Top Banner
STOP! WAIT A MINUTE Understanding the Consequences of Closing IPV Cases Too Early
44

STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Mar 27, 2022

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

STOP! WAIT A

MINUTEUnderstanding the Consequences of

Closing IPV Cases Too Early

Page 2: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 3: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Yupa is a RN with two children. Herhusband had a history of violenceand more than one restrainingorder. The court gave her husbandsole custody and gave her twohours of supervised visitation aweek.

What do you think influenced the court to make this decision?

Page 4: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

What does

research tell us?1

Page 5: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Why would

closing cases too

early increase

risk to children?

2

Page 6: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

What strategies

could we use?

3

Page 7: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 8: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

3 hrs

Page 9: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 10: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Significant overlap

Both forms of abuse occur in 30-60% of families

Page 11: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 12: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Continued risk

Leaving is the most dangerous time

Page 13: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 14: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Motivation to control increases

Page 15: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 16: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

More likely to seek sole custody

Frequently successful

Page 17: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 18: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Closed when immediate risk addressed

The children may still face the danger

Page 19: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Real PeopleReal Cases

Page 20: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 21: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

ACTION✓ Files for Divorce✓ Appoints GAL✓ Child Support✓ Supervised

Visitation✓ Court Ordered

Evaluation✓ Lawyer

$500.00$1,000+ $5,000$250/month$30/hr

$2,500

$5,000+25,000

Page 22: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 23: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

USE CHAT:

WHAT ARE YOUR

INITIAL REACTIONS TO

THIS CASE?

Page 24: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 25: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 26: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 27: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 28: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 29: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

“turned around cases”

Joyanna Silberg & Stephanie

Dallam (2019) Abusers gaining custody in

family courts: A case series of over turned

decisions, Journal of Child Custody, 16:2, 140-169, DOI: 10.1080/15379418.2019.1613204

Page 30: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Over 2,000 court cases

Greatest when mom claims child abuse

Meier, Joan S. and Dickson, Sean and O'Sullivan, Chris and Rosen, Leora and Hayes, Jeffrey, Child Custody Outcomes in Cases Involving Parental Alienation and Abuse Allegations (2019). GWU Law School Public Law Research Paper No. 2019-56; GWU Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2019-56. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3448062 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3448062

Page 31: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

USE CHAT TO LIST:

AT LEAST ONE TAKE

AWAY FROM THIS

RESEARCH

Page 32: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 33: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 34: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 35: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 36: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO

Play Video

Page 37: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 38: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 39: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 40: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 41: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO
Page 44: STOP! Wait a Minute - PCSAO