MARKET WATCH MARKET WATCH BLOOD MEAL OVERPRICED FEED Normand St-Pierre Extension Dairy Specialist Ohio State University [email protected]Feed prices are going up; milk prices are going down. e only questions remaining are: How bad will it get and for how long? Meanwhile, one can really affect the cost of feeding animals by choosing the right feed ingredients to use in dairy rations. In this column I track down different feed markets using the Sesame software. Results using market prices as of May 14 are summarized in tables specific to your region of publication. e feed table reports bracket prices for each feed. e Low and High values delineate the 75 percent confidence range for a feed. If you can buy a feed at a price less than the Low, then it is a bargain. If the market price exceeds the High, then it is overpriced. If your price is between the Low and High, then the feed is priced approximately for what it is worth. e ‘Status’ column provides you with a quick indicator of a feed status: a ★ indicates a bargain feed, a ■ denotes an overpriced feed,and a blank entry indicates the feed is priced about right. Lastly, a few feeds carry a special status symbol: a is shown if either a feed is grossly overpriced (in which case only the High column has a price, and the reported price is the calculated break-even price), or if a feed is grossly underpriced (in which case only the Low column has a price, and the reported price is the calculated break-even price) or if we are in no position to judge a feed status. e third option occurs, for example, with the different grades of alfalfa hay. We can calculate what each grade is worth but we do not have sufficient market information to identify an accurate market price for each grade with which we can compare to the values calculated by Sesame. e correct strategy is to maximize the use of bargain feeds while minimizing the use of overpriced ones, all within the constraint of a balanced ration. I use as a reference a cow weighing 1,400 lbs, producing 70 lbs per day of milk containing 3.7 percent fat, 3.1 percent true protein and 5.7 percent other solids. Nutrient costs are expressed three different ways in the nutrient table: $ per cow per day, ¢ per pound of dry matter (DM) and $ per hundredweight of milk. Beware that these feed costs do not include the costs of feeding the dry cows and the replacement herd. PD 8 Progressive Dairyman Issue 9 • June 11, 2012 Plus: • Beautiful leafy green hay for horses or cattle • 20-35% moisture hay without mold or spoilage • More leaves, more protein, more tons of hay per acre • More profit potential Stack Up Profits with HayPro ® II Better hay - Baled sooner with HayPro ® II. American Farm Products 800-624-7530 NY & VT - Larry Jones, Ph.D 607-591-9727 PA, MD & VA - Bob Kieselowsky 570-357-8241 Table 1 Item 1 Northeast Southeast Midwest NE L (¢/Mcal) 22.8 11.0 16.5 MP (¢/lb) 19.0 52.6 30.4 e-NDF (¢/lb) -6.0 6.6 -2.2 ne-NDF (¢/lb) -21.6 -1.6 -9.1 Nutrient costs ($/cow per day) 2 7.07 6.86 6.41 Nutrient costs (¢/lb of feed DM) 14.4 14.0 13.1 Nutrient cost ($/cwt of milk) 10.09 9.80 9.16 1 NEL = Net energy for lactation; MP = metabolizable protein; e-NDF = effective neutral detergent fiber; ne-NDF = non-effective NDF. 2 1,400-lb cow producing 70 lbs/day at 3.7% fat, 3.1% protein and 5.7% other solids. Supreme hay ($/ton) May 25 Price 3-week change IA $205-$215 $25 IL $200-$240 NC KS $240-$250 $30-$65 MO $210-$245 $20-$35 NE $200-$215 $10 PA $260-$415 $60 VA $213 $124 Source: USDA National Hay, Feed & Seed Summary May 25 Price 3-week change CA $375 $15 ID $347 $18 IL $282 $8 Soybean meal* ($/ton) May 25 Price 3-week change CA $458 $12 ID $455 $17 IL $419 $75 *Price quotes contributed by Western Milling, J.D. Heiskell, independent sources. Corn* (in tons) (in bushels) May 25 Price 3-week change CA $286 $4 ID $283 NC IL $221 $13 Price 3-week change $8.00 .12¢ $7.93 NC $6.18 .38¢ Cottonseed* ($/ton) COMMODITIES
9
Embed
Stack Up Profi ts with HayPro II - Home - Progressive Dairy
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Normand St-PierreExtension Dairy SpecialistOhio State [email protected]
Feed prices are going up; milk prices are going down. � e only questions remaining are: How bad will it get and for how long? Meanwhile, one can really aff ect the cost of feeding animals by choosing the right feed ingredients to use in dairy rations.
In this column I track down diff erent feed markets using the Sesame software. Results using market prices as of May 14 are summarized in tables specifi c to your region of publication.
� e feed table reports bracket prices for each feed. � e Low and High values delineate the 75 percent confi dence range for a feed. If you can buy a feed at a price less than the Low, then it is a bargain. If the market price exceeds the High, then it is
overpriced. If your price is between the Low and High, then the feed is priced approximately for what it is worth. � e ‘Status’ column provides you with a quick indicator of a feed status: a ★indicates a bargain feed, a ■ denotes an overpriced feed,and a blank entry indicates the feed is priced about right.
Lastly, a few feeds carry a special status symbol: a is shown if either a feed is grossly overpriced (in which case only the High column has a price, and the reported price is the calculated break-even price), or if a
feed is grossly underpriced (in which case only the Low column has a price, and the reported price is the calculated break-even price) or if we are in no position to judge a feed status. � e third option occurs, for example, with the diff erent grades of alfalfa hay. We can calculate what each grade is worth but we do not
have suffi cient market information to identify an accurate market price for each grade with which we can compare to the values calculated by Sesame.
� e correct strategy is to maximize the use of bargain feeds while minimizing the use of overpriced ones, all within the constraint of a balanced ration.
I use as a reference a cow weighing 1,400 lbs, producing 70 lbs per day of milk containing 3.7 percent fat, 3.1 percent true protein and 5.7 percent other solids. Nutrient costs are expressed three diff erent ways in the nutrient table: $ per cow per day, ¢ per pound of dry matter (DM) and $ per hundredweight of milk. Beware that these feed costs do not include the costs of feeding the dry cows and the replacement herd. PD
8 Progressive Dairyman Issue 9 • June 11, 2012
Plus:• Beautiful leafy green hay for
horses or cattle• 20-35% moisture hay without
mold or spoilage • More leaves, more protein,
more tons of hay per acre• More profi t potential
Stack Up Profi ts with HayPro® II
Better hay - Baled sooner with HayPro® II.
American Farm Products800-624-7530
NY & VT - Larry Jones, Ph.D 607-591-9727PA, MD & VA - Bob Kieselowsky 570-357-8241
Nutrient cost ($/cwt of milk) 10.09 9.80 9.161 NEL = Net energy for lactation; MP = metabolizable protein; e-NDF = effective neutral detergent fi ber; ne-NDF = non-effective NDF.2 1,400-lb cow producing 70 lbs/day at 3.7% fat, 3.1% protein and 5.7% other solids.
Supreme hay ($/ton)
May 25 Price 3-week change
IA $205-$215 $25 IL $200-$240 NC
KS $240-$250 $30-$65
MO $210-$245 $20-$35
NE $200-$215 $10
PA $260-$415 $60
VA $213 $124
Source: USDA National Hay, Feed & Seed Summary
May 25 Price 3-week change
CA $375 $15
ID $347 $18
IL $282 $8
Soybean meal* ($/ton)
May 25 Price 3-week change
CA $458 $12
ID $455 $17
IL $419 $75
*Price quotes contributed by Western Milling, J.D. Heiskell, independent sources.
Milk price and feed costs drive margins at the farm level. Certainly, sources of revenue other than milk and expenses other than feed impact profi tability, but not of the same magnitude. To gauge the economic health of the dairy industry, we have calculated margin based on mailbox milk price and an estimate of the market cost of a ration. Because feed prices change constantly and no one feed is a good indicator of total feed cost on a dairy, a ration was standardize to 10 percent rumen degradable protein, 6 percent rumen undegradable protein, 32 percent neutral detergent fi ber, 40 percent non-fi ber carbohydrates and 5 percent fat. Nutrient costs are derived using the nutrient composition and monthly average market prices for a basket of feeds available in the region. Income over feed cost is calculated as the mailbox milk price less the feed cost of producing a hundredweight (cwt) of milk assuming a feed effi ciency of 1.45. Operating income is IOFC less non-feed operating costs that are published biannually by the Economic Research Service.
� e fi gure shows the mailbox milk price, ration cost, IOFC and operating income for several U.S. regions over the last 28 months. Milk price gradually increased in 2010 and 2011 to a peak of $20 per cwt in Aug. 2011 and has since declined. Feed costs have followed a similar pattern but the magnitude of change has been much less. Income over feed cost and operating income track milk price more closely than feed cost with approximately 70 percent of the change in income due to milk price and 30 percent accounted for by changing feed costs. However, feed costs can’t be ignored because IOFC last fall was nearly equal to that of fall 2010 though milk was several $ per cwt greater. � e diff erence is feed cost, which was up $2.75 per cwt in the West, $2.70 in the Midwest and $2.50 in the Northeast over the same time period.
As we’ve entered the second quarter of 2012, indicators are stabilizing. April data is preliminary, but it appears that operations are at or near breakeven for operating costs in the West, slightly above in the Midwest and returning about $1 per cwt in the Northeast. At or near breakeven is not a desirable fi nancial position, but given the rapid erosion in margin over the last fi ve months an infl ection point on the graph is a welcome sight.
Absolute margin dollars is most important at the end of the day, margin percent has slipped below 33
percent in the Southwest, 42 percent in the Northwest, 45 percent in the Midwest and 50 percent in the Northeast, meaning that less than one-half or more of each milk income dollar is left after feed expense has
been covered. As mentioned above, percentages
and dollars per cwt allow us to compare how the dairy economy is changing over time. But some amount of milk fl ow is necessary to
generate enough dollars to sustain the business. Although counterintuitive, strategies that decrease milk fl ow and therefore feed effi ciency are counterproductive during periods of declining margins. PD
Lake Odessa LivestockLake Odessa, MI (616) 374-8213(sale 5/22/12)
$1,600$75
$1,300NC
N/T$950
$100 $500
NC$800
NC$350
$100 N/T $1,350
$100
Norwood Dairy Cattle AuctionNorwood, MO (417) 746-4242 (sale 5/10/12)
$1,550$140
$1,500$175
$1,275$125
$1,370$90
$650$150
$945$5
N/T$230$25
N/T
Pipestone Livestock Auction MarketPipestone, MI (507) 825-3306 (sale 5/17/12)
$1,625$25
$1,443$73
$1,399$80
N/T$113/cwt$4/cwt
$91/cwt$7/cwt
N/T N/T$1,110$10
Spring� eld Livestock Marketing Center Springfi eld, MO (417) 869-9500 Doug Thomas (417) 840-9316 (sale 5/22/12)
$1,250$210
$1,100$150
$950$125
$990$200
$340$60
$900 $10
$190$100
$300 $100
N/T
Topeka Livestock AuctionTopeka, IN (206) 593-2522 (sale 5/22/12)
$1,515$60
$900$100
N/T N/T$800
$100 $1,360$65
$240$20
N/T$1,150
NC
Tri-State LivestockSioux Center, IA (712) 722-0681Mike Koedam (712) 470-0198 (sale 5/16/12)
$1,650 $250
$1,475$110
$1,420$82
N/T$152/cwt$16/cwt
$100/cwt$19/cwt
N/T N/T$1,275$75
United Producers, Inc.Marion, MI (517) 294-3484 (sale 5/18/12)
$1,675$225
$1,500 $100
$1,300NC
$1,175$25
$600 $100
$1,050NC
$200NC
N/T $1,000$50
Brush Livestock of ColoradoBrush, CO (970) 842-2801 (sale 5/3/12)
$2,050$100
$1,900$125
$1,675$65
$1,210$35
$390$110
$920$90
N/T N/T N/T
Chehalis Livestock MarketChehalis, WA (360) 748-3191 (sale 5/4/12)
$1,150$150
$1,050$975
$125 N/T
$110/cwt$8/cwt
N/T N/T$85$5
$1,000
Producers LivestockJerome, ID (208) 324-4345 (sale 5/16/12)
$1,500 $30
$1,460$100
$1,300$60
$1,110$488$7
$560$108
N/T N/T N/T
Smith� eld Livestock AuctionSmithfi eld, UT (435) 563-3259 (sale 5/17/12)
$1,370$50
$1,230$45
N/T$1,150
NC$97/cwt
NC$105/cwt
NCN/T N/T N/T
Toppenish Dairy Replacement SalesToppenish, WA (509) 865-2820 (sale 5/7/12)
$1,500$50
$1,300 NC
$1,075$75
$1,200$100
$141/cwt$4/cwt
$95/cwt$20/cwt
N/T N/T N/T
A & M Livestock Auction, Inc.Hanford, CA (559) 582-0358 (sale 5/23/12)
$1,600NC
$1,300$100
$1,100$50
$1,050NC
$150/cwtNC
$100/cwt$10/cwt
$110$10
$150$10
$1,050NC
Sulphur Springs Livestock and Dairy AuctionSulphur Springs, TX (903) 885-7739(sale 5/24/12)
$1,500$100
$1,125$25
$1,125$25
N/T$675$35
$950NC
$275$25
$125 $145
$1,085
Escalon Livestock Market, Inc.Escalon, CA (209) 838-7011(sale 4/25/12)
$1,500 $50
$1,200 $50
$1,150NC
N/T$90/cwt
NC$115/cwt
NCN/T N/T
$900NC
Contact Judy about being included in Progressive Dairyman’s Market Watch! [email protected] • (208) 324-7513 NC = No change N/T = No test Decrease in price Increase in price
Log on to www.progressivedairy.com/marketwatch to get auction reports from more locations!
NOTE: The colored bar represents cumulative year-to-date milk production for 2012. When it does not surpass the dotted line at the center of the box, it indicates state production is below the previous year’s total (2011). When it does surpass the dotted line, it indicates production is above the previous year’s total.
MARKET WATCHMARKET WATCHMILK
Texas440 +1
1,915 NC843 +3.3%
3,346 105.5%
Utah91 NC
1,790 +2.9%163 +7.9%
647 109.1%
Vermont133 NC
1,625 +1.9%216 +0.5%
857 100.7%
Virginia96 NC
1,605 +1.3%154 +1.3%
608 102.9%
Washington263 NC
2,015 +1.3%530 +4.1%
2,090 105.7%
Wisconsin1,270 +11,785 +3.2%2,267 +3.5%
9,026 104.5%
Arizona194 NC
2,155 +1.4%418 +5.3%
1,648 107.6%
California1,787 +22,030 +1.7%3,628 +3.1%
14,553 106.5%
Colorado132 NC
2,020 +1.8%267 +6.8%
1,047 108.4%
Florida122 NC
1,760 +1.1%215 +3.9%
870 104.3%
Idaho577 -3
1,920 +2.7%1,108 +2.9%
4,393 104.7%
Illinois100 NC
1,730 +3.0%173 +4.8%
684 105.9%
Indiana176 NC
1,830 +3.1%322 +5.6%
1,256 106.5%
Iowa207 +2
1,855 +4.2%384 +3.2%
1,514 103.3%
Kansas123 NC
1,820 +0.8%224 +1.8%
889 103.6%
Michigan376 +1
2,000 +2.3%752 +6.2%
2,979 106.6%
Minnesota465 NC
1,655 +2.2%770 +1.3%
3,070 102.2%
Missouri94 NC
1,435 +4.0%135 +3.0%
501 103.3%New Mexico
337 +12,130 +0.2%718 +3.6%
2,804 104.5%
U.S. Total9,272 +51,854 +2.2%17,190 +3.2%
68,180 104.7%
New York610 NC
1,835 +3.7%1,119 +3.6%
4,410 103.6%
Ohio271 +1
1,680 +3.7%455 +4.8%
1,784 103.4%
Oregon123 NC
1,730 NC213 +3.4%
832 103.9%
Pennsylvania538 -2
1,690 NC909 -1.0%
3,577 100.5%
12 Progressive Dairyman Issue 9 • June 11, 2012
A John Deere Allied Supplier
By MasterVet®
The very fi rst step in protecting calves!!!
1-800-767-5611 • www.animalmedic.com
✓ Works on tractors, pickups and choppers
✓ Bolts to draw-bar✓ Makes chopping silage fun✓ Built tough – to pull even
the largest wagons✓ Increases productivity up
to 25%✓ Works with PTO
Bergman Mfg. Inc. • Barry Bergman800-551-4554 • www.bergmanmfg.com
Agri-Speed Hitch
FLORIDA PRODUCTION UP 4.3 PERCENT
Legend
Number of cows(in thousands)
Milk per cow(month)
(lbs.)Total milk
production (month)
(in millions of lbs.)
Year-to-date milkproduction (total)(in millions of lbs.)
Percentage of year-to-date production versus previous year-to-date
Monthly change(in thousands)
Annual percentchange
Annual percentchange
May2011
Jan2012
Feb Mar AprJune July Aug OctSept Nov Dec
20102011
9,1009,1259,1509,1759,2009,2259,2509,2759,300 April 2012: 9,266 High: 9,272 Low: 9,119Milk cows (in thousands)
Bob CroppProfessor EmeritusUniversity of Wisconsin – Madison
New York610 NC
1,835 +3.7%1,119 +3.6%
4,410 103.6%95% 105%100%
MAY ’12
USDA’s estimate of April milk production for the 23 reporting states was 3.3 percent higher than a year ago and for the U.S. 3.2 percent higher. Milk cows continue to increase with April numbers up 5,000 head from March, placing them 1.0 percent higher than a year ago.
� e USDA has now revised upward their milk production for 2012 and don’t expect cow numbers to decline until 2013. Dairy provisions in the 2012 Farm Bill approved by the U.S. Senate Agricultural Committee and now being discussed in the House perhaps are a contributing factor to the continued strong growth in milk production. One of the provisions is margin protection (returns over feed cost) where dairy producers could decide to participate and get a $4-per-hundredweight margin protection at no cost on 80 percent of their highest annual milk production for any of the past three years preceding implementation of the program. PD
USDA DOES NOT EXPECT COW NUMBERS TO DECLINE UNTIL 2013
Increase your profitability with the Rovimix® Beta-Carotene cow fertility solution.
Cow fertility problems are one of the costliest productionissues in dairy farming. Research shows that a sound nutritional program that emphasizes sufficient beta-caroteneintake can help reduce the problem.
Scientific studies indicate that DSM’s highly stable Rovimix®
Beta-Carotene is an excellent source of this nutrient forbreeding cows and can increase your profitability.
In addition, DSM offers you various Rovimix® supplementationprograms designed to meet your operation’s particular needs,as well as its unique iCheck technology to ensure your cowsconsistently receive optimal Rovimix® Beta-Carotene levels.
To find out about how Rovimix® Beta-Carotene can enhanceyour business growth, contact us at 1-800-526-0189 or visitwww.unlimitednutrition-na.dsm.com
We’ve conceived a better way to fertility.
ß-Carotene
CONTROL YOUR FEED COSTS
KNOW WHAT YOUR COWS ARE BEING FED & ACTUAL DMI’s
F i n e - t u n e y o u r f e e d i n g R e d u c e v a r i a t i o n I m p r o v e c o n s i s t e n c y M a n a g e r i s k a n d c o s t
800-225-7695 www.tmr t racker. com
TMR TRACKER
Available direct from your Feed Mixer Dealer!
K
C
TMR TRACKER ONLINEVIEW/EDIT FROM ANY PC
FEED MANAGEMENT SOFTWARE
800 225 7695 k
g
Issue 9 • June 11, 2012 Progressive Dairyman 13
Feb Mar Apr May July AugJune Sept Oct Dec Jan2012
Nov Feb Mar Apr May JuneAug Sept Oct Nov DecJuly2009
Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov DecJan2010
Jan2011
CA Class 1price
Federal Class I price$9
$11$13$15$17$19$21$23$25
MARKET WATCHMARKET WATCH NO MAJOR PRICING CHANGES PREDICTEDDAIRY PRICES
Recently, the tone in the market has shifted from bearish and extremely nervous to comfortable and even a touch bullish. In early May, Class III futures were forecasting a brutal couple months for dairymen with May trading below $15, June trading below $14 and July trading just above $14. Low milk prices coupled with higher feed prices were predicting a milk-feed margin that was comparable to 2009 levels. But after trading at those low levels for several days, the market started to turn and nearly every day it moved another notch higher. By May 23, the May price is comfortable over $15 and, more notably, the June price is trading back up to $15.50 and July has again reached $16. � e back half of the year has also found some strength in recent weeks. Trading around $15.10 earlier in May, the six-month average has increased nearly $1 in just over two weeks.
Overall, it seems that the market has found a bottom and is now going to test some higher prices. Although there is still a more-than-adequate supply of milk, it appears that the worst of the spring fl ush is behind us and hopes are for a slowing milk supply as we enter the summer months. Quotas and premium deductions imposed by cooperatives and processors across the country will hopefully result in a slowed growth of milk production. � e demand side continues to hold its ground with both the domestic and international demand staying relatively strong. � is continued demand is what has supported the Class III milk price in recent months and kept us from repeating a scenario similar to 2009 – low demand and more-than-adequate supplies.
While it seems that the worst is behind us, we have experienced a great amount of volatility in recent weeks, especially in the Class III futures, and I would not be surprised if that volatility continues. Although it seems we are making a steady climb out of the hole, the ground is not completely steady and a seemingly minor bump may push us back a bit. While the volatility may continue, it appears that the market has tested the lows and, unless there is a major shakeup in the system, we should primarily see prices trade higher than what we saw earlier in May.
For dairymen across the country, current Class III futures prices for the upcoming months are sustainable for some, but not for others. For the most part, producers out West are still dollars below break-even, while those in the middle and eastern parts of the country can make these prices
Feedtech with patented MiLab 393 plays a key role in forage preservation – helping you get more milk from every ton of silage. MiLab 393 is a unique strain of L. plantarum bacteria, which aids in reducing mold and yeast.
Unique benefits of MiLab 393:
Reduces mold and yeast levels – moldy feeds potentially contain toxins that have been linked to major health problems in dairy cattle
Optimizes nutrient retention – better nutrition leads to optimum milk production
To maximize your forage program, contact DeLaval or your local DeLaval dealer.
www.delaval-us.com
Maximize your herd’s potential DeLaval Feedtech™ with MiLab 393 helps reduce mycotoxins
After bottoming at $1.30 in early May, which is the lowest trading price in over two years, the spot butter price has inched its way back to $1.39. Although there are ample inventories of butter, the butter price found some strength and is working its way back to $1.40.
There continues to be no major changes in the spot cheese market. Both blocks and barrels traded within a four-cent range recently, with blocks reaching $1.50 and barrels $1.47. The Class III futures are predicting that cheese will continue to climb, but the market is currently making these moves very slowly.
Apr. 2012: $15.72 High: $21.67 Low: $13.38
cash fl ow with little pain. With no major pricing changes projected in the upcoming months, it will be interesting to see if this pricing dynamic will result in any major changes to production growth or pricing systems in the western part of the country. PD
Katie Krupa is the director of producer
services with Chicago-based Rice Dairy, a boutique brokerage fi rm off ering guidance, analysis, and execution services on futures, options, spot and forward markets. You can reach Katie at [email protected]. Visit www.ricedairy.com. � ere is risk of loss trading commodity futures and options. Past results are not indicative of future results.
by Royer EnterprisesBunker Shavers
Promote feed quality and prevent dry matter loss on your bunker
silo, silage pit or drive-over pile! Can be made to fi t telehandlers,
front-end loaders and skid loaders.
(574) 361-3343See them in action at
www.bunkershavers.com
« Front-end loader model
Skidsteer model
«
Telehandler«
$6,000
$4,800
$3,800
Feed High Quality Silage from your bunker with our machines