8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
1/52
=3
F} `nv cj n ikhd dl} cz} F lnrj }k qsk}je} `v hn`j) tlfel F lnrj qsk}je}jm}lskzdl `v =1 vjnsu fh qzcife ujsrfej( F tfii dl} cnegx Unegjm Hn}fkhni Czsjnz kb Fhrju}fdn}fkh Mfsje}ks @nd}nhddki Dn}mzin
j ljnm kb }lj qsfhefqni ndjhefju tfii cj n qjsukh tlk lnu kzs }szu} nhmekhmjhej( j }szu} fu hk ikhdjs }ljsj
x Qsjufmjh} Cjhfdhk N~zfhk FFF kh lfu mfu`fuuni kb Dn}mzin
QKFH] " EIFEG
Vkz enh neejuukhifhj sjujnselrfn vkzs Fh}jshj}ekhhje}fkh cv
eifegfhd qlsnuju
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=769987&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=769987&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=769987&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://link%20to%20%3E%3E%20http//newsinfo.inquirer.net/131709/president-aquino-nbi-chief-magtanggol-gatdula-lost-my-trusthttp://link%20to%20%3E%3E%20http//newsinfo.inquirer.net/131709/president-aquino-nbi-chief-magtanggol-gatdula-lost-my-trusthttp://link%20to%20%3E%3E%20http//newsinfo.inquirer.net/131709/president-aquino-nbi-chief-magtanggol-gatdula-lost-my-trusthttp://link%20to%20%3E%3E%20http//newsinfo.inquirer.net/131709/president-aquino-nbi-chief-magtanggol-gatdula-lost-my-trusthttp://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=769987&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=769987&publicationSubCategoryId=638/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
2/52
@jj} }lj ejhUJF Dn}j GjjqjsTf}l nh jhmijuu u}sjn` kb hjtu) csfjhdu) `jmfn u}n}j`jh}u) fh}jsrfjtu) uqjjelju)
rfmjk) fh-mjq}l u}zmfju) nhm k}ljs fhbks`n}fkh fhzhmn}fhd }lj khifhj tksim jrjsv
ujekhm) lkt mkju khj elkkuj }lj }kqfeu }k }negij nhm }lj `n}jsfni }k lfdlifdl};
Tf}l khj ~zju}fkh Tln}u kzs u}ksv ljsj; ]lj
ejhUJF
Sjqks} UjhfksJmf}ks Cfii Lznhd gjjqu tn}el krjs }lj fhbks`n}fkh }ln} hmu f}u tnv fh}k kzs qndju(
]lj bks`js jmf}ks kb ikeniiv-cnujm khifhj hjtu uf}j EvcjsMvnsvk nhm }lj Zhfkh kb
En}lkife Nufnh Hjtu) n Cnhdgkg-cnujm En}lkife Elzsel hjtu uf}j ijnmu @khmnv
`jj}fhdu tf}l jmf}ksu nhm tsf}jsu-nhnivu}u( ]kdj}ljs) }ljv sjrfjt }lj qnu} nhm
ezssjh} tjjgu jrjh}u nhm fuuzju) nhm mjefmj tlfel khju }k u}sn}jdfj) nhnivj) nhm
sjujnsel bks kzs sjnmjsu(
Tln}$u kzs u}ksv ljsj; fu Lznhdu ekhu}nh} ~zju}fkh }k jrjsv f}j` kh }lj }ncij(
Bsk` hfhj vjnsu nu jmf}ks kb @nhfin- nhm Cnhdgkg-cnujm khifhj hjtu qzcifen}fkhu)
F$rj ijnshjm }ln} hjtu `jnhu if}}ij fb tj enh$} dzsj kz} }lj ekh}j|}) }lj cfddjs
qfe}zsj) fh tlfel }lj hjtu fu }ngfhd qinej) lj j|qinfhu(
Nuufdh`jh}u u}ns} hk} tf}l) Tln} fu }lfu qfjej dkfhd }k cj nckz}; cz} sn}ljs) Tln}$u kzs u}ksv ljsj; Bks Lznhd) }lj
mfbbjsjhej fh ~zjsfju sjje} n uzc}ij cz} u}fii ufdhfenh} ulfb} fh ezi}zsj) bsk` n cjn}- nhm jrjh}-bkezujm u}vij kb hjtu dn}ljsfhd
}k n u}sn}jdfe nhm nhniv}fe nqqsknel nqqskqsfn}j }k qinhhfhd nhm mjefufkh `ngfhd(
Lznhd fu hk u}snhdjs }k j|}sne}fhd eszefni) inu}fhd ghktijmdj bsk` jj}fhd bne}u nhm dzsju( Lj mfm `zel kb f} jnshfhd lfu @N
fh Bfhnhefni Jekhk`feu bsk` Bksmln` Zhfrjsuf}v fh Hjt Vksg) }ljh tksgfhd fh @nsvinhm u}n}j$u Jekhk`fe nhm Ek``zhf}v
Mjrjikq`jh} mjqns}`jh}( Nhm lfu vjnsu fh }lj ikeni ek`qz}js fhmzu}sv fh ck}l ujiifhd ek`qz}jsu nhm tsf}fhd nckz} }lj`
u}jjqjm lf` fh }lj }jelhkikdv }ln} ejhUJFhkt zuju }k lnshjuu }lj Fh}jshj} bks inu}fhd) fh-mjq}l ghktijmdj(
N cfd qns} kb tln} ]ljejhUJFSjqks} mkju fu }k ifhg sjnmjsu }k }lj cfd qfe}zsju }ln} `nuuju kb cf}u nhm cv}ju n`kzh} }k)uz`u zq Lznhd( Sjnm kh nhm ujj tln} }lj Dn}j Gjjqjs fu ij}}fhd fh }lfu tjjg(
Jf}ks Lznhd? $Tln}$u kzs u}ksv ljsj;$
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
3/52
=
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
Elfhn cjjbu zq f}u dzhu nu N`jsfen sjbkezuju kh Nufn
Cv @nsfulgn Hkjiij @( Encsjsn
Fu n Hjt Eki Tns Ljn}fhd Zq;
Cnsneg Kcn`nu `nselfhd ksmjsu tjsj
eijns( N} }lj Qjh}ndkh ozu} mnvu nb}js
Hjt Vjns) }lj Z(U( Ek``nhmjsfh
Elfjb zhrjfijm n hjt ujezsf}v u}sn}jdv?
Uzu}nfhfhd Dikcni Ijnmjsulfq? Qsfksf}fju bks
3>u} Ejh}zsv Mjbjhuj( Nhm n dkkm hz`cjs
kb Tnulfhd}khu tksmu tjsj ckzhm }k szbj
msndkh ueniju fh Cjfofhd(
Bks fhu}nhej? }lj dskt}l kb Elfhnu
`fif}nsv qktjs `zu} cj neek`qnhfjm cv
dsjn}js einsf}v kb f}u u}sn}jdfe fh}jh}fkhu
fh ksmjs }k nrkfm enzufhd bsfe}fkh fh }lj
sjdfkh( Ks? ukqlfu}fen}jm nmrjsunsfju tfii
TKSIM
U]SN]JDV QKFH]U
Elfhn$u 31>> jbjhuj
czdj} skuj >3(4* }khjnsiv ->11 cfiifkh
Tkssfj krjs Cjfofhd$u
qktjs) }lj Z(U( nh f}uniifju jhlnhej }fju
Fh snhdj kb QIN skegj}u)ulkzi }lj Qlfifqqfhjudj} eikujs }k }lj Z(U(;
http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=sustaining%20us%20global%20leadership%3A%20priorities%20for%2021st%20century%20defense%20obama&source=web&cd=4&ved=0CD0QFjAD&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.defense.gov%2Fnews%2FDefense_Strategic_Guidance.pdf&ei=5UEVT8GPOeuTiAffsOhC&usg=AFQjCNFkWlkRdmtSNAuHApJMvJlgCp9wUAhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=sustaining%20us%20global%20leadership%3A%20priorities%20for%2021st%20century%20defense%20obama&source=web&cd=4&ved=0CD0QFjAD&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.defense.gov%2Fnews%2FDefense_Strategic_Guidance.pdf&ei=5UEVT8GPOeuTiAffsOhC&usg=AFQjCNFkWlkRdmtSNAuHApJMvJlgCp9wUAhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=sustaining%20us%20global%20leadership%3A%20priorities%20for%2021st%20century%20defense%20obama&source=web&cd=4&ved=0CD0QFjAD&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.defense.gov%2Fnews%2FDefense_Strategic_Guidance.pdf&ei=5UEVT8GPOeuTiAffsOhC&usg=AFQjCNFkWlkRdmtSNAuHApJMvJlgCp9wUAhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=sustaining%20us%20global%20leadership%3A%20priorities%20for%2021st%20century%20defense%20obama&source=web&cd=4&ved=0CD0QFjAD&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.defense.gov%2Fnews%2FDefense_Strategic_Guidance.pdf&ei=5UEVT8GPOeuTiAffsOhC&usg=AFQjCNFkWlkRdmtSNAuHApJMvJlgCp9wUA8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
4/52
:
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
zuj nuv``j}sfe enqncfif}fju) }k fheizmj
jije}skhfe nhm evcjs tnsbnsj) cniifu}fe nhm
eszfuj fuufiju) nmrnhejm nfs mjbjhuju)
`fhfhd) nhm k}ljs j}lkmu) }k ek`qifen}j
kzs kqjsn}fkhni eniezizu(
U}n}ju uzel nu Elfhn
nhm Fsnh tfii ekh}fhzj
}k qzsuzj nuv``j}sfe
`jnhu }k ekzh}js
kzs qktjs qskoje}fkh
enqncfif}fju(
Uk dzjuu tljsj N`jsfen
tfii ulfb} f}u dnj nhm
dzhu? tlfij }lj Z(U(
`fif}nsv tfii ekh}fhzj
}k ekh}sfcz}j }k ujezsf}v
dikcniiv) tj tfii kb
hjejuuf}v sjcninhej
}ktnsm }lj Nufn-Qnefe
sjdfkh( ]lj f}nifeu nsj
Tnulfhd}khu( Ozu} fh
enuj nhvkhj `fuujm }lj qnqjsu hj qsfh})
Qsjufmjh} Kcn`n lf`ujib uqjiijm f} kz})nu Elfhnu hjtu ndjhev \fhlzn sjqks}jm?
Tj$ii cj u}sjhd}ljhfhd kzs qsjujhej fh }lj
Nufn Qnefe) nhm czmdj} sjmze}fkhu tfii hk}
ek`j n} }lj j|qjhuj kb }lfu esf}feni sjdfkh(
Nhm f}u hk} ozu} N`jsfen }ln} Elfhn
`nv hjjm }k bsj} krjs fh }lj bz}zsj( ]lj
Zhf}jm U}n}ju) }lj hjt Qjh}ndkh qkifev?
fu niuk fhrju}fhd fh n ikhd}js` u}sn}jdfeqns}hjsulfq tf}l Fhmfn }k uzqqks} f}u ncfif}v
}k ujsrj nu n sjdfkhni jekhk`fe nhelks
nhm qskrfmjs kb ujezsf}v fh }lj csknmjs
Fhmfnh Kejnh sjdfkh( ]lj }js` N`jsfenh
Fhmfnhu hkt ekhozsju kh n bns `ksj
k`fhkzu f`ndj }lnh nssktu nhm bjn}ljsu(
Bij|fhd `fif}nsfu} `zueij( Cjfofhd tnu
lnsmiv }fegijm cv nii }lfu) }k unv }lj ijnu}(
Nu }ljTksim Ukefnifu} Tjcuf}j sjqks}jm)
Elfhjuj Mjbjhuj @fhfu}sv uqkgju`nh Djhd
Vnhuljhd csfu}ijm? ]lj neezun}fkhu ((( fh
}lfu mkez`jh} nsj }k}niiv cnujijuu( Lj
zsdjm Tnulfhd}kh }k mjni tf}l Elfhn nhm
}lj Elfhjuj fif}nsv fh nh kcoje}frj nhm
sn}fkhni tnv) cj ensjbzi fh
f}u tksmu nhm ne}fkhu) nhm
mk `ksj }ln} fu cjhjefni
}k }lj mjrjikq`jh} kb
sjin}fkhu cj}tjjh }lj
}tk ekzh}sfju nhm }ljfs
`fif}nsfju(
]lj u}n}j ndjhev \fhlzn
tnu `ksj `jnuzsjm) cz}
u}fii qjs}zscjm( F}u jmf}ksfni
neghktijmdjm? Ijdf}f`n}j
fh}jsju}u kb }lj Zhf}jm
U}n}ju) }lj tksimu cfddju}
qktjs) fh }lj Nufn-Qnefe
sjdfkh nsj djhjsniiv
sjuqje}jm( Ek``jh}n}ks
Vz _lf|fnk jrjh niiktjm?
]lj Z(U( Wujezsf}vP skij) fb bziiijm tf}l
n qkuf}frj n}}f}zmj nhm bsjj bsk` n EkimTnsu}vij jskuz` `jh}nif}v) tfii hk}
khiv cj ekhmzefrj }k sjdfkhni u}ncfif}v nhm
qskuqjsf}v) cz} cj dkkm bks Elfhn) tlfel
hjjmu n qjnejbzi jhrfskh`jh} }k ekh}fhzj
f}u jekhk`fe mjrjikq`jh}(
U}fii) \fhlzn tnshjm? Fb }lj Zhf}jm U}n}ju
fhmfuesjj}iv nqqifju fif}nsfu` fh }lj
sjdfkh) f} tfii cj ifgj n czii fh n elfhn ulkq)nhm jhmnhdjs qjnej fhu}jnm kb jhlnhefhd
sjdfkhni u}ncfif}v( ]lj Cjfofhd jmf}ksfni
uz``jm zq? ]lj Zhf}jm U}n}ju lnu }lj
dsjn}ju} qk}jh}fni }k ujezsj tksim qjnej nhm
u}ncfif}v) cz} f} niuk lnu }lj dsjn}ju} qktjs
}k esjn}j elnku( ((( ]lj Zhf}jm U}n}ju ulkzim
ijnsh bsk` f}u qnu} qnfhbzi j|qjsfjheju
nhm qinv n ekhu}sze}frj skij fh }lj Nufn
Qnefe fhu}jnm kb sjegijuuiv qsne}fefhd
`fif}nsfu`( Nb}js nii) `fdl} mkju hk} nitnvu
`ngj sfdl}(
Bks uk`j
kb Elfhnu
hjfdlcksu)
}lj Qjkqij$u
Ifcjsn}fkh
Ns`v lnu cjjh
j|fhd zueijunhm qsne}fefhd
`fif}nsfu` fh
sjejh} vjnsu
Fu n hjt ekim tns ljn}fhd zq;
http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/world/2012-01/06/c_131346317.htmhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=sustaining%20us%20global%20leadership%3A%20priorities%20for%2021st%20century%20defense%20china%20response&source=web&cd=6&ved=0CEAQFjAF&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Farticles%2F2012%2Fjan2012%2Fchin-j13.shtml&ei=MU4VT4HPBeaOiAf6kMAw&usg=AFQjCNExTdwBZyyveFds1rEna2Uoc-Tj4Ahttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348.htmhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348.htmhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348_2.htmhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348_2.htmhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348_2.htmhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348_2.htmhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348.htmhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/indepth/2012-01/06/c_131346348.htmhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=sustaining%20us%20global%20leadership%3A%20priorities%20for%2021st%20century%20defense%20china%20response&source=web&cd=6&ved=0CEAQFjAF&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Farticles%2F2012%2Fjan2012%2Fchin-j13.shtml&ei=MU4VT4HPBeaOiAf6kMAw&usg=AFQjCNExTdwBZyyveFds1rEna2Uoc-Tj4Ahttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english/world/2012-01/06/c_131346317.htm8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
5/52
2
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
@nvcj }lj Qjkqiju Ifcjsn}fkh Ns`v
ulkzim sjnm \fhlzn `ksj( Fh bne}) bks uk`j
kb Elfhnu hjfdlcksu) }lj QIN lnu cjjh
j|fhd zueiju nhm qsne}fefhd `fif}nsfu`
fh sjejh} vjnsu) nu fb Elfhjuj `fdl} `nmj
Elfhn sfdl}( Jnsiv inu} vjns) bks fhu}nhej)
uk`j ekzh}sfju bsj}}jm krjs Cjfofhdu
qinh }k ckku} f}u mjbjhuj czmdj} cv
>3(4* }k 21> cfiifkh vznh ks -6>(: cfiifkh)
nu \fhlzn sjqks}jm) zq bsk` 4(:*
fh 31>1(
If _lnk|fhd) uqkgju`nh kb }lj Hn}fkhni
Qjkqiju Ekhdsjuu) j|qinfhu? #]lj if`f}jm
`fif}nsv u}sjhd}l kb Elfhn fu ukijiv bks
unbjdznsmfhd f}u hn}fkhni ukrjsjfdh}v
Uzu}nfhfhd Z(U( Dikcni Ijnjsulfq?Qsfksf}fju bks 3>u} Ejh}zsv Mjbjhuj
N mjbjhuj u}sn}jdv }ln} }snhuf}fkhu kzs Mjbjhuj jh}jsqsfuj bsk` nh j`qlnufu kh
}kmnvu tnsu }k qsjqnsfhd bks bz}zsj elniijhdju nhm uzqqks}u }lj hn}fkhni ujezsf}v
f`qjsn}frj kb mjef} sjmze}fkh }lskzdl iktjs mjbjhuj uqjhmfhd( ]lj cninhej
cj}tjjh nrnfincij sjukzseju nhm kzs ujezsf}v hjjmu lnu hjrjs cjjh `ksj mjifen}j(
Qsf`nsv `fuufkhu kb }lj Z(U( Ns`jm Bkseju?
- Mj}js nhm Mjbjn} Nddsjuufkh - Mjbjhm }lj Lk`jinhm nhm Uzqqks} Efrfi Nz}lksf}fju
- Qskoje} Qktjs Mjuqf}j Nh}f-Neejuu + - Kqjsn}j Jbbje}frjiv fh Evcjsuqnej nhm Uqnej
Nsjn Mjhfni Elniijhdju - Ekhmze} U}ncfif}v nhm Ekzh}jsfhuzsdjhev Kqjsn}fkhu
- Ekzh}js Tjnqkhu kb @nuu Mju}sze}fkh - Ekhmze} Lz`nhf}nsfnh) Sjifjb) nhm K}ljs Kqjsn}fkhu
- @nfh}nfh n Unbj) Ujezsj) nhm Jbbje}frj - Qskrfmj n U}ncfiffhd QsjujhejHzeijns Mj}jssjh}
]lj Z(U( tfii ekh}fhzj hzs}zsfhd niifnheju fh Nufn nhm Jzskqj) nhm czfim qns}hjsulfqu fh Nbsfen nhm In}fh
N`jsfen( # tj tfii mjrjikq fhhkrn}frj) ikteku}) nhm u`niibkk}qsfh} nqqsknelju j|jsefuju) sk}n}fkhni
qsjujhej) nhm nmrfuksv enqncfif}fju(#
U}n}ju uzel nu Elfhn nhm Fsnh tfii ekh}fhzj }k qzsuzj nuv``j}sfe `jnhu }k ekzh}js WZ(U(P qktjs
qskoje}fkh( ]ljv fheizmj evcjs tnsbnsj) cniifu}fe nhm eszfuj `fuufiju) nhm nmrnhejm nfs mjbjhuju(
#Rfkijh} j|}sj`fu}u ekh}fhzj }k }lsjn}jh Z(U( fh}jsju}u) niifju) qns}hjsu) nhm }lj lk`jinhm( ]lj qsf`nsv
ikef kb }ljuj }lsjn}u nsj Ukz}l Nufn nhm }lj @fmmij Jnu}(#
Z(U( jekhk`fe nhm ujezsf}v fh}jsju}u nsj fhj|}sfenciv ifhgjm }k mjrjikq`jh}u fh }lj nse j|}jhmfhd bsk`
}lj Tju}jsh Qnefe nhm Jnu} Nufn fh}k }lj Fhmfnh Kejnh nhm Ukz}l Nufn
Krjs }lj ikhd }js`) Elfhnu j`jsdjhej nu n sjdfkhni qktjs tfii lnrj }lj qk}jh}fni }k nbbje} }lj Z(U(
jekhk`v nhm ujezsf}v( ]lj dskt}l kb Elfhnu `fif}nsv `zu} cj neek`qnhfjm cv dsjn}js einsf}v kb f}u
u}sn}jdfe fh}jh}fkhu }k nrkfm bsfe}fkh(
Qsjufmjh} Kcn`n? $Fh n elnhdfhd tksim }ln} mj`nhmu kzs ijnmjsulfq) }lj Zhf}jm U}n}ju kb N`jsfen tfii
sj`nfh }lj dsjn}ju} bksej bks bsjjmk` nhm ujezsf}v }lj tksim lnu jrjs ghkth$
N ]NIJ KB ]TK NS@FJU
http://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010/china/2011-03/04/c_13761030.htmhttp://www.defense.gov/news/Defense_Strategic_Guidance.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/news/Defense_Strategic_Guidance.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/news/Defense_Strategic_Guidance.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/news/Defense_Strategic_Guidance.pdfhttp://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010/china/2011-03/04/c_13761030.htm8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
6/52
4
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
nhm }jssf}ksfni fh}jdsf}v) nhm tkzim hk}
qkuj n }lsjn} }k nhv ekzh}sv( Elfhn fu
ek``f}}jm }k qjnejbzi mjrjikq`jh}
nhm n hn}fkhni mjbjhuj qkifev }ln}
fu mjbjhufrj(#
Hjrjs}ljijuu) Elfhn tn}eljsu cjifjrj
}lj ekzh}svu mjbjhuj uqjhmfhd fu lfdljs
}lnh tln} f}u ijnmjsu ensj }k mfueikuj)
`ksj }lnh }lj mfuesjqnhev fh `nhv k}ljs
ekzh}sfju( @ksj kh }ln} in}js(
]lj cfddju} ns`v dj}u }kzdljs( Elfhnu
Qjkqiju Ifcjsn}fkh Ns`v ks QIN fu }lj
tksimu insdju} tf}l 3(5 `fiifkh sjdzinsu nhm
>(3 fiifkh sjujsrju) neeksmfhd }k Czufhjuu
Elfhnu Hn}fkhni Mjbjhuj fh 31>1
Fh}jshn}fkhni u}sn}jdfe ek`qj}f}fkh nhm ekh}snmfe}fkhu nsj fh}jhufbvfhd) dikcni
elniijhdju nsj cjek`fhd ksj qsk`fhjh}) nhm ujezsf}v }lsjn}u nsj cjek`fhdfhesjnufhdiv fh}jdsn}jm) ek`qij| nhm rkin}fij(
Elfhn fu u}fii fh }lj qjsfkm kb f qks}nh} u}sn}jdfe kqqks}zhf}fju bks f}u mjrjikq`jh})
nhm }lj krjsnii ujezsf}v jhrfskh`jh} bks f} sj`nfhu bnrksncij(
Elfhnu mjbjhuj qkifev fu mjbjhufrj fh hn}zsj(
]lj dkniu nhm }nugu kb Elfhjuj mjbjhuj?
- Unbjdznsmfhd hn}fkhni ukrjsjfdh}v) ujezsf}v) nhm fh}jsju}u kb hn}fkhni mjrjikq`jh}
@nfh}nfhfhd ukefni lns`khv nhm u}ncfif}v7- Neejijsn}fhd }lj `kmjshfn}fkh kb hn}fkhni mjbjhuj nhm }lj ns`jm bkseju
@nfh}nfhfhd tksim qjnej nhm u}ncfif}v
Nufn-Qnefe ujezsf}v fu ujjh nu rkin}fij tf}l }jhufkhu kh }lj Gksjnh Qjhfhuzin nhm fh Nbdlnhfu}nh) qizu
keenufkhni mfuqz}ju krjs }jssf}ksfni nhm nsf}f`j sfdl}u(
Qskbkzhm elnhdju nsj }ngfhd ulnqj fh }lj Nufn-Qnefe u}sn}jdfe inhmuenqj( Sjijrnh} `noks qktjsu
nsj fhesjnufhd }ljfs u}sn}jdfe fhrju}`jh}( ]lj Zhf}jm U}n}ju fu sjfhbksefhd f}u sjdfkhni `fif}nsv niifnheju)
nhm fhesjnufhd f}u fhrkirj`jh} fh sjdfkhni ujezsf}v nbbnfsu(
]lj Zhf}jm U}n}ju ekh}fhzju }k ujii tjnqkhu }k ]nftnh) ujrjsjiv f`qjmfhd Ufhk-ZU sjin}fkhu nhm
f`qnfsfhd }lj qjnejbzi mjrjikq`jh} kb eskuu-U}snf} sjin}fkhu(
Elfhn }ngju nh ne}frj qns} fh ju}ncifulfhd ujezsf}v mfnikdzj nhm czfimfhd ujezsf}v `jelnhfu`u fh }lj
Nufn-Qnefe sjdfkh
Elfhn n}}nelju dsjn} f`qks}nhej }k `fif}nsv }snhuqnsjhev) nhm `ngju jbbks}u }k qsk`k}j `z}zni }szu}
tf}l k}ljs ekzh}sfju fh }lj `fif}nsv uqljsj(
Elfhn tfii hjrjs ujjg ljdj`khv) hks tfii f} nmkq} }lj nqqsknel kb `fif}nsv j|qnhufkh hkt ks fh }lj
bz}zsj) hk `n}}js lkt f}u jekhk`v mjrjikqu(
Fu n hjt ekim tns ljn}fhd zq;
LFDLIFDL]U KB Z(U( NHm ELFHN mJBJHUJ QNQJSU
http://www.defense.gov/news/Defense_Strategic_Guidance.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/news/Defense_Strategic_Guidance.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/news/Defense_Strategic_Guidance.pdf8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
7/52
3 Bsfdl}jhfhd Bne}u Nckz}
Elfhnu @nuufrj Dsktfhd @fif}nsv( Ufhej
}lj >661u) }lj QIN lnu cjjh u}sjhd}ljhfhd
f}u inhm) ujn) nfs) nhm uqnej enqncfif}fju(
Nhm tf}l }lj sfuj kb Elfhnu jekhk`v fh
sjejh} mjenmju) j|qjs}u unv f} fu khiv hn}zsni
}k fhesjnuj qzcife uqjhmfhd fh gjv nsjnu)
fheizmfhd mjbjhuj(
Elfhnu @fif}nsv Qktjs bsk` }lj Z(U(
Ekzhefi kb Bksjfdh Sjin}fkhu ~zk}ju On`ju
@zirjhkh kb }lj Ejh}js bks Fh}jiifdjhej
Sjujnsel nhm Nhnivufu? Elfhn$u fif}nsv
`kmjshfn}fkh ngju qjsbje} ujhuj }k j
nu n hn}zsni jrkiz}fkh ek``jhuzsn}j tf}l
Elfhn$u sfuj nu n dsjn} qktjs(
Hk}nciv) Cjfofhdu mjbjhuj uqjhmfhd
sj`nfhu n bsne}fkh kb }lj cfddju} kz}inv) }ln}
kb Tnulfhd}kh? hjnsiv -411 cfiifkh fh 31>1)
ks =(*) Fhmfn 3(4*)
Ukz}l Gksjn 3(1(=* nu ek`qfijm cv]lj
Jekhk`fu}&( Fh 311
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
8/52
6
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
unvu }lj Z(U( Mjbjhuj Mjqns}`jh} bnzi}u
Elfhn bks n lfdliv ekhu}sfe}jm nqqsknel
}k fif}nsv }snhuqnsjhev) fheizmfhd n
uzqqkujm sjifnhej kh u}sn}jdfe mjejq}fkh)
n qjhelnh} bks j|}sj`j ujesjev) n
ufdhfenh} zhmjsu}n}j`jh} kb }lj czmdj}nsv
sjukzseju niiken}jm }k hn}fkhni mjbjhuj) nhm
kcuezsf}v kh lkt }lj QIN `fdl} j`qikv
bksej fh n bz}zsj esfufu(
Krjs }f`j) Elfhn lnu dsnmzniiv cjek`j
`ksj }snhuqnsjh}( Fh f}u 31>> Nhhzni
Sjqks} }k Ekhdsjuu kh @fif}nsv nhm
Ujezsf}v Mjrjikq`jh}u Fhrkirfhd }lj
Qjkqiju Sjqzcife kb Elfhn) }lj Z(U(Mjbjhuj Mjqns}`jh} sjekdhfjm }ln}
Cjfofhd lnu nmj `kmju}) cz} fhesj`jh}ni)
f`qskrj`jh}u fh }lj }snhuqnsjhev kb f}u
`fif}nsv nhm ujezsf}v nbbnfsu) cz} sj`nfhu
zhejs}nfh nu }k lkt f} tfii zuj f}u dsktfhd
enqncfif}fju( Hk} }ln} }lj Z(U( ks nhv
k}ljs ekzh}sv fu uk bsjj nhm kqjh nckz} f}u
`fif}nsv u}sn}jdfju nhm }ne}feu(
Cjfofhdu ukb}-qktjs u}sn}jdv( U}fii)
}lj sjqks} hmu khj }lfhd eijns nhm
ekhufu}jh}? Sn}ljs }lnh elniijhdj }lj
j|fu}fhd dikcni ksmjs) Elfhn lnu nmkq}jm
n qsnd`n}fe nqqsknel }k fh}jshn}fkhni
sjin}fkhu nhm jekhk`fe mjrjikq`jh}
}ln} ujjgu }k u}sjhd}ljh }lj jekhk`v)
`kmjshfj }lj fif}nsv) nhm ukifmfbv }lj
WElfhjuj Ek``zhfu} Qns}vuP lkim
kh qktjs(
Fh k}ljs tksmu) Cjfofhd zuju ukb} qktjs
}k nmrnhej f}u fh}jsju}u fh }lj sjdfkh)
neeksmfhd }k }lj Ekhdsjuufkhni Sjujnsel
Ujsrfej sjqks} Elfhnu ukb}qktjs fh
Ukz}ljnu} Nufn( F}u dsktfhd fhzjhej)
}lj sjqks} einf`u) enh cj n}}sfcz}jm
}k hkh`fif}nsv fhmzej`jh}u) uzel nu
ezi}zsj) mfqik`nev) bksjfdh nfm) }snmj) nhm
fhrju}`jh}(
]k cj uzsj) Elfhn fu hk mfbbjsjh} bsk`
nhv k}ljs `noks qktjs tf}l ujibujsrfhd
qkifefju( U}fii) f} `nfh}nfhu }ln} f}u `fdl} fu
qzsjiv mjbjhufrj nhm) kh keenufkh) nrnfincij
bks fh}jshn}fkhni qjnejgjjqfhd( F}u 31>1
Mjbjhuj Tlf}j Qnqjs sjf}jsn}ju }ln} Elfhn
tfii hjrjs ujjg ljdj`khv( Sn}ljs) Elfhn
fu unfm }k cj ekhbskh}jm cv `ksj mfrjsuj
nhm ek`qij| ujezsf}v elniijhdju nhm }ln}
WqPskuqje}u bks tksim zi}fqkinsfn}fkh
nsj cjek`fhd eijnsjs( ]lj Z(U()
`jnhtlfij) fu unfm }k cj sjfhbksefhd f}u
sjdfkhni fif}nsv niifnheju) nhm fhesjnufhd
fhrkirj`jh} fh sjdfkhni ujezsf}v nbbnfsu(
]lj fuufij }lsjn}( Hkhj}ljijuu) nhv
fh }lj sjdfkh sj`nfh fh n u}n}j
kb mfu~zfj} krjs Elfhnu
`fif}nsv kmjshfn}fkh(
Khj qns}fezins nsjn kb
dsktfhd ekhejsh fu
}lj QINu fuufij
enqncfif}v) tlfel
ekzim mk `zel }ksjmzej }lj Z(U(
Qnefe Bijj}u mjenmju-
kim uzqsj`nev fh }lj
sjdfkhu tn}jsu( ]ln} hjt
ujezsf}v j~zn}fkh tskzdl}
cv Elfhjuj skegj} bkseju tj
ulnii sjrfjt fh }lj hj|} qns}
kb }lfu ns}feij(
Elfhn lnu }lj `ku} ne}frj
inhmcnujm cniifu}fe nhm eszfuj
`fuufij qskdsn` fh }lj tksim) n
3116 Qjh}ndkh sjqks} einf`u( ]ln}
fu lnsmiv uzsqsfufhd) ufhej }lj tksimu
cfddju} hzeijns nsujhniu) N`jsfenu nhm
Szuufnu ujrjsni }lkzunhm tnsljnmu)
nsj zq bks sjmze}fkh }k >)::1 jnel zhmjs
}ljfs 31>1 U}sn}jdfe Ns`u Sjmze}fkh
]sjn}v,U]NS]&) tlfel }kkg jbbje} fh
Bjcsznsv 31>>(
Fu n hjt ekim tns ljn}fhd zq;
http://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2011_cmpr_final.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2011_cmpr_final.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2011_cmpr_final.pdfhttp://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL34310.pdfhttp://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL34310.pdfhttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/China_Military_Power_Report_2009.pdfhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=new%2Bstart%2B2010%2Btreaty&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CBoQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FNew_START&ei=NyfATuamDYmUiQfZroGFBQ&usg=AFQjCNGkqSZNj6llyL8JwCknPYycdCcaPghttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=new%2Bstart%2B2010%2Btreaty&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CBoQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FNew_START&ei=NyfATuamDYmUiQfZroGFBQ&usg=AFQjCNGkqSZNj6llyL8JwCknPYycdCcaPghttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=new%2Bstart%2B2010%2Btreaty&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CBoQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FNew_START&ei=NyfATuamDYmUiQfZroGFBQ&usg=AFQjCNGkqSZNj6llyL8JwCknPYycdCcaPghttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=new%2Bstart%2B2010%2Btreaty&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CBoQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FNew_START&ei=NyfATuamDYmUiQfZroGFBQ&usg=AFQjCNGkqSZNj6llyL8JwCknPYycdCcaPghttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/China_Military_Power_Report_2009.pdfhttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL34310.pdfhttp://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL34310.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2011_cmpr_final.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2011_cmpr_final.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2011_cmpr_final.pdf8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
9/52
>1
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
@jnhtlfij) Elfhn lnu }k `ksj }lnh
mkzcij f}u hzgju ozu} }k sjnel khj}lfsm
kb }lj ndsjjm Z(U( nhm Szuufnh u}kegqfiju(
F} lnu nckz} 3=1 tnsljnmu) tf}l >4:
fh ne}frj `kmj nhm 2: fh sjujsrj)
neeksmfhd }k Tju}jsh ju}f`n}ju ef}jm fh
]lj Onqnh ]f`ju(
Tlku fh }lj sfhd
ifhj;]lj Hzeijns
]lsjn} Fhf}fn}frj
ifu}u Elfhnu qkuufcij
}nsdj}u tf}l f}u ezssjh}
cniifu}fe `fuufiju?
ulks}snhdj bks nsjnu
nikhd }lj cksmjs
fheizmfhd ]nftnh7
`jmfz`snhdj bks
hjnscv ekzh}sfju
ifgj Onqnh) Fhmfn)
nhm Ukz}ljnu} Nufnh
hn}fkhu7 fh}js`jmfn}j
snhdj bks }nsdj}u fh
Ejh}sni Nufn nhm }ljTju}jsh Qnefe ,tljsj
Szuufn nhm N`jsfen
lnrj inhm nhm ujn
cnujm hzgju&7 nhm
fh}jsekh}fhjh}ni bks Jzskqjnh Szuufn)
}lj ekh}fhjh}ni Zhf}jm U}n}ju) nhm
Tju}jsh Jzskqj(
NTfsjm`ndnfhj ns}feij mfuezuuju
}lj ckkgElfhjuj Njskuqnej Qktjs cv
Nhmsjt Jsfegukh kb N`jsfenu Hnrni
Tns Ekiijdj( Lj nsdzju }ln} Elfhnu QIN
ek`qjhun}ju bks f}u sjin}frj tjnghjuu cv
mjqikvfhd ksj nhm ksj fuufiju( Bks
jrjsv en}jdksv kb tjnqkhsv tljsj }lj
Qjkqiju Ifcjsn}fkh Ns`v indu cjlfhm
}lj Qjh}ndkh) }ljsju n Elfhjuj fuufij }k
ljiq ngj zq }lj mfbbjsjhej)
Jsfegukh j|qinfhu(
]lkuj }tk nuujuu`jh}u qkfh} }k Elfhnu
`fuufij u}sn}jdfju( Cn}}ijjim skegj}u enh
ujrjsjiv mjdsnmj ks hjz}snifj kqqkufhd
bkseju) uzel nu }lj rnu}iv uzqjsfks enssfjs
cnujm nhm ikhdsnhdj nfsesnb} kb }lj Zhf}jm
U}n}ju( ]lj bksju} kb nh}fulfq nhm nh}f
nfsesnb} cn}}jsfju nikhd }lj eknu} tkzim
mj}js jrjh n tjii
qsk}je}jm enssfjs dskzq
bsk` dj}}fhd }kk eikuj
ulkzim }ljsj cj dl}fhd
krjs) unv) ]nftnh ks
}lj Uqsn}ivu(
Ikhdsnhdj nhm
fh}jsekh}fhjh}ni `fuufiju)
kh }lj k}ljs lnhm) ekzim
`ngj hzeijns qktjsu
ifgj }lj Z(U( }lfhg }tfej
nckz} hzgfhd Elfhn) }lzu
enu}fhd uk`j mkzc} kh
}lj ukeniijm #hzeijns
z`csjiin# krjs N`jsfenh
niifju( Fb Elfhjuj n}k`fetjnqkhu lf} Onqnh ks }lj
Qlfifqqfhju) tkzim }lj
Z(U( sj}nifn}j) ghktfhd
}ln} Elfhn ekzim hzgj
Iku Nhdjiju ks Hjt Vksg fh sj}nifn}fkh;
]lj `ku} nins`fhd tjnqkh( Bks
uk`j Tju}jsh ujezsf}v j|qjs}u) nh nh}f
ulfq cniifu}fe fuufij ,NUC@& fu }lj `ku}
nins`fhd tjnqkh Elfhn fu mjrjikqfhd(
@kzh}jm kh kcfij inzhel rjlfeij) f} fu
Elfhnu su} `fuufij }ln} enh elnhdj
ekzsuj }k lf} n `krfhd }nsdj}( Tljh
inzheljm) }lj NUC@ tfii sfuj }k sjnel
uqnej nhm }ljh `nhjzrjs n} lvqjsukhfe
uqjjmu kh f}u tnv cneg mkth( Nfsesnb}
enssfjsu) }lj eksj kb Z(U( qktjs qskoje}fkh
fh }lj Nufn-Qnefe sjdfkh) ekzim cj
ujsfkzuiv }lsjn}jhjm(
Elfhnu dsktfhd
u}sn}jdfe qktjs
qz}u f} fh n
qkuf}fkh }kjf}ljs mjbv
}lj Tju}$u
mj`nhmu ks
tksg tf}l f}
}k czfim n hjt
tksim ksmjs
U}nhbksmZhfrjsuf}v u}zmv
http://www.japantimes.co.jp/text/eo20110304mr.htmlhttp://www.japantimes.co.jp/text/eo20110304mr.htmlhttp://www.nti.org/db/china/wbmdat.htmhttp://www.nti.org/db/china/wbmdat.htmhttp://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2011/07/china-plan-to-beat-u-s/http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2011/07/china-plan-to-beat-u-s/http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2011/07/china-plan-to-beat-u-s/http://www.nti.org/db/china/wbmdat.htmhttp://www.nti.org/db/china/wbmdat.htmhttp://www.japantimes.co.jp/text/eo20110304mr.htmlhttp://www.japantimes.co.jp/text/eo20110304mr.html8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
10/52
>>
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
Fh Ujq}j`cjs inu} vjns) ksjkrjs)
Elfhn ekhs`jm }lj uzeejuubzi }ju}fhd
kb f}u nh}f`fuufij uvu}j` }k ulkk}
mkth qskoje}fiju fh fmnfs) }lj
Fh}jshn}fkhni Czufhjuu ]f`ju sjqks}jm(
Uzel cn}}jsfju ekzim qsk}je} `fif}nsv
cnuju nhm skegj} nhm ns}fiijsv nssnvu
bsk` n}}neg cv `fuufiju nhm zh`nhhjm
mskhju) N`jsfenu hjt tjnqkhu
kb elkfej(
Nrfn}fkh Tjjgniuk sjqks}jm }ln} Elfhnu
su} u}jni}l dl}js oj} lnm ozu} j`jsdjm
bsk` n ujesj} mjrjikq`jh} qskdsn`( ]lj
nh}fsnmns }jelhkikdv tkzim `ngj f} lnsmjs
}k uqk} Elfhjuj oj}u n}}negfhd hnrni rjuujiu(
]lj O-31u }ju} fdl} krjsulnmktjm }lj
31>> Cjfofhd rfuf} kb Z(U( Mjbjhuj Ujesj}nsv
Skcjs} Dn}ju) neeksmfhd }k ]lj Hjt Vksg
]f`ju( ]lj Mnfiv Cjnu}) n mfrfufkh kb
Hjtutjjg) unfm }lj }f`fhd kb }lj nfsesnb}u
sjijnuj ujj`jm nh zhuzc}ij tnrj n} }lj
]nftnh fuuzj(
Hk tkssfju nckz} Elfhjuj skegj}u(
]lj qnqjs Elfhnu Hzeijns Nsujhni?
U}n}zu nhm Jrkiz}fkh cv }lj Zhfkh kb
Ekhejshjm Uefjh}fu}u) cnujm fh En`csfmdj)
@nuunelzuj}}u ,ifgj Lnsrnsm&) ekheizmju
}ln} Elfhnu ufj nhm qnej kb mjrjikq`jh}
kb f}u hzeijns bkseju nsj fh ifhj tf}l }lj
rfjt }ln} }lj bzhmn`jh}ni qzsqkuj
kb Elfhnu hzeijns nsujhni fu }k nuuzsj
qk}jh}fni hzeijns nmrjsunsfju }ln} Elfhn
enh sj}nifn}j fh sjuqkhuj }k nh n}}neg(
Elfhn j`qlnufju f}u qkifev kb hk-su}-zuj
kb n}k`fe tjnqkhu) fh f}u mjbjhuj
tlf}j qnqjs(
Nh fh}jsne}frj dsnqlfe bsk` ]lj Jekhk`fu}ulktu }lj snhdju kb }lj rnsfkzu }vqju kb `fuufijunh }lj nsjnu }ln} ekzi cj nbbje}j fb }ljv nsj inzhelj(
Fu n hjt ekim tns ljn}fhd zq;
http://au.ibtimes.com/articles/216489/20110920/china-s-anti-missile-military-breakthrough.htmhttp://au.ibtimes.com/articles/216489/20110920/china-s-anti-missile-military-breakthrough.htmhttp://www.aviationweek.com/aw/generic/story.jsp?id=news/awst/2011/01/03/AW_01_03_2011_p18-279564.xml&headline=China%27s%20J-20%20Stealth%20Fighter%20In%20Taxi%20Tests&channel=awsthttp://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/12/world/asia/12fighter.html?partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/12/world/asia/12fighter.html?partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2011/01/18/an-end-to-america-s-air-invincibility.htmlhttp://www.ucsusa.org/assets/documents/nwgs/UCS-Chinese-nuclear-modernization.pdfhttp://www.ucsusa.org/assets/documents/nwgs/UCS-Chinese-nuclear-modernization.pdfhttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2010/12/chinese_missile_rangeshttp://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2010/12/chinese_missile_rangeshttp://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2010/12/chinese_missile_rangeshttp://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2010/12/chinese_missile_rangeshttp://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2010/12/chinese_missile_rangeshttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://in.china-embassy.org/eng/xwfw/xxfb/t811491.htmhttp://www.ucsusa.org/assets/documents/nwgs/UCS-Chinese-nuclear-modernization.pdfhttp://www.ucsusa.org/assets/documents/nwgs/UCS-Chinese-nuclear-modernization.pdfhttp://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2011/01/18/an-end-to-america-s-air-invincibility.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/12/world/asia/12fighter.html?partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/12/world/asia/12fighter.html?partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.aviationweek.com/aw/generic/story.jsp?id=news/awst/2011/01/03/AW_01_03_2011_p18-279564.xml&headline=China%27s%20J-20%20Stealth%20Fighter%20In%20Taxi%20Tests&channel=awsthttp://au.ibtimes.com/articles/216489/20110920/china-s-anti-missile-military-breakthrough.htm8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
11/52
>3
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
Elfhnu Cniifu}fe @fuufij Qskdsn`u?
]jelhkikdfju) U}sn}jdfju) nhm Dkniu cv
Oklh Tfiukh Ijtfu nhm Lzn Mf kb U}nhbksm
Zhfrjsuf}v) sj`fhmu sjnmjsu? F} }lzu tkzim
cj n `fu}ngj }k sjdnsm Elfhnu nuqfsn}fkhu
}ktnsm mjbjhuj mjrjikq`jh} nu cjfhd
nhv `ksj ufhfu}js }lnh }lkuj kb k}ljs
dsjn} qktjsu(
Nu bks }snhuqnsjhev) Elfhnu hzgj
mjqikv`jh} nhm u}ksndj nsj jrjh
mkez`jh}jm fh Elfhn$u Hzeijns Tnsljnm
U}ksndj nhm Lnhmifhd Uvu}j`) n sjqks}
cvQskoje} 31=6) n sjujnsel dskzq tf}l }lj
nf`) Dzfmfhd mjefufkh ngjsu }ktnsm n
`ksj ujezsj Nufn cv 31=6(
U}fii) tlfij uk`j N`jsfenh j|qjs}u nv
bjji Elfhn fuh} nu cfd n }lsjn} nu f}u `fuufij
nsujhni nv uzddju}) hjfdlcksfhd Nufnh
ekzh}sfju enhhk} cz} bjji ijuu ujezsj)
juqjefniiv tf}l ikhdu}nhmfhd mfuqz}ju krjs
]nftnh) fh }lj Ukz}l nhm Jnu} Elfhn Ujnu)
nhm cksmjs nsjnu kb Fhmfn) Rfj}hn`) nhm
jrjh Szuufn(
Qinfhiv) }lj QIN nhm f}u czsdjkhfhd fuufij
enqncfif}v enh }lsjn}jh `zel kb Nufn)
nhm jrjh `ngj lnsm bks }lj Z(U( }k `ngj
dkkm kh f}u mjbjhuj ek``f}`jh}u fh }lj
sjdfkh( @ksjkrjs) Elfhnu jekhk`fe sfuj
enh bzs}ljs fh}f`fmn}j f}u hjfdlcksu nhm
jrjh }lj uzqjsqktjs neskuu }lj Qnefe( Nhv
ekzh}sv tnh}fhd n mjejh} uifej kb f}u `nsgj}
enhhk} nbbksm }k qfeg n dl} tf}l Elfhn)
nhm }ln} fheizmju }lj Z(U( hkt Elfhnu
cfddju} mjc}ks) tf}l }lj in}}jsu hjnsiv
-> }sfiifkh fh Z(U(
]sjnuzsv cfiiu(
N`jsfen nuuzsju niifjmNufn( U}fii) fh }nigu tf}l
Qsjufmjh} Cjhfdhk N~zfhk
FFF kh }lj ufmjifhju kb }lj
`fmHkrj`cjs NUJNH
Uz``f} fh Cnif) lfu
N`jsfenh ekzh}jsqns}
nuuzsjm? Tj nsj ikkgfhd
kz} bks jnel k}ljs tljh
f} ek`ju }k ujezsf}v(Fh @nhfin bks }lj 21}l
nhhfrjsunsvkb }lj
QlfifqqfhjuZ(U( @z}zni
Mjbjhuj ]sjn}v) Ujesj}nsv kb U}n}j
Lfiinsv Eifh}kh mjeinsjm n`fm Bfifqfhk
ejijcsn}fkhu krjs @nhhv Qne~zfnku
Hkrj`cjs ck|fhd tfh) }ln} N`jsfen tnu
fh }lj Qlfifqqfhju ekshjs(
Tf}l Tnulfhd}kh kh f}u ufmj) @nhfin lnu
cjjh `n}elfhd }kzdl }nig bsk` Cjfofhd(
]lj Mjqns}`jh} kb Bksjfdh Nbbnfsu inuljm
kz} n} Elfhn bks f}u dskuuiv fssjuqkhufcij
tnshfhd fh nh jmf}ksfni) Mkh$} }ngj qjnejbzi
nqqsknel bks dsnh}jm) bsk` ]lj Dikcni
]f`ju) kthjm cv }lj Elfhjuj Ek``zhfu}
Qns}vuQjkqij$u Mnfiv hjtuqnqjs) }k }lj
http://iis-db.stanford.edu/pubs/20613/china's_ballistic_missile_programs.pdfhttp://iis-db.stanford.edu/pubs/20613/china's_ballistic_missile_programs.pdfhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=China%2Bnuclear%2Bwarheads&source=web&cd=6&ved=0CFwQFjAF&url=http%3A%2F%2Fproject2049.net%2Fdocuments%2Fchinas_nuclear_warhead_storage_and_handling_system.pdf&ei=wyjATvSeMLGQiAewquydBQ&usg=AFQjCNHlCkryzZG0COPnWWzFuPwvonZCIghttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=China%2Bnuclear%2Bwarheads&source=web&cd=6&ved=0CFwQFjAF&url=http%3A%2F%2Fproject2049.net%2Fdocuments%2Fchinas_nuclear_warhead_storage_and_handling_system.pdf&ei=wyjATvSeMLGQiAewquydBQ&usg=AFQjCNHlCkryzZG0COPnWWzFuPwvonZCIghttp://project2049.net/about_us.htmlhttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/11/18/11/obama-says-us-looking-out-philippineshttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/11/18/11/obama-says-us-looking-out-philippineshttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/11/18/11/obama-says-us-looking-out-philippineshttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=hillary%20clinton%20manila%20visit&source=web&cd=3&ved=0CDEQFjAC&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.abs-cbnnews.com%2Fnation%2F11%2F15%2F11%2Fhillary-clinton-manila-working-visit&ei=chLGTt-0LNCWiQfH67jWDw&usg=AFQjCNH8vVKicjD8GLgbYGc2LCMKrfOl9ghttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=hillary%20clinton%20manila%20visit&source=web&cd=3&ved=0CDEQFjAC&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.abs-cbnnews.com%2Fnation%2F11%2F15%2F11%2Fhillary-clinton-manila-working-visit&ei=chLGTt-0LNCWiQfH67jWDw&usg=AFQjCNH8vVKicjD8GLgbYGc2LCMKrfOl9ghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_Defense_Treaty_(U.Shttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_Defense_Treaty_(U.Shttp://businessmirror.com.ph/home/nation/18469-dfa-hits-china-over-irresponsible-statement-on-west-philippine-seahttp://businessmirror.com.ph/home/nation/18469-dfa-hits-china-over-irresponsible-statement-on-west-philippine-seahttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=spratlys%20editorial&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCUQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.globaltimes.cn%2FNEWS%2Ftabid%2F99%2FID%2F680694%2FDont-take-peaceful-approach-for-granted.aspx&ei=7okVT8LlBIqziQersdBD&usg=AFQjCNEOfxNwqDvrLq53U045Ndm0mf0S4Qhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=spratlys%20editorial&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCUQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.globaltimes.cn%2FNEWS%2Ftabid%2F99%2FID%2F680694%2FDont-take-peaceful-approach-for-granted.aspx&ei=7okVT8LlBIqziQersdBD&usg=AFQjCNEOfxNwqDvrLq53U045Ndm0mf0S4Qhttp://www.globaltimes.cn/http://www.globaltimes.cn/http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=china%20people%27s%20daily&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CCcQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fenglish.peopledaily.com.cn%2F&ei=BowVT6CsA8WZiQfF76VD&usg=AFQjCNGQ8c_P29-4mUdaFg36CBdw4nt-9whttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=china%20people%27s%20daily&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CCcQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fenglish.peopledaily.com.cn%2F&ei=BowVT6CsA8WZiQfF76VD&usg=AFQjCNGQ8c_P29-4mUdaFg36CBdw4nt-9whttp://www.globaltimes.cn/http://www.globaltimes.cn/http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=spratlys%20editorial&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCUQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.globaltimes.cn%2FNEWS%2Ftabid%2F99%2FID%2F680694%2FDont-take-peaceful-approach-for-granted.aspx&ei=7okVT8LlBIqziQersdBD&usg=AFQjCNEOfxNwqDvrLq53U045Ndm0mf0S4Qhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=spratlys%20editorial&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCUQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.globaltimes.cn%2FNEWS%2Ftabid%2F99%2FID%2F680694%2FDont-take-peaceful-approach-for-granted.aspx&ei=7okVT8LlBIqziQersdBD&usg=AFQjCNEOfxNwqDvrLq53U045Ndm0mf0S4Qhttp://businessmirror.com.ph/home/nation/18469-dfa-hits-china-over-irresponsible-statement-on-west-philippine-seahttp://businessmirror.com.ph/home/nation/18469-dfa-hits-china-over-irresponsible-statement-on-west-philippine-seahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_Defense_Treaty_(U.Shttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_Defense_Treaty_(U.Shttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=hillary%20clinton%20manila%20visit&source=web&cd=3&ved=0CDEQFjAC&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.abs-cbnnews.com%2Fnation%2F11%2F15%2F11%2Fhillary-clinton-manila-working-visit&ei=chLGTt-0LNCWiQfH67jWDw&usg=AFQjCNH8vVKicjD8GLgbYGc2LCMKrfOl9ghttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=hillary%20clinton%20manila%20visit&source=web&cd=3&ved=0CDEQFjAC&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.abs-cbnnews.com%2Fnation%2F11%2F15%2F11%2Fhillary-clinton-manila-working-visit&ei=chLGTt-0LNCWiQfH67jWDw&usg=AFQjCNH8vVKicjD8GLgbYGc2LCMKrfOl9ghttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/11/18/11/obama-says-us-looking-out-philippineshttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/11/18/11/obama-says-us-looking-out-philippineshttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/11/18/11/obama-says-us-looking-out-philippineshttp://project2049.net/about_us.htmlhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=China%2Bnuclear%2Bwarheads&source=web&cd=6&ved=0CFwQFjAF&url=http%3A%2F%2Fproject2049.net%2Fdocuments%2Fchinas_nuclear_warhead_storage_and_handling_system.pdf&ei=wyjATvSeMLGQiAewquydBQ&usg=AFQjCNHlCkryzZG0COPnWWzFuPwvonZCIghttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=China%2Bnuclear%2Bwarheads&source=web&cd=6&ved=0CFwQFjAF&url=http%3A%2F%2Fproject2049.net%2Fdocuments%2Fchinas_nuclear_warhead_storage_and_handling_system.pdf&ei=wyjATvSeMLGQiAewquydBQ&usg=AFQjCNHlCkryzZG0COPnWWzFuPwvonZCIghttp://iis-db.stanford.edu/pubs/20613/china's_ballistic_missile_programs.pdfhttp://iis-db.stanford.edu/pubs/20613/china's_ballistic_missile_programs.pdf8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
12/52
>5
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
k}ljs einf`nh}u kb }lj mfuqz}jm Uqsn}ivu(
]lj jmf}ksfni nm`khfuljm? Fb }ljuj
ekzh}sfju mkh} tnh} }k elnhdj }ljfs tnvu
tf}l Elfhn) }ljv tfii hjjm }k qsjqnsj bks
}lj ukzhmu kb enhhkhu(
]lj Nuukefn}fkh kb Ukz}ljnu} Nufnh
Hn}fkhu) tlfel
fheizmju Uqsn}iv
einf`nh}u @ninvufn)
Qlfifqqfhju nhm
Rfj}hn`) fu lkqfhd
}ljsj tkh} cj
enhhkhu krjs }lj
fuinhmu(N} f}u ==}lUz``f} fh Cnif fh
`fmHkrj`cjs)
NUJNH ndsjjm tf}l
Elfhn kh n hjt
ndsjj`jh} }k nrkfm
ekhfe} nhm sjmzej
}jhufkhu fh }lj
Ukz}l Elfhn Ujn)
zqmn}fhd }lj 3113Mjeinsn}fkh kh }lj
Ekhmze} kb Qns}fju
fh }lj Ukz}l Elfhn
Ujn( ]lj Qlfifqqfhju
niuk }ncijm n qskqkujm ndsjj`jh} bks n
_khj kb Qjnej) Bsjjmk`) Bsfjhmulfq nhm
Ekkqjsn}fkh fh }lj Ukz}l Elfhn Ujn)
tlfel }lj >1hn}fkh dskzqfhd ueljmzijm
bks u}zmv(
N`jsfen ekh}fhzju }k jhlnhej f}u qsjujhej
fh }lj sjdfkh( ]lfu kh}l Z(U( Ujhn}ksu
Oklh @eEnfh) Okujql Ifjcjs`nh) Uljimkh
Tlf}jlkzuj) nhm Gjiiv Nvk}}j `j} tf}l
Qsjufmjh} N~zfhk nhm Bksjfdh Nbbnfsu
Ujesj}nsv Nicjs}k mji Skunsfk( ]lj rfuf}
ek`ju n`fm fhesjnujm Z(U( fif}nsv nfm
}k }lj Qlfifqqfhju) fheizmfhd }tk uzsbnej
ulfqu mjifrjsjm inu} vjns }k ljiq qn}ski
Qlfifqqfhjeinf jm nsjnu fh }lj Ukz}l
Elfhn Ujn( Fh n sjqks} bsk` ]lj Qlfifqqfhj
U}ns) @eEnfh unfm? Fb }ljsj fu fhmjjm n
tf}lmsntni kb }lj Z(U() }ljh F cjifjrj }ln}
}ln} tkzim `jnh n ijuujhfhd kb u}ncfif}v fh
}lj sjdfkh(
]nftnh nhm Onqnh lnrj
}ljfs tkssfju }kk( Elfhn
lnu cjjh ekhufu}jh} fh
f}u KhjElfhn qkifev
}ktnsm ]nftnh( Fh }lj
31>1 sjqks} kb }lj Z(U(Mjqns}`jh} kb Mjbjhuj)
]lj QIN fu mjrjikqfhd
}lj enqncfif}v }k mj}js
]nftnh fhmjqjhmjhej
ks fhzjhej ]nftnh
}k uj}}ij }lj mfuqz}j
kh Cjfofhdu }js`u
tlfij uf`zi}nhjkzuiv
n}}j`q}fhd }k mj}js) mjinv)ks mjhv nhv qkuufcij Z(U(
uzqqks} bks }lj fuinhm
fh enuj kb ekhfe}( ]lj
sjqks} nmmu) ]lj cninhej
kb eskuuU}snf} `fif}nsv bkseju ekh}fhzju }k
ulfb} fh }lj `nfhinhmu bnrks(
Onqnh) bks f}u qns}) bjnsu }ln} Elfhn tfii
zuj f}u dsktfhd jekhk`fe ijrjsndj nhm
`fif}nsv qsktjuu }k }lskt f}u tjfdl}
nskzhm nhm mk`fhn}j }lj sjdfkh)
neeksmfhd }k Ekzh}jsfhd Elfhnu @fif}nsv
@kmjshfn}fkh bsk` }lj Ekzhefi kb
Bksjfdh Sjin}fkhu( Onqnhjuj fif}nsv
nhnivu} Ulzhf ]nkgn }jiiuNionjjsn$u
#Fhufmj U}ksv# }ln} lj mkju hk} cjifjrj fh
n Elfhjuj `fif}nsv }lsjn}( Lj einf`u }ln}
Fu n hjt ekim tns ljn}fhd zq;
Tf}l Tnulfhd}kh
kh f}u ufmj)
@nhfin lnu
cjjh `n}elfhd
}kzdl }nig
bsk` Cjfofhd
kh }lj Uqsn}ivu(
Ij}u lkqj
}lj bsfe}fkhu
mkh} dk bsk`
}lj ck`cnu}fe}k }lj cniifu}fe
http://travelerparadise.blogspot.com/2011/07/asean-china-agree-to-observe-guidelines.htmlhttp://travelerparadise.blogspot.com/2011/07/asean-china-agree-to-observe-guidelines.htmlhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=768847&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=768847&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=768847&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.gov.cn/english/official/2005-07/27/content_17613.htmhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2010_CMPR_Final.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2010_CMPR_Final.pdfhttp://www.cfr.org/china/countering-chinas-military-modernization/p9052http://www.cfr.org/china/countering-chinas-military-modernization/p9052http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv55GZeme14http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv55GZeme14http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv55GZeme14http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv55GZeme14http://www.cfr.org/china/countering-chinas-military-modernization/p9052http://www.cfr.org/china/countering-chinas-military-modernization/p9052http://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2010_CMPR_Final.pdfhttp://www.defense.gov/pubs/pdfs/2010_CMPR_Final.pdfhttp://www.gov.cn/english/official/2005-07/27/content_17613.htmhttp://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=768847&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=768847&publicationSubCategoryId=63http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=south%20china%20sea%20code%20of%20conduct&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCsQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.southchinasea.org%2Fdocs%2FNguyen%20Hong%20Thao-2002%20Declaration.pdf&ei=EAXGTrfNMaOsiAfrpOD4Dw&usg=AFQjCNH5rlMO9goPtqlzV9A7eEIptp74bwhttp://travelerparadise.blogspot.com/2011/07/asean-china-agree-to-observe-guidelines.htmlhttp://travelerparadise.blogspot.com/2011/07/asean-china-agree-to-observe-guidelines.html8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
13/52
>=
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
nckz} 41* kb Elfhjuj j|qks}u ek`j bsk`
bksjfdh bne}ksfju kqjsn}fhd fh Elfhn) uk f}
enh fii nbbksm lku}fif}fju tf}l }lj `nsgj}u bks
f}u dkkmu(
Bsk` ns`u czfimzq }k mfnikdzj;
Hkhj}ljijuu) U}nhbksmu Ijtfu nhm Lzn
nsdzj) Elfhnu u}sn}jdfe fif}nsv qsktjuu
qineju f} fh n qkuf}fkh jf}ljs }k mjbv
qsjuz`q}zkzu Tju}jsh mj`nhmu nhm
fh}jsbjsjhej ks }k tksg tf}l }lj Tju} }k
czfim n hjt tksim ksmjs( Fh k}ljs tksmu)
}lj QINu czsdjkhfhd fuufij enqncfif}fju
nsj ljiqfhd jhuzsj }ln} fuuzju tf}l Elfhn
tkzim hk} cj uj}}ijm cv Tju}jsh `fif}nsv
uzqjsfksf}v(
]ln} `nv cj n dkkm }lfhd fb }lj j`jsdfhd
`fif}nsv u}nhmkbb ijnmu }k `ksj sju}snfh}
nhm mfnikdzj fh uj}}ifhd sjdfkhni mfuqz}ju
nhm }jhufkhu( Fh }lfu dikcni jekhk`v tljsj
fh}jsju}u kb fhmfrfmzni ekzh}sfju nsj mjjqiv
fh}js}tfhjm) u}sn}jdfe mfnikdzj ksj }lnh
uljjs mk`fhnhej fu eszefni(
Fhmjjm) fh gjjqfhd }lj qjnej) hn}fkhu
`zu} sniiv kh }lj ufmj kb dikcni ksmjs
tljsj fh}jshn}fkhni ckmfju qinv n qfrk}ni
skij fh qsk`k}fhd qjnej) ekkqjsn}fkh nhm
lns`khv( Ljhej) }lj krj bks djhzfhj
sjukiz}fkh kb ekhfe}u tkzim hk} uf`qiv cj
kh Elfhnu }js`u) ks }ln} kb nhv k}ljs cfd
qktjs bks }ln} `n}}js(
Uk fu Elfhnu `fif}nsv sjuzsdjhej `ngfhd
}skzcij bks Nufn; Ij}u ozu} lkqj f} tkzim
ijnm jrjsvkhj) fheizmfhd }lj Elfhjuj nhm
}lj N`jsfenhu) }k cj `ksj ensjbzi nckz}
sn}}ifhd ks csnhmfulfhd uncjsu( ]nig hkt
nhm) lkqjbziiv) ulkk} hjrjs(
Elfhn$u `fdl} kh qnsnj? Uk`j nug fb nii }lj tkssvfhd fu rnif
Fu n hjt ekim tns ljn}fhd zq;
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv55GZeme148/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
14/52
>:
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
HJTU KH ]LJ HJ]Tksim
Eszfuj ulfq enq}nfhfh }skzcij tn}jsu
]lj Eku}n Ekheksmfn eszfuj ulfq
mfunu}js fh tlfel }lj rjuuji
snh ndskzhm kbb }lj eknu} kb
Dfdifk Fuinhm lnu einf`jm n}
ijnu} >> ifrju) nhm nckz} }tk
mkjh qjkqij nsj sjqks}jmiv
u}fii `fuufhd( N} }lj ejh}js kb
fhrju}fdn}fkhu nu }k lkt }lj
}sndjmv keezssjm fu }lj ulfq$u
enq}nfh) Bsnhejuek Uelj}}fhk(
]lj }snhuesfq} kb Uelj}}fhk$u
ekhrjsun}fkh tf}l nh F}nifnh eknu}
dznsm kh }ln} bn}jbzi hfdl} qnfh}u
}lj qfe}zsj kb n enq}nfh tlk tnu
hk} tfiifhd }k dk mkth tf}l lfu
ulfq(
Cnhdinjul Ns`vunvu f} bkfij cf }kkzu} Lnufhn
]lj Cnhdinmjul Ns`v einf`u }k
lnrj }ltns}jm n ekzq n}}j`q}
fhu}fdn}jm cv uk`j hkhsjufmjh}
Cnhdinmjulfu nhm sj}fsjm kbejsu
tf}l j|}sj`j sjifdfkzu rfjtu
}k kzu} Qsf`j @fhfu}js Uljfgl
Lnufhnu dkrjsh`jh}( Lnufhn
tnu jije}jm fh Mjej`cjs 31111)111 ifrju(
]lj hmfhdu nsj kz}ifhjm fh n
okfh} csfjhd qnqjs eniijm) #N
Mnhdjskzu Mjinv? ]lj eku} kb
in}j sjuqkhuj }k jnsiv tnshfhdu
fh }lj 31>> mskzdl} fh }lj
Lksh kb Nbsfen(# Nh ns}feij bsk`
]lj Dznsmfnhuzddju}u }ln}
quvelkikdfeni nhm ksdnhfn}fkhni
bne}ksu tjsj }lj sjnukhu tlv }lj
sjuqkhuj tnu cjin}jm) nhm hk}ineg kb qkif}feni tfii(
http://edition.cnn.com/2012/01/18/world/europe/italy-ship-captain-profile/?hpt=wo_c2http://edition.cnn.com/2012/01/18/world/europe/italy-ship-captain-profile/?hpt=wo_c2http://edition.cnn.com/video/#/video/world/2012/01/16/vause-cruise-ship-path.cnnhttp://edition.cnn.com/video/#/video/world/2012/01/16/vause-cruise-ship-path.cnnhttp://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/costa-concordia-disaster-transcript-exchange-coast-guard-chief-commandant-ship-captain-article-1.1007794http://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-01-19/bangladesh-army-says-it-foiled-bid-to-oust-hasina-government.htmlhttp://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-01-19/bangladesh-army-says-it-foiled-bid-to-oust-hasina-government.htmlhttp://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-01-19/bangladesh-army-says-it-foiled-bid-to-oust-hasina-government.htmlhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheikh_Hasinahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheikh_Hasinahttp://www.facebook.com/pages/Mid-level-Officers-of-Bangladesh-Army-are-Bringing-down-Changes-Soon/224941730917446https://bangladesharmychanges.wordpress.com/http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16596181http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16596181http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16596181http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/17/indonesia-train-surfers-crackdown_n_1210154.htmlhttp://www.thejakartaglobe.com/home/jakarta-commuters-furious-at-train-chaos/482956http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYBeuQiQmZ8http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://http://www.oxfam.org/http://www.savethechildren.org/site/c.8rKLIXMGIpI4E/b.6115947/k.8D6E/Official_Site.htmhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/jan/18/east-africa-famine-warning?newsfeed=truehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYBeuQiQmZ8http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/jan/18/east-africa-famine-warning?newsfeed=truehttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://humanitariancoalition.ca/Download%20documents/dangerous-delay-horn-africa-drought-en.pdfhttp://www.savethechildren.org/site/c.8rKLIXMGIpI4E/b.6115947/k.8D6E/Official_Site.htmhttp://www.oxfam.org/http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-16606021http://http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYBeuQiQmZ8http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/home/jakarta-commuters-furious-at-train-chaos/482956http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/17/indonesia-train-surfers-crackdown_n_1210154.htmlhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16596181http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16596181http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16596181http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-16596181https://bangladesharmychanges.wordpress.com/http://www.facebook.com/pages/Mid-level-Officers-of-Bangladesh-Army-are-Bringing-down-Changes-Soon/224941730917446http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheikh_Hasinahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheikh_Hasinahttp://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-01-19/bangladesh-army-says-it-foiled-bid-to-oust-hasina-government.htmlhttp://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-01-19/bangladesh-army-says-it-foiled-bid-to-oust-hasina-government.htmlhttp://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-01-19/bangladesh-army-says-it-foiled-bid-to-oust-hasina-government.htmlhttp://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/costa-concordia-disaster-transcript-exchange-coast-guard-chief-commandant-ship-captain-article-1.1007794http://edition.cnn.com/video/#/video/world/2012/01/16/vause-cruise-ship-path.cnnhttp://edition.cnn.com/video/#/video/world/2012/01/16/vause-cruise-ship-path.cnnhttp://edition.cnn.com/2012/01/18/world/europe/italy-ship-captain-profile/?hpt=wo_c2http://edition.cnn.com/2012/01/18/world/europe/italy-ship-captain-profile/?hpt=wo_c2http://edition.cnn.com/2012/01/18/world/europe/italy-ship-captain-profile/?hpt=wo_c28/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
15/52
2
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
HN]FKH
Ndsnsfnh Sjbks` n} n EskuusknuJrjh nu Lnefjhmn Izfuf}n bneju csjngzq) f} fu eijns}lj inhmijuu hjjm bns `ksj }lnh ozu} }ljfs kth inhmCv Oklh Ensik Dfi @( Unmfnh
F}u cjjh n qskcij` bks }tk nhm n lnib
ejh}zsfju( Nu jnsiv nu >4:>) }lj Uqnhful
ekikhfni dkrjsh`jh} nisjnmv sjekdhfjminhm mfu}sfcz}fkh nu n `jnhu }k qnefbv
qjnunh}u fhrkirjm fh n ujsfju kb zqsfufhdu
ndnfhu} }lj Mk`fhfenh nhm Nzdzu}fhfnh
sjifdfkzu ksmjsu fh uk`j qns}u kb Izkh(
Uqnhful Gfhd Bjsmfhnhm RF) fh fuuzfhd
}lj Skvni Mjesjj kb Hkrj`cjs 4) >4:>)
neghktijmdjm }lj sjnukh cjlfhm }ljuj
mfu}zscnheju? }lj bsfnsu zuzsqn}fkh kb rnu}
}sne}u kb inhm tlfel mjqsfrjm qjnunh}u hk}
khiv kb kthjsulfq) cz} niuk kb }lj bszf}u kb
}lj inhm }ln} }ljv }fii(
U]SN]JDV QKFH]U
Nb}js jenju kbbnfij inh sjbks`)bns`jsu fh >5 k}ljslnefjhnu ujj uk`jdif``js kb lkqj tf}l}lj Uzqsj`j Ekzs}$uszifhd fu}sfcz}fhdLnefjhn Izfuf}n }k
f}u sfdl}bzi kthjsu
http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/july2011/171101_corona.htmhttp://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/july2011/171101_corona.htmhttp://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/july2011/171101_corona.htmhttp://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/july2011/171101_corona.htmhttp://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/july2011/171101_corona.htmhttp://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/july2011/171101_corona.htm8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
16/52
>4
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
]kmnv) }lj u}szddij }k dfrj inhm }k }lj
inhmijuu ekh}fhzju( Inu} tjjg bns`jsu n}
Lnefjhmn Izfuf}n) }lj ekzh}svu insdju}
qinh}n}fkh noksf}vkthjm cv }lj Ekoznhdek
bn`fiv kb Qsjufmjh} Cjhfdhk N~zfhk FFF)
eniijm kh }lj Uzqsj`j Ekzs}
}k lkim bnu} }k f}u Hkrj`cjs 31>> mjefufkh(
Cv n >=1 rk}j) }lj ozu}feju ksmjsjm
Izfuf}nu mfu}sfcz}fkh nhm mjeinsjm
fhrnifm }lj u}keg mfu}sfcz}fkh kq}fkh
,UMK& tlfel lnm jhncijm inhmkthjsu
}k nrkfm csjngfhd zq }ljfs ju}n}ju cv
ozu} dfrfhd bns`jsu ulnsju fh s`u }ln}
tkzim kth }lj inhmu) ifgj Lnefjhmn
Izfuf}n) Fhe( ,LIF&(
]lj Izfuf}n enuj dnfhjm nmmjm qsk`fhjhej
tljh f`qjneljm Elfjb Ozu}fej Sjhn}k
Ekskhn) tlkuj Ujhn}j }sfni cjdnh inu}
@khmnv) niijdjm n ekhuqfsnev }k sj`krj lf`
tf}l }lj nf` kb sjrjsufhd ks tn}jsfhd mkth
}lj >=1 Lfdl Ekzs} szifhd kh }lj lnefjhmn(
]lj zhnhf`kzu inhm`nsg mjefufkh bks }lj
inhmijuu jelkjm n qsjrfkzu `noks szifhd}k msn`n}fj }lj zsdjh} mj`nhm kb }lj
mfuqkuujuujm bks n qik} kb jns}l nu }ljfs qinej
fh }lj uzh(
Lkqj bks bns`jsu fh k}ljs ju}n}ju(
@ksj }lnh }lj sjukiz}fkh kb khj fukin}jm
ndsnsfnh enuj) }lj LIF mjefufkh lnu cjjh
ujjh nu n rfe}ksv bks inhmijuu qjnunh}u
}lskzdlkz} }lj ekzh}sv( ]lj Uzqsj`j
Ekzs} mjefufkh) Fh~zfsjs(hj} sjqks}jm)
lnu dfrjh uk`j lkqj }k bns`jsu kqqkufhd
}lj UMK kh }jh k}ljs insdj ju}n}ju nskzhm
}lj ekzh}sv(
]lj ijb}fu} Gfizunhd @ndczczgfm hd Qfifqfhnu
j|qsjuujm lkqj }ln} }lj LIF mjefufkh
ulkzim bnu}}sneg }lj sjrken}fkh kb k}ljs
UMK uelj`ju) tlfel G@Q unt nu n tnv
Wbks inhmkthjsuP }k ugfs} }lj qskrfufkhu kb
}lj Ek`qsjljhufrj Ndsnsfnh Sjbks` Int
,ENSI& nhm nrkfm }lj ne}zni mfu}sfcz}fkh kb
inhm }k bns`jsu(
Bks Inhf Bne}ks kb ]nug Bksej @nqninm)
}lj dskzq tksgfhd tf}l }lj bns`tksgjs
cjhjefnsfju ,BTCu& kb Lnefjhmn Nhf}n fh
Hjdsku Keefmjh}ni) }lj Lfdl Ekzs} szifhd
lnu n dsjn} f`qifen}fkh nhm ulkzim uj} n
qsjejmjh} bks k}ljs nsjnu zhmjs }lj
UMK uelj`j(
Gn}nszhdnh ujesj}nsv djhjsni Mnhhv
Enssnhn) kh }lj k}ljs lnhm) cjifjrju }lj
Izfuf}n mjefufkh lnu dfrjh }lj bns`jsu }lj
n``zhf}fkh }k elniijhdj UMK uelj`jufh k}ljs qinh}n}fkhu) nhm }ln} }ljsj fu
hk `ksj sjnukh tlv }lj UMK ulkzim cj
qjs`f}}jm fh k}ljs ju}n}ju nskzhm
}lj ekzh}sv(
Gfizunhd @ndczczgfm) ]nug Bksej @nqninm)
nhm Gn}nszhdnh nugjm }lj Mjqns}`jh} kb
Ndsnsfnh Sjbks` ,MNS& }k uqjjm zq }lj
qjhmfhd UMK nqqjniu nhm mfu}sfcz}j }lj inhm}k }lj bns`jsu(
]lj ikhd) lnsm sknm }k ifcjsn}fkh( Cz}
fb vkz }lfhg UMKu tfii u}ns} bniifhd ifgj uzdns
enhj u}nigu zhmjs }lj ckik) }lfhg ndnfh( ]lj
Lnefjhmn Izfuf}n u}ksv n`qiv mj`khu}sn}ju
lkt tfiv) qktjsbzi nhm mj}js`fhjm
inhmkthjsu nsj fh n`nuufhd nhm qsk}je}fhd
}ljfs ju}n}ju(
Fhmjjm)Qlfifqqfhj Mnfiv Fh~zfsjs ekiz`hfu}
Sfdkcjs}k ]fdink Os( jelkju n tfmjiv ljim
rfjt sjqjn}jmiv mjhfjm cv }lj Qninej
}ln} }lj Ekskhn f`qjnel`jh} fu n `jnhu
}k sjrjsuj }lj LIF szifhd ks dj} n ljb}v
ek`qjhun}fkh bks }lj inhm }k cj mfu}sfcz}jm(
Nhm nu }lj ekzh}svu unm j|qjsfjhej fh
ndsnsfnh sjbks` ulktu) jrjh fb bns`jsu dj}
}lj inhm }ljv ukzdl} bks djhjsn}fkhu) f} fu hk
dznsnh}jj kb n cj}}js ifbj(
Ndsnsfnh sjbks` n} n eskuusknmu
http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/november2011/171101.htmhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_view&gid=959&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_view&gid=959&Itemid=220http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri1989/jul1989/gr_78742_1989.htmlhttp://newsinfo.inquirer.net/101027/%E2%80%98luisita-ruling-gives-other-tillers-hope%E2%80%99http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1988/ra_6657_1988.htmlhttp://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1988/ra_6657_1988.htmlhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/http://www.dar.gov.ph/http://opinion.inquirer.net/21395/give-up-hacienda-luisita-now-mr-aquinohttp://opinion.inquirer.net/21395/give-up-hacienda-luisita-now-mr-aquinohttp://opinion.inquirer.net/21395/give-up-hacienda-luisita-now-mr-aquinohttp://opinion.inquirer.net/21395/give-up-hacienda-luisita-now-mr-aquinohttp://www.dar.gov.ph/http://www.dar.gov.ph/http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1988/ra_6657_1988.htmlhttp://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1988/ra_6657_1988.htmlhttp://newsinfo.inquirer.net/101027/%E2%80%98luisita-ruling-gives-other-tillers-hope%E2%80%99http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri1989/jul1989/gr_78742_1989.htmlhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_view&gid=959&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_view&gid=959&Itemid=220http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2011/november2011/171101.htm8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
17/52
>6:4) ]ncnenijsn kbbjsjm }k ujii }lj jh}fsj
lnefjhmn }kdj}ljs tf}l }lj ekh}skiifhd
fh}jsju} fh Nzensjsn fh n ufhdij fhmfrfufcij
}snhune}fkh) tf}l }lj lnefjhmn qsfej }k cjqnfm fh qjuku nhm }lj Nzensjsn eku}
fh mkiinsu(
]nsine Mjrjikq`jh} Eksqksn}fkh ,]nmjek&
kb qn}sfnsel Okuj Ekoznhdek
Us( ukzdl} dkrjsh`jh}
nuufu}nhej bks bzhmu }k
czv }lj lnefjhmn( Nu
hnssn}jm cvOzu}fej
Ns}zsk Csfkh fh lfu
mfuujh}fhd kqfhfkh)
Ekoznhdek
qjsuznmjm }lj
Ejh}sni Cnhg
}k qijmdj qns}
}lj ekzh}svu
bksjfdh sjujsrju
nu ujezsf}v bks lfu
mkiins iknh bsk`
n Hjt Vksg cnhg(
Lj niuk dk} n Q:(6>>`fiifkh iknh bsk` }lj
Dkrjsh`jh} Ujsrfej Fhuzsnhej Uvu}j`
,DUFU&( U}n}j hnhefhd tnu dsnh}jm nu ikhd
nu Ekoznhdek tkzim ne~zfsj Lnefjhmn
Izfuf}n bks mfu}sfcz}fkh }k bns`jsu tf}lfh >1
vjnsu bsk` f}u ne~zfuf}fkh(
Jrjh nb}js n mjenmj) ]nmjek u}fii ljim kh
}k }lj lnefjhmn( ]lj Ekoznhdeku einf`jm
f} lnm hk }jhnh}u) uk }ljsj tnu hk khj }k
mfu}sfcz}j }lj inhm }k( ]lj dkrjsh`jh} }kkg
hk ne}fkh zh}fi >6643) tnu `nssfjm }k n Ekoznhdek bn`fiv
`j`cjs) Eksnkh) tlk cjen`j qsjufmjh}
nb}js @nseku bjii fh >6661) >6
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
18/52
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
19/52
31
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
qskqks}fkh kb ulnsjlkimfhdu fh LIF) ufhej
}lj cjhjefnsfju lkim ozu} n }lfsm kb }lj
ulnsju( ]lzu) }lj Ekzs} u}szeg mkth }lj
UMK uelj`j nhm ksmjsjm }lj f``jmfn}j
mfu}sfcz}fkh kb }lj =)6>:(4: lje}nsju
kb inhm(
]lj Uzqsj`j Ekzs} niuk ksmjsjm }ln} }lj
bns`jsu sjejfrj khj}lfsm kb }lj qskejjmu
kb }lj >664 unij kb :11 lje}nsju kb Izfuf}n
,n ulnsj tks}l Q>(3: cfiifkh&) nhm ozu}
ek`qjhun}fkh qnfm cv }lj dkrjsh`jh}
bks lje}nsju zujm bks }lj Uzcfe
Einsg]nsine J|qsjuutnv ,rnizjm n} Q6 `fiifkh
qjs lje}nsj 3: }f`ju }lj >66= j|fu}fhd UMKu }lskzdlkz} }lj ekzh}sv
fu
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
20/52
3>
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
Lnefjhmn Qskrfhej Eskq Lje}nsju Nqqskrn
Lnefjhmn Izfuf}n) Fhe( ]nsine Uzdnsenhj =)6>2 >>-Hkr-:-Bjc-6>
Ijmju`n Ljs`nhku Ndsfezi}zsni Eksq( Hjdsku Keefmjh}ni Uzdnsenhj >)13= >5-@nv-6>UvEfq Qinh}n}fkh) Fhe( Hjdsku Keefmjh}ni Uzdnsenhj 25-Hkr-6>
Ljshnhmj Uzdns Qinh}n}fkh) Fhe( Fikfik Uzdnsenhj 35>
Hjdsku Fhmzu}sfni Cv-Qskm nhm Qske() Fhe( Hjdsku Keefmjh}ni Uzdnsenhj =5< 34= >-Ujq-63
URO Bns`u) Fhe( Hjdsku Keefmjh}ni Uzdnsenhj >41 >2-Hkr-63
Nufn Ndsk-Fhmzu}sfni Ujsrfeju Mnrnk mji Uzs Ekekhz} >11 32-Nqs-6=
LNEFJHMNU ZHMJS ]LJ U]KEG MFU]SFCZ]FKH UELJ@J
Tf}l }lj j|ejq}fkh kb Lnefjhmn Nhf}n,>41 lje}nsju tf}l >== BTCu&) szh cv
URO Bns`u Fhe() rj kb }ljuj uf|
qinh}n}fkhu nsj kthjm cv s`u ekh}skiijm
cv Nsujhfk Ni Nezn? ,>& Nsujhfk Ni Nezn
Ndsfezi}zsni Eksq() ,3& Nselfj Bfulqkhmu
Fhe() ,5& Jijhf}n Ndsfezi}zsni Mjrjikq`jh}
Eksq() nii fh Enmf Ef}v7 ,=& @nsfn
Einsn @nsfhj Rjh}zsju fh Cndk Ef}v)
nhm ,:& Qni`n Gncnhgninh Ndsfezi}zsni
Eksq( fh Fikd }kth(
]lj un`j sjqks} u}n}jm }ln} bns`jsu
fh Lnefjhmn ]ncfdzj) }lj khiv Nezn
kthjm ju}n}j hk} uzcoje} }k nhv
qj}f}fkh bks UMK enhejiin}fkh) nsj niuk
j|qje}jm }k ij }ljfs kth qj}f}fkhu
}kdj}ljs tf}l }lj bns`jsu fh Lnefjhmn
Bks}zhn ,>)13= lje}nsju) 4=4 BTCu&
szh cv Ijmju`n Ljs`nhku Ndsfezi}zsni
Eksq( fh Unh Ensiku Ef}v nhm Lnefjhmn
U}k( ]k`nu ,>4= lje}nsju) >44 BTCu&
szh cv Tz}lsfel Ljs`nhku Fhe( fh
Enin}snrn }kth niuk fh Hjdsku
Keefmjh}ni(
Hfhj kb }lj sj`nfhfhd >5 ju}n}ju zhmjs
}lj UMK uelj`j nsj fh Hjdsku Keefmjh}ni)
ekrjsfhd n }k}ni nsjn kb 3)5=< lje}nsjutf}l >)5 BTCu( Kz} kb }ljuj dzsju) }lj
`jsdjs kb Neznu uf| lnefjhmnu ekrjsu
n }k}ni nsjn kb 2:1 lje}nsju tf}l :2:cjhjefnsfju(
]lj khiv UMK uelj`j hk} bnefhd nhv
qj}f}fkh bks enhejiin}fkh fu }ln} fh Lnefjhmn
Hnonifh ,=5< lje}nsju) 345 BTCu& fh In
Ensik}n) Hjdsku Keefmjh}ni) tlfel fu kthjm
cv HNONIFH Ndsf Rjh}zsju Fhe( kb Szmkiql
J( Ozinscni nhm Okn~zfh D( ]jrju(
Bnfizsj kb Qlfifqqfhj inhm sjbks`(
Sjmfu}sfcz}fhd inhm) lktjrjs) fu hk} }lj
un`j nu zqifb}fhd }lj bns`jsu( NTksim
Cnhg u}zmvkh inhm qkifev bkzhm }lj
Qlfifqqfhj ndsnsfnh sjbks` fhljsjh}iv
`ksj qskcij`n}fe tf}l n zhfrjsuniiv
qkks }sneg sjeksm( ]lzu) ENSQ hjrjs `nmj
nhv f`qne} kh mfu}sfcz}fkh ks sjekdhf}fkh
kb fhbks`ni keezqn}fkh cv ek``zhf}fju
krjs nhv djhjsn}fkhu(
Nsjrfjt kb }lj ENSQ ek``fuufkhjm cv
Djs`nh incks dskzq Mjz}uelj Djujiiuelnb}
bs ]jelhfuelj _zun``jhnscjf} ,D]_&) kh
}lj k}ljs lnhm) ekheizmjm }ln} Fb ndsnsfnh
sjbks` fu khiv nckz} inhm mfu}sfcz}fkh) }ljh
}lj qjsbks`nhej kb MNS fu n dsjn} uzeejuu(
Lktjrjs) f} qkfh}jm kz} }ln} cjenzuj f}
fu niuk nckz} snfufhd ~znif}v kb ifbj nhmuqzssfhd fhmzu}sfnifn}fkh) f} fu ejs}nfhiv n
if}}ij uzeejuu) ks n bnfizsj(
Ndsnsfnh sjbks` n} n eskuusknmu
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/RPDLPROGRAM/Resources/459596-1161903702549/S8_Burns.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/RPDLPROGRAM/Resources/459596-1161903702549/S8_Burns.pdfhttp://www.pinoypress.net/2007/12/03/philippiness-land-reform-program-a-failure-study-shows/http://www.pinoypress.net/2007/12/03/philippiness-land-reform-program-a-failure-study-shows/http://siteresources.worldbank.org/RPDLPROGRAM/Resources/459596-1161903702549/S8_Burns.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/RPDLPROGRAM/Resources/459596-1161903702549/S8_Burns.pdf8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
21/52
33
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
]lj u}zmv hk}jm }ln} }lj mjenmjukim
qskdsn` lnu bnfijm }k fhesjnuj ndsfezi}zsni
qskmze}frf}v) sjmzej szsni qkrjs}v) nhm
inhmkthjsu$ fhrju}`jh} fh szsnicnujm
fhmzu}sfju( Krjs n ~zns}js kb BTCu
hn}fkhtfmj nisjnmv ukim }lj inhm }ljv
ne~zfsjm zhmjs ENSQ( ]lj ujiijsu ek`qsfuj
cfd dskzqu kb cjhjefnsfju fh Indzhn ,:5*
kb BTCu&) Hzjrn Jefon ,=>*&) Fikfik ,5:*&)
nhm zjkh ,32*&(
F} nmmjm? }ln} 22 qjsejh} kb 5(> `fiifkh
ndsnsfnh sjbks` cjhjefnsfju lnrj hk} cjjh
dfrjh uzqqks} ujsrfeju7 }lj Inhm Cnhg kb}lj Qlfifqqfhju lnu hk} cjjh dfrfhd eskq
iknhu }k ndsnsfnh sjbks` cjhjefnsfju
cjenzuj ijuu }lnh >4(< qjsejh} kb }lj`
Wnckz} khj fh jrjsv uf|P enh} jrjh qnv bks
}ljfs n`ks}fn}fkh kb }lj qzselnuj qsfej
kb }lj inhm7 nhm hjf}ljs tnu }ljsj jhkzdl
bzhmu }k qnv inhmkthjsu(
Cv ek`qnsfukh) }lj u}zmv nmmjm) Onqnh)Ukz}l Gksjn nhm ]nftnh n}}sfcz}jm }ljfs
uzeejuu }k }lj uzbefjh} uzqqks} ujsrfeju
nhm qzsuznhej kb fhmzu}sfnifn}fkh nu nh
f`qks}nh} ek`qkhjh} kb ndsnsfnh sjbks`(
Tf}lkz} u}n}j uzqqks} nhm esjmf}) bns`jsu
nsj zhncij }k `nfh}nfh }lj qskmze}frf}v kb
ju}n}ju mjqsfrjm kb inhmiksm fhrju}`jh}
nb}js mfu}sfcz}fkh( Nhm nu u`nii qskmzejsu)
}ljv niuk iku} }lj `nsgj} eikz} kb }lj
cfd qinh}n}fkhu }ljv zujm }k tksg bks(
Ekkqjsn}frju nsj uzqqkujm }k nbbksm }lj`
esjmf} nhm eikz}) cz} }ljuj dskzqu lnrj hk}
cjjh zhfrjsuniiv uzeejuubzi jf}ljs(
Fh uz`) tlfij }lj Lnefjhmn Izfuf}n enuj
`nv dsnc ljnmifhju) juqjefniiv tf}l }lj
fhhzjhmk ifhgfhd f} }k }lj f`qjnel`jh})
}lj cfddjs nhm ikhdjs}js` elniijhdj bksQlfifqqfhj inhm sjbks` ifju fh qskrfmfhd
cjhjefnsfju uzqqks} ujsrfeju nhm esjmf}(
]ln} fu bks }lj Qninej) hk} }lj Ekzs})
}k nmmsjuu(
Uk tfii }lj dkrjsh`jh} dfrj }lj inhmijuu
hk} ozu} inhm }k }fii) cz} }lj tljsjtf}lni
}k `ngj f} ckzh}fbzi; ]ln} mjqjhmu insdjiv
kh }lj ijnmjs tlkuj `k}ljs en`j zqtf}l }lj UMK nhm tlkuj bn`fiv lnu mjhfjm
}ljfs bns`jsu }lj mfdhf}v kb kthfhd }lj
inhm }ljv tksg bks nu ikhd nu lj lnu
cjjh nifrj(
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
22/52
35
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
Enh tj ukirj n ejh}zsfju-kim qskcij`;
Ndsnsfnh sjbks` n} n eskuusknmu
]k cj}}js zhmjsu}nhm }lj sjnukh bks }lj mfu`ni u}n}zukb }lj Qlfifqqfhj inhm sjbks` qskdsn`) f} fu }}fhd
}k ikkg fh}k }lj lfu}ksv kb dkrjsh`jh} n}}j`q}u }k
f`qij`jh} }lfu ejh}zsfju-kim msjn` kb mfu}sfcz}fhd
inhm }k }lj inhmijuu(
Jnsiv n}}j`q}u n} inhm sjbks`(Neeksmfhd }k }lj
Mjqns}`jh} kb Ndsnsfnh Sjbks` ,MNS&) }lj lfu}ksv
kb inhm sjbks` fh }lj Qlfifqqfhju enh cj }snejm cneg
}k qsj-ekikhfni }f`ju) tljh ezi}frn}fkh tnu mkhj
ek``khiv cv gnfhdfh,uinul-nhm-czsh `j}lkm&( Cneg}ljh) jrjsvkhj fh }lj cnsnhdnvu sjdnsmijuu kb u}n}zu
lnm neejuu }k inhm nhm `z}zniiv ulnsjm sjukzseju
nhm }lj bszf}u kb }ljfs incks( Zhmjs }lfu u}jtnsmulfq
uvu}j`) bkkm qskmze}fkh tnu fh}jhmjm bks bn`fiv
ekhuz`q}fkh khiv(
Tljh }lj jhek`fjhmn uvu}j` tnu fh}skmzejm
cv }lj Uqnhful ekikhfni dkrjsh`jh}) hn}frj szsni
ek``zhf}fju tjsj ksdnhfjm nhm jnel Elsfu}fnhfjm
bn`fiv tnu nuufdhjm bkzs }k rj lje}nsju kb inhm}k ezi}frn}j( ]lfu uvu}j` tnu cjhjefni }k }lj
Bfifqfhku cjenzuj) neeksmfhd }k }lj MNS u}zmv) inhm
mfu}sfcz}fkh zhmjs }lfu uvu}j` tnu zhfbks` uk hk
inhmijuu einuu j`jsdjm( Lktjrjs) }lfu ijm }k nczuju
kh }lj qns} kb }lj bsfnsu tlk ekiije}jm }sfcz}ju)}ljsjcv mjesjnufhd }lj ulnsj kb hn}frj Bfifqfhku fh
}ljfs kth lnsrju}(
]lj cfs}l kb }lj Lnefjhmn uvu}j`( ]lj MNS sjqks}
sjekzh}u }ln} }lj lnefjhmn uvu}j` u}ns}jm mzsfhd
}lj jnsiv qns} kb }lj >6}l ejh}zsv tljh }lj ekikhfni
dkrjsh`jh} kqjhjm Qlfifqqfhj jekhk`v }k }lj
tksim `nsgj} nu nh j|qks}js kb snt `n}jsfniu nhm
f`qks}js kb hfuljm dkkmu( Zhmjs }lj qkifefju kb }lj
dkrjsh`jh} n} }ln} }f`j) ndsfezi}zsni j|qks}u tjsj`nhmn}jm nhm lnefjhmn uvu}j` tnu mjrjikqjm nu n
hjt bks` kb kthjsulfq( @ksj qjkqij iku} }ljfs inhmu
nhm tjsj bksejm }k cjek`j }fiijsu(
In}js kh) }lj sjrkiz}fkh ndnfhu} }lj Uqnhful Eskth
cjen`j }lj kbbulkk} kb }lj qjkqiju nuqfsn}fkhu
bks ndsnsfnh sjbks` nhm bks n ozu} ukefj}v( ]lfu fu
}lj sjnukh }ln} tljh }lj N`jsfenhu }kkg krjs) }ljv
qzsuzjm ujrjsni inhm sjbks` qkifefju dsnh}fhd inhm
kthjsulfq nhm sjdfu}sn}fkh sfdl}u }k nmmsjuu ukefnizhsju}( ]lj MNS sjqks} ekheizmju }ln} }lj N`jsfenh
u}sn}jdv mfm hk} tksg cjenzuj }ljsj tnu hk if`f}
f`qkujm kh }lj ufj kb inhmlkimfhdu }ln} khj ekzim
qkuujuu) sjuzi}fhd fh inhmlkimfhd ekhejh}sn}jm fh }lj
http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www.philstar.com/article.aspx?articleid=513009http://www.philstar.com/article.aspx?articleid=513009http://www.philippinealmanac.com/2010/07/650/the-encomienda-system-during-the-spanish-regime.htmlhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www3.pids.gov.ph/ris/pdf/pidsdps0202.pdfhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www3.pids.gov.ph/ris/pdf/pidsdps0202.pdfhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www.philippinealmanac.com/2010/07/650/the-encomienda-system-during-the-spanish-regime.htmlhttp://www.philstar.com/article.aspx?articleid=513009http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=956&Itemid=2208/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
23/52
3=
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
lnhmu kb bjtjs fhmfrfmzniu nhm `ksj inhmu qinejm
zhmjs }jhnhev(
Zhmjs }lfu uj}zq) }lj inhmkthjsu qsjbjssjm }k
dk nb}js hjt kqqks}zhf}fju fh }lj ef}fju nhm ijb}
}ljfs bns`u fmij ks }k }lj `nhndj`jh} kb }ljgn}ftnin( ]lfu sjuzi}jm) neeksmfhd }k MNS) fh
qkksiv nhm zhozu}iv-`nhndjm lnefjhmnu( Ukefnimfuksmjs nskuj bsk` }lfu uvu}j`) tf}l `ksj qjnunh}u
nhm tksgjsu ksdnhfn}fkhu ckhmfhd }kdj}ljs
ndnfhu} }lj nczuju kb inhmiksmu( Neeksmfhd }k
MNS) }lfu dnrj cfs}l }k }lj Ek``zhfu} Qns}v kb }lj
Qlfifqqfhju(
]lj ulnsj-}jhnhev uvu}j`( @jnhtlfij) }lj
kz}csjng kb }lj Ujekhm Tksim Tns cskzdl} nckz}
nh kqqks}zhf}v }k elnhdj }lj qinvfhd jim( Mzsfhd
}lj Keezqn}fkh) qjnunh}u nhm tksgjsu ksdnhfjm
}lj Lzgck hd Cnvnh Incnh un Lnqkh ,Lzgcninlnq&
}k dl} kbb }lj Onqnhjuj( Ujekhmnsv }k }lfu) }lj
Lzgcninlnq tnu ncij }k }ngj krjs rnu} }sne}u kb inhm
tlfel }ljv mfu}sfcz}jm }k }lj qjkqij( Lktjrjs) mzsfhd
}lj Ifcjsn}fkh) }ljuj ju}n}ju tjsj ekhuen}jm nhm
sj}zshjm }k f}u kthjsu) nhm }lfu ijm }k uk`j kb }lj
bns`js-}jhnh}u elkkufhd }k okfh }lj Lzgcninlnq
`krj`jh} sn}ljs }lnh }k dk cneg nhm ujsrj }ljfs
inhmiksmu zhmjs }lj un`j ekhmf}fkhu qsfks }k }lj tns(
]lj nhutjs kb }lj Sk|nu Nm`fhfu}sn}fkh }k
}lfu qskcij` tnu }k ju}nciful n 41-51 ulnsfhd
nssnhdj`jh} tljsj 41* kb }lj lnsrju} tfii dk }k }lj
qjsukh tlk ulkzimjsjm }lj j|qjhuju bks nhf`niu)
qinh}fhd nhm lnsrju}fhd( Sk|nu niuk hjdk}fn}jm tf}l
}lj Nvnin-_kcji bn`fiv bks }lj qzselnuj kb lnefjhmnu cjfhd
mfu}sfcz}jm kz} kb }lj }nsdj}jm 511(
]lj MNS qnqjsn}}sfcz}ju }lfu }k ineg kb bzhmu
nhm fhnmj~zn}j uzqqks} ujsrfeju qskrfmjm bks W}lj
@ndunvunv Nm`fhfu}sn}fkhuP qskdsn`u( ]lzu)
inhmiksmu ekh}fhzjm }k cj zhekkqjsn}frj nhm esf}feni
}k }lj qskdsn`) sjuzi}fhd fh }lj ekh}fhzjm qskcij`u
fh f}u f`qij`jh}n}fkh(
]lj ijnujlkim uvu}j`(]lj `ku} ek`qsjljhufrj
nqqsknel }ktnsmu inhm sjbks` en`j zhmjs }lj
Bn}ljs kb Ndsnsfnh Sjbks`) Qsjufmjh} Mfkumnmk
@nenqndni) tlk qzuljm bks }lj jhne}`jh} kb }lj
Ndsfezi}zsni Inhm Sjbks` Ekmj ,SN 5
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
24/52
3:
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
Ndsnsfnh sjbks` n} n eskuusknmu
Qn`qnhdn) ]nsine) Keefmjh}ni @fhmksk) En`nsfhju
Uzs) nhm @fun`fu Ksfjh}ni( Neeksmfhd }k }lj sjeksmu
kb }lj MNS) }lj qskdsn` tnu ncij }k neek`qiful
66(36* kb f}u }nsdj} cv mfu}sfcz}fhd >5 lnefjhmnu fh }lj ekzh}sv zhmjs }ljfs
sjuqje}frj UMK uelj`ju(
Inhm mfu}sfcz}fkh zhmjs Eksv N~zfhku ENSI tnu
ksfdfhniiv ueljmzijm bks >1 vjnsu( Lktjrjs) fh >661 vjnsu }k j|qfsj fh 311=(
SN 6411 uqjiijm kz} }lsjj qlnuju bks }lj
ne~zfuf}fkh nhm mfu}sfcz}fkh kb inhmu fh rj vjnsu)
snhdfhd fh ufj bsk` >1 lje}nsju zq }k krjs :1
lje}nsju) }lskzdl }lj `kmju kb rkizh}nsv inhm
}snhubjs) kbbjs }k ujii) nhm ek`qziuksv ne~zfuf}fkh(
Zhmjs }lj hjt int) n inhmlkimfhd tfii cj mfu}sfcz}jm
zq }k n `n|f`z` kb }lsjj lje}nsju bks jnel ~znifjm
cjhjefnsv(
Neeksmfhd }k MNS) SN 6411 u}sjhd}ljhjm nhm
f`qskrjm ENSI tf}l f}u >:1 cfiifkh-qjuk czmdj}(
Tlj}ljs }lj ujekhm j|}jhufkh kb }lj ENSQ
tkzim hniiv tksg ks ij kz} ozu} ifgj }lj
qsjrfkzu khju mjqjhmu `nfhiv kh }lj
qkif}feni tfii kb }lj dkrjsh`jh} }k uzu}nfh
}lj qskdsn` }lskzdl bkiikt-}lskzdl
uzqqks} nhm esjmf} bnefif}fju( Nb}js nii)
inhm sjbks` fu hk} ozu} }lj mfu}sfcz}fkh
kb inhm }k }lj inhmijuu) cz} }lj
fhu}niin}fkh kb }lj bns`jsu }k }ljfs
sfdl}bzi qinej nu }lj `nu}jsu kb }lj
ukfi( Tf}lkz} uzbefjh} dkrjsh`jh}
uzqqks} }k jhncij }lj` }k uzu}nfh
}lj inhm }ln} tkzim cj dfrjh }k }lj`)
}ljsj fu hk sjnukh }k j|qje} }lj`
}k jrjh }sv }k ezi}frn}j }lj inhm }ljfs
nheju}ksu }fiijm bks mjenmju(
]lj uzeejuu kb }lj inhm sjbks` qskdsn`
enh khiv cj einf`jm }lj `k`jh} }lj bns`jsu
}lj`ujirju rfjt inhm hk} nu n ifncfif}v) cz} nu n
rnizncij nuuj} tks}l lkimfhd kh }k(
http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/presdecs/pd1972/pd_27_1972.htmlhttp://www.lawphil.net/executive/execord/eo1987/eo_229_1987.htmlhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_view&gid=959&Itemid=220http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2009/ra_9700_2009.htmlhttp://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2009/ra_9700_2009.htmlhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=961&Itemid=220http://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=961&Itemid=220http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2009/ra_9700_2009.htmlhttp://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2009/ra_9700_2009.htmlhttp://www.dar.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_view&gid=959&Itemid=220http://www.lawphil.net/executive/execord/eo1987/eo_229_1987.htmlhttp://www.lawphil.net/statutes/presdecs/pd1972/pd_27_1972.html8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
25/52
32
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
]lj Dsjjh Qktjs Mfij``n
Tfii }lj ekzh}sv$u n`cf}fkzu sjhjtncij-jhjsdv qinhcj zhmjs`fhjm cv f}u dsktfhd jhjsdv hjjmu;
Cv Dnsv Kifrns
Qjs }lj Qktjs Mjrjikq`jh} Qinh 3116
3151 bsk` }lj Mjqns}`jh} kb Jhjsdv
,MKJ&) }lj Qlfifqqfhju qjng jhjsdv hjjmu
tfii dskt n} nh nrjsndj =(=>* sn}j fh Izkh
bks }ln} qjsfkm) =(64* fh Rfunvnu) nhm
=(
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
26/52
]lj dsjjh qktjs mfij``n 34
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
3151 bsk` nckz} :)=11 @T n} qsjujh})
nhm fhesjnufhd }lj ekh}sfcz}fkh kb ne}zni
jhjsdv bsk` sjhjtncij ukzseju }k n} ijnu}
:1* kb }lj ekzh}sv$u jhjsdv `f| cv }ljh(
N`cf}fkzu nhm ekh}skrjsufni(
Tlfij }lj hn}fkhni qinh fu n`cf}fkzu) f}$u
niuk ekh}skrjsufni) `nfhiv cjenzuj kb n
bjjmfh}nsfbb ,BF]& uelj`j fh qinej bks
jhekzsndfhd }lj mjrjikq`jh} kb
sjhjtncijjhjsdv ukzseju(
]lj bkiiktfhd bjjmfh}nsfbb sn}ju tjsj
qskqkujm fh @nv 31>> cv }lj Hn}fkhni
Sjhjtncij Jhjsdv Cknsm nh ndjhev
]LJ KZ]iKKG bKS iZzKH
]ncij bsk` Qktjs Mjrjikq`jh} Qinh) 3116-3151) Mjqns}`jh} kb Jhjsdv
ikh Jhjsd Unju nhm Qjng Mj`nhm Nrjsndj
Nhhn Dstk}l Sn}j) 3116-3151
QjsfkmJhjsd Unju)
DTL
Qjng Mj`nhm) @T
Cnuj jns 311)34: 2)< 2=)515 >1)565
3151 >16)=44 >4)252
NNDS * *
3116-31>< =(:5 =(5
31>6-3151 =(:5 =(:>
3116-3151 =(:5 =(=>
http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/business/06/14/11/philippines-lifts-2030-renewable-energy-targethttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/business/06/14/11/philippines-lifts-2030-renewable-energy-targethttp://www.erc.gov.ph/pdf/Revised%20FIT%20Rules%20for%20POSTING_final.pdfhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.erc.gov.ph/pdf/Revised%20FIT%20Rules%20for%20POSTING_final.pdfhttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/business/06/14/11/philippines-lifts-2030-renewable-energy-targethttp://www.abs-cbnnews.com/business/06/14/11/philippines-lifts-2030-renewable-energy-target8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
27/52
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
28/52
36
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
If}jsniiv jrjsv}lfhd cz} }lj $kfhg$
Nu sjqks}jm fh ]lj @nhfin Cziij}fh) fh nh fhhkrn}frj kqjsn}fkh sj`fhfuejh} kb }lj inu} @nm @n| `krfj)
]lzhmjsmk`j) }lj Hdk bn`fiv kb Djhjsni ]sfnu) Enrf}j fu nckz} }k mkzcij) }k >(> @T) }lj qktjs f}
qskmzeju bsk` }lj qfd `nhzsj j|esj}jm kh f}u utfhj bns`( ]lj hz`cjs kb qfd ljnmu tfii fhesjnuj bsk` f}u
ezssjh} 2=)111 }k nckz} n lzhmsjm }lkzunhm) tf}l jnel qfd enqncij kb qskmzefhd }tk gfiku kb tnu}j n mnv)
tlfel fh }zsh ekhrjs}u fh}k 1(5> }k 1(5= ezcfe `j}jsu kb dnu(
Ufhej }lj qktjs djhjsn}jm fu bks f}u kth zuj) }lj bns` enhhk} einf` nrnfincij fhek`j }n| fhejh}frju kh f}u
cfkdnu tnu}j }k qktjs kqjsn}fkh( Cz} f} sj`nfhu jifdfcij bks mz}vbsjj f`qks}n}fkh kb enqf}ni j~zfq`jh} zhmjs
}lj Sjhjtncij Jhjsdv Ne}) nhm enh niuk sjdfu}js bks ensckh esjmf}u(
}k }lj fheizufkh kb tfhm nhm ukins qktjs fu
cnujm hk} ozu} kh lfdl qskqkujm }nsfbb sn}ju)
cz} niuk cjenzuj }lj fh}js`f}}jh} hn}zsj
kb tfhm nhm ukins qktjs qsjrjh}u }lj`
bsk` djhjsn}fhd jije}sfef}v 3=+4) tlfel
tkzim }ljh sj~zfsj cnegzq djhjsn}fkh(
]lj bjmjsn}fkh mfm uzqqks} }lj fheizufkh
kb cfk`nuubjm djhjsn}fkh bnefif}fju fh }lj
bjjmfh}nsfbb sjdf`j(
Sjnukhu }k ekhufmjs bjjm-fh-}nsfbbu(
Mjbjhmjsu kb }lj qskqkujm }nsfbb sjdf`j)
ijm cv }lj ifgju kbUjh( Jmdnsmk Nhdnsn)
nmrnhej }lj bkiiktfhd nsdz`jh}u fh
f}u bnrks?
Uzcufmfju nsj hjjmjm fh ksmjs }k
jhekzsndj fhrju}`jh} fh sjhjtncijjhjsdv
}jelhkikdfju nhm uzqqks} j|qnhufkh kb }lj
sjhjtncijjhjsdv nsgj} zh}fi zhf} eku}u
u}ns} }k ek`j mkth mzj }k ijnshfhd ezsrj
jbefjhefju nhm jekhk`fju kb uenij(
]ljsj tfii cj fhmzu}sv uqfh-kbbu zq nhm
mkth }lj rnizj elnfh) uzel nu }lj qk}jh}fni
esjn}fkh kb n ukins qlk}krki}nfe tnbjs
`nhzbne}zsfhd fhmzu}sv }k uzqqiv `nsgj}mj`nhm bks ukins qlk}krki}nfe bnefif}fju(
]lj uzcufmfju nsj uzcoje} }k sjrfjt jrjsv
}lsjj vjnsu nhvtnv) nhm tfii ek`j kbb khej
sjhjtncijjhjsdv }jelhkikdfju nelfjrj eku}
qnsf}v tf}l bkuufibzji qktjs ukzseju }k }lj
hn}fkhni dsfm(
]lj ekzh}sv lnu }k ulnsj fh }lj dikcni
sjuqkhufcfif}v }k ek`cn} eif`n}j elnhdj cv
nmmsjuufhd }lj fuuzj kb dsjjhlkzuj dnuju
nhm }lj jhinsdfhd dikcni ensckh bkk}qsfh}(
]nsfbb kqqkhjh}u sj}ks} }ln} tj hjjm hk} cj
fh uzel n lzssv( ]lj Qlfifqqfhju enh uf`qiv
tnf} bks }lj eku}u kb sjhjtncijjhjsdv
}jelhkikdv }k ek`j mkth kh }ljfs kth) mzj
}k fhesjnufhd zundj jiujtljsj fh }lj tksim)
}jelhkikdv nmrnheju) nhm nhzbne}zsfhd
jbefjhefju }lj in}}js `ku} qskhkzhejm fh
}lj enuj kb ufifekh elfqcnujm }jelhkikdfju
uzel nu ukins qlk}krki}nfe tnbjsu) tlfel
tfii bkiikt @kksju Int kb lnirfhd zhf}
eku}u jrjsv }tk vjnsu(
]lj hn}fkhni sjhjtncijjhjsdv
qskdsn` fdl} niuk sj~zfsj }sj`jhmkzu
sjukirj }k f`qij`jh} nhm nfh}nfh)
fh ifdl} kb n sjejh} mfsj tnshfhd kbnbziicikth qktjs esfufu cv 31>=) nu sjqks}jm
]lj dsjjh qktjs mfij``n
http://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://www.doe.gov.ph/EP/Devp.htmhttp://mb.com.ph/articles/328430/pig-farm-runs-rehttp://www.senate.gov.ph/press_release/2011/0708_angara1.asphttp://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=750240&publicationSubCategoryId=66http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=750240&publicationSubCategoryId=66http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=750240&publicationSubCategoryId=66http://www.philstar.com/Article.aspx?articleId=750240&publicationSubCategoryId=66http://www.senate.gov.ph/press_release/2011/0708_angara1.asphttp://mb.com.ph/articles/328430/pig-farm-runs-re8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
29/52
51
EKH]JH]U TKSIM HN]FKH CZUFHJUU ]JELHKIKDV
N`cf}fkzu nh tjii-j~zfqqj bks }lj bz}zsj;
Nu qsjrfkzuiv sjqks}jm fh Qns} > kb }lfu ujsfju) }lj Mjqns}`jh} kb Jhjsdv$u sjhjtncij-jhjsdv qskdsn` nf`u}k ksj }lnh mkzcij }lj ekzh}svu djk}ljs`ni nhm lvmskqktjsdjhjsn}fhd enqnef}fju tlfel ek`qsfujm
61 tlfij j|qnhmfhd ufdhfenh}iv }lj ulnsj kb tfhm)
ukins) cfk`nuu) nhm kejnh qktjsdjhjsn}fhd enqnef}fju >(5* kb }lj sjhjtncijjhjsdv enqnef}v fh 31>1 }k
>5(*) >3*) sjuqje}frjiv) kb }lj ekzh}svu qktjs sj~zfsj`jh}u( @ksjkrjs) }ljsj fu
dsktfhd fh}jsju} fh ukins nhm tfhm jhjsdv) nu tjii nu jhks`kzu qk}jh}fni bks }lj u}n}jkb}ljns} }jelhkikdv kb
}fmni qktjs) dfrjh }lj nselfqjindk$u fh}js-fuinhm tn}jsu nhm ikhd eknu}ifhju(
]LJ QLFiFQQFHJU SJHJTNCiJ JHJSDv ]NSDJ]U
Uje}ks Fhu}njmEnqnef}) ,@T&
nu k 31>1
]nsdj} Enqnef} Nmmf}fkh c ]k}n Enqnef}Nmmf}fkh ,@T&
31>>-3151
]k}n
Fhu}njm
Enqnef} c
3151
31>: 3131 313: 3151
Djk}ljs`ni >)622(1 331(1 >)>11(1 6:(1 )=6:(1 5)=2>(1
Lvmsk 5)=11(11 5=>(5 5)>2>(1 >)(< 1(1 :)56=(>
Cfk`nuu 56(1 342(4 1(1 1(1 1(1 342(4 5>:(4
Tfhm 55(1 >)1=
8/2/2019 The CenSEI Report (Vol. 2, No. 03, January 23-29, 2012)
30/52
5>
]ljejhUJFSjqks} Onhznsv 35-36) 31>3
sjdfu}jsjm f}u ikeni lvmskqktjs qskoje}u
ncsknm bks }lj kqqks}zhf}v }k }snmj ensckh
esjmf}u jrjh cjvkhm 31>3) }lj j|qfsv mn}j
bks }nsdj}u zhmjs }lj ezssjh} Gvk}k
Qsk}kekiu(
Qjhmfhd nhv j|}jhufkh) ek`qnhfju ifgj
QlfiEnsckh enh ekh}fhzj }k }snmj esjmf}u
cv sjdfu}jsfhd }lj`ujirju zhmjs }lj ZHu
Eijnh Mjrjikq`jh} Uelj`j fh ksmjs }k
~znifbv bks qns}fefqn}fkh fh }lj Jzskqjnh
J`fuufkhu ]snmfhd Uelj`j( Neeksmfhd
}k }lj ek`qnhv$u tjcuf}j) nufmj bsk` }tk
`fhflvmsk mjrjikq`jh} qskoje}u nisjnmv
u}ns}jm fh _n`cknhdn Ef}v nhm fh Eksmkh)Funcjin) }lj ek`qnhv fu niuk mjrjikqfhd
}tk `zel insdjs tfhm qskoje}u) fh Undnmn)
Ckh}ke) nhm fh Czininenk) Ksfjh}ni
@fhmksk(
]k ek`qij`jh} f}u hn}fkhni sjhjtncij
jhjsdv qinh) }lj MKJ sjejh}iv mfueikujm }k
}ljQlfifqqfhj Mnfiv Fh~zfsjs }ln} f} lnu
cjjh invfhd mkth }lj dskzhmtksg bks }lj
ju}nciful`jh} kb n hn}fkhni sjhjtncij
jhjsdv nsgj} bks }lj fuuznhej) khf}ksfhd)
nhm qkuufcij }snmfhd kb sjhjtncijjhjsdv
ejs}fen}ju fuuzjm }k jije}sfef}v uzqqifjsu
nhm mfu}sfcz}ksu tlk ukzsej }ljfs qktjs
bsk` sjhjtncij ukzseju( Neeksmfhd }k }lj
sjqks}) }lj MKJ lkqju }k lnrj dzfmjifhju
qzcifuljm cv }lj su} ~zns}js kb 31>3(
,Sjhjtncij-jhjsdv ejs}fen}ju nsj `jnh}
}k ljiq sjhjtncijjhjsdv qskmzejsu
`nfh}nfh sjrjhzj u}sjn`u bks hnhefhd
bz}zsj qskoje}u( Bks nh fh}skmze}fkh }k }ljj`jsdfhd nsgj} bks sjhjtncijjhjsdv
ejs}fen}ju fh }lj Z(U() n Onhzn