Presented by: Nguyen Phan Thanh Southern Taiwan University of Science and Technology
Mar 19, 2016
Presented by: Nguyen Phan Thanh
Southern Taiwan University of Science and Technology
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
2
Objective
To protect the distribution substation from lightning overvoltage, the lightning arrester is installed at the high voltage side of transformers.
If the lightning arrester is installed at the terminals of transformers, the transformer will be protected safety.
However, lightning arrester must to protect for all insulation of the substation’s components.
Thus, the determination of reasonable distance between lightning arrester and terminals transformer to protect efficiency the transformer and switching devices of the substation is very necessary.
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
3
This project presents a new method for calculating the separated distance and the Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF) of the transformer with different configurations to make sure that the life of transformer according to first requirement, considering the affected factors such as the shielding factor of the object, areas ground flash density, the inductance value of connected wires.
The OPSOLA program is built to help the users easily determine the appropriate installed position of lightning arrester and check MTBF for the existing configuration of substation.
Objective
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
4
The previous protection methods The proposed protection method The OPSOLA Program
Result
ContentContent
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
PC BILD . U2.S 1,2
Un kV 17,5 24 36
BIL kV 95 125 170
Up kV 57,2 79,9 117,6
5
1. The simple protection methodThe maximum distance:
Table 1. BIL and Up
(Với: D = a + b)
a : The maximum separation between J and pole-mounted transformer, mb : Distance between J and surge arrester, mUt : Arrester residual voltage, kVC: Velocity of wave propagation, C = 300 m/s.BIL: Basic Insulation Level of Transformer (KV)
I. The previous protection methodsI. The previous protection methods
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
6
2. The improved protection method (J. R. Lucas Method)
DO : Point of lightning stroke S0 : Rate of rise at O, kV/µs I0 : Lightning stroke current , kAX :Distance in which a surge with an infinite slope will decay to slope SA at A, mSA : Rate of rise of surge voltage at A, kV/µs : Reflection coefficient at transformerEt : Peak surge voltage at transformer, kVSf : Shielding factor (0,3 ÷ 0,5) N : The number of direct stroke into line, times/100km/year h : Height of nearby objects, m b : Horizontal span between outermost conductors, m Ng: Number of stroke per km2 per yearLF: Lifetime of transformer, year FR: Failure rate of transformer, %Nf : Number of lightning surges arriving at A /year, with slope higher SA
T : Wave front time, sk : Corona damping constant, kV.km/s .
I. The previous protection methodsI. The previous protection methods
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
g f
0,628h bN N 1 S10
AS
7
ycf
FR (%)N
LF
AAS2.T 0,02878 .Z 1 S .k.X
f0
xN N. e .dx
t PA
0,8E U CD , m2S
t pE 2U , kV
DO : Point of lightning stroke S0 : Rate of rise at O, kV/µs I0 : Lightning stroke current , kAX :Distance in which a surge with an infinite slope will decay to slope SA at A, mSA : Rate of rise of surge voltage at A, kV/µs : Reflection coefficient at transformerEt : Peak surge voltage at transformer, kVSf : Shielding factor (0,3 ÷ 0,5) N : The number of direct stroke into line, times/100km/year h : Height of nearby objects, m b : Horizontal span between outermost conductors, m Ng: Number of stroke per km2 per yearLF: Lifetime of transformer, year FR: Failure rate of transformer, %Nf : Number of lightning surges arriving at A /year, with slope higher SA
T : Wave front time, sk : Corona damping constant, kV.km/s .
2. The improved protection method (J. R. Lucas Method)
I. The previous protection methodsI. The previous protection methods
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
8
The previous methods: Accounting for influence elements with some experiment
parameters Just considered to single transformer substation
The proposed method: Determining surge arrester‘s location for 3-line, 2-transfomer
substation based on: IEEE Std C62.22.2009 Influence elements (can be calculated) Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF ) of Transformer
I. The previous protection methodsI. The previous protection methods
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
9
1m
3m 3m 3m
LineA B
LineC
Line
3m
T12T
D12D Arrester
S.1. Eliminate 1 transformer and determine the line which the lightning wave transmitted into.
S.2. Define the following parameters: - J, the common point between transformer, surge arrester and the line identified in step 01.
- D1, distance from J to pole-mounted transformer
- D2, distance from arrester to ground
(3-line , 2 - transformer substation) The proposed protection method based on IEEE Std C62.22.2009
S.3. Eliminate all line connected to D1
S.4. Calculate SJ
cJ
mtt tt.
K3 3S S .N 2 d N 2
, kA/s
A, B, C: Line A, B, C.T1,T2 : Transformer T1 and T2
D1: Separate distance between T1 and line, m.D2: Separate distance between T2 and line, m.Ntt: Number of identified lines
II. II. The proposed protection method
d2 =
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
10
Transformer
Arrester
B
2
1
S
md
D
d
d JS.5. Distance : stroke - substation
m1d =
N(MTBF).100
, km
J Jsa a a o1 2 .
2S 2SV V L. V d + d L .
Z Z
S.6. Voltage of ArresterB: insulation equipments.d1: distance between line and arrester , m.D2: distance between arrester and ground, m.S : slope wave, kA/s.MTBF: mean time between failure, yearFR: acceptable failure rate, %N : number of stroke into line, times /100 km/yearKc: corona damping constant , kV.km/s Va: Mức bảo vệ đầu sóng của chống sét van tại 0,5s, kV Z : line impedance, L : Inductance, H.
with:1MTBF FR(%)
The proposed method based on IEEE Std C62.22.2009
II. II. The proposed protection method
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
11
1m
3m 3m 3m
LineA B
LineC
Line
3m
T12T
D12D Arrester
S.7. Determine D1 and D2: D1 = min (D1_T1_Line A ; D1_T1_Line B ; D1_T1_Line C) D2 = min (D2_T2_Line A ; D2_T2_Line B ; D2_T2_Line C)
II. II. The proposed protection method
The proposed protection method based on IEEE Std C62.22.2009
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
12
Shielding Factor
Distance from objects to line (DO = x), m
(Sf)
Object ‘s Height
H = 10m: Sf = 5,013.10 - 7.x3 – 6,051.10-5.x2 – 0,003655.x + 0,4813 H = 14m: Sf = – 6,047.10 - 12.x5 + 1,452.10 - 8.x4 – 3,332.10 - 6.x3 +0,3459.10 - 3.x2 – 0,0247.x + 0,9982
Nonlinear regression technique
Curve Fitting Matlab
Build 16 relationships Sf, H và DO
Sf = SfL + SfRSfL: S.F at left sideSfR: S.F at right side
II. II. The proposed protection method
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
13
The number of stroke into line
g gf fL fR
0,6 0,628h b 28h bN N 1 S N 1 S S10 10
The inductance line which connect to surge arrester
, times/100km/year
- The inductance at line (length 1 m)
7 123o
DL =2.10 .ln
r , H/m
- The inductance line which connect to surge arrester
7 123o1 2 1 2.
DL = d + d L = d + d .2.10 .ln
r , H
Which: 3123 12 23 13D D D D , m
II. II. The proposed protection method
FEEEEnsuring Enhanced Education
14
Check MTBF of transformer
2
a a2 T Ta aJ J T2
2,92.D.V .Z D.V .Z 0,77.L.C.V 1,54.L.V .C5,84.L.D.Z 1,54.C.L S S 0,385.C.V V V 0 ZZ
J
g c f
1000.SMTBF 0,6N .K .(28h b).(1 S )
II. II. The proposed protection method
(1)(3)
Nonlinear regression technique
Curve Fitting Matlab
Build 6 relationships Sf, H và DO
0,9998gMTBF =107,5.N 0,02619
1g MTBF 195,4.N 0,0254 M
TB
F (y
ear)
Ng (times/km2.year)