Page 1
Climate Security and Sustainable Development
TEMPLATE
STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION
REPORT
PUBLICATION DATE 14.10.2020
VERSION v. 1.1
RELATED SUPPORT
- TEMPLATE GUIDE Stakeholder Consultation Report v. 1.1
This document contains the following Sections
Key Project Information
SECTION A - Information made available to Stakeholders
SECTION B - Invitations made to Stakeholders
SECTION C - Report of the Consultation Process
SECTION D - Continuous input / Grievance mechanism
SECTION E – Stakeholder Feedback Round
Page 2
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
2 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
KEY PROJECT INFORMATION
SECTION A. INFORMATION MADE AVAILABLE TO STAKEHOLDERS
A.1. non–technical summary of the project
The objective of the small-scale VPA “Water and Climate VPA #2 – Madhya Pradesh,
India” is to provide safe drinking water to at least 25,000 households (125,000
beneficiaries) in rural and tribal communities in Alirajpur District and Jhabua District of
Madhya Pradesh through Solar Water Disinfection (SODIS) with the UV indicator WADI.
The project includes additional activities to improve the water and hygiene situation in
households and the community over the initial 5-year project period.
The target group of the project are households boiling unsafe drinking water using non-
renewable biomass (e.g., firewood) and/or consume unsafe water (suppressed
demand) in the baseline scenario. Madhya Pradesh is the largest forest state of India
endowed with diverse forest resources. The project focuses on households in villages
that rely on non-renewable biomass (e.g. firewood) as a fuel source, like forest and
forest fringe villages.
The proposed project activities starting in 2022 involve:
(a) Distribution of WADI technology to up to 25,000 households and training on
application of Solar Water Disinfection (SODIS) with WADI. The household will
be supplied with a WADI device and the necessary transparent bottles to treat at
least 20 liters of water per day.
GS ID of Project GS11448
Title of Project Water and Climate VPA #2 – Madhya Pradesh,
India
Version number of the SCR V1.0
Completion date of version 11/02/2022
Time of First Submission Date 11/02/2022
Start Date of the Project 01/01/2022
Date of Meeting (s) 30/11/2021
Project Cycle: Regular
Retroactive
Page 3
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
3 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
(b) Training and awareness workshops on safe water and hygiene management
based on WHO guidelines, including transmission of waterborne diseases and
health benefits.
(c) Training and awareness workshops on household waste management, plastic
recycling and environmental protection. Establishing recycling groups to promote
key messages and coordinate recycling activities.
(d) Establishing project groups (e.g. WADI user groups) in the villages and triggering
of improvement of water and hygiene management on community level. The
groups shall provide space for exchange of experiences and addressing open
questions through discussion with other group members and the project team.
Figure 1: Screenshot of a presentation slide in Hindi (presented) and English language (for reference) presented at the Local Stakeholder Consultation (LSC) meeting in the project region. The slide was used to explain the project objective. Source: HELIOZ Group.
Implementation Structure
The VPA is developed by the Indian entity Helioz Global Services Pvt. Ltd. (Project
Developer) and implemented in cooperation with local partners Caritas India and Pragati
Sansthan under the GS11445 PoA “Water and Climate – Multi-country PoA”. The PoA
and VPA are part of the global “Water and Climate” initiative by the CME Helioz GmbH,
which aims at increasing access to safe drinking water for at-risk and marginalized
communities.
The sister project of the VPA “Water and Climate VPA#1 – Madhya Pradesh, India”
(GS11447) is being implemented in Khandwa District and Barwani District, Madhya
Pradesh.
Page 4
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
4 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 2: Presentation slide in Hindi (presented) and English language (for reference) presented at the Local Stakeholder Consultation (LSC) meeting in the project region. The slide was used to explain the implementation structure of the project to the stakeholders. Source: HELIOZ Group.
Project technology
WADI is a UV-indicator device for the method of Solar Water Disinfection (SODIS).
SODIS is a point-of-use, household water treatment technology (HWT) that utilizes
natural UV radiation to inactivate pathogens in biologically contaminated water stored
in transparent containers (e.g., PET bottles, glass bottles) of up to three liters per
container. The containers are exposed to direct sunlight.
The method of Solar Water Disinfection has been developed in the 1980s and
consequently studied intensively by several research institutions like EAWAG1 and ETH
Zurich, which have also been consulted during the development of the WADI device.
Previous studies have demonstrated that SODIS significantly reduces incidence of
waterborne diseases and provides benefit in household finances.
Advantages of WADI
• Sustainable: No maintenance, no spare parts needed, simultaneous use of several
bottles, women’s time saved to collect fuelwood (SDG 5)
• Environmentally friendly: No batteries, no chemicals, no CO2 emissions, and
avoidance of fuelwood burning (SDG 13)
• Practicable: Water resistant and dust proof (IP65), easy to transport
1 Overview SODIS research. Online access: https://www.sodis.ch/methode/forschung/index_EN.html
Page 5
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
5 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 3: Illustration on application of the method of Solar Water Disinfection (SODIS) with WADI. Source: HELIOZ Group.
Application of Technology
Step 1 - Fill PET bottles with water
Step 2 - Expose the PET bottles and WADI to the sun, and press it’s reset button
Step 3 - Wait for some hours while the sun disinfects the water
Step 4 - Watch that a happy smiley face appears on the WADI display. Water is now
ready for consumption.
A.2. Contact details to get further technical detail and project information
The Project developer and/or implementation partners can be contacted via e-mail or
letter to the following representatives.
Contact details for further technical details and project information
Project Developer
Helioz Global Services Pvt. Ltd.
Attn. Gregor Riss , Director GF and FF, Worldmark L, Asset Area 11
Aerocity Hospitality District IGI Airport, New Delhi, South West Delhi DL 110037, India
E: [email protected]
Helioz Global Services Pvt. Ltd. Attn. Barbara Oberfichtner, Programme Manager
E: [email protected]
Attn. Utkarsh Sethia, Project Manager India E: [email protected]
Implementation Partner Caritas India
Attn. Mr. Ghanshyam Jethwa
Head of Programmes
Page 6
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
6 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Caritas India, CBCI Centre, 1 Ashoka Place,
Goledakkhana,
New Delhi, 110 001
E: [email protected]
A.3. Summary of economic, social and environmental impacts of the Project
Access to safe drinking water is linked to different social/health, ecological and economic
benefits. The project aims at contributing to nine Sustainable Development Goals.
Sustainable Development
Goals (SDG) SDG Impact
SDG 1 – No Poverty Increased access to basic services (water treatment)
Reduction of expenses for medical costs and buying
fuel materials (firewood, charcoal, etc.)
SDG 3 – Good Health and
Well-Being
Reduction of waterborne diseases
SDG 4 – Quality Education Received education for sustainable development,
environmental protection, and gender equality
(trainings, courses, workshops, etc.)
SDG 5 – Gender Equality Reduced unpaid care and domestic work for women
Empowerment of women for increased participation
and taking leadership
SDG 6 – Clean Water and
Sanitation
Increased access to safe drinking water
SDG 8: Decent Work and
Economic Growth
Employment generation and decent work with equal
pay
SDG 10 – Reduced
Inequalities
Empowerment of marginalized people for increased
participation and taking leadership (e.g. People with
Disabilities, tribal communities, etc.)
SDG 13 – Climate Action Emission Reductions
SDG 15 – Life on Land Reduced consumption of firewood
Page 7
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
7 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
The stakeholders were provided with a Project Impact Leaflet illustrating the proposed
economic, social, and environmental impacts of the project during the Local Stakeholder
Consultation meeting (see A.4.).
A.4. Other relevant information to help stakeholders understand the project
The stakeholders were provided with different project documents during the invitation
process as well as the Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting itself to provide an
overview of the project design and objectives.
The core document was the Key Project Information document, which was sent out to
the invited stakeholders (English and Hindi version) and distributed as a print copy
during the Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting (Hindi version). During the physical
meeting the attending stakeholders were also provided with a Project Impact Leaflet
illustrating the project impact and a brochure on the project technology WADI (Hindi
version).
Key Project Information Document
The Key Project Information document contains the following core points:
• Project objective
• Project description and proposed activities
• Technology description
• Project boundary
• Socio-economic aspects of the project
• Project developer description
• Contact details of Project developer and Implementation partner
The following pages provide scans of the Key Project Information document in Hindi and
in English.
Page 8
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
8 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 9
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
9 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 10
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
10 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 11
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
11 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 4: Key Project Information Document (Hindi and English version). Source: HELIOZ Group.
Project Impact Leaflet
A 5-pager leaflet on the project impact in Hindi language was distributed to stakeholders
during the Local Stakeholder Consultation meetings held in the project region. The
leaflet uses text and illustrative elements to cater to all stakeholders. The leaflet
provides insights into the following aspects of the project:
• Impact of the project: SDG impacts that will be achieved through project
intervention
• Safeguarding Principles: Core social, economic, environmental, and ecological
safeguarding principles and proposed mitigation measures
The following pages provide scans of the leaflet in Hindi as distributed to the
stakeholders and in English for reference.
Page 12
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
12 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 13
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
13 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 14
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
14 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 5: Project Impact Leaflet (English and Hindi version). Source: HELIOZ Group.
Technology Brochure
Furthermore, the stakeholders attending the Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting
were provided with a brochure on the project technology WADI in Hindi, which includes
the application steps as text and illustration.
Page 15
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
15 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 6: WADI folder in Hindi and English language. The folder was distributed to stakeholders in the LSC meetings held in the project region. Source: HELIOZ Group.
Page 16
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
16 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
SECTION B. INVITATIONS MADE TO STAKEHOLDERS
B.1. Invitation tracking table
Category
Code
Stakeholder Type /
Organization (If
relevant)
Name of invitee Male/
Female
Method of
invitation
Date of
invitation
>30 Days
before
meeting
Category A - Local people, communities and or representatives who are directly or
indirectly affected by the project
A School Teacher Laxman singh Chabda M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Dhuliya Parmar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A Traditional Priest Pangala Ninama M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A Traditional Priest Bhuru Bhabor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Laveleet Ninama M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A Self Help Group - SHG Bhaggu Garwal F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Premlata Ganawa F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Javarsingh Nalwaya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A Self Help Group - SHG Ditu Gundiya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Sardar Hatila M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Nabu Singh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Unkar Kanesh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Deelip Morya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Sunil Kumar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Gambhir Bhimde M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Raju Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A School Teacher Guman Gadriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A Traditional Priest jamsingh Rawat M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A Traditional Priest fattu Bagel F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
A Traditional Priest Mathur Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 17
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
17 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Category C - Local policy makers and representatives of local authorities
C PRI Member Kamiya Navlish
Vasuniya
F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Chamansingh Damor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Nirmala Makwana F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Amarsingh Makwana M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Guard Siru Mavi M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Sunil Parmar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Premlata Solanki F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Vina Bariya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Vasna Bhabor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Nathu Sarpanch M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Dinesh Parmar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Mrs. Senadi Bhura F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi VasnaNinama M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Mrs. Nabbu Ninama F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C MGNREGA worker prabhu Katara M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Lalu Damor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Mrs.Badu Mangu F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Ansingh Bhabor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member bharat Singh Bilewal M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Gita Ninama F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Ballu Katara M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village guard Bahadur Katara M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Munni Jisaph Katara F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Shushila Ninama F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Paskeli Katara F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 18
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
18 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C PRI Member Kubersingh Hatila M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Sharma Khapeda M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Manish Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Dhansingh Pargi M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD jyoti Ninama F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village guard Sukla garwal M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Ranga Bharat F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member karansingh Parmar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Purvaraj jain F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Dolsingh Bhabir M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Makha Kharadi M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Parvati Dewal F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Manga Somal F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Eshawar Dewal M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Rupa Makwana M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Basanti Kharadi F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Leela Chouhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Bhurji katara M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Dallu Katara M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Parvati Hihor F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department kamla damor F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village guard Ramsingh Mavee M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Bhumika kamlesh F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Kali Sanjay F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Sakriya Ninama M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Saga Bhabor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 19
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
19 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C PRI Member Badar Pal M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Divya Machar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Suraj Singad F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Ramesh Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Narvarsingh Bhabor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Vinita Bhabor F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Ramila Hatila F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Mamta Bhuriya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Parvat Khaped M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Lalita Vamkhela F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Manju Bhuriya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Narvarsingh Nayak M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Anita Bhuriya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Ramu Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Jamsingh Dahma M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Reena Dahma F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Nansingh Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Varma Meda F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Varma Katara M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member chatarsingh Parmar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Kela Parmar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Dhansingh Parmar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Dhumsingh Bhabor M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Huraji Bhabir M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Dema Bhabor F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Lalita Shah F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 20
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
20 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C Village Tadvi Ansingh Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village guard Ratan Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Bina Bhuriya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department chanda Gamad F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Savita Sunil
Singhadiya
F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Kamala Machar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Madiya Rawat M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Bhava Katara M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Seema Satru Meda F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Veshali Bhuriya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Paskeli Katara F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Devu Mansingh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Bhavala Hatila M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Anita Hatila M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Sudipta F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Ramesh Dawar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Pradeep Chouhan M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Neru Bai Bamniya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Prakash Bamniya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Angurbala Rawat F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Thakur Singh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Savita Bai F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Kesar Rawat F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Naval singh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Parsingh Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Lakhma Bai F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 21
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
21 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C Health Department Shavitri Bai F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Sena Kanesh F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Mahendra Rawat M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Annu BaiMori F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Mukam Singh Harwal M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Dholkiya Singh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Sardar Singh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Eandi Bai Chouhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Vesti Chouhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Kalam Singh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Kiran Mandaloe F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Nansingh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Vesti Chouhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Kalam Singh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Rajam Bai F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Kiran Versingh F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Kiran houhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Nansing Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Kalam Singh Mori M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Thansingh Dawar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Kamala Dawar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village guard Karan Dawar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Denesh Patel M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Birbal Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Magan Singh Rawat M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Dulesingh Kanesh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 22
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
22 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C PRI Member Vinod Morya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Kesae Damor F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Ranjana Tomor F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Shersingh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Vijay Chouhan M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Madhu Chouhan M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Gilbai Dawer F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village guard Teju Solanki F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Narsinh Morya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Raju Chouhan M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Gan Bai dawar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Gul Bai chouhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village guard Gamaru Mehada M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Vesta Mehda M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Ganga Patidar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Ajeysingh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Denesh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Kamala jetendr
Chouhan
F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Radhu Kanesh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Chandarsingh Jamra M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Mesari Intarsingh F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Tensingh Kanesh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Magan Singh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Amarsingh Tomar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department J.K. Baghel F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Keri Dudve F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 23
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
23 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C Village guard Bhagada Vesta M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Shayda Dawar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Lumba Bai Rawat F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Naval singh Chouhan M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Pratap Chouhan M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Karma Chouhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Health Department Kalam Bai Chouhan F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Bharata Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi ramsingh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Raju Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Hatari Bhurka F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Dalsingh Dudve M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Punam Bai F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Savitri Bai F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Kali Jeetenra
Panchayat
F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Vikas Nigwal M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Vijay sigh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Keram Singh Chouhan M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Karan Gadriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Lila Bai Morya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Naval singh Bamniya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Madan Mayda M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Radhesingh Gadriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Sangeeta Dawar F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Ramesh Gadriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Seema Rawat F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Page 24
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
24 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C Health Department Banni Bai Gadriya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Madan Mayda M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PRI Member Mr. Manoj Barsakar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Village Tadvi Bhuru Kanesh M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C District Health
Department
Dr. Rahul Ganwa M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C District Administration Mr. Somesh Mishra M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PHED Mr. Narayan Singh
Binde
M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PHED Mr. Rahul Surya
Vanshi
M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PHED Mr. Deenesh Jain M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PHED Mr. Dhuliya Bamniya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C MLA Mr. Kantilal Bhuriya M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C ICDS-WCD Mrs. Meera Gadriya F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C KVK Dr. Chandan Kumar M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PHED R.S Dudve F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Block Helth
Department
Dr. K. Gehlot M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C KVK Pramila Dudve F Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C KVK Mukam Singh Chogad M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C Veterinary
Department
Dr. Ajay Singh Harwal M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
C PHED Gajendra Vaskel M Invitation
Letter
29/10/2021
Category D - National government officials or National focal bodies responsible for
the project in the host country, for example, Designated National Authority (DNA)
D MOEFCC, Scientist-
F/Director and
Member Secretary
(DNA)
Dr. Subrata Bose M Email 30/10/2021
D SustainCERT Annyta Luo F Email 30/10/2021
D SustainCERT Richard Iliffe M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Tribal
Affairs India,
Secretary
Shri. Anil Kumar Jha M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Tribal
Affairs India, Director
Dr. Anil Kumar
Addepally
M Email 30/10/2021
Page 25
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
25 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
D Ministry of Tribal
Affairs India, Research
Officer
Sh. Manoj Kumar M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Tribal
Affairs India,
Department of Tribal
Affiars MP, Divisional
Deputy Commissioner
Bhopal
Mrs. Seema Soni F Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Tribal
Affairs India,
Department of Tribal
Affiars MP, Divisional
Deputy Commissioner
Indore
On Shri Ganesh Bhan M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of
Environment, Forest
and Climate Change
India, Secretary
Mr. Rameshwar
Prasad Gupta
M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of
Environment, Forest
and Climate Change
India, Swachh aur
Bharat Cell (SSB),
Scientist G
Mrs. Rita Khanna F Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of
Environment, Forest
and Climate Change
India, Green India
Mission (GIM),
Additional Secretary
Mrs. B.v. Umadevi F Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Health and
Family Welfare India,
Department of Health
& Family Welfare,
Secretary
Shri. Rajesh Bhushan M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Health and
Family Welfare India,
Department of Health
& Family Welfare,
Additional Secretary
Smt Arti Ahuja F Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Health and
Family Welfare India,
Department of Health
& Family Welfare,
National Health
Mission MP, Director
NHM
Dr. Pankaj Shukla M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Jal Shakti,
Department of
Drinking Water &
Sanitation, Secretary
(DWS)
Shri Pankaj Kumar M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Jal Shakti,
Department of
Drinking Water &
Shri Arun Baroka M Email 30/10/2021
Page 26
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
26 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Sanitation, Additional
Secretary (SBM &
CVO)
D Ministry of Jal Shakti,
Department of
Drinking Water &
Sanitation, Additional
Secretary (JJM)
Shri Bharat Lal M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Jal Shakti,
Madhya Pradesh
Public Health
Engineering
Department,
Additional Chief
Secretary
Shri Malaya
Srivastava
M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Women
and Child
Development,
Secretary
Shri Indevar Pandey M Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Women
and Child
Development, Deputy
Secretary (Anganwadi
Services, Scheme for
Adolescent Girls)
Shri Alex P. Thomas M Email 30/10/2021
D Niti Aayog, Sensior
Consultant
Shri Rakesh Ranjan M Email 30/10/2021
D Niti Aayog, Specialist
(Climate Change)
Ms. Saloni Goel F Email 30/10/2021
D Ministry of Rural
Development,
Secretary
Shri Nagendra Nath
Sinha
M Email 30/10/2021
Category E - Local non-governmental organisations (NGOs), Women Groups
working on topics relevant to the project or working with communities who are
likely to be affected by the project
E Social Worker Laaxamnsingh dawar M Email 29/10/2021
E Local NGOs Jeemi Nirmal M Email 29/10/2021
E IGSSS Nitesh Bop Cha M Email 29/10/2021
E Local NGOs Sr. Veenita F Email 29/10/2021
E NRLM. ramchandra Jhavariya M Email 29/10/2021
E Sonne International office@sonne-
international.org
N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E GIZ India, Country
Director
Ulrike Reviere M Email 30/10/2021
E WWF India [email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E UNICEF India [email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E UNICEF India, Office
Madhya Pradesh
[email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Swiss Agency for
Development and
Cooperation, Director
General
Particia Danzi M Email 30/10/2021
Page 27
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
27 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
E Barefoot College
India, Head Indian
Partnerships
Devashish Taknet M Email 30/10/2021
E India-EU Water
Partnership, Head
Birgit Vogel F Email 30/10/2021
E Safe Water Network
India
india@safewaternetwo
rk.org
N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Water Aid India [email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Oxfam India Friendsofoxfam@oxfa
mindia.org
N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Piramal Foundation communication@pira
malfoundation.org
N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Gram Vikas [email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Centre for Science and
Environment
[email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Centre for
Environment
Education
[email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E Development
Alternatives
[email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
E India Water
Partnership, Executive
Secretary
Dr. Veena Khanduri F Email 30/10/2021
E Water Quality Network [email protected] N.A. Email 30/10/2021
Category F - A Gold Standard representative
F Gold Standard
Representative
[email protected]
g
N.A. Email 30/10/2021
Category G - Relevant international Gold Standard NGO Supporters with
representation in your region and all Gold Standard NGO Supporters located in the
host country of the project
G Global Offset Research siddharth Yadav M Email 30/10/2021
G CEDESOL David Whitfield M Email 30/10/2021
G Lean Management
Systems Promotion
Society
Raave Jain M Email 30/10/2021
G NCMA India Bholendra Singh M Email 30/10/2021
G HIVOS Harry Clemens M Email 30/10/2021
G Redemption Research
for Health and
Educational
Development Society
Kennady Pulipati M Email 30/10/2021
Page 28
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
28 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
B.1.1. Appropriateness of methods
The invitations were sent out on the 29/10/2021 and 30/10/2021, therefore 30 days
prior to the physical meeting. Follow-up calls and e-mails were performed to ensure
attendance. The stakeholders were invited using different invitation methods adjusted
to the stakeholder category as well as customs. The invitation letter as well as the Key
Project Information document were prepared in English and translated to Hindi.
The invitation methods were as follows:
• In person invite via a delivery of letter: This was mostly done for local
stakeholders which are accessible in person to the implementation partners. The
method of invitation offers the opportunity to inform stakeholders about the project
and answer initial questions prior to the physical meeting and ensures that no one
is left behind. The language used in the letter was Hindi which is a language popularly
used for communication in the project region, Alirajpur and Jhabua district.
• Telephonic follow-up: Stakeholders invited via letter were called up several times
prior to the physical meeting to follow-up on their attendance. This was done mostly
through telephone/mobile and at least one week prior to the physical meeting. In
addition, stakeholders were reminded in person to attend the meeting.
• Email invitations: This was the preferred method of invitation for stakeholders
falling under category D, E, F and G. The invitations were sent out in English
language as this is the language used in the work and business setting. The attached
invitation letter and Key Project Information document were provided both in English
and Hindi language. The follow-up was done via e-mail prior to the physical meeting.
All the invites were made at least 30 days prior to the physical meeting to ensure
sufficient time for stakeholders to make arrangements to participate.
B.1.2. Gender Sensitivity
In the invitation and stakeholder consultation process, the project team ensured that
the process is open for everyone and there are no barriers to attend the physical
meeting. The date and time of the Stakeholder Consultation meeting were chosen based
on local practices and availability of stakeholders. The mode and language of invitation
were chosen to ensure that the information reaches all stakeholder categories.
Page 29
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
29 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
The following points justify that the invitation methods were marginalized
groups inclusive:
• The invitations to the stakeholders in category A, C and local NGOs belonging to
category E were made in Hindi language as this is the language of written
communication among marginalized groups (Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes
etc.). Besides this, the in-person invitations to the stakeholders from the above-
mentioned category ensure that there is a scope of verbal in-person communication
and possibility for invitation of people (illiterate people) who are not able to read
Hindi language.
• The project team invited community members (Example: Traditional priests from
category A) and local representatives (Members from Panchayati Raj Institutes like
Sarpanch – Village chief, Sacheev and Kotwar from category C) from the tribal
villages of the project region. This ensures that marginalized groups are represented
in the physical meeting.
• Invitations to the Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting were also sent to National
government organizations/departments that are responsible for the development of
marginalized/tribal communities (Example: Ministry of Tribal Affairs2, GOI).
The following points justify that the invitation methods were gender sensitive:
• The project team made additional efforts to provide women access to the
Stakeholder Consultation meeting by personally getting in touch and arranging
transportation options if needed.
• Women from villages were invited for the physical Stakeholder Consultation
meeting. Examples are: ASHA, Anganwadi workers, ANMs from Panchayati Raj
Institutes under category C. Women-lead Self Help Group (SHGs) leaders were also
invited to the meeting. These are the women who have strong influence in the
villages of India and thus can represent the women of the project villages.
• Stakeholders from Integrated Child Development Services (Category C) and National
authorities from the Department of Women and Child Development (Category D)
were invited.
2 Ministry of Tribal Affairs India. See: https://tribal.nic.in/
Page 30
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
30 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
• Some of the International and national NGOs invited for LSCs have a strong focus
on women development.
In addition, the decision was made to hold addition Stakeholder Consultation meetings
on village level to ensure easy participation for community members (see C.2.1).
B.1.3. Evidence proving invites took place as stated
The following screenshots and photos provide evidence that the stakeholders were
invited using digital and physical invitation methods.
Figure 7: Email invitation to stakeholders (Category F and G) requesting their presence in LSC meetings of the project.
Figure 8: A reminder email sent as a follow-up email to the actual invitation for LSC meetings. The email is addressed to stakeholders falling under category F and G.
Page 31
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
31 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 9: Invitation letter to a woman (Category
C) from Jhabua district. The invitation is dated 29/10/2021 and is handed over by Pragati Sansthan (Grassroot level implementation
partners).
Figure 10: Invitation letter to a woman (Category
C) from Alirajpur district. The invitation is dated 29/10/2021 and is handed over by Pragati Sansthan (Grassroot level implementation
partners).
Figure 11: Project village cluster coordinator from Pragati Sansthan (Grassroot level implementation partner) delivering an invitation letter for LSC meetings to Chief Health Officer's office, Jhabua district (Category C).
Figure 12: Project village cluster coordinator from Pragati Sansthan (Grassroot level implementation partner) delivering an invitation letter to a stakeholder from Alirajpur district (Category C).
Page 32
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
32 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 13: Follow-up telephonic conversation with Public Health and Engineering Department (MP PHED) - Jhabua district. The call was a reminder for attendance in LSC meetings. Phone number is intentionally made hidden in the image because of privacy concerns
Figure 14: Followup telephonic conversation with a stakeholder from Alirajpur district. The call was a reminder for attendance in LSC meetings. Phone number is intentionally made hidden in the image because of privacy concerns
B.1.4. Sample content of invites (for each Method above)
Two main methods were used for invitation: Invitation via Email and via Letter. The
following table describes the attachment or handout provided to the stakeholder as part
of the invitation process:
Page 33
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
33 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Type of invitation Method
Attachment or Handout provided
Email Letter
Cover Letter in Hindi language Included
General invitation in English language Included
General invitation in Hindi language Included
Key Project Information (Refer section
A.4.) in English Language
Included
Key Project Information (Refer section
A.4.) in Hindi Language
Included Included
Refer to B.1.3. for sample e-mail invitation text. The handouts and attachments used
for letter invitation and as e-mail attachments are provided below for reference:
Figure 15: Sample cover letter in Hindi language.
Page 34
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
34 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 16: Sample cover letter in English language (for reference).
Page 35
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
35 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 17: General invitation letter in Hindi and English language.
B.1.5. Description of other Means and methods to provide feedback for those
who are not able to join the consultation meeting
The following measures were taken to ensure that feedback is received from the
stakeholders who were not able to join the consultation meetings:
1. The physical Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting was attended by a high
number of invited stakeholders and community members. All stakeholders will be
invited to provide further feedback during the Stakeholder Feedback Round. The
Page 36
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
36 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
project information, including results of the physical meeting, will be shared with
stakeholders who were unable to attend the event to also gather their feedback.
2. Stakeholder were informed on options to contact the project team and provide
feedback about the project or get further information as part of the general invitation
letter (see Figure 18).
Figure 18: Screenshot of the “Feedback and Comment section” from the General invitation letter. Here in English language (see Section B.1.4.).
3. Detailed communication and engagement with stakeholders were made during
(i) the main Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting at district level which includes all
the invited and attending stakeholders and (ii) additional follow-up meetings at “village
cluster” level (1 meeting per group of five villages). This decision was made to ensure
that feedback on the project design is received from the stakeholders who are not able
to attend the main Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting. Refer to section C.2.1. for
further details.
Page 37
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
37 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
SECTION C. REPORT OF THE CONSULTATION PROCESS
C.1. Date of Meeting
The Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting was conducted on 30/11/2021 for the
project region, Alirajpur and Jhabua district. Additional village level consultation
meetings took place from 01/12/2021 to 06/12/2021 (see C.2.1).
C.1.1. List of participants
Date and Time: 30/11/2021, 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Location: Jyoti Bhavan (Near Deelip Gate), Jhabua block, Jhabua district
Category Code
Name of participant, job / position in the community
Male / Female
Contact details Organization (if relevant)
Signature
C Ganpat Singh Kharadi M Kotawal
A Lalsingh Karadi M Farmer
A Dhuliya Kharadi M Farmer
A Madiya Khradi M Farmer
A Gulabsingh Bhabor M Farmer
A Harsingh Bhabor M Farmer
A Bijiya Bhabor M Farmer
A Joseph Ninama M Farmer
A Mahendra Baghel M Farmer
A Juvansingh Mavi M Farmer
A Lalita Rathod F Farmer
A Chendi Bhura F Farmer
A Pushpa Katara F Farmer
A Javari Pal F Farmer
A Mangali Dhak F Farmer
A Leela Hihor F Farmer
A Kali Dhak F Farmer
A Vardi Dhak F Farmer
A Sunki Hihor F Farmer
A Kamali Hihor F Farmer
A Ghesu Hihor F Farmer
A Vesti Hihor F Farmer
A Kali Hihor F Farmer
A Deetu hihor F Farmer
A Dalku hihor F Farmer
A Sunita Hihor F Farmer
A Lushiya Makwana F Farmer
A Seema Babalu F Farmer
A Sanga Bhabor F Farmer
Page 38
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
38 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
A Leela Makwana F Farmer
A Anita Dulla F Farmer
A Ramali Bhabor F Farmer
A Kasma Piter F Farmer
A Nanu Makawana F Farmer
A Ratu Lakha F Farmer
A Janata Damor F Farmer
A Lushiya Prakash F Farmer
A Bhuri Bhabor F Farmer
A Basnti Deelip F Farmer
A Baddu Bhabor F Farmer
A Leela Kalusingh F Farmer
A Ambu Bhabor F Farmer
A Leela Pal F Farmer
A Sunki Hihor F Farmer
A Leela Hihor F Farmer
A Deetu Bariya F Farmer
A Meera Ninama F Farmer
A Vardi Dhak F Farmer
A Sunki Garawal F Farmer
A Kali Dhak F Farmer
A Kaku Garawal F Farmer
A Pangali Dhak F Farmer
A Dhuli Garawal F Farmer
A Ranga Bhuriya F Farmer
A Vesudi Garawal F Farmer
A Anita Bhuriya F Farmer
A Toli Garawal F Farmer
A Kama Bhabor F Farmer
A Sama Kharadi F Farmer
A Nirmala Dudve F Farmer
A Jenu Gaerawal F Farmer
A Sakari Dudve F Farmer
A Mamata Kharadi F Farmer
A Meta Ninama F Farmer
A Nura Bhai F Farmer
A Sushila Baberiya F Farmer
A Antuli Garawal F Farmer
A Ramatu Bhabor F Farmer
A Guddi Garawal F Farmer
A Bhuri Makwana F Farmer
A Anita Bhabor F Farmer
A Mena Bhabor F Farmer
A Shanti Ninama F Farmer
A Gulabi Bhabor F Farmer
Page 39
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
39 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
A Resama Ninama F Farmer
A Annu Makwana F Farmer
A Madi Singadiya F Farmer
A Sangeeta Pal F Farmer
A Martha Ninama F Farmer
A Shanti Makwana F Farmer
A Guddi Ninama F Farmer
A Dhulki Makawana F Farmer
A Kama Ninama F Farmer
A Geeta Bhabor F Farmer
A Gulli Ninama F Farmer
A Dalla Makawana F Farmer
A Hura Ninama F Farmer
A Priyanka Ninama F Farmer
A Bhura Ninama F Farmer
A Fatu Makawana F Farmer
A Lila Ninama F Farmer
A Narengi Pargi F Farmer
A Jhabu Pargi F Farmer
A Khima Makawana M Farmer
A Huma Bhabor M Farmer
A Roshani Makwana F Farmer
A Kalla Kharadi F Farmer
A Badali Damor F Farmer
A Saka Bariya F Farmer
A Lalita Rathod F Farmer
A Hura Khadiya F Farmer
A Senadi Bhura F Farmer
A Lali Madiya F Farmer
A Pushpa Katara F Farmer
A Guddi Ninama F Farmer
A Hakari Bariya F Farmer
A Guma Bhabor F Farmer
A Kela Bhabor F Farmer
A Sevali Ninama F Farmer
A Dhuma Bariya F Farmer
A Santa Makwana F Farmer
A Samari Bariya F Farmer
A Mangu Tersingh F Farmer
A BHamu Bariya F Farmer
A Halu Ninama F Farmer
A Dubali Bariya F Farmer
C Anjeeta Meda F Anganwadi Worker
A Bhura Bhuriya F Farmer
A Mulli Ninama F Farmer
Page 40
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
40 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
A Vikash Dudve M Farmer
A Kali Ninama Farmer
A Madan Dudve M Farmer
A Raju Makwana M Farmer
A Vijay Bhaydiya M Farmer
A Jogi Bhuriya M Farmer
A Pankesh Bhaydiya M Farmer
A Mansu Vasuniya M Farmer
A Bhavariya Baghel M Farmer
A Kaliya Baberiya M Farmer
A Sumala Baghel M Farmer
A Saka Bhabor M Farmer
A Sardar Dudve M Farmer
A Lali Baberiya F Farmer
A Navalsingh Bhagel M Farmer
A Jyoti Mariya F Farmer
A Gamatu Damor F Farmer
A Galli Baberiya F Farmer
A Suman Baghel M Farmer
A Deelip Baghel M Farmer
A Bharta Baghel M Farmer
A Bhiyan Baghel M Farmer
A Dharmsingh Baghel M Farmer
A Limsingh Baghel M Farmer
A Samir Baghel M Farmer
A Savajira Mavda M Farmer
A Sannu Bhuriya F Farmer
A Kallu Bhabor M Farmer
A Sangeeta Bhabor F Farmer
A Vesti Bhabor F Farmer
A Pangali Vasuniya F Farmer
A Hudi Bhuriya F Farmer
A Anjula Sanjay F Farmer
A Jamana Dhuliya F Farmer
A Rinku Dudve F Farmer
A Prabhu Dawar M Farmer
A Gopal Parmar M Farmer
A Mukesh Dawar M Farmer
A Ditiya Garawal M Farmer
A Prakash Dudve M Farmer
A Sandeep Dansingh M Farmer
A Salam Kanesh M Farmer
A Mukesh Solanki M Farmer
A Vikas Dudve M Farmer
A Vikram Gadriya M Farmer
Page 41
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
41 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
A Madan Dudve M Farmer
A Vinod Bhaydiya M Farmer
A Shishupal Bhaydiya M Farmer
A Mukam Chouhan M Farmer
A Varsingh Chouhan M Farmer
A Suka Ninama M Farmer
A Mesu Meda M Farmer
A Janta Makawana M Farmer
A Ramatu Makwana M Farmer
A Kama Gundiya M Farmer
A Munsingh Makwana M Farmer
A Madiya Ninama M Farmer
A Aasha Damor F Farmer
A Dhansingh Dudve M Farmer
A Ramesh Dudve M Farmer
A Kailash Dudve M Farmer
A Sumala Dudve M Farmer
A Suban Dudve M Farmer
A Kamalesh Dudve M Farmer
A Bhilu Dudve M Farmer
A Rahul Solnki M Farmer
A Vasna Bhabor M Farmer
A Pinku Dudve M Farmer
A Karmi Kanesh F Farmer
A Mamata Dudve F Farmer
A Seema Dudve F Farmer
A Jitu Singadiya M Farmer
A Narma Singadiya F Farmer
A Madi Bhabor F Farmer
A Vardi Damor F Farmer
A Aarti Ninama F Farmer
A Bhuri Manu F Farmer
A Shanti Katara F Farmer
A Aasha Makwana F Farmer
A Furati Makawana F Farmer
A Papu Bhuriya F Farmer
C Sugari Baruya F Aanganvadi Worker
A Samari Bariya F Farmer
A Mohan Bariya M Farmer
A Pangali Bhuriya F Farmer
A Mlli Baberiya F Farmer
A Jemati Bariya F Farmer
A Jahama Bariya F Farmer
A Babudi Bhabor F Farmer
A Meera Bhabor F Farmer
Page 42
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
42 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
The original signed version of the “List of participants” table can be referred to below.
A Mannu Bhabor F Farmer
A Huka Bhabor F Farmer
A Nirmala Bhabor F Farmer
A Mariya Bhabor F Farmer
A Kamiya Vasuniya F Farmer
A Hakari Ninama F Farmer
A Vina Bhabor F Farmer
A Valki Ninama F Farmer
A Mariya Meda F Farmer
A Kela Bhuriya F Farmer
A Puni Ninama F Farmer
A Jena Bhuriya F Farmer
C Fr. Piter Kattara M 7869272366 Director, Pragati So.
C Dr. Rahul Ganawa M 9981401675 CHO
C Sandeep Singh M 8392812068 Program Officer
C Ritesh Ninama M 7223919895 Project Coordinator
C Nansingh Bariya M 72259334452 Field Coordinator
C Dhuliya Bamaniya M PHED Department
C Rohit Katija M 7869339647 Field coordinator
C Sunil Gundiya M 7223945473
C Mr. Utkarsh Sethia M 8860744203 Project Manager India
C Fr. Piter Kharadi M 6267333092 Administrator
C Fr. Pratap Bariya M 6260214377 Din.
E Piter Baberiya M 7999841766 Journalist
E Sister Vineeta F - Local NJO.
E Jeemi Nirmal M 9755279888 Local NJO.
C Vijay Ganawa M 9630583203
C Nathusingh Vasuniya M 9691457292
C Pidiya Damor M 9630491195
C Miss Manila Bhabor F 9294887780 Field coordinator
C Mrs. Mamata Ganawa F 7224814532 Field Coordinator
C Mrs. Priyanka Parmar F 7389358460 Accountant
Page 43
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
43 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 44
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
44 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 45
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
45 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 46
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
46 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 47
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
47 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 48
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
48 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 49
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
49 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 50
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
50 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 51
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
51 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 52
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
52 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 53
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
53 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Page 54
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
54 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C.1.2. Pictures from physical meeting(s) (best practice)
Refer to section C.2. for the pictures that are included as part of the minutes of Local
Stakeholder Consultation meeting. The newspaper coverage of the LSC meeting is
provided below.
Figure 19: Screenshots of local newspaper coverage on the Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting.
C.2. Minutes of physical meeting(s)
Agenda of the meeting
The agenda of the Local Stakeholder Consultation (LSC) meeting was structured in
accordance with (a) the Gold Standard requirements and (b) the local customs and
habits. The agenda structure was set in line with agenda points suggested by the local
implementation partners. Therefore, the agenda included additional items to ensure
that the meeting takes place in a familiar way to all attendees. Special session on Water
Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) was also conducted as part of the meeting since this is
one of the focus points of the VPA.
Page 55
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
55 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 20: Scan of the agenda of the physical Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting. The agenda was provided to the attending stakeholders for orientation.
Opening of the meeting
• Signing of participation list: Details of stakeholders in line with Gold Standard
requirements were taken at the registration desk. Facilitation was provided by the
project team in general and especially for the participants who are unable to write
Hindi language. In the latter case, thumb prints of the participants were taken as
proof of their presence instead of a signature.
• Distribution of workshop kit: Each participant was provided with a kit which
included:
Page 56
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
56 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
(i) Key Project Information / Project Idea Note
(ii) Technology brochure
(iii) Project Impact Leaflet - SDG Assessment and Safeguarding principles
(iv) Agenda
(v) Meeting pad and pen
(vi) Selected (and relevant to project) SDG logos
(vii) Evaluation forms
• Welcome note and introduction of project team: Father Peter (Director –
Pragati Sansthan) delivered a welcome note to the participants. This was followed
up by introductions of the companies and organizations building the project team
held by representatives of Helioz Global Services, Caritas India and Pragati
Sansthan.
Figure 21: Signing of participation list.
Figure 22: Workshop kit.
Figure 23: Father Peter (Director - Pragati Sansthan) delivering a welcome note to the
participants.
Page 57
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
57 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Special session on Water Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH)
Mr. Sandeep from Caritas India delivered a session on Water, Sanitation and Hygiene
(WASH). The main objective of the session was to make the stakeholders aware of (i)
the need for safe drinking water, (ii) how drinking water is contaminated, and (iii) the
need for proper sanitation and Hygiene practices. The special session provided an
overview of core message and WASH aspects that will be addressed in the project as
part of the Hygiene Education Campaign.
Figure 24: Mr. Sandeep from Caritas India taking a session on WASH with the attending stakeholders.
Explanation of the project in non-technical terms
This session was jointly taken by Mr. Utkarsh from Helioz Global Services and Mr.
Sandeep from Caritas India. The mode of delivery was through presentation and
interactive talks. The topics covered were as follows:
• Project objective
• Project boundary and timeline
• Project scope and outreach
• Implementation structure of the project
• Financing mechanism and methodology followed by the project
• Selection criteria of Households
• Project activities: Distribution of technology (WADI) and PET bottles, planned
awareness programmes, PET bottle recycling, water testing plan, formation of WADI
groups etc.
• Socio-economic and health benefits of the project with special focus on women
empowerment
Page 58
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
58 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 25: Screenshot of a presentation slide in English language (for reference) and in Hindi language presented at the Local Stakeholder Consultation (LSC) meeting in the project region. The slide was used
to explain the project geography (implementation districts) of “Water and Climate VPA #2 – Madhya Pradesh, India” Project and a sister project – “Water and Climate VPA #1 – Madhya Pradesh, India”.
The stakeholders were also informed about the Gold Standard, the approved
methodology use for the project and the funding mechanism of carbon credit projects,
incl. transfer of carbon credit ownership to the project developer.
Page 59
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
59 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 26: Screenshot of a presentation slide in Hindi (presented) and English language (for reference) presented at the Local Stakeholder Consultation (LSC) meeting in the project region. The slide was used to explain the project financing mechanism and project methodology.
Figure 27: Mr. Sandeep from Caritas India explaining about the proposed formation of WADI groups as
part of the core project activity.
Explanation of Project Technology
The project technology WADI was explained by Mr. Utkarsh from Helioz Global Services.
The mode of explanation was hybrid and included the following:
• Power point presentation and hands on demonstration of project technology: This
included the explanation of (i) Components of Technology (WADI) (ii) the practical
application (iii) recognition of technology (example: Jal Jeevan Mission) (iv)
advantages of using the technology. Refer to section A.1. for more details.
• Technology display and demonstration (under natural sunlight): WADI and PET
bottles were kept in sunlight just outside the workshop hall. The set-up was arranged
similar to the practical application case for the user.
Page 60
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
60 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 28: Technology demonstration presentation delivered by Mr. Utkarsh from Helioz Global Services.
Figure 29: Project technology (WADI) explanation during the LSC meeting in project region. Source:
HELIOZ Group.
Figure 30: Screenshot of a presentation slide presented at the Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting in the project region. The slide was used to explain the practical application of WADI. Source: HELIOZ Group.
Page 61
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
61 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 31: WADI technology demonstration in sunlight outside the LSC hall venue.
Question and answer session about the Project and Project Technology
The session on “Project explanation” and “Project technology demonstration” was
interactive and stakeholders listened to it attentively and had certain queries. The
queries are summarized below:
Q1 – Can drinking water after being disinfected by WADI + SODIS application be stored
in “Matka” (Earthen pot)?
A1 – Yes, the disinfected water can be stored in “Matka” or can also be stored and
consumed directly from PET bottle. In case of storage in “Matka” it must be ensured
that it is clean and proper WASH measures are followed to avoid recontamination of
disinfected water.
Q2 – After disinfection of water using WADI + SODIS, how long is it drinkable?
A2 – It is recommended to use the treated water within 48 Hours once the disinfection
process is completed.
Q3 – How will WADI + SODIS work during times when there is no sunshine?
A3 – The stakeholders were informed that the method is based on UV rays of the sun
which can be present even when the sun is not visible. They were advised to consult
the WADI to determine if the UV rays were sufficient to disinfect the water. In summary
WADI can work under difficult environmental conditions like low light, clouding,
intermittent rain. It ensures an optimized disinfection time under such conditions.
Page 62
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
62 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Q4 – Will WADI be damaged when exposed to rainfall?
A4 – Stakeholders were informed that WADI is water resistant and dust proof.
Q5 – Will the WADI machine be provided free of cost?
A5 – It was explained to stakeholders that the project targets vulnerable households in
need of an environmentally friendly water treatment method. The households will
receive the WADI device for free as part of the project.
Q6 – How many water-filled bottles can be kept adjacent to WADI for disinfection?
A6 - One WADI can be used with several bottles at the same time. As WADI is a UV
measurement device that visualizes the process of Solar Water Disinfection, it is
possible to use one WADI with several PET bottles filled with contaminated water
simultaneously.
Q7 – Water scarcity is prevalent in the region. Will the project work for providing access
to water?
A7 – The project aim is to provide households with access to safe drinking water by
providing a technological solution (SODIS with WADI) for disinfecting the water
obtained from existing water sources in use.
Q8 – There is no water for irrigation of crops especially in summer season. Will the
project activities address this issue?
A8 – This is out of scope of the project under the existing project design.
Assessment of project impact (SDG Group exercise)
The aim of this exercise was to allow for free and transparent discussion among
stakeholders regarding the impact of the project and to initiate discussions regarding:
• Any perceived negative impact of the project in stakeholders’ day to day life
• Any perceived positive impact of the project in stakeholders’ day to day life
In order to facilitate this discussion, the project team divided the stakeholders in seven
groups with different focus themes. Each group was assigned one to two guiding
questions. The questions and the outcome of the discussions are documented below.
Each group presented the outcomes of their discussions to the other groups. The
assessment of the group discussion is summarized in Table 1.
Page 63
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
63 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Group No. 1
SDGs assigned - SDG 13 (Climate Action) & SDG 15 (Life on Land)
Guiding Question 1 – How do you depend on forests for your fuelwood needs?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Dependence on firewood for livelihood of the household (cooking, personal hygiene,
etc.) and the animals (fodder)
• Easy availability of firewood from forests for their use
• Benefit of good forest coverage for the environment (air quality)
Guiding Question 2 – Do you see any positive or negative effects the project
could have on forests?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• No negative impact of the project on forests
• Importance of tree and forest protection for environmental benefit
• Benefit of the project for poor/vulnerable people and their health
• Additional tree planting activities of fruit bearing trees or shady plants around the
houses could be an addition to the project
Page 64
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
64 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Group No. 2
SDG assigned - SDG 4 (Quality Education) & SDG 6 (Clean Water & Sanitation)
Guiding Question 1 – What is your knowledge regarding safe drinking water,
sanitation, hygiene & environmental protection?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Consumption of safe drinking water will not cause waterborne diseases
• Hygiene and storage: Utensils and water vessels should be kept clean to avoid
contamination of water, clean water should be properly stored
• Project can support in reduction of waterborne diseases
Guiding Question 2 – How can our project create community awareness on
these issues?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Engagement with community groups and stakeholder structures (children’s groups,
women’s meetings, Gram Sabha)
Page 65
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
65 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
• Awareness campaigns to raise community awareness (e.g. within social programs,
family engagement)
• Conversations with family members on WADI and the project
Page 66
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
66 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Group No. 3
SDG assigned - SDG 5 (Gender Equality)
Guiding Question 1 – What household work do women do and why?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Women take care of household chores (cleaning, cooking, etc.)
• Women do agricultural work – more work than done by men – and take care of
animals (collection of fodder, feeding and milking animals)
• Women take care of family members, in particular children
• Women also have additional work/jobs; example: government jobs (Anganwadi
worker, ASHA, etc.)
Guiding Question 2 – How could the project influence the life of women?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Women will get access to clean water
• Positive impact on women’s health
• Increased capacity for income generating work (e.g. working in the field) if women
are not sick
• Education and increased awareness on WASH
Page 67
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
67 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Group No. 4
SDG assigned - SDG 6 (Clean Water and Sanitation)
Guiding Question 1 - Do you have access to safe drinking water? How are you
currently disinfecting drinking water?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Drinking water is consumed directly without treating it (e.g. not filtering water)
• Need for treating water before consumption and proper storage
• Need to travel long distances for collection of drinking water (e.g. collection from
hand-pump)
Guiding Question 2 – Do you like SODIS+WADI for disinfecting water? Provide
reasons.
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• General appreciation for the technology (WADI device)
Page 68
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
68 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
• Benefits of the technology, e.g. small device that can be carried around
• Positive impact on people’s health and the environment through usage of SODIS
with WADI
Group 5
SDG assigned - SDG 6 (Clean Water and Sanitation) & SDG 3 (Good Health and Well-
Being)
Page 69
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
69 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Guiding Question 1 - How can access to safe drinking water contribute to
improved health?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Importance of treating water before drinking it using available and known methods
• Consumption of clean drinking water will not lead to sickness
• Additional proper hygiene measures are necessary, e.g. keeping water utensils
clean, personal hygiene when handling water or food, etc.
Guiding Question 2 - Do you see any effects the project could have on your
health?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Increased access to clean water
• Reduction and avoidance of diseases and sickness
• Reduction of annual medical treatment costs and frequency of hospital visits
• Increased school attendance of children due to reduction of sick days
Group 6
SDG assigned – SDG 1 (No Poverty)
Guiding question – Can the project help in improving economic conditions of
rural communities? How?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
Page 70
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
70 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
• Conservation of natural resources (wood, trees, clean air)
• Increased household savings and reduction of medical costs
Group 7
Guiding Question – Have you come across any such project before? What
have you learnt from it?
The stakeholders stressed the following points in the discussion:
• Stakeholders have not come across a similar project before, know about other
projects with focus on water but not with similar project activities and work done
• Stakeholders generally appreciated the project and recommended that
collaboration/exchange with other government or private projects could be of benefit
• Appreciation of the project design, particularly the focus on vulnerable people, the
information and awareness component on WASH and protection of wood resources
• Stakeholders heard and learned for the first time about the project technology, WADI
Page 71
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
71 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Table 1: Assessment of positive and negative impact of the project based on Stakeholder’s perspective.
SDG
Concerned
Perceived positive impact of the project
(Stakeholder’s views)
Perceived negative
impact of the project
(Stakeholder’s views)
SDG 13 & 15 The project will help in reducing deforestation.
More trees will ensure healthy life and pure air
No comments received
The project will help in reducing the need for
firewood
SDG 4 and 6 The project will help in creating awareness
related to safe drinking water, sanitation, and
hygiene
No comments received
SDG 4 and 5 The project will empower and create awareness
among SHGs, children, adolescent, and Women
groups
No comments received
SDG 1, 3, 5
and 6
Access to safe drinking water will improve
health of women. This in turn will ensure that
women be able to do household and income
generation work
No comments received
SDG 3 The project will ensure that there are less
incidences of waterborne diseases
No comments received
SDG 13 The project will help in reducing air pollution No comments received
SDG 1 The project will save time which can be put to
productive use
No comments received
SDG 1 and 3 The project will help in saving money because
of less incidences of waterborne diseases
No comments received
SDG 1 and 6 The project will ensure access to safe drinking
water
No comments received
SDG 6 The project will ensure better hygiene
conditions
No comments received
SDG 3 and 4 Less incidences of waterborne diseases will
ensure enhanced attendance in schools
No comments received
Special session – Gaps in Project
All stakeholders in the workshop were invited to provide their overall feedback on the
project design and if they see any gaps in the project design. This was documented in
the form of comments received by stakeholders (feedback cards). Figure 33 provides
an overview of the comments received (in Hindi).
Page 72
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
72 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 32 - Guiding question board "What are the gaps in the project? How it can be overcome?"
The comments received regarding the gaps in project are provided below. These and
the other comments are assessed in section C.3.
• One WADI is not sufficient for the whole family. Can more be provided?
• Sometimes water collected from handpump is turbid. What should be done regarding
this? How can the project address this issue?
• Village level meetings for discussion on WADI technology was requested
• Can project work on watershed management related activities including deepening
of wells, check dam construction, construction of farm bunds etc.?
• Scarcity of water is prevalent in summer season. What can the project do in this
regard?
• Water is scarce for agricultural purpose. Can project do anything regarding this?
Page 73
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
73 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Monitoring plan for Sustainable Development Impacts
Stakeholders were briefed regarding SDG impacts of the project by using the Project
Impact Leaflet (Refer section A.4.) and while conducting the SDG impact. Stakeholders
were also informed that the project team will conduct (i) Baseline study and (ii) Project
Impact assessment studies in line with GS4GG requirements. The project team
requested stakeholders for their coordination and support during the study.
Mechanism for input and grievance
This was discussed during the Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting. The
stakeholders and beneficiaries were encouraged to voice their feedback and grievances
concerning the project throughout the project period to enrich the process. Three modes
were presented and discussed: (i) Person to Person, (ii) Grievance Books, and (iii)
written feedback through letter or online communication. Refer to section D for more
details.
Closure of meeting
The project team thanked the workshop participants for their time and valuable
feedback. It was requested by the team to fill the evaluation forms.
Figure 33: Group photo of the LSC workshop organizer team.
Page 74
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
74 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C.1.3. Minutes of other consultations
Detailed communication and engagement with stakeholders were made during (i) the
main Local Stakeholder Consultation meeting at district level which includes all the
invited and attending stakeholders and (ii) additional follow-up meetings at “village
cluster” level especially for community stakeholders and future beneficiaries. This
decision was made to ensure that feedback on the project design is received from the
stakeholders who are not able to attend the main Local Stakeholder Consultation
meeting. The project team conducted cluster village level meetings.
The geographical scope and dates of these follow-up meetings are as described in Table
2.
VPA#2 - Jhabua & Alirajpur District Venue Details
Cluster No Date Venue (Address)
Cluster – 1 (Heerakhandan, Jhabua) 01/12/2021 Heerakhandan Aanganwadi Center
Cluster – 2 (Gopalpura, Jhabua) 02/12/2021 At St. Joseph High School Gopalpura
Cluster – 3 (Barod, Jhabua) 02/12/2021 Barod Panchayat Building
Cluster – 4 (Nawapada Bhandariya,
Jhabua)
03/12/2021 Nawapad Bhandariya Panchayat
Building
Cluster – 5 (Kotada, Jhabua) 03/12/2021 Kundala Panchayat Building
Cluster – 6 (Thapli, Alirajpur) 04/12/2021 Thapali Panchayat Building
Cluster – 7 (Jamani, Alirajpur) 04/12/2021 Jamani Panchayat Building
Cluster – 8 (Devalai, Alirajpur) 05/12/2021 Devalai Panchayat Building
Cluster – 9 (Choti Khatali, Alirajpur) 05/12/2021 Choti Khatali Panchayat Building
Cluster – 10 (Bhilkhedi, Alirajpur) 06/12/2021 Govt. Primary and Middle School
Campus Bhilkhedi
Table 2: Date and location of village cluster follow-up meetings.
Agenda of the meetings:
• Opening and signing of participant list
• Non-technical description of the project
• Technology demonstration
• Q & A session
• SDG impacts of the project
• Discussion on grievance and feedback mechanism
• Closure of meeting
Page 75
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
75 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
These meetings were conducted and facilitated by the local implementation partners
Caritas India and Pragati Sansthan and covered a total of 50 villages in 10 meetings.
Five meetings in villages of Jhabua District and five meetings in villages of Alirajpur
District.
Sample Participant list
Table 3: Village cluster level stakeholder consultation meeting held at Chhoti Khatali
village of Alirajpur district. Date of meeting: 05/12/2021.
S.No. Name of participant Male / Female Occupation
1 Mohan Juvansingh M Farmer
2 Jitendra Keramsingh M Farmer
3 Guman Sekadiya M Farmer
4 Bhavasing Dursingh M Farmer
5 Kalu Bhangada M Farmer
6 Vishal Rajamal M Farmer
7 Rekha Chandarsingh F Farmer
8 Sarita Dursingh F Farmer
9 Manisha Vesta F Farmer
10 Kusham Keramsingh F Farmer
11 Dasri Dursingh F Farmer
12 Khajari Juvansingh F Farmer
13 Navalsingh Sekadiya F Farmer
14 Pataliya Indarsingh F Farmer
15 Hiru Indarsingh F Farmer
16 Rupesh Magan M Farmer
17 Narayan Rakesh M Farmer
18 Bandari Bhagu M Farmer
19 Edi Ramu F Farmer
20 Anabai Magan F Farmer
21 Hugari Ramesh F Farmer
22 Chagan dursingh M Farmer
23 Bhadu Kalsingh M Farmer
24 Tersingh KAlsingh M Farmer
25 Magan Dursingh M Farmer
26 Prakash Kailash M Farmer
27 Dasham Narsingh M Farmer
28 Manna Bhangada M Farmer
29 Sangita Narsingh F Farmer
30 Kali Dasham F Farmer
31 Sarda Raju F Farmer
32 Shagari Narsingh F Farmer
33 Ramakha Mehtam F Farmer
34 Sangita Vikram F Farmer
Page 76
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
76 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
35 Sajja Bai Chagan F Farmer
36 Ramila Ganpat F Farmer
37 Vesta Dursingh F Farmer
38 Anita Prakash F Farmer
39 Resami Sundarsingh F Farmer
40 Kekadi Bai Hiru F Farmer
41 Karma Dungarsingh F Farmer
42 Puni Ramsingh F Farmer
43 Shayadi Raju F Farmer
44 Fundi Guman F Farmer
45 Nansingh Motisingh M Farmer
46 Ramalu Bhangada M Farmer
47 Kailash Inandru M Farmer
48 Fr. Peter Kattara M Director
49 Mr. Sandeep sigh M Program Officer
50 Ritesh Ninama M Project Coordinator
51 Abhesingh Chagan M Farmer
52 Bhisan Naharsingh M Farmer
53 Hursingh Dalsingh M Farmer
54 Nirmala Keramsingh M Aanganwadi Worker
55 Indarsingh Bhayadiya M Field Coordinator
56 Kailash Dudve M Field Coordinator
57 Keram Dudve M Field Coordinator
58 Sagar singh Bhaydiya M Field Coordinator
59 Raju Mayada M Field Coordinator
Page 77
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
77 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Figure 34: Scanned copies of participant list from Stakeholder consultation meetings held at Chhoti Khatali
village, Alirajpur district.
Photographs from the meetings
Figure 35: Stakeholder meetings at Chhoti Khatali
village in Alirajpur district.
Figure 36: Technology demonstration at a
stakeholder meeting in Gopalpura village of Jhabua
district.
Question and Answer session
Some of the general questions raised by the communities are summarized below. The
questions related to WADI were answered by the implementation partner and any
expectations from the project were noted and included in section C.3.
Page 78
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
78 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Q1 - How does WADI purify water?
A1 – WADI is a UV measurement device that visualizes the process of Solar Water
Disinfection. When microbiologically contaminated water is filled into a transparent
Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET) bottle and exposed to the sun, the UV radiation of the
sun kills pathogens in the water.
Q2 - How much time does the WADI take to purify water?
A2 – Application of WADI was explained. Project team explained that when a happy
smiley face appears on the WADI display then water is ready for consumption. The
duration depends on the UV radiation and usually takes a couple of hours.
Q3 – There is water scarcity in the village. How can the project help?
A3 - The projects aim is to provide households with access to safe drinking water by
providing a technological solution (SODIS and WADI) for disinfecting the water obtained
from existing water sources in use.
Q4 – Will the WADI machine be provided free of cost?
A4 – It was explained to stakeholders that the project target vulnerable households in
need of an environmentally friendly water treatment method. WADI will be provided to
the selected households for free as part of the project.
Q5 – How many water-filled bottles can be kept adjacent to WADI for disinfection?
A5 - One WADI can be used with several PET bottles at the same time. As WADI is a
UV measurement device that visualizes the process of Solar Water Disinfection, it is
possible to use one WADI with several PET bottles filled with contaminated water
simultaneously.
Q6 – Some of the stakeholders from particular villages demanded installation of hand
pump in the village
A6 – It was explained that this is outside the scope of the project design. The
expectation was noted for assessment by the project team.
Q7 – Some of the stakeholders from particular villages demanded deepening of wells
A7 - It was explained that this is outside the scope of the project design. The expectation
was noted for assessment by the project team.
Page 79
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
79 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Q8 – Illiteracy is a concern raised by stakeholders in some villages. How will the project
help in this regard?
A8 – The project has a strong focus on SDG 4 – Quality Education. It is aimed to provide
trainings to 30,000 people spread across Alirajpur and Jhabua district. The trainings will
be focused on (i) application of Solar Water Disinfection with WADI (ii) awareness
training on water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) measures, and (iii) environmental
protection (plastic waste management and recycling). The trainings will be adapted to
the education background of the target group.
C.3. Assessment of comments from all consultations above
Gender of
Stakeholder
Stakeholder
comment
Was comment
taken into
account (Yes/
No)?
Explanation (Why? How?)
General
(M & F)
Provide separate WADI
for school and
Anganwadis as children
and adults need
drinking water while
they are in school and
Anganwadis
Yes
The project focuses on the supply of
safe water on household level.
Although WADI usage at schools and
Anganwadis can create additional
impacts, the project will currently not
involve them in the project under the
aspects of safe water access. This
option might be explored as part of a
project expansion.
General
(M & F)
Request for retraining
on practical application
of WADI
Yes, already
planned
The households will be trained on the
application of SODIS with WADI as part
of the distribution process. The project
has a strong focus on community
empowerment through awareness
campaigns. Optimal usage of WADI by
households will be ensured via (i)
frequent visit of grassroot level field
workers to households using WADI (ii)
Discussion on WADI usage during
WADI group meetings (ii) community
level trainings and re-trainings on
WADI usage (as required).
M WADI should be
provided to all the HHs
in the villages
Yes
The project focuses on vulnerable
households in need of an
environmentally friendly method of
water treatment on household level.
Further interest in WADI will be
documented and the option to build up
a supply chain through the local
implementation partners can be
explored.
Page 80
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
80 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
M
Will the project work on
removal of chemical
contaminants from
water
No, beyond
the scope of
project
WADI is a UV measurement device that
visualizes the process of Solar Water
Disinfection. The process of SODIS is
used to remove microbiological
contaminants from water. It does not
remove metals or chemical pollutants.
F
A woman stakeholder
requested to consider
providing WADI for free
of cost
Yes, was
already
planned
The project has a defined selection
criteria for the eligible households that
will receive WADI. WADI will be
provided to the selected households for
free as part of project based on current
project design.
General
(M & F)
Water scarcity is
prevalent in the villages
especially during
summer season. Will
the project work for
providing access
(availability) to water?
No, beyond
the scope of
project
The projects aim is to provide
households with access to safe drinking
water by providing a technological
solution (WADI + SODIS) for
disinfecting the water obtained from
existing water sources in use.
M
There is no water for
irrigation of crops
especially in summer
season. Will the project
activities address this
issue?
No, beyond
the scope of
project
The current project is focused on
drinking water and WASH and does not
include the provision of irrigation grade
water for agricultural activities.
F
One WADI is not
sufficient for the whole
family. Can more be
provided?
Yes
As WADI is a UV measurement device
that visualizes the process of Solar
Water Disinfection, it is possible to use
one WADI with several PET bottles
filled with contaminated water
simultaneously. This will ensure that
sufficient water can be disinfected with
the help of one WADI and several
bottles per household. If a household
require more than one WADI device to
cater to their needs, additional WADI
devices can be procured/purchased.
General
(M & F)
Sometimes water
collected from
handpump is turbid.
Will project address this
issue
Yes
The project focuses on providing
access to safe drinking water at
household level by providing SODIS +
WADI to households for water
disinfection. The project has a strong
WASH component built in it which aims
to provide awareness among
stakeholders regarding best practices
in relation to water, sanitation and
hygiene.
Page 81
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
81 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Approaches to reduce turbidity of
drinking water at household level for
pre-treatment are part of the WASH
awareness campaign.
General
(M & F)
Village level meetings
for discussion on WADI
technology was
requested
Yes, was
already
planned
Detailed communication and
engagement with stakeholders were
made during (i) the main Local
Stakeholder Consultation meeting and
(ii) additional follow-up meetings at
village cluster level.
The project team will continuously visit
villages as part of implementation and
monitoring activities. Regular village
level meetings for exchange on project
technology and further questions are
planned.
General
(M & F)
Can project work on
watershed management
related activities
including deepening of
wells, check dam
construction,
construction of farm
bunds etc.?
No, beyond
the scope of
project
The current project is focused on
provision of safe drinking water and
WASH. Watershed management and
related activities are beyond the scope
of the current project. The need for
such activities is noted by the project
team.
General
(M & F)
Demand for handpump
installation and well
deepening
No, beyond
the scope of
project
The current project is focused on
provision of safe drinking water and
WASH.
F
Illiteracy is a concern
raised by stakeholders
in some villages. How
will the project help in
this regard?
Yes, already
planned
The project has a strong focus on SDG
4 – Quality Education. It is aimed to
provide trainings on the project
technology and WASH to at least
30,000 people spread across Alirajpur
and Jhabua district. The trainings will
be adapted to the education
background of the target group.
Page 82
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
82 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C.3.1. Evaluation forms (best practice)
Name Ajita Medha
Function/Organization Farmer
Gender – Male/Female: Female
What is your impression of the meeting? We loved this project
What do you like about the project? felt good
We loved the wadi machine
What do you not like about the project?
Signature Ajita
Name Mr. Lal Singh Kharadi
Function/Organization Farmer
Gender – Male/Female: Male
What is your impression of the meeting? Good and this type of meeting should be taken place
What do you like about the project? Wadi device every family should have
What do you not like about the project? Nothing
Signature Lal Singh
Name Seema Dudway
Function/Organization Housewife
Gender – Male/Female: Female
What is your impression of the
meeting?
Everything about this project is good, the water should
be boiled, cleaned and drunk.
What do you like about the project? Wadi device
What do you not like about the
project?
everything seemed fine
Signature
Name Bheelu Dudwe
Function/Organization Farmer
Gender – Male/Female: Male
What is your impression of the
meeting?
We liked this project very much and will make this project
successful in future also. we are very happy
What do you like about the project? Here we found everything good and learned to purify
water.
What do you not like about the
project?
everything seemed fine
Signature
Name Maria Medha
Function/Organization Group secretary
Gender – Male/Female: female
What is your impression of the
meeting?
I got education about clean water in the meeting. Nice to
know about this project
Page 83
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
83 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
What do you like about the project? wadi device
What do you not like about the
project?
everything seemed fine
Signature
Page 84
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
84 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
C.4. Summary of alterations based on comments
No alterations of the project design due to stakeholder comments are necessary. There
were no major societal, environmental, or other concerns raised during the Local
Stakeholder Consultation meeting and follow-up meetings which would result in the
need to change the project design. The feedback on planned activities was overly
positive. The stakeholders welcomed the project in the community and shared the need
for a water treatment solution and additional activities addressing WASH and climate
change. All concerns or questions stakeholders raised during the Stakeholder
Consultation meeting as well as the follow-up village cluster meetings were jointly
discussed in the plenum and clarified and explained by the project team to the
stakeholders. The project team takes note of the need for water supply solutions in
particular for agricultural purposes in the project region.
Page 85
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
85 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
SECTION D. CONTINUOUS INPUT / GRIEVANCE MECHANISM
Method Chosen (include all known details e.g.,
location of book, phone, number, identity
of mediator)
Justification of Choice
(best practice)
Continuous Input /
Grievance Expression
Process Book
(mandatory)
Grievance/Feedback books: The general
project description as well as feedback
books will be placed at key intervention
points (e.g. local office of implementation
partners) that are easily accessible to
stakeholders. Stakeholders and project
communities will be informed about the
location where and mode how feedback can
be provided.
Continuous feedback: The monitoring
process of the project includes regular
community meetings and household visits
through the field team of the
implementation partners. The field team will
document any feedback/grievances of the
community members (analogue notes &
digital notes in monitoring app).
(i) In line with GS4GG
requirements
(ii) The method was
discussed during the
Local Stakeholder
Consultation meeting
with stakeholders and
the stakeholders were
comfortable with it.
GS Contact (mandatory) [email protected] N.A.
Other Project Developer: Helioz Global
Services Pvt. Ltd.
GF and FF, Worldmark L, Asset Area 11
Aerocity Hospitality District
IGI Airport, New Delhi, South West Delhi DL
110037, India
Attn. Gregor Riss
Director
E: [email protected]
Attn. Barbara Oberfichtner
Programme Manager
E: [email protected]
Attn. Utkarsh Sethia
Project Manager India
E: [email protected]
Implementation Partners: Caritas India
and Pragati Sansthan
Caritas India
Attn. Mr. Ghanshyam Jethwa
Head of Programmes
Caritas India, CBCI Centre, 1 Ashoka Place,
Goledakkhana,
New Delhi, 110 001
Agreed and discussed
within concerned
organizations (Helioz
Global Services,
Caritas India and
Pragati Sansthan) to
assign the contact
points.
Page 86
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
86 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
E: [email protected]
Pragati Sansthan
Attn. Fr. Peter Katara
Director - Pragati Sansthan
Jeevan Jyoti Hospital Campus,
Meghnagar, District Jhabua
Madhya Pradesh – 457779
E: [email protected]
SECTION E. STAKEHOLDER FEEDBACK ROUND
Please check this box if the project is retroactive and has done only 1 consultation
with a physical meeting integrated into the SFR.
Length of the Feedback Round
Stakeholder Feedback Round Planned Actual
Start Date 11/02/2022
End Date 12/04/2022
Summarise how all stakeholders were/will be invited to provide feedback
The Stakeholder Feedback Round will use different mechanisms to invite stakeholders
for feedback:
• Publication of the Local Stakeholder Consultation report on the website of the
HELIOZ Group
• E-mail invitation to the Stakeholder Feedback Round for stakeholders that
attended and could not attend the meeting
• Provision of printed copies of the Local Stakeholder Consultation report as well
as an overview of the core comments/feedback received during the physical
meeting (in Hindi) to community stakeholders at central access points (e.g.,
office of implementation partner, PHED, District Health Department, etc.).
Page 87
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
87 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Summarise Feedback received, including if any changes in project design were
made
To be completed after the Stakeholder Feedback Round.
Page 88
TEMPLATE- T-PreReview_V1.1-Stakeholder-Consultation-Report
88 Climate Security and Sustainable Development
Revision History
Version Date Remarks
1.1 14 October
2020
Inclusion of Key Project Information
Restructure, new headings and reorder to better match the
steps a developer will follow in consultations.
Removal of some non-mandatory template tables (Blind
Sustainable Development Assessment). Clarification of best
practice steps that are non mandatory processes, clarification
of mandatory discussion points. Clarification regarding
publishing names and that original evaluation forms (optional)
and attendance lists (mandatory) should be separate
documents.
Improved clarity on Stakeholder Feedback round section and
procedures for retroactive projects
Provision of an accompanying Guide to help the user
understand detailed rules and requirements
1.0 14 August
2017
Initial adoption