Top Banner
The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop 4-5 October 2018
20

The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

May 23, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy

Shonali PachauriBandung Workshop 4-5 October 2018

Page 2: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Background: Clean Cooking Access LowProportion of Population Dependent on Solid Fuels for Cooking

Page 3: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Background: Associated Health Impacts High

Page 4: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Health & Safety Impacts of Dependence on Solid Fuels

Almost 3 million die prematurely every year due to exposure to household pollution due to inefficient combustion of solid fuelsBack aches, pains, and injuries from

biomass collection

Source: Pachauri et al., ‘Energy Access for Development’, GEA, 2012

Page 5: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Livelihood Impacts of Lacking Access to Modern Energy

Limited productive hours in the day for those who spend time in own fuel collectionLack of access to modern energy

also limits work and business possibilities

Source: Pachauri et al., ‘Energy Access for Development’, GEA, 2012

Page 6: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Equity Impacts of Lack of Access to Modern Energy

The deaths from household pollution and drudgery of fuel collection falls disproportionately on women and childrenPerpetuates poverty, gender and other

social disparities

Source: Pachauri et al., ‘Energy Access for Development’, GEA, 2012

Page 7: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Environmental Consequences of Solid Fuels Dependence

Local forest, land and soil degradationCO2 emissions if biomass is non-

renewably harvestedEmissions of non-CO2 GHG and PIC

with higher GWP Growing evidence of strong climate

impacts of black carbon (soot) for arctic and glacial ice melting

Page 8: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Potential Synergies of Clean Cooking with Other SDGs

• SDG1 – Poverty alleviation• SDG3 – Improved health• SDG5 – Gender equality• SDG10 – Reduced

inequalities• SDG11 – Livable human

settlements and cities• SDG12 – Improved

production and consumption patterns

• SDG15 - Halt deforestation and prevent biodiversity loss

Source: South Centre

Page 9: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Relationship of Fuel Choices with Income in South Asia

Source: Poblete-Cazanave & Pachauri 2018

Page 10: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Emissions consequences of cooking transition in India between 2001-2011

Page 11: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Change in Share of HHs Using Firewood & LPG in India 2001- 2011

Urban Rural

Exclusive Fuelwood HH 8% 3%

Exclusive LPG HH 17% 5%

Multi – fuel HH (min. LPG + fuelwood)

2% 5%

Source: Singh et al 201711

Page 12: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Estimate of Fuel Use for Cooking• National displacement of 7.6 million tons of biomass.

Almost 1 million tons displaced in rural, while over 6 million tons displaced in urban areas.

• Rural displacement of biomass < urban displacement, as fewer rural HHs gained access compared to urban HHs and average per capita LPG use in urban areas is higher than in rural areas.

• About 217 thousand tons of LPG used in 2011.

Source: Singh et al 201712

Page 13: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Net emissions – assumptions on fNRB

-0.07-0.41 -0.48-0.53

-3.25

-3.794.00

3.00

2.00

1.00

0.00

Rural HH Urban HH National HH

fNRB = 0

fNRB = 0.3

MtCO2e

Source: Singh et al. 201713

Page 14: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Net emissions: accounting of GHGs

-0.53 -0.70-1.24

-3.25

-4.36

-7.61

-3.79

-5.06

-8.8510.00

8.00

6.00

4.00

2.00

0.00

Kyoto (fNRB = 0.3)Non-Kyoto Climate

Forcing Kyoto + non-Kyoto

Rural HH Urban HH

National HH

MtCO2e

Source: Singh et al 2017

~5% of 2011 HH emissions

14

Page 15: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Net Emissions Estimation - Conclusions

The transition to LPG cooking in India reduced pressure on forests and achieved modest climate benefits, though uncertainties regarding the extent of non-renewable biomass harvesting and suite of climate-active emissions included matters for households emissions accounting and should be considered carefully in any analysis and policy-making.

Page 16: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Population Distribution in S.Asia –Current & in 2040 for Alternate Socio-Economic Futures

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2

2010 2020 2030 2040 2050

Billi

ons

SSP1 - High Economic Growth, Urbanization

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2

2010 2020 2030 2040 2050

Billi

ons

SSP2 - Medium Economic Growth

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2

2010 2020 2030 2040 2050

Billi

ons

SSP3 - Low Economic Growth, High Pop

R < $5/dayR > $5/day

U< $5/dayU> $5/day

Source: Poblete-Cazanave & Pachauri 2018

Page 17: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Scenarios of Cooking Fuel Transition Under SSPs in South Asia in 2040

Source: Poblete-Cazanave & Pachauri 2018

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

R<$5/day R>$5/day U<$5/day U>$5/day

Ene

rgy

in P

J

2040 SSP1- High Growth

ModernBiomass

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

R<$5/day R>$5/day U<$5/day U>$5/day

Ene

rgy

in P

J

2040 SSP2 - Middle of the Road

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

R<$5/day R>$5/day U<$5/day U>$5/day

Ene

rgy

in P

J

2040 SSP3 - Slow Growth

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

R<$5/day R>$5/day U<$5/day U>$5/day

Ener

gy in

PJ

Current state 2015

Page 18: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Additional Policies to Accelerate a Transition Away from Solid Biomass Cooking• R&D for improved combustion and conversion

technologies • Standards for improved stoves• Grants or reduced-cost dissemination of clean stoves• Fuel subsidies on alternative fuels, like LPG• Targeted cash transfers to below poverty line households• Information and education campaigns• Incentivizing electric induction cook stoves

Page 19: The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems ... · The Role of Solid Biomass in Future Energy Systems: Considering Access to Clean Energy Shonali Pachauri Bandung Workshop

Key Insights• Without new policies achieving the SDG 7 target of universal

access to clean cooking by 2030 unachievable• Futures with higher economic growth, more equitable income

distribution and faster urbanization are likely to have more rapid transitions away from biomass cooking

• Policies that combine subsidies on cleaner fuels (LPG) with grants for the stoves and deposits are more effective

• The emissions consequences of shifting from biomass to LPG cooking are negligible and could be even negative if some biomass is unsustainably harvested

• The potential air quality and health benefits are large and synergies with other SDGs are also significant