1 Australian Unity Wellbeing Index Report 28.1: The wellbeing of parents Australian Unity Wellbeing Index Survey 28.0 Report 28.1 August 2014 “The wellbeing of Australians - the wellbeing of parents” Melissa K. Weinberg Bengianni Pizzirani and The Australian Unity Wellbeing Research Team Australian Centre on Quality of Life Deakin University, 221 Burwood Highway Melbourne, Victoria 3125, Australia http://www.deakin.edu.au/research/acqol/auwbi/survey-reports/index.php
20
Embed
“The wellbeing of Australians - the wellbeing of parents
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1 Australian Unity Wellbeing Index Report 28.1: The wellbeing of parents
Figure 1: Children and wellbeing ............................................................................................................ 4
Figure 2: Children and wellbeing (domains) ........................................................................................... 4
Figure 3: Parenthood and wellbeing x gender ........................................................................................ 5
Figure 4: Children and wellbeing domains (men only) ........................................................................... 6
Figure 5: Have children x age group (PWI) (men) ................................................................................... 6
Figure 6: Have children x income group (PWI) (men) ............................................................................. 7
Figure 7: Relationship status x children (PWI) (men) ............................................................................. 8
Figure 8: Number of children and wellbeing (men only) ........................................................................ 8
Figure 9: Father’s wellbeing and gender of children .............................................................................. 9
Figure 10: Number of children and gender of children x PWI (Fathers) ............................................... 10
Figure 11: Number of children (grouped) and Gender of children x PWI (fathers only) ...................... 11
Figure 12: Fathers of at least 3 children on all domains ....................................................................... 11
3 Australian Unity Wellbeing Index Report 28.1: The wellbeing of parents
The Wellbeing of Parents – An Introduction
Subjective wellbeing (SWB) refers to cognitive and affective evaluations that individuals make about the quality of their own life (Diener, 2006), and is reflected in terms
of their satisfaction with different domains of life that contribute to their overall life
satisfaction (Cummins, Eckerskley, Pallant, Van Vugt, & Misajon, 2003). These domains represent universal predictors of life satisfaction (IWBG, 2013). By its nature, SWB is relatively
stable over time, though it can change in response to significant life events (Suh, Diener, & Fujita, 1996). One life event that has been explored in the SWB literature is the experience of
becoming a parent. Research has captured both the highs and lows of parenthood, with
some studies indicating that parenting is associated with higher wellbeing (e.g., Aassve, Goisis, & Sironi, 2012), and others suggesting a negative effect of parenting on SWB (e.g.,
Evenson & Simon, 2005).
For example, a meta-analytic review of parenthood and marital satisfaction found
that parents report lower marital satisfaction compared to people without children (Twenge,
Campbell, & Foster, 2003). The same review also revealed a significant negative correlation between marital satisfaction and number of children, highlighting the possible strains
children can place on relationship satisfaction – one of the seven SWB domains.
Despite these negative effects, research has continued to find support for the notion that parents are happier than people without children (Nelson, Kushlev, English, Dunn, &
Lyubomirsky, 2013), even after controlling for individual characteristics, such as number of
children and household income. This effect appears to be more pronounced for fathers, who reported higher satisfaction and happiness than non-fathers. The same effect was not
apparent for mothers (Nelson et al., 2013).
A more recent study modelled the SWB trajectory of parents from four years prior to four years post the birth of their first child, and demonstrated that some parents were
happier (4.3%), some were less happy (7.2%), and most remained stable (84.2%) (Galatzer-Levy, Mazursky, Mancini & Bonanno, 2011). These findings are consistent with the idea that
we may experience temporary fluctuations in SWB in response to a life event, but that over
time SWB returns to a set-point (Suh, Diener, & Fujita, 1996; Cummins, 2010). We consider the wellbeing of Australian parents using data collected as part of the
Australian Unity Wellbeing project in 2012. More information about this project and the
survey can be found at http://www.deakin.edu.au/research/acqol/reports/auwbi.php.
Sample and Methodology
The sample for this study was derived from the 28th survey of the Australian Unity Wellbeing Index. The sample comprised a geographically representative national subsection
of the Australian population, aged 18 years or over and fluent in English, who were surveyed
by telephone over the period 19th September to 4th October, 2012. Interviewers asked to
speak to the person in the house who had the most recent birthday and was at least 18 years
old. Of the total sample of 1964 participants, 1492 (76.0%) were parents. The average age of the sample was 53.36 (SD = 16.64), and participants had on average 2.59 children (SD = 1.15).
The majority of participants (57.6%) were married, and either engaged in full time work
Std of living Health Achieving Relationships Safety Community Security
Sati
sfa
cti
on
Domains of life
All sons All daughters Mixed
12 Australian Unity Wellbeing Index Report 28.1: The wellbeing of parents
Conclusions 1. There is a significant difference in the wellbeing of men who have children and men
who do not. There is no significant difference in the wellbeing of women based on
whether or not they have children.
2. This difference in men’s wellbeing emerges due largely to differences in the domain of personal relationships. Fathers report significantly higher satisfaction with their
personal relationships than men without children. This occurs because most fathers are married or in defacto relationships, whereas men without children are more likely
to be unmarried.
3. For fathers, wellbeing appears to peak for those who have 3 children. Their wellbeing is significantly higher than those who have no children or just one child.
4. For fathers who have 1 or 2 children, there are no differences in wellbeing if they
have sons or daughters. However, for fathers of at least 3 children, those who have all
daughters and no sons report lower wellbeing than those who have a combination of
daughters and sons, and this is driven particularly by lower satisfaction with standard of living, health, and safety.
Summary
These findings support the general idea that SWB is higher for parents compared to people without children, though further analyses revealed that this difference was driven by
fathers, whose wellbeing was significantly higher than for men without children. This finding
is consistent with the previous research that supports the positive effects of parenthood on SWB (Aassve, Goisis, & Sironi, 2012; Nelson et al., 2013). The present findings emerged due
to the large difference in satisfaction with the domain of personal relationships between
fathers and men without children. Most fathers in our study were married or in a defacto
relationship, and so they have the benefit of a close partner to provide social support, which
is essential for higher wellbeing (Cummins, 2010). Amongst fathers, the highest wellbeing was reported by those with 3 children, whose
SWB was significantly higher than those with no children or just one child. However, for
fathers with at least 3 children, wellbeing was significantly lower if they had only daughters compared to those who had at least one son. These findings were driven by differences in
three key life domains: Standard of living, health, and safety. One explanation for these
findings from the economic literature is that sons may consume fewer financial resources than daughters (Lundberg, 1995). Alternatively, fathers may be more involved and active in
the lives of their sons compared to their daughters, thereby deriving the wellbeing benefits in return for their greater investment. In support of this explanation, research on time
allocation in the USA has revealed that men spend more time with their children if they have
at least one son (Barnett & Baruch, 1987, Harris & Morgan, 1991).
Overall, the wellbeing of fathers is within the normal range for Australians, and is
higher than for men without children. This difference in parental wellbeing appears to be
exclusive to fathers, with no significant difference in wellbeing emerging for women. Structural differences like the number of children and gender of children account for
differences in wellbeing amongst fathers, but the importance of being in a committed
relationship with a partner was a key factor contributing to the higher wellbeing of fathers in general.
13 Australian Unity Wellbeing Index Report 28.1: The wellbeing of parents
Appendix of Tables
Table 1. Children vs No Children (PWI)
Do you have any
children?
PWI
N Mean SD
No 429 73.91 13.48
Yes 1419 76.24 12.89
t(1846) = -3.247, p=.001, Cohen’s d=.18
Table 2. Children vs No Children (GLS and domains)
Domain No children Children t-test Effect
N Mean SD N M SD p d
GLS 461 74.86 17.43 1490 78.68 17.01 .000 .22
Standard of living 460 79.09 16.62 1491 78.84 16.53 .779
Health 461 74.79 19.81 1489 73.82 19.09 .344
Achieving in life 453 72.10 19.10 1474 74.31 18.58 .027 .12