-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
1/746
Your Property. Our Priority.1745 W. Orangewood Avenue, Suite
110, Orange, CA 92868
Telephone (714) 634-9500 Fax: (714) 634-9507
www.HillmannConsulting.com
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENT
2450ROSEMEAD BOULEVARD
2559,2603,2610,2622,2630&2634CHICO AVENUE
2607,2629&2637HUMBERT AVENUE
SOUTH EL MONTE,CA91733
Prepared For:
Warmington Residential CA
3090 Pullman StreetCosta Mesa, CA 92626
August6, 2015
Hillmann Project No: C3-6341
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
2/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
3/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -i- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
.........................................................................................................................
11.1 Project Details Summary Table
....................................................................................................................
1
1.2 Findings Summary Table
.............................................................................................................................
2
1.3 General Description, Current and Historic Property Use
.............................................................................
3
1.4 Findings, Opinions, and Conclusions
...........................................................................................................
3
1.5
Recommendations
........................................................................................................................................
5
2.0 INTRODUCTION
........................................................................................................................................
72.1 Purpose and Scope
.......................................................................................................................................
7
2.2 Property Location/Legal Description
...........................................................................................................
9
2.3 Significant
Assumptions...............................................................................................................................
9
2.4 Limitations and Exceptions
..........................................................................................................................
9
2.5 Data Gaps
...................................................................................................................................................
10
2.6 Special Terms and Conditions
....................................................................................................................
10
3.0 USER PROVIDED INFORMATION
.....................................................................................................
123.1 Prior Reports and other Provided Documentation
......................................................................................
12
3.2 Title Records/Environmental Liens/Activity and Use
Limitations
............................................................ 12
3.3 Specialized Knowledge or Experience
.......................................................................................................
12
3.4
Commonly Known or Reasonably Ascertainable Information
...................................................................
123.5 Property Value Reduction due to Environmental Conditions
....................................................................
12
3.6 Reason for Performing Phase I ESA
..........................................................................................................
12
4.0 RECORDS REVIEW
.................................................................................................................................
134.1 Standard Environmental Record Sources
...................................................................................................
13
4.2 Additional Environmental Record Sources
................................................................................................
18
4.3 Physical Setting Sources
............................................................................................................................
19
4.4 Historical Use Property and Adjoining Properties
..................................................................................
19
5.0
SITE RECONNAISSANCE
.....................................................................................................................
235.1 Methodology and Limiting Conditions
......................................................................................................
23
5.2 General Site Setting
....................................................................................................................................
23
5.3 Interior & Exterior Observations
................................................................................................................
25
6.0
INTERVIEWS
............................................................................................................................................
28
6.1 Interviews with Past and Present Owners and Occupants
..........................................................................
28
6.2 Interviews with State and/or Local Government Officials
.........................................................................
28
7.0 NON-ASTM SCOPE CONCERNS
.........................................................................................................
297.1 Asbestos-Containing Material (ACM)
.......................................................................................................
29
7.2 Lead-Based
Paint........................................................................................................................................
29
7.3 Radon
.........................................................................................................................................................
29
7.4 Mold
...........................................................................................................................................................
29
7.5 Wetlands
.....................................................................................................................................................
29
8.0 ENVIRONMENTAL PROFESSIONAL STATEMENT
.....................................................................
31
9.0 REFERENCES
...........................................................................................................................................
32
10.0 APPENDICES
............................................................................................................................................
33Appendix A Site Diagram/Vicinity Map
Appendix B Site Photographs
Appendix C Questionnaires / User Provided InformationAppendix D
Historical Records Documentation
Appendix E Regulatory Records Documentation
Appendix F Other DocumentsAppendix G Project Personnel
Qualifications
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
4/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -ii- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
List of Abbreviations/Acronyms
Hillmann may use the following abbreviations and acronyms for
common terminology described in
our report. Not all abbreviations or acronyms may be applicable
to this report:
ACM Asbestos Containing Material
AST Aboveground Storage TankASTM American Standard for Testing
Materials
CERCLA Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and
Liability Act
CERCLIS Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and
Liability Information SystemCESQG Conditionally Exempt Small
Quantity Generator
CORRACTS Corrective Action Sites
CREC Controlled Recognized Environmental ConditionDNPL Delisted
National Priority List
DTSC Department of Toxic Substances Control
ENG EngineeringERNS Emergency Response Notification System
FOI Freedom of Information
FOIA Freedom of Information Act
FOIL Freedom of Information Letter
HVAC Heating Ventilation & Air ConditioningHREC Historic
Recognized Environmental Condition
IAQ Indoor Air Quality
INST Institutional
LBP Lead-Based PaintLQG Large Quantity Generator
LUST Leaking Underground Storage Tank
MSDS Material Safety Data SheetNFA No Further Action
NFRAP No Further Remedial Actions Planned
NPDES National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System
NPL National Priority List
RCRA Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
RCRIS Resource Conservation and Recovery Information SystemREC
Recognized Environmental Condition
RWQCB Regional Water Quality Control BoardSCAQMD South Coast Air
Quality Management District
SQG Small Quantity Generator
TSDF Treatment Storage and/or Disposal FacilityUSEPA United
States Environmental Protection Agency
UST Underground Storage Tank
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
5/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
6/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -2- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
1.2 Findings Summary Table
The following table summarizes the key findings of this
assessment. This table, alone, does not
constitute the complete assessment. The report must be reviewed
in its entirety.
Assessment Section No Sig.
Concern
Potential Env Concern REC Recommended
Follow-up
Rep.
Ref.
User Provided Info X 3.0
Data Gaps X 2.5
Regulatory Review
Regional groundwater/ soil
gas contamination within
San Gabriel ValleySuperfund site.
REC
Obtain future
monitoring results
as they becomeavailable
4.1
Historical ReviewProperty historically used as
a dry cleanerREC Phase II 4.4
Site UsePoor housekeeping within
the maintenance shop
REC Phase II 5.2
Adjoining Properties X4.1.25.2.8
Hazardous Materials X 5.3
Bulk Petroleum Storage X 5.3
PCBs X 5.3
Waste / Discharges X 5.3
Asbestos Containing
Materials (ACM)
Potential for ACM on
Property
Compliance with
regulations7.1
Lead Based Paint (LBP)Potential for LBP on
Property
Compliance with
regulations
7.2
Radon X 7.3
MoldVisible mold present on
ceiling of maintenance shop
Compliance with
regulations7.4
Wetlands X 7.5
NA = Not Applicable, TBD = To Be Determined, UNK = Unknown
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
7/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
8/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -4- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
The US ENG Controls listing indicates that groundwater is being
treated with the followingsystems: ion exchange, biological
treatment (NOS & Ex-situ), UV oxidation, air stripping,
flocculation, extraction, carbon adsorption, reverse osmosis,
natural attenuation, and monitoring.
The Consent and ROD listings provide no pertinent information.
The ICIS listing provides no
pertinent information. The FINDS listing indicates the site is
on the CERCLIS and ICISdatabases. The PRP listing provides more
than 400 parties that are potentially responsible for
contributing to the groundwater contamination.
San Gabriel Basin Groundwater Quality Management and Remediation
Plan, prepared by the
San Gabriel Basin Water Quality Authority and dated April 19,
2011. According to a map of the
South El Monte OU in Appendix G and updated in February of 2011,
the Property is locatedwithin an area of VOC contamination where
levels of contaminants are between the Maximum
Contaminant Level (MCL) and ten times (10x) the MCL. Considering
the Property will be
utilized for residential development, this VOC contamination is
considered to be a REC inconnection with the Property.
The adjoining properties were listed on several regulatory
databases including LUST and SLIC
cases located to the west and south, respectively. Both cases
received agency closure.
1.4.2 Non-ASTM Scope Considerations
Hillmann has also performed preliminary evaluations for ASTM
Non-Scope items, such as
asbestos-containing materials (ACM), lead-based paint, radon,
mold and wetlands. Our
observations and research did not identify any notable concerns,
except for the following:
Considering the dates of construction of the existing buildings,
asbestos containing materials(ACM) may be present at the Property.
Suspected ACM observed during a preliminary visual
screening included roofing materials, plaster walls, drywall,
acoustical ceiling, vinyl flooring,
cove base, adhesive, and stucco. It is possible that additional
quantities of suspect ACM mayexist in enclosed areas or areas not
accessed during the assessment. It is emphasized that this
limited screening does not constitute a comprehensive asbestos
survey of the premises and is
meant only to provide a preliminary evaluation regarding the
potential presence of ACM at the
Property.
Considering the dates of construction of the existing buildings,
lead-based paint may be present
at the Property. In general, interior painted surfaces within
the space were observed to be in faircondition to damaged
condition. It is emphasized that this limited screening does not
constitute a
comprehensive lead-based paint survey of the premises and is
meant only to provide a preliminary
evaluation regarding the potential presence of LBP at the
Property.
During the assessment, Hillmann conducted a preliminary
inspection of the accessed areas of the
building for evidence of excessive or amplified mold growth, or
for conditions favorable for
mold growth. The interior of the maintenance shop had excessive,
visible mold growth on thedrywall ceiling where an apparent breach
in the roof is located. No other obvious evidence of
excessive or amplified mold growth, or conditions favorable for
mold growth, was observed on
the Property during the site assessment.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
9/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -5- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
1.4.3 Significant Data Gaps
No data gaps that significantly impacted Hillmanns ability to
identify RECs in connection with
the Property have been identified.
1.4.4 Recognized Environmental Conditions
Hillmann has performed a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
in accordance with the scopeand limitations of ASTM Practice E
1527-13 of the Property as described in Section 2 of this
report. Any additions to, exceptions to, or deletions from this
practice are also described in
Section 2 of this report. This assessment has revealed no
evidence of recognized environmental
conditionsin connection with the Property, except for the
following:
Recognized Environmental Conditions (RECs):
The location of the Property within the San Gabriel Valley
Superfund site, specifically in anarea identified as having VOC
contamination between the MCL and 10x the MCL is
considered to be a REC.
The historic use of the Property as a dry cleaner at 2622 Chico
Avenue is considered to be a
REC.
The use of the maintenance shop for approximately 50 years with
evidence of poor
housekeeping is considered to be a REC in connection with the
Property.
Controlled Recognized Environmental Conditions (CRECs):
No evidence of any CRECs in connection with the Property was
identified.
Historical Recognized Environmental Conditions (HRECs):
No evidence of any HRECs in connection with the Property was
identified.
1.5 Recommendations
1.5.1 Recognized Environmental Conditions
Based on the findings of the Phase I Environmental Site
Assessment, Hillmann recommends that
the VOC contamination from the NPL site as well as the potential
for releases from the historic
dry cleaner and current maintenance shop at the Property be
assessed prior to the sitesredevelopment for residential use.
1.5.2 Non-ASTM Considerations
The following should be considered with regard to further
investigation or management of Non-ASTM considerations addressed by
this report:
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
10/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -6- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
Compliance with all applicable rules and regulations pertaining
to the presence of ACM,
lead based paint, and amplified microbial growth at the
Property.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
11/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -7- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
2.0 INTRODUCTION
2.1 Purpose and Scope
This assessment was conducted utilizing generally accepted Phase
I ESA industry standards in
accordance with the ASTM Standard Practice E 1527-13. The ASTM
describes these
methodologies as representing good commercial and customary
practice in the United States ofAmerica for conducting an
environmental site assessment of a parcel of commercial real
estate
with respect to the range of contaminants within the scope of
the Comprehensive Environmental
Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA) and petroleum
products. As such, this
practice is intended to permit a user to satisfy one of the
requirements to qualify for the innocentlandowner, contiguous
property owner or bona fide prospective purchaser limitations
on
CERCLA liability (hereinafter, the landowner liability
protections, or LLPs): that is, the
practice that constitutes all appropriate inquiries into the
previous ownership and uses theproperty consistent with good
commercial and customary practice as defined at 42 U.S.C.
9601(35) (B). The primary goal of the processes established by
ASTM E1527-13 is to identifyrecognized environmental conditionsin
connection with the Property.
The term recognized environmental condition (REC)is defined by
the ASTM as the presence or
likely presence of any hazardous substances or petroleum
products in, on or at a property: (1)due to a release to the
environment; (2) under conditions indicative of a release to
the
environment; or (3) under conditions that pose a material threat
of a future release to the
environment.
The ASTM has also defined the terms historical recognized
environmental conditions andcontrolled recognized environmental
conditions as two additional types of RECs. The termhistorical
recognized environmental condition (HREC) is defined as a past
release of any
hazardous substances or petroleum products that has occurred in
connection with the Property
and has been addressed to the satisfaction of the applicable
regulatory authority or meetingunrestricted use criteria
established by a regulatory authority, without subjecting the
Property to
any required controls (for example, property use restrictions,
activity and use limitations,
institutional controls or engineering controls).
The term controlled recognized environmental condition (CREC) is
defined as a recognized
environmental condition resulting from a past release of
hazardous substances or petroleumproducts that has been addressed
to the satisfaction of the applicable regulatory authority,
with
hazardous substances or petroleum products allowed to remain in
place subject to the
implementation of required controls.
Conditions determined to be de minimis conditions are not
considered to be RECs norCRECs. De minimis condition is defined by
the ASTM as a condition that generally does not
present a threat to human health or the environment and that
generally would not be the subjectof an enforcement action if
brought to the attention of appropriate governmental agencies.
The chief components of this assessment are described as
follows:
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
12/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -8- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
A non-invasive visual reconnaissance of the Property and
adjoining properties in accordance
with ASTM guidelines for evidence of RECs.
Interviews of past and present owners and occupants and state
and local government
officials, seeking information related to the potential presence
of RECs at the Property.
A review of standard physical record sources for available
topographic, geologic andgroundwater data.
Review of standard historic record sources, such as fire
insurance maps, city directories,
aerial photographs, prior reports and interviews, etc., to
determine prior uses of the Property
from the present, back to the Propertys first developed use, or
back to 1940, whichever isearlier.
Review of standard environmental record sources including
federal and state environmental
databases, and additional environmental record sources, to
identify potential regulatoryconcerns with the Property, adjoining
properties and properties located within the
surrounding area.
These methodologies are described as representing good
commercial and customary practice for
conducting an Environmental Site Assessment of a property for
the purpose of identifying
recognized environmental conditions.
2.1.1 Non-ASTM Scope Considerations
In accordance with our contract agreement, Hillmann may have
addressed the followingpotential environmental concerns that are
outside of the requirements of the ASTM E1527-13
standard:
Asbestos-Containing Materials (ACM): A preliminary visual
inspection for the presence of
suspect ACM within the accessed areas of buildings on the
Property.
Lead-Based Paint (LBP): A preliminary visual inspection of the
condition of painted surfaces in
the accessed areas of buildings on the Property.
USEPA Designated Radon Potential: Review of general non-site
specific data published by theUSEPA regarding the potential for
elevated indoor levels of radon gas to occur in the area of the
Property.
Mold: A preliminary visual inspection within the accessed areas
of buildings on the Property forevidence of systemic microbial
problems, including visible mold growth, water damaged
building materials or musty odors.
Wetlands: A preliminary review of data published by the US Fish
and Wildlife Service
regarding the presence or absence of mapped wetlands on the
Property. The US Fish andWildlife Service wetlands data is
typically provided to Hillmann by Environmental Data
Resources, Inc. (EDR).
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
13/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -9- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
2.2 Property Location/Legal Description
The Property is located at 2450 Rosemead Boulevard, 2559, 2603,
2610, 2622, 2634 & 2634
Chico Avenue, and 2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert Avenue, South El
Monte, California. The legal
designations of the Property are Assessors Parcel Numbers (APNs)
8102-037-020, 8102-037-021, 8102-037-001, 8102-035-017,
8102-029-025, 8102-029-007, 8102-029-006, 8102-029-005,
8102-029-026, 8102-029-019, and 8102-029-020. The Property is
located between RosemeadBoulevard and Humbolt Avenue (See Figure 2
for a site map). The latitude and longitude of theProperty is
approximately North 34.0583 degrees, and West 118.0614 degrees.
2.3 Significant Assumptions
The following significant assumptions are made:
Hillmann can neither warrant nor guarantee the accuracy or
completeness of the information
obtained from EDR during the course of this assessment.
Hillmann can neither warrant nor guarantee the accuracy or
completeness of information thatwas obtained from ostensibly
knowledgeable individuals, regulatory agency representativesor
other secondary sources.
Hillmann has assumed that the site operations at the time of the
site visit reflect typical site
conditions relative to potential environmental conditions and
that no concealment ofenvironmental conditions or releases by site
owners or occupants has occurred. Likewise,
Hillmann has also assumed that no areas of the Property with
potential environmental
concerns or RECs were concealed or otherwise not made known to
us, intentionally orunknowingly, by the Property owners/occupants
and/or site escort at the time of the site
visit.
For the purpose of estimating the approximate direction of
groundwater flow in the absenceof site specific groundwater data,
unless indicated otherwise, Hillmann has assumed that the
gradient of groundwater flow follows the surface topography of
the Property and immediate
surrounding area.
2.4 Limitations and Exceptions
2.4.1 Limiting Conditions
Hillmann was unaware of any significant limiting conditions at
the time of the assessment.
2.4.2 Other Exceptions or Deletions:
No exceptions or deletions from the ASTM Standard E 1527-13 are
reported.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
14/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -10- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
2.5 Data Gaps
A data gapis defined by the ASTM as a lack of or inability to
obtain information required by
this practice despite good faith efforts by the environmental
professional to gather such
information. A data gap is only significant if other information
and/or professional experienceraises reasonable concerns involving
the data gap and the ability to determine the presence or
absence of recognized environmental conditions.
Data Gap: Significant
(Yes/No)?
Discussion
Response to agency records
requests not received as of date
of report.
No Any additional information indicative of a REC will be
forwarded upon receipt.
2.6 Special Terms and Conditions
Hillmann has prepared this Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
using reasonable efforts in
each phase of its work to identify recognized environmental
conditions associated with
hazardous substances, wastes and petroleum products at the
Property. The methodology of thisPhase I Environmental Site
Assessment was consistent with the ASTM Standard Practice for E
1527-13. Findings within this report are based on information
collected from observations made
on the day of the site visit and from reasonably ascertainable
information obtained from
governing public agencies and private sources.
This report is not definitive and should not be assumed to be a
complete or specific definition of
the conditions above or below grade. Information in this report
is not intended to be used as aconstruction document and should not
be used for demolition, renovation or other construction
purposes. Hillmann makes no representation or warranty that the
past or current operations at
the Property are, or have been, in compliance with all
applicable federal, state and local laws,
regulations and codes.
Findings, conclusions and recommendations presented in this
report are based on our visual
observations of the Property, the research findings reasonably
obtained, information provided bythe Client, and/or a review of
readily available and supplied drawings and documents. Hillmann
relies completely on the information, whether written, graphic
or verbal, provided by the subject
Property contact(s) or as shown on any documents reviewed or
received from the subjectProperty contact, owner or agent, or
municipal source, and assumes that information to be true
and correct. Although there may have been some degree of overlap
in the information provided
by these various sources, Hillmann did not attempt to
independently verify the accuracy orcompleteness of all information
reviewed or received during the course of this assessment.
Regardless of the findings stated in this report, Hillmann is
not responsible for consequences or
conditions arising from facts that were concealed, withheld or
not fully disclosed at the time theassessment was conducted.
This report does not warrant against future operations or
conditions, nor does it warrant againstoperations or conditions
present of a type or at a location not investigated.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
15/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -11- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
The regulatory database report provided is based on an
evaluation of the data collected andcompiled by a contracted data
research company. The report focuses on the Property and
neighboring properties that could impact the Property.
Neighboring properties listed in
governmental environmental records are identified within
specific search distances. The search
distance varies depending upon the particular government record
being checked. The regulatoryresearch is designed to meet the
requirements of ASTM Standard E 1527-13. The information
provided in the regulatory database report is assumed to be
correct and complete.
Subsurface conditions may differ from the conditions implied by
the surface observations and
can only be reliably evaluated through intrusive techniques.
Reasonable efforts have been made during this assessment to
identify aboveground and
underground storage tanks and ancillary equipment. Reasonable
efforts are limited to
information gained from visual observation of largely
unobstructed areas, recorded databaseinformation held in public
record and available information gathered from interviews. Such
methods may not identify subsurface equipment that may have been
hidden from view due to
parked automobiles and other vehicles, snow cover, vegetative
growth, pavement, construction
or debris pile storage or incorrect information from
sources.
Unless otherwise specified in Section 2.1 of this report, an
ASTM Vapor Encroachment
Screening of the Property utilizing the information collected
during the course of thisassessment is excluded from the scope of
service for this assessment.
Hillmann is not a professional title insurance firm and makes no
guarantee, explicit or implied,that the records which were reviewed
represent a comprehensive or precise delineation of past
Property ownership or tenancy for legal purposes.
In the event of any conflict between the terms and conditions of
this report and the terms and
conditions of the consulting services agreement between
Warmington Residential CA andHillman Consulting, the consulting
services agreement shall control.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
16/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -12- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
3.0 USER PROVIDED INFORMATION
3.1 Prior Environmental Reports/Documentation
No previous environmental reports or documentation was provided
to Hillmann.
3.2 Title Records/Environmental Liens/Activity and Use
Limitations
Review of title records is not included in the scope of work for
this assessment project. No
information regarding environmental liens or activity and use
limitations was provided to
Hillmann by the Client.
3.3 Specialized Knowledge or Experience
No indication of any specialized knowledge or experience
regarding the Property was reported
to Hillmann by the Client.
3.4 Commonly Known or Reasonably Ascertainable Information
No commonly known or specialized knowledge of the Property was
reported to Hillmann by the
Client.
3.5 Property Value Reduction due to Environmental Conditions
No information was provided by the Client to Hillmann regarding
a reduction of the Property
value due to environmental problems or conditions.
3.6 Reason for Performing Phase I ESA
It is Hillmanns understanding that the Phase I ESA was being
performed in consideration of a
pending real estate transaction involving the Property.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
17/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -13- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
4.0 RECORDS REVIEW
4.1 Standard Environmental Record Sources
An EDR Radius Map report was obtained from Environmental Data
Resources of Shelton, CT.
The EDR Radius Map Report provided a search of standard
environmental record sources in
general accordance with the requirements of the ASTM E1527-13.
Hillmann has reviewed theEDR Radius Map report and a summary of
findings is presented in the following tables and
report sections. Hillmann also reviewed the list of unmapped
sites (referred to by EDR as
Orphan List sites). Unmapped sites identified as falling within
an applicable specific search
distance or warranting discussion in the report, if any, have
been included in the informationpresented below. Detailed
descriptions of the meaning and significance of the regulatory
databases can be found in the EDR Radius Map Report in Appendix
E.
Regulatory DatabaseSearch
Distance
Property
Listed?
Adj.
Properties
Listed?
Total Listings
Within Search
Distance
Fed. NPL/Proposed NPL 1-mile No No 1Fed. Delisted NPL -mile No
No 0
Fed. CERCLIS -mile No No 1
Fed. CERC-NFRAP -mile No No 2
Fed. RCRA CORRACTS 1-mile No No 0
Fed. RCRA TSD -mile No No 1
Fed. RCRA LQG Site & Adj. No No
Fed. RCRA SQG Site & Adj. No Yes
Fed. RCRA CESQG Site & Adj. No No
Fed. ENG Control List Site Yes
Fed. INST Control List Site No
Fed. ERNS Site No
State/Tribal Hazardous Waste Site 1-mile No No 14
State/Tribal Landfill/Solid Waste -mile No No 2State/Tribal
Leaking Storage Tanks -mile No Yes 66
State/Tribal Registered Storage Tanks Site & Adj. No No
State/Tribal Eng. Control List Site No
State/Tribal Inst. Control List Site No
State/Tribal Voluntary Cleanup Sites -mile No No 0
State/Tribal Brownfields -mile No No 0
Supplemental Databases Site & Adj. Yes Yes
4.1.1 Property Listings
The Property is located within the boundaries of a National
Priorities List (NPL) site named theSan Gabriel Valley (Area 1) as
part of the South El Monte Operable Unit (OU). The following
listings were identified for the site:
AOC, NPL, CERCLIS, US ENG Controls, Consent, ROD, ICIS, FINDS,
PRP San Gabriel
Valley (Area 1), Peck Roack & Real: The AOC listing only
indicates that VOC contamination is
at or above the MCL as regulated by region 9 of the EPA. The NPL
listing indicates thatgroundwater is approximately 100 feet bgs and
is contaminated with chloroform, TCE and PCE.
The listing provides a description of the site conditions from
September of 1983 that indicates
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
18/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -14- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
groundwater is contaminated with TCE, PCE and carbon
tetrachloride which affectsapproximately 200,000 people. In 1984
the EPA installed water treatment systems to water
companies who had no alternate supply of water other than the
contaminated groundwater. The
listing has a status of Final with a status date of 05/08/1984.
The CERCLIS listing indicates the
site is on the Final NPL. The listing discusses the details of
various OUs within San GabrielValley Area 1. The details about the
South El Monte OU indicate that shallow and intermediate
groundwater aquifers were contaminated with PCE TCE,
1,4-dioxane, n-nitrosodimethylamine(NDMA), and hexavalent chromium.
It also indicates that the shallow aquifer has the
mostcontamination, as high as hundreds of times the drinking water
standard. The South El Monte
OU Interim Record of Decision plans to prevent exposure of the
public to VOC contaminated
groundwater, limit the movement of contaminated groundwater,
reduce the impact ofcontaminant migration to downgradient wells,
and protect uncontaminated areas. The majority
of the shallow and intermediate contaminated groundwater from
the South El Monte OU will
flow into the Whittier Narrows OU (WNOU) which will be captured
by the groundwaterremedies in place there. The groundwater is being
treated via a pump and treat system using
carbon adsorption.
The US ENG Controls listing indicates that groundwater is being
treated with the followingsystems: ion exchange, biological
treatment (NOS & Ex-situ), UV oxidation, air stripping,
flocculation, extraction, carbon adsorption, reverse osmosis,
natural attenuation, and monitoring.
The Consent, ROD, and ICIS listings provide no pertinent
information. The FINDS listingindicates the site is on the CERCLIS
and ICIS databases. The PRP listing provides more than
400 parties that are potentially responsible for contributing to
the groundwater contamination.
The location of the Property within the South El Monte OU region
of the San Gabriel Valleysuperfund is considered to be a REC.
The Propertys address was identified on the following
databases:
EDR Historical Cleaners, HIST UST, WIP Brite-Way Laundry, 2622
Chico Avenue: TheEDR Historical Cleaners listing indicates that
Brite-Way Laundry was present in 1999. The
HIST UST listing indicates the site had a UST of an unreported
capacity which stored waste.
The WIP listing indicates a file staff of Historical. The
historic use of the Property as a dry
cleaning facility is considered to be a REC in connection with
the Property.
4.1.2 Adjoining Property Listings
The adjoining properties were identified on the following
databases:
SLIC, WIP General Enameling Company, 2463 Chico Avenue,
adjoining to the south, higher
relative elevation: The SLIC listing indicates that groundwater
was affected. The listingindicates a status of Completed Case
Closed with a status date of 03/12/2015. The WIP
listing indicates a file status of Historical. A second WIP
listing indicates a facility status of
Active. Considering the status, this site is not considered to
be a REC in connection with theProperty.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
19/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -15- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
Drycleaners, WIP Eldon Drapery Cleaners, 2461 Chico Avenue,
adjoining to the south, higherrelative elevation the Drycleaners
listing indicates that a drycleaning operation was present at
the site and became inactive on 06/30/2002. The WIP listings
both have file statuses of
Historical. Considering a lack of reported spills or releases,
this site is not considered to be a
REC in connection with the Property.
HIST CORTESE, LUST Champ Corp., 2500 Rosemead Boulevard N.,
adjoining to the west,lower relative elevation: The HIST CORTESE
listing provides no pertinent information. TheLUST listing
indicates that gasoline contaminated soil at the site. The listing
has a status of
Completed Case Closed with a status date of 06/18/1996.
Considering the case status, this
site is not considered to be a REC in connection with the
Property.
HIST UST, SWEEPS UST, Los Angeles Co. HMS, WIP Sunset Ladder
Co., 2526 Rosemead
Boulevard, adjoining to the northwest, lower relative elevation:
The listing indicates that the siteformerly had one UST with a
capacity of 9,970 gallons storing regular product. The SWEEPS
UST listing provides no pertinent information. The Los Angeles
Co. HMS listing indicates a
facility status of Removed. The WIP listing indicates a file
status of Historical. Considering
a lack of reported spills or releases, this site is not
considered to be a REC In connection withthe Property.
NPDES, WIP, WDS Alloys Nonferrous Foundry Inc., 2532 Chico
Avenue, adjoining to theeast, higher relative elevation: The NPDES
listing indicates a status of Terminated with a
status date of 10/14/2010. The Primary SIC for the site is for
Aluminum Foundries. The WIP
listing indicates status of Historical. The WDS listing has a
status of Active and indicatesthe site is considered a minor threat
to water quality.
RCRA-SQG, FINDS AMC Forklift Generator Starter Co., 2504 Chico
Avenue, adjoining to
the east, higher relative elevation: The RCRA-SQG listing
indicates no violations found. The
FINDS listing indicates the site is registered on the RCRA
program. Considering a lack ofreported spills or releases, this
site is not considered to be a REC in connection with the
Property.
RCRA-SQG, FINDS Trio Carburetor, 2545 Rosemead Boulevard,
adjoining to the west, lowerrelative elevation: The RCRA-SQG
listing indicates no violations found. The FINDS listing
indicates that the site is registered on the RCRA program.
Considering a lack of reported spills
or releases, this site is not considered to be a REC in
connection with the Property.
Numerous supplemental database listings from the EDR Historical
Auto Stations and WIP (Well
Investigation Program) databases were identified as being
adjoining to the east, west, and south
of the Property. None of the sites were identified on additional
databases unless discussedabove. All of the WIP listings have
statuses of Historical or Not Reported. Considering a lack of
reported spills or releases from these sites, these supplemental
listings are not considered to be a
REC in connection with the Property.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
20/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -16- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
4.1.3 ASTM Search Distance Findings
The following is a summary of the findings of the regulatory
database review with regard to
sites identified as located within the ASTM specified search
distance surrounding the Property.
In order to keep this report informative and yet concise,
Hillmann has provided a briefdiscussion of the listed site(s) for
each database category that appears most likely to impact the
Property based on distance, topography and/or case status. A
copy of the full EDR Radius MapReport, including available details
of all listed sites, is included in Appendix E.
Note that listings for the following databases, if identified,
would be discussed above in Sections
4.1.1 and 4.1.2: Registered Storage Tanks, Federal RCRA
Generators, Federal and State INSTand ENG Controls, ERNS.)
Federal NPL: One (1) NPL listing was identified within a
one-mile radius of the Property. Thelisting was identified as
affecting the Property and is discussed in Section 4.1.1.
Federal Delisted NPL: No DNPL listings were identified within a
-mile radius of the
Property.
Federal CERCLIS: One (1) CERCLIS listing was identified within a
-mile radius of the
Property. The listing was identified as affecting the Property
and is discussed in Section 4.1.1.
Federal CERCLIS-NFRAP: Two (2) CERC-NFRAP listings were
identified within a -mile
radius of the Property. The closest listing is described as
Alum-A-Coat Inc. at 9859 Kale Street.This site is approximately
1,813 feet east-southeast and at a higher elevation relative to
the
Property. The listing indicates that the site does not qualify
for the NPL and was archived on02/01/1985. Considering the status
and distance, this site is not considered to be a REC in
connection with the Property.
Federal RCRA-CORRACTS: No CORRACTS listings were identified
within a one-mile
radius of the Property.
Federal RCRA-TSD: One (1) TSD listing was identified within a
-mile radius of theProperty. The listing is described as Paragon
Press at 9323 Rush Street. This site is
approximately 2,337 feet south-southwest and at a lower
elevation relative to the Property. The
listing indicates that the site was historically a hazardous
waste treatment storage or disposalfacility and that the site
received various violations. All violations appear to have
achieved
compliance. Considering the distance and topographical relation
to the Property, this site is not
considered to be a REC in connection with the Property.
State/Tribal Hazardous Waste Sites: Twelve (12) SHWS listings
were identified within a one-
mile radius of the Property on the EnviroStar database. The
closest listing is described as Vaga
Industries at 2505 Loma Avenue. This site is approximately 1,549
feet to the west and at a lowerelevation relative to the Property.
The listing indicates no specified contaminants of concern or
media affected. The listing has a status of Refer: Other Agency.
Considering the distance and
status, this site is not considered to be a REC in connection
with the Property.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
21/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -17- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
Two (2) SHWS listings were identified within a one-mile radius
of the Property on theRESPONSE database. The closer listing is
described as El Monte Disposal Service at Storage
Yard and Maple Canyon. This site is approximately 2,919 feet
southeast and at a higher
elevation relative to the Property. The listing indicates no
confirmed contaminants within
sediments, soil or soil vapor. The listing has a status of
Certified with a status date of01/01/1983. Considering the status,
this site is not considered to be a REC in connection with
the Property.
State/Tribal Landfill/Solid Waste Disposal Sites: Two (2) SWF/LF
listing was identified
within a -mile radius of the Property. Both listings appear to
be for the same site named
Caltrans Rosemead Disposal Site and Caltrans Rosemead DS at 3000
Rosemead Boulevardand NE Corner of Rosemead Boulevard and Garvey
Avenue, respectively. This site is
approximately 1,577 feet northwest and at a higher elevation
relative to the Property. The listing
described as Caltrans Rosemead Disposal Site indicates that the
site accepted inert waste andcurrently has a status of Closed. It
also indicates that the site is currently used for commercial
and residential purposes. The listing described as Caltrans
Rosemead DS indicates that the site
was estimated to have closed on 12/31/1977. Considering a lack
of reported spills or releases,
this site is not considered to be a REC in connection with the
Property.
State/Tribal leaking Storage Tanks: Twenty-six (26) LUST
listings were identified within a
-mile radius of the Property. The closest listing was identified
as being adjoining to theProperty and is discussed in Section
4.1.2. The next closest listing is described as EC
Construction Co. at 2213 Chico Avenue. This site is
approximately 1,077 feet to the south-
southeast and at a lower elevation relative to the Property. The
listing indicates that gasolinecontaminated soil at the site. The
listing has a status of Open Site Assessment with a status
date of 01/20/2009. The online GeoTracker listing has a status
of Open Inactive as of05/15/2015. Considering the distance and
status, this site is not considered to be a REC in
connection with the Property.
Forty (40) SLIC listings were identified within a -mile radius
of the Property. The closest
listing was identified as being adjoining to the Property and is
discussed in Section 4.1.2. The
next closest listing is described as American General Business
Syst at 2340 Chico Avenue. This
site is approximately 105 feet southeast and at a higher
elevation relative to the Property. Thelisting indicates that an
aquifer is potentially contaminated from the site. The listing has
a status
of Open Inactive with a status date of 10/29/2014. Considering
the status, this site is not
considered to be a REC in connection with the Property.
State/Tribal Voluntary Cleanup Sites:No VCP listings were
identified within a -mile radius
of the Property.
State/Tribal Brownfields:No BROWNFIELDS listings were identified
within a -mile radius
of the Property.
Review of the sites identified within the ASTM search parameters
did not identify any nearby or
surrounding area sites that are considered to be a REC in
connection with the Property, unless as
discussed otherwise previously in this section.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
22/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -18- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
4.2 Additional Environmental Record Sources
4.2.1 Supplemental Database Listings
Hillmann reviewed the EDR Radius Map report for listings on
supplemental databases that weresearched in addition to the
Standard Environmental Record Sources. Any property or
adjoining
property listings on such databases, if identified, would be
discussed in Section 4.1.1 and 4.1.2.None of the other supplemental
database listings identified by the EDR Radius Map report
areconsidered to be a REC in connection with the Property.
4.2.2 Local Agency & Internet Research
Hillmann performed a search of available local and municipal
agencies for pertinent information
pertaining to the Property, particularly with regard to
potential environmental concerns such aspetroleum storage tanks,
storage and usage of hazardous substances and petroleum
products,
and/or known or suspected environmental contamination. Hillmann
also conducted a cursory
internet search of the Property address for information
indicative of a REC. The following table
summarizes the findings of the research:
Source:Inquiry
Made?Type: Outcome:
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) YesFOIA
Request
Response indicated no records found.
Los Angeles County Fire Department
(CUPA)Yes
FOIA
Request
Response not received prior to report
completion.
Department of Toxic Substances Control
(DTSC)Yes
FOIA
Request
Response not received prior to report
completion.
Regional Water Quality Control Board
(RWQCB) Los Angeles Region (4)Yes
FOIA
Request
Response not received prior to report
completion.
County of Los Angeles, Department of
Public Health YesFOIA
Request
Response not received prior to report
completion.
Los Angeles County Department of
Public Works Online databaseYes
FOIA
Request
Hillmann performed an online search
for records. One result for a permit for
Brite-Way Laundry at 2622 ChicoAvenue was identified. The
listing
indicates the site had an industrial
waste permit which is currently closed.
No other information was available.
South Coast Air Quality Management
District (SCAQMD)Yes
FOIA
Request
Response received indicated the
request has been assigned for
processing.
Los Angeles County GeographicalInformation System (GIS)
YesOn-linesearch
No information indicative of a RECwas identified.
CA DTSC EnviroStor
databasehttp://www.envirostor.dtsc.ca.gov/public/
Yes InternetThe Property address was searched. Noresults for the
Property were found.
CA GeoTracker databasehttp://geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/
Yes InternetThe Property address was searched. Noresults for the
Property were found.
USEPA Envirofacts searchhttp://www.epa.gov/enviro/index.html
Yes Internet
The Property address was searched. No
results for the Property were found.Adjoining to the north,
Buerge
Volkswagen is listed as a small
generator of hazardous wastes. The
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
23/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -19- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
facility does not represent an
environmental concern.
www.google.com YesOn-line
search
The Property address search returns
results as a swap meet.
Other: NA
Hillmann obtained the following document from the EPAs superfund
website which details the
remedial activities of superfund sites:
San Gabriel Basin Groundwater Quality Management and Remediation
Plan, prepared by the
San Gabriel Basin Water Quality Authority and dated April 19,
2011. According to a map of the
South El Monte OU in Appendix G and updated in February of 2011,
the Property is locatedwithin an area of VOC contamination where
levels of contaminants are between the Maximum
Contaminant Level (MCL) and ten times (10x) the MCL. Considering
the Property will be
utilized for residential development, this VOC contamination is
considered to be a REC inconnection with the Property.
4.3 Physical Setting Sources
4.3.1 USGS 7.5 Minute Topographic Map
The USGS 7.5 minute series topographic maps covering the
Property (El Monte, CA 1994) werereviewed. The maps indicated an
approximate elevation at the Property of 244 feet above mean
sea level. The topography indicated by the map appeared to be
sloping downward to the west-
southwest. The closest down gradient body of water appeared to
be a Rio Hondo, approximately2,050 feet to the west.
4.3.2 Soils
Based on USDA Soil Conservation Service (SCS) data summarized by
the EDR Geocheck-
Physical Setting Source Addendum, the soil type at the Property
is classified as Urban Land.
The Urban Land designation indicates that a majority of the
original soils on the site have beendisturbed by developed or
covered with impervious surfaces, such as buildings or
pavement.
4.3.3 Geology
Based on geologic data summarized by the EDR Geocheck - Physical
Setting SourceAddendum, the geologic formation in the vicinity of
the Property is described as a stratified
sequence of the Cenozoic Era, Quaternary System, Quaternary
Series.
4.3.4 Hydrology
No site specific hydro-geologic data was available for the
Property.
4.4 Historical Use Property and Adjoining Properties
Hillmann has conducted research in order to help identify the
likelihood of past uses having ledto recognized environmental
conditions in connection with the Property. Standard historical
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
24/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -20- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
sources have been sought in an attempt to document the past uses
of the Property as far back asit can be shown that the Property
contained structures; or from the time the Property was first
used for residential, agricultural, commercial, industrial or
governmental purposes.
4.4.1 Fire Insurance Maps
A search of Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps for the Property and
surrounding area was conductedby Environmental Data Resources, Inc.
(EDR) of Shelton, Connecticut. EDR provided aSanborn report stating
fire insurance maps covering the Property were not found.
4.4.2 City Directories
Hillman obtained an EDR City Directory Abstract report to obtain
data of historic city directory
listings for the Property. The following is a generalized
summary of the findings of CityDirectory Research:
YEAR(S) SUMMARY
1950 - 2013
Property: The Property is listed with a variety of owners and
businesses including MasterDesign Sofa Inc., Bratcher Ford,
Brite-Way Laundry, Starlite Drive in Theatre, andStarlite Swap
Meet.
Adjacent
Properties:
The adjoining properties are listed with numerous businesses
including California
Shell Co. Caskets, Hooter Bros. Enameling, Buchanan Co Sheet
Metal, restaurants,German A Printing, and automotive repair
shops.
4.4.3 Historical Topographic Map Review
Hillmann obtained and reviewed an EDR Historical Topographic Map
Report from EDR
containing historic aerial photography of the Property and
adjoining properties. The followinginterpretation of land usage was
made by review of the maps:
YEAR(S) DESCRIPTION
1896, 1900,1901
Property The scale of the map is too large to discern specific
details about the
Property.
Adjacent
Properties
The scale of the map is too large to discern specific details
about theadjacent properties, however the area of the Property
appears to be
generally undeveloped.
1953
Property The Property is depicted with a drive-in theater and is
shaded to denote
general urban development.
Adjacent
Properties
The adjoining properties are generally shaded to denote
urban
development. One adjoining property to the east is depicted as
Potrero
School.
1966, 1972,
1981, 1994
Property The Property is depicted with a drive-in theater with
several structures and
is shaded to denote general urban development.Adjacent
Properties
The adjoining properties are generally shaded to denote
urban
development. The adjoining properties to the north are depicted
with large
structures. One adjoining property to the east is depicted as
Potrero School.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
25/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -21- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
4.4.4 Aerial Photograph Review
Hillmann obtained and reviewed an EDR Aerial Photo Decade
Package Report from EDR
containing historic aerial photography of the Property and
adjoining properties. In addition,
Hillmann reviewed historic aerial photographs of the Property
online atwww.historicaerials.com. The following interpretation of
land usage was made by review of the
aerial photographs:
YEAR(S) DESCRIPTION
1928
Property The Property appears to be developed with agricultural
land and associated
structures.
Adjacent
Properties
The adjoining properties appear to be agricultural land.
1938
Property The Property appears to be developed with a commercial
structure towards
the west, and a parking lot towards the east.
Adjacent
Properties
The adjoining properties to the north appear with commercial
buildings and
residences. The adjoining property to the west appears as
undeveloped landand a small outbuilding. The adjoining properties
to the south appear as
undeveloped land and a warehouse. The eastern adjoining
properties appearas undeveloped land.
1938
Property The Property appears to be developed with a dairy,
single family homes,
and agricultural land.
Adjacent
Properties
The adjoining properties appear to consist of single family
homes,
orchards, and agricultural land.
1948
Property The Property appears to be developed with a dairy,
single family homes,
and agricultural land.
Adjacent
Properties
The adjoining properties appear to consist of single family
homes,
agricultural land, and industrial buildings to the east.
1952, 1953,
1964
Property The Property appears to be developed with a drive-in
theater with several
associated buildings, parking lots, and residences. The
northeast portion of
the Property appears to be developed with residences.
AdjacentProperties
The northern adjoining properties appear to consist of
industrial businesses,single family homes, and a school.
1972
Property The Property appears to be developed with a drive-in
theater, several
associated buildings, parking lots, residences, a commercial
business withtwo structures, and undeveloped land.
Adjacent
Properties
The northern adjoining properties appear to consist of
industrial businesses,single family homes, and a school.
1977, 1980,
1983, 1989,
1994
Property The Property appears to be developed with a drive-in
theater, several
associated buildings, parking lots, residences, and a commercial
businesswith two structures.
Adjacent
Properties
The northern adjoining properties appear to consist of
industrial businesses,single family homes, and a school.
2002, 2003,
2004, 2005,2009, 2010,
2012
Property The Property appears to be developed with a large
parking lot, several
associated buildings, a residence, and a commercial business
with twostructures.
Adjacent
Properties
The northern adjoining properties appear to consist of
industrial businesses,
single family homes, and a school.
4.4.5 Petroleum/Natural Gas Well Review
Hillmann reviewed historical record sources for evidence of
historic petroleum and/or natural
gas wells at the Property. In addition, Hillmann conducted a
search of the property location on
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
26/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -22- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
the Division of Oil, Gas & Geothermal Resources Well Finder
database(http://maps.conservation.ca.gov/doggr/index.html).No
record of any historical petroleum/natural
gas wells at the Property was identified.
4.4.6 Historical Records Data Failure
Historic land use data prior to 1896 was not readily available
at the time of the assessment. TheProperty was determined by this
assessment to have been first used as agricultural land datingback
to at least 1928. It is Hillmanns opinion that no significant data
gaps were encountered.
4.4.7 Summary of Historic Use Research
The Property appears to have first been used as agricultural
land dating back to 1928. By 1938 a
dairy appeared to have been developed on the western portion of
the Property, and residenceswere developed on the eastern portion.
By 1952 the western portion of the Property was
redeveloped with a drive-in theater. By 1972 the eastern portion
of the Property was
redeveloped with two commercial structures and two large parking
lots. By 1989 two of the
three residences at the Property were demolished. By 2002 the
screen of the drive-in theaterwas removed.
The adjoining properties appear to have been historically used
as agricultural land dating back toat least 1928. By 1938 the
adjoining properties to the west and northeast were developed
with
residences, and a school was developed to the east. By 1948
additional residences were
developed to the north and industrial structures were developed
to the east. Industrialdevelopment to the north and south continued
in 1952 and 1953, and it continued to the west in
the 1970s. The adjoining properties appear to retain the mixed
residential and industrial use.
The historical use of the Property by Brite-Way Cleaners, a dry
cleaning operation, at the 2622
Chico Avenue address is considered to be a REC in connection
with the Property. Additionally,the long term use of the adjoining
properties for various industrial uses including automotive
repair should be considered during the Propertys redevelopment
for residential uses. Further,
the location of the Property within the South El Monte OU region
of the San Gabriel Valley
(Area 1) NPL site is considered to be a REC.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
27/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -23- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
5.0 SITE RECONNAISSANCE
5.1 Methodology and Limiting Conditions
The site reconnaissance consisted of visual and/or physical
observations of the Property and
improvements, adjoining properties as viewed from the Property
boundaries and the surrounding
area based on visual observations from adjacent public
thoroughfares. Building exteriors wereobserved at ground level,
unless otherwise indicated. Where applicable, Hillmann accessed
and
observed representative areas of building interiors to the
extent they were made safely accessible
with the cooperation of the site escort.
The site reconnaissance was conducted by Mr. Gregory Shaffer on
July 31, 2015. Weather
conditions at the time of the assessment included a temperature
of approximately 83 degrees F and
clear skies. Hillmann was escorted by Mr. Jenghong Benson Li,
the Propertys manager.
5.1.1 Significant Inaccessible Areas
The parking lots at the northeastern portion of the Property
were fenced and locked at the timeof the site assessment. Hillmann
was only able to photograph the parking lots through a chain-
link fence. No other areas were excluded from Hillmanns visual
inspection.
5.2 General Site Setting
5.2.1 Site and Vicinity Characteristics
The Property consists of eleven parcels, ten of which are
rectangular. The parcels are locatedbetween Rosemead Boulevard and
Humbolt Avenue (See Figure 2 for a site map). The site is
currently occupied by the Starlite Swap Meet, a residence, and
Master Designs Furniture. The
total Property area is approximately 17.37 acres and includes
approximately 14,189 SF ofbuilding area. The Property is located in
a suburban area characterized by industrial properties
and residences.
5.2.2 Topographic Characteristics
The terrain of the Property appeared to be generally sloping to
the west. The terrain at thewestern portion of the Property is
irregular as is characteristic of a drive-in theater. No
natural
surface bodies of water were observed.
5.2.3 General Description of Structures
The Property is improved with six structures totaling
approximately 14,189 SF which includes a
restaurant, maintenance shop, residence, and two commercial
buildings. The buildings are set ona slab-on-grade foundation and
have roll on roofs with the exception of the residence which
has
a raised foundation and pitched roof.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
28/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -24- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
5.2.4 Sources of Heating and Cooling
Heating and cooling systems consisted of electric powered units
located on the roofs as well as
window mounted air conditioners.
5.2.5 Potable Water Source/Sewage Disposal System
The Property is currently serviced by the municipal water and
sewer systems.
5.2.6 Current Use(s) of the Property
The Property is currently used as a swap meet, residence, and
furniture building and retailer.
5.2.7 Past Use(s) of the Property
No obvious indication of past Property usage likely to have
involved the use, treatment, storage,
disposal or generation of hazardous substances or petroleum
products was observed at the time
of the site visit. Please refer to Section 4.4 for findings of
historical site use research. Hillmannwas informed by Mr. Li that
the furniture store was previously used as a dry cleaner which
was
present at least between the 1980s and 1990s. This historic use
of the Property as a dry cleaner
and the potential for unreported spills to have occurred is
considered to be a REC in connectionwith the Property.
5.2.8 Current Use(s) of the Adjoining Properties
The following describes adjacent and abutting properties:
Dir Street Address Description
N Rosemead Boulevard,Maybeth Avenue,
Giovane Street
Cash & Carry Wholesale, International Pet & Supplies
Inc., Cole Lighting, Single-family homes
E Chico Avenue Ramiros Custom Cabinets, C&D Kitchen and
Bath, National Grocers Corp., ABSAuto Body Repair and Paint
S 8921 8925 Lindblade St. Commercial office/warehouse spaces
W Rosemead Boulevard Bestile Cabinet, Stone & More, Yummy
Chinese Cuisine, Swap Meet Printing
No visual observations indicative of a potential environmental
concern were noted of theadjoining properties.
5.2.9 Past Use(s) of the Adjoining Properties
No indication of past uses of the adjoining properties was noted
at the time of the site visit.
Please refer to Section 4.4 for the findings of historical site
use research.
5.2.10 Current/Past Uses of Surrounding Area
The Property is located in suburban area of South El Monte,
California. The vicinity of the
Property consists of a mix of single and multi-family
residential properties and industrial
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
29/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -25- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
properties. No indications of past Property uses that differ
substantially from current conditionswere observed at the time of
the site visit.
5.3 Interior & Exterior Observations
5.3.1 Storage/Usage of Hazardous Substances and Petroleum
Products
The facility at the Property stored various hazardous materials
including paints, wood finishes,paint thinner, various greases,
gasoline in gas cans, and cleaning products. A large amount of
these chemicals were stored in the maintenance shop on the
southeastern portion of the Property.All products were stored in
the manufactured containers. The maintenance shop showed
evidence of poor housekeeping including stains on the pavement
as well as the large amount of
items stacked upon one another. Considering the length of time
that this shop has been utilized(approximately 50 years), this poor
housekeeping involving hazardous materials is considered to
be aREC.
5.3.2 Drums
Numerous metal and plastic 55-gallon drums were observed
throughout the Property which are
used as trash cans during swap meets. These features do not
appear to represent anenvironmental concern to the Property. No
other drums used for other purposes were observed
at the Property.
5.3.3 Other Hazardous Substances/Petroleum Products
No other containers of hazardous substances or petroleum
products were noted on the Propertyat the time of the site
visit.
5.3.4 Unidentified Substance Containers
No other unidentified containers suspected of containing
hazardous substances or petroleum
products were noted on the Property at the time of the site
visit.
5.3.5 Storage Tanks
One approximately 12,000 gallon aboveground storage tank (AST)
is located within themaintenance shop building at the southeast
corner of the Property. According to Mr. Li, the AST
stores water and is necessary to provide water to the restrooms
due to the large amount of people
present during the swap meets. No other evidence of any past or
present underground storage
tanks (USTs) or ASTs was identified on the subject Property. No
visual evidence of any leaks orspills was observed.
5.3.6 Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs)
Approximately eight (8) pole-mounted transformers were observed
on the southern Property
boundary and on the northeastern portion of the Property. No
leaking or surface staining wasobserved around the vicinity of the
transformers.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
30/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
31/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -27- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
5.3.16 Wells
One capped water well is located adjacent to the water AST in
the maintenance shop. This well
was reportedly capped approximately 30 years ago when the
current owner purchased the
Property. No other evidence of wells was observed at the
Property.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
32/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
33/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
34/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -30- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
It is emphasized that the absence of NWI mapped wetland areas
indicated by the EDR reportdoes not necessarily rule out the
potential presence of regulated wetland areas on or immediately
adjoining the Property. A wetland delineation should be sought
from a qualified firm if a more
comprehensive determination regarding the presence or absence of
wetlands on or adjacent to
the Property is warranted.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
35/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
36/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -32- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
9.0 REFERENCES
EDR Aerial Photo Decade Package, Environmental Data Resources,
2015
EDR City Directory Abstract Report, Environmental Data
Resources, 2015
EDR Historical Topographic Map Report, Environmental Data
Resources, 2015
EDR Radius Map Report with GeoCheck, Environmental Data
Resources, 2015
EDR Sanborn Map Report, Environmental Data Resources, 2015
Los Angeles Countys On-line Geographical Information System
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
37/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment -33- Hillmann Project No.
C3-63412540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
10.0 APPENDICES
Appendix A Site Diagram / Vicinity Map
Appendix B Site PhotographsAppendix C Questionnaires / User
Provided Information
Appendix D Historical Records Documentation
Appendix E Regulatory Records DocumentationAppendix F Other
Documents
Appendix G Project Personnel Qualifications
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
38/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Hillmann Project No.
C3-6341
2540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
APPENDIX A
SITE DIAGRAM / VICINITY MAP
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
39/746
Figure 1: SITE VICINITY MAP SCALE: (Not to Scale) N
Project
Location:
Project No.:
2450 Rosemead Boulevard2559, 2603, 2610, 2622,2630 & 2634
Chico Avenue
2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert AvenueSouth El Monte, CA 91733
C3-6341
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
40/746
Figure 2: SITE DIAGRAM SCALE: (Not to Scale) N
Project
Location:
Project No.:
2450 Rosemead Boulevard2559, 2603, 2610, 2622,
2630 & 2634 Chico Avenue2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert
AvenueSouth El Monte, CA 91733
C3-6341
Locationmaintenance shop
Location of formerdry cleaner
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
41/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Hillmann Project No.
C3-6341
2540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
APPENDIX B
SITE PHOTOGRAPHS
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
42/746
PHOTO LOG
2450 Rosemead Boulevard, 2559, 2603, 2610, 2622, 2630 & 2634
Chico Avenue
2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert Avenue
South El Monte, CA 91733
C3-6341
View of the Starlite sign along Rosemead
BoulevardView of the drive in parking lot facing
northeast
View of the maintenance shop View of the interior of the
restaurant
View of the interior of the former projector
room used as storage
View of office space within the restaurant
Page 1 of 5
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
43/746
PHOTO LOG
2450 Rosemead Boulevard, 2559, 2603, 2610, 2622, 2630 & 2634
Chico Avenue
2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert Avenue
South El Monte, CA 91733
C3-6341
View of the maintenance shop patio area View of exterior storage
of hazardous materials
and equipment
View of the interior of the maintenance shop View of the
interior of the maintenance shop
with visible mold on the ceiling
View of an interior floor drain within the
maintenance shop
View of various paints, stains, and other
chemicals
Page 2 of 5
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
44/746
PHOTO LOG
2450 Rosemead Boulevard, 2559, 2603, 2610, 2622, 2630 & 2634
Chico Avenue
2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert Avenue
South El Monte, CA 91733
C3-6341
View of the large AST within the maintenance
shop
View of the capped well at the eastern end of
the AST
View the western building at 2622 Chico Ave. View of the
interior of the furniture store
View of the eastern building at 2622 Chico
Ave.
View of the interior of the warehouse
Page 3 of 5
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
45/746
PHOTO LOG
2450 Rosemead Boulevard, 2559, 2603, 2610, 2622, 2630 & 2634
Chico Avenue
2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert Avenue
South El Monte, CA 91733
C3-6341
View of the residence View of the interior of the residence
View of the northern-most parking lot at the
northeastern portion of the Property
View of the parking lot at the northeastern
portion of the Property
View of the adjoining warehouse grocery store
to the north
View of the adjoining pet supply store to the
north
Page 4 of 5
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
46/746
PHOTO LOG
2450 Rosemead Boulevard, 2559, 2603, 2610, 2622, 2630 & 2634
Chico Avenue
2607, 2629 & 2637 Humbert Avenue
South El Monte, CA 91733
C3-6341
View of the adjoining properties to the east View of the
adjoining auto shop to the east
View of the adjoining properties to the west View of the
adjoining industrial property to the
south
View the adjoining properties to the south
Page 5 of 5
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
47/746
Hillmann Consulting LLC
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Hillmann Project No.
C3-6341
2540 Rosemead Boulevard, South El Monte, California
APPENDIX C
QUESTIONNAIRES/USER PROVIDED INFORMATION
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
48/746
Ol'',..'
H I L L M A NN
C O N S U L T I N G
The ollowing questionnaire hould be completedby a representative
f the Propety that is most
knowledgeable
bout its usage,
onditionand history.Pleasecomplete nd
either
give
to the
Hillmann
representatiye
uring
the site nspection, r
ax
to 711-634-9507.
General:
Property
ame:
Street ddress:
City,ST Zip:
Company:
Date:
Number
of
years
at or famili
r , r i th
hePropeny,
3
/
property
ize:
17,
e
4C(e
Building
ize(s)
#
ofunits:
(ifappl.)
Utilities
and Services:
(nlease
heck
Yes . No
or
NA-Not
Annlicable )and ndicate
nrovider
f
Yes .
'?+
Completed y:
Signature:
.TZr&Hor16
, -1 . -
/'i '
Site
Descrintion:
Block
& Lot #(s):
Number
f building(s):
6
Year(s)
uilt:
Type
of Property:
Phase ESA
-
Environmntal
uestionnaire
Water
JhN @FC;et-
Fuel
Oi l
Sewer
h(rt .r,l9
HVAC Maint.
Power
i trftt 'rl(N
(*
EIevMaint.
Nat Gas
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
49/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
50/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
51/746
fw
H I L L M A N N
C O N 5 U L T I N G
19. Ifthe
property
s servedby a
private
well
or
non-public
watersystem, avecontaminants
been dentified n the well
or system hat exceed
uidelines
pplicable o the watersystem,
or has he well
beendesignated scontaminated y any
government
nvironmental,tlealth
aganay?
ifnot
applicable,
please
checkNO)
n E t
Yes No D/K
20.
Is thereaay environmental
itigation,administrative ctionor cleanup ction nvolving he
property
elated o
a
release
r threatenedelease fany hazardous ubstance
r
petroleum
product?
F
Yes No D/K
21.
Are
you
awareof testingof any environmental edia
soil, groundwater ,
urfacewater,
etc.)at the
property
which identified
evelsofcontaminantsn excess
fregulatory
standards
nd/orcleanup
uidelines?
x
Yes No D,4(
22.
Has asbestos
esting ever been conducted atthePrcperty? IfYES,
pleaseforward
a copy of
test results
and/or survey reDorts:
F
Yes No
D/K
23.
Are any
asbestosontainingmaterials
resent
t
he Property?
fyes,
please
laborate:
n x
Yes
No D,{(
24. Has lead
paint
testing ever been conducted
at the
Property?
YES,
pleaseforuard
a copy of
test results.
A
Yes No D/K
25 .
Is Iead-based
aintpresent
t the Properry?fyes,
piease
laborale:
L I ( L I
Yes No D/K
26 Has
rudon testing ever been
conduatedat the Prcperty? f
yES,
please
forward
a copy of test
resultt.
t r F
Yes No D/K
27. Are
thereany
problems
with water
ntusion, waterdamaged urfaces r excessive
mold
growth
within the buildings? fyes,
please
laborate:
. e n
Yes No D/K
For any
questions
qnswered
"yES"
thqtwqrr(intfunher
elaboration,
please
use hefollowing
spaceas necessary;
Page 4 of 4,
Revised /23/2013
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
52/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
53/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
54/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
55/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
56/746
EDR Aerial Photo Decade Package
Environmental Data Resources, Inc. (EDR) Aerial Photo Decade
Package is a screening tool designed to assistenvironmental
professionals in evaluating potential liability on a target
property resulting from past activities. EDRsprofessional
researchers provide digitally reproduced historical aerial
photographs, and when available, provide one photoper decade.
When delivered electronically by EDR, the aerial photo images
included with this report are for ONE TIME USEONLY. Further
reproduction of these aerial photo images is prohibited without
permission from EDR. For moreinformation contact your EDR Account
Executive.
Thank you for your business.Please contact EDR at
1-800-352-0050
with any questions or comments.
Disclaimer - Copyright and Trademark Notice
This Report contains certain information obtained from a variety
of public and other sources reasonably available to Environmental
Data Resources, IncIt cannot be concluded from this Report that
coverage information for the target and surrounding properties does
not exist from other sources. NOWARRANTY EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, IS
MADE WHATSOEVER IN CONNECTION WITH THIS REPORT. ENVIRONMENTAL
DATA
RESOURCES, INC. SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS THE MAKING OF ANY SUCH
WARRANTIES, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION,MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS
FOR A PARTICULAR USE OR PURPOSE. ALL RISK IS ASSUMED BY THE USER.
IN NO EVENT SHALLENVIRONMENTAL DATA RESOURCES, INC. BE LIABLE TO
ANYONE, WHETHER ARISING OUT OF ERRORS OR OMISSIONS,
NEGLIGENCE,ACCIDENT OR ANY OTHER CAUSE, FOR ANY LOSS OF DAMAGE,
INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, SPECIAL, INCIDENTAL,CONSEQUENTIAL,
OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES. ANY LIABILITY ON THE PART OF ENVIRONMENTAL
DATA RESOURCES, INC. IS STRICTLYLIMITED TO A REFUND OF THE AMOUNT
PAID FOR THIS REPORT.Purchaser accepts this Report AS IS. Any
analyses, estimates, ratings,environmental risk levels or risk
codes provided in this Report are provided for illustrative
purposes only, and are not intended to provide, nor should thebe
interpreted as providing any facts regarding, or prediction or
forecast of, any environmental risk for any property. Only a Phase
I Environmental SiteAssessment performed by an environmental
professional can provide information regarding the environmental
risk for any property. Additionally, theinformation provided in
this Report is not to be construed as legal advice.
Copyright 2015 by Environmental Data Resources, Inc. All rights
reserved. Reproduction in any media or format, in whole or in part,
of any report or maof Environmental Data Resources, Inc., or its
affiliates, is prohibited without prior written permission.
EDR and its logos (including Sanborn and Sanborn Map) are
trademarks of Environmental Data Resources, Inc. or its affiliates.
All other trademarksused herein are the property of their
respective owners.
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
57/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
58/746
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
59/746
NQUIRY #:
EAR:
4352716.9
1938
= 500'
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17Acres PhaseI 2015
60/746
NQUIRY #:
EAR:
4352716.9
1948
= 500'
-
7/23/2019 Starlite Drive In 17A