RMF Consulting Group Presented by: Presented by: Robert Frimet, CAMS Robert Frimet, CAMS S S uspicious uspicious A A ctivity ctivity R R eport eport Check Cashers and Check Cashers and Pawn Shops Pawn Shops
RMF Consulting Group
Presented by:Presented by: Robert Frimet, CAMSRobert Frimet, CAMS
SSuspicioususpicious AActivityctivity
RReporteport
Check Cashers and Check Cashers and
Pawn ShopsPawn Shops
RMF Consulting Group
2
Presentation ObjectivesPresentation Objectives
•• Demonstrate the importance of filing SARsDemonstrate the importance of filing SARs
•• Illustrate how to identify suspicious activitiesIllustrate how to identify suspicious activities
•• Identify the traits of a quality SAR Identify the traits of a quality SAR
•• Define SAR recordkeeping requirementsDefine SAR recordkeeping requirements
RMF Consulting Group
3
Money LaunderingMoney Laundering
•• Engaging in financial transactions to Engaging in financial transactions to
disguise:disguise:
–– OriginOrigin
–– True natureTrue nature
–– Ownership of illicit fundsOwnership of illicit funds
•• $1$1 to to $2$2 trillion laundered worldwide trillion laundered worldwide
annuallyannually
•• Terrorists/ tax evaders / criminals use Terrorists/ tax evaders / criminals use
large cash payments to large cash payments to ““launderlaunder”” money money
from illegal activitiesfrom illegal activities
RMF Consulting Group
4
StatisticsStatistics
•• Since the October 1, 2002, money services business filers have Since the October 1, 2002, money services business filers have submitted 1,165,804 SARs.submitted 1,165,804 SARs.
•• The number of SARs filed by money services businesses during theThe number of SARs filed by money services businesses during thefirst six months of 2006 increased 52% from the same period in first six months of 2006 increased 52% from the same period in 2005.2005.
•• Money services business filers identified money transfers as theMoney services business filers identified money transfers as themost common type of financial service involved in suspicious most common type of financial service involved in suspicious activity.activity.
•• During the first six months of 2006, suspicious activity During the first six months of 2006, suspicious activity characterized as characterized as ““Same individual's) using multiple locations over a Same individual's) using multiple locations over a short period time periodshort period time period”” increased 138% from the same period in increased 138% from the same period in 2005.2005.
•• In the first six months of 2006, suspicious activity characterizIn the first six months of 2006, suspicious activity characterized as ed as ““Comes in frequently and purchases less than $3,000Comes in frequently and purchases less than $3,000”” increased increased 94% from the same period in 2005.94% from the same period in 2005.
RMF Consulting Group
6
MMoney oney SServices ervices BBusinesses (usinesses (MSBsMSBs) )
Required to File SARs:Required to File SARs:•• Issuers of travelerIssuers of traveler’’s checks or money orderss checks or money orders
•• Sellers / redeemers of travelerSellers / redeemers of traveler’’s checks or money orders s checks or money orders
•• Money transmittersMoney transmitters
•• Currency exchangersCurrency exchangers
•• Check cashers only (voluntary)Check cashers only (voluntary)
•• Pawn Brokers (voluntary) Pawn Brokers (voluntary)
RMF Consulting Group
7
MSB required to file a SAR when it knows / suspects MSB required to file a SAR when it knows / suspects
that:that:
•• Source of Source of fundsfunds isis derivedderived from illegal activityfrom illegal activity or or conducted to conducted to disguise fundsdisguise funds from illegal activityfrom illegal activity
•• Transaction Transaction designeddesigned to to evade BSA requirementsevade BSA requirements
•• Appears to serveAppears to serve nono known known businessbusiness or apparent or apparent lawful lawful purposepurpose
•• UsesUses the the MSB MSB to to facilitate criminal activityfacilitate criminal activity
•• And is $2,000 and or more.And is $2,000 and or more.
SARSAR
RMF Consulting Group
8
SarSar requirements for the Pawn Brokerrequirements for the Pawn Broker
For Pawn Brokers:For Pawn Brokers:
•• A transaction in which it appears the customer A transaction in which it appears the customer
is attempting to cause the 8300 form not to be is attempting to cause the 8300 form not to be
filed, or is trying to cause the filing of a false or filed, or is trying to cause the filing of a false or
incomplete form, or a transaction that appears incomplete form, or a transaction that appears
to be to be ““IllegalIllegal””..
RMF Consulting Group
11
What is Suspicious?What is Suspicious?
•• This determination can be subjective This determination can be subjective
•• Requires use of judgmentRequires use of judgment and and knowledge of normal business knowledge of normal business practices practices
•• A suspicious transaction may:A suspicious transaction may:
–– stand out as unusual or stand out as unusual or
–– have no apparent business or have no apparent business or lawful purposelawful purpose
RMF Consulting Group
12
SAR Red FlagsSAR Red Flags
An MSB should ask itself:An MSB should ask itself:
•• Is the amount of the transaction unusually large Is the amount of the transaction unusually large
for a typical customer or for the MSB?for a typical customer or for the MSB?
•• Does the customer make the same or similar Does the customer make the same or similar
transactions more frequently than normal?transactions more frequently than normal?
•• Does the type of transaction seem unusual for Does the type of transaction seem unusual for
the customer or the MSB?the customer or the MSB?
RMF Consulting Group
13
SAR Red Flags SAR Red Flags ––Pawn BrokerPawn Broker
An Pawn Broker should ask itself:An Pawn Broker should ask itself:
•• Is the amount of the transaction unusually large Is the amount of the transaction unusually large
for a typical customer (3 Rolex watches)for a typical customer (3 Rolex watches)
•• Does the customer make the similar transactions Does the customer make the similar transactions
more frequently than normal? (pawning more frequently than normal? (pawning
numerous high ticket items regularly) numerous high ticket items regularly)
•• Does the type of transaction seem unusual for Does the type of transaction seem unusual for
the customer or the Pawn Brokerthe customer or the Pawn Broker
RMF Consulting Group
14
Customers attempt to evade BSA reporting or recordkeeping Customers attempt to evade BSA reporting or recordkeeping requirements by keeping transactions just below the reporting orrequirements by keeping transactions just below the reporting or
recordkeeping thresholds such as: recordkeeping thresholds such as:
–– Currency exchanges just under Currency exchanges just under $1,000$1,000
–– Cash sales of money orders or travelerCash sales of money orders or traveler’’s checks just under s checks just under $3,000$3,000
–– Pawn redemptions in a combination of cash and checks that Pawn redemptions in a combination of cash and checks that are $10,000 or greater.are $10,000 or greater.
–– Items that have a high propensity to be stolen.Items that have a high propensity to be stolen.
–– Other Examples?????????????????????Other Examples?????????????????????
SAR Red Flags SAR Red Flags --ThresholdsThresholds
RMF Consulting Group
15
SAR Red Flags SAR Red Flags –– CustomersCustomers
Customer red flags include:Customer red flags include:
•• Providing insufficient and/or suspicious Providing insufficient and/or suspicious information information
•• Engaging in activity inconsistent with normal Engaging in activity inconsistent with normal business practices and/or customerbusiness practices and/or customer’’s businesss business
•• Engaging in activity that seems unusual or Engaging in activity that seems unusual or illogical for any reason, business or notillogical for any reason, business or not
•• Changing normal business habitsChanging normal business habits
RMF Consulting Group
16
SAR Red Flags SAR Red Flags –– EmployeesEmployees
Employee traits that might cause suspicion Employee traits that might cause suspicion
include:include:
•• Living a lifestyle not supported by salary Living a lifestyle not supported by salary
•• Reluctance to take a vacationReluctance to take a vacation
•• Is working when unusually large transactions, Is working when unusually large transactions,
or numbers of transactions take place at the or numbers of transactions take place at the
MSB or Pawn Shop.MSB or Pawn Shop.
RMF Consulting Group
17
RedRed Flags reported by banks on pawnFlags reported by banks on pawn
•• Two hundred and fortyTwo hundred and forty--six SARs were reviewed six SARs were reviewed
from the years 1996 through 2002. filed by from the years 1996 through 2002. filed by
banks on pawn brokers The following are banks on pawn brokers The following are
summaries of these types of activities summaries of these types of activities
•• The top five reported violations were: 1) The top five reported violations were: 1)
BSA/Structuring/Money Laundering (52.15%); BSA/Structuring/Money Laundering (52.15%);
2) Other (8.28%); 3) Credit Card Fraud 2) Other (8.28%); 3) Credit Card Fraud
(7.97%); 4) Check Kiting (7.36%); and 5) (7.97%); 4) Check Kiting (7.36%); and 5)
Check Fraud (4.91%). Check Fraud (4.91%).
RMF Consulting Group
18
RedRed Flags reported by banks on pawnFlags reported by banks on pawn
•• A number of pawnbrokers conducted unusually large A number of pawnbrokers conducted unusually large
cash deposits and withdrawals, relative to the type of cash deposits and withdrawals, relative to the type of
business, at various alternating bank branches. SARs business, at various alternating bank branches. SARs
were filed on those pawnbrokers exhibiting a high were filed on those pawnbrokers exhibiting a high
frequency of this activity relative to other closely frequency of this activity relative to other closely
located pawnshops.located pawnshops.
•• Numerous pawnbrokers withdrew and/or deposited Numerous pawnbrokers withdrew and/or deposited
cash just falling under the CTR reporting requirements. cash just falling under the CTR reporting requirements.
Some customers did so with unusual frequency within a Some customers did so with unusual frequency within a
short period of time (days) at various bank branches short period of time (days) at various bank branches
within close proximity. within close proximity.
RMF Consulting Group
19
SAR SAR –– Essential Elements (MSBEssential Elements (MSB’’s)s)
To be useful to authorities, all SARs should contain To be useful to authorities, all SARs should contain
the the ““5 Ws and the How5 Ws and the How”” of the transaction: of the transaction:
•• WhoWho
•• WhatWhat
•• WhenWhen
•• WhereWhere
•• WhyWhy
•• HowHow
RMF Consulting Group
20
SAR Quality SAR Quality –– Who?Who?
To explainTo explain whowho is conducting criminal or suspicious is conducting criminal or suspicious
activity a SAR should include the customeractivity a SAR should include the customer’’s:s:
–– Descriptive informationDescriptive information
–– Employer / occupational informationEmployer / occupational information
–– Relationship to the MSBRelationship to the MSB
–– Length of financial relationshipLength of financial relationship
RMF Consulting Group
21
SAR Quality SAR Quality –– What?What?
The SAR should describe The SAR should describe whatwhat instrument the instrument the
customer used in the transaction, such as :customer used in the transaction, such as :
•• Cash deposits/withdrawalsCash deposits/withdrawals
•• Checks (cashiers, bank)Checks (cashiers, bank)
•• Money ordersMoney orders
•• TravelerTraveler’’s checkss checks
•• Wire transfersWire transfers
RMF Consulting Group
22
SAR Quality SAR Quality –– When?When?
•• Give the date of the Give the date of the
transaction for a one time transaction for a one time
occurrence occurrence
•• Give the date first Give the date first
detected and a description detected and a description
of activity for a series of of activity for a series of
transactionstransactions
To describe To describe whenwhen the suspicious activity occurred, the suspicious activity occurred,
the SAR should:the SAR should:
RMF Consulting Group
23
SAR Quality SAR Quality –– Where?Where?
Every SAR should accurately describe Every SAR should accurately describe wherewhere the the
activity took place by : activity took place by :
•• Naming the branch, department and location(s) Naming the branch, department and location(s)
of the MSB where the transaction occurred of the MSB where the transaction occurred
•• Identifying all account numbers and types of Identifying all account numbers and types of
accounts involvedaccounts involved
•• Indicating involvement of other MSBsIndicating involvement of other MSBs
RMF Consulting Group
24
SAR Quality SAR Quality –– Why?Why?
A SAR must explain A SAR must explain whywhy the transaction is the transaction is
suspicious by: suspicious by:
•• Describing its businessDescribing its business
•• Clearly describing why it believes the Clearly describing why it believes the
transaction is suspicioustransaction is suspicious
RMF Consulting Group
25
SAR Quality SAR Quality –– How?How?
Lastly, the SAR must explain Lastly, the SAR must explain howhow the suspicious the suspicious
activity occurred by: activity occurred by:
•• Concisely, accurately and logically describing Concisely, accurately and logically describing
how the customer completed the how the customer completed the
transaction(s) andtransaction(s) and
•• Providing an as complete as possible Providing an as complete as possible
explanation of the customerexplanation of the customer’’s source and s source and
application of the transacted fundsapplication of the transacted funds
RMF Consulting Group
26
SAR Quality SAR Quality -- RecapRecapEach SAR narrative must:Each SAR narrative must:
•• Describe what is unusual, irregular or suspiciousDescribe what is unusual, irregular or suspicious
•• Describe conduct that raised suspicionDescribe conduct that raised suspicion
•• Explain if transaction was attempted or completedExplain if transaction was attempted or completed
•• Explain who benefited from transactionExplain who benefited from transaction
•• Describe/retain explanation provided by subjectDescribe/retain explanation provided by subject
•• Describe the subjectDescribe the subject
•• Describe and retain any evidenceDescribe and retain any evidence
•• Do Not includeDo Not include any any attachmentsattachments
RMF Consulting Group
27
83008300’’ss
•• Mark the box Mark the box SUSPICIOUSSUSPICIOUS
•• Complete the form as you normally would.Complete the form as you normally would.
•• Add comments on last page. (recommendation) Add comments on last page. (recommendation)
RMF Consulting Group
28
Voluntary?Voluntary?
Yes, 8300Yes, 8300’’s are s are voluntaryvoluntary when reporting suspicious activitywhen reporting suspicious activity
BUTBUT
Penalties may be imposed on your customer and YOU if Penalties may be imposed on your customer and YOU if the customer attempts to cause you not to file an 8300 the customer attempts to cause you not to file an 8300 by providing misinformation or the pawn shop attempts by providing misinformation or the pawn shop attempts to allow the customer to structure the transactions in to allow the customer to structure the transactions in order to avoid filing of the 8300order to avoid filing of the 8300
Penalties may include:Penalties may include:
Customer: 5 years in prison/$250.000 fineCustomer: 5 years in prison/$250.000 fine
Pawn Shop: 5 years in prison/$500,000 finePawn Shop: 5 years in prison/$500,000 fine
RMF Consulting Group
Presented by: Robert Frimet
Bank Secrecy Act Specialist
Phone: (702) 596-8370
Email: [email protected]
www.checkcashingcompliance.com
www.checkconsultants.com
Presented by: Robert Frimet
Bank Secrecy Act Specialist
Phone: (702) 596-8370
Email: [email protected]@checkconsultants.com
www.checkcashingcompliance.comwww.checkcashingcompliance.com
www.checkconsultants.com