The Problem of the Grudge Informer

8/3/2019 The Problem of the Grudge Informer

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-problem-of-the-grudge-informer 1/9

APPENDIX: THE PROBLEM OF i

TH'E IOR,U:DG'B, I ,N' :poa:M:E, 'R,

; ! ! I i , J i l I , & '[~

Copy r ig hted m ate ri a l



' ! i " ! i I AC . : '[iiii~U




TH 'B 0_U'''D68-- I - " N - - ' P - ' O - -aM-- 'SR'. - . . ; I . . i : . . . . ,: ,I' II I ~ " ; : : . ,> . I. ,': : 1 ' . . . . . 1 ' 1 : , : :_1 .:: .. : 1 " . : I, I .._ ' _ _ .•. _ '. _ '_ "... _ _ '_ _ ._ '_ '_ ,_J .•

Copy r i g hted m a te r i a l



,A,PPEN,D,I..X

to cO n fen :DQ e~ A'l.tRle con fe re nee d le D,V 1C Depu,t ies , : s p e ' a ' k in tum'i!:IIC!, f" ,ft1i~,n'W' ' , ' s : , •t;W1 _,vJHlv. ," _".I

'F~RS'fDEP'I}TY~~~ ,Its pm iedtly c lear to m e that 'w e [ c a m do [ladlin.g

,about th es e s o..i::aj1 ed B'tud: t re informers" The acts th ,--"eoened- - - - - - - - , - - - ,- ,I!!t" ' - - - D" ---, - - -,' ,-, , ac s -ey , r...., -

were un law fu l fUccoId in l ; to fil e tui[es of th e ,government then in ,

actuM , con ,tm l 0 :" 'the n a t i o n , " : s , 8 'ffairs. T he se nten ce s : m m J p o s e d , on

the1r victim s 'w ·cr-e:,cl1der,ed ill accord anee: wi th p : r i n c i I p l [ c 5 , of !ltW

t hen . obta~in:il1g,. Th,esf" p lin ci,p ie s d:if te red 'fro m th ose 'fIlDU:iar' to

HI i~ , waysdi ,a t ' w 1 e consider del'e s'table. :Nievertheless, t " h e y weretbeiJ i l tbe ~Qw ~f the I,~lld..One o " - f the ~r,inc:in,'7,tl l ,A,"f' -' enc ' •1 4 " , , :+ , - :- , !~- ~ .....', - - iii!! - - - - - - - ,I'" - - -t'iW. Ulll!leJCn,ces uclI.we-en

'diat, hlW and our own ltes in the m uch 'w ider discretion ' ~ ' C ,;B,coor,ded

to the judge in c-rim,inalmaJt~ers,., This rule a ( [ l d its c eas eq ue n ee s

are as nU lch en.ti.tled to r ! e s , p e c . t by 'U s as the; reform 'w h , ie b , , t ih , e :

, P u : r p : l e Shirts : in. troduced, i:nto the bl,w' of will,s" whe reby [o aty two.

wi lmesses 'w ere requ ired ln s tead o f' th re e, It ~s immatedaltn,at

th e 'm' le granth lS 'th e judl l';e a, mo r e or less, uneon t ro l ted discr,etion

in crlminal eases was never f o rmaUy enac ted 'but, was a 'mIlleT'

O 'f tac it [ac ce ptan ce . E~xacUy the sa-m e dl,i'i l,g can 'b e s : a i d , . o f ' theoppos i t e rule wh i ch we:accept that restric ts ,the ,jn d,g e's discretion

D M .F [o w : l y ~ Toe ; dUifer [enoe between o u r : s - e ~ l v ! e s 8 J , n . d the 'P urp 'le Shins

is, not tbat theirs w ,as ;ao uolawf 'ul , l o v 1 e r . n m e . n . t : - - - = a cOIll.tr~adi,ctton.

'in te rm s bu t l ies , rather in the ' f ield, o f : i d , e - o , 1 o g y " N o, one has a

,pea;te:r abhorrence tnsnl for Pu:rp'le , S h ' k t i s m m 'V ie t the f unda -

m en tal di.fte '"en oe ' b e t w l e r e ; n our' plli , losoph.y and. theirs w s 'Chat we

'p e rm , it and te lerare d : ~ R e f 1 e ; n o e s , i . n v:i 'ewpoint, while they ,anemptedto impo s e 'lhe:ir m e no l ith le code OR everyone ' . Ou:,' wh o le :sys tem

. o f gov e r nmen t assumes that l a . w ' is a ft,e x:ib le d~'ing~icapa'ble o f

e~p'es'Sjng, and 'efifeCUll,atin.,g 'many dUlereH' t . a ims , The cardb]aJ

po in t o f' our creed is tb,at when an ob jec t jve has 'been duly' ineor -

p o rm ted in to a law or jud ie ial decree i, t :mus ' t 'b e 'p rov is io .oaJ Iy - ae-

eep ted even by those that hare :;t; w ho HUlS t . a,w',ait their' chance

at the polls,~O F ' :inanother nUS;3IiUO:il" 'to secure a ] i eg~dT , o c o g n i t i o n

fo r 'th e~ irow n alm s 'T he , Pu rp le Sh ,irts ,t o n th e odle r hand, s imp ly

disJle,garded ~,a ,ws thaLt :iacorperated objectives of wbi.ch ' n ley did

no t ap prov e, not even conside;dng, it 'wor th, the ,e ffio rt in 'yolved



T D j ' I ~ , O · , · ~ · · ·. , - ' . ' U I · ; . · D - : [ ~ , ' 1 - " . r ~"!B 0 [ ' ' I I i I : ' iU' B·'·,~" .. 1. . 'LIt nl~· .--- ------ -- -- - -

_CON!O :O.EPUTi'". [ "~ur , ious l , ,~1 , [ m , i , v e , at: the SfdIU): [eOJn~~]Hkm,15

., eo:lleape{~ i b : y ' ,alii. [e -DCl1, opposi te mute~ T10 m .e h, :seems ,10 . ,

surd, to cal l i l h e : Ptr~~~-'bllt· '-:~Qt~,~',(' ' 1 ' - ' w f l l J ~ '~nUI~ft!t A.le~~,li.... '.~-~ ~---~ ~lJle ,~-~-,,rc~mc a _8... _. ~~¥----" '.''''''C~- - -

' s , s tem, [ d O e s , B ot: ex ist sim p ly' because : p o U c e m m , ,eol!tt~IUllC~onmfm] 'IP' :S '''~ ii;S , .. . . . . . 0 :1 . , ~ ~ ~ . '~' iI i ;i l l i [~f[~ii:].:~i: '! ~i" '~"'~I"I1i,liI!~: a ~n""tiit!UittMl,r~- -- -~~ ..~I~Il.. , , _ l I U " - ~ ~ u l l . ~ . _ 1 f~.lll.l.~ ~ . J ~ . ~ . ~ '~l~ "_~__ ~~ _d ~ Ide 10 . 1:0 ._[1" ... ~ \ a " " 1 A·~· [~311'[ .,:~,:~: a r e : ~J;;,_u. OD [ b i e 5u~: : 1 l0 R ; ) lC l : l !U .? u . , ~ . ~ . l e , p _ : s : " s t e m 'pre-

:S'u\~ s ,~ a 'W S,m at are ' k IROW Iii , t o r ' CaD, be k'n.own" [ b y ' tbose: : s u J b , r l r e c l

to t b .@ I I] , . , [ I t : ' prauppos .es ' s o m e i t l l l i foIml ty e l f ac,tion and ' t l b a t , :~ilte:~- ,

[Cuts, \ V , i n : ' 0 0 : g ivm :ijte t r e a l m : e n t , I ' t p m i l i lp p o s e s , ~ 'h e :, a h J .e n .o o :Q t '

:m~' :1]§'W 1al r ! l C ' ! : 'nn""'~r,~~'~iL.,.1 1 ; . ; , ~ ,Purele ~ " I : , j ~ i I " *- - - : , ' ; ! i~1t~ ;i l!J~~I.dJ';~ IQ i' :;o oc '~ r'l ..{a!- -~M"" lu,.~Il~ljll" iIr""''ft§, [ I~II !.."" [..~:l~ ._u~rJ,e ~Db,!!!o, _ AII,I!!o" l! ! [~!!!O~Ii.. .I~. i4Ul) ' 9 . " I I iO '

'ii!"l..p !On''iji,8:i''!ftm~~~*n.t·~n,A · B ' ' ' ' ' I ~ . '' 8 " ' " : 8 ' r.Ii,",,' :t'~J-e'i_ '~nj~ •• _ 'n!;~li;lL. '1 " ' ' " ' ' ' ' '1 , ,. .A ] ~'_II~ o~[1!·~~~,~_~I_~l~!!Ll ~YI :_ 'v .~ ~ . _ _:.. _\11_"'~' l~_~~L_ '. :· !5!V 11L'~I!_~~:II~~~ I"~Uu.u.; au.-

'Rliiilli.:tt~I'f:' ,'rT'-4!:!'--, 'w ' IT - - ~ ' ~ , - ~ ,'" :"jt"~""''':' ,'~~' +1i"'.~'-it"'~·1 : ·~·,~4~,~,,_~L~~~~S._!.U1D 0' , lIlJS",ICe,~. :lIllIj!:e,'¥er I,. ~ 5i , 1 1 1 0 ' 1 , ,l l . !IIJln:.c,,~Dfil l 8CeOIUID,I,

' t . o the w 'h:( rn s,O 'f ' t i l a t : P O w , e r , ,A U of' 'tlhcse p r , e - S l p p o s l t k m s , en!ttl'

l inJtu'the ~.~ [oonoom ' i o l l 1 ,af an ,,);rd.' [o f ~ : - : - 'W ':-:~d'hj-~'" ' l lo t 'bMg,to- .... ~ -. '"""·"1 ... , ... , :........, ..... "",. ','~ '._ ' , . a . . _ ~ . . _ " I I· . . · ! I ! l O ' ~ ~ " - - . . . . , .

dQ w litll, ~:~it[ta] aad ee l JRomi e i d c o l o , D ! c s " I n , m : v [.,n1i1j1iSD 1 ; 1 ' " :in~i ~:.,;, ~'r~-III!M J , ' ,ordiH1'Y sease of 't 'litO W OI "d . [ceas.ed ' 1 . 0 exist: 'w 'hem the ,hrpie

Ibi i ids, came : '~o powe r. ,Du rin l 'tlIe ir repe we ' h a d ] , m . [elm; anIlnI'tirre,gn[Utll : i 0 ! the; ruh~'o f' ~ aw .,, I · m s m a d . 0 1 ' I,go ' -ernm~nj t m ' ialws'iUiiIo ' 1 r : . . . fI i ,81 'ii:~\iIIi;I'" [ " " f ~ ' a' 'II'~ ,!i:iI~tI~''"''r~~' ,-I'll [~ ,on-: l i f I"~II~~.6d"1 ~··· :b' :~ i~d·· '· · f t ' - . i i I ; d " i ,~L"""t'i!'\-.,"'"",, ,IJliIU , "'"'.... ' 1Ul __ I, ~b~~ t . , [ltiu Cll l ; ; ! '~~ui l ! l , . . . ,~ . . . . .~.~h~., .. @iIi".,~ ~.1.,5,![

b l , d.k a)]!Gywa"St il l p alac e bl.trlpes'j[ .£1 prmon..;,ard. C O l i l. "

S tfr:ac in .. T he ;On t;s,f" ~ i ! : - -Y ~ '. ~ ~ ' . : , ; I ~ " " ' : ~ l ~[,' i l '~I-',:: i" ,~ '~ : ;:; '~ ~ : ~~~ ': '. ' r',~:j :·'r,'t:" p ~ - ,~ . _ ~ _ , '" " ' ' " _ (L Ut~"eR:so<a~Q.iI,"roup In~lUlr:ters wer.e JILIS

one: 'phase [o f 'that: w , e r . · " For us t ' .o con .•• n , , t ' h e s e acts IS, er.imi a m ,would . lo ,y o :l : v e a s MIO l l , m c o d i , I N i 1 t y ' M, if w e w ere t 'O [ iattemp t 'to,a.,pl,' j ;u ris t i~ iQQ o ce p tio n s ,tO r 't'hestr~,gfeif~ r ' e D 5tcD e t: , that PIon . [t~ ..,'~. J " I I ~ 1 ! I i ~ ' 1 i F 4 :o r benea ~ " I i o - ' ~ ' h ~ ' ! i : ! : [ ~ I " r f. - ; , ~ ~ [~f~~,1J..~: i:j,~,8~1Jl~~j [:[-~I~t,'.'~',~ :- ~ ~I, Uti .... ,..Q....ay.'" . \Ii ~. i I . " " '__Il.IiI, IJ.. " '" OJU" _"'""" Y. '~1111I!!i~~!,"e miliJ, 'S, ,pit

2-.41....

",:.," [."

~ ,".;.".:

Copy rig hted m ateri a l



o I i , pi ':!Ii; a " N " I'n'iiI' 'V_'_- ' I~~'_-" '_ .U~IA

' t b j s , w b n l c dako t J a w t e s s [ c i a p t e r ' o f' [ a . . Risto l l ' b c l b J i r D d , s :lib: , ' I . ' b ~ ' ~ " ~ , A ' , , : , , : : ,~,'[~~I-,- I : 'f : '~ ' ~ ~ : , : : : ' ; t ' l t - : ~ i i i " '-I-[IG i ! r i' ; D ' "till" b~:n~i'""" '1'I~'" - ' : s : , 'b - _ 1"'1'111: a r . . r i " " ' I I ~ c ' '~l;nnn,11a _,au,w,eag, '~~'w~ i , 1 ' J . , aBtU;,"~iI~lkl;!! ._a~iJ.I~"-:li'__Iii' __)~II!I, 'VI,~, ll!o<l!r-~"

[o "],· e - l :m m e th iD l o f ' iiI [ c ;v i ]SP l ri t _d r 1 S k uuectiol1 f rom, 15 ,

'm i i c a s m u - ~ diimef-a~e:S 3 r ' V 'wia 'm y O O n e j a ~ I ~ ~ ' let ~~\~---Sl be ~~ -•• _ .- ~ ~ - ~~ l. " I _~_ __ ' ._~~_,__ .~ ~ .. _ - __ -..;I ' ._.- _"'_. __ . -"'D~' ':11 I._-,_ [~ I'a -Y '~ -" '- ' . ~ . _ U , J

ann;iI!iC 'Le t 'Il.ICl: IAI_: ' I U l t l r i i l : i l 'I l I i ' : a b o - m t ' , t h e - ' : C!~-eal [ t ld .'~~~,QfI!; '~rmHS,!e.lI~~-"~-~!!1 ~._ - . __ .~ YU '-'--"---~-o . _,___1 .__ "_._. ~ - _. - ... ~.~ .. ' . _. II -"~

W1i,-ft t ! b : : : ' ~ l _ " d ; ! d , do ,~~,c,~~_ n e t d i J . : e : r ' I a w f l - I l - : ~ ' o r oontlr,_":' t~ l -w , ' for ' thei~ '_ ,._1 )., _ ~".Ii ,.0wp . ,1 . , '. ' u n_~, "~'O , _ a , ~ ~ ~ _ _ ~.. .. -

I ~ l y e d ; , : 1 1 1 0 0 1 ,wnder ,I , : r - e , i l m , e [of : I a w I' ' b l a , t 'under' O l l e o ! ' aud_, :m d:I i~I'1"'.;o~''I i ''L- ' IF. -I l ~ U ti] ~







. , P . , " j D i ' 1 : : 1 , 1 f I 1 ' ~ ' j I j ' 'yRJ _ ,~' [~ 1,1 .~ ,~,4!. .

Copy r i g hted m a te r i a l




The Problem of the Grudge Informer

Documents