SSRN-id2567276

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

1/25

"

"#$%&'()*% +(## ,-.&$/ 0) ,#(123*2 4. ,5'1$*##2)%$ 6'2%&*%$78

"'*3 9:;&*%-.-(,$ H/'D-B0/I:/0C/'DD- 20/ /-&-'/@$A ,-@$(0J0C%@'J +-.-J0*D-(, '(+ +-D0(&,/',%0( )(+-/ K/'(,LC/--D-(, M0N 5O77P;N

5Q0(,'@, @%-(@-A H'@)J,4 02 L/,&A Q0D-(%)&

F(%.-/&%,4A W/',%&J'.'N K0(+0.' 5A :NXNW0Y "A O"" 65A W/',%&J'.' "ZA >J0.'I%'N ED'%JR-/%INJ'&,%@[)(%\'N&I

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

2/25

5

0)&'(=5%&*()L),0D',%@ M)D\-/ :J',- =-@0C(%,%0( 1LM:=8 ,-@$(0J0C4 %( >J0.'I%' %& +-*J04-+A 0/ %&,0 \- +-*J04-+ %( &-.-/'J '/-'&N H%/&,A %, %& )&-+ '& ' ,-@$(0J0C4 ,0 @0(,/0J .-$%@J- '@@-&&%( \)%J+%(C& '(+ *'/I%(C J0,&N #$- &-@0(+ '/-' 02 +-*J04D-(, 02 ,$- LM:= $'& ,0 +0 B%,$,$- J')(@$ 02 ,B0 (-B +','\'&-& 1Q-(,/'J =-C%&,/4 H0/ X22-(@-& '(+ M',%0('J >4&,-D 02

#/'22%@ 4&,-D 12)/,$-/ '& _E#>_8 J')(@$-+ %( 56"6N

#$- /-*0/, B%JJ \/%-2J4 +-&@/%\- &,',- 02 ,$- '22'%/& %( ,$- &-@0(+A ,$%/+ '(+ 20)/,$ '/-'

'(+ ,$-( D0.- ,0 ' @0D*/-$-(&%.- /-.%-B 02 ,$- EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ >4&,-D %( >J0.'I%'N!"#$%&' )"*+,$%- ./% 011"#2", 4&$+/#&' 5-,$"6 /1 7%&11+2 8#1/%6&$+/#

#B0 +','\'&-& '/- *J'((-+ 20/ J')(@$ %( (-'/ 2),)/- \4 ,$- C0.-/(D-(,N %(20/D',%0( &4&,-DN %(20/D',%0( &4&,-D 1-NCN *0/,'\J- '(+ &,',%0('/4 C',-&A@'D-/' &4&,-D&A /'+'/ '(+ J'&-/ &4&,-D&8N M0 0,$-/ *0J%@4 +-,'%J& '/- '.'%J'\J- 0( ,$-

Q-(,/'J /-C%&,/4N #$- +',' 2/0D E#> +','\'&- B%JJ 'J&0 \- )&-+ %( '(0,$-/ */0?-@,A ,$%&0(- @00/+%(',-+ \4 ,$- #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4A @'JJ-+ !"#$%&"' )*+#,- %. /0"..$12&.%0-"#$%&N #$- D'%( 2)(@,%0( 02 ,$- &4&,-D %& ,0 */0.%+- @0D*J-Y D0(%,0/%(C 02 ,/'22%@&%,)',%0( 0( >J0.'I /0'+&N;

9877 1/% 5'/:&; J0.'I D-+%' ,$', %(20/D-+ %( M0.-D\-/ 56"; '\0), (-B @'/& 20/>J0.'I :0J%@- ,$', B%JJ \- )&-+ 20/ @/%D- */-.-(,%0( '(+ J'B -(20/@-D-(,N 7L**/0Y%D',-J4 O66 *0J%@- @'/& 10), 02 ]6668 B%JJ )&- (-B $'/+B'/- %(&,'JJ',%0( B%,$,0)@$&@/--(A %(,-C/',-+ @'/+ /-'+-/ '(+ @'D-/' B%,$ aVV /-@0/+%(C '(+ LM:=

;#$- D'%( '(CJ- 02 ,$- '/,%@J- $0B-.-/ @0(2/0(,& &)++-( @$'(C- %( -&,%D',-+ */%@- ,'C20/ ,$- */0?-@, ,$', B-(, 2/0D "76 D%JJ%0( EF=X %( 56"5 ,0 0(J4 "7 D%JJ%0( EF=X ,$%&4-'/N >-- >`EA "6b"5b56";A -- 20/ -Y'D*J-R >`EA :0Jf@%' \)+- ?'c+%g (' %(,-J%C-(,(h@$ '),T@$ 1:0J%@- B%JJ +/%.-

%(,-JJ%C-(, @'/&8A 56b6Pb56";A '.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*Rbb'),0N&D-N&Ib@bZP]"P67b*0J%@'?,%e\)+)e?'c+%,e('e%(,-J%C-(,(4@$e'),'@$N$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6Pb"6b56";

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

3/25

;

@'*'\%J%,4N #$- &4&,-D %& %(,-/@0((-@,-+ B%,$ &-.-/'J *0J%@- +','\'&-& 1-NCN +/%.-/J%@-(@-&A @'/ /-C%&,/',%0(&A &,0J-( .-$%@J-&A -- >`EA ='+'/4 .T& c',%'o &'D4 (-@$4,%' 1='+'/& B%JJ (0, @',@$ p0)8A 6;b6db56"5A

'.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*Rbb'),0N&D-N&Ib@bZ]]]O]6b/'+'/4e.'&ec',%'Je&'D4e(-@$4,%'N$,DJA'@@-&&-+ 6Pb6db56";

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

4/25

]

/%C$,& '& '( -Y'D*J-"6N $&?(=(#(@-#$- ,0*%@ 02 .-$%@J- &)/.-%JJ'(@- $'& (0, \--( %(.-&,%C',-+ %( >J0.'I%' ', 'JJN 9%,$0),022-/%(C -Y,-(&%.- -Y*J'(',%0(& 20/ ,$- J'@I 02 /-&-'/@$ 0( >J0.'I%'A ,$', $'& ,0 +0 B%,$J%D%,-+ *00J 02 /-&-'/@$-/&A ,$- ,0*%@ 02 &)/.-%JJ'(@- %& 0(J4 /-@-(,J4 C-,,%(C D-+%'',,-(,%0( +)- ,0 >(0B+-( @'&- '(+ &-.-/'J *0J%@4 %(%,%',%.-& ,$', '/- 1%(8+%/-@,J4@0((-@,-+ ,0 &)/.-%JJ'(@- 1-NCN Ee$-'J,$ %(%,%',%.-A Ee/-C%&,-/ 02 @%,%c-(&8N

#$/0)C$0), ,$- /-*0/, B- */0.%+- D)J,%*J- -.%+-(@- '\0), ,$- -J-@,/0(%@ ,0JJ &4&,-D

,$', %& /-C'/+-+ */-+0D%('(,J4 '& ' 2%('(@%'J J-.4 %D*0&-+ \4 ,$- &,',-A \4 \0,$ ,$-B',@$-/& '(+ B',@$-+N #$- +0D%('(, '(CJ- ,$', '**-'/& %& (0, ,$', 02 ,$- &)/.-%JJ'(@-A\), 02 ,$- -@0(0D%@'J %D*'@, 02 ,$- E#>N #$- &4&,-D B'& %(,/0+)@-+ ,0 %(@/-'&- \)+C-,/-.-()-&s ,$- 0*-/',0/ 02 ,$- &4&,-DA ' */%.',- @0D*'(4 ,$', 0*-/',-& &4&,-D %&D0,%.',-+ \4 ,$- */02%,N #$- &)\?-@,& 02 ,$- ,0JJA $')J%-/ @0D*'(%-& '(+ +/%.-/& )&-.'/%0)& ,-@$(%i)-& ,0 '.0%+ E#>A \), ,$-%/ D0,%.',%0(& '/- 'J&0 2%('(@%'JN Q/%,%@'J -.-(,&'(+ /-&*0(&-& ,0 ,$- E#> '/- D0,%.',-+ \4 ,$- @0&,&A (0, ,$- */%.'@4N W-@')&- 02 ,$%&A,$- '&*-@, 02 *-/&0('J +',' '(+ ,$- */%.'@4 %& D%&&%(C 'J,0C-,$-/ 2/0D J-C'JA *0J%,%@'J '(+*)\J%@ +%&@)&&%0(& '\0), ,$- E#>N #$- &'D- %& ,/)- 20/ E#> '& ' 20/D 02 &)/.-%JJ'(@-N9$%J- ,$%& tJ'@I 02 &)/.-%JJ'(@- '&*-@,u %& )(+-/&,'(+'\J- ,0 ' J'/C- -Y,-(,A %( @'&- 02 ,$-E#> %( >J0.'I%' %, %& D0/- */020)(+ +)- ,0 J'@I 02 '@,%.%,4 02 &,'I-$0J+-/& 1>J0.'I V:LA

MKXG&A Q0)/,&8 ,$', $'.- @'*'@%,4 ,0 &$%2, ',,-(,%0( ,0 0,$-/ '&*-@,& 02 ,$- E#> ,$'(2%('(@%'JN #$%& J'@I 02 '+.0@'@4 %( +',' */0,-@,%0( '(+ &)/.-%JJ'(@- %& \4 (0 D-'(&J%D%,-+ 0(J4 ,0 E#>A \), %& ,$- (',)/'J &,',- 02 ,$%(C& %( >J0.'I%' &0 2'/N

a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

"6>-- +%&@)&&%0( )(+-/ '/,%@J- >`EA :0Jf@%' *0I),4 *0U,0) (-*0&%-J' 1#$- *0J%@- +0-&(0, &-(+ 2%(-& \4 D'%J8A 65b6Pb56"5A '.'%J'\J- ',$,,*RbbBBBN&D-N&Ib+%&I)&%-b56];""Zb"b:0I),4e*0&,0)e*0J%@%'e(-*0&%-J'N$,DJA'@@-&&-+ 6Pb""b56";N F&-/ bbb0e0vB/%,-& _Q%,%c-(& $'.- ' /%C$, ,0 +',' */0,-@,%0(A '(+LM:= $'& ,0 B0/I B%,$ '@@0/+'(@- ,0 J'BN < +0)\, ,$', @)//-(, ,-&,%(C 02 LM:=,-@$(0J0C4 %& J-C'JJ4 XqN X(- 02 ,$- D0&, 2)(+'D-(,'J 0\J%C',%0(& %& ' .%&%\J-%(20/D',%0( ,$', */-D%&-& '/- D0(%,0/-+A &0 ,$', ' @%,%c-( %& 'B'/- 02 *0&&%\%J%,4 02\-%(C /-@0/+-+N_

"">-- ,$- 56"; %(,-/.%-B B%,$

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

5/25

7

,/'(&@/%*,& '(+ /-*0/,& '(+ &-@0(+'/4 &0)/@-&A -NCNR D-+%' '/,%@J-&N H0/ D-+%' '('J4&%&B- )&-+ ' @0D*/-$-(&%.- D-+%' +','\'&- ,$', 022-/& ,/'(&@/%*,& 20/ #lA /'+%0 '(+ */%(,@0(,-(,N 9- 'J&0 &-'/@$-+ ,$- J0.'I V:L -%,$-/*/0.%+-+ 0(J4 C-(-/'J %(20/D',%0( 0/ /-2)&-+ @0DD-(,N

"]W-@')&- >J0.'I%' %& ' &D'JJ )(%,'/4 &,',-A ,$- */-*'/',%0( '(+ %D*J-D-(,',%0( 02 ,$-(',%0('J E#> B'& (0, @0(2/0(,-+ B%,$ %&&)-& @0((-@,-+ ,0 2-+-/'J%&D '& %( K-/D'(4 0/W-JC%)DN

"7>-- W)&%(-&& =-C%&,/4 -(,/4A$,,*RbbBBBN0/&/N&Ib.4*%&N'&*j--$,,*RbbBBBN0/&/N&Ib.4*%&N'&*j

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

6/25

Z

@0(,/'@, "d0( ,$- :/0.%&%0( 02 Q0D*/-$-(&%.- >-/.%@- 02 EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ Q0JJ-@,%0(-(,-/-+ %(,0 \4 MV> 1O75 D%JJ%0(& EF=X"O8s )&-+ '(+ )&-& .'/%0)& &)\@0(,/'@,0/&20/ +%22-/-(, '&*-@,& 02 ,$- E#>A -NCN *'4D-(, &-/.%@-&"PA HJ--,:'4 13>Q856A 0/ yeH/--5"A&)\@0(,/'@,-+ 20/ @-(,/'J ,0JJ%(C '(+ -(20/@-D-(, &4&,-D

+(## 6(#*%$ L('%$D -&,'\J%&$-+ \4 ,$- J'B '& ' &-*'/',- )(%, B%,$%( ,$- :0J%@- H0/@-

02 >J0.'I%'A /-&*0(&%\J- 20/ J-C'J -(20/@-D-(, 02 ,$- E#> M25#$'. 0)&$'$.& N'(5C.

o 8++%1$"#$%&+ %. 9%": /0"&+;%0# 6'$1 1zE>`LV8ABBBN@-&D'+N&IA \%CC-&, %(,-/-&, C/0)* 02 $')J-/&A 'J&0 &)\@0(,/'@,-+ \4 ,$->I4#0JJ 20/ 0*-/',%(C _@0(,'@, *0%(,&55 ,$', */0.%+- .'/%0)& &-/.%@-&A -NCN'),$0/%c-+ %(&,'JJ%(C 02 XWF&5;

o ?&$%& %. @%#%0 A"00$,0+ 1FML>8A BBBN)(%'+0*/'[email protected]&IA %(,-/-&, C/0)*J')(@$-+ %( 566P %( /-&*0(&- ,0 ,$- E#>A D0/- /'+%@'J ,$'( QE>`LVA B'&\-$%(+ \J0@I'+- 02 ,$- D'%( /0'+& %( 3'()'/4 56"6A 0*-/',-+ '( H'@-\00IC/0)* 1< >)**0/, >,/%I- 02 a')J-/&A Ee#0JJ %& E.-/40(-^& :/0\J-D8 B%,$ 0.-/

76 666 D-D\-/&5]

O.$'. (B &?$ "+,A \'&-+ 0( /-@-(, */-&& /-J-'&- \4 ,$- >I4#0JJA E#> $'&

5;" 5Od XWF& %( -.%+-(@-A d5A; { 02 B$%@$ '/- /-C%&,-/-+ \4 20/-%C( -(,%,%-&57

X,$-/ &,'I-$0J+-/& ,$', B-/- 0/ '/- %(.0J.-+ B%,$ ,$- E#> '/- (0, J%&,-+A -%,$-/ \-@')&-,$-4 %(2J)-(@- 0(J4 J%D%,-+ *'/, 02 ,$- E#> 1-NCN E)/0*-'( Q0DD%&&%0(A /-C%0('JC0.-/(D-(,&8A 0/ ,$-%/ %(2J)-(@- %& )(I(0B( +)- ,0 ,$- (',)/- 02 ,$-%/ @0((-@,%0( ,0E#> 1-NCN >J0.'I I4#0JJA L@@-&&-+ 6Pb""b56";

"O>--A $,,*Rbb+','(-&,N2'%/e*J'4N&Ib+','&-,&b5b/-@0/+&b;d"7Z

"P>-- >`EA q) >I4#0JJ) */%UJ' }'JU%' 2%/D'A I,0/T c'/0\f (' Dh,- 1L(0,$-/ Q0D*'(430%(& >I4#0JJ ,0 E'/( `0(-48A "Zb6]b56"6A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb-I0(0D%I'N&D-N&Ib@b7;;6Z7ZbI)e&I4,0JJ)e*/%&J'e+'J&%'e2%/D'eI,0/'ec'/0\%e('eD4,-N$,DJj),Dk&0)/@-wJ%(Ix),DkD-+%)Dw/&&x),Dk@'D*'%C(w/&&A '@@-&&-+6Pb""b56";

56>-- W)&%(-&& =-C%&,/4 -(,/4A

$,,*RbbBBBN0/&/N&Ib.4*%&N'&*jJ'(w-(xJ0.'I%'N*+2A '@@-&&-+ 6db"5b56";

55>-- ,$- &@'J- 02 ,$- &-/.%@-& */0.%+-+ \4 ,$- @0(,'@, *0%(,&A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*&RbbBBBN-D4,0N&IbB-\bC)-&,b@0(,'@,e*0%(,&A '@@-&&-+ 6db"5b56";

5;>--A $,,*RbbBBBN@-&D'+N&Ib*'C-N*$*jI',w5O"

5]>--A $,,*&RbbBBBN2'@-\00IN@0Db*'C-&b:0+*0/)?-De+0*/'[email protected],/'?I)e`h,0e&'e,hI'e(T&e.U-,Ih@$b55Z;"5POOOd;A '@@-&&-+ "db"5b56";

57>I4#0JJA :/-&& =-J-'&-A "Zb"5b56";A '.'%J'\J- ',R

$,,*RbbBBBN&I4,0JJN&Ib+0B(J0'+b#>k.4\-/kD4,'k(0.-D\-/k56";k."N6k&.Ik56";"5"ZN*+2A '@@-&&-+ "Ob"5b56";

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

7/25

d

P7 +?$ ?*.&('- (B &?$ "+,

%( >J0.'I%' 2/0D J-C'JA *0J%,%@'J '(+ ,-@$(0J0C%@'J*-/&*-@,%.- '(+ %,& @)//-(, &,',-N

P7876(#*&*%2# 6$'.C$%&*1$#$- $%&,0/4 02 E#> %( >J0.'I%' %& %(,-/,B%(-+ B%,$ +-.-J0*D-(, %( ,$- Q-(,/'J E)/0*-AB$-/- &-.-/'J @0)(,/%-& 1-NCN K-/D'(4A L)&,/%'5Z8 %(,/0+)@-+ E#> %( 5667 '(+ 566]/-&*-@,%.-J4N LJD0&, %DD-+%',-J4 Qc-@$ #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4 '((0)(@-+ ' *J'( ,0%(,/0+)@- E#> '& &00( '& *0&&%\J-A 'J&0 %( 0/+-/ ,0 J%D%, %D*'@, 02 ,/'(&%,%0( .-$%@J-&,$', +-@%+-+ ,0 )&- Qc-@$ /0'+& %(&,-'+ 02 K-/D'(4 '(+ L)&,/%'5dN 9%,$%( ,$- (-Y,+-@'+- 'JJ @0)(,/%-& %( ,$- /-C%0( %(,/0+)@-+ ,0JJ &4&,-D& 20/ $-'.4 .-$%@J-& 0.-/ ;N7,0(& 1:0J'(+5OA a)(C'/45PA Qc-@$ =-*)\J%@;68N _#$- *0J%@4 ,/-(+ 02 D'(4 @0)(,/%-&A-&*-@%'JJ4 %( -'&,-/( E)/0*-A ~B'& ,0 %D*J-D-(, \/'(+ (-B @$'/C%(C &4&,-D& '%D-+ ',

2%('(@%(C ,$- \)%J+%(C '(+ D'%(,-('(@- 02 (-B /0'+ %(2/'&,/)@,)/-&_N;"

>J0.'I%' &00( 20JJ0B-+ L)&,/%'( '(+ K-/D'( -Y'D*J-N J0.'I C0.-/(D-(,'**/0.-+ ' &,/',-C%@ +0@)D-(, 0( ,/'(&*0/, *0J%@4;5,$', -(.%&'C-+ ,$- /-*J'@-D-(, _02)&-/ 2--& '**J%-+ 0( D0,0/B'4&A -Y*/-&&B'4& '(+ &-J-@,-+ 2%/&, @J'&& /0'+& B%,$-J-@,/0(%@ ,0JJ &4&,-D %( 566Z_N a0B-.-/A ,$- %(,/0+)@,%0( 02 ,$- E#> B'& +-J'4-+ ,%JJ3'()'/4 02 56"6 +)- ,0 *0J%,%@'J '(+ J-C'J */0\J-D&N H%/&,J4A ,$- */-*'/',%0( 02 ,$- E#>@0%(@%+-+ B%,$ ,$- 566Z *'/J%'D-(,'/4 -J-@,%0(& ,$', /-&)J,-+ %( ' @0D*J-,- @$'(C- 02C0.-/(D-(,N >-@0(+J4A 'J,$0)C$ ,$- 2/'D-B0/I J-C%&J',%0( 20/ E#> B'& '**/0.-+ ', ,$--(+ 02 566Z \4 ,$- >J0.'I *'/J%'D-(,A ,$- *)\J%@ */0@)/-D-(, */0@-&& 20/ ,$- E#> B'&+-J'4-+ &-.-/'J ,%D-& +)- ,0 @0D*J%@',%0(&N #$- E#> &4&,-D B'& 0(- 02 ,$- 2%/&, ,0 ,-&,

,$- 2%('(@%(C ,$/0)C$ *)\J%@ */%.',- *'/,(-/&$%* 1:::8A \4 B$%@$ ,$- (-B C0.-/(D-(,J-+ \4 ,$- :/%D- `%(%&,-/ =N H%@0 *J'((-+ ,0 2%('(@- &-.-/'J J'/C- %(2/'&,/)@,)/-*/0?-@,&N

5Z>-- $,,*RbbBBBNC0eD'),N',

5d>--R z#q 1Qc-@$ :/-&& LC-(@48R EJ-I,/0(%@Im Dh,0 '? . z= 1EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ 'J&0 %(Qc-@$ =-*)\J%@8A 6]b6"b5667

5O>-- $,,*RbbBBBN.%',0JJN*Jb-(b$-'.4e.-$%@J-&b(-B&

5P

>--R $,,*&RbbBBBN$)eC0N$)b'/,%@J-&b%(+-Yb;"76;6$,,*RbbBBBND4,0@cN-)b%(+-YN$,DJ

;">--R >,)+4 0( -@0(0D%@ '(+ &0@%'J %D*'@, 02 ,$- %D*J-D-(,',%0( 02 V%/-@,%.-566]b75bQE 0( %(,-/0*-/'\%J%,4 02 -J-@,/0(%@ 2-- @0JJ-@,%0( %( E)/0*-A H%('J =-*0/,A'.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb-@N-)/0*'N-)b,/'(&*0/,b,$-D-&b%,&b&,)+%-&b+0@b--,&k&0@%0k-@0(0D%@k%D*'@,N*+2

;5#$- X22%@- 02 #$- K0.-/(D-(,A #/'(&*0/, :0J%@4 02 ,$- >J0.'I =-*)\J%@ F(,%J 56"7A'**/0.-+ \4 ,$- K0.-/(D-(, 02 ,$- >J0.'I =-*)\J%@ M0N ]]7 2/0D ON 3)(- 5667A'.'%J'\J- ',

$,,*RbbBBBN,[email protected]&Ib%(+-Yb0*-(k2%J-N*$*j2%J-wD,*,b,/'(&*0/,k*0J%@4k"N*+2A'@@-&&-+ 6;b""b56";

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

8/25

O

V)/%(C ,$- */-*'/',%0( *$'&- 02 E#> &-.-/'J *0J%,%@'J @0DD-(,',0/& *0%(,-+ ,0 ,$- &@'J-02 ,$- */0?-@, 1,$- -&,%D',-+ .'J)- 02 ,$- @0(,/'@, B'& \-J%-.-+ ,0 \- '/0)(+ ZZ6 D%JJ%0(EF=X8 '(+ %,& _',,/'@,%.-(-&&_ 20/ %(,-/-&, C/0)*& @J0&- ,0 ,$- *0J%,%@'J *'/,%-& %( ,$-C0.-/(D-(,N;; #$-&- 0*%(%0(& B-/- @0(2%/D-+ \4 ,$- *)\J%@ */0@)/-D-(, %,&-J2A %(

B$%@$ ,$- M',%0('J a%C$B'4 Q0D*'(4 1MV>8 ,$', */0@)/-+ ,$- &4&,-D 0( \-$'J2 02 ,$-&,',- -Y@J)+-+ ,$/-- 0), 02 20)/ \%+& 20/ 2'%J%(C ,0 D--, ,-@$(%@'J /-i)%/-D-(,& '(+-(+-+ )* *%@I%(C ,$- 0(J4 /-D'%(%(CA '(+ 'J&0 ,$- D0&, -Y*-(&%.- \%+ 20/ O75A" D%JJ%0(EF=X8N;] #$- */0@)/-D-(, %& &,%JJ &)\?-@, 02 '( 0(C0%(C %(2/%(C-D-(, */0@-+)/-%(%,%',-+ \4 ,$- E)/0*-'( Q0DD%&&%0( _20/ \/-'@$%(C E)/0*-'( J-C%&J',%0( \4 2'%J%(C ,0'((0)(@- ' E)/0*-eB%+- ,-(+-/ 20/ %,& -J-@,/0(%@ /0'+e,0JJ &4&,-D 0*-/',0/ '(++%&@/%D%(',%(C 'C'%(&, @'(+%+',-& %( ,$- ,-(+-/ */0@-&&_N;7V-&*%,- ,$- J-C'J @$'JJ-(C-2/0D ,$- EQA '(+ &-.-/'J J-C'J @$'JJ-(C-& 2/0D @0D*'(%-& ,$', &)\D%,,-+ 2'%J-+ \%+&A ,$-B%((%(C @0(&0/,%)D >'(#0JJ e B'& D-, B%,$,$- D'&&%.- */0,-&,& 02 %(,-/-&, '&&0@%',%0(& ,$', ',,-D*,-+ ,0 \J0@I D'%( /0'+& \0,$ %(3'()'/4 '(+ H-\/)'/4 56"6A \), B%,$0), D)@$ &)@@-&&N #$- */0,-&,& -(+-+ '2,-/ 2-B

;;ENCN >`EA l%+-0eE+%,0/%'JA 3- U0I0DA - ,-(+-/ (' Dh,0 .4$/'J' ('?+/'$U%' *0()I' 1-- #L>=A EQ &-(+& /-'&0(-+ 0*%(%0( ,0 >J0.'I%' 0.-/ /0'+e,0JJ &4&,-D,-(+-/A 6"b"6b56"6A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb&*-@,',0/N&D-N&Ib'/,%@J-&b.%-Bb]6;6Pb"6b-@k&-(+&k/-'&0(-+k0*%(%0(k,0k&J0.'I%'k0.-/k/0'+k,0JJk&4&,-Dk,-(+-/N$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6Pb6Pb56";

;7>-- E)/0*-'( Q0DD%&&%0(A :)\J%@ */0@)/-D-(,R Q0DD%&&%0( @'JJ& 0( >J0.'I%' ,0/-&*-@, EF /)J-& 20/ -J-@,/0(%@ ,0JJ @0JJ-@,%0( @0(,/'@,&A ;6b6Pb56"6A L.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb-)/0*'N-)b/'*%+b*/-&&e/-J-'&-k

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

9/25

P

+'4&N X(@- 'C'%(A %, %& %D*0/,'(, ,0 &,/-&& ,$', ,$-&- */0,-&,& B-/- (0, D0,%.',-+ \4 ,$-&)/.-%JJ'(@- '&*-@, 02 ,$- E#>A \), \4 ,$- 2%('(@%'J %D*'@, 02 ,$- ,0JJ '(+ @0(.%@,%0( ,$',,$- &4&,-D B'& (0, /-'+4N L& */0,-&,-/& D'('C-+ ,0 C-, &0D-,$%(C 2/0D ,$-C0.-/(D-(,A ('D-J4 %(,/0+)@,%0( 02 ,%@I-,%(C &4&,-D 20/ &0D- /0'+&;d'(+ ,-D*0/'/4&)&*-(&%0( 02 ,$- ,0JJ @0JJ-@,%0( 0( "&, @J'&& /0'+&;OA %( ,$- -(+ ,$- B',@$-+ '@@-*,-+

,$- -Y%&,-(@- 02 ,$- E#>N L /-.%-B 02 @/%,%@'J /-&*0(&-& ,0 E#> &4&,-D 1\J0@I'+-A )&- 02?'DD-/&A '.0%+'(@- 02 ,0JJ (-,B0/I8 %& +%&@)&&-+ %( *'/, ]N

#$- \%CC-&, i)-&,%0( 2/0D *0J%,%@'J *-/&*-@,%.- 02 ,$- E#> %& %(,-/,B%(-+ B%,$ ,$- *)\J%@*/0@)/-D-(, '(+ &)&*%@%0(& 02 20)J *J'4 \4 ,$- C0.-/(%(C *0J%,%@'J *'/,%-& '(+ ,$-%/\)&%(-&& 2/%-(+&N;PE.-( %( V-@-D\-/ 56"; ,$- i)-&,%0( 02 ,$- /-'J 0B(-/& 02 >I4#0JJ/-D'%(& )('(&B-/-+N ]6

P7*-@%2%-+ >-@,%0(& 02 K/0)(+ =0'+& B'&'**/0.-+ \4 ,$- >J0.'I *'/J%'D-(, ', ,$- -(+ 02 566ZN #$- J'B -&,'\J%&$-+ \'&%@@0(+%,%0(& 20/ %(,/0+)@,%0( 02 E#> %( >J0.'I%' '(+ 'JJ0B-+ 20/ *)\J%@ */0@)/-D-(, 20/ '&4&,-D 0*-/',0/N #$- J'B 'J&0 %D*J-D-(,-+ ,B0 EF +%/-@,%.-&A 566]b75bEQ 0(4&,-D %( ,$- Q0DD)(%,4 '(+ "PPPbZ5bEQ 0(,$- Q$'/C%(C 02 a-'.4 K00+& l-$%@J-& 20/ ,$- F&- 02 Q-/,'%( J0.'I%' ,$', B-/- (-'/ ,$- \0/+-/ B%,$ Qc-@$=-*)\J%@A a)(C'/4 '(+ :0J'(+N #$- ,%@I-,%(C -(+-+ %( >-*,-D\-/ 56";N >--R #%@I-,%(CA'.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*&RbbBBBN-D4,0N&IbB-\bC)-&,b,%@I-,%(CA '@@-&&-+ 6Pb"5b56";

;O#$- ,0JJ @0JJ-@,%0( B'& &)&*-(+-+ ,%JJ `'/@$ "A 56"6N

;P>-- -NCN %(.-&,%C',%.- /-*0/, \4 (-B&*'*-/ >`E %( `'/@$ 56"6A %( B$%@$ +'%J4)(&)@@-&&2)JJ4 ',,-D*,-+ ,0 20)(+ 0), B$0 %& P6{ D'?0/%,4 0B(-/ 02

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

10/25

"6

#$- E#> %& J-C'JJ4 @0D*J-Y '(+ %, %& +%/-@,J4 %(,-/,B%(-+ B%,$ 0,$-/ J'B&A -NCN S'B 0( ,$-='%JB'4 :0J%@-A 02 B$%@$ ,$- #0JJ :0J%@- %& 0/C'(%c',%0('J )(%, 0/ ,$- J'B M0N ;"7b"PPZQ0JJN 0( ,$- =0'+ #/'22%@A %( B$%@$ ,0JJ 022-(@-& '/- +-2%(-+N W-&%+- ,$',A ,$- D'%( E#>J'B %& 'J&0 %D*J-D-(,-+ \4 .'/%0)& -Y-@),%.- J-C'J '@,&A -NCN =-C)J',%0( 02 ,$-K0.-/(D-(, M0N ;76b566d Q0JJN &,%*)J',%(C ,$- ,0JJ /',- 'D0)(, 20/ ,$- )&- 02 &*-@%2%-+

&-@,%0(& 02 C/0)(+ /0'+&A V-@/-- M0N ;OOb566P Q0JJN 1#0JJ X/+-/8 02 ,$- `%(%&,/4 02#/'(&*0/,A :0&, '(+ #-J-@0DD)(%@',%0(& C0.-/(%(C +-,'%J& 02 ,0JJ @0JJ-@,%0( 0/ +-@/--M0N ]]"b56"" Q0JJN 02 ,$- `%(%&,/4 02 #/'(&*0/,A :0&, '(+ #-J-@0DD)(%@',%0(& ,$',&*-@%2%-& ,$- &-@,%0(& 02 $%C$B'4&A -Y*/-&&B'4& '(+ ,$- "&, @J'&& /0'+& %( ,$- ,0JJ&4&,-DN

>%(@- %,& '**/0.'J %( 566Z ,$- D'%( ,0JJ J'B B'& 'D-(+-+ "" ,%D-&A D0&,J4 \4 %(+%/-@,'D-(+D-(,&N #$%& %& (0, )()&)'J %( >J0.'I J-C'J &4&,-DA -&*-@%'JJ4 %2 0/%C%('J J'B B'&'**/0.-+ 2)JJ ,$/-- 4-'/& \-20/- ,$- E#> J')(@$-+ %(,0 ,$- &-/.%@-N

A B$', '/- ,$- *)/*0&-&A B$%@$ &)\?-@,& $'.- ,$- '@@-&& ,0 ,$- +',' '(+ B$-,$-/,$-/- B-/- '(4 @$'(C-& &*-@%2%@ ,0 '20/-D-(,%0(-+ ,0*%@& \-,B--( 566Z '(+ 56";N H0/,$%& B- '('J4c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

B7"# 5"#" 2+ A%'',1#,: "&: C%0 D%E F%&GH

#$-/- '/- ,B0 ,4*-& 02 +',' ,$', '/- @0JJ-@,-+ B%,$%( ,$- E#>N H%/&,J4A %, %& ,$- +',' ,$', %&@0JJ-@,-+ \4 ,$- 0*-/',0/ -J-@,/0(%@'JJ4A %N-N *J',- ()D\-/A ,-@$(%@'J */0*-/,%-& 02 ,$-.-$%@J-A %+-(,%2%@',%0( @0+- 02 0(e\0'/+ )(%, 1_XWF_8A +%&,'(@- +/%.-( 0( ,$- ,0JJ /0'+A,0JJ /',- '(+ %(20/D',%0( '\0), ,$- .-$%@J-^& 0*-/',0/N >-@0(+ ,4*- 02 ,$- +',' %&@0JJ-@,-+ +)/%(C ,$- %(%,%'J /-C%&,/',%0( 02 .-$%@J- 20/ @0(,/'@, *)/*0&-&N ]"9$%J- ,$-/- %&' &*-@%2%@ +0@)D-(, 0( +',' */0,-@,%0( */0.%+-+ \4 ,$- >I4#0JJA %, %(20/D& 0(J4 '\0),,$- 2'@, ,$', ,$- +',' @0(,/0JJ-/ 02 ,$- E#> %& ,$- MV> 1_M',%0('J a%C$B'4 Q0D*'(48A,$', ,$- +',' */0@-&&0/ %& ,$- >I4#0JJ '(+ ,$', ,$- ,$%/+ *'/,%-& '/- %(.0J.-+ B%,$

]"#$- l-$%@J- X*-/',0/ %& 0\J%C-+ ,0 */0.%+- ,$- 20JJ0B%(C +','R ,$- %+-(,%2%@',%0(+-,'%J& 20/ .-$%@J- 0*-/',0/ 1-NCN('D-A '++/-&&8A ,$- 2%/&, ('D- '(+ &)/('D-A +',- 02\%/,$A @%,%c-(&$%* '(+ $0D- '++/-&& 02 ,$- .-$%@J- +/%.-/A ,$- *-/&0('J -@,%0(& ,$', ,$- l-$%@J- X*-/',0/ *J'(& ,0

+/%.- %( ,$- @0)/&- 02 ' +-&%C(',-+ ,%D- *-/%0+A ,$- \'(I%(C +-,'%J& 02 ,$- l-$%@J-X*-/',0/A ,$- @0(,'@, +-,'%J& 02 ,$- l-$%@J- X*-/',0/N

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

11/25

""

+%&,/%\),%0( 02 XWF )(%,&A '(+ ,$-/-20/-A B%,$ *-/&0('J +','N]5 9$%J- ,$- ,4*- 02 +','@0JJ-@,-+ B%,$%( ,$- E#> %& -Y*J%@%,J4 J%&,-+ \4 \0,$ J'BA '(+ J-C'J @0(,/'@,& */0.%+-+ \4,$- >I4#0JJA ,$- +',' /-,-(,%0( %& J%D%,-+ ,0 @%,',%0(& 02 +',' */0,-@,%0( J'BN #$- +','*/0,-@,%0( J'B %,&-J2 %& .-/4 C-(-/'J B$-( %, @0D-& ,0 ,$- +',' /-,-(,%0(N #$- 0(J4-Y*J%@%, *-/%0+ D-(,%0(-+ %( +0@)D-(,& %& ,$- *-/%0+ 02 &%Y D0(,$& '2,-/ B$%@$ ,$-

*-/&0('J +',' 02 ,$- .-$%@J- 0*-/',0/ %( ,$- E#> '/- +-J-,-+ %2 2'%J%(C ,0 D'I- ,$-@0(,/'@, B%,$%( &%Y D0(,$N #$- /-,-(,%0( 02 ,$- +',' B'& 0(- 02 ,$- i)-&,%0(& < '&I-+ ,$-+',' */0@-&&0/A >I4#0JJA B$-( < B'& %(,-/-&,-+ B$', $'**-(& ,0 ,$- +',' ,$', '/-/-@0/+-+ \4 @0(,/0J C',-& B$-( ,$-/- %& (0 $%, 1-NCN ,$- @'/ %& /-C%&,-/-+ '(+ *'%+ ,0JJ8A,$- /-&*0(&- B'& ,$', ,$- %(20/D',%0( %& _@0(2%+-(,%'J_N

B7% D"+ 811,++ #% 3/) 5"#"H

#$- @0D*'/%&0( 02 ,$- 2%/&, +/'2, 02 ,$- -J-@,/0(%@ ,0JJ J'B];A '& +%&@)&&-+ \4 ,$-C0.-/(D-(, %( H-\/)'/4 566ZA B%,$ ,$- @)//-(, B0/+%(C 02 ,$- J'B '& 02 V-@-D\-/56"; &$0B& 0(- %D*0/,'(, +%22-/-(@-N Q)//-(, J'BA %N-N Z1d8 0\J%C-& ,$- E#> 0*-/',0/ #%

G0" '$4, "&: :$0,1# "11,++ #% "'' :"#" 1%'',1#,: E$#7$& 3/) #% #7, I%'$1, "&: )'%4"=2&.%0-"#$%& ),04$1, J)2)K $,''$G,&1, "G,&1*LN #$%& *'/, %& D%&&%(C 2/0D ,$- 566Z 0/%C%('J+/'2,N #$- */0*0&'J ,0 C/'(, '@@-&& ,0 E#> ,0 ,$- :0J%@- B'& &)\D%,,-+ +)/%(C ,$- &-@0(+/-'+%(C 02 ,$- ,0JJ J'B %( V-@-D\-/ 566Z \4 @0'J%,%0( `: `/N :-J-C/%(%A ,0C-,$-/ B%,$&-.-/'J 0,$-/ @$'(C-& $- */0*0&-+ ,0 ,$- +/'2,]]N a%& /-'&0(%(C B'& ,$', _,$- :0J%@-(--+& ,0 @0(,/0J ,$- -(20/@-D-(, 02 ,$- J'BA ,$-/-20/- %, (--+& ,0 $'.- '( '@@-&& ,0 E#>+','_N LJ,$0)C$ %( /-'@,%0( ,0 $%& */0*0&'J 0(- `: 2/0D 0**0&%,%0( /'%&-+ ' &)&*%@%0(,$', ,$- -Y,-(&%.- */0*0&'J B'& %( 2'@, */-*'/-+ \4 ,$- `%(%&,/4 02 #/'(&*0/,A '& %, %&02,-( ,$- @'&-A ,$- `%(%&,-/ SN lT(4 /-2)&-+ ,$%& '(+ '@I(0BJ-+C-+ 0(J4 -Y,-(&%.-@0(&)J,',%0(& B%,$ `/N :-J-C/%(%N #$- */0*0&'J ,0 C/'(, ,$- '@@-&& ,0 E#> B'& '**/0.-+\4 '( '\&0J),- D'?0/%,4 02 `:& 1"56 0), "768N]7

L 4-'/ J',-/A %( 566dA ,$- #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4 */-*'/-+ '( 'D-(+D-(, ,0 ,$- S'B 0(='%JB'4 :0J%@- %( 0/+-/ ,0 -&,'\J%&$ ,$- #0JJ :0J%@- '& '( 0/C'(%c',%0('J )(%,N V)/%(C ,$-@0(&)J,',%0(& 0( ,$- +/'2, ,B0 02 ,$- @0)(,/4^& %(,-JJ%C-(@- 'C-(@%-&A > '(+ `%J%,'/4N W0,$ +-D'(+& &$'/-+ &%D%J'/ '/C)D-(,&A *0%(,%(C ,0 'C-(@%-& J-C'J0\J%C',%0(& '(+ +),%-&N X(J4 > $0B-.-/ */0+)@-+ -J'\0/',- -Y*J'(',%0( ,$', '/C)-+,$', +%/-@, '@@-&& ,0 E#> +',' 1-NCN J%@-(&- *J',-&A *%@,)/-&A J0@'J%c',%0( +','A ,%D- +','8

]5

>--A >I4#0JJA -- #$- =-@0/+%(C 02 ,$- l0,-A

$,,*RbbBBBN(/&/N&IbB-\bV-2')J,N'&*Yj&%+w&@$0+c-b$J'&0.'(%-b$J'&IJ)\x

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

12/25

"5

B'& -&&-(,%'J +)/%(C %(,-JJ%C-(@- 0*-/',%0(& '(+ @0)J+ (0, \- &)\&,%,),-+ B%,$ %(+%/-@,'@@-&&A '& ,$%& B0)J+ _0\?-@,%.-J4 @')&- (0%&- '(+ 2')J,4 +','_]ZN #$- #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4'@@-*,-+ 0(J4 ,$- */0*0&'J \4 ,$- > '(+ ,$- 'D-(+D-(, B'& '**/0.-+ %( ,$-*'/J%'D-(, %( 566OA ,$- S'B M0N OZb566O 0( ,$- ='%JB'4 :0J%@-N#$-/- '/- (0 *)\J%@ +',' '.'%J'\J- 0( $0B 02,-( ,$- '@@-&& %& )&-+ \4 ,$- :0J%@- '(+ >N

M-%,$-/ 022%@%'J :0J%@- &,',%&,%@&A (0/ '(()'J /-*0/, \4 ,$- > %(@J)+-& '(4 %(20/D',%0(NLJ&0A 0), D-+%' '('J4&%& +%+ (0, 2%(+ '(4 '/,%@J- %( B$%@$ ,$- :0J%@- '@I(0BJ-+C-+ ,$-)&- 02 E#> +',' 20/ %,& 0*-/',%0(&N < '&I-+ '\0), ,$- '@@-&& %( -D'%J ,0 ,$- :0J%@-A ,$',B-(, )('(&B-/-+A '(+ ,0 ,$- >I4#0JJA ,$', @'JJ-+ ,$- %(20/D',%0(A 0(@- 'C'%(A@0(2%+-(,%'JN ]d

811,++ 9,M>,+#+

#$- C-(-/'J V',' */0,-@,%0( J'B /-C)J',-& ,$- &)\?-@, '@@-&& /-i)-&, ,0 E#> +','N #$-'20/-D-(,%0(-+ +0@)D-(, 0( */%.'@4 ,$', %& '.'%J'\J- 0( ,$- B-\&%,- 02 ,$- E`4,0N&I1Ee#0JJ8 ?)&, D-(,%0(& -Y%&,-(@- 02 ,$- &)\?-@, '@@-&& /-i)-&,A B%,$ /-2-//%(C ,0 ,$- V:

J'BN a0B-.-/A (0 ,-D*J',-& 10(J%(- 0/ */%(,-+8 20/ /-i)-&,& '/- '.'%J'\J-N L& 20/ ,$-)&'C- 02 ,$- /%C$,A (0 *)\J%@ +',' B-/- '.'%J'\J-N L@@0/+%(C ,0 ,$- /-&*0(&- 2/0D ,$->J0.'I V:LA ,$-/- B-/- (0 @0D*J'%(,& D'+- ,0 ,$- V:L '\0), \4 J-C'J &)\?-@,& '\0),,$- E#>N

P7P7 +$%?)(#(@*%2# 6$'.C$%&*1$#$- 0/%C%('J J'B 0( ,$- -J-@,/0(%@ ,0JJ 2/0D 566d B'& %(,-(,%0('JJ4 (-),/'J 0( ,$-,-@$(0J0C4 ,$', B'& ,0 \- )&-+ %( ,$- 2),)/- ,0JJ &4&,-DN LJJ ,$/-- I(0B( ,0JJ,-@$(0J0C%-& B-/- '@I(0BJ-+C-+ %( ,$- J'BA ,$-/-20/- 0*-(%(C ' *0&&%\%J%,4 20/ \/0'+-/@0D*-,%,%0( 20/ 2),)/- @0(,/'@,N #$- >J0.'I E#> )&-& KJ0\'J M'.%C',%0( >',-JJ%,- >4&,-D

1KM>>8 20/ .-$%@J- *0&%,%0(%(C ,0C-,$-/ B%,$ ,$- @-JJ)J'/ D0\%J- &4&,-D 02 ,$- @-JJ)J'/(-,B0/I ,0 @0DD)(%@',- B%,$ '( E#>N #$- X(eW0'/+ F(%,& )&-+ \4 .-$%@J-& %(,-C/',- 'JJ,$/-- ,-@$(0J0C%-&R &',-JJ%,- K:> D0+)J- 1*0&%,%0(%(C8A K>`bK:=> D0+)J-1@0DD)(%@',%0( B%,$%( D0\%J- (-,B0/I&8 '(+ D%@/0B'.- V>=Q D0+)J- 1&$0/,e+%&,'(@-@0DD)(%@',%0(8N #$- XWF& @'J@)J',- ,$- *0&%,%0( 02 ' .-$%@J- \'&-+ 0( ,%D- +','A ,$-D',$-D',%@'J D0+-J 02 ,$- KM>> &',-JJ%,- D0.-D-(,A '(+ /-@-%.-+ &%C('J&N )&%(C ,$- K>` 1K:=>8NW'&-+ 0( ,$- +',' '(+ ,$- l-$%@J- *'/'D-,-/& 1l-$%@J- @',-C0/4A B-%C$,A ()D\-/ 02

]ZL.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*RbbBBBN/0I0.'(%'N&IbH%J-N'&*Ybl%-BV0@)D-(,a,DJb`',-/eV0I)Dedd]"7j*/-2%YH%J-wDk

]d>-- ED'%J @0(.-/&',%0( B%,$ `/N W0+%&A >I4#0JJA V-@-D\-/ 56";N y)-&,%0(& '&I-+R "Na0B +0-& ,$- '@@-&& ,0 E#> B0/IA ENCN %& :0J%@- C/'(,-+ -Y,-/('J '@@-&&A 0/ %& D-D\-/ 02:0J%@- *$4&%@'JJ4 */-&-(, %( %(20/D',%0( @-(,/-A 0/ 'J,-/(',%.-J4A '@@-&& %& C/'(,-+ )*0(' /-i)-&,NA 5N V0-& ,$- >I4#0JJ $'.- '(4 &,',%&,%@& 0( $0B 02,-( %& ,$- '@@-&& )&-+A -NCN %(@'J-(+'/ 4-'/jA ;N a0B +0-& ,$- +',' /-,-(,%0( B0/I B%,$%( ,$- E#>N ENCN %2 ,$- @0(,/0J,0JJ C',- ,'I-& *%@,)/- 02 '( .-$%@J-A '(+ %, %& ' (-C',%.- $%, 1/-C%&,-/-+ '(+ ,0JJ %& *'%+8A

$0B J0(C +0-& ,$- *%@,)/- /-D'%( %( ,$- +','\'&-N

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

13/25

";

'YJ-&A -D%&&%0( @J'&&8A ,$- E#> J-.%-& ' ,0JJ '@@0/+%(C ,0 ,$- /',-& &*-@%2%-+ %( ,$- +-@/--02 ,$- C0.-/(D-(,N]O

#$- LM:= ,-@$(0J0C4 %( ,$- E#> %& +-*J04-+ 20/ +4('D%@ '(+ &,',%@ @0(,/0J 02 ,$-.-$%@J-&N V4('D%@ @0(,/0J %& *-/20/D-+ \4 ,$- #0JJ :0J%@-A B$%@$ %& '),$0/%c-+ \4 ,$-

J'B ,0 @0(,/0J ,$- @0D*J%'(@- B%,$ ,$- ,0JJ J'BN #$- #0JJ :0J%@- )&-& D0\%J- )(%,&-i)%**-+ B%,$ V>=Q /-'+-/A @'D-/' '(+ J%.- '@@-&& ,0 @-(,/'J %(20/D',%0( &4&,-DN #$-)(%,& @0(&%&, 02 ,B0 @/-BD-D\-/& '(+ '/- +-*J04-+ 'JJ 4-'/ '/0)(+A B%,$ 0(- D-D\-/\-J0(C%(C ,0 ,$- #0JJ :0J%@- '(+ &-@0(+ ,0 >I4,0JJA ,$- @0D*'(4 ,$', 0*-/',-& ,$- E#>N#$- D0\%J- )(%, @0(+)@,& ,B0 ,4*-& 02 &-'/@$-&A ,'/C-,-+A B$%@$ '/- \'&-+ 0( ,$-%(20/D',%0( 0\,'%(-+ 2/0D +%&*',@$-/ '(+ /'(+0DN /-D'%( ,$- &'D- 1'& 02V-@-D\-/ 56";8A ,$-/- %& ' &%C(%2%@'(, 20/D'J J-C'J @$'(C-N L (-B 2/'D-B0/I J'B 0( ,0JJ

B'& '**/0.-+ \4 ,$- *'/J%'D-(, %( M0.-D\-/ 56";N 9$-( `%(%&,-/ 02 #/'(&*0/,',%0( 3N:0%',-I %(,/0+)@-+ ,$- J'B %( %( ,$- *'/J%'D-(,A $- &,/-&&-+ ,$', ,$- D'%( /-'&0( 20/,$- J'B %& _*/0,-@,%0( 02 5(+ '(+ ;/+ @J'&& /0'+& 2/0D +-&,/)@,%0( \4 $-'.4 C00+.-$%@J-& \4 '\&0J),- \'( 20/ .-$%@J-& 0( ;/+ @J'&& /0'+&A -Y,-(&%0( 02 ,0JJ &4&,-D 20/ 5(+'(+ ;/+ @J'&& /0'+&A %(,/0+)@,%0( 02 '\&0J),- J%'\%J%,4 20/ ,0JJ 022-(@-& '(+ %(@/-'&- 022%(-& 20/ ,0JJ 022-(@-&N76 #$- *J'( 02 ,$- D%(%&,/4 %& ,0 )&- ' c-/0e,0JJ 0( 5(+ '(+ ;/+

]OW'&-+ 0( E#> K)%+-A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*&RbbBBBN-D4,0N&Ib@b+0@)D-(,kJ%\/'/4bC-,k2%J-j))%+w2O'-2;5-ed+d@e]2-Ze\-7'eZ-@];']]6Z6@xC/0)*.-, ,-@$(0JC%fA 190/J+ 02 ,-@$(0J0C%-&8A5Ob""b566PA #l /-*0/, ,$', %(.-&,%C',-+ ,-@$(0J0C%@'J '&*-@,& 02 E#> &4&,-D %(>J0.'I%'A B%,$ &*-@%'J 20@)& 0( ,$- -(20/@-D-(,A 0/ W0\0UfIA `NA >I4#0JJR EY*-/%-(@-& %(EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ Q0JJ-@,%0( %( >J0.'I /-*)\J%@A */-&-(,',%0(A `'/@$ 56""A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*RbbJ%&,&N)D(N-+)b@C%e\%(bB'jL;w%(+""67xSwQXMe:==

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

14/25

"]

@J'&& /0'+& 20/ 'CC/-C',%0( 02 */-@%&- +',' _'\0), D0.-D-(,& 02 ,/)@I& %( %(+%.%+)'J/-C%0(&_ '(+ -.'J)',- ,$%& +',' -.-/4 &%Y D0(,$&N7"

#$- (-B J'B /-*J'@-& ,$- 566d J'BN E22-@,%.- 2/0D 3'()'/4 "A 56"] %, +0-& (0, 'J,-/ J-C'J2/'D-B0/I 02 ,$- E#> +/'D',%@'JJ4A \), %, %(,/0+)@-& &-.-/'J @$'(C-& ,$', '/- /-J-.'(,

20/ ,$- &)/.-%JJ'(@- '&*-@, 02 ,$- E#>N75H%/&,A ,$- J'B -(J%&,& %( D0/- +-,'%J B$', I%(+ 02+',' ,$- E#> 0*-/',0/A 0/ ,$%/+ *'/,%-& @0JJ-@, '(+ */0@-&&N >-@0(+J4A ,$- '@@-&& ,0 ,$-+',' 2/0D E#> %& ,0 \- C/'(,-+ (0, 0(J4 ,0 ,$- :0J%@- '(+ >A '& %, B'& )(,%J (0BA \),'J&0 ,0 H%('(@%'J L+D%(%&,/',%0( '(+ `%J%,'/4 J0.'I /0'+&A '&\0,$ J-C'J 2/'D-B0/IA '(+ ,$- ,-@$(%@'J %(2/'&,/)@,)/- B%JJ \- %( *J'@-N

Q7 E()&'(1$'.*$. 2)= '$.C().$. &( &?$ "+,

'(+A '& %, B'& %( */-.%0)& ,-Y,A '**-'/ ,0 \- +%/-@,J4%(2J)-(@-+ \4 ,$- -@0(0D%@'J D0,%.',%0(& 02 &)\?-@,& )(+-/ ,$- &)/.-%JJ'(@-N a0B-.-/A

'C-w>*-'I-/>-@,%0(x>*-'I-/>-@,%0(*-@,',0/A 5"b"6b56";A Q$'(C-& #0 EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ >4&,-DA '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb&*-@,',0/N&D-N&Ib'/,%@J-&b.%-Bb7"d;Pb5;b@$'(C-&k,0k-J-@,/0(%@k,0JJk@0JJ-@,%0(N$,DJA '@@-&&-+ "Zb"5b56";

75>--

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

15/25

"7

'& ' D',,-/ 02 2'@,A &-.-/'J 02 ,$- @0(,/0.-/&%-& 1'(+ &,/',-C%-& -D*J04-+ \4 ,$-&)\?-@,&8 $'.- ' +%/-@, %D*'@, 0( ,$- &)/.-%JJ'(@- */'@,%@-N

Q787 4##$@$= G2&2 >*./2)2@$/$)& R*&?*) &?$ "+,H-B D0(,$& \-20/- ,$- 56"6 *'/J%'D-(,'/4 -J-@,%0(A '(+ 2-B B--I& '2,-/ ,$- E#> B-(,

0(J%(-A '( 0**0&%,%0( `: 2/0D >VqFA '(+ D-D\-/ 02 ,$- :'/J%'D-(,'/4 Q0DD%,,-- 20/N 3'(%U 0/C'(%c-+ ' */-&& @0(2-/-(@-7] %( B$%@$$- '@@)&-+ >I4#0JJ 02 D%&$'(+J%(C E#>N a- @/%,%@%c-+ ' &-/%0)& ,$/-', ,0 ,$- */%.'@4 02@%,%c-(& ,$', %& @')&-+ \4 ,$- D'J2)(@,%0(%(C E#>A '(+ 'J&0 ,$- 2'@, ,$', ,$- @0(&0/,%)Dt0B(-+ \4 D4&,-/%0)& @0D*'(%-& B%,$ '@@0)(,& %( Q4*/)&u $'(+J-& ,$%& ,$/-',N L& '(-Y'D*J- 02 */0\J-D& `/N 3'(%U /-@'JJ-+ '( %(@%+-(, 2/0D ,$- @0DD%,,--^& %(.-&,%C',%0(%(,0 E#>A +)/%(C B$%@$ ' D-D\-/ 02 ,$- Q0DD%,,-- 2/0D @0'J%,%0( `/N :-J-C/%(% @'JJ-+ 'QEX 02 >I4#0JJ '(+ B%,$%( ,$- 2%.- D%(),-& $'+ +-,'%J-+ %(20/D',%0( '\0), ,0JJ *'%+ \40(- */%.',- ,/'(&*0/, @0D*'(4N _9- '/- C0%(C ,0 \- )(+-/ ,$- &)/.-%JJ'(@- \4 ,$-*/%.',- @0D*'(4_A &'%+ `/N 3'(%UN J0.'I a')J-/&A/-*0/,-+ @0//-@, %(20/D',%0( '\0), ,0JJ $%& @0D*'(4 *'%+ 1;666 %( ,$- 2%/&, D0(,$8N a-@0(@J)+-+ ,$', ,$- %(@%+-(, $'& ,0 \- &--( '& _)(+-(%'\J- */002 ,$', E#> %& B0/I%(C*/0*-/J4_N #$- */-&& @0(2-/-(@- +%+ C-, ,/'@,%0( B%,$%( ,$- +'4^& (-B& @4@J-A '(+ B'&/-*0/,-+ \4 'JJ /-J-.'(, D-+%'A %(@J)+%(C D0&, *0*)J'/ #l -.-(%(C (-B&N7Z V-&*%,-&-/%0)& (',)/- 02 '@@)&',%0(&A '(+ ,$- 2'@, ,$', ,$- #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4 J')(@$-+ '20/D'J %(.-&,%C',%0( %(,0 ,$- 'JJ-C-+ J-'IA ,$- @'&- .'(%&$-+ 2/0D D-+%' '(+ B'& (0,20JJ0B-+ J-C'JJ4 0/ *0J%,%@'JJ4N7d

7]>-- >VqF :/-&& =-J-'&-A 5;b65b56"6A V%'o(%(m Dh,0 $/0c\' n(%I) 0&0\(h@$n+'?0. 1a%C$B'4 #0JJe L #$/-', 02 :-/&0('J V',' S-'I8A '.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*RbbBBBN&+I)e+&N&Ib'/,%@J-b&$0BL/,%@J-b5dOA '@@-&&-+ 6Ob""b56";

77>--R >`EA 5;b65b56"6A ,T, .4U-,/)?- n(%I n+'?0. c0 >I4#0JJ 1>,',- '4&R VqFA ', ,$', ,%D- @0'J%,%0( *'/,4A (0D%(',-+ ,B0 20/D-/ D'('C-/& 2/0D >I4#0JJ ,0$%C$ D'('C-/%'J *0&%,%0(& B%,$%( ,$- @-(,/'J C0.-/(D-(,N >-- a0&*0+T/&I- M0.%(4A5Pb6Pb56"6A >Vq .&T+c' (' o)+f c Dh,(-? 2%/D4 1>VqF W-,& 0( #$- :-0*J- 2/0D #0JJ

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

16/25

"Z

Q7--A -NCN D0&, *0*)J'/ ,'\J0%+A M0.h z'&A :0/'cf D%J%(0.m -J-I,/0(%@Im Dh,0 /)U%I'c' O6 -)/j 19%JJ E#> 20/ `%JJ%0(& W- W-',-( \4 3'DD-/ 20/ O6 EF=Xj8A 5db6;b56"6

Z6>-- >`EA `h,0 ./'? I'D%(4 0\@$T+c'?n /)U%I'D%A 1#0JJ ,%JJ 0( #0JJ =0'+&8A

;6b67b56"6A '.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*Rbb&N&D-N&Ib/e/&&b7;PP;6Ob-I0(0D%I'N&D-N&Ib/)&%@I4eceD4,(4@$e@%-&,e(-cD%cJ%N$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6Pb"6b56";

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

17/25

"d

'(+ ,$- >I4#0JJ /-2)&-+ ,0 @0DD-(,N I4#0JJ/-*/-&-(,',%.- *0%(,-+ 0), ,0 ,$- 2'@, ,$', ?'DD-/& B-/- %JJ-C'J '(+ ,$', ,$- @0D*'(4I(-B $0B ,0 _$'(+J- %(.%&%\J- @'/&_N #$- #0JJ :0J%@- /-2)&-+ ,0 */0.%+- '(4 +',' 0( ,$--(20/@-D-(, 02 ,$- \'(N #$%& &-/%-& 02 '/,%@J-& B'& J'&, 0(- ,$', %(.-&,%C',-+ )&- 02?'DD-/& %( ,$- E#>N `0/-0.-/A ' @$'(C- 02 @0DD)(%@',%0( &,4J- %& .%&%\J- 2/0D ,$- #0JJ

:0J%@-N #$- :0J%@- %& D0/- */0'@,%.- &%(@- 56"" '(+ %(20/D& *-/%0+%@'JJ4Z] '\0), %,&-(20/@-D-(, B%,$%( ,$- E#>R -NCNA %( 56"5 ,$- #0JJ :0J%@-A ,0C-,$-/ B%,$ ,$-#-J-@0DD)(%@',%0(& X22%@- 02 >J0.'I%' *-/20/D-+ Od 0*-/',%0(& ,$', 20)(+ 5Z ?'DD-/&A&'D- 'D0)(, ,$', %( 56""NZ7N `-+%' '('J4&%& */0.%+-+ 0(J4 '(-@+0,'J -.%+-(@-s ,$-022%@%'J +',' 2/0D *0J%@- %(@J)+- +0c-(& 02 @'&-& 20/ 56"" '(+ 56"5N >-.-/'J @0DD-(,&)(+-/ ,$- ,$-D- _W'+ Q0D*'(%-&_ 0( :/02%.0+%@N&IA '( &%,- 20/ */02-&&%0('J +/%.-/&A 'J&0*0%(, ,0 ,$- -Y%&,-(@- 02 ,$- @0D*'(%-& B$-/- D'('C-D-(, 20/@-& +/%.-/& ,0 '.0%+ ,0JJ\4 )&%(C ,$- ?'DD-/&NZZ 9$%J- ,$- K:> ?'DD-/& &,%JJ /-D'%( -'&%J4 0\,'%('\J- .%'I4#0JJR p0) a'.- #0 -- .%+-0 02 *0J%@- 0*-/',%0(A '.'%J'\J- ',R

$,,*RbbBBBN40),)\-N@0DbB',@$j.w769DJ50a9OA '@@-&&-+ 6Pb""b56"; 0/ '/,%@J-&R>`EA q0(,/0J4 /)U%%-I .J'(% 0+$'J%J% '? @-Jn I0J() (TIJ'+(h@$ .0c%+%-J 1S'&, p-'/^&Q0(,/0J 02 3'DD-/& LJ&0 F(@0.-/-+ HJ--, 02 #/)@I&8A 5db5b56";A '.'%J'\J- ',R

$,,*Rbb'),0N&D-N&Ib@bZd"Z;PObI0(,/0J4e/)&%@%-Ie.J'(%e0+$'J%J%e'?e@-J)eI0J0()e('IJ'+(4@$e.0c%+%-JN$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6;b"5b56";

ZZ>-- :/02%.0+%@N&I A V%&@)&&%0( #0*%@A M-&-/%c(- H%/D4 1W'+ Q0D*'(%-&8A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*RbbBBBN*/02%.0+%@N&Ib(0+-b;77j*'C-w"A '@@-&&-+ 6Ob"5b56";

ZdENCNA $,,*RbbBBBN$-)/-I'N&Ibj${7W2/'c-{7Vw/)U%I'A '@@-&&-+ "5b"5b56";N

ZOQ%,%(C 2/0D W-/,-J&D'(( #/'(&20/D',%0(

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

18/25

"O

`LVA ,$- \%CC-&, %(,-/-&, C/0)* /-*/-&-(,%(C $')J-/& %(>J0.'I%'A @'JJ-+ 0( ,$- #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4 ,0 */0*0&- J0B-/%(C 02 -Y@%&- ,'Y-& 0( D0,0/0%J %( 0/+-/ ,0 @0D*-(&',- %(,/0+)@,%0( 02 ,$- E#>N L 2-B +'4& \-20/- ,$- 022%@%'J J')(@$02 ,$- E#> %( >J0.'I%'A +0c-(& 02 >J0.'I $')J-/& ,$', B-/- )(&',%&2%-+ B%,$ -220/,& 02 ,$-zE>`LVA -&,'\J%&$-+ ,$- F(%0( 02 >J0.'I a')J-/& '(+ @'JJ-+ 0( ,$- #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4

,0 +-J'4 J')(@$ 02 ,$- E#>A '& %, B'& _(0, /-'+4 4-,_NZP#$-4 'J&0 '((0)(@-+ ,$', ,$-4B-/- */-*'/-+ ,0 \J0@ D'%( \0/+-/ ,/'(&%, %( 3'()'/4A %2 ,$- `%(%&,/4 +0-& (0, '@@-*,&0D- 02 ,$-%/ +-D'(+&Nd6 A ' /-+)@,%0( %( -Y@%&- ,'Y-& 0( D0,0/2)-J '(+ +-@/-'&-& %( /0'+ ,'Y /',-&N N

V)/%(C ,$- */0,-&,& 02 ,/'(&*0/, @0D*'(%-& ,$- D-+%' %(20/D-+ '\0), ,$- @'&- 02 '+-&,/04-+ ,0JJC',- ', ' "&, @J'&& /0'+ (-'/ W/',%&J'.'Nd5 #$- :/%D- `%(%&,-/ =N H%@0D-(,%0(-+ ,$- %(@%+-(, +)/%(C $%& */-&& \/%-2%(CA &'4%(CA _#$%& %& ' /0'+ ,0 $-JJ_N `/N H%@0B'/(-+ -.-/40(- B$0 %& C0%(C ,0 +-&,/04 ,0JJC',-& ,0 \- */-*'/-+ 20/ @0(&-i)-(@-&N

>00( '2,-/ '(0,$-/ ,0JJC',- B'& +-&,/04-+A B%,$ %,& $'/+B'/- &,0J-(Nd; -- V0*/'.@0.%'NB\JN&IA '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*RbbBBBN+0*/'.@0.%'NB\JN&IA '@@-&&-+6Pb"5b56";

d6>

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

19/25

"P

LJ,$0)C$ ,$- F(%0( 02 >J0.'I a')J-/& /-D'%(-+ %( &,/%I- -D-/C-(@4 20/ /-D'%(%(C 02,$- 4-'/A )(&)@@-&&2)JJ4 &)-+ >I4#0JJ 20/ 2')J,& 02 ,$- E#> %( 56"6 d]'(+ ,$/-',-(-+ B%,$'(0,$-/ \J0@I'+- %( 56""A ,$- (-B J-'+-/&$%* 02 ,$- F(%0( @$'(C-+ ,$-%/ ,'@,%@& '(+&,'/,-+ ,0 @0(@-(,/',- ,$-%/ -220/,& 0( D0/- ,/'+%,%0('J J0\\4%(C '@,%.%,%-& ,0 +-D'(+2'.0/'\J- @0(+%,%0(& 20/ $')J-/ \)&%(-&& %( >J0.'I%'d7N --A (%' +0*/'.@0. >J0.-(&I' 'J)?- >I4#0JJ 1F(%0( 02 >J0.'I a')J-/& >)-& >I4#0JJA"Ob""b56"6A '.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*RbbBBBN*J)&I'N&Ib-I0(0D%I'b&J0.-(&I'e

-I0(0D%I'b)(%'e'),0+0*/'[email protected]&J0.-(&I'ec'J)?-e&I4,0JJN$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6Ob"5b56";d7>-- ,$- %(,-/.%-B B%,$ ,$- (-B :/-&%+-(, 02 ,$- F(%0( 02 >J0.'I a')J-/&A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb)(%'+0*/'[email protected]\JN&Ib:=E>>N$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6Pb"5b56";

dZ>J0.'I >*-@,',0/A Q$'(C-& ,0 -J-@,/0(%@ ,0JJ @0JJ-@,%0(A 5"b"6b56";

ddL 2-B B--I& '2,-/ J')(@$ 02 ,$- E#> ,$- D-D\-/& 02 /-C%0('J C0.-/(D-(,& %(20/D-+', ,$- */-&& @0(2-/-(@- ,$', '.0%+%(C 02 ,$- ,0JJ /0'+& %& 'J/-'+4 @')&%(C ' &%C(%2%@'(,+'D'C- ,0 J0@'J /0'+&N >--R LI,)'J%,4N&IA q'D%(4 (%%' @-&,4 1#/)@I& L/- V-&,/04%(C=0'+&8A 6;b65b56"6A '.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*RbbBBBN'I,)'J%,4N&Ib@J'(0Ib"77PdObI'D%0(4e(%@%'e@-&,4e$0.0/%e*/-+&-+'e,,&Ie%e&,'/0&,0.%'bA '@@-&&-+ 6db"5b56";

dO#$- */0\J-D %,&-J2 B'& &)\?-@, 02 +0c-(& 02 D-+%' /-*0/,&A -NCN >`EA V.0/%'(I'D (%%'%.0/ I'D%(4 1V.0/%'(I4 V-&,/04-+ \4 #/)@I&8A 6Pb6Ob56";A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*RbbBBBN&D-N&Ib@bZOPd"6Pb+.0/%'(I'De(%@%'ec%.0,eI'D%0(4e0\4.',-J%'e&,/'@'?)e,/*-cJ%.0&,N$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6db"5b56";s M0.h z'&A #/T*-(%- 0\4.',-o0. `h,(-?1>)22-/%(C 02 `h,('8A ""b6db56";A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb.'&N@'&N&Ib@J'(0IbO556b,/'*-(%-e0\4.',-J0.eD4,(-?e+0D4e%De*'+'?)e('e$J'.)e(%@%'e%@$eI'D%0(4N$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6db"5b56";s :J)&I'N&IA q'D%(4 &*&0\)?n*/'&I'(%- +0D0. 1#/'@I& L/- Q')&%(C ' V'D'C- #0 a0)&-&8A "]b"6b56"6A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*RbbBBBN*J)&I'N&Ib&J0.-(&I0b/-C%0(4bI'D%0(4e&*0&0\)?)e*/'&I'(%-e+0D0.N$,DJA'@@-&&-+ 6Pb"5b56";s >D-N&IA 'J'(%' %'+'?n &*0*J',(-(%- @-&,4 I,0/T */-@$T+c'D-&,0D 1:-0*J- 02 'J' +-D'(+ #0JJ =0'+8A "7b""b56""A '.'%J'\J- ',R

$,,*Rbb(%,/'N&D-N&Ib@bZ";PZ7;b&'J'(%'ec%'+'?)e&*0*J',(-(%-e@-&,4eI,0/'e*/-@$'+c'eD-&,0DN$,DJA '@@-&&-+ 6Pb"5b56";

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

20/25

56

%,N #0 @0D*J%@',- ,$- &0J),%0( ,0 ,$- */0\J-D -.-( D0/-A ,$/-- +%22-/-(, (',%0('JC0.-/(D-(,& B-/- %( ,$- 022%@- \-,B--( 56"6 '(+ 56";NdP

J0.'I%' %( ,$%& %(&,'(@- %& */0.%+-+ \4 ,$- J-'+-/ 02 *-,%,%0( @0DD%,,-- %( .%JJ'C-V.0/%'(I4N `/N 3N l%,I0.%A B$0 ',,-D*,& 20/ &-.-/'J 4-'/& ,0 &0J.- ,$- */0\J-D \4'JJ-/,%(C &,',- '),$0/%,%-&N

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

21/25

5"

V.0/%'(I4O"A B$-/- @%,%c-(& 0/C'(%c-+ '( %(20/D'J C/0)* ,$', &4&,-D',%@'JJ4 D0(%,0/-+,$- &%,)',%0(N --A $,,*Rbb+.0/%'(I47NB-\(0+-N&Ib&,'.bI'D%0(4e.%I-(+bA '@@-&&-+ 6Ob"5b56";

O;L.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*RbbBBBN40),)\-N@0Db*J'4J%&,jJ%&,wFFqqF52\dD|i@D,pD0@EV>IC

O]>`E \J0CA $,,*Rbb?'(.%,I0.%@N\J0CN&D-N&Ib@b;];]OObX,/'&4e5]e$0+%(e+-((-e:/'&I'?)e/0+%((-e+0D4N$,DJA L@@-&&-+ 6Pb"5b56";

O7>-- $,,*Rbb+.0/%'(I47NB-\(0+-N&I

OZ$,,*&RbbBBBN2'@-\00IN@0Db?'(N.%,I0.%@NPZ

Od>-- >`E \J0CA ";b"5b56";A |Tc/'I &' (-I0(T 1#$- `%/'@J-

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

22/25

55

T7 E()%#5.*()

#$- EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ >4&,-D %( >J0.'I%' B'& J')(@$-+ '& ,$- &,',- 02 ,$- '/, ,0JJ%(C&-/.%@- B%,$ 0(- 02 ,$- J'/C-&, @0.-/'C- 02 /0'+& %( E)/0*-N a0B-.-/A ,$- */-*'/',%0( 02,$- */0?-@, '(+ %,& %D*J-D-(,',%0( B-/- @0(2/0(,-+ B%,$ .'/%0)& */0\J-D&A &0D- 02

B$%@$ $'.- B%+-/ %D*J%@',%0(& 20/ '@@0)(,'\%J%,4A ,/'(&*'/-(@4 '(+ C0.-/('(@- %(>J0.'I%'N

#$- E#> B'& 0(- 02 ,$- 2%/&, J'/C- &@'J- */0?-@,& ,$', )&-+ *)\J%@e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

MV>A )(+-/ +%/-@, &)*-/.%&%0( 02 ,$- #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,/4A +-@%+-+ ,0 +%&i)'J%24 ,$/--\%+& 2/0D ,$- */0@)/-D-(, '(+ 'B'/+-+ ,$- @0(,/'@, ,0 ,$- 0(J4 /-D'%(%(CA '(+ ,$-D0&, -Y*-(&%.- \%+ 2/0D ,$- @0(&0/,%)D @0(,/'@, B%,$ >I4,0JJ %( 0/+-/,0 /-&,/)@,)/- &0D- 02 ,$- *'4D-(,&A -.-( &$- B'& 20/@-+ ,0 '@I(0BJ-+C- (0, ,0 $'.-*/-@%&- %(20/D',%0( B$4 @-/,'%( *-0*J- '/- /-*/-&-(,%(C >I4#0JJ +)/%(C ,$-

(-C0,%',%0(& B%,$ $-/ C0.-/(D-(,N 9%,$ ,$- :/%D- `%(%&,-/ H%@0 156"5e8 \'@I %( ,$-022%@-A ,0C-,$-/ B%,$ 'JJ ,$- *0J%,%@'J '@,0/& ,$', B-/- +%/-@,J4 /-&*0(&%\J- 20/ ,$- E#>1-NCN 20/D-/ #/'(&*0/, `%(%&,-/ SN lT(4A @)//-(,J4 &-/.-& '& l%@- :` H0/ >,/',-C%@:/0?-@,&8A ,$- i)-&,%0( 02 ,$- /-'J 0B(-/& 02 ,$- >I4#0JJ /-D'%(& )('(&B-/-+A +-&*%,-\-&, -220/,& 02 ,$- D-+%'N #$- */0\J-D $-/- %& (0, 0(J4 0(- 02 ,$- ,/'(&*'/-(@4A B$-/-,$- &,',- %& )(B%JJ%(C ,0 )(@0.-/ B$0 B'& 'B'/+-+ \%CC-&, *)\J%@ @0(,/'@, %( >J0.'I$%&,0/4A \), 'J&0 02 ,$- '@@0)(,'\%J%,4A B$-/- %(,-/-&,& 02 ,$- *0J%,%@'J '@,0/& &--D ,0 \-'J%C(-+ D0/- B%,$ ,$-%/ &*0(&0/& ,$'( B%,$ ,$0&- 02 ,$- *)\J%@N

:%@,)/- "R XB(-/&$%* >,/)@,)/- 02 >I4 #0JJOO

OO>-- >`E \J0CA =-D%U0.TA l-/0(%I'R EJ-I,/0(%@Im Dh,0 *0+o' H%@0.-? .JT+4 cJ0+-?&Ih*'.nI 1EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ >4&,-D L@@0/+%(C H%@08A 1%( >J0.'I8N L.'%J'\J- ',R

$,,*Rbb.-/0(%I'/-D%&0.'N\J0CN&D-N&Ib@b;d"5;5b-J-I,/0(%@I-eD4,0e*0+J'e2%@0.-?e.J'+4ecJ0+-?&I4e*'.)IN$,DJA L@@-&&-+ "db5b56"7

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

23/25

5;

9$%J- >J0.'I%' $'+ %,& 'D0)(, 02 \%C &@'J- */0?-@,& B%,$ 'JJ-C',%0(& 02 @0//)*,%0(A ,$-E#> %& )(%i)- '& %, %& ,$- 2%/&, 0(- B%,$ D'&&%.- &)/.-%JJ'(@- *0,-(,%'JN L& B- -Y*J'%(-+

%( ,$- /-*0/,A ,$- &@0*- 02 ,$- E#> %(@/-'&-+ &%C(%2%@'(,J4 &%(@- ,$- 56"6 J')(@$ '(+ B%[email protected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`0/-0.-/A ,$- C0.-/(D-(, *J'(& ,0 )&- E#> +',' %( ,B0 +','\'&-& ,0 \- J')(@$-+ %( ,$-(-'/ 2),)/-N LJJ ,$-&- @$'(C-& B-/- '**/0.-+ ,$/0)C$ ,$- /-C)J'/ J-C%&J',%.- */0@-&&A'(+ B-/- '@@-*,-+ B%,$0), '(4 0**0&%,%0( 2/0D &,',- 'C-(@%-&A ,$- 0**0&%,%0( *'/,%-&A

%(,-/-&, C/0)*& '(+ ,$- D-+%'N #$%& %& B$-/- ,$- J'@I 02 '+.0@'@4 20/ */%.'@4 %&&)-& %&D0&, .%&%\J-N #$-0/-,%@'JJ4A 0(- B0)J+ -Y*-@, >J0.'I V',' :/0,-@,%0( LC-(@4 ,0 *J'4&%C(%2%@'(, /0J- +)/%(C */-*'/',%0( 02 E#>A %,& %D*J-D-(,',%0( '(+ @)//-(, @$'(C-&N #$-0**0&%,- %& ,$- @'&-N #$- 'C-(@4 +%+ (0, /'%&- ' &%(CJ- 0\?-@,%0( +)/%(C ,$- @0(&)J,',%0(&02 ,$- 566d J'B '(+ ,$- 56"; J'BN 9$-( %( 56"6 ' `: 2/0D 0**0&%,%0( 'JJ-C-+ ,$',@0'J%,%0( `: B'& '\J- ,0 0\,'%( *-/&0('J +',' 2/0D ,$- E#> _'2,-/ 0(- *$0(- @'JJ ,0 ,$-+%/-@,0/ 02 >I4#0JJ_A ,$- V:L +%+ (0, J')(@$ '(4 %(.-&,%C',%0( %(,0 ,$- D',,-/N 9$%J- ,$%&D'4 \- '( -Y@-*,%0(A 0)/ /-*0/, 20/ 9:7 'J&0 20)(+ ,$- >J0.'I V:L %& ' ,-@$(0@/',%@'C-(@4 ,$', /'/-J4 -(,-/& *)\J%@ +-\',-& '(+ @0(,/0.-/&%-&NOP X,$-/ ,/'+%,%0('J

OPp0) B%JJ (0, 2%(+ '(4 022%@%'J /-*0(&-& ,0 >(0B+-( &@'(+'JA 0/ (-B C0.-/(D-(,'J*/0?-@,& 2/0D >J0.'I V:LN

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

24/25

5]

'+.0@',-&A -NCN MKX^& '/- $%&,0/%@'JJ4 D0/- 20@)&-+ 0( ,/'(&*'/-(@4 '(+ 2%C$, 'C'%(&,,$- @0//)*,%0(N #$- J'@I 02 ,$- 'B'/-(-&& %& %+-'J 20/ 2)(@,%0( @/--* 02 ,$- E#> ,$', B-'/- B%,(-&&%(C ,$-&- +'4&N 9$', %& D0/- B0//4%(C %& ,$', ,$-/- '/- &-.-/'J EeK0.-/(D-(, */0?-@,& %( ,$- */-*'/',%0(P6,$', D'4 &00( -Y*0(-(,%'JJ4 %(@/-'&- D'&&%.-&)/.-%JJ'(@- %( >J0.'I%'N J0.'I& @%,%c-(& '(+ @0D*'(%-& D'4 -(+ )* \-%(C B',@$-+ 0.-/\4 0D(%*0,-(, 2%('(@%'J C/0)*& ,$', 'J/-'+4 &--D ,00 \%C ,0 2'%JN

P6 J0.'I%' %(,/0+)@-+A 0/ %& ,0%(,/0+)@- &-.-/'J J'/C- *)\J%@ */0?-@,& ,$', $'.- ' &-/%0)& &)/.-%JJ'(@- *0,-(,%'JA 2/0D0D(%*0,-(, *0J%@- @'/&A

7/24/2019 SSRN-id2567276

25/25

U7 F$.(5'%$. V/$=*2 .(5'%$. 2'$ %*&$= *) $)=)(&$.W

MT/0+(T +%'o(%(T &*0J0(0&gA 56"6A =-*0/,R `)J,%eJ'(- H/--e2J0B EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ%(C %(,$- >J0.'I =-*)\J%@A '.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*RbbBBBN&@$%J+e*'/,(-/N@0Db>):b=0'+k:/%@%(CkxkEJ-@,/0(%@k#0JJ%(CkkH/--kHJ0BAk&',-JJ%,-k\'&-+k,0JJ%(

Ck&4&,-D&kkk>@$%J+kxk:'/,(-/k2%J-&b`)J,%eS'(- H/--eHJ0B EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ%(C %( ,$->J0.'I =-*)\J%@N*+2A '@@-&&-+ 6Ob"6b56";

W0\0UfIA `NA >I4#0JJR EY*-/%-(@-& %( EJ-@,/0(%@ #0JJ Q0JJ-@,%0( %( >J0.'I /-*)\J%@A*/-&-(,',%0(A `'/@$ 56""A '.'%J'\J- ',R $,,*RbbJ%&,&N)D(N-+)b@C%e\%(bB'jL;w%(+""67xSwQXMe:=J0.'I%'A V0@)D-(, M0N ]]7 2/0D ON 3)(-5667A '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*RbbBBBN,[email protected]&Ib%(+-Yb0*-(k2%J-N*$*j2%J-wD,*,b,/'(&*0/,k*0J%@4k"N*+2A'@@-&&-+ 6Pb"6b56";

E/(&, x p0)(CA >,)+4 0( -@0(0D%@ '(+ &0@%'J %D*'@, 02 ,$- %D*J-D-(,',%0( 02 V%/-@,%.-566]b75bQE 0( %(,-/0*-/'\%J%,4 02 -J-@,/0(%@ 2-- @0JJ-@,%0( %( E)/0*-A H%('J =-*0/, 20/EQA '.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*Rbb-@N-)/0*'N-)b,/'(&*0/,b,$-D-&b%,&b&,)+%-&b+0@b--,&k&0@%0k-@0(0D%@k%D*'@,N*+2A '@@-&&-+ 6Pb"6b56";

E)/0*-'( H-+-/',%0( 20/ #/'(&*0/, '(+ E(.%/0(D-(,A L :/%@- 90/,$ :'4%(CR L C)%+- ,0,$- (-B EF /)J-& 20/ /0'+ ,0JJ& 20/ J0//%-& >-@0(+ -+%,%0(A 3)(- 566d A L.'%J'\J- ',R$,,*RbbBBBN,/'(&*0/,-(.%/0(D-(,N0/Cb&%,-&b+-2')J,b2%J-&bb+0@&b:)\J%@',%0(&b566db566de6Zk*/%@-kB0/,$k*'4%(Ck.5N*+2A '@@-&&-+ 6Pb6Pb56";