THERMODYNAMIC STUDY OF TERNARY REFRIGERANT EQUILIBRIA A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE UNIVERSITY OF MUMBAI FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING (PARTLY BY PAPERS PARTLY BY RESEARCH) SUBMITTED BY NILESH WAMAN GONNADE UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF PROFESSOR SUNIL S. BHAGWAT INSTITUTE OF CHEMICAL TECHNOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF MUMBAI MATUNGA, MUMBAI-400019 JUNE 2010
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
THERMODYNAMIC STUDY OF TERNARYREFRIGERANT EQUILIBRIA
A THESIS SUBMITTED
TO THE
UNIVERSITY OF MUMBAI
FOR THE DEGREE OF
MASTER OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING
(PARTLY BY PAPERS PARTLY BY RESEARCH)
SUBMITTED BY
NILESH WAMAN GONNADE
UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF
PROFESSOR SUNIL S. BHAGWAT
INSTITUTE OF CHEMICAL TECHNOLOGY
UNIVERSITY OF MUMBAI
MATUNGA, MUMBAI-400019
JUNE 2010
STATEMENT TO BE INCORPORATED BY THE CANDIDATE IN THE
THESIS AS REQUIRED UNDER REGULATION FOR THE M. CHEM . ENGG.
DEGREE IS AS UNDER:
STATEMENT BY THE CANDIDATE
As required by the University Regulation No. R.2316, I wish to state that the work
embodied in this thesis titled “Thermodynamic Study Of Ternary Refrigerant Equi-
libria ” forms my own contribution to the research work carried out under the guidance of
Prof. Sunil S. Bhagwatat the Institute of Chemical Technology, University of Mumbai.
This work has not been submitted for any other degree of this or other university. When-
ever references have been made to previous works of others, it has been clearly indicated
as such and included in the bibliography.
Nilesh Waman Gonnade
(Research Student)
Certified by
Prof. Sunil S. Bhagwat
(Research Supervisor)
Department of Chemical Engineering
Institute of Chemical Technology,
University of Mumbai, Matunga,
Mumbai-400019.
Date:
Place: Mumbai.
CERTIFICATE
The research work presented in this thesis has been carried out by Gonnade Nilesh
Waman for Master of Chemical Engineeringdegree under my supervision. I certify
that, it is his bonafide work. The research work is original and has not been submitted for
any other degree of this or other university. Further, that he was regular student and has
worked under my guidance as a full time student at MUICT untilthe submission of the
thesis to the University of Mumbai.
Prof. Sunil S. Bhagwat
(Research Supervisor)
Department of Chemical Engineering
Institute of Chemical Technology,
University of Mumbai, Matunga,
Mumbai-400019.
Date:
Place: Mumbai.
Acknowledgement
Acknowledging people for their efforts and help is indeed a tricky job especially as
the feeling regarding someone can’t be expressed in words. Still it is necessary on my
part to express my thankfulness to some of the people, who have been kind to me and
sharing hands with me to show me the better way of life where the success lives.
Success is the manifestation of diligence, perseverance, inspiration, motivation, inno-
vation. I ascribe my success in this venture to my research guide Prof. S. S. Bhagwat for
his valuable guidance throughout the project work. His systematic approach to solve any
type of difficulty has helped me during research. His continuous guidance. inspiration,
support and co-operation in each and every respect made me tocomplete this work. I
am really thankful to him. It is my pleasure to acknowledge him for the freedom that he
has given to me to pursue the research work independently andfor his constant encour-
agement with critical appraisal on my work. His guidance helped me in all the time of
research and writing of this thesis.
I would like to specially thank my senior colleagues Sachidanad Satpute, Ramesh P.,
Nilesh M., Manish S., Chaitanya K. who had helped all the times with constant encour-
agement, valuable suggestions and for the stimulating discussions. All were the source
of inspiration throughout my work. I convey my deep sense of gratitude to Bhushan,
formations and many such processes. These processes involve non-volatile salts, arise in
two situations. First, as an alternative to extractive or azeotropic distillation, salts may
be added to a system to alter the VLE behavior. Second, there are cases where salt is
generated in the process before final product purification [Booneet al. , 1976].
The addition of salt to any binary or multicomponent system may change the VLE of
system by changing the relative volatility, solubility, thermal conductivity, density, sur-
face tension and partial pressure etc. of the solvents because of the interactions between
2
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
the salt ions and solvent components [Lee, 1997; Darwish andAl-Anbar, 1997]. These
changes, if they occur, will result in altering the VLE of thesystem [Johnson and Furter,
1957; Darwish and Al-Anbar, 1997]. VLE of ammonia-water system can be effectively
changed by using the additives like NaOH and KOH [Brasset al. , 2000; Salaveraet al.
, 2005], LiBr [Peterset al. , 1994] and LiNO3 [Liboteanet al. , 2007]. The VLE data
available for ammonia-water-salt systems is inadequate. Astudy of the effect of various
salts on the VLE of ammonia-water system was therefore undertaken to suggest changes
in the binary ammonia-water system.
Decrease in the solubility of a non-electrolyte in the solvent caused by the addition
of a salt is called as salting-out effect and the opposite is called as salting-in effect. Both
these effects is useful in AAR cycle. The salting-out salts will be useful in the generator
where the vapor pressure of ammonia can be increased and salting-in salts will be useful
in the absorber where the solubility of ammonia in water willbe enhanced. The addition
of salting-out salt in the generator of AAR system will significantly increase the vapor
pressure of the system by reducing the solubility of ammoniain water. This salt will be
carried into absorber along with the weak solution from the bottom of the generator. The
presence of salting-out salt in the absorber of AAR cycle, will have adverse effect on its
performance. Hence we need to restrict the salt in the generator side. This can be done by
using membrane separation process and the pressure gradient between the generator and
absorber can be utilised for the said separation of salt fromthe ammonia-water mixture.
The pressure required for the separation of the salt, using membrane separation technique
will depend on the size of the salt molecule. Smaller the sizeof the molecule, higher the
pressure required for the separation. The presence of salt may cause corrosion problems
to the equipment and hence we may have to spend more capital investment for having
equipments made up of corrosion resistant material. Considering all the above mentioned
things, the criterion for the selection of salts to be testedon the VLE of ammonia-water
mixture was decided on the basis of its solubility in ammoniaand water, its molecular
size and its corrosivity.
The salts were selected on the basis of their solubility in water and ammonia inde-
3
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
pendently. If a salt is more soluble in water than in ammonia,then it will show more
interaction with water than with ammonia and hence the resulting effect will be salting-
out of ammonia. Similarly, if a salt is more soluble in ammonia than in water or if salt
is soluble in both ammonia and water, then it will show interaction with both and the
resulting effect will be salting-in.
Salting-in or salting-out effect are considerable industrial and theoretical importance.
It is observed that, the molecules of the more polar component are generally preferentially
attracted by the electrostatic field of the ions and hence thevapor composition is enriched
by the less polar solvent in which the salt is less soluble [Iliuta et al. , 1998]. On the
addition of salt to the binary system, if the total vapor pressure of the system increases
then it is called as salting-out effect and if the total vaporpressure of the system decreases
then it is called as salting-in effect.
The performance of AAR cycle can be improved by adding salt, which either in-
creases or decreases the solubility of ammonia in water. In tropical conditions like India
where both the condenser and absorber are operated at a temperature of around40 0C,
the use of low temperature heat sources is more difficult. If we want to run a standard
AAR cycle at a heat source of around70−100 0C, we need to add salting-out salt which
will give same vapor pressure in the generator as it gives at120 − 140 0C without salt.
We need such a salt, which shows salting-out effect at70 − 100 0C and salting-in at 40
0C or at least no effect or very less salting-out effect at 400C. So that the overall effect
of salt on the AAR cycle will be positive and there will not be any need to restrict the salt
up to the generator side.
Very few additives are tested on the VLE of ammonia-water system. Therefore the
study of ammonia-water VLE with different additives is important to suggest the changes
in the binary ammonia-water system.
The different additives studied includes potassium acetate, copper acetate, ammo-
nium sulphate, sodium thiocynate, sodium nitrate and potassium nitrate. All these addi-
tives were tested at ammonia concentration of 10, 20 and 30 mass% {mass of ammonia
/ (mass of ammonia + mass of water)} and at different concentrations of additives. PTx
4
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
data was generated for these systems. Rocked static VLE cellwas used to generate the
VLE data for ammonia-water system with additive. The salt concentration used in mass%
and is given as
Salt mass concentration =mass of salt
mass of salt + mass of ammonia + mass of water×100
The generated VLE data for ammonia-water-salt system was correlated using the
Redlich-Kister and NRTL equation.
1.2 Refrigeration
Maintaining the temperature below that of the surrounding is called as refrigeration. It
is the process of removal of heat from low temperature and rejecting it at higher tem-
perature. This process is opposite to the natural directionof heat flow. Second Law of
thermodynamics states that heat can not be transferred fromlow temperature to higher
temperature without expenditure of energy. Refrigerationis best known for its appli-
cations in air conditioning and in the treatment, transportation and preservation of food
and beverages. It also finds large scale industrial applications in manufacturing of ice
and dehydration of gases. Application in the petroleum industry includes in lubricating
oil purification, low temperature reactions and separationof volatile hydrocarbons. Gas
liquefaction process also requires large scale refrigeration. Generation of refrigeration
below the temperature of -1500C is called as cryogenics.
Types of Refrigeration Cycles
There are number of refrigeration techniques and their combinations, that can generate
cold condition for domestic and industrial applications. Vapor compression (mechanical)
refrigeration cycle and Vapor absorption refrigeration cycle are the most widely used.
The main difference between the two cycle is the type of energy source used for produc-
5
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
tion of refrigeration. Vapor Compression cycle needs mechanical work as energy input
while vapor absorption refrigeration cycle is a heat operated refrigeration cycle.
1.2.1 Vapor Compression Refrigeration
Currently, electric motor driven vapor compression refrigeration cycles dominate the air
conditioning and refrigeration applications. Figure 1.1 shows the block diagram for a
Vapor Compression Refrigeration cycle. The four basic components of the system are
the compressor, condenser, evaporator and expansion valve.
1 2Evaporator
Compressor
34
ThrottleValve
Condenser
Figure 1.1: Block Diagram of Vapor Compression Refrigeration system.
A working Fluid (refrigerant) is boiled off in the evaporator at pressure, low enough
to provide the cooling. A work driven compressor (usually electrical work) then increases
the pressure of the evaporated working fluid. The high pressure vapors are condensed in
the condenser by rejecting heat to the surrounding. The condensed working fluid is then
expanded back into the evaporator, (via an expansion valve)where it can again provide
the cooling. The cycle involves two pressures, high and low,to enable continuous process
to produce the cooling effect.
6
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
1.2.2 Vapor Absorption Refrigeration
The heat operated vapor absorption refrigeration technique employs a solute gas as the
vaporizing refrigerant and a suitable solvent for recovering and recycling the refrigerant.
Figure 1.2 shows the block diagram of Vapor absorption refrigeration cycle. The refriger-
ant is vaporized in the evaporator at low pressure to providethe cooling. The evaporated
refrigerant is absorbed in solvent liquid (absorbent) in the absorber. The heat of solution
released in the absorber is removed by cooling water. The rich solution produced in the
absorber is separated by application of heat in the generator. The refrigerant is boiled
off, producing a lean solution which is recycled to the absorber. The vapors from the
generator are condensed and returned as refrigerant liquidto the evaporator. The cycle
involves two pressures, high pressure side (Generator and condenser) and low pressure
side (absorber and evaporator). Refrigerant solution fromthe absorber is pumped to the
generator, where the absorption refrigeration cycle requires electrical energy. However,
the electricity required is much less compared to the heat required.
A large number of refrigerant-solvent combinations can produce refrigeration by ab-
sorption refrigeration technique. Some of the industrially important solute-solvent com-
binations are;
• Ammonia as refrigerant and Water or dilute aqueous solutionof Ammonia as ab-
sorbent.
• Water as the refrigerant and aqueous Lithium Bromide solution as absorbent.
Ammonia-water system is advantageous when compared to the water-lithium bromide
because the later can not operate below freezing point of water.
7
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
Condenser
Generator
Evaporator
Absorber
QB
QCQE
QA
RefluxTop product
Feed
weak aqua
Refrigerant
Evaporated Refrigerant
Figure 1.2: Block Diagram of Vapor Absorption Refrigeration system.
1.3 Ammonia - Water Mixture
Ammonia and ammonia-water mixtures attract more attentionto the usage as natural
refrigerant, supercritical fluid solvent and working medium in power cycles and refriger-
ation cycle. Power cycles with ammonia-water mixtures as working fluids have been
shown to reach higher thermal efficiencies than the traditional steam turbine (Rank-
ine) cycle with water as the working fluid. Ammonia is highly soluble in water. Its
high solubility is because of the hydrogen bond formation between water and ammo-
nia. While these bonds, are not exactly sharing electrons like Covalent bonding. The
hydrogen bond is an electrostatic force between covalentlybonded hydrogen atom of
one molecule and electronegative atom of another molecule.It is very week (strength
about 2-10 Kcal/mole) as compared to a covalent bond (strength 50-100 Kcal/mole).
The hydrogen bonding between water molecules is stroger as compaired to the hydrogen
bonding between ammonia molecules. This is the main reason,why water is liquid and
ammonia is gas at room temperature. Comparison of the physical properties of the am-
monia with that of water shows that ammonia has the lower melting point, boiling point,
density, viscosity, dielectric constant and electrical conductivity; This is due to weaker
8
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
H-bonding in ammonia.
Water and ammonia are natural fluids which do not harm the environment. There-
fore, they are also considered as an alternative refrigerant to replace chlorofluorocarbons
in some refrigeration applications. For design, simulation and optimization of such ma-
chinery, accurate description of the thermodynamic properties of the mixture for a wide
range of pressure, temperature and composition are needed.For this purpose, correla-
tions for calculating thermodynamic properties of binary mixtures have been presented
by researchers.
1.4 Objective of the Work
1. The first objective is to measure a set of pressure-temperature-total composition
data.
2. To study the influence of salt concentration on the vapor-liquid equilibrium behav-
ior of ammonia-water and to develop a fundamentally sound approach to correlat-
ing the influence of salt on the behavior of a system.
3. To estimate activity coefficients of the solvents from experimental data correlated
using Redlich-Kister and NRTL equations.
9
Chapter 2
Literature Survey
10
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
2.1 Literature Survey for Ammonia - Water System
TheNH3 −H2O mixture is receiving increasing attention due to the potential use of the
system as a working fluid in refrigeration and power cycles. The binaryNH3−H2O mix-
ture has a large technical significance in the fields of absorption refrigeration machines,
absorption heat pumps and heat transformers. Ammonia and water have been considered
as alternative organic refrigerants to replace chlorofluorocarbons (CFC) in some refriger-
ation applications to prevent the destruction of environment and natural working fluids.
NH3 − H2O mixture does not affect the atmospheric ozone layer nor do they contribute
to the green house effect. Therefore, the significance of this mixture in refrigeration
technology is strongly increasing. Refrigerating cycle with NH3 − H2O mixtures as
working fluids to reach higher coefficient of performance than traditional working flu-
ids. Thermodynamic modeling of a technological processes requires information on the
phase equilibrium and other thermodynamic properties of theNH3 − H2O mixtures.
The first attempt to obtain the VLE data on the ammonia-water system over the full
range of composition was made by Wilson, who measured the total vapor pressure VLE
data from 273.15 K to 364.15 K and up to 1.17 MPa. His study was further extrapolated
to 3.85 Mpa. Isobaric VLE of the systemNH3 − H2O are experimentally determined
at 14.69 and 65 psia in dilute solution of ammonia in water. The results obtained are
correlated in terms of the relative volatility [Polaket al. , 1975].
Vapor-liquid equilibrium data for the ammonia-water system over the complete com-
position range have been obtained at the temperature from 313.15 K and 588.7 K [Gille-
spieet al., 1987]. The total pressure method is used to obtain PTx data,and in a separate
procedure equilibrium vapor and liquid phase composition (PTxy data) are analyzed. The
PTx data is reduced to PTxy data using the Redlich - Kister activity coefficient expan-
sion with four parameter. The parameter of the Redlich-Kister expansion is obtained
by fitting the total pressure data using a least squares procedure. One PTxy is used to
evaluate the second cross virial coefficient. Relative volatility is calculated from the the
total pressure data, which are in good agreement with the values obtained from equilib-
rium phase measurements. The reduced data thus obtained is in good agreement with
11
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
the actual PTxy measurement, giving a thermodynamically consistant set of vapor-liquid
equilibrium measurements.
Syed et al. have measured the Isothermal vapor-liquid equilibrium data for the ammonia-
water system at temperatures from 306 to 618 K and at pressures up to 22 MPa [Syed
et al. , 1987]. The equilibrium temperatures, pressures, and the compositions of both liq-
uid and vapor phases are measured simultaneously and compaired results with literature.
The data is extended into the critical regions of the seven-phase envelopes at temperatures
between the critical points of ammonia and water.
Pressure-temperature-overall composition VLE data are determined for the ammonia-
water system at five temperatures between 293.15 and 413.15 Kand up to 500 psia
[Smolenet al. , 1991]. The measured data is correlated by means of Redlich-Kwong
equation of state modified to include Peneloux’s volume translation and a density-dependent
mixing rule. Different constants values in the vapor and liquid phases have used to achive
calculated vapor-phase composition with previous literature result.
The experimental data on phase equilibria in ammonia-watermixture are fitted on
basis of thermodynamic perturbation theory in the range of temperature (200 - 640 K)
and pressure (0.02 - 23 MPa) [Abovsky, 1996]. Data for the vapor-liquid equilibrium are
regressed by least square method. Effects of mixing on enthalpy and volume and some
deviations from one-fluid approximation is analyzed.
Mejbri et al. have model the ammonia-water refrigerant mixture by three different
approaches and compared with model [Mejbri and Bellagi, 2005]. The first is an empiri-
cal approach based on a free enthalpy model of the mixture considered as resultant of the
properties of its pure components and of an excess term corresponding to the deviation
to ideal solution concept. Secondly, a semi-empirical approach based on the PATEL and
TEJA cubic equation of state is considered. Finally, a theoretical approach formulated as
PC-SAFT (perturbed chain statistical associating fluid theory) equation of state is treated.
Comparison of these three methods proves the superiority ofPC-SAFT in predicting and
extrapolating the thermodynamic properties of the water-ammonia system up to very high
temperatures and pressures.
12
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
The PVTx properties ofNH3 − H2O mixture have been measured in the near and
supercritical regions. Measurements are made at temperatures from 301 to 634 K and
at pressures up to 28 MPa [Polikhronidiet al. , 2009]. Temperatures and densities at
the liquid-gas phase transition curve, dew and bubble-pressure points, and the critical
parameters for theNH3 −H2O mixture are obtained using the quasi-static thermograms
and isochoric break-point techniques.
2.2 Literature Survey for Ammonia - Water - Salt Sys-
tem
Vapor-liquid equilibrium data for the system ammonia - water and lithium bromide (LiBr)
at four temperatures, 303.15, 333.15, 373.15 and 423.15 K and pressures up to 1.5 MPa.
The salt concentration in the liquid phase was chosen in the range 5-60 mass % LiBr in
pure water [Peterset al. , 1994]. Similar type of experiments has done by Zimmermann
(1989) in the temperature range of 303 K to 423 K and pressuresup to 15 bar [Zimmer-
mann and Keller, 1989]. The analysis of the data obtained forthe two binary mixtures
ammonia-water and water- lithium bromide indicates, the static method to be useful to
measure VLE in theNH3 − H20 − LiBr system.
Boone et al. have explained the procedure for correlating the effect of non-volatile
salts on the vapor-liquid equilibrium of binary solvents [Booneet al. , 1976]. The pro-
cedure is based on estimating the influence of salt concentration of both components in
a pseudo-binary solution. Using this technique and Wilson parameter have determined
from the infinite dilution activity coefficients, precise estimation of bubble point temper-
ature and vapor phase composition is obtained over a range ofsalt and solvent composi-
tion.
Data for a number of alcohol-water system saturated with various inorganic salts have
been correlated by computing pseudo-activity coefficientsfor the volatile components
[Rousseauet al. , 1972]. Coefficient computed are readily correlated by means of the
Van-laar, Wilson and Renon equations.
13
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
A static method is used to obtain vapor liquid equilibrium data for the systems am-
monia - water - potassium hydroxide and ammonia - water - sodium hydroxide at tem-
peratures of 303 and 318 K and pressures from 0.1 to 1.3 MPa [Brasset al. , 2000]. The
salt concentration in the liquid phase is chosen in the rangefrom 2 to 60 mass % salt in
water. In both systemsNH3 − H2O − NaOH andNH3 − H2O − KOH, solid liquid
vapor equilibrium are observed. In theNH3−H2O−KOH system, liquid - liquid vapor
equilibrium is observed at 318 K and 1.1 MPa.
An equilibrium cell is used to measure thermal property of the ternaryNH3−H2O−
LiBr mixtures. The pressure and temperature data for their VLE data are measured at
ten temperature points between 15-850C, and pressures up to 2 MPa [Yuyuan and Tiehui,
2005]. The LiBr concentration of the solution is chosen in the range of 5-60% of mass
ratio of LiBr in pure water and ammonia concentration up to 0-60%. The VLE for the
NH3 − H2O − LiBr ternary solution is measured statically. The experimentalresults
show that the equilibrium pressures reduced by 30-50%, and the amount of component
of water in the gas phase reduced greatly to 2.5% at 700C temperature.
Vapor-liquid equilibrium of ammonia - water - potassium hydroxide and ammonia -
water - sodium hydroxide systems are measured by a static method from 293.15 K to
353.15 K. The experimental vapor pressure data has been correlated with temperature
and mass percent concentration using an analytical polynomial equation [Salaveraet al.
, 2005].
The vapor pressure of ammonia - lithium nitrate - water and ammonia - lithium ni-
trate mixtures is measured by a static method from 293.15 K to353.15 K in ammonia
mass fractions ranging from 0.2 to 0.6 [Liboteanet al. , 2007]. The equilibrium liquid
and vapor compositions are determined using the Redlich-Kister equation for activity co-
efficients of the liquid phase and the Redlich-Kwong equation of state for the modeling
the vapor phase nonideality. Vapor pressure, Temperature and liquid-phase composition
are correlated using an empirical equation. The capabilityof the electrolyte nonrandom
two liquid (E-NRTL) model to predict the VLE of the ternary mixture is evaluated by
comparing predicted and experimental data of the ammonia - lithium nitrate - water so-
14
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
lutions. The binary interaction parameters of ammonia - lithium nitrate needed for the
prediction of ternary VLE are determined from binary experimental data. The isobaric
data for the system methanol-water, ethanol-water and 1-propanol water, each saturated
with a inorganic salts is correlated by means of the Van-laar, Wilson and Renon equations
[Rousseauet al. , 1972]. Activity coefficients are calculated for each volatile component
using standard equation state for thermodynamic equilibrium.
The simultaneous solubility of sulfur dioxide and ammonia in aqueous solutions of
(ammonium sulfate or sodium sulfate) is measured by a synthetic method in the tempera-
ture range from 313.6 K to 373.2 K and at pressures up to 2.5 MPa[Meyeret al. , 2006].
The enthalpy change upon diluting aqueous solutions of sulfur dioxide, ammonia and
(ammonium sulfate or sodium sulfate) in aqueous solutions of the same salt is measured
in a batch calorimeter at about 313 K and 352 K. The experimental results are compaired
with predictions from a thermodynamic model for the vapor-liquid equilibrium and the
enthalpy of dilution of those chemical reacting systems. Inthat model, activity coeffi-
cients are calculated from Pitzer’s modality-scale-basedGibbs excess energy model.
15
Chapter 3
VLE of Ammonia - Water System
16
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
Vapor-liquid equilibrium, is a condition where a liquid andits vapor (gas phase) are
in equilibrium with each other, a condition or state where the rate of evaporation (liq-
uid changing to vapor) equals the rate of condensation (vapor changing to liquid) on a
molecular level such that there is no net (overall) vapor-liquid interconversion. Although
in theory equilibrium takes forever to reach, such an equilibrium is practically reached
in a relatively closed location if a liquid and its vapor are allowed to stand in contact
with each other long enough with no interference or only gradual interference from the
outside. Vapor-liquid equilibrium is at the heart of many chemical and envirmental en-
gineering processes and activities. Distillation, dryingand evaporation are all based on
VLE. For ideal solution, it is simple and we can separate any mixture of species with
different boiling points. For nonideal solution, the process is more complex, specially in
the case of ammonia-water mixture.
3.1 VLE Equations for Ammonia - Water Binary System
The starting point is the equality of the fugacity of each species in the two phases:
fi
V= fL
i
i = 1, 2, · · · · · · · · · · · · , N
where for the N-component mixturefi
Vis the fugacity of the component i in the vapor
phase andfLi is the fugacity of component i in the liquid phase. In the activity coefficient
approach the vapor-liquid equilibrium of ammonia-water system was calculated by using
the equation,
P φi yi = xi γi Psati φ sat
i exp
V Li (Pi −Psat
i )
RT
ff
(3.1)
Component 1: Ammonia
Component 2: Water
Correlation for calculating saturated temperature and saturated pressure of ammonia
and water are given as,
17
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
For Ammonia,
log P sat1 = 7.36048 −
926.13
T sat1 + 240.17
(3.2)
For Water,
log P sat2 = 8.07131−
1760.63
T sat2 − 233.426
(3.3)
whereP sat1 and P sat
2 are in mm Hg andT sat1 andT sat
2 are in0C
Equation of state analogous toRedlich-Kwongequation of state has been used, how-
ever, it also includes2nd and3rd virial coefficients [Gillespieet al. , 1987].
Z =V
V − b+
B − b
V+
C − b2
V 2(3.4)
where,
V molar volume
b,B,C Virial Coefficients
b is theRedlich-Kwongb, given as:
b = y1b1 + y2b2 (3.5)
where,
b1 = 21.11 andb2 = 15.0
Second Virial Coefficient (B):
B = y2
1B11 + 2y1y2B12 + y2
2B22 (3.6)
where,
B11 = 18.02
[1.898 −
(2641.62
T
)exp
(186210
T 2
)](3.7)
18
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
B22 = 0.926
[26.35 − 27.93
(exp
(725
T
)− 1.0
)](3.8)
B12 =1
2
[B∗
11
(Vc2
Vc1
)+ B∗
22
(Vc1
Vc2
)](3.9)
Vc1 andVc2 are critical volumes of water and ammonia respectively,
Vc1 = 56 cc/mol
Vc2 = 72.5 cc/mol
Here,B∗
11 meansB11 calculated from Eqn. 3.7, substitutingA12
Tfor 1
T. Similarly for
B∗
12
A12 = 0.944 + 0.0138(
1000
T
)2T < 405.9K
= 1.015 T ≥ 405.9K
Third Virial Coefficient (C):
C = y3
1C111 + 3y2
1y2C112 + 3y1y2
2C122 + y3
2C222 (3.10)
where,
C111 = 2097 (cc/mol)2
C222 = 4178 (cc/mol)2
3C112 = 2
(Vc2
Vc1
)C111 +
(Vc1
Vc2
)2
C222
3C122 = 2
(Vc1
Vc2
)C222 +
(Vc2
Vc1
)2
C111
Fugacities of Pure Species
Fugacity Coefficient of Pure Species,
Fugacity coefficient of pure species can be calculated by,
19
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
ln φi =1
RT
∫ V
∞
(RT
V− P
)dV − lnZ + (Z − 1) (3.11)
ln φi =
∫ V
∞
(1 − Z)dV
V− ln Z + (Z − 1)
substituting Z from Eqn. 3.4 in above Equation,
ln φi = ln
(V
V − b
)+
B − b
V+
2 (C − b2)
V 2− ln Z + Z − 1 (3.12)
Fugacity Coefficient of Pure Species in a Solution,
ln φi =1
RT
∫ V
∞
[RT
V− N
(∂P
∂Ni
)
T,V,Nj
]dV − ln Z (3.13)
For ammonia,
ln φ1 = (M1 + M2 + M3 + M4) − ln Z (3.14)
where,
M1 = log
(V
V − b
)
M2 =b2
V − b
M3 =− (b + b2 − 2 (y2B22 + y1B12))
V
T4A = 3y2
2C222 + 2y1y2C122F + y2
1C112F
M4 =− (b2 + 2bb2 − T4A)
2V 2
For Water,
20
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
ln φ2 = [M1 + M2 + M3 + M4] − ln Z (3.15)
M1 = log
(V
V − b
)
M2 =b1
V − b
M3 =− (b + b1 − 2 (y1B11 + y2B12))
V
M4A = 3y2
1C111 + 2y1y2C112F + y2
2C122F
M4 =(b2 + 2bb1 − M4A)
2V 2
where,
C111 = 2097 (cc/mol)2
C222 = 4178 (cc/mol)2
3C112 = 2
(Vc2
Vc1
)C111 +
(Vc1
Vc2
)2
C222
3C122 = 2
(Vc1
Vc2
)C222 +
(Vc2
Vc1
)2
C111
21
Chapter 4
VLE Measurements of Ammonia -
Water - Salt System
22
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
4.1 Experimental Set up
The use of rocket cell for ammonia-water system to study their equilibrium total vapor
pressure at varying temperature was initially measured by Gillespie et al. [Gillespieet al.
, 1987]. Similar type of setup with special arrangement of horizontal autoclave rotation
as shown in figure 4.1 was used for further research work. The volume of the autoclave
was 300 cm3 and the material of construction was SS 316. The digital pressure indicator
(Wika, Mumbai) with an accuracy of±0.25% was mounted on top of autoclave. The
autoclave has an arrangement for RTD sensor Pt 100 at the center. Temperature was
controlled and measured using a PID controller with an accuracy of 0.10C. Autoclave
was kept on oscillation, to attain better mixing and vapor-liquid phase equilibrium. The
oscillator stand was pivoted to motor with a rod connecting the flywheel which rotates
the autoclave to forward and backward direction.
T
P
M
G
F
H
A
PS
TS
C
B
Figure 4.1: Block Diagram of Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium set up.
(A, B = sampling tube; F = Flange; G = Gear box; T =Temperature indicator; PS =Pres-sure sensor; M = Motor; H = Casing containing heating coil; TS= Temperature sensor;V = Autoclave)
23
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
4.2 Materials
Ammonia solution (sp. gravity 0.89, 30% AR solution), potassium acetate (AR grade,
99.0% purity), and copper acetate (AR grade, 99% purity), ammonium sulphate (AR
grade, 99% purity), sodium thiocyanate (LR grade, 98% purity), sodium nitrate (AR
grade, 99.5%) and potassium nitrate (AR grade, 99.5% purity) were used for experimen-
tal work. All chemicals were purchased from M/S sd fine Chemicals Ltd Mumbai.
4.3 System Details
The vapor liquid equilibrium of ammonia-water mixture and water-ammonia-salt were
studied in 10K steps at varying temperature from 313.15 K to 403.15 K. Every set of
experiment were carried out for 45 minutes to attain equilibrium. The effect of differ-
ent concentration of salt additives on ammonia-water system was studied, as their small
presence in system exerts a significant effect on the relative volatility of the component.
Therefor the effect of salt on the VLE of ammonia-water system was studied at different
concentrations. The different salt additives as potassiumacetate, copper acetate, ammo-
nium sulphate, sodium thiocyanate, sodium nitrate and potassium nitrate at concentration
of 5, 10, 15 and 20 mass % was added to the mixture of water and ammonia at the con-
centration of 10, 20 and 30 mass% to study the ammonia-water-salt VLE system. Rocked
static VLE cell was used to generate the VLE data for ammonia-water system with addi-
tive.
4.4 Result and Discussion
Aim of the present research work, is to correlate the vapor pressure values obtained from
experimental data with Redlich-Kister and NRTL equations.VLE setup was calibrated
by using pure water, the obtained experimental vapor pressure values matches with the
literature values with 2% difference, as shown in figure 4.2.
24
Thermodynamic Study of Ternary Refrigerant Equilibria
90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180
Temperature 0C
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Tot
al V
apor
Pre
ssur
e (a
tm)
Antonie EquationExperimetal
Figure 4.2: Vapor-Liquid equilibrium of Pure Water System.