Top Banner

of 60

The Scottish American Invest Co.

Apr 06, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    1/60

    SAINTSF Inc an Gwt

    Annual Report and Financial

    Statements 31 December 2010

    http://www.bailliegifford.com/Default.aspx
  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    2/60

    Contents

    1CompanySummary 2OneYearSummary 3FiveYearSummary 4ChairmansStatement 6DirectorsandManagement 8 ManagersReview12 PerormanceAttribution12DistributionoPortolio13 ThirtyLargestHoldings13 InvestmentChanges14 ClassifcationoInvestments

    15ListoInvestments18 PropertyPortolio19TenYearRecord20DirectorsReport

    28DirectorsRemunerationReport30StatementoDirectorsResponsibilities31IndependentAuditorsReport32IncomeStatement32 StatementoTotalRecognisedGainsandLosses33 BalanceSheet34 ReconciliationoMovementsinShareholdersFunds35 CashFlowStatement36 NotestoFinancialStatements49 PlansManagedbyBaillieGiord50 CommunicatingwithShareholders

    51 FurtherShareholderInormation51 DividendDatesor201152AnalysisoShareholders53 NoticeoAnnualGeneralMeeting57 AppendixtotheNoticeoAnnualGeneralMeeting

    THIS DOCUMENT IS IMPORTANT AND REQUIRES YOUR IMMEDIATE ATTENTION. If you are in any doubt as to the action you should takeyou should consult your stockbroker, bank manager, solicitor, accountant or other independent nancial advisor authorised under the FinancialServices and Markets Act 2000 immediately.

    If you have sold or otherwise transferred all of your ordinary shares in The Scottish American Investment Company P.L.C., please forward thisdocument and the accompanying form of proxy as soon as possible to the purchaser or transferee or to the stockbroker, bank or other agentthrough whom the sale or transfer was or is being effected for delivery to the purchaser or transferee.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    3/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 1

    CompANy SummAry

    Company Summary

    Company data at 31 December 2010Total assets Shareholders funds Market capitalisation

    418m 331m 325mTotalnetassetsbeoredeductionodebenture.

    ObjectiveSAINTSobjectiveistoincreasecapitalandgrowincomeinordertodeliverrealdividendgrowth.

    Investment PolicySAINTSpolicyistoinvestexiblyandactivelyacrossabroadrangeoassetsandmarkets.Listedequities,bothUKandoverseas,ormthelargestpartotheportolio.Investmentsarealsomadeinbonds,propertyandotherassetclasses.FulldetailsotheCompanysinvestmentpolicyarecontainedwithintheBusinessReviewonpages20and21.

    Company History

    SAINTSwasoundedin1873.Around80%otheCompanyssharesareheldbyprivateindividuals.

    BenchmarkTheportoliobenchmarkagainstwhichperormancehasbeenmeasuredis50%FTSEAll-ShareIndexand50%FTSEAll-WorldExUKIndex(insterlingterms).

    IncomparingNAVperformancetothebenchmarktheCompanysassetsandliabilitiesaremeasuredatfairvalue.

    Management DetailsBaillieGiord&CowereappointedasInvestmentManagersandSecretariestotheCompanywitheectrom1January2004.

    Themanagementcontractcanbeterminatedonsixmonthsnotice.ThepropertyportolioismanagedbyOLIMLimited.Theagreementcanbeterminatedonthreemonthsnotice.

    Management FeesBaillieGiord&Cosannualmanagementeeis0.45%ototalassetslesscurrentliabilities,excludingthepropertyportolio,calculatedonaquarterlybasis.

    OLIMLimitedreceivesanannualeeo0.5%othevalueothepropertyportoliosubjecttoaminimumquarterlyeeo6,250.

    Capital StructureAttheyearendtheCompanyssharecapitalconsistedo132,485,943ordinaryshareso25peachwhichwereissuedandullypaid.TheCompanyhasbeengrantedtheauthoritytobuybackalimitednumberoitsownshares.Longtermgearinghasbeensecuredby80million(nominalvalue)odebenturestock,whichwasissuedinthreetranchesbetweenApril1997andJanuary2001.

    Saving VehiclesSAINTSsharescanbeheldthroughavarietyosavingsvehicles(seepage49ordetails).

    AICTheCompanyisamemberotheAssociationoInvestmentCompanies.

    NotesNoneotheviewsexpressedinthisdocumentshouldbeconstruedasadvicetobuyorsellaparticularinvestment.

    InvestmenttrustsareUKpubliclistedcompaniesandassuchcomply

    withtherequirementsotheUKListingAuthority.TheyarenotauthorisedorregulatedbytheFinancialServicesAuthority.

    SAINTS aims to be a core investment for private investors seeking income.Its objective is to achieve capital and income growth in order to grow thedividend at a faster rate than ination. The focus of the portfolio is onlisted equities, both UK and overseas, but investments are also made inbonds, property and other asset types.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    4/60

    2 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    oNe yeAr SummAry

    31 December 31 December

    2010 2009 % change

    Totalassets(beoredeductionodebenture) 418.3m 365.1mDebenture(bookvalue) 87.5m 87.9mShareholdersunds 330.8m 277.2m

    Netassetvalueperordinaryshare(debentureatairvalue) 242.5p 206.0p 17.7Netassetvalueperordinaryshare(debentureatbookvalue) 249.7p 209.2p 19.4Shareprice 245.5p 181.0p 35.6FTSEAll-ShareIndex 3,062.8 2,760.8 10.9FTSEAll-WorldExUKIndex(insterlingterms) 207.5 181.4 14.4Benchmarkcompositeindex* 12.7

    Premium/(discount)debentureatairvalue 1.2% (12.1%)Discount(debentureatbookvalue) (1.7%) (13.5%)

    Revenueearningsperordinaryshare 8.51p 9.05p (6.0)Dividendspaidandpayableinrespectotheyear 9.25p 9.05p 2.2Expenseratio 0.90% 1.02%

    Year to Year to

    31 December 2010 31 December 2009

    Years high and low High Low High Low

    Netassetvalue(debentureatairvalue) 247.2p 196.4p 208.3p 125.8pNetassetvalue(debentureatbookvalue) 253.8p 203.3p 211.2p 129.1pShareprice 245.5p 178.7p 185.0p 113.3p

    Premium/(discount)debentureatairvalue 2.3% (12.1%) (4.3%) (14.7%)Premium/(discount)debentureatbookvalue (1.4%) (13.5%) (7.7%) (15.9%)

    Year to Year to

    31 December 2010 31 December 2009

    Total return performance

    Netassetvalue(debentureatairvalue) 22.8% 49.6%Netassetvalue(debentureatbookvalue) 24.3% 45.5%Shareprice 41.8% 47.3%Benchmarkcompositeindex* 15.8% 25.4%

    Pastperormanceisnotaguidetoutureperormance.

    One Year Summary

    One Year Performance(fguresplottedonamonthlybasisrebasedto100at31December2009)

    Share price

    NAV (fair value)

    Benchmark*

    Dividends are not reinvested.

    Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream/Baillie Gifford & Co

    *The Companys benchmark index is: 50% FTSE All -ShareIndex and 50% FTSE All-World ex UK Index (in sterling terms).

    2010

    J F M A M J J A S O N2009

    80

    140

    110

    100

    90

    D D

    120

    130

    150

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    5/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 3

    Five Year Summary

    FIve yeAr SummAry

    5 Year Total Return Performance(fguresrebasedto100at31December2005)

    Relative Annual Net Asset Value andShare Price Total Returns (relative to

    the benchmark* total return)

    Premium/(discount) to Net Asset Value(plottedonamonthlybasis)

    Dividend and RPI Growth Rate(fguresrebasedto100at31December2005)

    Pastperormanceisnotaguidetoutureperormance.

    *Witheectrom1January2009theportoliobenchmarkagainstwhichperormancehasbeenmeasuredis50%FTSEAll-ShareIndexand50%FTSEAll-WorldExUKIndex(insterlingterms).FortheearlieryearscoveredbytheabovegraphstheCompanysbenchmarkwas70%FTSEAll-ShareIndexand30%FTSEWorldExUKIndex(insterlingterms).Forthepurposesotheabovegraphsthereturnsonbothbenchmarksortheirrespectiveperiodshavebeenlinkedtoormasinglebenchmark.

    20092005 2006 2007 200840

    60

    80

    120

    140

    2010

    160

    100

    Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream/Baillie Gifford & Co

    Share price total return

    NAV total return (book value)

    Benchmark* total return

    (CUMULATIVE TO 31 DECEMBER)

    Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream/Baillie Gifford & Co

    SAINTS premium/(discount) book value

    SAINTS premium/(discount) fair value

    The discount is the difference between SAINTS quotedshare price and its underlying net asset value.

    YEARS TO 31 DECEMBER

    2%

    (4%)

    20092005 2007 2008

    (2%)

    20102006

    0%

    (6%)

    (8%)

    (10%)

    (12%)

    (14%)

    (16%)

    Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream/Baillie Gifford & Co

    NAV total return (fair value) relative tobenchmark* total return

    Share price total return relative to benchmark*total return

    YEARS TO 31 DECEMBER

    20092006 2007 2008

    20%

    (20%)

    (10%)

    10%

    0%

    2010

    30%

    Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream

    RPI

    SAINTS dividend

    (CUMULATIVE TO 31 DECEMBER)20092006 2007 2008

    100

    130

    120

    110

    2010

    140

    150

    160

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    6/60

    4 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    ChAIrmANS STATemeNT

    Pastperormanceisnotaguidetoutureperormance.

    Overview

    Theglobaleconomycontinuedtorecoverduring2010andmostinvestmentmarkets,althoughvolatileromonemonthtothenext,deliveredgoodreturnsovertheyear.Manycompaniesreportedstronggrowthinproftsandstockmarketsaroundtheworldrecordedgains.SAINTSparticipatedullyinthisrally.

    Performance

    Thenetassetvaluetotalreturn(incomeandcapital),withthedebenturevaluedatitsairvalue,was22.8%.Thiscomparestoabenchmarktotalreturno15.8%.Thenetassetvaluepersharerose

    rom206pto242.5p,ariseo17.7%.Theriseinthesharepricewasstrongerstill,rom181pto245.5p.This35.6%gainmeantthatthesharepricefnishedtheyearatasmallpremiumtonetassetvalue.

    Revenues and Dividend

    Totalincomewas16.4min2010comparedto17.2minthepreviousyear.Thisdeclineisexplainedbyaallinbondincome,itselaunctionotransactionsanddecliningmarketratesointerest.In2009,therevenueaccountalsobeneftedromexceptionalpaymentsrelatingtoVATamountingto1.6m.Thesewerenotrepeatedin2010.Thecombinedeectothesetwoactorshasmeantthat2010earningspersharewas8.51p,some6%lowerthanthe9.05precordedinthepreviousyear.Thisdeclinemasksamorepromisingunderlyingpicture.Strongcorporateproftabilityisencouragingquotedcompaniestoraisetheirdividends.Ourexpectationisthatthistrendwillcontinuein2011.

    Thedeclineinearningspersharemeansthatourdividendthisyearwillnotbeullycoveredbyearnings.However,revenuereservesaresubstantial(10.6ppershare)andthis,alongsidetheexpectationorimprovinginvestmentincomeintheyearahead,allowsustoproposeanincreaseddividendor2010.

    Threepaymentso2.3phavealreadybeenmadeandweproposetopayafnaldividendo2.35pmakingatotalo9.25portheyearasawhole.Thisisanincreaseo2.2%onlastyearsdividend.

    Chairmans Statement

    ThisrateoincreaseallsshortothecurrentrateoinationintheUK.However,weareconfdentthattheinvestmentportolioiscapableosupportingrealdividendgrowthinthemediumtermandlonger.Overthelastfveyears,thedividendhasrisen42%whichcomparestoanincreaseintheRetailPriceIndexo18%.

    Borrowings

    SAINTSborrowingstaketheormoasingledebenturedueorrepaymentinApril2022.Thebookvalueotheseborrowedundsis87.4m.However,sincethedebenturewasissuedatapremiumtoitsparvalue,thefnalrepaymentamountwillbe80m.

    Atthestartotheyear,thebookvalueothedebenturewasequivalenttoapproximately32%oshareholdersunds.Formuchotheyear,thisborrowedmoneywasullydeployedinundingarangeoinvestmentsacrossbondmarketsandinUKcommercialproperty.Theseperormedwelland,togetherwithgainsontheequityportolio,contributedtoasignifcantriseinshareholdersundsduringtheyear.Thismeantthatattheyearendthedebenturesbookvaluehadallento26%oshareholdersunds.

    Supply and Demand for the Companys Shares

    Oneothemostnotableeaturesothelastyearhasbeenthestrongperormanceothesharepricerelativetoournetassetvalue.Atthestarto2010thediscounttonetassetvalue(debentureatairvalue)stoodat12.1%but,bytheendotheyear,a1.2%premiumhademerged.

    ThisdevelopmentowesmuchtoSAINTSbeingabletooerarelativelyhighandgrowingdividendwhilstmanyotherormsosavinghaveseenincomereturnsall.TheBoardandtheManagershavealsoputmuchthoughtandeortintopromotingSAINTSasacost-eectivesavingsvehicleorprivateinvestors,particularlythoseseekingagrowingincomestream,whichhasledtoincreasingdemandortheshares.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    7/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 5

    ChAIrmANS STATemeNT

    Demandorregularandgrowingincomewillremainstrong.ShouldSAINTScontinuetobeneftromthisandthepremiumtonetassetvaluepersisttheBoardislikelytosubmitablocklistingapplicationtotheLondonStockExchange.Thiswouldallownewsharestobeissuedtothemarketaswellastomeetdemandorsharesromregularsaversinthevarioussavingsschemes.Shareswouldonlybeissuedatapremiumtonetassetvalue.SuchissuanceisbenefcialtoexistingshareholdersasitenhancesnetassetvalueandtheincreaseinthesizeotheCompany,althoughmodest,spreadstheburdenoitsadministrativecosts.

    Notwithstandingtheabove,wealsointendtoseekshareholders

    approvalatthisyearsAGMortherenewalotheCompanysauthoritytobuybackitsownsharesatadiscounttonetassetvalue.Althoughthishasnotbeenusedinrecentyears,theBoardbelievesthatbuybackscanbeuseulincertaincircumstancesorreducingvolatilityinthediscountandenhancingnetassetvalueorcontinuingshareholders.

    Outlook

    Financialmarketvaluationsreachedtheirlowestpointothe2007-2009fnancialcrisisduringthefrstquartero2009.Sincethen,marketshaveralliedstronglyasexceptionalfscalandmonetarypoliciesinmanycountrieshavestimulatedasubstantialrecoveryinglobaleconomicactivityandasignifcantriseininvestorconfdence.

    WethinktheyearaheadwillbeoneourtherChinaledgrowthintheworldeconomy.Wealsoexpectthecorporatesectortoshowgoodgrowthinproftswhichshouldallowthecompaniesinwhichweareinvestedtoraisetheirdividends.Onthisbasis,weareexpectingourownrevenuepositiontoimprove.

    However,signifcanteconomicriskspersistincludingimbalancesinworldtrade,risinginationandhighdebtlevelsinsomeothematureeconomies.RecentdevelopmentsinanumberoMiddleEastcountriesalsoremindusthatunexpectedeventscan,andwill,happen.Wethereorestartthisnewfnancialyearwithaslightlymorecautiousoutlookthanlastyear.

    Annual General Meeting

    AttheAGM,underSpecialBusiness,theCompanyisproposingtoadoptnewArticlesoAssociationtoreecttheimplementationothelastpartsotheCompaniesAct2006whichcameintoorceon1October2009.ItisalsoproposedthattheArticlesbeamendedtoincreasethelimitsontheDirectorsees.WhilstitisnottheBoardsintentiontoincreaseDirectorseesor2011,theeesarenearthecurrentlimitwhichallowslittlescopeoranincreaseinutureyears.Furtherinormationonthisresolutioncanbeoundonpage27intheDirectorsReportanddetailsothemainchangesproposedtotheArticlesaresetoutintheAppendixtotheNotice

    otheAGMonpage57.AllotheDirectorsareseekingre-electionthisyearandwillcontinuetodosoonanannualbasis.

    TheAGMwillbeheldat11amonThursday7AprilatBaillieGiordsofcesatCaltonSquare,1GreensideRow,Edinburgh(seemaponpage53).TheManagerswillmakeapresentationontheinvestmentportolio.TherewillalsobeanopportunitytoaskquestionsandtheDirectorsandManagerslookorwardtomeetingyouthere.

    SirBrianIvory,CBEChairman18February2011

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    8/60

    6 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    dIreCTorS ANd mANAGemeNT

    Directors and ManagementMembers of the Board come from a broad variety of backgrounds. The Board can draw on anextensive pool of knowledge and experience. Baillie Gifford & Co, a leading UK investmentmanagement rm established in 1908, have acted as Managers and Secretaries since 1 January 2004.

    Directors

    Sir Brian Ivory, CBE, CASirBrianjoinedtheBoardin2000andwasappointedChairmanin2001.HeisalsotheChairmanotheNominationCommittee.HeisadirectoroRemyCointreauSA,InsightInvestmentManagementLtdandoMarathonAssetManagement(Services)LtdandischairmanoRetecDigitalplcandArcusEuropeanInrastructureFundGPLLP.HewasormerlychairmanoHighlandDistillersPlcandotheTrusteesotheNationalGalleriesoScotlandandadirectoroHBOSPlc.

    The Rt Hon Sir Menzies Campbell, CBE, QC, MPSirMenziesjoinedtheBoardinDecember2007.HewasLeaderotheLiberalDemocratpartyuntilOctober2007.HewaselectedasanMPin1987,andwasForeignAairsSpokesmanbeorebecomingDeputyLeaderohisparty.HequalifedasanadvocateinScotland,beingadmittedtotheFacultyoAdvocatesin1968andbecomingQueensCounselin1982.

    Eric Hagman, CBE, CAMrHagmanjoinedtheBoardin2005andbecametheChairmanotheAuditCommitteeaterthe2009AGM.HejoinedArthurAndersenin1971andbecamethemanagingpartnerinScotlandin1982.Hespentthelastfveyearsuntil2002inLondonasamanagingpartnerontheUKLeadershipTeam.HeisadirectoroBritishPolytheneIndustriesplcandTheRoyalCollegeoArt.

    HewasormerlyatrusteeotheNationalGalleriesoScotlandandadirectoroGlenGroupplc,ScottishFinancialEnterpriseandScottishEnterprise.

    Lord Kerr of Kinlochard, GCMGLordKerrjoinedtheBoardin2002.HewaschairmanotheAuditCommitteeuntilhesteppeddownaterthe2009AGM.HewasHeadotheDiplomaticServicerom1997to2002,havingpreviouslybeenAmbassadortotheEuropeanUnionandthentotheUnitedStates.HeisdeputychairmanoRoyalDutchShellplc,adirectoroRioTintoPlcandScottishPowerandchairmanoImperialCollegeLondon.

    Rachel LomaxMsLomaxjoinedtheBoardin2008.SheservedasDeputyGovernorotheBankoEnglandbetween2003and2008,havingpreviouslybeenPermanentSecretaryattheDepartmentorTransport,theDepartmentorWorkandPensionsandtheWelshOfce.ShewaspreviouslyChieoStatothePresidentotheWorldBank,HeadotheEconomicandDomesticSecretariatattheCabinetOfce.SheworkedormanyyearsatHMTreasury,whereshewasPrincipalPrivateSecretarytotheChancellorotheExchequeranddeputyChieEconomicAdviser.SheisadirectoroHSBCHoldings,BAALimited,theReinsuranceGroupoAmerica(RGS),theRoyal

    NationalTheatre,ImperialCollegeLondon,theCentreorEconomicPolicyResearch(CEPR)andtheSupervisoryBoardoArcusEuropeanInrastructureFundGPLLPandisPresidentotheInstituteoFiscalStudies.

    Peter MoonMrMoonjoinedtheBoardin2005.HewaschieinvestmentofcerotheUniversitiesSuperannuationSchemeLimitedundrom1992untilAugust2009.HeisadirectoroFirstPropertyplcandArdenPartnersplcandisaormerdirectoroMBNAEuropeandisaormerMemberotheNationalAssociationoPensionFundsInvestmentCommittee.PriortojoiningUniversitiesSuperannuationScheme,MrMoonmanagedinvestmentsattheBritishAirwaysPensionFundandtheNationalProvidentInstitution,whichhejoined

    in1978.

    David PriceMrPricejoinedtheBoardin1997andistheseniorindependentdirector.HeisadirectoroMelchiorJapanInvestmentTrustplcandStramongateAssetsPlc.HewasormerlydeputychairmanoMercuryAssetManagementGroupplcandchairmanoF&CManagementLimited.

    AllDirectorsaremembersotheNominationandAuditCommittees.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    9/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 7

    Managers and Secretaries

    SAINTSismanagedbyBaillieGiord&Co,aninvestmentmanagementfrmormedin1927outothelegalfrmBaillie&Giord,WS,whichhadbeeninvolvedininvestmentmanagementsince1908.

    BaillieGiord&CoareoneothelargestinvestmenttrustmanagersintheUKandcurrentlymanageeightinvestmenttrusts.BaillieGiord&CoalsomanageunittrustsandOpenEndedInvestmentCompanies, togetherwithinvestmentportoliosonbehalopensionunds,charitiesandotherinstitutionalclients,bothintheUKandoverseas.FundsunderthemanagementoradviceoBaillieGiord&Cototalaround70billion.BasedinEdinburgh,theyareoneotheleadingprivatelyownedinvestmentmanagementfrmsintheUK,with35partnersandastaoaround700.

    ThemanageroSAINTSportolioisPatrickEdwardson,apartneroBaillieGiord&Co.PatrickisresponsibleorSAINTSequityinvestments,workingcloselywithalloBaillieGiordsequityinvestmentteams.SAINTSbondinvestmentsaremanagedbyspecialistsinBaillieGiordsfxedincometeam.ThepropertyinvestmentsaremanagedseparatelybyOLIMLimited,aspecialistpropertymanager.

    ThefrmoBaillieGiord&CoisauthorisedandregulatedbytheFinancialServicesAuthority.

    Fromlettoright:DavidPrice,TheRtHonSirMenziesCampbell,RachelLomax,SirBrianIvory,EricHagman,PeterMoon,LordKerroKinlochard

    dIreCTorS ANd mANAGemeNT

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    10/60

    8 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    mANAGerS revIe

    Overview

    Theglobaleconomystrengthenedduring2010andmoststockmarketsrosebacktowardsthelevelsprevailingbeorethecollapseoLehmanBrothersandthefnancialcrisisinlate2008.Mostotherinvestmentmarketsalsodeliveredgoodreturnsalthoughgovernmentbondslostsomegroundtowardstheendotheyearasgrowthacceleratedandsomeconcernsemergedaboutination.

    SAINTSreturned22.8%,astrongresult.Formostotheyearwewereullyinvested,mainlyinequitiesbutalsoinavarietyobondholdings,indirectlyheldUKcommercialpropertyandinlistedpropertyandorestryunds.Theproportioninvestedinequitieswas

    alittlebelowwhatwewouldnormallyhavebutthiswasnotbecausewewerebearishonequities.Insteaditreectedaviewthatanumberoothermarketswerecapableogeneratingequallygoodinotbetterreturns.Creditmarketsinparticularoeredsomeveryappealingopportunities.

    Chinawas,onceagain,themainengineogrowthintheworld.Togetherwithrapidgrowthinotherlowerpercapitaincomecountries,thismeantthat2010wasanotheryearinwhichthebalanceoeconomicandpoliticalpowershitedsouthandeast.Therewassomeimprovementinthedevelopedeconomies;ateraalteringrecoveryin2009,thegeneraltrendwasorstrongergrowthparticularlyintheUSandGermany.However,highdebtlevelsandweakbankingsystemsstillweighonmanyothese

    economiesandwhatstrengththerewasowedmuchtosupportivemonetarypolicyandheavyborrowingbygovernments.

    Thestronginvestmentreturnsmaskwhatwasanotheryearoconsiderablevolatilityinmarkets.Thefrsthalotheyear,andparticularlytheperiodbetweenAprilandJune,wasdominatedbyacrisisinEuropeangovernmentdebtmarketswhichwassufcientlygraveastoundermineconfdenceacrossabroadswatheoglobalmarkets.TheimmediateissuewastheabilityoGreecetorefnancecertainbondissuesbutthebroaderpointwasthedurabilityotheeuro-zoneinitscurrentormandthesustainabilityogovernmentdebtlevelsinsomeothesmallerEuropeancountries.

    Inthesecondhalotheyear,economicandcorporatenewsincreasinglysupportedamoreupbeatassessmentoinvestment

    prospects.FinancialmarketswerealsobuoyedbythedecisionotheUSFederalReservetoundertakeasecondroundoquantitativeeasingandanextensionogeneroustaxcutsbytheUSgovernment.

    AlthoughmuchisrightlymadeothedecliningrelativeimportanceotheUS(aslarger,morepopulousnationssuchasIndiaandChinagrowinwealthandimportance),itremainsinabsolutetermsthesinglelargesteconomyintheworld.Itshealthandvitalitystillhaveaveryimportantbearingontheglobaleconomyandfnancialmarkets.Whilstthelongtermsustainabilityandimpactoitscurrentpoliciesareopentoquestion,theyappearorthetimebeingtohavebolsteredconfdenceinUSgrowthprospectsandaregivinginvestorscauseoroptimism.

    LoosemonetarypolicyintheUSalsoboostedgrowthinthedevelopingnations.Thedesireomanyothesecountriestofxor

    managetheirexchangerates,principallyagainstthedollar,requiredthemtosetinterestratesatlevelswhich,whilstappropriateoradebt-burdenedUSeconomy,wereinappropriateorthem.Theresultwasoverheatingeconomies,risingdomesticpricesandsignifcantincreasesingloballytradedoodandcommodityprices.

    Howcountriesreacttotheemergenceoinationarypressureswillbeanimportantinuenceoninvestmentreturnsintheyearahead.However,in2010stronggrowthandrisingpriceswereagoodcombinationorourcompanies,bothintermsotradingresultsandshareprices.Mostreportedrisingsalesandmanywereabletoclaimsatisyinglyhighproftmargins.Risingprofts,improvingcashowsandgenerallystrongbalancesheetsalsoencouragedquotedcompaniestostartraisingdividendsagain.Inthe2010revenueaccount,thisencouragingdevelopmentwasoutweighedbyadropinbondincomeandtheimpactodividendcutsannouncedinthepreviousyear.However,weareconfdentthatitwillbenefttherevenueaccountin2011.

    Equities

    Onaverageduringtheyear69%otheportoliowasinvestedinequities.Expressedasapercentageoshareholdersunds,thefgurewas89%.Thetotalreturnortheyearwas19.3%.

    ThedirectionochangeinthegeographicdistributionotheportolioisstillawayromtheUKandtowardsoverseasmarkets,inparticularthedevelopingnations.However,thescaleochangeduring2010wasmodest.WemadereductionstoholdingsinsuchtraditionallyamiliarnamesasVodaone,BP,TescoandGlaxosmithKlineandoutrightsalesoseveralsmallerholdings.Asaresultothese,UKlistedstocksrepresentedlessthan30%oSAINTStotalportoliobytheendotheyear.Becauseotheirrelativelyhighyields,amoresubstantialreductionintheUKlistedholdingswouldhavehadanunhelpulimpactontherevenueaccountthisyear.

    Managers Review

    Pastperormanceisnotaguidetoutureperormance.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    11/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 9

    mANAGerS revIe

    Weappliedtheproceedsromthosesalestoavarietyoopportunitieslistedelsewhereintheworld.Itisworthrecordingthatthespurtobuyingaparticularstockisinvariablyitsstrengthsandprospectsasabusinessratherthanwhereithappenstobedomiciledorlisted.Nonetheless,theortunesoseveralholdingsthatenteredtheportolioorthefrsttimethisyeararecloselytiedtothelongtermdevelopmentotheemergingnations.ExamplesotheseincludeSouthAricanlistedStandardBank,theHongKongandBrazilianstockexchangesandatollroadoperatorinwesternChina,SichuanExpressway.

    Closertohome,wetookholdingsinseveralEuropeanlisted

    companies.SvenskaHandelsbankenisaremarkablysuccessulanddisciplinedSwedishbankthathaslongemphasisedorganicgrowthandcapitalstrength.Wethinktheseattributeswillbringitgoodortuneintheyearsahead.Asagoodexampleohowdomicileolistingmatterslittlenowadays,wepurchasedPortugueselistedoodretailerJeronimoMartinsbutdidsobecauseoitslargeandsuccessulPolishbusiness.WealsoboughtRoche,theSwisslistedpharmaceuticalscompany.Ourpositioninginthepharmaceuticalindustryissomewhatcautiousaswearewaryotheindustrysabilitytomaintaincurrentlevelsoproftability.HoweverwethinkRochemaybecapableogrowthandisonanundemandingrating.

    MostoourothertransactionswereinUSstocks.TheUSmarketis,inourview,themostsusceptibletoabearishassessmentovaluationsbecausetheratiooUSstockmarketpricestoearnings,onceallowanceismadeortheupsanddownsotheeconomiccycle,issignifcantlyaheadoitslongrunaverage.ThisobservationpromptedageneralreviewoUSholdingswhich,alliedwithsomelossopatienceorconfdenceintheinvestmentcaseledtosalesoseveralstocksincludinginsuranceandinvestmentgroupBerkshireHathaway,vethospitalgroupVCAAntech,documentstoragecompanyIronMountainandswimmingpoolsupplierPoolCorporation.ThetransactionsintheUSwerenotallonewaythough.WeboughtMcDonalds,theeponymousburgerandastoodchain;wethinkitslongtermprospectsareexcellentasitrollsoutitsormatintothemanydevelopingnations.

    Inabsoluteterms,virtuallyallpartsotheportoliodeliveredpositivereturnsduring2010.Incomparisontoourbenchmark,onwhichthereturnwas15.8%,webeneftedmostromourEuropeanandNorthAmericaninvestments.

    ThesizeoourEuropeaninvestmentswasnotmuchgreaterthanthoseothebenchmarkindex,buttheirperormancewasconsiderablystrongerwitha29%gainduringtheyearcomparedto6%romthebenchmarksEuropeancomponent.TheSwedishengineeringholdingAtlasCopcowasparticularlyimportantbutwealsohadverysignifcantgainsonourholdingsintheaorementionedJeronimoMartins,litscompanySchindlerandSwissbasedprivateequitymanagerPartnersGroup.NorthAmericanstockmarketsenjoyedstronggains,helpedbyrecoveryintheUSeconomyandrisingoverseasearnings.Overall,ourholdingsperormedwell,notablyonlineretailerAmazon,insurancesotwareproviderSoleraandmortgagelenderNewYorkCommunityBank.Canadianlistedoil

    companyPennWestalsoperormedwell,reectingstrengthinthepriceocrudeoil.

    TheperormanceoourEmergingMarketinvestmentswasactuallylessgoodthantherelevantindicesorthosemarketsbutwehadasubstantiallylargerallocationthancontainedinSAINTSbenchmark(22%against8%).ThemainreasonsortheperormanceshortallweretherelativelylargeallocationtoChinesestocks(whichdespitethatcountryseconomicstrengthdeliveredsomewhatmutedreturns)andaholdinginBrazilianoilcompanyPetrobras(whichellovertheyearonconcernsaboutequityissuanceandgovernmentinvolvement).Morepositively,andincontrasttothegeneralperormanceotheChinesemarket,wehadstrikinggainsromaholdinginChineseinternetsearchcompanyBaidu(whichreturned

    over140%).Oneoouremergingmarketretailers,SouthAricanbasedMassmart,alsobeneftedromabidapproach.

    Lookingatourindustryexposureovertheyear,thestrongcontributionromindustrialstocksgivesagoodindicationohowthestrengtheningeconomicenvironmentdroveequityreturns.WehavealreadymentionedAtlasCopco,butUSlistedagriculturalmachinerycompanyDeeremadealmostaslargeacontribution.Variouscompaniesinvolvedinthedistributionogoodsthrougheconomiesalsoaredwell,notablyUSdeliveryfrmUPSandAustralianlistedpalletdistributorBrambles.Weownavariedselectionofnancialstocksandthesedidwellascreditmarketsandthewesternbankingsystemcontinuedtoheal.Ourretailingexposureisverymuchocusedonthedevelopingworldwhererisinglivingstandardsand

    lowconsumerdebtburdenscontrastsharplywiththesituationacedbywesternconsumers.Wealsocontinuetobeimpressedbytherateotechnologicalchangeinthemodernworldandthewayin

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    12/60

    10 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    mANAGerS revIe

    whichsomecompaniesareleadingthatchangeinaveryproftableway.Thelowdividendyieldstypicallyoeredbythesecompanieswillpreventusowningtheminaslargeasizeaswewouldideallylike.Theirsharepriceperormancecanalsobevolatileromoneyeartothenext.Nonetheless,ownershipocompaniessuchasinternetsearchcompaniesGoogleandBaiduandelectronicsmanuacturerSamsungElectronicsis,webelieve,likelytoprovearewardingexperienceinthelongrun.

    Bonds

    Bondmarketsagainpresenteduswithsomeveryappealinginvestmentopportunities,thebestevidenceorwhichisthe35.1%returnwhichourholdingsdeliveredduring2010.Thesewerealsosignifcantinvestmentsorus,onaveragetheymadeupjustover15%otheportolioequivalentto20%oshareholdersunds.

    ThelargestsingleholdingwasinapooledundmanagedbyLondonbasedinvestmentfrmPrytania.WeinvestedintheirAthenaDebtOpportunitiesFundduring2008butthestructureddebtinstrumentsinwhichitspecialisessueredbadlyduringthecrisisthatenguledfnancialmarkets,andcreditmarketsinparticular,duringtheclosingmonthsothatyear.Thesemarketshavestagedasignifcantrecoverysincethen,particularlyoverthelasttwelvemonthsduringwhichtheAthenaundgainedover40%.Itsunitpricenowstandsapproximately10%higherthanwhenwemadeouroriginalinvestmentandwehavealsoreceivedsignifcantinterest

    payments.

    Thenextlargestholdingisinanindex-linkedbondissuedbythegovernmentoBrazil.Wehaveheldthisbondorfveyearsnow,attractedbyitshighrealyieldandtheprospectthatBrazilscurrencywouldappreciateagainststerling.Bothactorscamegoodin2010andthesterlingvalueotheholdingrosealmost30%.

    ThesameimprovementincreditmarketswhichbolsteredtheAthenaundalsoledtolargegainsonmanyoourotherbondholdings.ThemostsignifcantothesewastheholdingintheBaillieGiordHighYieldFund.Thisundtypicallyinvestsinbondsissuedbymorehighlyindebtedcompaniesandwasanunsurprisingbenefciaryoimprovingconditionsoncreditmarketsandinthebroadereconomy.

    Withtheenvironmentsosupportiveorourholdings,wemadeewchangesduringtheyear.Ourremaininginsurancelinkedsecuritiesmaturedandthistypeobond,whicheectivelyseestheinvestorprovidinginsurancetotheissueragainstspecifednaturalcatastrophes,nolongereaturesintheportolio.Ourexperiencewiththemwasproftableandwemaytakesimilarholdingsintheutureshouldthetermslookattractive.WesoldourholdingoabondissuedbyhedgeundmanagerManGroup(andswitchedthemoneyintoManGroupshares).WealsopurchasedaoatingratenotewhoseortunesaretiedtotherentalincomeonalargeportoliooGermanresidentialandsocialhousingunits.

    Listed Investment FundsSAINTSownsanumberolistedinvestmentundswhichweuseasaconvenientwayogettingexposuretosomemarketsandassetclasses.Currentlyweownoneorestryundandseveralundsinvestedinoverseaspropertymarkets.Inaggregate,theserepresented5%otheportolioduring2010oralittleunder7%oshareholdersunds.Thereturnromtheorestryundwasadisappointing1.1%butthepropertyundsreturned42.2%.

    TheorestryholdingisaUKlistedundcalledCambiumGlobalTimberland.ThisundownsorestryplantationsinvariouslocationsaroundtheworldincludingtheUnitedStates,BrazilandAustralia.Theinvestmentwasmadeinthefrsthalo2007at100ppershareanditisdisappointingthat,asattheendo2010,theshareprice

    andtheundsnetassetvaluewerebothsignifcantlybelowthislevel(68pand80prespectively).

    TheinvestmentsinlistedpropertyundsallowustoparticipateincommercialpropertymarketsinEurope,JapanandChina.Toalargeextent,thestrongreturnsdeliveredbythispartotheportolioreectarecoveryromdistressedvaluationsthesesameundslostconsiderablevalueduringthefnancialcrisisandlargegapsemergedbetweentheirsharepricesandtheirunderlyingnetassetvalues.Aswelookorward,webelievethereisscopeorthevaluationotheseundstorise,driveneitherbyanarrowingodiscountsorbygainsontheirunderlyingportolios.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    13/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 11

    mANAGerS revIe

    Direct Property

    ThedirectinvestmentsinUKcommercialpropertyaremanagedbyOLIMLtd,aspecialistpropertymanager.Thetotalreturnor2010was12%whichcomparestothereturnontheIPDAllPropertyIndexoapproximately15%.

    Twopropertiesweresoldduringtheyearandthreepurchased.Thesetransactions,alongwithasmallcapitalgainonpropertiesheldthroughouttheyear,tookthevalueothepropertyportolioto32mbytheyearend,approximately8%othetotalportolio.Sincetheyearend,anotherpropertyhasbeenpurchasedor3mandwemaymakeurtherinvestmentsisuitablecandidates

    canbeound.WeandOLIMbelievethatcommercialpropertyvaluationsintheUKareattractive,bothinabsolutetermsandwhencomparedtoothermajorassetclassessuchasgiltsorequities.TheaverageyieldonthepropertiesthatSAINTSnowownis7.7%andwewouldexpectrentalincometogrowbroadlyinlinewithinationoverthemediumtolongterm.

    Outlook

    Atthistimelastyear,wewrotethatewinvestmentmarketsoeredcompellingvaluebutcontinuedimprovementintheglobaleconomyandstrengthincorporateproftsmightyetallowgoodinvestmentreturns.Itispossibletoargueasimilarcasenowandindeedour

    centralexpectationisthatstockmarketswillfnishtheyearhigherthantheycurrentlyare.

    Intheverynearterm,worldGDPgrowthislikelytobestrong.ThestructuralactorsunderpinninggrowthinChinaandtheotherdevelopingnationsremainfrmlyinplaceandtheircyclicalmomentumissubstantial.Growthinthedevelopedeconomiesmaybemorevariedbutshouldstillbepositive.

    Webelievethiseconomicbackdropwillallowmanycompaniestoreportrisingproftsoverthenextyear.Thisshouldbeaccompaniedbyurthergrowthindividendpaymentsandmayalsoencourageapick-upinacquisitionactivityandincorporateinvestment.

    However,theriseinstockmarketlevelsoverthelastyearhascapturedatleastsomeothisprospect.Wealsothinkthesustainabilityocurrenteconomicstrengthisopentoquestion.Anincreasingnumberothedevelopingnationsnowacerisinginationandsomehavealreadybeguntotightenmonetarypolicyinresponse.Asorthedevelopedeconomies,itisnotclearwhatunderlyingstrengthwillbeletoncethevariousfscalandmonetarystimulusprogrammesdeployedduringthefnancialcrisisarewithdrawn.

    Wesuspectwearestillinwhatwillprovealongperiodoadjustmentandchangeintheworldeconomy.Thedevelopednationsborrowedtoomuchortoolongandmustnowadjustto

    consuminglessandsavingmore.Thedevelopingnationswillcontinuetheirlongmarchtoeconomicdominancebasedontheiroverwhelmingpopulationadvantage,buttheymayhavetoproceedataslowerpacethantheywouldlikeitheyaretoavoidaseriousinationprobleminthenextewyears.

    Adjustmentandchange,onthisglobalscaleatleast,rarelyproceedinastraight,orderlyashion.Asthisreportisbeingprepared,wearebeingservedapowerulreminder(inEgyptandotherMiddleEasterncountries)thatunexpectedeventshappen.Sometimestheirimpactwillbebenign,positiveeven.Onotheroccasions,theirimpactcanbemorecostly.Eitherway,theytendtoinvokevolatilityinmarketsandcanleadtolargeswingsininvestorconfdenceandmarketlevels.

    Astohowthisimpactsourinvestmentstrategy,wethinkaslightlymorecautioustoneiswarranted.Westillexpectpositivereturns,butwouldbepleasantlysurpriseditheyapproachthelevelsenjoyedinthelasttwelvemonths.

    PatrickEdwardsonBaillieGiord&Co.18February2011

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    14/60

    12 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    perFormANCe ATTrIBuTIoN ANd dISTrIBuTIoN oF porTFolIo

    Distribution of Portfolio

    Asset Allocation as at 31 December 2010 (2009) Quoted Equities* by Sector as at 31 December 2010 (2009)

    Quoted FixedInterest

    15.4% (14.6%)

    Net Liquid Assets 1.2% (2.8%)

    Quoted

    Equities*70% (68.8%)

    Unquoted0.4% (0.5%)

    Quoted Equity

    PropertyInvestments

    2.9% (2.0%)

    Direct Property7.7% (8.5%)

    Quoted Equity ForestryInvestments2.4% (2.8%)

    Basic Materials8.9% (7.4%)

    Health Care4.1% (4.9%)

    ConsumerGoods10.4% (10.9%)

    Industrials13.9% (12.6%)

    Financials23.8% (23.2%)

    Telecommunications 2.4% (3.3%)

    Consumer Services8.4% (6.7%)

    Technology10.7% (11.2%)

    Oil and Gas15.4% (17.6%)

    Utilities2.0% (2.2%)

    * Excludesquotedequitypropertyandorestryinvestments.

    Average allocation Total returnSAINTS Benchmark SAINTS Benchmark

    Portfolio breakdown % % % %

    QuotedEquities* 89.3 100.0 19.3 15.8QuotedFixedInterest 20.1 35.1

    DirectProperty 10.0 12.0QuotedEquityForestryInvestments 3.6 1.1QuotedEquityPropertyInvestments 3.2 42.2Unquoted 0.6 3.1Deposits 2.5 Debentureatbookvalue (29.3) (6.8)Portfolio Total Return (debenture at book value) 24.2 15.8Otheritems 0.1Fund Total Return (debenture at book value) 24.3 15.8Adjustmentorchangeinairvalueodebenture (1.5)Fund Total Return (debenture at fair value) 22.8 15.8

    Theabovereturnsarecalculatedonatotalreturnsbasiswithnetincomereinvested.

    Pastperormanceisnotaguidetoutureperormance.Source:BaillieGiord&Co.

    * Excludesquotedequitypropertyandorestryinvestments.ThisincludesBaillieGiordandOLIMmanagementees,othercostsorunningthetrustsuchasmarketingexpenditureandaresidualitemwhicharisesbecauseoadisparitybetweentheNAVtotalreturnfgureandtheindividualassetclassportolioreturnnumbersascalculatedbyBaillieGiordsperormancemeasurementsystem(providedbyStatpro).

    Performance Attribution for the Year to 31 December 2010

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    15/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 13

    ThIrTy lArGeST holdINGS ANd INveSTmeNT ChANGeS

    2010 2009

    Value % of Value

    Name Classication Business 000 total assets 000

    AthenaDebtOpportunitiesFund FixedInterest Debtopportunitiesund 22,063 5.3 14,501

    BrazilCPILinked15/05/2045 FixedInterest Braziliangovernmentbond 18,780 4.5 14,487

    BaillieGiordHighYieldBondFund FixedInterest Highyieldbondund 13,545 3.2 9,663BaillieGiordGreaterChinaFund Overseas Equityinvestmentund 10,338 2.5 9,075

    CambiumGlobalTimberland QuotedEquityForestryInv Forestryinvestmentund 9,975 2.4 10,350

    AtlasCopco Overseas Engineering 8,061 1.9 3,653

    BritishAmericanTobacco UnitedKingdom Cigarettemanuacturer 7,459 1.8 6,104

    RioTinto UnitedKingdom Mining 7,089 1.7 4,509

    HolidayVillageinNewRomney DirectProperty Holidayvillage 6,800 1.6 6,500

    BHPBilliton UnitedKingdom Mining 6,735 1.6 5,267

    PennWestEnergyTrust Overseas Oilandnaturalgasincometrust 6,584 1.6 4,704

    DBS Overseas Banking 6,158 1.5 5,851

    Deere Overseas Farmmachinery 6,142 1.5 3,874

    TaiwanSemiconductorManuacturing Overseas Semiconductormanuacturer 5,669 1.4 5,013

    PhilipMorrisInternational Overseas Cigarettemanuacturer 5,574 1.3 4,444HSBC UnitedKingdom Banking 5,491 1.3 7,118

    NewYorkCommunityBank Overseas Banking 5,466 1.3 4,079

    CVRD Overseas Mining 5,428 1.3 4,318

    NursinghomeinKenilworth DirectProperty Nursinghome 5,200 1.2 5,000

    SamsungElectronics Overseas Electronicdevices 5,032 1.2 3,541

    Canon Overseas Imagingdevices 4,907 1.2 3,849

    RoyalDutchShell UnitedKingdom Integratedoil 4,865 1.2 4,165

    Petrobras Overseas Integratedoil 4,817 1.2 5,789

    ManGroup UnitedKingdom Hedgeundmanager 4,644 1.1 3,282

    QuorumOilandGas UnitedKingdom Oilindustrytechnologyund 4,250 1.0 6,255

    Massmart Overseas Foodretailer 4,249 1.0 2,255

    JapanResidentialInvestmentCompany QuotedEquityPropertyInv Japaneseresidentialpropertyund 4,172 1.0 1,600

    JeronimoMartins Overseas Discountretailer 4,169 1.0

    Vodaone UnitedKingdom Mobiletelecommunicationservices 4,052 1.0 5,463

    Aviva UnitedKingdom Lieassurance 4,048 1.0 4,079

    211,762 50.8 168,788

    Thirty Largest Holdings

    Thefguresaboveortotalassetsaremadeupototalnetassetsbeoredeductionothedebenture.

    *Excludesquotedequitypropertyandorestryinvestments.

    Investment Changes

    Valuation at Net acquisitions/ Appreciation/ Valuation at

    31 Dec 2009 (disposals) (depreciation) 31 Dec 2010

    000 000 000 000

    UnitedKingdomQuotedEquities* 106,147 (12,296) 9,026 102,877OverseasQuotedEquities* 144,926 13,338 31,755 190,019

    TotalQuotedEquities* 251,073 1,042 40,781 292,896DirectProperty 31,000 (172) 1,122 31,950QuotedEquityPropertyInvestments 7,548 1,750 3,015 12,313QuotedEquityForestryInvestments 10,350 (375) 9,975QuotedFixedInterest 53,198 (3,684) 14,705 64,219Unquoted 1,780 56 1,836

    TotalInvestments 354,949 (1,064) 59,304 413,189NetLiquidAssets 10,118 (4,339) (699) 5,080

    TotalAssets 365,067 (5,403) 58,605 418,269

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    16/60

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    17/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 15

    lIST oF INveSTmeNTS AS AT 31 deCemBer 2010

    Value

    Classication Name 000 %

    UnitedKingdomQuotedEquities*

    Oilandgasproducers BGGroup 3,033 BP 2,928 RoyalDutchShell 4,865 TullowOil 1,513

    12,339 3.0Oilequipment,servicesanddistribution Amec 2,246 QuorumOilandGas 4,250 WellstreamHoldings 1,345 WoodGroup 2,792

    10,633 2.5

    Chemicals Victrex 2,924 0.7

    Mining BHPBilliton 6,735 RioTinto 7,089

    13,824 3.3

    Generalindustrials Rexam 2,803 0.7

    Industrialengineering LupusCapital 440 0.1Supportservices Capita 1,750 Hays 1,791

    3,541 0.8

    Tobacco BritishAmericanTobacco 7,459 ImperialTobacco 3,720

    11,179 2.7

    Pharmaceuticalsandbiotechnology GlaxoSmithKline 3,050 0.7

    Foodanddrugretailers Tesco 2,584 0.6

    Media ReedElsevier 1,983 0.5

    Mobiletelecommunications Vodaone 4,052 1.0

    Electricity Scottish&SouthernEnergy 3,185 0.8

    Gas,waterandmulti-utilities NationalGrid 2,710 0.6

    Banks Barclays 2,092 HSBC 5,491

    7,583 1.8

    Nonlieinsurance Amlin 2,307 Hiscox 1,135

    3,442 0.8

    Lieinsurance Aviva 4,048 1.0

    Realestate TerraCatalystFund 3,302 0.8

    Generalfnancial ManGroup 4,644 1.1

    Equityinvestmentinstruments BlackrockLatinAmerican 1,724 DamilleInvestments 978 LevelEMayaFund 1,909

    4,611 1.1

    Total United Kingdom Quoted Equities* 102,877 24.6

    *Excludesquotedequitypropertyandorestryinvestments.Comprisesaholdinginaconvertiblesecurity.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    18/60

    16 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    lIST oF INveSTmeNTS AS AT 31 deCemBer 2010

    Value

    Classication Name 000 %

    OverseasQuotedEquities*

    Oilandgasproducers Gazprom 3,132 Lukoil 2,011 OGXPetroleo 1,228 PennWestEnergyTrust 6,584 Petrobras 4,817 Total 3,567

    21,339 5.3

    Chemicals Monsanto 1,401 0.3

    Mining CVRD 5,428ImpalaPlatinum 2,328

    7,756 1.9

    Electronicandelectricalequipment Canon 4,907 1.2

    Industrialengineering AtlasCopco 8,061 Deere 6,142 Schindler 3,789

    17,992 4.3

    Industrialtransportation SichuanExpressway 1,783 UnitedParcelService 2,549 ZhejiangExpressway 3,187

    7,519 1.8

    Supportservices Brambles 2,457 Meitec 1,026

    3,483 0.8

    Automobilesandparts HeroHondaMotors 2,479 0.6

    Foodproducers Nestl 3,534 0.8

    Leisuregoods Nintendo 2,121 0.5

    Personalgoods LOral 2,520 0.6

    Tobacco Altria 3,523 PhilipMorrisInternational 5,574

    9,097 2.1

    Pharmaceuticalsandbiotechnology JohnsonandJohnson 2,607 Novozymes 1,706 RocheHoldings 2,653 TevaPharmaceuticals 2,309

    9,275 2.2

    Foodanddrugretailers JeronimoMartins 4,169 Massmart 4,249 McDonalds 2,696 Walgreen 2,006

    13,120 3.1Generalretailers Amazon.com 2,298 DutyFreeShops 930 eBay 1,403 Walmex 2,758

    7,389 1.7

    Mobiletelecommunications ChinaMobile 3,067 0.7

    Banks DBS 6,158 ItauUnibanco 2,074 NewYorkCommunityBank 5,466 StandardBankGroup 2,632 SvenskaHandelsbanken 3,342

    19,672 4.7

    Nonlieinsurance Progressive 1,382 0.3

    *Excludesquotedequitypropertyandorestryinvestments.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    19/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 17

    lIST oF INveSTmeNTS AS AT 31 deCemBer 2010

    Value

    Classication Name 000 %

    OverseasQuotedEquitiescont.*

    Generalfnancial BM&FBovespa 1,687 HongKongExchangesandClearing 2,135 Moodys 1,514 PartnersGroup 4,003

    9,339 2.3Equityinvestmentinstruments BaillieGiordGreaterChinaFund 10,338 VisionOpportunitiesChinaFund 958

    11,296 2.7

    Sotwareandcomputerservices Baidu.com 2,232 Exact 2,261 Google 1,517 InspurInternational 793 Microsot 2,423 SAP 3,057 SoleraHoldings 2,092 TaiwanSemiconductorManuacturing 5,669

    20,044 4.8

    Technologyhardwareandequipment AsustekComputer 1,036 CiscoSystems 1,083 LinearTechnology 3,714 Pegatron 422 SamsungElectronics 5,032

    11,287 2.7

    Total Overseas Quoted Equities* 190,019 45.4

    Total Quoted Equities* 292,896 70.0

    DirectProperty

    Directproperty Seetableoverlea 31,950 7.7

    QuotedEquityPropertyInvestments

    FukuokaREIT 3,506 InvistaEuropeanRealEstateTrust 909 JapanResidentialInvestmentCompany 4,172 TamarEuropeanIndustrialFund 1,050 TreasuryChinaTrust 2,676

    Total Quoted Equity Property Investments 12,313 2.9

    QuotedEquityForestryInvestments

    CambiumGlobalTimberland 9,975 2.4

    *Excludesquotedpropertyandorestryinvestments.Includesaholdinginpreerenceshares

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    20/60

    18 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    Value

    Classication Name 000 %

    lIST oF INveSTmeNTS ANd properTy porTFolIo AS AT 31 deCemBer 2010

    2010 2009

    Value % of Value

    Location Type Tenant 000 total assets 000

    Dundee PublicHouse JDWetherspoonPlc 1,050 0.3 1,100

    Dunermline Shop WHSmithRetailHoldingsLtd 2,300 0.5 2,300Earley PublicHouse PunchPubCompany(Pubs)Ltd 2,800 0.7 2,800Kenilworth NursingHome TrinityCareLtd 5,200 1.2 5,000

    MarketDeeping Warehouse AdvancedHandling 900 0.2 NewRomney HolidayVillage ParkResortsLtd 6,800 1.6 6,500Nottingham Soldin2010 3,500Oban Shop WHSmithRetailHoldingsLtd 1,600 0.4 1,550Otord PublicHouse PunchPubCompany(Pubs)Ltd 1,900 0.5 1,850Perth Bank BankoScotland 2,650 0.6 Portsmouth PublicHouse JDWetherspoonPlc 2,200 0.5 2,250Reading Restaurant BellaItaliaRestaurantsLtd 1,150 0.3 1,200

    Redditch Warehouse WestonBodyHardware 1,150 0.3 Torquay PublicHouse Mitchells&ButlerRetailLtd 1,100 0.3 1,100Weybridge Soldin2010 700Winchester PublicHouse FullerSmith&TurnerPlc 1,150 0.3 1,150

    31,950 7.7 31,000

    Property Portfolio

    QuotedFixedInterest

    Sterlingdenominated BaillieGiordHighYieldBondFund 13,545 BarclaysBank14%2019 3,593 CQSRigFinanceFundC 612 Resolution6.5864%2016 2,657

    20,407 4.8Eurodenominated GermanResidentialDFRN2016 1,502 SemperFinanceFRNSLP2015 1,467

    2,969 0.8

    USdollardenominated AthenaDebtOpportunitiesFund 22,063 5.3

    Brazilianrealdenominated BrazilCPILinked15/05/2045 18,780 4.5

    Total Quoted Fixed Interest 64,219 15.4

    Unquoted 1,836 0.4

    Net Liquid Assets 5,080 1.2

    Total Assets 418,269 100.0

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    21/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 19

    Debenture Net asset Net asset Premium/ Premium/At Total stocks Shareholders value per value per Share (discount ) (discount) 31 December assets and loans funds share (book) * share (fair) * price (book) (fair)

    000 000 000 p p p % %

    2000 543,251 78,471 464,780 296.8 254.5 (14.3) 2001 422,850 90,274 332,576 225.7 192.3 (14.8)

    2002 312,634 89,767 222,867 161.9 132.8 (18.0) 2003 340,546 89,260 251,286 185.8 181.9 149.3 (19.6) (17.9)2004 361,691 89,760 271,931 205.3 197.1 167.5 (18.4) (15.0)2005 426,021 89,430 336,591 254.1 241.2 218.8 (13.9) (9.3)2006 462,673 89,079 373,594 282.0 272.6 241.3 (14.4) (11.5)2007 460,094 88,708 371,386 280.3 272.7 240.0 (14.4) (12.0)2008 289,087 88,312 200,775 151.5 145.3 130.5 (13.9) (10.2)2009 365,067 87,892 277,175 209.2 206.0 181.0 (13.5) (12.1)2010 418,269 87,446 330,823 249.7 242.5 245.5 (1.7) 1.2

    Capital

    * Netassetvalueperordinarysharehasbeencalculatedaterdeductingthedebentureateitherbookvalueorairvalue. Premium/(discount)isthedierencebetweenSAINTSquotedsharepriceanditsunderlyingnetassetvalueateitherbookvalueorairvalue.

    Available Earnings DividendYear to Gross for ordinary per ordinary per ordinary Expense Actual Potential31 December revenue shareholders share share (net) ratio gearing gearing

    000 000 p p %

    2000 13,346 7,794 4.87 5.53 0.41 103 1172001 12,551 8,337 5.46 5.57 0.20 100 1272002 12,075 7,932 5.64 5.61 0.23 99 1402003 11,412 7,913 5.82 5.65 0.13 103 1362004 13,707 8,379 6.30 6.00 0.96 106 1332005 13,986 9,000 6.80 6.53 0.80 110 1272006 15,326 10,002 7.55 7.40 0.78 105 1242007 17,751 11,345 8.56 8.25 0.80 105 1242008 20,901 13,905 10.50 8.80 0.84 100 144

    2009 17,194 11,989 9.05 9.05 1.02 97 1322010 16,379 11,271 8.51 9.25 0.90 96 126

    ThecalculationoearningsperordinaryshareisbasedontherevenuecolumnothereturnonordinaryactivitiesatertaxationintheIncomeStatementandtheweightedaveragenumberoordinarysharesinissue.

    Ratioototaloperatingcoststoaverageshareholdersunds. Totalassets(includingalldebtusedorinvestmentpurposes)lesscash,fxedinterestsecurities(exconvertibles)andpropertydividedbyshareholdersunds. Totalassets(includingalldebtusedorinvestmentpurposes)dividedbyshareholdersunds.

    Revenue Gearing Ratios

    BaillieGiord&CowasappointedasInvestmentManagersandSecretariesotheCompanywitheectrom1January2004.OnthesamedatetheCompanyalsochangeditsbenchmarkrom65%FTSEAll-ShareIndexand35%FTSEWorldExUKIndexto70%FTSEAll-ShareIndexand30%FTSEWorldExUKIndex.Witheectrom1January2009,theCompanysbencharkbecame50%FTSEAll-ShareIndexand50%FTSEAll-WorldexUKIndex.Forthepurposesotheabovetablesthereturnsonthesebenchmarksortheirrespectiveperiodshavebeenlinkedtoormasinglebenchmark. Thefgurespriorto2004havenotbeenrestatedorthechangesinaccountingpoliciesimplementedin2005.

    Pastperormanceisnotaguidetoutureperormance.

    Net asset Net asset Share Benchmark Earnings Dividend per Retail

    At value value Share price total total per ordinary ordinary price31 December per share total return price return Benchmark return share share (net) index

    2000 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 1002001 76 78 76 77 85 86 112 101 1012002 55 57 52 55 62 65 116 101 1042003 63 68 59 65 73 79 120 102 1072004 69 78 66 76 79 88 129 108 1102005 86 99 86 103 94 108 140 118 1132006 95 112 95 117 104 123 155 134 1182007 94 115 94 120 108 131 176 149 1222008 51 64 51 68 77 97 216 159 1242009 70 94 71 101 93 121 186 164 1272010 84 118 96 143 105 140 175 167 133

    Compound annual returns

    5year (0.4%) 3.6% 2.3% 6.8% 2.1% 5.4% 4.6% 7.2% 3.3%10year (1.7%) 1.7% (0.4%) 3.6% 0.5% 3.5% 5.8% 5.3% 2.9%

    Cumulative Performance (taking 2000 as 100)

    TeN yeAr reCord

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    22/60

    20 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    Directors Report

    TheDirectorshavepleasureinsubmittingtheirAnnualReporttogetherwiththeresultsotheCompanyortheyearto31December2010.

    Business Review

    Business and StatusTheCompanyisaninvestmentcompanywithinthemeaningosection833otheCompaniesAct2006.

    TheCompanycarriesonbusinessasaninvestmenttrust.ItwasapprovedbyHMRevenue&Customsasaninvestmenttrustundersection842otheIncomeandCorporationTaxesAct1988ortheyearended31December2009,subjecttoanymattersthatmay

    ariseromanysubsequentenquirybyHMRevenue&CustomsintotheCompanystaxreturn.IntheopinionotheDirectorstheCompanyhassubsequentlyconducteditsaairssoastoenableittocontinuetoseekapprovalundersection1158otheCorporationTaxAct2010(ormerlysection842ICTA1988)eachyear.

    Objective and PolicySAINTSobjectiveistoincreasecapitalandgrowincomeinordertodeliverrealdividendgrowth.

    SAINTSpolicyistoinvestexiblyandactivelyacrossabroadrangeoassetsandmarkets.Listedequities,bothUKandoverseas,ormthelargestpartotheportolio.Investmentsarealsomadeinbonds,propertyandotherassetclasses.

    TheBoardbelievesthataexibleapproachtoinvestmentisimportant.Asmarketvaluationsacrossandwithindierentassetclassesvaryovertime,theabilitytoadjustassetallocationandportoliopositioninginresponsetothesevariationsisimportant.Therearenopre-defnedmaximumorminimumexposurelevelsorassetclasses,sectorsorregions.

    TheBoardalsobelievesthatamediumtolongtermapproachislikelytoleadtothebestinvestmentreturns.SAINTSperormanceinanyoneyearislikelytodierromthatoitsbenchmarkindex,sometimesbyasignifcantamount.Financialmarketsarevolatile,particularlyovershorttimeperiods,buttheManagerisencouragedtoviewsuchvolatilityasgivingrisetoinvestmentopportunitiesrather

    thanasarisktobeavoided.

    Inordertoachieverealgrowthinthedividend,theincomegeneratedromSAINTSassetsneedstogrowoverthemediumtolongertermataasterratethanination.Consequently,theocusotheportolioisonlistedequities.Investmentsareregularlyconsideredandmadeinabroadrangeootherassettypesandmarkets.DerivativeandstructuredinstrumentsmayalsobeusedwithpriorBoardapproval,eithertohedgeanexistinginvestmentoracurrencyexposureortoexploitaninvestmentopportunity.

    TheequityportolioconsistsoshareslistedbothintheUKandinoverseasmarkets.Theportolioisdiversifedacrossarangeoholdingswithlittleregardpaidtotheweightingoindividual

    companiesinthecompositebenchmarkindex.Thenumberoindividualcompanieswillvaryovertimeandtheportolioismanagedonaglobalbasisratherthanasaseriesoregionalsub-portolios.

    InvestmentsaremadeinmarketsotherthanlistedequitymarketswhenprospectivereturnsappeartobesuperiortothoseromequitymarketsorareconsideredlikelytoexceedSAINTSborrowingcosts.Thelistotheseotherinvestmentswillvaryromtimetotimeasopportunitiesareidentifedbutincludeinvestmentgradebonds,highyieldbonds,property,orestry,privateequityandotherassettypes.

    Asaninvestmenttrust,SAINTSisabletoborrowmoneyanddoessowhentheBoardandManagershavesufcientconvictionthatthe

    assetsundedbyborrowedmonieswillgenerateareturninexcessothecostoborrowing.Wheneverlongtermborrowingscannotbeullyinvestedinsuchmanner,theborrowedundsareusedtopurchaseadiversifedportolioosimilarmaturitybondstotheborrowings.Thishastheeectohedgingoutmuchotheinterestrateriskandremovingthemismatchbetweenborrowingcostsandassociatedinvestmentreturns.GearinglevelsarediscussedbytheBoardandManagersateveryBoardmeetingandmonitoredbetweenmeetings.TheBoardwillnottakeoutadditionalborrowingsithistakestheleveloeectivegearingbeyond130%.

    dIreCTorS reporT

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    23/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 21

    Thestartingpositionorinvestmentoshareholderundsis100%exposuretoequitymarkets.TheallocationtoequitymarketsatanypointintimewillreecttheBoardsandManagersviewson

    prospectivereturnsromequitiesandtheullrangeoalternativeinvestmentopportunitiesbut,inbroadterms,SAINTSwillgearupthroughtheuseoborrowingsiequitymarketslookundervaluedandwillholdcashorinvestinnon-equityassetswhenequitymarketslookovervalued.

    Theexposuretolistedequitiesissetwithinarangeo75%to125%oshareholdersundsinnormalcircumstances.Thenumberoindividualequitiesheldwillvaryovertimebut,inordertodiversiyrisk,willtypicallybeinarangebetween50and100.

    TheBoardmonitorstheaggregateexposuretoanyoneentityacrossthewholeinvestmentportolio.Themaximumexposureattimeoinvestmenttoanyoneentityis15%ototalassets.TheBoardis

    notifedinadvanceoanytransactionthatwouldtakeanindividualequityholdingabove5%oshareholdersunds.SAINTSdoesromtimetotimeinvestinotherUKlistedinvestmentcompanies.Themaximumpermittedinvestmentinsuchcompaniesis15%ogrossassets.

    AdetailedanalysisotheCompanysinvestmentportolioissetoutonpages12to18.

    Board OversightWhenassessingtheperormanceotheCompanyandtheManagers,theBoardlooksatdividendgrowthandatnetassetvaluetotalreturnsrelativetothebenchmarktotalreturn.TheBoardbelievesitisappropriatetomakethisassessmentoveramediumto

    longtermtimerame,atleastthreetofveyears,inaccordancewiththemediumtolongtermapproachtakentoinvestment.

    TheBoardmonitorscloselytheactivitiesotheManagers,thecompositionotheinvestmentportolioandthelevelogearingtoensuretheseexposuresareidentifedandtojudgewhetherornotprospectiveinvestmentreturnsarecommensuratewiththenatureandsizeotheseexposures.

    TheBoardsetsanumberoguidelinesandplaceslimitsandrestrictionsontheManagersinordertominimisetheriskopermanentlossocapital.Withintheseconstraints,theBoardencouragestheManagertomaximiselongtermcapitalandincomegrowthratherthanminimiseshorttermvolatilityinthecapitalvalue

    otheinvestmentportolio.ThemainsourceobothlongtermreturnandshorttermvolatilityintheSAINTSportolioislikelytobetheinvestmentsinlistedequities.

    TheBoardalsomonitorsSAINTSrevenuepositionandreceivesregularestimatesromtheManagersolikelyincomegrowth.Thelevelodividendinanyoneyearissetaterassessingtheincomegeneratedbytheportoliointhatyear,thelevelorevenuereservesandlongtermtrendsinincome.

    Discount/PremiumTheBoardhaspowerstobuybackitsownsharesatadiscounttonetassetvalueandtoholdsuchsharesintreasuryaswellastoissuenewsharesandre-issuetreasurysharesatapremiumtonetassetvalue.

    Buy-backpowershavebeenusedinthepastincircumstanceswhenlargelinesostockcannotbeabsorbedbythemarket.Thediscount,inabsolutetermsandrelativetoothersimilarinvestmenttrustcompanies,andthecompositionotheshareregisterisdiscussedateveryBoardmeeting.WhilethereisnodiscounttargettheBoardisawarethatdiscountvolatilityisunwelcometomanyshareholdersandthatsharepriceperormanceisthemeasureusedbymostinvestors.TheBoardoverseestheManagersmarketingprogrammewhichisdesignedtostimulatedemandortheCompanysshares,provideeectivecommunicationtoexistingandpotential

    shareholdersandmaintaintheprofleotheCompany.PerformanceAteachBoardmeeting,theDirectorsconsideranumberoperormancemeasurestoassesstheCompanyssuccessinachievingitsobjectives.

    Thekeyperormanceindicators(KPIs)usedtomeasuretheprogressandperormanceotheCompanyovertimeareestablishedindustrymeasuresandareasollows:

    themovementinnetassetvalueperordinaryshare(aterdeductingdebenturesatairvalue)comparedtothebenchmark;

    themovementintheshareprice;

    thediscount(aterdeductingdebenturesatairvalue);

    thetotalexpenseratio;

    earningspershare;and

    dividendpershare.

    Ahistoricalrecordothesemeasuresisshownonpages2,3and19.

    Inadditiontotheabove,theBoardconsiderspeergroupcomparativeperormance.

    ResultsThenetassetvaluepersharerose17.7%,comparedtoariseinthebenchmarko12.7%,dividendsincreasedby2.2%to9.25ppershareandtheCompanyssharepricemovedromadiscounto12.1%toapremiumo1.2%.

    DividendsTheBoardrecommendsafnaldividendo2.35pperordinarysharewhich,togetherwiththeinterimdividendsalreadypaid,makesatotalo9.25portheyear.

    Iapproved,therecommendedfnaldividendontheordinaryshareswillbepaidon11April2011toshareholdersontheregisteratthecloseobusinesson11March2011.Theex-dividenddateis9March2011.TheCompanysRegistraroersaDividendReinvestmentPlan(seepage52)andthefnaldateorelectionsorreinvestmentothisdividendis21March2011.

    dIreCTorS reporT

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    24/60

    22 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    Review of the Year and Future TrendsAreviewotheyearandtheinvestmentoutlookiscontainedintheChairmansStatementandtheManagersReview.

    Principal Risks and UncertaintiesTheCompanysassetsconsistmainlyolistedsecuritiesanditsprincipalrisksarethereoremarketrelatedandincludemarketrisk(comprisingcurrencyrisk,interestrateriskandotherpricerisk),liquidityriskandcreditrisk.Anexplanationothoserisksandhowtheyaremanagediscontainedinnote19tothefnancialstatementsonpages44to48.

    OtherrisksacedbytheCompanyincludetheollowing:

    Regulatory RiskailuretocomplywithapplicablelegalandregulatoryrequirementscouldleadtosuspensionotheCompanysStockExchangeListing,fnancialpenaltiesoraqualifedaudit

    report.Breachosection1158otheCorporationTaxAct2010(ormerlysection842ICTA1988)couldleadtotheCompanybeingsubjecttotaxoncapitalgains.TheManagersmonitorinvestmentmovementsandtheleveloorecastincomeandexpendituretoensuretheprovisionsosection1158arenotbreached.BaillieGiordsHeadsoBusinessRisk&InternalAuditandRegulatoryRiskprovideregularreportstotheAuditCommitteeonBaillieGiordsmonitoringprogrammes.

    Operational/Financial Risk ailureotheManagersaccountingsystemsorthoseootherthirdpartyserviceproviderscouldleadtoaninabilitytoprovideaccuratereportingandmonitoringoramisappropriationoassets.TheBoardreviewstheManagersReportonInternalControlsandthereportsbyotherkeythirdpartyproviders

    arereviewedbytheManagersonbehalotheBoard.Discount VolatilitythediscountatwhichtheCompanyssharestradecanwiden.TheBoardmonitorsthelevelodiscountandtheCompanyhasauthoritytobuybackitsownshares.

    Gearing RisktheCompanymayborrowmoneyorinvestmentpurposes(sometimesknownasgearing).Itheinvestmentsallinvalue,anyborrowingswillmagniytheextentothisloss.Iborrowingacilitiesarenotrenewed,theCompanymayhavetosellinvestmentstorepayborrowings.

    AllborrowingsrequirethepriorapprovalotheBoardandgearinglevelsarediscussedbytheBoardandManagersateverymeeting.ThemajorityotheCompanysinvestmentsareinquotedsecurities

    thatarereadilyrealisable.

    EmployeesTheCompanyhasnoemployees.TheexecutiveresponsibilityorinvestmentmanagementhasbeendelegatedtoBaillieGiord&Co.

    Social and Community IssuesAsaninvestmenttrust,theCompanyhasnodirectsocialorcommunityresponsibilities.TheCompanyhoweverbelievesthatitisinshareholdersintereststoconsiderenvironmentalsocialandgovernanceactorswhenselectingandretaininginvestments.DetailsotheCompanyspolicyonsociallyresponsibleinvestmentcanbeoundunderCorporateGovernanceandStewardshiponpage25.

    Corporate Governance

    TheBoardiscommittedtoachievinganddemonstratinghigh

    standardsoCorporateGovernance.ThisstatementoutlineshowtheprinciplesoTheCombinedCodeonCorporateGovernance,publishedin2008(theCombinedCode)wereappliedthroughoutthefnancialyear.

    ComplianceTheBoardconfrmsthattheCompanyhascompliedthroughouttheyearunderreviewwiththerelevantprovisionsotheCombinedCode.TheAssociationoInvestmentCompanies(AIC)haspublisheditsownCodeoCorporateGovernancewhichprovidesarameworkobestpracticeorinvestmentcompanies.TheBoardisotheopinionthattheCompanyhascompliedwiththerecommendationsotheAICCode.

    The BoardTheBoardhasoverallresponsibilityortheCompanysaairsandithassetoutanumberomattersthataresubjecttoBoardapprovalincludingstrategy,investmentpolicy,currencyhedging,gearing,treasurymatters,dividendandcorporategovernancepolicy.Aseparatemeetingdevotedtostrategyisheldeachyear.TheBoardalsoreviewsthefnancialstatements,investmenttransactions,revenuebudgetsandperormance.FullandtimelyinormationisprovidedtotheBoardtoenabletheBoardtounctioneectivelyandtoallowDirectorstodischargetheirresponsibilities.

    TheBoardcurrentlycomprisessevenDirectorsallowhomarenon-executive.TheexecutiveresponsibilityorinvestmentmanagementhasbeendelegatedtotheCompanysManagersandSecretaries,

    BaillieGiord&Co,and,inthecontextoaBoardcomprisedentirelyonon-executiveDirectors,thereisnochieexecutiveofcer.TheseniorindependentdirectorisDavidPrice.

    TheDirectorsbelievethattheBoardhasabalanceoskillsandexperiencewhichenablesittoprovideeectivestrategicleadershipandpropergovernanceotheCompany.InormationabouttheDirectors,includingtheirrelevantexperience,canbeoundonpage6.

    ThereisanagreedprocedureorDirectorstoseekindependentproessionaladviceinecessaryandattheCompanysexpense.

    Terms of AppointmentLetterswhichspeciythetermsoappointmentareissuedtonew

    Directors.Thelettersoappointmentareavailableorinspectiononrequest.

    ADirectorappointedduringtheyearisrequiredtoretireandseekelectionbyshareholdersatthenextAnnualGeneralMeeting.TheBoardhasagreedtogobeyondtheminimumrequirementsotheCompanysArticlesoAssociationandTheCombinedCodeandhasresolvedthatallotheDirectorswillretireateachAnnualGeneralMeetingand,iappropriate,oerthemselvesorre-election.

    Independence of DirectorsAllDirectorsareconsideredbytheBoardtobeindependentotheManagersandreeoanybusinessorotherrelationshipwhichcouldintererewiththeexerciseotheirindependentjudgement.

    dIreCTorS reporT

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    25/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 23

    dIreCTorS reporT

    SirBrianIvoryandMrDavidPricehaveservedontheBoardormorethannineyears,althoughtherehasonlybeenarelationshipwiththeManagersorsevenyearsasBaillieGiordwereappointed

    in2004.TheDirectorsrecognisetheimportanceosuccessionplanningorcompanyboardsandreviewtheBoardcompositionannually.HowevertheBoardisotheviewthatlengthoservicewillnotnecessarilycompromisetheindependenceorcontributionoDirectorsoaninvestmenttrustcompany,wherecontinuityandexperiencecanbeabenefttotheBoard.TheBoardconcurswiththeviewexpressedintheAICCodethatlong-servingDirectorsshouldnotbepreventedrombeingconsideredindependent.Followingaormalperormanceevaluation,theBoardhasconcludedthat,notwithstandingtheirlengthoserviceSirBrianIvoryandMrDavidPriceremainindependent.TheiractionsanddecisionshaveconfrmedtheirindependenceandtheDirectorsbelievetheirlengthoservicehasbeenabenefttotheBoard.

    MeetingsThereisanannualcycleoBoardmeetingswhichisdesignedtoaddress,inasystematicway,overallstrategy,reviewoinvestmentpolicy,investmentperormance,marketing,revenuebudgets,dividendpolicyandcommunicationwithshareholders.TheBoardconsidersthatitmeetssufcientlyregularlytodischargeitsdutieseectively.ThetableonthispageshowstheattendancerecordortheBoardandCommitteemeetingsheldduringtheyear.AllDirectorsattendedtheAnnualGeneralMeeting.

    Nomination CommitteeTheNominationCommitteeconsistsothewholeBoardandtheChairmanotheBoardisChairmanotheCommittee.

    TheCommitteemeetsonanannualbasisandatsuchothertimesasmayberequired.TheCommitteehaswrittentermsoreerencewhichincludereviewingtheBoard,identiyingandnominatingnewcandidatesorappointmenttotheBoard,Boardappraisal,successionplanningandtraining.TheCommitteealsoconsiderswhetherDirectorsshouldberecommendedorre-electionbyshareholders.TheCommitteeisresponsibleorconsideringDirectorspotentialconictsointerestandormakingrecommendationstotheBoardonwhetherornotthepotentialconictsshouldbeauthorised.TheCommitteestermsoreerenceareavailableonrequestromtheCompanyandromtheSAINTSpageontheManagerswebsitewww.saints-it.com.

    Performance EvaluationAnappraisalotheChairman,eachDirectorandaperormanceevaluationandreviewotheBoardasawholeanditsCommitteeswascarriedoutduringtheyear.TheChairmanandeachDirectorcompletedaperormanceevaluationquestionnaireandeachDirectorhadaninterviewwiththeChairman.TheappraisalotheChairmanwasledbyMrDavidPrice.Theappraisalsandevaluationsconsidered,amongstothercriteria,thebalanceoskillsotheBoard,thecontributionoindividualDirectorsandtheoveralleectivenessotheBoardanditsCommittees.FollowingthisprocessitwasconcludedthattheperormanceoeachDirector,theChairman,theBoardanditsCommitteescontinuestobeeectiveandeachDirectorandtheChairmanremainscommittedtotheCompany.

    AreviewotheChairmansandotherDirectorscommitmentswascarriedoutandtheNominationCommitteeissatisfedthattheyarecapableodevotingsufcienttimetotheCompany.TherewerenosignifcantchangestotheChairmansothercommitmentsduringtheyear.

    Induction and TrainingNewDirectorsareprovidedwithaninductionprogrammewhichistailoredtotheparticularcircumstancesotheappointee.RegularbriefngsareprovidedonchangesinregulatoryrequirementsthatcouldaecttheCompanyandtheDirectors.Directorsreceiveotherrelevanttrainingasnecessary.

    RemunerationAsalltheDirectorsarenon-executive,theprovisionsotheCombinedCodeinrespectoDirectorsremunerationarenotrelevanttotheCompanyexcepttotheextentthattheyrelatespecifcallytonon-executivedirectors.ConsequentlythereisnorequirementoraseparateRemunerationCommittee.DirectorseesareconsideredbytheBoardasawholewithinthelimitsapprovedbyshareholders.

    TheCompanyspolicyonremunerationissetoutintheDirectorsRemunerationReportonpages28and29.

    Internal Controls and Risk ManagementTheDirectorsacknowledgetheirresponsibilityortheCompanyssystemointernalcontrolsandorreviewingitseectiveness.Thesystemointernalcontrolsisdesignedtomanageratherthaneliminatetheriskoailuretoachievebusinessobjectivesandcanonlyprovidereasonableandnotabsoluteassuranceagainstmaterialmisstatementorloss.

    TheBoardconfrmsthatthereisaprocessoridentiying,evaluatingandmanagingthesignifcantrisksacedbytheCompanyinaccordancewiththeguidanceInternalControl:RevisedGuidance

    orDirectorsontheCombinedCode.TheDirectorsconfrmthattheyhavereviewedtheeectivenessothesystemointernalcontrolandtheyhaveproceduresinplacetoensureregularuturereviews.

    Thepracticalmeasurestoensurecompliancewithregulationandcompanylaw,andtoprovideeectiveandefcientoperationsandinvestmentmanagement,havebeendelegatedtotheManagersandSecretaries,BaillieGiord&Co,underthetermsotheManagementAgreement.Thepracticalmeasuresinrelationtothedesign,implementationandmaintenanceocontrolpoliciesandprocedurestosaeguardtheassetsotheCompanyandtomanageitsaairsproperly,includingthemaintenanceo

    eectiveoperationalandcompliancecontrolsandriskmanagementhavealsobeendelegatedtoBaillieGiord&Co.TheBoardacknowledgesitsresponsibilitiestosuperviseandcontrolthedischargebytheManagersandSecretariesotheirobligations.

    Directors Attendance at Meetings

    Audit Nomination

    Board Committee Committee

    Number of meetings 6 2 1

    SirBrianIvory 6 2 1TheRtHonSirMenziesCampbell 6 2 1EricHagman 6 2 1LordKerroKinlochard 6 2 1RachelLomax 6 2 1PeterMoon 6 2 1DavidPrice 6 2 1

    http://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspx
  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    26/60

    24 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    TheBaillieGiord&CoHeadsoBusinessRisk&InternalAuditandRegulatoryRiskprovidetheAuditCommitteewithregularreportsonBaillieGiord&Cosmonitoringprogrammes.Thereporting

    proceduresorthesedepartmentsaredefnedandormalisedwithinaservicelevelagreement.BaillieGiord&CoconductsanannualreviewoitssystemointernalcontrolswhichisdocumentedwithinaninternalcontrolsreportwhichcomplieswithTechnicalReleaseAAF01/06AssuranceReportsonInternalControlsoServiceOrganisationsmadeavailabletoThirdParties.ThisreportisindependentlyreviewedbyBaillieGiord&CosauditorsandacopyissubmittedtotheAuditCommittee.

    TheCompanysinvestmentsaresegregatedromthoseoBaillieGiord&CoanditsotherclientsthroughtheappointmentoTheBankoNewYorkMellonasindependentcustodianotheCompanysinvestments.

    Adetailedriskmapispreparedwhichidentifesthesignifcantrisks

    acedbytheCompanyandthekeycontrolstomanagetheserisksareconfrmedasinplaceandoperatingeectively.

    TheseproceduresensurethatconsiderationisgivenregularlytothenatureandextentotherisksacingtheCompanyandthattheyarebeingactivelymonitored.Wherechangesinriskhavebeenidentifedduringtheyeartheyalsoprovideamechanismtoassesswhetherurtheractionisrequiredtomanagetherisksidentifed.TheBoardconfrmsthattheseprocedureshavebeeninplacethroughouttheCompanysfnancialyearandcontinuetobeinplaceuptothedateoapprovalothisReport.

    Internal AuditTheAuditCommitteecarriesoutanannualreviewotheneedoran

    internalauditunction.TheCommitteecontinuestobelievethatthecomplianceandinternalcontrolsystemsandtheinternalauditunctioninplacewithintheInvestmentManagersprovidesufcientassurancethatasoundsystemointernalcontrol,whichsaeguardsshareholdersinvestmentandtheCompanysassets,ismaintained.Aninternalauditunction,specifctotheCompany,isthereoreconsideredunnecessary.

    Accountability and AuditTherespectiveresponsibilitiesotheDirectorsandtheAuditorsinconnectionwiththeFinancialStatementsaresetoutonpages30and31.

    Going Concern

    InaccordancewithTheFinancialReportingCouncilsguidanceongoingconcernandliquidityriskissuedin2009,theDirectorshaveundertakenarigorousreviewotheCompanysabilitytocontinueasagoingconcern.

    TheCompanysprincipalrisksaremarketrelatedandincludemarketrisk,liquidityriskandcreditrisk.Anexplanationotheserisksandhowtheyaremanagediscontainedinnote19tothefnancialstatements.TheCompanysassets,themajorityowhichareinvestmentsinquotedsecuritieswhicharereadilyrealisable,exceeditsliabilitiessignifcantly.AllborrowingsrequirethepriorapprovalotheBoard.GearinglevelsandcompliancewithborrowingcovenantsarereviewedbytheBoardonaregularbasis.TheCompanyhasnoshorttermborrowingsandtheredemption

    dateortheCompanysDebentureisApril2022.Accordingly,thefnancialstatementshavebeenpreparedonthegoingconcernbasisasitistheDirectorsopinionthattheCompanywillcontinueinoperationalexistenceortheoreseeableuture.

    Audit CommitteeAnAuditCommitteehasbeenestablishedconsistingoallDirectors.ItsauthorityanddutiesareclearlydefnedwithinitswrittentermsoreerencewhichareavailableonrequestromtheCompanyandontheSAINTSpageotheManagerswebsitewww.saints-it.com.EricHagmanischairmanotheAuditCommittee.TheCommitteesresponsibilities,whichweredischargedduringtheyear,include:

    monitoringandreviewingtheintegrityothehal-yearlyand

    annualfnancialstatementsandanyormalannouncementsrelatingtotheCompanysfnancialperormance;

    reviewingstandardsointernalcontrolandriskmanagement;

    makingrecommendationstotheBoardinrelationtotheappointmentotheexternalauditorsandapprovingtheremunerationandtermsotheirengagement;

    developingandimplementingpolicyontheengagementotheexternalauditorstosupplynonauditservices;

    reviewingandmonitoringtheindependence,objectivityandeectivenessotheexternalauditors;

    reviewingthetermsotheInvestmentManagementAgreement;

    reviewingthearrangementsinplacewithinBaillieGiord&Cowherebytheirstamay,inconfdence,raiseconcernsaboutpossibleimproprietiesinmattersofnancialreportingorothermattersinsoarastheymayaecttheCompany;and

    consideringannuallywhetherthereisaneedortheCompanytohaveitsowninternalauditunction.

    KPMGAuditPlcwereappointedtheCompanysAuditorsin2004.Havingconsideredtheexperienceandtenureotheauditpartnerandstaandtheleveloserviceprovided,theCommitteeremainssatisfedwiththeAuditorseectiveness.Theauditpartnersresponsibleortheauditarerotatedeveryfveyearsandthecurrentleadauditpartnerhasbeeninplaceortwoyears.TherearenocontractualobligationsrestrictingtheCompanyschoiceoexternalauditor.

    dIreCTorS reporT

    Directors Interests

    Nature Ordinary 25p shares

    Name of interest 2010 2009

    SirBrianIvory Benefcial 31,000 31,000TheRtHonSirMenziesCampbell Benefcial 2,315 2,194EricHagman Benefcial 2,000 2,000LordKerroKinlochard Benefcial 59,991 54,187RachelLomax Benefcial 17,057 5,864PeterMoon Benefcial 10,000 10,000DavidPrice Benefcial 10,000 10,000

    TheDirectorsattheyearend,andtheirinterestsintheCompanyat31December,wereasshownabove.Duringtheperiodrom1January2011to17February2011RachelLomaxadded247sharestoherbenefcialholdingasaresultomonthlyinvestmentintheBaillieGiordsavingsvehicles.

    TherehavebeennootherchangesintimatedintheDirectorsinterestsupto17February2011.

    http://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspxhttp://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/UKPersonalInvestors/InvestmentTrusts/SAINTS/SAINTSLiterature.aspx
  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    27/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 25

    dIreCTorS reporT

    TheCommitteereceivesconfrmationromtheAuditorsthattheyhavecompliedwiththerelevantUKproessionalandregulatoryrequirementsonindependence.Nonauditeesortheyearto

    31December2010were1,000andrelatedtothecertifcationofnancialinormationorthedebenturetrustee.TheCommitteedoesnotbelievethatthishasimpairedtheAuditorsindependence.

    Relations with ShareholdersTheBoardplacesgreatimportanceoncommunicationwithshareholders.TheCompanysManagersmeetregularlywithshareholdersandreportshareholdersviewstotheBoard.TheChairmanisavailabletomeetwithshareholdersasappropriate.ShareholderswishingtocommunicatewithanymembersotheBoardmaydosobywritingtothemattheCompanysregisteredofce.

    TheCompanysAnnualGeneralMeetingprovidesaorumorcommunicationwithallshareholders.Theleveloproxieslodgedor

    eachresolutionisannouncedatthemeetingandispublishedontheSAINTSpageotheManagerswebsitesubsequenttothemeeting.ThenoticeperiodortheAnnualGeneralMeetingisatleasttwentyworkingdays.Shareholdersandpotentialinvestorsmayobtainup-to-dateinormationontheCompanyromtheSAINTSpageotheManagerswebsite,www.saints-it.com.

    Corporate Governance and StewardshipTheCompanyhasgivendiscretionaryvotingpowerstotheinvestmentmanagers,BaillieGiord&Co.TheManagersvoteagainstresolutionstheyconsidermaydamageshareholdersrightsoreconomicinterests.

    TheCompanybelievesthatitisintheshareholdersintereststo

    considerenvironmental,socialandgovernance(ESG)actorswhenselectingandretaininginvestmentsandhaveaskedtheManagerstotaketheseissuesintoaccount.TheManagersdonotexcludecompaniesromtheirinvestmentuniversepurelyonthegroundsoESGactorsbutadoptapositiveengagementapproachwherebymattersarediscussedwithmanagementwiththeaimoimprovingtherelevantpoliciesandmanagementsystemsandenablingtheManagerstoconsiderhowESGactorscouldimpactlongterminvestmentreturns.TheManagersstatementocompliancewiththeUKStewardshipCodecanbeoundontheManagerswebsiteatwww.bailliegifford.com .TheManagerspolicyhasbeenreviewedandendorsedbytheBoard.

    TheManagersaresignatoriestotheUnitedNationsPrinciplesor

    ResponsibleInvestmentandtheCarbonDisclosureProject.

    Conicts of InterestEachDirectorsubmitsalistopotentialconictsointeresttotheNominationCommitteeonanannualbasis.TheCommitteeconsidersthemcareully,takingintoaccountthecircumstancessurroundingthemandmakesarecommendationtotheBoardonwhetherornotthepotentialconictsshouldbeauthorised.Boardauthorisationisoraperiodooneyear.HavingconsideredthelistsopotentialconictstherewerenosituationswhichgaverisetoadirectorindirectinterestoaDirectorwhichconictedwiththeinterestsotheCompany.

    Investment Managers

    AnInvestmentManagementAgreementbetweentheCompanyand

    BaillieGiord&CosetsoutthemattersoverwhichtheManagershaveauthorityinaccordancewiththepoliciesanddirectionso,andsubjecttorestrictionsimposedby,theBoard.TheManagementAgreementisterminableonnotlessthansixmonthsnotice.CareulconsiderationhasbeengivenbytheBoardastothebasisonwhichthemanagementeeischarged.TheBoardconsidersthatmaintainingarelativelylowtotalexpenseratioisinthebestinterestoallshareholders.TheBoardisalsootheviewthatcalculatingtheeewithreerencetoperormancewouldbeunlikelytoexertapositiveinuenceoverthelongtermperormance.

    DetailsotheeearrangementswithBaillieGiord&Coareshownonpage37.

    TheBoardconsiderstheCompanysinvestmentmanagementand

    secretarialarrangementsortheCompanyonanongoingbasisandaormalreviewisconductedannually.TheBoardconsiders,amongstothers,theollowingtopicsinitsreview:thequalityopolicyguidance;successoinvestmentstrategyandinvestmentperormance;theadministrativeservicesprovidedbytheSecretaries;qualityandcoverageoBoardpapers;themarketingeortsundertakenbytheManagers;comparativecosts;andcommunicationwithshareholders.FollowingthemostrecentreviewitistheopinionotheDirectorsthatthecontinuingappointmentoBaillieGiord&CoasManagers,onthetermsagreed,isintheinterestsoshareholdersasawhole.

    Underaormalmanagementagreement,OLIMLimitedisappointed

    managerotheCompanyspropertyportolio.Detailsoitseesareshownonpage37.Theagreementcanbeterminatedonthreemonthsnotice.Ontermination,OLIMisentitledtoaprorataproportionoitseestothedateotermination.ItistheBoardsviewthatthecontinuationoOLIMsappointmentonthetermsagreedisintheinterestoshareholdersasawhole.

    Substantial Holdings in the Companys Shares

    No. of ordinary

    Name 25p shares held % of issue

    BrewinDolphinLimited 6,660,412 5.0Legal&GeneralGroupPlc 5,240,223 3.9DCThomson&CoLtd 4,100,000 3.1

    TheaboveinormationhasbeenintimatedtotheCompanyasat17February2011.

    http://www.saints-it.com/http://www.saints-it.com/http://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/documentgateway.aspx?d=83068http://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/documentgateway.aspx?d=83068http://www.bailliegifford.com/pages/documentgateway.aspx?d=83068http://www.saints-it.com/
  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    28/60

    26 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    dIreCTorS reporT

    Directors

    InormationabouttheDirectors,includingtheirrelevantexperience,

    canbeoundonpage6.AsexplainedintheTermsoAppointmentsectiononpage22,theBoardhasagreedtogobeyondtheminimumrequirementsotheCompanysArticlesoAssociationandtheCombinedCodeandhasdecidedthatallDirectorsshouldseekre-electionannually.

    AllDirectorswillthereoreberetiringattheAnnualGeneralMeetingandtheyalloerthemselvesorre-election.Followingormalperormanceevaluation,theirperormancecontinuestobeeectiveandtheyremaincommittedtotheCompany.TheBoardrecommendstheirre-electiontoshareholders.

    Deeds of Indemnity and Insurance

    TheCompanyhasenteredintodeedsoindemnityinavouroeach

    oitsDirectors.Thedeedscoveranyliabilitiesthatmayarisetoathirdparty,otherthantheCompany,ornegligence,deaultorbreachotrustorduty.TheDirectorsarenotindemnifedinrespectoliabilitiestotheCompany,anyregulatoryorcriminalfnes,anycostsincurredinconnectionwithcriminalproceedingsinwhichtheDirectorisconvictedorcivilproceedingsbroughtbytheCompanyinwhichjudgementisgivenagainsthim.Inaddition,theindemnitydoesnotapplytoanyliabilitytotheextentthatitisrecoveredromanotherperson.

    TheCompanymaintainsDirectorsandOfcersLiabilityInsurance.

    Share Capital

    Capital structureTheCompanyscapitalstructureconsistso132,485,943ordinaryshareso25peach(2009132,485,943ordinaryshares).TherearenorestrictionsconcerningtheholdingortranserotheCompanysordinarysharesandtherearenospecialrightsattachingtoanyotheshares.

    DividendsTheordinarysharescarryarighttoreceivedividends.InterimdividendsaredeterminedbytheDirectors,whereastheproposedfnaldividendissubjecttoshareholderapproval.

    Capital entitlementOnawindingup,atermeetingtheliabilitiesotheCompany,thesurplusassetswillbepaidtoordinaryshareholdersinproportion

    totheirshareholdings.

    VotingEachordinaryshareholderpresentinpersonorbyproxyisentitledtoonevoteonashowohandsand,onapoll,toonevoteoreveryshareheld.

    Inormationonthedeadlinesorproxyappointmentscanbeoundonpage55.

    Purchase of Own Shares

    TheCompanysbuy-backauthoritywaslastrenewedattheAGMon8April2010inrespecto19,859,642shareso25peach(equivalentto14.99%oitsthenissuedsharecapital).Noshares

    wereboughtbackduringtheyearunderreviewandnosharesareheldintreasury.

    Theprincipalreasonsorsharebuy-backsare:

    (i) toenhancethenetassetvalueorcontinuingshareholdersby

    purchasingsharesatadiscounttotheprevailingnetassetvalue;and

    (ii) toaddressanyimbalancebetweenthesupplyoanddemandortheSAINTSsharesthatresultsinadiscountothequotedmarketpricetothepublishednetassetvaluepershare.

    TheDirectorsareseekingshareholdersapprovalattheAnnualGeneralMeetingtorenewtheauthoritytomakemarketpurchasesoupto14.99%otheCompanysordinarysharesinissueatthedateopassingotheresolution,suchauthoritytoexpireattheAnnualGeneralMeetingotheCompanytobeheldin2012.Anysuchsharespurchasedshalleitherbecancelledorheldintreasury.InaccordancewiththeListingRulesotheUKListingAuthority,themaximumprice(excludingexpenses)thatmaybepaidontheexerciseotheauthoritymustnotexceedthehighero:

    (i) 5percentabovetheaverageclosingpriceontheLondonStockExchangeoanordinaryshareoverthefvebusinessdaysimmediatelyprecedingthedateopurchase;and

    (ii) thehigherothepriceothelastindependenttradeandthehighestcurrentindependentbidontheLondonStockExchange.

    Theminimumpricethatmaybepaidwillbe25ppershare.Purchasesoshareswillbemadewithinguidelinesestablished,romtimetotime,bytheBoard.TheCompanydoesnothaveanywarrantsoroptionsinissue.YourattentionisdrawntoResolution15intheNoticeoAnnualGeneralMeeting.

    Share Issuance Authority

    Resolution13intheNoticeoAnnualGeneralMeetingseekstorenewtheDirectorsgeneralauthoritytoissuesharesuptoanaggregatenominalamounto11,040,495.Thisamountrepresents33.33%otheCompanystotalordinarysharecapitalcurrentlyinissueandmeetsinstitutionalguidelines.NoissueoordinaryshareswillbemadepursuanttotheauthorisationinResolution13whichwouldeectivelyalterthecontrolotheCompanywithoutthepriorapprovaloshareholdersingeneralmeeting.

    Resolution14,whichisproposedasaspecialresolution,seekstorenewtheDirectorsauthoritytoissuesharesorsellsharesheldin

    treasuryonanon-pre-emptivebasisorcash(i.e.withoutfrstoeringsuchsharestoexistingshareholderspro-ratatotheirexistingholdings)uptoanaggregatenominalamounto3,312,148(representing10%otheissuedordinarysharecapitalotheCompanyasat17February2011).TheauthoritiessoughtinResolutions13and14willcontinueuntiltheconclusionotheAnnualGeneralMeetingtobeheldin2012orontheexpiryo15monthsromthepassingothisresolution,iearlier.

    Suchauthoritieswillonlybeusedtoissuesharesorre-sellsharesromtreasuryatapremiumtonetassetvalueandonlywhentheDirectorsbelievethatitwouldbeinthebestinterestsotheCompanytodoso.

    TheDirectorsconsiderthattheauthoritytoissue/sellsharesis

    advantageousshouldthesharestradeatapremiumtothenetassetvalueandnaturalliquidityisunabletomeetdemand.

    Noshareswereissuedduringtheyearto31December2010andnoshareswereheldintreasuryon17February2011.

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    29/60

    THE SCOTTISH AMERICAN INVESTMENT COMPANY P.L.C. 27

    Amendment to the Articles of Association

    ItisproposedinResolution16toadoptnewarticlesoassociation

    (theNewArticles)inordertoupdatetheCompanyscurrentarticlesoassociation(theArticles)totakeaccountotheimplementationon1October2009othelastpartsotheCompaniesAct2006(the2006Act)inrespecto,amongstotherthings,theCompanysauthorisedsharecapital,itsmemorandumoassociationandtheabilityotheCompanytochangeitsname.TheCompaniesAct1985was,orallpracticalpurposesrepealedon1October2009.ItisalsoproposedtoamendtheArticlestoincreasethelimitsontheDirectorsees.WhilsttheBoardisnotproposinganincreaseineesor2011,theeesarenearthecurrentlimitwhichleaveslittlescopeoranincreaseinutureyears.

    AsummaryothematerialchangesproposedtobebroughtaboutbytheadoptionotheNewArticlesissetoutintheAppendixtothe

    NoticeotheAnnualGeneralMeetingonpage57.AcopyotheNewArticleswillbeavailableorinspectionattheofcesoDicksonMintoW.S.,BroadgateTower,20PrimroseStreet,LondonEC2A2EWduringnormalbusinesshoursonanyweekday(Saturdays,Sundaysandpublicholidaysexcepted)romthedateothenoticeotheAGMuntiltheconclusionotheAGM.AcopywillalsobeavailableattheplaceotheAGMor15minutesbeoreandduringtheAGM.

    Creditor Payment Policy

    ItistheCompanyspaymentpolicytoobtainthebesttermsorallbusiness.Ingeneral,theCompanyagreeswithitssuppliersthe

    termsonwhichbusinesswilltakeplaceanditisitspolicytoabidebytheseterms.TheCompanyhadnotradecreditorsateither31December2009or31December2010.

    dIreCTorS reporT

    Disclosure of Information to Auditors

    TheDirectorsconfrmthatsoaraseachotheDirectorsisaware

    thereisnorelevantauditinormationowhichtheCompanysauditorsareunawareandtheDirectorshavetakenallthestepsthattheyoughttohavetakenasDirectorsinordertomakethemselvesawareoanyrelevantauditinormationandtoestablishthattheCompanysauditorsareawareothatinormation.

    Independent Auditors

    Theauditors,KPMGAuditPlc,arewillingtocontinueinofceandinaccordancewithsection489andsection491(1)otheCompaniesAct2006resolutionsconcerningtheirre-appointmentandremunerationwillbesubmittedtotheAnnualGeneralMeeting.

    Recommendation

    TheBoardunanimouslyrecommendsyoutovoteinavourotheresolutionstobeproposedattheAnnualGeneralMeeting.

    ByorderotheBoardSIRBRIANIVORY18February2011

  • 8/3/2019 The Scottish American Invest Co.

    30/60

    28 ANNUAL REPORT 2010

    dIreCTorS remuNerATIoN reporT

    Directors Remuneration Report

    TheBoardhaspreparedthisreport,inaccordancewiththerequirementsotheCompaniesAct2006.AnordinaryresolutionortheapprovalothisreportwillbeputtothemembersattheorthcomingAnnualGeneralMeeting.

    ThelawrequirestheCompanysauditorstoauditcertainothedisclosuresprovided.Wheredisclosureshavebeenaudited,theyareindicatedassuch.Theauditorsopinionisincludedintheirreportonpage31.

    Remuneration Committee

    TheCompanyhassevenDirectors,allowhomarenon-executive.

    ThereisnoseparateremunerationcommitteeandtheBoardasawholeconsiderschangestoDirectorseesromtimetotime.BaillieGiord&Co,whohavebeenappointedbytheBoardasManagersandSecretaries,provideadvicean