7/23/2019 Struggle for Existence http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/struggle-for-existence 1/15 Struggle for Existence: A Case Study About Marginalized People of Sundarban Samik Chakraborty* *Samik Chakraborty, (M.Sc. – Geography, B.Ed.), Ph.D. Research Scholar, Department of Applied Geography, School of Earth, Atmosphere and Oceanic Sciences, Ravenshaw University, Cuttack – 753003, Odisha, India. Email ID: [email protected], Contact: +91- 89616-02706. Abstract: Sundarban is a vast mangrove ecosystem, located in the eastern coastal part of Bay of Bengal in southern Bangladesh and West Bengal in India (21° - 22°30´ N and 88° - 89°29´ E), it was formed by the sediments brought down by the river Ganga, Bramhaputra and Mehgna. The name ‘Sundarban’ is literally termed as ‘beautiful forest’ in Bengali (Sundar – beautiful, ban - forest). The name may have been derived from the ‘Sundari’ trees (a type of mangrove – Heritiera fomes), that are found in Sundarban in large numbers. It became inscribed as a UNESCO world heritage site in 1984. But, the living conditions of people of Sundarban is not very well due to so many problems like frequent cyclones and floods, embankment breaching, poverty, illiteracy, malnutrition, unemployment, lack of safe drinking water and electricity, rapid population growth, infiltration, girl trafficking, poor communication, lack of banking service, soil erosion, forest depletion, loss of navigability of rivers and so on. For these problems they are become deprived and marginalized. Government has taken so many projects for their development. ‘Sundarban Development Authority’ was also established for this purpose but such steps are not enough to mitigate their problems completely. They need much more proper plans for their permanent development from both, Government and NGOs. Key words: introduction, livelihood pattern, problems, solutions, future of people of sundarban. Introduction: Mal distribution of wealth is seen since the beginning of civilization and this situation is still unchanged even today. It is very painful to see that in the most of the cases, economic status 1
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Sundarban is a vast mangrove ecosystem, located in the eastern coastal part of Bay ofBengal in southern Bangladesh and West Bengal in India (21° - 22°30´ N and 88° - 89°29´ E), it
was formed by the sediments brought down by the river Ganga, Bramhaputra and Mehgna. The
name ‘Sundarban’ is literally termed as ‘beautiful forest’ in Bengali (Sundar – beautiful, ban -
forest). The name may have been derived from the ‘Sundari’ trees (a type of mangrove –
Heritiera fomes), that are found in Sundarban in large numbers. It became inscribed as a
UNESCO world heritage site in 1984. But, the living conditions of people of Sundarban is not
very well due to so many problems like frequent cyclones and floods, embankment breaching,
poverty, illiteracy, malnutrition, unemployment, lack of safe drinking water and electricity, rapid
population growth, infiltration, girl trafficking, poor communication, lack of banking service,
soil erosion, forest depletion, loss of navigability of rivers and so on. For these problems they are
become deprived and marginalized. Government has taken so many projects for their
development. ‘Sundarban Development Authority’ was also established for this purpose but such
steps are not enough to mitigate their problems completely. They need much more proper plans
for their permanent development from both, Government and NGOs.
Key words: introduction, livelihood pattern, problems, solutions, future of people of sundarban.
Introduction:
Mal distribution of wealth is seen since the beginning of civilization and this situation is
still unchanged even today. It is very painful to see that in the most of the cases, economic status
becomes the main indicator to determine the standard of living as well as social status of human
beings. In recent years, regional disparities in terms of development are a very popular concern
among geographers and scholars from other branches of disciplines, also. The developmental
processes are mainly taking place in the large urban centers whereas the rural areas are still in the
darkness of deprivation. There are many marginalized group of people in those rural areas whohave very least access to basic minimum facilities for their living in terms of food, shelter,
employment, health, education, social security and so on. They always struggle with extreme
poverty. Even Governments do not have proper master plan to mitigate their problems and
permanent solution. Extreme poverty and endless deprivation have made these groups of people
and region marginalized. High standard of living, various job opportunities, access to civic
amenities of these urban areas act as pull factors which attract mainly the working population
from the marginalized regions. Even sometimes children are forced to work as child laborers in
various unorganized sectors in those urban centers. Hence, urban areas enjoy the inflow of
resources from rural or marginalized regions and become more developed gradually where as
rural areas face a lot of problem because of the outflow of natural as well as human recourses.
So, we can term this process as Development Terrorism.
People of Indian Sundarban are underprivileged from the basic minimum facilities of
living. They always fight with the environmental unreliability for their existence. This is one of
the most underdeveloped regions of the country. There are so many problems which have made
the people of this region marginalized, these are extreme poverty, illiteracy, malnutrition among
women and children, unemployment, lack of safe drinking water, rapid population growth,
problems of infiltration from Bangladesh, human trafficking, lack of electricity, underdeveloped
communication system, lack of banking system, loss of quantity and quality of land due to
embankment beaching, flood problem, increasing salinity and various socio-economic and
infrastructural problems.
Das (2005) has done an extensive work on man and environment of Sundarban. He has
given the primary focus on the distinct environmental features and problems of marginalized
people of Sundarban. This study also includes some plan of development, significance and future
Das and Pramanik (2010) have also discussed the areas of problem of people of
Sundarban. They have given the elaborate explanations of factors responsible for this and they
also have classified the types of problems such as physical, socio-economic, infrastructural as
well.
A research entitled “living with Changing Climate” (2012), done by Centre for Science
and Environment under the direction of Mr. Chandra Bhushan, worked on impact, vulnerability
and adaptation challenges in Indian Sundarban. This study consists of effects of changing climate
on Indian sundarban, land erosion and management, survival of people, development deficit,
causes of rural migration and agendas for action.
Present Study:
Keeping the above facts in mind the present study focuses on the struggle for existence of
marginalized people of Sundarban.
Geographically, Indian Sundarban is located at 21º00´ to 22º30´ North latitude and 88º00´
East to 89º29´ East longitude at a height of 3 to 8 meters from the mean sea level on the southern
fringes of the state of West Bengal, where the Gangetic plain meets the Bay of Bengal. The site
of the world’s largest mangrove ecosystem, the Sundarban is a group of several hundred islands,
spread across 9,630 sq km in India and 16,370 sq km in Bangladesh. On the Indian side, it
extends over two districts, 13 blocks in South 24 Parganas and 6 in North 24 Parganas.
The Sundarban delta has taken its current shape over the past 300 years. The islands are
low, marshy, alluvial plains that are still in the process of being formed through siltation and
powerful tidal currents, a continuous process of erosion and accretion. As new land is added to
the existing mass, some parts are eroded away as part of a natural cycle. The delta is
characterized by beaches, mudflats, coastal dunes, sand flats, estuaries, creeks, inlets and
mangrove swamps. Rivers, estuaries and creeks carry saline water nearly 300 km inland from the
Bay of Bengal. Approximately 2,069 sq km area is occupied by the regions seven main tidalriver systems or estuaries, which finally end up in the Bay of Bengal.
The delta comprises of 102 low-lying islands, of which 54 are inhabited. All habitation is
on reclaimed land, which amounts to an area of 5,363 sq km. Some 4,266 sq km of the Indian
Sundarban are covered by these swampy estuarine forests that make up at least 60 per cent of
India’s mangrove stock. The Sundarban has 84 species of mangrove plants, the highest recorded
among the mangroves of the world, and the Sundari tree (Heritiera fomes) is one of these. These
trees are eponymous with the region, the area deriving its name from them. Besides these trees,
the Sundarban is home to a number of other unique and endangered flora and fauna. It is the only
mangrove forest in the world which holds the Royal Bengal Tigers.
History of the Study Area:
Before 19th century, Indian Sundarban had no human population or habitation. In 1771,
British collector general Clod Russell initiated a plan to divide the forest land into plots and lease
them out to prospective landlords. At stake were timber and the collection of land revenue. Theselease-holding landowners encouraged poor farming communities from other parts of Bengal as
well as from neighboring states (present day Odisha, Bihar, Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh) to come
and settle in the Sundarban. These people were put to work on clearing the forests and
developing the land. This exercise of forest clearing began in 1781, and was initiated by Tillman
Henkel, the then magistrate of Jessore district, currently in Bangladesh. Initially, the forests were
cleared mostly in the northern parts, closer both to Kolkata and Dhaka. By 1873, the blocks of
Hasnabad, Bhangar, Haroa, Hingalgunj, Minakhan (North 24 Parganas) and Canning, Joynagar,
Mathurapur and Sagar (South 24 Parganas) had been fully or substantially cleared of forests. The
migrants were also made to erect embankments to make the place habitable by blocking
ingression of saline water. Apart from the lure of paid work, these poor farmers were also offeredthe bait of small pieces of land by the lease-holders. The initial provisions and some cultivable
land of their own made a majority of these migrants stay back in the Sundarbans. Migration
continued in the later periods from Midnapur in the west of Bengal as well as from the east (now
Bangladesh). Over the years, the population of Indian Sundarban has increased dramatically –
from 11.59 lakh in 1951 to 37.57 lakh in 2001, or almost 224 per cent over half a century. The
decadal increase between 1991 and 2001 was close to 18 per cent, which is equal to the
population growth in the entire district of South 24 Parganas. It was declared as a “World
Heritage Site” by UNESCO in 1984 and as a “Biosphere Reserve” in 1989.
Objectives:
The main objectives of the study are as follows:
To examine the livelihood pattern of marginalized people of Sundarban.
To analyze the major socio-economic problems of them.
To find out the factors responsible for such problems.
To find out some remedial measures to mitigate their problems.
Database and Methodology:
The study is based completely on the secondary sources of data collected from Census of
India, District Human Development Report, District Crime Data and various reports of
Sundarban Development Board and Centre for Science and Environment. The indicators of this
Sundarban that have substantial commercial value and need capital investment are
aquaculture (aquafarming) and marine fishing.
The other types of fishing activities are largely at subsistence levels. These
include brackish water fishing (nona-ghery or bheri), tank and bile (water pods within
paddy fields), fishing in the rivers, fishing in the forest and winter migratory bag-netfishery – where migratory fish and seedlings are trapped in the shallow estuaries.
But now, both commercial and subsistence fishing are threatened and declined
due to over-exploitation. This is a direct outcome of the increase in the number of people
moving towards fishing. The diminishing returns in agriculture prompt many farmers to
shift to fishing.
The mangrove biomes of Sundarban provide some of the essential components of
livelihood of the forest-dependant island villagers of the area. These people collect a wide
variety of non-timber forest produce including tannin bark, natural honey, cultured
honey, bees wax, fuel wood, prawn, crab, shrimps, lime etc. It is mentionable that
villagers often enter into the protected area in search of fish or honey and are killed or
injured by tigers and they do not get compensation from the Government.
Poverty:
About 44 per cent of the people of Sundarban live below the poverty line (income
- less than Rs 26 a day).Blocks Basanti Sandeshkhali
centers is also very low. None of the high schools and colleges in Sundarban teaches any science
subjects
Blocks Upper Primary Drop Out Blocks Households with Education
Beyond Class X
Canning II 57.11 Gosaba 20.70
Kultali 52.95 Mathurapur I 17.64
Mathurapur I 46.86 Canning I 16.60
Basanti 45.61 Joynagar I 16.52
Patharpratima 44.33 Patharpratima 16.26
Kakdwip 43.26 Sagar 15.98
Joynagar II 42.83 Kakdwip 15.82
Mathurapur II 40.64 Namkhana 15.70
Canning I 39.31 Mathurapur II 15.63
Gosaba 35.51 Joynagar II 13.71
Sagar 34.85 Basanti 9.88
Joynagar I 33.85 Kultali 9.02
Namkhana 27.40 Canning II 7.91
because the lack of electricity does not allow laboratories to function. Many blocks do not have
any college or technical institute.
Access to Electricity and Transport and Communication:
Many blocks of Sundarban do not have access to electricity; this is one of the serious
problems of the people. For instance, none of the high schools and colleges in Sundarban
teaches any science subjects because the lack of electricity. Absence of electricity leads tolarge number of cases of snake bites. Even tiger attacks are attributed to unavailability of
street lights. Unavailability of power also affects livelihood options like agriculture and
fisheries. Absence of cold storages is a major constraint for farmers and fisherfolk.
The transport and communication system of Sundarban is in very poor state. This is
one of the primary causes which have made the people of Sundarban marginalized. The
people only depend upon waterways. There are only two road ways, from Kolkata to
Bishnupur via Nula and another is Barasat to Buranhati. The facilities of railways are mainly
confined upto Canning, Diamond Harbour, Lakkhikantapur and Hansabad from Kolkata.
During monsoon, roads become impossible to walk on, boat rides become riskier and
vehicles need to be pushed out of mud-holes every now and then.
Fishery and collection of non-timber forest produce supplement the agricultural income,
but both are under tremendous pressure due to over exploitation and climatic changes.
Fish density in shallow waters has reduced and the catches of commercially important
fish have declined.
There are no major industries. Marketing infrastructure for agricultural, fishery and non-timber forest produce sectors is negligible.
Today, the resource base of Sunderban is not able to sustain the lives and livelihood of
people. As a result, the people of Sunderban are migrating to survive.
Majority of households don’t have access to electricity.
About 60 per cent of the households don’t have access to clean and safe drinking water.
87 per cent people live with some sort of food shortage. So, food insecurity is high.
There is a huge deficit in health care infrastructure. The Sundarban will need more
infrastructures such as doctors, public health centers, specialized hospitals etc. About
one-third of the population doesn’t have access to primary health care.
The education system does not provide the options to people to expand livelihood
opportunities. There is just one degree or technical college in per 250 sq km area. The
drop-out rates are very high.
The coverage of institutional banking and insurance facilities in Sundarban is very low.
Only about 10 per cent of the population avail institutional banking and there is no
agricultural insurance.
Finally, Sunderban still lacks disaster warning and disaster shelters. In fact, it lacks a
comprehensive disaster management system.
Suggestions and conclusions:
The people of Sundarban need a long term plan to mitigate their problem and for their
development. Following remedial measures can be taken. First of all, guaranteed job opportunity
and employment generation may upgrade the quality of life of the people. Besides this, definitesupply of safe drinking water, electricity, more health centers with proper medical facilities,
school and colleges having vocational and technical education are needed. Government should
be responsible about the protection of forests, land reclamation, development of transport and
communication system. A new land and embankment policy is urgently required to stop or
reduce the detoriation of quality and quality of land. Awareness programs about controlling