Top Banner
24

Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale

Jul 29, 2015

Download

Documents

Avtips

Confidential Evaluation leaked by the Swiss media. The Gripen NG was chosen by the Federal Government, but the report reveals that the Gripen is not able to fulfill the minimum requirements needed during standard operations in the national airspace.
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 2: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 3: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 4: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 5: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 6: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 7: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 8: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 9: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 10: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 11: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 12: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 13: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 14: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 15: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 16: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 17: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 18: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 19: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 20: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 21: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 22: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale
Page 23: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale

Evaluationskriterien (1/2)

1. operationelle Wirksamkeit (60 %)- Luft-Luft (50 %)- Aufklärung und Luft-Boden (je 20 %) - Wachstumspotential (10 %)

2. operationelle Eignung (15 %)- Wartungs-Prozesse (30 %)

5

- Wartungs-Prozesse (30 %)- Miliztauglichkeit (25 %)- Kompatibilität mit CH Infrastruktur (25 %)- Lärm- und Abgas-Emissionen (20 %)

3. Beteiligung / Kooperation (25 %)- Beteiligung CH Industrie (70 %) - militärische Kooperation (30 %)

Page 24: Swiss Air Force Confidential Report on the Evaluation of the Eurofighter, the Gripen NG, and the Rafale

Evaluationskriterien (2/2)

Kosten- Beschaffung, inkl. Logistikpaket- Anpassung Infrastruktur- Betrieb und Instandhaltung erste zehn Jahre (3x)

pro memoria:

6

pro memoria:- Risiken- Zeitplan- Verhältnis Wirksamkeit zu Kosten

nicht Kompetenz der Projektorganisation:- politische Aspekte