Top Banner
Energy and water conserva0on expo and forum 2013
33

Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Apr 20, 2023

Download

Documents

May Al-Saffar
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Energy  and  water  conserva0on  expo  and  forum  2013  

Page 2: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Name  :  May  Jalal  Al-­‐Saffar    Profession  :  Architect/  Researcher  Na0onality  :  Bahraini    Organiza0on  :  Bri0sh  University  in  Dubai  

Msc.  In  Sustainable  Design  and  Built  Environment        

Page 3: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Life-Cycle Assessment of Sustainable Buildings

May  Al-­‐Saffar    Bri-sh  University  in  Dubai    

Page 4: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

LCA is the detailed analysis that gives you the information you need to make the most environmentally friendly decisions throughout product design.

What is sustainability ?

Page 5: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Culture Technology China

Dubai

And all over the world

Page 6: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

BACK to the ecology

Page 7: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)
Page 8: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Extended Problem!

New York

London

Dubai

TODAY

Page 9: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Problem Definition Bahrain!

Waste    

Landfill    

Transporta0on    

Construc0on    

Page 10: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Solution

Page 11: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Do  you  know  the  problem?  

Do  you  know  the  solu-on?  

YES  ?

Page 12: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making Correct answer

(4)  Acquisi0on     (1) Procurement/     Construc0on        

(2)  Consump0on        (3)  Disposal        Back  to  nature  (Grave)  

From  nature  (Cradle)  Manufacture  Process    Assemble  Pack  Transporta-on    

Energy,  Water    Maintenance    Refurbishment    

Reuse    Reduce    Recycle  (Cradle)      

(LCA)  is  technique  to  assess  environmental  impacts  associated  with  all  stages  of  product  life  

Page 13: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design

Op-on  1  :  Masdar  city  in  Abu  Dhabi       Op-on  2  :  Some  where  in  Dubai      

Page 14: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design

Page 15: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Example  :  Choosing  the  ligh-ng  fixtures  –  Stage  1    

To  get  an  indica-on  of  energy  and  electrical  demand  savings  possible  with  dayligh-ng;  this  figure  shows  how  many  60  W  incandescent  lamps  would  be  required  to  produce  the  same  amount  of  light  as  a  .9  X  1.5  window  

Page 16: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Example  :  Choosing  the  ligh-ng  fixtures  –  Stage  2    

To  get  an  indica-on  of  energy  and  electrical  demand  savings  possible  with  CFL  ;  this  figure  shows  how  many  60  W  incandescent  lamps  would  be  required  to  produce  the  same  amount  of  light  as  1  CFL  light  1800  W  

Page 17: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Example  :  Choosing  the  ligh-ng  fixtures  –  Stage  3    

Op-on  1:    Incandescent  Lamp  Cost:   BD  0.150  Output:     1250  W  

Op-on  2:    CFL  Lamp  Cost:   BD  1.500  Output:     1250  W  

-­‐ Based  on  the  informa-on  which  one  are  you  going  to  choose?  -­‐ Are  you  aware  of  those  two  lamps  or  not?  Does  your  awareness  affect  your  decision?  

Page 18: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Example  :  Choosing  the  ligh-ng  fixtures  –  Stage  3  (Con-nue)    

Op-on  1:    Incandescent  Lamp  Cost:   BD  0.150  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   100  W  Life  Span:  1000  hr  

Op-on  2:    CFL  Lamp  Cost:   BD  1.500  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   20  W  Life  Span:  8000  hr  

&  NOW  Based  on  the  informa-on  which  one  are  you  going  to  choose?  -­‐ Are  you  aware  of  those  two  lamps  or  not?  Does  your  awareness  affect  your  decision?  

Business  case  (Payback  period,  return  on  investment  …..  Etc)      

Page 19: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Factors  affec-ng  the  decision  making:  

(1)  Affordability    (2)  Ownership      

(3)  Lows  and  codes        

(4)  Engagement  (the  will)          

(5)  Future  thinking  (Energy  Saving)    

Page 20: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Factors  affec-ng  the  decision  making  (Con-nue):    

Op-on  1:    Incandescent  Lamp  Cost:   BD  0.150  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   100  W  Life  Span:  1000  hr  

Op-on  2:    CFL  Lamp  Cost:   BD  1.500  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   20  W  Life  Span:  8000  hr  

-­‐ No  flickering  -­‐ Good  color  rendering  -­‐ Color  temperature    -­‐ No  noise    

-­‐Flickering  -­‐ Low  color  rendering  -­‐ Color  temperature    -­‐ Noise    

Page 21: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Example  :  Choosing  the  ligh-ng  fixtures  –  Stage  4  (Con-nue)    

Op-on  1:    Incandescent  Lamp  Cost:   BD  0.150  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   100  W  Life  Span:  1000  hr  

-­‐ No  flickering  -­‐ Good  color  rendering  -­‐ Color  temperature    -­‐ No  noise    

Op-on  2:    CFL  Lamp  Cost:   BD  1.500  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   20  W  Life  Span:  8000  hr  

-­‐Flickering  -­‐ Low  color  rendering  -­‐ Color  temperature    -­‐ Noise    

-­‐ General  Waste     -­‐ Hazardous  Waste    

Lamp  contents  glass,  metals  but    NO  mercury    

Lamp  contents  glass,  metals  and    1  to  5  mlg    mercury  per  lamp      

NOW  what  ?  Should  we  banned  CFL  lamps?    

Page 22: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Health  and  Environmental  problems:  in  many  countries  hazardous  waste  is  dumped  in  landfills  along  with  general  waste.  

Page 23: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design (1)  How  much  would  it  take  to  clean  the  environment?  (2)  Who  will  carry  that  cost  of  collec0ng  and  transporta0on  processing?      

Page 24: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Industrial  country  have  programs  for  collec0ng  and  recycling  CFL  

Page 25: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design (1)  How  much  would  it  cost  to  clean  the  environment  from  mercury  ader  using  it?    

1)  The  improper  disposal  of  the  CFL  lamps  can  cause  mercury  to  be  released  to  the  air  and  water.  2)  Mercury  in  the  waterway  is  changed  by  bacteria  into  harmful  components  on  toxic  from  that  builds  up  in  animals  that  eats  fish.  3)  Most  humans  are  exposed  to  mercury  effects  is  from  ea-ng  contaminated  fish    

1  mg  of  mercury  can  contaminate  huge  area  of  sea  water.          

Cradle  to  Cradle    

Page 26: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)
Page 27: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design Example  :  Choosing  the  ligh-ng  fixtures  –  Stage  5  (Con-nue)    

Op-on  1:    Incandescent  Lamp  Cost:   BD  0.150  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   100  W  Life  Span:  1000  hr  

-­‐ No  flickering  -­‐ Good  color  rendering  -­‐ Color  temperature    -­‐ No  noise  -­‐ General  Waste  

Op-on  2:    CFL  Lamp  Cost:   BD  1.500  Output:     1250  W  

Power:   20  W  Life  Span:  8000  hr  

-­‐Flickering  -­‐ Low  color  rendering  -­‐ Color  temperature    -­‐ Noise  -­‐ Hazardous  Waste    

-­‐ Mercury  emissions  due  to  electricity  genera0on  is  5  –  6  mg      

-­‐ Mercury  emission  due  to  electricity  genera0on  is  1-­‐1.5  mg  

How  clean  is  the  electricity  we  are  using?  

THINK    

Page 28: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design

Cradle  to  Cradle    Cradle  to  Grave    

Page 29: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design

Reuse  and  renovate  instead  of  demolish  

Page 30: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design

Reuse  

Page 31: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Decision making in sustainable design

If  you  demolish  you  s0ll  can  recycle  

Asphalt  and  concrete    

Page 32: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Problems associated with LCA -­‐ New  approach  to  the  market.    -­‐ What  is  the  func0on  unit?  (example:  toy,  house,  phone  ..etc)  -­‐ Varity  of  process  done  are  huge  to  each  product.  -­‐ Impact  categoriza0on  is  different  (global  warming,  foot  print  or  maybe  health  issues.    -­‐ No  na0onal/worldwide  standardized  system  for  LCA.  -­‐ Lace  of  accurate  databases.  -­‐ Every  study  has  different  outputs.  -­‐ Lack  of  awareness  and  educa0on.        

Page 33: Sustainable Buildings Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Thank you

May Al-Saffar The British University in Dubai

[email protected]