1579 THE RIGHT TO KNOW: AN APPROACH TO GUN LICENSES AND PUBLIC ACCESS TO GOVERNMENT RECORDS Kelsey M. Swanson * Every state has passed laws, often called open records statutes or freedom of information acts, that provide for disclosure of certain information possessed by government agencies. But how does a state legislature decide which information should be subject to disclosure? Is there a discernable pattern in the types of records available to the public? Using concealed carry licenses as the main example, this Comment explains the inconsistencies that often characterize states’ treatment of different records and attempts to bring clarity by offering a new framework for determining which types of personally identifiable information should be available to the public. The proposed framework focuses on (1) the substantial value of the information to others in structuring their social and economic interactions, and (2) the underlying purpose of the practice implicated by the record. Taken together, these prongs address the needs of the public in a systematic manner, while explaining the current state treatment of common records, such as arrest, property tax, medical, and personnel records. Applied to the gun license context, this understanding of government records suggests that such licenses should be available to the public. INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................1580 I. THE PROBLEM: STATE TREATMENT OF GUN RECORDS IN OPEN RECORDS STATUTES ..................................................................................................1583 A. Current Concealed Carry Provisions ................................................................1583 B. Catchall Privacy Exemptions ............................................................................1585 C. Other Firearm Records ......................................................................................1587 D. Policy Justifications............................................................................................1588 E. Agency Discretion and Open Records Goals ...................................................1590 II. AN EXAMINATION OF OTHER RECORDS CONTAINING PERSONAL INFORMATION..........................................................................................1592 A. Income and Property Tax Records ....................................................................1592 B. Individual Medical Records...............................................................................1593 * Senior Editor, UCLA Law Review, Volume 56; J.D., UCLA School of Law, 2009; B.A. and B.S., Santa Clara University, 2006. I am grateful for the helpful comments and critiques of Professor Eugene Volokh, the students of the academic writing circle, and the UCLA Law Review, especially Dale Larson. Most importantly, I want to thank my parents, my brother and sister, and my fiancé, Brent, for their constant encouragement, support, and love.
THE RIGHT TO KNOW: AN APPROACH TO GUN LICENSES AND PUBLIC ACCESS TO GOVERNMENT RECORDS
Jul 05, 2023
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Related Documents
