third leg spring semester 2012
Jan 12, 2015
third leg
spring semester 2012
introduction
BackgroundBestnet AS is modern towing trailer manufacturer. It is so popular, that even word „trailer“ in estonian is often pronounced as „tiki-trailer“. Bestnet is also one of the biggest exporter of Estonia, with yearly turnover in exess of 15 million euros. The main market is Scnadinavian countries and the brands are called TIKI and AKU. Tiki-trailer focuses on continuous development of quality and production technology.
Aim of the projectThe aim of this project is to develop a smart trailer. Smart trailer is a trailer that has higher self-awarness than current plain metallic structures. Following points give a brief overview of points which to consider: - Smart trailer, that is able to register overload due to exessive weight, bad weight distribution, wrong driving manners etc. - Integrating electronics to raise the trailer self-awareness. - Integrating smart structures that react on abnormal function of trailer. - The aerodynamics to reduce the fuel consumption. - The weight reduction to reduce the fuel consumption. - Unification of used materials to reduce the manufacturing costs.
Team
Tutors
Tarko Koger
MA D&Efirst year
Henrik Herranen
Tallinn University of Technology
Aleksei Oleinik
MA D&Efirst year
Sven Sõrmus
Estonian Academyof Arts
Janno Nõu
MA D&Efirst year
Max Böhme
BA Industrial Designfourth year
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
contents
introductioncontentscar trailerworking methodvisit of Tikiuser interviewsinterviews with leasing servicesopinions from internet blogsmarket situationTikis range of productscompetitors in comparancetrailer attributesusers specific used trailer
analysis of the web-presentationtrailer problemsprogresssecond meeting with Tikiritual of boot-trailers usageritual vs. robotic
direction for ideasidea generationidea selection and evaluationconcept preparationconcept selection
mechanical inspirationsconcept modellingcoupling connectionadaption to the real traileradvanced concept-modelsfinal designdeveloped designcalculation for the springrisk analysisstatic-load-stress analysistrigger developmentprototypingsources
RESEARCH
ANALYSIS
CONCEPT
DESIGN
A general overview
For many transportation issues, trailer are the first choice. Be it, that people cannot afford a big transporter, or that they don‘t need it every day, in relation to the price of a big car allows a trailer more specialized use. Besides this are some goods or objects simple to big for cars, like boots for example.Indeed, using and driving of a trailer needs experience, especcially for bigger trailers and so people need the special application BE for their driver-licence. That this is not a guarantee for a diligent use is totally clear, everybody is oblivious in a way.
car-trailer
[some examples how not to transport something]
?
research
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
So trailer manufacturer nowadays are producing more and more special trailer for the special issues. That less mistakes will happen and that the use of working become more practical and give mor independence to the people. There existing one the one side solutions trough extra equipment and on the other side customized trailers with adapted dimensions, characteristics and implemented equipment.
current situation, analyse
of tiki
Pictures
Competitionanalyse/picturesNeeds of users/
owners, from our interviews
pile of information
Requirements for the trailer
brainstorming
Ideas
Comparing / Ideation
WINNERBreef and clear understanding,
what, where ,for whom ect.
ideas
teisipäev, 28. veebruar 12
working method
Our goal
Due to the fact, that the bigger part of the team didn‘t worked deeper in the trailer-business before, we started with a broad research. Also it was important to find some special solution for Tiki, which gives them the possibility to set apart from their competitors and reach a unique selling pont. Our final development of one product means in this way of thinking not the only possible way. In analysis of the current state and the circumstances, our discussion and concept-generating about the future of trailers in general, became the second leg in this project.What we did at the end, is only a first step in this proposed direction.
Our way
We collected a bunch of informations and analyse them, for setting the different importances. Then we made concepts of the trailers close, medium and far future, for which we created respective ideas and concepts. These are presented in this report. For the most realistic issue, which is also in the frame of time, costs, producing possibility and without competitive alternatives we finally made a range of solutions. In decision of the circumstances we selected one idea, worked out the design and brought it to a prototyp.
research
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
visit of Tiki
7.02 Our first visit to the companyTiki presented their company in general: structure, facilities, manufacturing, machinery, warehousing, logistics. During our consultation company representatives said that they do not want to restrict our flights of thoughts but contrary during our process, more and more restrictions and “things needed to be considered” continuesly appeared themselves while developing because realistic outcome – prototype – was expected at the end of the course. Our team also only sees point and value generating concepts that are feasible. Therefore production and development possibilities needed to be clarified. That was definitely essential to set further frames because this probably wouldn’t be some futuristic concept but more realistic one that might even end up prototyping.
user interviews
It lasts so long to winch the third wheel up again.
It‘s all about experience.
When I drive my vehicle on the tilted trailer, he seems to brake.
To drive back is difficult; the back of the trailer is out
of view.
The empty trailer is dancing on the
highway!
The third wheel makes often
problems while driving.
When I don‘t need the trailer I store it
in the garage.
I expect that the trailer is usable everywhere like my Lada-Niva.
Never sure if the load an the hook
is still ok; you can only gauge.
I have no feeling for the trailer when
taking a turn.
I check the weight of the load while
looking how broad the tires are.
For our first interviews we asked private users with more and less experience. Of course the problems are different from person to person, but some points appeared again and again.
research
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
the taillights are often broken while driven backwards
against sth.
the leasers forgot to wind up the
third wheel
people rarely read the manual
the leasers don‘t know the parameters for
loading
plastic covers are more aerodynamik
the cover is too heavy for women
sometimes people want to have a trailer but don‘t
have a hook
we prefer Respo cause of the better supply, when we have to repair
something
the customers don‘t care about the trailer, cause it‘s not their own
interviews with leasing services
For our interviews of trailer-leasing we went to some building markets in Tallinn, which offer a less or more good service, to some Gas-stations in Pärnu, whose want to earn extra cash and so only use the most easy trailers of less than 750kg (no special permissions neccessary) and at least to the bigger rental service in Pärnu.
TIKI RESPO
Pros Cons Pros Cons
do not complainlights were connected in a wrong way
more quality made
lack of INNER hooks in standard equipment
new TIKIs handle overloading better
does not handle overloading
cheapertendency to float underload
hits suspension to the end
falls apart (8 years experienced both)
feels massive and heavy
higher trailer surface - higher lifting surface
LOADED TRALER: side swinging
good capacity/ overloading carrier
tighter in width
stronger sides small ground clearance
problems with brakes
more fixing hooks on standard package
suspension does not strike if some extra kg-s
LOADED TRALER: vertical swinging
tolerates overcapacity/overloading
lightness (3m - 220 kg)
due to low ground clearance - frequent harvesting
better looking stronger frame - rec new RESPO
issues with brakes but 2 times less than TIKI
more reliable (used both)
cheaper exploitation
better assembly, integration if parts needed to be exchanged
TIKI user feedbackRESPO user feedback
Used both or just commentator
opinions from internet blogs
The users also make recommendations• Go for better offer (8 years experiencced both)• With brakes• new respo (stronger frame)• respo because of handling overcapacity• 4 wheels: TIKI - 1 shaft balanssiiridega; RESPO - 2 separate shafts• IT‘S ALL ABOUT MAINTAINER
research
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
internet blogs
market situation
stan
dard
tra
ilers
spec
ial o
ffer
700
€
prof
essi
onel
tra
ilers
prof
essi
onel
tra
ilers
with
brak
es
clos
ed t
raile
rs
prof
essi
onel
boo
t tr
aile
rs
boot
tra
ilers
beac
h tr
aile
rs
trac
tor
trai
lers
cabl
e tr
aile
rs
car
trai
lers
and divisionTikis range of
products
research
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
By checking the range of products from competitors, some small differences were found. It‘s at least not only about the products, which vary less, but also more about the way of presenting, which gives a different accentuation on the trailers.So we compared the prices related to the different trailers, marked some specialized parts and took looks into the presentation/way of providing (see analysis of Tikis homepage).Other than Tiki or Respo, the P+P trailer center is a trading firm instead of a producer. They are selling trailers which are mostly manufactured in Germany or the Netherlands. The range of products is wide and so it gives an insight into the german trailer business.
standard
standard with brakes
double axes
double axes with brakes
boat trailers
boat trailers with brakes
car trailers
flatbed trailers
van trailers
RESPO TRAILERS prize in €
525-1770
2066-2396
1422-1760
2294-3035
466-1345
1533-3811
2493-4664
2428-4388
2190-5515
max. weight in kg
750kg
1500kg
750
1700-2700
700-750
900-3500
2000-3500
1700-2700
750-2000
size in cm
1.50x1.203.50x2.063.00x1.503.50x1.803.00x1.503.50x1.803.00x1.504.00x1.503.80x1.795.80x2.095.80x2.098.10x2.414.00x1.824.90x2.053.06x1.685.50x2.203.00x1.503.50x1.75
types
17
5
8
9
11
11
6
4
9
<750kg
<1400kg
<2000kg
<2600kg
Trailer at the P+P Trailercenter prize in €
500-1235
1045-2000
1325-2745
1790-3470
load in kg
520-580
780-1080
1100-1620
2100-2190
size in cm
202x114300x150210x110300x150250x125300x150300x150400x185
types
19
21
13
7
smile T.
standard T.
profi T.
profi with break T.
boot T.
profi boot T.
strand T.
car T.
closed T.
cable T.
tractor T.
TIKI TRAILERS prize in €
700
710-970
900-1630
2010-4220
800-1000
1110-4830
630-1000
3350-3800
3740 , 4530
3720 , 4360
3140-4180
load in kg
629
443-612
387-579
968-1682
369-635
582-2001
484-1043
1430-2010
386 , 935
1071 , 2187
2301-3023
size in cm
265x122
200x122275x138350x148252x123299x148382x209
418x196489x194346x144
types
1
4
9
9
4
7
3
4
2
2
3
Differences in the range of products from P+P
- no boat trailers and less speciallised order of trailers - cheapeast offering for a standard trailer (but it‘s a small one) - trailers use not only metal, for example also plywood for the sideboards - sale most times already with the third wheel - accentuation on the „service-friendly“ bolting, so less welded trailers - 10 years of guarantee (Koch-Trailers) - differentiation through the weight of the load and applied covering
competitorsin comparance
research
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
Differences in the range of products from Respo
- more use of bolted trailers - well organized homepage (see later in analysis of Tikis homepage) - more specialized trailers and better range of products - boat trailers much cheaper than from Tiki - biggest possible choice of standard trailer
the inconsiderable diffence in the look:
braking issues
overweight
weight positioning
anti-theft devices
reliability
normal functionsabnormal functions
upgrade possibility
weather proofed
empty driving
tilting possibility
opening possibility
weakwheelarches
foldablepole
processof coupling
to car
the third wheel
power- cables to the car long life
materials
fixing of the load
trailer attributes
TRAILER
research
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
users specific used trailer
prefer the trailer with the longest life
prefer normally the cheapest trailer
just need something for transportation
HIGH OPERATING EXPERIENCE
LOW OPERATING EXPERIENCE
private owners
leasers
boots
vehicles
manifold load
commercial
]
]
]
[
[
[
animals
analysis of the web-presentation
To find more reasons for Tikis current market situation, we also examined their homepage in comparance to other trailer-companys. The main problem we get out of this, is that Tiki don‘t determine a special orientation of their qualities. That way the users and customers don‘t know about the special characteristics, which in our opinion could be a accentuation on long life. Some small failure in the web-presentation let the homepage of Tiki standing back behind the one of Respo. Again the inconciderable difference in the look:
We took also looks into other webpages of german trailer companies, to get more different design-solutions.
analysis
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
first look - at the startpage for the countrys no picture of a trailer - looks like Respo (colours) - no mark on a special characteristic of TIKI
shop - categories only with words --> less clearness what it is - no possibility for a comparance of trailer on the first look (like Respo) --> non-direct connection between trailer and the information about - totaly no pictures for the extra-stuff
extra informations - in „Why Tiki“, Products and Contact no pictures - „Why Tiki“ implicate other companys for trailers - in „About Company“ bad graphic-design (non-professional) - no helping information for the customer, which trailer is the best for him
orientation - differentiation with countrys or languages? - three clicks to the final product is OK (sometimes only 1 click), but the way is hard to find
From the research with users of normal and also boot trailers, we listed the most common problems and handicaps in use. The choice contains largely the points, which could be intersting in the view of deign and engineering.
trailer problems
sharp edge which rip clothes
sidesboards become instable
without the backboard
overload on the coupling
hook
third wheel isa forgotten in the down
position overladissue
lights brake easy while backdriving
analysis
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
third wheel falls down
while driving
only help for alight the boot
out of the water, not for alighting
water get into the lights, but not out again
balancing of the boat even with help quite
difficult
tends to rust
not adjustable in height
no places to stand during the procedure braking
electronic connections
progress
On a gigantic map we collected all our previous informations. Some of the original issues seemed to be quite ridiculous in consideration of the feasibility Tiki could offer. We tried to find a logical direction from Tikis recent position to our design.
Finally we chose some issues to working on, which we presented to Tiki:
stronger connection
plug
failsafe third wheel
weight measuring equipment
weight measuring on coupling
wheel
analysis
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
15.03Second meeting with Bestnet AS.
We made brief presentation and discussed over the following topics:• Trailer in general• Tiki’s product portfolio• Tiki products in comparison with competitors• Market and competitor analyses• Customer survey: from users aspect• Resellers/distributors feedback: problems with users
Additionally we introduced and proposed several initial possible solutions for improvements to the main problems. Our main goal was to fix the development direction among standard, professional or boat trailers. Bestnet’s interest was to go towards boat trailers.
In our discussion afterwards we decided to elaborat more on a research for the boot-trailer, but we allready said, that many problems of the boot-trailer not so much different from normal ones. That for we would also go on with finding solutions for most of the common trailer problems.
second meeting with Tiki
the ritual use of a boot trailer
• Technical service, check• Visual check• Holistically in one piece• Safe to drive• Condition of tires and pressure in it• Connecting trailer to a car – „click“ sound• Control lifting for coupling hook connection• Safety cable mounting• Socket connecting• Car ignition• Lights check• Turn signals• Break lights• Side (gauge) lights• Reverse lights• Lifting up the third wheel: if doesn’t fix -> remove entirely• Delivering trailer from storage place to yachtport where loading takes place: meanwhile as well as default short distance control ride• Trailer unlinking from car: for later balancing• Trailer position fixing with chocks and handbreak• Loading• Yacht is lifted with crane• Edges are tied with rops for more exact positioning and directing the yacht• Fixing the load with fastening belts and elastic rope hooks• Positioning the softeners in between possibly might frictioning surfaces• The equipment is prepacked before loading in order to avoid dust, dirt and possible damages from hitting tarmac from the road • If loading is fixed – physical check for fasteners via shaking and wiggling• Reversing car as near as possible to coupling hook: for most it’s difficult (even I have had slight touch between coupling hook and rear spoiler)• Appling handbreak for car • Connecting trailer with car• Loading distribution check: if nessecary – adjustment• Visual check and evaluation from sides as well as from back view• Tire pressure control: if need for adaption – stop in gas station• Visual check via mirrors when starting to drive• While fueling or stops – visual check and physical control for fastenings
From a for many years experienced user of boat trailers we get the exactly order what you have to do, when using a boat trailer:
analysis
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
ritual vs. robot
Allready in the research we mentioned, that a lot of the problems like broken third wheel or broken lights, but also a bad weight distribution or an overloading are caused by careless users. These problems are not more important, when the users have a lot of experience. Of course also for the well experienced owner of a trailer would these kind of systems like an electrical weight-measuring practical. The question arised, how many technological affort how much benefit for the users would bring.
As the two extreme points we set a super experienced user and on the other side a fully automatical trailer, which act nearly like a robot. Both extremes are not desirable, cause of the costs for the robotic-trailer or because of the mistakes which can happen till a user is well experienced.So the aim is, to find smart technical solutions or designs, how user can play the ritual in an easier way without mistakes.
users neccessary experience
technicalsolutions
use with least risk
design solutions
use with more risk
fullrobotic trailer
expert use
(ritual)
direction for ideas
From the already collected problems, we choose four which seemed to fit in our claims for smartness, benefit for the users and feasability for Tiki.
weight distribution
easy to forget to plug or to
unplug
get wet and short the
whole electric system
needs time while using
fall down while driving
will brake when it is forgotten
no information if the load iss to much and
right balanced
dangerous problems
while driving
brake while backdriving
third wheel
lights and electrical system
oblivious user(ritual of use)
concept
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
idea generation
We collected some ideas, how it would be possible to solve the problems:
Long discussions in the team, with Henrik and the teachers brought us the problem, that on the one side super-technical-advanced solutions would be innovative and able to solve the problems, on the other side these solutions are not possible today. Tiki wanted to give us a free field for exploration, but also we wanted to make something realizable.So we decided to kick out the problem of the weight distribution: To solve this problem you have to change the complete system of the coupling part, what is not possible in the context of our project, or you can implement some simple extra systems. Latter already exist how we found out; special scales you can use on the coupling hook of the car or which are implemented in the third wheel:
For other problems also exist some smart additive solutions:
idea selectionand evaluation
concept
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
The residual solutions we checked out with an evaluation matrix:
concept prepraration
The idea evaluation didn‘t identified a clear way; again it was a contradiction between too simple and too difficult solutions. So we made a second evalution with the aim, to find realisable work in the context of our project and to be also able to say, what would be the next step on the path of developing the super-smart trailer.
After all we distributed the ideas into three concepts, to show what would be possible in the future, but what doesn‘t fit into the recent schedule.
NOW
improved
ritual
no budgetsimple add-ons
low-tech
helper
some budgetsome basical changes
FEW YEARS
intelligent
robot
unlimited budgethigh-technical
FUTURE
concept
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
NOW
improved
ritual
no budgetsimple add-ons
easy change with
plugconnections
third wheel gets a secondary adjustment
systemshort checklist of the ritual at the coupling
more hooks for fasten the belts and the plane
simple metal structures
pretend the ligths from
braking
The use of the trailer like a ritual means actually, that you will not forget the actions you have to do nowadays. All solutions have a cheap realisation and don‘t change the system, only add something. For task like the weight-measuring should be used already available add-ons. (see idea-selection)
possibility to winch the boot into the water
failsafe and easier use of
the third wheel
third wheel cannot be forgotten
plug has remind-bell
against being forgotten
ability to adjust the height
completely waterproofed & brake-secured
lights scale for load balancing
low-tech
helper
some budgetsome basical changes
FEW YEARS
The use of the trailer like a helper means, that all systems should become more reliable and with more adjustment possibilities. Also is the trailer able to mention, when for example the the user forgot top connect the lights. Then a noise would sound. Systems like measuring tools could be partly implented, but could be also still exist as add-ons.
concept
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
intelligent
robot
unlimited budgethigh-technical
FUTURE
The trailer like a robot would be able to achieve a lot of actions by his own. Controlled by a central black-box, the user can command via his voice or a smartphone screen. There it is also possible to check the conditions of the load and if problems appear you will get autonomous information.
automatic pushing and pulling of the
boot
automaticalle uprising third
wheelvoice-control,connection to the car & smartphone application
digital load measuring for
balancing
automatical adjusting
rollers
automatically decoupling and power-connection
black-box control system with wireless connection to
the user
concept selection
Adequacy for the project
From all single solutions in the three possible concepts we finally decided in the team to work on the issue of the third wheel. It shall be possible to create an design, which can Tiki produce by its own without investing in special equiptment or capacities. Also the mechanical part seemed to be complex enough, when it should work mechanical automatically.Following the NOW-concept for a promtly realisation, the aim is find a solution with fits in the most already existing trailer.
Benefit for the User
In the research become clear, that the third wheel is a point which has often problems. These are more important than, for example the lights system, which is only needed for communication in traffic. When you lose the third wheel, than that will have other bad consequencies. (see red graph) With inversion of the problems to their reasons, we can say what the third wheel should be able to do. (green graph)
concept
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
recently problematic
conceptional third wheel
not possible to discouple the
trailer when it‘s loaded
you have to remove it while
driving
cannot usethe trailer
(only super-light load)
the third wheel brakes
the wheel can fall down while driving
the user can forget to rise
the wheel
you have to buy a new one
lose money
lose time
save time
wheel cannotbe forgotten
wheel cannotfall down
save money
mechanical inspirations
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
design modelling
With a bound of sketches we started to approach the design and found out, that for the 3rd-wheel-system are mostly three parts neccessary:1. the way the third wheel is able to rise2. how it will be locked in both positions3. how we can connect the system to the coupling
1. the way the third wheel is able to riseFor uprising exist two posibilities: The wheel can strictly lift up or it can turn arround an pivotable point. Latter would have to advantage, that there is less friction to be mentioned. For both solutions it has to find a way, how giving the power to the system. The system should also work, when there is no electrical power from the car, so in mechanical thinking springs are most capable.
a straight uplifting system with locker and pulling springs
X
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
some pivotable systems(pivotbale point inside/outside the main profile; rotable plate instead of axis; different solutions for the fixing point)
Finally we decided for a torsion spring in a pivotable system. Then there is no long way (for lifting up the third wheel) like a normal spring had also need and this torsion spring would take the least space for working.A common use of them you can find in automatic knifes, which have already an intersting locking system.
One problem of the spring was the length (or broad) of the spiral: This would mean, that the third wheel have to be placed more far away from the main profile and could become so instable. Or it has te be place beneath the spring, which also brings quite similar problems.
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
2. How it will lock
Again with the pivotable spring system we had to decide, if we want to use one turning point or better a turning plate. The plate would have much more stability and distribute the tension of the wheel, but would also generate much more friction. Together with the fact, that for the locking system are two fix-points better (even the third wheel would stay up, because of the spring), we choose the pivotable plate. So the locker, or trigger how we called it, can have to fixpoints in the plate.It should be made out of one material to don‘t use to much parts and assembling time. The flexibility can be created with cutting long holes into the material, which drops the resistibility of the solid material.
3. how we can connect the system to the coupling
For an intelligent connection to the coupling-system, we evaluated when the locking system need and can get which input-information from the coupling:
It showed, that the couple-connection (the system which will unlock the third wheel when you couple the trailer to the car) is only allowed to work when the car is uncoupled and the third wheel is fixed. If it would also work when the car is coupled, then you cannot push the third wheel down by discoupling; the locker wouldnt work.
process
trailer alone
coupling
before discoupling
third wheel
down
up
down
coupled
no
yes
yes
locker
locked
unlocked
workable
connected to couple
yes
working
no
coupling connection
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
3rd wheel down + car uncoupled
The locker (right orange part) hold the 3rd wheel (left orange part) in tension; the couple-connection (blue) is pulled back by a spring (blue)
coupling
The couple-connection pulls(0) the locker out of the tab location(1) and the pulling end (red cross) slides upwards in the hole(2) of the backplate (green).The 3rd wheel already try to turn.(3)
coupling + uprising wheel
The trailers coupling is nearly closed and the 3rd wheel turn 90° in the hoizontal position.The pulling end is so high in the hole(4), that it nearly gives the locker free again.coupled + uprised/
The puller is at the end; his spring want to pull him back, but the coupling of the car is holding him.The puller gets free and flip back because of the own flexibility.(5)It‘s possible to push the 3rd wheel down again, even though the car is coupled.
uncoupling
By uncoupling the car, the spring bring the puller back in the original position.If the trailer loaded, the third wheel has to be pushed down at first.
1
3
2
4
5
x
0
Examination if the trailer-partFor a better and constant development we removed the front part of the trailer Tiki had given to us. In the coupling system we checked at the part, which is moving by connecting the trailer to the car. The bolt is able to pull strongly over a distance of 2 cm. Also we took the right measurments of the recent adjustment of the third wheel.
The moving part in the coupling system. The red dot-line marks the way and distance it pass.
adaption to the real trailer
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
In this idea the spring works also around a tube, which is holding additionalle the pivotable part and is holded by itself through a sheet-metal-shroud. This shroud would be able to stop the third wheel at the lowest point and has directly the connections to the base at the trailers frame.
Here a turnable plate, holded in a ring between two other plates is holding a tube for spring and the third wheel with two long screws. The holding plates are connected with screws and also with screws fixed to the base of the trailer profile.
advanced concept-models
Problems of the design with the movable plate had been, that it has to be really big when it should fit together with the recent holding part of the third wheel. The tubes with the special cut should be not necessary, while using the original holding part. The three layers for holding the pivotable part, also a lot of scews and in this way assembling time is required.By an inversion of the holding frame to the inside and using the most of the parts in a opposite way, we finally found an easier design with less parts:
base on the trailer profil
base-plate
movable partwheel-adjustment
triggerholding plate
tube
The adjustment for the 3rd wheel is combined with the movable part and holding the tube.The base on the trailer profil is combined with the base-plate and the holding-plate; they are fix and hold the other sid of the tube.
The completely movable part is stabilized by pressing against the edge of the holding-plate and against the end of the tube (which leads on the base) in the other direction.
The spring is attached to the movable part und in a hole in the fixed holding-plate.
final concept
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
- movable parts (orange) - fixed parts (blue) - tube (light grey) - screws (dark grey) - spring (red)
developeddesign
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
calculationfor the spring
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
risk analysis
static-load-stressanalysis
To check if the indeed robust planed design seems to be able for competing with the reality, we made a digital static-load-stress analysis. It showed that all expectations on the material should be fulfilled.
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
trigger development
To find the best working trigger, we had checked also a few different shapes of the material-spring-mechanism.
final version
stress
displacement
prototyping
With the help of Tiki we started a prototype-production, to check out the function in real. For this we had to divide the movable part into two pieces, which later become welded together. Together with the spring and the screws, which were supposed to be standard-parts, we assemblied all in TUT for the testing and the final presentation.
admin 24.05.2012
Designed by Checked by Approved by Date
1 / 1 Edition Sheet
Date
130
109
55
58,6
31
R20
R5,5
4,1
Materjali paksus 3 mm
A ( 1 : 1 )
A
admin 24.05.2012
Designed by Checked by Approved by Date
1 / 1 Edition Sheet
Date
167
R90
130
80
3
85
16
5,5
124°
Materjali paksus 3 mm
admin 24.05.2012
Designed by Checked by Approved by Date
1 / 1 Edition Sheet
Date
8028
R6
R3
155
167
161
22
52,5 52,5
40
1111
Materjali paksus 3mm
puller
kogus 2
admin 23.05.2012
Designed by Checked by Approved by Date
1 / 1 Edition Sheet
Date
Materjali paksus 2 mm
3520
20°
3,5
7
R3,5
R5R3
,5
tube
admin
23.05.2012
Designed by
Checked byApproved by
Date
1 / 1 Edition
Sheet
Date
32
36
40
Oluline välisdiam
eeter 40 mm
. Sisem
ine diameeter vastavalt võim
alustele vahemikus 30...36 m
m
design
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012
With the exception of the trigger, Tiki made all parts quite well. But while testing the prototype, Alex and Tarko found out: some parts needs little changes of 0.1 - 2.0 millimetre in the design, to work fluently. Also the spring has to have exactly the right power.
scources
http://www.anhaenger24.de/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=30http://www.mobil.org/_news/fahren_mit_anhnger_fordert_disziplin_am_steuerhttp://www.wer-weiss-was.de/theme107/article5899701.htmlhttp://de.cars.yahoo.com/25052007/348/anhaenger-esp-gespannfahren-endlich.html
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anh%C3%A4ngerhttp://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gummifederachsehttp://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anh%C3%A4ngerkupplunghttp://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/St%C3%BCtzlasthttp://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bremse_%28Kraftfahrzeug%29http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/St%C3%BCtzlastwaagehttp://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Schlinger-Kupplung
http://ppanhaengercenter.com/Kipper:::1765.htmlhttp://www.boeckmann.com/pkw_anhaenger.htmlhttp://www.brenderup.de/http://www.anssems.nl/du/bedrijfsinfo.htmlhttp://www.cargotrailers.de/http://www.eduard-anhaenger.de/http://www.hulco-anhaenger.de/http://www.excalibureurope.com/http://www.humbaur.com/http://www.kochanhaengerwerke.de/http://www.pongratz-anhaenger.com/http://www.wmmeyer.de/intro/http://www.stedele.de/http://www.respo.ee/en/about-us/Company-informationhttp://www.midtrailer.se/Engelska/CompanyInformation.aspx
http://www.amazon.de/St%C3%BCtzlast-Waage/dp/B00116XDIShttp://www.amazon.de/Berger-Digitale-St%C3%BCtzlastwaage/dp/B003DOCHYC/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_3http://www.kc-engineering.de/aid-1970-5er-Pack-2-3-oder-4-polig.htmlhttp://www.satking.de/Empfangstechnik/Empfangszubehoer/Stecker-und-Dosen/F-Stecker-7-mm-Wasserdicht-HQ.htmlhttp://german.alibaba.com/products/underwater-connector.html
http://texaskayakfisherman.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=53&t=119229&start=0&sid=c71d2bd8ff1ed452821973a00df186c3 http://www.sherline.com/disaster.htm http://www.tysse.no/ http://forum.4x4.ee/viewtopic.php?f=49&t=13218&sid=5b43d7a990f64e21bce699053fd68ce2http://carshowroom.autotrader.com.au/forge/data_entry?tp=Prod&category=vehicle+specifications&temp_type=detail&style_id=64315620080201
Vibration Analysis for Electronic Equipment (3rd Edition)Steinberg, Dave S. © 2000 John Wiley & SonsMotor Vehicle Structures: Concepts and Fundamentals, Jason C. Brown, A. John Robertson, Stan T. Serpento, Butterworth-Heinemann 2002Sclater & Chironis - Mechanisms And Mechanical Devices Sourcebook 3rd ed [McGraw-Hil 2001]Marks‘ Standard Handbook For Mechanical Engineers_Mcgraw Hill (1996)(1519s), 10th.EdMachinery‘s Handbook 26Th Edition (Complete Despite The Size)
design & engineering | TTÜ & EKA Tallinn | springsemester 2012