Slide 1 December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction Common Law Statutes The Role of Statutes in English and American Law
Slide 1December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Common Law Statutes
The Role of Statutesin
English and American Law
Slide 2December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The Relationship Between Statutes and Case Law
Slide 3December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The Relationship Between Statutes and Case Law
Slide 4December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The Relationship Between Statutes and Case Law
Slide 5December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Parliamentary SovereigntyWhen statutes and case law conflict, statutes will be followed.This has been the rule since the Glorious Revolution (1688)
House of Commons, ca. 1710
Slide 6December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Parliamentary SovereigntyParliament can make laws concerning anything.No Parliament can bind a future parliament.A valid Act of Parliament cannot be questioned by the court.
Parliament is the supreme lawmaker.NOTE – EU law complicates this.
Slide 7December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Modern ExamplesHouse of Lords ruled that the Crown (government) must compensate oil companies for certain losses sustained during WWII.Parliament passed the War Damage Act 1965, saying that the Crown was not, and never had been, liable for such.
Slide 8December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Modern ExamplesA challenge was launched in court against the legitimacy of the British Railway Act 1968.The claim was supporters of the Act mislead Parliament.House of Lords ruled they had no jurisdiction to hear such claim.
Slide 9December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The American ModelCongressional sovereignty exists, but it is limited by the Constitution!
Congress has defined powerThe Courts can determine whether has exceeded this power or violated the Constitution.
Slide 10December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Types of Legislation (UK)Primary
Acts of Parliamentsometimes referred to as general acts.these are subject to overriding legislation of the EU.Further Classification:
Public
Private
Local
Secondarysometimes referred to as delegated legislation.includes rules, orders, regulations and byelaws created by subordinate bodies of government under powers delegated to it by Parliament.
Slide 11December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Reading Acts of Parliament
see http://denning.law.ox.ac.uk/lrsp/overview/legislation.php#types
Slide 12December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Types of Legislation (US)Bills
become law after passage by both Houses and signed by President.Can be temporary or permanent.
Rule/Regulationscreated by agencies
Resolutionsdo not have the force of law.used to express opinion of Congress or delegate power to President.Can also be used to start Constitutional Amendments.
Slide 13December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Act of Congress An Act To define and protect the institution of marriage. Sept. 21, 1996 [H.R. 3396]
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled: Defense of Marriage Act.
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Defense of Marriage Act''.
SEC. 2. POWERS RESERVED TO THE STATES.
(a) In General.Chapter 115 of title 28, United States Code, is amended by adding after section 1738B the following:
bill that started processPreamble
shows how Act should be integrated into US Code
Slide 14December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Organization of Statutesalphabetical by subject matter
Slide 15December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Role of Judges in the SystemInterpret statutesCreate case law in areas not regulated by statute
Role of LegislatureCreate rules in any area it want
Even in areas traditionally dominated by case law!
“the codification of the law”
Revise rules that have been “improperly” interpreted by the courts.
“legislative overruling”
Cooperative Interplay
Slide 16December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Codification of the LawPrior to 1952, commercial contract law was dominated by case law.Passage of the Uniform Commercial Code codified much of the case law in this area AND changed some it.Case law is still used in commercial contract law where the U.C.C. is silent.
Slide 17December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Legislative OverrulingSpecifically reject and change a common law rule.
Example – common law rule was assumption of risk barred negligence claim. Many legislatures have replaced this rule with comparative negligence.
Specifically reject a court's interpretation of a statute.
Slide 18December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
UK: Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 (c. 34)
“3. The rule of law known as the rule in Bain v. Fothergill is abolished in relation to contracts made after this section comes into force.”
Legislative Overruling
Slide 19December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
California, USA: California Civil Code
§ 1714 (a) Every one is responsible, not only for the result of his willful acts, but also for an injury occasioned to another by his want of ordinary care or skill in the management of his property or person, except so far as the latter has, willfully or by want of ordinary care, brought the injury upon himself. The extent of liability in such cases is defined by the Title on Compensatory Relief.(b) It is the intent of the Legislature to abrogate the holdings in cases such as Vesely v. Sager (1971) 5 Cal.3d 153, Bernhard v. Harrah's Club (1976) 16 Cal.3d 313, and Coulter v. Superior Court (1978) 21 Cal. 3d 144 and to reinstate the prior judicial interpretation of this section as it relates to proximate cause for injuries incurred as a result of furnishing alcoholic beverages to an intoxicated person, namely that the furnishing of alcoholic beverages is not the proximate cause of injuries resulting from intoxication, but rather the consumption of alcoholic beverages is the proximate cause of injuries inflicted upon another by an intoxicated person.(c) No social host who furnishes alcoholic beverages to any person shall be held legally accountable for damages suffered by such person, or for injury to the person or property of, or death of, any third person, resulting from the consumption of such beverages.
Legislative Overruling
Slide 20December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Statutory Interpretation
Rules and Canons of Interpretation
“[I]n the field of statutory construction …, there are 'correct,' unchallengeable rules of 'how to read' which lead in happily variant directions.”
Karl N. Llewellyn
Slide 21December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Common Rules of Interpretation
Literal/Plain Meaning RuleHistorical Rule/Original IntentGolden Rule/Soft Plain Meaning RuleMischief Rule (U.K. only)Purposive/Functional Rule
Whole Act Rule
Slide 22December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The court does not ask what the legislation might be intended to say, just what it actually says.What is the literal and ordinary meaning of the words used?
Literal (Plain Meaning) Rule
Slide 23December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Pros/Cons of Literal RuleEncourages precisionRespects legislaturePrevents judges from rewriting lawOther approaches make it difficult to predict outcomes.
Ignores wider contextAssumes perfectionIgnores limits of languageCan lead to absurd or harsh results.
Slide 24December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Historical Ruleoriginal intent, intentionalism
Taking into consideration all circumstances at the time of the creation of the statute, the court determines what the legislators intended with their actual words.What did the original legislators intend with the words that they used?
use of legislative history. Pepper v Hart [1993]
Slide 25December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Golden RuleIf the words used are ambiguous the court should adopt an interpretation which avoids an absurd result.
ProsAvoids absurd resultsAvoids harsh results
ConsNo clear test for absurdity/harshnessAllow judges to rewrite statutes
Slide 26December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The interpretation should aim to remedy the “mischief” that the statute itself aimed to remedy.Gives judges power to “discover” Parliament's intentions.
used when legislature passes law to remedy common law defect.some argue that this undermines Parliament's supremacy.
Mischief Rule
Slide 27December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The court tries to find the purpose of the legislation, rather than just looking at the words used.What is the general underlying purpose of the statute?
employed in interpreting European law
Functional Approach
Slide 28December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
The Whole Act Rule
When interpreting a statute, a court should construe particular statutory provisions in light of the statute as a whole Court will look particularly to:
TitlePreamble
Slide 29December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Example
Slide 30December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
CanonsWhat is a canon?
A wise saying backed by experience and intuition.Not law, not binding, but more significant than mere cliché.Something between homespun saying and general truths of math or science.
Slide 31December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
ejusdem generistreating items "of the same kind" together
Noscitur a sociis known from associates
expressio unius est exclusio alterius "the expression of one thing is the exclusion of another"
Strict Construction
Canons of Construction
Slide 32December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
treating items "of the same kind" togetherWhen a list of specific items belonging to the same class is followed by general words, the general words are to be taken as referring only to those things of the same class as specifically mentioned E.g., ‘cats and dogs’ does not include wild animals.
Ejusdem Generis
Slide 33December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Noscitur a sociis A word will be interpreted in the context of surrounding words.Example:
Foster v Diphwys Casson (1887) 18 QBD 428, involved a statute which stated that explosives taken into a mine must be in a "case or canister". Here the defendant used a cloth bag. The courts had to consider whether a cloth bag was within the definition. Under noscitur a sociis, it was held that the bag could not have been within the statutory definition, because parliament's intention was referring to a case or container of the same strength as a canister.
Slide 34December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
the expression of one thing is the exclusion of anotherWhen a list of specific items is not followed by general words, it should be taken as exhaustive.
expressio unius est exclusio alterius
Slide 35December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Interpreting Law That Changes Common Law
Classic Rule/CanonStatutes in derogation of the common law will not be extended by construction.
Also called Strict Construction
Liberal Rule/CanonSuch acts will be liberally construed if their nature is remedial.
Slide 36December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
A statute in derogation of the common law is to be strictly construed.California Civil Code § 4. The rule of the common law, that statutes in derogation thereof are to be strictly construed, has no application to this Code. The Code establishes the law of this State respecting the subjects to which it relates, and its provisions are to be liberally construed with a view to effect its objects and to promote justice. [1872]
Strict Construction
Slide 37December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Statutory Interpretation
EXAMPLE
Slide 38December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Church of the Holy Trinity v. United States
Holy Trinity Church (in the US) hires UK minister.At the time, such employment contracts were illegal under US law (23 Stat. 332):
prohibits any "...person, company, partnership, or corporation, in any manner whatsoever to prepay the transportation, or in any way assist or encourage the importation (of) ... any foreigner ... into the United States... under contract or agreement... to perform labor or service of any kind in the United States..."EXCEPTION: but not actors, artists, lecturers, or domestic servants.
Holy Trinity was a very wealthy church and the minister was to be quite highly paid.ISSUE: Did Church violate the law?
Slide 39December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Literal ReadingNo employment of any kind with limited exceptions.COURT: "We cannot think Congress intended to denounce with penalties a transaction like that in the present case."Court searches for “true” intent.
Soft Plain Meaning Rule, Purposive Approach
Slide 40December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
Using Rules to Find IntentWhole Act Rule
title of Act:"An act to prohibit the importation and migration of foreigners and aliens under contract or agreement to perform labor in the United States, its territories, and the District of Columbia."
COURT = this show Congress intended to apply this only to manual labor.
Legislative HistoryCommittee report indicated word “manual” was considered as amendment but deemed not necessary.
Slide 41December 26, 2012 Statutory Construction
expressio unius?Except for “professional actors, artists, lecturers, singers, and domestic servants.”Why not limit it to the list using this rule?