Thayer Strategy and Maritime Power in a Contested Environment: National, Military, Maritime Strategy in the South China Sea

8/21/2019 Thayer Strategy and Maritime Power in a Contested Environment: National, Military, Maritime Strategy in the Sou…

1/20


2/20

PROGRAM OF

EVENTS

TUESDAY,

JUNE 16

(Civilian-businessattire/Military-summer white orserviceequivalent)

7:30

a.m.

Guest

Registration

8:30 Administrative Remarks

8:40

Keynote

Address:

All

Domain Accessand FutureChallenges

Admiral

Michelle

J.

Howard,U.S.Navy,ViceChiefof NavalOperations

9:00 Questions andAnswers

9:20

Keynote

Address

Dr.Andrew F.Krepinevich,Center

for

StrategicandBudgetaryAssessments)

10:10

Break

10:30 Panel 1:ContestedArenas

Dr.PatrickM. Cronin,Centerfor aNew AmericanSecurity

Dr.BernardHaykel,Princeton University

Dr.NikolasK.Gvosdev,U.S.Naval

War

College

Moderator:

Dr. HayatAlvi, U.S.Naval

War

College

12 :00

p.m. lunch

1:30

Keynote

Address

Lieutenant GeneralKenneth

J.

Glueck, Jr.,U.S

Marine

Corps,DeputyCommandant

for Combat Development and Integration

2: 15 Break

2:30 Panel2:Challenges

and

Trends

Dr.Mathew Burrows,

Atlantic

Council

Dr.ChrisC.Demchak,U.S.Naval

War College

ProfessorJoelP.Trachtman, TuftsUniversity

Moderator:

Dr.Andrea

J.

Dew, U.S.Naval

War

College

WEDNESDAY, JUNE 17 (Civilian-business

attire/Military-summer

white or service equivalent)

8:30

a.m. Keynote

Address

Dr.Peter W.Singer, New AmericaFoundation

9:30 Break/Move to seminar locations

10:00 Seminars

11:30 lunch Break

1:00

p.m. Keynote

Address:An Interview

The Honorable HenryM. Paulson,Jr.,The Paulson

Institute

with Dr.John F.Garofano, U.S.NavalWar College

2:15

Panel3:National, Military,

Maritime

Strategy

Dr.ThomasG.

Mahnken,

U.S.NavalWar College

Mr. Ronald O'Rourke,Congressional ResearchService

ViceAdmiral FrankC.Pandolfe,U.S.Navy,StrategicPlansand Policy (J-5),Joint Staff

Dr.CarlyleA.Thayer,Universityof NewSouthWales,AustralianDefenceForceAcademy

Moderator: Dr.JamesR Holmes,U.S.Naval War College

4:00

Adjourn

1


3/20

C RLYLE

A

TH YER

Carlyle A. Thayer is Professor Emeritus at The University of New South Wales (UNSW) at the Australian

Defence Force Academy (ADFA), Canberra. He was educated at Brown University and holds an M.A.

degree in Southeast Asian Studies

from

Yale and a PhD in International Relations

from

The Australian

National University. Thayer joined the UNSW in 1979 and

taught

first in The Faculty of

Military

Studies at

the The Royal

Military

College-Duntroon (1979-85) before transferring to Australian Defence Force

Academy. He was given leave in

the

national interest to take up the position of Deputy Chair of the

Department of Regional Studies at the Asia-Pacific Center

for

Security Studies

APCSS),

U.S. Pacific

Command, Hawaii (1999-02). On return to Australia he was seconded to Deakin University and served as

On-Site Academic Co-ordinator at Weston Creek

for

the Defence and Strategic Studies Course, the

senior course, at the Centre for Defence and Strategic Studies CDSS) at the Australian Defence College

(2002-04). He later directed Regional Security Studies at the Australian Command and Staff College

(2006-07 and 2010).

Professor Thayer was the

C

V. Starr Distinguished Visiting Professor at the School of Advanced

International Studies, Johns Hopkins University in Washington (2005) and the Inaugural Frances M. and

Stephen F. Fuller Distinguished Visiting Professor at the Center

for

International Studies, Ohio University

(2008). He is also director of Thayer Consultancy, a small business registered in Australia in 2002 that

provides political analysis of current regional security issues and

other

research support to selected

clients. Thayer wr ites a regular column on Southeast Asia defence and security

for

The Diplomat.

Professor Thayer is the

author

of over 500 publications including: Southeast Asia; Patterns

o

Security Cooperation

ASPI

Strategy Report. Canberra: Australian Strategic Policy Institute, 2010.


4/20

!"#$"%&' $)* +$#,",-% ./0%# ,) $

1/)"%2"%* 3)4,#/)-%)"5

6$",/)$78 +,7,"$#'8 +$#,",-% !"#$"%&' $)* "9% !/:"9 19,)$ !%$

"#$%&%' () *+#&'$

A US Navy crewman on board a P-8A Poseidon surveillance aircraft flyingnear a Chinese man-made island in the Spratly Islands in a disputed area ofthe South China Sea. Photo: Reuters, May 22, 2015

"#$%&'() *%+,$))+% -.%/0/$ 12 34.0$%

*%$)$5'.'&+5 '+ '4$ 66'4 -(%%$5' 7'%.'$80 9+%(#

:272 ;. ;$?@+%'> A4+B$ C)/.5B

D(5$ E6FEG> HIEJ


5/20

H

"#$%#&'( %)* +%$,#,-& ./0&$ ,) % 1/)#&2#&* 3)4,$/)-&)#5

6%#,/)%78 +,7,#%$(8 +%$,#,-& "#$%#&'( %)* #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%

1:$$&)# "#$%#&'( ;/$:- ?

1%$7(7& @A B9%(&$C

;)"#/*:

B9& 1:$$&)# "#$%#&'( ;/$:- /4&$4,&0 %72/ )/#&2 #9%# #9& D/)#&2#&* 2H%D& /E #/*%( ,2

)/# /)7( '&/H/7,#,D%7 I:# %72/ ,)D7:*&2 )&0 */-%,)2A B9,2 H$&2&)#%#,/) E/D:2&2 /) #9&

"/:#9 19,)% "&% %2 % D/)#&2#&* 2H%D& ,) 09,D9 #9& )&0 */-%,)2 ,)D7:*& 19,)%F2 :2& /E

7&'%7 0%$E%$&8 ,)E/$-%#,/) 0%$E%$& %)* )/)O-,7,#%$( ,)2#$:-&)#2 2:D9 %2 -%$,#,-& 7%0

&)E/$D&-&)# 4&22&72 P1/%2# Q:%$*R8 E,29,)' E7& #9%# /H&$%#& %2 2#%#& -,7,#,%8 %)*

D/--&$D,%7 /,7 &JH7/$%#,/) H7%#E/$-2 #/ %22&$# ,# D7%,-2 #/ M,)*,2H:#%I7& 2/4&$&,')#(AN

B9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% 0,77 ' -/$& D/)#&2#&* ,) #9& -,7,#%$( */-%,) %2 19,)% *&4&7/H2

,#2 )%4%7 I%2& /) S%,)%) ,27%)* %)* D/-H7&2 D/)2#$:D#,/) /E E/$0%$* /H&$%#,)' I%2&2

/) %$#,E,D,%77( D/)2#$:D#&* M,27%)*2N ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A

T9( ,2 #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% 2/ ,-H/$#%)#U B9& 0/$7*F2 -%V/$ D/--&$D,%7 29,HH,)'

$/:#&2 W /$ 2&% 7,)&2 /E D/--:),D%#,/) P"XY1R W H%22 #9$/:'9 #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A

B9&2& "XY12 D%$$( 4,#%7 #$%*& %)* &)&$'( #/ 19,)%8 Z%H%)8 B%,0%) %)* "/:#9 [/$&%A B9&

"/:#9 19,)2 "&% ,2 %72/ #9& -%V/$ #$%)2,# $/:#& E/$ #9& *&H7/(-&)# /E LA"A )%4%7 29,H2

%)* -,7,#%$( %,$D$%E# I&&) #9& .%D,E,D %)* \)*,%) YD&%)2A B9& "XY12 H%22 #9$/:'9 #9&

-%$,#,-& 9&%$# /E "/:#9&%2# @2,%8 % $&',/) D&)#$%7 #/ #9& @22/D,%#,/) /E "/:#9&%2# @2,%)

6%#,/)2 P@"3@6RA ;,)%77(8 #9& "XY12 #9%# H%22 #9$/:'9 #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% %$& 4,#%7 E/$

@:2#$%7,% #9%# ,2 % 6/$#9&%2# @2,% #$%*& *&H&)*&)# )%#,/)A

B9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% ,2 %72/ % $&',/) /E D/)#&2#%#,/)A ",J D/:)#$,&2 9%4& D7%,-2 #/

E&%#:$&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A B%,0%)8 19,)% %)* ],)%- %77 D7%,- 2/4&$&,')#( %)*

2/4&$&,') V:$,2*,D#,/) /4&$ #9& .%$%D&7 %)* "H$%#7( ,27%)*2A 19,)% 9%2 *&D7%$&* ,# 9%2

M,)*,2H:#%I7& 2/4&$&,')#(N /4&$ %77 #9& E&%#:$&2 %)* M%*V%D&)# 0%#&$2N &)D/-H%22&* ,)

C 3-&$,#:2 .$/E&22/$8 B9& L),4&$2,#( /E 6&0 "/:#9 T%7&2 %# #9& @:2#$%7,%) ^&E&)D& ;/$D& @D%*&-(8

1%)I&$$%A G&4,2&* Z:)& >_8 ?A

> 1:$$&)# "#$%#&'( ;/$:- ?K 9##H25``000A:2)0DA&*:`34&)#2`1";`1:$$&)#O"#$%#&'(O;/$:-O?A%2HJA


6/20

K

,#2 %-I,# M),)&O*%29 7,)&N -%H #9%# ,)D7:*&2 E$/- 2,J#( #/ &,'9#( H&$D&)# /E #9& "/:#9

19,)% "&%A

B9& .9,7,HH,)&2 %)* +%7%(2,% D7%,- 2/4&$&,')#( /4&$ 2H&D,E,D E&%#:$&28 09,7& a$:)&,

D7%,-2 2/4&$&,') V:$,2*,D#,/) /4&$ #9& 0%#&$2 ,) ,#2 3JD7:2,4& 3D/)/-,D b/)& P33bRA

19,)%F2 ),)&O*%29 7,)& D:#2 #9$/:'9 #9& 33b2 /E %77 7,##/$%7 2#%#&2A

\)*/)&2,%8 09,D9 ,2 )/# % D7%,-%)# 2#%#&8 ,2 I&,)' *$%0) ,)#/ #9&2& *,2H:#&2 #9$/:'9 #9&

&)D$/%D9-&)# I( 19,)&2& E,29,)' E7& ,) ,#2 33b %)* #9&,$ H$/#&D#,/) I( 19,)&2&

-%$,#,-& 7%0 &)E/$D&-&)# 4&22&72A

B9& .9,7,HH,)&2 ,2 #9& /)7( D/:)#$( #9%# ,2 % #$&%#( %77( /E #9& L),#&* "#%#&2A

19,)% 9%2 %''$&22,4&7( %22&$#&* ,#2 D7%,-2 /4&$ #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% ,) %) %2(--$,D

-%))&$ #9%# :2&2 -%$,#,-& 7%0 &)E/$D&-&)# %'&)D,&2 %2 0&77 %2 E,29,)' E7&`2#%#&

-,7,#,% #/ %22&$# 2/4&$&,') V:$,2*,D#,/)A .&/H7&F2 X,I&$%#,/) @$-( 6%4( P.X@6R 0%$29,H2

-%,)#%,) %) M/4&$O#9&O9/$,c/)N H$&2&)D& #/ D/-& #/ #9& %22,2#%)D& /E 19,)%F2 1/%2#

Q:%$* 4&22&72 ,E )&D&22%$(A @DD/$*,)' #/ #9& LA"A YEE,D& /E 6%4%7 \)#&77,'&)D&8 19,)%F2

-%$,#,-& 7%0 &)E/$D&-&)# E7& ,2 #9& 7%$'&2# ,) ):-I&$ P>= 2-%77RA.? ;3( @A1; -(0;B?8 8 HA g?K

9##H5``000A/),A)%4(A-,7`\)#&77,'&)D&j1/--:),#(`D9,)%A9#-7A X%$'& 29,H2 %$& >8=== #/)2 /$ -/$&8 2-%77

29,H2 E%77 ,) #9& $%)'& /E ?==O>8=== #/)2

f S%)2 +A [$,2#&)2&)8 M6&0 19,)&2& ""a6 ^&H7/(2 #/ S%,)%) \27%)*8N ;&*&$%#,/) /E @-&$,D%) "D,&)#,2#28

@H$,7


7/20

L

.%D,E,D #9&( 0,77 I& %I7& #/ 2#$,h& %)(09&$& /) D/)#,)&)#%7 L),#&* "#%#&2A B9& )%4%7 I%2&

)&%$ i:7,) H$&2&)#7( 9%2 ,)E$%2#$:D#:$& #9%# 2:HH/$#2 )%4%7 D/-I%#%)#2K ,) #9& E:#:$& #9&

,)E$%2#$:D#:$& 0,77 2:HH/$# %,$D$%E# D%$$,&$2 %)* %-H9,I,/:2 %22%:7# '$/:H2A \) k %

)&0 2H%D& 7%:)D9 D&)#&$ %# T&)D9%)' /) S%,)%) ,27%)* 0,77 D/--&)D& /H&$%#,/)2A \#

0,77 7%:)D9 9&%4( 2H%D& 7%:)D9 4&9,D7&2 #/ *&H7/( 2:$4&,77%)D& 2%#&77,#&2 ,) 7/0 &%$#9

/$I,#Ag

;:$#9&$ 2/:#98 ,) g8 19,)% D/--&)D&* *$&*',)' 2%)* E$/- #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%

2&%I&* %)* 2D$%H,)' D/$%7 $&&E2 #/ D/)2#$:D# %$#,E,D,%7 ,27%)*2 /) 2&4&) E&%#:$&2A

1/)2#$:D#,/) %D#,4,#,&2 H,Dh&* :H H%D& #9,2 (&%$ /) ;,&$( 1$/228 +,2D9,&E8 Z/9)2/) "/:#98

Q%4&)8 +D[&))%) %)* 1:%$#&$/) $&&E2A @2 % $&2:7# 19,)% 9%2 &)7%$'&* #9&2& #,)(

E&%#:$&2 #/ % 7%)* %$&% /E __g 19,)%

,)2#%77&* &%$7( 0%$),)' $%*%$ #9&$&A a( 2/-& &2#,-%#&28 ,) #9& E:#:$& 19,)% 0,77 I& %I7&

#/ 2#%#,/) :H #/ #9,$#( D/-I%# %,$D$%E# %)* % 2l:%*$/) /E D/-I%# 29,H2 %# ;,&$( 1$/22

g Z%-&2 @A X(/)2 %)* G,D9%$* ;,29&$8 M19&Dh,)' 19,)%F2 -,7,#%$( I:,7*O:H ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%8N 23(

C*13:0D;.0 2:&(18 Z:)& >g8 ?A

? 1%$7(7& @A B9%(&$8 M6/8 19,)% ,2 6/# G&D7%,-,)' X%)* ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%8N 23( E:',.&*; 8 Z:)& d8 ?A

9##H5``#9&*,H7/-%#AD/-`?`=k`)/OD9,)%O,2O)/#O$&D7%,-,)'O7%)*O,)O#9&O2/:#9OD9,)%O2&% Àk

G&H:I7,D /E #9& .9,7,HH,)&28 6/#,E,D%#,/) %)* "#%#&-&)# /E 17%,-8 Z%):%$(


8/20

J

G&&EAe

.9,7,HH,)&2 2/:$D&2 $&H/$# #9%# 19,)% ,2 7,h&7( #/ D/)2#$:D# %,$2#$,H2 /) +,2D9,&E %)* ":I,

$&&E2A

Y) +%$D9 >_8 ?8 "&)%#/$2 Z/9) +D1%,) PGO@$,cAR %)* Z%Dh G&&* P^OGA\AR8 #9& 19%,$-&)

%)* G%)h,)' +&-I&$ /E #9& "&)%#& @$-&* "&$4,D&2 1/--,##&&8 %)* "&)%#/$2 a/I1/$h&$ PGOB&))AR8 %)* a/I +&)&)*&c P^O6AZAR8 #9& 19%,$-&) %)* G%)h,)' +&-I&$

"&)%#& ;/$&,') G&7%#,/)2 1/--,##&&8 2&)# % 7#&$ #/ "&D$%$( /E ^&E&)2& @29 1%$#&$

%)* "&D$%$( /E "#%#& Z/9) [&$$(A B9,2 7#&$ 2#%#&*5

+/$&/4&$8 I&D%:2& #9&2& 7%)* $&D7%-%#,/) %D#,4,#,&2 D/:7* ,-H$/4& 19,)%F2

2:2#%,)-&)# /E ,#2 E,29,)' I/%#28 "#%#& YD&%),D @*-,),2#$%#,/) 29,H28 .&/H7&F2

X,I&$%#,/) @$-( 6%4( P.X@6R 29,H28 .X@ @,$ ;/$D& P.X@@;R E,'9#&$28 %)* /#9&$ 7/',2#,D2

%)* *&E&)2& -%#&$,%7 E$/- #9&2& D/-H7&* ,27%)*28 ,# D/:7* &-I/7*&) 19,)% #/

*&D7%$& %) @,$ ^&E&)2& \*&)#,E,D%#,/) b/)& P@^\bR ,) %77 /$ H%$# /E #9& "/:#9 19,)%

"&%A_

Y) Z:)& >k8 19,)%F2 ;/$&,') +,),2#$( ,22:&* % H$&22 $&7&%2& #9%# 2#%#&*8 m\) 7,)& 0,#9 #9&H7%) %7$&%*( ,) H7%D&8 19,)% 0,77 2//) E,),29 7%)* $&D7%-%#,/) /) 2&4&$%7 $&&E2 %)* ,27%)*2

,) #9& 6%)29% n"H$%#7(o ,27%)*2AAA @E#&$ 7%)* $&D7%-%#,/) ,2 D/-H7&8 #9& )&J# 2#%'& 0,77

I& D/)2#$:D#,/) #/ E:7E,77 4%$,/:2 E:)D#,/)2Am X: [%)'8 % 2H/h&2H&$2/) E/$ 19,)%F2 ;/$&,')

+,),2#$(8 2#%#&*8 M%2 H7%))&*8 #9& 7%)* $&D7%-%#,/) H$/V&D# /) 19,)%F2 D/)2#$:D#,/) /)

2/-& 2#%#,/)&* ,27%)*2 %)* $&&E2 ,) #9& 6%)29% n"H$%#7(o 0,77 I& D/-H7&* ,) D/-,)'

*%(2AN

\) /#9&$ 0/$*28 19,)% ,2 D/)#,):,)' #/ H:$2:& ,#2 7/)'O2#%)*,)' H/7,D( /E H:29,)' ,#2

D7%,-2 E/$0%$* :)#,7 #9&( &)D/:)#&$ 2#,EE ,)#&$)%#,/)%7 /HH/2,#,/)8 %)* #9&) H%:2,)' #/

D/)2/7,*%#& ,#2 '%,)2 I&E/$& H:29,)' %'%,)A \# ,2 7,h&7( #9%# 19,)%F2 #&-H/$%$( -/$%#/$,:-

,2 *&2,')&* #/ D7&%$ #9& H/7,#,D%7 %,$ ,) %*4%)D& /E #9& -,),2#&$,%7O7&4&7 >d #9 "#$%#&',D %)*3D/)/-,D ^,%7/':& 0,#9 #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 ,) T%29,)'#/) E$/- Z:)& #",@,_#9 V/,)# 7#&$ I( "&)%#/$2 +D1%,) %)* 1/$h&$ 2#%#&*8 :0;(? *,:*5

T& %$& 0$,#,)' ,) $&'%$* #/ 19,)&2& 2#$%#&'( ,) #9& \)*/O.%D,E,D -%$,#,-& */-%,)28

%)* #9& %7%$-,)' 2D/H& %)* H%D& /E #9& 7%)* $&D7%-%#,/) )/0 I&,)' D/)*:D#&* I(#9& .&/H7&F2 G&H:I7,D /E 19,)% P.G1R ,) #9& "H$%#7( ,27%)* D9%,) /E #9& "/:#9 19,)%

e X(/)2 %)* ;,29&$8 M19&Dh,)' 19,)%F2 -,7,#%$( I:,7*O:H ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%AN

_ M"&)%#/$2 +D1%,)8 G&&*8 1/$h&$8 %)* +&)&)*&c "&)* X#&$ /) 19,)&2& +%$,#,-& "#$%#&'(8N L),#&*

"#%#&2 "&)%#& 1/--,##&& /) @$-&* "&$4,D&28 9##H5``000A%$-&*O2&$4,D&2A2&)%#&A'/4`H$&22O

$&7&%2&2`2&)%#/$2O-DD%,)O$&&*OD/$h&$O%)*O-&)&)*&cO2&)*O7#&$O/)OD9,)&2&O-%$,#,-&O2#$%#&'(A


9/20

6

"&%q T,#9/:# % D/-H$&9&)2,4& 2#$%#&'( E/$ %**$&22,)' #9& .G1F2 I$/%*&$ H/7,D( %)*

D/)*:D# #/ %22&$# ,#2 2/4&$&,')#( D7%,-2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% %)* 3%2# 19,)% "&%8

,)D7:*,)' 7%)*O$&D7%-%#,/) %)* D/)2#$:D#,/) %D#,4,#,&28 7/)'O2#%)*,)' ,)#&$&2#2 /E #9&

L),#&* "#%#&28 %2 0&77 %2 /:$ %77,&2 %)* H%$#)&$28 2#%)* %# D/)2,*&$%I7& $,2hA

q L),7%#&$%7 &EE/$#2 #/ D9%)'& #9& 2#%#:2 l:/ #9$/:'9 E/$D&8 ,)#,-,*%#,/)8 /$ D/&$D,/)

#9$&%#&) #9& H&%D& %)* 2#%I,7,#( #9%# 9%4& I&)&E,#&* %77 #9& )%#,/)2 /E #9& \)*/O.%D,E,D

$&',/)A 19,)%F2 7%)*O$&D7%-%#,/) %)* D/)2#$:D#,/) %D#,4,#,&2 /) -:7#,H7& ,27%)*2 %D$/22

#9& "H$%#7( D9%,)8 %)* #9& H/#&)#,%7 D/--%)* %)* D/)#$/78 2:$4&,77%)D&8 %)* -,7,#%$(

D%H%I,7,#,&2 ,# D/:7* I$,)' #/ I&%$ E$/- #9&2& )&0 7%)* E&%#:$&28 %$& % *,$&D# D9%77&)'&

)/# /)7( #/ #9& ,)#&$&2#2 /E #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 %)* #9& $&',/)8 I:# #/ #9& &)#,$&

,)#&$)%#,/)%7 D/--:),#(A

qG&D7%-%#,/) I( %)( 2#%#& #/ &)9%)D& #9&,$ 2/4&$&,')#( $,'9#2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%

D/-H7,D%#&2 #9&2& *,2H:#&2 %)* $:)2 D/)#$%$( #/ D%772 E$/- #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 %)*

@22/D,%#,/) /E "/:#9&%2# @2,%) 6%#,/)2 E/$ H%$#,&2 #/ &J&$D,2& 2&7EO$&2#$%,)#A S/0&4&$8

09,7& /#9&$ 2#%#&2 9%4& I:,7# /) &J,2#,)' 7%)*-%22&28 19,)% ,2 D9%)',)' #9& 2,c&8

2#$:D#:$& %)* H9(2,D%7 %##$,I:#&2 /E 7%)* E&%#:$&2 #9&-2&74&2A B9,2 ,2 % l:%7,#%#,4&

D9%)'& #9%# %HH&%$2 *&2,')&* #/ %7#&$ #9& 2#%#:2 l:/ ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A

q @# % -,),-:-8 #9& D/)2#$:D#,/) %D#,4,#,&2 4,/7%#& #9& D/--,#-&)#2 #9%# 19,)%

-%*& %2 H%$# /E #9&


10/20

G

;. *


11/20

M

%$#,D7&A>A "H&D,E,D %D#,/)2 #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 D%) #%h& #/ 27/0 */0) /$ 2#/H 19,)%F2 $&D7%-%#,/)

%D#,4,#,&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* *&4&7/H %) ,)*,$&D# 2#$%#&'( #/ D/:)#&$ 19,)&2& %D#,4,#,&2 :2,)'

H$,-%$,7( O I:# )/# &JD7:2,4&7( W )/)O-,7,#%$( %22A>g

L)*&$ #9,2 2#$%#&'( #9& L),#&*

"#%#&2 29/:7* %4/,* *,$&D#7( D/)E$/)#,)' .&/H7&F2 X,I&$%#,/) @$-( 6%4( P.X@6R 0%$29,H2

0,#9 ,#2 /0) )%4%7 E/$D&2A 6/$ 29/:7* #9& LA"A 6%4( *,$&D#7( D/)E$/)# 19,)&2&

H%$%-,7,#%$( 7%0 &)E/$D&-&)# %'&)D( 29,H2 %)* E,29,)' D$%E# I&D%:2& #9,2 0/:7* %HH&%$

#/ I& % 9&%4( 9%)*&* /4&$ $&%D#,/)A 19,)% 0/:7* -%h& % H$/H%'%)*% -&%7 /:# /E %)(

2:D9 D/)E$/)#%#,/)2 %)* 2h,##,29 "/:#9&%2# @2,%) 2#%#&2 0/:7* I& 2D%$&* /EE E$/-

2:HH/$#,)' LA"A %D#,/)2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* D7%$,E( 09%# ,# -&%)2 I( E$&&*/- /) )%4,'%#,/) %)* /4&$ E7,'9#

"H&D,E,D%77( #9& L),#& "#%#&2 29/:7* -%h& D7&%$ #9%# ,# ,2 E$&&*/- /E )%4,'%#,/) %)* /4&$E7,'9# I( -,7,#%$( 29,H2 %)* %,$D$%E# #9%# ,2 %# 2#%h& )/# D/--&$D,%7 29,HH,)'A B9& LA"

29/:7* %72/ )/#& #9%# %)( 19,)&2& D9%77&)'& #/ -,7,#%$( E$&&*/- /E )%4,'%#,/) %)* /4&$

E7,'9# #9%# 7&* #/ D/)E7,D# 0/:7* 9%4& % -%V/$ )&'%#,4& ,-H%D# /) ,)2:$%)D& $%#&2 %)*

D/--&$D,%7 #$%)2,# #9$/:'9 #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% #/ #9& *$,-&)# /E 19,)%F2 ,)#&$&2#2A

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 %)* ,#2 #$&%#( %77,&2 29/:7* D/)*:D# H&$2,2#&)# )%4%7 %)* %,$ H%#$/72 #/

%22&$# E$&&*/- /E )%4,'%#,/)8 /4&$ E7,'9# %)* ,))/D&)# H%22%'& ,) #9& 0%#&$2 %)*

>< L61XY" .%$# p8 @$#,D7& >f ;/$ #9& #&J# /E #9& ^Y1 D/)2:7#5 9##H5``000A%2&%)A/$'`%2&%)`&J#&$)%7O

$&7%#,/)2`D9,)%`,#&-`*&D7%$%#,/)O/)O#9&OD/)*:D#O/EOH%$#,&2O,)O#9&O2/:#9OD9,)%O2&%A

>g B9,2 %)* #9& E/77/0,)' 2&D#,/)2 *$%0 /) 1%$7(7& @A B9%(&$8 %0


12/20

N

%,$2H%D& )&%$ %)* %I/4& #9& %$#,E,D,%7 ,27%)*2 D:$$&)#7( I&,)' I:,7# I( 19,)% #/ H$&4&)#

%Dl:,&2D&)D& #/ 19,)%F2 &JD&22,4& D7%,-2 I( $&',/)%7 2#%#&2 %)* #9& L),#&* "#%#&2A>?

@2 Z%-&2 [$%2h% 9%2 )/#&*8 #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 6%4( 9%2 I&&) D/)#,):%77( D9%77&)',)'

19,)%F2 #&$$,#/$,%7 D7%,-2 ,) #9$&& %$&%25

P>R LA"A E/$D&2 D/)#,):%77( D9%77&)'& 19,)%F2 ),)&O*%29 7,)& D7%,- #/ #9& E&%#:$&2 %)*0%#&$2 0,#9,) #9& ),)& *%29&2A

P< )%:#,D%7 -,7& #&$$,#/$,%7 2&% E$/-

2:I-&$'&* E&%#:$&2A>k

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* ,-H7&-&)# [$%2h%F2 $&D/--&)*%#,/) #9%# LA"A E/$D&2 29/:7*

D/)*:D# ,))/D&)# H%22%'& #9$/:'9 #9& #0&74& )%:#,D%7 -,7& #&$$,#/$,%7 2&% %)* )%#,/)%7

%,$2H%D& E$/- 2-%77 $/Dh2 ,77&'%77( D7%,-&* I( 19,)%A "/ E%$ #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 9%2$&E$%,)&* E$/- */,)' 2/A

19,)% ,2 &JH&D#&* #/ D/)#,):& -/:)#,)' %)):%7 %''$&22,4& )%4%7 *,2H7%(2 ,) #9& "/:#9

19,)% "&% E$/- +%( #/ @:':2#A>d

B9,2 H$/4,*&2 %) /HH/$#:),#( E/$ #9& LA"A 6%4(8 Z%H%)

+%$,#,-& "&7EO^&E&)2& ;/$D&8 @:2#$%7,% %)* 7,h&O-,)*&* 2#%#&2 #/ /$'%),c& % 2&$,&2 /E

)%4%7 &J&$D,2&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% H$,/$ #/ #9& %$$,4%7 /E .X@6 E/$D&2 &%D9 (&%$A

B9&2& &J&$D,2&2 29/:7* I& ',4&) 0,*& H:I7,D,#( #/ &)9%)D& #$%)2H%$&)D(A

B9&2& &J&$D,2&2 H$/4,*& #9& -&%)2 E/$ #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 #/ ',4& H$%D#,D%7 &JH$&22,/) #/

,#2 *&D7%$%#/$( H/7,D( /E /HH/2,)' ,)#,-,*%#,/) %)* D/&$D,/) #/ 2#7& #&$$,#/$,%7 *,2H:#&2A

B9& LA"A 29/:7* D/)*:D# )%4%7 &J&$D,2&2 ,) 0%#&$2 #9%# #$%)24&$2& 19,)%F2 ),)&O*%29 7,)&A

G&',/)%7 -,7,#%$( /I2&$4&$2 E$/- #9& .9,7,HH,)&28 ],)%- %)* /#9&$ $&',/)%7 2#%#&229/:7* I& ,)4,#&* #/ /I2&$4& #9&2& &J&$D,2&2 /) LA"A )%4%7 4&22&72A B9,2 2#$%#&'( */&2 )/#

$&l:,$& #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 #/ *,$&D#7( D/)E$/)# 19,)% I:# #/ H$/4,*& $&%22:$%)D& #/

$&',/)%7 2#%#&2A

;/$&,') /I2&$4&$2 D/:7* %72/ I& ,)D7:*&* /) %&$,%7 $&D/))%,22%)D& E7,'9#2A B9& /IV&D#,4&

0/:7* I& #/ -%,)#%,) % D/)#,):/:2 )%4%7 %)* %,$ H$&2&)D& #/ *&$ 19,)% E$/- :2,)'

,)#,-,*%#,/) %)* D/&$D,/) %'%,)2# #9& .9,7,HH,)&28 ],)%- %)* /#9&$ $&',/)%7 2#%#&2 I(

>? ;/$ D/)#$%$( %)* D%:#,/)%$( 4,&028 $&2H&D#,4&7(8 2&&5 "/:$%I9 Q:H#%8 MB9& $,'9#2 %)* 0$/)'2 /E L"

/4&$E7,'9#2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%8N L*1; 61:* N.?B&8 +%( (01( #(/1M Z:)& e8 ?A

9##H5``000A*&E&)2&)&02AD/-`2#/$(`*&E&)2&`D/--&)#%$(`?`=k`=e`*&E&)*OE$&&*/-O)%4,'%#,/)O

D9,)%OH%D,E,DO,27%)*2O29,H2O,)#&$D&H#O2/4&$&,')#(`d ;/$ %) %)%7(2,2 /E H%2# 19,)&2& )%4%7 &J&$D,2&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% 2&&5 19$,2#/H9&$ SA "9%$-%)8

-3:0* =.7(1 OB;9 ";('':0D ";.0(1 2./*?< * #(/ =*?:;:&( ";?*;(D8 8 \6"" 19,)% "#$%#&',D .&$2H&D#,4&2 6/A

_8 1&)#&$ E/$ #9& "#:*( /E 19,)&2& +,7,#%$( @EE%,$28 \)2#,#:#& E/$ 6%#,/)%7 "#$%#&',D "#:*,&28 6%#,/)%7

^&E&)2& L),4&$2,#(8 @H$,7 ?A


13/20

EI

$%,2,)' #9& $,2h /E *,$&D#7( D/)E$/)#,)' #9& LA"A /$ % LA"A #$&%#( %77(A B9& 2D/H& %)*

,)#&)2,#( /E #9&2& &J&$D,2&2 D/:7* I& %7#&$&* ,) $&2H/)2& #/ #9& #&-H/ /E 19,)&2& )%4%7

%D#,4,#,&2A

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 D/:7* :)*&$#%h& -/$& )/4&7 -&%)2 #/ D/)4,)D& 19,)% #9%# #9& D/2#2

/E I$%c&),)' ,# /:# /:#0&,'9 D//H&$%#,/)A ;/$ &J%-H7&8 ,) >___ #9& .9,7,HH,)&2 I&%D9&*

% E/$-&$ LA"A X"B8 #9& PG4 ":(??* =*


14/20

EE

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* #%h& #9& 7&%* ,) % D%-H%,') #/ D/:)#&$ 19,)%F2 M,)E/$-%#,/)

0%$E%$&N I( H:I7,D,c,)' ,) % #,-&7( -%))&$ *%,72 /E 19,)&2& :),7%#&$%7 *&2#%I,7,c,)'

%D#,4,#,&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* H:# ,)E/$-%#,/) ,) #9& H:I7,D

*/-%,) 2/ #9& -&*,%8 2D9/7%$28 2&D:$,#( 2H&D,%7,2#28 /#9&$ %)%7(2#28 %)* &7&D#&* /EE,D,%72

-%( :2& ,#A B9& -/*&7 E/$ #9,2 %HH$/%D9 D/:7* I& *$%0) E$/- #9& H:I7,D%#,/) /) ".7:(;

=:,:;*?8 4./(? *:$,)' #9& 1/7* T%$ #9%# &JH7,D,#7( &JH/2&*8 :0;(? *,:*8 "/4, )%4%7/H&$%#,/)2 E$/- 1%- G%)9 a%( ,) ],)%-A

B9,2 (&%$8 E/$ &J%-H7&8 L),#&* "#%#&2 /EE,D,%72 D7%,-&* #9%# 19,)% H7%D&* -/#/$,c&*

%$#,77&$( /) /)& /E ,#2 %$#,E,D,%7 ,27%)*2 #9%# 9%2 2,)D& I&&) D/)D&%7&* /$ $&-/4&*A \#

0/:7* 9%4& I&&) -/$& &EE&D#,4& ,E #9& ^&H%$#-&)# /E ^&E&)2& 9%* $&7&%2&* ,-%'&$( /E

#9&2& 0&%H/)2 %7/)' 0,#9 #9& *%#& %)* ,*&)#,E,&* #9& E&%#:$& /) 09,D9 #9&2& 0&%H/)2

0&$& H7%D&* %2 0&77 %2 #9& $%)'& /E -/#/$,c&* %$#,77&$(A

LA"A /EE,D,%72 %72/ D7%,-&* #9%# ],)%- /DD:H,&* E/$#(O&,'9# E&%#:$&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)%

"&%A T9&) "&D$%$( /E ^&E&)2& @29 1%$#&$ 4,2,#&* S%)/, #9,2 Z:)& 9& D%77&* /) ],)%-

#/ H&$-%)&)#7( 9%7# %77 7%)* $&D7%-%#,/) %D#,4,#,&2 /) #9&2& E&%#:$&2A S,2 ],)%-&2&

D/:)#&$H%$#8 +,),2#&$ /E 6%#,/)%7 ^&E&)2& Q&)&$%7 .9:)' s:%)' B9%)98 %$':&* #9%#

M7%)* $&D7%-%#,/)N 0%2 I&,)' :)*&$#%h&) #/ H$&4&)# 2/,7 &$/2,/)A Q&)&$%7 B9%)9 %72/

%$':&* #9%# ],)%- 2#%#,/)&* -,7,#%$( H&$2/))&7 /) ),)& ME7/%#,)' ,27%)*2N %)* #0&74&

M2:I-&$'&* ,27%)*2N /$ % #/#%7 /E E&%#:$&2A>_

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* 9%4& H:I7,29&*

% 7,2# /E %77 ge E&%#:$&2 #9%# ,# D7%,-&* ],)%- 0%2 /DD:H(,)'A @72/8 #9& LA"A 29/:7* 9%4&

H$/4,*&* 2H&D,E,D *%,72 %I/:# #9& &J#&)# %)* H:$H/2& /E ],)%-F2 M7%)* $&D7%-%#,/)AN

\) %**,#,/)8 #9&$& %$& % ):-I&$ /E 19,)&2& %D#,/)2 #9%# %$& )/# 0&77 h)/0) H:I7,D7( #9%#

29/:7* I&A ;/$ &J%-H7&8 19,)% $&H/$#&*7( 9%2 &-H7/(&* &7&D#$/),D V%--,)' #/ ,)#&$E&$&

0,#9 #9& 7%0E:7 /H&$%#,/)2 /E %) \)*/)&2,%) -%$,#,-& 7%0 &)E/$D&-&)# 4&22&72 #9%# 9%*

%HH$&9&)*&* 19,)&2& E,29&$-&) D%:'9# H/%D9,)' ,) \)*/)&2,%F2 33bA


15/20

EH

,)D7:*&* ,) E:#:$& %)):%7 $&H/$#2 #/ 1/)'$&22A B9& .&)#%'/) 29/:7* ,22:& /#9&$ -/$&

#,-&7( $&H/$#2A

B9& 1/--%)*&$ /E #9& LA"A .%D,E,D 1/--%)* P.@1Y+R 29/:7* I& $&l:,$&* #/ $&H/$# ,)

*%,7 /) 19,)&2& %D#,4,#,&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% ,) 9,2 %)):%7 H/2#:$& 2#%#&-&)# #/ #9&

$&2H&D#,4& @$-&* "&$4,D& 1/--,##&&2 /E #9& S/:2& %)* "&)%#&A .@1Y+ 29/:7* %72/

$&7&%2& ,)E/$-%#,/) %I/:# 19,)&2& %D#,4,#,&2 /) % $&':7%$ I%2,2A

B9& ^&H%$#-&)# /E "#%#& 29/:7* H$/*:D& -/$& E$&l:&)# %)* #,-&7( $&H/$#2 ,) ,#2 5:&:;1

:0 ;3( "(*1 2&$,&2 D9%77&)',)' 19,)%F2 :),7%#&$%7 ,)#&$H$%#,/) /E ,)#&$)%#,/)%7 7%0A @

2H&D,E,D ,22:& E/D:2,)' /) #9& 7&'%7 ,-H7,D%#,/)2 /E 19,)%F2 D/)2#$:D#,/) /E %$#,E,D,%7

,27%)*2 0/:7* I& :2&E:7A

B9& ^&H%$#-&)#2 /E ^&E&)2& %)* "#%#& 29/:7* H$/4,*& %**,#,/)%7 E:)*28 $&2/:$D&2 %)*

/#9&$ %22,2#%)D& #/ @-&$,D%)OI%2&* #9,)h #%)h2 P,)D7:*,)' #9& 19,)% +%$,#,-& "#:*,&2

\)2#,#:#& %# #9& 6%4%7 T%$ 1/77&'&8 6&0H/$#R #/ $&2&%$D9 %)* $&H/$# /) D:$$&)# 19,)&2&

%D#,4,#,&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% %)* 9/0 #9&2& %$& 7,h&7( #/ ,-H%D# %*4&$2&7( /) LA"A

,)#&$&2#2 %)* $&',/)%7 2&D:$,#(A ;:)*,)' 29/:7* I& -%*& %4%,7%I7& #/ 2:HH/$# 2H&D,%7,c&*D/)E&$&)D&2 %)* 0/$h29/H2 #/ 09,D9 "/:#9&%2# @2,%) 2D9/7%$2 %)* /EE,D,%72 %$& ,)4,#&*

#/ %##&)*A

LA"A /EE,D,%72 09/ %##&)* @"3@6O$&7%#&* 2&D:$,#( -&,)'28 2:D9 %2 #9& @"3@6 G&',/)%7

;/$:-8 3JH%)*&* @"3@6 +%$,#,-& ;/$:-8 @"3@6 ^&E&)D& +,),2#&$2F +&,)' .7:28 %)*

#9& "9%)'$,OX% ^,%7/':& 29/:7* :2& #9&2& /DD%2,/)2 #/ H$/4,*& *%,7&* I%Dh'$/:)*

I$,&E,)'2 /) 19,)&2& %D#,4,#,&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A LA"A 2D9/7%$2 09/ $&':7%$7( %##&)*

B$%Dh >A? %)* B$%Dh < $&',/)%7 0/$h29/H2 %)* D/)E&$&)D&2 29/:7* I& /EE&$&* I$,&E,)'2

I( ^&E&)2& /EE,D,%72 /) % 4/7:)#%$( I%2,2A

B9& H:$H/2& /E #9,2 ,)E/$-%#,/) D%-H%,') ,2 #/ D9%77&)'& *,$&D#7( 19,)%F2 M,)E/$-%#,/)

0%$E%$&N %)* H$/H%'%)*% &EE/$#2A @)/#9&$ %,- /E #9,2 ,)E/$-%#,/) D%-H%,') 0/:7* I&#/ -%,)#%,) :)$&7&)#,)' H:I7,D H$&22:$& /) 19,)% #/ I& -/$& #$%)2H%$&)# %I/:# ,#2

%D#,4,#,&2 %)* #/ I$,)' ,#2 %D#,/)2 ,)#/ %DD/$* 0,#9 $&',/)%7 )/$-2 %)* ,)#&$)%#,/)%7 7%0A

fA T9%# E/$-2 /E 2&D:$,#( D//H&$%#,/) 0,#9 19,)% 0/:7* I& ,)%HH$/H$,%#& #/ D/)#,):& ,E

7%)* $&D7%-%#,/) %D#,4,#,&2 H$/D&&* %)* 09%# E/$-2 /E &)'%'&-&)# -,'9# H$/4,*&

,)D&)#,4&2 E/$ 19,)% #/ %7#&$ ,#2 I&9%4,/$A

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 %)* 19,)% 9%4& ,) H7%D& % 4%$,( /E 9,'9O7&4&7 %)* -,7,#%$(O#/O-,7,#%$(

*,%7/':&2 2:D9 %2 #9& "#$%#&',D %)* 3D/)/-,D ^,%7/':& P"t3^R8 "#$%#&',D "&D:$,#(

^,%7/':& P""^R8 ^&E&)2& 1/)2:7#%#,4& B%7h28 +,7,#%$( +%$,#,-& 1/)2:7#%#,4& @'$&&-&)#

%)* ^&E&)2& ./7,D( 1//$*,)%#,/) B%7h2A

LA"A /EE,D,%72 29/:7* D/)#,):%77( &)'%'& 0,#919,)% ,) #9&2& 4&):&2 #/ H$/-/#& % $:7&2OI%2&* %HH$/%D9 #/ #9& $&2/7:#,/) /E -%$,#,-&

*,2H:#&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A ;/$ &J%-H7&8 ,) 6/4&-I&$ g8 19,)% %)* #9& L),#&*

1%$7(7& @A B9%(&$8 M3)9%)D,)' B$%)2H%$&)D(U LA"AO19,)% +,7,#%$(O#/O+,7,#%$( 1/)#%D#2 %)* "#$%#&',D

^,%7/':&28N .%H&$ #/ \)#&$)%#,/)%7 1/)E&$&)D& /) B9& LA"A %)* 19,)% ,) G&',/)%7 "&D:$,#(5 \-H7,D%#,/)2 E/$

@2,% %)* 3:$/H&8 D/O2H/)2/$&* I( "#,E#:)' T,22&)29%E# :)* ./7,#,h %)* [/)$%* @*&)%:&$ "#,E#:)'8 a&$7,)8

;&*&$%7 G&H:I7,D /E Q&$-%)(8 Z:)& >eO>_8


16/20

EK

"#%#&2 $&%D9&* % +&-/$%)*:- /E L)*&$2#%)*,)' /) #9& G:7&2 /E a&9%4,/$ E/$ #9&

"%E( /E @,$ %)* +%$,#,-& 3)D/:)#&$2A


17/20

EL

1/%2# Q:%$* ,) H%$#,D:7%$A B9& $&-%,),)' $&2#$,D#,/)2 D/:7* I& 7,E#&* 7%#&$ ,) #9& (&%$ #/

-%$h #9& D&7&I$%#,/)2 /E #9& #0&)#, %)),4&$2%$( /E #9& )/$-%7,c%#,/) /E *,H7/-%#,D

$&7%#,/)2 I&&) #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 %)* ],)%-A

],)%- $&D&)#7( V/,)&* #9& .$/7,E&$%#,/) "&D:$,#( \),#,%#,4&A B9,2 H$/4,*&2 %)

/HH/$#:),#( E/$ #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 #/ %22,2# ],)%- E:$#9&$ *&4&7/H ,#2 D%H%D,#( E/$

-%$,#,-& */-%,) %0%$&)&22A B9& LA"A 29/:7* &)D/:$%'& ],)%- #/ H:$D9%2& #9& .Of

Y$,/) )%4%7 $&D/))%,22%)D& %,$D$%E# %)*8 ,) $&2H/)2& #/ %)( E:$#9&$ *&$,/$%#,/) ,) #9&

2&D:$,#( &)4,$/)-&)# ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%8 %:#9/$,c& #9& 2%7& /E %)#,O29,H %)* %)#,O

2:I-%$,)& -,22,7&2A

\) %**,#,/)8 Z%H%) ,2 D:$$&)#7( H$/4,*,)' H%#$/7 I/%#2 %)* /#9&$ -%#&$,%7 %22,2#%)D& #/

#9& .9,7,HH,)&2 %)* ],)%- #/ ,-H$/4& #9&,$ D%H%D,#,&2 E/$ -%$,#,-& 2&D:$,#(A @:2#$%7,%

9%2 %72/ */)%#&* #0/ 9&%4( 7%)*,)' D$%E# #/ #9& .9,7,HH,)&2A B9& LA"A 2#%#&2 29/:7*

D//$*,)%#& 0,#9 Z%H%) %)* @:2#$%7,% :)*&$ #9& :-I$&77% /E #9& B$,7%#&$%7 "#$%#&',D

^,%7/':& #/ &)9%)D& #9&,$ -%$,#,-& */-%,) %0%$&)&22 %22,2#%)D& #/ $&',/)%7 2#%#&2A

@72/8 #9&$& ,2 2D/H& E/$ &)D/:$%',)' &)9%)D&* -:7#,7%#&$%7 D//$*,)%#,/) %)*D//H&$%#,/) %-/)' @"3@6 2#%#&2 ,) I:,7*,)'O:H #9&,$ D%H%D,#( E/$ -%$,#,-& */-%,)

%0%$&)&22A

?A S/0 #/ 9&7H $&',/)%7 H%$#)&$2 &)9%)D& #9&,$ /0) D%H%D,#(A

B9& LA"A %7$&%*( 9%2 /) #9& I//h2 2&4&$%7 H$/'$%- *&2,')&* #/ &)9%)D& #9& D%H%D,#( /E

$&',/)%7 2&D:$,#( H%$#)&$2 P&A'A 1//H&$%#,/) @E7/%# %)* G&%*,)&22 %)* B$%,),)' /$

1@G@BRA B9&2& 29/:7* I& E:)*&* %)* D/)#,):&*A ;/$ &J%-H7&8 #9& L),#&* "#%#&2 %)*

],)%- %7$&%*( 9%4& %) %'$&&-&)# E/$ D//H&$%#,/) I&&) #9&,$ 1/%2# Q:%$*28 I:#

#9,2 &)#%,72 #$%,),)' /) 7%)* ,) #9& E/$- /E 29/$# D/:$2&2A LA"AO],)%- D//H&$%#,/) )/0

)&&*2 #/ -/4& /EE29/$& ,) #9& E/$- /E V/,)# #$%,),)' &J&$D,2&2 #9%# '$%*:%77( &JH%)*

#9&,$ 2D/H& E$/- 2&%$D9 %)* $&2D:& #/ %)#,OH,$%D( *$,772 %)* -%$,#,-& 2:$4&,77%)D&H%#$/72A

B9& H:$H/2& /E #9,2 )%4%7 ,)#&$%D#,/) ,2 #/ I:,7* :H #$:2# #/ $&%D9 #9& 2#%'& 09&$& I/#9

2,*&2 D%) %'$&& #/ &JD9%)'& /I2&$4&$2 /) &%D9 /#9&$F2 29,H2 %)* H%#$/7 %,$D$%E#A \),#,%77(

#9,2 &JD9%)'& D/:7* #%h& H7%D& *:$,)' H7%))&* #$%,),)' &J&$D,2&2K /4&$ #,-& ,# D/:7* 7&%*

#/ #9& D$/22 H/2#,)' /E 1/%2# Q:%$* /EE,D&$2 E/$ 7/)'&$ *&H7/(-&)#2A Z/,)# H%#$/72 29/:7*

I& D%$$,&* /:# &,#9&$ ,) #9& 33bF2 /E 7,##/$%7 2#%#&2 /$ /) #9& 9,'9 2&%2 #9%# %$& 0,#9,)

19,)%F2 ),)&O*%29 7,)&A

B9,2 -/*&7 D/:7* I& &JH%)*&* #/ ,)D7:*& 2,-,7%$ %D#,4,#,&2 I&&) #9& LA"A %)*

.9,7,HH,)& 1/%2# Q:%$*28 #9& Z%H%)&2& %)* .9,7,HH,)& 1/%2# Q:%$*28 %)* #9& .9,7,HH,)&2%)* ],)%-&2& 1/%2# Q:%$*2A Y4&$ #,-& #9&2& I,7%#&$%7 %$$%)'&-&)#2 D/:7* I&

&JH%)*&* #/ #$,7%#&$%7 /$ &4&) -:7#,7%#&$%7 &J&$D,2&2A 19,)% 0/:7* I& D/)E$/)#&* 0,#9

#9& :)D&$#%,)#( /E *,$&D#7( D9%77&)',)' 4&22&72 D/)#%,),)' -%$,#,-& /EE,D,%72 E$/- #9&

L),#&* "#%#&2 %)*`/$ ,#2 #$&%#( %77,&2A B9,2 D/:7* ,)4/74&8 E/$ &J%-H7&8 #9& *&H7/(-&)# /E

LA"A %)* Z%H%)&2& 1/%2# Q:%$* H&$2/))&7 /) 1/%2# Q:%$* 4&22&72 /H&$%#&* I( #9&

.9,7,HH,)&2 %)* ],)%-A \# D/:7* %72/ ,)4/74& % -,J /E ;,7,H,)/ %)* ],)%-&2& -%$,#,-&

&)E/$D&-&)# H&$2/))&7 D$/22OH/2#&* #/ #9&,$ $&2H&D#,4& 1/%2# Q:%$*2A


18/20

EJ

B9& LA"A 1/%2# Q:%$* 9%2 7,-,#&* $&2/:$D&2 #/ &JH%)* '$&%#7( ,#2 &J#&$)%7 2:HH/$# #/

%22,2# "/:#9&%2# @2,%) D/:)#$,&2 ,) -%$,#,-& D%H%D,#( I:,7*,)'A B9,2 27%Dh )&&*2 #/ I&

#%h&) :H I( #9& LA"A 6%4(A

"&)%#/$ +D1%,)F2 H$/H/2&* "/:#9&%2# @2,% +%$,#,-& ":$4&,77%)D& \),#,%#,4& H$/4,*&2

E:)*,)' E/$ #9& H$/4,2,/) /E &l:,H-&)#8 2:HH7,&28 #$%,),)'8 2-%77O2D%7& -,7,#%$(

D/)2#$:D#,/) %)* #$%,),)' #/ -,),2#$(8 %'&)D( %* 9&%*l:%$#&$2O7&4&7 /$'%),c%#,/)2 E/$

$&',/)%7 -,7,#%$( E/$D&2A B9& ,),#,%#,4& H$/4,*&2 $%#9&$ -/*&2# E:)*,)' &2H&D,%77( 09&) ,#

0,77 I& *,2#$,I:#&* #/ E,4& D/:)#$,&2 /4&$ % E,4&O(&%$ H&$,/*A B9,2 ,2 % 0&7D/-& ,),#,%#,4&8

I:# ,# 29/:7* I& 4,&0&* %2 %) ,),#,%7 E,$2# 2#&HA

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* ,-H7&-&)# % D/-H$&9&)2,4& 2#$%#&'( ,)4/74,)' V/,)# %)*

D/-I,)&* D//H&$%#,/) I&&) D,4,7,%) -%$,#,-& %'&)D,&2 /E 7,h&-,)*&* &J#&$)%7

H/0&$2 %)* #9& .9,7,HH,)&2 %)* ],)%-A B9,2 2#$%#&'( 29/:7* I& D%$$,&* /:# /) #9$&&

7&4&725 %-/)' 7,h&O-,)*&* @"3@6 *,%7/':& H%$#)&$2 P@:2#$%7,%8 Z%H%)8 "/:#9 [/$&%8 6&0

b&%7%)*8 %)* \)*,%RK -:7#,7%#&$%77( 0,#9 $&',/)%7 %77,&2 %)* 2&D:$,#( H%$#)&$2K %)*

I,7%#&$%77(A

LA"A 6%4( -%$,#,-& 2:$4&,77%)D& %,$D$%E# I%2&* ,) #9& .9,7,HH,)&2 :)*&$ #9& $&D&)#

3)9%)D&* ^&E&)2& 1//H&$%#,/) @'$&&-&)# 9%4& /H&$%#&* E7,'9#2 0,#9 .9,7,HH,)&

-,7,#%$( /I2&$4&$2A B9,2 29/:7* I&D/-& 2#%)*%$* H$%D#,D&A LA"A 6%4( -%$,#,-&

2:$4&,77%)D& %,$D$%E# D/:7* I& *&H7/(&* /4&$ #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&% %)* 7%)* ,) ],)%- /)

% #&-H/$%$( I%2,2 I&E/$& $:$),)' #/ #9&,$ 9/-& I%2& ,) #9& .9,7,HH,)&2A LA"A -%$,#,-&

H%#$/7 %,$D$%E# %72/ D/:7* D/)*:D# V/,)# -%$,#,-& 2:$4&,77%)D& -,22,/)2 0,#9 #9&,$ ;,7,H,)/

%)* ],)%-&2& D/:)#&$H%$#2A LA"A -,7,#%$( H&$2/))&7 D/:7* E7( /) .9,7,HH,)&2 %)*

],)%-&2& $&D/))%,22%)D& H7%)&2 %2 /I2&$4&$2 %)* 4,D& 4&$2%A

kA @**,#,/)%7 *,H7/-%#,D &)'%'&-&)# 0,#9 @"3@6 D/:)#$,&2 /$ /#9&$2 ,) #9&

,)#&$)%#,/)%7 D/--:),#( #/ 2:HH/$# :),-H&*&* %DD&22 #/ #9& \)*/O.%D,E,D -%$,#,-&D/--/)2A

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* D/)#,):& #/ H$/4,*& *,H7/-%#,D %)* H/7,#,D%7 2:HH/$# #/ @"3@6

,) ,#2 %##&-H#2 #/ ' 19,)% #/ ,-H7&-&)# #9&


19/20

E6

B9& L),#&* "#%#&2 29/:7* D/)#,):& #/ 2:HH/$# ,#2 #0/ #$,7%#&$%7 2&D:$,#( *,%7/':&2 PLA"AO

Z%H%)O@:2#$%7,% %)* LA"AOZ%H%)O\)*,%R8 #/ D//$*,)%#& -%$,#,-& 2&D:$,#( H/7,D( #/0%$*2

#9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A B9& LA"A 29/:7* H$/-/#& #9& &JH%)2,/) %)* -&$'&$ /E #9&2& #0/

#$,7%#&$%7 *,%7/':&2 ,)#/ /)& l:%*$,7%#&$%7 E$%-&0/$h #/ I#&$ D//$*,)%#& -%$,#,-&

2&D:$,#( D//H&$%#,/) 0,#9 @"3@6 %2 0&77 %2 ,)*,4,*:%7 "/:#9&%2# @2,%) 2#%#&2A

T,7* 1%$*2

B9&$& %$& %# 7&%2# &,'9# 0,7* D%$*2 #9%# D/:7* %D# #/ H/2,#,4&7( /$ )&'%#,4&7( ,)E7:&)D& %

)&0 LA"A D/-H$&9&)2,4& 2#$%#&'( #/ %**$&22 19,)%F2 D/)2#$:D#,/) %D#,4,#,&2 ,) #9& "/:#9

19,)% "&%5

>A B9& $&D&)# *&E&%# ,) 1/)'$&22 /E B$%*& .$/-/#,/) @:#9/$,#( E/$ .$&2,*&)# YI%-%

D/:7* 2H&77 #9& &)* /E 9,2 &EE/$#2 #/ 2&D:$& % B$%)2O.%D,E,D .%$#)&$29,H %'$&&-&)#

I&E/$& 9,2 #&$- ,) /EE,D& &JH,$&2A ",)'%H/$&F2 ;/$&,') +,),2#&$ "9%)-:'%)

$&2H/)*&* #/ #9,2 *&4&7/H-&)# I( /-,)/:27( 0%$),)' #9%# MLA"A D$&*,I,7,#( ,) @2,%

0,77 2:EE&$8 %)* %77,&2 0,77 %'%,) 0/)*&$ 09&$ YI%-%F2 %22:$%)D& #9%# #9& L),#&*

"#%#&2 0,77 $&-%,) %) &22&)#,%7 .%D,E,D H/0&$ %)* ':%$%)#/$ /E 2&D:$,#( ,) #9& $&',/)0,77 I& E:7E,77&*AN "9%)-:'%) D/)D7:*&*8 Mi/: n#9& L),#&* "#%#&2o %$& &,#9&$ ,) /$ (/:

%$& /:#AN


20/20

EG

dA \) 6/4&-I&$ k #9& LA"A 0,77 &7&D# % )&0 H$&2,*&)#A \# ,2 :)D7&%$ 09/ #9& -%,)

D%)*,*%#&2 0,77 I& %)* 09&$ 09/&4&$ ,2 &7&D#&* 0,77 D/)#,):& #/ 2:HH/$# #9&

$&I%7%)D& #/ @2,% ',4&) #9& H:77 /E 2&D:$,#( ,22:&2 ,) #9& +,**7& 3%2# %)* 3:$/H& P%)*

#9& H/22,I7& E%,7:$& #/ 2&D:$& % B..RA

eA "/-,-& ,) #9& E,$2# 9%7E /E k #9& L6 @$I,#$%7 B$,I:)%7 ,2 2D9&*:7&* #/ $&%D9 %

*&$-,)%#,/) /) #9& .9,7,HH,)&2F D7%,- P%22:-,)' #9%# #9& @$I,#$%7 B$,I:)%7 #%h&2 :H

#9& D%2&RA L)*&$ L61XY" ,#2 *&D,2,/)2 -:2# I& &)E/$D&* ,--&*,%#&7( %)* %$& )/#

2:IV&D# #/ %HH&%7A T,)8 7//2& /$ *$%0 #9& *&$-,)%#,/) /E #9& @$I,#$%7 B$,I:)%7 0,77

%7#&$ #9& 7&'%7 7%)*2D%H& 0,#9 $&2H&D# #/ *,2H:#&2 ,) #9& "/:#9 19,)% "&%A

Thayer Strategy and Maritime Power in a Contested Environment: National, Military, Maritime Strategy in the South China Sea

Documents