The Advance CV Workgroup The Advance CV Workgroup March 16, 2015
Dec 27, 2015
2
• Teaching/Mentoring– Current sections– Ideas discussed at 2/23/15 meeting– Mockups– Additional discussion: Mentoring
• Recap/Timeline• Feedback from 2014 FAS Survey• List of changes that will impact the user• Other CV topics
Agenda
8
• Header name changes– Formal Scheduled Classes for UCSF Students
Formal Teaching– Postdoctoral Fellows and Residents Directly
Supervised or Mentored Postdoctoral Fellows and Residents Mentored
– Other Visiting Faculty Supervised Visiting Faculty Mentored
– Teaching and Mentoring Aids Educational Materials Created
Ideas discussed
9
• Formal Teaching– Replace the Qtr column with a new field: header
should display “Not UCSF” – user can check a box to indicate which teaching was not at UCSF
– Replace the Units column with a new field: header to display “School” – user selects Dentistry, Medicine, Nursing, Pharmacy, Grad
– Enable the user to link to the Evalue for this course• Reviewer should be able to access the Evalue from
the CV
Ideas discussed
10
• Remove the header Postgraduate and Other Courses and combine with Formal Teaching
• Teaching Summary– Make it appear before Formal Teaching – Enable the user to self-identify as
• Primary creative activity IS teaching: fills out defined section based on the Educator Portfolio’s Executive Summary
• Primary creative activity IS NOT teaching (i.e., Research or Clinical): fills out free text field to summarize teaching accomplishments
Ideas discussed
11
• All sections that list mentees– Clarifying text: include only those people who
would say that you were their mentor
• Mentoring Summary– Make it appear before Predoctoral Students
Supervised or Mentored– Enable the user to self-identify as
• A primary creative activity IS mentoring: fills out defined section based on the Educator Portfolio’s Exec Smry
• A primary creative activity IS NOT mentoring (i.e., Research or Clinical): fills out free text field to summarize mentoring accomplishments
Ideas discussed
12
• Remove the header Other and combine with Educational Materials Created– Roll-over and other help text needs to
• Describe what is expected• Include an example:
– Chapter from <textbook name> textbook has been translated into six languages
– Candidate should be advised not to duplicate items already listed in the CV (e.g., publications, books and chapters, etc.)
Ideas discussed
13
• Remove the header Teaching and Mentoring Awards and combine with Honors and Awards – Use roll-over text to clarify this
• Summary of Teaching and Mentoring Hours– Delete this section
Ideas discussed
23
Recap – our mission
• Develop an updated CV format that allows faculty greater flexibility to represent the full range of their academic accomplishments
• Provide feedback and guidance on functionality for uploading/editing the CV
• Determine and maintain a standard CV format to provide efficiency for faculty reviewers
• Represent your constituencies during the revision process
• Advocate for the CV Module we develop
24
Recap – our accomplishments
• Reviewed all sections of the CV• Voiced comments and agreed to changes:
– Header text– New sections– Hide/consolidate some sections on the review CV– Improve functionality
25
Recap – still to do
• Review list of changes• Discuss additional CV functionality ideas• Decide on a best approach to soliciting
faculty input• Review faculty input• Finalize design
27
Changes directly related to comments:• Reduce the number of clicks to edit a line• Embedded instructions and examples, also visible
from Edit mode • Include an example CV• Ability to add sections• Ability to sort and re-order within a section• We will make moving grants simpler• We will add a field for poster title, but not include it
in the Review CV
2014 FAS Survey
28
Comments without easy answers• I'd appreciate it if, when something was changed
by an administrator in my Advance information such as funding percent and source, that I would receive an email notification to go look at it.
• Times out. Doesn't have an automatic save /recovery system which Is problematic. Not easy to get standard fonts and text size.
• No place to click ""finished"" or ""done"" for example, so you are never 100% sure the changes/updates have been saved.
2014 FAS Survey
29
Comments without easy answers• Make it possible to print a decent looking CV from
the ADVANCE system. It should be possible to export the CV to Word and reformat and edit it in Word.
• The online CV tool is pretty good, although could do a little better about allowing us to insert links into our CV. That is very important moving forward.
• CV does not allow much/any flexibility in including the multi-faceted work of faculty and too many important pieces of historical information must be included as ""other.""
2014 FAS Survey
30
• List of changes that will impact the user– Grants
• Make the Description field part of the CV • Display a warning when a field is blank• Include a Percent Effort field• Add a field to describe the role (1-2 lines)
– Honors and Awards• Optional field to indicate importance (2-3 lines)
– Service to Professional Publications• Add a Role (select ad hoc reviewer or editorial board)• “Services Rendered” indicate the number of papers
reviewed in the past year and in the past five years
List of changes
31
• List of changes that will impact the user– “Effort allocation” section: candidate indicates %
time for each applicable area (Clinical, Research, etc.)
– Clinical Activities section• Indicate activities and years
– Hospital Service sub-section (include Quality Improvement information)
– Contributions to Diversity (A summary field)
List of changes
32
Other Topics• Other topics that need to be discussed:
– How do we transition?– List of Accomplishments– Rich Text fields– Sharing your data– “Granularity” of fields
33
• What will the new world look like in relation to the old world?
• How will the 15/16 packets appear AFTER January 1?
• Will there be TWO options for users (old My CV, new My CV)?
How do we transition?
34
• Add the Annual List of Accomplishments to the CV Roll Out– Selling point for the new CV– This kind of report could be useful for all faculty
for their annual meeting with their chair
List of Accomplishments
35
Rich Text Fields• Rich Text fields
– BENEFIT - Rich Text enables bold, underline, italics, formatting tricks like bullets, indents, hanging indents, etc.
– ISSUE - “Pasting” into a Rich Text field can introduce unwanted code
– OPTIONS• Leave as is• “Strip” rich text when pasting, forcing the user to add
formatting using the rich text tools
36
Sharing CV Data• Sharing CV data
– Default is NOT to share data– User can enable sharing– Do we want system-defined access to some
data?
37
Granularity• “Granularity” of fields
– Original design considered sorting and reporting– Do we need more granularity?