7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
1/30
ANALISA LOKASI KERUANGAN(RP09-1209)
Teori Weber :
Ind us t r ial Loc at ion Theory
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
2/30
Classic Industrial Location
Key Issues Transportation Costs Production Costs
Inputs (ubiquitous v. place -based) Labor
- Agglomeration and De-agglomeration
PENDEKATANBIAYA LOKASITERKECIL
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
3/30
Webers Theory of the Location of Industries In 1909 the German location economist Alfred Weber formulated atheory of industrial location in his book entitled ber den Standort der Industrien (Theory of the Location of Industries, 1929).Weber 's theory , called the location triangle, sought the optimumlocation for the production of a good based on the fixed locations of themarket and two raw material sources, which geographically form atriangle.He sought to determine the least-cost production location within thetriangle by figuring the total costs of transporting raw material from bothsites to the production site and product from the production site to themarket.The weight of the raw materials and the final commodity are importantdeterminants of the transport costs and the location of production.Commodities that lose mass during production can be transported lessexpensively from the production site to the market than from the rawmaterial site to the production site.The production site, therefore, will be located near the raw materialsources. Where there is no great loss of mass during production, totaltransportation costs will be lower when located near the market.
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
4/30
ASUMSI TEORI WEBER 1. UNIT STUDI TERISOLASI, HOMOGEN, KONSUMEN
TERPUSAT DI TITIK TERTENTU, SEMUA UNITPERUSAHAAN DAPAT MEMASUKI PASAR YANGTIDAK TERBATAS (PERSAINGAN SEMPURNA).
2. SUMBER DAYA ALAM: AIR, PASIR, LEMPUNG,TERSEDIA DI MANA-MANA (UBIQUITOUS )
3. BAHAN LAINNYA SEPERTI MINERAL DAN BIJIBESI TERSEDIA TERBATAS PADA SEJUMLAHTEMPAT (SPORADIS)
4. TENAGA KERJA TIDAK TERSEDIA SECARA LUAS,MENGELOMPOK PADA BEBERAPA LOKASI DANMOBILITASNYA TERBATAS.
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
5/30
Konsep Weber
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
6/30
KONSEP INI DIJELASKAN DENGAN MENGGUNAKANSEGITIGA LOKASIONAL, DI MANA LOKASIOPTIMUM (P) ADALAH KESEIMBANGAN ANTARA KEKUATAN YANG DITIMBULKAN OLEH SUMBER
BAHAN BAKU (INPUT 1 DAN INPUT 2) DAN TITIK PASAR (MARKET).
UNTUK MENGETAHUI APAKAH LOKASI OPTIMUMLEBIH DEKAT KE SUMBER INPUT ATAU PASAR,DIGUNAKANINDEX BAHAN, YAITUPERBANDINGANBERAT INPUT BAHAN LOKALDENGANBERAT PRODUK AKHIR.
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
7/30
Perhitungan Indeks Bahan (IB)
IB = ----------------------------Bobot Bahan Baku LokalBobot Produk Akhir
Keterangan:
-IB > 1, perusahaan akan berlokasi dekat ke bahan baku,-IB < 1, perusahaan akan berlokasi dekat ke pasar
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
8/30
Isotim & Isodapane
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
9/30
ISOTIMS
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
10/30
ISODAPAN
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
11/30
Other Concerns
Spatial Division of Labor No just cost but skills too
Quality of Life
Institutional Supports Economies of Scale & Scope
Agglomeration & localization
Site & Situation Neo-traditional issues
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
12/30
FAKTOR LOKASI MENURUT ALFRED WEBER (1909)
BERDASARKAN KELAZIMAN YG TERJADI
BERLAKU UMUM DAN PRAKTIS UNTUK SETIAP KEGIATANINDUSTRI (BIAYA TRANSPORT, BIAYA TENAGA KERJA, BIAYA LAHAN, ETC.)
BERLAKU KHUSUS DAN HANYA TERJADI PADA KEGIATAN
TERTENTU PADA BOBOT (BAHAN MENTAH DAN PRODUK MUDAH BUSUK, KELEMBABAN UDARA, ALIRAN AIR)
BERDASARKAN PENGARUH RUANG
FAKTOR REGIONAL DIMANA INDUSTRI TERTARIK PADA ASPEK GEOGRAFIS TERTENTU, JARINGAN UTAMA ORIENTASI
INDUSTRI (KETERSEDIAAN LAHAN, SIMPUL TRANSPORTASI,TEMPAT BONGKAR-MUAT, PELABUHAN)
FAKTOR REGIONAL YANG MURNI EKONOMI ADALAH HARGA BAHAN BAKU, BIAYA TENAGA KERJA, BIAYA TRANSPORT
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
13/30
LANJUTAN WEBER
FAKTOR AGLOMERASI/DEGLOMERASI DIMANA DALAMJARINGAN UTAMANYA TIDAK TERGANTUNG PADA ORIENTASI GEOGRAFIS, ANTAR INDUSTRI SALING TERKAIT
ATAU SALING BERJAUHAN (MENEKAN HARGA MELALUIPRODUKSI MASSAL, PENGGUNAAN MESIN YG LEBIH BAIK
(INTERNAL FAKTOR), KETERSEDIAAN BANTUAN(EKSTERNAL FAKTOR)
BERDASARKAN SIFAT DAN KEADAAN
FAKTOR ALAMIAH DAN TEKNIS: POSISI DAN IKLIM,TINGKAT UPAH (UMR), KUALITAS TENAGA KERJA
FAKTOR SOSIAL BUDAYA: TINGKAT SUKU BUNGA, TINGKATPENDIDIKAN, TINGKAT KINERJA
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
14/30
FAKTOR LOKASI UNTUK KEGIATAN INDUSTRIFAKTOR LOKASI DARI SISI MAKRO
TRANSPORTASIJARAK TERHADAP PEMASOK, KONSUMENKETERSEDIAAN KOMUNIKASI (POS, BANK, TELKOM, ETC)POSISI TERHADAP JARINGAN JALAN (ARTERI, KOLEKTOR, TOL)POSISI TERHADAP JARINGAN KERETA API & TERMINAL CONTAINER POSISI TERHADAP KANAL, ANGKUTAN SUNGAI & PENYEBERANGANPOSISI TERHADAP BANDARA, PELABUHAN
TENAGA KERJA KETERSEDIAAN TENAGA KERJA KEMAMPUAN/KETERAMPILAN (PROFESIONAL, TUKANG, BURUH)UPAH TENAGA KERJA TEMPAT PELATIHAN TENAGA KERJA (BLK)KONDISI SOSIAL BUDAYA MASYARAKAT SETEMPAT
IKLIM (TEMPERATUR, KELEMBABAN, CURAH HUJAN, ETC.)PAJAK, RETRIBUSI, PUNGUTAN, INSENTIF
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
15/30
LANJUTAN
FAKTOR LOKASI DARI SISI MIKROLAHANLAYANAN TRANSPORTASIPENYEDIAAN ENERGI
KELISTRIKAN (TEGANGAN, KINERJA, GARDU INDUK, BIAYA SAMB.)GAS (JENIS PELAYANAN, JARING DISTRIBUSI, HARGA, BIAYA SAMB.)
BATUBARA PENYEDIAAN AIR BERSIH
LAYANAN JARINGAN PDAM (SAMBUNGAN, KINERJA, SUMBER AIR,HARGA JUAL)PENGGUNAAN AIR TANAH (KUALITAS, KUANTITAS)
PENGOLAHAN LIMBAH CAIR PENGELOLAAN LIMBAH PADATKEGIATAN USAHA YG BERDEKATAN
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
16/30
PERTIMBANGAN DALAM PEMILIHAN LOKASIINDUSTRI
LOCATION OF RESOURCES & MARKETSCHANGING DEMAND FOR PRODUCTS
TRANSPORTATION COSTS FOR ASSEMBLY & DISTRIBUTION
VARIATIONS IN MANUFACTURING COSTS; PRINCIPALLY INLABOR COST, BUT ALSO IN LAND COST, COSTS OFHEATING & COOLING THE PLANT, DISPOSAL OF WASTE,
AND CORPORATE & INVENTORY TAXES
SCALE OF OPERATIONS
TECHNIQUES OF PRODUCTION
LABOR-INTENSIVE OR CAPITAL INTENSIVE AVAILABILITY OF CAPITAL
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
17/30
LANJUTAN PEMILIHAN LOKASI INDUSTRI
GOVERNMENTAL POLICY THAT SERVES TO ENCOURAGEINDUSTRY TO LOCATE IN SPECIAL AREAS BY GUARANTEEING MARKETS, PROVIDING LAND AND/ OR TRAINED EMPLOYEES & TAX REDUCTIONS
AGGLOMERATION ECONOMIES ACHIEVED THROUGH
AVAILABILITY OF SPECIALIZED SERVICES & INTER-INDUSTRY LINKAGES BETWEEN SUPPLIERS & CUSTOMERSWITHIN SPECIALIZED MANUFACTURING REGIONS
AMENITY FACTORS, SUCH AS SUPERIOR SCHOOLS, OR LOCATION ADJACENT TO COLLEGE OR UNIVER-SITY,WHICH OFFERS POOL OF PROSPECTIVE EMPLOYEES. MILDCLIMATE, CULTURAL AMENITIES, AND SUBURBANLOCATIONS ARE ESPECIALLY TO MANAGEMENT
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
18/30
VARIABEL LOKASI INDUSTRI
MATERIALSMANUFACTURINGPROCESS (V.A)
PRODUCTIONFACTORS
INPUT
PRODUCT MARKET
OUTPUT
ASSEMBLY COSTS DISTRIBUTIONCOSTS
TRANSPORTATION INPUTS
TECHNIQUE SCALE
LOCATION
3 MAJOR
DECISIONS
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
19/30
LOKASI ALTERNATIF
ASUMSI: SEMUA ELEMEN SAMA, KECUALI TRANSP. COST
PROPORSIONAL THD JARAK, MAKA LOKASI ALTERNATIFPADA RAW MATERIAL SITE, MARKET, OR ANYPLACE INBETWEEN
KASUS 1: SEMUA LOKASI DAPAT DIPILIH TANPA MENINGKATKAN TRANSP. COST.
MATERIALSOURCE MARKET
C O S T
TOTAL COST
DC = DISTR. COST
AC = ASSEMBLY COST
DISTANCE
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
20/30
LOKASI ALTERNATIF (LANJUTAN)
KASUS 2: BILA ASSEMBLY COST MENINGKAT LEBIH CEPATDIBANDING DISTRIBUTION COST, LOKASI PADA TEMPATPRODUKSI LEBIH MENGUNTUNGKAN, CONTOH INDUSTRIPENGALENGAN BUAH-BUAHAN.
MATERIALSOURCE MARKET
C O S T
DC = DISTR. COST
AC = ASSEMBLY COST
DISTANCE
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
21/30
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
22/30
LOKASI ALTERNATIF (LANJUTAN)
KASUS 4: TRANSPORT COST INCREASES UNLINEAR. THERE
ARE ALSO LOADING & UNLOADING COSTS TO CONSIDER.CITIES AT THE BREAK POINT IN TRANSHIPMENT (RIVER,PORT, RAILROAD) GAINED ADVANTAGE BECAUSE OF COSTIN TRANSFERRING GOODS & OPPORTUNITIES FOR MANUFACTURING. CONTOH INDUSTRI TEPUNG TERIGU
MATERIALSOURCE MARKET
C O S T
TOTAL COST
DC = DISTR. COST
AC = ASSEMBLY COST
DISTANCE
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
23/30
LOKASI ALTERNATIF (LANJUTAN)
KASUS 5: COMPLICATE PROBLEM BY INTRODUCING THIRD
PLACE WITH ADVANTAGE OF CHEAPER LABOR OR POWER SOURCE. RAW MATERIAL SOURCE IS CENTRALIZED. ASSEMBLY COST INCREASE TO MARKET, OR LOW-COSTPROCESSING PLACE. EXAMPLE LOCATION OF ELECTRONICPLANT
MATERIALSOURCE MARKET
C O S T
TOTAL COST
D.C.
A.C.
DC = DISTR. COST
AC = ASSEMBLY COST
DISTANCE
P.C.PC = PROCESS COST
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
24/30
KLASIFIKASI INDUSTRI
RESOURCE ORIENTATION: UTILIZE BULKY OR PERISHABLE RAWMATERIAL NORMALLY SEEK LOCATION CLOSE TO SOURCE OFRAW MATERIAL. EXPL. MINING INDUSTRIES, FRUIT CANNING
MARKET ORIENTATION: LOCATION OF MARKET-ORIENTED
INDUSTRIES HAVING HIGH DISTRIBUTION COST IS POSITIVELY CORRELATED WITH LOCATION OF POPULATION.EXPL. PRINTING INDUSTRIES, OFFICE EQUIPMENT & SUPPLIES
OPTIONAL ORIENTATION: INDUSTRIES CAN BE EITHER MARKETOR RESOURCE ORIENTED BECAUSE OF ABILITY TO REARRANGE(EXCHANGE) TECHNIQUE PRODUCTION TO MAXIMIZEPROFITABILITY OF ALTERNATIVE LOCATION
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
25/30
CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRY BY LOCATIONALORIENTATION
Market
Market Market
Marketoptional
Marketoptional
Optionalmarket
Optionalmarket
Resource
Resource
DISTRIBUTION COST
High Medium Low
Medium
Low
High
A S S E M B L Y C O S T
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
26/30
REFERENSI Dedi NS Setiono [2011], Ekonomi PengembanganWilayah: Teori dan Analisis , Lembaga PenerbitFE-UI, JakartaRustiadi, Ernan, et.al. [2009], Perencanaan danPengembangan Wilayah , Crestpent Press danYayasan Obor Indonesia, JakartaSjafrizal [2008], Ekonomi Regional: Teori dan
Aplikasi , Baduose Media, PadangTarigan, Robinson [2006], Ekonomi Regional:Teori dan Aplikasi , Edisi Revisi, Bumi Aksara,JakartaKrumme,(http://faculty.washington.edu/krumme/450/weber.html)
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
27/30
Alfred Weber and Subsequent Developments in Industrial Location Theory (http://faculty.washington.edu/krumme/450/weber.html)
1. Why are we interested in Weberian Triangles?Objectives of deriving Weberian principles andleast-cost location theory.
2. Setting up the theoretical model: the constraints
(assumptions)1. the "objective function" for this "normative" model1. starting with transport cost minimization2. overall cost minimization3. profit maximization
2. Assumptions related to organization and, importantly, toproduction process and production function [the initialWeber model is based on linear production relations withno scale economies and no input substitution; "Leontief-type production function".
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
28/30
Alfred Weber and Subsequent Developments
3. Assumptions related to inputs used in the
production process1. Inputs are available in unlimited supply at given (fixed)prices independent of location
2. These material inputs are either localized at a limitednumber of locations or ubiquitously available ( =
everywhere).3. "pure" versus weight-losing materials4. competitive price formation on markets for inputs
(input prices are independent of production levels)
4. Assumptions related to markets1. Demand is fixed and concentrated at a limited number
of (known) locations (points)2. competitive price formation (given prices at market, i.e.
prices are independent of production levels)
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
29/30
Alfred Weber and Subsequent Developments
5. Assumptions related to thetransportation process and transportcosts.
Transport is possible in any direction, andtransport costs for materials or products arelinear, i.e. directly proportional to weight anddistance, implying a "flat plain" and anabsence of networks and distance & scaleeconomies in transportation.
7/22/2019 Teori Weber - Industrial Location Theory
30/30
SEKIAN DAN TERIMA KASIH