The Spektator 22

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

1/28

Wpdctjthr 00 Wdptda`dr 0>:7

_hur rjrdey pu`eosbdm iuomd th wbjts bjppdkoki ok jkm jrhukm @osbcdc

]BD

Pdstjurjkt Iuomd]hurost Ajp Ejtdst Kdws

Iroa

Khrtbup

^eus6 Cyriyzstjks rhjroki ?>s, geoa`oki ^djc

Tgbotde, `jgcgbjt tbd pheogd, jkm augb ahrd...

\hrcutj6

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

2/28

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

3/28

Ghktdkts

]bos Ahktb

]B

D

Wpdctjthr]bd Wpdctjthr os khw hkeokd jt www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc.gh.uc

Pdstjurjkts, @jrs, Geu`sJee tbd `dst `jrs jkm geu`s ok thwk. Whad

wdee-ckhwk sphts bjvd `ddk tjcdk huthl tbos ahktbs dmotohk wotb kdw sphts

jmmdm. Luee eostokis jvjoej`ed hk tbd

wd`sotd.

0=

9

=]bd Iuomd

Kdws jkm \odwsHur rdsdktlue dmothroje, j `osdxuje rdao-

kosgdkgd hvdr j pjssohkjtd jjor wotb j

ajrrodm whajk, j ahjk j`hut qududs

ok Cyriyzstjk jkm tbd hpphsotohks ejtdst

vomdh-tjpdm sgjkmjes.

2

0>

00

]bd Wpdctjthr Ajijzokd os jvjoej`ed jt ehgjtohks tbrhuibhut @osbcdc, okgeumoki6(]rjvde Jidkgods) Jmvdkturd Wdeedr, Jc-Wjo ]rjvde, Gjreshk Yjihkeot, Gdedstoje Ahuktjoks, Dghthur, Iejvthur,Cyriyz Ghkgdpt,

Cyriyz ]rjvde, Auzj, KhvoKhajm (@jrs & Pdstjurjkts) Bheeywhhm, Adtrh, Kdw _hrc ^ozzj, Kh:, 0x0, @huedvjrm, Ghddbhusd, Mhcj, Ljt`hys, Lhur Wdjshks, Eovd @jr, Ehukid @jr, Adro,Kjvoijthr, Wtjry Dmijrs \drjkmj, Jmrojtogh, Gygehkd, Mhegd \otj, Wjktj Ajroj, @deej Otjeoj (Gjsokhs) Durhpj, Ihemdk Mrjihk, RH (Bhtdes) Mhstuc, Byjtt, Ihemdk Mrjihk, Bheomjy, Jepokost

(Da`jssods jkm Hrijkosjtohks) ]bd TK uoemoki, ]bd Jadrogjk jsd, ]bd Idrajk Da`jssy, ]bd Mutgb Ghksuejtd, GJA^ Jej-thh, KGGP, ]bd @osbcdc Hpdrj & @jeedt Whgodty.

HK ]BD GH\DP6 \hrcutj - aoibty ghem (Wyevjok Mostok)

]bd Wpdctjthr Ajijzokd

Lhukmdr6]ha Ydeeokis

Dmothr6]ha Ydeeokis

(dmothrNtbdspdctjthr.gh.uc)

Wtj wrotdrs6 @dk Pogb, Ph`drtAjrcs, ]bhajs Hesdk, Mdkkos Cddk,

^jeadr Cddk, Bheey Aydrs, AjttbdwWthw`romid, Focj ], Jmdeokd @dee,

^jue Muaadtt, jtrogc @jrrhw, Mokj]hc`jdvj, Jeogd Fjkvrok, W. \yshtscy,

]ha ]wddmy

Iudst Ghktro`uthr6 Mrdsmdk Aurpby

Mdsoik6 Bvjrd Lorhuzdb

www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

Yjkt th ghktro`utd js j lrddejkgd

wrotdr8 ^edjsd ghktjgt6dmothrNtbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

:=

Hut & J`hut

Jej-Jrgbj6 @dyhkm ogkogsJej-Jrgbj, j 7> aokutd mrovd lrha @osbcdc,

hdrs shad hl tbd whrems irdjtdst wjecs.

Lhgus

Wpdctjthr Wjtord]bd mogtjthr hl shad eotted-ckhwk osejkm

bjm j `ortbmjy mh ok @osbcdc djreodr tbos

suaadr jkm ]urcadkostjks prdsomdkt fust

ijvd `ortb th j wbjed. Pdada`dr, khkd hl

tbos os rdjeey bjppdkoki...

@hhc Pdvodw^boeop Wboscoks Pdstedss \jeedyPdstedss \jeedy6 Pdvheutohk, Aurmdr jkmOktroiud ok tbd Bdjrt hl Gdktrje Jsojos j

rop-rhjroki fhurkdy tbrhuib tbd ahmdrk

bosthrods hl Cyriyzstjk jkm Tz`dcostjk

pdkkdm y boeop Wbosbcok. ]ha ]wddmy

rdvodws ot.

]bd Dkm

0

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

4/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

= ]bos Ahktb

Jkm tbdrd ot os, tbd Wpdctjthr ajijzokd eoapshk lhr tbd sjcd hl yhur jausdadkt j whrtby

dkhuib gjusd, wd supphsd. Hur ehoks bjvd khwossudm twdkty-twh sords, kht ghuktoki tbd `js-tjrms, jkm jkhtbdr suaadr ossud tbjt aossdmtbd ajfhroty hl suaadr os khw rdjmy lhr yhurghdd tj`ed hr tbd spjgd `dbokm yhur ejvjthry,mdpdkmoki hk bhw yhu vodw us. Ljahus pdh-ped tbjt bjvd bdjrm hl tbd Wpdctjthrokgeumd tbd@rotosb Ja`jssjmhr th Cjzjcbstjk jkm bos wold,Jadrogjk ghadmy wrotdr Cdvok @edybdr jkm Wjry,jk djied buktdr lrha Ossyc-Cue prhvokgd. @dgjusdhl tbos, wd jrd kht j`hut th mdvdehp jk okldrohr-oty ghapedx hr j gbop hk hur sbhuemdr jky toadshhk. Bhkdstey...

Hur \jedktokds Mjy ossud gdrtjokey gjusdmj stor, ahstey mud th hur iuomd th @osbcdcs strop

`jrs, wbogb jrhusdm prjosd jkm grotogosa jeahstok dquje adjsurd (grotogosa seoibtey hutwdoibdmtbd prjosd, th `d ljor). Pdjeey, wd mhkt hdr jkyjphehiods lhr tbos, sokgd jltdr kdjrey vd ydjrs okwbogb wd bjvd ghvdrdm dvdrytboki lrha `jkyjsjkm tbd @jsajgbo rd`deeohk th skhw edhpjrmsjkm Wdridy ^rhcumok-Ihrscy, yhu tjcd wbjtdvdrpdhped hdr yhu. ]bd htbdr mjy j lrodkm hl hurshdrdm th seddp j koibt ok tbd supphsdmey bjukt-dm Kjtohkje Bosthry Ausdua ok @osbcdc hk hur`dbjel. Yd prhaptey pedmidm th prokt tbd jrtogedwbdtbdr sbd modm hr kht.

Dajoe toted eokds jmmrdssoki hur mdevd okthtbd sddmodr somd hl Cyriyz thurosa okgeumdm sdx-ost sbjads (iuekhrjXj`mysjkhvjNajoe.ru) th O

usdm th rdjm tbd Wpdctjthr `ut (aheeysokstokgtNiajoe.gha). J ghuped hl mosrdputj`ed typds jscdmlhr ahrd hl tbd sjad, wboed l`ostdvdNyjbhh.gha

fust wjktdm `dttdr mordgtohks th tbd sjom okstotu-tohks. Whrry Wtdvd, wd whuem bhhc yhu up wotbtbd jutbhr `ut bd wjktdm th rdajok jkhkyahus.Whadtboki j`hut boa whrcoki ok oktdrkjtohkjemdvdehpadkt...

Jkybhw, tbjt wjs tbdk, tbos os khw. Ossud00 bjs shad grjgcoki rdjms, dvdk `y tbd boibstjkmjrms tbd Wpdctjthr bjs trodm th sdt otsdelhvdr tbd ydjrs. Hur ajok ldjturds jrd hk \hrcutj,tbd dx-iueji-bhstoki thwk khrtb hl tbd Pussojkjrgtog gorged tbjt hur oktrdpom rdphrtdr @dk Pogbbjm tbd lhrtukd hl vosotoki djreodr tbos ydjr, jkm

]BJ] jrtoged j`hut @osbcdc ok tbd kjuibty kokd-tods. Jehkisomd tbdsd fdwdes ok tbd grhwk wd bjvdhur rdvodw hl ^boeop Wbosbcoks `hhc Pdstedss \je-edy6 Pdvheutohk Aurmdr jkm Oktroiud ok tbd Bdjrthl Gdktrje Jsoj, j rjkt j`hut qududs, j rhajktogrdaokosgdkgd, j spht hl sjtord, j trdc tbrhuib JejJrgbj, jmvogd lhr jvhomoki pheogd sbjcdmhwks, jkupmjtdm iuomd wotb shad hl tbd ahrd h`vohuspejgds tjcdk hut, jkm phsts lrha hur pjrtkdrs (jdupbdaosa lhr pdhped wbhsd jrtogeds wd stdjejkm rd-prokt).

Lokjeey wd whuem eocd th tbjkc ghktrjgthrMdkkos Ghkkdey, wotbhut wbhsd idkdrhus iolttbos dposhmd whuem kht bjvd `ddk phsso`ed. Ghk-

kdey wjs possdm js j ljrt wbdk bd pjrtdm wotb bosoee-ihttdk gjsb jkm wboed bd ajy `d rdirdttoki otkhw wd jrd aoibty irjtdlue bd mom. Jltdr jee, wdwhuem kdvdr dxpdgt jkyhkd th iovd ahkdy th tbd Wpdctjthr wbdk sh`dr. Gbddrs Mdkky `hy!

]djrokij Wtrop hll us

@OWBCDC, Wdptda`dr 4, (]bd Wpdctjthr)- Aoibt tbos

`d j vosohk hl tbd dkm hl buajkcokm8 O jscdm aysdel6sbjvdk-bdjmdm bdjvods ajkjioki wbjt rdajokshl tbd whrems prdgohus rdshurgds, jk jkiry ah`

turkoki ok hk otsdel, sbhrtjids hl dvdrytboki dxgdptoksuets, oee-woee jkm vohedkt rjid, j Ajetbusojk toppokiphokt, tbd ijtdwjy th ukmoikodm dxtokgtohk8

Ot ghuem bjvd `ddk, `ut ok ahrd tjkio ed tdrasot wjs j qudud strdtgboki hut hl j sco rdktje sbjgc jttbd Khwruz sco rdshrt kht ljr lrha @osbcdc, ajokey

ghaphsdm hl wdee-th-mh goty typds wbh bjm jee `ddkphssdssdm `y tbd sjad okgeokjtohk th bot tbd sehpds

hk Fjkujry 4, tbd ejst mjy hl tbd woktdr bheomjys. ]bdsbjvdk bdjmdm Wejvs wdrd kh bdee `djsts dotbdr, `ut

yhuki Pussojk skhw`hjrmdrs whrcoki pjrt-toad`dbokm tbd rdktje sbjgc mdsc, ehjkoki hut sco `hhts,scos, pheds, bdeadts jkm sedms. _dt tbdrd wjs j lroibt-lue j`sdkgd hl jkytboki jvjoej ed lhr bord tbd idjr

bjm jee `ddk skjppdm up djreodr tbd sjad ahrk-oki - jkm khw tbd bjpedss grdw wdrd wjotoki lhr ot

th ghad `jgc ok mrops jkm mrj`s js tbdy ldkmdm hj lrustrjtdm grhwm hl whuem-`d-scodrs. Lhr tbd ltbtoad wd mhkt bjvd jky sozd =0 `hhts. Yd bjvd fust

rdgdovdm `hhts ok 7: jkm 02, hkd hl tbda grodm okmdspdrjtohk.

]bd wokkdrs ok sugb sotujtohks jrd ldw. @ut ol j

vogthr dadrids ot os usujeey j wdee-`uoet whajk wotbcoms ok thw6 wdee-`uoet `dgjusd lhrgoki yhur wjy

tbrhuib j tbrhki th gejoa j sgjrgd rdshurgd rdquordsj edvde hl pbysogje strdkitb tbjt wjols soapey gjkkhtaustdr, whajk `dgjusd mhoki tbd sjad js j ajk

woee ejkm yhu ok oktdksovd gjrd, jkm wotb coms ok thw`dgjusd ok jkiry qudud-typd sotujtohks gboemrdk gjk`d mdpehydm js thhes th ajkopuejtd tbd pdhped yhu

jrd pusboki pjst, j cokm hl rdtrhjgtovd fustogjtohklhr tbd soks hl tbd pjrdkt.

Wugb j whajk dadridm hk tbjt ljtdlue Fjku-

jry mjy. Yotb tbd iusth hl j `okih jmmogt wbhsdeugcy kua`drs bjvd fust `ddk gjeedm, sbd pusbdm

bdrsdel okth tbd sbjgc quotd jk jgbodvdadkt ghk-somdroki tbd vheuad hl pdhped jerdjmy oksomd jkmtbd sozd hl tbd sbjgc mhhr rdejtovd th bdr hwk ghehs-

sje lrjad pjeadm h j `urey ajk eocd bd wjskt

tbdrd, jkm `ddeokdm tbrhuib j sgrua hl scokkodrauas th gheejpsd bdrsdel hvdr tbd lrhkt mdsc jkm

gejoa tbd twh pjors hl `hhts. Wbd whuem bjvd thwjot lhr tbd scos `ut l*** ot, sbd wjs bjelwjy tbdrd.

Yhajk yhu bjvd kh sbjad, rdahkstrjtdm

jk jkiry mjm, wbh bjm wjktdm tbd 02s lhr bos

mjuibtdr `ut wjs wdmidm okth j ghrkdr hl tbdsbjgc. Wtogc yhur sbjad, rdpeodm tbd whajk. ]bdihssjadr-eocd shgoje lj`rog tbjt bdem tbd qudud

ghkgdpt ok pejgd bjm fust `ddk roppdm jpjrt jt tbdsdjas6 O mhkt iovd j sbot.

J eoldtoad hl qududs

Zududs, jkm ok pjrtoguejr, oksjkdey ehki qududs, wdrdj ghrkdrsthkd hl eold ok tbd Whvodt Tkohk. ]bos wjs

tbd rdsuet hl j ghaajkm dghkhay tbjt jeehgjtdmghksuadr ihhms ok ts jkm `ursts, sudroki rdiuejr

mdgots js wdee js orrjtohkje ieuts. Ok tbdsd strjkiddghkhaog toads, tbd eokds hutsomd stjtd mdpjrtadkt

sthrds ok Ahsghw dgjad tbd stu hl edidkms. Bdrh-okd Ahtbdrs (Auas wotb kokd hr ahrd gboemrdk) jkmvdtdrjks hl Yhrem Yjr ]wh wdrd sbudm th tbd lrhkthl qududs. Edss bhkhurdm ut ahrd rdshurgdlue typds

ghuem dkiokddr j prdsdkgd ok sdvdrje qududs jt tbdsjad toad `y idttoki tbd pdrshk ok lrhkt hl tbda th

bhem tbdor phsotohk js tbdy mjsbdm dtwddk eokds. ]bdjee ghkqudroki gurrdkgy ok j ghaaukost qudud, bhw-dvdr, wjs `ejt - tbd phwdr hl j pdrshkje ghkkdgtohk.

Yotb `ejtok aokm, j sbhpcddpdr sdeeoki shad prozdmwjrd rdgdktey muapdm hk tbd Ahsghw ajrcdt whuemhltdk wjvd j ljahus ehgje mhgthr hr jk bhkhurdm

jrtost thwjrms tbd toee, js tbd ahrtje rjkc jkm edmrhwkdm tbd eugcy qudud-fuapdr ok soedkt ord.

J lhradr Whvodt stjtd, Cyriyzstjk os pjrt hl tbjtsjad quduoki gueturd, jetbhuib tbdrd jrd soiks tbjttbd vuekdrj ed sdksd hl hrmdr tbjt bdem Whvodt drj

qududs thidtbdr bjs ahrd hr edss ukrjvdeedm6 Cthphsedmko8 ( wbh os ejst8) bjs `dghad jk hkihokifhcd ok Cyriyz eokds lhr jkytboki lrha ajkmjthry

ehhm sjapeds th pdksohks, `dgjusd yhu gjk iujr-jktdd tbd pdrshk wbh os ejst woee `d tbd ejst pdrshkth jmaot ot. Hk j rdgdkt trop th tbd Gbokdsd da`jssy,

j lrodkm wotkdssdm jkhtbdr ejrid ehgje whajk phsdtbos mrdjmdm qudstohk. Ybdk kh-hkd rdpeodm sbd

sjom6 Ydee ol khkd hl yhu ckhw wbh os ejst O jarst! J Idrajk, ldjroki lhr bos pejgd ok tbd sgbdadhl tbokis, gjuibt tbd `ui. O ja wotb jk oktdrkjtohkje

hrijkozjtohk! bd dxgejoadm, ukjwjrd tbjt tbos edkt

boa edss `ejt, kht ahrd.Oapjtodkgd, ot whuem sdda, os j ldjturd hl hur

ahmdrk jid. Ejwedsskdss os j ldjturd hl ahmdrk Cyr-iyzstjk. Gha okdm tbdy shukm j mdjtb ckdee lhr jk

hem-ljsbohkdm omdj6 tbd hrmdrey qudud.

Ybhsd Zudud os tbos Jkywjy8

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

5/28

www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr

4]bos Ahktb

^urphrtdm Dxthrtohk \omdh j @om th @hhst Lhrdoik Okvdsthr Ghkmdkgd8@OWBCDC, Juiust 0? (Durjsojkdt.hri)- Lhr ydjrs

okmustry h`sdrvdrs bjvd jssdrtdm tbjt dkvorhk-adktje prhtdsts hutsomd tbd Gjkjmojk-ruk Cua-thr Ihem Aokd ok Cyriyzstjks djstdrk ahuktjoks

wdrd pjrt hl jk dej`hrjtd sbjcdmhwk sgbdad.

Khw j vomdh bjs dadridm tbjt jppdjrs th su`-stjktojtd tbos vodw.Cyriyzstjks Wtjtd Ghaaottdd hk Kjtohkje

Wdguroty (ICK@) jkkhukgdm tbd hpdkoki hl j

groaokje okvdstoijtohk jltdr tbd vomdh jppdjrdmhk stjtd tdedvosohk Juiust 02, purphrtoki thsbhw twh adk wbh bjm prdvohusey vhogdm dkvo-

rhkadktje ghkgdrks mdajkmoki $7 aoeeohk lrhaj Cuathr rdprdsdktjtovd ok dxgbjkid lhr jk jp-

pjrdkt iujrjktdd kht th hrgbdstrjtd prhtdsts. ]bdvomdh purphrtdmey bjs j toad stjap hl Fuey 7:.

]bd vomdhs jppdjrjkgd hk stjtd tdedvosohk

suiidsts tbjt gdktrje ihvdrkadkt hgojes ok@osbcdc jrd oktdkt kht hkey hk sheomolyoki tbdorbhem hk phwdr, `ut wjkt th lhrid j strhkidr

whrcoki rdejtohksbop wotb Cuathrs hpdrjthrs,jkm, ahrd `rhjmey, `hhst lhrdoik-okvdsthr ghk-mdkgd sbjcdk `y rdiuejr aokoki-rdejtdm rohts.

ICK@ rdprdsdktjtovds mdgeokdm th jmmrdss tbdvomdhs prhvdkjkgd.

Wpdjcoki ok `rhcdk Pussojk ok tbd vomdh, tbdtwh adk, omdktodm js @jcbtojr Curajkhv jkm Dr-adc Mzbukusb`jdv, tdee Mhuiejs Irodr, Cuathrs

mordgthr hl sustjokj`ed mdvdehpadkt, tbjt ol tbdormdajkms wdrd kht adt, tbd aokd whuem sudrmord ghksdqudkgds. Yd woee gehsd Cuathr, hkd

gejoas. ]bdy ih hk th tbrdjtdk tbdy jrd rdjmy thmdgejrd wjr, tbdrd woee d j govoe wjr, tbdrd woee d

j rdvheutohk, ol Cuathr mhds kht iovd tbda wbjttbdy wjkt.

]bd twh gejoa ok tbd vomdh th bjvd tbd sup-phrt hl kjtohkjeost pheotogojks Cjagby`dc ]jsbodvjkm Wjmyr Fjpjrhv. ]bhsd twh rdgdktey ehst tbdorsdjts ok pjreojadkt wbdk tbd Wuprdad Ghurt

lhukm tbda, jehki wotb jkhtbdr Jtj-Furt A^,iuoety hl jttdaptoki th sdozd phwdr ok ghkkdgtohkwotb jk Hgth`dr 0>:0 okgomdkt, ok wbogb jk jkto-

Cuathr mdahkstrjtohk druptdm okth j roht.Ok ejtd Ajy hl tbos ydjr, jkhtbdr roht jkm rhjm-

`ehgc hutsomd Cuathr -- rdejtdm th tbd tbdk-pdkm-oki gjsd jijokst ]jsbodv jkm Fjpjrhv -- gjusdm jsbutmhwk jt tbd aokd. Mostur`jkgds jesh rdsuetdm

ok jt edjst 44 okfurods dlhrd pheogd rdsthrdm hrmdr.Mzbukusb`jdv jkm Curajkhv, tbd twh adk

jppdjroki ok tbd vomdh, ghktdkm ot os ljcd. Jmmoki

ausged th tbdor gejoa, sdvdrje bukmrdm supphrtdrs`ehgcdm tbd rhjm kdjr tbd aokd hvdrkoibt hk Ju-

iust 02, ehgje kdws jidkgods rdphrtdm. ]brhuib-hut Juiust 0? tbdrd bjvd `ddk sgjttdrdm rdphrtshl htbdr jttdapts th ehgc tbd rhjm kdjr tbd aokd.

Irodr ghkradm th DurjsojKdt.hri tbjt tbdmdajkms, jkm tbd addtoki sddk ok tbd vomdh,jrd idkuokd. Ok jk Juiust 0? stjtdadkt, Cuathr

Hpdrjtoki Ghapjky, wbogb os hwkdm y ]hrhkth-eostdm Gdktdrrj Ihem, sjom tbd ghapjky bjs `ddk

ghkstjktey rdgdovoki tbrdjts hl phsso`ed rhjm`ehgcs ok tbd dvdkt hl khk-ghapeojkgd wotb vjro-hus cokms hl mdajkms. ]bd stjtdadkt jmmdm tbjt

Cuathr rdprdsdktjtovds jrd ghhpdrjtoki wotb tbd

hgoje okvdstoijtohk.Cuathr dxdgutovds bjvd rdiuejrey gha-

pejokdm j`hut sbjcdmhwks jkm tbrdjts lrhaehgjes purphrtoki th rdprdsdkt voeejidrs dk-vorhkadktje ghkgdrks. ]bd adk ok tbd vomdh,

hkd Cuathr dxdgutovd them DurjsojKdt.hri, bjmghktokudm th tbrdjtdk tbd ghapjky tbrhuibhut

Juiust.]bd vomdh sgjkmje lheehws hk tbd bddes hl

rdphrts tbjt @osbcdc jkm Gdktdrrj jrd gehsd th

jirddoki hk j kdw hpdrjtoki jrrjkidadkt jl-tdr ahktbs hl wrjkieoki. ^road Aokostdr FjkthrhWjty`jemoydv sjom hk Juiust 00 tbjt tbd twh somds

bjm jirddm th hpdrjtd Cuathr tbrhuib j fhoktvdkturd, jkm tbjt bd bhpdm th su`aot tbd mdje lhr

pjreojadktjry jpprhvje ok Wdptda`dr.Gdktdrrj jkkhukgdm hk Juiust 07 tbjt, uk-

mdr tbd tdras hl tbd prhphsje, tbd stjtd-ruk Cyr-

iyzjetyk ihem ghapjky whuem dxgbjkid ots 70.9pdrgdkt dquoty oktdrdst ok Gdktdrrj lhr jk oktdrdst

hl dquovjedkt vjeud ok j fhokt vdkturd ghapjkytbjt whuem hwk tbd Cuathr prhfdgt. Ghapjkyrdprdsdktjtovds wdkt hk th strdss tbjt wboed

Gdktdrrj `deodvds tbjt prhirdss bjs `ddk ajmdok tbhsd mosgussohks, kh kje jirddadkt bjs ydt`ddk rdjgbdm.

Js kdws hl prhirdss trogcedm hut tbos ahktb,ajky okmustry oksomdrs dxpdgtdm tbjt hpphsotohkedjmdrs whuem jijok usd dkvorhkadktje ghkgdrks

jkm ehgje prhtdsts ok jk jttdapt th tbwjrt tbdmdje jkm ukmdraokd tbd lrjioed rueoki ghjeotohk wbdk pjreojadkt ghkvdkdm kdxt ahktb.

Ok tbos ghktdxt, tbd vomdh os sugb j `hhk thtbd ihvdrkadkt tbjt shad jrd gjeeoki ot j `ejtjkt

sdtup6 ]bos os P th mosgrdmot tbdsd iuys sh tbjt

tbd prhtdsts tbjt wdrd pejkkdm lhr jutuak woee`d mosgrdmotdm. ]bdsd iuys ldee lhr tbd `jot, sjom

]urjt Jcoahv, dmothr hl Mdkio o \ejst(Ahkdy jkm^hwdr), j ajijzokd ok @osbcdc.

Cuathr os Cyriyzstjks ahst soikogjkt dgh-khaog jssdt. Ok j ihhm ydjr, ot jgghukts lhr j`hut

:0 pdrgdkt hl tbd ghuktrys IM^. Jutbhrotods ok@osbcdc bjvd `ddk dkijidm ok j tussed lhr ghk-

trhe hvdr tbd aokd jee ydjr, gejoaoki tbjt tbd prd-vohus hpdrjtoki mdje, soikdm ok 0>>?, wjs okvjeom`dgjusd ot wjs kdihtojtdm wotb lhradr prdsomdkt

Curajk`dc @jcoydv, wbh wjs hvdrtbrhwk tbd lhe-ehwoki ydjr jaom womdsprdjm ghrruptohk jeedij-tohks. Hpphsotohk iurds sugb js ]jsbodv jkm Fjp-

jrhv bjm ejtgbdm hkth tbd Cuathr kdihtojtohks okwbjt ajky h`sdrvdrs ldet wjs j phpueost jttdaptth mosgrdmot tbd ihvdrkadkt usoki uksu`stjkto-

jtdm gejoas hl dkvorhkadktje mjajid gjusdm `yaokoki hpdrjtohks. Pjosoki dkvorhkadktje ghk-

gdrks bjs trjmotohkjeey `ddk jk ddgtovd wjy thah`oeozd prhtdstdrs ok Cyriyzstjk.

Yboed jeahst kh hkd mhu`ts tbd aokd bjs j

mdtroadktje dkvorhkadktje oapjgt, sdvdrje rd-gdkt, okmdpdkmdkt jumots bjvd mdtdraokdm tbjttbd ghapjkys hpdrjtohks jrd kht `rdjcoki jky

Cyriyz hr Durhpdjk rdiuejtohks.Whad okmustry h`sdrvdrs ghktdkm tbd vomdh

dxphsds j prh`eda rdejtdm th ihhm ihvdrkjkgd.Hrhz`dc Muosbddv, gbjorajk hl tbd Jsshgojtohk hlAokdrs jkm Idhehiosts, sjom tbd vomdh sbhws tbjt

Cyriyzstjks aokoki okmustry hpdrjtds ok j stjtdhl jkjrgby. Bd ghktokudm tbjt tbd ihvdrkadkt,wotb ots j`sdkgd hl gedjr pheogy, oskt jmmrdssoki

prh`edas.

]bdsd adk jrd fust ehhcoki th `dkdt tbda-sdevds, Muosbddv them DurjsojKdt.hri, jmmoki tbjt

tbd vomdh ukmdraokds tbd rdiuejr dkvorhkadktjegbjrids edvdedm jijokst Cuathr.

@OWBCDC, Wdptda`dr 7, (PLD/PE) - Wdvdrjehpphsotohk edjmdrs bjvd `ddk suaahkdm thCyriyzstjk's Wtjtd Ghaaottdd lhr Kjtohkje

Wdguroty (TCAC) lheehwoki tbd `rhjmgjst hl jghktrhvdrsoje vomdh hk stjtd tdedvosohk.

]bd gbj orajk hl tbd h pph sot ohk Jcyoc jt

(]rutb) pjrty, Jeoc`dc Fdcsbdkcuehv, themPLD/PE tbjt tbd hpphsotohk edjmdrs austjppdjr jt tbd TCAC hk tbd jltdrkhhk hl

Wdptda`dr 7 jltdr tbdor kjads wdrd adk-tohkdm ok tbd vomdh, wbogb wjs jordm `y tbd

ajok stjtd tdedvosohk gbjkkde tbd prdvohusdvdkoki.

Ok tbd vomdh, yhutb jgtovost Drejk`dc Hau-

rjeodv gejoas ckhwedmid hl jk jeedidm peht okwbogb hpphsotohk pheotogojks pejkkdm th pho-shk tbd Kjryk Povdr jkm `ejad tbd Cuathr

ihem-aokoki ghrphrjtohk lhr tbd ghktjaokj-tohk. Bd sjys tbdy jesh pejkkdm th rdgruotjgtovosts hl tbd `jkkdm Boz` ut-]jbror Osejaog

irhup th okgotd ajss jktoihvdrkadkt prh-tdsts.

Cyriyz Hpphsotohk Wuaahkdm Hvdr \omdh

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

6/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

< ]bos Ahktb

Ot wjs kdvdr bjrm th strocd up j ghkvdrsjtohkwotb Cyriyz tjxo mrovdrs. O bdjrm j`hut eold ok tbdPdm Jray, mosgussdm rdvheutohks, jkm hk j sehw

mjy eostdkdm th tbd mrovdr tjec j`hut bhw bos comswdrd stumyoki Dkieosb jkm wjktdm th sdd Jadr-

ogj. Hkd mjy j lrodkm jkm O iht okth j rjkmha tjxojkm stjrtdm gbjttoki wotb tbd mrovdr wbdk bd gjvj-eodrey them us j`hut tbd twh whadk bd bjm hutsomdbos ajrrojid. Ay hkey hutwjrm rdsphksd wjs hb

whw wboed hk tbd oksomd O tbhuibt j`hut bhw wdwhuem prh`j ey kht `d sh hpdk j`hut sugb j tboki

th strjkidrs ok Jadrogj. @ut ok Cyriyzstjk, Ovd `ddkthem, ot os ghaahk lhr adk, wbdtbdr tbdy jrd Cyriyz,Pussojk, hr Tz`dc, th bjvd aostrdssds hk tbd somd,

shad ghksomdrdm sdghkm wovds wboed htbdrs adrdeyehvdrs. O tbhuibt th aysdel O whuem kdvdr mh shad-tboki eocd tbjt wboed O wjs ok j rdejtohksbop. O whuem

stjy ljotblue th ay hylrodkm ok Jadrogj, jkm kh ajt-tdr bhw rjkmy O wjs O whuem kdvdr gbdjt hk boa hr d

okvhevdm wotb shadhkd wbh os gbdjtoki hk bos hr bdrsphusd hr soikogjkt htbdr. Bhw wrhki O wjs.

Yotbhut ljoe tbrdd qudstohks sddadm th jeahst

jewjys ghad up ok ghkvdrsjtohk ok Cyriyzstjk. Lorst6Ybdrd jrd yhu lrha8 Wdghkm6 Ybjt jrd yhu mhokibdrd8 ]borm6 Mh yhu bjvd j iorelrodkm hr wold8 Js j

yhuki ajk ot whuem kht bjvd `ddk jmvosj ed th sjytbjt O bjm j `hylrodkm, sh O whuem fust sjy kh th tbdejst qudstohk, wbogb whuem `d lheehwdm `y jk oktdr-

rhijtohk j`hut wby O mom kht. O whuem sjy O bjm khtlhukm tbd roibt iore, hr shad htbdr eod. J ghaahk

vodw ok Cyriyzstjk, ot sddas, os tbjt ol yhu jrdkt ajr-rodm `dlhrd yhurd tborty tbdrd os dotbdr shadtbokiwrhki wotb yhu hr yhu jrdkt tryoki bjrm dkhuib.

Pdijrmedss hl tbd prhmmoki hl strjkidrs jkm tbd

vodws hl Cyriyz shgodty, O quodtey ajoktjokdm ay ehkimostjkgd rdejtohksbop. Ydee, lhr j wboed jt edjst. Ok rdt-

rhspdgt ot sddadm mhhadm lrha tbd stjrt, ut O momktrdjeozd tbos uktoe sdvdrje ahktbs hl eovoki j`rhjm. @y

Ajy tbd rdejtohksbop wjs hvdr ok ay bdjrt, `ut ghk-tokuoki hgojeey.

Ybdtbdr ot wjs gjrkje tdaptjtohk hr tbd mdsord

th idt mrukc jkm mjkgd, O wdkt th @osbcdcs hkey ijygeu lhr j koibt hl wbjt O jssuadm whuem `d eocdahst spdkt tbdrd, j`sdkt hl ghad-hks, lrdd mrokcs,

jkm sdksuje mjkgoki wotb rjkmha strjkidrs. ]bdkoibt wdkt idkdrjeey js dxpdgtdm `ut shadtbokimodrdkt bjppdkdm tbos toad. J whajk gjad up

th ad jkm stjrtdm mjkgoki wotb ad. Wbd wjs `dju-tolue jkm gedjrey mrukc. O lhukm hut ejtdr tbjt sbd

hkey mjkgdm wbdk mrukc. Yd mjkgdm jkm sphcd okPussojk, prhaptoki bdr th jsc wbdrd O wjs lrha, thwbogb O rdpeodm Jadrogj. ]bd koibt wdkt hk jkm wd

ahvdm lrha tbd mjkgd ffhhr th tbd dktrywjy ghugbwbdrd wd gbjttdm jkm cossdm. Ot irdw lrha idktedjkm swddt th pjssohkjtd jkm sdksuje. O bjm kht ldet

tbos ok shad toad. Yd stjydm uktoe tbd ausog sthppdmjkm tbd geu gehsdm. O wjecdm wotb bdr uktoe hur wjys

bhad pjrtdm jkm wd sbjrdm j kje coss. O tbdk rdffdgt-dm jehkd hk tbd hkd tboki tbjt sbd bjm them ad oktbd geu . Wbd wjs ajrrodm. Bdr bus`jkm bjm gbdjtdm

hk bdr, jkm sbd wjs mhkd wotb boa, jetbhuib bd wjskht mhkd wotb bdr. O tbhuibt th aysdel bhw wd wdrd`htb ok rdejtohksbops, bdrs ahrd sdrohus tbjk aokd,

tbjt wd wdrd `htb mhkd wotb.

O wjskt surd ol O whuem sdd bdr jijok. O momktckhw ol O ghuem bjkmed ot. O sjw bdr hkgd ahrd thbdep bdr wotb j pjpdr ok Dkieosb, jkm jltdrwjrms wdwjecdm jkm tjecdm j`hut eold jkm hur rdejtohksbops.

Ybdtbdr ot wjs tbos ghkvdrsjtohk hr j sdksd hl iuoet

Lrha tbd Bdjrt6 J @osbcdc Jjortbjt ajmd ad `rdjc up wotb ay `hylrodkm `dlhrday rdturk bhad os stoee j ot ukgedjr. Ajy`d j wddchr twh bjm pjssdm `dlhrd O sjw bdr jijok hk j wboa.

Yd strheedm tbrhuib ^jkehv ^jrc jkm sjt mhwk thdjt wbdk j whajk wotb j orm gjad up th us. Wbd

wjs j lhrtukdtdeedr. O momkt ckhw wbjt tbd lhrtukd-tdeedr them bdr uktoe rdgdktey. ]bd lhrtukd tdeedr themtbd whajk tbjt sbd wjs ok j rdejtohksbop `ut sbdwjskt bjppy. ]bos wjs trud. Wbd them bdr tbjt sbd

eocdm shadhkd desd. Ybdk sbd qudstohkdm tbd lhr-tukdtdeedr j`hut wbh tbos htbdr pdrshk wjs sbd rd-

peodm6 ]bd ajk sottoki wotb yhu. O wjs h eovohus thjee hl tbos sokgd ay Pussojk wjs jkm stoee os phhr. Ot wjsejtdr hk ok tbd mjy jkm ok shad pjrc wbdk wd kjeey

cossdm jijok. Ot sddadm eocd O ghuem coss bdr eops lhrdtdrkoty. O momkt gjrd ol sbd wjs ajrrodm, O whuem `dtbd htbdr ajk, jee wd wjktdm wjs th dkfhy hur toad

thidtbdr jkm tbjt wjs jee.Js adktohkdm `dlhrd ot os kht ukghaahk lhr

adk ok Cyriyzstjk th bjvd hkd hr ahrd aostrdssds,`ut lhr j whajk th bjvd jkhtbdr ajk os kdotbdrghaahk khr jggdptj ed. Js sbd whuem put ot ejtdr

th ad, j bus`jkm gjk ih hut jkm bjvd jk jjor jkmtbd wold os stoee dxpdgtdm th ghhc jkm gedjk lhr tbosj**bhed - ot os tbd wolds fh th ajcd tbd ajrrojid

whrc. Ybdk sbd kjeey ajmd ot gedjr tbjt sbd wjsidttoki j movhrgd tbdrd wjs eotted syapjtby lhr bdr. Otwjs bdr ljuet tbjt tbd ajrrojid ljoedm, ot momkt ajttdr

tbjt bd bjm gbdjtdm rst jkm tbjt bd wjs j fdrc, otwjs stoee bdr ljuet.

Bdr bus`jkm whuem ejtdr `d them j`hut ad, `ybdr O `deodvd. ]bos edm th grjzy `dbjvohr jkm j ljktjsyth aurmdr us lhr j toad, `ut tbd Cyriyz pheogd lhrgd

bjm jerdjmy mdsdksotozdm ad th dapty tbrdjts. Hur

lrodkms ckdw tbjt wd wdrd sddoki djgb htbdr js wdee,`ut wd jewjys oksostdm tbjt wd wdrd cddpoki tbokis

eoibt jkm luk. Hur lrodkms sddadm th ckhw us `dttdrtbjk wd ckdw hursdevds, tbhuib. Lrodkms whuem tdee

ad tbjt tbdy ghuem tdee y tbd wjy wd ehhcdm jt djgbhtbdr tbjt wd gjrdm ahrd tbjk wd whuem mjrd sjy. Ordada`dr hkd koibt hk tbd sbhrd hl Ossyc-Cue tdee-

oki bdr O wjs jlrjom hl idttoki thh gehsd. O bjm `ddkok ehvd `dlhrd jkm tbdrd wjs kh irdjtdr burt lhr adtbdk ckhwoki ot whuem dkm. O momkt tdee bdr ay htbdr

ldjr tbjt O bjm ijokdm lrha pjoklue dxpdrodkgd tbjtO whuem ehvd bdr jkm sbd whuem kht ehvd ad ok tbdsjad wjy.

Yddcs bjm pjssdm jkm wd bjm irhwk gehsdr,tbjkcs th toad spdkt thidtbdr, jkm hur ghaahk

oktdrdsts ok Korvjkj, Zudktok ]jrjktokh ahvods, sbj-ajkosa jkm Yoksthk goijrdttds. @ut eocd jee tbokishur toad thidtbdr bjm ghad th jk dkm. Ok j rdvdr-

sje hl rheds lhr ad ot whuem `d bdr th jgtujeey edjvdtbd ghuktry rst. Yd sjw djgb htbdr hkd kje toad.O grodm ahrd tbjk O bjm ok j ehki toad. O wjs edlt ok

tbd pejgd wbdrd O bjm ukdxpdgtdmey ljeedk ok ehvd,surrhukmdm `y sajee rdaokmdrs hl bdr jkm j lddeoki

hl sjmkdss tbjt eokidrdm wotb ad lhr ahktbs. ]bdrjkmha tjxo mrovdr ajy bjvd bjm bos aostrdssds, `utghuem bd phsso ey bjvd ldet js jttjgbdm th tbda tbd

wjy O mom th bdr8Ot bjs `ddk hvdr j ydjr khw sokgd wd pjrtdm

wjys. Yd stoee tjec j`hut eold, edss j`hut Korvjkj jkm

]jrjktokh. Wbd os khw eovoki tbd eold sbd wjkts th

edjm3 sbd stoee bjs ay sbort ukwjsbdm tbjt sbd eocdmsh augb, jkm wd stoee bhem j `djutolue pejgd lhr djgbhtbdr ok hur bdjrts. ]h tbos mjy O stoee ehvd bdr, jkmwboed wd ajy kdvdr addt ok @osbcdc jijok, O ckhw

hkd mjy wd woee sdd djgb htbdr jijok.Jkhk

O@OWBCDC, Wdptda`dr =, (HWGD) - Hk = Wdp-tda`dr 0>:7 tbd HWGD Gdktrd ok @osbcdc prhvomdmCyriyzstjks Mdldkgd Aokostry wotb jk h`stjged

ghursd lhr trjokoki jkto-tdrrhrosa ukot hgdrs jkm

mhkjtdm dquopadkt lhr ahuktjok pjtrheeoki okHsb, Whutbdrk Cyriyzstjk.

^rjgtogje h`stjged trjokoki woee `d prhvomdm lhrada`drs hl tbd Oe ors (Wkhw Edhpjrms) WpdgojeLhrgds `roijmd. ]bd ghursd joas th oaprhvd pjr-

togopjkts j oeoty th quogcey jkm ddgtovdey rdsphkmth tdrrhrost irhups jgtovd ok ahuktjokhus rdiohks

jkm woee okgeumd okstrugtohk ok rukkoki, geoa oki,fuapoki, grjweoki, swoaaoki, jkm `jejkgoki. ]bdmhkjtdm dquopadkt woee `d usdm lhr ghkmugtoki

ahuktjok pjtrheeoki jkm jkto-tdrrhrosa hpdrjtohksdxdrgosds.

]bd Oe ors jrd tbd rst rdsphkmdrs th jky grhss-

`hrmdr okgursohks lrha jradm irhups ok WhutbdrkCyriyzstjk, sjom Phss @rhwk, Bdjm hl tbd ^heotogh-

Aoeotjry Tkot jt tbd HWGD Gdktrd ok @osbcdc. ]rjok-oki jkm supphrtoki tbda os grugoje ok jssostokiCyriyzstjk th ddgtovdey gha`jt trjkskjtohkje

tdrrhrosa tbrdjts.]bd okstjeejtohk hl tbd h`stjged ghursd jkm tbd

mhkjtohk hl dquopadkt jrd pjrt hl tbd HWGD Gdk-

trd ok @osbcdcns hkihoki dhrts th supphrt Cyriyzihvdrkadkt ok gha`jttoki tdrrhrosa.-

@OWBCDC, Wdptda`dr

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

7/28

www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr

9Ajp

Codvscj

yj

]h

cthi

uej

]hcth

iuej

]hcth

iuej

Ahschvscj

yj

Ahsch

Ahschvscj

yj

Codvscj

yj

Ajkjsjvd.

Ajkjsjvd.

Evj]hesthih

Evj]hesth

ih

Evj]hesth

ih

AhehmjyjIvjr

Fo`dc

Fheu

Fu

ajdc

Chdkchzhvj

Osjkhvj]

. J ` m

y a h a u k h v

D k

i d e s j

P y

s c u

e h v j

A o g b j d e L r u k

z d

Wp

jrtjc

stjmoua

AogbjdeL

ru

kzd

Jm

yahaukh

vj

Fuaj`dc

Drco

Gorgus

]ykystjkhvj

Pjzzjchvj

PjzzjchvjHrhz`

dchvj

Hrhz`dchvj

@ h c h k ` j d v j

yj`eh

iu

]

@ h c h k

Ehivokdkch

OsjkhvjOsjkhvj

]ykystjkhvj

J.Tsdk`jdvj

Ded`jdvj

Ljtojkhvj

Wbhphchvj

Wbhphchvj

Ihiheyj

IhiheyjH

ihk`jdvj

]hihehcAhemh

Drcokmoc

WH\D]WCJ_J

rjvmj

rjvmj

WH\D]WCJ_J

WH\D]WCJ_J

Gbuo

Gbu

o

Gbuo

AhehmjyjIvjrmo

j

Ajkjsjvd.

Codvscj

yj

]BDAHTK]JOKW

Khrtb

Mvhrdts

Wphrtj

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

8/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

2 Hut & J`hut

Jej-Jrgbj os j ehvdey pejgd, `ut ots `dstjpprdgojtdm jwjy lrha tbd mrukcdk-

pogkog-grhwm wbh phpuejtd tbd ehwdrsehpds. ]bdh Yjothdrs twh suiidstohkslhr wddcdkm bocds tbjt sbhwgjsd tbd dsthl wbjt tbd ljahus kjtohkje pjrc bjs thhdr.

BD IPHYOKI KTA@DPW hl lhrdoikdrswhrcoki jkm stumyoki ok tbd Cyriyz gjpo-

tje os surdey tdstjadkt th tbd jttrjgtohks hltbd @osbcdc eoldstyed. Whad lhrdoikdrs md-eoibt ok eovoki ok j adetoki pht hl jkgodkt

gueturds wbdrd Djst addts Ydst ok j rohthus spogd-oklusdm gheeosohk hl ahmdrkoty jkm trjmotohk. Htb-drs rdvde ok tbd ajiogje ddgt hl `dghaoki ltddkydjrs yhukidr, tbrdd sthkd eoibtdr, jkm j`ed th sphut`oihtry jkm aoshiyky ok tbos ljor ejkm hl uksbjgcedmeo`drty wbdrd pheotogje ghrrdgtkdss os khtboki `ut jidhehiosts jm mrdja. Lurtbdrahrd, tbdrd os ljktjs-tog ahuktjok sgdkdry prjgtogjeey hk yhur mhhrstdp.

Jkyhkd wbh bjs spdkt ahrd tbjk jk bhur ok@osbcdc bjs bdjrm hl tbd Jej-Jrgbj kjtohkje pjrc,jkm tbos os kht wotbhut ihhm rdjshk, lhr tbd rdiohkos kht hkey spdgtjguejrey `djutolue `ut jesh hdrs

shad hl tbd dst geoa`oki jkm bocoki hpphrtukotodsth d lhukm jkywbdrd ok tbd whrem. Jt hkey tborty coe-hadtrds jwjy lrha tbd gdktrd hl @osbcdc, jkm wotbdjsy th lheehw trjoes, ot os jesh ukkdgdssjry th dkeosttbd dxpdksovd sdrvogds hl j thur ghapjky hr iuomd.Yotb dvdk admohgrd kdihtojtohk scoees yhu sbhuem`d j ed th idt j tjxo mrovdr th tjcd yhu th tbd rdm-rhhldm Jepejidr Bhtde lhr :>>> sha peus pjrc dktry `ut ahrd hl tbjt ok tbd irdy `hx th ghad. Lhr khw,O prdsdkt twh suiidstohks lhr wddcdkm bocds tbjtghuem jesh `d gha`okdm okth j tbrdd hr lhur koibtjmvdkturd ol yhur usy whrc sgbdmued jeehws.

]h ]bd Dkm hl Jej-Jrgbj \jeedy

]bos bocd os jk dxgdeedkt omdj lhr tbd ldd ed-eukidm

wbh wosb th `dttdr jggeoajtosd `dlhrd bdjmoki upth boibdr jetotumds, `ut jesh sdrvds js jk dkfhy-j`ed jkm edosurdey hvdrkoibt trdc ok otsdel. Wtjrt jttbd gjr pjrc ok lrhkt hl tbd Jepejidr Bhtde (00>>a)jkm ajrgb `hemey hkwjrms mhwk tbd tjrajgcdm

ejkd tbjt wdjvds `dtwddk tbogcdts hl pokd trddsjkm (muroki suaadr wddcdkms) mrukcdk pogkogc-

drs, mosgjrmdm `htteds hl `ddr, dapty pjgcdts hlgoijrdttds, dtg. Jltdr j`hut j coehadtrd jkm j bjeltbd rhjm dkms jkm tbd whhmejkm hpdks hut hkthj womd `huemdr-strdwk gedjroki wbdrd tbd Jc-Wjo tro`utjry hk yhur edlt fhoks wotb tbd Jej JrgbjPovdr, gburkoki ots wjy tbrhuib tbd vjeedy lrha tbdshutb. Grhss tbd tro`utjry, wbogb os sbjeehw jkmgjea jt tbos phokt, jkm cddp th tbd edlt hl tbd Jej-Jrgbj Povdr jehki tbd h`vohus pjtb. Hkgd uphkj toad Whvodt h-rhjm trugcs usdm th mrovd up tbostrjgc jee tbd wjy th tbd thp hl tbd vjeedy, `ut ehhc-oki jt ots prdsdkt ghkmotohk, tbos khw sddas jk uk-eocdey prhphsotohk. Jltdr j coehadtrds wjec tbd pjtbrosds up jk okgeokd th j ghpsd hl trdds bdrd yhukddm th km tbd sajee pjtb th tbd roibt wbogb woee

edjm yhu mhwk j stddp `jkc jkm jgrhss j ajcd-sbolt whhmdk `romid th tbd wdst `jkc hl tbd rovdr.

]bd ajok trjgc ghktokuds hk tbd djst `jkc lhr jsbhrt wboed `ut shhk mops tbrhuib tbd rovdr jkm

fhoks yhu hk tbd htbdr somd. Lrha bdrd, yhu sbhuemkm kh prh`edas ok lheehwoki tbd trjoe hkwjrms.

J`hut vd coehadtrds mhwk tbd trjoe tbdrd osj sdghkm, dvdk ahrd ajcdsbolt `romid jgrhss tbdrovdr (044>a) okgomdktjeey tbdrd jrd shad edvde jr-djs bdrd jkm tbd sotd ajcds quotd j kogd gjapokijrdj. ]bd ajok pjtb grhssds tbd `romid jkm ghktok-uds hk tbd djst `jkc, bhwdvdr wd bjvd lhukm tbjttbos rhutd rdquords tbd grhssoki hl j lurtbdr tro`utjry(wotb kh `romid) wbogb muroki rjoky pdrohms gjk `drjtbdr woem. ]bdrdlhrd wd rdghaadkm oikhroki tbd

`romid jkm ghktokuoki mhwk tbd wdst jkc wbdrd jedss h`vohus ut djsoey kjvoij`ed trjoe woee jeehw yhuth jvhom idttoki yhur lddt wdt. Jltdr j ghuped hl coeh-adtdrs ot os phsso`ed th rdfhok tbd dstj`eosbdm pjtb jsot grhssds jgc th tbd wdst jkc hkgd ahrd.

]BDH YJO]

]Jej-Jrgbj6@dyhkm

]hp ]bd sdghkm `romid. ]h jvhom j trogcy rovdr

grhssoki, wd rdghaadkm stjyoki hk tbd wdst`jkc hl tbd rovdr lrha tbos phokt hkwjrms -

tbd ajok pjtb dvdktujeey grhssds `jgc hkth

tbd wdst somd, jkm kjvoijtohk os djsy (Jee pbh-

ths ]ha Bjkshk)

ogkogs

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

9/28

www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr

?Hut & J`hut

Ghktokuoki up tbd trjoe yhu woee ghad th jkj`jkmhkdm wdjtbdr stjtohk (02>>a) hk j edvde

jkm irjssy pejok prhvomoki j prjgtogje ol ddrod gjap-sotd, jk okghkiruhus gheedgtohk hl sdao-h`eotdrjtdmadtdhrhehiogje dquopadkt grdjcoki kdjr`y ok tbdwokm. ]bd grua`eoki wdjtbdr stjtohk `uoemoki gjkprhvomd shad sbdetdr ok dadridkgods, `ut tbd poedshl ru``osb, buajk wjstd jkm ihjt scuees edkm otjk oksjeu`rohus jor. Lrha bdrd tbd trjoe edjms ahrdstddpey upwjrms jkm th tbd roibt, okth j dem hl sgrddjkm rhgcs, jkm pjst j bjel `urodm Whvodt `ueemhzdr(7>>>a) wbogb bjs sddk `dttdr mjys. Lokjeey, jt tbdbdjm hl tbd vjeedy os j gjuemrhk hl pdjcs jkm iej-godrs, hkd hl wbogb wjs bhad th j sco stjtohk (khwmosusdm) wbdrd tbd Whvodts trjokdm tbdor sco tdjas.Eocd ahst tbokis up bdrd tbdsd mjys tbd hem sco eoltos `doki irhukm okth must `y tbd dedadkts, jkm ok

irdy wdjtbdr jkm j ghem wokm ot os bjrm kht th mdtdgtshadtboki adejkgbheog ok tbd rjrodm jor. Hk tbdmdsgdkt ot os up th yhu th mdgomd wbogb gjap sotd os`dst, ut wbdrddvdr yhu mdgomd th potgb, wd rdgha-adkm mrokcoki vhmcj jkm tdeeoki ibhst sthrods.

^oc ugbotde6 ]bd ]djgbdr djc

^oc Tgbotde (=40>a) os j khk-tdgbkogje geoa wbogbgjk `d jttdaptdm js j twh-mjy bocd `y jkyhkd wotbihhm tkdss. Bhwdvdr, jt lhur jkm j bjel tbhusjkmadtrds boib tbd ahuktjok sbhuem kht `d ukmdrds-toajtdm6 jetotumd gjk tjcd ots thee, j gedjr eud scygjk quogcey turk jk haokhus sbjmd hl irdy, jkm olyhu `rdjc yhur edi hk j `huemdr hk tbd wjy mhwk,yhurd sgrdwdm. Yotb tbos ok aokm ot os wosd th ih ok j

sajee irhup, jkm mrdss jpprhprojtdey. Grjaphks jrdkht kdgdssjry, `ut j pjor hl sturmy `hhts os j aust,jkm wjecoki pheds gjk `d vdry bdeplue. ]bd djsodsttoad th jttdapt jk jsgdkt os `dtwddk Ajy jkm djreyHgth`dr.

Mjy hkd6 Lrha tbd gjr pjrc, wjec thwjrms tbdJepejidr bhtde (00>>a) jkm tjcd tbd ajrcdm trjoe th

Pjtsdc (77>>a) wbogb vddrs edlt h tbd tjrajgcdmejkd jkm okth tbd trdds. J sdrods hl sdrpdktokds wokmsup th j adjmhw (044>a) wbogb jhrms irdjt vodwshl tbd Jej-Jrgbj \jeedy. Lrha bdrd, ghktokud jehkitbd h`vohus trjoe, pjst tbd wjtdrljee (02>>a) up okthtbd boib rdjgbds hl tbd vjeedy, cddpoki tbd rovdr thyhur roibt, jkm tbd geos th yhur edlt. ]bd bocd gjk `dthuib jkm gjk hggjsohkjeey okvhevd shad sgrja-

eoki ut ok ihhm ghkmotohks ot sbhuem tjcd kh ehkidrtbjk vd bhurs wotb j mdgdkt sozdm rugcsjgc.

Pjtsdc but os hpdk jee ydjr rhukm jkm os stjdm`y j wjrmdk. _hu gjk potgb j tdkt lhr lrdd kdjr`yhr pjy jrhukm :>>> sha (lhrdoikdr rjtd) lhr j `ukcspjgd. @jsog adjes gjk `d `huibt ok tbd jr lhr :4TWM, hr j luee `hjrm hl `rdjcljst eukgb jkm mokkdr lhr

74 TWM, `ut ot os `dst kht th rdey hk tbos.Mjy twh6 Jeehw vd bhurs up jkm tbrdd bhurs

mhwk ok ihhm ghkmotohks. Lrha tbd but gjrry hk jlurtbdr :>>a okth tbd vjeedy uktoe yhu sdd j buid`huemdr (pogturdm j`hvd). J trjoe edjms up j sgrddsehpd, pjst shad sphrt geoa oki potgbds hk tbd edltjkm dvdktujeey up th j idkted romid. Lheehw tbd romidup th tbd roibt, kdihtojtoki tbrdd rhgcy hutgrhps,jkm hk j gedjr mjy yhu sbhuem sdd tbd suaaot hlTgbotde jbdjm th yhur roibt. ]bd romid dvdktujeey ok-tdrsdgts twh pdjcs jt j`hut =74>a - j rhgcodr hkd thtbd edlt, jkm Tgbotde th tbd roibt. Lheehw tbd romid thtbd roibt, jvhomoki tbd ghrkogd hl skhw jkm jmaorokitbd vodws hl @osbcdc jkm tbd Cjzjcb stdppd. Hkd ejstsehi hl j`hut :4> adtrds bdoibt ijok, jkm yhu woee

ajcd tbd suaaot - tbd Jc-Wjo Iejgodr wokms `dkdjtbyhu, tbd Pjtsdc gjap ieoaadrs ok tbd sukeoibt (ol yhujrd eugcy), jkm dvdk tbd rdm rhhl hl tbd Jepejidr Bh-tde gjk `d pogcdm hut lrha jahkist tbd trdds, ahrdtbjk twh coehadtrds `dehw.

]hp Edlt ]bd vodw lrha tbd uppdr sehpds hl

^oc Tgbotde, ehhcoki thwjrms tbd Jc-Wjo Iej-

godr jkm ^oc @hcs

]hp PoibtTgbotde rhutd6 Lrha tbd Pjtsdc but

wjec :>>a lurtbdr okth tbd vjeedy jkm bot

tbd Tgbotde trjoe wbogb bdjms edlt jt tbd ejrid

`huemdr

]rjksphrt6 Idttoki th Jej-Jrgbj `y ajrsbrutcj`us os `jsogjeey j pjok ok tbd jrsd, jkm j tjxo os

mdkotdey whrtb tbd dxtrj dxpdksd. Dxpdgt thpjy ok tbd rdiohk hl :>>> sha (0: TWM) lhr j hkd

wjy tjxo, peus 2> sha pdr pdrshk jkm 04> shalhr j gjr lhr dktry th tbd pjrc otsdel. _hu kddm thdxpejok th yhur tjxo mrovdr tbjt yhu wjkt th ih jee

tbd wjy th tbd Jepejidr Bhtde (ot bjs j mostokgtovdrdm rhhl), wbogb os j lurtbdr :0ca mhwk tbd rhjmlrha tbd pjrc ijtds. ]bd gjrpjrc jt tbd lrhkt hl

tbd bhtde os tbd stjrt phokt lhr `htb tbdsd bocds.Ol yhu jrd ukj ed th hrijkosd j tjxo th pogc yhu up,tbd Jepejidr gjk hrijkosd hkd lhr yhu lhr :4>> sha

pdr gjr. Jetdrkjtovdey ot os hltdk phsso ed th botgbbocd`jgc th @osbcdc - shadtoads dvdk lhr lrdd.Kjvoijtohk6J mdgdkt bocoki ajp hl tbd rdiohk

gjk `d `huibt lrha tbd Idhom ajp sbhp hk Co-dvscjyj :>9 (jt tbd jgc hl tbd MBE uoemoki), ]de.

(>7:0) ?::4, dajoe6 trdcNdegjt.ci

Idttoki ]bdrd

]bd Wuaaot!

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

10/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

:> Hut & J`hut

EHHCDM HT] HL ]BD YOKMHY hl ay bhtde

rhha hk tbd ltb ffhhr. ]bd sgdkd `dehw wjskht jk okvotoki hkd3 j wokmswdpt gdktrje squjrdhvdrehhcdm hk tbd ljr somd `y Whvodt-drj jpjrt-

adkt uoemokis. Wueedk ehhcoki pdhped wrjppdmup ok tbogc woktdr ghjts jkm lur bjts wjotdm jt

j `us sthp ok soedkgd. ^dmdstrojks wjecdm `roscey,

`udtdm `y j wokm tbjt `edw h tbd tukmrj jkmwbostedm jehki tbd gotys tbhrhuibljrds kmoki ots

wjy hkth jky dxphsdm scok, up seddvds jkm mhwkgheejrs. Ok tbd mostjkgd jgrhss tbd ehw rosd gotysgjpdj ljgthry sahcdstjgc daottdm j `ejgc sadjr jgrhss

tbd eoibt `eud scy. Ot wjs j lhr`d`hmoki sgdkd, dvdk`rutje, js ukokvotoki js jkywbdrd O bjm dvdr `ddk.

]bd idkdsos hl ay ukeocdey vosot ghuem d trjgdm

`jgc twdkty-vd ydjrs. Ok ay tddks O bjm j ajphl tbd Whvodt Tkohk hk ay `dmrhha wjee. J `ejgc

eokd rukkoki hut hl Ahsghw mdpogtdm j rjoewjy eokd

bdjmoki khrtb djst. ]bd rjoewjy eokd wdkt hk pjsttbd phokt wbdrd tbd thwks sthppdm, pjst tbd phokt

wbdrd tbd rhjms dkmdm, jkm kjeey tdraokjtdmjt j goty ajrcdm \hrcutj. Jk osejkm ok tbd tukmrj,bukmrdms hl aoeds lrha jkywbdrd. Hl jee tbd pejgds

ajrcdm hk tbd ajp tbos wjs tbd hkd tbjt ljsgo-kjtdm ad tbd ahst. ]bd ajp wjs dvdktujeey tjcdk

mhwk jkm put jwjy, jkm tbd goty jee `ut lhrihttdkj`hut uktoe ajky ydjrs ejtdr wbdk O wjs wjecokitbd strddts hl Ahsghw, wjecoki h j sdvdrd bjkih-

vdr. Ay `rjok ldet js tbhuib ot wjs mro``eoki hut hlay djrs jkm O bjtdm aysdel lhr sugb sdel okffogtdmj`usd. O wjs ehhcoki lhr j pejgd th dsgjpd th, dsgjpd

aysdel js augb js jkytboki. O bdjmdm th Ahsghws_jrhsejvscjyj stjtohk ehhcoki lhr j romd hut hl tbd

goty. Ehhcoki up jt tbd mdpjrturd `hjrm O sjw okoeeuaokjtdm ydeehw edttdrs tbd kjad \hrcutj. Jgboembhhm adahry rdturkdm eocd j ehki ehst lrodkm

jkm hk j wboa O `huibt j togcdt lhr tbd dvdkokismdpjrturd.

Ot wjs kh surprosd hl ghursd tbjt tbd goty ehhcdm

sh lhrd`hmoki - ot wjs kht ajmd lhr tbd `dkdt hltbd okbj`otjkts, ut rjtbdr lhr tbd stjtd. \hrcutj jkmtbd gotods ay trjok bjm pjssdm hk tbd fhurkdy khrtb

wdrd uoet lhr hkd rdjshk3 th d dxpehotdm y tbd thoehl proshkdrs. @dkdjtb tbd bjrm shoe hl tbd khrtb eodstbd luee `rdjmtb hl Adkmdeddvs tj`ed. ^roshks jkm

oklrjstrugturd wdrd `uoet lhr tbd shed purphsd hl dx-pehotoki tbd aokdrjes tbjt ejy dkdjtb tbda. @dlhrd

tbd :?7>s wbdk ghkstrugtohk hk tbd rjoewjy `dijktbdrd wjs khtboki ok tbd jrdj dxgdpt tbd kjtovdChao pdhped lheehwoki tbd aoirjtohk pjtbs hl tbd

rdokmddr. Ybdk Whvodt idhehiosts lhukm buid ghjerdsdrvds hk tbd uppdr rdjgbds hl tbd rovdr \hrcutjgdktrje pejkkdrs mddadm ot js j pejgd th `uoem tbd

rst gjaps hl j sprjweoki jrgbopdejih tbjt whuemghad th `d ckhwk ukmdr tbd jgrhkya ITEJI.

]rjok ok \jok]rjok kua`dr =0 edlt Ahsghw jkm spdkt tbd kdxt

lhrty bhurs rheeoki khrtb pjst bjets jkm stjtohkswbhsd kjads jrd sykhkyahus wotb tbd gjaps6 ^d-gbhrj, Oktj, Tcbtj, \hrcutj. ]bd pjtb lhr tbd rjoewjy

wjs bjgcdm hut hl tbd lhrdst y proshkdrs thrk lrhamovdrsd ehgjtohks jgrhss tbd dapord jkm lhr pdr-

gdovdm groads js dqujeey movdrsd. Muapdm ok tbdjrdj hltdk ok tbd aommed hl woktdr jkm wotb kh rdjegehtboki hr sbdetdr th prhtdgt tbda lrha tbd bjrsb-

dst hl geoajtds tbhusjkm modm wbdrd tbdy whrcdm,edjmoki tbd proshkdrs th mu` tbd rhutd ]bd Pjoe-wjy Hl @hkds. Js tbd trjok trukmeds khrtb whhm-

dk grhssds hl tbhsd wbh modm iuomd tbd wjy. Aywjihk wjs luee hl aokdrs bdjmoki khrtb lhr stokts

`dehw irhukm. ]huib adk lrha thuib thwks sugbjs ]ja`hv jkm Kozbkby ]jioe. Yotb jeghbhe prhbo`-otdm ok tbd aokoki gjaps tbdy usd tbd fhurkdy js

j kje gbjkgd th mrokc tbdor sbjrd lhr j ahktb. Hktbd rst dvdkoki hl tbd fhurkdy jkm wotb tbd ok-

Jltdr j rdgdkt trop th Pussojs jrgtog khrtb,

@dk Pogbprhvomds jk jktomhtd th tbd Cyriyz

suaadr bdjt wotb tjeds hl ehvd, trjidmy, jkm

mruis ok j ghem geoajtd.

OTpIroa

@DK POGB

]hp edlt\hrcutj strddt sgdkd (Jee pbhths @dk

Pogb)

]hp roibt ]bd ajtokdd pdrlhrajkgd hl ]bd

Bjkihvdr 7prhvdm ukphpuejr jt tbd \hrcutj

Hmdhk

Khrtb

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

11/28

www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr

::Hut & J`hut

dvotj`ed mrukcdkkdss idttoki hut hl bjkm tbd ehgje

pheogd bjm `hjrmdm tbd trjok ok _jrhsejve jkm mdeov-drdm j gbhogd th tbd aokdrs6 turk ok lhr tbd koibt hr`d iovdk j lrdd thur hl tbd thwk ok tbd `jgc hl tbdor

wjihk. Kh`hmy wjs lhheosb dkhuib th jggdpt tbdhdr.

Hk tbd sdghkm mjy hl tbd fhurkdy tbd lhrdst d-

gjad tbokkdr jkm tbd voeejids phhrdr. ]bd trjok wjsj eoldeokd th tbdsd ghaaukotods ok tbd lhrdst jkm wjs

lhr shad tbd hkey ghkkdgtohk th tbd womdr whremtbdy bjm. Ot jesh `rhuibt prh`edas, bhwdvdr. Hkdvoeejid wd pjssdm bjm j ejrid pjoktdm soik jmvdrtos-

oki tbjt ot wjs j voeejid wotbhut kjrghtogs. Ot ajmdyhu whkmdr wbjt bjppdkdm ok tbd htbdr voeejids.

]bd lurtbdr khrtb wd pusbdm tbd lurtbdr tbd tda-

pdrjturd mrhppdm. Jt ^dgbhrj ot wjs aokus twdktygdktoirjmd, jt Oktj aokus twdkty-vd, jkm wbdk

dvdktujeey wd rheedm okth \hrcutj hk tbd tborm mjy

hl tbd trop tbd tbdrahadtdr sbhwdm aokus tborty.Wtdppoki hut hl tbd wjihk jt hur mdstokjtohk wjs

jcok th wjecoki okth j ejrid lrddzdr. Ot wjs pbyso-gjeey pjoklue th `rdjtbd. \hrcutjk tjxo mrovdrs hktbd pejtlhra bhwdvdr thutdm lhr gusthadrs wotb

`jrd bdjms jkm bjkms. Ay cupdghapjkohk, j eh-gje `usokdssajk wbh wjs rdturkoki lrha j scooki

bheomjy ok Jkmhrrj prhaosdm ad O whuem idt usdmth ot, dvdktujeey.

Ijzoki hut hl ay wokmhw hk tbjt rst ahrk-

oki ok tbd goty ot sddadm okghkgdovj`ed tbjt O whuemdvdr jggeoajtosd. ]bd tdapdrjturd wjs j `jeay ao-kus twdkty-lhur gdktoirjmd `ut hpdkoki ay wok-

mhw, dvdk `rodffy, rdaokmdm ad hl bhw oee jmfustdmjkm phhrey prdpjrdm O wjs lhr sugb wdjtbdr. Yotb

kh pejk hl ghaoki tbos ljr khrtb uktoe jk bhur `d-lhrd mdpjrturd O bjm wotb ad gehtbds suotj`ed lhr jAhsghw sproki - tdapdrjturds jrhukm zdrh ut kht

augb `dehw. @ut `y khw O ghuem kh ehkidr suprdssay okstokgt th dxpehrd.

Wbhuem O stjy hr Wbhuem O Ih

]bd wokm strugc ad vogohusey js O dxotdm tbd uoemokijkm bdjmdm jehki ogy strddts thwjrms tbd gdktrd hlthwk. Ot tjcds yhu j wboed th idt yhur sdj edis ok tbd

woktdr. Ybost ehgjes wjecdm jehki pjvdadkts wotbghkmdkt stdps O seoppdm, scommdm jkm ghkthrtdmay `hmy okth modrdkt sbjpds, tryoki th cddp ay

`jejkgd jkm jvhom tbd oikhaoky hl j ljee hk tbd ogd.Pussoj oskt j pejgd wbdrd yhu dxpdgt j bjkm `jgc

up. Ol yhu ih mhwk, bhwdvdr bjrm, yhu woee usujeeyrdgdovd khtboki ahrd tbjk ehhcs hl ghktdapt.

]bd hkey ghktjgt O bjm ok tbd goty wjs ay gjrrojid

ghapjkohk lrha tbd trjok romd. Wdrido bjm spdkt tbd

ajfhroty hl tbd fhurkdy gbdgcoki bos pbhkd lhr j soi-

kje jkm tbdk lrjktogjeey tdxtoki js shhk js hkd `rodffy`dgjad jvjoej ed kdjr j thwk. O gjeedm boa jkm jr-rjkidm th addt ok j goty gdktrd gjl. Yd sjt jt j tj ed

jkm bd edjkdm ok ghksoprjtohkjeey, @dk, bjvd yhudvdr `ddk ajrrodm8 bd jscdm js tbd uksaoeoki wjot-rdss `rhuibt us hur ghdds. ]bdk ajy`d yhu woee

ukmdrstjkm ad. O bjvd `ddk ajrrodm lhr doibt ydjrs`ut rdgdktey O bjvd ddk sddoki j iore. Bd sbhwdm ad

j pbhth hk bos pbhkd hl boasdel jkm jk jttrjgtovd`rukdttd sottoki thidtbdr ok j rdstjurjkt. ]bos iore oskhtboki eocd ay Wvdtj, mhdskt tjcd gjrd hl ad eocd

sbd mhds, mhdskt dvdk ehhc js ihhm `ut shadtbokij`hut bdr mrovds ad grjzy. Gjk yhu ukmdrstjkm tbos8

Ot wjs j ghaahk thpog hl ghkvdrsjtohk ok j ghuktry

wbdrd pdhped usujeey ajrrodm yhuki jkm tbdk bjmydjrs th rdirdt bjvoki mhkd sh.

O jttdaptdm th stddr Wdrido thwjrms htbdr thp-

ogs, hl eold ok tbd ljr khrtb. Ots kht js `jm js pdhpedtbokc ot os. hejr djrs mhkt wjec tbd strddts, yhu bjvdsddk tbjt wd bjvd dedgtrogoty. O mhkt ckhw. Jt toads

O wjkt th edjvd `ut tbdk wbdk O vosot Ahsghw hr Wt.^dtdrs`uri O rdjeosd tbjt O kdvdr ghuem. Ots ihhm bdrd

ol yhu bjvd ahkdy. Zuotd bhw Wdrido ajmd ahkdybd mom kht sjy, bhwdvdr O ghuem kht bdep `ut khtogdtbjt bdm jrrovdm jt tbd gjl ok j kdw oaphrtdm =x=

jkm bd bjm fust `ddk scooki ok Durhpd, tbokis tbjtwdrd `dyhkm tbd rdjgb hl ahst Pussojks eovoki ok tbdprhvokgds. Wdridos pbhkd `ddpdm, ot wjs bos aostrdss

Orokj, bd bjm th ih. Ybjt gjk O mh8 bd sjom sprdjm-oki bos bjkms. _hu ckhw bhw ot os. Jkm O mom.

Ybotd PohtWtrdtgboki jrhukm tbd goty hl \hrcutj hvdr tbd tuk-

mrj os j rhjm tbjt wjs `uoet th eokc tbd kuadrhusproshk gjaps hl tbd rdiohk. Hk tbos lrhzdk rovdr `j-sok j Whvodt bhehgjust thhc pejgd. O bjoedm j gj` jkm

kdihtojtdm j ljrd th ^ot 0?. Ot os j kjad wd sbhuemjee ckhw.

Hk Fuey :?, :?47, shadtboki bjppdkdm tbjtgjuibt tbd gjap jmaokostrjtohk jkm ehgje KC\Mhgdrs ghapedtdey h iujrm. ]bd wbdde jt ^ot

9 sthppdm turkoki. ]bd proshkdrs jkm iujrms okkdjr`y gjaps wbh khtogdm tbos wdrd ghklusdm. ]bdwbddes kdvdr sthppdm, pejks bjm th `d lueeedm. Pu-

ahurs `dijk. ]bdk ghje trjoks wdrd sddk rdturkokilrha ^ot 9, dapty. Whhk kdws wjs sauiiedm hut hl

tbd gjap. ^ot 9 wjs hk strocd. Hk bdjroki tbd kdwstbd proshkdrs jt ^ot := mhwkdm thhes ok supphrt,tbdk ^ot :< mom eocdwosd, jkm tbdk lurtbdr hut jt ^ot

0?. ]bd rst ajss prhtdst sokgd tbd :?0: Crhkstjkmtautoky wjs ukmdrwjy.

Iueji Eotdrjturd]bd Iueji Jrgbopdejih, Whezbdkotsyks ajstdrwhrc, os surdey tbd ahst ljahus hl rst bjkmjgghukts hl eold oksomd tbd Iueji. Ot mdsgro`ds

j vjst gjkvjs hl gjaps, proshks, trjksot gdktrdsjkm sdgrdt pheogd, hl oklhradrs jkm spods jkm ok-

tdrrhijthrs jkm jesh hl bdrhosa - j Wtjeokost jkto-whrem jt tbd bdjrt hl tbd Whvodt Tkohk. Eocdwosd,Whezbdkotsyks khvdeej J Mjy Ok ]bd Eold Hl OvjkMdkoshvogb os j mdkotovd admotjtohk hk tbd ok-ajtds struiied lhr buajk moikoty, tbd hutrjidhl ukfust pukosbadkt jkm tbd oaphrtjkgd hl

bhpd.J Yhrem Jpjrt`y Iustjv Bdreoki os j augb

edss wdee ckhwk whrc, `ut hkd tbjt @drtrjkm Pus-

sdee mdsgro`dm js tbd ahst oaprdssovd jgghukthl eold ok tbd Whvodt gjaps tbjt bd bjm rdjm. Ok

spotd hl tbos tdstoahky lrha hkd hl tbd irdjtdstoktdeedgtujes hl tbd 0>tb Gdktury, tbd `hhc os eottedckhwk hutsomd Bdreokis kjtovd ^hejkm.

Lokjeey, Jkkd Jpped`juas Iueji6 J Bosth-rytbjt bjs `ddk rdghikosdm js j ejkmajrc whrchl 0>tb gdktury bosthry hdrs tbd rst lueey mhgu-

adktdm phrtrjot hl tbd Iueji, lrha ots hroioks oktbd Pussojk Pdvheutohk, tbrhuib ots dxpjksohkukmdr Wtjeok, th ots gheejpsd ok tbd drj hl iejskhst.

Jpped`jua oktoajtdey rd-grdjtds wbjt eold wjseocd ok tbd gjaps jkm eokcs tbda th tbd `rhjmdr

bosthry hl tbd Whvodt Tkohk.

Hk bdjroki tbd kdws tbd proshk-drs jt ^ot := mhwkdm thhes ok sup-

phrt, tbdk ^ot :< mom eocdwosd, jkm

tbdk lurtbdr hut jt ^ot 0?. ]bd rstajss prhtdst sokgd tbd :?0: Crhk-stjkmt autoky bjm `diuk

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

12/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

:0 Hut & J`hutEdlt \hrcutj ok ots Wtjeok drj mjys

Hpphsotd pjid roibt Edkok wdjrs bos hvdrghjt

th wjrm h tbd khrtb jrgtog gboee

]bd wbddes sthppdm turkoki jkm :4,>>> sejvd

whrcdrs bjm sphcdk. Wtukkdm jt tbd ukoajiokj`edgbjeedkid th tbdor jutbhroty tbd gjap jmaokostrj-tohk wdrd uksurd bhw th prhgddm. ]bd proshk-

drs bjm vjrodm mdajkms tbrhuibhut tbd strocokigjaps `ut lhgusdm hk twh ajok phokts6 tbd rdmug-

tohk hl sdktdkgds jkm j khrajeosjtohk hl ghkmo-tohks. ]bdy wdrd jscoki lhr buajkoty.Yd mrhvd hvdr tbd ldjturdedss tukmrj uktoe jk

j`jkmhkdm pot wbdde gjad okth vodw j bjel j coeh-adtrd h tbd rhjm. Yotb ot `doki Ajrgb ot wjs oa-phsso`ed th idt th, tbd skhw whuem d wjost mddp ok

tbd rdiohk uktoe Fukd. \ejmoaor, wbh bjm ghad lrhaHmdssj th whrc tbd aokds jkm ejtdr ahvdm okth tbdtjxo `usokdss th suppedadkt j adjird pdksohk,

bjkmdm ad bos lur bjt. O trodm th km j pjtb hl sbje-ehw skhw tbjt whuem jeehw ad th jpprhjgb tbd pot

`ut O sjkc ok up th ay tboibs js shhk js O stdppdmh tbd rhjm. ]brhuib tbd wokmsgrddk O ghuem sdd\ejmoaor iovoki ad jk O them yhu sh ehhc. ]bd j`jk-

mhkdm gjaps hl \hrcutj jrd kht j pejgd th wjec

`eokm, surrhukmdm js tbdy jrd `y proshkdr gdadtdr-ods jkm ghaaukje irjvds - yhu mhkt ckhw wbjt

`urodm sdgrdts yhu aoibt `d stdppoki hk.Ahsghw wjs oklhradm hl tbd strocd oaadmojtd-

ey. ]bd ihvdrkadkt sdkt j ghaaossohk bdjmdm `y

tbd lhraomj`ed Idkdrje Mdrdvojkch (tbd sjad idk-drje wbh, jehki wotb Idkdrje Mhuiejs AgJrtbur,

jggdptdm tbd surrdkmdr hl tbd Fjpjkdsd ok :?=4)wotb tbd joa hl idttoki tbd proshkdrs th rdturk thtbd pots. Hk tbd ltb mjy hl tbd strocd jkm wotb tbd

proshkdrs bhemoki ra, tbd jutbhrotods hdrdm j sd-rods hl ghkgdssohks6 `jrs wdrd th `d rdahvdm lrhagjap wokmhws, kua`dr pjtgbds ghuem d rdahvdm

lrha fjgcdts, proshkdrs wdrd kht th `d ehgcdm oktbdor buts jt koibt, proshkdrs ghuem khw wrotd th

tbdor ljaoeods hkgd j ahktb okstdjm hl hkgd j ydjr,jkm wotb pdraossohk hl tbd gjap ghaajkmdr lja-oey ada`drs whuem `d jeehwdm jk jkkuje vosot. ]bd

khtogd wjs tjcdk jrhukm tbd gjaps `y adssdkidrjkm tbd proshkdrs oaadmojtdey sdt j`hut roppoki

kua`dr pjtgbds h tbdor whrc idjr jkm bjgcoki

`jrs h tbd wokmhws hl tbdor buts. Bhwdvdr tbdadssjid lrha tbd jutbhrotods rdajokdm ra6 pros-hkdrs bjm th whrc.

Js tbd oktoaomjtohk wjs stdppdm up hvdr tbdwddcs tbd aokds suggua`dm hkd `y hkd, proshkdrs

rdturkdm th whrc jkm tbd pot wbddes `dijk turk-oki. Dvdktujeey hkey hkd pot bdem hut - ^ot 0?, tbdrdajoks hl wbogb O ghuem sdd ok tbd mostjkgd. ]bd

proshkdrs bdem ra ok tbd ljgd hl ghdrgohk, `ro`dryjkm tbrdjts, rdlusoki hrmdrs lrha gjap jutbhrotodsth gjee h tbd strocd. Jltdr wddcs hl stjedajtd tbd

KC\M wjs hrmdrdm th jgt. ]bdy surrhukmdm ^ot 0?wotb trhhps jkm tjkcs mdeovdroki j kje uetoajtuajkm edjvoki tbd strocoki proshkdrs ok kh mhu`t js

th wbjt whuem jwjot tbda sbhuem tbdy rdlusd. Wtoeetbdy sthhm ra. ]bd lheehwoki mjy tbd tjkcs dk-

tdrdm tbd gjap, grjsboki tbrhuib tbd ajok ijtds.Ok lrhkt hl tbda sthhm tbd proshkdrs, jras eokcdmjkm sokioki. Hkd `y hkd tbdy ldee ukmdr tbd vheedy

hl sajee jkm bdjvy jras rd. Ybdk ot wjs hvdr tbd

mdjm ejy hk tbd irhukm, jras stoee eokcdm th tbdorgharjmds. ]bd `hmods wdrd tbrhwk okth j ghaau-

kje irjvd tbjt bjm `ddk mui hutsomd tbd pdroadtdrldkgd ok jktogopjtohk hl tbd ajssjgrd. Ot whuem `djkhtbdr tdk ydjrs uktoe tbd `jr`dm word jkm wjtgb-

thwdrs wdrd kjeey tjcdk mhwk jkm tbd ejst hl tbdproshkdrs lrddm. O wjktdm th ldde shadtboki, shad

mddp storroki hl vosgdrje dahtohk `ut oajids hltbhsd ldjredss vogtoas wdrd kht lhrtbghaoki.

Ehst Ok ]bd Wupdrajrcdt

Yd mrhvd hk th \hrijsbhr, j bjel j`jkmhkdm thwk`jttdrdm y phejr wokms. O dktdrdm tbd gdktrje sbhp-

poki gdktrd wbogb os j irjkmohsd kjad lhr wbjtwjs j musty bjee ok j sdao-mosusdm `uoemoki eokdm

wotb iejss cohscs. ]bdrd wjs j phwdr gut wbogbadjkt pdhped wjecdm tbd mjrc jeedywjys sbhp-poki `y tbd eoibt hl tbdor ah`oed pbhkds. O dktdrdm

j gjld jkm jtd j seogd hl stjed gjcd wjtgboki tbd ldwrdajokoki gotozdks hl tbd thwk burryoki `dtwddk

`uoemokis geutgboki tbdor bjts jkm gheejrs gehsd

th tbda. ]bdrd wdrd kh adk hk tbd strddts, jee hltbda `dehw irhukm bjgcoki jt tbd rhgc ljgd tbjtijvd tbd thwk ots rdjshk lhr `doki. O dktdrdm jk-

htbdr `uoemoki ehhcoki th purgbjsd j pjor hl sturmy`hhts. ]wh aommed jidm whadk rukkoki j cohsc

tbjt shem oaotjtohk sphrts gehtboki usbdrdm ad ok,sddaokiey bjppy lhr tbd mostrjgtohk hl tjecoki th jkhutsomdr. @usokdss momkt sdda ihhm3 O wjs tbd hkey

gusthadr ok tbd sbhppoki gdktrd. Eumaoej jkm Eoeojwdrd `htb ajrrodm th aokdrs jkm bjm hpdkdm tbdsbhp thidtbdr th supphrt tbdor bus`jkms wjids

jkm, O suspdgtdm, djgb htbdr. O ghuem kht oajiokdwbjt desd tbdrd wjs th mh ok tbd thwk th cddptbdasdevds hggupodm.

Wh tdee us j`hut yhur trjvdes ok Pussoj, Eum-aoej, j kjtovd hl Cjzjk, jscdm ad js sbd rdtrodvdm

j ejrid gbhghejtd gjcd lhra ukmdr tbd ghuktdr. Ordghuktdm ay rdgdkt trop th tbd Khrtb Gjugjsus jssbd gut tbd gjcd okth ejrid seogds. ]bd pdhped tbdrd

jrd ihhm, sbd hdrdm. Yd bjvd ajky Mjidstjkos

ok tbd goty, tbdy gjad bdrd lhr whrc ok tbd aokdsjkm kdvdr edlt. Bhkdst typds. Ot wjs tbd rst toad O

bjm bdjrm j Pussojk bjvd shadtboki phsotovd th sjyj`hut pdhped lrha tbd shutb, `ut ok j goty wbdrdahst pdhped wdrd lrha shadwbdrd desd tbdrd wjs

sddaokiey edss hl j tbda jkm us jttotumd.Wh jrd yhu ajrrodm8 Eoeoj jscdm. Ot wjs tbd

qudstohk O wjs jscdm ahst hltdk ok Pussoj, usu-jeey `y aommed jidm whadk ehhcoki th ajtgbajcd. @doki ejtd 7>s jkm ukajrrodm pdrpedxdm

ahst wbh jscdm. Ydee ol yhu rdturk wd woee kmyhu j wold, yhu aust bjvd sddk bhw `djutolue tbdwhadk hl tbd khrtb jrd. Ybjt O bjm khtogdm wjs

bhw ldw yhuki pdhped tbdrd sddadm th `d, dvd-ryhkd sddadm th `d ok tbd ejttdr ydjrs hl aommed

jid. O jscdm ol tbdy bjm gboemrdk. O bjvd j shk jkmj mjuibtdr `ut tbdy eovd ok Ahsghw. ]bdy edlt lhrukovdrsoty jkm kdvdr rdturkdm. ]bdy vosot ut jltdr j

mjy hr twh tbdy `dghad rdstedss jkm wjkt th edjvdEumaoej sjom. O wjskt surprosdm. ]bd thwk wjs bjel-

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

13/28

www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr

:7

mdrdeogt jkm sddadm th hdr khtboki ok tbd wjy

hl dktdrtjokadkt. Lhr pdhped usdm th tbd `roibteoibts hl Ahsghw, sugb js Eoeojs gboemrdk, ot austbjvd `ddk pjrtoguejrey bjrm th rdjmfust th.

O wjecdm tbd strddts hl \hrijsbhr. ]bd scods wdrd`eud jkm gedjr `ut tbd ghem wjs ukeocd jkytboki O

bjm dxpdrodkgdm `dlhrd. O wjs wdjroki js ajkyejydrs js O bjm `rhuibt khrtb `ut stoee tbd ghem pdk-dtrjtdm. ]bd strddts wdrd eokdm y bjel-dapty jpjrt-

adkt uoemokis tbjt wdrd uoet ok j gurvdm sbjpd shjs th jeehw tbd Jrgtog wokms th rhee h tbda. Khkdbjm `jeghkods, sugb tbokis `doki jk ukkdgdssjry

euxury ok j goty wbdrd tdapdrjturds hkey pdjcdmj`hvd zdrh lhr twh ahktbs hl tbd ydjr. ]bdsd khrtb-drk thwks wdrd dxpdksovd lhr Ahsghw th ruk jkm

bdkgd ok tbd ejtd :??>s j prhirjaad hl rdehgjtohkwjs `diuk, bdepoki pdhped wbh wosbdm th edjvd

ahvd shutb. Pussojs wdjetb eods ok hoe jkm ijs, rdk-mdroki ghje aokoki thwks sh ljr khrtb ukdghkhao-gje. Ahst hl tbd aokds ok tbd jrdj bjm `ddk gehsdm.

Ahsghw whuem mdjrey eocd th gehsd tbd rdst, `ut js

tbdrd os kh htbdr whrc ok tbd rdiohk tbos whuem edjmth j bhst hl shgoje prh`edas tbjt tbd gdktrd ghuem

mh wotbhut. Js wotb ahst sugb sgbdads ok tbd phst-Whvodt whrem, bhwdvdr, daoirjtohk su`somods mrodmup jkm pdhped wbh mom kht idt hut ok tbd rst wjvd

rdajok strjkmdm ok `edjc bjel-dapty thwks sugbjs \hrijsbhr, kh ahrd j`ed th edjvd khw tbjk tbd

hroiokje bj`otjkts hl tbd pot thwks. @djtdk `y tbddedadkts O gjuibt j aoko`us `jgc th tbd goty hkwbogb tbd pjssdkidrs bjm bjkms okirjokdm wotb

ghje must lrha j eold spdkt `dehw irhukm.

Fukcod Weop

]bjt koibt O lhukm aysdel ok j ruk mhwk jpjrt-adkt `uoemoki hk tbd dmid hl tbd goty stjkmoki hk

j moaey-eot ejkmoki tbjt stjkc hl urokd. O wjs mrukc.J iuy O bjm adt djreodr ok tbd dvdkoki bjm ihkd thspdjc th j mdjedr bd ckdw tbjt ghhcdm up crhchmoe

ok bos ahtbdrs cotgbdk. Crhchmoe os j gbdjp bdrhoksu`stotutd tbjt wjs rjvjioki tbd mosdklrjkgbosdm

hl Pussojs prhvokgoje gotods. Woaped th ajcd wotb

hvdr tbd ghuktdr admogokds ot bjm dghad phpuejrrst ok gotods jehki tbd Cjzjcb `hrmdr wbdrd jm-mogts wdrd ehhcoki lhr gbdjpdr jetdrkjtovds th Gdk-

trje Jsojk bdrhok. Okdvotj`ey, bhwdvdr, tbd rdgopdsprdjm jehki rjoewjy eokds jkm `jgcrhjms th htbdr

thwks. O wjs oktdrdstdm ok tjcoki j ieoapsd okthtbjt whrem. ]b whrem hl crhchmoe, bhwdvdr, os hkdrold wotb mjkidr. _hu mhkt km crhchmoe mdjedrs

jkm jmmogts ok goty gdktrd rdstjurjkts hr bhtde `jrs,yhu km tbda ok vogohus koibt geu`s jkm phhr su`-

ur`jk bhusoki dstjtds eocd tbd hkd O wjs stjkmoki

ok. O whuem addt Kocotj djreodr ok tbd dvdkoki jt jgeu` ok tbd su`ur`s gjeedm ^dkiuok. ]bd toted wjs jk

orhkog fhcd sokgd wd wdrd boib up ok tbd Jrgtog, jsljr lrha pdkiuoks js hkd ghuem d. \hrcutjks wdrdprhpjijtdrs hl orhky - tbd htbdr geu` ok tbd goty

wjs gjeedm ]rhpogjkj jkm tbd ajok supdrajrcdtwjs gjeedm Lejaokih. J cokm hl ijeehws buahur.

]bd tjxo mrovdr wbh thhc ad th tbd geu` wjrkdmad th `d gjrdlue. Ot wjs ihhm jmvogd, tbd geu` wjssddaokiey luee hl typds O whuem usujeey mh ay `dst

th jvhom - jmmogts, tbuis jkm wbhrds. O iht tjecokith tbd jrajk jkm jscdm hvdr tbd mddp tbum hl tbd`jss ol jkyhkd mdjet tbd mrui ok tbd geu`. Bd phokt-

dm hut j iuy ok j kyehk Jmomjs trjgcsuot wbh wjssottoki jehkd ok tbd ghrkdr sahcoki j goijrdttd. O

wjecdm jgrhss tbd bjel dapty mjkgd ffhhr pjst jkh-rdxog ehhcoki iores wotb `ruosdm edis jkm dxpejokdmwbjt O wjktdm th sdd jkm pbhthirjpb. Bd ckdw

shadhkd `ut wjs suspogohus hl ay oktdrdst. ]wheoibt irddk khtds lrha ay wjeedt wdrd hdrdm jkm

bos suspogohks dvjphrjtdm. ]h sdje tbd mdje wd hr-mdrdm sbhts hl J`soktbd wjradm up wotb j eoibtdr.

O wjs tbdk bjkmdm j strjw jkm okstrugtdm th okbjedtbd luads. Ot wjs j stupom tboki th mh.

@y tbd toad wd bjm rdjgbdm tbd su`ur`jk

jpjrtadkt `uoemoki wbdrd tbd ghhc eovdm O wjs ljrmrukcdr tbjk O sbhuem bjvd `ddk ok sugb ukljaoe-ojr surrhukmokis. Yd thhc tbd eolt th tbd tborm ffhhr

wbdrd O wjotdm `y tbd rjmojthr wboest Kocotj wdktth sdd tbd ghhc jkm jsc ol O ghuem dktdr jkm pbhth-

irjpb boa jt whrc, hr rjtbdr th jsc bhw ajky ahrdeoibt irddk khtds O kddmdm th prhvomd ok hrmdr thmh sh.

Hk tbd ejkmoki j`hvd O bdjrm twh ajed vhog-ds. Hkd hl tbd vhogds mdsgdkmdm jkm jscdm ad okjk uklrodkmey ajkkdr ol O bjm j goijrdttd lhr boa.

O momkt, jkm bd sthhm tbdrd ehhcoki jt ad ehkidrtbjk wjs kdgdssjry dlhrd ihoki jgc upstjors jkmtjecoki th jkhtbdr vhogd ok busbdm thkds. Kocotj

rdturkdm wotb j `htted hl `ddr jkm sjom wd whuembjvd th wjot. ]bd ghhc wjs hut hk j mdeovdry `ut

whuem `d `jgc. ]bdk dvdrytboki wdkt okth sehwahtohk. ]bd eolt mhhr hpdkdm hk tbd ffhhr `dehwjkm summdkey tbdy wdrd hk us. Hkd iuy, yhuki jkm

phwdrlueey `uoet, rjk up lrha tbd eolt pjst ad jkmsajsbdm bos st okth Kocotjs ljgd, tbd yhuki xdrsscuee `hukgoki h j irddk-pjoktdm wjee `dlhrd bos

`hmy sjkc okth jk ukghksgohus seuap jijokst ot. Osthhm tbdrd thh mrukc th rdiostdr lueey wbjt O bjm

fust sddk. Jkhtbdr iuy, tbd hkd wbh bjm jscdm lhrtbd goijrdttd, rjk mhwk tbd stjors lrha tbd uppdrejkmoki jkm irj``dm ad, strjkidey O tbhuibt O sjw

ldjr ok bos dyds. Yd ldee mhwk tbd stjors thidtbdr jkmejkmdm hk tbd gdadkt ffhhr `dehw lheehwdm `y tbdhtbdr iuy. ^ukgbds jkm cogcs rjokdm mhwk hk ad

`ut O ldet khtboki jt jee. O bjm kdvdr `ddk jttjgcdmhk ay trjvdes `dlhrd jkm jee O ghuem tbokc js O wjs

`doki cogcdm wjs tbjt O bhpdm ay ljgd whuem kht`d bot. O saoedm okwjrmey jt ay vjkoty. ]bdrd wjs khldjr, fust j strjkid jggdptjkgd hl wbjt wjs bjp-

pdkoki. Dvdktujeey tbdy prozdm ay gjadrj `ji huthl ay bjkms, tbd pukgbds jkm cogcs gdjsdm jkm ayjttjgcdrs rjk mhwk tbd stjors jkm hut hl tbd `uoem-

oki okth tbd koibt. O wjs ok kh t stjtd th iovd gbjsd.O sthhm up jkm rdjeosdm tbjt shadbhw O wjs gha-pedtdey ukajrcdm. Kocotj stjiidrdm mhwk geutgb-

oki tbd `htted hl `ddr ok hkd bjkm jkm bos fjw oktbd htbdr. Bd sjt mhwk kdxt th ad, thhc j swoi jkm

pjssdm ad tbd htted. Mh O stoee idt pjom8 bd jscdm.

Ehkmhk Gjeeoki

O sthhm hk tbd pejtlhra wotb tbd htbdr pjssdkidrs

wbh wdrd edjvoki tbd khrtb jkm rdturkoki th tbdajokejkm js tbd okbj`otjkts hl tbd goty mdsgro`dm

tbd rdiohk wbdrd tbd rhjm `dioks. Wdrido jrrovdmjt tbd rjoewjy stjtohk th sjy ihhm`yd. Bos wold jkm

j sajee gboem bd bjm kht adktohkdm th ad djreodrstjydm ok tbd wjratb hl tbd gjr. Orokj jkm ad, otshvdr, @dk. Bd wjs upsdt ut tryoki kht th sbhw ot. O

ajmd ay gbhogd ehki jih jkm O sbhuem jggdpt ot, bdsjom, khmmoki ok tbd mordgtohk hl bos ljaoey. ]bjtsot lhr ad jkm whadk. Lrha khw hk Oee `d j ihhm

bus`jkm. Bd bjkmdm ad j `htted hl vhmcj. Mrokc otok Ehkmhk jkm rdada`dr us. Jk jttrjgtovd `ehkmdiore ok j sbhrt scort jkm ejrid suotgjsd `hjrmdm ay

wjihk. Bos dyds lheehwdm bdr up tbd stdps. O wosbO wjs ghaoki wotb yhu, bd sjom mostjktey `dlhrd

turkoki jkm wjecoki `jgc jehki tbd pejtlhra thtbd gbhogd bd ajmd ehki jih.

@dk Pogb os j lrddejkgd wrotdr wbhsd `ehi gjk `d lhukmjt www.`dtwddktbdbjaadrjkmtbdsogced.gha

J iuy O bjm adt djreodr ok tbddvdkoki bjm ihkd th spdjc th jmdjedr bd ckdw tbjt ghhcdm upcrhchmoed ok bos ahtbdrs cotgbdk

Hut & J`hut

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

14/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

:= Lhgus

]PJ\DEEDM ]H C_PI_W]JK tbrdd toads ok

:??9 js j fhurkjeost. @ut tbdrd os kh hgoje rd-ghrm tbjt O dvdr sdt lhht hk Cyriyz shoe. Djgb

toad tbd pejkd lrha Ahsghw thugbdm mhwk

j Adrgdmds whuem puee up th tbd stjorwjy

jkm ay trjvde ghapjkohks jkm O whuem edjvd

tbrhuib tbd `jgc ijtd hl Ajkjs jorphrt wotbhut

sh augb js j ffjsb hl hur pjssphrts.

O whuem mdpjrt lhr Ahsghw ok tbd sjad ljsb-

ohk, dxgdpt hk tbd ejst hggjsohk wbdk O bjm kh

gbhogd ut th ih th mdpjrturds jt tbd jorphrt. O woee

ghad `jgc th bhw tbjt whrcdm hut ejtdr.

]bd omdj hl ihoki th Cyriyzstjk gjad lrha

Oihr, j lhradr CI@ hgdr O wjs oktrhmugdm th ok j

gjsokh ok Ahsghw. Bd bjm `ot hl j rhuedttd prh`-

eda jkm j `ot hl j mrokc prh`eda `ut bjm j rdpu-

tjtohk jahki shad hl tbd dxpjt ghrrdsphkmdkts

lhr `doki j`ed th idt tbda okth trogcy pejgds jkm,

ahrd oaphrtjktey, `jgc hut. Bd wjs j xdr.

O wjs j groad ghrrdsphkmdkt jkm bjm fust

ghapedtdm j mhguadktjry j`hut tbd okljahus

Ahsghw HAHK roht pheogd tbjt bjm prhvdm j bot

lhr tbd Idrajk ]\ stjtohk O whrcdm lhr. Ot bjm `jm

ghps, prhstotutds, ajj jkm irjtuothus vohedkgd,

tbd roibt okirdmodkts lhr Idrajk proadtoad.

Oihr wjs hdroki tbd hpphrtukoty th spdkm j

wddc hr twh eaoki tbd Cyriyz Aokostry hl Oktdro-

hrs Jkto-Kjrghtog Movosohk ok tbdor vjeojkt struiied

jijokst tbd mrui ehrms ok tbd shutb hl tbd ghuktry.

Yboed O eocdm tbd omdj ot wjs wdee-mhguadktdm

wbh wjs wokkoki tbd struiied, sh jpjrt lrha tbd

eaoki `doki phtdktojeey mjkidrhus tbdrd wjs

tbd rdje prhspdgt hl spdkmoki twh wddcs pjtrhe-

eoki tbd ahuktjoks shutb hl Hsb jkm ghaoki

`jgc dapty bjkmdm.

O them Oihr O wjs oktdrdstdm ut wd whuem kddm

j ^ejk @ ok gjsd tbd mrui sthry momkt whrc hut.

O them boa wd bjm j mdje ol bd ghuem iujrjktdd

ad eaoki jggdss th j whadks proshk. Js ljr js

O ckdw kh`hmy bjm eadm oksomd hkd ok Cyriyz-

stjk jkm ldet surd tbjt Idrajk vodwdrs (rdjm6 vhy-

durs) whuem tjcd th shadtboki hl tbjt oec dvdk ol

khtboki spdgoje bjppdkdm muroki eaoki.

Oihr sjom bd bjm j lrodkm ok @osbcdc wotb

wbha bd bjm ihkd th CI@ sgbhhe, wbh whuem `dgrotogje th us idttoki jggdss. Lovd aokutds ejtdr bd

iht h tbd pbhkd wotb bos lrodkm jkm them ad tbjt

bd ghuem iujrjktdd tbd luee ghhpdrjtohk hl tbd

Jkto-Kjrghtogs Tkot, jggdss th tbd ldajed proshk-

drs ghehky hutsomd @osbcdc jkm wjs ghkmdkt bd

ghuem hrijkozd j `djuty ghapdtotohk ok tbd pros-hk lhr us th dksurd wd iht ihhm pogturds.

Oihr jkm O ghksuaajtdm tbd mdje hvdr wbjt

wjs th `d tbd rst hl ajky `htteds hl vhmcj wd

whuem sbjrd thidtbdr. Yd jirddm th ffy th @osbcdc

tbd lheehwoki wddc th bjaadr hut mdtjoes wotb

bos lrodkm jkm tbdk rdturk ejtdr th mh tbd eaoki.

@osbcdc ok :??9 wjs wjcoki lrha ots Whvodt

seua`dr th j kdw koibtajrd hl ejwedsskdss jkm

phvdrty. Yd stjydm ok tbd Mhstuc Bhtde wbogb wjs

js iroa tbdk js ot os khw. ^rhstotutds bjuktdm tbd

bjeewjys wotb tbdor poaps jkm tbd `jr hk tbd sdg-

hkm ffhhr ldjturdm j stroptdjsd wotb irjmujtds hl

tbd @osbcdc @jeedt Wgbhhe wbh bjm ljeedk hk bjrm

toads.

]bd wjr adahroje jgrhss tbd rhjm ghaada-

hrjtoki tbd Irdjt Ahtbdrejkm Yjr wjs sya`heog

hl tbd dghkhaog mdgjy tbjt `eoibtdm tbd ghuktry.

]bd dtdrkje ffjad bjm ehki sokgd pdtdrdm hut js

tbd ijs wjs gut mud th khk-pjyadkt. Jee hl tbd

`rjss edttdroki okirjokdm ok tbd irjkotd bjm `ddk

thrk hut `y sgjvdkidrs th `d shem js sgrjp adtje

th tbd Gbokdsd. Ahst hl @osbcdcs ajkbhed ghvdrs

bjm `ddk swopdm lhr tbd sjad purphsd.

Hk tbd rst dvdkoki hl hur rdghkkjossjkgd

trop Oihr jkm O wjkmdrdm hvdr th tbd gjsokh jgrhss

tbd rhjm th addt bos ghktjgt th mosguss hur otokdr-

jry lhr tbd kdxt twh wddcs. Yd gbuiidm mhwk

j ghuped hl ghapedadktjry mrokcs wboed wjotoki

jkm Oihr trodm bos eugc jt rhuedttd.

Jt tbd phkthhk tj`ed kdxt th us j puktdr

wdjroki j trjmotohkje Cyriyz bjt `dijk sbhutoki

jt tbd grhupodr tbjt tbd gjsokh wjs gbdjtoki boa.

Bd phukmdm tbd tj`ed wotb bos sts jkm tbrdjtdm

th coee boa ukedss bd iht bos ahkdy `jgc.

]wh sdguroty iujrms quogcey jppdjrdm lrha

`dbokm boa, hkd hl tbd `urey pjor prhmugoki jk

dedgtrog gjtted prhm lrha ukmdr bos fjgcdt tbjt

bd prhgddmdm th zjp tbd prhtdstoki geodkt wotb.

]bd ukbjppy ija`edr rhjrdm ok gbhrus wotb tbd

shukm hl tbhusjkms hl vhets ghursoki tbrhuib bos

`hmy `dlhrd ljeeoki th tbd irhukm ok wbjt ehhcdm

eocd jk dpoedptog t.

Bjrmey jky`hmy tbrdw tbd ajk j iejkgd jstbd sdguroty iujrms pejgdm bos bjt hk bos stha-

jgb, irj``dm j edi djgb jkm tbdk mrjiidm boa

thwjrms tbd ajok dktrjkgd dlhrd turki boa hut

okth tbd mjrc.

Ybjt wdrd yhu mhoki ok :??98 Mrdsmdk

Aurpbys jkswdr th tbos qudstohk os `y kh

adjks ruk-hl-tbd-aoee.

MPDWMDK ATP^B_

J`hvd, Poibt jkm Kdxt ^jid ]bjkclueey Cyr-

iyzstjks CI@ wjs ukj`ed th ghksgjtd jee hl

Mrdsmdks lhhtjid (jee pbhths stoees tjcdk lrha

hroiokje vomdh lhhtjid)

&Mruis]buis

Gjttedprhms

O

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

15/28

www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr

:4Lhgus

Oihrs lrodkm, wbh O woee rdldr th js Cjjrajk-

`dc, turkdm up sbhrtey jltdrwjrms wdjroki jsbjrp suot jkm gjrryoki tbd jor hl shadhkd jggus-

thadm th ghaajkmoki rdspdgt. ]bdy da`rjgdm

`dlhrd wd jee rdtordm th j provjtd rhha th mosguss

tbd eaoki hvdr j `htted hl vhmcj jkm pejtds hl

jppdtozdrs.

Bd wjs gedjr lrha tbd hutsdt tbjt tbd jkto-

kjrghtogs ukot wjs ukmdrlukmdm, `jmey trjokdm

jkm up jijokst jk jmvdrsjry wotb ljr `dttdr rd-

shurgds. @ut bd wjs jmjajkt tbjt twh wddcs ok

Hsb jkm ok tbd ahuktjoks shutb hl tbd goty whuem

okvhevd rjoms, jrrdsts jkm mruis.

]h tdst bhw ihhm bos ghktjgts wdrd O jscdm

boa th edt ad ckhw ol j aurmdr thhc pejgd ok @osb-

cdc wotbok tbd kdxt =2 bhurs, sh tbjt bd ghuem

tjcd ad th tbd sgdkd hl tbd groad jkm edt ad ok-

tdrvodw tbd aurmdrdr ol tbdy wdrd jpprdbdkmdm.

Bd sjom ot whuem `d kh prh`eda, thhc hut j

pheogd rjmoh lrha bos ji jkm jrcdm shad hrmdrs

okth ot. Bd tbdk eedm hur iejssds jkm sjom wotb j

ajgj`rd saoed6 Khw wd wjot lhr shad`hmy th

mod.

]wh bhurs ejtdr j ukolhradm pheogdajk gjad

th tbd rhha jkm wbospdrdm th Cjjrajk`dc wbh

tbdk turkdm th us jkm them us tbdrd bjm `ddk j

aurmdr hk tbd htbdr somd hl @osbcdc. J ajk bjm

`ddk coeedm jkm tbdk rh``dm ok j mrukcdk mosputd

wotb j lrodkm wbh bjm `ddk jpprdbdkmdm sbhrtey

jltdrwjrms eyoki ukghksgohus ok j pjrc wotb j ao-

grhwjvd, j rdghrm pejydr jkm j ji hl fdwdery ejom

hut `dsomd boa.

Yd bdjmdm hvdr th tbd groad sgdkd ok j ghp

gjr wotb tbd sordk hk jkm `eud eoibts ffjsboki jt

ay rdqudst. Ot wjs j aosdrj`ed pogturd. ]bd wold

hl tbd mdgdjsdm wjs ckddeoki `y bos somd sh``oki

jkm tbd cotgbdk ckold tbjt bjm `ddk usdm th coee

boa wjs stoee prhtrumoki lrha bos gbdst.

Dapty vhmcj `htteds ejy strdwk hk tbd ffhhr

hl tbd cotgbdk jehki wotb phhes hl `ehhm.

]bd gueprot wjs `doki bdem ok sheotjry ghkkd-

adkt jt j kdjr`y pheogd stjtohk, wbogb wd wdrd

okvotdm th vosot.

Ybdk wd jrrovdm wd wdrd them bd wjs stoee

pjssdm hut `ut wd wdrd wdeghad th ehhc ok hkboa. Yd wdrd tjcdk mhwk th gdees ehgjtdm ok j

kjrrhw mjap ghrromhr hl tbd `jsdadkt. ]bd stokc

hl poss jkm swdjt hkey jmmdm th tbd sdksd hl

mdshejtohk.

Ybdk wd sthhm hutsomd bos gdee O ahvdm lhr-

wjrm th pddr tbrhuib tbd Fumjs bhed, kht khtog-oki tbdrd wjs kh iejss ok ot. Cjjrajk`dc irj``dm

ay jra jkm pueedm ad `jgc. Bd dxpejokdm hkd

bjm th `d gjrdlue js ot wjs kht ukckhwk lhr pros-

hkdrs th wjot uktoe j iujrm ehhcdm tbrhuib tbd

bhed jkm tbdk stogc j pdkgoe hr shad htbdr sbjrp

h`fdgt okth tbdor dyd.

J iujrm ukehgcdm tbd mhhr womd dkhuib lhr

us th sdd tbrhuib tbd mjrckdss tbjt j ajk wjs

eyoki hk j whhmdk pejtlhra ok tbd ghrkdr hl tbd

gdee. Bd sbhutdm jt boa th stjkm up `ut tbd ajk

ghuem hkey ajkjid th idt hk bos ckdds.

Bd tbdk jscdm boa wby bd bjm coeedm bos

lrodkm. Bd rdpeodm tbjt bd ghuemkt rdada`dr mh-

oki ot jkm tbdk guredm up ok j ldtje phsotohk, aua-

`eoki th boasdel. O wjs them bd whuem prh`j`ey idt

:4 ydjrs `ut whuem bjvd moguety survovoki tbd

tdra wotbhut tbd bdep hl bos rdejtovds. ^hhr kutro-

tohk, mosdjsd jkm ghrrupt iujrms whuem tjcd tbdor

thee ehki `dlhrd tbd sdktdkgd wjs sdr vdm.

Cjjrajk`dc tbdk turkdm th ad jkm jscdm

rjtbdr sokostdrey ol tbdrd wjs jkytboki desd O whuem

eocd boa th hrijkozd. Ol kht, wbdk ghuem bd dxpdgt

ad `jgc th stjrt eaoki8

J ahktb ejtdr O gjad `jgc wotb Oihr, j gja-

drjajk jkm j shukm ajk. Ot wjs tbd sjad rhutokd

js `dlhrd3 wbdk tbd pejkd ejkmdm jee tbd pjssdk-

idrs wdrd them th rdajok ok tbdor sdjts wboed ay

tdja jkm O wdrd them th mosda`jrc rst. @dehw tbd

stjors tbd `ejgc Adrgdmds wotb jk Oktdrohr Aokos-

try kua`dr pejtd wjotdm th wbosc us jwjy voj tbd

`jgc dxot.

Yd spdkt twh wddcs eaoki ok Hsb jkm ok

tbd surrhukmoki ahuktjoks wotb tbd jkto-kjrght-

ogs ukot. Yd bjm jggdss th tbd proshk jkm prdtroje

mdtdktohk gdktdr wbdrd wd ghuem ea ghkvogtdm

mrui sauiiedrs. Hk pjtrhe hr jt gbdgcphokts wd

ajkjidm th ukghvdr sajee jis hl hpoua bommdkok pdhpeds gehtboki hr ok tbdor euiijid. Yd dvdk

iht hkd iuy wbh gjad `y lhht hvdr tbd ahuk-

tjoks gjrryoki twh coehs hl hpoua. O wjs them bd

wjs prh`j`ey j mdghy th mostrjgt ejw dklhrgd-

Bd tbdk eedm hur iejssds jkmsjom wotb j ajgj`rd saoed6 Khw

wd wjot lhr shad`hmy th mod

adkt lrha j `oiidr hpdrjtohk j ldw grua`s th

ajcd tbd ghps ehhc eocd tbdy wdrd mhoki tbdor fh`.Khkd hl ot whuem ajcd ihhm vodwoki.

]bdrd wdrd pedkty hl hdrs th sdt shadtboki

up jkm ajcd ot ehhc rdje `ut O wjskt oktdrdstdm.

O bjm ghad th tbd ghkgeusohk tbjt ok tbd ijad hl

gjt jkm ahusd `dtwddk tbd mrui `jrhks jkm tbd

pheogd ot wjs tbd mrui `jrhks wbh wdrd tbd gjts

wotb `oi gejws.

Hk hur ejst mjy ok tbd ahuktjoks wd wdrd

eaoki jt j rhutokd gbdgcphokt. ]h pjss tbd toad O

bjm jscdm pdraossohk th `d tbd hkd wbh mdgomdm

wbogb vdbogeds wd sthppdm. J Cjajz trugc gjad

okth vodw thwoki jkhtbdr hkd wotb ]jfoc kua`dr

pejtds jkm O them tbd ghp stjkmoki `dsomd ad wotb

tbd Cjejsbkochv th puee tbda hvdr.

]bd usuje pdrlukgthry sdjrgb dijk. ]bd mhi

bjkmedr jkm bos mhi gorgedm tbd trugc wboed tbd

mrovdr bjm bos mhguadkts gbdgcdm. Jethidtbdr

tbdrd wdrd j`hut tdk ghps jt tbd gbdgc phokt

jehki wotb Cjjrajk`dc, Oihr jkm ay ea grdw.

Bjrmey jky hl tbd ghps thhc jky khtogd hl tbd

sdjrgb js tbdy sahcdm jkm dxgbjkidm fhcds.

@ut tbdk summdkey tbd mhi bjkmedr `dgjad

jkoajtdm js bos mhi `dijk pueeoki jt bos edjsb,

skoki ldvdrosbey `dkdjtb tbd mrovdrs gj`. Whhk

ot wjs wbokoki jkm ot bjm gjuibt jee hl hur jttdk-

tohk. ]bd mrovdr `dijk th ehhc mdgomdmey ukgha-

lhrtj`ed.

]bjts wbdk tbd `jm ghp/`jm ghp rhutokd hl

oktdrrhijtohk `dijk. ]wh ghps `dijk sbhutoki

jt tbd mrovdr jkm phcoki tbdor kidrs ok bos gbdst

wboed phoktoki th tbd gj`.

]bd ghp ok gbjrid hl tbd hpdrjtohk mdgomdm

th bjvd tbd trugcs mrovdk th j ehgje pheogd stjtohk

js bd ldet wd wdrd thh dxphsdm hk tbd ahuktjok

thp. Hkgd tbdrd j iuy wotb j word bjkidr jkm jk-

htbdr wotb j bjaadr `dijk prh`oki jkm tbuap-

oki th sdd ol tbdy ghuem km j ljesd ghapjrtadkt.

Lovd aokutds ejtdr :9 coehirjas hl `ejgc tjr hpo-

ua ejy ok pejstog `jis hk tbd irhukm. ]bd mrovdr

ehhcdm tdrrodm js bd wjs bjkmgudm jkm ajk-

bjkmedm okth j gjr.

Yd eadm dvdrytboki, dvdk idttoki jk oktdr-

vodw wotb tbd mrovdr wbh gejoadm bd bjm ruk okthkjkgoje moguetods ok ]jfocostjk jkm bjm `ddk

lhrgdm th sauiied tbd hpoua ok hrmdr th sdtted j

md`t hl 4> mheejrs. ]bd hpoua otsdel bjm j strddt

vjeud hl $70>,>>> ok Durhpd `dlhrd `doki

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

16/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

:< Lhgus

ghkvdrtdm okth bdrhok.

Yd mrhvd fu`oejktey ok j ghkvhy `jgc th Hsbth idt tbd mrovdr `hhcdm jkm bjkm hvdr tbd

mruis. Js wd dktdrdm tbd wjrdbhusd ok tbd `jgc

hl pheogd bdjmqujrtdrs tbd sadee hl hpoua sjtu-

rjtdm tbd jor. ]bd rhha wjs j`hut 0> squjrd ad-

tdrs jkm wjs stjgcdm wjost boib wotb ghksgjtdm

`jis hl mruis. Yotbok aokutds O wjs `diokkoki

th ldde j `ot eoibtbdjmdm jkm tbd hgdr ok gbjrid

wjs gedjrey sthkdm.

Ejtdr ok tbd dvdkoki js wd gded`rjtdm hur

lhrtuothus mjy jt tbd Okthurost j wjotdr jscdm

Oihr th ih addt shad adk wbh wdrd wjotoki jt

tbd dktrjkgd. Ybdk bd rdturkdm O jscdm boa ol

tbdrd wjs j prh`eda.

Bd sjom tbjt dvdry-

tboki wjs HC `ut tbjt

ot aoibt kht `d j `jm

omdj ol wd bdjmdm th

tbd jorphrt djreodr tbjk

pejkkdm tbd lheehwoki

ahrkoki.

Hk tbd pejkd bd

whuem tdee ad tbjt tbd adk wbh bjm jpprhjgbdm

boa bjm them boa tbjt tbd mruis `ust bjm `ddk

j `oi aostjcd jkm sbhuem kdvdr bjvd bjppdkdm.

]bdy sjom tbjt tbdy bjm iht tbdor mruis `jgc jkm

ol Oihr whuem iovd tbda tbd gjssdttds tbdy whuem

prdtdkm khtboki bjm bjppdkdm. Bd prhaosdm th

addt tbda jt >9.>> tbd kdxt ahrkoki wotb tbd

gjssdttds. Yd edlt lhr tbd jorphrt jt >>.

Yd mdgomdm tbjt ot wjs `dst lhr us th edjvd

tbd ghuktry strjoibt jwjy jkm rdturk wbdk wd

iht j soikje lrha Cjjrajk`dc tbjt tbdrd whuem

`d kh rdpdrgussohks.

J ahktb ejtdr wd rdturkdm th ea tbd wha-

dks proshk ghehky. Ay Idrajk dmothr bjm `ddk

sdmugdm y tbd prhaosd hl tbd proshk jutbhrotods

bhemoki j `djuty ghktdst muroki hur vosot. ]borty

hr sh whadk pjrtogopjtdm wotb tbd wokkdr doki

j yhuki `ehkmd wotb j ahutb luee hl ihem tddtb.

Wbd wjs sdrvoki sdvdk ydjrs lhr aurmdroki bdr

bus`jkm.

Jltdr eaoki wjs hvdr O mdgomdm th bjki hut

j ldw dxtrj mjys ok @osbcdc wboed tbd rdst hl tbdtdja ffdw `jgc th Ahsghw. Bhwdvdr, hk tbd mjy

`dlhrd ay mdpjrturd Cjjrajk`dcs ljtbdr modm

jkm bd bjm th ih th tbd lukdrje ok Kjryk.

Bos jssostjkt Jeajz pogcdm ad up jt tbd

bhtde ok jk jkgodkt Vboiueo wotb tbd stjkmjrm

mjrcdkdm wokmhws. O bjm j seoibt sdksd hl lhrd-`hmoki js wd jpprhjgbdm tbd jorphrt jkm bd

mrhppdm ad jt tbd mdpjrturd ehukid.

Gbdgcoki ok wjs tbd djsy pjrt ut wbdk O iht

th pjssphrt ghktrhe tbdy them ad tbjt O ghuemkt

edjvd tbd ghuktry js tbdrd wjs kh dvomdkgd hl

ad bjvoki dvdr `ddk tbdrd. Ot thhc j wboed `ut

O wjs j`ed th ghkvokgd tbda th edt ad tbrhuib

jrrovjes ok hrmdr th idt jk dktry stjap jkm tbdk

ih `jgc th tbda.

]bos grdjtdm j kdw prh`eda wbdk jrrovjes

jscdm ad wbogb pejkd O bjm ghad ok hk. Ybdk

O them tbda O bjm ffhwk ok lrha Ahsghw tbdy

rdpeodm wotb jsthkosb-

adkt tbjt tbdrd wjs

kh ffoibt lrha Ahsghw

tbjt mjy.

Ot wjs tbdk tbjt

O sjw Jeajz wotb bos

bdjm stogcoki hut lrha

tbd gurtjoks bjkioki

hvdr tbd `jiijid ghk-

vdyhr `det. Bd `dgchkdm ad hvdr jkm wd prh-

gddmdm th wjec mhwk tbd `det th wbdrd j sajee

euiijid trjgthr wjs wjotoki lhr us.

Yd ahuktdm tbd euiijid trjgthr jkm mrhvd

hkth tbd tjrajg wbdrd O ghuem sdd ay Cyriyz-

stjk Jorwjys ffoibt tjxooki lhr tjcdh.

Jeajz uridm tbd trjgthr mrovdr th bdjm tbd

pejkd h ut wboed wd mrhvd okth ots tjcdh pjtb

j ghp gjr gjad burteoki thwjrms us wotb tbd

ehumspdjcdr, sbhutoki jt us th gbjkid ghursd.

]bd pejkd, tbd trjgthr jkm tbd ghp gjr gjad

th j bjet. Bjkms wdrd sbhhc js os sddaokiey gus-

thajry dvdk wbdk tryoki th `ehgc tbd mdpjrturd

hl j pejkd. Jeajz dxpejokdm th tbd ghps tbjt O

wjs j iudst hl Cjjrajk`dc wbh wjs ukj`ed th

ajcd ot th tbd jorphrt. ]bd tdksohk eoltdm oaadmo-

jtdey. @jgcs wdrd sejppdm, goijrdttds wdrd eot jkm

j stjorwjy jppdjrdm lhr ad th `hjrm tbd pejkd.

Jeajz jgghapjkodm ad up jkm dxpejokdm th

tbd surprosdm bhstdssds tbjt O wjs jk oaphrtjkt

iudst hl tbd Oktdrohr Aokostry. ]bd pejkd wjs sh

luee tbjt tbdrd wdrd j`hut tdk pdhped stjkmokijt tbd `jgc. ]bd ajk ok ay sdjt wjs hrmdrdm th

vjgjtd ot. O thhc bos pejgd jkm ffdw `jgc th Ahs-

ghw wotbhut tbdrd bjvoki dvdr `ddk j rdghrm hl

ay stjy ok Cyriyzstjk.

]bd wold hl tbd mdgdjsdm wjs

ckddeoki `y bos somd sh``oki jkmtbd cotgbdk ckold tbjt bjm `ddkusdm th coee boa wjs stoee prhtrum-oki lrha bos gbdst

Cyriyz ]oadwjrpYboest tbd Wpogd Iores wdrd spogoki up hur eovds

hvdr ok tbd TC, Ybjt wjs ihoki hk ok Cyriyzstjkok :??98

Mokjah @osbcdcwhk tbd Cyriyz Lhht`jee

Edjiud, tbd tdjas rst ok j ghksdgutovd bjtrogchl edjiud toteds `dtwddk :??9 jkm :???. Ok jkukgdrtjok mdgjmd Mokjah gbjkidm tbdor kjad

th LG Mokjah-Hoe @osbcdc, th LG GJI-Mokjah-A\M @osbcdc, th LG Drcok Ljra @osbcdc, th LGMokjah-Drcok Ljra @osbcdc, th LG Mokjah-

^heyht @osbcdc, uktoe tbdy wdrd mosshevdm ok0>>7. ]bd tdja wjs rdgdktey rdlhukmdm ok 0>:0,

rd`hrk js Mokjah A\M @osbcdc.]bd Cuathr ihem aokd stjrtdm prhmug-

tohk. J ydjr ejtdr ok :??2 j Cuathr ehrry spoeedm

gyjkomd okth tbd rovdr @jrschhk, wbogb gjusdmj ljor jaahukt hl jiirh. Khwjmjys tbd aokdghktro`utds :>-:0% hl Cyriyzstjks IM^ `ut

pdhped stoee jrdkt bjppy wotb ot. Ok Ajy tbos ydjrtbd voeejids surrhukmoki tbd aokd `urst okthro-hts, wotb j irhup hl rdstedss yhuki adk `urk-oki j Wpdg Hps vdboged ok j potgb `jtted wotb tbdihvdrkadkt. Cuathr os eocdey th `d gdktrje th

jky pheotogje ghktrhvdrsods ok tbd ghuktry lhr tbdkdxt ldw ydjrs jt edjst.

Jpjs Fuajijehv wjs ^road-Aokostdr hl

Cyriyzstjk. Jgtujeey, Jpjs, j khrtbdrkdr, bjmj sbht jt `doki tbd rdpu`eogs lorst prdsomdkt,

`ut kdotbdr boa khr shutbdrkdr J`sjajt

Ajsjeoydv ghuem jgbodvd j ajfhroty ok tbd vhtd,pjvoki tbd wjy lhr Jscjr Jcjydv th dadrid js j

ghaprhaosd gjkmomjtd. Fuauijehv whuem tjcdup j peua phsotohk jt tbd stjtd dkdriy ghapjkyCyriyzKdltIjs jltdr bos prdaodrsbop, `ut bd

kdvdr bot tbd pheotogje bdoibts Jcjydvmom. Bos-thry, js tbdy sjy, os j modrdkt ghuktry.

Hk Jproe 0?, Gbokdsd, Cyriyz jkm Tz`dc mde-

dijtohks adt ok ]jsbcdkt th tjec j`hut j rjoewjyeokc tbjt whuem ghkkdgt Jkmofjk, ok Tz`dcostjk

th Cjsbijr, ok Gbokj. Chaadrsjkt.ru rdphrtdmtbjt tbdrd wdrd prh`edas wotb tbd kdihtojtohks

iovdk tbjt Pussoj wjs hpphsdm th tbd eokc okprokgoped jkm j `oi tdgbkogje botgb dxostdm rd-ijrmoki tbd womtb hl tbd prhphsdm trjgc. Ljstlhrwjrm soxtddk ydjrs jkm eotted bjs gbjkidm.

]bos prhfdgt os j sehw `urkdr.

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

17/28

7/22/2019 The Spektator 22

18/28

Wdptda`dr 0>:7 ]bd Wpdctjthr www.tbdspdctjthr.gh.uc

:2 Hk tbd @hx

BOED ]BD TWihvdrkadkt guts lukm-

oki lhr rdsdjrgb jkm dmugjtohk ok

Gdktrje Jsoj, F Ehs surprosd `ortbmjy

sdrdkjmd ok ]urcadkostjk rdaokms

us hl wbjt Jadrogjks truey mh `dst6

dktdrtjokadkt. Jetbhuib sjtojtoki tbd wboas hl jk

jppjeeokiey rdprdssovd rdioad os pdrbjps kht tbd

ahst prhmugtovd lhra hl dxdrtoki okffudkgd, dktdr-

tjokadkt mhds bjvd tbd gjpjgoty th ddgt shgoje jkm

pheotogje gbjkid. ]bus ok Cyriyzstjk, `edssdm wotb

tbd rdiohks edjst strokidkt admoj ghktrhes, wd gjk

dxpehrd tbd lruots hl j prhmugtovd lhra hl okffudkgd6

tbd kdw tdedvosohk sdrods Mhra.

Jt rst Mhra, hr H`sbjij ok Pussojk, sddas

eocd j typogje yhutb-hrodktdm sotgha. Eocd tbd

ehki-rukkoki Jadrogjk sdrods Lrodkms, tbd sbhwgdktdrs jrhukm tbrdd ajed jkm tbrdd ldajed

gbjrjgtdrs tbjt sbjrd oktoajtd lrodkmsbops jkm rd-

ejtohksbops. Eocd tbd Pussojk ghadmy Tkovdr, tbd

prhtjihkosts jrd jee gheedid stumdkts wbh sbjrd j

mhraothry. ]bdk tbd soaoejrotods ljmd, lhr Jadro-

gjk jkm Pussojk sotghas tdkm th bjvd gedjrdr

`hukmjrods `dtwddk idkrds. Lrodkms jkm Tkovdr

jrd ukja`oiuhus ghadmods wotb j bdlty mhsd hl

sejpstogc jkm ldw shue-wrdkgboki sheoehquods. H`-

sbjijeocdwosd hdrs idkuokd boejroty, `ut `dlhrd

yhu bot tbd ffhhr ejuiboki, hut phurs ukdxpdgtdm

pjtbhs. ]bd sdrods ukj`jsbdmey ghklrhkts Cyriyz-

stjks ahst prdssoki shgoje prh`edas.

]bd gdktrje ossud tjgcedm `y Mhra os tbd tdk-sohk surrhukmoki kjtohkjeoty. Jetbhuib tbd djrey

Whvodt pdrohm bdepdm dktrdkgb jspdgts hl dtbkog

omdktoty ok Gdktrje Jsoj tbjt wdrd prdvohusey khk-

dxostdkt, muroki tbd ajfhroty hl ots bosthry tbd stjtd

whrcdm th su`suad dtbkog modrdkgds ok ljvhr

hl j sbjrdm Whvodt gotozdksbop. Wokgd Cyriyzstjk

`dgjad okmdpdkmdkt ok :??:, tbd kjrrjtovd prh-

ahtdm y ots rst prdsomdkt Jcjydv hl Cyriyzstjk

hur ghaahk bhad bjs `dghad stdjmoey ukrjv-

dedm ok ljvhr hl prjgtogds tbjt dxgeusovdey prhahtd

tbd totuejr kjtohk. ]bd `rdjcoki phokt hl okgrdjs-

oki tdksohk ok tbd wjcd hl Jproe 0>:> rdvheutohk

hggurrdm twh ahktbs ejtdr ok Hsb, wbdrd sdvdrje

bukmrdm pdhped wdrd coeedm ejridey jehki dtbkogeokds. Wokgd tbos wjr js ajky ok Hsb rdldrrdm th

ot jt tbd toad wjs pdrgdovdm hl js `dtwddk Cyriyz

jkm Tz`dcs, Mhra prhahtds jk jetdrkjtovd vosohk

lhr oktdrdtbkog rdejtohks6 ajcd ehvd, kht wjr.

Y

DAOE_ GJKKOKI

]bus dktdr hur mhraothry bdrhokd6 j strocokiey

`djutolue Tz`dc iore lrha Hsb kjadm ]jbaokj. ]bd

h`fdgt hl bdr jdgtohks8 J bjkmshad Cyriyz ejm

wbh ok bos spjrd toad prjgtogds Fumh jkm struas

bos iuotjr3 tbjt os wbdk bds kht `usy sjvoki mja-

sdes ok mostrdss. _dt ots kht fust tbdor ehvd sthry tbjt

idts yhur bdjrt rjgoki. ]bd htbdr gbjrjgtdrs jrd

dqujeey oktroiuoki. ]bdrds Mrdo tbd ghhe, rogb goty

`hy wbh bjs ljeedk hut hl bos ljtbdrs ihhm irjgds

jkm `jkcrhee. Mrdo os tbd pdrldgt lhoe th kjvd ghuk-

try `uapcok, Jzjajt, wbh os ghkstjktey ljeeoki

prdy th tbd sbdkjkoijks hl bos sbjjrmyc (ur`jk)

pddrs. Lhr okstjkgd, tbdrd os jk dposhmd wbdrd Mrdo

dxpejoks th Jzjajt tbjt tbhkis jrd jee tbd rjid ok

ljsbohk jkm ghkvokgds boa th wdjr hkd . Bhwdvdr,

tbos ljux pjs mhds kht prdvdkt ]jbaokjs swddtPussojk rhhaajtd, Kjmyj, lrha kmoki Jzjajt

jmhrj`ed jkm lddmoki boa `hrsgb.

]bd sbhw tdapts thedrjkgd ok tbd sjad wjy

tbjt jee irdjt whrcs hl gtohk mh6 tbrhuib dapjtby.

Js wd lheehw tbd gbjrjgtdrs tbrhuib tbdor trojes jkm

tro`uejtohks js tbdy jttdkm ukovdrsoty ok @osbcdc, wd

sdd `dyhkm tbdor ej`des jkm rdejtd th tbda js okmo-

vomujes. Js sugb, O khtogdm shad okgrdmo`ed gbjkids

ok pdhpeds ghaadkts hk tbd wd`sotd kja`j.ci,

wbdrd yhu gjk wjtgb tbd sbhws 04 dposhmds. Jt

rst tbdrd wdrd ehts hl kjtohkjeost stjtdadkts eocd,

wbjt, yhu ghuemkt km jky Cyriyz iores lhr tbos

sbhw8 ]bos jeeumds th tbd ljgt tbjt ok jmmotohk th

]jbaokj jkm bdr Pussojk rhhaajtd Kjmyj, wbhjrd pejydm `y Tz`dc jkm Pussojk jgtrdssds rdspdg-

tovdey, tbd tborm ldajed rhhaajtd (Addroa) os jesh

jk Tz`dc jgtrdss pejyoki tbd pjrt j Cyriyz iore. _dt

ghaadkts eocd ots sugb j sbjad wbjt bjppdkdm

th Addroa! hr ^hhr ]jbaokj! ljr hutkua`dr tbd

hggjsohkje rjgost trhee. ]bd dapjtby wjs sprdjmoki.

Ok jmmotohk th lhstdroki dapjtby thwjrm tbhsd

wotb movdrsd dtbkog `jgcirhukms, tbd sbhw ghk-

lrhkts htbdr prdssoki shgoje ossuds. Lrha ghrruptohk

jahki tbd pheogd th tbd `ro`oki hl prhldsshrs, tbd

yhuki gbjrjgtdrs strovd lhr ljorkdss ok j pheotogje

systda tbjt os wdoibtdm jijokst tbda. _dt ghrrup-

tohk os jk ukghktrhvdrsoje prh`eda ghapjrdm th

tbd augb bdjvodr ossuds tbjt jrosd. Lhr okstjkgd, otsddas eocd kh shjp hpdrj whuem `d ghapedtd wotb-

hut j surprosd prdikjkgyjkm vodwdrs woee kht `d

mosjpphoktdm tbdrd. @ut tbd ljgt tbjt sdx bjppdks

ok tbd mhras hl @osbcdc`dlhrd ajrrojidos kht

jt jee suijrghjtdm. ]bdrd os mdsord. ]bdrd os mjkidr.

Gbjrjgtdrs gbjkid3 tbdy `dghad mosoeeusohkdm. @ut

kht jee bhpd os ehst.

Hkd bhpdlue soik lhr tbd luturd os tbd sbhws

eok