THE IMPACT OF HIGHWAY SAFETY FLARES ON DRIVER BEHAVIOR · The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 5 ... Five and Ten paces apart ... The Impact of Highway Safety Flares

THE IMPACT OF HIGHWAY SAFETYFLARES ON DRIVER BEHAVIOR

THE IMPACT OF HIGHWAY SAFETYFLARES ON DRIVER BEHAVIOR

Philip M. Garvey

Miguel de la RivaMartin T. Pietrucha

(2003-2005 presented at TRB 2006)

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 2

Introduction

Every year (as of 2005):

507 people are killed.

30,000 people are injured.

350,000 PDMV crashes occur.

Crashes Involving Collisions with Parked/disabled Motor Vehicles

PDMV crashes are the most frequent type of collision with non-fixed objects.

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 3

IntroductionSafety Measures Aimed at Reducing Crashes involving Collisions

with Parked/Disabled Vehicles on Highway Shoulders

Source: www.orionsignals.com

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 4

IntroductionPurpose of Flare Deployment

Warn approaching traffic of unusual road hazard.Mark the location of the traffic incident scene.Prompt a safe response from passing traffic.

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 5

IntroductionAdditional research and more uniform guidance is needed

for safe and effective flare deployment

Number of flares to deployDistance between flaresFlare deployment patternLocation of the leading flareAdded safety benefit of using flares in combination with police car’s light bars

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 6

MethodSite Selection: Blair County, Pennsylvania

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 7

MethodData Collection Equipment

a) Roadway sensors (pneumatic tubes)

b) Automatic traffic recorderc) Export utility software

(TraxproPSU)d) Excel® programmed

worksheets

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 8

Method

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 9

MethodData Collection Equipment: Final Configuration

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 10

MethodBase Flare Configurations Tested

Three flaresFive and Ten paces apart

Six flaresFive and Ten paces apart

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 11

MethodBase Flare Configurations Tested

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 12

MethodRoadway Scenarios Tested

Road Scenario Treatment Description

(a) Police Car + FlaresA 3 flares @ 5 pacesB 3 flares @ 10 pacesC 6 flares @ 5 pacesD 6 flares @ 10 paces

(c) Police Car Only E No flares deployed

(b) Disabled + Flares

F 3 flares @ 5 pacesG 3 flares @ 10 pacesH 6 flares @ 5 pacesI 6 flares @ 10 paces

(d) Baseline None Normal conditions

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 13

MethodMeasures of Effectiveness / Dependent Variables

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 14

MethodData Collection Schedule and Order of Testing

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 15

MethodStatistical Analysis Techniques

ANOVA, Bonferroni, and two-sample t-tests were used for analyses of continuous variables.Contingency tables, Chi-square tests, and the Marascuilo procedure were used for analyses of categorical variables.Conventional 0.05 level of significance was used for hypotheses testing.Minitab® and Excel® used for the computations.

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 16

ResultsSample Size

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 17

ResultsHistogram (with normal curve) of Spot Speeds

(Baseline Condition)

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 18

ResultsLane Distribution

(Baseline Condition)

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 19

ResultsLateral Placement (Baseline Condition)

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 20

Results

…. What happened when treatments were in place?

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 21

ResultsSpot Speed (Experimental Conditions)

Baseline

Passing traffic’s speed was dramatically reduced

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 22

ResultsLane Distribution (Experimental Conditions)

Baseline

a safer zone was created around the emergency event, since high volumes of traffic at high speeds are now as far as possible from the emergency event.

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 23

ResultsLateral Placement (Experimental Conditions)

Baseline

Lateral separation

significantly increased.

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 24

ResultsAnalysis by Traffic Scenario - Speed

Police+Flares Police Only Disabled+Flares Baseline

Baseline≈A few road flares, stored in your trunk and used under emergency situations, would provide a safety benefit comparable to having a patrol car present at the scene.

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 25

ResultsFlare Number - Speed

Three Flares vs. Six Flares

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 26

ResultsFlare Placement - SpeedFive Paces vs. Ten Paces

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 27

ResultsFlare Performance as a Function of Elapsed Combustion Time

First 20 minutes Last 10 minutes

The Impact of Highway Safety Flares on Driver Behavior 28

Conclusions & Recommendations

Road flares significantly enhance the safety around a traffic emergency event and their use is highly recommended for both personal vehicle operators and road safety professionals as a supplement to their flashing light bars.

(Before the 2009 “Steer Clear” law.)