8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
1/21
THE POWERS OF
GOVERNMENT
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
2/21
Principle of Separation ofPowers
The system ofseparation of powerscontemplates thedivision of the
functions ofgovernment into itsthree (3) branches:the legislative which
is empowered tomake laws; theexecutive which isrequired to carry outthe law; and the
judiciary which is
LEG
ISLATIVE
EX
ECUTIVE
JU
DICIAL
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
3/21
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
4/21
INTERDEPENDENCE, NOT TOTALINDEPENDENCE
The separation of powersis a fundamental principle inour system of government. Itobtains not through expressprovision but by actual division inour Constitution. Each departmentof the government has exclusive
cognizance of matters within its jurisdiction, and is supreme withinits own sphere. But it does notfollow from the fact that the threepowers are to be kept separateand distinct that the Constitutionintended them to be absolutely
unrestrained and independent ofeach other. The Constitution hasprovided for an elaboratesystem of checks and balancesto secure coordination in theworkings of the variousdepartments of the
government.
This is not tosay, however, thatthese branches ofgovernment aretotally independentof each other.
Rather, the systemlaid down under ourpresent Constitutionprescribes interplayin the exercise o
those separate anddistinct powers.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
5/21
First, legislative power
a paramount force in a
republican system likeours. Being, as we are,
a government of laws
and not of men, all theinherent powers of ou
State police power,
taxation and eminen
domain can only beexercised through
legislative fiat.
So, whatpowers are
involved inthis systemand how isthe interplayeffected?
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
6/21
But, what is legislative power?
Legislative power is the authority tomake laws and to alter or repeal them,and this power is vested with the
Congress under Section 1, Article VI ofthe 1987 Constitution which states:Section 1. The legislative power shall be vested in
the Congress of the Philippines which shall consist of aSenate and a House of Representatives, except to the
extent reserved to the people by the provision oninitiative and referendum.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
7/21
Legislative poweris
the authority, under the Constitution, to make laws, andto alter and repeal them. The Constitution, as the will ofthe people in their original, sovereign and unlimited
capacity, has vested this power in the Congress of thePhilippines. The grant of legislative power to Congress isbroad, general and comprehensive. The legislative bodypossesses plenary power for all purposes of civilgovernment. Any power, deemed to be legislative byusage and tradition, is necessarily possessed by Congress,unless the Constitution has lodged it elsewhere. In fine,except as limited by the Constitution, either expressly orimpliedly, legislative power embraces all subjects andextends to matters of general concern or common interest. (Ople vs. Torres)
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
8/21
Congress inherent legislativepowers, broad as they may be, aresubject to certain limitations. As
early as 1927, in Government v.Springer, the Court has defined, inthe abstract, the limits on legislativepower in the following wise:
Someone has said that thepowers of the legislative department
of the Government, like theboundaries of the ocean, areunlimited. In constitutionalgovernments, however, as well asgovernments acting under delegatedauthority, the powers of each of thedepartments x x x are limited and
confined within the four walls of theconstitution or the charter, and eachdepartment can only exercise suchpowers as are necessarily impliedfrom the given powers. TheConstitution is the shore of legislativeauthority against which the waves oflegislative enactment may dash, butover which it cannot leap.
Butlegislativ
epower,asbroad
asitis,IsNOT
unrestrai
Th l i l ti i
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
9/21
Thus, legislative power remains
limited in the sense that it is subject tosubstantive and constitutional
limitations which circumscribe both theexercise of the power itself and theallowable subjects of legislation. Thesubstantive constitutional limitationsare chiefly found in the Bill of Rightsand other provisions, such as Sec. 3,Art. VI of the Constitution prescribing
the qualifications of candidates forsenators.
---SJS vs. vs. Dangerous Drugs Board, et al.. GR # 157870,
Nov. 3, 2008
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
10/21
However, to forestall the danger ofcongressional encroachment beyond
the legislative sphere, the Constitutionimposes two basic and relatedconstraints on Congress. It may not vestitself, any of its committees or its
members with either executive orudicial power. And, when it exercisesits legislative power, it must follow thesingle, finely wrought and exhaustively
considered, procedures specifiedunder the Constitution, including theprocedure for enactment of laws andpresentment. ( )
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
11/21
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
12/21
Second, executive power
The executive power is vested in the President. It isgenerally defined as the power to enforce and administer laws. Itis the power of carrying the laws into practical operation andenforcing their due observance. This makes the President thesingle most powerful person in the state.
As head of the Executive Department, the President is theChief Executive. He represents the government as a whole andsees to it that all laws are enforced by the officials and employeesof his department. He has control over the executivedepartment, bureaus and offices. This means that he has theauthority to assume directly the functions of the executivedepartment, bureau and office, or interfere with the discretion ofits officials. Corollary to the power of control, the President alsohas the duty of supervising the enforcement of laws for themaintenance of general peace and public order. Thus, he isgranted administrative powerover bureaus and offices under hiscontrol to enable him to discharge his duties effectively.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
13/21
Aside from these, thePresident has other powersspecifically granted under theConstitution military power,the pardoning power, treatymaking power, among others and those powers granted under
the laws, including residualpowers granted under EO 292.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
14/21
Third,judicialpower.
This Courts power of judicial reviewis conferred on the judicial branch ofthe government in Section 1, ArticleVIII of our present 1987 Constitution:
SECTION 1. The judicial powershall be vested in one SupremeCourt and in such lower courts asmay be established by law.
Judicial power includes theduty of the courts of justice to settleactual controversies involving rightswhich are legally demandable andenforceable, and to determinewhether or not there has been agrave abuse of discretionamounting to lack or excess ofjurisdiction on the part of anybranch or instrumentality of thegovernment. (Emphasis supplied)
the most passive butnonetheless aspotent as legislat vested in the
Judiciary theSupreme Court andthe lower courtscreated by law. Thepower is referred toas the power ofjudicial review.
ive and executive
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
15/21
x x x In times of social disquietude or politicalexcitement, the great landmarks of the Constitution areapt to be forgotten or marred, if not entirely obliterated.In cases of conflict, the judicial department is theonly constitutional organ which can be called uponto determine the proper allocation of powersbetween the several departments and among theintegral or constituent units thereof.
As any human production, our Constitution is of courselacking perfection and perfectibility, but as much as itwas within the power of our people, acting through theirdelegates to so provide, that instrument which is the
expression of their sovereignty however limited, hasestablished a republican government intended tooperate and function as a harmonious whole, under asystem of checks and balances, and subject to specificlimitations and restrictions provided in the said
instrument.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
16/21
The Constitution sets forth in no uncertain language the
restrictions and limitations upon governmental powersand agencies. If these restrictions and limitations aretranscended it would be inconceivable if theConstitution had not provided for a mechanism by whichto direct the course of government along constitutionalchannels, for then the distribution of powers would be mereverbiage, the bill of rights mere expressions of sentiment, andthe principles of good government mere political apothegms.Certainly, the limitations and restrictions embodied in ourConstitution are real as they should be in any livingconstitution. In the United States where no expressconstitutional grant is found in their constitution, thepossession of this moderating power of the courts, not tospeak of its historical origin and development there, has beenset at rest by popular acquiescence for a period of more thanone and a half centuries. In our case, this moderating power isgranted, if not expressly, by clear implication from
section 2 of article VIII of our Constitution.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
17/21
And when the judiciary mediates toallocate constitutional boundaries, it does notassert any superiority over the other departments; it
does not in reality nullify or invalidate an act of thelegislature, but only asserts the solemn and sacredobligation assigned to it by the Constitution todetermine conflicting claims of authority underthe Constitution and to establish for the partiesin an actual controversy the rights which thatinstrument secures and guarantees to them. Thisis in truth all that is involved in what is termed"judicial supremacy" which properly is the power ofudicial review under the Constitution.
JUDICIAL SUPREMACY
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
18/21
We find therefore that the powers of thesethree branches of government do not overlap; theseparation is real and exists as the powers areactually divided and allocated among the threebranches. The system has been elaboratelydesigned so that the branches interact, not
compete, with each other; so that the powerscomplement, not clash with, each other, so that inthe exercise of these powers, the branches checkand balance, not control, each other. Often,
however, conflicts arise as to the interpretationand exercise of these powers.
In cases involving separation of
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
19/21
In cases involving separation ofpowers, the rulings of the SupremeCourt have streamed along certain
logical bases What the Constitution provides ;The Supreme Court, as guardian of the
Constitution, will always uphold what is providedunder the Constitution. To make its
determination, the Supreme Court interprets theConstitution, not as piecemeal provisions, but as awhole. Usually also, if it is possible to decide thecontroversy without putting its foot down on theusurpation-of-power issue, it will decide it onother considerations. Also, it will not shirk away
from its duty to settle controversies just because itis, or any one of its members, is in the thick of theissue. So there is no such thing as judicialrestraint, as long as all the requisites for
justiciability are present.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
20/21
In cases involving separation of powers, therulings of the Supreme Court have streamed
along certain logical bases
The nature of the power allegedlyusurped;
The Court will decide one
way or the other based on thenature of the power allegedlyusurped, if there is a clash
between the legislative andexecutive branches. However, if itis the judicial sphere which is beingencroached upon, it will always put
its foot down.
8/14/2019 The Powers of Government
21/21
In cases involving separation of powers, therulings of the Supreme Court have streamed
along certain logical bases
The protection of individual rights,if an individual person is caught inthe clash.
A paramount considerationwhen deciding cases involvingseparation of powers is whether ornot there is an individual rightwhich must be protected. For the
courts decide not merely toallocate the boundaries among thebranches of government, but alsoto provide relief to those who seek
judicial recourse meritoriously