Top Banner
TAP Temporal Analysis of Products SSITKA Steady State Isotopic Transient Kinetic Analysis Modern Methods in Heterogeneous Catalysis Cornelia Breitkopf, 14.11.2003 Universität Leipzig, Institut für Technische Chemie
91

TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Jul 28, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAPTemporal Analysis of Products

SSITKA Steady State Isotopic Transient

Kinetic Analysis

Modern Methods in Heterogeneous Catalysis

Cornelia Breitkopf, 14.11.2003Universität Leipzig, Institut für Technische Chemie

Page 2: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Transient methods are a powerful tool for gaining insights into the mechanisms of

complex catalytic reactions.

Page 3: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Outline

• Microkinetic modeling• Laboratory reactors• Background

Diffusion, mathematics• TAP

System hardware, theory, examples• SSITKA

Theory, examples

Page 4: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Macrokinetics and Microkinetics

Page 5: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Kinetic measurements

Complexity of heterogeneously catalyzed reactions –Macrokinetics and Microkinetics

O. Deutschmann, XXXIV. Jahrestreffen Deutscher Katalytiker/ Fachtreffen Reaktionstechnik, Weimar 21.-23.3.2001

Page 6: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Microkinetic modeling

J.A.Dumesic

„Microkinetic analysis is an examination of catalytic reactions in terms of elementary chemical reactionselementary chemical reactionsthat occur on the catalyst surfacesurface and their relationrelationwith each other and with the surface during acatalytic circle.“

Review article: P. Stoltze

Page 7: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Microkinetic model development

Surface science studies

Microkinetic model

Reactor model

Comparison of expe-riment and simulation

Tentative surface reaction mechanism

AnalogiesAb initiocalculations

TST, collision theory

Steady-state kinetics

Transient experiments

Optimization of kinetic parameters, sensitivity analysis

Page 8: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Kinetic measurements

Tasks of laboratory investigations of heterogeneous catalytic processes

o catalyst preparation

o catalyst screening

o activity

o selectivity

o stability

o scale-up

o process optimization

Complex reaction

o species

o reaction mechanism

o reaction kinetics

Laboratory reactors

o microcatalytic pulse r.

o gaschromatographic r.

o single pellet diffusion r.

o catalytic fixed bed r.

o recycle r.

o ( TAP )

Page 9: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Kinetic investigations

• Steady-state or unsteady-state experiment ?• Quantitative evaluation of kinetic data ?

Constructing of amathematical model

Evaluation of the reaction mechanism

Parameter estimation

How to do…?

Page 10: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Steady-state experiments

• Most common reaction technique used inheterogeneous catalysis

• Achieved by operation such that temperature,pressure, concentration, and flow rate at anypoint in the reactor is time invariant

• Access to activity, selectivity, reaction order, activation energy

Page 11: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Steady-state experiments

• Advantages:- Easy to build and operate- Results can be described with mathematical

models based on algebraic equations - Most industrial processes are operated under

steady-state conditions

• Disadvantages:- Provide global kinetic parameters, limited

information on individual reaction steps- Interpretations often based on „simple“

assumptions

Page 12: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Unsteady-state experiments

• Transient techniques provide information on

- Reaction intermediates (pulse response) (Gleaves 1988)

- Reaction sequence in a multistep reaction (Kobayashi 1975)

- Rate constants of elementary steps (Ertl 1979, Creten 1995)

Page 13: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Unsteady-state experiments

• Transient techniques provide information on

- Investigation of complex kinetic phenomena(oscillating chemical reactions, hysteresis)that are not observable under steady-state conditions

- Probe of catalyst surfaces that are not easily observed under steady-state conditions (oxidation catalysis) (Haber 1983)

Page 14: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Unsteady-state experiments

• Disadvantages

- Not easy to build up, expensive

- Main problem: theory is very complex

Page 15: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Steady-state and transient methods

• measure overall performance

• give integrated picture of reaction system

• have minimum reactor residence time of 1 s

Steady-state methods

Transient methods

• give information on individual steps

• operate in millisecond time regime; resolution increase

Page 16: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Transient experiments

• Transients are introduced into a system by varying one or more state variables (p, T, c, flow)

- Temperature-programmed experiments temperature change

- Step change experiments concentration change

• Examples:

- Molecular beam experiments pressure change

Page 17: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – A transient technique

• The key feature which distinguishes it from other pulse experiments is that no carrier gas is used and, gas transport is the result of a pressure gradient.

• At low pulse intensities the total gas pressure is very small, and gas transport occurs via Knudsen diffusion only.

• Pulse residence time under vacuum conditions is much shorter than in conventional pulse experiments. Thus a high time resolution is achievable.

Page 18: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Microkinetic model development

Surface science studies

Microkinetic model

Reactor model

Comparison of expe-riment and simulation

Tentative surface reaction mechanism

AnalogiesAb initiocalculations

TST, collision theory

Steady-state kinetics

Transient experiments

Optimization of kinetic parameters, sensitivity analysis

Page 19: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Features• Extraction of kinetic parameters differs compared to

steady-state and surface science experiments

- Steady-state: kinetic information is extracted from the transport-kinetics data by experimentally eliminating effects of transport

- Surface science: gas phase is eliminated

- In TAP pulse experiments gas transport is not eliminated. The pulse response data provides in-formation on the transport and kinetic parameters.

Page 20: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Features

• TAP pulse experiments are state-defining

- Typical pulse contains ≈ 1013 moleculesor 1010 moles

- Example: § sample surface of 10 m2/g § a single pulse would be equivalent to 1/10000 of

the total surface per gram of sample§ conventional pulsed reactor experiments

address approximately 20 % of the surface per pulse

Page 21: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Background - Diffusion

Transport mechanisms in porous solids

Pore diffusion depending on pore diameter

Λ …mean free path length

w …mean velocity of molecule

wD free Λ=31

MRTdwdD ppKnudsen π

831

31

==

Page 22: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Background - Diffusion

Characterization of porous structures

• Porosity

• Pore radius, pore diameter• Pore radius distribution, -density

• Specific surface area• Tortuousity factor

kgm

mm 3

3

3

,mass- volume,total

volumepore

p

ppp

r

rpp dr

rHdrhrdrhrH

p

p

)()(;)()(

min,

== ∫

Page 23: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Background - DiffusionKnudsen diffusion

• mean free path length of molecule > pore diameterΛ …mean free path lengthσ2…molecular cross-sectionV… gas molar volume at p

• NA/V at 298 K : cges ≈ 3.1019 *p (molecules/cm3) (dimension of p 105 Pa)

• mean free path length with typical σ (9-20*10-16 cm2)

ANV

221πσ

)(102

nmp

≅Λ

Page 24: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Background - DiffusionKnudsen diffusion

• Knudsen flow through one zylindrical pore

• For porous solids, the relative pore volume εb and thetortuousity factor τK have to be considered

)01.0,293(1083

26

, MPaKats

mMRTd

D piK

−≈=π

MRTd

D p

K

PiK

eff

πτε 8

3, =

Page 25: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Background - Mathematics

• Delta function f(x) = δ (x-a)

- functional which acts on elements of a function

- integral

- multiplication with a function f(x)

yxforayxa

yaxdtat

y

x

<<<

<<

=−∫ ,01

)(δ

∫+∞

∞−

=− )()()( afdxaxxf δ

Page 26: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Background - Mathematics

• Delta function

- graphical representation as „Sprungfunktion“ (limes)

- graphical representation as „Pulsfunktion“

x

u(x-a)

1

a

)(sin)(

1lim)( axnax

axn

−−

=−∞→ π

δ

)()( axdx

axdu−=

−δ

1

x

u(t-a)

a

=−01

)( dtatδ

Page 27: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Background - Mathematics

• Laplace transformation- aim: transformation of differential and integral

expressions into algebraic expressions- definition

- examplesdttFesf ts )()(

0∫∞

−=

[ ]s

es

dteLsf tsts 111)(00

=−===∞

−∞

−∫

[ ]s

dteeeLsf ttst

−=== ∫

∞−

ααα 1)(

0

Page 28: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – System hardware

• Injection of a narrow gas pulse into an evacuated microreactor

• Gas pulses travel through the reactor• Gas molecules (reactant and product)

are monitored as a function of time and produce a transient response at the MS

Reaction zoneGas pulse Detector

Simplified schematic of a TAP pulse response experiment

Page 29: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – System hardware

Page 30: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – System hardware

Page 31: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – System hardware

1) High speed pulse valve2) Pulse valve manifold3) Microreactor4) Mass spectrometer5) Vacuum valve6) Manual flow valve7) Mosfet switch

Page 32: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Response curves

Typical pulse response experimental outputs

Page 33: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Multipulse experiment

• Key features of input:- typical pulse intensity range from 1013 to 1017

molecules/pulse- pulse width 150-250 µs- pulse rates 1-50 s-1

• Key features of output:- different products have different responses- individual product response can change with pulse number

Page 34: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Pump probe experiment

• Key features of input:- different reaction mixtures are introduced sequentially from separate pulse valves

• Key features of output:- output transient response spectrum coincides with both valve inputs

Page 35: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transient response data

In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantity in TAP pulse response experiments is the time dependent gas flowescaping from the outlet of the microreactor.

The outlet flow is measured with a MS (QMS) that detects individual components of the flow with great sensitivity.

The composition of the flow provides information on the types of chemical transformation in the microreactor.

The time dependence of the flow contains information on gas transport and kinetics.

Page 36: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Theory

Goal

• Interpretation of pulse response data- determine typical processes- find parameters for these processes- develop a model

• Analyzation of experiments that provide parameters of diffusion, irreversible adsorption or reaction and reversible reaction

Page 37: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – General models

Currently there are three basic models in application based on partial-differential equations.

- One-zone-model- Three-zone-model- Thin-zone-model

The mathematical framework for the one-zone-model was first published in 1988 (Gleaves).

Basic assumptions of one-zone-model:- catalyst and inert particle bed is uniform- no radial gradient of concentration in the bed- no temperature gradient (axial or radial)- diffusivity of each gas is constant

Page 38: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Gas transport model

The gas transport is the result of Knudsen diffusion.

An important characteristic of this tranport process is that the diffusivities of the individual components of a gas mixture are independent of the presssure or the compositionof the mixture.

2

22

1

11 T

MD

TM

D ee =De,i …effective Knudsen diffusivityMi …molecular weight Ti …temperature 1,2 …gas 1, gas 2

Page 39: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

2

2

zCD

tC A

eAA

b ∂∂

=∂

∂ε

(1) Diffusion only case –Mass balance for a non-reacting gas A transported by Knudsen diffusion

CA … concentration of gas A (mol/cm3)DeA … effective Knudsen diffusivity of

gas A (cm2/s)t … time (s)z … axial coordinate (cm)εb … fractional voidage of the packed

bed in the reactor

Page 40: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

initial conditions: 0 ≤ z ≤ L , t = 0 , A

NC

b

pAzA ε

δ=

boundary conditions: z = 0 ,

z = L ,

0=∂

∂z

CA

0=AC

The equation can be solved using different sets of initial and boundary conditions that correspond to different physical situations.

NpA … number of moles of gas A in one pulseA … cross-sectional area of the reactor (cm2)L … length of the reactor (cm)

Page 41: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

The gas flow at the reactor exit FA (mol/s) is described by

LzA

eAA zCDAF =∂

∂=

and the gas flux (mol/cm2 s) by

AFA=AFlux

To solve for the gas flow it is useful to express initial and boundary conditions in terms of dimensionless parameters.

Page 42: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - Transport model

Use of dimensionless parameters

… dimensionless axial coordinate

… dimensionless concentration

… dimensionless time

Lz

LANCC

bPA

AA ε

=

2LDt

b

eA

ετ =

Page 43: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

2

2

ξτ ∂∂

=∂

∂ AA CC initial conditions: 0 ≤ ξ ≤ 1 , t = 0 , ξδ=AC

boundary conditions: ξ = 0 ,ξ = 1 ,

0=∂

∂ξ

AC

0=AC

Dimensionless form of mass balance

Solution:- analytical a) method of separation of variables

b) Laplace transformation- numerical for more complex problems

Page 44: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

Method of separation of variables:

solution for dimensionless concentration

( ) ( )τππξτξ 22

0)5.0(exp)5.0(cos2),( +−+= ∑

=

nnCn

A

solution for dimensionless flow rate

( ) ( )τππξπξ

τξτξ 22

0)5.0(exp)5.0(sin)12(),(),( +−++=

∂∂

−= ∑∞

=

nnnCFn

AA

dimensionless flow rate at the exit (ξ=1)

( )τππ 22

0)5.0(exp)12()1( +−+−= ∑

=

nnFn

nA

Page 45: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

( )τππ 22

0)5.0(exp)12()1( +−+−= ∑

=

nnFn

nA

Expression for the dimensionless exit flow rate as a function of dimensionless time

Standard diffusion curve

For any TAP pulse response experiment that involves only gas transport, the plot of the dimensionless exit flow rateversus dimensionless time will give the same curveregardless the gas, reactor length, particle size, or reactor temperature.

Page 46: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

+−+−= ∑

=2

22

02 )5.0(exp)12()1(

LDtnn

LD

NF

b

eA

n

n

b

eA

pA

A

επ

επ

Due to initial condition the surface area under SDC is equal to unity – flow rate in dimensional form

An important property of this dimensional dependence is that its shape is independent on the pulse intensity if the process occurs in the Knudsen regime.

Page 47: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

+−+−= ∑

=2

22

02 )5.0(exp)12()1(

LDtnn

LD

NF

b

eA

n

n

b

eA

pA

A

επ

επ

Characteristics of standard diffusion curve

… peak maximum

… corresponding height

… „fingerprint“ for Knudsen regime

eA

bpp D

Lt2

61,

61 ε

τ ==

2, 85.1,85.1L

DHFb

eAppA ε

==

31.0, ≈= ppppA tHF τ

Page 48: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport model

a) Standard diffusion curve showing key time characteristics and the criterion for Knudsen diffusion

b) Comparison of standard curve with experimental inert gas curve over inert packed bed

Page 49: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport + adsorption model

AabvsA

eAA

b CkSazCD

tC )1(2

2

εε −−∂

∂=

∂∂

(2) Diffusion + irreversible adsorption

(adsorption is first order in gas concentration)

as … surface concentration of active sites (mol/cm2 of catalyst)

ka … adsorption rate constant (cm3 of gas/mol s)

Sv … surface area of catalyst per volume of catalyst (cm-1)

θA … fractional surface coverage of A

AaA Ck

t=

∂∂θ

Page 50: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

+−+−−= ∑

=2

22

0

´2 )5.0(exp)12()1()exp(

LDtnntk

LD

NF

b

eA

n

na

b

eA

pA

A

επ

επ

TAP - Transport + adsorption model

Flow rate FA at reactor exit

(2) Diffusion + irreversible adsorption

b

abvsa

kSakε

ε )1(´ −=with

Exit flow curve for diffusion+irreversible adsorption - is smaller than SDC by a factor of exp(-ka´t)- is always placed „inside“ the SDC (fingerprint)

Page 51: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - Transport + adsorption model

Exit flow curve for the diffusion+irreversible adsorption case

Comparison of irreversible adsorption curves with standard diffusion curve(A) ka=0 (SDC), (B) ka=3 (C) ka=10

Page 52: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

(3) Diffusion + reversible adsorption

Mass balances- for component A in gas phase

)()1(2

2

AdAabvsA

eAA

b kCkSazCD

tC

θεε −−−∂

∂=

∂∂

AdAaA kCk

θ−=

∂∂

- for component A on the catalyst surface

kd …desorption rate constant (s-1)

TAP – Transport and adsorption model

Page 53: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - Transport + adsorption model

Exit flow curve for the diffusion+reversible adsorption case

Comparison of reversible adsorption curves with standard diffusion curve(A) ka=0 (SDC), (B) ka=20, kd=20 (C) ka=20, kd=5

Page 54: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport, adsorption, reaction

(3) Diffusion + reversible adsorption + irreversible reaction

)()1(2

2

AdAAaAbvsA

eAA

b kCkSazCD

tC

θεε −−−∂

∂=

∂∂

ArAdAAaAA kkCk

tθθ

θ−−=

∂∂

)()1(2

2

BdBBaBbvsB

eBB

b kCkSazCD

tC

θεε −−−∂

∂=

∂∂

BdBBdBArB kCkkt

θθθ

+−=∂

A(gas) B(gas)

A(ads) B(ads)kr

Page 55: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport, adsorption, reaction

(3) Diffusion + reversible adsorption + irreversible reaction

The initial and boundary conditions used in the transport-only case can be applied to the transport+reaction case as well.

Initial condition t = 0 , CA = 0

Inlet boundary condition )(,0 1,1, t

zC

Dz AeA δ=

∂∂

−=

Page 56: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Transport, adsorption, reaction

(3) Diffusion + reversible adsorption + irreversible reaction

)(1,1, t

zC

D AeA δ=

∂∂

The inlet flux is respresented by a delta function. With this combination, analytical solutions in the Laplace-domain can be easily derived when the set of differential equations that describe the model is linear.

Page 57: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Characteristic values

Use of dimensionless parameters

eA

baa D

Lkk2

´ ε= dimensionless apparent adsorption

rate constant

b

abvsa

kSakε

ε )1(´ −=

ka´ contains:

- the kinetic characteristics of the active site (ka)- the structural characteristics of the whole

catalytic system b

bvs Saε

ε )1( −

with

Page 58: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Extended models

Three-zone-model

Additional boundary conditions between the different zones have to be applied

catalystinert inert

zone 1 zone 2 zone 3

pulse outcome to QMS

Evaluation of curve shapes and „fingerprints“ are basicly the same as for the one-zone-model

Page 59: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Theory

Moment-based quantitative description of TAP-experiments

• idea behind: observed TAP data consist of a set of exit flow rates versus time dependencies

• analytical solutions in integral form can be usually obtained

• analysis of some integral characteristics (moments) of the exit flow rate

• moments reflect important primary features of the observations

Page 60: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Theory - Moments

• moment Mn of the exit flow rate (i.e. not of concentration)

n…order of moment

• representation in dimensionless form

dttFtMt

nn )(

0∫=

)/(with 2

0 eAbA

nn DL

tdFmε

τττ == ∫∞

Page 61: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP – Theory - Moments

Application to TAP experiments:- for irreversible adsorption / reaction

DaI … Damköhler number I

- mean dimensionless residence time

eA

baI

I DLkDa

DaXm

0 withcosh

11 ε==−=

[ ]Dif

n I

n Ires

DanBnA

DanBnA

mm

ττ

∑∞

=

=

+

+==

0

0

0

1

)()(

)()(

)12()1()( +−= nnnA22)5.0()( π+= nnB

Ae

bDif D

L

,

2ετ =

Page 62: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - Examples

Mechanism and Kinetics of the Adsorption and Combustionof Methane on Ni/Al2O3 and NiO/Al2O3 (Dewaele et al. 1999)

- Supported Ni catalysts for steam reforming of natural gasto synthesis gas

- Combination of TPR with single pulse experiments

Page 63: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesSelective oxidation of n-butane to maleic anhydride (MA)

over vanadium phosphorous oxide (VPO) (Gleaves et al. 1997)

• important heterogeneous selective oxidation• complex reaction (electron transfer, fission of C-H-bonds,

addition of oxygen, ring closure)• literature: (VO)2P2O7-lattice as active-selective phase, but it

is not clear how the lattice supplies the oxygen- possible involvation of oxygen adspecies adsorbed on

vanadium surface sites- possible involvation of bulk oxygen- possibly other crystal phases are active

Page 64: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesSelective oxidation of n-butane to maleic anhydride (MA)

over vanadium phosphorous oxide (VPO)

• Steady-state kinetic studies yielded different rate expressions and kinetic parameters – this may be related to differences in c. composition, c. structure, c. oxydation state, etc. no unique information

• Aim of TAP investigations:Relate changes in kinetic dependencies to changes inthe catalyst

• How to do ? Systematic alteration of the state of the catalyst and measuring kinetic dependencies

Page 65: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesSelective oxidation of n-butane to maleic anhydride (MA) over

vanadium phosphorous oxide (VPO)

Kinetics of n-butane conversion over VPO in the absence of gas phase oxygen

- n-butane curve lies completelywithin the generated diffusion curve irreversible process

- initial step is irreversible (fissure of CC or CH bond)

Page 66: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesSelective oxidation of n-butane to maleic anhydride (MA) over

vanadium phosphorous oxide (VPO)

Kinetics of n-butane conversion on oxygen-treated VPO

- values of apparent activationenergy is strongly dependenton the VPO oxidation state

- decreasing number of active centers

- TAP + Raman: V4+ V5+Arrhenius plots for pulsed n-butane conversion over an oxygen-treated VPO catalyst sample as a function of oxidation state

Page 67: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesN-Butane Isomerization on Sulfated Zirconia Catalysts(SPP-1091, Acid-Base Catalyzed Alkane Activation)

0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

reference helium 100 °C 150 °C 200 °C 250 °C

height

nor

malized

cur

ve

time [s]

0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

100 °C 150 °C 200 °C 250 °C

h.n.

time [s]

Pulses of n-butane

over inert material over SZ

τ [s] at 100 °C: 0.107 0.500

Page 68: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesN-Butane Isomerization over Sulfated Zirconia Catalysts

(SPP-1091, Acid-Base Catalyzed Alkane Activation)

Influence of sulfation - pulses of n-butane

SZ, calcined unsulfated precursor, inert

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

BS-1 BSV-1 Ref. Ref.

h.n.

time [s]

-1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

BS-1 BSV-1 Ref. Ref.

h.n.

time [s]

Page 69: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesN-Butane Isomerization over Sulfated Zirconia Catalysts

(SPP-1091, Acid-Base Catalyzed Alkane Activation)

Activation plots for active SZ, inactive SZ, industrial reference

at begin of reaction

1.9 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7-2.4

-2.2

-2.0

-1.8

-1.6

-1.4

-1.2

-1.0

-0.8

-0.6

BS-1 BS-2 BSMln

τre

s

1000/T [1/K]

EAkt (BS-1) ≈ EAkt (BS-2) at beginning

Page 70: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

TAP - ExamplesN-Butane Isomerization over Sulfated Zirconia Catalysts

(SPP-1091, Acid-Base Catalyzed Alkane Activation)

Variation of activation state through switch between vacuum and atmospheric flow conditions at 150 °C

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

-0.0010.0000.0010.0020.0030.0040.0050.0060.0070.0080.0090.0100.0110.0120.0130.014

pulsing before flow after 1 min flow after 2 min flow after 3 min flow after 4 min flow after 10 min flow after 20 min flow after 60 min flowin

tens

ity o

f am

u 43

time [s]

Page 71: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA

Steady State Isotopic TransientKinetic Analysis

Page 72: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - Theory• Initially developed by Happel 1978, Bennett 1982 and

Biloen 1983• Determination of kinetics and catalyst surface reaction

intermediates in situ• The technique is based upon the detection of isotopic

labels in the reactor effluent species versus time following a switch (step change) in the isotopic labeling of one of the reactant species in the reactor feed.

• Isothermic and isobaric conditions !• Reactant and product concentrations remain undisturbed

during step change !Steady-state reaction conditions are maintained under

isotopic-transient operation

Page 73: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - TheoryReview article: Shannon, Goodwin 1995

Typical reaction system for SSITKA experimentation

Page 74: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - Theory

• The step-input response is a statistical distribution representing the probability that an isotopic label remains adsorbed on the catalyst surface or appears in the effluent stream with time.

Typical normalized isotopic-transient responses

Page 75: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - Theory

• Characteristic values- Step-input response of the product for the new isotopic

label

- Step-decay response of the old isotopic label (prior to switch)

- Relationship

- Inert-tracer transient response for determination of gas-phase holdup

)(* tF Pm

)(tF Pm

)(1)( * tFtF Pm

Pm −=

)(tF Im

Page 76: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - Theory

• In SSITKA, it is common to consider the catalyst surfaceto be composed of a system of interconnected pools, also termed compartments, where each pool represents a homogeneous or well-mixed subsystem within the reaction pathway.

• A seperate pool is assumed to exist for each uniqueadsorbed reaction-intermediate species or type of catalytically active site.

• It is assumed that there is essentially no mixing or holdup time associated with each pool or within the reaction pathway except for the residence time of a reaction-intermediate species adsorbed on the catalyst surface.

Page 77: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - Theory

Catalyst-surface model showing the isotopic distributionbetween n pools in series following an isotopic switch, R à*R, at the reaction volume inlet

Page 78: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - Theory

Catalyst-surface mechanistic models, transientresponses, and kinetic parameters

Page 79: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - Theory

Catalyst-surface mechanistic models, transientresponses, and kinetic parameters

Page 80: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response
Page 81: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA – Kinetic parameters

Page 82: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - ExamplesSelective NO reduction over Co-ZSM-5

(Sadovskaya et al. 2001)

• SCR of NO with CH4 in the presence of excess oxygen • Controversial discussion of formation mechanism of

surface NOx species • IR investigation in presence of O2 showed bands for

nitrite and nitrate complexes and for NOxδ+

• Focus on formation of adsorbed NOx species in absence and presence of oxygen, but in absence of methane by using doubly labeled nitric oxide

Page 83: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - ExamplesSelective NO reduction over Co-ZSM-5

(Sadovskaya et al. 2001)

Page 84: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - ExamplesSelective NO reduction over Co-ZSM-5

(Sadovskaya et al. 2001)

Page 85: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - ExamplesSelective NO reduction over Co-ZSM-5

(Sadovskaya et al. 2001)

• Cobalt mononitrosyls, NOxδ+ species, nitrite complexes

have average lifetimes of 0.1, 1, and 100 s• Observation in agreement with DRIFT • Concentration of mononitrosyls was found proportional to

NO content in feed gas; no saturation• NOx

δ+ species approached maximum coverage within the same concentration range; only part of cobalt active species participate in NOx

δ+ species formation

Page 86: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA - ExamplesSelective NO reduction over Co-ZSM-5

(Sadovskaya et al. 2001)

• Rate of gaseous NO2 formation comparable with nitrite formation and substantially lower than that of NOx

δ+

formation• Conclusion: NOx

δ+ can not originate from NO2 formation but formed in two sequential steps (i) molecular oxygen adsorption and (ii) NO reaction with oxidized surface sites

• Rate of oxygen exchange within NOxδ+ lower than their

formation indicating that the two oxygens are nonequivalent

Page 87: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Kinetic modeling

Page 88: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Way down South in the land of cottonWhere good mints juleps are not forgottenAn old farmer sits on his plantationThinking up problems to astound the nationLindemann and Hinshelwood can stand it no moreWhile Smith and Carberry have run for the doorNow there is one as he told it to meAnd I give it to you, completely for freeWe know kinetics is a staid sort of sportIf reaction order is all there´s to reportSo we´ve studied about reactor designIn detail and elegance quite so fineMixing models have been disussedWhere proper equations are a mustAge distributions become important hereAn intricate analysis, it is clearNow this is the question to give you fitsAn excellent chance to test your witsOf these distributions there are many it´s sureDerived from a theory assuredly most pure

Page 89: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

Residence time, internal, and exit ageAll we owe to Danckwerts, that clever sageWhat are they, please, a clear explanationCombining words with an appropriate equationRelationships between them are almost horrendousA discussion of this would be simply tremendousWhen you´ve written all this consider you´re doneNow wasn´t that all just good clean funIf you did what was aked, and that I hopeThen with chemical reactors you´re able to copeOne final thing I must now sayOf the light of knowledge a final rayReaction kinetics is in a messIn spite of Eyring and ArrheniusAlas, was it ever thus so

The more we learn, the less we know !

John B. Butt

Page 90: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

SSITKA• Happel J. J. Chem. Eng. Sci. 33 (1978), 1567.• Bennett CO. ACS Symposium Series Washington 1982, Vol. 178, 1.• Biloen PJ. J. Mol. Cat. 21 (1983) 17.• Bennett CO. Adv. Catal. 44 (2000) 329.• Sadovskaya EM, Suknev AP, Pinaeva LG, Goncharov VB, Bal´zhinimaev BS,

Chupin C, Mirodatos C. J. Catal. 201 (2001) 159-168.

Page 91: TAP Temporal Analysis of Products · TAP – Transient response data In contrast to traditional kinetic methods, that measure concentrations, the observable quantityin TAP pulse response

LiteratureTAP• Gleaves JT et al. Appl. Cat. A 160 (1997) 55-88.• Phanawadee P. PhD thesis Washington 1997.• Chen S. PhD thesis Washington 1996.• Yablonsky GS et al. J. Catal. 216 (2003) 120-134.• Gleaves JT et al. Cat. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 30 (1988) 49-116.• Dumesic JA et al (Ed) „The Microkinetics of Heterogeneous Catalysis“ ACS, Washington 1993.• Stoltze P. Progress in Surface Science 65 (2000) 65-150.• Kobayashi H et al.. Cat. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 10 (1974) 139-176.• Engel T, Ert G. Adv. Catal. 28 (1979) 1-78.• Ertl G. The dynamics of interactions between molecules and surfaces. Berichte Bunsengesellschaft

für Physikalische Chemie 99 (1995) 1282.• Creten G et al. J. Catal. 154 (1995) 151-152.• Haber J. 1983. Concepts in catalysis by transition metal oxides. Bonelle JP et al. (Ed.) D. Reidel

Publishing Company. Surface Properties and Catalysis by nNonmetals. 45, 1-45.• Hinrichsen O. DECHEMA-Kurs „Angewandte Heterogene Katalyse“, Bochum 2001.• Dewaele O, Froment GF. J. Catal. 184 (1999) 499-513.• Christoffel EG „Laboratory Studies of Heterogeneous Catalytic Processes“ Stud.Surf.Sci.Catal. 42. • Müller-Erlwein E. Chemische Reaktionstechnik, Teubner Stuttgart-Leipzig, 1998, 237.