Symmetry of Single-walled Carbon Nanotubes
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 1/15
Symmetry of Single-walled
Carbon Nanotubes
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 2/15
Carbon Nanotubes
Outline
Part I (November 29)
Symmetry operations
Line groups
Part II (December 6)
Irreducible representations Symmetry-based quantum numbers
Phonon symmetries
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 3/15
Construction of nanotubes
a1 , a 2 primitive lattice vectors of
graphene
Chiral vector:
c = n1 a1 + n2 a2
n1 , n2 integers: chiral numbers
Mirror lines:
"zig-zag line” through the midpoint of
bonds
"armchair line” through the atoms
Sixfold symmetry: 0 < 60°
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 4/15
Construction of nanotubes
a1 , a 2 primitive lattice vectors of
graphene
Chiral vector:
c = n1 a1 + n2 a2
n1 , n2 integers: chiral numbers
Mirror lines:
"zig-zag line” through the midpoint of
bonds
"armchair line” through the atoms
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 5/15
Why "chiral" vector?
Chiral structure: no mirror symmetry
"left-handed" and "right-handed" versions
If c is not along a mirror line then the
structure is chiral
and 60° – pairs of chiral structures
It is enough to consider 0 30°
n1 n2 0
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 6/15
Discrete translational symmetry
The line perpendicular to the chiral vector
goes through a lattice point.
(For a general triangular lattice, this is
only true if cos ( a1 ,a2) is rational. For
the hexagonal lattice cos ( a1 ,a 2) = ½.)
Period:
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 7/15
Space groups and line groups
Space group describes the symmetries of a crystal.
General element is an isometry:
( R | t ) , where R O(3) orthogonal transformation (point symmetry: it has a fixed point)
t = n1 a1 + n2 a2 + n3 a3 3T (3) (superscript: 3 generators, argument: in 3d space)
Line group describes the symmetries of nanotubes (or linear polymers, quasi-1d subunitsof crystals)
( R | t ) , where R O(3)
t = n a 1T (3) (1 generator in 3d space)
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 8/15
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 9/15
Rotations about the principal axis
Let n be the greatest common divisorof the chiral numbers n1 and n2 .
The number of lattice points (open
circles) along the chiral vector is n + 1.
Therefore there is a C n rotation (2 / n
angle) about the principal axis of the
line group.
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 10/15
Mirror planes and twofold rotations
Mirror planes only in achiral nanotubes
Twofold rotations in all nanotubes
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 11/15
Screw operations
All hexagons are equivalent in thegraphene plane and also in the
nanotubes
General lattice vector of graphene
corresponds to a screw operation in the
nanotube:
Combination of
rotation about the line axis
translation along the line axis
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 12/15
General form of screw operations
q — number of carbon atoms in the unit cell
n — greatest common divisor of the chiral numbers n1 and n2
a — primitive translation in the line group (length of the unit cell)
Fr(x) — fractional part of the number x
( x) — Euler function
All nanotube line groups are non-symmorphic!
Nanotubes are single-orbit structures!
(Any atom can be obtained from any other atom by applying a symmetry operation
of the line group.)
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 13/15
Glide planes
Only in chiral nanotubes
Combination of reflexion to a plane
and a translation
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 14/15
Line groups and point groups of carbon
nanotubesChiral nanotubs:
Lq p22
Achiral nanotubes:
L2nn / mcm
Construction of point group PG of a line group G :
( R | t ) ( R | 0 ) (This is not the group of point symmetries of the nanotube!)
Chiral nanotubs:
q22 ( Dq in Schönfliess notation)
Achiral nanotubes:
2n / mmm ( D2nh in Schönfliess notation)
8/2/2019 Symmetry of SWNTs Kriza Gyorgy I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/symmetry-of-swnts-kriza-gyorgy-i 15/15
Site symmetry of carbon atoms
Chiral nanotubs:
1 (C 1) only identity operation leaves the carbon atom invariant
Achiral nanotubes:
m (C 1h) there is a mirror plane through each carbon atom