Top Banner

of 21

Those Who Knock on Europe’s Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

Jun 04, 2018

Download

Documents

TransformEurope
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    1/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door MustRepent?Bll Bd D d EU El

    Adw Gdd d Adw Tyl

    N. 54 | N 2013

    WORKING PAPER

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    2/21

    2 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    KFG Working Paper Series

    Edited by the Kolleg-ForschergruppeT Tafmav Pw f E

    T KFG W P S d l f Kll-F y

    ll d l. I d x wll d d

    x l d xl d E d E U.

    All KFG W P ll KFG w www.f. dd

    l [email protected].

    Cy f : Adw Gdd d Adw Tyl

    Edl d d: Ad B d Fl B

    Gdd, Adw/Tyl, Adw 2013: T W K E D M R? Bll Bd D d

    EU El, KFG W P S, N. 54, N 2013, Kll-F (KFG) T TfPw f E F U Bl.

    ISSN 1868-6834 (P)

    ISSN 1868-7601 (I)

    T l fdd y G R Fd (DFG).

    F U Bl

    Kll-F

    T Tf Pw f E:

    T E U d D f Id

    I. 26

    14195 Bl

    Gy

    P: +49 (0)30- 838 57033

    Fx: +49 (0)30- 838 57096

    [email protected]

    www.f.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    3/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 3

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent?

    Bilaal Bd Di ad EU Elagm

    Adw Gdd ad Adw Tayl

    Abstract

    T xl ld f wd d EU l; ly ll d

    w M S d l, w f , ,

    l l d. A w w ly f - Ily d Sl,

    Sl d C, d G d Md - EU f w d lwy w

    wd wd . T q l

    l w ld l y flly l

    f . O l EU f w x f d

    ld d f d. W l w dy

    l, l lly dlz wy ld dl EU ly. I

    C f d ld llly d-y.

    T A

    Adw Gdd Pf f Pl Uy f Sld. H w-

    xly f B, E d EU l, w l

    f l f . R l ld Migraon and

    Mobility in the EU(w C Bwll) d The EU and South East Europe:

    The Dynamics of Mul-Level Governance and Europeanisaon (w Adw

    Tyl d Cl L). H w V Fllw Kll-FT Tf Pw f E J/Jly 2012. F Fy 2013,

    wll ld f 5-y E R Cl dd

    j l .

    C: .dd@ld..

    Adw Tayl Pf f Pl Uy f Sld. H w l -

    ESRC fdd j dl f l-ll

    S E E. I y w fd Ez

    f W Bl d f ;

    State Failure(Pl Mll) d j

    EU l -ld W Bl. H l w l f

    d Ud Kd.

    C: .j.yl@ld..

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    4/21

    4 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    Contents

    1. Id 52. Bd d E I 6

    3. Ily - Sl 7

    4. C - Sl 10

    5. FYROM - G 12

    6. Cl 16

    Rf 18

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    5/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 5

    Those who knock on Europes door such as Ljubljana must make a gesture of repentance.

    (Gianfranco Fini in Corriere della Sera 1994: 5)

    1. Id

    Sd f l f l w E C f

    M S d l y. El , d l d

    d l d l w, xl l. Cl

    l M S collecvelyw y l d ( )

    dd y fy EU lly, d w fy -

    l, l . M S , f, d ll l . A

    ld f ll d w M S d l, w

    f , , l l d. T d

    xly d w x , w Ily d Sl, Sl d C, d

    G d Md.

    W w EU f w d lwy w wd wd

    d q l l w

    ld l y flly l f . E

    d dl f y wl E d -

    zd ld, l d fzzy (f xl, R 1993; F/My 1999; C

    l. 2004). Hw, d dy d fy w l w d/d d

    /-, w w yy dly f f f. T x

    : w Ily d Sl y Dlz, I d F;

    P By w C d Sl; d, d w G d Md. T

    d w f lx f Bl l fd y E , d

    y xl l w E d

    (H 1966). T l d f l EU d y Lx

    d Slf w w : x f l ll f

    f f E d f w f dd (2009:791-92). T f w d d f d l d

    ld ly w l, l d l l d

    (Bzl/R 2012). Hw, , w d xd . I Ily-Sl

    w d f f f E d, C-

    Sl d, EU, wl ll l w dw d l, d

    G-Md w EU flly l.

    Bd -ll dl dy lx l d ll d y y:

    y fy d-d (Wl 1993) d l-xl (Ll 1998),

    w l d, w ly l d, d d

    d (Bw 2001: 119). T EU l f d, d f dd l-,

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    6/21

    6 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    z d d w d. Bd y

    dly . T d xd x f d d d-

    , d Wl -y wll j f dy d d dl

    (Nw 2001: 147).

    2. Bd ad Ea Iga

    I Al, Gd Wwll, G f , d Bl

    l lly l : T l f ,

    dy, f E U, w w fd f f ydy. T wy

    dw f l d f q, ld Bl. I E, d

    l (D Wll 2013). Wwll ly d y f

    EU d.

    F d My (1999) w w EU d d -,

    E d y dl f y. Udl f EU -

    (R 1993). F d My (1999), dw S (1996), dfy -ll, l/

    ll, l d ll d d, d, ld d, d

    d w EU ld d l d, - d

    lly (F/My 1999: 217). T w w fzzy d. C l.

    (2004) f E l d, w w d

    Yl -. I y dl, y dy f -

    lx d l. F xl, w d y dld d

    -dld d EU -dl, dl (All 2004).

    I l, w wld x d w yy w d d d d

    f f. T l w f l d y -

    f d d y (Ml 2002; Gdd/Tyl 2013). E

    l d ( M S) d d (l ) d f l w

    z l. F d d d, dy , w -l d d d, l d. Hy w EU l

    dy l dly -EU d f l f -

    f l . F l y lly ld, l w EU

    d l (Klly 2004; S 2012). E y ll dy d f EU -

    (, f xl, EU f Nl P Pz) l - ,

    ll dy l - . T EU l , lly,

    l f. El ld d lld y

    l d EU . T lly d

    ly f d l d l -EU ly d l, w

    y EU.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    7/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 7

    Dz l. (2006) dfy f EU d d. T , compulsory impact, w

    l dl f l (Slf/Sdl 2004) w

    w yy d dly f d d -

    (Dz l. 2006: 575). T w yy d l wld f w ld x d d ld f f d

    f d w d ly . If EU ( wll ) l l, w

    ?

    O w EU x l d . Enablingl

    l d EU d jfy dlly ll . T j

    f d l dd d f EU jfy d l

    dd. D wd f xd f l (Dz l. 2006: 578)? Ay -

    l l , f, l l d y xly -:

    connecve (Dz l. 2006: 581). T EU y l, l l. T

    w y idexe ll, l EU f f

    d f f f ly, w EU dlz .

    EU x-d x f l d EU , d

    lf dy, l f fl - . E w EU

    l, f, construcve (Dz l. 2006: 584). Sl d l

    y-wd d f dwd y d dy. T EU

    l ( d y H 1966), l d

    ly, lz ly . T w l: , f f

    l, d ly ; d d, x-ddy

    w d x . T EU , f f,

    l -fl. R EU d l (Vd

    2005) ( l lz) d d l . T

    lly y dd d l

    w. A ly q l d l l, ll d-

    ll x d dd f EU d l . T, w d

    xd . I Ily-Sl , d (Ily) d ly; C-Sl

    EU, d f ll, w l fl l; d lly, G-Md d f ld , d l d f EU

    d f d .

    3. Ialy - Slvia

    Bw Ily d Sl l 199 ld d d 29 d d ll ly

    w l f d [d] d y f ll y w xll x-

    l f x (Kl/G 2001: 130). T Ily-Sl d l ddd

    w d l d. F xl, Czz (2007) d f f d

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    8/21

    8 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    d f d Ily l d f

    d d qly f l f d Cld W. W Il

    ll y f w fl ly -f f Il l.

    A d f Sd Wld W d 350,000 Il d Dlz, F d I (y

    w d dd , le foibe); y d w lzd y T. T - d

    -f Il l d ldly l le foibe, d l f

    l l dy (Fy 10) d y 2004 lw.

    T Ty f P (Fy 1947) dd Yl Z, ld f Pl, y f F d

    f I l, w f y f T d UN . I 1954 Yl -

    d T Il l. Ud Ty f O (N 1975) w Ily d Yl,

    Ily d l l I l d w ld y f -

    l (T 1980, Ud 1982 d Ljlj 1988) d ld (Kl/G 2001). T

    - f Yl d Sl dl f dd d dy EU , ld

    y Ily, f l d d P d d y Ty f

    O. L w q f y f Il d w. Al 68 f

    Sl f 1991 d y f ld y -Sl z. I 1992 -d-

    d ld R w dl f ld z

    d l .

    T l y d f Cl Azl C

    (Al 1993 My 1994) d d y , -ld Bl l

    l f 1994, w ldd f -f M Sl Il-Allz

    Nzl (MSI-AN). I O, Il f M d w ll

    ld: f y d fl y f xl.

    M d Ed, EU dd (L

    Rl 1994).

    T w l x EU wld w Ily -

    ld w dz f -f d f f MSI AN

    (Jy 1995). T ld w d dld y y ldGf F y f T O 1994. T I q w lly

    f AN w l T d ld f MSI. T d-

    l f AN w d y f w E dy:

    l l dd f l d d d l-

    w EU. T MSI-AN d l wld fd f w

    Sl l d f Sl w d d f y .

    Hw, C dll S (1994) w, F ld f y l y,

    d ld f l w l

    ld. F w l dly, f xl y U. S. d w

    lly dly f l-l. T U. S. w l y f Yl

    wd EU. T dl f F w dy/f d ll/l

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    9/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 9

    d, w w fd w dl : E l? T Sl

    w f ld MSI l d d ly -

    y, AN.

    F l w d w y lly T (O 1994). Idd y ll

    f l wd f d-l , w wd- wd y : Triesni:

    d y l fd f Sl? T w wd dd N!. El dy,

    F d dld AN d w f d dy (w ll ld f d-

    y) d , F d l f l dy w wll

    , z ld d 1994 w Il d Sl f

    d Aql d d Pl. F d w

    E d f ; Sl d z ld I d

    Dlz w Il d y l f (le foibe) w w w

    f l ld y T fllw (C dll S 1994).

    T fll f Bl (D 1994) dd

    ld y L D, w dd d Sl l ll

    l d wy f . T d w - w ll

    ld ly jy . T dl : Ily wld

    l Sl wl Sl wld f x-Il

    y. T d ly f AN w F Pl

    dd f f d Pl. F w ly

    l f fl l Pl w Ud-Sy f F A, S All,

    d (4 M 1995) Il wld l f l w

    Sl. D d A Ty w Sl d EU J 1996 x-Y-

    l y wd EU. T EU lyd y l . T Sl

    (A 1995) w d y S F M J Sl d S EU dy.

    I qd Sl wld, w f y f f , z

    f EU z y y Sl w dly xdd EU z

    d dd f l y Sl y, ldd I l f. T

    q f f y w l .

    I My 1996 D w ld y -l ld y R Pd. T

    Ud-Sy f F A w P F f -l Ol T . I

    y, Per Passione, F (2003) w Pd d ld y Pd Cl x-

    d l fl Sl . Ud Pd, Il d l

    wld d l f f y f d wl F d f

    Sl y wld Sl . T ld d

    f Il . T w l Il . Sl

    w ly d y G wl Sl w l

    f E Bl wd j EU d NATO.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    10/21

    10 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    I f wd wd. T w lly ld l l f

    f le foibe f Il l d dz f -f

    d F. F q f l d d ll ly d

    E. T f D d Pd w y l f US, d w l ly -E, w -d y l

    x f d y .

    4. Caa - Slvia

    I ly-1990 C d Sl d ( w , -

    f d S-dd fd) f dd ll l w

    , ylzd y d By f P (Bl R 2004) d y f y

    d d ql () lzd d l l d ll ld

    (RFE/RL Nw 2009). T d d w d ly xlly y

    Yl -, w dd d f 668 w d wfl yl

    f l l d d fdly l w EU (A 2002; /

    Aly 2007).

    D l d f Sl dd dl d x l d-

    (u possides juris) fllw y Sl dld y lf (S

    2010: 93-111). C, f Al 15 f UN C Lw f S, ld

    d ld qd f w Sl zd d

    l f ex aequo et bono(d d d f qy d ) w

    d w l f lw f f w y d f d ql.

    A l d l Jly 2001 w Sl d C , Jz D

    d I R, fld D- R A d 3.6 y 12 d

    ( 80 f P By) f Sl d w y d

    EU wll lz ll l w w l d ylz-

    w l Bl. Hw, ly, Sl (f xl, Sl

    Nl Py d Sl D Py) d d , J J,w f f y Sl, d l

    f l l: 1918 l f C A, 1945 l f T d Gz, 1954

    l f Sl y f M R () (Bl R 2001). Sl l

    d D- R A C dd d d R

    f d C Sl, d fd Il C

    f J T H (ICJ). M w xd y C 2003 dl f d -

    ll z Ad. C l w xl z d dw

    f EU d . C l w d N d

    ( C P Py d Py f Hl R) dld dl l-

    l z d Sl y. O y, D Py f Rd P, d

    l f f Idd S f C d w wdd l f

    f fl dfd Sl y (Bl R 2003).

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    11/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 11

    I 2007 C d Sl , I Sd d Jz J, d l f

    d H. T -lld Bld A jyd C , w

    Sl l , d j wd d f . I

    2007 Sl d C l ll d d (f w P By w ly ) w f j d yl f ll

    -ll , d C EU w Sl f , D

    Rl, l . A Sl w w f d d ll l-

    w Sl Nl Py ld y Z Jl d , Dj Rl ( f

    Sl D U) d D M ( f ) f .

    T w w wl Sl (ld ld f Sl Pl Py) w

    d y C d l J J ( ). T P M, A

    R, dld - 2004 l (w R l) C w l

    f EU.

    T EU, f y f l, d w ll . C w -

    d y C d d ( l w dl; w

    ) C d w dd , w Sl d fl

    l C d ld . Oll R, l -

    , w ld f Cy f , wd d C w

    ll d d ll d l (Bl I 2008).

    T C d Sl d, S M d Dl T, lld f dl, w T

    D- R A l wy fwd d ly f l -

    . T C jd f f d-y . I 2007 Sl d

    d f ICJ qly d , d f-

    wd F , ld EU Pdy, d l. Szy d

    Sl d C -jd d d fl

    w l. T l dd -dy d f Sl d d

    Szy C f P R (COREPER). Of EU ly

    Sl d F l d w d. Sl d

    ld d l ll , w d, EU -

    w wll - EU f d d. Sly,

    F C Sl d.

    O 19 D 2008 Sl ld f w w C. T

    EU d d zd Sl -E

    . S C l, ld d, d Sl ll ly d

    EU l f d l C w ll,

    EU l q (Bl I 2008). Jd l df f Sl

    , 23 J d 23 Jly Sl ld l f f w C.

    I Jy Sl d l C NATO. T x-ly Py f

    Sl N d I f 25 J d 5,000 f fd C

    , w l M ddl 40,000 dd l f-

    d. T fld dlly (ly f 2,500 w d) d C jd NATO Al

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    12/21

    12 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    2009. Al l w C d, ly lwd d Sl

    d fqly wld l d w ld.

    W R , d l d x ll, w dld ly l wy fwd w l w ld y d w

    w d f ld (C w ll ICJ). Nl, ly

    2009 w w d w EU ll , -

    ld w f d-y . N w d w Sd

    d P M Sl, f C ICJ d l

    E-ll l. R fd y fl EU l dd C wld fl

    d: I f E C ll ()

    w E , l dly d w C j

    EU (Bl I 2009). R d - l f ll x dl j -

    jd d d ld , d d l .

    Sl d C w wy fwd ll w d l I Sd

    1 Jly 2009. H w dd y Jd K. A w l y, d (

    11 S Ljlj) ld l dl f d K fd Swd

    Pdy C wld jd d (lly F l)

    d P d Sl wld ld, wld l d EU

    . T l f w ld Z (26 O); 2 N

    C l d , w w d Sl 4 N

    2009 (RFE/RL Nw: N 4, 2009). D Sl l

    (, , d f, y d df) fd d l

    y 51.4 48.5 J 2010. T l (25 My 2011) d -

    l d f l ll x ( w jly ld f l f y

    w , w wld l ) d d- l w d

    w UN. I w xd y l d d wld d.

    N E C, EU, w y , d

    ll , C wld d d , ld

    ll l f f dl f d ly l w w

    wll f W Bl [] w w dl ld ld (CEC 2012, 1).

    5. FYROM - G

    Md dld dd f Yl (S 1991); ld

    Rl f Md d d G d d f .

    T G f y fdl l f l lw d

    d [d] f d ly l, y d l y. Md -

    d f d d l () f f y d f

    G l d l ; dd w d l d

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    13/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 13

    f Md , w w ld ylly fl f y d

    xl f Md (). I G d ly

    f l d l d d [f FYROM] d ld

    NATO d EU (Hll Rl, .d.; l REF/RL 2011). T Md w y l ld dd d f

    d dlz . My Md d FYROM ll d xl -

    f w d l d l d l (RFE/RL 2005).

    Md dd d ly ld f (T 1995). T

    E C (EC) f Bl d Dl Yl (16

    D 1991). T ldd y x-Yl d l

    d ll l l wd Cy S

    d wll d l d Cy S, ld

    d f w l l l (ASIL 1992: 1486). T Dl ld

    d w Bd C ( A C f Yl, d

    f EU Yl) wld Md q f , l

    w llly d. Bd ldd ( fll O 6, dld

    11 Jy 1992) Md f d, xlly d ll -

    l l l, ldd f Md f ly y l

    l S (T 1993: 77-80). EC f G (2 My 1992)

    dld d , l ll d fd. A l

    dd Md w l Md , wl

    l w l G d dd

    f d w A d Sj, w f () x d f f EU

    ly q (R 1993, 53).

    O 30 Jly 1992 Md ld f UN l lld f y lly

    l f l y (Pll 2004). Hw, d 1992 l d,

    IMF d Wld B, ly dd ll f Yl Rl f Md

    (FYROM) w, Jy 1993 ( l f F, S d UK), w d y UN

    Sy Cl jd y G d Md. Ud f EU d NATO,

    C M, G P M, dd FYROM l M, dd Sj . O 7 Al Sy Cl dd Gl Aly FYROM

    d UN w l ddd (UN 1993; 1993). T w

    flly d G jd FYROM d d M d FYROM jd F, w

    lly d d ( f) x Tld. Al UN d w d-

    y, FYROM w dlly d .

    Bll l w flzd y I Ad (13 S 1995). T f

    Mx B l; f y w d (G w Py f P d FYROM

    Py f Sd P) fl dl l w ld, f w d

    ll, Md dd V S l yl d d ,

    l d ll y wld xld y d, f l d d

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    14/21

    14 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    ( d d y G 1993 w d d U.S. ) wld llwd, d

    wld l d UN l d (UN 1995). A ,

    ddd l d f (RFE/RL 2005).

    FYROM d UN ld f G f , A S, df f

    Nw Dy, ld fll f M d df y Pd PASOK

    O 1993. T w PASOK dd d l. T Md l-

    d UN dl 30 28 w 18 VMRO-DPMNE (Il

    Md Rly Py D Py f Md Nl Uy) lld f -

    d w d. N d d dlly d

    l 5 f I Ad ll dl ll d.

    T l l w G wd Md, d lly

    l d y f d (f xl, N Mdj, Vd Md);

    G d l f Rl f Md d

    y ql wll fll dd. T Sj fl ql wld

    ld q f dy; Pd C, f xl, d l Md wll

    y Rl f Md dl w f wld (RFE/RL

    2005). G d l z d FYROM fld. I M 1997, f

    xl, w l d , G f , Td Pl,

    Md Pd, K Gl, d dly dd y f Md d

    ly w f l (Nl 1997).

    Ud I Ad G w FYROM f l z.

    A NATO B (Al 2008) G f - f FYROM w d

    (NATO 2008: 21). W EU, J 2008 EU Cl xd

    FYROM wld l w EU fy dly ld dw

    l d d lly l l

    l (CEC 2008, 6). T, d f l .

    G ly w d y VMRO-DPMNE ly f Azzj (qz). T VMRO-

    DMNPE l f VMRO, z fd 1893. I dd

    -/C d, -NATO d EU , d l, dw lf f Md. A 1990 VMRO-DPMNE w l y fd

    f l w Al d yd 1994 l; 1998 dd l w

    D Py f Al. I 1999 VMRO-DPMNE dd l d. I 2002

    VMRO-DPMNE w dfd d 2004 l dy. Ry 2006 w

    d qz ly, w ld NATO - w

    d VMRO-DPMNE 2008 l, w ll xl (RFE/RL

    2008). I 2008 ly l VMRO-DPMNE ll l lld 48.7 f

    . I D 2006 Sj w d Ald Vl (Alxd G) d

    l f Alxd d f Pl II f Md w d, l l

    f 22 W H Sj 2011 d l f Pl II ld f

    q f Sj 2014 wl . S d, wy d ,

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    15/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 15

    wll d q ll d (RFE/RL 2011). A d, w

    x f dy, d f -ld x, d f -

    d (Kz 2009). T Sj 2014 j d qz ly f y

    l f l ll f , lly Al d l y Md w d . T j d w EU f d,

    y ly G, lly (ICG 2011: 23).T

    (f G ) w Md d d w l l w MK

    l d. Jd z w EU l, G d l d d-

    l w y- (OC 2012).

    Aqz ly lly d l yy. I l ld f

    w l d f VMRO-DPMNE, w d d

    Od A d w l w Al y d jdz l ly. T

    fdl Md dy, dly ll f Al, d y l l l

    wld d ll . Al l d l wl x

    dq wy G d VMRO-DPMNE d d d

    ly f wd EU y f w G. Cf

    d fl; ly l d-y . Pl d y

    l fd, w l l l q w-d jy

    55 (64 d Al ) f f EU -

    (ICG 2011: 20-21).

    I N 2008 FYROM d d G ICJ, ll f Al

    11 f I Ad l FYROM NATO . I jd (5 D 2011)

    ICJ fd (y 15 1, ly G jd d ) G d d I Ad

    ld d G ly G w y

    z (ICJ 2011). EU l w Md (Tyl l. 2012) x -

    d f Slz d A P (SAP) d w fly dy

    (16 J) dd ld . A Slz d A A (d

    9 Al 2001) f 1 Al 2004, FYROM W Bl y

    f. O 9 N 2005 C d O FYROM l

    f d dd dd , w E Cl d D. I J 2007 E Pl d l , , d Md,

    EU d l , wy d

    l f d EU (RFE/RL 2007).

    T EU l ll w ld y UN d

    f f l (RFE/RL 2009). T C w d -

    ld ll d EU ll 27 EU f . I

    O 2009 C dd w ld

    y G l w ld. T H Ll A Dl (HLAD) w d y

    E Cl D 2012 f f G . A

    f HLAD l d d UN d l Nw Y (29-30

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    16/21

    16 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    Jy; 8-9 Al) w (CEC 2012: 11-12). I 2009 D D, w d

    f y l w P M Pd, dld, T ld -

    f w f w Sj (). W ll l

    d l (RFE/RL 2009). T . T C wll f wl G y d y f E-z d w

    l d l.

    6. Cli

    I l? T d d x f EU l

    d d l , lly. O fy l EU

    f w x f d ld d f d.

    T d f E f w -

    f d dd d l l.

    Ed f Cl d E E (CEE) l d, l d, W

    Bl w l w dy l l lly dlz

    wy ld dl EU ly. I C f

    d ld llly d-y.

    I ll f d , d l l dy l

    d l j d y ll d f y

    y EU.

    T j f : , l d ll l

    f dy; d, d l l ; d d,

    j l f l, l w l d E . All

    -d EU fldd l, f wd d

    d d d y l d d d. Hw, y l l

    f l-. T f l ly dw EU

    d l w yy d l d f l wld f f d. Nl, w, EU l

    , d ll ld l. T EU

    ly ( Dz l. 2006) xl nonef . A f EU l

    d dx: w yy l l, w ly

    , ly l EU f w ld dlz d-

    l d l y l lll l. A l w l:

    f d, l, w ll w w d w d . W

    d f d (Ily-Sl), l dj (Sl-C) d l

    (G-Md) xld y, , f ; d d, xd -

    y d y EU dd d f EU f.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    17/21

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    18/21

    18 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    Rf

    Ansell, Christopher K.2004: R y d ly, : All, C K./Pl, G- d (d): R Tly: E d Ud S Cd, Cd:

    Cd Uy P, 3-18.Arnaut, Darmir2002: Sy W Wy H S: T C f Tl S Dl

    Bw C d Sl, : Jl f O d Cl Lw 21/8, 1-39.

    ASIL 1992: E Cy: Dl Yl d Gdl Rl f NwS, : Il Ll Ml 31/6, 1485-1487.

    Balkan Insight2008: Sl Bl C EU P, 16 O, ://www.l.//l/l-l----, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Insight2008: Bl R Sl V C Bd, 18 D, : ://ld.l-.///w/15675/?l=297, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Insight2009: EU: Sl, C Ud Md, 6 M, : ://ld.l./

    //w/17188/?l=297, d 15 O 2013.Balkan Report2001: Sl d C R Bd A, 3 A, : ://www.fl./

    /l/1341147.l, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Report 2003: N Sl R Nw C Z, 17 O, : ://www.fl.//l/1341040.l, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Report2004: Sl d C: T Pl f D, 20 A, : ://www.fl.//l/1340991.l, d 15 O 2013.

    Brzel, Tanja A./Risse, Thomas 2012: F E d: Id, : W EPl 35/1, 1-19.

    Bw, C 2001: Bd d Idy Il Pll Ty, : Al, M/J,

    Dd/Ld, Yf (d): Id, Bd, Od: R Il Rl Ty,M d Ld: Uy f M P, 117-136.

    Caaruzza, Marina 2007: LIl l C Ol, Bl: Il Ml.

    CEC2012: R f C E Pl d Cl. T F YlRl f Md: Il f Rf W T Fw f H Ll A- Dl d P Of Gd Nly Rl. COM(2013) 205 l, S-: E C.

    CEC2010: Bd A A w Sl d C MEMO/12/8, Bl: EC.

    CEC2008: Cl f E U. Pdy Cl, 19-20 J. 11018/08 CONCL2, B-

    l: E C.ernic, Jernej L./Avbely, Matej 2007: T Cd f P By: Sl C T C

    f M Dl, : Jl f Il Lw d Ply 5/2, 1-19.

    Chrisansen, Thomas/Peto, Fabio/Tonra, Ben2004: Fzzy l d fzzy d: T EU N Ad, : C d C 35/4, 389-415.

    Corriere della Sera1994: F: ll Sl , 19 O.

    Deutsche Welle2013: Gy Bl: D l , 23 Fy, : ://www.dw.d/y--l-d-l-/-16623276, d 15 O 2013.

    Diez, Thomas/Steer, Stephan/Albert, Mathias 2006: T E U d d : T -f w f E , : Il Oz 60/3, 563-593.

    Fassino, Piero2003: P P, Ml: Rzzl.

    Friss, Lykke/Murphy, Anna 1999: T EU d Cl d E E: d d, :

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    19/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 19

    Jl f C M Sd 37/2, 211-232.

    Geddes, Andrew/Taylor, Andrew J.2013: Hw EU Cy B S S: M d B-d Sy S-E E, : W E Pl 36/1: 51-70.

    Hellenic Republic.d.: FYROM N I, A: My f F A, : ://www.f.//

    FYROM--/, d 15 O 2013.

    Homan, Stanley1966: O Ol? T F f N-S d C f WE, : Ddl 95/3: 862-915.

    ICG2011: Md: T Y A T C. E R N215, Sj, Il d Bl:Il C G.

    ICJ2011: Al f Ad f 13 S 1995 (T F Yl Rl f M-d . G) Jd 5 D, T H: Il C f J.

    Kelley, Judith G.2004: E Pl E. T Pw f N d I, P, NJ: P- Uy P.

    Klemeni, Mladen/Gosar, Anton2001: T l f Il-C-Sl d dl

    N Ad, : Gjl, 52/2, 129-137.

    Kuzmanovski, Blagoje2009: W I A N? Y Wld A T Q If Y Ld Md-, : RFE/RL, Jy 30, : ://www.fl.//Md__W_T_S_H_G_N_/1376847.l, d 15 O 2013.

    La Repubblica 1994: Cd l ll Sl. R L , 7 O.

    Lavenex, Sandra/Schimmelfennig, Frank2009: EU Rl Byd EU Bd: Tz Exl G-, : Jl f E Pl Ply 16/6, 791-812.

    Linklater, Andrew 1998: T Tf f Pll Cy, Cd: Ply P.

    Mali, Walter2002: Sy B Rl I, : Il Sd Rw 2/2,149-180.

    Naegele, Jolyon 1997: Md: G M V Sl I Rl, : RFE/RL, 9M, : ://www.fl.//l/1083950.l, d 15 O 2013.

    NATO2008: NATO Cl B S Dl, 3 Al, Bl: N Al Ty O-.

    Newman, David 2001: Bd, d d : ll, : Al, M/J, Dd/Ld, Yf (d): Id, Bd, Od: R- Il Rl Ty, M d Ld: Uy f M P, 137-152.

    OConnor, Coilin 2012: L B: Md N Pl R G I, : RFE/RL, Jy26, : ://www.fl.//d--l---/24626570.l,

    d 15 O 2013.Phillips, John2004: Md. Wld d Rl Bl, Nw H d Ld: Yl U-

    y P.

    RFE/RL2011: G Cz Md O Alxd T G S, RFE/RL, J 16, : ://www.fl.//d_lxd_____d/24237371.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL2009: Md F A S I M El, RFE/RL, Jy 27, : ://www.fl.//Md_EU_F_A_S_I_M_El/1375434.l, d15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL 2009: G A Cll Md EU A, RFE/RL, O 28, : ://www.fl.//G_A_Cll_Md_O_EU_A/1863435.l, -d 15 O 2013.

    REF/RL2008: Md: Vl M Gl El, RFE/RL, J 1, : ://www.fl./-/l/1144531.l, d 15 O 2013.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    20/21

    20 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    RFE/RL2007: Md W EU S I N D, RFE/RL, J 6, : ://www.fl.//l/1143886.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL2005: Md Pd O Fl T Ed N D W G, RFE/RL Nwl,Jy 24, : ://www../w/l/fl/2005/05-01-24.fl.l, d 15O 2013.

    RFE/RL 2005: Nw Dl Md-G N Rw, Bl R, Al 15, : ://www.fl.//l/1340941.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL News2009: Sl/C: A Nw D Bll Rl, 1 A, : ://www.fl.//l/1060066.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL News 2009: Sl, C S Bd A Dl, 4 N, : ://www.fl.//Sl_C_S_Bd_A_Dl/1869476.l, d 15 O2013.

    Rich, Rich 1993: R f S: T Cll f Yl d S U, : E J-l f Il Lw 4/2, 36-65.

    Ruggie, John G. 1993: Tly d yd: lz dy l l, :Il Oz 77/1, 139-174.

    Sancin, Vasilka2010: Sl-C Bd D: F D- R P-K A,: E P 2/2, 93-111.

    Schimmelfennig, Frank/Sedelmeier, Ulrich2004: G y Cdly: EU Rl Tf Cdd C f Cl d E E, : Jl f E Pl Ply 11/4:661-679.

    Smith, Michael J.1996: T E U d E: l d f d, :Jl f C M Sd 34/1, 5-28.

    Stroschein, Sherrill 2012: E Sl, Cx, d Dz E E, Cd:Cd Uy P.

    Taylor, Andrew J./Geddes, Andrew/Lees, Charles2012: T E U d S E E. TDy f Ez d Mlll G, Ld: Rld/UACES.

    Turk, Danilo 1993: R f S: A C, : E Jl f Il Lw 4/2, 66-71.

    UN1993: Sy Cl Rl S/RES/817, 7 Al, Nw Y: T Ud N.

    UN1993: Gl Aly Rl A/RES/47/225, 8 Al, Nw Y: T Ud N.

    UN1995: G d F Yl Rl f Md I Ad, 13 S. UN T-y S Vl. 189. I-32193, Nw Y: T Ud N.

    Vd, Mld A. 2005: E Uddd. Dy, L, d I A C,Oxfd: Oxfd Uy P.

    Walker, R.B.J.1993: Id/Od: Il Rl Pll Ty, Cd: Cd U-y P.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    21/21

    T Kllg-Fg - Eagig Aadmi Exag ad

    Iiv Ra

    T Kll-F (KFG) w fd l-d y G R Fd 2008. I - f KFG d lly l

    w dl w y d dd w ll f d j .

    T Kll-F T Tf Pw f E E Bl-Bd- d lz w - d . I x l f EU - d f d, lyz d f l d xl d :

    Idy d Pl S

    Cl, Cdly d Byd

    C Rl d E Exl Rl