Top Banner
Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options 10 Long and 10 Short Strategies for Forward Pricing Livestock CME COMMODITY PRODUCTS
52

StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts...

May 30, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

Strategies for CME LivestockFutures and Options

10 Long and 10 Short Strategies for Forward Pricing Livestock

CM E C OMMOD I T Y P R O D U C T S

Page 2: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

3

Global Leadership in the Financial Marketplace

CME is the largest and most diverse financial exchange in the world for

trading futures and options. In 2005 our volume surpassed one billion

contracts, worth $638 trillion, and we continued to set and break volume

and open interest records in 2006. Founded in 1898, we serve the

risk-management needs of customers around the globe by offering the

widest range of benchmark financial products available on any exchange,

traded via our CME Globex electronic trading platform and on our trading

floors. Our innovative products cover major market segments including

interest rates, equities, foreign exchange, commodities and alternative

investment products. In addition, our clearing house matches and settles all

trades and guarantees the creditworthiness of every transaction that takes

place in our markets.

CME Commodity Products

CME agricultural commodity products help farmers and agribusinesses

manage the constant price risks they face, enabling them to lock in profits,

enhance business planning and more effectively serve their markets.

Commodity-related businesses that use CME commodity products to support

and strengthen their operations are able to provide products to their

customers at better prices.

Page 3: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

1

PAGE

PART I: TEN SHORT HEDGE STRATEGIES

FOR INVENTORY PROTECTION 3

For Livestock Producers

BASIC STRATEGIES

1. Locking in a Fixed Selling Price: Selling Futures 3

2. Establishing a Minimum Selling Price: Buying Puts 4

ADVANCED STRATEGIES

3. Collecting Options Premiums-Selling Call Options 6

4. Establishing a Minimum Selling Price at Reduced 7

Premium Costs: Purchasing Puts and Selling Call

Options – “The “Fence”

5. Creating a Minimum Sale Price by Combining 8

Two Transactions: Cash Contracting (or Selling

Futures) and Buying Call Options

COMPARISONS OF STRATEGIES 1-5

Situation: Live Cattle to Market in August 10

Situation: Feeder Cattle to Market in March 11

Situation: Lean Hogs to Market in February 13

ADJUSTMENT STRATEGIES

6. Converting a Fixed Price to a Minimum Price: 14

Purchasing a Call Option After Selling Futures

or After Forward Contracting at a Fixed Price

7. Converting a Fixed Price to a Minimum Price: 16

Purchasing Put Options After Liquidating a

Short Futures Hedge

8. Converting a Minimum Price to a Fixed Price: 18

Selling Futures or Cash Contracting After a

Put Purchase

9. Increasing the Minimum Price: 20

Purchasing Put Options as Prices Increase

10. Cashing in Minimum Price Protection: 22

Purchasing Put Options as Prices Decrease

PAGE

PART II: TEN LONG HEDGE STRATEGIES

FOR PROCUREMENT PROTECTION 24

For Cattle Feeders, Stocker Operators,

Meat Packers and Institutional Users of Meats

BASIC STRATEGIES

1. Locking in a Fixed Purchase Price- Buying Futures 24

2. Establishing a Maximum Purchase Price - Buying Calls 25

ADVANCED STRATEGIES

3. Collecting Options Premiums-Selling Put Options 27

4. Establishing a Maximum Purchase Price at 28

Reduced Premium Costs: Purchasing Calls and

Selling Put Options – The “Fence”

5. Creating a Maximum Purchase Price by Combining 29

Two Transactions: Cash Contracting (or Buying

Futures), and Buying Put Options

COMPARISON OF STRATEGIES 1-5

Situation: Live Cattle for August Acquisition 30

Situation: Feeder Cattle to Place on Feed in March 32

Situation: Lean Hogs for February Acquisition 33

ADJUSTMENT STRATEGIES

6. Converting a Fixed Price to a Maximum Price: 34

Purchasing a Put Option After Buying Futures

7. Converting a Fixed Price to a Maximum Price: 36

Purchasing Call Options After Liquidating a Long

Futures Hedge

8. Converting a Maximum Price to a Fixed Price: 38

Buying Futures or Cash Contracting After a

Call Purchase

9. Decreasing the Maximum Price: 40

Purchasing Call Options as Prices Decrease

10. Cashing in Maximum Price Protection: 42

Purchasing Call Options as Prices Increase

GLOSSARY 44

GETTING STARTED 48

Table of Contents

Page 4: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

2cme.com

This publication is intended for people in the livestock industry who are

comfortable with their basic knowledge of how to use CME Livestock

futures and options and who want to know more. It guides readers

through the mechanics of strategies that are becoming widely used in

the livestock and meat business, and demonstrates how to evaluate

pricing possibilities on a daily or weekly basis.

Readers who don’t feel comfortable with their basic knowledge of

futures and options may first wish to review the Self-Study Guide for

Hedging with Livestock Futures and Options, as well as other CME

publications and publications available from universities, lenders, brokers

and bookstores. Additional materials may help readers better

understand terms and concepts such as basis, short, performance bond,

put, call and premium, which are also defined in this publication.

Throughout Strategies for CME Livestock, the term “basis” is used to

mean the local cash price minus the futures price at the time a producer

intends to market his livestock, which should be prior to futures

expiration. A positive basis means the local cash price is higher than

the futures price; a negative basis means the futures price is higher

than the local cash price.

Within this publication, actual basis is the same as estimated basis for

every example. Of course, this is not realistic. In practice, an estimated

basis determined from historical price relationships is used to estimate

the forward price.

Basis risk is always part of using futures or options. Every alternative

pricing strategy has to be evaluated in the context of each local basis

situation, using local basis for the quality and size of the livestock

produced. The realized price when the hedge is liquidated depends

on the actual basis at that time.

CME Live Cattle options expire the first Friday of the delivery month of

the underlying futures contract; CME Feeder Cattle and CME Lean Hog

options expire on the same day as their corresponding futures contract.

Therefore, when hedging with CME Live Cattle options, it is necessary

to use the basis for the period when the options expire and not for

when the futures contract expires. Also, always check with the

exchange or a broker regarding current rules.

All examples in Strategies exclude commissions and performance

bonds (margins). In real situations, a brokerage commission would have

to be paid for all futures and options transactions, and performance

bond deposits would be required for any option writing and all

futures transactions.

Please note that all strategies involving exchange-traded futures and

options have an important advantage over fixed price forward cash

contracts: flexibility. Once producers have entered into fixed price

forward contracts, they are normally committed, no matter how

circumstances change. With exchange-traded futures and options,

it is possible to alter or totally remove those commitments by taking

offsetting positions in the market.

The examples in this publication use real option premiums and price

levels that existed in a past time period in order to demonstrate the

concept of each strategy. Varying market conditions, length of time to

expiration, price level and general market volatility significantly impact

the cost of options; but the concepts of these strategies remain the

same. Producers should judge the validity and costs against their own

situations, including breakeven costs, capital at risk and market forecast.

As understanding of livestock futures and options grows, livestock

producers will no doubt develop variations on these strategies, as

well as new applications for these contracts. We hope that Strategies

for CME Livestock Futures and Options is a valuable resource to all

who explore the uses of livestock futures and options in their

marketing plans.

Introduction

Page 5: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

3Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Basic Short Strategies

1. Locking in a Fixed Selling Price: Selling Futures

This traditional hedge offers a “locked-in” or guaranteed price

plus or minus any variation in actual basis from expected basis.

The expected local hedge price is equal to the short futures price

plus or minus the expected local basis. Selling futures is less attractive

than the forward contract in that the futures hedge does not lock

in a precise price, due to the inability to perfectly predict the basis.

Selling futures is more attractive than the forward contract in that

it allows the flexibility of altering the pricing decision and capitalizing

on a strong basis.

Advantages

» Guarantees a price, subject to basis fluctuation

» Yields best price if market declines significantly after placing hedge

» Can price as much as 12 months in advance

Disadvantages

» Attempts to capitalize on price increases

» Involves re-exposure to market risk

» Performance bond call responsibility

Liquidation

To liquidate the hedge, the producer buys back the futures contract

and sells the livestock in the cash market. Delivery is an option to

the seller of a futures contract and should only be attempted if it is

economically profitable to do so (negative basis greater than delivery

costs and the livestock meet contract specifications).

Part I: Ten Short Strategies for Inventory ProtectionFor Livestock Producers

Example

A producer sells October CME Live Cattle futures at $84/cwt. He expects a local basis of minus $1/cwt.

in October, when the cattle reach slaughter weight; therefore, his expected local hedge price is $83/cwt.

In October when the cattle are ready to be slaughtered:

A B C

If Sept. futures are Local Cash Purchase Gain/Loss from futures Realized Purchase Price

$ 92 $ 91 $ 8 $ 83

88 87 4 83

84 83 0 83

80 79 -4 83

76 75 -8 83

A-B = C

Page 6: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

4cme.com

2. Establishing a Minimum Selling Price: Buying Puts

Buying a put option gives a producer a minimum or “floor” price without limiting the opportunity of price increases. The floor price that a put offers

is the strike price of the option minus the premium cost, adjusted by the estimated basis. However, if futures prices increase above the strike price by

the time the put option expires and the livestock are ready for market, the producer receives the current cash price less the amount of premium paid

for the put option. In this scenario of increasing market prices, the put will have declined in value and probably will expire worthless. More expensive

(higher strike) puts offer a higher floor price but a lower net price if prices increase. Less expensive (lower strike) puts offer a lower floor price but

more opportunity of gaining from market price increases.

Advantages

» Minimum price but no maximum

» No performance bond calls

» Many levels of price insurance (strike prices) to choose from

Disadvantages

» Premium costs; purchasing a long time period of protection in a volatile market is expensive

» Options currently don't offer protection as far into the future as futures contracts trade

Liquidation

When the producer sells the livestock in the cash market, he will usually sell the put if it has value. If livestock prices have increased, the put probably

will expire worthless and will not have to be liquidated. Exercising the put is an alternative for the buyer and will result in a short futures position at

the strike price of the put. Exercising the put would make sense under the following conditions, and if the producer is comfortable with the resulting

short futures position:

1. The livestock had not gained as quickly as expected and protection is still needed.

2. The put is deep-in-the-money, and its liquidity is low.

3. Basis is abnormally weak.

If the producer exercises the put, then he would later liquidate the resulting short futures position when he markets the livestock, just as he would in

a simple futures hedge.

Page 7: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

5Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Example

A producer purchases a December 60 put @ $3/cwt. to price one group of hogs and a December 56 put @ $1/cwt. to price another group of hogs.

At the time, December CME Lean Hog futures are at $58/cwt. Estimated basis for the end of November is minus $2/cwt. His estimated minimum

prices are: $60 (strike price of first put), minus $3 premium, less $2 basis = $55/cwt.; and $56 (strike price of second put), minus $1 premium less

$2 basis = $53/cwt.

At the beginning of December, when the hogs are ready for slaughter:

A B C

If Dec. futures are Value of 60 Put 60 Put Gain/Loss Local Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 68 $ 0 $ -3 $ 66 $ 63

63 0 -3 61 58

58 2 -1 56 55

53 7 4 51 55

48 12 9 46 55

A+B = C

A B C

If Dec. futures are Value of 56 Put 56 Put Gain/Loss Local Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 68 $ 0 $ -1 $ 66 $ 65

63 0 -1 61 60

58 0 -1 56 55

53 3 2 51 53

48 8 7 46 53

A+B = C

Page 8: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

6cme.com

Advanced Strategies

3. Collecting Options Premiums:Selling Call Options

This strategy is not considered a standard price risk management

strategy because it affords very little protection against declining prices.

It will enhance the price received for livestock, but only by the amount

of the premium taken in. It will, however, outperform other strategies

during very stable markets. Selling a call caps the price received for

livestock at the strike price sold, plus the premium taken in, plus or

minus the basis. Selecting a higher strike gives more opportunity for

a price increase but will yield less income from selling the call. Selecting

a lower strike will yield more income but give less opportunity if prices

increase. Also, the producer is subject to performance bond call risk

when selling an option.

Advantages

» Performs better than cash sales alone in a steady or declining market

Disadvantages

» Places a ceiling on the livestock price, with the risk of performance

bond calls in a market in which price is increasing

» Only protection against declining prices is the amount of premium

received

» Short futures position at call strike price results if buyer exercises

Liquidation

As a call seller, the producer needs to buy back the call if it has value,

or face exercise. If the call is expiring worthless (price declines) it need

not be bought back, but can be if the producer chooses. Even a

worthless call should be bought back, if it has time remaining, when

the producer sells the livestock: it could increase in value if the market

climbs before the call expires.

Example

A producer sells a September 102 call @ $1/cwt. to apply to the final sale price of his feeder cattle. The September CME Feeder Cattle futures contract is

trading at $100/cwt. His estimated basis for 700 lb. yearlings is $2/cwt. (positive basis, cash above futures). The maximum price he will receive is: $102

(strike price of the call), plus $1 premium received, plus $2 basis = $105/cwt. If prices decline he will receive the cash price plus the $1 premium taken in.

In September when the cattle are physically ready to be marketed:

A B C

If Sept. futures are Value of 102 Call 102 Call Gain/Loss Local Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 110 $ 8 $ -7 $ 112 $ 105

105 3 -2 107 105

100 0 +1 102 103

95 0 +1 97 98

90 0 +1 92 93

A+B = C

Page 9: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

7Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

4. Establishing a Minimum Selling Price at ReducedPremium Costs: Purchasing Put and Selling Call Options –The “Fence”

This combination of two previous strategies results in a risk/reward

profile that some advanced users of options have found very

advantageous. The strategy gives all the downside price protection

of an outright out-of-the-money put purchase, but costs less because

of the premium taken in from selling the call. Many people try to

accomplish it with little or no net premium cost. Selling the call means

that there is performance bond (margin) call liability and that price

increase opportunities are limited.

The maximum selling price equals the strike price of the call less the

net premium payout. The minimum selling price equals the strike price

of the put less the net premium payout. Both are adjusted for local

basis. This yields a range or “window” of possible realized price

outcomes. The closer the strike prices of the call and put are to each

other, the more narrow the window of price risk and opportunity that

will result. The further apart the strike prices, the wider the window

of price risk and opportunity.

Advantages

» Price risk protection of put option at a lower cash outlay for

premium cost

» Higher floor price than outright purchase of put

Disadvantages

» Limited opportunity for price increases

» Performance bond call liability on “short” option position (call that

was sold). Short futures position at call strike price results if buyer

exercises

Liquidation

Buy back the call (if it has value) or let it expire worthless, and sell the

put (if it has value) or let it expire worthless. Sell the livestock in the

cash market.

Example

A producer sells a December CME Live Cattle 90 call @ $1/ cwt. and purchases a December 82 put @ $1/cwt. December CME Live Cattle futures are

currently trading at $86/cwt. He estimates his local basis to be + $1/cwt. for December. His cost for the options is $1/cwt. for purchasing the put less

the $1/cwt. he received for selling the call, or a net cost of $0/cwt. Therefore, his maximum sale price is: $90 (strike price of call), minus net cost of

option, $0/cwt., plus $1 basis = $91/cwt. His minimum sale price is: $82 (strike price of put), minus net cost of options, $0/cwt., plus $1 basis =

$83/cwt.

When the beginning of December arrives and the cattle are ready for slaughter:

A B C D

If Dec. Local Net

futures Value of 90 Call Value of 82 Put Cash Realized

are 90 Call Gain/Loss 82 Put Gain/Loss Sale Price

$ 94 $ 4 $ -3 $0 $ -1 $ 95 $ 91

90 0 1 0 -1 91 91

86 0 1 0 -1 87 87

82 0 1 0 -1 83 83

78 0 1 4 3 79 83

A+B+C = D

Page 10: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

8cme.com

5. Creating a Minimum Sale Price by Combining Two Transactions: Cash Contracting (or Selling Futures)and Buying Call Options

If done at the same time, with the strike price of the call at or very close to the futures sale price or cash contracted price, this strategy is known

as a “Synthetic Put.” It gives a floor price without sacrificing all price increase opportunity. It will be discussed again later as a “follow-up” strategy

because in practice the call is often purchased after the forward cash sale or futures contract sale.

Selling futures, as in a normal hedge (cash-forward contracting), establishes a fixed selling price for livestock. It is fixed to the penny in the case of a

cash contract (with an established basis guarantee). With a futures hedge or shared-basis risk cash contract, it is a fixed price plus or minus any basis

variation. Purchasing a call option in addition to the “short” futures hedge or cash contract converts that “fixed-price” into a “floor-price” – with

the opportunity to benefit from price increases. In a market where price is increasing, the call will increase in value, repaying part of the performance

bond costs of the short futures position or adding dollars to the price of the cash contract.

Advantages

» Excellent for those who prefer cash contracts, but like to keep the potential to benefit from market price increases

» May offer higher floor price than an outright put purchase

» Offers alternative to distant month put options which may be too expensive or are not yet trading

Disadvantages

» Performance bond call liability on short futures position

» If a call with a strike price above the current market is purchased, the call will not begin yielding higher prices until the futures contract goes

above the strike of the call and also repays the premium

Liquidation

Sell the call when the livestock are ready to be sold in the cash market or let the call expire worthless. Buy back the short futures contract, if used,

and sell the livestock in the cash market or make delivery on your cash contract obligation.

Page 11: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

9Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Example 1

A producer sells an August CME Lean Hog futures contract at $56.00/cwt. and at the same time purchases an August CME Lean Hog 56 call @

$1/cwt. His estimated basis for late July is minus $1/cwt. His estimated minimum sale price is: Short futures price ($56/cwt.), minus premium cost of

$1/cwt., minus estimated basis of $1/cwt = $54/cwt. If the market price increases, he will begin to realize the increase when the futures price rises

above the strike price of the call, 56, plus the premium paid out, $1/basis = $57/cwt.

At the beginning of August, when the hogs are ready for slaughter:

A B C D

If August Futures Value of 56 Call Local Net

Futures Are Gain/Loss 56 Call Gain/Loss Cash Sale Realized Price

$ 66 $ -10 $ 10 $ 9 $ 65 $ 64

61 -5 5 4 60 59

56 0 0 -1 55 54

51 5 0 -1 50 54

46 10 0 -1 45 54

A+B+C = D

Example 2

If the producer contracted to sell finished hogs during late July for $55/cwt. and also purchased an August 56 call @ $2, his estimated minimum

sale price is: $55/cwt. cash contract price, minus premium cost of $2 = $53. If August futures rally above $58, the producer will realize a positive

return on the call.

At the beginning of August, when the hogs are ready for slaughter:

A B C

If August Cash Value of 56 Call Net

Futures Are Contract Price 56 Call Gain/Loss Realized Price

$ 66 $ 55 $ 10 $ 8 $ 63

61 55 5 3 58

56 55 0 -2 53

51 55 0 -2 53

46 55 0 -2 53

A+B = C

Page 12: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

10cme.com

Comparison of Strategies 1-5

Situation: Live Cattle to Market in August

Prices Available When Hedge Is Placed:

August CME Live Cattle (LC) Futures $ 86/cwt.

August LC 88 Put 3

August LC 84 Put 1

August LC 88 Call 1

Local Basis estimate (August) -1

Gains and Losses When Hedge Is Lifted:

Buy Buy 88 Buy 84 Sell 88 Buy 88

If Aug. Futures Put Put Call Call

Futures @86 @ $3 @ $1 @$1 @$1

Are Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss

$ 94 $ 8 $ 0 $ -3 $ 0 $ -1 $ 6 $ -5 $ 6 $ 5

90 4 0 -3 0 -1 2 -1 2 1

86 0 2 -1 0 -1 0 1 0 -1

82 -4 6 3 2 1 0 1 0 -1

78 -8 10 7 6 5 0 1 0 -1

Page 13: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

11Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Net Realized Prices When Hedge Is Lifted: Gain or loss from above table plus cash sale

Fence: Synthetic Put

If August And August Sell Futures Buy 88 Buy 84 Sell 88 Sell 88 Call Sell Fut. @ $86

Futures Are Cash Is @ $86 Put Put Call Buy 84 Put Buy 88 Call

$ 94 $ 93 $ 85 $ 90 $ 92 $ 88 $ 87 $ 90

90 89 85 86 88 88 87 86

86 85 85 84 84 86 85 84

82 81 85 84 82 82 83 84

78 77 85 84 82 78 83 84

Situation: Feeder Cattle to Market in March

Prices Available When Hedge Is Placed:

March CME Feeder Cattle (FC) Futures $ 92/cwt.

March FC 94 Put 3

March FC 90 Put 1

March FC 96 Call 1

Local Basis estimate (March) +1

Page 14: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

12cme.com

Gains and Losses When Hedge Is Lifted:

Sell Buy 94 Buy 90 Sell 96 Buy 96

If Mar. Futures Put Put Call Call

Futures @ $92 @ $3 @ $1 @$1 @$1

Are Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss

$ 102 $ -10 $ 0 $ -3 $ 0 $ -1 $ 6 $ -5 $ 6 $ 5

97 -5 0 -3 0 -1 1 0 1 0

92 0 2 -1 0 -1 0 1 0 -1

87 5 7 3 3 2 0 1 0 -1

82 10 12 8 8 7 0 1 0 -1

Net Realized Prices When Hedge Is Lifted: Cash purchase minus gain or loss from above table

Fence: Synthetic Put

If March And March Sell Futures Buy 94 Buy 90 Sell 96 Sell 96 Call Sell Fut. @ $92

Futures Are Cash Is @ $92 Put Put Call Buy 90 Put Buy 96 Call

$ 102 $ 103 $ 93 $ 100 $ 102 $ 98 $ 97 $ 98

97 98 93 95 97 98 97 93

92 93 93 92 92 94 93 92

87 88 93 92 90 89 91 92

82 83 93 92 90 84 91 92

Page 15: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

13Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Situation: Lean Hogs to Market in February

Prices Available When Hedge Is Placed:

February CME Lean Hog Futures $67/cwt.

February LH 66 Put 1

February LH 64 Put .50

February LH 70 Call .50

Local Basis estimate (February) -1

Gains and Losses When Hedge Is Lifted:

Sell Buy 66 Buy 64 Sell 70 Buy 64

If Feb. Futures Put Put Call Put

Futures @ $67 @ $1 @ $.50 @$.50 @ $.50

Are Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss

$ 77 $ -10 $ 0 $ -1 $ 0 $ -.50 $ 7 $ -6.50 $ 7 $ 6.50

72 -5 0 -1 0 -.50 2 -1.50 2 1.50

67 0 0 -1 0 -.50 0 .50 0 -.50

62 5 4 3 2 1.50 0 .50 0 -.50

57 10 9 8 7 6.50 0 .50 0 -.50

Net Realized Prices When Hedge Is Lifted: Cash purchase minus gain or loss from above table

Fence: Synthetic Put

If Feb. And Feb. Sell Futures Buy 66 Buy 64 Sell 70 Sell 70 Call Sell Fut. @ $67

Futures Are Cash Is @ $67 Put Put Call Buy 64 Put Buy 70 Call

$ 77 $ 76 $ 66 $ 75 $ 75.50 $ 69.50 $ 69 $ 72.50

72 71 66 70 70.50 69.50 69 67.50

67 66 66 65 65.50 66.50 66 65.50

62 61 66 64 62.50 61.50 63 65.50

57 56 66 54 62.50 56.50 63 65.50

Page 16: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

14cme.com

Adjustment Strategies

6. Converting a Fixed Price to a Minimum Price: Purchasing Call Options After Selling Futures, or After ForwardContracting at a Fixed Price

Most producers fear missing the opportunity of a market rally after they have hedged or forward contracted at a fixed price. Hedged producers

are tempted to lift the hedge early to seize such opportunity, but that exposes them to the downside risk they were trying to avoid in the first

place. Both hedged and forward contracted producers can avoid risk while seizing opportunity by buying a call as a second component of their

marketing strategy.

By purchasing a call option, producers can restore the opportunity of price increase without sacrificing downside price protection. In effect, the

fixed price futures hedge or cash contract is converted to a floor price, and the whole position resembles a put.

The more the strike price of the selected call is above the futures price, the greater the price increase required before the producer will begin to

realize a higher price. If he selects a call strike price at or below the futures price, a higher price will be realized much more quickly in a rising market.

However, the lower the strike price the producer can choose, the more premium he will have to pay and the lower the resulting floor price will be.

Advantages

» Riskless way to restore price increase opportunity to cash contract or futures hedge

Disadvantages

» Premium cost of call, as well as the margin liability on the short futures position which remains after the adjustment

» Timing important, because call is purchased after hedge or cash contract is made

Liquidation

Sell the call when the livestock are ready to be sold in the cash market, or let the call expire worthless. Buy back the short futures contract,

if used, and sell the livestock in the cash market or make delivery on your cash contract obligation.

Page 17: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

15Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Example

A short futures hedge or cash contract has been established and the market declines. The producer observes that call options have declined in value

and he can now cheaply restore the upside opportunity to his futures hedge or cash contract. This doesn't mean that the only time this strategy

should be used is after a market decline. It may be a wise strategy anytime a price advance is anticipated and opportunity may be missed.

A producer sells April CME Feeder Cattle futures at $98/cwt. to hedge some 700-800 lbs. cattle. His estimated basis is plus $1/cwt. His estimated local

hedge price is then $98/cwt. plus $1/cwt. = $99/cwt.

The April futures contract declines to $95.00/cwt. He purchases an April 96 call for $1.50/cwt. Now his combined position is: minimum sale price =

futures price ($98/cwt.), minus call premium ($1.50/cwt.), plus estimated basis ($1.00/cwt.) = $97.50/cwt.

In April when the cattle are physically ready to be marketed:

Without Follow-Up

A B C

If April Futures Are Futures Gain/Loss Cash Purchase Net Realized Price

$ 108 $ -10 $ 109 $ 99

103 -5 104 99

98 0 99 99

93 5 94 99

88 10 89 99

A+B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If April Futures Value of 96 Call Local

Futures Are Gain/Loss 96 Call Gain/Loss Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 108 $ -10 $ 12 $ 10.50 $ 109 $ 109.50

103 -5 7 5.50 104 104.50

98 0 2 0.50 99 99.50

93 5 0 -1.50 94 97.50

88 10 0 -1.50 89 97.50

A+B+C = D

Page 18: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

16cme.com

7. Converting a Fixed Price to a Minimum Price: Purchasing Put Options After Liquidating a Short Futures Hedge

This strategy is very similar to follow-up #6 except there is no continued performance bond liability because the short futures hedge is offset.

The incentive for carrying out this strategy is much the same as in #6: A producer has a fixed forward price and thinks there is opportunity ahead

for a price increase. He wants this opportunity without removing his protection against the risk of a market decline.

Many times a hedger will look at this strategy after he has seen a market decline and realized a positive flow of funds into his futures performance

bond account. Now he thinks the market may rebound and go higher, but he doesn’t want to go unprotected. Therefore, he liquidates his hedge

and uses part or all of the futures gain to purchase a put option. Usually a producer in this situation will purchase an “at-” or “out-of-the-money”

put which would, along with the futures gain, give him a minimum price fairly close to his original fixed-price and leave plenty of potential for

market increases.

Advantages

» Can restore opportunity to profit from price increases

» Ends performance bond call liability without sacrificing price risk protection

Disadvantages

» May sacrifice part of the original hedge price if market remains lower, because of the premium paid out

Liquidation

Sell livestock in the cash market and sell back the put option if it has value, or let the put expire if worthless.

Page 19: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

17Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Example

A producer sells June CME Live Cattle futures @ $84/cwt. to hedge his slaughter cattle. His estimated basis for June is + $1/cwt. His estimated local

hedge price is then $84/cwt. plus $1/cwt. = $85/cwt. The June futures contract declines to $79/cwt. in April. He purchases a June 78 put for $1/cwt.

and buys back his futures contract for a gain of $84/cwt. minus $79/cwt. = $5/cwt. Now his minimum sale price = futures hedge gain of $5 plus

strike price of put ($78/cwt.), minus put premium of $1/cwt., plus estimated basis of $1/cwt. = $83/cwt. So $2/cwt. has been sacrificed from the

original hedge price, if the market continues to decline. Additionally, should prices rise, the producer will have the $4/cwt. net gain to add to his

local price.

At the beginning of June, when the cattle are physically ready to be marketed:

Without Follow-Up

A B C

If June Futures Are Futures Gain/Loss Local Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 89 $ -5 $ 90 $ 85

84 0 85 85

79 5 80 85

74 10 75 85

69 15 70 85

A+B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If June Futures Value of 78 Call Local

Futures Are Gain/Loss 78 Call Gain/Loss Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 89 $ 5 $ 0 $ -1 $ 90 $ 84

84 5 0 -1 85 79

79 5 0 -1 80 74

74 5 4 3 75 73

69 5 9 8 70 73

A+B+C = D

Page 20: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

18cme.com

8. Converting a Minimum Price to a Fixed Price - Selling Futures or Cash Contracting After a Put Option Purchase

Often a producer may be committed to a production situation in which he thinks prices are going to increase, but still wants some risk protection.

Possibly he is committed to pasture rental, feedlot space or feeder pig purchase. Just in case, he wants some low-cost insurance while waiting for a

price increase that he thinks is coming. This floor price may be at least enough to repay a production loan or prevent financial disaster if the producer

is highly leveraged. A way to accomplish this is to purchase a low cost put option to afford some risk protection while waiting for a more favorable

pricing opportunity. The subsequent pricing could be fixed-price (futures hedge or cash contract).

Advantages

» Risk management while waiting for more favorable pricing opportunity

Disadvantages

» A drastically lower price could occur before a follow-up “short-hedge” or cash contract is in place

Liquidation

Sell the put or let it expire if it has no value, buy back the futures hedge and sell livestock in the cash market, or deliver the livestock to the cash

contracted party. The put can be liquidated when the follow-up pricing is done, but it is not essential and adds no risk if it is not liquidated.

Example

A producer purchases an October CME Lean Hog 52 put for $1/cwt. October CME Lean Hog futures are trading at $56/cwt. He expects a local

basis of + $1/cwt. for the end of September. Therefore his estimated minimum sale price from the put is: strike price of put ($52/cwt.), minus put

premium ($1/cwt.), plus basis of $1/cwt. = $52/cwt.

In the following two months the October futures price increases to $66/cwt. With two months remaining before the hogs are ready for slaughter,

the producer sells a futures contract (or establishes a cash contract). He could liquidate the put at this time if it had any value, but there is no risk

and very little cost to just leaving it in place. He now has a fixed price of: futures contract sale price ($66/cwt.), minus put premium cost ($1/cwt.),

plus basis of $1/cwt. = $66/cwt., unless the futures price falls below the put strike of $52, in which case the net realized price rises by $1 for each

$1 the futures falls below $52.

Page 21: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

19Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

At the beginning of October, when the hogs are ready for slaughter:

Without Follow-Up

If October A B C

Futures Are Value of 52 Put 52 Put Gain/Loss Local Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 72 $ 0 $ -1 $ 73 $ 72

66 0 -1 67 66

60 0 -1 61 60

54 0 -1 55 54

48 4 3 49 52

A+B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If October Futures Value of 52 Put Local

Futures Are Gain/Loss 52 Put* Gain/Loss Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 72 $ -6 $ 0 $ -1 $ 73 $ 66

66 0 0 -1 67 66

60 6 0 -1 61 66

54 12 0 -1 55 66

48 18 4 3 49 70

A+B+C = D

* Put not liquidated when follow-up action taken.

Page 22: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

20cme.com

9. Increasing the Minimum Price: Purchasing Put Options as Prices Increase

When a producer has purchased a put and market prices subsequently increase, he may want to do something to capture this new higher price level,

again without sacrificing protection against price decline. Follow-up strategy #8 would be one alternative, but it would limit the potential gain from

another price increase. Another alternative is to purchase a second, higher strike put, which is favorably priced because of the futures price increase.

The new minimum price is the strike of the second put minus total premium paid out, plus or minus basis.

Advantages

» Capitalizes on market price increases without limiting extreme price increases

» No performance bond liability

» Allows the market time to move up without accepting limitless risk

Disadvantages

» More than one premium payout. (It may be possible to liquidate the first put with some remaining value, when the second higher strike put

is purchased.)

Liquidation

Sell back any puts you hold that have value. Sell the livestock in the cash market.

Example

A producer purchases a November CME Feeder Cattle 96 put for $1/cwt. The November CME Feeder Cattle futures contract is trading at $100/cwt.

He expects a basis for his 400-500 pound calves of + $5/cwt. in November. Therefore the 96 put is offering him an estimated minimum price of:

put strike price ($96/cwt.), minus premium cost ($1/cwt.), plus basis ($5/cwt.) = $100/cwt.

One month later, November futures are trading at $105/cwt. He purchases a November 102 put for $1/cwt. He can liquidate his 96 put if it has

value or he may choose to leave it in place for double protection should the market drop back down below $96. His new minimum price is: put

strike ($102/cwt.) minus total premium cost ($2/cwt., $1 for 96 put + $1 for 102 put), plus basis ($5/cwt.) = $105/cwt.

Page 23: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

21Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

In November, when the cattle are physically ready to be marketed:

Without Follow-Up

If November A B C

Futures Are Value of 96 Put 96 Put Gain/Loss Local Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 110 $ 0 $ -1 $ 115 $ 114

105 0 -1 110 109

100 0 -1 105 104

95 1 0 100 100

90 6 5 95 100

A+B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If November 96 Put* Value of 102 Put Local

Futures Are Gain/Loss 102 Put* Gain/Loss Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 110 $ -1 $ 0 $ -1 $ 115 $ -113

105 -1 0 -1 110 108

100 -1 2 1 105 105

95 0 7 6 100 106

90 5 12 11 95 111

A+B+C = D

*Assumes first put was retained, since it had practically no value and there was no benefit

to selling it at the time the second put was purchased.

Page 24: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

22cme.com

10. Cashing in Minimum Price Protection: Purchasing Put Options as Prices Decrease

When a producer has purchased a put and market prices later decline, he will probably observe that his put has increased in value. He may wish

he could cash in the value of those puts and use the value to pay down a line of operating credit, but may still want some price protection. He can

accomplish that by using a portion of the gain from the first put purchased (higher strike price), then purchasing a lower strike price put after a

substantial market decline. The final minimum price equals the strike price of the last put purchased, minus its premium, plus the gain from the first

put, adjusted for basis. This is similar in nature to follow-up strategy # 7.

Advantages

» Allows hedger to collect on a portion of his price insurance early if the market declines, and payoff some of his production expenses

» Allows for a higher net realized price in cases when the market subsequently increases

Disadvantages

» Usually sacrifices a portion of the floor price because of second put premium

Liquidation

This forward pricing strategy is liquidated just like the straight put purchase pricing strategy, by liquidating the remaining put if it has value or

letting the put expire worthless, and selling the cash livestock.

Example

A producer purchases a February CME Live Cattle 84 put for $1.50/cwt. The February CME Live Cattle futures contract is trading at $86/cwt.

He expects a basis for his cattle that will be ready for slaughter in February at 1100 lb. of -$2/cwt. Therefore, the 84 put is offering him an

estimated minimum price of: put strike price ($84/cwt.), minus premium cost ($1.50/cwt.), minus basis ($2/cwt.) = $80.50/cwt.

Two months later the February futures contract is trading at $78/cwt. He sells the 84 put for $6.50/cwt. and purchases a February Live Cattle

78 put at $1.50/cwt. His new minimum sale price is: gain from 84 put ($5/cwt.) plus strike price of second put ($78/cwt.), minus 78 put premium

($1.50/cwt.), minus basis ($2/cwt.) = $79.50.

Page 25: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

23Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

In February, when the cattle are ready for slaughter:

Without Follow-Up

If February A B C

Futures Are Value of 84 Put 64 Put Gain/Loss Local Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 92 $ 0 $ -1.50 $ 90 $ 88.50

87 0 -1.50 85 83.50

82 2 0.50 80 80.50

77 7 5.50 75 80.50

72 12 10.50 70 80.50

A+B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If February 84 Put* Value of 78 Put Local

Futures Are Gain/Loss 78 Put* Gain/Loss Cash Sale Net Realized Price

$ 92 $ 5 $ 0 $ -1.50 $ 90 $ 93.50

87 5 0 -1.50 85 88.50

82 5 0 -1.50 80 83.50

77 5 1 -0.50 75 79.50

72 5 6 4.50 70 79.50

A+B+C = D

Page 26: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

In September when the producer is ready to place the cattle on feed:

A B C

If Sept. Futures Are Local Cash Purchase Gain/Loss from futures Realized Purchase Price

$ 102 $ 101 $ 8 $ 93

98 97 4 93

94 93 0 93

90 89 -4 93

86 85 -8 93

A-B = C

24cme.com

Basic Long Strategies

1. Locking in a Fixed Purchase Price-Buying Futures

This traditional hedge offers the advantage of “locking in” input costs

plus or minus any variation in actual basis from expected basis. The

expected local hedge price is equal to the long futures price plus the

expected local basis. Some prefer forward cash contracting over buying

futures because of basis risk. Buying futures, however, allows the

flexibility of altering the pricing decision at some future time, which

cash contracting does not.

Advantages

» Locked in price, subject to basis variation

» Yields best price if market advances significantly after placing hedge

» Can price input costs as much as 12 months in advance

Disadvantages

» Attempts to capitalize on price declines by liquidating hedge

early re-exposes position to market risk

» Performance bond call responsibility

Liquidation

To liquidate the hedge, sell back the futures contract at the same time

acquiring the livestock. Holding a long position until the delivery period

arrives creates the risk of being assigned the livestock delivery. If a hedger

is willing to stand for delivery, be aware that it is the seller, and not the

buyer, who decides the day and location, and consult exchange rules to

determine what will be expected of both parties. At this writing, deliveries

are possible in live cattle only, while feeder cattle and lean hogs are

cash-settled.

Example

A feedlot manager purchases September CME Feeder Cattle futures

at $94/cwt. He expects a local basis of minus $1/cwt. in September

when yearlings are to be placed; therefore, his expected hedged

price is $93/cwt.

Part II: Ten Long Hedge Strategies for Procurement ProtectionFor Cattle Feeders, Stocker Operators, Meat Packersand Institutional Users of Meats

Page 27: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

25Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

2. Establishing a Maximum Purchase Price: Buying Calls

Buying a call option provides a maximum or “ceiling” price without limiting the opportunity of price decreases. The ceiling price that a call offers

is the strike price of the option plus the premium cost, adjusted by the estimated basis. However, if futures prices decrease below the strike price

by the time the call option expires, the buyer pays only the current cash price plus the amount of premium paid for the call option. In this scenario

of decreasing market prices, the call will have declined in value and probably will expire worthless. More expensive (lower strike) calls offer a lower

ceiling price but a higher net purchase price if prices decrease. Less expensive (higher strike) calls offer a higher ceiling price but more

opportunity of gaining from market price decreases.

Advantages

» Maximum purchase price but no minimum

» No performance bond calls

» Many levels of price insurance (strike prices) to choose from

Disadvantages

» Premium outlay

» Options currently don’t offer protection as far into the future as futures contracts do

Liquidation

When a hedger buys livestock in the cash market, the call is usually sold if it has value. If it is worthless there is no need to offset. Exercising the

call if it has value is an alternative for the buyer and will result in a long futures position purchased at the strike price of the call. Exercising the call

into a long futures position for live cattle should be considered if:

1. The option is about to expire and the livestock have not yet been purchases

2. The hedger is comfortable with the potential performance bond calls associated with a futures position

3. The hedger is comfortable with the risk of being assigned a livestock delivery on the long futures contract position in the delivery month

If the hedger exercises the call, then he liquidates the resulting long futures position when he purchases the livestock, just as he would in a simple

futures hedge.

Page 28: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

26cme.com

Example

A hog packer purchases a December 60 call @ $1/cwt. to price one group of hogs and a December 56 call @ $3/cwt. to price another group of hogs.

At the time, December CME Lean Hog futures are at $58/cwt. Estimated basis for the beginning of December is minus $2/cwt. The firm’s estimated

maximum prices are: $60 (strike price of first call), plus $1 premium, less $2 basis = $59/cwt.; and $56 (strike price of second call), plus $3 premium,

less $2 basis = $57/cwt.

At the beginning of December, when the cash hogs are ready for slaughter:

A B C

If Dec. Futures Are Local Cash Purchase Value of 60 Call 60 Call Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 68 $ 66 $ 8 $ 7 $ 59

63 61 3 2 59

58 56 0 -1 57

53 51 0 -1 52

48 46 0 -1 47

A-B = C

A B C

If Dec. Futures Are Local Cash Purchase Value of 56 Call 56 Call Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 68 $ 66 $ 12 $ 9 $ 57

63 61 7 4 57

58 56 2 -1 57

53 51 0 -3 54

48 46 0 -3 49

A-B = C

Page 29: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

27Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Advanced Strategies

3. Collecting Option Premiums:Selling Put Options

This strategy is not considered a standard price-risk management

strategy because it affords protection against rising prices only to the

extent of the premium taken in. Selling a put establishes the minimum

price paid for livestock at the strike price, less the premium taken in,

plus or minus the basis. Selecting a lower strike gives more opportunity

for a price decrease, but will yield less income from selling the put.

Selecting a higher strike will yield more income, but give less

opportunity if prices decrease. Also, the seller is subject to performance

bond call risk when selling an option. This strategy is best suited for

very stable market periods.

Advantages

» Performs better than cash purchases alone in a steady market

Disadvantages

» Establishes a minimum cost of livestock purchases, with the risk of

performance bond calls in a market in which prices are decreasing

» Only protection against rising prices is the amount of premium

received

» Long futures position at put strike price results if assigned an exercise

Liquidation

A put seller needs to buy back the put if it has value, or face exercise.

Even a worthless put should be offset when the seller purchases the

livestock; otherwise a sharp market decline could increase the value

of the long put before the option expires.

Example

A feedlot manager sells a September 90 put @ $1/cwt. The September CME Feeder Cattle futures contract is trading at $92/cwt. His estimated basis

for 700 lb. yearlings is minus $2/cwt. The minimum price he will pay is $90 (strike price of put), minus $1 premium received, minus $2 basis = $87/cwt.

If prices rise, he will have to pay the higher cash price minus only the $1.50 premium taken in.

In September when the producer is ready to place the cattle on feed:

A B C

If Sept. Futures Are Local Cash Purchase Value of 90 Put 90 Put Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 100 $ 98 $ 0 $ 1 $ 97

95 93 0 1 92

90 88 0 1 87

85 83 -5 -4 87

80 78 -10 -9 87

A-B = C

Page 30: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

28cme.com

4. Establishing a Maximum Purchase Price atReduced Premium Costs: Purchasing Calls and SellingPut Options - The “Fence”

This combination of two previously mentioned strategies results in a

risk/reward profile that some sophisticated users of options have found

very sensible. The strategy gives all the upside price protection of an

outright out-of-the-money call purchase, but costs less because of the

premium gained from selling the put. Many people try to accomplish

it with little or no net premium cost. However, selling a put involves

performance bond call liability and limits price decrease opportunities.

The maximum purchase price equals the strike price of the call, plus

the net premium payout. The minimum purchase price equals the strike

price of the put, plus the net premium payout. Both are adjusted for

local basis. This yields a range or “window” of possible realized prices.

The closer the strike prices of the put and call are to each other, the

narrower the window of price risk and opportunity. The further apart

the strike prices, the wider the window.

Advantages

» Price risk protection of call purchase at a lower cash outlay

for premium

» Yields lower ceiling price than purchase of call alone

Disadvantages

» Limited opportunity for price decreases

» Performance bond call liability on “short” option position

(put that was sold). Long futures position at put strike price

results if the put is exercised

Liquidation

Buy back the put (if it has value) or let it expire worthless, and sell

the call (if it has value) or let it expire worthless. (Buying back even a

worthless put may be a smart idea, to guard against a sudden market

down-move.) Purchase the livestock in the cash market.

Example

A packer sells a December CME Live Cattle 82 Put @ $1/cwt and purchases a December CME Live Cattle 88 call @ $1.50/cwt. December CME Live

Cattle futures are currently trading at $86/cwt. He estimates his local basis to be + $1/cwt. for December. His net cost for the option is $.50/cwt.

Therefore, his maximum purchase price is $88 (strike price of the call), plus net cost of options, $.50/cwt., plus $1 basis = $89.50/cwt. His minimum

purchase price is $82 (strike price of the put), plus net cost of options, $.50/cwt., plus $1basis = $83.50/cwt.

When the beginning of December arrives and the cattle are acquired for slaughter:

A B C D

If Dec. Local Cash Value of 82 Put Value of 88 Call Net Realized

Futures Are Purchase 82 Put Gain/Loss 88 Call Gain/Loss Price

$ 94 $ 95 $ 0 $ 1 $ 6 $ 4.50 $ 89.50

90 91 0 1 2 .50 89.50

86 87 0 1 0 -1.50 87.50

82 83 0 1 0 -1.50 83.50

78 79 4 -3 0 -1.50 83.50

A-B-C = D

Page 31: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

29Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

5. Creating a Maximum Purchase Price by CombiningTwo Transactions: Cash Contracting (or Buying Futures)and Buying Put Options

If done at the same time, with the strike price of the put at, or very

close to, the futures purchase price or cash contracted price, this

strategy is known as a “Synthetic CalI.” It provides a ceiling price

without sacrificing all price decrease opportunity. It will be discussed

again later as a follow-up strategy, because in practice the put is

often purchased after the forward cash contract purchase or the long

futures contract is initiated.

Buying futures as in a normal hedge or cash-forward contracting

establishes a fixed purchase price for cash livestock needs. It is fixed

to the penny in the case of a cash-contract (with an established basis

adjustment). With a futures hedge it is a fixed price plus or minus any

variation in basis. By purchasing a put option in addition to the long

futures hedge or cash contract, the hedger has converted that fixed-

price into a ceiling-price, with the opportunity to benefit from price

decreases. In a market where price is decreasing, the put will increase

in value, repaying the performance bond costs of the long futures

position or subtracting dollars from the price of the cash contract.

Advantages

» Excellent for those dealing in cash contracts, but who like to

keep the potential for benefiting from market price decreases

» May offer lower ceiling price than an outright call purchase

Disadvantages

» Performance bond call liability on long futures position

» If a put with a strike price below the current market is purchased,

the put will not begin yielding lower prices until the futures price

moves below the strike of the put

Liquidation

Sell the put (if it has value) when the livestock are ready to be

purchased in the cash market, or let the put expire if worthless.

Sell the long futures contract, if used, and buy the livestock in the

cash market; or take delivery on cash contract initiated earlier.

Example 1

A packer buys an August CME Lean Hog futures contract at $66/cwt. and at the same time purchases an August 66 put @ $2/cwt. His estimated

basis for late July is plus $1/cwt. The estimated maximum purchase price is: long futures price $66/cwt., plus premium cost of $2/cwt., plus estimated

basis of $1/cwt = $69/cwt. If the market price decreases below $66/cwt., the packer will realize a return on the put to compensate for the long

hedge performance bond requirements.

At the beginning of August, when the hogs are acquired for slaughter:

A B C D

If Aug. Local Futures Value of 66 Put Net

Futures Are Cash Price Gain/Loss 66 Put Gain/Loss Realized Price

$ 76 $ 77 $ 10 $ 0 $ -2 $ 69

71 72 5 0 -2 69

66 67 0 0 -2 69

61 62 -5 5 3 64

56 57 -10 10 8 59

A-B-C = D

Page 32: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

30cme.com

Example 2

If the packer contracts to purchase finished hogs in late July for $67/cwt., and purchases an August 66 put @ $2/cwt., his estimated maximum

purchase price is: $67/cwt. cash contract price, plus premium cost of $2/cwt. = $69. If the August futures price drops below $66/cwt., the packer

will realize some return on the put.

At the end of July, when the hogs are acquired for slaughter:

A B C

If Aug. futures are Cash Contract Price Value of 66 Put 66 Put Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 76 $ 67 $ 0 $ -2 $ 69

71 67 0 -2 69

66 67 0 -2 69

61 67 5 3 64

56 67 10 8 59

A-B = C

Comparison of Strategies 1-5

Situation: Live Cattle for August Acquisition

Prices Available When Hedge Is Placed:

August CME Live Cattle (LC) Futures $ 86/cwt.

August LC 84 Call 3

August LC 88 Call 1

August LC 84 Put 1

Local Basis estimate (August) +1

Page 33: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

31Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Gains and Losses When Hedge Is Lifted:

Buy Buy 84 Buy 88 Sell 84 Buy 84

If Aug. Futures Call Call Put Put

Futures @ $86 @ $3 @ $1 @ $1 @ $1

Are Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss

$ 94 $ 8 $ 10 $ 7 $ 6 $ 5 $ 0 $ 1 $ 0 $ -1

90 4 6 3 2 1 0 1 0 -1

86 0 2 -1 0 -1 0 1 0 -1

82 -4 0 -3 0 -1 2 -1 2 1

78 -8 0 -3 0 -1 6 -5 6 5

Net Realized Prices When Hedge Is Lifted: Cash purchase minus gain or loss from above table

Fence: Synthetic Call:

If Aug. And August Buy Futures Buy 84 Buy 88 Sell 84 Sell 84 Put Sell Fut. @ $86

Futures Are Cash is @ $86 Call Call Put Buy 88 Call Buy 84 Put

$ 94 $ 95 $ 87 $ 88 $ 90 $ 94 $ 89 $ 88

90 91 87 88 90 90 89 88

86 87 87 88 90 86 87 88

82 83 87 88 90 84 85 86

78 79 87 88 90 84 85 82

Page 34: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

32cme.com

Situation: Feeder Cattle to Place on Feed in March

Prices Available When Hedge Is Placed:

March CME Feeder Cattle (FC) Futures $92/cwt.

March FC 90 Call 3

March FC 94 Call 1

March FC 88 Put 1

Local Basis estimate (March) +1

Gains and Losses When Hedge Is Lifted:

Buy Buy 90 Buy 94 Sell 88 Buy 88

If Mar. Futures Call Call Put Put

Futures @ $92 @ $3 @ $1 @ $1 @ $1

Are Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss

$ 102 $ 10 $ 12 $ 9 $ 8 $ 7 $ 0 $ 1 $ 0 $ -1

97 5 7 4 3 2 0 1 0 -1

92 0 2 -1 0 -1 0 1 0 -1

87 -5 0 -3 0 -1 1 0 1 0

82 -10 0 -3 0 -1 6 -5 6 5

Net Realized Prices When Hedge Is Lifted: Cash purchase minus gain or loss from above table

Fence: Synthetic Call:

If Mar. And March Buy Futures Buy 90 Buy 94 Sell 88 Sell 88 Put Buy Fut. @ $92

Futures Are Cash is @ $92 Call Call Put Buy 94 Call Buy 88 Put

$ 102 $ 103 $ 93 $ 94 $ 96 $ 102 $ 95 $ 94

97 98 93 94 96 97 95 94

92 93 93 94 94 92 93 94

87 88 93 91 89 88 89 93

82 83 93 86 84 88 89 88

Page 35: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

33Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Situation: Lean Hogs for February Acquisition

Prices Available When Hedge Is Placed:

February CME Lean Hog Futures $67/cwt.

Feb. LH 68 Call 1

Feb. LH 70 Call .50

Feb. LH 64 Put .50

Local Basis estimate (February) +1

Gains and Losses When Hedge Is Lifted:

Buy Buy 68 Buy 70 Sell 64 Buy 64

If Feb. Futures Call Call Put Put

Futures @ $67 @ $1 @ $.50 @ $.50 @ $.50

Are Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss Value Gain/Loss

$ 77 $ 10 $ 9 $ 8 $ 7 $ 6.50 $ 0 $ .50 $ 0 $ -.50

72 5 4 3 2 1.50 0 .50 0 -.50

67 0 0 -1 0 -.50 0 .50 0 -.50

62 -5 0 -1 0 -.50 2 -1.50 2 1.50

57 -10 0 -1 0 -.50 7 -6.50 7 6.50

Net Realized Prices When Hedge Is Lifted: Cash purchase minus gain or loss from above table

Fence: Synthetic Call:

If Feb. And February Buy Futures Buy 68 Buy 70 Sell 64 Sell 64 Put Buy Fut. @ $67

Futures Are Cash is @ $67 Call Call Put Buy 70 Call Buy 64 Put

$ 77 $ 78 $ 68 $ 70 $ 71.50 $ 77.50 $ 71 $ 68.50

72 73 68 70 71.50 72.50 71 68.50

67 68 68 69 68.50 67.50 68 68.50

62 63 68 64 63.50 64.50 65 66.50

57 58 68 59 58.50 64.50 65 61.50

Page 36: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

34cme.com

Adjustment Strategies

6. Converting a Fixed Price to a Maximum Price-Purchasing a Put Option after Buying Futures

Suppose a cattle feeder has either long hedged or forward contracted to buy livestock. The market goes up, so he is glad he protected himself.

But then the market begins to fall back again, and the feeder sees that he is missing out on opportunity. What can he do? He can buy a put to

restore downside opportunity without sacrificing upside protection. Prior to the advent of options he was either locked in, or if hedged, he could

have lifted the hedge prematurely and taken his chances.

By purchasing a put option after he has purchased futures or forward contracted livestock, he is converting the fixed price futures hedge or cash

contract to a ceiling price, and the whole position resembles a call.

The further the strike price of the selected put is below the futures price, the greater the price decrease required before he will begin to realize

a lower price. If he selects a put with a strike price at or above the futures price, a lower price will be realized much more quickly in a declining

market, but it will be more costly than a put with a lower strike price.

Advantages

» Riskless means to restore downside opportunity to cash contracts or futures hedge

Disadvantages

» Premium outlay for put, as well as performance bond liability on long futures position which remains after adjustment

» Timing is important, because put is purchased after hedge or cash contract is initiated

Liquidation

Sell the put (if it has value) when the livestock are ready to be purchased in the cash market, or let the put expire if worthless. Sell the long

futures contract, if used, and buy the livestock in the cash market; or take delivery on the cash contract initiated earlier.

Example

A feedlot operator buys April CME Feeder Cattle futures at $98.00/ cwt. for placement of 600-700 lb. calves. His estimated basis is +$1/cwt.

His estimated local hedge price is then $98/cwt. + $1/cwt. = $99/cwt.

The April futures contract increases to $105/cwt. He purchases an April 104 put for $1.50/cwt. Now his combined position is: maximum

purchase price = futures price, $98/cwt., plus call premium, $1.50/cwt., plus estimated basis, $1/cwt. = $100.50/cwt.

Page 37: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

35Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

In April when the producer is ready to place the cattle on feed:

Without Follow-Up

A B C

If April Futures Are Cash Purchase Futures Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 108 $ 109 $ 10 $ 99

103 104 5 99

98 99 0 99

93 94 -5 99

88 89 -10 99

A-B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If April Cash Futures Value of 104 Put Net

Futures Are Purchase Gain/Loss 104 Put Gain/Loss Realized Price

$ 108 $ 109 $ 10 $ 0 $ -1.50 $ 100.50

103 104 5 1 -.50 99.50

98 99 0 6 4.50 94.50

93 94 -5 11 9.50 89.50

88 89 -10 16 14.50 84.50

A-B-C = D

Page 38: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

36cme.com

7. Converting a Fixed Price to a Maximum Price- Purchasing Call Options after Liquidating a Long Futures Hedge

This strategy is very similar to follow-up #6 except there is no continued performance bond liability because the long futures hedge is offset.

The incentive for carrying out this strategy is much the same as in #6. There is a fixed forward price and apparent opportunity ahead for a price

decrease. A livestock hedger wants this opportunity without removing protection against the risk of a market increase.

Often a long hedger will look at this strategy after a market increase has resulted in a positive flow of funds into his futures performance bond

account. Now he thinks the market may retrace and go lower, but he doesn’t want to go unprotected. Therefore, he liquidates his hedge, and

uses part or all of the futures gain to purchase a call option. Usually a hedger in this situation will purchase an at- or out-of-the-money call which

would give him a maximum price fairly close to his original fixed-price, while leaving plenty of potential for a market decline.

Advantages

» Can restore opportunity to profit from price decreases

» Stops performance bond call liability without sacrificing price risk protection

Disadvantages

» Premium outlay may sacrifice some of the original hedged price if market remains higher

Liquidation

Buy livestock in the cash market and sell back the call option (if it has value) or let the call expire if worthless. Can exercise the call into a long

futures position and even take delivery of live cattle if comfortable with that situation.

Example

A packer buys June CME Live Cattle futures @ $84/cwt. to hedge his slaughter requirements. His estimated basis for June is +$1/cwt. His hedge

price is then $84/cwt. + $1/cwt. = $85/cwt. The June futures contract increases to $89/cwt. in April. He purchases a June 90 call for $1/cwt. and

sells back his futures contract for a gain of $5/cwt. Now his combined position is: maximum purchase price = the strike price of the call ($90/cwt.),

minus the net futures gain of $5/cwt., plus call premium of $1/cwt., plus estimated basis, $1/cwt. = $87/cwt. The packer has sacrificed $2/cwt.

from the original hedge price, if the market continues to increase. However, should prices drop, he has an additional $4/cwt. net gain to reduce

the purchase price of the cattle.

Page 39: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

37Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

At the beginning of June when the cattle are acquired for slaughter:

Without Follow-Up

A B C

If June Futures Are Cash Purchase Futures Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 99 $ 100 $ 15 $ 85

94 95 10 85

89 90 5 85

84 85 0 85

79 80 -5 85

A-B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If June Cash Futures Value of 90 Call Net

Futures Are Purchase Gain/Loss 90 Call Gain/Loss Realized Price

$ 99 $ 100 $ 5 $ 9 $ 8 $ 87

94 95 5 4 3 87

89 90 5 0 -1 86

84 85 5 0 -1 81

79 80 5 0 -1 76

A-B-C = D

Page 40: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

38cme.com

8. Converting a Maximum Price to a Fixed Price-Buying Futures or Cash Contracting after a Call Purchase

Often a livestock purchaser may be in a situation where he thinks prices are going to decrease, but still wants some upside risk protection.

He could purchase a low cost call option to afford some risk protection and then comfortably wait for a more favorable pricing opportunity,

specifically an opportunity to buy futures at a lower price.

Advantages

» Risk management while waiting for more favorable pricing opportunity

Disadvantages

» Timing is critical

» Margins if futures are employed in follow-up

Liquidation

Sell the call or let it expire if it has no value, sell back the futures hedge and purchase livestock. (The call can be liquidated when the follow-up

pricing is done, but it is not essential and adds no risk if it is not liquidated.)

Example

A packer purchases an October CME Lean Hog 60 call for $1/cwt. October CME Lean Hog futures are trading at $56.00/cwt. He expects a local

basis of + $1/cwt. for the beginning of October. Therefore, his maximum purchase price from the call is: strike price of call ($60/cwt.), plus call

premium ($1/cwt.), plus basis of $ 1/cwt. = $62/cwt.

In the following two months the October futures price decreases to $50.00/cwt. With two months remaining until the hogs are ready for slaughter,

the hedger buys a futures contract. He could liquidate the call at this time if it had any value, but there is no risk and very little cost to just leaving it

in place. He now has a fixed price of: futures contract purchase, $50/cwt., plus call premium, $1/cwt., plus basis of $1/cwt. = $52/cwt., unless the

futures price rises above the call strike of $60/cwt., in which case his net realized price would drop favorably by $1 for each $1 the futures rises

above $60/cwt.

Page 41: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

39Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

At the beginning of October, when the hogs are ready for slaughter:

Without Follow-Up

A B C

If October Futures Are Cash Purchase Value of 60 Call 60 Call Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 72 $ 73 $ 12 $ 11 $ 62

66 67 6 5 62

60 61 0 -1 62

54 55 0 -1 56

48 49 0 -1 50

A-B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If October Cash Futures Value of *60 Call Net

Futures Are Purchase Gain/Loss 60 Call Gain/Loss Realized Price

$ 72 $ 73 $ 22 $ 12 $ 11 $ 40

66 67 16 6 5 46

60 61 10 0 -1 52

54 55 4 0 -1 52

48 49 -2 0 -1 52

A-B-C = D

* Assumes 60 call was retained because it had almost no value when the futures

were purchased @ $50/cwt., and there was no benefit to selling it at that time.

Page 42: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

40cme.com

9. Decreasing the Maximum Price - Purchasing Call Options as Prices Decrease

When a livestock hedger has purchased a call and the market price subsequently decreases, he may want to capture this new lower price level, again

without sacrificing protection against price increases. Follow-up Strategy #8 would be one alternative, but it would limit the possibility of an extreme

down-move in prices. As prices decrease, all call options would become less expensive. This means that any call would be offering a lower net ceiling

price if purchased then than if purchased before.

In this strategy a hedger would take advantage of the decline in call prices by buying a call with a lower strike price than the one he already has.

The new maximum price is the strike of the second call plus total premium paid out, plus or minus the basis.

Advantages

» Capitalize on market price decreases without limiting benefit of a further price decrease

» No performance bond liability

» Allow market time to move down without accepting limitless risk

Disadvantages

» More than one premium payout (though it may be possible to liquidate first call with some remaining value, when the second lower strike

call is purchased)

Liquidation

Sell back any calls that have value. Buy livestock in cash market.

Example

A producer purchases a November CME Feeder Cattle 104 call for $1/cwt. to set a ceiling on the price he will pay for calves going into his stocker

operation. The November CME Feeder Cattle futures contract is trading at $100/cwt. He expects a basis of +$5/cwt. in November. Therefore the 104

call is offering him an estimated maximum price of: call strike price ($104/cwt.), plus premium cost ($1/cwt), plus basis ($5/cwt.) = $110/cwt. One

month later, November futures are trading at $94/cwt. He purchases a November 96 call for $1/cwt. He can liquidate his 104 call if it has value or, if

it has no value, he may choose to leave it in place for double protection should the market go back up above 104. His new maximum price is call

strike ($96/cwt.), plus premium cost of $2/cwt. ($1 for 104 call + $1 for 96 call), plus basis ($5/cwt.) = $103/cwt.

Page 43: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

41Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

In November, when he is ready to acquire the calves:

Without Follow-Up

If November A B C

Futures Are Cash Purchase Value of 104 Call 104 Call Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 110 $ 115 $ 6 $ 5 $ 110

105 110 1 0 110

100 105 0 -1 106

95 100 0 -1 101

90 95 0 -1 96

A-B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If November Cash *104 Call Value of 96 Call Net

Futures Are Purchase Gain/Loss 96 Call Gain/Loss Realized Price

$ 110 $ 115 $ 5 $ 14 $ 13 $ 97

105 110 0 9 8 102

100 105 -1 4 3 103

95 100 -1 0 -1 102

90 95 -1 0 -1 97

A-B-C = D

* Assumes first call was retained, because it had practically no value and there

was no benefit to selling it at the time the second call was purchased.

Page 44: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

42cme.com

10. Cashing-In Maximum Price Protection – Purchasing Call Options as Prices Increase

When a livestock hedger has purchased a call and market prices later increase, he will see that his call has increased in value. He may want to cash

in the value of that call, without sacrificing protection against further livestock price increases before making cash purchases. He can do this by

selling the first call, then using a portion of the gain to purchase a higher strike price call after a substantial market increase. The final maximum

price equals the strike price of the last call purchased, plus its premium, minus the gain from the first call, adjusted for basis. This is similar in nature

to Follow-up Strategy # 7.

Advantages

» Allows hedger to collect a portion of his price insurance early if the market increases

» Lowers net realized price in cases when the market subsequently declines

Disadvantages

» Usually sacrifice a portion of the ceiling price because of second call purchase

Liquidation

Just like the straight call purchase strategy, the hedger would liquidate the remaining call if it has value or let the call expire if worthless, and

purchase cash livestock.

Example

A packer purchases a February CME Live Cattle 86 call for $1.50/cwt. The February CME Live Cattle futures contract is trading at $84/cwt. He expects

a basis in January of minus $2/cwt. Therefore, the 86 call is offering him an estimated maximum price of: call strike price ($86/cwt.), plus premium

cost ($1.50/cwt.), minus basis ($2/cwt.) = $85.50/cwt.

Two months later the February futures contract is trading at $92/ cwt. He sells the 86 call for $6/cwt. and purchases a February CME Live Cattle

92 call at $1.50/cwt. His new maximum purchase price is: strike price of second call ($92/cwt.), plus 92 call premium ($1.50/cwt.), minus gain from

86 call ($4.50/cwt.), minus basis ($2/cwt.) = $87.

Page 45: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

43Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

In February when the cattle are acquired for slaughter:

Without Follow-Up

A B C

If February Futures Are Cash Purchase Value of 86 Call 86 Call Gain/Loss Net Realized Price

$ 97 $ 95 $ 11 $ 9.50 $ 85.50

192 90 1 4.50 85.50

87 85 1 -.50 85.50

82 80 0 -1.50 81.50

77 75 0 -1.50 76.50

A-B = C

With Follow-Up

A B C D

If February Cash 86 Call Value of 92 Call Net

Futures Are Purchase Gain/Loss 92 Call Gain/Loss Realized Price

$ 97 $ 95 $ 4.50 $ 5 $ 3.50 $ 87

92 90 4.50 0 -1.50 87

87 85 4.50 0 -1.50 82

82 80 4.50 0 -1.50 78

77 75 4.50 0 -1.50 72

A-B-C = D

Page 46: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

44cme.com

Appropriate Futures Contract When hedging, this is the futures

contract that will expire when or just after the cash product is physically

ready for market. This is also the futures contract to use when figuring

that basis.

Assignment of Hedging Account The establishment of a first lien

by a lender who provides credit to a borrower for purposes of hedging

(performance bond money).

At-the-Money Option Call and put options are at-the-money when

the price of the underlying futures is the same as the strike price.

Basis (actual) The difference between the local cash price and the

“nearby” expiring futures contract.

Basis (estimated) An estimate of the normal difference between

the local cash market price and the futures market price, based on past

history. The basis is estimated for the specific time period when livestock

are going to be marketed.

Breakeven Cost An average amount for each unit of production

that pays a business operator a wage for his labor and interest on his

money invested.

Broker: A person paid a fee or commission for executing buy or sell

orders of a customer. In commodity futures trading, the term may

refer to: (1) floor broker: a person who actually executes orders on

the trading floor of an exchange; (2) account executive, associated

person, registered commodity representative or customer's man: the

person who deals with customers in the offices of futures commission

merchants (FCMs); and ( 3 ) futures commission merchants .

Buyer, Holder An individual who buys an option.

Call Option An exchange-traded contract that gives the purchaser

the right to buy the futures contract underlying the option at the stated

strike price prior to the expiration date of the option. A seller (writer)

has the obligation to sell the underlying futures contract at the strike

price, prior to expiration, if the buyer chooses to exercise the option.

Clearing House An adjunct to a futures exchange that settles

sales transactions executed on the floor of an exchange as well as

electronically matched trades, using a process of matching purchases.

A clearing organization is also charged with properly conducting

delivery procedures and guaranteeing the adequate financing of the

entire operation.

Cost of Delivery Basis The costs - transportation, yardage, inspection

fees - of delivering livestock that fulfill the contract specifications of a

CME futures contract to a CME-approved delivery point.

Exercise or Strike Price The price at which one may purchase or sell

the underlying futures contract upon the exercise of an option.

Expiration Date The last day an option may be offset or exercised.

Futures Commission Merchant (FCM) Individuals, associations,

partnerships, corporations and trusts that solicit or accept orders for

the purchase or sale of any commodity for future delivery on or subject

to the rules of any contract market, and that accept payment from, or

extend credit to, those whose orders are accepted.

Futures Contract A contract traded on a commodity futures exchange

for the purchase or sale of a standardized quantity and quality of a

financial instrument or physical commodity for later delivery.

Hedge A means of managing price or market risk by taking a position

in the futures market opposite to that held in the cash market.

Glossary

Page 47: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

45Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

In-the-Money Option An option that has intrinsic value. A call option

is in-the money when the price of the underlying futures contract is

above the strike price. A put option is in-the-money when the price of

the underlying futures contract is below the strike price.

Intrinsic Value The amount of money that could be realized by

exercising an option at its strike price. See “In-The-Money Option.”

Limit Order An order that must be executed at a specific price

or better.

Long One who has bought a futures contract and who has not yet

closed out his position by an offsetting sale or by taking delivery.

Also, one who has purchased and still holds an unexpired option.

Long Hedge The purchase of futures contracts as a temporary

substitute for the subsequent purchase of the actual cash commodity.

Maintenance Performance Bond A sum, usually smaller than – but

part of – an initial performance bond, which must be held on deposit at

all times. If a customer's equity falls below the futures maintenance

performance bond level, the broker must issue a “performance bond

call” for the amount of money required to restore the customer’s equity

in the account to the original, or initial, level.

Market Order An order to be executed immediately at the best

available price.

Market Risk The possibility of price decline for the owner of a

commodity or producer and the possibility of price increase for a

person who needs to purchase the commodity.

Offset a Hedge Sometimes called “liquidate” or “unwind.” This is a

process whereby a hedger both fulfills a cash transaction and cancels

a futures position. A short hedger would buy the previously sold futures

and sell his cash product. A long hedger would sell the previously

purchased futures and buy the cash product.

Out-of-the-Money Option An option that has no intrinsic value and

the premium paid is all time value. A call option is out-of-the-money

when the strike price is above the current price of the underlying futures

contract. A put option is out-of-the-money when the strike price is

below the current price of the underlying futures contract.

Performance Bond Funds that must be deposited with a broker

for each futures contract (and for each short options position) as a

guarantee of fulfillment of the contract. Also called a security deposit

or margin. (This is the Initial Performance Bond, the level to which the

account must be returned if a performance bond call is issued.)

Premium The market-determined cost of an option. The premium

is ultimately determined by the willingness of buyers to purchase the

option and sellers to sell the option at a particular price. Key factors

that affect this willingness are: strike price level relative to futures price

level, time remaining until expiration and market volatility.

Put Option An exchange-traded contract that gives the purchaser

the right to sell the futures contract underlying the option at the stated

strike price prior to the expiration date of the option. The seller has the

obligation to buy the underlying futures contract at the strike price prior

to expiration, if the buyer chooses to exercise.

Risk Preference Individuals may be risk-averse, risk-neutral or

risk-taking in their attitudes toward taking on business opportunities.

Futures and options permit the transfer of risk.

Page 48: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

46cme.com

Seller, Writer An individual who sells an option, either to offset a

previous purchase, or to initiate a short option position.

Short One who has sold a futures contract and who has not yet closed

out his position by an offsetting purchase or by delivery. Also, one who

has sold an option which is unexpired.

Short Hedge The sale of futures contracts as a temporary substitute

for the later sale of the cash commodity.

Speculate To assume a pre-existing market or business risk for the

opportunity of making a profit.

Stop Order An order that will become a market order when the

market reaches a designated price. Sell-stops are placed below the

current market and buy-stops are placed above the current market.

Time Value The amount of value an option has over and above its

intrinsic value.

Underlying Futures Contract The futures contract that may be

purchased or sold upon the exercise of the option.

Intrinsic Value The amount of money that could be realized by

exercising an option at its strike price. See “In-The-Money Option.”

Limit Order An order that must be executed at a specific price or better.

Long One who has bought a futures contract and who has not yet

closed out his position by an offsetting sale or by taking delivery.

Also, one who has purchased and still holds an unexpired option.

Long Hedge The purchase of futures contracts as a temporary

substitute for the subsequent purchase of the actual cash commodity.

Maintenance Performance Bond A sum, usually smaller than - but

part of - the initial performance bond, which must be held on deposit

at all times. If a customer’s equity falls below the futures maintenance

performance bond level, the broker must issue a “performance bond

call” for the amount of money required to restore the customer’s equity

in the account to the original, or initial, level.

Market Order An order to be executed immediately at the best

available price.

Market Risk The possibility of price decline for the owner of a

commodity or producer and the possibility of price increase for a person

who needs to purchase the commodity.

Offset the Hedge Sometimes called “liquidate” or “unwind.” This

is a process whereby the hedger both fulfills his cash transaction and

cancels his futures position. A short hedger would buy the previously

sold futures and sell his cash product. A long hedger would sell the

previously purchased futures and buy the cash product.

Out-of-the-Money Option An out-of-the money option has no

intrinsic value and the premium paid is all time value. A call option is

out-of-the-money when the strike price is above the current price of the

underlying futures contract. A put option is out-of-the-money when the

strike price is below the current price of the underlying futures contract.

Performance Bond Funds that must be deposited with the broker

for each futures contract (and for each short options position) as a

guarantee of fulfillment of the contract. Also called a security deposit

or margin. (This is the Initial Performance Bond, the level to which

the account must be returned if a performance bond call is issued.)

Glossary

Page 49: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

47Strategies for CME Livestock Futures and Options

Premium The market-determined cost of an option. The premium is

ultimately determined by the willingness of buyers to purchase the

option and sellers to sell the option at a particular price. Key factors

that affect this willingness are: strike price level relative to futures price

level, time remaining until expiration and market volatility.

Put Option An exchange-traded contract that gives the purchaser

the right to sell the futures contract underlying the option at the stated

strike price prior to the expiration date of the option. The seller has the

obligation to buy the underlying futures contract at the strike price prior

to expiration, if the buyer chooses to exercise.

Risk Preference An individual may be risk-averse, risk-neutral or

risk-taking in his attitude toward taking on business opportunities.

Futures and options permit the transfer of risk.

Seller, Writer An individual who sells an option, either to offset a

previous purchase, or to initiate a short option position.

Short One who has sold a futures contract and who has not yet closed

out his position by an offsetting purchase or by delivery. Also, one who

has sold an option which is unexpired.

Short Hedge The sale of futures contracts as a temporary substitute

for the later sale of the cash commodity.

Speculate To assume a pre-existing market or business risk for the

opportunity of making a profit.

Stop Order An order that will become a market order when the

market reaches a designated price. Sell-stops are placed below the

current market and buy-stops are placed above the current market.

Time Value The amount of value an option has over and above its

intrinsic value.

Underlying Futures Contract The futures contract that may be

purchased or sold upon the exercise of the option.

Page 50: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

48cme.com

Today’s greater need for risk management and hedging tools has required investors to become increasingly sophisticated about futures and options on

futures products. In light of growing global demand and expanding electronic accessibility, CME commodities are generating increased opportunities

for hedgers and speculators in these markets. With customers around the world; a diverse product line; deep, liquid markets; and strategic alliances

with other exchanges, CME is truly a global marketplace. Why not make it yours?

Electronically traded CME Livestock products:

• CME Live Cattle futures and options

• CME Feeder Cattle futures

• CME Lean Hog futures and options

• CME Frozen Pork Bellies futures

CME Livestock Trading Tools:

• Trading E-Livestock Options on CME Globex Demo: www.cme.com/elivestockoptionsdemo

• Free, real-time quotes: www.cme.com/elivestockquotes

• Daily Livestock Report: www.dailylivestockreport.com

• Historical data: www.cme.com/moorereports

For additional information about CME commodity products, please visit our Web site at www.cme.com/commodity. You will be able to access a

number of other brochures and marketing and education materials that can answer your questions or help you to begin trading these products.

For information on how the CME cash-settlement indexes are calculated contact the CME Commodity Marketing Department at 312.930.4597.

The indexes are also published online on our Web site. Additionally, if you would like to talk to a CME representative, please call our Customer Service

Line, 1.800.331.3332. Outside the U.S., please call 312.930.2316.

Getting Started in CME Livestock Products

Page 51: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

49

Futures trading is not suitable for all investors, and involves the risk of loss. Futures are a leveraged investment, and

because only a percentage of a contract’s value is required to trade, it is possible to lose more than the amount of money

deposited for a futures position. Therefore, traders should only use funds that they can afford to lose without affecting

their lifestyles. And only a portion of those funds should be devoted to any one trade because they cannot expect to

profit on every trade.

All references to options in this brochure refer to options on futures.

The Globe Logo, Globex®, CME®, CME Feeder Cattle Index™ and CME Lean Hog Index® are trademarks of CME. All other trademarks are the property

of their respective owners.

This brochure is intended as a discussion of the use of livestock futures. It was not prepared to meet the Commodity Futures Trading Commission

requirements for a disclosure statement about the risks of trading options on futures contracts. This statement must be furnished by your broker.

A broker can also provide additional information about futures and options, the important new opportunities they provide, and what role they can

play in your investment strategy.

The information within this brochure has been compiled by CME for general purposes only. CME assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions.

Additionally, all examples in this brochure are hypothetical situations, used for explanation purposes only, and should not be considered investment

advice or the results of actual market experience. All matters pertaining to rules and specifications herein are made subject to and are superseded by

official CME rules. Current CME rules should be consulted in all cases concerning contract specifications.

Copyright © 2007 CME

Page 52: StrategiesforCMELivestock FuturesandOptionsOptions.pdf4 cme.com 2.EstablishingaMinimumSellingPrice:BuyingPuts Buyingaputoptiongivesaproduceraminimumor“floor”pricewithoutlimitingtheopportunityofpriceincreases

AC020/500/01/07

IDEAS THAT CHANGE THE WORLDTM