KYPC;
- Hrpana 6~ PO~b CTHMy~a K Orp8HH~eHHD aCCRrHOBaHM~ Ha CO~
B auepHKaHCKOM KOHrpeCCe, CT~Myna TaM 60~ee Ae~CTBeHHOrO, ec~ 6~
YAanOCb COxpaHHTb KMeD~eCH OrpaHH~eHHH, COKpaTHTb KaKHe-TO BOOpy
~eHHH, XOTH 6~ ~. rrO~HTKqeCKH~ H nCHXO~OrHqeCKH~ ~~eKT TaKOrO
mara 6~ 6~ OqeHb BeCOM, oc06eHHO ~THBaH pac~e ~HHaHCOB~e
TPY~OCTH CillA.
4. C06cTBeHHo COX. nOKa COBeTCKH~ COD3 CTOHT Ha n03KQHH no~
Horo OTBe~eHHfl Boe~ TeXHOnOrH~, 3aKn~Bae~ B OCHOBy ~aHHO~
aMepHKaHCKO~ nporpaMMH. EC~H 6~Tb ~orH~ H y6e~Tenb~ B 60
pb6e C COM Ha ~TO~ nnaT~opMe, HaM Hy!H0 6HTb rOTOB~ K B~HXe
HHD K~eH He oppaHKqeHHH, a nOnHoro oTKasa OT CHCTeM ITPO, T.e.
yxeCTOqeHHH Tpe60BaHH~ AoroBopa 1972 r. ]E6oe OrpaHH~eHHe BcerAa
AByc~c~eHHO, OCTa~HeT ~ase~KH ~H 06xoAa H HeAOpa3yMeHK~.
3arrpeT Ha ITPO Mano QTO MeHKn 6s ~H Hac peanbHo, K60 3a no
c~e~ee AeCHTH~eTHe nOHBH~KCb CHCTe~, npOTHB KOTO~ nOKa He
C03AaHO 3~eKTK~ KOHTpcpeAcTB, a Ko~~eCTBe~e OrpaHKqeHHH no
AorOBOpy nnoxo YBH3~ C AeMCTBHTeXb~ MacmTa6aMH B03MO~ Mac
CHPOB~ YAapOB. CneAOBaTe~bHO, MOCKOBCKHn pa~OH ITPO HMeeT 3Ha
qeHKe XHmb KaK HccneAoBaTenbCKO-HCnNTaTenbHHn nonHrOH Ha c~aM,
eC~H BCTaHeT Bonpoc 0 pasBepTHBaHHH CHCTeM 060po~ H~OH~HO~
TeppHTopKH.
ilO-BH~OMY, CillA - no KpaMHe~ Mepe AO ~aKTHqeCKOrO onp060Ba
HHH pa3pa6aT~Bae~ HMH TeXHonorH~ Ha peaHb~ ~e~HX - He CTaHyT
BCTynaTb C HaMH B neperOBOp~ Ha npeAMeT rrpeBp~eHRH AoroBopa 06
OrpaHHqeHHH B AoroBop 0 3arrpe~eHHH ITPO. rroc~e~ee 6YAeT B03M~
B cEyqae, ec~ HC~TaHHH B paMKax CO~ OK~TCR pa30qapOBHBan~
H~ CaMH CHCTe~ HaCTO~bKO c~o~ H AOpOrHMH, QTO ~HrToH
Page 15
15.
npe~o~eT CBepHYTb CHCTeMY. O~aKO HCDHTaHHe sa npeAe~aMHc~eCT
BYID~ero AorOBopa OSHaqanO 6H OKOHqaHHe ero Ae~CTBHR, eCnn,DOHRTHO,
e~e ~O v.CnHTaHK~ CTOpOHH He YC~OBRTC~ 06 HHOM.
PeQb 06 yCTynRe aMepHKaHQaM B "mHpOKOM TO~KoBaHHH" AoroBopa
no ITPO Mor~a sa~K B rrpaKTKu.ecKoM n~aHe TO~bRO np* COOTBeTCTBYD
~e~ KOMneHCaQMH co CTOPO~ BamHHPTOHa. HanpHMep, Hax0!8eHHe cor
naCOBaHHoro MOAYca no npaBoMY cTaTycy KOCNHqeCROrO npocTpaHcTBa.
~a~ee, Bapa60TKa pernaUeHTagHH Ha onpe8eneHHRe BH8U 8eHTenbHOCTH
B KOCMoce, a eme ~e - B OTHomeHKH KOCMHqeCKHX 06oeKTOB. HaKO
Heg, YCTaHOB~eHHR 06oeKTHB~ KpHTepHeB An? pasrpaHHqeHHB 060POHH
TenbHoro H He060poHHTe~bHoro xapaKTepa CHCTeM, 80gycKBeMHX K pas
MemeHHD B KOCMoce, H MeToAHRH KOHTpOnH sa BHTIOnHeHHeM npHHBTHX
o6RsaTenbcTB.
B qeM c~cn B~~eHHff TaKoro po~a c006paMeHHR? Bo-nepBHX,
BP~ nH geneco06pasHo sa~M qHCnOM AaBaTb rrpOTHBHHKaM nOBOA
~~ff YTBe~AeHH~, 6Y~TO CCCP c~enan HeBOSU~HHM ycnex B Pe~KhRBKeKe,
CBBsaB RAepHoe pasopyxeHHe C COM. BO-BTOpHX, AeTanHSa~e~ Hamero
no~o~a (pacKpHTHe nOHRTH~, ~o TaRoe na60paTopHHe HccneAOBaHHB
H np.) 6~0 6H npoAeMOHCTpV.pOB8HO, KeROe pasBHTHe 6Hno 6H BOSMa.!
HO e~e B Pe~KbHBHKe, eCnH 6H eIDA cTpeMH~ch K C6nH~eHHID nosHHH~.
B-TpeThHx, nOCTaHOBKa Ha60pa BonpocoB ~ 06cJXAeHHB nOSBOnHT
6e3 ypoHa AnR Hamero npecT~a OCna6v.Th BsaHMosaBHCHMOCTh Me~AY
CHB H CO~, BSRTh npHHQHn napannenhHUX neperoBopoB.
B HenOM qaCTM~e 8oroBopeHHocTH - RaR no np06neMaM COM, TaR
H no BceN ~yrHM, - B HamHX HHTepeCax H no HX rrOTe~a~HOMY CO
Ae~a~, H TeM, QTO caMO HX H8nHqRe pacmupBno 6~, YRperr~no rro
nMTHKO-npaBOBYID 6a3Y COBeTCKo-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHomeHH~. Hy!HO MaR
CY-ManbHO paC~CTHTh pyTb R TaRHM cornameHHRM.
Page 16
16.
r) MHHgHaTHBa ce~c HaXOAHTCR Y Hac. MH BHCKaSa~ ~aReKO
H~e npe~o~eHHH, npe~pHHRRH marH K TOMy, ~06H c~e~aTb peaRb
HHM HX oc~eCTBReHHe. CIDA, 3ana~ OTBeTHnH Oqepe~HO~ cepHeA BCERoro
po~a "HO" H "eCRH" , HCK,YCCTBeHHUX H peanhHHX COMHeHH~. 3a~a~a
Tenepb - CRETh HCK,YCCTBeHHHe npenffTCTBHH H BHCTaBHTb H8 060speHHe
MHPOBO~ 06~eCTBeHHOCTH HCTHHHHe, rRY6HHHRe MOTHBH aMepHK8HCKO~
nOnMTHKH. ~ 3Toro HY!eH HOBH~ rrpopHB - C TeM, OARaKO, nOHHMaHHeu,
~O pea~fi H8 STOT npopHB B ellA no~eT no SHaKOMOu,y ~e Kpyry
(~O 60Ree, ~eM BepOflTHO), H CnyCTH KaKOe-TO BpeMfi Mo~eT TIOHa~O
6HTbCH ~aRbHe~ee paSBHTHe HamHX npe~~~eHH~ B HHTepecax no~e~a
HHR nOCTOHHHoro HaxHM8 Ha CllA (npH~n "MaTpemKH" npH ~OPMy~pOBxe
HHHnHaTHB).
e TOqKH speHHH Ha~OHaRhHO~ 6esonaCHOCTR eecp "paSBHSHBaHHe
naxeTa" He CBEsaHO HH C KaKHMH peanb~ "MHgycaMH": co~e~aHHe
npe~R~eHH~ OCTaeTCR no c~eCTBY npeXHHM. ~aKT paSBHSKH caM no ce6e
HHKaK He OSHaqaeT aBTOMaTRqeCKOrO SaKnIDqeHKH corRameHH~ Ha HeBHro~
HHX ~ Hac yCROBHRX. OCTaeTCH H BOSM~HOCTb BHcTynReHH~ npH He06
XO~OCTH C Ap,YrHMH YBHSK8MH H naKeTaMH.
CRO~HOCTbD nponara~CTCKoro nRaHa Mo~eT CT8Th Bonpoc, nOqeMY
B Pe~KbHBHKe MH CO~ He06xo~MHM BHCTyTIMTb HMeHHO C naKeTOM, a
He npOCTO C Ha6opOM npe~no~eHH~. AYMaeTcR, ~O aTa TPY~OCTb
Mo~eT 6HTh rrpeO~OReHa yKaSaHHeM Ha TO, ~O OTK8S OT npH~na
"naReTa" c~eRaH HaMH B OTBeT Ha HHH~aTHBH sana~HoeBpone~cKKX ro
cy~apcTB H npe~CTaBREeT HS ce6H yCTynK,Y. TaKO~ mar pas06naQan 6H
H nosHUHH KOHcepBaTopOB 3anaAHo~ EBpOITH. nOKasan 6H, qero CTOHT
Ha ~ene HX "CTpeMReHHe K cornameHHEM C eeCP".
He 6y~eT nM pasBRsKa "naReTa" HHTeprrpeTHpoBaTbcR RBR BHpaEeHMe
Hamen KpanHe~ SBHHTepeCOBBHHoCTH B cornameHHRX? By~eT, ROHe~o.
Page 17
17.
Ho H Ce~qaC Bce TaR ~HTepnpeT~pyeTCE. rrO~HRTb ypOBeHb Tpe60BaHH~
R HaM a~HHHcTpa~E Pe~raHa He Mo~eT: OH H TaK nO~HflT ~O npe~eEa,
a 06~aR nOYlHTM~eCKaR aTMoc~pa H nOSH~H a~HHCTpa~H ~aEeKO He
TaKHe, KaKKMH OH~ 6~ B 1981-1982 ro~ax. ~o npHxo~a xe K BEaCTH
HOBO~ a~HHHCTpaUHH CpOK eme 60~bmOa.
Y~THBaR, OABaRO, ~o C rrpHXO~OM K BEaCTH ~yro~ ~H~CTpa
~H MOryT C~OXHTbCB 6o~ee 6~aronpHBT~e ycnoBHH ~H AOCT~e~R
corEaIDeHH~, B TOM ~CEe H no npo6EeMaTHKe COM, rrpeACTaB~ReTCB
HaH60Eee ~e~ecoo6pasHHM sapaHee no~rOTOBHTb nOSH~H. "PacIDHYPOBH
BaHHe ITaKeTa" ce~ac 6~o 6H BOCnpHHRTO, nOMHMO rrpo~ero, H RaR
TaKaH no~rOTOBKa. Ha060poT, npH6~eHHe SToro K MOMeHTy AOCT~eHHff
6y~x AorOBopeHHOCTe~ AaBa~o 6H CllA 60nbme OCHOBaHHfi ~e~aTb BH
BOA 0 HaIDeH Kpa~e~ 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH B cor~ameHHRX.
ny6~~oe BHCTynAeHHe C pa3BR3KO~ naKeTa~ eCnH 6H OHO COCTOR
nOCb B 6~a~ee BpeMR, Mor~o 6H KOMrreHCHpOBaTb B rE8sax MHPOBO~
06meCTBeHHOCTH paRT OTBeTHoro B0306HOBEeHHR HaMH gAepHHX ~CTIHTaHH~.
Coo6p~eHHe B 88HHOM c~ae He pemanmee, HO Ta~e HY!8aDmeeCR B
zqeTe.
~) KpaAHe B~HO ce~ac He TepffTb B3HTHn TeMn, He ynyCKaTb
BpeMR. ECEH paSBR3HBaTb naKeT, TO Ae~aTb aTO Ha~o HMeHHO ce~ac,
H60 TI03~Hee S~KT c~eTCR CHEbHO ocna6AeHHHM:
- B HaCTo~ee BpeMR HHKTO He ~eT OT Hac TaKoro mara; Hanpo
THB, Ha 3aTIa~e H B CllA, noxo~e, KpeTIHeT BneqaT~e~e, ~O MH "no
CTaBHnH KpeCT" Ha a~HHCTpa~H Pe~raHa;
- ce~ac e~e ~a~eKO AO B~6opOB B ClliA. B~e K Haqany Hs6Hpa
TeEbHO~ KaMTIaHMH Ham mar HeHs6e~HO 6y~eT HCTonKOBaH MHorHMH KaK
TIODHTKa rrOBnHRTb Ha HCXO~ BH6opOB;
Page 19
19.
no OT~e~bHHM nOSH~flM), TaR H TIpo.qB~~eHMH KMM ceHqac RnH B 6y~eM
rOTOBHOCTH R COrRameHHHM.
B qaCTHOCTH, Tpe6yeT HsyqeHHH BeCb KOMnneKC BonpOCOB, CBflSaH
HHX C BOSMO~OCTbD oc~eCT~eHHH COBMeCT~X nporpaMM B ROCMoce
(B TOM qHc~e H RaK ~O~ ROHTPO~H sa HeOC~eCTBneHHeM orrpe~eReHHHX
B~OB BoeHHO~ ~eflTe~bHOCTH TaM), a TaKEE nporpaMM COTpy~HqeCTBa
B c~pe "BblCOKHX TeXHo~orHH".
HaMH no cymecTBy e~a S8TpOH,YTH B03MOXHOCTH Mep no BoeHHO~
nKHHH, Haq~aR OT np~ KOHTaKTOB Me~ BOeHHHME Be~OMCTBaMH H
KORtieR, B03Momo, HeKOTopOH "CTblKOBKOH" CHCTeM KOM~OBaHHH H yn
paBJIeHHfl.
Tpe6YIDT HsyqeHHH npaBOB~e aCneRTbl npoJIeT8 H~ HaqHOHaJIbHO~
TeppHTopHe~ KOCMHqeCKHX CHCTeM Boop,y~eHHi1, eCJIH H Kor~a TaRRe
CHCTeMH HaqRyT paSBepTblBaTbCH (c6HBaTb RnH He c6HBaTb B MHpHoe
BpeWl) •
BO~bmaH TeM8 ~R aHanH3a - B03MOMHOCTH HCnOJIb30BaHHH HaMH
Ha BSaHMHO~ OCHOBe Me~apo~ nPOqeAYP 11 yc~r TpeTbHX CTpaH
B BonPOcax KOHTpoJIfl, ap6HTp~a H T.n.
B TO ~e BpeMH Heo6xo~o no~epKHyTb, qTO nepeqHCJIeHHRe 11
KHHe rrp06JIeMH Tpe6yDT C HaIDeM CTOpOHR BHMMaTeJIbHOrO KX aH8nKSa
B JIRJ60M c.rry'tiae, 6esoTHocHTe~bHo K "naKeTy", pasBH3Ka KOToporo
Mo~eT cne~aTb He06xOAHMHM JIKmb HeKoTopoe yCRopeHMe TaKoM pa60T@.
Brrpo'tieM , M TaKoe yCKopeHHe Ta~e ~eJIaTeJIbHO B JIRJ60M cgyqae.
f!;t! t7