Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 1/23Page 1

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 400 OF 2010

K. SARAVANAN KARUPPASAMY & ANR. .P!"!"#$%

V%'

STATE OF TAMILNADU & ORS. ..R#$$!

 J U D G M E N T

R. BANUMATHI, J.

 T*" +%"! !"!"#$ *, -$ "/ - !*

!"!"#$% "$ , +%"! # 3,$,3' !# "$"!",! ,$

"$$$! "$!",!"#$ %%,-/ - C$!%,/ 5'%,' #

I$!",!"#$ (C5I) #% S6",/ I$!",!"#$ T,3 (SIT) "$!#

!* "$6"$! # ,// -,!"$ # !'$! # D%. A3-,%

G#%$3$! L,+ C#//7 C*$$," #$ 12.11.2008 - #3

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 2/23Page 2

3"6%,$! # !*,! 6%"3"$,/ %#6"$ 6#'/ - "$"!",!

,,"$! !* '"/! #/"6 %#$$/ , +// , !* #!*%

%#$ %#$"-/ #% !* ," "$6"$!.

2. 5%" ,6! +*"6* / !# !* "/"$ # !* +%"!

!"!"#$ ,% , #//#+9: A %#' # !'$! # D%. A3-,%

L,+ C#//7 C*$$," -/#$"$ !# T*,% C#33'$"! "

," !# *, ,! #!% ,$ ,3*/! "$" !* 6#//

%3" "$ 6#$$6!"#$ +"!* !* -"%!*, 6/-%,!"#$ #

P,'3#$ M'!*'%,3,/"$,3 T*,% "$ +*"6* !* $,3 #

!* /,+ 6#// +, %"$! , ;G#%$3$! L,+ C#//<

"$!, # ;D%. A3-,% G#%$3$! L,+ C#//<.

A"!,! D,/"! S!'$! ='!"#$ !* N#$:D,/"! S!'$!

+*"6* / !# +#% ,/!%6,!"#$ -!+$ !* !+# %#'

6'/3"$,!"$ "$ ,$ '$!#+,% "$6"$! +*"6* #66'%% "$ !*

6,3' # D%. A3-,% G#%$3$! L,+ C#//7

C*$$," #$ 12.11.2008 ,! ,-#'! 2.20 P.M. 5#!* !* %#'

# !'$! ,!!,6 ,6* #!*% ,$ "! " ,// !*,! N#$:

D,/"! S!'$! (T*,% S!'$!) +% -%'!,// -,!$ -

!* #!*% %#'. R,%"$ !* "$6"$!7 6%"3"$,/ 6, +%

%"!% ,,"$! -#!* !* %#'. F+ #/"6 %#$$/

2

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 3/23Page 3

+% '$ #$ !* ,3 , ,$ , C#33""#$ #

E$='"% *, - , %!"% H"* C#'%! J' +, ,/#

,#"$! +*"6* "/ "! %#%! ,$ !* ,3 +, ,66!

- !* S!,! G#%$3$! ,$ #3 #//#+ ' ,6!"#$ +,

!,$.

>. T* !"!"#$% 6/,"3 !# - !* P%"$! ,$

S6%!,% # ?W#%/ H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ & R6'

C$!%@ ,$ 3,"$ ,"3 # !*"% #%,$",!"#$ " !,! !# -

!# "$!"/ , $ # '-/"6 ,+,%$ ,-#'! !* *'3,$

%"*! ,$ !, ' 6, # %# *'3,$ %"*! "#/,!"#$.

G%",$6 # !* !"!"#$% " !*,! !*#'* !* #66'%%$6

+, "$ %#$! # !* L,+ C#// "$ -%#, , /"*! ,$ ,

$'3-% # #/"6 %#$$/ +% %$!7 !* " $#!

"$!%$ !# %$! !* 6/,* ,$ !* #/"6 %3,"$

"/$! 6!,!#%. A66#%"$ !# !* !"!"#$%7 !*

/"$='$! #/"6 #"6",/ /"-%,!/ " $#! "$!%$7

#$/ "$ #%% !# ,, !*"% #/"!"6,/ -# ,$ !*

#/"6 %#$$/ +% $/"$! "$ %$!"$ !* "$6"$!.

S"$6 !*% +, "#/,!"#$ # *'3,$ %"*! ,$ %/"6!"#$

# '! #$ !* ,%! # #/"6 %#$$/ "$ %$!"$ !*

3

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 4/23Page 4

"$6"$!7 !* !"!"#$% !%" !# /# , 6#3/,"$! +"!* !*

S!,! H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ (?SHRC@)7 -'! SHRC

%' !# $!%!,"$ !* ,3 ,$ !* !"!"#$% N#. 2 +,

/! +"!* $# #!"#$7 -'! !# "/ , 6#3/,"$! -#% !*

N,!"#$,/ H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ (?NHRC@) ,$ , 6,

-,%"$ N#.142B22B1>B08:0BUC +, %"!% +"!*

NHRC. C, # !"!"#$% " !*,!7 "$6 !* !"!"#$% *,

"/ 6#3/,"$! -#% NHRC ,-#'! !* /,+ 6#// "$6"$!7

!* !"!"#$% ,% ,6"$ 6#$"%,-/ *,%,3$! ,! !*

*,$ # !* T,3"/$,' P#/"6 ,$ %"#/#' 6, ,%

%"!% ,,"$! !* !"!"#$% ,$ !*"% O%,$",!"#$

"$6 !* !"!"#$% *, %' !# +"!*%,+ !*

6#3/,"$! "/ +"!* !* NHRC %,%"$ !* /,+ 6#//

"$6"$!. A// !* ,66#'$! ,$ %#%!" # !* O%,$",!"#$

*, -$ " - C5 CID ,%-"!%,%"/ +"!*#'! #//#+"$

%#% %#6'%. T* !"!"#$% !*%#% ,// !*,! !*

"$!",!"#$ "$ !* L,+ C#// "$6"$! *, $#! -$

%#6 +"!* ,// %"#'$ ,$ !* !"!"#$%

"$$$! "$!",!"#$ "$!# !* "$6"$! # -%'!,/ -,!"$

4

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 5/23Page 5

# !'$! # D%. A3-,% G#%$3$! L,+ C#// #$

12.11.2008 - ,$ "$$$! ,$6 "!*% C5I #% SIT.

4. U#$ $#!"67 !* S!,! # T,3"$,' ,$ SHRC

*, "/ !*"% S!,!' R#%!B%#$.

. M%. P%,*,$! 5*'*,$7 /,%$ 6#'$/ ,,%"$

#% !* !"!"#$% '-3"!! !*,! "$6 !* !"!"#$% "/

6#3/,"$! ,,"$! !* %%"$ #/"6 #"6",/ +"!* NHRC ,$

"$6 !"!"#$% *, %' !# +"!*%,+ !* 6#3/,"$!

"/ +"!* NHRC7 !* !"!"#$% ,% 6#$!,$!/ -"$

*,%, - !* S!,! P#/"6 O%,$" C%"3 U$"! (OCU)

,$ C%"3 5%,$6* C%"3 I$!",!"#$ D,%!3$! (C5 CID)

,$ ,/ 6, *, -$ %"!% ,,"$! !*

!"!"#$%. L,%$ 6#'$/ '%!*% '-3"!! !*,! OCU

,$ C5 CID #/"6 ' ,// "$ # !*"% % 3!*#

,$ !* "%! !"!"#$% +, -%'!,// -,!$ $#! #$/ - !*

#/"6 -'! ,/# - %#+ /3$! ,$ !* !"!"#$% ,$

*" ,3"/ 33-% '$%+$! , %,! ,/ # 3$!,/

,#$7 ,"$ ,$ *,%,3$!. D%,+"$ #'% ,!!$!"#$ !# !*

S!,!' R#%! "/ - !* S!,!7 /,%$ 6#'$/ '-3"!!

5

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 6/23Page 6

!*,! "$ !* ,%!3$!,/ %#6"$7 !* %%"$ #/"6

#"6",/ *, -$ /! # "!*% +"!* ?6$'%@ #% $#3"$,/

'$"*3$! ,$ !* 3,!!% *, $#! -$ %#6 +"!* ,//

%"#'$ ,$ '% !*,! !* "$!",!"#$ # !* L,+

C#// "$6"$! #$ 12.11.2008 - *,$ #% !# C5I #%

SIT.

. M%. S'-%,3,$"'3 P%,,7 L,%$ A"!"#$,/

A#6,! G$%,/ ,,%"$ #% !* S!,! # T,3"/$,'

*, !,$ ' !*%#'* !* S!,!' R#%! "/ - !* S!,!

,$ '-3"!! !*,! 6%"3"$,/ 6, +% %"!% ,,"$!

-#!* !* %#' # !'$! ,$ ,66!"$ !* %#%! #

O$ M,$ C#33""#$7 !* S!,! G#%$3$! "$"!",!

,%!3$!,/ %#6"$ ,,"$! !* #/"6 %#$$/ ,$

'$"*3$! +% ,/# "3# #$ !*3. I! +, '-3"!!

!*,! 6%"3"$,/ 6, ,% %"!% ,,"$! !* !"!"#$%

,$ !* ,% 6*,% *! #% !* #$6 # 6*,!"$ ,$

#!*% #$6 ,$ !"!"#$% +"!* 3,/," "$!$!"#$ ,%

/"$"$ !* /,+ 6#// "$6"$! , !* 6,' #% %"!%,!"#$

# 6%"3"$,/ 6, ,,"$! !* !"!"#$% - !* #/"6 ,$

'6* ,$ ,//,!"#$ " -,/.

6

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 7/23Page 7

. W *, ,/# *,% M%. K. S'-%,3,$",$7 /,%$

S$"#% C#'$/ ,,%"$ #% !* "$!%$%B"3/,

%#$$! : K. A%3!%#$ ,$ M%. R. 5,/,'-%,3,$",$7

/,%$ S$"#% C#'$/ ,,%"$ #% SHRC.

8. G%",$6 # !* !"!"#$% " !+#:#/9: (")

,// "$,6!"#$ #% $#3"$,/ ,6!"#$ # !* S!,! ,$ !*

#/"6 ,$ SHRC #$ !* L,+ C#// "$6"$! #$ 12.11.2008

,$ $ #% ,$ "$!",!"#$ - ,$ "$$$! ,$6 /"

C5I ,$ ("") ,// *,%,3$! # !* !"!"#$% - !*

#/"6 ,$ %"!%,!"#$ # ,/ 6, ,,"$! !* !"!"#$%.

. A % !* S!,!' R#%! "/ - !* S!,!7 #$ !*

6#3/,"$! # M%. A,'%," (T*,% C#33'$"!) #$ # !*

"$'% !'$!7 , 6, +, %"!% , C%"3

N#. 1>1B2008 # 52 E/,$, P#/"6 S!,!"#$ '$% S6!"#$

147 1487 >417 >247 >0 & 0 ("") IPC ,,"$! #$

M%. C*"!*"%,"/,$ ,$ 40 #!*% !'$!. I! " !,! !*,!

2> ,66' !'$! +% ,%%! ,$ $! !# '"6",/

6'!# ,$ #3 # !* ,66' '%%$% -#% !*

6#'%! ,$ !* +% %/, #$ -,"/ ,$ %3,"$"$ ,66'

#-!,"$ ,$!"6",!#% -,"/ %#3 !* H"* C#'%! M,%,.

7

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 8/23Page 8

S"3"/,%/7 #$ !* 6#3/,"$! # C*"!*"%,"/,$ (D,/"! S!'$!)7

, 6%"3"$,/ 6, +, %"!% "$ C%"3 N#. 1>2B2008

,,"$! !+# !'$! "$ 52 E/,$, P#/"6 S!,!"#$ '$%

S6!"#$ >417 >24 ,$ 0 ("") IPC ,$ !* ,3 +,

'-='$!/ ,/!% "$!# S6!"#$ >417 >247 >0 ,$ 0

("") IPC. T*# !+# !'$! +*# ,% ,66' +% ,%%!

,$ !* +% %/, #$ -,"/ #$ !* "%6!"#$ # !* H"*

C#'%! #$ 12.1.200. F#% !* ,// %,$,6"$ ,$

,3,"$ # '%$"!'% ,$ #!*% %#%!" # !* P%"$6",/@

R##3 #$ 1>.11.2008 ,$#!*% 6, +, %"!% "$ 52

E/,$, P#/"6 S!,!"#$ -"$ C%"3 N#.1>4B2008 '$%

S6!"#$ 147 148 IPC ,$ S6!"#$ >(1) # T,3"/$,'

P%#%! (P%$!"#$ # D,3, ,$ L#) A6!7 12 ,$ 14

,66' +% ,%%! +*# +% '-='$!/ %/, #$

-,"/ #$ 2>.12.2008 , % !* #%% # !* H"* C#'%!.

10. A % S!,!' R#%! "/ "$ !*" C#'%! #$

8..20147 "$ C%"3 N#.1>1B2008 6*,%:*! +, "/

-#% VII!* M!%##/"!,$ M,"!%,!7 G#% T#+$7 C*$$,"

#$ 10.>.2011 ,$ !* ,3 +, %!'%$ #% %6!""6,!"#$ #

6%!,"$ %%#% ,$ ,!% %6!""6,!"#$ "! +, %'-3"!! #$

8

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 9/23Page 9

1..2011 ,$ !* ,3 " ! !# - !,$ #$ "/. I$ C%"3

N#.1>2B20087 6*,%:*! +, "/ ,$ !* ,3 *,

-$ !,$ #$ "/ C, N#.2B2011 ,$ !* $! ,! #

*,%"$ *, -$ " #% ..2014. I$ C%"3

N#.1>4B20087 #3 # !* ,66' ,% ! !# -

,%*$ ,$ !* 6*,%:*! *, -$ "/ #$

22.>.2011 -#% VII!* M!%##/"!,$ M,"!%,!7 G#% T#+$7

C*$$," +*"6* " ,/# ! !# - !,$ #$ "/.

11. I$ !* S!,!' R#%!7 "! " !,! !*,! #$

12.11.20087 #$ !* ,3 ,! # "$6"$! !*% #"6",/

$,3/7 (1) M%. K.K. S%"7 P%"$6",/ # !* L,+ C#// ,$

(2) M%. K. N,%,,$,3##%!*7 A"!,$! C#33""#$% #

P#/"6 # !* J'%""6!"#$ R,$ ,$ (>) M%.M. S,% 5,-'7

I$6!#% # P#/"6 # 52 E/,$, P#/"6 S!,!"#$ +%

'$ ,$ #'% S'- I$6!#% # P#/"6 +*# +%

+#%"$ "$ !*,! ,%, *, -$ !%,$%% !# #!*% "!%"6!.

G#%$3$! # T,3"/$,' ,#"$! , C#33""#$ #

I$='"% *, - J'!"6 P. S*,$3',37 , #%3% J'

# !* M,%, H"* C#'%! !# "$='"% "$!# !* "$6"$! ,$ !*

"' %%% !# - !* G#%$3$!. T* C#33""#$

9

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 10/23Page 10

'-3"!! "! %#%! #$ 8..200 !# !* G#%$3$! ,$

,66!"$ !* %6#33$,!"#$ # !* C#33""#$7

,%!3$!,/ ,6!"#$ +, "$"!",! ,,"$! !*% #/"6

%#$$/ ". (1) M% .K. N,%,,$,3##%!*7 A"!,$!

C#33""#$% # P#/"6 (2) M%. M. S,% 5,-'7

I$6!#% # P#/"6 ,$ (>) M%. E. P%'3,/7 S'-

I$6!#% # P#/"6. A!% 6#3/!"$ !* "$='"% ,,"$! !*

#/"6 #"6% 6#$6%$7 %#%! +, '-3"!! !# !*

G#%$3$! ,$ 3,!!% +, $"$ -#% !* H#3

D,%!3$! #% "$,/ 6""#$ #% ='"! #3!"3. 5 O%%

,! 2.4.20117 !*" C#'%! "%6! !* %#$$! !#

$'% !*,! !* "$,/ #%% ,% , -#% !* $! ,!

,$ !* S!,! +, "%6! !# "/ S!,!' R#%! +"!* %,%

!# !* $!"% "!',!"#$. I$ '%!*%,$6 # "%6!"#$ # !*"

C#'%!7 !* S!,! "/ , '%!*% S!,!' R#%! !,!"$ !*,!

G#%$3$! ,66! !* "$"$ # !* I$='"% O"6% ,$

"3# '$"*3$! # ?6$'%@ !# M%. N,%,,$,3##%!*7

A"!,$! C#33""#$% # P#/"6 "$ G.O. (2D) N#. 21

H#3 (P#/"6:2) D,%!3$! ,! 18..201> ,$

(2) M%. S,% 5,-'7 I$6!#% # P#/"6 "$ G.O.(2D) N#.218

10

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 11/23Page 11

H#3 (P#/"6:2) D,%!3$! ,! 18..201>. I$#,% ,

M%. E. P%'3,/7 S'- I$6!#% # P#/"67 !* G#%$3$!

%## !# "3# '$"*3$! # 6'! "$ $"#$ ,! !* %,!

# R.200B: % 3#$!* #% !+# ,% '$% R'/ # !*

 T,3"/$,' P#/"6 R'/ ,$ !* ," #/"6 #"6% *, -$

6,// '#$ !# *#+ 6,' ,,"$! !* %## '$"*3$!.

12. M%. P%,*,$! 5*'*,$7 /,%$ 6#'$/ ,,%"$

#% !* !"!"#$% '-3"!! !*,! $ !*#'* !*% +,

%, %/"6!"#$ # '! #$ !* ,%! # !* #/"6

%#$$/7 !*% *, -$ "$6#$='$!",/ ,%!3$!,/

,6!"#$ ,$ #$/ $#3"$,/ '$"*3$! # 6$'% +,

"3# #$ !+# #/"6 #"6% ,$ "$ 6, # ,$#!*% #/"6

#"6% M%. E. P%'3,/7 S'- I$6!#% # P#/"67 !*

G#%$3$! %## !# "3# 3,% '$"*3$! # 6'!

"$ $"#$ ,! !* %,! # R. 200B: % 3#$!* #% !+# ,%

(R. 47800B: "$ ,//) ,$ !*' "$ 6! $# '$"!" ,6!"#$ *,

-$ !,$ ,,"$! !* #/"6 %#$$/ 6#33$'%,!

+"!* !*"% %, %/"6!"#$ # '!7 +*"6* #$/ *#+ !*

%/'6!,$6 #$ !* ,%! # !* S!,! "$ '%'"$ !* 3,!!%

+"!* ,// %"#'$. I$#,% , 6%"3"$,/ 6, %"!%

11

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 12/23Page 12

%,%"$ !* "$6"$!7 !* /,%$ 6#'$/ '-3"!! !*,!

"$ !+# 6, 6*,%:*! ,% ! !# - !,$ #$ "/ ,$

'% !*,! "$ #%% !# *, , ,"% "$!",!"#$7 !* 3,!!%

- $!%'! !# C5IBSIT #% '%!*% "$!",!"#$. L,%$

6#'$/ '-3"!! !*,! "! " "$ !*" -,6%# # !* "$,6!"#$

#$ !* ,%! # S!,!7 !"!"#$% 6*# !# 3# SHRC ,$

"$6 SHRC *, $#! %#3!/ %#$7 !"!"#$% 3#

NHRC #% +*"6*7 !* !"!"#$% *, -$ *,%, ,$

,/ 6, *, -$ %"!% ,,"$! !* !"!"#$%. 1>.

M%. R. 5,/,'-%,3,$",$7 /,%$ $"#% 6#'$/

,,%"$ #% SHRC '-3"!! !*,! !* SHRC +, !*$

*, - , %!"% C*" J'!"6 # !* H"* C#'%! ,$ !*

!"!"#$% ,% $#! '!"" "$ 3,"$ -,/ ,//,!"#$

,,"$! SHRC #% $#! !,"$ "33",! ,6!"#$. T* /,%$

6#'$/ '-3"!! !*,! "$6 !* S!,! G#%$3$!

,#"$! C#33""#$ # I$='"% *, - , %!"% H"*

C#'%! J'7 SHRC " $#! "#%#'/ '%' !* 3,!!%7 ,

"! +#'/ *, ,3#'$! !# *#/"$ , ,%,/// "$='"% -

SHRC.

12

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 13/23Page 13

14. W *, %' + "# 6/""$ %#'6

-#% ' ,$ %#%! # !* C#33""#$ # I$='"%. 5'! +

,% %%,"$"$ %#3 $!%"$ "$!# !* !,"/ !*%#7 /!7 "!

3, %'"6 ,$ ,%!. 5 , %',/ # !* S!,!' R#%!

,$ #!*% 3,!%",/7 + / !*,! !* 3,!!% +, $#!

%#6 +"!* %"#'$ +"!* +*"6* "! #'*! !# *,

-$ %#6 +"!*. F#% "$!,$67 !* 3,"$ ,66' K.

A%3!%#$ "$ C%"3 N#.1>1B2008 +, $#! ,%%! #%

/#$ !"3 ,$ +, *#+$ , ,$ ,-6#$% "$ !* "$,/

%#%! !*#'* * " !,! !# - , %,6!""$

,#6,! ,$ ,/# , 6#$!!"$ 6,$",! "$ !* /6!"#$.

O$ 8.2.20117 !* 3,!!% +, -%#'*! !# !* $#!"6 # !*"

C#'%! ,$ #$/ ,!% !* #%% +, , - !*" 6#'%!7

,66' K. A%3!%#$ +, ,%%! #$ 1..2011 +*# +,

'-='$!/ %/, #$ -,"/ #$ 4..2011. L"+" "$ !+#

6%"3"$,/ 6, 6*,%:*! ,% ! !# - !,$ #$ "/ ,$

#3 # !* ,66' ,% ! !# - ,%*$ ,$ !%",/ "

! !# 6#33$6.

1. I$#,% , 6#$!$!"#$ # M%. 5*'*,$ !# $!%'!

!* 3,!!% #% '%!*% "$!",!"#$ !# C5IBSIT " 6#$6%$7

13

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 14/23Page 14

!"3 ,$ ,,"$7 "! *, -$ %"!%,! - !*" C#'%! !*,!

'6* ,$ #%% !# 6#$'6! "$!",!"#$ - C5I " $#! !# -

, , , 3,!!% # %#'!"$ 3%/ -6,' !* ,%! *,

/// ,//,!"#$ ,,"$! !* /#6,/ #/"6. T* !%,:

#%"$,% #+% "$ *,$"$ #% "$!",!"#$ !# C5I 3'! -

%6" 6,'!"#'/ ,$ "$ 6!"#$,/ 6"%6'3!,$6. I$

S!,! # West Bengal & Ors. . Committee for Protection of

Democratic Rights, West Bengal & Ors.7 (2010) > SCC 17

, C#$!"!'!"#$

 5$6* # !*" C#'%! */ , '$%9:

;0. 5#% ,%!"$ +"!* !* 6,7 + 3 "! $6,% !#3*," !*,! "! +" #+% 6#$%% - A%!"6/>2 ,$ 22  # !* C#$!"!'!"#$7 +*"/ ,"$ ,$ #%%7!* C#'%! 3'! -,% "$ 3"$ 6%!,"$ /:"3#/"3"!,!"#$ #$ !* %6" # !* C#$!"!'!"#$,/ #+%. T* % /$"!' # !* #+% '$% !* ," A%!"6/%='"% %,! 6,'!"#$ "$ "! %6". I$#,% , !*='!"#$ # "'"$ , "%6!"#$ !# C5I !# 6#$'6!"$!",!"#$ "$ , 6, " 6#$6%$7 ,/!*#'* $# "$/"-/'"/"$ 6,$ - /," #+$ !# 6" +*!*% #% $#! '6*

#+% *#'/ - %6" -'! !"3 ,$ ,,"$ "! *, -$%"!%,! !*,! '6* ,$ #%% " $#! !# - , , ,3,!!% # %#'!"$ #% 3%/ -6,' , ,%! *, ///#3 ,//,!"#$ ,,"$! !* /#6,/ #/"6. T*" !%,:#%"$,% #+% 3'! - %6" ,%"$/7 6,'!"#'/,$ "$ 6!"#$,/ "!',!"#$ +*% "! -6#3 $6,%!# %#" 6%"-"/"! ,$ "$!"/ 6#$"$6 "$"$!",!"#$ #% +*% !* "$6"$! 3, *, $,!"#$,/ ,$

14

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 15/23Page 15

"$!%$,!"#$,/ %,3""6,!"#$ #% +*% '6* ,$ #%% 3, -$6,% #% #"$ 6#3/! '!"6 ,$ $#%6"$ !*'$,3$!,/ %"*!. O!*%+" C5I +#'/ - /## +"!*, /,% $'3-% # 6, ,$ +"!* /"3"! %#'%67 3,"$ "! ""6'/! !# %#%/ "$!",! $ %"#' 6,

,$ "$ !* %#6 /# "! 6%"-"/"! ,$ '%# +"!*'$,!",6!#% "$!",!"#$.<

1. L,/ '6,!"#$ *, , "%6! "3,6! #$ !*

%!" # !* /,/ %#"#$. I! " , 3,!!% # 6#$6%$

!*,! '6* ,$ '$#%!'$,! "$6"$! *#'/ *, *,$

+"!*"$ !* %6"$6! # L,+ C#//7 C*$$," +*"6* *,

%#'6 3,$ 3"$$! /,+% ,$ /,/ /'3"$,%". W

/ !*,! !* 3,!!% *#'/ *, -$ ,% - !*

#/"6 ,$ !* S!,! +"!* %,! 6#$6%$ ,$ %#3!"!'.

 T*#'* !* 3,!!% +, $#! %#6 "$ !* +, "$ +*"6* "!

*#'/ *, -$ %#6 +"!*7 + / !*,! ,! !*"

"!,$! #"$! # !"37 "! " $#! $6,% !# *,$ #% !*

"$!",!"#$ !# C5I #% !# SIT. T* %,#$ -"$ 6%"3"$,/

6, *, -$ %"!% ,$ 6*,%:*! ,% ,/# "/

,$ ,%!3$!,/ ,6!"#$ +, ,/# "$"!",! ,,"$! !* #/"6

%#$$/ ,$ '$"*3$! !*#'* 3, - $#3"$,/ +,

"3# #$ !*# #/"6 %#$$/. S"$6 6*,%:*! "$

15

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 16/23Page 16

,// !*% 6, *, ,/%, -$ "/ -#% !* VII!*

M!%##/"!,$ M,"!%,! C#'%!7 G#% T#+$7 C*$$,"7 #$

# +*"6* " ,/%, !,$ #$ "/7 "$ #'% "+7 "! +#'/

'"6 " + "%6! !* VII!* M!%##/"!,$ M,"!%,! C#'%!7

G#% T#+$7 C*$$," !# %#6 +"!* !* 3,!!%

"!"#'/.

1. L,%$ 6#'$/ #% !"!"#$% M%. P%,*,$!

5*'*,$ /," 6,!*"$ ,!!,6 #$ SHRC ,$ '-3"!! !*,!

SHRC +, "3%"#' !# !* "$6"$! , +// ,

*,%,3$! !# !* !"!"#$% ,$ SHRC " $#! %#3!/

!, ! %,%"$ L,+ C#// "$6"$!. L,%$ 6#'$/

,/# '-3"!! !*,! !* #"6 # , C*,"%%#$ #

 T,3"/$,' S!,! H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ *, -$

%3,"$"$ ,6,$! #% 3#% !*,$ !*% ,%.

18. I$#,% , !* %",$6 # !* !"!"#$% #$ !*

$#$:!,"$ # ,6!"#$ - SHRC7 !* /,%$ 6#'$/ #%

SHRC '-3"!! !*,! !* #"6 # C*,"%%#$ # SHRC "

/"$ ,6,$! "$6 A''! 2011 ,$ SHRC +, "$"$ "!

""6'/! !# !, #//#+ ' ,6!"#$. H,"$ %,% !# !* ,"

16

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 17/23Page 17

'-3""#$7 + *, , !* S!,! # T,3"/$,' !# "/ "!

%#$ , !# !* $#$:"//"$ ' # !* #"6 # C*,"%%#$

# SHRC ,$ !* S!,! *, "/ "! S!,!' R#%! #$

8..2014 +"!* %,% !# !* ,#"$!3$! # C*,"%%#$ !#

SHRC.

1. I$ !* S!,!' R#%!7 "! " !,! !*,! #"6 #

C*,"%%#$7 T,3"/$,' S!,! H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ *,

-$ /"$ ,6,$! "$6 2.8.2011 ' !# $#$:,,"/,-"/"! #

'"!,-/ 6,$",!. I! " !,! !*,! "$ %#$ !# !*

%='! # !* S!,! G#%$3$!7 H"* C#'%! # M,%, *,

$! !* /"! # %!"% C*" J'!"6 +*# +% !* F#%3%

 J' # !* M,%, H"* C#'%! ,/#$ +"!* !*"% ,! #

-"%!* ,$ !*"% %$! ,%. A66#%"$ !# !* S!,!7

"$ !* /"! $! - !* R"!%,% G$%,/7 H"* C#'%! #

M,%, 3#! # !* 6,$",! ,% "!*% ,/%, ,#"$!

!# "%$! A//,! T%"-'$,/ #% ='",/$! #! #'!"

 T,3"/$,' #% *, ,!!,"$ !* , /"3"! # 0 ,% #% $#!

*,"$ ,$ ,3"/",%"! +"!* !* /,$', ,$ 6'/!'% #

 T,3"/$,' ,$ "! +, ,/3#! "3#"-/ !# "$ , '"!,-/

17

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 18/23Page 18

6,$",! #% !* #! # C*,"%%#$7 SHRC7 T,3"/$,'. I! "

!,! !*,! "$ !%3 # S6!"#$ 2(1) # !* P%#!6!"#$ #

H'3,$ R"*! A6! 1>7 O%% ,! 4.12.201> +, "'

!# M. J,,$!*"7 IAS (R!.) M3-% !# ,6! , !* C*,"%%#$

"$ S!,! H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$7 T,3"/$,' '$!"/ !*

,#"$!3$! # , $+ C*,"%%#$ !# !* C#33""#$. I! "

'%!*% !,! !*,! "$ !*" %,% G#%$3$! # T,3"/$,'

*, %## !# G#%$3$! # I$", !*,! , '"!,-/

,3$3$! !# S6!"#$ 21(2)(,) # P%#!6!"#$ # H'3,$

R"*! A6!7 1> (#% *#%! ?!* A6!@) 6#'/ - 3, !# 3,

/""-/ %!"% J' # H"* C#'%! +"!* , 3"$"3'3

%"$6 # $ ,% , , J' # !* H"* C#'%! #%

!* #! # C*,"%%#$7 SHRC7 T,3"/$,' ,$ '6* %##,/

" '$% 6#$"%,!"#$ # !* G#%$3$! # I$",. S!,!'

R#%! "/ - !* S!,! %% !# ,%"#' /!!%

6#%%#$$6 - !* S!,! +"!* U$"#$ # I$", "$ !*"

%,%.

20. W # $#! +"* !# # "$!# !* $"6!" # !*

%##,/ 3, - !* S!,! # T,3"/$,' %='!"$ #%

18

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 19/23Page 19

'"!,-/ ,3$3$! !# S6!"#$ 21(2)(,) # !* A6!. W

6#$"$ #'% #6' #$/ +"!* %,% !# !* ,6,$6 #

#"6 # C*,"%%#$7 SHRC %3,"$"$ ,6,$! #% ='"!

#3 !"3.

21. P%#!6!"#$ # H'3,$ R"*! A6! 1> *, -$

$,6! !# %#" #% -!!% %#!6!"#$ # *'3,$ %"*! -

6#$!"!'!"$ , N,!"#$,/ H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ ,$ ,/#

S!,! H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ ,$ H'3,$ R"*! C#'%!.

S6!"#$ 2(1)() # !* A6! "$ “human rights” as the

rights relating to life, liberty, equality, ignity of the

ini!iual guarantee by the Constitution or emboie in

the "nternational Co!enants an enforceable by courts in

"nia. T* ,-# %"*! ,% !%,6,-/ !# P,%! III # !*

I$",$ C#$!"!'!"#$ ',%,$!"$ F'$,3$!,/ R"*! ,$

,%!"6'/,%/ A%!"6/ 147 17 207 217 ,$ 22. C*,!% V #

!* A6! 6#$"!"$ # S6!"#$ 21 !# 2 ,/ +"!* !*

6#$!"!'!"#$ # S!,! H'3,$ R"*! C#33""#$ ,$ "!

'$6!"#$ !*%!#. S!,! C#33""#$ 6#$"! # ,

C*,"%%#$ +*# *, -$ , C*" J'!"6 # , H"* C#'%!

19

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 20/23

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 21/23Page 21

*, -$ !* C*" J'!"6 # , H"* C#'%! *#'/ %3,"$

,6,$! #% 3#% !*,$ !*% ,%. I$ #'% "+7 $"$ !*

S!,! G#%$3$!@ %='! #% ,3$3$! !# S6!"#$

21(2)(,) # !* A6! +*"6* %#6 +"// !, /#$ !"37 "! +"//

- "$ #%% " !* S!,! # T,3"$,' !, ! !# "// ' !*

,6,$6 # !* #! # C*,"%%#$7 SHRC7 T,3"/$,' "$

!%3 # S6!"#$ 21(2)(,) - 6#$!"!'!"$ , S,%6*

C#33"!! ,! ,$ ,%/ ,!.

22. S# ,% , !* %",$6 # !* !"!"#$% ,

%,% %"!%,!"#$ # ,/ 6, ,,"$! !*3 "

6#$6%$7 "! " !,! !*,! #$ !* 6#3/,"$! /# -

R6!"#$ O"6% # !* C"%6'"! H#' C#"3-,!#%7 , 6%"3"$,/

6, *, -$ %"!% ,,"$! !* "%! !"!"#$% "$

C%"3 N#. 11B200 "$ 54 R,6 C#'% P#/"6 S!,!"#$7

C#"3-,!#% C"! '$% S6!"#$ 420 IPC. O%,$" C%"3

U$"! (OCU) C5:CID *, %"!% , 6, C%"3 N#.1B200

,,"$! !* !"!"#$% #$ !* 6#3/,"$! # #$

K%"*$,'3,% #% !* ,// ,6! # 6*,!"$. I$ -#!* !*

6,7 6*,%:*! *, -$ "/ -#% !* C*"

21

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 22/23Page 22

 J'"6",/ M,"!%,! C#'%!7 C#"3-,!#% +*"6* +% !,$ #$

"/ "$ CC 84B2010 ,$ 8>B2010. 5#!* !* !"!"#$% *,

"/ =',* !"!"#$ '$% S6!"#$ 482 C%.P.C.

-#% !* H"* C#'%! # M,%, !# =',* !* 6*,%

,,"$! !*3 "$ C%"3"$,/ O.P.N#.140 & 1410B2011 ,$

1411 & 1412 B2011 ,$ #-!,"$ "$!%"3 !, ,$ =',*

!"!"#$ ,% !,! !# - $"$. S"$6 !* !"!"#$%

*, ,/%, "/ !"!"#$ '$% S6!"#$ 482 C%.P.C.7 !*

!"!"#$% ,% ,! /"-%! !# %," ,// 6#$!$!"#$ -#% !*

H"* C#'%! "$ !*# !"!"#$ "/ - !*3.

2>. T*" +%"! !"!"#$ " "# # "%6!"$ !*

VII!*

  M!%##/"!,$ M,"!%,! C#'%!7 G#% T#+$7 C*$$,"

!# "33",!/ !, !* 6, #$ "/ %/,!"$ !# !* L,+

C#// "$6"$! ,$ "! !* !%",/ ,$ "# # !*

6, "!"#'/ "$ ,66#%,$6 +"!* /,+ +"!*"$ , %"# #

#$ ,%. T* VII!* M!%##/"!,$ M,"!%,! *,// "/ %#%!

%,%"$ !* %#% # !* 6, !# !* H"* C#'%! #$6 "$

!+# 3#$!* ,$ + %='! !* H"* C#'%! !# 3#$"!#% !*

%#% # !* 6,. I$ "+ # #'% "6'"#$ "$ ,%, (21)7

22

8/11/2019 Supreme Court says no to CBI enquiry in Chennai Law College Case.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supreme-court-says-no-to-cbi-enquiry-in-chennai-law-college-casepdf 23/23

!* S!,! # T,3"/$,' +#'/ # +// " "! !, ,%#%",!

! !# "// ' !* ,6,$6 # !* C*,"%%#$7 SHRC7

 T,3"/$,' "!"#'/.

J.(T.S. T*,'%)

J.

  (R. 5,$'3,!*")

N+ D/*"S!3-% 17 2014