Top Banner
PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS by Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE Principal Kramer Gehlen & Associates, Inc. Vancouver, WA 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE © Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 1 of 35
35

Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

Jul 02, 2018

Download

Documents

doliem
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS               CAUSES AND REPAIRS

by

Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

Principal

Kramer Gehlen & Associates, Inc.

Vancouver, WA

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 1 of 35

Page 2: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

KGA projects 

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 2 of 35

Page 3: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

OVERVIEW

• Post – Tension Flat Plate Structures – Unbonded Monostrand

• Robust Structural System

• Millions of square feet of construction each year

• Problems can occur – during and after construction is completed

• Repairs can be done

• Designers/Contractors can learn from past problems

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 3 of 35

Page 4: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Presentation Covers:

• 4 types of Problems

• Examples – Case studies

• Causes

• Repairs

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 4 of 35

Page 5: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

PROBLEM TYPES

Type 1 ‐ Anchorage Zone Blowouts

Type 2 ‐ Internal Slab Blowouts

Type 3 ‐ Tendon Eruption

Type 4 ‐ Surface Spalls at Tendons

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 5 of 35

Page 6: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Type 1  ANCHORAGE ZONE BLOWOUT

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 6 of 35

Page 7: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 7 of 35

Page 8: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 8 of 35

Page 9: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 9 of 35

Page 10: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 10 of 35

Page 11: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Possible Causes

‐ Lack of bursting reinforcing steel‐ Bursting reinforcing steel misplaced(laying on the side or 

too far away)‐ Low strength concrete‐ Voids or rock pockets in concrete‐ Offset anchorages allowing a head in the anchorage zone 

of another.‐ Inadequate confining steel in thin slabs‐ Tendons located at a slab corner without adequate 

confining reinforcing

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 11 of 35

Page 12: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

REPAIRS

• Safety ‐ detensioning

• Investigation

• Evaluation

• Cleaning – chipping away to sound concrete

• New anchorage heads

• Adequate Confinement

• Replace concrete and restress

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 12 of 35

Page 13: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Type 2 ‐ INTERNAL SLAB BLOWOUTS

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 13 of 35

Page 14: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 14 of 35

Page 15: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 15 of 35

Page 16: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 16 of 35

Page 17: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Causes

• Sharp tendon sweeps/near surface

• Inadequate confinement

• Stage Stressing not done

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 17 of 35

Page 18: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Repairs:

• Investigation ‐ Evaluation

• Situation Specific

• Repair in‐place or completely rebuild

• Extent of tendon damage

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 18 of 35

Page 19: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Type 3 – Tendon Eruption

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 19 of 35

Page 20: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 20 of 35

Page 21: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 21 of 35

Page 22: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Causes

• Anchorage slip

• Corrosion – tendon breakage

• Saw cutting or drilling

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 22 of 35

Page 23: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Repairs

• Investigation – Evaluation

• Often is neglected if only (1) tendon

• Replace tendon with 3/8” diameter tendons

• Patch Concrete

• Mitigate penetration of water

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 23 of 35

Page 24: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Type 4 – Surface Spalls

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 24 of 35

Page 25: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 25 of 35

Page 26: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 26 of 35

Page 27: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 27 of 35

Page 28: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 28 of 35

Page 29: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 29 of 35

Page 30: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Causes

• During construction – reverse curvature

• Possible voids

• Sometimes unknown

• Post‐Construction ‐ water

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 30 of 35

Page 31: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Repairs

• Investigation – Evaluation

• Corrosion

• Mitigate water Problem

• Clean and patch

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 31 of 35

Page 32: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 32 of 35

Page 33: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 33 of 35

Page 34: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Summary

• Robust system – but problems can occur

• Most causes are identifiable, but not always

• Repairs can be made

• Details, Details, Details.

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 34 of 35

Page 35: Tendon Blowouts and Eruptions, Causes and Repairs Convention... · 2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas ... pockets in concrete ...

PTI 2009 Technical Conference & Exhibit – Portland, OR

Thank You!

2009 PTI Technical Conference TENDON BLOWOUTS AND ERUPTIONS CAUSES AND REPAIRS Douglas Sarkkinen, PE, SE

© Copyright Post-Tensioning Institute all rights reserved. Page 35 of 35