THE ECONOMIC & FINANCIAL MARKET OUTLOOK THROUGH 2004: What Next For The U.S. & California Economies? A Presentation To The Annual CMTA Pre-Conference Workshop South Lake Tahoe, California April 19, 2004
Dec 26, 2015
THE ECONOMIC & FINANCIAL MARKET OUTLOOK THROUGH 2004:
What Next For The U.S. & California Economies?
A Presentation To The Annual CMTA Pre-Conference Workshop
South Lake Tahoe, CaliforniaApril 19, 2004
THE ECONOMIC & FINANCIAL MARKET OUTLOOK THROUGH 2004:
What Next For The U.S. & California Economies?
A Presentation To The Annual CMTA Pre-Conference Workshop
South Lake Tahoe, CaliforniaApril 19, 2004
ANOTHER "JOBLESS RECOVERY" ANOTHER "JOBLESS RECOVERY" Cumulative % Change In Private, Non-Farm Cumulative % Change In Private, Non-Farm
Payrolls Before And After The Cyclical Low PointPayrolls Before And After The Cyclical Low Point
-1-1
00
11
22
33
44
55
66
77
-12-12 -10-10 -8-8 -6-6 -4-4 -2-2 00 22 44 66 88 1010 1212 1414 1616 1818 2020 2222 2424 2626Months Before And After The Cyclical Low In Economic ActivityMonths Before And After The Cyclical Low In Economic Activity
* Based on six economic cycles back through 1953.* Based on six economic cycles back through 1953.Source: U.S. Commerce DepartmentSource: U.S. Commerce Department
Avg., Past 6 Long Avg., Past 6 Long Economic Cycles*Economic Cycles*
Current Cycle, 11/00-3/04Current Cycle, 11/00-3/04
CCUUMMUULLAATTIIVVEE
GGRROOWWTTHH
RecessionRecession RecoveryRecovery
3/90-7/92 Cycle3/90-7/92 Cycle
"MISERY'S"* WARNING FLAG FOR THE "MISERY'S"* WARNING FLAG FOR THE PRESIDENTPRESIDENT
Cumulative % Chg. In The "Misery Index*"Cumulative % Chg. In The "Misery Index*"
-15%-15%
-10%-10%
-5%-5%
0%0%
5%5%
10%10%
15%15%
20%20%
00 33 66 99 1212 1515 1818 2121 2424 2727 3030 3333 3636Months From The Start Of RecoveryMonths From The Start Of Recovery
* Avg. of inverted index for job gains, rolling 12-mo. periods, and an index of retail gasoline prices.* Avg. of inverted index for job gains, rolling 12-mo. periods, and an index of retail gasoline prices. Sources: U.S. Dep'ts. Of Energy and LaborSources: U.S. Dep'ts. Of Energy and Labor
Current Recovery Current Recovery (11/01-3/04(11/01-3/04
3/91-7/93 Recovery3/91-7/93 Recovery
INVENTORIES UNUSUALLY "LEAN" VS. INVENTORIES UNUSUALLY "LEAN" VS. SALESSALES
Business Inventory-Sales (I/S) RatioBusiness Inventory-Sales (I/S) Ratio
1.311.31
1.331.33
1.351.35
1.371.37
1.391.39
1.411.41
1.431.43
1.451.45
1.471.47
1.491.49
Dec-96Dec-96 Dec-97Dec-97 Dec-98Dec-98 Dec-99Dec-99 Dec-00Dec-00 Dec-01Dec-01 Dec-02Dec-02 Dec-03Dec-03Source: U.S. Department Of CommerceSource: U.S. Department Of Commerce
Rolling 3-Year Rolling 3-Year Avg.Avg.
MonthlyMonthly
2/042/04
U.S. EXPORT ORDERS RESPOND U.S. EXPORT ORDERS RESPOND
TO A WEAKER DOLLARTO A WEAKER DOLLAR
4444
4646
4848
5050
5252
5454
5656
5858
6060
Dec-98Dec-98 Dec-99Dec-99 Dec-00Dec-00 Dec-01Dec-01 Dec-02Dec-02 Dec-03Dec-039292
9494
9696
9898
100100
102102
104104
106106
108108
110110
112112
* Based on the dollar's inflation-adjusted, trade-weighted exchange rate against 44 other currencies.* Based on the dollar's inflation-adjusted, trade-weighted exchange rate against 44 other currencies.
Sources: Nat'l Ass'n Of Purchasing Mgrs.; J.P. Morgan & Co.Sources: Nat'l Ass'n Of Purchasing Mgrs.; J.P. Morgan & Co.
3/043/04
"Real Trade-Weighted" $*"Real Trade-Weighted" $* (Right Scale)(Right Scale)
Export Orders, Mfd. Export Orders, Mfd. GoodsGoods
(Left Scale)(Left Scale)
% Rept'g An Increase% Rept'g An Increase Index: 2000=100Index: 2000=100
A BETTER SHOWING BY CALIFORNIA DURING A BETTER SHOWING BY CALIFORNIA DURING THE CURRENT ECONOMIC CYCLETHE CURRENT ECONOMIC CYCLE
Non-Farm Job Growth; Year-Ago Percent ChangeNon-Farm Job Growth; Year-Ago Percent Change
-2.5%-2.5%
-1.5%-1.5%
-0.5%-0.5%
0.5%0.5%
1.5%1.5%
2.5%2.5%
3.5%3.5%
4.5%4.5%
Dec-89Dec-89 Dec-91Dec-91 Dec-93Dec-93 Dec-95Dec-95 Dec-97Dec-97 Dec-99Dec-99 Dec-01Dec-01 Dec-03Dec-03
3/043/04
U.S.U.S.
CACA
Source: U.S. Dep't Of LaborSource: U.S. Dep't Of Labor
Note: Bars Denote U.S. Recession Note: Bars Denote U.S. Recession PeriodsPeriods
TRADING PLACES: NORTHERN CALIFORNIA ON TRADING PLACES: NORTHERN CALIFORNIA ON THE THE
LEADING EDGE OF THE ECONOMIC LEADING EDGE OF THE ECONOMIC SLOWDOWNSLOWDOWN
Yr-Ago % Change In Non-Farm PayrollsYr-Ago % Change In Non-Farm Payrolls
-7.8%-7.8%
-6.8%-6.8%
-5.8%-5.8%
-4.8%-4.8%
-3.8%-3.8%
-2.8%-2.8%
-1.8%-1.8%
-0.8%-0.8%
0.2%0.2%
1.2%1.2%
2.2%2.2%
3.2%3.2%
4.2%4.2%
5.2%5.2%
6.2%6.2%
Dec-89Dec-89 Dec-91Dec-91 Dec-93Dec-93 Dec-95Dec-95 Dec-97Dec-97 Dec-99Dec-99 Dec-01Dec-01 Dec-03Dec-03
No. CaliforniaNo. California
2/042/04
So. CaliforniaSo. California
Central ValleyCentral Valley
Source: U.S. Dep't Of LaborSource: U.S. Dep't Of Labor
Note: Bars Denote Recession Note: Bars Denote Recession PeriodsPeriods
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMIC GROWTH DRIVEN BY CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMIC GROWTH DRIVEN BY "DOMESTIC," NOT “EXPORT” INDUSTRIES"DOMESTIC," NOT “EXPORT” INDUSTRIES
Year-Ago Percent Change In Employment, March 2004Year-Ago Percent Change In Employment, March 2004
-7%-7%
-6%-6%
-5%-5%
-4%-4%
-3%-3%
-2%-2%
-1%-1%
0%0%
1%1%
2%2%
3%3%
4%4%
5%5%
6%6%
Tot
al N
onfa
rmT
otal
Non
farm
Res
id. C
onst
r.R
esid
. Con
str.
Sof
twar
e P
ub
.S
oftw
are
Pu
b.
Rea
l Est
ate
Rea
l Est
ate
Pro
f &
Bu
s S
vcs
Pro
f &
Bu
s S
vcs
Ed
uc
& H
ealt
hE
du
c &
Hea
lth
Svc
sS
vcs
Lei
sure
&L
eisu
re &
Hos
p.it
yH
osp
.ity
Gov
ern
men
tG
over
nm
ent
Source: California Employment Development DepartmentSource: California Employment Development Department
"Export" Industries"Export" Industries
"Domestic" Industries"Domestic" Industries
TTeecchh
MMffgg
IInntteerrnneett
MMoottIIoonn
PPIIccttuurreess
FFIInnll
SSvvccss
A MORE VULNERABLE CA HOUSING MARKET A MORE VULNERABLE CA HOUSING MARKET TO HIGHER INTEREST RATES? TO HIGHER INTEREST RATES?
% Of Households Qualifying For The Median-Priced Home, By % Of Households Qualifying For The Median-Priced Home, By Selected AreaSelected Area
00
1010
2020
3030
4040
5050
6060
U.S.U.S. CACA LALA SFSF Cent. ValleyCent. ValleySource: California Association Of RealtorsSource: California Association Of Realtors
12/9612/96
12/0012/00
2/032/03
2/042/04
ECONOMIC OUTLOOK: THE U.S. AND CALIFORNIA ECONOMIC OUTLOOK: THE U.S. AND CALIFORNIA ECONOMIES COMPAREDECONOMIES COMPARED
Year-To-Year Percent Change, Unless Otherwise SpecifiedYear-To-Year Percent Change, Unless Otherwise SpecifiedForecastForecast
19911991 19921992 19931993 20002000 20012001 20022002 20032003 20042004 20052005
"Real" GDP/ GSP"Real" GDP/ GSP U.S.U.S. -0.9-0.9 2.72.7 2.72.7 3.73.7 0.50.5 2.22.2 3.13.1 4.14.1 3.03.0 CaliforniaCalifornia -1.9-1.9 -1.2-1.2 -0.8-0.8 6.56.5 -1.3-1.3 1.91.9 3.03.0 3.73.7 2.72.7
Unemployment Rate (%)Unemployment Rate (%) U.S.U.S. 6.96.9 7.57.5 6.96.9 4.04.0 4.84.8 5.85.8 66 5.85.8 6.06.0 CaliforniaCalifornia 7.77.7 9.39.3 9.49.4 4.94.9 5.45.4 6.76.7 6.76.7 6.26.2 6.26.2
Housing Starts/PermitsHousing Starts/Permits U.S. (Starts, MM)U.S. (Starts, MM) 1.011.01 1.21.2 1.291.29 1.571.57 1.601.60 1.711.71 1.851.85 1.861.86 1.671.67 California (Permits, Th)California (Permits, Th) 105105 9898 8484 149149 149149 168168 198198 196196 189189
Other Key California DataOther Key California DataTax. Retail Sales(% Chg.)Tax. Retail Sales(% Chg.) -3.9-3.9 0.60.6 -0.1-0.1 12.012.0 0.00.0 -0.2-0.2 3.13.1 4.24.2 4.94.9
Population (% Chg.)Population (% Chg.) 2.32.3 2.12.1 1.31.3 1.91.9 1.91.9 1.71.7 1.61.6 1.51.5 1.41.4Net Inmigration (Thus)Net Inmigration (Thus) 224224 225225 -45-45 322322 364364 308308 251251 237237 199199
Source: The UCLA Anderson Forecast, March 2004Source: The UCLA Anderson Forecast, March 2004
AGGRESSIVE COST-CUTTING HELPS SUSTAIN AGGRESSIVE COST-CUTTING HELPS SUSTAIN THE RECOVERY IN MARGINS AND PROFITS THE RECOVERY IN MARGINS AND PROFITS Year-Ago % Change, Selling Prices Vs. Non-Farm Year-Ago % Change, Selling Prices Vs. Non-Farm
Unit Labor Costs*Unit Labor Costs*
-4%-4%
-3%-3%
-2%-2%
-1%-1%
0%0%
1%1%
2%2%
3%3%
4%4%
5%5%
Mar-89Mar-89 Mar-91Mar-91 Mar-93Mar-93 Mar-95Mar-95 Mar-97Mar-97 Mar-99Mar-99 Mar-01Mar-01 Mar-03Mar-03
Selling PricesSelling Prices
Unit Labor CostsUnit Labor Costs
Source: U.S. Commerce Dep't.Source: U.S. Commerce Dep't.
'03Q4'03Q4
Note: Bars DenoteNote: Bars DenoteRecession PeriodsRecession Periods
Margin PressureMargin Pressure
Margin ExpansionMargin Expansion
WEAK "PRICING POWER" DRIVES A TECH-WEAK "PRICING POWER" DRIVES A TECH-LED INVESTMENT RECOVERYLED INVESTMENT RECOVERY
Year-Ago Percent Change, Inflation-Adjusted Year-Ago Percent Change, Inflation-Adjusted SpendingSpending
-24-24
-20-20
-16-16
-12-12
-8-8
-4-4
00
44
88
1212
1616
2020
2424
2828
01-Mar-9101-Mar-91 01-Mar-9401-Mar-94 01-Mar-9701-Mar-97 01-Mar-0001-Mar-00 01-Mar-0301-Mar-03
'03Q4'03Q4
Info Processing EquipmentInfo Processing Equipment
Low-Tech EquipmentLow-Tech Equipment
StructuresStructures
Source: U.S. Commerce Department Source: U.S. Commerce Department
Note: Bars Denote Note: Bars Denote Recession PeriodsRecession Periods
"APPRECIATING-CURRENCY" COUNTRIES "APPRECIATING-CURRENCY" COUNTRIES LIFT U.S. IMPORT PRICES & “PRICING LIFT U.S. IMPORT PRICES & “PRICING
POWER” POWER” Year-Ago Percent Change, Import Prices Of Year-Ago Percent Change, Import Prices Of
Manufactured GoodsManufactured Goods
-7%-7%
-5%-5%
-3%-3%
-1%-1%
1%1%
3%3%
5%5%
7%7%
Dec-99Dec-99 Jun-00Jun-00 Dec-00Dec-00 Jun-01Jun-01 Dec-01Dec-01 Jun-02Jun-02 Dec-02Dec-02 Jun-03Jun-03 Dec-03Dec-03 Jun-04Jun-04
CanadaCanadaEuropeEurope
"Emerging Asian" "Emerging Asian" EconomiesEconomies
3/043/04
Source: U.S. Department Of Labor Source: U.S. Department Of Labor
SMALL BUSINESS "PRICING POWER" ON THE SMALL BUSINESS "PRICING POWER" ON THE RISERISE
Percent Of Small Businesses Reporting Price Percent Of Small Businesses Reporting Price IncreasesIncreases
-8-8
-4-4
00
44
88
1212
1616
2020
Dec-94Dec-94 Dec-96Dec-96 Dec-98Dec-98 Dec-00Dec-00 Dec-02Dec-02
Source: National Federation Of Independent Businesses (NFIB)Source: National Federation Of Independent Businesses (NFIB)
Mar. '04Mar. '04
Recession Recession PeriodPeriod
A LOOK BACK AT THE LAST A LOOK BACK AT THE LAST “UP CYCLE” FOR INTEREST RATES “UP CYCLE” FOR INTEREST RATES
The Treasury Yield Curve, Selected Periods; Yields The Treasury Yield Curve, Selected Periods; Yields In PercentIn Percent
4.34.3
5.35.3
6.36.3
7.37.3
00 55 1010 1515 2020 2525 3030 3535Years To MaturityYears To Maturity
Fed Funds Target Rate, Fed Funds Target Rate, 11/17/98=4.75%11/17/98=4.75%
5/18/005/18/00
Source: Bloomberg Financial News, Inc.Source: Bloomberg Financial News, Inc.
6/29/996/29/99
11/18/9811/18/98
Federal Funds Target Rate, Federal Funds Target Rate, 5/16/00=6.50%5/16/00=6.50%
HOW CLOSE A CLASH BETWEEN PUBLIC & HOW CLOSE A CLASH BETWEEN PUBLIC & PRIVATE-SECTOR BORROWING?PRIVATE-SECTOR BORROWING?
Year-Ago % Change In Federal & Non-Federal Year-Ago % Change In Federal & Non-Federal BorrowingBorrowing
-10%-10%
-5%-5%
0%0%
5%5%
10%10%
15%15%
Dec-89Dec-89 Dec-91Dec-91 Dec-93Dec-93 Dec-95Dec-95 Dec-97Dec-97 Dec-99Dec-99 Dec-01Dec-01 Dec-03Dec-03Source: Federal Reserve BoardSource: Federal Reserve Board
Non-FederalNon-Federal
FederalFederal
'03Q4'03Q4
THE FEDERAL RESERVE KEEPING THE THE FEDERAL RESERVE KEEPING THE POLICY "PEDAL TO THE METAL"POLICY "PEDAL TO THE METAL"
The Federal Funds Rate Less The PCE "Deflator;" The Federal Funds Rate Less The PCE "Deflator;" PercentPercent
-2.0-2.0
-1.0-1.0
0.00.0
1.01.0
2.02.0
3.03.0
4.04.0
5.05.0
Jan-90Jan-90 Jan-92Jan-92 Jan-94Jan-94 Jan-96Jan-96 Jan-98Jan-98 Jan-00Jan-00 Jan-02Jan-02 Jan-04Jan-04
3/043/04
Avg., 1969-2003=2.6%Avg., 1969-2003=2.6%
Sources: Bloomberg Financial News, Inc., U.S. Commerce Dep'tSources: Bloomberg Financial News, Inc., U.S. Commerce Dep't
Fed "Easing" During TheFed "Easing" During TheSluggish 1991-92 RecoverySluggish 1991-92 Recovery
Note: Bars Denote Note: Bars Denote Recession PeriodsRecession Periods
EIGHT SURPRISES FOR 2004EIGHT SURPRISES FOR 2004
* ANOTHER TERRORIST ATTACK* ANOTHER TERRORIST ATTACK
* THE “CARRY TRADE” UNRAVELS* THE “CARRY TRADE” UNRAVELS
* “DISINFLATION” LINGERS ON * “DISINFLATION” LINGERS ON
* A DOLLAR TAILSPIN* A DOLLAR TAILSPIN
* SAUDI TURMOIL* SAUDI TURMOIL
* A CHINESE RECESSION* A CHINESE RECESSION
* A DEMOCRATIC ELECTION VICTORY* A DEMOCRATIC ELECTION VICTORY
* POLICY STRAINS BEGIN TO SHAKE THE EURO* POLICY STRAINS BEGIN TO SHAKE THE EURO
BOND MANAGERS STILL CAUTIOUSBOND MANAGERS STILL CAUTIOUSPortfolio Duration Vs. Target, In Percent; 4-Wk. Moving Portfolio Duration Vs. Target, In Percent; 4-Wk. Moving
AveragesAverages
9494
9595
9696
9797
9898
9999
100100
101101
102102
103103
104104
25-Dec-0125-Dec-01 25-Jun-0225-Jun-02 24-Dec-0224-Dec-02 24-Jun-0324-Jun-03 23-Dec-0323-Dec-03 22-Jun-0422-Jun-04Source: Stone McCarthy Research Associates, Inc.Source: Stone McCarthy Research Associates, Inc.
4/13/04 4/13/04 WeekWeek
"Neutral" (100% Of "Neutral" (100% Of Benchmark Duration)Benchmark Duration)
EARNINGS GROWTH TO PROPEL STOCKS EARNINGS GROWTH TO PROPEL STOCKS HIGHERHIGHER
-23%-23%
-17%-17%
-11%-11%
-5%-5%
1%1%
7%7%
13%13%
19%19%
25%25%
Mar-97Mar-97 Mar-98Mar-98 Mar-99Mar-99 Mar-00Mar-00 Mar-01Mar-01 Mar-02Mar-02 Mar-03Mar-03 Mar-04Mar-04 Mar-05Mar-05-60%-60%
-40%-40%
-20%-20%
0%0%
20%20%
40%40%
60%60%
80%80%Qtr-To-Qtr % Chg Qtr-To-Qtr % Chg
* First Call "bottom-up" consensus estimate, including goodwill adjustments.* First Call "bottom-up" consensus estimate, including goodwill adjustments.Source: First Call, Inc.Source: First Call, Inc.
Forecast*Forecast*
Yr.-Ago % Chg.Yr.-Ago % Chg.
S&P 500 Earnings GrowthS&P 500 Earnings Growth(Left Scale)(Left Scale)
S&P 500S&P 500(Left Scale)(Left Scale)
A FAIRLY TIGHT LINK BETWEEN THE S&P A FAIRLY TIGHT LINK BETWEEN THE S&P 500 P/E MULTIPLE AND INTEREST RATES500 P/E MULTIPLE AND INTEREST RATES
00
22
44
66
88
1010
1212
1414
1616
Jan-79Jan-79 Jan-82Jan-82 Jan-85Jan-85 Jan-88Jan-88 Jan-91Jan-91 Jan-94Jan-94 Jan-97Jan-97 Jan-00Jan-00 Jan-03Jan-0333
77
1111
1515
1919
2323
2727S&P 500 Price Per $ Of Opng. EarningsS&P 500 Price Per $ Of Opng. EarningsPercentPercent
Sources: Standard & Poors, Inc.; Federal Reserve BoardSources: Standard & Poors, Inc.; Federal Reserve Board
10-Yr T-Note10-Yr T-Note(Left Scale)(Left Scale)
P/E RatioP/E Ratio(Right Scale)(Right Scale)
4/5/044/5/04
SEEMINGLY "RICH" STOCKS "CHEAP" VS. SEEMINGLY "RICH" STOCKS "CHEAP" VS. BONDSBONDS
33
77
1111
1515
1919
2323
2727
Jan-79Jan-79 Jan-83Jan-83 Jan-87Jan-87 Jan-91Jan-91 Jan-95Jan-95 Jan-99Jan-99 Jan-03Jan-030.40.4
0.60.6
0.80.8
1.01.0
1.21.2
1.41.4
1.61.6
1.81.8
Sources: Standard & Poors, Inc., IBES, Federal Reserve BoardSources: Standard & Poors, Inc., IBES, Federal Reserve Board
Yield Ratio*Yield Ratio*S&P 500 P/E MultipleS&P 500 P/E Multiple
* Ratio, 10-Yr. Treasury yield vs. earnings-price yield (E/P) on S&P 500 stocks.* Ratio, 10-Yr. Treasury yield vs. earnings-price yield (E/P) on S&P 500 stocks.
S&P 500 P/E MultipleS&P 500 P/E Multiple(Left Scale)(Left Scale)
Yield Ratio, Bonds Vs. StocksYield Ratio, Bonds Vs. Stocks(Right Scale)(Right Scale)
4/16/044/16/04
"DEFENSIVE" STOCKS* TURN WITH "DEFENSIVE" STOCKS* TURN WITH INTEREST RATESINTEREST RATES
Cumulative % Chg., Past 4 Bus. Cycles*Cumulative % Chg., Past 4 Bus. Cycles*
-12-12
-9-9
-6-6
-3-3
00
33
66
00 22 44 66 88 1010 1212 1414 1616 1818 2020 2222 2424 2626 2828 3030 3232 3434 3636 3838 4040 4242 4444 4646 4848-17-17
-15-15
-13-13
-11-11
-9-9
-7-7
-5-5
-3-3
-1-1
11
33
* Health care and consumer staples. Expansions beginning 12/70, 4/75, 1/83 and 4/91. * Health care and consumer staples. Expansions beginning 12/70, 4/75, 1/83 and 4/91. Source: Federal Reserve Board; Citigroup, Inc.Source: Federal Reserve Board; Citigroup, Inc.
Month's From Recession's EndMonth's From Recession's End
Cum. % Chg. In 10-Yr. Treas. Cum. % Chg. In 10-Yr. Treas. YieldsYields
(Right Scale)(Right Scale)
Cum. % Chg. In "Defensive" Vs. Cum. % Chg. In "Defensive" Vs. S&P 500 StocksS&P 500 Stocks
(Left Scale)(Left Scale)