8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
1/14
1 www.visionias.in Vision IAS
G. S. PAPER II GOVERNANCE, SOCIAL JUSTICE
Development processes n! t"e !evelopment #n!$str%& t"e role o'
NGOs, S(Gs, vr#o$s )ro$ps n! ssoc#t#ons, !onors, c"r#t#es n!
ot"er st*e"ol!ers
VISIONIAS +.v#s#on#s.#n
.v#s#on#s.or!press.com
12
Cop%r#)"t - % V#s#on IAS
All rights are reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or
transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise,
without prior permission of Vision IAS
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
2/14
2 www.visionias.in Vision IAS
/. 0"% "s 1prt#c#pt#on2 n! 1empoerment2 )#ne! #!e c$rrenc% #n recent !evelopment l#tert$re3
Decades of development efforts have provoked a feeling of disenchantment with the conventional growth-oriented
strategy of development not prodcing the desired trickle-down effect. !he failres sensiti"ed the planners and
administrators to the need for drawing on the indigenos knowledge system of the local people. #nless people
themselves participate$ the programmes administrated %y e&ternal agencies remain e&ogenos to the rral
commnity there%y affecting reslts. A people-centred vision is %eing advanced %y citi"en's organisations working tocreate an alternative world order %ased on economic (stice$ environmental sta%ility and political inclsiveness.
As the )man Development *eport +#,D 1/0 commented eople's participation is %ecoming the central isse of
or times3
/. So, #s people prt#c#pt#on recent !#scover%3
4eople' as real actors in history have %een %roght forward %y the 4 S$ltern' school. easant resistances were
s%tle and effective peoples' actions against oppression. eople do act$ it is for s to appreciate it and mo%ilise it for
participatory people-centric movements. eople as development actors emerged long ago in the vision and action of
!agore at Shantiniketan and 5andhi at 6ardha. !agore e&perimented with people centred rral development in thevillages for the re(venation of rral arts and crafts and economy in general. 5andhi relied on the mo%ili"ation of
masses and their economic pliftment throgh the development of cottage and small-scale indstries
/. O*. I )et t"t prt#c#ptor% !evelopment #s #mportnt. 0"t s"pes4'orms !oes #t t*e3
Anisr*ahman has identified the following different forms of commnity organisations representing collective action
%y the nderprivileged people to improve their socio-economic conditions
5#rst$ there are grassroots organisations that are %asically economic in natre$ ndertaking income-generatingactivities with the help of internal resorce mo%ili"ation spplemented %y resorce and knowledge spport
from otside Secon!$ there are other organisations that emerge in 4pressre grop' activities. !hey resist e&ploitation or
oppression %y other grops$ assert economic$ social and hman rights inclding women's rights$ or demand
services from the p%lic agencies
T"#r!$ some of the organisations ndertake social and cltral activities in sch areas as health$ edcation$cltre and so on
5o$rt"$ some aim at the promotion of holistic life %y way of activities that integrate spirital advancementwith economic and social development
5#'t"$ commnity organisations to promote ecologically oriented socio-economic life are also growing in manyareas sch as organic agricltre$ social forestry$ coastal fishing etc.
S#6t"$ participatory action research is %eing prsed %y some organisations to develop people's own thinkinga%ot their living conditions and environment
/. T"#s prol#'ert#on o' comm$n#t% se! or)n#st#ons m$st e c*e! % some ene'#ts, r#)"t3
!he vale of participation as a facilitative development process has %een widely recognised and ma(or %enefits have
%een identified as follows
!he participatory process provides important information in the planning$ programming and implementationstages there%y ensring congrence %etween o%(ectives and commnity vales and preferences
7y rationali"ing manpower resorces tili"ation$ the process redces pro(ect cost Any change %roght a%ot throgh development is more accepta%le to the commnity if the local people are
involved$ also$ mistakes are more tolera%le if these are made %y people who have to live with them
8onitoring is %etter$ and sstaina%ility of the pro(ect is more likely even after the withdrawal of the e&ternalagent$ %e it government or ,59 agency
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
3/14
/ www.visionias.in Vision IAS
!he commnity learns from its own involvement and from this point of view$ participation is a 2 way learningprocess in which the administrator and the people %ecome co-learners
Active commnity participation helps re%ild commnity cohesion and installs a sense of dignity into thecommnity. eople gain in confidence and steadily emerge as real actors in the development process.
/. Is comm$n#t% prt#c#pt#on t"en& t"e nser to ll !evelopment prolems3
:ritics of commnity participation arge participation has poplarity withot clarity and is s%(ect to growing
faddishness and a lot of lip service.
Serios analysis of local commnity life reveals differentiation in terms of stats$ income and power. :onflicts and
rivalries are not ncommon even among the poor and nderprivileged. !he romantic vision of frictionless$
harmonios commnity life does not match grond realities
;&ternal intervention %y social workers or political activists has %een fond necessary almost everywhere to organi"e
the local commnity and mo%ili"e the local people
It has also %een o%served that there is an imaginary notion of continos activism %y the local people %ehind all
discssions on commnity participation. !otal and continos commitment to activism is more a revoltionary's
dream than the poor people's actal %ehavior
!here are critics who do%t the efficacy of commnity participation in %ringing a%ot radical change in the life of the
poor and the nderprivileged throgh atonomos local action only. Small changes are not rled ot$ %t commnity
participation$to %e really effective$ needs profond social strctral change at %oth domestic and international levels.
:ommnity mo%ili"ation cannot$ on its own$ correct the %asic social im%alances that have their roots in deeper socio-
economic layers of the society
7r6#st r)$ment participatory development within capitalistic mode is nworka%le$ the prpose of participation is
to diffse revoltionary movements and create an illsion of soltion. !he state seeks to s%vert poplar movements
throgh maniplative co-optation of the poor
/. O*%. Prt#c#ptor% !evelopment "s #ts '$lts n! s"ortcom#n)s $t #t !oes stn! 'or ct#on, e8$#t% #n reso$rce
!#str#$t#on 9 soc#l cp#tl n! "ence cnnot e #)nore!. 0"t #s t"e role o' stte #n ll t"#s3
!he state plays a fndamental role in helping or hindering participation. Different social science theories evoke
different images of state-society relationships. 6hile 8ar&ian and elite theories are pessimistic a%ot the possi%ility
of commnity participation$ li%eral-democratic and plralist theories are mch more helpfl.
State's actions depend pon the definition and prpose of commnity participation$ state's perception a%ot its role
and the political will to decentrali"e power and resorces to local instittions
Accordingly < different state's responses have emerged +ideal models to characteri"e %etter0
Ant#&prt#c#ptor% mo!e !he state in a capitalist system is interested$ not in ameliorating the conditions of the poor$%t in promoting the interests of capital and the rling class. ower is$ therefore$ concentrated and not dispersed to
facilitate accmlation of wealth
7n#p$lt#ve mo!e !he state follows a diplomatic approach and the state spport to commnity participation is
intended to ensre political and social control as well as redce local development costs and facilitate sccessfl
pro(ect implementation. State seeks to netrali"e political opposition %y co-opting atonomos movements with the
lterior motive of gaining control over them. !he rhetoric of participation is invoked to mo%ili"e local la%or in state's
development activities and to give legitimacy to the regime in power
Incrementl mo!e It is marked %y an am%ivalent approach to commnity participation. !here is no lack of
government spport to participation %t the policy is nclear and piecemeal = ad-hoc approaches are the norm. !he
state in reality is not willing to part with power and to devolve resorces to local commnity grops. Also$ the
%reacrats and the technocrats have their own ways of %ringing a%ot efficient3 local development management.
Still$ commnity participation is not$ in theory$ re(ected and decentralisation contines in an ad-hoc fashion with a
plrality of actors
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
4/14
< www.visionias.in Vision IAS
Prt#c#ptor% mo!e :haracteri"ed %y state's own initiative to create instittions of commnity participation to ensre
effective involvement at the grassroots level. !here are no lterior motives and genine poplar involvement is
ensred %y providing resorces to local %odies and sensiti"ing %reacracy throgh training and directives. 6ithin an
overall development planning framework$ the central$ regional and local development policies and activities are
harmoni"ed throgh positive political will and %reacratic spport
>5ollo&$p / 6hich of these modes is tre for India? )ave we evolved from one mode to another or is there one
particlar mode more applica%le or does the state adopt different modes at different times@places
Eno$)" o' prt#c#pt#on, lets come to vol$ntr% or)n#st#ons:
/: 0"t #s NGO3
According to the 6orld 7ank$ a ,on-governmental 9rgani"ation +,590 is a private organi"ation that prses
activities to relieve sffering$ promote the interests of the poor$ protect the environment$ provide %asic social
services$ or ndertake commnity development3. In other words$ ,59s are legally constitted organi"ations$ operate
independently from the government and are generally considered to %e non-state$ non-profit oriented grops who
prse prposes of p%lic interest3. !he primary o%(ective of ,59s is to provide social (stice$ development and
hman rights. ,59s are generally fnded totally or partly %y governments and they maintain their non-governmental
stats %y e&clding government representatives from mem%ership in the organi"ation.
In a democratic society$ it is the state that has the ltimate responsi%ility for shering development to its citi"ens. In
India$ throgh the progressive interpretation of the :onstittion and its laws and policies$ the scope of development
has %een significantly %roadened to inclde not (st economic progress for citi"ens$ %t also promotion of social
(stice$ gender eBity$ inclsion$ citi"en's awareness$ empowerment and improved Bality of life. !o achieve this
holistic vision of development$ the state reBires the constrctive and colla%orative engagement of the civil society in
its varios developmental activities and programs. ,on-governmental organisations +,59s0 as the operational arm of
the civil society therefore have an important role in the development processes.
/: 0"t re t"e !#''erent t%pes o' c#v#l soc#et% or)n#;t#ons3
C#v#l r#)"ts !vocc% or)n#;t#ons to promote hman rights of specific social grops e.g. women$ migrants$disa%led$ )IV$ se& workers$ Dalit people$ tri%al people$ and the likes.
C#v#l l#ert#es !vocc% or)n#;t#ons to promote individal civil li%erties and hman rights of all citi"ens$rather than focsing on particlar social grop.
Comm$n#t% se! or)n#;t#ons, c#t#;en2s )ro$ps, 'rmers2 coopert#ves to increase citi"en's participationon p%lic policy isses so as to improve the Bality of life in a particlar commnity.
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
5/14
www.visionias.in Vision IAS
Eocal volntary organisations can %e very helpfl in mo%ili"ing poplar
spport and assistance of the people in the activities of local %ody. It is possi%le to maintain constant and close
contact with the people throgh these organisations
As"o* 7e"t Comm#ttee 9f the several volntary organisations engaged in rral welfare$ a few have helped the *Isin preparation of area development plans$ condct feasi%ility stdies and cost@%enefit analysis$ e&plore ways and
means to indce local participation in planning and implementation.
In the S#6t" 5#ve Ber Pln =>&=>?F$ the government identified new areas in which ,59s as new actors cold
participate in development
!he Sevent" 5#ve Ber Pln =>?& =>>F$ envisioned a more active role for ,59s as primary actors in the efforts
towards self-reliant commnities. !his was in tne with the participatory and empowerment ideologies$ which was
gaining crrency in the developmental discorse at that time
5overnment spport and encoragement for ,59s contined in the E#)"t" 5#ve& %er pln$ where a nation-wide
network of ,59s was soght to %e created
!he N#nt" 5#ve&%er plnproposed that ,59s shold play a role in development on the p%lic-private partnership
model. Also$ the agricltral development policies of the government and its implementation mechanisms provided
scope and space for ,59s. A case in point is the watershed development program$ which has led to the growth of
,59s working for rral development
In 8arch 2FFF$ the 5overnment declared Plnn#n) Comm#ss#on as the no!l )enc% 'or GO&NGO #nter'ce. !he
message was clear- government has to and will work with the volntary sector. A 1C#v#l Soc#et% 0#n!o2was started
in 2FF
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
6/14
J www.visionias.in Vision IAS
6omen in India +1K0$ the Indian ,ational :onference +1K0 etc. !he Society's *egistration Act +S*A0 was approved
in 1JF to confirm the legal stats of the growing %ody of non-governmental organi"ations.
In India$ it was the 1KFs which saw rapid growth in the formation of formally registered ,59s and the process
contines to this day. 8ost ,59s have created their respective thematic$ social grop and geographical priorities sch
as poverty alleviation$ commnity health$ edcation$ hosing$ hman rights$ child rights$ women's rights$ natral
resorce management$ water and sanitationC and to these ends they pt to practice a wide range of strategies and
approaches. rimarily$ their focs has %een on the search for alternatives to development thinking and practiceC
achieved throgh participatory research$ commnity capacity %ilding and creation of demonstra%le models. 6hen
we review some of the work done %y ,59s over the past / decades$ we find that they have contri%ted greatly to
nation %ilding.
8any ,59s have worked hard to inclde children with disa%ility in schools$ end caste- %ased stigma and
discrimination$ prevent child la%or and promote gender eBality reslting in women receiving eBal wages for the
same work compared to men. Dring natral calamities they have played an active role in relief and reha%ilitation
efforts$ in particlar$ providing psycho-social care and spport to the disaster affected children$ women and men.
,59s have %een instrmental in the formation and capacity %ilding of farmers and prodcers' cooperatives and
women's self- help grops. Several ,59s have worked hand in hand with the 5overnment to ensre that millions of
ot of school children are enrolled and contine their school edcation$ ths making the right to edcation a reality.
!he leprosy eradication programme was spearheaded %y ,59s and today only residal leprosy remains in or
contry. ,59s have implemented the JeevnD"r programme for creation of wells for safe drinking waterC
promoted commnity toilets for total sanitation$ and spported the p%lic health programs on immnisation and for
eliminating t%erclosis and malaria. !he mch cele%rated ,*;5A$ I:DS$ I:S$ ,irmal 5ram and Swasthya7ima of the
government have their roots in the work of many ,59s. ,59s have significantly inflenced the development of laws
and policies on several important social and developmental isses sch as the right to information$ (venile (stice$
ending corporal pnishment in schools$ anti-trafficking$ forests and environment$ wildlife conservation$ women$
elderly people$ people with disa%ility$ reha%ilitation and resettlement of development indced displaced people to
name a few. Grther$ ,59s made their modest attempts to ensre the effective implementation of these laws and
policies %y condcting and disseminating findings from participatory research$ %dget analysis$ p%lic hearings$ social
adits$ workshops$ seminars and conferences.
Smming p$ it is now well esta%lished that ,59s have an important role to play in the development processes and
that %oth the state and market need the colla%oration of credi%le$ active$ and acconta%le ,59s. 5iven their connect
with the grassroots realities$ ,59s can and shold play the game changer3 to pro-poor development throgh
leadership on participatory research$ commnity empowerment and search for development alternatives.
6ith the increasing role of the ,59s in development activities they are now attracting professionals from varios
other sectors$ and capacities are %eing %ilt in spport areas sch as financial management$ resorce mo%ili"ation$
hman resorces$ leadership development$ governance procedres and practices and instittional development. At
another level ,59s have %een addressing the social service isses and empowerment related advocacy efforts have
%een increasing. !he stdy condcted %y a ,ew Delhi %ased ,59 conclded that every fifth ,59 in India works on the
isses of commnity and social service. !he favora%le disposition of the governments and the political will to involve
,59s is more prononced in implementation of the welfare schemes addressing cases of women and children.
Grther$ the indstrial policies have inflenced the formation and relations %etween the %sinesses and ,59s. !he
:onfederation of Indian Indstries +:II0$ a leading organisation$ has %een raising the isses of corporate social
responsi%ility. !he emphasis of indstrial policies on the promotion and development of small$ cottage and village
indstries has also lead to the formation of agencies sch as the Lhadi and Village Indstries :ommission$ Small
Indstries Associations and likes.
Pro'#l#n) NGOs:
India has possi%ly the largest nm%er of active non-government$ non-profit organi"ations in the world. !here has %een
a sharp increase in the nm%er of new ,59s in the past decade in India. According to a government stdy$ there were
only 1.
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
7/14
K www.visionias.in Vision IAS
It can %e noted that a great ma(ority of the ,59s are small and a%ot three-forths of all ,59s are rn entirely %y
volnteers. A%ot 1/ percent of the ,59s have %etween 2 to employeesC a%ot percent have %etween J to 1F
employees and only a%ot . percent ,59s employ more than 1F people. According to a srvey condcted %y
society for articipatory *esearch in Asia +*IA0$ K/.< percent of ,59s have one or no paid staff$ althogh across the
contry$ more than 1 million persons work as volnteers or paid staff at an ,59. 8ore often ,59s are registered as
trsts$ societies$ or as private limited non-profit companies$ nder Section- 2 of Indian :ompanies Act$ 1J. !hey
also en(oy income ta& e&emption. Goreign contri%tions to non-profits are governed %y Goreign :ontri%tion
*eglation Act +G:*A0$ 1KJ.
/: 0"t re t"e *e% )overnnce c"llen)es 'c#n) NGOs3
In view of the emergence of a new paradigm of scaling p$ in which ,59s are seen as catalysts of policy innovations
and social capitalC as creators of programmatic knowledge that can %e spn off and integrated into government and
market instittionsC and as %ilders of vi%rant and diverse civil societies$ it's imperative to critically analy"e the role of
,59s in the process of development and nderstanding the challenges facing the sector.
!ransparency and acconta%ility are key ingredients of 5overnance in the ,59 Sector as these determine operational
efficiencies and risk mitigation. 9ver the years$ corporate sector has %een a%le to recogni"e and implement %est
governance practices throgh appropriate instittional framework. )owever$ the ,59 sector is yet to evolve anyinstittionali"ed framework$ which cold potentially play an important role in overall development of the nation.
,59s play an increasingly active role in today's political and social arenas. :ivil society organi"ations are increasing in
nm%er all over India. 9f late$ some of the local and national ,59s have %een fond involved in malpractices and
acting irresponsi%ly$ ths ndermining the credi%ility of civil society. It's a hge concern and poses a great challenge to
the development movement spearheaded %y ,59s in the contry.
!here is a hge flow of fnds into the non-government organi"ation sector and this reBires prdence and good
practices to maintain acconta%ility and transparency to the %enefit of all stakeholders. Althogh ,59s do internal
aditing %t for more acconta%ility and transparency$ it is advisa%le to go throgh e&ternal aditing also$ especially
where p%lic fnds are involved. )ence$ isses of internal control mechanisms$ professionalism$ acconta%ility$
transparency and financial management mst %e given impets. !he challenge is mltidimensional$ and is
componded %y the4norganised' natre of the sector$ lack of reglatory frameworks and the fact that India %oasts ofmore than a million ,59s of different roles$ strctres and si"es. In particlar$ the Indian volntary sector rgently
needs self-reglatory gidelines and transparency mechanisms to increase the trst and awareness as to how the
philanthropic fnds are %eing tilised.
!his is a critical challenge that creates a %arrier to raising fnds and capital for the sector. !he general lack of
transparency in the fnctioning of a large proportion of ,59s leads to aversion in donating fnds for charita%le cases
since the general p%lic is largely cynical a%ot the 4genineness' of the non-profit spirit of the sector. !he stringent
governance standards of an ,59 will facilitate the effective management and increase the acconta%ility to its
stakeholders inclding donors$ the government and the commnity. It is in the self-interest of the ,59s to reali"e the
fact that to implement a strctre of 4corporate governance' principles wold provide the real vale to the
stakeholders.
Also$ this wold ena%le to track the potentially d%ios sorces of fnding coming in for the volntary sector M an
aspect which has gained impets in the wake of the increased nm%er of terror attacks and e&tremist activities.
*ecently$ the #nion )ome 8inistry has identified some ,59s as secrity threat to the contry. Sch secrity
considerations have nderscored the rising need of improving the governance practices in the Indian ,59s and
e&ercising %etter reglatory mechanisms$ disclosre norms$ and management processes inclding financial
management and %dgeting systems as well. 8oreover$ in the larger interest going %eyond the secrity
considerations$ the impets has to %e on inclcating a cltre of inclding performance goals$ condcting financial
and performance adits$ and reforms for increasing the operational acconta%ility and transparency in the eyes of the
p%lic$ volnteers$ donors and other stakeholders.
S$))est#ons:
!he implementation of a strategic framework is essentially important in the management of an ,59. !heendorsement of sch a framework %rings in professionalism and internal control mechanisms$ which frther makes
the organi"ation's performance more effective. Developing strategies also inclde esta%lishing a mechanism of
consistent monitoring of whether they are %eing implemented and linking the reslts to the organi"ation's goals.
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
8/14
www.visionias.in Vision IAS
!here is need to %olster p%lic confidence in the volntary sector %y opening it p to greater p%lic scrtiny. !he
5overnment shold encorage :entral and State level agencies to introdce norms for filing %asic docments in
respect of ,59s$ which have %een receiving fnding %y 5overnment agencies and placing them in the p%lic domain
+with easy access throgh the internet0 in order to inclcate a spirit of p%lic oversight.
%lic donation is an important sorce of fnds for the ,59 sector and one that can and mst increase s%stantially.
!a& incentives play a positive role in this process. !he 5overnment cold simplify and streamline the system for
granting income ta& e&emption stats to charita%le pro(ects nder the Income !a& Act. At the same time$ the
5overnment might consider tightening administrative and penal procedres to ensre that these incentives are not
missed %y paper charities for private financial gain.
!he 5overnment shold encorage all relevant :entral and State 5overnment agencies to introdce pre-service and
in-service training modles on constrctive relations with the volntary sector. Sch agencies need to introdce time
%ond procedres for dealing with the V9s. !hese cold cover registration$ income ta& clearances$ financial
assistance$ etc. !here mst %e a formal system for registering complaints and for redressing grievances of ,59s.
!he 5overnment shold encorage setting p of Noint :onsltative 5rops @ Gorms or Noint 8achineries of
government and volntary sector representatives$ %y relevant :entral Departments and State 5overnments. It also
needs to encorage district administrations$ district planning %odies$ district rral development agencies$
"illaparishads and local governments to do so. !hese grops cold %e permanent forms with the e&plicit mandate to
share ideas$ views and information and to identify opportnities and mechanisms of working together. !he5overnment also might introdce sita%le mechanisms for involving a wide cross-section of the volntary sector in
these 5rops@Gorms.
S$mm#n) Up:
6e are entering into an important phase where there are many targets that the government intends to achieve with
the active colla%oration of V9s$ in the 12th
plan. !herefore$ it is important to condct an effective review or report
card of the ,ational olicy with specific recommendations. !hese recommendations cold %ecome an agenda for all
Volntary 9rgani"ations$ lanning :ommission$ state governments and national 8inistries. ;fforts are also needed to
frther disseminate the information a%ot the policy and its intentions with small V9s as well as government
fnctionaries. !here is a need to solicit commitment from state governments and national ministries. A systematic
intervention is also needed to get ,ational olicy approved and adopted %y the Indian arliament. !he most serioschallenge faced %y India today is the conflict %etween violent and non-violent approach of development. ,eedless to
say that ma(ority of poplation of India is still deprived of %asic frits of development$ %t rather than adopting the
approach which is more inclsive and look for soltions within the constittion$ India is faced %y distr%ances in many
parts of the contry. !his not only hampers the development pro(ects %t also shrink the space for people's
participation to achieve their goals throgh peacefl means. !he volntary sector %eing present in sch locations
faces the challenge of delivering the services and even mo%ili"ing people on the development agenda. !he need of the
hor is to work closely with each other for the %enefit of the marginali"ed people$ as even today the dream of
8ahatma 5andhi has not %een achieved.
(v#n) loo*e! t NGOs, no let $s t*e loo* t S(Gs:
/: 0"t re S(Gs3
Self-)elp 5rops are informal associations of people who choose to come together to find ways to improve their living
conditions. !hey help to %ild Social :apital among the poor$ especially women. !he most important fnctions of a
Self-)elp 5rops are
to encorage and motivate its mem%ers to save to persade them to make a collective plan for generation of additional income to act as a condit for formal %anking services to reach them.
Sch grops work as a collective garantee system for mem%ers who propose to %orrow from organised sorces.
:onseBently$ Self-)elp 5rops have emerged as the most effective mechanism for delivery of micro-finance services
to the poor. !he range of financial services may inclde prodcts sch as deposits$ loans$ money transfer and
insrance.
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
9/14
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
10/14
1F www.visionias.in Vision IAS
Rs"tr#%7"#lHos":
!he *ashtriya8ahilaLosh was set p %y the 5overnment of India in 8arch 1/ as an Atonomos 7ody registered
nder Societies *egistration Act$ 1JF nder the Department +now 8inistry0 of 6omen and :hild Development. !he
o%(ective was to facilitate credit spport to poor women for their socio-economic pliftment.It was felt that the credit
needs of poor women$ especially those in the norgani"ed sector$ were not adeBately addressed %y the formal
financial instittions of the contry. !hs *8L was esta%lished to provide loans in a Basi-formal credit delivery
mechanism$ which is client-friendly$ has simple and minimal procedre$ dis%rses Bickly and repeatedly$ has fle&i%le
repayment schedles$ links thrifts and savings with credit and has relatively low transaction costs %oth for the
%orrower and the lender. !he Losh lends with a niBe credit delivery model *8L M ,59-S)5- 7eneficiaries3. !he
spport is e&tended throgh ,59's$ 6omen Development :orporations$ State 5overnment agencies like D*DA's$
Dairy Gederations$ and 8nicipal :oncils etc.
SID
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
11/14
11 www.visionias.in Vision IAS
articipation in grop activity significantly contri%ted to improvement of self-confidence among the mem%ers. In
general$ grop mem%ers and particlarly women %ecame more vocal and assertive on social and family isses.
!he strctre of the S)5 is meant to provide mtal spport to the participants in saving money$ preparing a
common plan for additional income generation and opening %ank acconts that wold help them in developing credit
relationship with a lending instittion. It ltimately spports them in setting p micro-enterprises e.g. personalised
%siness ventres like tailoring$ grocery$ and tool repair shops. It promotes the concept of grop acconta%ility
ensring that the loans are paid %ack. It provides a platform to the commnity where the mem%ers can discss and
resolve important isses of mtal concern.
6hile some of the S)5s have %een initiated %y the local commnities themselves$ many of them have come throgh
the help of a mentor 7ody +either government or an ,590 which provided initial information and gidance to them.
Sch spport often consists of training people on how to manage 7ank acconts$ how to assess small %siness
potential of the local markets and how to pgrade their skills. In the end$ it creates a local team of resorce persons.
5rop formation %ecomes a convenient vehicle for credit delivery in rral areas. :ommercial 7anks and other
instittions which are otherwise not receptive to the demands of marginali"ed individals$ start considering sch
grops as their potential cstomers. 9verall sch Noint-Eia%ility 5rops e&pand the otreach of the micro-finance
programme in an effective way$ reaching ot to the e&clded segments e.g. landless$ sharecroppers$ small and
marginal farmers$ women$ S:s@S!s etc.
!he ma(ority of Self-)elp 5rops comprise of women mem%ers. !here is evidence in this contry as well as elsewhere
that formation of Self-)elp 5rops has a mltiplier effect in improving women's stats in society as well as in the
family. !heir active involvement in micro-finance and related entreprenerial activities not only leads to improvement
in their socio-economic condition %t also enhances their self-esteem. 6omen in a gropenvironment %ecome more
articlate in voicing their concerns and a change occrs in their self-perception. !hey start to see themselves not only
as %eneficiaries %t also as clients @ informed citi"ens seeking %etter services. 9n the home front$ their new fond
awareness and the confidence generated ot of their entreprenerial skills make them more confident vis-P-vis their
menfolk.
!he S)5 programme has contri%ted to a redced dependency on informal money lenders and other non-
instittional sorces. It has ena%led the participating hoseholds to spend more on edcation than non- client
hoseholds. Gamilies participating in the programme have reported %etter school attendance and lower drop-otrates.
!he financial inclsion attained throgh S)5s has led to redced child mortality$ improved maternal health and the
a%ility of the poor to com%at disease throgh %etter ntrition$ hosing and health M especially among women and
children.
7t the S)5 movement has certain weaknesses as well
contrarytothevisionforS)5development$mem%ersofagropdonotcome necessarily from the poorest familiesC the S)5 model has led to definite socialempowerment of the poor %t whetherthe economic gains are
adeBate to %ring a Balitative change in their life is a matter of de%ateC
many of the activities ndertaken %y the S)5s are still %ased on primitive skills related mostly to primarysector enterprises. 6ith poor vale addition per worker and prevalence of s%sistence level wages$ schactivities often do not lead to any s%stantial increase in the income of grop mem%ers.
!here is lack of Balified resorce personnel in the rral areas who cold help in skill pgradation@acBisitionof new skills %y grop mem%ers.
/: 0"t t"en re t"e *e% #ss$es 'c#n) S(Gs to!%3
!hogh$ dring a short span of fifteen years the S)5 movement has recorded remarka%le progress mch still remains
to %e done. !he movement shows steep territorial variations. 8any areas of the contry lack adeBate %anking
strctre. #r%an and semi-r%an areas$ to a large e&tent$ stand e&clded from this mode of credit delivery. Grther
growth of this movement faces threat from inadeBacy of skills in the rral areas. And finally the pace of the
movement needs to %e accelerated. !he following eight isses of this sector deserve priority attention
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
12/14
12 www.visionias.in Vision IAS
Q 7#nt#n#n) t"e prt#c#ptor% c"rcter
6e saw the cooperative sector %ecame a spring%oard for political aspirants. !hogh the S)5 movement is relatively
new$ government interventions and s%sidies have already started showing negative reslts. !he patronage and
s%sidies provided to the S)5s %y government and the anchayats often lead to their politici"ation. !herefore$ de
care mst %e taken to ensre that government initiatives do not erode the fndamental principles of self-help and
empowerment of the poor.
Q Nee! to e6pn!the S)5 movement to States sch as 7ihar$ #ttar radesh$ 8adhya radesh$ 9rissa$ *a(asthan andin the ,orth-;ast +where the S)5 movement and micro-finance entreprenership is weak0
9verall K/O of the farmer hosehold +in rral areas0 have no access to any formal sorce of credit. In 8arch$ 2FF1$
K1O of the total linked S)5s of the contry were in (st for States of the sothern region vi". Andhra radesh$
Larnataka$ Lerala and !amil ,ad. !he figre went down to O in 2FF$
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
13/14
1/ www.visionias.in Vision IAS
;ven after many years of e&istence$ %y and large$ S)5s are heavily dependent on their promoter ,59s or government
agencies
Q 5#nnc#l ss#stnce toS(PIs n! ot"ers$pport#nst#t$t#ons
Gorty-five per cent of the total nm%ers of women S)5s of the contry are located in Andhra radesh. !his envia%le
position of the State is primarily de to the initiative shown %y promoter ,59s often known as Self-)elp romoting
Instittions +S)Is0 @ mentor organisations. If the S)5 movement is to spread across the entire contry$ there is need
to provide ma(or incentives to S)Is @ promoter ,59s. :rrently$ the financial spport to S)Is comes from the 8icroGinance Development and ;Bity Gnd +8GD;G0 of ,A7A*D. It is limited to an amont of *s.1FF per S)5 +formed
and activated0. !o attract more and more S)Is to the rral areas$ this Bantm of spport needs to %e revised.
Q Role o' 7#cro&5#nnce Inst#t$t#ons
8icro-credit is defined as provision of thrift$ credit$ and other financial services +sch as deposits$ loans$ payment
services$ money transfer$ insrance and related prodcts0 of very small amonts to the poor in rral$ semi-r%an and
r%an areas for ena%ling them to raise their income levels and improve living standards. 8icro-finance instittions are
those which provide sch micro-credit facilities. 8icro-credit is an instrment of %oth social as well as economic
policy. It opens p integral development processes sch as se of financial and technical resorces$ %asic services and
training opportnities to the nprivileged. Access to savings$ credit$ money- transfer$ payment$ and insrance can help
poor people take control of their financial life. It also empowers them to make critical choices a%ot investing in%siness$ sending children to school$ improving health care of the family$ covering the cost of key social o%ligations
and nforeseen sitations. 7t the most important of all$ an access to finance generates self- esteem among them.
ARC&has made the following recommendations and the 8icro Ginance Sector +Development and *eglation0 7ill$
2FFK needs to %e amended to inclde the following sggestions-
!he scope of 8icro-finance Services shold %e s%stantially widened to cover credit @ savings$ insrance$pension services$ money transfer$ isse @ discont of warehose receipts and ftre @ option contracts for
agricltral commodities and forest prodce.
!he activities of Section 2 :ompanies to the e&tent they concern micro-financial services as descri%ed nderthe proposed 7ill shold also %e %roght nder the prview of this legislation. )owever$ for their
management and other fnctions$ they will contine to %e governed %y the provisions of the :ompanies Act.
!he isse of interest rate charged %y the 8GIs shold %e left to the *eglatory Athority which is %eingcreated nder the proposed 7ill.
It shold %e ensred that if 8GIs are allowed to handle thrift @ savings and money transfer services$ theywold do so only as %siness correspondents of commercial 7anks.
/: 0#t" n e%e on t"e '$t$re, let $s e6plore Corporte&S(G l#n*)es 'or r$rl mr*ets:
*ral 8arket offers tremendos potential of growth for corporations %y making their prodcts and services availa%le
to these areas. Eot of interventions are designed %y varios companies to tap the rral market inclding designing
tailor made spply chain$ rral marketing campaigns$ prning marketing mi& elements and integrating social elements
to develop their %rand awareness and market for their prodcts. Apart from all these endeavors there is still asignificant area largely ntapped. Integration of S)5s with corporations as a part of their company policies in tackling
the isses of reach and market awareness is a win-win soltion. 6ith varios government initiatives inclding
romotion of S)5 formation$ microenterprise development$ microcredit %y GIIs and ,7G:s and skill training$ S)5s are
%ecoming via%le in their operations. Sym%iotic association of corporations and S)5s tili"ing distinctive competence
can prove to %e fritfl for %oth in the long rn %roadly in the form of market and socio-economic development. S)5s
are %roadly stdied on two %asis- 8icrofinance and 8icroenterprises. !he first aspect of S)5s +8icrofinance0 is widely
stdied and several changes have %een incorporated towards making S)5s via%le. Development of 8icro-enterprises
is relatively a new phenomenon. As per stdy of 8.Lnhaman$ 2F12$ S)5s can %etter promote 8icro-enterprises$
especially in rral areas.
!he real effort to spport S)5s in India$ however$ came in the late 1Fs when the central government of Indiaintrodced a holistic program$ S5SH- Swarna(ayanti 5ram Swaro"garHo(ana %ased on the grop approach for rral
development. !he S5SH approach was to encorage the rral poor to organise themselves into S)5s and to
independently take p via%le economic activities as micro-enterprises with spport from government s%sidies and
8/12/2019 The Role of NGOs SHGS Development Processes
14/14
1< www.visionias.in Vision IAS
%ank credit. 6ith the development of indstrial norms$ micro-enterprises are also coming p apart from large$
medim and small indstries. 8icro-enterprises can %e started and managed %y individals$ grops or S)5s. Intended
to strengthen via%le$ small %sinesses$ reslting in increased hosehold income and savings and ths alleviating the
crnch of economic poverty$ 8icro-enterprise development aims at %ilding self-esteem$ self-reliance$ encoraging
atonomy and creating a commnity atmosphere. It %ilds economic capital %y creating (o%s and generating income$
ltimately working towards commnity development in impoverished or nemployed areas.
!he report of the working committee of *7I +1