Top Banner
Thinking of visiting Oxford? Allow m e to be y our guide... and discover the history of Oxford with an Oxford historian. I offer a wide range of guided walks around the city and university. These can be a general introduction to the history and architecture or looking at specific themes and subjects. More information . About Me ONCE I WAS A CLEVER BOY I am a Catholic and a historian based in Oxford, where I am a member of Oriel College. My THURSDAY, 26 MAY 2011 New Papal tiara The New Liturgical Movement has this piece about the presentation to the Pope of a new tiara: Just a quick note as some of our readers may be interested in this story published by John Sonnen about a papal tiara that was gifted to Pope Benedict XVI , commissioned by Dieter Philippi and crafted by a Bulgarian Orthodox liturgical firm. The tiara was presented to the pontiff today by Dieter Philippi and a small delegation of Catholics and Eastern Orthodox. Споделяне Сигнал за злоупотреба Сигнал за злоупотреба Следващ блог» Създав Once I was a clever boy learning the arts of Oxford... is a quotation from the verses written by Bishop Richard Fleming (c.1385-1431) for his tomb in Lincoln Cathedral. Fleming, the founder of Lincoln College in Oxford, is the subject of my research for a D. Phil., and, like me, a son of the West Riding. I have remarked in the past that I have a deeply meaningful on-going relationship with a dead fifteenth century bishop... It was Fleming who, in effect, enabled me to come to Oxford and to learn its arts, and for that I am immensely grateful.
3

Thinking of visiting New Papal tiara1. Speaking as a schoolmaster, I would beware the grins on those faces. I've seen those expressions on the faces of naughty schoolboys. Those presenting

Jun 06, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Thinking of visiting New Papal tiara1. Speaking as a schoolmaster, I would beware the grins on those faces. I've seen those expressions on the faces of naughty schoolboys. Those presenting

Thinking of visitingOxford

A llow m e to be y ou r

g u ide a n d discov er th e

h istor y of Ox for d w ith a n

Ox for d h istor ia n

I offer a w ide r a n g e of

g u ided w a lks a r ou n d th e

city a n d u n iv er sity

Th ese ca n be a g en er a l

in tr odu ct ion to th e

h istor y a n d a r ch itectu r e

or lookin g a t specific

th em es a n d su bjects

Mor e in for m a tion

About MeON CE I W A S A CLE V E R

B OY

I a m a Ca th olic a n d a

h istor ia n ba sed in Ox for d

w h er e I a m a m em ber of

Or iel Colleg e My

T HURSDA Y 2 6 MA Y 2 0 1 1

New Papal tiara

The New Liturgical Movement has this piece about the presentationto the Pope of a new tiara

Just a quick note as some of our readers may be interested in this

story published by John Sonnen about a papal tiara that was gifted to

Pope Benedict XVI commissioned by Dieter Philippi and crafted by a

Bulgarian Orthodox liturgical firm

The tiara was presented to the pontiff today by Dieter Philippi and a

small delegation of Catholics and Eastern Orthodox

Споделяне Сигнал за злоупотреба Сигнал за злоупотреба Следващ блогraquo Създаване на блог

Once I was a clever boy learning the arts of Oxford is a quotation from the verses written byBishop Richard Fleming (c1385-1431) for his tomb in Lincoln Cathedral Fleming the founder of

Lincoln College in Oxford is the subject of my research for a D Phil and like me a son of theWest Riding

I have remarked in the past that I have a deeply meaningful on-going relationship with a deadfifteenth century bishop It was Fleming who in effect enabled me to come to Oxford and to

learn its arts and for that I am immensely grateful

r esea r ch for a lon g

dela y ed DPh il is a stu dy

of Rich a r d Flem in g

Bish op of Lin coln in th e

secon d deca de of th e

fifteen th cen tu r y I a lso

w or k a s a fr eela n ce tu tor

in Histor y a n d a s a n

in depen den t tou r g u ide I

w a s r eceiv ed in to th e

Ch u r ch in 2 005 a n d a m

a Br oth er of th e Ex ter n a l

Or a tor y of St Ph ilip Ner i

a t th e Ox for d Or a tor y

V iew m y com plete pr ofile

Other Blogs andWebsites I Read

A ctu osa Pa r t icipa t io

A n Hon ou r a n d a

Respon sibility

A n cien t Rich bor ou g h

A r t in Mediev a l Hu n g a r y

A r th u r Cr u m ly blog

A u dio Sa n cto

A u n tie Joa n n a w r ites

A u str a lia In cog n ita

Ba d V estm en ts

Belg ia n Mon a r ch y

Belm on t A bbey

Bir m in g h a m LMS

Bir m in g h a m Or a tor y

Bish op of Ebbsfleet

Br a zilia n Mon a r ch y

Br it ish Mon a r ch y

Br oth er s of th e Sa n Dieg o

Or a tor y

Bu ckfa st A bbey

Ca n on s Reg u la r of th e

New Jer u sa lem

Ca r din a l New m a n ca u se

Ca r ita s in V er ita te

Ca th olic Ch u r ch

Con ser v a t ion

Ca th olic Her a ld

Ca th olic Ox for d

Cer em on ia y r u br ica de

la Ig lesia espa n ola

Ch r istu s V in ch it

CIEL UK

Com m u n ion in th e Ha n d

Cor pu s Ch r ist i Ma iden

La n e

Cr oss of La eken

Da n ish Mon a r ch y

De Cu r a A n im a r u m

Div in u m Officiu m

Dom Don a ld

Dom in ica n Litu r g y

Em per or Ch a r les Lea g u e

of Pr a y er

Em pr ess Zita ca u se

En g lish Dom in ica n s

Eu r opea n Her a ldr y

Ex Fide

Fr Hu n w ickes Litu r g ica l

Notes

Fr Ra y Bla ke

Posted Wednesday May 25 2011 Comments (33)

Fr Blake has also commented about it here

Both posts have attracted anumber of comments - including one frommy self

I cannot understand why any one would not want the Pope to becrowned with the tiara and wear it on appropriate occasions

The origins of the tiara are complex and may once have representedtemporal authority under the By zantine Emperor By the time itbecame the tiara we recognise it had been spiritualised as a sy mbol ofthe Papal monarchy governing the Church As in medievalrepresentions God the Father is often represented wearing the tiara itis a reminder that the Papal power is delegated from God and as withthe decree on Papal Infallibility refers to that power inherent in theChurch itself The Pope wears the tiara on behalf of the whole Churchand exercises authority on behalf of the whole Church over theChurch as Gods v icar Coronation points out the limitations andresponsibilities of the monarchical office spiritual or secular - it wasabsolutist monarchies that tended to dispense with or downgradecoronations Pope Paul VI may have set aside his tiara but in respectof the liturgy at least he acted in an absolutist manner

I think this is a very handsome gift and we must hope the Pope or atsome distant date in the future his successor takes the hint Whetherthey will is of course an unknowable matterat the moment

This story reminds me of a plan I had a while ago which was topublish some posts about the history of the tiara and the exampleswhich exist in the Vatican and elsewhere Once I can find some moretime I will do so

Posted by Once I Was A Clever Boy at 2253 Labels Papal coronation Papal tiara Pope Benedict XVI

1 comments

Fr ien ds a n d Follow er s of

St Ph ilip Ner i

Fr ien ds of Rea din g A bbey

FSSP En g la n d

Ger ia tr ics for a

Ch a n g elin g Ch u r ch

Godzdog z

Gr eek Mon a r ch y

Gy r on n y Her a ld

Ha bsbu r g Mon a r ch y

Ha n ov er ia n Mon a r ch y

Hea v en g a te

Her m en eu tic of

Con tin u ity

Hiber n o Ca th olic

Holy Na m e Ma n ch ester

Holy Sm oke

Idle Specu la t ion s

Il blog deg la la m ici di

Pa pa Ra tzin g er

In st itu te of Ch r ist th e

Kin g

In st itu te of Ch r ist th e

Kin g Sov er eig n Hig h

Pr iest

In ter v est ibu lu m et

a lta r e

Ita lia n ell A r te Mediev a le

Ite a d Th om a m

Jon Ca n n on s Ch u r ch es

Ju v en tu tem Ox for d

La cr im a r u m V a lle

La t in Ma ss Society

La u dem Glor ia e

Le Fleu r de Ly s too

Let Noth in g You Dism a y

Lew es Pr ior y

Liber a m e

Lin coln sh ir e Ch u r ch es

Lin en on th e Hedg er ow

Litu r g ia La t in a

LMS Ch a ir m a n

Lon don Or a tor y

Ma d Mon a r ch ist

Ma r y Tu dor - Ren a issa n ce

Qu een

Mediev a l ca len da r

ca lcu la tor

Mediev a l Hu n g a r y

Mex ica n Mon a r ch y

Missa Tr iden ta n a em

Por tu g a l

Mon ks a n d Mer m a ids

Motu s Septen tr ion a lis

Mu lier For t is

My sta g og y

New Litu r g ica l Mov em en t

New m a n r ea der

Noblesse et Roy a u te

Nor ber t in e V oca t ion s

Nor w eg ia n Mon a r ch y

Offer im u s t ibi Dom in e

Officiu m Div in u m

On lin e Goth a

Or bis Ca th olicu s

Or der of Ma lta

Or din a r ia te Por ta l

Or iel Colleg e

Ou r La dy of Ca v er sh a m

Newer Post Older Post

Post a Comment

Enter your comment

Com m ent as Google Account

Publish Preview

Home

Subscribe to Post Comments (Atom)

davidforster said

My two thoughts when I saw this picture were

1 Speaking as a schoolmaster I would beware the grins on

those faces Ive seen those expressions on the faces of

naughty schoolboy s Those presenting the tiara are say ing

Go on I dare y ou That on the face of His Holiness is

say ing Id rather like to can I get away with it

2 Its interesting that this tiara was presented by a mixed

Catholic and Orthodox group This seems to be a very

strong message from the Orthodox involved We may well

be ready to accept y our primacy and heal the Great

schism But y ouve got to behave like a pope That means

defending the faith And it means preserv ing and

respecting y our own Western traditions because if y ou

cant defend y our own we cant trust y ou with ours

28 May 2011 1119

Page 2: Thinking of visiting New Papal tiara1. Speaking as a schoolmaster, I would beware the grins on those faces. I've seen those expressions on the faces of naughty schoolboys. Those presenting

r esea r ch for a lon g

dela y ed DPh il is a stu dy

of Rich a r d Flem in g

Bish op of Lin coln in th e

secon d deca de of th e

fifteen th cen tu r y I a lso

w or k a s a fr eela n ce tu tor

in Histor y a n d a s a n

in depen den t tou r g u ide I

w a s r eceiv ed in to th e

Ch u r ch in 2 005 a n d a m

a Br oth er of th e Ex ter n a l

Or a tor y of St Ph ilip Ner i

a t th e Ox for d Or a tor y

V iew m y com plete pr ofile

Other Blogs andWebsites I Read

A ctu osa Pa r t icipa t io

A n Hon ou r a n d a

Respon sibility

A n cien t Rich bor ou g h

A r t in Mediev a l Hu n g a r y

A r th u r Cr u m ly blog

A u dio Sa n cto

A u n tie Joa n n a w r ites

A u str a lia In cog n ita

Ba d V estm en ts

Belg ia n Mon a r ch y

Belm on t A bbey

Bir m in g h a m LMS

Bir m in g h a m Or a tor y

Bish op of Ebbsfleet

Br a zilia n Mon a r ch y

Br it ish Mon a r ch y

Br oth er s of th e Sa n Dieg o

Or a tor y

Bu ckfa st A bbey

Ca n on s Reg u la r of th e

New Jer u sa lem

Ca r din a l New m a n ca u se

Ca r ita s in V er ita te

Ca th olic Ch u r ch

Con ser v a t ion

Ca th olic Her a ld

Ca th olic Ox for d

Cer em on ia y r u br ica de

la Ig lesia espa n ola

Ch r istu s V in ch it

CIEL UK

Com m u n ion in th e Ha n d

Cor pu s Ch r ist i Ma iden

La n e

Cr oss of La eken

Da n ish Mon a r ch y

De Cu r a A n im a r u m

Div in u m Officiu m

Dom Don a ld

Dom in ica n Litu r g y

Em per or Ch a r les Lea g u e

of Pr a y er

Em pr ess Zita ca u se

En g lish Dom in ica n s

Eu r opea n Her a ldr y

Ex Fide

Fr Hu n w ickes Litu r g ica l

Notes

Fr Ra y Bla ke

Posted Wednesday May 25 2011 Comments (33)

Fr Blake has also commented about it here

Both posts have attracted anumber of comments - including one frommy self

I cannot understand why any one would not want the Pope to becrowned with the tiara and wear it on appropriate occasions

The origins of the tiara are complex and may once have representedtemporal authority under the By zantine Emperor By the time itbecame the tiara we recognise it had been spiritualised as a sy mbol ofthe Papal monarchy governing the Church As in medievalrepresentions God the Father is often represented wearing the tiara itis a reminder that the Papal power is delegated from God and as withthe decree on Papal Infallibility refers to that power inherent in theChurch itself The Pope wears the tiara on behalf of the whole Churchand exercises authority on behalf of the whole Church over theChurch as Gods v icar Coronation points out the limitations andresponsibilities of the monarchical office spiritual or secular - it wasabsolutist monarchies that tended to dispense with or downgradecoronations Pope Paul VI may have set aside his tiara but in respectof the liturgy at least he acted in an absolutist manner

I think this is a very handsome gift and we must hope the Pope or atsome distant date in the future his successor takes the hint Whetherthey will is of course an unknowable matterat the moment

This story reminds me of a plan I had a while ago which was topublish some posts about the history of the tiara and the exampleswhich exist in the Vatican and elsewhere Once I can find some moretime I will do so

Posted by Once I Was A Clever Boy at 2253 Labels Papal coronation Papal tiara Pope Benedict XVI

1 comments

Fr ien ds a n d Follow er s of

St Ph ilip Ner i

Fr ien ds of Rea din g A bbey

FSSP En g la n d

Ger ia tr ics for a

Ch a n g elin g Ch u r ch

Godzdog z

Gr eek Mon a r ch y

Gy r on n y Her a ld

Ha bsbu r g Mon a r ch y

Ha n ov er ia n Mon a r ch y

Hea v en g a te

Her m en eu tic of

Con tin u ity

Hiber n o Ca th olic

Holy Na m e Ma n ch ester

Holy Sm oke

Idle Specu la t ion s

Il blog deg la la m ici di

Pa pa Ra tzin g er

In st itu te of Ch r ist th e

Kin g

In st itu te of Ch r ist th e

Kin g Sov er eig n Hig h

Pr iest

In ter v est ibu lu m et

a lta r e

Ita lia n ell A r te Mediev a le

Ite a d Th om a m

Jon Ca n n on s Ch u r ch es

Ju v en tu tem Ox for d

La cr im a r u m V a lle

La t in Ma ss Society

La u dem Glor ia e

Le Fleu r de Ly s too

Let Noth in g You Dism a y

Lew es Pr ior y

Liber a m e

Lin coln sh ir e Ch u r ch es

Lin en on th e Hedg er ow

Litu r g ia La t in a

LMS Ch a ir m a n

Lon don Or a tor y

Ma d Mon a r ch ist

Ma r y Tu dor - Ren a issa n ce

Qu een

Mediev a l ca len da r

ca lcu la tor

Mediev a l Hu n g a r y

Mex ica n Mon a r ch y

Missa Tr iden ta n a em

Por tu g a l

Mon ks a n d Mer m a ids

Motu s Septen tr ion a lis

Mu lier For t is

My sta g og y

New Litu r g ica l Mov em en t

New m a n r ea der

Noblesse et Roy a u te

Nor ber t in e V oca t ion s

Nor w eg ia n Mon a r ch y

Offer im u s t ibi Dom in e

Officiu m Div in u m

On lin e Goth a

Or bis Ca th olicu s

Or der of Ma lta

Or din a r ia te Por ta l

Or iel Colleg e

Ou r La dy of Ca v er sh a m

Newer Post Older Post

Post a Comment

Enter your comment

Com m ent as Google Account

Publish Preview

Home

Subscribe to Post Comments (Atom)

davidforster said

My two thoughts when I saw this picture were

1 Speaking as a schoolmaster I would beware the grins on

those faces Ive seen those expressions on the faces of

naughty schoolboy s Those presenting the tiara are say ing

Go on I dare y ou That on the face of His Holiness is

say ing Id rather like to can I get away with it

2 Its interesting that this tiara was presented by a mixed

Catholic and Orthodox group This seems to be a very

strong message from the Orthodox involved We may well

be ready to accept y our primacy and heal the Great

schism But y ouve got to behave like a pope That means

defending the faith And it means preserv ing and

respecting y our own Western traditions because if y ou

cant defend y our own we cant trust y ou with ours

28 May 2011 1119

Page 3: Thinking of visiting New Papal tiara1. Speaking as a schoolmaster, I would beware the grins on those faces. I've seen those expressions on the faces of naughty schoolboys. Those presenting

Fr ien ds a n d Follow er s of

St Ph ilip Ner i

Fr ien ds of Rea din g A bbey

FSSP En g la n d

Ger ia tr ics for a

Ch a n g elin g Ch u r ch

Godzdog z

Gr eek Mon a r ch y

Gy r on n y Her a ld

Ha bsbu r g Mon a r ch y

Ha n ov er ia n Mon a r ch y

Hea v en g a te

Her m en eu tic of

Con tin u ity

Hiber n o Ca th olic

Holy Na m e Ma n ch ester

Holy Sm oke

Idle Specu la t ion s

Il blog deg la la m ici di

Pa pa Ra tzin g er

In st itu te of Ch r ist th e

Kin g

In st itu te of Ch r ist th e

Kin g Sov er eig n Hig h

Pr iest

In ter v est ibu lu m et

a lta r e

Ita lia n ell A r te Mediev a le

Ite a d Th om a m

Jon Ca n n on s Ch u r ch es

Ju v en tu tem Ox for d

La cr im a r u m V a lle

La t in Ma ss Society

La u dem Glor ia e

Le Fleu r de Ly s too

Let Noth in g You Dism a y

Lew es Pr ior y

Liber a m e

Lin coln sh ir e Ch u r ch es

Lin en on th e Hedg er ow

Litu r g ia La t in a

LMS Ch a ir m a n

Lon don Or a tor y

Ma d Mon a r ch ist

Ma r y Tu dor - Ren a issa n ce

Qu een

Mediev a l ca len da r

ca lcu la tor

Mediev a l Hu n g a r y

Mex ica n Mon a r ch y

Missa Tr iden ta n a em

Por tu g a l

Mon ks a n d Mer m a ids

Motu s Septen tr ion a lis

Mu lier For t is

My sta g og y

New Litu r g ica l Mov em en t

New m a n r ea der

Noblesse et Roy a u te

Nor ber t in e V oca t ion s

Nor w eg ia n Mon a r ch y

Offer im u s t ibi Dom in e

Officiu m Div in u m

On lin e Goth a

Or bis Ca th olicu s

Or der of Ma lta

Or din a r ia te Por ta l

Or iel Colleg e

Ou r La dy of Ca v er sh a m

Newer Post Older Post

Post a Comment

Enter your comment

Com m ent as Google Account

Publish Preview

Home

Subscribe to Post Comments (Atom)

davidforster said

My two thoughts when I saw this picture were

1 Speaking as a schoolmaster I would beware the grins on

those faces Ive seen those expressions on the faces of

naughty schoolboy s Those presenting the tiara are say ing

Go on I dare y ou That on the face of His Holiness is

say ing Id rather like to can I get away with it

2 Its interesting that this tiara was presented by a mixed

Catholic and Orthodox group This seems to be a very

strong message from the Orthodox involved We may well

be ready to accept y our primacy and heal the Great

schism But y ouve got to behave like a pope That means

defending the faith And it means preserv ing and

respecting y our own Western traditions because if y ou

cant defend y our own we cant trust y ou with ours

28 May 2011 1119