The Origins of Journalism in India
Dec 31, 2015
The Origins of Journalism in India
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
From time immemorial, news comprised of issues, laws or actions that kings or governments (currently) dealt with or implemented
Inscriptions on walls of temples, on copper plates, victory coins and writing on walls
Town criers, wandering minstrels, folk artists
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
The newspaper as we know today is of European origin
Wall posters were the forerunners of the newspaper in Europe
They first appeared in Venice, in 1566 They were called Notize Scritte (written
notices) and were displayed in public places A small token fee of a small coin called
gazetta was levied on those who wanted to read them
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Individual newsletters sent to businessmen and statesmen containing foreign news
News books
1621 primitive news sheet called coranto
The first periodical to come close to the newspaper was the Oxford Gazette in 1655
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Printed twice a week and after 24 issues became the London Gazette
It was in the 18 century that the newspaper as we know now – with daily publication and miscellaneous content emerged
Parties emerged at the very time when the newspapers came to be a force in the political and social affairs of a people interested more and more in government
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Once the authorities realised the value of printing and publishing news, they kept a firm grip on the press and nothing could be published without a license
It was a time which presented the writer with two options : truth and lies
One could not know easily where truth lay and so authority had to lead the way
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
On March 11, 1702, the first daily newspaper appeared in London , the Daily Courant
Produced and sold by E. Mallet, it lasted only for a few days
However, it was revived by Samuel Buckley who made it into a remarkable newspaper
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
He did not want it to be a rumour mill and was determined that it should report factual news rather than opinion
He was always careful to indicate the place and date for the news he published, so that “the public seeing from what country a piece of news comes with the allowance of that Government, may be better able to judge of the credibility and fairness of the relations”
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Newspapers in India
The newspaper came to India as an alien product, one of the benefits of British rule
In the early years it was confined to and served the interests of the ruling classes
The East India company not favourably inclined to newspapers and specially criticisms
The press in India controlled by Englishmen drew its strength from the power of the press in England
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Calcutta- Birthplace of Journalism in India First newspaper- Bengal Gazette (Calcutta
General Advertiser)- January 29th 1780 in Calcutta, two sheet weekly
Editor : James Augustus Hicky Gossip and scandal- for European readers No editorial, but Hicky’s Column Described as a ‘witty and scurrilous’ paper
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Hicky was not popular with officials, merchants and businessmen
Ample publicity to social do’s and life, but also ridiculed them
Used the paper to hit out at people he disliked Enmity of Governor general Warren Hastings
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
‘Indian Gazette’ rival to the Bengal Gazette came in the same year
4 pages, 16 inches long, well printed and better
Readers started deserting him Hicky attacked his proprietors (suspected for
supplying types to his rival) Indian Gazette was also granted postal
facilities, whereas Hicky was denied Hicky complained to readers Advised to approach Mrs Hastings
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
In 1781 Hicky was convicted of defamation on two counts, sentenced to a year of imprisonment and Rs 2000 fine
Although in prison, the Bengal Gazettte continued to appear and was now more defiant
Great public support
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
But in March 1782, Hastings seized the types used for printing on the paper and Hickys Gazette winded up
Within 6 years of Hickys newspaper four weeklies and a monthly were started in Calcutta
In Bombay and Madras there were very few newspapers
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
In 1785 the Madras Courier which was officially recognized and owned by the government printer
1793- Hurkaru, Editor Boyd which lasted one year
The Indian Herald an unauthorized newspaper edited by Humphrey
He was punished for printing without permission
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
There were no newspapers in Bombay till 1789
1789, the Bombay Herald was started
It merged into the Bombay Gazette in 1791 and became an official publication
The Courier started in 1790 had the distinction of carrying Gujrathi ads to serve Indian readership
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
The governments attitude was one of contempt for newspapers and their editors
The government exercised strict control over the press. Parliament proceedings in England could not be published in India as they were considered “seditious literature”
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
William Bolts was prosecuted for supplying information of Parliamentary proceedings to Siraj-Ud-Daula, the Nawab of Bengal
Newspapers in Bengal were ordered in 1785- not to publish resolutions of the governor- generals council
General pre-censorship on news- Submit copies before being published
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
The press was submissive in Madras and Bombay, not so in Calcutta
William Duane the Editor of Bengal Journal accused of publishing false report of the death of Lord Cornwallis in 1791
He refuses to publish apology, saying that the source of his news was a prominent Frenchman
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Ordered to be deported, saved by intervention of a French agent
He however lost his editorship and became a marked man
Started another paper Indian World which ran for three years
Finally was deported in late 1794
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Indian newspapers were disgusted with the complete lack of freedom
Some reprinted articles from Britain, were duly penalized
Some wrote articles resembling their British contemporaries
All highly critical of the government
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
James Silk Buckingham Hailed as the first real journalist in India in the
early 19th century Described by Nehru as “earliest champions
of freedom of the Press and a man who is still remembered in this country”
Came to India as the Editor of the Calcutta Chronicle which was started by some Calcutta merchants to propagate their views and protect their interests
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
The first issue on October 2 1818, indicated that it would be a chronicle of political, commercial and literary news and views
Buckingam was a scholar in anthropology and literature, well read and a keen observer of customs and habits of people
He brought a breath of fresh air to atmosphere polluted by scandal-mongering, frivolous and flippant Press
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Introduced his readers to great writers like Walter Scott, Byron etc
Introduced drawings and charts in the paper to make matter more interesting and easy to understand
Laid more emphasis on news of local conditions than fashion and social life of people
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
A notable feature was letters to editor, very different from what used to appear in other newspapers
Criticism just and fair
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Editorials were on government policies regarding issues like, postal services, military establishments, deportation laws, Govt. indifference etc
Fearless in condemning Indian social evils like Sati and the governments inability to put an end to them
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Gave prominence to native language journals like Bengali and Persian
Friend of Indian press, defended its right to exist and voice the opinion of the Indian people
He wrote in his editorial, “ The languages of the East are surely fit for noble purposes than being conned over in schools and colleges and stored up in lexicons”
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Was the inspiration behind the growth of Indian journalism
The advent of public discussion, public conduct of bureaucrats and state functionaries and educated public opinion were thanks to him
Raja Ram Mohan Roy and Buckhingam shared a mutual admiration for each other
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
He believed that “ If knowledge is a blessing and ignorance a curse, then the objective of a good Press would be to dispel the latter and promote the former”
His opinions were revolutionary, especially in the background of the prevailing notion about the Press
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
He believed that “ when men know the eyes of the world upon them and that their conduct will be scrutinised by their enemies as well as their friends, they are more careful to act justly than when they know that their deeds will neither be seen nor questioned.”
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Calcutta Chronicle soon appeared twice a week and became an eight pages paper
Had rivals in eight other papers and these led by major competitor Asiatic Mirror editor Boyce. Boyce attacked Buck on many occasions, raked up his mysterious past, tried demeaning him on many accounts
Not much is known about his past except that he sympathised with the Whigs
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Whig" and "Tory" are political party labels that have been in use in England since around 1681--and their specific meaning has varied somewhat with changing historical circumstances.
By extension, then, the Whigs were seen as asserting the primacy of Parliament over the monarch, while the Tories were seen as asserting the inverse.
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Whigs believed that the King was there at the request and goodwill of the people of the country so could only continue to rule at their approval.
The Tories believed in the divine right of Kings to rule - that they were ordained by God
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Buckingam was not a favorite with the government due to constant criticism of their policies.
The advocate general and a section of the Supreme Court wanted him deported
Though he had the support of Hindu intellectuals like Roy it was more of a disability than a strength to him
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Though he was acquitted in that particular case, his detractors finally managed to have him deported in 1823
He appointed an Anglo Indian as his successor (Anglo Indians could not be deported)
Government realised that deportation ceased to be effective and fool proof
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Censorship of press in India took a new turn
New order was passed prohibiting publication and selling of newspapers and journals which the governor might disapprove
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Buckingham’s ‘folly’ Took topics that touched roots of
administration Repeated disclosures of official malpractices Success in securing redressal of grievances Gaining popularity Influencing public opinion Discussing topics sensitive to the East India
Company
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Even after Buckingam left, Calcutta Chronicle continued with full vigour
Attempts were made to suppress the paper
But the editor was half Indian, therefore could not deported, other paltry punishments proved ineffective
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
However, Arnot a sub-editor was imprisoned, he appealed, since no case against him, was released
But he was ‘transported’ back to England.
Though he was kept a prisoner he was told to pay expenses
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Calcutta Chronicle temporarily stopped till the son-in-law of Buckingam accepted editorship
Buckingam appealed to the Board of Directors and Parliament against the injustice meted out to him and his paper
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Finally he was awarded a compensation of 200 pounds annually
Calcutta Chronicle meanwhile continued, no longer in its former glory
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Buckingam’s contributionHe made the newspaper the mirror of the
people. He manifested the spirit of enquiry and criticism. And he imparted to the Press, the quality of leadership. By deporting him, the bureaucracy wanted to warn others. But it could not put out the spark he had kindled. Buckingham was one of those rare journalists who are born rather than made.”
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
A FEW CHANGES
• Deportation of journalists disgusted many Englishmen, a few who were high ranking officials in East India Company
• Charles Forbes in the House of Commons,1825, “conduct of the govt. in India loudly calls for the intervention of Parliament… natives are continually imprisoned without trial… native ruler behind bars for 15 years for no reason”
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Called the restrictions on the Press “absurd”
and “useless”
A Colonel Robinson wrote to a Calcutta journal that the
“Press did more to check abuse of power, foul play, illegal trading and cheating cases than all the regulations of the Bengal Code”
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
New Laws
1825- “Company servants should have no connection either as proprietors or editors with any journal which was not devoted to literary or scientific topics”
Licensing-Bombay Govt. passed a law ‘to prohibit the publication of any NP except by person holding a license, which will be revocable at will by the Governor’
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
Press before the awakening of Indian Nationalism 1800 to 1840- Dark years for India & UKo England – Complete misadministrationo India- absolute autocracy o Natives- Immersed in taxes
The Press which had been subject to ordinary laws under Hastings now became subservient to the Company by arbitrary licensing laws
Seema NarendranRamnarain Ruia College
THE END